nba 600: session 10 online communities 20 february 2003 daniel huttenlocher
TRANSCRIPT
2
Today’s Class
Finish up discussion of online communities– Trust– Fraud– Reputation– Protecting material created by community
• Cyber-trespass laws
– “Pure communities” versus complementing other activities
– Dynamics of communities
Mid (1/3) term course evaluation
3
Online Community
People spending time adding value because they are having fun doing it– Interacting with others
• Areas where people are “expert” or “obsessive” draw more participants
– Need to attract both experts and non-experts• Providers and users of information, skill or
knowledge
Feedback is critical– Experts want to see they’re reaching audience– Non-experts want way to assess credibility– People want to know how well they are doing
4
Types of Communities
Community as supplement– E.g., Amazon uses reviewer community to
enhance site, not as sole value– As opposed to Ebay where community has
been entire value• This is changing with corporate sellers
Community as addiction– E.g., Many eBay users find auctions addictive
• Regular shopping can be addictive as well
– Gaming sites can have this property
If neither, challenge getting off the ground
5
Community Trust
Ebay’s initial challenge– Building trust to trade with strangers online
• Focused on sense of community and “inherent goodness of people”
Means of running cheaters out of town – Reputation scores based on completed
transactions (+,0,-)• Number of positives minus negatives• About half of transactions result in ratings
High reputation scores – “best citizens”– Ebay rewards its highest reputation sellers
• 85,000 points
6
Maintaining Trust
Ebay says fraud less than 1/100th percent– But still moving beyond “community policing”– Highly visible case involved real world too
• Merchant who fled with over $200K also had shop and employees
Poor experiences more common than outright fraud– Sellers now being verified through credit card or
other information• Contract with Verisign
Works in sense that fraud off eBay higher– E.g., case of fake cashiers check and used Mac’s
7
Is Fraud an Increasing Threat?
National consumer’s league reports large increase in 2002 auction fraud– From 70% to 87% of reported cases– About 15,000 cases average of nearly $500
Ebay reports only percentage of transactions that are fraudulent– But does not report numbers of transactions
nor dollar volume of fraud• Most eBay transactions much smaller than $500
Most seller fraud involves stolen ID’s and payment other than credit card
8
Reputation
Reputation mechanisms commonly used to build trust online– Need to trust the provider of the reputations
• The site, e.g., eBay, Amazon
Rankings of reviewers, rankings of transaction experience– Only works if people provide rankings
• They do, even though not of immediate value
– Studies show people more likely to provide positive than negative ratings• So either having very good experiences or bias
in reporting
9
Value of Reputation to Participants
Resnick (UMich) study shows price effect– Controlled study with “matched pairs” of
vintage postcards• Done in conjunction with established seller who
had high reputation• Sold one of each pair as relatively new seller with
little reputation– High reputation seller received closing bids on
average 7.6% higher than unknown sellers
Perhaps surprisingly, a few negative scores had little effect– Treated similar to unknown with a few positives
and no negatives
10
Value of Reputation to Provider
If participants could take reputations elsewhere would threaten provider– Verifiably high eBay score might make people
willing to shop directly at merchant site– Similar for gaming sites
Reputations are “owned” by the providers, as they are conferring their trust on the participants– All restrict the use in their terms of service
• Ebay monitors quite actively
– Not transferred when shut down or merged
11
Value of Community Product
An active community produces information that can be of substantial value– Currently open auctions on eBay– Reviews on Amazon
Substantial new legal decisions being made in this arena– New cyber-trespassing rulings
• Based on several hundred year old laws on “trespass to chattels”
– Prohibits unauthorized access to networked computer systems
12
Why New Laws Have Been Sought
Community generated value not usually protected by prior laws– Copyright does not apply to “facts” only
creative works• Landmark case – Feist telephone directory
listings• Open auctions are facts
– Reviews are creative works but copyright generally belongs to author• Explicit rights granted to site to display the work,
but author can display elsewhere• Authors would need to protect their rights
13
Limited Access to Ebay’s Site
Conventions restricting Web access by automated programs (so called robots or spiders)– Special Web page stating what access allowed
Ebay explicitly prohibits such automated access except as licensed– Grant rights to search engines– Have in past granted rights to auction
aggregators for a fee• Aggregators were formed in late ’90’s to provide
access to best prices across auction sites
14
Auction Aggregator Threat
Ebay’s dominant position could have been threatened– Items listed because it has biggest audience,
but aggregators might remove that advantage
Bidders Edge and eBay could not agree on license terms– Bidders Edge “copied” eBay’s site anyway– eBay sued to block access based on cyber-
trespass laws• Was granted preliminary injunction in early ‘00
Effectively shut down aggregator business
15
Implications of Cyber-Trespass
Findings based on– Unauthorized access to systems
• Up to provider to state what is authorized
– Resulting damage to systems from this access• Including diminution in value
It is this threat of diminished value of eBay’s site that was used in Bidders Edge decision
Does it threaten open access of Internet?– E.g., some worried price comparison sites
could be limited in ability to search retailers• This hasn’t really happened, in fact retailers
often pay comparison sites
16
Epinions and “Pure” Community
Goal to provide unbiased reviews of products and services– Contributed by visitors to site
• Small payments for reviews based on views• Rated for accuracy and value by other visitors
– Intent to be better than sites such as Amazon by having more of a community• Not restricted to items sold on one site
Initial revenue model – advertising Developed active community
– But not clearly larger or more informative than say Amazon reviewers
17
Evolution of Epinions
Changed model to being a shopping comparison site– Combining prices and user reviews– Similar to Bizrate which started with more of
focus on price comparison
Revenue model changed to include merchant fees for listings and/or referrals
Privately held – claims to have reached GAAP profitability for 2002– But mainly reports 50M unique visitors and
31M referrals to merchants
18
Dynamics of Communities
Need balance of creators and consumers– Can be difficult to get started
• Each requires other
– Can also be difficult to maintain• Imbalances arise, much as in markets
Hard to “bootstrap”– In traditional businesses can choose to lose
money while building up• E.g., content creation not done by employees
Yet online community remains a major potential of Internet over other channels
19
Examples of Community Dynamics
Auction sites have tended to exhibit strong all-or-none properties– Seller seeks largest possible audience
Despite eBay’s estimated 85% share in US, Yahoo and uBid both still active
In Japan, Yahoo auctions dominates– Ebay closed their Japanese site due to lack of
volume
In UK, eBay dominates– To extent that Yahoo closed their auction site
20
Announcements
Change in syllabus– Next week talk about digital content
• Pricing and versioning of information E.g., hardcover vs. paperback books
– Defer discussion of marketplaces until after digital content• What’s a marketplace? Multiple buyers and/or
sellers of commodity goods or services Note differs from most eBay auctions
Reminders– Appointments to discuss case project
• I’m away next Monday 2/24 and Friday 2/28– Short paper #3 due Tuesday (2/25)