northern ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem:...

21
Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. Place and Role of Minorities in the Euromed Context: Ethnic, Linguistic & Religious” Bilbao, Spain, September 2007

Post on 20-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious.

“Place and Role of Minorities in the Euromed Context: Ethnic, Linguistic & Religious” Bilbao, Spain, September 2007

Page 2: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Aims We will try to analyse the causes, the origins

and the consequences of this conflict in the local, regional and international context.

Also, using the Case Study of Northern Ireland demonstrate how can ethnic and religious minorities who are in conflict influences sharply the political, the economical and the cultural context on the local, regional and also the international context.

Page 3: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Objectives receive a historical overview of the irish

religious and ethnic conflict look at the causes and the consequences

of the conflict be able to contextualise the issues

relevant to the conflict receive an overview of how the conflict

can be solved or at least avoided.

Page 4: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Context Setting

Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain (England, Scotland and Wales and Northern Ireland)

Northern Ireland is on the island of Ireland and sits alongside it’s neighbour, the Republic of Ireland

Page 5: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Context Setting Northern Ireland has a population of

approximately 1.5million people of which it is estimated that 55% are from a Protestant background and 44% are Catholic and under 1% others

There are 32 counties in Ireland, 6 of which are in Northern Ireland and these 6 are in the ancient province of Ulster (9 counties). There are four provinces in Ireland: Ulster, Connaught, Leinster and Munster

There is no one indigenous Irish Nation: history includes Normans, Vikings, Gaels, etc

Page 6: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Significant Dates 1155 – King Henry II grants permission

to invade Ireland 1366 – Statute of Kilkenny to keep Irish

and English apart 1530s – Anglicisation Laws 1608 – Plantation 1690 – Battle of the Boyne 1795 – Orange Order formed 1798 – Irish Rebellion

Page 7: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Significant Dates 1800 – Act of Union 1840s – Irish Famine 1916 – First World War/Easter Uprising 1921 – Partition 1937 – Free State becomes Rep of Irl:

Articles 2 & 3 1939-45 – Second World War 1968 – Civil Rights Movement 1969 – British Troops enter N Ireland 1972 – Direct Rule

Page 8: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Significant Dates

1980 – Hunger Strikes 1985 –Anglo Irish Agreement 1994 – First IRA Ceasefire 1998 – Good Friday Agreement 2002 – Direct Rule re-introduced 2007 – Devolution returns

Page 9: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Who’s who?

Unionists: British, Loyalist, Protestants, Orange, believe in the Union between GB and NI

Nationalists: Irish, Republican, Catholic, Green, believe in a United Ireland

Key Figures: Ian Paisley, Gerry Adams, John Hume, Tony Blair, Bertie Ahern

Page 10: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Conflict Northern Ireland has suffered a

protracted, low intensity conflict which has encountered both individual and collective trauma

Different Phases but current conflict began in 1968

Over 3, 500 people have died in the conflict

Page 11: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Efforts and Political Agreement

1974 – Sunning dale ‘Power Sharing’ Agreement

1998 – Good Friday Agreement 2007 – Devolution returns

Page 12: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Causes of conflict in NI

Territory Identity Nationality Injustice Policing Decommissioning Politics

Page 13: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Causes of conflict in NI

Military Equality Sectarianism Religion Class Violence Justice System

Page 14: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Causes of conflict in NI Sport Legitimacy Language Customs Traditions Education Symbols Economy

Page 15: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Why we failed….. Failure to recognise legitimate concerns Non-recognition of identity Not inclusive Violence viewed as legitimate Rights Vs Responsibilities Lack of Contact Victimhood Failure to address all issues fully ‘Whataboutery….’ Economical Differing Value Base

Page 16: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Why we succeeded….. Britain and Ireland’s relationship changed Outside Intervention – United States People grew tired of violence Those on the extremes were ‘brought in from

the cold’ Recognition of each other, our identities,

nationality and legitimate concerns Commitment of British and Irish

governments Key Issues dealt with by ‘others’ &

‘outsiders’, i.e., decommissioning, policing, victims, parades, etc

Page 17: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Why we succeeded….. Peace Process was on-going ‘on the

ground’ EDI Principles All issues were addressed Recognition of the past Commitment to peaceful change Commitment to removing conditions that

caused conflict Constitutional Issues addressed Trust Fears were addressed Humour!

Page 18: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Cultural Aspects Live Apart Go to different Schools Different Names Languages Different Sports Music Historical Narrative Religion Wealth Identity – ‘not sure who I am but know

what I’m not’

Page 19: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Dangers Living in segregated areas Segregated Education Poverty Power Base among Loyalist

paramilitaries Some Republicans still opposed to

political process Growing tide of Racism and homophobia

Page 20: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Dangers Sectarianism still underneath the surface Communities feel more polarised than

ever Economy dependent on GB Potential Political Instability Parading Issues There are still guns in society Trust and ‘Blind Faith’ Young people involved in Street Politics

Page 21: Northern Ireland: analysis of a case study of conflictual situation based on minority problem: ethnic, linguistic and religious. “ Place and Role of Minorities

Thanks