new emerging technologies€¦ · new emerging technologies kim erickson november 20, 2014 phoenix,...
TRANSCRIPT
New Emerging Technologies
Kim Erickson
November 20, 2014
Phoenix, AZ
2
Strategic Energy
Management
Premium Efficiency
Motors
Motor Systems
Distribution
Transformers
Municipal Water and
Wastewater
Whole House
HVAC
Gas Space Heating
Appliances
Gas Water Heating
Lighting
Consumer
Electronics
Swimming Pools
Building Performance
Unitary Air-
conditioning
and Heat Pumps
Gas Boiler Systems
Clothes Washers
Kitchens
Gas Water Heating
Lighting Systems
Data Centers
and Servers
CEE member program administrators impact
markets in the US and Canada
Residential Commercial Industrial
3
CEE supports cross cutting functions
BC Hydro
Bonneville Power
Administration
ComEd
DTE Energy
Northwest Energy Efficiency
Alliance
NYSERDA
Sacramento Municipal Utility
District
Sempra
Southern California Edison
Xcel Energy
EM&V Behavior change
Connectivity Emerging
Technology
2014 Emerging Technologies Collaborative Sponsors
4
Emerging Technologies 101
Time
Ad
op
tio
n
•How do we identify the
highest performers?
•How do we leverage existing
trade networks?
•Does it work?
•Does it save energy?
•Can the market
deliver it?
•Do people like it?
Energy efficiency programs work to shorten the adoption time
5 Str
ate
gic
En
erg
y M
an
ag
em
en
t average
annual
energy
intensity
reduction
5%
More savings
over time
6
SEM Minimum Elements
Customer commitment
• Policy, goals, resources
Planning and implementation
• Assessment, map, metrics and goals, project register,
employee engagement, implementation,
reassessment,
System for measuring and reporting energy
performance
• Measurement, data collection and availability,
analysis, reporting
7
Strategic Energy Management
Programs 2014 Industrial SEM Programs & Pilots (21)
AEP Ohio
Ameren IL
BC Hydro
BPA
Commonwealth Edison-Nicor Gas
Consumers Energy
Efficiency New Brunswick
Efficiency Nova Scotia
Efficiency Vermont
Energy Trust of Oregon
Focus on Energy WI
Hydro Quebec
Idaho Power
National Grid
OPA
PPL Electric Utilities
Puget Sound Energy
Pacificorp
Snohomish PUD
So Cal Edison-So Cal Gas Co.
Tacoma Power
Bold indicates programs that use the CEE SEM Minimum Elements in program design or delivery
Data collected by CEE in the 2011-2014 CEE SEM Program Case Studies surveys
8
Strategic Energy Management
Multi-year
engagements
Ability to claim
savings from O&M,
behavior
Goals related to
customer satisfaction,
economic
development
CEE Initiative,
common definition
Case studies
National and
international platforms
• DOE Superior Energy
Performance
• ENERGY STAR for
Industry
• ISO 50001
CONSIDERATIONS RESOURCES
9
Health Care
Opportunity: Interested industry
Challenges
• Limited data, particularly on plug loads
• Competing customer priorities
Resources
• ENERGY STAR, CEE Health Care Exploration
Work together, bigger impact
• Define targeted objective
• Support interested industry meet targeted objective
10
Demand Control Kitchen Ventilation
(DCKV)
Range of
fan
energy
savings
30-
70%
11% HVAC
savings in
mild
climate
+
11
DCKV Programs 2014
DCKV Programs (31) AEP Ohio, Ameren IL, Austin Energy
BC Hydro, BPA, City of Palo Alto
Commonwealth Edison, Consumers
Energy
DTE Energy, Efficiency Nova Scotia
Energy Trust of Oregon, Fortis BC
Gaz Metro, Georgia Power
Hawaii Energy Efficiency Program
Northern California Power Agency
NV Energy, NYSERDA
PG&E, Pacificorp, PECO
Platte River Power Authority
Sacramento Municipal Utility District
San Diego Gas and Electric
Snohomish PUD, So Cal Edison
Southern Minnesota Municipal Power
Agency
Union Gas. Vermont Gas
WI Focus on Energy, Xcel Energy
Based on the 2014 CEE Commercial Kitchens Program Summary.
• >1,000,000 Kitchen Ventilation
Systems in the US
• Market penetration around 5%
12
Demand Control Kitchen Ventilation
(DCKV)
Savings vary by
application, climate,
system configuration
Quality installation,
commissioning, and
training are key
Ongoing monitoring
and commissioning
helps persistence
CEE Program Design
Guide
ENERGY STAR
Emerging Tech Award
DOE Better Buildings
Alliance Guide and
member interest
Field test protocol and
case study collection
CONSIDERATIONS RESOURCES
13
Commercial Advanced Lighting and
Controls Worst case scenario,
controls only
70%
70% % of lighting not
automatically controlled
Source: Cree
Source: Lighting Controls Association
Savings from controls
alone
Savings from controls
+ lighting upgrade
0%
93%
<0.1% Market penetration
of LED linear
replacement lamps
14
Commercial Advanced Lighting
Controls
Savings vary by
application, product
and existing
conditions
Technology evolves
very rapidly
Program “claimable”
savings vary based
on building codes
CEE Assessment
Procedure for
Commercial Lighting
Controls
Compilation of CEE
members
assessments
In process/under
consideration by CEE
Lighting Committee
CONSIDERATIONS RESOURCES
15
Heat Pump Water Heaters
Annual energy
savings for an
average family
with a 50 gallon
HPWH with an
EF of 2.35,
when compared
to an electric
resistance
water heater.
2,684
kWh*
*Based on the US Government Energy Guide Label.
Source: US DOE, Measure Guideline: Heat Pump Water Heaters in New and
Existing Homes, February 2012.
16
Heat Pump Water Heaters Assessments (18)
Bonneville Power Administration, Duke
Energy, Northwest Energy
Efficiency Alliance, Pacific Gas and
Electric, Sacramento Municipal
Utility District, San Diego Gas and
Electric, Tennessee Valley
Authority
2014 Programs (27)* Baltimore Gas and Electric, Black Hills
Energy, Cape Light Compact, City
of Palo Alto Utilities, Con Ed, CT
Light and Power, Efficiency ME,
Efficiency VT, Fortis BC, Liberty
Utilities, National Grid, NH Electric
Coop, NJ Clean Energy Program,
NIPSCO, NSTAR, NYSERDA,
PG&E, Public Service of NH, Puget
Sound Energy, Sacramento
Municipal Utility District, SoCal
Edison, Tennessee Valley
Authority, United Illuminating, Unitil,
Western MA Electric
*Based on the 2014 CEE Residential Appliances Program Summary.
17
Heat Pump Water Heaters
Market readiness:
installer capabilities
Customer readiness:
Noise
Complexity
Site requirements
Adequate airflow
Condensate drain
Ambient temps
Compilation of CEE
member assessments
(in process)
ENERGY STAR
specification
Online reviews
CONSIDERATIONS RESOURCES
18
Clothes Dryers, Heat Pump Clothes
Dryers
Savings Potential: 20%*
Resource: ENERGY STAR
ET Award and 2015 Spec
Concern: Understanding
actual energy performance of
baseline and EE models • Multiple test procedures
• Do test procedures reflect real world
conditions?
Concern: Customer
preferences and drying time
*Based on ENERGY STAR website
19
Televisions and Set Top Boxes
Savings Potential: 45%*
Resource: ENERGY STAR,
CEE working group
Challenges: non-traditional
partners, lack of data on energy
consumption and use *Based on ENERGY
STAR website
Savings Potential: 25%*
Resource: ENERGY STAR,
CEE Consumer Electronics
Program Center
What’s new: Ultra HD TVs
20
Wrap Up
Heat Pump Water
Heaters
Advanced Lighting
and Lighting Controls
Televisions
Clothes Dryers
Set Top Boxes
Strategic Energy
Management
Demand Control
Kitchen
Ventilation
