nationally coordinated dental foundation training ... · the majority of these schemes...
TRANSCRIPT
London Recruitment, Health Education South London (HESL) working on behalf of England, Wales and Northern Ireland
for Dental Foundation Training (DFT) national recruitment 2015
Nationally Coordinated Dental Foundation Training
Recruitment in England, Wales and Northern Ireland
DFT National Applicant Guide - 2015
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 2
Introduction Prior to 2012, the recruitment to Dental Foundation Training (DFT) posts was held at deanery or local practice level. In order to standardise this process across England and Wales, and to ensure a fair and equitable process for all applying to these posts, a nationally coordinated recruitment process was introduced in 2012. This was led by COPDEND and administered by London Deanery (currently known as London Recruitment (HESL), with participation and input from individual deaneries at local selection centres. We are pleased to confirm that this process continued for 2013 and 2014 placements and that Northern Ireland also participated, and that it will continue to be in place for 2015 placements. DFT posts consist of placements in General Dental Practice and, occasionally, the Salaried Dental Services or as part of longitudinal schemes working in both the primary and secondary care environment. Dental foundation training introduces dentists to general dental practice and is a requirement for dental graduates from UK Dental Schools who wish to join a NHS Performers List. Trainees are employed under a standard contract for one year for 35 hours per week. One day per week during term time is designated a study day, usually at a local postgraduate centre. There is a minimum of thirty study days per year that must be attended in order to complete the programme. There are approximately seventy-one schemes in total, located in thirteen Local Education and Training Boards (LETBs) and deaneries across England, Wales and Northern Ireland. The majority of these schemes (approximately sixty nine) are for September 2015 start dates; two schemes have March only start dates and one has an August start date. Please note that the number of schemes have not yet been finalised.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 3
Contents 1. How to apply and the Dental Foundation national training portal
2. Enquiries
3. Eligibility
4. Right to work in the United Kingdom
5. Fitness to Practise process
6. Applicants with special requirements or disability
7. References
8. Expressing Preferences
9. Deferred Entry
10. Longlisting
11. Selection Centre
12. Offer Process 13. Allocation Process 14. Feedback 15. Enquiries 16. Expenses 17. Dental Foundation Trainee Salary Appendix I: Person Specification
Appendix II: Fitness to Practice process
Appendix III: Example scenario Communication in a clinical setting
Appendix IV: Example scenario Professionalism, Management and Leadership
Appendix V: Example SJT item
Appendix VI: SJT FAQs
Appendix VII: Selection Centre Document Checklist
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 4
Thank you for your interest in applying to Dental Foundation Training (DFT) national recruitment in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Please ensure you read and fully understand the contents of this guidance and the ‘Oriel Applicant System Guide’ before submitting your application. Failure to do so may result in you missing vital information in relation to your application.
If you have any questions, please contact London Recruitment, Health Education South London dedicated applicant enquiries by visiting the relevant section of the website. We aim to answer all emails in 48 hours (not including weekends or bank holidays) and the service is staffed from 9.00am to 5.00pm, Monday to Friday. Alternatively you can also call the phone service which is available Tuesday – Friday 11.00am-12.00 noon and 2.00pm- 4.00pm on 0207 863 1653.
In submitting an application form, applicants confirm that they have read and understood the application process. You will NOT be able to change your application once it has been submitted; if you have any questions please ensure you email the team prior to submitting your application.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 5
1. How to apply and the Dental Foundation Training (DFT) national recruitment portal
All applications must be made via the recruitment portal hosted by Health Education England using the nationally agreed application form.
Applications open at 12.00 noon (UK local time) on Monday 1 September 2014 and close at 12.00 noon (UK local time) on Monday 22 September 2014.
It will not be possible to submit an application after the deadline of 12 noon (UK local time) on 22 September 2014.
An advert will appear on NHS Jobs, Job Centre Plus, and the COPDEND website, as well as LETB/Deanery websites, advising interested applicants to visit the national recruitment portal of application.
Information about the LETBs and DFT schemes will be available to applicants via the recruitment portal, as well as on individual LETB’s websites.
To register with the recruitment portal you must ensure you have a valid email address. We recommend that you use an alternative email address to the one provided by your university or employer as these may expire prior to DFT start dates.
Communication between London Recruitment and applicants will be primarily via email. Applicants should check their email account and online recruitment account a minimum of once every 24 hours. Failure to do so may result in you missing vital information in relation to your application. Please also check ‘spam’ or ‘junk-mail’ to ensure correspondence has not been filtered by your provider.
2. Enquiries
Applicant enquiries regarding the process should be made by visiting the relevant section of the website.
Please do not contact individual LETBs/deaneries or the COPDEND Secretariat directly as they will not be able to answer queries. All correspondence should be directed to London Recruitment (HESL).
3. Eligibility
Before beginning your application it is important for you to determine whether you are eligible to apply. Applicants must meet certain eligibility criteria in order to be considered for Dental Foundation Training (DFT). These criteria are in place to meet GDC, legal and other requirements and will be assessed during the longlisting/selection centre stages.
These criteria include:
BDS (or equivalent) – your application form needs to state either date awarded OR anticipated date of award. Please note, you will not be eligible for a start date in March unless you will be awarded BDS by 1 January 2015. For an September start, you must have BDS (or equivalent) awarded by 1 July 2015. Equivalent qualifications must be achieved by the same timelines. If your primary qualification is not in English you will need to provide a certified translation prior to the start date.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 6
Eligible for full registration with the GDC by time of commencement of post. Please ensure you check the GDC website to determine whether you meet their eligibility criteria.
Eligibility to work in the UK.
Fitness to practise.
Eligible to join an NHS Dental Performer List (England and Wales only) by time of appointment
Dental Foundation Training (DFT) is designed for applicants to complete the necessary training required for entry on the UK Performers List (‘UKPL’) and hence to work unsupervised as a dentist in the NHS.
DFT is the only route available for many dental applicants to be included on the UKPL. Other applicants can be included on the UKPL without completing DFT, as they are exempt from needing to complete it or able to undertake Foundation Training by Assessment of Competences.
There are a limited number of DFT places available in England, Wales and Northern Ireland (‘DFT Places’). Previous recruitment rounds have been oversubscribed. Therefore, priority will be given in the 2015 DFT national recruitment process to those applicants for whom DFT is the only route available to be included on the UKPL. For the avoidance of doubt, this scheme is also open to Scottish graduates.
In the 2015 DFT national recruitment process, applicants who can be included on the UKPL without completing DFT will only be considered for DFT Places if there are insufficient suitable applicants who have no alternative route for entry on the UKPL.
The 2015 DFT recruitment process will be undertaken in one of two ways:
1. At the close of the application stage, if it is deemed that there are sufficient numbers of suitable applicants for whom DFT is the only route available to be admitted on the UKPL to fill all of DFT Places available, then applicants with alternative routes for entry will not progressed any further in the recruitment process;
Or 2. If at the close of the application stage it is deemed there is no certainty that there
will be sufficient numbers of such suitable applicants to fill all DFT Places, then eligible applicants who have alternative routes for entry on the UKPL will be progressed to the selection stage of the recruitment process. If following the selection centre process there are sufficient suitable appointees for whom DFT is the only route available to be admitted on the UKPL to fill all available DFT Places, then priority will be given to such applicants. Should there be insufficient number of such suitable applicants to fill all DFT Places, then applicants with alternative routes to entry on the UKPL may be offered DFT Places in the initial round. Any remaining applicants may be eligible for a second stage of offers (if needed) following the outcome of UK BDS/BChD results in July 2015.
Please note that this programme is designed to meet the requirements of the NHS Performers List and to allow those with little or no clinical experience post qualification to consolidate undergraduate learning.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 7
It is important to note that your application is likely to be rejected prior to assessment at the selection centre should you fail to demonstrate a criterion assessed at longlisting. Please refer to the person specification for full details. Please see Appendix I.
4. Right to work in the United Kingdom
Some applicants may be considered before others on the basis of immigration status, in accordance with guidance from the UK Visas & Immigration.
Applicants should refer to the UK Visas & Immigration website for up to date information regarding the right to work in the UK.
Neither London Recruitment (HESL), COPDEND nor any LETB/Deanery participating in this process will be able to provide any advice regarding immigration.
5. Fitness to Practise process
Applicants who answer “yes” to one or more of the ten questions listed on the application form under the Fitness to Practise section must provide full details via email to [email protected] by the application closing date (Monday 22 September at 12.00 noon). In this email please indicate clearly the question(s) to which you have provided a positive response. Please ensure you state that you have applied to DFT recruitment.
Failure to do so will result in your application being withdrawn.
For full details of the Fitness to Practise process please see Appendix II.
6. Applicants with a disability, health concerns or religious requirements
Applicants who wish to discuss the possibility of an adjustment at the selection centre (for example a prayer room or specific requirements relating to a disability) must provide full details via email to [email protected] by the application closing date, failure to do so will result in no action being taken. In this email please indicate what your requirements are, providing evidence if applicable (for example, applicants with dyslexia will need to provide their work psychology report).
Please see the following flow diagram.
Do you consider yourself to have a disability? Yes No
Do you need an adjustment because of a
disability?
Do you require adjustments to be made for your assessment? Do you require adjustments to be made for you to undertake the posts as advertised?
Yes No No
Contact [email protected]
e.nhs.uk with details and any supporting
evidence eg Educational Psychologist report by closing
date of application
No further action required
No further action
required
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 8
Failure to provide details prior to the application closing date may result in an inability of London Recruitment HESL to make reasonable adjustments for your requirements at the selection centre. Reasonable adjustments WILL NOT be made if you do not inform London Recruitment HESL in advance. Individual selection centres will only make adjustments as advised by London Recruitment HESL and not by applicants directly.
Please see ‘Supporting trainees with a disability’ for further information.
7. References
Candidates will not be asked to submit any reference details as part of their application. These will be requested after offers have been accepted.
8. Expressing Preferences
This year expressing preferences will be completed via the Oriel recruitment system, and will be done separately from the submission of your application form. Scheme information will be made available to all applicants by visiting a dedicated page on the London Recruitment HESL website. Applicants will be sent the relevant link via the e-mail address stated on the application form no later than 26 September 2014. Applicants are advised to look at this Scheme information carefully in order to inform decisions on preferencing. On 8 December 2014, eligible applicants will be sent an email to their registered email account with full instructions on how to complete preferencing including use of the recruitment system. This will involve logging into the system and submitting preferences by 15 December 2014. Once the preferencing window closes on 15 December 2014 no changes to preferencing can be made.
Please note the email regarding preferencing will come from [email protected]. Please
ensure your email settings regarding SPAM allow emails to be received from
[email protected]. Any emails from this address are authentic.
Information regarding local allocation to dental practices is explained in section 13 of this document.
9. Deferred Entry
Deferment can only be considered on statutory grounds such as maternity leave or ill health. Please ensure you inform London Recruitment (HESL) of your intention to defer as soon as it is known, via the applicant enquiries service.
10. Longlisting
Longlisting will be conducted as one single national exercise, and will be conducted to check the eligibility of applicants.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 9
Applications will be longlisted using the entry criteria from the person specification. Please see Appendix I.
11. Selection Centre
The selection process will be managed via six selection centres across England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Selection will be conducted at the following centres: Belfast, Birmingham, Bristol, London, Manchester and Newcastle.
Eligible UK undergraduate applicants will be allocated to a selection centre which is closest to their dental school. Postgraduate applicants and eligible applicants from outside England, Wales and Northern Ireland will be allocated to any one of the six centres based on centre capacity.
Selection centres will be held on the following dates:
Selection Centre Dates Centre Venue Dental Schools Covered
17 – 18 November 2014 London London Recruitment Events Centre King’s College London
Queen Mary, University of London
18 – 19 November 2014
Bristol Bristol Marriott Hotel, City Centre
Bristol University
Cardiff University
Peninsula College of Dentistry
Manchester Macron Stadium, Bolton
University of Central Lancashire
University of Liverpool
University of Manchester
19 - 20 November 2014
Birmingham West Bromwich Albion
University of Birmingham
University of Sheffield
Belfast Ramada Hotel, Shaw's Bridge, Belfast Queen’s University, Belfast
20 - 21 November 2014 Newcastle Newcastle United Football Club
Newcastle University
University of Leeds
Eligible undergraduates from Scotland will be accommodated at the Newcastle centre.
In exceptional circumstances these dates may be amended and every effort will be made to advise applicants in good time.
A formal notification, inviting applicants to selection centre will be sent via email on 20 October 2014.
Applicants will be informed via the recruitment system that they have been invited to selection centre. Should an applicant wish to decline the invite, they should do so within 48 hours of receipt, otherwise it will be assumed that the applicant will be attending.
The selection centre process comprises of two stations that cover the following domains: communication in a clinical setting, professionalism, management, leadership. This will be followed by a Situational Judgement Test (SJT).
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 10
Station 1 – Communication in a Clinical Setting
This station will take the form of a role play. A medical role player will play the part of a patient with a clinical problem. Applicants will be assessed on their interaction with the ‘patient’. This station will last 10 minutes, and accounts for 25% of the final score. Applicants will read a scenario five minutes prior to entering this station. For an example Communication in a Clinical Setting scenario, please see Appendix III.
Station 2 – Professionalism, Management and Leadership
In this station the applicant will be asked to answer scenario based questions by two DFT assessors in a standard interview format. This station will last 10 minutes, during which one scenario will be covered, and accounts for 25% of the final score.
For an example Professionalism, Management and Leadership (PML) scenario, please see Appendix IV.
Please see diagrammatic representation of an applicant’s selection centre process:
TIME Communication PML
5 minutes Reading/Break
10 minutes Candidate A Candidate B
5 minutes Reading/Break
10 minutes Candidate B Candidate A
There will be a five minute break between Station 1 and Station 2. This is to allow for reading time.
During the assessment process, it is necessary for the DFT assessors to be made aware that the ten minute time for a station is nearing an end. A timekeeper will signal after eight minutes have passed that there are two minutes remaining.
Each station will assess different aspects of the person specification and will include one or more domains. The two stations will be scored by two DFT assessors. Please note in the Communication in a Clinical Setting station one of the DFT assessors is the actor. All DFT assessors will have experience and training and will have been fully calibrated.
Situational Judgement Test
After completing the assessment process shown above, all applicants will complete the Situational Judgement Test in exam settings. This will last for 105 minutes and accounts for 50% of the final score. For an example SJT question, please see Appendix V. For FAQs relating to the SJT please see Appendix VI.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 11
Lay Chairs
National and local Lay Chairpersons will oversee the selection process and ensure that all panels are consistent and managed in accordance with the process agreed by COPDEND. The role of the Lay Chair will be to:
- Attend and chair recruitment meetings organised by the centre
- Brief and advise on selection centre and allocation panels for compliance with good employment practice
- Ensure that decisions are fair and equitable
- Ensure selection panels understand and comply with guidance on the provision of feedback to applicants
Please note, external observers will be present at the Assessment Centres. They will play no part in the assessment process and are present as part of the quality assurance of this process. They will observe individual stations as well as the general organisation of the day.
Documentation
Important: Applicants will be asked to bring certain documentation with them to the selection centre. Failure to bring the specified documents may result in applicants not being assessed. Any applicants with concerns over their ability to bring the required documents with them to a selection centre should make urgent contact with London Recruitment in advance of the selection centre.
Full details of the documents required for the selection centre can be found in Appendix VII. Please ensure you bring the original document plus a photocopy (as stipulated below). This copy will be retained by staff at the selection centre.
12. Offer Process
The scores of all applicants from the six centres will be centrally collated to produce a single national ranking based upon the scores from the six selection centres.
Offers of training placements will be made based upon applicant rank and preferences, and will be subject to success at BDS or equivalent. If you are unsuccessful in obtaining BDS or equivalent by either 1 January 2015 for March schemes or by 1 July 2015 for September schemes, you will no longer be eligible to take up the post.
As this selection constitutes a method by which an individual’s suitability for a DFT post is assessed, applicants should be aware that based on their performance they may be found unsuccessful in this process on this occasion. This will exclude some applicants from receiving an offer of a training post, but does not exclude them from future rounds of DFT recruitment.
Your allocation to a foundation scheme will depend on the ranking you achieve as a result of your selection centre performance.
It is envisaged that offers of a DFT place detailing the LETB/Deanery and scheme will be available to successful applicants via the recruitment system by London Recruitment (HESL) website on behalf of COPDEND by 7 January 2015 for all schemes.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 12
Applicants will be given 48 hours in which to accept, accept with upgrades or reject an offer (including weekends and bank holidays) by logging in to the recruitment system and responding. If applicants fail to respond during this 48 hour period, they will be deemed to have rejected the offer made. In this case the system will automatically decline the offer.
Applicants who reject an offer will not be offered any further placements.
Once an offer is accepted it cannot be changed to a training placement in another LETB/Deanery or scheme.
- Please be aware that applicants will only be made one offer. If you limit the number of schemes you are prepared to train in this could limit the possibility of being offered a training placement.
- Any offer is made in accordance with rank and preference.
- The first ranked applicant will be offered their first preferenced scheme and so on.
- If you limit your preferences and you do not rank highly enough to be offered any of them, you will not be offered a training post.
- This may mean that applicants who would be eligible for an offer based on their score and rank will not receive an offer of a training post.
- In this case applicants are considered to have pre-emptively declined an offer of a post as the only vacancies left are in schemes that the applicant is not prepared to train in. This is indicated by the applicant having placed the scheme in the ‘Not wanted’ column on the system.
At this stage of the process the offer is to an LETB/Deanery and scheme (not a training practice).
In the event of a tied rank, the combined score from the Professionalism, Management and Leadership stations will be used to differentiate between applicants. If this score is also equal, the score received in the Communication in a Clinical Setting will next be used as the discriminator. In the unlikely event this score is also tied, the final score from the Situational Judgement Test will be used as the final discriminator.
Once all offers have been accepted the list of successful applicants, with their ranking within each scheme, will be sent to the LETB/Deanery hosting that scheme. This ranking may then be used to inform the local allocation process of a training post at individual dental practice.
Please note special circumstances will not be taken in to account when allocating to a specific scheme or practice.
If you have a disability you must let us know by contacting [email protected] at the time of application, with details of any reasonable adjustments which might need to be made if you are appointed (please see Section 6 Applicants with a disability, health concerns or religious requirements for further details). We will pass these details on to your allocated LETB/Deanery. The allocation of schemes may be made on the basis of your ranking and your preferences.
If you are considered to be appointable but do not rank highly enough to receive an offer in the first iteration made in January 2015 you will remain on the reserve list. Should any training placements become available between January 2015 and the start date of posts, due to appointees withdrawing or failing to meet eligibility requirements, remaining eligible candidates on the reserve list will be offered a
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 13
placement in rank order and in relation to preferences provided upon application. This smaller iteration of offers will occur in early July after BDS results have been announced, and will continue until all vacant posts have been filled.
All applicants will receive notification of the status of their application following selection centre by 7 January 2015. This will be in the form of an email and will state one of the following:
An offer to a DFT scheme
A notification that all current vacancies have been filled and you are on the reserve list
A notification that you have been found unsuccessful in this process on this occasion
13. Local Allocation Process
Allocation to a training practice within a DFT scheme will be managed locally by the LETB/Deanery hosting the scheme and DOES NOT constitute part of the England, Wales and Northern Ireland national process.
Any applicant can decline the offer made to them but this will result in failure to secure a DFT place for 2015.
For both March and September 2015 start dates, allocation to a practice will take place from 7 January 2015.
14. Feedback
Individual feedback will be available to all applicants on 7 January 2015 from the recruitment portal. The information will be specific to each applicant and will provide information regarding their rank and score.
15. Enquiries
Any further enquiries should be made via the applicant enquiries service.
16. Expenses
Please note that any expenses incurred by applicants as part of the recruitment process will not be reimbursed.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 14
17. Dental Foundation Trainee Salary Dental foundation trainees are paid according to the nationally agreed salary in each of the three UK countries involved in this nationally coordinated recruitment process. For England and Wales the exact figure appears in the Statements of Financial Entitlement published periodically by The Departments of Health for England and Wales. For Northern Ireland this is published in the Statement of Dental Remuneration (SDR). Please note that the figure published and applicable at the date of application may not be the same as that in force at the time of starting in post. Thank you for your interest in applying to 2015 Dental Foundation Training recruitment. We hope you have found this guidance useful, however if you have any further queries please do not hesitate to contact our dedicated Applicant Enquiries team. You are required to read and fully understand the ‘Applicant User Guide’. In submitting an application form, applicants confirm that they have read and understood the application process. You will be unable to change your application once it has been submitted; if you have any questions please ensure you email the Applicant Enquiries team prior to submitting your application.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 15
Appendix I
DENTAL FOUNDATION TRAINING NATIONAL PERSON SPECIFICATION 2015
ESSENTIAL DESIRABLE WHEN EVALUATED PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS AND ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENTS
BDS (or equivalent) by 1 January 2015 for March 2015 start, or by 1 July 2015 for September 2015 start
Must have full registration with the GDC by time of commencement of post
Eligible to join an NHS Dental Performer List at the time of appointment
Application Form
ELIGIBILITY
Eligibility to work in the UK
Application Form
CAREER PROGRESSION
Provide complete dental education and dental employment history
Requires Dental Foundation Training as the only route to access the NHS Dental Performers List
Application Form
FITNESS TO PRACTISE
Is up to date and fit to practise safely
Application Form
APPLICATION FORM
ALL sections of application form completed FULLY according to
written guidelines
Application Form
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 16
LANGUAGE SKILLS
All applicants to have demonstrable skills in written and spoken English adequate to enable effective communication with patients and colleagues demonstrated by one of the following:
that applicants have undertaken undergraduate medical/dental training in English; or
have achieved the following scores in the academic International English Language Testing System (IELTS)in a single sitting within 24 months at time of application – Overall 7.5, Speaking 7, Listening 7, Reading 7, Writing 7
If applicants believe they have adequate communication skills but do not fit into one of these examples they must provide supporting evidence
Selection Centre
CLINICAL SKILLS
Appropriate knowledge base and ability to apply sound clinical judgement to problems
Ability to apply clinical knowledge
Ability to prioritise clinical need
Understanding of clinical risk management
Clear logical thinking, showing an analytical approach
Demonstrates understanding of evidence-informed practice.
Shows awareness of own limitations
Shows initiative/ drive/enthusiasm (self-starter, motivated, shows curiosity, initiative)
Selection Centre
COMMUNICATION
Empathy & Sensitivity:
Capacity to take in others’ perspectives and treat others with understanding
Communication Skills:
Capacity to adapt language as appropriate to the situation
Uses a non-judgmental approach to patients and colleagues (regardless of their sexuality, ethnicity, disability, gender, age religious beliefs or financial status)
Selection Centre
MANAGEMENT AND LEADERSHIP
Organisation & Planning:
Capacity to manage/prioritise time and information effectively
Thoroughness (is well prepared, shows self-discipline/commitment, is punctual and meets deadlines)
Selection Centre
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 17
Managing Others & Team Involvement:
Capacity to work effectively with others
Understands the importance of working in teams
Vigilance & Situational Awareness:
Capacity to monitor developing situations and anticipate issues
Coping with Pressure:
Capacity to operate under pressure. Demonstrates initiative & resilience to cope with changing circumstances
PROFESSIONALISM
Professional Integrity:
Capacity to take responsibility for own actions. Demonstrates respect for all
Demonstrates an understanding of the importance of putting patients’ needs and interests first
Selection Centre
PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS
Meets professional health requirements
Evaluated by local deanery and occupational health assessment (if required)
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 18
Appendix II – Fitness to Practise process
Applicant answers YES to one or more of 10 Fitness to Practise
questions upon application
Applicant contacts Fitness to Practise at London Recruitment
(HESL) by application close date
Initial review conducted by London Recruitment (HESL), taking into
account representation from the candidate
If applicant is interviewed and subsequently offered a post, London
will discuss with the local LETB
Decision reached at local LETB
Proceed with
Offer
Applicant
Withdrawn
EITHER
Applicant does not contact
London Recruitment (HESL)
Applicant Withdrawn
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 19
Appendix III – Communication in a Clinical Setting example scenario
Applicant Briefing:
You are a Dental Foundation trainee working in a busy multi surgery dental practice.
Mr Andrew Smith is a 40 year old male. He attended the practice for the first time 2 days ago and was seen by one of the associates. At that visit Mr Smith was complaining of slight discomfort with an upper tooth. The broken tooth had only caused slight discomfort for the past few days and cleared when taking paracetamol. Mr Smith is an irregular attender for dental treatment and his last visit was 5 years ago. Intra oral examination revealed a carious upper left first premolar tooth. Special tests undertaken at that first visit by the associate revealed a positive response to an electric pulp test. In addition a periapical radiograph was taken of the maxillary left first premolar to assess the extent of caries, root morphology and the presence/absence of any apical pathology. The tooth was dressed by the associate and an appointment had been booked in a week’s time. Mr Smith has been booked in today for an emergency appointment. He is now complaining of pain with the UL4 and it had affected his sleep for the past 2 nights. He cannot wait until his appointment with the associate next week. Before you see Mr Smith you study the previous clinical records including the medical history as highlighted in the text above. You have read the radiographic report of the UL4 completed by the associate and visually examined the radiograph to confirm the findings. The report states there is
A deep carious lesion distal UL4
No evidence of apical pathology UL4
Good bone support
No evidence of caries in adjacent teeth
Using appropriate language and communication undertake the necessary history when the patient attends for this emergency appointment; discuss your clinical and radiographic findings with the patient. In addition outline the treatment options available and respond to any questions the patient may have.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 20
Appendix IV – Professionalism, Management and Leadership example scenarios
Scenario 1 You are in your Dental Foundation training practice. A 21 year old female patient who does not speak English is accompanied by her father who interprets. The patient has a mesial cavity in the upper central incisor which is causing her some pain but which is restorable. You suggest restoring the tooth but her father asks you to extract the tooth as ‘she does not want to be bothered with fillings’ Scenario 2 You are in your Dental Foundation training practice. A patient returns following a recent endodontic procedure which was carried out by a colleague in the practice. The patient is complaining of pain and swelling associated with the tooth which you find has a fractured instrument in situ. The patient is not aware of the fractured instrument.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 21
Appendix V - Example SJT item
A new patient, Louise, asks you to veneer all her front teeth. She hopes to pursue a career as a model and has been advised by a friend that veneers may help her do this. On examination Louise’s teeth are perfectly healthy with no previous restorations and just some very mild crowning. Her teeth are vita shade A3. Rank in order the following actions in response to this situation (1=most appropriate, 5=least appropriate)
A. Respect Louise’s wishes and schedule appointment for the veneers B. Ensure Louise is aware of alternatives such as orthodontics and tooth
whitening. C. Suggest a course of tooth whitening and explain the legal issues involved. D. Establish exactly what Louise does not like about her teeth E. Offer to refer Louise to a specialist to discuss the veneers in more detail
British Dental Journal Volume 13 NO.1 Jul 14 2012 (page 24)
Fig 1 Fill in the box to indicate the rank for each option on the answer sheet. If you think A is the most appropriate option in this question and B the second most appropriate, C the third, D the fourth and E the fifth and least appropriate you would complete your answer as follows:
Fig 2 Fig 2 shows how to complete the answer sheet and is not an indication to correct answer to the example scenario
Most Least
A 1
2
3
4
5
B 1
2
3
4
5
C 1
2
3
4
5
D 1
2
3
4
5
E 1
2
3
4
5
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 22
Appendix VI – SJT FAQs
What is a Situational Judgement Test (SJT)? A Situational Judgment Test is a measurement tool where applicants are tested on hypothetical work situations. The DFT SJT is set within the context of a dental practice. Applicants will be assessed against the professional attributes expected of a trainee soon to enter the Dental Foundation programme such as:
Professional integrity
Resilience and coping with pressure
Effective communication
Empathy
Working effectively as part of a team The recruitment process includes a panel interview and focuses on measuring the skills and knowledge of applicants. Having an SJT as part of the selection process will measure a wider set of skills which should identify the most suitable applicants for the DFT programme. The SJT is a multiple choice paper based assessment; The SJT will last for 105 minutes and will consist of 56 questions. Please note that only 50 of these questions will be used for the overall SJT score. 6 questions are being asked as part of an evaluation process. Applicants will not be made aware which questions are part of the evaluation process. Can I revise for the SJT? There is no need to revise for the SJT as it is not a test of clinical knowledge. The SJT assumes that applicants have knowledge of, and insight into the job role of a DFT dental student and applicants will be required to respond as they should at this level. The SJT lasts 105 minutes. How long do I spend on each question? What if I don’t finish on time? The SJT is designed so that there is sufficient time for applicants to complete the test. It is important that you try and plan your time carefully and attempt to answer all questions. You will receive no marks for any questions that you do not answer, but you will not be negatively marked (i.e. your score on other items won’t be reduced). How are the SJT items written? After consulting clinicians and consultants in the field, the Work Psychology Group (WPG) has written the questions for the SJT. (WPG) are experts in creating selection and assessment processes. The questions are multiple choice, paper based questions designed to assess applicants’ behaviour and responses to hypothetical scenarios in work relevant situations. How much of my overall Interview score does the SJT account for? The SJT will account for 50% of your final total score. The Communication in a Clinical Setting, and Professionalism, Management and Leadership stations will account for 25% of your total score each. I usually have adjustments made for my university exams. Will this count for the SJT? Any adjustments you have arranged for the recruitment process including the written exam will be carried over to the SJT. You can do this by emailing [email protected]
How are SJT items scored?
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 23
SJT items are scored against pre-determined keys that have been derived from consultations with multiple SMEs, so that the scoring of the test is standardised and fair to all applicants.
Ranking items: For ranking items, you will receive marks dependent on your responses’ proximity to the correct answers. Full marks for an item are awarded if your response matches the correct answer and partial marks are awarded if your response is close to the correct answer. There is generally a maximum of 20 points available for each ranking item.
The table below illustrates the scoring system in more detail. Imagine you are answering a ranking question in the exam. You are given a list of five actions/options and are then asked to rank in order the following actions in response to this situation (1 = most appropriate and 5 = least appropriate). Let’s say that the predetermined key for this question is CABDE. Option C has thus been predetermined by multiple SMEs to be the ‘most appropriate’ option (and in other words, ranked as 1 out of 5). If you note down on the answer sheet that Option C is the most appropriate option you would be awarded 4 full marks. If you select instead one of the adjacent options, Option B or Option D, you would still be awarded 3 points, and so on. Therefore, an applicant does not need to get every option exactly in the correct order to obtain a good score on the SJT.
Multiple choice items: For multiple choice questions, 4 marks are awarded for each correct option chosen, with a maximum of 12 marks generally available for each question. Please note that if you select more than three options then you will not be awarded any marks for this question.
You will receive no marks for any questions that you do not answer, but you will not be negatively marked (i.e. your score on other items won’t be reduced).
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 24
Appendix VII
Selection Centre Document Checklist
Required documentation you MUST bring to the selection centre
All of the documentation listed below is required, both in the form and number specified. A summary checklist is attached for review.
Please note, failure to bring the required documents listed below may result in you not being assessed. In most cases, a photocopy of the documentation is required to be given to the recruitment staff at the assessment centre. It is the responsibility of all applicants to obtain photocopies PRIOR to the assessment centre. There will be no provision for this at the assessment centre.
Essential Documents Required by ALL Applicants
Proof of Identity (see Appendix A of a list of acceptable documents). We require either:
o TWO forms of photographic personal identification and ONE original document providing proof of address (e.g. recent utility bill)
OR o ONE form of photographic person identification and TWO original
documents confirming your address
Permission to work (see Appendix B for a list of acceptable documents). We require:
o ONE original document as specified in either List A or List B)
ONE Passport photo with your name printed on back
Original, current passport and ONE clear photocopy of each of the following:
Front cover
Name/signature and photo page
Visa/right to work page (if applicable)
If you are NOT a UK or EEA citizen, you MUST provide:
The original document at the selection centre, along with a clear photocopy of the page/s in your passport showing current immigration status.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 25
OR
If you have an identity card / biometric residence permit card issued by UK Border Agency, the original document at the selection centre, along with a clear photocopy of each side of the identity card.
AND
Original and one copy of all supporting documentation from the Home Office regarding your current visa status. This is the approval letter from the UK Border Agency granting the visa. It will have a start date and an end date. This should be accompanied by the relevant page of the valid current passport showing the visa stamp OR the Biometric Resident Permit.
If applicable:
Original and ONE photocopy of your primary qualification - BDS (or equivalent). If your primary qualification is not in English then please bring a certified translation.
Original and ONE photocopy of any postgraduate qualifications
English Language Proficiency
Original of your CURRENT GDC licensing letter and one photocopy – out of date certificates will not be accepted as proof
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 26
Appendix A:
Documents which provide proof of identity
I. Photographic personal identification
Valid current passport
Valid current photo-card driving licence
Valid current national ID card and / or other valid documentation relating to immigration status and permission to work
Valid current ID card issued by the UK Visa and Immigration (UKVI) NB organisational ID cards are not acceptable (e.g. NHS ID card)
II. Confirmation of address documents
Recent utility bill (gas, electricity or land line phone) or a certificate from a supplier of utilities confirming the arrangement to pay for the services on pre-payment terms.
Local authority tax bill valid for the current year
Bank, building society or credit union statement or passbook containing current address
Most recent mortgage statement from a recognised lender
Current local council rent card or tenancy agreement
Current benefit book or card or original notification letter from Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) confirming the rights to benefit.
Confirmation from an electoral register search that a person of that name lives at the claimed address
Court order All the above must be dated within the last six months and must contain the name and address of the applicant. Please note we will not accept print-outs of online accounts/statements. The requirements for ID checking are defined by the Cabinet Office and employers are required to obtain original documents to comply with the HMG's Minimum Requirements for the Verification of the Identity of Individuals (Version 2.0 January 2003).
If you are unable to provide photographic proof of identity, we can accept the following non-photographic proof of personal identification documents.
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 27
You will need TWO DOCUMENTS from the list AND an ADDITIONAL passport sized photograph of yourself, endorsed on the back with the signature of a “person of standing”. This should be someone from your community who has known you for at least three years.
A “person of standing” could be a magistrate, medical practitioner, officer of the armed forces, teacher, lecturer, lawyer, bank manager or civil servant.
Document giving your permanent National Insurance Number and name - this could be a P45, P60, National Insurance card, or a letter from a Government agency
Original full birth certificate issued in the UK, which includes the name of at least one of your parents; (issued within six weeks of birth)
Original birth certificate issued in the Channel Islands, the Isle of Man or Ireland;
Current UK driving licence (full version)
Original UK adoption certificate
Original UK marriage / UK civil partnership certificate
Original UK divorce or annulment papers
Police registration document
Certificate of employment in HM Forces
Current UK firearms certificate
Application Registration Card issued to people seeking asylum in the UK
Certificate of registration or naturalisation stating that the holder is a British citizen
Current benefit book or card or original notification letter from the Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) confirming legal right to benefit.
Residence permit issued by the Home Office to EU Nationals on inspection of own-country passport
Most recent tax notification from HM Revenue and Customs (Formerly Inland Revenue)
Letter issued by the Home Office to you which indicates that you can stay indefinitely in the UK, or has no time limit on your stay
Letter issued by the Home Office to you which indicates that you can stay in the UK and this allows you to do the type of work we are offering
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 28
Appendix B:
Documents which provide proof of entitlement to work in the UK
LIST A
Passport showing that the holder is a British citizen or a citizen of the UK and colonies having the right of abode in the UK
Passport or national ID card showing that the holder is a national of the EEA or Switzerland
Residence permit indicating permanent residence issued by the Home Office or UKVI to a national of a EEA country or Switzerland
Permanent residence card issued by the Home Office or UKVI to the family member of a national of an EEA country or Switzerland
Biometric Immigration Document issued by the UKVI which indicates that the person named in it is allowed to stay indefinitely in the UK or has no time limit on their stay in the UK
Passport or other travel document endorsed to show that the holder is exempt from immigration control, is allowed to stay indefinitely in the UK, has the right of abode in the UK or has no time limit on their stay in the UK
Immigration Status Document issued by the Home Office or UKVI to the holder with an endorsement indicating that the person named in it is allowed to stay indefinitely in the UK or has no time limit on their stay in the UK, when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
Full birth certificate issued in the UK which includes the name(s) of at least one of the holder's parents when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
Full adoption certificate issued in the UK which includes the name(s) of at least one of the holder's parents when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
Birth certificate issued in the Channel Islands, the Isle of Man or Ireland when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
Adoption certificate issued in the Channel Islands, the Isle of Man or Ireland when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
Certificate of registration or naturalisation as a British citizen when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 29
Letter issued to the holder by the Home Office or UKVI indicating the person named in it is allowed to stay indefinitely when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name LIST B – Limited Leave to Remain
Passport or travel document endorsed to show that the holder is allowed to stay in the UK and is allowed to do the type of work in question, provided that it does not require the issue of a work permit
Biometric Immigration Document issued by the UKVI which indicates that the person named in it can stay in the UK and is allowed to do the work in question
Work permit or other approval to take employment issued by the Home Office or the UKVI when produced in combination with either a passport of another travel document endorsed to show the holder is allowed to stay in the UK and is allowed to do the work in question
Certificate of application that is less than 6 months old issued by the Home Office or the UKVI to, or for, a family member of a national of an EEA country or Switzerland stating that the holder is permitted to take employment, when produced in combination with evidence of verification by the UKVI Employer Checking Service
Residence card or document issued by the Home Office or the UKVI to a family member of a national of an EEA country or Switzerland
Application Registration Card issued by the Home Office or UKVI stating that the holder is permitted to take employment, when produced in combination with evidence of verification by the UKVI Employer Checking Service
Immigration Status Document issued by the Home Office or UKVI to the holder with an endorsement indicating that the person named in it is allowed to stay in the UK and is allowed to do the type of work in question, when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
Letter issued by the Home Office or UKVI to the holder or the employer or prospective employer with an endorsement indicating that the person named in it is allowed to stay in the UK and is allowed to do the type of work in question, when produced in combination with an official document giving the person's permanent NI number and their name
None of the document descriptions reflect the precise wording contained in the legislation. If you would like to obtain a full account of the legal changes, this will be available in the booklet the Home Office will be producing alongside this guidance. Further guidance on preventing illegal working can be found at
https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/uk-visas-and-immigration
This information comes from NHS Employment Check Standards – published by http://www.nhsemployers.org/Pages/home.aspx
Version 1 (22/08/2014) 30
Applicants with any concerns regarding their ability to provide documentation at the selection centre must contact the relevant LETB/Deanery prior to the selection centre date.