novel criticsm by m. fikri dwantara darajat

8/13/2019 NOVEL CRITICSM By M. Fikri Dwantara Darajat

1/5

NOVEL CRITICSM

TITLE CINTA TIADA BATAS

By: Muhammad Fikri Dwantara Drajat

Class: X-6/20

SMANSA 2012/2013


2/5

1. Background of this novela. This story tells about how importance is the figure of daddy in Anis

family. Bapak Syamsuddin who plays as father was a kind hearted-man,

wise, love his family, pay attention to their children, and like to help other

people.

b. This story tells about how importance is the figure of children in Anisfamily. Ani who plays as a daughter and sister was friendly, polite,

confident, kind hearted, patient, have spirit everyday, diligent,

responsible, always tell story of her day to her family, not easily hopeless.

c. This story tells about how importance is the figure of children in Anisfamily. Kak Roy who plays as a son and brother was love his sister and

brother, loyal, patient, caring his sister and brother, understanding,

responsible, mature, good listener.

d. This story tells about how importance is the figure of teacher in Anisfamily. Pak Usman who plays as religious teacher was wise and a kind

hearted-man.

e. This story tells about how importance is the figure of teacher in Anisfamily. Pak Minto who plays as sport teacher was a kind hearted-man.

f. This story tells about how importance is the figure of neighbor in Anisfamily. Acil Hasnah who plays as neighbor was kind hearted and caring

about Ani and Kak Roy.

2. Readers viewpointsa. Bapak Syamsuddin taught us fight was not good, we might defend

ourselves in a pinch, but we are not the cause of the fight. He also taught

us about better compete for reach a good score, rather than fight. And,

helping each other is a duty that must be carried out, not good insult

someone, and also, start something with earnestly and in the name of

Allah, so we get the pleasure of Allah.

b. Ani taught us no matter how the problems we face, we have to keepsmiling and strong. She also taught us aboutsave money if it is not reallyneeded, compact to resolve the issue with the family, always give thanks

to Allah, obedient to parents, and also share everything to family.


3/5

c. Kak Roy taught us for mutual support, loving, and respect each membersof family.

d. Pak Usman taught us for giving knowledge, we should not expect a reward.And also, very important to learn, because of the knowledge we have, our

charity can be increase.

3. Strong point and weak pointa. The strong point:

1. Explanation of events is explained clearly, so the reader can clearlytake a positive viewpoints.

2. The writer always use language that is lightweight and used everyday,so the reader is not difficult to interpret the language.

3. Contains many positive characters in each story, so readers areinspired to follow the good character.

b. The weak point:1. The writer sometimes use the word "I" to tell the life of Ani,

sometimes using the word "Ani" as well. So the reader will be confused

who the "I" referred to by the author.

2. The writer put words sometimes less precise, so sometimes thephrase is somewhat difficult to understand.

3. Sometimes timeline is not clear, so reader do not understand thedivision of time in the novel.

4. Personal Impression after reading the novela. Character building:

1. The character building can be shown in chapter 1, page 1, titledNamaku Ani. It stated when Ani entered into a new class, Kak Roy

waited in front of Ani's class until Ani finished introduce herself.

Which in fact, Kak Roy's friends was busy looking their new class.

- The character builiding is care.2. The character building can be shown in chapter 3, page 11, titled

Mengangkat Batu Bata. It stated when Ani with her brothers and

sisters worked part-time to alleviate the burden of her father and as

a proof of their love for Bapak Syamsudin.

- The character builiding is love each other.


4/5

3. The character building can be shown in chapter 4, page 15, titledSambel Goreng Kak Yanti. It stated when Bapak asked Kak Remy, why

his face looked bruised, Kak Remy only silent. And then Kak Roy said

that, Kak Remy defend when Kak Roy was bullied by his friends in

class, if Kak Remy didn't come, then roy who will be hurt.

- The character builiding is care and protect each other.4. The character building can be shown in chapter 6, page 23, titled

Kewajiban Tolong Menolong. It statedwhen Kak Enyong and Kak Yantigave the task of cleaning the house to Ani, Ani did her jobs with a

sense of responsibility and sincerity.

- The character builiding is responsible.5. The character building can be shown in chapter 7, page 31, titled Baju

Olah Raga Tetangga. It stated when Kak Roy knew that the ball hitAni's chest, he went straight to Ani, and asked Ani to went home to

wash her clothes were dirty and smelly. So that afternoon, Ani was not

wearing dirty clothes, and had spirit to join gymnastics competitions.

- The character builiding is care.6. The character building can be shown in chapter 7, page 33, titled Baju

Olah Raga Tetangga. It stated when Ani and Kak Roy dried Ani'sclothes under hot sun, suddenly, Acil Hasnah came to them with

compassion. And said that Acil Hasnah still kept her daughter's

exercise clothes.

- The character builiding is care.7. The character building can be shown in chapter 9, page 53, titled

Lomba Melukis Hello Kitty. It stated when there was a beggar asked

for money, Ani and Kak Roy only had one sheet of money, 20 thousand

rupiahs, so they gave all the money to beggar. Even they will use that

money to ride public transportation to the Gedung Gelora, but they

gave all the money with a big smile. And ran to the Gedung Gelora.

- The characters builiding are respect and care to other.8. The character building can be shown in chapter 9, page 54, titled

Lomba Melukis Hello Kitty. It stated when someone accidentally said

to Ani "where is your mother, kid?", Ani paused, then Kak Roy who


5/5

heard that sentence immediately came to Ani and asked her to find

the jury.

- The character builiding is care to other.

9. The character building can be shown in chapter 9, page 57, titledLomba Melukis Hello Kitty. It stated when Ani wanted to eat, Kak Roy

said that, before have lunch, we should pray first, then they prayed

fervently.

- The character builiding is religious.b. Self Controlling

1. It can be shown in chapter 2, page 7, titled Ada Untuk Berbagi. Itstated when Ani was thirsty after playing with Kak Roy, she did notcomplain. Because Ani knew that money was Kak Roy's money to bought

books.

2. It can be shown in chapter 13, page 85, titled Cinta Itu Tiada Batas.It statedwhen Ani looked happy even if her father was not there tosaw her carnival.

c. Strategic Collaboration1. It can be shown in chapter 6, titled Kewajiban Tolong Menolong. It

stated when every morning Ani with her brothers and sisters divided

the tasks, to reduce the burden of Bapak.

2. It can be shown in chapter 10, titled Bapak Sakit. It stated when Aniknew that Bapak was sick, and then Ani prepared a towel and water to

compress Bapaks head, Kak Yanti made a porridge and hot tea for

Bapak, and Kak Rita took care of Saly. After returned from the

mosque, Kak Enyong and Kak Roy massage Bapak.

d. Total Action1. It can be shown in chapter 6, titled Kewajiban Tolong Menolong. It

stated when Ani and Bapak at the traditional market, they saw

beggars on the side of traditional market. Bapak gave his coins to all

of beggars whom he met and said Assalamualaikum,here it is Pak or

Bu or son.

novel criticsm by m. fikri dwantara darajat

Documents