nsls-ii accelerator system advisory committee review diagnostics design and r&d
DESCRIPTION
NSLS-II Accelerator System Advisory Committee Review Diagnostics Design and R&D Om Singh – Group Leader July 17-18, 2008. Outline. SR Diagnostics Hardware -- Layout & Locations RF BPM Resolution Requirements – Various time scale Standard RF BPM Insertion Device RF BPM - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 1/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Accelerator System Advisory Committee Review Diagnostics Design and R&D
Om Singh – Group Leader July 17-18, 2008
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 2/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Outline
• SR Diagnostics Hardware -- Layout & Locations
• RF BPM Resolution Requirements – Various time scale
• Standard RF BPM
• Insertion Device RF BPM
• RF BPM Electronics Evaluation
• Pin-hole Camera Resolution Simulation
• Near Term Plan
• Summary
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 3/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
SR Cell Diagnostics Systems – BPM & Beam Loss Monitors
3PW or BM B-Line
BPMBPM
SC FC FC FC FC SC
BPMBPM
BPMBPM
BPMBPM
BPMBPM
BPMBPM
BPMBPM
BPMBPM
A) Standard Gap RF BPM 6 per cell A) Standard Gap RF BPM 6 per cell B) Small Gap RF BPMs 2 or 3 per Cell; Button Assembly on a Stand or ID Chamber
B) Small Gap RF BPMs 2 or 3 per Cell; Button Assembly on a Stand or ID Chamber
D) Slow & Fast Correctors
C) X-ray BPMs – up to 2 / FE
ID Beamline
E) Beam Loss monitor (Location TBD) p-i-n diode detector ; 2 per cell scintillation detectors; 10 total
F) RF PUEs 2 total for top-off
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 4/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
SR Diagnostics Hardware Locations - Preliminary
Location Hardware
Cell 22 - 3PW Diagnostics Beamline – X-Ray pinhole
Cell 24 - BM-A Diagnostics Beamline –zone plates imaging
Cell 26 - 3PW location
1 short stripline – 0.15 m
Cell 28 -3PW location
1 short stripline – 0.15 m
Cell 30 –BM-A Source
Diagnostics Beamline –Visible Synch. imaging
Cell 30 –CH2S2A location
Vertical Scraper # 2
Cell 30 –Up of P3S4A BPM
Horizontal Scraper # 2
Location Hardware
Cell 1 (or 29) –Up of P3S4B BPM
Horizontal Scraper # 1
Cell 1 (or 29) –3PW location
Vertical Scraper # 1
Cell 7 - Upstream of ID
1 Long stripline – 0.3 m
Cell 11 -Upstream of ID
1 Long stripline – 0.3 m1 DCCT – 0.3 m
Cell 27 –3PW location
1 Short stripline
Cell 29 –3PW location
1 Short stripline
Odd Cells Even Cells
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Types of source
8.6m ID
1-T 3-Pole wiggler
Bend magnet
6.6m ID
x (µm) 108 175 44.2 29.6x’ (µrad) 4.6 14 63.1 16.9y (µm) 4.8 12.4 15.7 3.1
y’ (µrad) 1.7 0.62 0.63 2.6
NSLS-II Lattice Functions & Electron Beam sizes / divergences
Lattice Functions
Electron Beam Sizes & Divergences
Most challengingBeam stabilityRequirements= ~ 0.31 μm
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 6/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II SR RF BPM System – Performance Requirements*
Parameters/ Subsystems Conditions Standard RF BPM System Resolution RequirementVertical Horizontal
Single bunch, Single turn resolution (@ 378 kHz)
0.05 nC charge 500 μm rms 500 μm rms 5.0 nC charge 20 μm rms 20 μm rms
Single bunch stored beam resolution (0.017-200 Hz BW)
0.02 mA current 10 μm rms 10 μm rms2.0 mA current 1 μm rms 1 μm rms
50 mA *** to 500 mA Stored beam resolution – 20% to 100 % duty cycle
BPM ReceiverElectronics
Assuming no contribution from bunch/ fill pattern effects
**0.017 Hz to 200 Hz 0.2 μm rms 0.3 μm rms200 Hz to 2000 Hz 0.4 μm rms 0.6 μm rms**1 min to 8 hr drift 0.2 μm pk-pk 0.5 μm pk-pk
Bunch charge/ fill pattern effects only DC to 2000 Hz 0.2 μm rms 0.3 μm rmsMechanical motion limit at Pick-up electrodes assembly (ground & support combined)
Vibrations 50 Hz to 2000 Hz 10 nm rms 10 nm rms4 Hz to 50 Hz 25 nm rms 25 nm rms0.5 Hz to 4 Hz 200 nm rms 200 nm rms
Thermal **1 min to 8 hr 200 nm pk-pk
500 nm pk-pk
* Requirement values are preliminary - work in progress** ID BPM system resolution values will be smaller ( factor of ~ 0.5) *** @ 5 mA – 50 mA stored beam, BPM receiver resolution values will be worse (factor of ~2)
(Req. met - Test Data Later)
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 7/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
BPM Evaluation - Baseline Design
Baseline Design (one button/flange) Consists of one 10 mm dia. button w 34 mm flanges ~ 28 mm horizontal separation & ~ 25 mm vertical aperture Matlab Simulation input power level @ 500 mA= - 2 dBm (OK)
Sx =~ 0.12 / mm ; Sy =~ 0.04 / mm (low)
Electronic Resolution in frequency band 0.017 – 200 Hz
H-Resolution =~ 100 nm ; V-Resolution =~ 300 nm
Baseline Design (28x25)
SX=~0.12 SY=~0.04
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 8/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
BPM Evaluation - Proposed Design
Proposed Design
(two button/flange)
Consists of two ~7 mm dia. buttons on a single 50 mm dia. Flange; with ~16 mm H-separation (vertical aperture remains same - 25mm)
Two buttons on a flange reduces total flange counts & makes survey/ alignment process easier
7 mm button (over 10 mm) is also favored for beam heating issue
50
16
25
2
A
A
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 9/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
BPM Evaluation - Proposed Design (cntd)
Proposed Design (two button/flange) Matlab Simulation shows
input power level @ 500 mA = -8 dBm (OK)
Sx =~ 0.09 / mm ; Sy =~ 0.09 / mm (OK)
Electronic Resolution in 0.017 – 200 Hz BW
H-Resolution =~ 135 nm
V-Resolution =~ 135 nm (200 nm reqd)
Resolution vs Input Power
-8 dBm
Res
olut
ion
SX=~0.09 SY=~0.09
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 10/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Flange Layout – 7mm buttons
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 11/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
RF BPM Button
Findings, recommendations and comments:
Button block cooling issues should be addressed, including block distortion and the possible compromise of Helicoflex flex gasket integrity due to beam heating from trapped modes (Diamond experience). A smaller button diameter should be considered to reduce button heating and impedance (look at the ALBA paper submitted to the 2007 DIPAC).
NSLS-II Accelerator Technical Review Instrumentation and Diagnostics
August 9-10, 2007Report of the Review Committee
submitted September 28, 2007
Button Heating
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 12/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
RF Button Heating Mini-Workshop at EPAC (June,2008)
Organized by Soleil/NSLS-II - attended by experts from NSLS- II, KEK, Soleil, Diamond, PEP-II, ESRF, PETRA-III, SLS, SPEAR3, Bergoz & Others.
Presentations from NSLS-II, Soleil, Diamond, ESRF Measured temperatures of connector pin on ambient side
in the range of 60oC @ ESRF in the range of 100oC @Diamond suggesting buttons themselves may be considerably hotter (~ several hundred oC)
Estimated power at Diamond (from both GdfidL and temperature measurements) is ~5W/button, distortions/ position drifts are large ~10 microns
Scaling to NSLS-II parameters suggests to do initial Ansys analysis with ~3W/button
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 13/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
RF Button Heating mini-Workshop at EPAC (June,2008) (cntd)
Agreement on mechanism of heating – hi Q trapped mode in transmission line formed by outer circumference of button and inner surface of housing.
Diamond results suggest - do initial Ansys analysis with 3W/button to get thermal distribution/distortion – this is in progress
Soleil simulations suggest - adjust button thickness and gap to wall to change transmission line impedance
Gdfidl simulation - Kloss factor as thickness 0.012 V/pc @ 2 mm; 0.007 V/pc @ 5mm
Repeat the analysis with “Microwave Studio” simulationOngoing communication/collaboration with other labs
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
ID BPM Button - Baseline Design
~70 mm
~10 mm
Baseline design provides adequate sensitivity – SX=0.26; SY=0.14 Detail button heating analysis needs to be done with NSLS-II beam Two configurations of ID BPMs are proposed
Normal configuration - uses a low thermal expansion stand for stability Alternate configuration – buttons mounted on ID chamber, when adequate space is not available for bellows, transitions and stand.
Established Design – used at APS & Elettra
Two 4 mm Dia buttonsHS = 10 mm
Flanges mounted on top & bottom of Small gap
Chamber
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Sensitivity Optimization – Rotated Flange
Vertical sensitivity will be further optimized by rotating the 2-button flange, if needed
Effects of longitudinal displacement of buttons needs to be analyzed
Rotated Un-Rotated
Sensitivity vs H-separation
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 16/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Calibrator Set-up
Confirm transfer function calculations
Use single wire to simulate beam current; mounted on two motor controlled assemblies.
Use two 34 mm dia. flanges; mount on a large flange to adjust H-separation by rotation
Explore interaction between beampipe modes and button resonance
Evaluate BPM electronics
Develop beam simulator – Possible Collaboration with SLAC
Evaluate position and fill pattern dependencies – critical for top off operation
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 17/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
ID-BPM Stable Support
10” Dia Carbon fiber composite stand limits thermal expansion to 20 nm/m/0.1oC
BPM assembly – has 3 invar rods for alignment small gap vertical aperture & 4 mm dia buttons for optimizing sensitivity Standard size flange at each end
Specification Total Thermal expansion < 100 nm R. Alforque
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 18/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
ID BPM Support Thermal Stability
Position Stability Requirement for User BPMs is 100nm vertical
Temperature stability spec for the tunnel is +/- 0.1C
Need to verify that support post meets spec
Build a fiducial structure using additional low TEC posts (next slide)
Thermally isolate the fiducial, and give it lots of mass ( ~ 1 week)
Thermally isolate the test post, use heaters to vary temperature ( ~ 1 hour)
Use capacitive and DVRT sensors to measure length variations
Status
DAQ, some position sensors, and some temperature sensors in house
POs for remaining position and temperature sensors have been written
Shop fabrication of the test stand is underway
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 19/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
~4
8”
~48” Notes:
1. All components to be wrapped with insulating blankets wherever possible
2. 3/16” sstl rods in tension will support the central tube
3. All materials sstl other than the carbon fiber tubes
Indicates Pt temp sensor Indicates TC temp sensor
ID-BPM Support Test Set-up
at both ends measure relative displacement due to temperature variation
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 20/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
RF BPM Electronics -Proposed Studies
• Long term stability (for centered and off-centered beams)• Measure dynamic range• Dependence on ambient temperature• Fill pattern dependence (including different envelopes)• Dependence on RF frequency• Effects of cable length mismatch• Noise spectrum• Explore for “dangerous” frequencies• Signal pre-processing • Establish acceptance test requirements
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 21/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Stand for Stability Test for Libera Brilliance
Libera Brilliance
Attenuator
A B C D
4-waySplitter
Gated Oscillator
Func. Generator
Attenuator
Attenuator
Attenuator
system clock
machine clock
500 MHz
Reference 10 MHz
External Clock
Repeater
• RF frequency can be modified by external clock
• Chosen configuration provides phase locking between carrier and beam envelope
• Arbitrary waveform generator - provides amplitude or phase modulation/ trigger pulse modulation
• Temperature is monitored with platinum PT-100 probe using Digital Multi-meter
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 22/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
First Results from the Libera Tests – Meet Drift Spec.
TEMP~ 1 oC
HOR~ 200 nm
VERT~ 100 nm
TE
MP
HO
RV
ER
T
7 Hrs
Power level 6 dBm (0 dBm at each input)
80% fill (2 μs pulse duration with 2.62 μs pulse repetition rate)
Temperature Drift 200 nm /°C
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 23/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Pinhole Camera with 3PW Source
3PW has higher magnetic field (1.14 T) than dipole. Shorter critical wavelength provides better spatial resolution. Large vertical β-function (21 m) gives large beam size (12.4 μ). Horizontal beam size is defined predominantly by energy spread (σE/E·η=170μ) rather than emittance (1nm·4.1m)½=64μ. Attenuator reduces heat load on elements and serves as high pass filter for synchrotron radiation.Estimation of resolution is done using MATLAB script.
Achievable resolution of 5.2 microns is sufficient for reliable measurement of vertical beam size (12.5 microns for 8 pm emittance)
Image of the beam is magnified by factor 5 and loss of resolution due to phosphor is of less importance)
Three-polewiggler
Bending magnet Al window
Attenuator TungstenPinhole
CdWO4 scintillator
Mirror
CameraL1=3 m L2=15 m
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 24/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Near Term Plan
Complete detail RF button heating analysis Prototype two-button/flange BPM & test ID-BPM support procurement in process Design & build test set-up to measure support
thermal stability Integrate & test BPM calibrator set-up with computer control Develop program to evaluate/ compare BPM electronics
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 25/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Summary
Location of bpms and diagnostics hardware have been identified
SR BPM resolution requirement table vs time scale in progress
New button design in progress for standard RF BPM
Heat issues are being addressed for standard & ID BPMs (RF)
ID-BPM support design is complete; Procurement is progress
ID-BPM support thermal test set-up designs in progress
ID-BPM calibration test set-up complete; Integration to follow
Pin-hole diagnostic beamline design analysis in progress
Near term plan has been identified
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 26/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Acknowledgements
R. Alforque, A. Blednykh, A. Broadbent, P. Cameron, B. Dalesio, L. Doom, R. Heese, G. Ganetis, D. Hseuh, E. Johnson, S. Kramer, F. Lincoln, R. Meier, I. Pinayev, J. Rose. S. Ozaki, S. Krinsky, B. Mullany, V. Ravindranath, S. Sharma, J. Skaritika, T. Tanabe, T. Shaftan, W. Wildes, F. Willeke, L.Y. Yu.
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 27/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Backup Slides
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 28/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Diagnostics System Hardware Layout
Dipole (BM-A)
QL1Q
L2QL3
SL3
SL2
e-
Dipole (BM-B)
Short straight section – 11-ID
DCCT Stripline SCW
e-
~1 m
4 diagnostics hardware slots at 3 PW locations
Cell # 26-29
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 29/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
courtesy Alexei Blednykh
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 30/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
courtesy Alexei Blednykh
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 31/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
0 5 10 15 20 25 300
1
2
3
4
5
6x 10-3
s, mm
lo
ss,
V/p
C
th=2mm
th=5mm
-40 -20 0 20 40 60-0.02
-0.01
0
0.01
0.02
s, mm
Wlo
ng,
V
th=2mm
th=5mm
Ploss, W
th=2mm th=5mm
loss, V/pCs=4.5mm
3.4 (h=1000)6.8 (h=500)
1.6 (h=1000)3.3 (h=500)
loss, V/pCs=6.5mm
1 (h=1000)2 (h=500)
0.5 (h=1000)0.9 (h=500)
loss, V/pCs=30mm
0.03 (h=1000)0.07 (h=500)
0.01 (h=1000)0.03 (h=500)
loss, V/pC
th=2mm th=5mm
s=4.5mm 5.2e-3 2.5e-3
s=6.5mm 1.5e-3 0.7e-3
s=30mm 0.05e-3 0.02e-3
Iav=500mA, T0=2.6e-6m
Loss factor and Power Loss
NSLS-II ASAC Review – 7/17-18/2008 32/ 26
BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Partial Compilation of Relevant Parameters
color code: yellow – NSLS-II options red – danger of physical damage purple – thermal distortion due to heating