ngc and l3 ccds - eso · shot noise = gain noise ... the sensitivity of the high voltage clock...

16
First Light First Light L3 L3 CCD 60 CCD 60 Screenshot Screenshot M.Meyer M.Meyer Dez Dez 05 05 NGC and L3 NGC and L3 CCDs CCDs

Upload: others

Post on 24-Mar-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

First LightFirst Light

L3L3 CCD 60CCD 60

ScreenshotScreenshot

M.MeyerM.MeyerDezDez 0505

NGC and L3 NGC and L3 CCDsCCDs

Page 2: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

IntroductionIntroduction

The goal of this project was getting in touch with the technology needed to read an electron multiplying CCD sensor, because in adaptive optics an sensor of this type ( CCD 220 ) is foreseen as wave-front sensor.

The sensor was running uncooled, so the data may be much worse than with a cooled device.

Page 3: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

CCD 60

Page 4: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Test SetTest Set--up NGC Prototype for L3 Readup NGC Prototype for L3 Read--out 1out 1The read-out electronic used is the NGC prototype and an add on board with some components ( mainly fast clock drivers and a high voltage resonant circuit ).

A small housing with a NIKON objective was used as optic set up.

The sensor runs uncooled.

The ADC on NGC Proto has a maximum conversion rate of 1 MS/s, this determined the maximum pixel rate ( at a later time it is foreseen to run with a high speed, pipelined ADC ( till 40 MS/s ) of the add on board - footprint implemented but chip not yet delivered).

Page 5: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Test SetTest Set--up NGC Prototype for L3 Readup NGC Prototype for L3 Read--out 2out 2

Page 6: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

L3 with and without GainL3 with and without Gain

Page 7: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Multiplication Gain versus Phase ShiftMultiplication Gain versus Phase ShiftDependence L3 Gain from HV Clock Shift

[ Pixel Clock 1000 ns ]

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

R$2_HV to R$2 [ Relative Shift in ns ]

L3 G

ain

∆∆ Gain = 1/27 = ~ 0.037 @ assume 10MHz clock and phase noisGain = 1/27 = ~ 0.037 @ assume 10MHz clock and phase noise e of 2ns and therefore a gain change of 1of 2ns and therefore a gain change of 1(equal behavior of clock phase to 1MHz) (equal behavior of clock phase to 1MHz)

Shot noise = SQRT(N) Shot noise = SQRT(N) | N after multiplicationGain Noise = 0.037 * N Gain Noise = 0.037 * N

Shot noise = Gain Noise Shot noise = Gain Noise SQRT(N) = 0.037 * NSQRT(N) = 0.037 * N

Assume operation at gain 100Assume operation at gain 100

This means already with 730 electrons after multiplication (or This means already with 730 electrons after multiplication (or 7 at 7 at sensor) the noise caused by gain variation is as big as shot noisensor) the noise caused by gain variation is as big as shot noise.se.The error will then always be > 3.7 %!The error will then always be > 3.7 %!

Page 8: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Multiplication Gain versus R$2_HV Gate VoltageMultiplication Gain versus R$2_HV Gate VoltageDependence L3 Gain from HV Clock Amplitude [ V ]

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47

R$2_HV [ V ]

L3 G

ain

Estimation of the error caused by gain variation due to R$2HV voltage variation :

∆ Gain = 100 for 1Volt at a Gain 100∆ Gain = 1 for 10mV | 10mV RMS estimated amplitude noise

Shot noise = SQRT(N) | N after multiplicationGain Noise = 0.01 * N

Gain Noise = 0.01 * N Shot noise = Gain Noise SQRT(N) = 0.01 * N

This means already with 10000 electrons after multiplication (or 100 at input) the noise caused by gain variation is as big as shot noise.

Then the error will always be > 1%!

For higher multiplication gains also ∆ Gain increases exponentially, and so the sensitivity to amplitude noise ! The estimated 10mV areprobably not easy to achieve.

Page 9: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Dark exposure

As already mentioned , the device runs As already mentioned , the device runs uncooleduncooled with with relatively high dark current.relatively high dark current.

The picture below shows a dark image ( ~ 750 e/Frame The picture below shows a dark image ( ~ 750 e/Frame and Pixel ) and the typical smearing in row direction. and Pixel ) and the typical smearing in row direction. What causes this effect is unclear , a bad transfer What causes this effect is unclear , a bad transfer efficiency could cause it. Let’s hope with a cooled chip efficiency could cause it. Let’s hope with a cooled chip things get better.things get better.

Page 10: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

A different ReadA different Read--outout

frame transfer image to storage

transfer of one line to horizontal register

read out and digitizing of whole horizontal chain

= four times ( 8 bit register bends + 128 bit multipliers )

+ 8bit register bends + 128 bit pixel register

2 and 3 129 times to read out complete image

Page 11: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Mechanical SetMechanical Set--upupforfor

WaveWave--front Sensorfront Sensor

DesignerDesignerRalf Ralf ConzelmannConzelmann

Page 12: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Mechanical SetMechanical Set--up 1up 1

Page 13: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Mechanical SetMechanical Set--up 2up 2

Page 14: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

Mechanical SetMechanical Set--up 3up 3

Page 15: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for

ConclusionThe L3 CCD behaved in the measurements like described the delivered data sheets from E2V.

The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase to the gain of the chip is seen as critical for applications in adaptive optics. Lets hope we will be much better than estimated before.

Critical is also the bad transfer efficiency. There is hope thatthis will be better at low temperatures.

Thanks especially for the help in preparing the mechanical camera setup to Mr. Kirchbauer from our mechanical workshop and Mr. Eschbaumer from the IR workshop.

Thanks to Joerg Stegmaier for the excellent software support, Gert Finger and Reinhold Dorn for helpful discussions and ideas.

Page 16: NGC and L3 CCDs - ESO · Shot noise = Gain Noise ... The sensitivity of the high voltage clock amplitude and phase ... this will be better at low temperatures. Thanks especially for