northeast regional nursing conference - dementia bpsd · 3/28/18 3...
TRANSCRIPT
3/28/18
1
The$Management$of$Behavioral$and$Psychotic$Symptoms$(BPSD)$in$Dementia
What$is$the$State$of$the$Science?
Ipsit&V.&Vahia,&M.D.Medical&Director,&Geriatric&Psychiatry&Outpatient&Programs,McLean&Hospital
Member&of&the&Faculty,Harvard&Medical&School
Disclosures! No$financial$relationships$! Collaboration$with$Apple$Inc.$on$a$research$project$(technical$Support$only)$
! Presenting$findings$from$research$supported$in$part,$by$the$UC$San$Diego$(UCSD)$Stein$Institute,$UCSD$RPC$iPad$Project,$John$A.$Hartford$Foundation,$and$NIH
Outline
• What%are%the%behavioral%and%psychotic%symptoms%of%dementia%(BPSD)
• How%do%we%assess%them• Non>pharmacologic%approaches• Pharmacology%
Outline
• What%are%the%behavioral%and%psychotic%symptoms%of%dementia%(BPSD)
• How%do%we%assess%them• Non>pharmacologic%approaches• Pharmacology%
A"(very)"brief"history"of"BPSD
Alzheimer)A,)Allg)Zeitschr)Psychiatry,)1906
Auguste'Deter'(1850/1906):'loss'of'memory,'hallucinations,'delusions
Evolution)of)Nosology
Psychosis(of(Dementia((2002)
Neuropsychiatric(Symptoms(of(AD((mid(2000s)
Behavioral(and(Psychotic(Symptoms(of(Dementia((BPSD)((2005)
Alois(Alzheimer((1906C07)
Senile(Psychosis((earlyClate(1900s)
Agitation Psychosis Depression/Anxiety
Insomnia/Circadian(disruption
3/28/18
2
Psychosis
• Delusions:*simple,*paranoid,*non1bizarre1 e.g.*accusations*of*infidelity,*accusations*of*theft,*claims*of*impersonation
• Hallucinations:*predominantly*visual*(rather*than*auditory)
• Complex*bizarre*psychosis:*ABSENT*(*e.g.*‘First*rank’*symptoms*such*as*thought*broadcasting,*thought*insertion,*multiple*voices*conversing)
Agitation• Aberrant(Vocalization:(repetitive(requests,(moaning,(screaming
• Motor(Agitation:(pacing,(wandering,(moving(in(chair,(intrusiveness,(banging,(disrobing,(taking(others’(possession:(redirect(able(vs.(non?redirectable
• Aggressiveness:(verbal(threats,(physical(towards(property,(assault
• Resistance(to(Care((washing,(dressing,(eating,(meds):(avoidance,(verbal(refusal,(striking(out
Rosen,'Burgio'et'al,'Am'J'Geriatric'Psych,'1994
Peak%Frequency%of%Behavioral%Symptoms%With%Alzheimer%Disease%Progression
!40$$$$$$$$$$$!30$$$$$$$$$$$!20$$$$$$$$$$$!10$$$$$$$$$$$0$$$$$$$$$$$10$$$$$$$$$$$20$$$$$$$$$$$30
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0 Months$Before$and$After$Diagnosis
Peak$of$Occurrence$(%$Patients)
Jost%BC,%et%al.%J"Am"Geriatr"Soc.%1996;44:107861081
Depression
Diurnal$Rhythm
Social$Withdrawal
Anxiety
Paranoia
Suicidal$Ideation
Agitation
Wandering Aggression
Hallucinations
Socially$Unacceptable
Outline
• What%are%the%behavioral%and%psychotic%symptoms%of%dementia%(BPSD)
• How%do%we%assess%them• Non>pharmacologic%approaches• Pharmacology%
• 67#year#old#male,#diagnosed#with#Alzheimer’s#Disease#6#years#ago,#living#with#wife#at#home,#retired#accountant
• Two#month#history#of#insomnia,#irritability#and#physical#restlessness#and#pacing#especially#late#in#the#day#
• One#week#of#talking#to#“imaginary#people#in#his#home”#and#increased#nonCspecific#confusion#per#wife’s#report
• No#significant#past#medical#history• Medications:#Donepezil#10#mg#per#day,#Memantine#10#mg#twice#daily,#Mirtazapine#15#mg#bedtime
Case DICE%Approach%for%Assessing/Managing%BPSD
DESCRIBE'the'symptoms
INVESTIGATE'the'cause
CREATE'an'appropriate'plan'
EVALUATE'the'planKales&et&al.&J&Am&Geriatr&Soc&62:762–769,&2014.
3/28/18
3
Operationalizing-the-DICE-Approach-to-BPSD
• Type• Frequency• Severity• Pattern• Timing
Characterize-Symptoms
• Clinical5History• Lab5Panel• Medications• Standard5scales
• (sensor5data)
Clinical-Assessment
Medical5Cause(Delirium)
Psychiatric5Cause/Meds
Other5modifiableFactors• Pain• Hunger• Noise• Boredom• Sensory5
deprivation• Other5unmet5
needs
Treat
Modify
EstablishEtiology
IndividualizedPlan
Standardized*Measures• Psychosis:
) Neuropsychiatric1Inventory1Questionnaire1(NPI)Q)) Brief1Psychiatric1Rating1Scale1(BPRS)
• Agitation) Pittsburgh1Agitation1Scale1(PAS)) Cohen1Mansfield1Agitation1Inventory1(CMAI)
• Depression) Geriatric1Depression1Scale) Cornell1Scale1for1Depression1in1Dementia
Outline
• What%are%the%behavioral%and%psychotic%symptoms%of%dementia%(BPSD)
• How%do%we%assess%them• Non>pharmacologic%approaches• Pharmacology%
Non$Pharmacological.approaches• Treatment(of(Pain
• Enhanced(Communication((
• Caregiver(Support(and(Resources
• Meaningful(Activities(for(patient
• Simplifying(Tasks
• Enhancing(or(Calming(environment
Non$Pharmacological.Aids Systems'based+Approach
Boston&Globe,&June&5,&2016
3 Study&of&a&videoconference3based&intervention&(ECHO3AGE)&providing&nursing&home&staff&access&to&consultation&with&geriatric&experts.
3 In&comparison&with&controls,&patients&treated&at&facilities&with&ECHO3AGE&had&17%&fewer&antipsychotic&prescriptions&and&75%&less&likely&to&be&placed&in&restraints.
Gordon&et.al.,&JAMDA,&2016
3/28/18
4
! Dinner'at'Kensington'Grill,'San'Diego'with'friends'and'their'boisterous'4'year'old! iPhone'used'to'keep'him'calm'during'dinner
Late%April%2013
Can%an%iPad%be%used%to%control%the%behavior%of%someone%
functioning%at%the%level%of%a%4%year%old%i.e.%severe%dementia?
• Conducted)on)UCSD)Senior)Behavioral)Health)Geriatric)Psychiatry)inpatient)unit
• Patients)with)history)of)behavioral)symptoms)(agitation))who)required)psychotropic)medications)
• All)consented)patients)trained)in)iPad)use)by)staff• Menu)of)approximately)70)apps)– all)available)commercially)for)free)on)App)Store
• When)patients)became)agitated,)devices)given)by)research)staff.
• Outcome)Measure:)feasibility)and)safety)data,)subjective)efficacy)of)app)use)(as)rated)by)staff)
Tablet'Devices'for'Controlling'Behavior'in'Dementia
Vahia%et%al,%Am%J%Geriatr%Psych,%2014,%Supplement%1Vahia%et%al%Am%J%Geriatr%Psych,%2016,%under%review
Tablet'Devices'for'Controlling'Behavior'in'DementiaTablet'Use'Among'Inpatients'with'Dementia
Vahia%et%al,%2016,%Am%J%Geri%Psych,%under%review
Tablet'Use'Among'Inpatients'with'Dementia
Vahia%et%al,%2016,%Am%J%Geri%Psych,%under%review
Outline
• What%are%the%behavioral%and%psychotic%symptoms%of%dementia%(BPSD)
• How%do%we%assess%them• Non>pharmacologic%approaches• Pharmacology%
3/28/18
5
Triggers'for'Antipsychotic'use'in'Dementia
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Agitation
Delusion
Halluc
ination
Sleep9
disturban
ce
Irritab
ility
N=1769outpatients9at9the9Salem9VAMC,9Virginia
Sapra%et.al.%Federal%Practitioner,%2012
The$Psychobehavioral$Metaphor
• Identification+of+the+hypothesized+underlying+psychiatric+or+other+illness
• Examples:– Depression++++++++++++irritability++++++++++agitation
– Paranoia++++++++++++++fear++++++++++++++agitation
– Embarrassment++++++++++disinhibition++++++++++agitation
– Pain+Disorder movement agitation
Chronologic*Trends*in*Antipsychotic*Use
Ventimiglia*J,*Kalali A,*Vahia*IV*and*Jeste DV,*Psychiatry*(Edgemont),*2010
American)Psychiatric)Association)(APA))GuidelinesAssessing)Benefits)and)Risks)of)Antipsychotic)Treatment
• Non$emergency+Antipsychotic+medication+should+only+be+used+for+treatment+of+agitation+or+psychosis+when+the+symptoms+are+severe,+dangerous+and/or+cause+significant+distress+to+the+patient
• Review+clinical+response+to+nonpharmacological+treatments+prior+to+non+emergency+use+of+antipsychotics
• Prior+to+use,+potential+risks+and+benefits+should+be+reviewed+by+the+clinician+and+discussed+with+the+patient+(if+feasible)+and+their+surrogate+decision+maker(s)+with+input+from+family+and+others
American)Psychiatric)Association)(APA))GuidelinesDosing,)Duration)and)Monitoring)of)Treatment
• Treatment(should(be(initiated(at(a(low(dose(and(titrated(up(to(minimal(effective(dose
• If(a(clinically(significant(side(effect(from(antipsychotic(treatment(occurs,(potential(risks(and(benefits(should(be(reviewed(to(determine(whether(tapering(and(discontinuation(are(indicated
• If(there(is(no(clinically(significant(response(after(a(4<week(trial(of(an(antipsychotic,(treatment(should(be(tapered(and(withdrawn
American)Psychiatric)Association)(APA))GuidelinesDosing,)Duration)and)Monitoring)of)Treatment
• If#there#is#significant#clinical#effect#on#BPSD,#attempt#should#be#made#to#taper#the#medication#after#4#months#unless#there#is#prior#history#of#relapse#upon#tapering.
• In#patients#whose#medication#is#being#tapered,#reassessments#should#occur#at#least#monthly,#and#for#at#least#4#months#after#taper to#assess#for#signs#of#relapse
3/28/18
6
American)Psychiatric)Association)(APA))GuidelinesUse)of)Specific)Medications
• In#the#absence#of#delirium,#if#non#emergency#antipsychotic#treatment#is#indicated,#haloperidol#should#not#be#used#as#a#first#line#agent
• Long8acting#injectable#antipsychotic#should#not#be#used in#dementia#unless#indicated#for##co8occurring#primary#psychotic#disorder
Expert'consensus'panel:'Which'of'the'following'prevented'you'from'using'antipsychotics'for'agitation?
The$CATIE)AD$StudyN"="421"(outpatients"with"AD"and"BPSD)
Olanzapine (mean"dose"5.5"mg/day)
Risperidone (mean"dose"1.0"mg/day)
Quetiapine (mean"dose"56.5"mg/day)
Placebo
• Time"to"discontinuation"for"inefficacy
Risperidone:"26.7"wkOlanzapine:"22.1"wkQuetiapine:"9.1"wkPlacebo:"9.0"wk
Schneider"LS"et"al."NEJM 2006;355:1525S38.
Comparing*risk*of*specific*agents:
• Number'Needed'to'Harm:• Haloperidol: 26• Olanzapine:' 40• Risperidone:' 27• Quetiapine:' 50• Antidepressant:'' 166
What%if%Antipsychotic%Is%Stopped?
!After&16&weeks&of&open&label&Rx&&with&risperidone,&180&patients&randomized&to&maintenance&risperidone versus&placebo
!Relapse&in&first&16&weeks:&60%&placebo&vs 33%&risperidone
!Relapse&after&the&next&16&weeks:&48%&placebo&vs15%&risperidone
Devanand'DP,'et'al.'NEJM 20120'367:149771507''
• Study&measured&time&to&nursing&home&placement&and&time&to&death&in&957&patients&with&diagnosis&of&probable&Alzheimer’s&disease&
• Use&of&antipsychotics&was¬&associated&with&time&to&nursing&home&admission&or&time&to&death&after&adjustment&for&psychosis&and&agitation.
• Conclusion:&The&psychiatric&symptoms,¬&the&medications,&predict&time&to&NH&placement&and&death
Long%Term%Effects%of%Antipsychotics
Lopez'OL'et'al.'Am#J#Psychiatry#20131'170:1051–1058
3/28/18
7
Other&Agents:&Commonly&used
• Divalproex:, 3.out.of.4.placebo.controlled.trials.indicated.modest.benefit, most.frequently.used.in.combination.with. antipsychotics
• Citalopram:.The.CitAD Study.(Porsteinsson et.al,.JAMA,.2014).
Other&Agents:&Limited/New&evidence
• Dextromethorphan:Quinidine&(Nuedexta)! NMDA&antagonist,&sigma!1&agonist,&5HT&and&NE&uptake&inhibitor&approved&by&FDA&for&pseudobulbar&affect! 10!week&2!phase&RCT&with&N&of&194&found&clinically&significant&reduction&in&NPI&scores&(Cummings&JL&et&al,&JAMA&2015)
• Prazosin! Alpha!1&adrenergic&antagonist&known&to&be&efficacious&in&PTSD&found&in&one&small&open&trial&to&be&effective&for&BPSD.&! Average&dose&1!6mg.&No&parkinsonian&side&effects&but&may&cause&decrease&in&BP
Other&Agents:&Novel&therapiesECT:
Dronabinol
Other&Agents:&Common&Agents
• Cholinergic+Agents:+may+decrease+visual+hallucinations+and+apathy,+but+have+potential+to+worsen+agitation.+
• Benzodiazepines:+minimal+efficacy+data,+and+high+risk+of+confusion,+falls+and+sedation.+Occasionally+short+acting+(lorazepam)if+other+options+fail.+
• Antidepressants:+ mirtazapine+or+trazodone+may+be+effective+if+depression+or+insomnia+are+components+or+triggers
• Anxiety(and(Non-specific(agitation(without(aggression(or(psychosis:(SSRI(or(Mirtazapine(or(Trazadone(prn(if(episodic
• Agitation(or(aggression(with(psychosis:(atypical(antipsychotic(
• Agitation(or(aggression(with(depression:(SSRI,(SNRI(or(Mirtazapine
• Aggression(without(psychosis:(mood(stabilizer(or(atypical(antipsychotic
• Lewy-body(Disease:(Cholinergic(agents,(mood(stabilizers,(quetiapine,(clozapine
• Fronto-temporal(dementia:(Mood(stabilizers,(atypical(antipsychotics
Pharmacological+Approach:+Key+Points Summary• BPSD%are%common,%disruptive,%primary%drivers%of%caregiver%burden%and%institutionalization.%
• Systematic%characterization%of%symptoms%in%each%individual%is%the%foundation%for%successful%management.
• Novel%technologies%have%a%potentially%major%role%in%management.%
• Non%pharmacologic%approaches%should%be%tried%first• Pharmacologic%approach%should%be%tailored%based%on%symptom%profile%and%clinical%urgency
• The%newly%released%APA%practice%guidelines%provide%a%framework%for%use%of%antipsychotics%in%dementia.%
