naplan narratives resource
TRANSCRIPT
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 1/33
NAPLaN
Narratives
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 2/33
Précis
This resource analyses approaches to text construction and recommends a structured, explicit
approach to the teaching of NAPLaN Narrative. It explores the teaching of NAPLaN Narrative
within a model of functional grammar and includes information for teachers, templates for
student writing and resources such as teaching posters that can be displayed in classrooms.
Background
The Text Construction and Text Analysis Research Project commenced in 2006, and is exploring
what happens in the teaching and learning process - from before students construct a text, to
after a text has been analysed and assessed .
In response to the Research Project’s findings, the following materials have been developed and
are being explored by teachers, with a view towards the continual improvement in the
development and delivery of professional learning and resources.
The Text Construction and Text Analysis Research Project has been exploring:
• the link between teaching practice and student writing
• strategies for supporting the development of student competence in writing for a range of
purposes and contexts
• embedding explicit teaching of language and literacy in classroom teaching
More recently the research has centred around the explicit teaching practice required to support
students to be successful in the NAPLaN writing task.
Introduction
The aim of this resource is to explore approaches to supporting the teaching and learning process
around NAPLaN Narratives. This also includes supporting students to manage working under
NAPLaN testing conditions.
This resource acknowledges the reality that one of the main foci of NAPLaN is to assess student
understanding and writing of a narrative around an unknown topic/context within a set time
limit. The NAPLaN writing task does not explicitly request, nor require teachers to follow a
teaching and learning cycle. However, based on this research, the benefits of undertaking an
explicit teaching and learning cycle are realised in improved student writing of the task required.
(See pre and post teaching student writing samples, pages 17- 18).
Pam Boyle Giuseppe Mammone
ESL Regional Consultants ESL Regional Consultants
Eastern Adelaide & Adelaide Hills Western Adelaide, & Eyre & Western
July 2010
NAPLaN Narratives 1
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 3/33
Contents
Page Number
Précis 1
Background 1
Introduction 1
Contents 2
Aligning Teacher and Student Understandings of theWriting Task in NAPLaN
3
NAPLaN Marking Criteria 3
Time Management 4
Assessing the Narrative Using ESL Scales 4
NAPLaN Narrative Hot Tips 5
Reproducible Resources for Classroom Use 6
My Narrative Writing Plan 1 7
My Narrative Writing Plan 2 8
Narrative Writing Template 9
My Narrative Plan 10
Time Management 11
Proofreading and Editing My Narrative 12
Teaching Resources 13
Sample Teaching and Learning Cycle for a Narrative 14
Suggested Pre Teaching Script 15
Suggested Post Teaching Script 16
Student Sample Pre Teaching Text 17
Student Sample Post Teaching Text 18-19
Overview Of The Functional Model Of Language 20
Text Analysis 21
Language Markers From ESL Scope And Scales 22
Text Developmental Levels 23
Whole Class Text Analysis Findings 24
Text Analysis And Scales 25
Extra Resources And Support 26
Glossary 27-31
Acknowledgements 32
NAPLaN Narratives 2
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 4/33
Aligning teacher and student understandings of the writing task in NAPLaN
Based on research findings, it is recommended that the text construction process focuses
on ensuring that teacher and student understandings are shared (aligned). Evidence
suggests that where student and teacher understandings about the NAPLaN Narrative and
its marking are not aligned, then the narrative constructed by students can deviate
significantly from their actual linguistic understandings. It is therefore suggested that
student understanding of the writing task is monitored and clarified in the pre NAPLaN
teaching, to ensure that the narrative produced reflects the true linguistic capacity of the
student.
In order to improve student NAPLaN Narrative, it is further recommended that as part of
the teaching and learning cycle, students need to understand and make connections with
the purpose, structural features, and how language patterns are shaped by audience,
identity and attitude. These processes need to be taught explicitly in order for students to
achieve the purpose of the text. The language choices depend on where the text is based
on the following continua:
Audience
close distant
familiar NAPLaN marker
Identity
novice eg student writer expert eg literary author
Attitude
boring entertaining
non engaging engaging
As mentioned above, in order to achieve the purpose of a text, particular structural
features and specific language are required. The language choices need to be appropriate
for the audience, be cognisant of the desired identity and express an appropriate attitude.
Failure to do so will impact on the student NAPLaN result.
NAPLaN marking criteria (http://www.naplan.edu.au/writing_2010_-_domains.html)The criteria are:
• Audience
• Text structure
• Ideas
• Character and setting
• Vocabulary
• Cohesion
• Paragraphing
• Sentence structure
• Punctuation
• Spelling
NAPLaN Narratives 3
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 5/33
Time Management
Current research indicates that students are not managing the time allocated to the writing
task very well. The teaching of time management skills is thus crucial to the text
construction process. A strategy being explored involves students practising, planning,
writing, proofreading and editing within set time limits. (See time management resource
page 11).
Planning for Writing the Text
The planning stage of writing should be taught explicitly. This could include generating
key ideas/information about the topic, note writing or graphic organizers and writing
within a genre structure template. (See writing plans pages 7-10).
Writing
As the time allocated for the writing is 30 minutes, it is recommended that students be
taught to write what can be best managed in the time. This may include writing less or
limiting the number of complications and resolutions. It should also include practising
writing within a time limit so students know what they can complete within the timeconstraint.
Proofreading and Editing Techniques
Explicit teaching of proofreading and editing techniques should take place. This needs to
include the whole text level, paragraph level and word level. Furthermore, the focus
should make connections between purpose, structure, grammar, spelling and punctuation.
Once again, as students will only have 5 minutes to proofread and edit their text,
decisions and choices need to be made around a much narrower and achievable narrative.
(See proofreading and editing my narrative page 12).
Assessing the Narrative Using the ESL Scales
Teachers should ensure that the analysis and scaling of the student text is aligned with the
writing task. That is, if the task involves writing a narrative for a friend, it is analysed and
scaled with this in mind. If the narrative is for a teacher, the analysis and scaling of the
language used in a text needs to be significantly different. Research suggests that where
such considerations are not made, the texts analysed and scaled may deviate significantly
from where student scales sit. It is therefore strongly suggested that students are
instructed to write for a range of different audiences and purposes. The analysis and
scaling outcome is then likely to be much closer to the true scale level of the student.
The first consideration when scaling student texts is to read the text and make a
judgement about the extent to which the text is aligned with the writing task. Are the
language choices that relate to audience, identity and attitude appropriate? If they are not,
the purpose will not be achieved even though the structure and language may be
complex. Once this level of analysis is completed, the focus shifts onto the structural
features of the narrative eg orientation, complication/s resolution/s, coda and language.
This will reveal the evidence required to make a judgement about the scale level.
NAPLaN Narratives 4
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 6/33
NAPLaN Narrative Hot Tips
Focus areas for teachers:
• teach narrative genre using a teaching and learning cycle
- provide students with opportunities to develop understandings and make
connections with the purpose, structural features, and how language patterns are
shaped by audience, identity and attitude• teach the NAPLaN narrative marking criteria
- get students to practise writing to topics (prompts)
• teach time management
- practise writing to time (5min planning, 30min writing, 5min proofreading and
editing)
• practise reading and discussing writing instructions
• teach planning skills for writing
- practise planning within a 5 min time limit
• teach writing to the task
- practise writing a one page narrative with one or two complications- teach variation in language (emotive language, intensification, foregrounding,
naming words, describing words, use of similes, metaphors, interesting verbs,
circumstances - place, time, manner, tense consistency)
- practise writing within 30 min
• teach proofreading and editing techniques
- practise editing within 5 min
• reassure students before, during and after the experience (it’s only a test!!!)
• monitor student wellbeing
Key messages for students: • listen to teacher instructions and ask questions
• remember that the purpose of a narrative is to entertain and/or give a message
- make your narrative engaging (excitement, happiness, tension, suspense,
sadness…..)
- teachers are your audience, so you need to use appropriate language and grammar
• plan your narrative (5min planning, 30min writing, 5min proofreading and editing)
- a one page narrative with title, orientation, one or two complications and/or a range
of events, main resolution/coda
• write to the topic
- write an engaging narrative for the NAPLaN markers (1 - 2 pages)
- make sure you finish within the time limit (only 1 or 2 complications and resolutions)
• use a range of interesting language eg verbs and describing words
• use different paragraph beginnings
• leave a line between each paragraph
• use punctuation appropriately (use speech marks)
• proofread and edit your work
- you only have 5min to check spelling, punctuation, paragraphs
• do your best, it’s only a test!!!
• remember, you can talk to your teacher about how you are feeling
NAPLaN Narratives 5
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 7/33
Reproducible Resources forClassroom Use
The following pages can be printed as posters for
classroom display or student use.
NAPLaN Narratives 6
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 8/33
My Narrative Writing Plan 1
The NAPLaN narrative has a time limit, so it needs to be much shorter than
under normal writing conditions.
• The reader/marker of my narrative is a teacher I don’t know
• I need to write as a student author
• The main purpose of a narrative is to entertain and/or give a message
• The narrative needs to engage feelings and emotions (excitement,
happiness, tension, suspense, sadness…..)
• My topic is….. (eg Lost)
Structure of my narrative:
• Title
• OrientationAn introduction to the characters and setting (who, when, where) and the
beginning of the plot (what).
• ComplicationsThe number will vary according to year levels (guide 1-2) and a series of events related to the complications (how the complications/problems are
resolved, fully and/or partially).
• Resolution/Coda Last bit, how it all ended/message for the reader/marker/teacher.
NAPLaN Narratives 7
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 9/33
My Narrative Writing Plan2
Paragraphing:
• start a new paragraph for the orientation, each major complication, coda/main resolution, change of focus,
new events/happenings
• leave a line between each paragraph
• use different paragraph beginningsSentence construction:
• use different sentence beginnings
• use a range circumstances (when, where, how, withwhom, why)
• use a range of conjunctions
• expand noun groups
• use interesting names for characters and places
• use words about feelings and emotions
• use intensification (adverbs)
• use modality when appropriate• use nominalisation when appropriate
• most of the narrative will use past tense
• use consistent tense
• avoid repetition
• use direct and reported speech
Punctuation:
• use capital letters, commas, full stops, question marks,
speech marks
Spelling:
• think about spelling
• sound the word
• use chunking to help with spelling
NAPLaN Narratives 8
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 10/33
Narrative Writing TemplatePurpose - To write a story with a major problem/happening, a number of events and/or
unexpected things/resolutions and an ending, that entertains and/or gives a message
Structural features
Title Eg Lost
Orie n/ma
complication The setting and an
explanation of the main problem/ happening
ntatio in
(what, when, where, who – the order may vary).
Complications
A number of complications. The
number will vary (primarylevel guide 1-2), and aseries of events related tothe complications (how thecomplications/problems
are resolved, fully and/or partially).
Resolution/CodaLast bit, how it all
ended/message for thereader.
NAPLaN Narratives 9
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 11/33
My Narrative Plan
Topic
Title
Orientation:
• who
• what
• when
• where
Complication:
Events
Resolution:
How it ended
NAPLaN Narratives 10
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 12/33
Time Management
The teacher will explain the writing task.
You can ask questions.
Time managementI have 5 minutes to plan my writing:
• re-read the prompts• think about the topic
• plan carefully and quickly using dot points
I have 30 minutes to write my narrative:• remember to use interesting language and
to write in paragraphs
I have 5 minutes to proofread and edit my
narrative:
• check your spelling and punctuation
NAPLaN Narratives 11
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 13/33
Proofreading and Editing MyNarrative
I have 5 minutes to proofread and edit mynarrative. ( Be realistic about what changes
can be made in the time.)
Check my spelling:• Think about my spelling
• Does it look right?
• Use chunking to help with spelling
Punctuation:• Start sentences with a capital letter
• End sentences with a full stop
• Use commas, full stops, speech marks
Grammar:• Check tenses
• Check sentence beginnings eg not “then, then,
then”
• Use interesting language eg not “said, said, said”
NAPLaN Narratives 12
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 14/33
Teaching Resources
The following pages are examples for teacher use
NAPLaN Narratives 13
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 15/33
Teaching and Learning Cycle
Learning Area: English/ ESL Story writing (Narrative)
Theme: (These suggested ideas are not ordered. Activities would be selected according to
the age of the students and the theme or book being used. There can be movement
backwards and forwards between Setting the Context, Modelling and Deconstruction and Joint Construction. Building the field continues through out the Teaching Learning cycle
approach).
NAPLaN Narratives 14
• Discuss pictures of storybook or film
characters.
• Make a story map around the room.
• Elements of a good story? Brainstorm.
• Group and whole class concept map of
“stories”
• Excursion to suitable film eg “Up” or
video eg “Harry Potter”.
• Invite a children’s book writer
• Collect stories from children’s cultural
b’ground. Share and discuss.
• Match titles with synopsis of stories.
Do as a game. Have prizes.
• Info gap activities: Small group
of students are assigned cards with
character info. Other students ask
questions; complete a questionnaire.
• Narrative rubric can be given to older students at
the beginning of cycle and discussed.
• Students create own rubric for Narrative.
• Focus on narrative structure using proforma.
• Use own life stories as resource.
• Discuss audience before writing
• Peer assessment of oral presentation of story
• Students tape each other and discuss editing
• Students write (or tell) same model story in
different person (eg first person to third person).
• Students write (or tell) model story in different
tense (eg present tense to past tense or visaversa).
• Groups of students write story from viewpoint of
at least three different characters including
animals/aliens/robots. Can also be done as oral
task.
• Teacher models foregrounding for effect.
• Class jointly constructs opening paragraph of story.
• Students tell a story together.
• Groups write introduction; pass it on to next group
for first complication, then next group for
resolution.
• Have suggestion box for story titles.
• reassemble pictures from a story.
• Students re-assemble short story text
justifying order of paragraphs.
• Develop graphic outline of well known story.
• Students read various stories and learn to identify
complications and resolutions (or partial resolutions).
• Students identify what they like/dislike about a
story. How does author engage reader?
• Students examine language of tenor and
intensification.
• Students rewrite a story using different appraisal
and intensification.• Students use noun group proforma to develop long
noun groups with qualifiers.
• Vocab lists are displayed and highlighted.
• Similes and metaphors are introduced and discussed.
• Direct speech is discussed and practiced.
• Students asked to predict next stage of
written or spoken story
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 16/33
Suggested teacher script for pre teaching student text construction
• We are going to be learning about how to write a narrative. To helpme in planning, today you will be writing about the topic Lost . Some
of you know lots about narratives and others are still learning. That’s
okay. Therefore, some of you will be able to write more, and othersless. Over the next term/ weeks you will be learning how to write
excellent narratives; the things you need to plan and do to produce a
really good narrative. Then, when we have finished learning aboutnarratives you will again write a narrative on the topic Lost and it will
be much better than the one you write today.
• The purpose of narrative is to entertain and/or give a message about
the topic, in this case Lost .
• All kinds of writing have a structure (parts). Make sure you include allthe parts.
• I would like you to write the narrative as an author would.
• The audience/readers of your narrative will be teachers you don’t
know.
• I would also like you to make your narrative engaging and
entertaining which means that your reader will be interested in your
story.
• To do this you need to think about the language that you will use.
• You will have 5 minutes to plan your writing. When planning, write
your ideas in dot points.
• You will have 30 minutes to write your narrative. Use your plan to
help you with the structure, ideas and language.
• You will have 10 minutes to proofread and edit your narrative. When
you proofread and edit, read your text carefully, check your spelling,
punctuation and language.
During the various abovementioned stages, remind students about time
management and what each part of the writing process involves.
Once students have finished, give encouragement for their effort and
reassurance that their post teaching text will be much better than the pre
teaching text.
Modify the information and process to suit the student cohort.
NAPLaN Narratives 15
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 17/33
Suggested teacher script for post teaching student text construction
• After all the teaching and learning about writing narratives that we havedone, I am now going to ask you to write another narrative about the
topic Lost . You now know a lot more about narratives, and the topic Lost
than you did at the beginning. You have all made so much progress. Your narrative will be much better than the first one that you wrote.
• The purpose of narrative is to entertain and/or give a message about the
topic, in this case Lost .
• All kinds of writing have a structure (parts). Make sure you include all
the parts.
• I would like you to write the narrative as an author would.
• The audience/readers of your narrative will be teachers you don’t know.
• I would also like you to make your narrative engaging and entertaining
which means that your reader will be interested in your story.
• To do this you need to think about the language that you will use.
• You will have 5 minutes to plan your writing. When planning, write your ideas in dot points.
• You will have 30 minutes to write your narrative. Use your plan to help
you with the structure, ideas and language.
• You will have 10 minutes to proofread and edit your narrative. When you
proofread and edit, read your text carefully, check your spelling,
punctuation and language.
During the various abovementioned stages, remind students about time
management and what each part of the writing process involves.
Once students have finished, give encouragement for their effort and
reassurance that their post teaching text will be much better than the pre
teaching text.
Modify the information and process to suit the student cohort.
NAPLaN Narratives 16
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 18/33
Pre teaching text
NAPLaN Narratives 17
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 19/33
Post teaching text
NAPLaN Narratives 18
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 20/33
Post teaching text (continued)
NAPLaN Narratives 19
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 21/33
Overview of the Functional Model of Language
Genre(understanding)
Register(considerations)
Awareness of the contextual variables that will impacton the language choices and meaning. In different
contexts consideration to (Who is present? Where am
I?, What is the focus of the interaction?/What’s
happening?) are essential to the successful
achievement of purpose.
Purpose:What is thecommunicative
purpose of thetext?
What structural
features do I
need, to make
the text work?
Audience:Who is the text
being written
for?
What language
choices will I
need to make for
my audience?
Who is going to
read/assess my
text?
Identity:What identitywill the text take
on?
What language
choices will I
need to
construct the
chosen identity?
Who am I going
to be in the text?
Attitude:What attitudewill the text take
positive– negative?
What language
choices will I
need to make to
express my
attitude?
How do I want
to make people
feel in the text?
These are expressed through
Genre Register
Structure
The structural
features of the
text
Field
The language for
expressing ideas
and experiences
Tenor
The language for
interacting with
others
Mode
The language for
creating spoken
and written texts
NAPLaN Narratives 20
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 22/33
Text AnalysisWhole text level:
Audience (Who is it for?)Appropriate to the audience as per writing task
Appropriate Inappropriate
Identity (Who is speaking/writing?)Appropriate as per writing task
Appropriate Inappropriate
Attitude of the writer (How does the writer make you feel?)Appropriate as per writing task
Appropriate Inappropriate
Contextual understandings/conceptual understandingsRelevant to the topic
Evident Not evident
Genre structure No evidence of genre structure – uses basic structure – uses expanded structure - uses logically
more refined structure
Language choices:Has the language choices required to achieve the purpose
Simplistic-formulaic-expanded-complex–refined
Mostly spoken like – more written like– very written like - written like
Uses a varied range of describers, circumstances, reference items, intensifiers, linking and binding
conjunctions, relative pronouns, modality and nominalisation - broad forms
Uses more varied foregrounding
Uses voice appropriately (one – many)
Moves from subjectivity – objectivity appropriately
Uses colloquial and idiomatic language, rhetorical conjunctions, and reported speech and direct
speech appropriately
Paragraph level Not evident - some evidence of paragraphs- evidence of paragraphs- consistent evidence of
paragraphs and uses subheadings
Sentence levelBegins to construct sentences – writes simple sentences - expands sentences– complex sentences
– sophisticated sentences – refined sentences
Word levelEveryday – specialised – technical
Begins to copy - narrow range - repetitive- some specialised and technical - varied - larger range -
uses specialised and technical vocabulary - more varied - extended range - uses a broad range of
specialised and technical vocabulary - sophisticated
NAPLaN Narratives 21
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 23/33
Language markers from the ESL Scope and Scales
Scale 1 No evidence of genre structureBegins to copy and write short groups of words
Writes predominantly left to right
Scale 2 Copies and collaboratively constructs strictly limited texts
Begins to construct own basic texts by copying or jointly constructing eg. report
Writes predominantly left to right top to bottom
Scale 3 Constructs basic genres with a high degree of scaffolding Uses a limited range of evaluative vocabulary expressing feelings and emotions
Writes simple sentences
Scale 4 Constructs with support basic genres
Begins to use linking conjunctions ( and, but)Begins to write full sentences
Experiments with punctuation
Scale 5 Begins to construct independently basic genres with some detail and is relevantand consistent
Uses linking conjunctions (but, or, so) and binding conjunctions ( because)Uses a small range of phrases expressing where ( by the table) and how ( carefully,
quickly)
Scale 6 Increases range of basic genres constructed independently and logically Expands short noun groups, sometimes using qualifiers (the man in the shop)
Uses with some accuracy the most elementary modality ( might, must; maybe, I
think, I know)
Scale 7 Constructs with some confidence written basic genres which have a number of stages
Uses, with some accuracy, simple direct and reported speech
Chooses a strictly limited range of colloquial and idiomatic language
Scale 8 Writes simple sequential explanations and more developed reports that are
detailed and relevant
Begins to use a small range of relative pronouns –who, which
Organises texts in simple, logically ordered paragraphs on the basis of a change of topic
and writes a topic sentence for each paragraph
Scale 9 Constructs a range of written genres which have a number of stages or series
of events Uses subheadings and conjunctions to organise text (Secondly, Later, In addition to..)
Scale 10 Constructs longer, increasingly complex factual and story genres
Begins to identify how meanings can be made either subjectively or objectively
Scale 11 Constructs well-organised, longer and complex factual genres and longer
story genres using variations
Uses a small range of alternatives to conjunctions,-One of the main arguments instead of Firstly Uses rhetorical questions in an argument – And what do the students think..
NAPLaN Narratives 22
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 24/33
Text Developmental Levels
Basic textsScales 1-4
Expanded texts
Scales 4-6
Complex texts
Scales 6-9
Refined Texts
Scales 9-14
NAPLaN Narratives 23
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 25/33
Whole Class TextAnalysis FindingsWhole text level
Positives
Teaching focus
PD focus
Paragraph level
Positives
Teaching focus
PD focus
Sentence levelPositives
Teaching focus
PD focus
Word levelPositives
Teaching focus
PD focus
NAPLaN Narratives 24
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 26/33
Text Analysis And Scales
Classroom teacher Year Genre
Student’s name Year
level
Scale Focus area/s for improvement
NAPLaN Narratives 25
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 27/33
Extra Resources and Support
Further resources for teachers can be accessed through their ESL Regional
Consultants. A series of PD Shorts will be offered on the various elements
of this resource with a particular focus on classroom applications.
Below is an example of content that will be explored.
Achieving Communicative Purposes
The following overview summarises the stages involved in achieving communicative
purposes for spoken and written texts.
Purpose1. There is a desire/need in relation to
an audience
I want/need to explain something to …..
I want/need to persuade someone to…..
I have to report on …..
I want to entertain ……
(These are genres)
Clarity of purpose NAPLaN narrative - To entertain
AudienceUnderstanding how the audience of the
text shapes the language choices.
Clarity of audienceThe audience for the NAPLaN narrative
are teachers that I don’t know, who will
be making a judgement on my text.
Identity2. Who does the writer of the narrative need to be in order to achieve thepurpose/make it happen? (characters taken on/or personas)
Attitude3. What attitude will help to achieve the purpose/make it happen?emotionally engaging/entertaining (creating tension)
4.Register(field - language for expressing ideas and experiences, tenor - language for interacting
with others, mode - language for creating spoken and written texts) Are the language choices appropriate?
5. How do I make it happen? Alignment – connecting abovementioned elements
(1 – 4) These should be taught as part of the teaching and learning cycle
Provide opportunities to practice writing for the NAPLaN
Make it fun
6. Assessment – meeting NAPLaN criteria or scale
7. Future teaching and learningInformed by NAPLaN results and analysis
NAPLaN Narratives 26
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 28/33
GLOSSARY FROM THE ESL SCOPE AND SCALES
active voice: Refers to the organisation of a clause so the “do-er” of the action comes first, eg “The
children washed the windows” as opposed to “The windows were washed by the
children” which is in the passive voice. Refer to passive voice.
agreement: Describes the relationship between two elements of the language where the form of one
determines the form of another. One type of agreement is subject-verb agreement where,for example, a plural subject requires a plural verb (“ Chairs were smashed”) and asingular subject requires a singular verb (“A chair was smashed”). Note that in clausesof the type “There is …”, agreement occurs with the first element in the participant
immediately following the verb, eg “There is a table and two chairs in that room”,“There are two chairs and a table in that room”
antonym: Words having the opposite or contrasting meaning to a given word.
circumstance: The element of a clause (expressed by adverbial phrase/group or prepositional phrase)which gives information about the process in a clause. This information is about when,where, how, why, with what, or with whom the process occurred, eg(place) She knocked the clock off the shelf
(time) She knocked off early.(with whom) He left with his friend
(how - means) She left by car.(how - comparison) He opened it like an expert
(how - quality) She opened it carefully.
(why) The man died of heart failure.
clause: A unit of meaning grouped around a verb/process: often referred to as the basic building block of language.
(independent - always finite) I finished my work.
(independent - 2 finite clauses) I had something to eat // and then I finished my work.
(dependent and finite) I finished my work even though I was tired.
(dependent and non-finite) I finished my work after having something to eat. (dependent, finite and included) My boss, who's moving to another department
soon, is having a farewell party.(dependent, finite and included) I had something to eat and then, even though I
was tired, finished my work.(dependent, non-finite and included) I had something to eat and, being tired , went to
bed.
A dependent clause is in a relationship of dependency with either another dependentclause or an independent clause. A sentence must have at least one independent clause.“ Because we ran out of petrol , (dependent) we had to walk to the town” (independent)We had to walk to the town (independent) because we ran out of petrol (dependent) after the fuel line got a leak” (dependent)
Included clauses are separated by commas from the clauses they interrupt.
cohesive resource: Grammatical tools or linguistic structures which tie together elements of a text, making itcohesive. These include:
conjunctions that join sentences: Therefore, However pronouns that link to other parts of the text: The house was incredible. You should’veseen it”
synonyms and antonyms: “The tenants were not happy at all. So the landlord and
all of the residents of the building gathered in the office below”.
colloquialism: An informal, slang or non-standard expression usually used where the speaker feels the
tenor of a situation allows it (eg We went like the clappers).
NAPLaN Narratives 27
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 29/33
conjunction: A word whose primary function is to join two parts of the language together and indicatethe relationship between them. Conjunctions can relate bits of language in different
ways:- additive: and
- comparative: though
- temporal: after
- consequential: since
They also function to join clauses at different levels:
- to join clauses to make a sentence: linking and binding conjunctions- to sentences : cohesive conjunctions
- to join paragraphs to organise the text: rhetorical conjunctions Linking conjunctions join two clauses forming a relationship of independence, eg “We bought the car on Saturday but we couldn’t pick it up until Tuesday”. Binding conjunction join two clauses forming a relationship of dependence (hence the
notion of ‘binding’), eg “We went and bought the car after we’d asked the bank for aloan”. The bound clause can be moved to the front of the sentence, eg “ After we’d asked
the bank for a loan, we went and bought the car”.
binding conjunctions: A large set of conjunctions (eg because, if , as, since) that join two clauses forming a
relationship of dependence (hence the notion of ‘binding’). The sentences formed are
often labelled complex sentences (eg We went and bought the car after we’d asked the
bank for a loan).
The bound clause can be moved to the front of the sentence (eg After we’d asked the
bank for a loan , we went and bought the car ).
Compare with ‘linking conjunctions’.
connectives: A broad term to describe elements of the language that join various parts together; for
example, the different kinds of conjunctions and elements that act like conjunctions (eg
One of the reasons … instead of Firstly, …).
dependent clause: A clause which is in a relationship of dependency with either another dependent clause
or an independent clause. (Note that a sentence must have at least one independent
clause.) For example: Because we ran out of petrol (dependent), we had to walk to the
town (independent); We had to walk to the town (independent) because we ran out of
petrol (dependent) after the fuel line got a leak (dependent).
describer: A word (usually an adjective) in a noun group whose function is to describe the quality
of the head word of the group (eg The pretty flowers were sitting in a pot, We drove
down the long and winding road ).
embedded clause: A clause that is embedded in another, acting either as:
- a qualifier in a noun group: “The woman who won the race is my mother” or as- a participant itself: “Winning the race has been a life-long goal”, “ Being good isn’t
easy” "What I need is a massage"- a nominal group in a Circumstance: " Because of what he did, he was forced to resign.An embedded clause is rank shifted and functions at the rank of group.
euphemism: This refers to expressions which are used to refer indirectly to topics or things that are
culturally constructed as taboo or difficult to say directly (eg to pass away instead of to
die, the C word instead of cancer ).
NAPLaN Narratives 28
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 30/33
foreground: Make the focus or the orientation by placing at the beginning of a sentence, paragraph or text, eg
- foregrounding the time: “After five minutes, place the mixture in the oven”- foregrounding the process: “Place the mixture in the oven after five minutes”
- foregrounding the non-human participant in the process: “The mixture was placed inthe oven after five minutes” "Evaporation is a process …."- foregrounding the human participant in the process: “We placed the mixture in theoven after five minutes”
Foregrounding appropriately is one of the requirements for a text to be coherent.At the text level foregrounding refers to the theme of the whole text, usually found in the
introductory paragraph, which foregrounds what the rest of the text will be about.At the paragraph level foregrounding refers to the theme of the paragraph, usually found in the topic sentence.
formulaic: This refers to expressions that are so common at certain stages of an exchange that theycan be memorised and used almost instinctively, eg “Good morning”, “Bye”, “Excuseme”, “Thank you”, “How’re ya going?”.
idiom: This refers to an expression that has a meaning that differs from its literal one (eg
raining cats and dogs). Idioms also include slang and euphemisms.
intonation: The distinctive patterns of the pitch, tune or melody of a clause (eg the rising tone
contour of a question as opposed to the falling tone contour of a statement).
Punctuation can be defined as the ‘written form of intonation’, hence the importance to
consider intonation when teaching punctuation.
linking conjunctions: A small set of conjunctions (and, or, so, but ) that join two clauses forming a relationship
of independence (eg We bought the car on Saturday but we couldn’t pick it up until
Tuesday). They can also be used to join words within a group.
metaphor: An expression which replaces a congruent meaning with a more figurative one (eg Thenews hit me right between the eyes instead of the more congruent I was shocked by the
news).
modality: This refers to the elements of the language that express the speaker’s judgement or assessment of certainty, obligation, usuality and inclination.These include:modal finites may, might, should, could : “That might be the one”mood adjuncts really, probably, certainly, always, never: “She always wins” "It's probably him"
comment adjuncts (expresses some degree of modality about the whole clause):“ Perhaps you could sign here”, Unfortunately, I fell at the last hurdle. Luckily, I don't
have to sit for the test again.
attributive relational clauses “ I am certain he’s the one”, “I can certainly help”nominalisations “The likelihood of your winning is nil, mate”mental processes I think, I believe, I hope, I think: “ I think I’d better go” “ I believe
that’s right”or a combination of these “ I suppose I could have said that”, “I always have to help”
“I would probably help”, “I always have to help” “ I wonder if you could possibly see
your way clear to signing this for me”
nominalisation: The process of changing verbs, adjectives or conjunctions into nouns, eg
“The crowd applauded wildly” can have its process nominalised and so get “Thecrowd’s wild applause was breathtaking”."Because the river was broad we were not able to cross it" can have the adjectivenominalised and so get "The river's breadth prevented the crossing"
" The street flooded because of the rain, " can have the conjunctions nominalised and soget "The result of rain was flooding."
NAPLaN Narratives 29
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 31/33
noun group: A group of words in which the head word is a noun and all the other words serve tospecify, or enumerate or describe or classify or qualify that noun,
“Some of the beautifully wrapped Christmas presents under the tree had been opened”
enumerates specifies describes classifies head word qualifies
A describer (or epithet) is a word (usually an adjective) in a noun group whose functionis to describe the quality of the head word of the group, eg “The pretty flowers were
placed” “We drove down the long and winding road ”
Epithets can have an attitudinal aspect: That bloody officer; a brilliant first novel.Epithets can also have intensifiers, which alter the degree of the epithet, and areexpressed with adverbs "a somewhat unlikely person" "a quite stunning view"
A classifier classifies the Thing. More than one classifier can be used (with no punctuation between them) and can be realised by adjectives (degradable bags), nouns
(bird house) or verbs (distilling process)
A qualifier is the element of the noun group that comes after the head word and whosefunction is to qualify the head word, eg“ A verb that contains a preposition is often a phrasal verb”
“The house at the end of the street was said to be haunted”
participants: The things (animate and inanimate things and abstract phenomena) directly involved with the process of the clause. They can be expressed as a nominal group or embedded clause eg “The woman brushed her hair away from her face” “The test tube was
heated slowly” “The reasons for the changes were not presented” “I can’t accept yourexcuses” "What the man broke was the clock"
The participant can also be an attribute expressed by an adjective " She is incredible"
passive voice: Refers to the organisation of a clause so the “done to” rather than the “do-er” of theaction comes first, eg “The car was washed by the children, wasn’t it?” as opposed to“The children washed the car, didn’t they?” which is in the active voice.The passive voice is used when:
the speaker/writer wishes to foreground the goal of the action, eg“The dried ingredients are added to the mixture” “The car gets serviced at the garage”
“Taxes were raised after the election” b) the actor (doer of the action) is unimportant (the one who adds the mixture), or unknown (the one who services the car) or wishes to remain unknown (the one whoraises the taxes).
phrasal verbs: Verbal groups which contain a preposition but still have only one meaning and where the process or meaning of the verbal group changes with the deletion or change of preposition:“She put her off just as she was getting ready to swing” (distracted)
“They put out the fire before it could spread” (extinguish)“ Put up your hand” (raise)
“The things I have to put up with” (endure)
processes: The verbal group of a clause that express the processes of:action(material, behavioural): kicked, ran, drove, smiled, sneezed, listened
sensing (cognition, affection, perception): believe, think, know, realise, hope, feel, hate,
enjoy hear, see, notice, feel, like, worry
saying (verbal): told, said, replied, exclaimed
relating (identifying, attributive, possessive, existential): are, is, become, turn into, mean,
represent, consist of, has, includes
qualifiers: The element of the noun group that comes after the head word and whose function is to
qualify the head word. Qualifiers can be either an embedded clause (eg A verb that
contains a preposition is often a phrasal verb) or a prepositional phrase (eg The house at
the end of the street was said to be haunted ).
See also ‘noun group’.
NAPLaN Narratives 30
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 32/33
reference items: One kind of cohesive resource where a pronoun is used as a substitute for a noun group.Pronouns include items such as I, me, he, she, they, you, these, this, it, their, them.
Other reference items include the definite article (The election), determiners (don't dothat) and comparative forms (that's better).
See also cohesive resources.
relative clause: A clause which begins with a relative pronoun (who, which, that, whose, whom), eg“The lift, which had only just been fixed , stopped between menswear and furniture”
“The lift got fixed after about an hour, which was one hour too late for me”Such non-defining relative clauses are included clauses.Defining relative clauses such as in "The man who gave me the money was my brother "
are embedded clauses which modify the head noun.
rhetorical conjunctions: These are conjunctions (eg Firstly, In addition, Finally) whose function is to join large
parts of a text in a way that organises the text. They come at the beginning of the stages
of a genre.
rhetorical questions: Expressions that have the usual grammatical structure of questions but whose function is
not to seek information but instead to give information and even help to organise the
text. For example, What is the government’s policy on drugs in schools could be used ina formal oral presentation to inform the audience that the speaker is now going to speak
about the government’s policy on drugs in schools. They are not asking the audience to
give them the answer.
simile: An expression where on thing or idea is likened to another and usually introduced withlike or as (eg My skin felt like parchment, The moon was as big as a beach ball).
synonym: A word with a similar meaning to another, eg house, home, dwelling, abode, residence.As the example illustrates, synonyms are best examined as a continuum so that nuanced differences can be explored.
tense: The setting in time of a clause.
The primary tenses are the past, present and future; for example:
past: I ate , I said
present: I am eating , I know what you mean
future: I will eat , I’ m going to have it later.
Secondary tenses are those that are a combination of the primary tenses; for example:
the present happening in the past: I was eating my dinner
the past happening in the present: I have eaten my dinner
the past happening in the past: I had eaten my dinner.
verbal group A verb or group of verbs that encode the process (eg study, was studying, will be
studying, would have been studying, tried to study).
NAPLaN Narratives 31
7/15/2019 NAPLaN Narratives Resource
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/naplan-narratives-resource 33/33
AcknowledgementsThe support and inspiration provided by Dr Peter White, University of New
South Wales and Dr John Walsh, University of South Australia, through
their involvement in the Text Construction and Text Analysis Research
Project.
All staff at Cowandilla Primary School. In particular, Julie Hayes, Principal
and Katrina Sexton, Assistant Principal.
All staff at Richmond Primary School. In particular, Lindy Brooke, Principal
and Carol Jones, ESL teacher.
Veronica Wachla, ESL teacher, Allenby Gardens Primary School
Madeline Tarzia, ESL teacher, Plympton Primary School
Sue Lang and Mary Tsokas, ESL teachers, Torrensville Primary School
ESL Regional Consultants:Pam Boyle
Dick Doyle
Stella Emberson
Ross Hamilton
Camilla Karaivanoff
Giuseppe Mammone
Joan Richards
Richard Waugh
A/ESL Regional Consultants:Jackie Morgan
Sabrina Walker
Rosie Antenucci
Manager, ESL Programs
Karyl MartinManager, ESL General Support