nroum 2012 p2 - nro.nao.ac.jpnroum/html/nroum2012/data/p34_matsui_nrou… · nroum_2012_p2.pptx...

1
Stacking Analysis of CO spectra a5er the velocity axis normaliza;on. Kana MatsuiNario KunoNRO INTRODUCTION The recovery of CO emission from the HI<gas dominated region by stacking CO spectra a5er re=normalizing the CO velocity axis so that v=0 corresponds to the local mean HI velocity (Scuruba et al. 2011,ApJ,142,37) Recovering the weak 13 CO emissions using the 12 CO velocity field DATA Sample galaxy should have 12 CO and 13 CO mapping data NGC3627 12 CO map from Kuno et al. (2007,PASJ,59,117) and 13 CO map from Watanabe et al. (2011,MNRAS,411,1409), both are obtained with Nobeyama 45<m telescope. RESULTS SUMMARY We invesZgated the validaZon of the method of stacking analysis of 13 CO spectra a[er the velocity axis normalizaZons with the informaZon of the velocity field of 12 CO using the 12 CO and 13 CO maps of NGC3627. Different features in each region different reasons? Interarm region: high raZo of FWHM Bar region: high raZo of T peak We obtained consistent values of the integrated intensity calculated from the just<stacked spectra with that from the V<shi[<stacked spectra. With this method and mul;=CO observa;on with FOREST, we can es;mate the more realis;c value of gas mass of 13 CO=diffuse region and total gas mass of galaxies with observing ;me necessary for obtaining 12 CO map. Figure 1, Images of NGC3627. From le[ to right, K<band image (2MASS), 12 CO integrated intensity map (Kuno et al. 2007) and 13 CO integrated intensity map (Watanabe et al. 2011). Validate this method !!! 1) CalculaZng moment<1 from 12 CO cube fits. 2) Shi[ing velocity axis of each 13 CO spectrum according to the moment<1 value of corresponding pixel in 12 CO map. ANALYSIS 3) Summing up all spectra of the region interested in. We divide the galaxy into the arm, interarm, bar, bar<end, central and off<set regions referring to Watanabe et al. (2011) (see figure 2). Figure 2, Le[: profile map of 12 CO (Kuno et al. 2007), right: profile map of 13 CO (Watanabe et al. 2011). The area in each color corresponds to purple: arm, yellow: interarm, green: bar, blue: bar<ends, red: central and orange: offset regions, respecZvely. Widely accepted and used molecular gas tracer: 12 CO The strongest known extragalacZc molecular line However… opZcally thick line, just the surface of the clouds… Total emission of 12 CO depends primarily on the # of clouds AssumpZon: all clouds are the same (T, ρ) and virialized. Mass of molecular clouds. Ideally, op;cally=thin lines like 13 CO or C 18 O are beTer tracers... But they are 5<20 Zmes or >~20 Zmes weaker than 12 CO… Applying this method… Arm Interarm Bar Bar=end Center Offset 12 CO 13 CO 12 CO, V=shi5 13 CO, V=shi5 Arm Interarm Bar Bar=end Center Offset T peak 13.3 ± 0.8 17.6 ± 2.1 25.3 ± 4.0 12.2 ± 0.8 20.6 ± 2.9 11.3 ± 2.1 FWHM 0.95 ± 0.28 1.88 ± 0.67 0.89 ± 0.19 1.05 ± 0.31 0.93 ± 0.12 1.42 ± 0.68 I CO 13.0 ± 0.4 25.8 ± 1.1 27.7 ± 2.4 12.9 ± 0.5 16.9 ± 0.9 14.1 ± 1.7 Figure 3, Resulted spectra. From le[ to right, the stacked spectra of 12 CO w/o velocity shi[ (T mb ), 13 CO w/o velocity shi[ (T a * ), 12 CO w/ velocity shi[ (T mb ), and 13 CO w/ velocity shi[ (T a * ). From top to boqom, the spectra of arm, interarm, bar, bar<end, center and offset region defined in figure 2. We show the resulted spectra in figure 3 and summarized basic results of obtained spectra in table 1. The 12 CO<to< 13 CO raZo of peak temperature, FWHM and integrated intensity of stacked spectra of each region are shown in table 2. We could successfully detect the 13 CO emissions of interarm and bar regions by stacking analysis a[er the velocity axis normalizaZon !! The ra;o of integrated intensi;es of Interarm and bar regions are high (higher T 12 /T 13 in the bars while higher FWHM 12 /FWHM 13 in the interarms). 12 CO w/o V=shi5 13 CO w/o V=shi5 12 CO w/ V=shi5 13 CO w/ V=shi5 Arm 157 ± 19 mK (S/N=8) 29.8 ± 0.8 K km/s (37) 375 km/s, 200 km/s 13.7 ± 3.1 mK(4) 2.11 ± 0.25 K km/s (9) 320 km/s, 160 km/s 254 ± 10 mK (10) 28.5 ± 0.4 K km/s (70) 325 km/s, 95 km/s 19.1 ± 0.8 mK (24) 2.19 ± 0.07 K km/s (33) 375 km/s, 200 km/s Interarm 103 ± 22 mK (5) 21.4 ± 0.9 K km/s (23) 380 km/s, 350 km/s 6.87 ± 2.55 mK(3) 1.05 ± 0.20 K km/s (5) 300 km/s, 260 km/s 145 ± 16 mK (9) 20.3 ± 0.6 K km/s (32) 320 km/s, 150 km/s 8.23 ± 0.39 mK (21) 0.787 ± 0.026 K km/s(30) 220 km/s, 80 km/s Bar 276 ± 34 mK (8) 45.2 ± 1.6 K km/s (29) 410 km/s, 280 km/s 8.29 ± 1.81 mK(5) 1.43 ± 0.18 K km/s (8) 500 km/s, 420 km/s 340 ± 28 mK (12) 44.7±1.1 K km/s (41) 300 km/s, 125 km/s 13.5 ± 1.8 mK (7) 1.61 ± 0.13 K km/s (12) 260 km/s, 140 km/s Bar=end 243 ± 27 mK (9) 46.7 ± 1.3 K km/s (36) 455 km/s, 95,135 km/s 20.8 ± 2.5 mK(8) 3.84 ± 0.26 K km/s (15) 540 km/s, 120,80 km/s 421 ± 18 mK (22) 46.7 ± 0.6 K km/s (70) 260 km/s, 105 km/s 34.5 ± 1.6 mK (20) 3.61 ± 0.13 K km/s (32) 220 km/s, 100 km/s Center 367 ± 36 mK (10) 68.7 ± 1.6 K km/s (43) 390 km/s, 230 km/s 22.3 ± 4.5 mK(5) 4.10 ± 0.45 K km/s (10) 400 km/s, 200 km/s 376 ± 34 mK (11) 70.5 ± 1.6 K km/s (45) 440 km/s, 205 km/s 18.2 ± 2.0 mK (9) 4.16 ± 0.19 K km/s (20) 540 km/s, 220 km/s Offset 319 ± 35 mK (9) 20.8 ± 0.9 K km/s (22) 145 km/s, 75 km/s 28.7 ± 4.4 mK(7) 1.55 ± 0.21 K km/s (7) 120 km/s, 60 km/s 244 ± 29 mK (9) 20.6 ± 0.9 K km/s (23) 180 km/s, 85 km/s 21.7 ± 3.0 mK (7) 1.46 ± 0.16 K km/s (9) 140 km/s, 60 km/s Table 1, Summary of the stacking analysis. In each box, from top to boqom, peak temperature (T peak in T mb ), integrated intensity (I CO ), the full width of the emission lines and the full width half maximum (FWHM). The value in parenthesis are the signal<to<noise raZo (S/N). Table 2, The 12 CO<to< 13 CO raZo of peak temperature, FWHM and integrated intensity of each region. Integrated intensity of spectra obtained with the velocity shi[ procedure almost could recover that of just<stacked spectra. Validated this method !! With this method, we successfully detected the 13 CO emission from the interarm and bar regions where the S/Ns of the lines are too low for the detecZon when the just<stacked spectra were used. The 12 CO<to 13 CO raZo of integrated intensiZes in the interarm and bar regions are high. CO

Upload: others

Post on 19-May-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Stacking)Analysis)of)CO)spectra)a5er)the)velocity)axis)normaliza;on.��Kana$Matsui�Nario$Kuno�NRO �

������INTRODUCTION�������

The$recovery$of$CO$emission$from$the$HI<gas$dominated$region$by$stacking$CO$

spectra$a5er)re=normalizing)the)CO)velocity)axis)so$that$v=0$corresponds$to$the$local$mean$HI$velocity$(Scuruba$et$al.$2011,ApJ,142,37)�

Recovering)the)weak)13CO)emissions)

using)the)12CO)velocity)field�

��������DATA����������Sample$galaxy$should$have$12CO$and$13CO$mapping$data$�NGC3627��12CO$map$from$Kuno$et$al.$(2007,PASJ,59,117)$and$13CO$map$from$Watanabe$et$al.$(2011,MNRAS,411,1409),$both$are$obtained$with$Nobeyama$45<m$telescope.�

��������RESULTS����������������SUMMARY���������We$invesZgated$the$validaZon$of$the$method$of$stacking$analysis$of$13CO$spectra$a[er$the$velocity$axis$normalizaZons$with$the$informaZon$of$the$velocity$field$of$12CO$using$the$12CO$and$13CO$maps$of$NGC3627.$

�Different$features$in$each$region$$different$reasons?$$Interarm$region:$high$raZo$of$FWHM$$Bar$region:$high$raZo$of$Tpeak$

�We$obtained$consistent$values$of$the$integrated$intensity$calculated$from$the$just<stacked$spectra$with$that$from$the$V<shi[<stacked$spectra.$

�With)this)method)and)mul;=CO)observa;on)with)FOREST,)we)can)

es;mate)the)more)realis;c)value)of)gas)mass)of)13CO=diffuse)region)

and)total)gas)mass)of)galaxies)with)observing);me)necessary)for)

obtaining)12CO)map.)

Figure$1,$Images$of$NGC3627.$From$le[$to$right,$K<band$image$(2MASS),$12CO$integrated$intensity$map$(Kuno$et$al.$2007)$and$13CO$integrated$intensity$map$(Watanabe$et$al.$2011).$

�Validate$this$method$!!!$

1)$CalculaZng$moment<1$from$12CO$cube$fits.�

2)$Shi[ing$velocity$axis$of$each$13CO$spectrum$according$to$the$moment<1$value$of$corresponding$pixel$in$12CO$map.�

�������ANALYSIS��������

3)$Summing$up$all$spectra$of$the$region$interested$in.�

We$divide$the$galaxy$into$the$arm,$interarm,$bar,$bar<end,$central$and$off<set$regions$referring$to$Watanabe$et$al.$(2011)$(see$figure$2).�

Figure$2,$Le[:$profile$map$of$12CO$(Kuno$et$al.$2007),$right:$profile$map$of$13CO$(Watanabe$et$al.$2011).$The$area$in$each$color$corresponds$to$purple:$arm,$yellow:$interarm,$green:$bar,$blue:$bar<ends,$red:$central$and$orange:$offset$regions,$respecZvely.$

Widely)accepted)and)used)molecular)gas)tracer:)12CO) $The$strongest$known$extragalacZc$molecular$line$

However…$opZcally$thick$line,$just$the$surface$of$the$clouds…$Total$emission$of$12CO$depends$primarily$on$the$#$of$clouds$

AssumpZon:$all$clouds$are$the$same$(T,$ρ)$and$virialized.$

$Mass$of$molecular$clouds.�Ideally,)op;cally=thin)lines)like)13CO)or)C18O)are)beTer)tracers...)

But$they$are$5<20$Zmes$or$>~20$Zmes$weaker$than$12CO…�

Applying)this)method…�

Arm�

Interarm�

Bar�

Bar=end�

Center�

Offset�

12CO� 13CO)� 12CO,)V=shi5� 13CO,)V=shi5�

Arm� Interarm� Bar� Bar=end� Center� Offset�

Tpeak� 13.3$±$0.8� 17.6$±$2.1� 25.3)±)4.0� 12.2$±$0.8� 20.6$±$2.9� 11.3$±$2.1�FWHM� 0.95$±$0.28�1.88)±)0.67�0.89$±$0.19�1.05$±$0.31�0.93$±$0.12�1.42$±$0.68�ICO� 13.0$±$0.4� 25.8)±)1.1� 27.7)±)2.4� 12.9$±$0.5� 16.9$±$0.9� 14.1$±$1.7�

Figure$3,$Resulted$spectra.$From$le[$to$right,$the$stacked$spectra$of$12CO$w/o$velocity$shi[$(Tmb),$13CO$w/o$velocity$shi[$(Ta*),$12CO$w/$velocity$shi[$(Tmb),$and$13CO$w/$velocity$shi[$(Ta*).$From$top$to$boqom,$the$spectra$of$arm,$interarm,$bar,$bar<end,$center$and$offset$region$defined$in$figure$2.$

We$show$the$resulted$spectra$in$figure$3$and$summarized$basic$results$of$obtained$spectra$in$table$1.�

�The$12CO<to<13CO$raZo$of$peak$temperature,$FWHM$and$integrated$intensity$of$stacked$spectra$of$each$region$are$shown$in$table$2.$�

�We$could$successfully$detect$the$13CO$emissions$of$interarm$and$bar$regions$by$stacking$analysis$a[er$the$velocity$axis$normalizaZon$!!�

�The)ra;o)of)integrated)intensi;es)of)Interarm)and)bar)regions)are)high)

(higher)T12/T13)in)the)bars)while)higher)FWHM12/FWHM13)in)the)interarms).)�

12CO)w/o)V=shi5� 13CO)w/o)V=shi5� 12CO)w/)V=shi5� 13CO)w/)V=shi5�

Arm� 157$±$19$mK$(S/N=8)$29.8)±)0.8)K)km/s)(37))

375$km/s,$200$km/s$

13.7$±$3.1$mK(4)$2.11)±)0.25)K)km/s)(9))

320$km/s,$160$km/s$

254$±$10$mK$(10)$28.5)±)0.4)K)km/s)(70))

325$km/s,$95$km/s$

19.1$±$0.8$mK$(24)$2.19)±)0.07)K)km/s)(33))

375$km/s,$200$km/s$

Interarm� 103$±$22$mK$(5)$21.4)±)0.9)K)km/s)(23))

380$km/s,$350$km/s$

6.87$±$2.55$mK(3)$1.05)±)0.20)K)km/s)(5))

300$km/s,$260$km/s$

145$±$16$mK$(9)$20.3)±)0.6)K)km/s)(32))

320$km/s,$150$km/s$

8.23$±$0.39$mK$(21)$0.787)±)0.026)K)km/s(30))

220$km/s,$80$km/s$

Bar� 276$±$34$mK$(8)$45.2)±)1.6)K)km/s)(29))

410$km/s,$280$km/s$

8.29$±$1.81$mK(5)$1.43)±)0.18)K)km/s)(8))

500$km/s,$420$km/s$

340$±$28$mK$(12)$44.7±1.1)K)km/s)(41))

300$km/s,$125$km/s$

13.5$±$1.8$mK$(7)$1.61)±)0.13)K)km/s)(12))

260$km/s,$140$km/s$

Bar=end� 243$±$27$mK$(9)$46.7)±)1.3)K)km/s)(36))

455$km/s,$95,135$km/s$

20.8$±$2.5$mK(8)$3.84)±)0.26)K)km/s)(15))

540$km/s,$120,80$km/s$

421$±$18$mK$(22)$46.7)±)0.6)K)km/s)(70))

260$km/s,$105$km/s$

34.5$±$1.6$mK$(20)$3.61)±)0.13)K)km/s)(32))

220$km/s,$100$km/s$

Center� 367$±$36$mK$(10)$68.7)±)1.6)K)km/s)(43))

390$km/s,$230$km/s$

22.3$±$4.5$mK(5)$4.10)±)0.45)K)km/s)(10))

400$km/s,$200$km/s$

376$±$34$mK$(11)$70.5)±)1.6)K)km/s)(45))

440$km/s,$205$km/s$

18.2$±$2.0$mK$(9)$4.16)±)0.19)K)km/s)(20))

540$km/s,$220$km/s$

Offset� 319$±$35$mK$(9)$20.8)±)0.9)K)km/s)(22))

145$km/s,$75$km/s$

28.7$±$4.4$mK(7)$1.55)±)0.21)K)km/s)(7))

120$km/s,$60$km/s$

244$±$29$mK$(9)$20.6)±)0.9)K)km/s)(23))

180$km/s,$85$km/s$

21.7$±$3.0$mK$(7)$1.46)±)0.16)K)km/s)(9))

140$km/s,$60$km/s$

Table$1,$Summary$of$the$stacking$analysis.$In$each$box,$from$top$to$boqom,$peak$temperature$(Tpeak$in$Tmb),$integrated$intensity$(ICO),$the$full$width$of$the$emission$lines$and$the$full$width$half$maximum$(FWHM).$The$value$in$parenthesis$are$the$signal<to<noise$raZo$(S/N).$

Table$2,$$The$12CO<to<13CO$raZo$of$peak$temperature,$FWHM$and$integrated$intensity$of$each$region.$

�Integrated$intensity$of$spectra$obtained$with$the$velocity$shi[$procedure$almost$could$recover$that$of$just<stacked$spectra.�

Validated)this)method)!!�

�With$this$method,$we$successfully$detected$the$13CO$emission$from$the$interarm$and$bar$regions$where$the$S/Ns$of$the$lines$are$too$low$for$the$detecZon$when$the$just<stacked$spectra$were$used.$

�The$12CO<to13CO$raZo$of$integrated$intensiZes$in$the$interarm$and$bar$regions$are$high.$

������������CO��������