national institute of economic and social research uk economic policy and prospects jonathan portes...
TRANSCRIPT
National Instituteof Economic and Social Research
UK economic policy and prospects
Jonathan Portes
June 2013
www.niesr.ac.uk
Twitter: @jdportes
Niesr.ac.uk/blog
What explains UK economic underperformance?- Fiscal policy: predictable result of premature consolidation
- Continued dysfunctionality of financial sector
- Commodity prices/imported inflation
- And of course the eurozone
- Fortunately the labour market has come to the rescue..
Blaming the eurozone? Yes and no..
Impact of consolidation programmes on level of GDP, 2013
-14
-12
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
Aus
tria
Bel
gium
Fin
land
Fra
nce
Ger
man
y
Gre
ece
Irel
and
Ital
y
Net
hs
Por
tuga
l
Spa
in
UK
Eur
oA
rea
% d
iffer
ence
fro
m b
ase
Scenario 1 Scenario 2
How to minimise the damage? Lots of Plans..
• Posen: public and private investment, BIB, BoE purchases
• NIESR: public infrastructure, NICs, reverse benefit cuts
• LSE GC: investment, skills/human capital, innovation
• Fabians (Pryce, Weldon, Mazzucato, Portes, et al) : state banks, innovation, immigration, inequality, etc.
• “Hayekians”: cut spending “properly”, cut taxes
No-one left to defend “muddling through”, but that’s what we’ll get..
What does a (medium-term) growth strategy look like?• Building on successes (competition, labour market)
• Addressing weaknesses (management, educational underperformance, planning/housing)
• Identifying and maximising sectors of comparative advantage (HE, finance, creative industries, business services, pharma, hi-tech manufacturing)
• Much of this is common ground – so what are the issues/challenges?
Housing• Housing market contributes to number of structural problems with UK
economy:
– Financial instability– Labour immobility– Inequality/social immobility
• But Help To Buy has achieved the impossible..
• Reforms/investment needed for social housing, planning, and mortgage finance
National Instituteof Economic and Social Research
UK economic policy and prospects
Jonathan Portes
February 2013
www.niesr.ac.uk
Twitter: @jdportes
Blog: notthetreasuryview.blogspot.com