mvo scientific report for volcanic activity between 1 may and 30
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Montserrat Volcano Observatory - P.O. Box 318 - Flemmings – Montserrat Tel : +1 (664) 491-5647 | Fax: +1 (664) 491-2423 | [email protected] | www.mvo.ms
1/83
MVOScientificReportforVolcanicActivitybetween1Mayand30September2016
AnupstreamviewoffloodedgravelpitsintheBelhamValleyduringthelaharon24August2016.Photo:A.Stinton.
AStinton,VBass,TChristopher,MFergus,KPascal,PSmith,RStewart,RSyers,PWilliams
OpenFileReportOFR16-03
3December2016
![Page 2: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 2
ExecutiveSummaryThisreportsummarisesthevolcanicactivityattheSoufrièreHillsVolcano,Montserratfortheperiodfrom1Mayto30September2016,inclusive,includingallmonitoringandvisualobservations.
Overall,activityduringthereportingperiodhasbeenlow.Seismicactivityhasconsistedofsporadicvolcano-tectonic(VT)earthquakes,sometimesinstringsorbriefswarms.Low-frequencyearthquakes(hybrids,LPs)havebeenabsent.Rockfallactivitycontinuedataverylowlevel,consistentwithweatheringofthecollapsescarandthedome.
Grounddeformationcontinuedtoshowslowradialinflationsimilartothatduringpreviouspausesinactivity.
Duetoinstrumentproblems,dailySO2fluxwasnotmeasured.Effortsareunderwaytoobtainnewequipmenttore-establishcontinuousmonitoring.
Therehavebeennosignificantchangestothedomeorfumarolicactivity.
Thepauseinlavaextrusionthatstartedon11February2010continuesandisover79monthslongasof30September2016.
![Page 3: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 3
TableofContents
ExecutiveSummary..............................................................................................................................2
TableofContents.................................................................................................................................3
ListofFigures.......................................................................................................................................5
ListofTables........................................................................................................................................7
1VolcanicActivityforthePeriod1Mayto30September2016............................................................81.1Summary............................................................................................................................................81.2Seismicity.........................................................................................................................................10
1.2.1Summary...................................................................................................................................101.2.2Currentlevelsofseismicity.......................................................................................................101.2.3VTStrings..................................................................................................................................18
1.3GroundDeformation........................................................................................................................221.3.1.G.P.S.........................................................................................................................................221.3.2.‘Spider’stations.......................................................................................................................331.3.3.EDM.........................................................................................................................................331.3.4.Strain........................................................................................................................................38
1.4GasMonitoring................................................................................................................................391.4.1SO2DailyFlux............................................................................................................................391.4.2SO2DiffusionTubes..................................................................................................................40
1.5DomeVolumeandGeology.............................................................................................................431.5.1DomeVolume...........................................................................................................................431.5.2DomeMorphology....................................................................................................................431.5.3RockfallActivity........................................................................................................................431.5.4DomeIncandescenceandFumaroleTemperatures.................................................................44
2DiscussionofActivityandComparisonwithPastActivity................................................................462.1PauseinDomeGrowth....................................................................................................................462.2DomeStability..................................................................................................................................472.3CriteriaforContinuationofActivity.................................................................................................48
2.3.1Seismicity..................................................................................................................................482.3.2Gas............................................................................................................................................482.3.3Grounddeformation.................................................................................................................48
2.4PhasesandPause............................................................................................................................49
3HazardsandRisks............................................................................................................................503.1RiskAssessment...............................................................................................................................503.2HazardLevelSystem........................................................................................................................503.3AccesstoZoneV..............................................................................................................................503.4TouristVisitstoPlymouth................................................................................................................503.5GeothermalWellMON#3................................................................................................................51
4MVOMonitoringNetworks.............................................................................................................524.1SeismicMonitoring..........................................................................................................................52
4.1.1Softwareandacquisitionchanges............................................................................................524.1.2Instrumentalchangesatstations..............................................................................................52
![Page 4: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 4
4.1.3Ongoingproblemsandknownissues.......................................................................................534.1.4Futuredevelopments................................................................................................................54
4.2GroundDeformationMonitoring.....................................................................................................554.2.1ContinuousGPS(cGPS).............................................................................................................554.2.2CampaignGPS(eGPS)...............................................................................................................554.2.3GPSArchivingandProcessing...................................................................................................554.2.4EDM..........................................................................................................................................564.2.5Tilt.............................................................................................................................................564.2.6Strain.........................................................................................................................................564.2.7Spidersstations:single-frequencyGPS,EDMandTiltmeter....................................................57
4.3GasMonitoring................................................................................................................................574.3.1Multigas....................................................................................................................................574.3.2DOASUVspectrometernetwork..............................................................................................57
4.4DomeVolume..................................................................................................................................584.5FumaroleMonitoring.......................................................................................................................584.6RemoteCameras..............................................................................................................................584.7ThermalCameras.............................................................................................................................594.8RemoteSensingData.......................................................................................................................594.9InfrasonicMonitoring......................................................................................................................594.10WEBOBS.........................................................................................................................................60
5MVOOperations.............................................................................................................................615.1Staffing............................................................................................................................................615.2EducationandOutreach..................................................................................................................615.3Helicopter.........................................................................................................................................615.4Volunteers/PhDstudents/Visitors................................................................................................615.5Internships.......................................................................................................................................625.6CollaborationandExternalProjects................................................................................................625.7MVOArchive....................................................................................................................................635.8MVOWebsite...................................................................................................................................63
References.........................................................................................................................................64
AppendixA:25June2016RFevent....................................................................................................65A1Introduction......................................................................................................................................65A2Seismics............................................................................................................................................65
A2.1Infrasound.................................................................................................................................65A2.2Lowfrequencyonset.................................................................................................................65
A3Fieldobservations.............................................................................................................................70A4Summary..........................................................................................................................................70
AppendixB:TrendsinVTearthquakedepthssincePhase5...............................................................72B1Introduction......................................................................................................................................72B2Dataanalysis....................................................................................................................................72B3Discussion.........................................................................................................................................77
AppendixC:AdditionalGPSData.......................................................................................................79
![Page 5: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 5
ListofFiguresFigure1: Summaryplotofthedailyseismicitycounts(top),GPS(middle,stationGERD)andSO2flux
(bottom)fortheperiod1Mayto30September2016............................................................8Figure2: ViewsofthelargelaharintheBelhamValleyon24August2016..........................................9Figure3: DailycountsofthedifferentearthquaketypesrecordedbytheMVOnetworkfortheperiod
coveredbythisreport:i.e.between1May2016and30September2016..........................13Figure4: DailycountsofthedifferentearthquaketypesrecordedbytheMVOsincetheendofPhase
5.............................................................................................................................................14Figure5: HypocentresoflocatedVTearthquakesrecordedbytheMVOseismicnetworkbetween1
Mayand30September2016.................................................................................................15Figure6: Fault-planesolutionsoflocatedVTearthquakesrecordedontheMVOseismicnetwork
between1Mayand30September2016...............................................................................16Figure7: DailycountsofrockfalleventssincetheendofPhase5.......................................................17Figure8: VTearthquakesrecordedatSHVsincetheendofPhase5...................................................17Figure9: SeismicandstraindatafromtheVTswarmon14June2016...............................................19Figure10: StemplotshowingthenumberoftriggeredVTearthquakesineachVTstring................20Figure11: StemplotshowingthedurationsinminutesofallVTstringssincefirstidentifiedin
November2007.................................................................................................................20Figure12: StemplotsshowingindividualenergyestimatesforallVTstrings....................................21Figure13: Radialextensionrelativetothevolcanicventsince1June2015......................................23Figure14: Tangentialdisplacementsrelativetothevolcanicventsince1June2015.......................24Figure15: Verticaldisplacementsobservedsince1June2015..........................................................25Figure16: RadialextensionrelativetothevolcanicventforPause5................................................26Figure17: TangentialdisplacementsrelativetothevolcanicventforPause5..................................27Figure18: VerticaldisplacementsforPause5....................................................................................28Figure19: Radial(top)andVertical(bottom)displacementsrecordedatcampaignsitesduringPause
5.........................................................................................................................................29
![Page 6: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 6
Figure20: Comparisonoftheradial(top)andvertical(bottom)displacementsmeasuredatnineMVOcontinuousGPSstationsduringPause3,Pause4bandPause5(solidlines)andsubsequentextrusionphases(dashedlines).....................................................................30
Figure21: HorizontalvelocitiesobservedattheMVOGPSstations..................................................31Figure22: HorizontalandverticalvelocitiesobservedattheMVOcontinuousGPSstationsduring
Pause5...............................................................................................................................32Figure23: MSCP,MSS1,MSUH‘Spider’Stations:Radial,tangential,andverticaldisplacements
relativetothevolcanicvent..............................................................................................34Figure24: MapoftheEDMnetwork(blackfilledcircles)usedatMVO.............................................35Figure25: Slantlengthvariations(m)oftheEDMbaselines..............................................................36Figure26: Horizontallengthvariations(m)ofseveralpairsofcGPSstationsbetweenMayand
September2016................................................................................................................37Figure27: Horizontallengthvariations(m)ofseveralpairsofcGPSstationsduringPause5...........38Figure28: Dailyand30-dayaverageSO2fluxfromtheSoufriereHillsVolcanofortheperiod1
January2014to17September172015............................................................................39Figure29: MonitoredSO2concentrations(ppb)betweenFebruary2010andAugust2016.............41Figure30: TheannualmeanconcentrationsoftheSO2diffusiontubesfromsixofthemostproximal
locations.............................................................................................................................42Figure31: Dailyandcumulativerockfallcountsfortheperiod1January2015to30April2016......44Figure32: Seismic,GPSandSO2monitoringdatafortheperiod1January1995to30September
2016...................................................................................................................................46Figure33: Seismic,GPSandSO2monitoringdatafortheperiodsincetheendofPhase5...............47
![Page 7: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 7
ListofTablesTable1: Totalnumberofeventsandmeandailyeventratesforeachearthquaketypeduring(a)the
wholeofPause5(since11February2010)and(b)theperiodcoveredbythisreport(1Mayto30September2016)..........................................................................................................11
Table2: Totalnumberofeventsandmeandailyeventratesforeachearthquaketyperecordedat
SHVduringpausesinlavaextrusion.ThedatesofthepausesaredefinedinTable6..........11Table3: TablelistingtheVTStringsobservedatSHVbetween1Mayand30September2016........18Table4: Overviewofphasesoflavaextrusionanderuptivepauses1995-2010andthemeanSO2flux
foreach..................................................................................................................................40Table5: Maximumrecordedtemperaturesoffumarolesonthelavadomederivedfromthermal
imagesacquiredduringtheperiod1Mayto30September2016........................................45Table6: PhasesandpausesoftheeruptionoftheSoufriereHillsvolcano,withdurationscalculated
uptoandinclusiveof30September2016............................................................................49Table7: Changesmadetoinstrumentsatindividualseismicstations................................................53
![Page 8: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 8
1VolcanicActivityforthePeriod1Mayto30September2016
1.1 SummaryFigure1belowsummarisesthedailyseismicity,GPSandSO2fluxfortheperiod1Mayto30September2016.Duetocontinuedinstrumentissues,noSO2fluxdataisavailableforthisreportingperiod(seeSections1.4and4.3fordetails).
Figure1: Summaryplotofthedailyseismicitycounts(top),GPS(middle,stationGERD)andSO2flux(bottom)fortheperiod1Mayto30September2016.Duetoinstrumentproblems,thereisnoSO2dataavailable.
Activityremainedlowduringthereportingperiod.Seismicitywasdominatedbyvolcano-tectonic(VT)earthquakesandrockfalls(RF).AslightincreaseinRFshascoincidedwiththerainyseasoninMontserrat(seeSection1.5.3RockfallActivity).Therewasonlyonelong-periodrockfall(LPRF)eventon28August2016andnohybridorlongperiodevents.
ThetrendofoccasionalburstsofVTseismicityintheformofVTstringsorbriefswarmscontinued.ThreeVTstrings,ofvaryinglengthandintensity,occurredduringthereportingperiod,bringingthetotalnumbersinceNovember2007to82(seeSection1.2.3VTStrings).NoneofthestringswereassociatedwithanyobservablechangesinSO2flux,fumaroleactivityortheoccurrenceofashventing.
On26June2016,MVOreceivedareportofashintheupperAmershamareafromCaribbeanHelicopters.Twodayslater,MVOstaffvisitedtheareaandobservedashblowingaroundandstucktovegetation.Initially,theoriginoftheashwasnotclear,butlaterinvestigationoftheseismicrecordrevealedaparticularlyunusualRFeventon25June2016(basedonUTC)thatshowedsomesignificant
![Page 9: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 9
low-frequencyenergyandacoincidentsignalintheinfrasound.Thisstronglysuggestsatleastsome(small)explosivecomponenttotheRFevent.MoreinformationonthiseventispresentedinAppendixA.
Followingthepassageofastrongtropicalwaveovernightfrom23-24August2016,severallargelaharsweregenerated,primarilyintheBelhamValley,butalsoinchannelsleadingthroughPlymouthandinGingoesGhaut.ThelaharintheBelhamValleyhadasignificantimpactonthevalley(Figure2),withboththeupper(toZoneC)andlower(toGaribaldi)crossingscutandupto4moferosionoccurring.Thelaharfloodedthemajorityofthegravelpitsinthevalley.ThisisthelargestlahartohaveoccurredintheBelhamvalleysincethosegeneratedbyTropicalStormRaphaelinNovember2013whenlaharsreachedtheseainOldRoadBay.ThesandminerstrackleadingtothejettyinPlymouthwasalsocutintwolocationsbylahars.
Figure2: ViewsofthelargelaharintheBelhamValleyon24August2016.A)Thelaharcutthroughthetrackoftheuppercrossing.B)4+moferosioninvalleydownstreamofuppercrossingcuttingthroughtrack.c)Floodedgravelpitbetweentheupperandlowercrossing.
![Page 10: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 10
1.2Seismicity
1.2.1SummaryThelevelofseismicactivityrecordedatSHVduringthisreportingperiodhasremainedlow.
Figure3displaysthedailycountsofthedifferentvolcanicearthquaketypesfortheperiod1May2016to30September2016inclusive,andshowsthatthepatternofsporadicVTearthquakesandoccasionalrockfallshascontinued.VTearthquakesmadeupthevastmajorityofthetotalseismicity.
AfurtherthreeVTstringsoccurredduringthereportingperiod,withthemostintenseintermsofduration,eventnumbersandearthquakemagnitudeoccurringon14June.
Low-frequencyseismicityhasbeenalmostabsent,withonlyonesinglelong-periodrockfallrecordedduringthisperiod.Thispatternremainstypicalofapauseinlavaextrusion,withthelevelofactivitylower,butstillcomparableto,thatseenduringpreviouspauses.
Alargerockfallsignaloccurredon25June2016,withalow-frequencysignalonsetandcoincidentwithaninfrasonicsignalatMBFL.ThissuggestsatleastsomeexplosivecomponenttothiseventthatwastheprobablesourceofsomeminorashfallobservedtothewestofthedomeneartoPlymouth.
1.2.2CurrentlevelsofseismicityThetotalcountsandmeandailyeventrateforeacheventtypearegiveninTable1.CountsforboththewholereportingperiodandfortheperiodsincetheendofPhase5areshown.
Rockfallactivityhasbeenlow,inkeepingwiththeslowlydecliningtrendoverthelastfewyearsasthedomehasstabilised(seeFigure3andparticularlyFigure7).Thesmallincreaseinrockfallactivitycomparedtothelastreportingperiodwaslikelyaresultofseasonaleffectsandincreasedrainfall.Low-frequencyseismicityhasbeenextremelylow,withonlyonelong-periodrockfallsignalrecordedon28August.
ThreeVTstringsoccurredduringthisreportingperiod(seeSection1.2.3VTStrings).ThemeandailyrateofVTsforthelast5monthsof0.41islessthantheaverageacrossthewholeofthecurrentpauseof0.69(Table1).Thisisalsoadecreaseonthevaluefortheprevious7monthsreportingperiodof0.60perday,aresultoffewerVTstringsoccurringduringthisperiod.
Figure5displaysthehypocentresofallVTearthquakesrecordedbytheMVOnetworkduringthereportingperiodthatwereabletobelocated,alongsideaplotoftheirfocalmechanisms(Figure6)showingtherangeoffault-planeorientations.ThefocalmechanismswerecalculatedusingFPFIT(Reasenberg&Oppenheimer,1985)andonlythosewithhigh-quality,well-constrainedsolutionsareshown.Thehypocentresaresubjecttotheusualerrorsandnetworkbiases,butareconsistentwithallrecentVTseismicityatSHV.Theyareclusteredwithinacomparativelysmallseismogenicvolumebeneaththedomeandthe2010collapsescaratdepthsbetween0.5and4km.
![Page 11: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 11
ComparingthecurrenteventratesinTable1withtheratescalculatedforpreviouspausesinTable2,thetotalmeandailyeventrateforthiswholepauseperiodremainsbroadlycomparablewiththeratesseenduringpreviouspauses,eveniftheratesforthisreportingperiodaresomewhatlower,indicativeofageneraldecliningtrendinoverallseismicityrates.
EventTypePause5(since11February2010) 1Mayto30September2016
Total Events/Day Total Events/DayLP/Rockfall 106 0.04 1 0.01Hybrid 138 0.06 0 0.00LP 97 0.04 0 0.00
Rockfall 1615 0.67 35 0.23VT 1673 0.69 63 0.41
Total 3629 1.50 99 0.65
Table1: Totalnumberofeventsandmeandailyeventratesforeachearthquaketypeduring(a)thewholeofPause5(since11February2010)and(b)theperiodcoveredbythisreport(1Mayto30September2016).
EventType
Pause1 Pause2 Pause3 Pause4a Pause4b
Total Events/Day Total Events
/Day Total Events/Day Total Events
/Day Total Events/Day
LPRFs 44 0.07 2 0.00 34 0.07 31 0.54 12 0.04Hybrid 627 1.00 1696 2.72 393 0.82 78 1.37 2 0.01LP 273 0.44 145 0.23 1458 3.02 74 1.30 12 0.04RF 6336 10.11 257 0.41 454 0.94 153 2.68 174 0.64VT 3689 5.88 256 0.41 432 0.89 84 1.47 172 0.63
Total 10969 17.49 2359 3.78 2797 5.80 420 7.36 372 1.36
Table2: TotalnumberofeventsandmeandailyeventratesforeachearthquaketyperecordedatSHVduringpausesinlavaextrusion.ThedatesofthepausesaredefinedinTable6.
1.2.2.1VTenergyreleaseAnalysisofearthquakenumbersalonemaybemisleadingasitdoesnotconsidertherateofenergyreleasesincethesizeoftheearthquakesarenottakenintoaccount.Figure8showsanestimateofthecumulativeVTenergycalculatedfromthelocalmagnitudesusingthefollowingequation:
log𝐸! = 1.5𝑀! + 11.8 (1)
(Gutenberg-Richtermagnitude-energyrelation).ThismethodtoestimatetotalVTearthquakeenergyshouldbemorerobustthanrelyingonamplitudemeasurementsatsinglestations,withtheimpactofsiteeffectsanddatagapsetc.minimised.
![Page 12: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 12
Figure8highlightsthedistinctseismicgap(inbothVTenergyandnumbers)thatoccurredforseveralmonthsfollowingthe23March2012episode.Asimilar,butshorter,gapoccurredfollowingthe8March2014activity,withverylittleVTenergyreleasedbetween8MarchandJune2014.Inthe2.5yearsorsosincethen,theenergyreleaseratehasremainedroughlyconstantdespitenumeroussmallerVTstringsoccurringduringthistime.
ThisfigurealsoshowsthatalthoughtheVTstringoccurringon14June2016wasthelargestinthisreportingperiod(seeTable3)itstillreleasedmorethanoneorderofmagnitudelessenergythanthoseinMarch2012andMarch2014.
![Page 13: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 13
Figure3: DailycountsofthedifferentearthquaketypesrecordedbytheMVOnetworkfortheperiodcoveredbythisreport:i.e.between1May2016and30September2016.Thetotalcountofalleventtypesisshownatthetop,followedbyindividualcountsforVTs,Rockfalls,Hybrids,LPeventsandLP/Rockfalls.ThethreeVT“strings”tohaveoccurredduringthisperiodaremarkedbytheredstarsontheVTplot.
![Page 14: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 14
Figure4: DailycountsofthedifferentearthquaketypesrecordedbytheMVOsincetheendofPhase5,i.e.from12February2010until30September2016.Tickmarksareat3monthintervals.Thetotalcountofalleventtypesisshownatthetop,followedbyindividualcountsforVTevents,Rockfalls,Hybrids,LPeventsandLP/Rockfalls.VT“strings”aremarkedbytheredstarsontheVTplot.
![Page 15: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 15
Figure5: HypocentresoflocatedVTearthquakesrecordedbytheMVOseismicnetworkbetween1Mayand30September2016(61eventsofthe63total).Thesizeofeachcircleisafunctionoftheearthquakemagnitudeandthelowerpaneldisplaysthedepthsasafunctionoftime.
![Page 16: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 16
Figure6: Fault-planesolutionsoflocatedVTearthquakesrecordedontheMVOseismicnetworkbetween1Mayand30September2016(37eventsofthe63total).ThefocalmechanismsshownwerecalculatedusingFPFITwithinSEISAN,withonlywellconstrained‘A’qualitysolutionsshownontheplot.Thelowerpaneldisplaysthedepthsasafunctionoftime.
![Page 17: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 17
Figure7: DailycountsofrockfalleventssincetheendofPhase5,i.e.from12February2010until30September2016.Theredlinerepresentsa60-daymovingaverage,andthegreena60-daylow-passfilterofthedailyeventcounts.Thelast5monthsofactivityduringthisreportingperiodshowasmallincreaseinrockfallactivity,duetoseasonaleffectsandaresponsetoseveralperiodsofheavyrainfall.
Figure8: VTearthquakesrecordedatSHVsincetheendofPhase5.ThebluehistogramshowsdailycountsofVTearthquakes,withVTstringsmarkedbyredstars.ApproximatecumulativeVTenergyrelease(calculatedfromthemagnitudesusingEquation(1))isshownbythegreenline.Notethetotalenergyreleaseofaround409GJduringthisperiodisapproximatelyequivalenttoasingleM4.5earthquake.
![Page 18: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 18
1.2.3VTStringsAsdiscussedinpreviousreports,VTstrings,definedasshortintenseswarmsofVTearthquakes(sometimesreferredtoelsewhereintheliteratureas‘Spasmodicbursts’),havebecomearelativelycommonphenomenonatSHVsincetheywerefirstidentifiedin2007(seeFigure9-Figure12).Table3liststhedetailsofthreemoresuchstringsthatoccurredduringthisreportingperiod.ThedatainthistableandFiguresFigure9-Figure12showthatthestringoccurringon14Junewasthemostsignificantintermsofthenumberofearthquakesandenergyrelease.However,nosignificantshort-termstrainsignalwasobservedcoincidentwiththisseismicity(Figure9),unlikeforsomeoftheprevioushighenergyVTstrings.
ItshouldbenotedthatTable3onlycontainsearthquakeslargeenoughtotriggertheearthwormeventdetectionalgorithm(whichcanbesubjectiveiftheeventrateishighandseveraleventsaremanually“cutout”fromasinglewaveformfile).Inallcasesmanyadditional,loweramplitudeeventswereidentifiedfromdetailedinspectionofthecontinuouswaveformdata(particularlythemoreproximalstationsMBLYandtheMSS1Spider).
# Date/Time(UTC)
TriggeringVTs
LocatedVTs
Approximateduration(minutes)
Max.LocalMagnitude
Approx.Energy(GJ)
1 14-Jun-201620:56:27 9 8 7.2 M3.2 5.98
2 28-Aug-201620:23:42 4 4 37.7 M1.7 0.04
3 17-Sep-201604:48:58 2 2 2.0 M2.5 0.36
Table3: TablelistingtheVTStringsobservedatSHVbetween1Mayand30September2016.Thetableliststhedateandonsettimeofthefirstearthquakeofthestring,thenumberofVTeventsthattriggeredtheearthwormeventdetectionalgorithm,thenumberofeventsthatwerelocated,theapproximatedurationofthestringinminutes,themaximumlocalmagnitude,andtheapproximatetotalenergyoftheearthquakes.
![Page 19: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 19
Figure9: SeismicandstraindatafromtheVTswarmon14June2016.ThetopplotshowstheverticalcomponentseismogramfromstationMBGH.Thelowertwoplotsshowthe50Hzand1Hzstraindatarecordedatthe3CALIPSOstations:AIRS(AirStudios),GERD(Gerald’s)andTRNT(Trant’s).Straindataamplitudeshavebeencorrectedtounitsofnanostrain.Nofilteringwasapplied,butalineartrendwasremovedfromthe24hrsofstraindatatoaccountfordrift,andthemeansubtractedfromthedatashownintheplots.
![Page 20: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 20
TherelationshipbetweenVTstringsandsurfaceactivityhasbeendiscussedinpreviousreports,whereithasbeenassertedthatthereisevidenceofapositivecorrelationbetweentheoccurrenceofVTs,particularlyVTstrings,andincreasedSO2output.ThestringsoccurringinthisreportingperiodcanaddnonewinformationaboutthisrelationshipasnoSO2fluxdatawasrecorded.
Noneofthestringsthatoccurredduringthisreportingperiodwerefollowedbysubsequenttremorsignalsoranyotherobservableactivityorchangesatthesurface.
ThetotalnumberofVTstringsidentifiedbetweenNovember2007andtheendofthisreportingperiodnowstandsat85,withonly17(≈20%)ofthesedirectlyprecedingobservablesurfaceactivityorchanges.
Figure10: StemplotshowingthenumberoftriggeredVTearthquakesineachVTstring.Filledwhitecirclesrepresentstringsthatprecededobservablesurfaceactivity.Thebluelineontheright-handaxisrepresentsthecumulativeVTenergyreleaseforthesameperiod(includingbothVTstringandnon-stringVTearthquakes).
Figure11: StemplotshowingthedurationsinminutesofallVTstringssincefirstidentifiedinNovember2007.Filledwhitecirclesrepresentstringsthatprecededobservablesurfaceactivity.
![Page 21: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 21
Figure12: StemplotsshowingindividualenergyestimatesforallVTstrings(fromasummationoftheearthquakeenergiesderivedfrommagnitudes).Thelowerplotshowsthecumulativestringenergyconvertedbacktoatotalorpseudo-magnitudeforeachstring–equivalenttoplottingtheenergyonalogscale.
![Page 22: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 22
1.3GroundDeformation
1.3.1.G.P.STherewasnochangeinthedeformationpatternobservedbetween1Mayand30September2016.Thecloseststationsfromthedomeshownodeformationwhilethestationsfurtherawayshowaradialextensionfromthedome,ataslowrate.Allstationsshowaverticalupwardmovement.Thisisconsistentwiththecontinuationofthepauseinvolcanicactivityandthelong-terminflationoftheedifice/island.
Theslowinflationrateat‘far-field’stations(e.g.MVO1,GERD,TRNT,NWBL)impliesthatthedeformationisbestseenonlongertime-series,asplottedinFigure13-Figure15fortheperiodJune2015–September2016,andinFigure16-Figure18fortheentirePause5(since12February2010).ThetimeseriesoftheradialandverticaldisplacementsmeasuredatthecampaignstationsareplottedinFigure19forPause5.AdditionalplotscoveringtheentiredatasetarepresentedinAppendixC.
‘Close-field’stations(e.g.HERM,SPRI,FRGR),moveupwardsbutnosignificanthorizontaldisplacementsarerecorded,exceptedinrelationwithstrongeventsuchastheashventingeventinMarch2012(Figure16).NosucheventshaveoccurredbetweenMayandSeptember2016,andnodisplacementswereobservedassociatedtotheVTstringsneitherinthedailypositiontimeseries,norinhigh-rateGPSdata.OnlySPRI(SWofthedome)time-seriesshowsasignificantradialshorteningtowardsthedomesinceJuly2016.Fornow,thissignalremainsunexplainedandcouldstillberelatedtotherainyseason(June-November),whichcommonlyaffectsSPRIdatathemostamongstthenetwork.
Figure20,wherethedisplacementshavebeenfilteredtoremovepartofthenoise,alsoshowsthatthedeformationpatternisthesamesincethebeginningofPause5.Ateachstation,thedeformationrateisrelativelysimilarforthefivepauses.
ThehorizontalvelocitiesvectorsarerepresentedinFigure21forPause5,foradurationof18months(sinceJune2016)andfora12monthperiod(sinceSAC20),thelatterforindicationsincevelocitiesneedatleast18monthsdataforareliabletime-series.ForPause5,thevelocitiesofbothcontinuous(namesinred)andofcampaignstations(namesinblack)havebeencalculated.Stationsmissingasignificantamountofdataduringanyofthesethreeperiodswereomittedfortheperiodconcerned(e.g.SGH1).
ThedirectionsofthevelocityvectorsofPause5andofthelast18monthsofdataareoverallsimilar.Whilethecloseststationsvelocityvectorsdirectionsarevariableandtheiramplitudessmallifnotnegligible,themoredistalstationsshowaclearradialextensionawayfromthedome(indicatedbyaredstar).Forthesestations,theextensionrateisupto~1cm/yrisslowerforthelast18monthsperiod,becausethedeformationrateswerehigheratthebeginningofPause5(seepreviousSACreports).
ThePause5verticalvelocityvectorsarealsorepresentedinFigure22andshowanupwardmovementatallstations.Theiramplitudesvary,withthemaximumvelocitiesintheNEoftheedifice(TRNT,HARR,WTYD),aswellasSPRIontheSWflankoftheedifice.
![Page 23: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 23
Figure13: Radialextensionrelativetothevolcanicventsince1June2015.Thereportingperiod(May-September2016)isboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HigherenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline.Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 24: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 24
Figure14: Tangentialdisplacementsrelativetothevolcanicventsince1June2015.Thereportingperiod(May-September2016)isboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HigherenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline.Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 25: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 25
Figure15: Verticaldisplacementsobservedsince1June2015.Thereportingperiod(May-September2016)isboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HigherenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline.Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 26: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 26
Figure16: RadialextensionrelativetothevolcanicventforPause5(February2010-September2016).Thereportingperiodisboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HighenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline,andthestrongestevents(27October2010,9July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted(reddashedline).Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 27: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 27
Figure17: TangentialdisplacementsrelativetothevolcanicventforPause5(February2010-September2016).Thepresentreportingperiodisboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HighenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline,andthestrongestevents(27October2010,9July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted(reddashedline).Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 28: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 28
Figure18: VerticaldisplacementsforPause5(February2010-September2016).Thepresentreportingperiodisboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HighenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline,andthestrongestevents(27October2010,9July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted(reddashedline).Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 29: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 29
Figure19: Radial(top)andVertical(bottom)displacementsrecordedatcampaignsitesduringPause5(February2010-September2016).Thereportingperiodisboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.HighenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline,andthestrongestevents(27October2010,9July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted(reddashedline).Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.SeeAppendixC:AdditionalGPSDatafortangentialdisplacements.
![Page 30: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 30
Figure20: Comparisonoftheradial(top)andvertical(bottom)displacementsmeasuredatnineMVOcontinuousGPSstationsduringPause3,Pause4bandPause5(solidlines)andsubsequentextrusionphases(dashedlines).A60-daylow-passfilterwasappliedtothedata.SeeAppendixC:AdditionalGPSDatafortangentialdisplacements.
![Page 31: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 31
Figure21: HorizontalvelocitiesobservedattheMVOGPSstations.Velocitiesarecalculatedrelativetoatectonicplatemodeldefinedusingvelocitiesfromlocalandreferencestationsthatprovideastatisticallyconsistentplaterotationpole/velocity.ThevelocitiesvectorscomparedarethosecomputedfortheentirePause5(black),forJune2015-April2016(blue),andforthereportingperiod(red).Continuousandcampaignsitesareindicatedwithredandblacknames,respectively.Stationsmissingasignificantamountofdatahavebeenremovedforthecorrespondingperiod.Theredstarmarksthedomelocation.
![Page 32: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 32
Figure22: HorizontalandverticalvelocitiesobservedattheMVOcontinuousGPSstationsduringPause5.HorizontalVelocitiesarecalculatedrelativetoatectonicplatemodeldefinedusingvelocitiesfromlocalandreferencestationsthatprovideastatisticallyconsistentplaterotationpole/velocity.Whenlackingasignificantamountofdataoveroneoftheperiodstudied,thestationisomitted.Theredstarmarksthepositionofthedome.
![Page 33: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 33
1.3.2.‘Spider’stationsThedeployed‘Spider’continuousGPSstationsareprocessedincombinationwiththerestofthenetwork.ThedeformationrecordedatMSUH(UpperHermitage),MSS1(Scar),andMSCP(Chance’sPeak)betweentheirrespectivedeploymentin2014until15April2016ispresentedinFigure23,inparallelwiththedisplacementsrecordedatoneclose-field(FRGR)andonefar-field(GERD)station.Unfortunately,sinceMay-June2015,thedataqualityofMSUHandMSCPhasbeendegrading,explaininginparticularthestepinthetime-seriesinMay2015.ThesetwostationshavenotbeenfunctioningsinceNovember2015.
Noneofthe‘Spiders’haveshownanysignificantdeformationsincetheirdeployment,eveninrelationwiththestrongerVTstringswhichoccurredduringthisperiod.TheradialandtangentialdisplacementsrecordedatMSUHarelikelyrelatedtothespiderssettlingdown,sincenosimilardisplacementswererecordedatHERMwhichisonlytensofmetersaway.
1.3.3.EDMAmapoftheEDMbaselinesmeasuredsinceFebruary2010isgiveninFigure24(filledblackcircled).EDMmeasurementsprovidedataonthenear-fielddeformationofthevolcano.InFigure25,theslantdistanceschangesrecordedovertheEDMnetworkarerepresentedforPause5andforMaytoSeptember2016.
SignificantdisplacementshavebeenrecordedsincethebeginningofPause5,inrelationwithstrongVTstrings.NosignificantdeformationhasbeenrecordedduringtheperiodMaytoSeptember2016atthebaselineslocatedintheSWofthedome.Duetoweatherandtechnicalissues,itwasnotpossibletotakeanymeasurementsofEDMbaselinesintheNorthofthedome
TheEDMplotsarealsocomplementedwithhorizontaldistancevariationsmeasuredatseveralpairsofcontinuousGPSstations,acrosstheedificeandacrosstheisland(Figure25),fortheperiodMay–September2016(Figure26)andforPause5(Figure27).
DuringPause5,thestepinthehorizontaltime-seriesoccurringinrelationwiththeMarch2012ashventingeventisvisibleforbaselinesinvolvingclose-fieldstations.Theextensionisemphasizedbetweenthesouthernandnorthernstations(SSOU-NWBL,FRGR-NWBL).Somedistancesdonotvary,forexample,thebaselineSPRI-WTYD,twoclose-fieldstationsSWandNEofthedome,respectively.Thecontractionseenattheendofthetime-seriesisduetotheunexplainedradialdisplacementofSPRImentionedearlier.
BetweenMayandSeptember2016,nodeformationisclearlyvisible.
![Page 34: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 34
Figure23: MSCP,MSS1,MSUH‘Spider’Stations:Radial,tangential,andverticaldisplacementsrelativetothevolcanicventsinceMSUH,MSS1andMSCPdeployment(June2014-September2016).FRGRandGERDdisplacementsarealsoshown.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Theplatevelocityhasbeenremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HighenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline.Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 35: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 35
Figure24: MapoftheEDMnetwork(blackfilledcircles)usedatMVOduringthereportingperiodandPause5andofcomplementingbaselinescomputedbetweenthecontinuousGPSstations(blackcircles).SeealsoFigure25Figure27.
![Page 36: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 36
Figure25: Slantlengthvariations(m)oftheEDMbaselinesduringthereportingperiod(2upperpanels)andduring Pause 5 (5 bottom panels). See Figure 24 for network map. The strongest events (27October2010,9 July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted (reddashedline).
![Page 37: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 37
Figure26: Horizontallengthvariations(m)ofseveralpairsofcGPSstationsbetweenMayandSeptember2016.SeeFigure24fornetworkmap.
![Page 38: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 38
Figure27: Horizontallengthvariations(m)ofseveralpairsofcGPSstationsduringPause5(February2010–present).SeeFigure24fornetworkmap.Thestrongestevents(27October2010,9July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted(reddashedline).
1.3.4.StrainAlthoughstrainmeasurementsduringtheentirereportingperiodneedtobestudiedforconfirmation,itisunlikelythananysignificantdeformationwasrecordedinrelationtothesmallseismiceventswhichhappenedduringthereportingperiod.TherewasnostrainsignalrelatedtothehigherenergyVTstringswhichoccurredduringMay-September2016,anddescribedinSection1.2.
![Page 39: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 39
1.4GasMonitoring
1.4.1SO2DailyFluxUnfortunately,duetofailureofthelastworkingDOASinstrumenton17September2015,ithasnotbeenpossibletomeasurethedailySO2fluxfromtheSoufriereHillsVolcanoduringthisreportingperiod.Priortothis,theDOASnetworkhadbeenrunningononeinstrumentlocatedatBroderick’s.ThishadbeenthecasesinceFebruary2013.
Figure28belowshowsthedailySO2fluxforthe20monthspriortothefailureofthelastDOASinstrumentatBroderick’s(1January2014to17September2015).Duringthisperiod,theaveragedailySO2fluxwas340tonnesperday.Thisisslightlybelowthelongtermaverageof375tonnesperdayforPause5andconsiderablylowerthantheaveragesforpreviouspauses(Table4;Christopheretal.,2014).
AsdiscussedinpreviousMVOreports,thedatainFigure28stillshowstheabsenceoftheSO2pulse/cyclepatternontheorderofyears(seeSAC13report).Instead,theSO2fluxisdominatedbyvariationsontimesscalesontheorderofdaystomonths,whichattimesstillcorrelatewithVTearthquakes,e.g.,thelargespikeinSO2outputfollowingtheVTstringsinMarch2014.PriortothefailureoftheinstrumentinSeptember2015,itappearedthatthegasfluxwasdescendingintoatroughofa6-8monthcycle,thesecondsinceJanuary2014.ThisreflectstheoveralltrendinSO2fluxsincethestartofPause5(seeFigure32andFigure33).
Figure28: Dailyand30-dayaverageSO2fluxfromtheSoufriereHillsVolcanofortheperiod1January2014to17September172015whentheDOASinstrumentatBroderick'sfailed.The6-8monthpulses
![Page 40: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 40
arepresentinthedata,asistheinfluenceoftheelevatedSO2fluxfollowingtheMarch2014VTstringonthe30-dayrunningaverage.
Eruptivephase n Meandailyflux(t/d) Pausefollowing n Meandailyflux
(t/d)I–15thNov1995 68 569 I–10thMarch1998 112 699II–27thNov1999 563 471 II–1stAugust2003 698 561III–8thAug2005 604 429 III–4thApril2007 482 620
IVa–29thJul2008 77 923 IVa–14thOctober2008 50 800
IVb3rdDec2008 32 451 IVb–4thJanuary2009 258 627V–4thOct2009 7 379 V–11thFebruary2010 2270 376
Table4: Overviewofphasesoflavaextrusionanderuptivepauses1995-2010andthemeanSO2fluxforeach.“Pausefollowing”istheeruptivepausethatimmediatelyfollowedtheeruptivephaseinthesamerow;nisthenumberofdaysintheeruptivephaseorpause(updatedto30April2016,fromChristopheretal.,2014).
1.4.2SO2DiffusionTubesMVOmeasurestheaverageground-levelconcentrationofSO2usingdiffusiontubespositionedattwelvedifferentlocationsonMontserrat.Figure29showstheaverageconcentrationofSO2fromalltwelvesitesaroundtheislandandcoverstheperiodMarch2010toAugust2016.TheconcentrationvaluesforChancesPeakareconsiderablyhigherthanalloverlocationsduetoitscloseproximitytothelavadome(1.5km).
Duringthecurrentreportingperiod,measuredSO2concentrationscontinuetoshowanoveralldecliningtrend.Measuredconcentrationsatthemostdistallocationsarenowfallingbelowtheminimumdetectionlevelof0.28ppb.
![Page 41: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 41
Figure29: MonitoredSO2concentrations(ppb)betweenFebruary2010andAugust2016.
Figure30showsacomparisonofSO2concentrationfrom6ofthemostproximallocationstothatofTheUnitedStatesNationalAmbientAirQualityStandards(USNAAQS)annuallimitof30ppb.Allofthelocations,whichareineitherZoneCorZoneVarenowshowingconcentrationsbelowtheUSNAAQSlimit.ThisincludesPlymouth(measurednearAngelo’sSupermarket)whichpriorto2015hadbeenconsistentlyoverthe30ppblimit.Since2015,Plymouthhasnowdroppedbelowthe30ppblimitandreflectingacontinueddecreasingtrendsince2008.Chance’sPeak,notshownontheplotduetothehighconcentrationslevels,hasconsistentlyremainedoverthelimit.
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400SO
2Con
centra^o
n(ppb
)
PoliceHeadQuarters,Plymouth RichmondHillSugarMill St.GeorgesHillWeekes VuePointeHotel St.Augus^nesPrimarySchoolSt.Johns(DMCA) JackBoyHill Brodericks(DOASSite)SalemClinic BradesPrimarySchool ChancesPeak
![Page 42: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 42
Figure30: TheannualmeanconcentrationsoftheSO2diffusiontubesfromsixofthemostproximallocations.Chance’sPeak,themostproximallocation,isnotshownduetothehighconcentrationsofSO2recordedatthatsite.
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
PlymouthRichmondHillStGeorgesHillWeekesVuePointe30ppbBrodericks
![Page 43: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 43
1.5DomeVolumeandGeology
1.5.1DomeVolumeTherehasbeennoextrusionoflavasincetheendofPhase5on11February2010.Therefore,therehasbeennoincreaseinthedomevolume.Therehas,however,beensomeminorrockfall(RF)activity.Duringthecurrentreportingperiod,therehavebeennopyroclasticflows.Thelastrecordedpyroclasticflowwason29September2012.
1.5.2DomeMorphologyWithnoextrusionoccurringsince11February2010,thelavadomehasundergoneverylittlechange.Throughoutthereportingperiod,fewobservationsofthewholedomeweremadeduetopersistentcloudcover.Whenobservationswerepossible,littletonoobvioussignsofsignificantchangewereidentified.LargefracturescontinuetobeobservedinthestepcliffintheTarRiver(east)flankofthedomewithsomeaccumulationoflargeblocksatthebaseofthecliff.Thenear-continuouspresenceofcloudpreventsmoreregularobservationofthedomesummit.
1.5.3RockfallActivityFigure31showsthedailyandcumulativerockfall(RF)countsfortheperiod1January2015to30September2016.AlthoughitshowsacontinuedlowlevelofRFactivity,therehasbeenaslightincreaseinRFactivityduringthecurrentreportingperiodwithatotalof35RFeventstriggeringtheseismicmonitoringsystem.Ofthese,therewere4RFeventson25August,associatedwithheavyrainfallduringthepassageofastrongtropicalwave,andafurther5on1September2016.Overall,theincreaseisrelatedtotheonsetoftherainyseasoninMontserrat,atrendwhichhasbeenobservedinpreviousyears.
AlargeRFeventoccurredon25June2016(UTC).Noobservationswereimmediatelypossibletoduetocloudcover,butareportoffreshashfallintheupperAmershamareawasreceivedfromCaribbeanHelicopterson27June.Itisassumedthattheeventoccurredinsidethe2010collapsescar.SeeAppendixA:25June2016RFeventformoredetail.
ObservationsduringhelicopterflightshaveshownthattheRFactivityhasbeenconcentratedintwomainlocations:insidethe2010collapsescarwhereRFsoriginatefromtheclifffaceintheSWcorner;andfromtheTarRiverclifffacewithlargeblocksaccumulatingonthetalusslopeatitsbase.
![Page 44: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 44
Figure31: Dailyandcumulativerockfallcountsfortheperiod1January2015to30April2016
1.5.4DomeIncandescenceandFumaroleTemperaturesNolong-exposurephotographshavebeenacquiredfromMVOduetounfavourablenight-timeconditions.Incandescencehas,however,beenrecordedonoccasionbytheremotecameraatHarrisLookout.Thesephotographsrevealnochangestothelocationoftherecordedincandescence.
Thermalimagesacquiredduringbriefclearperiodshavecontinuedtoshownochangesinthenumber,distributionorintensityoffumarolesandhotspotsonthedome.Temperaturesofindividualfumarolesderivedfromthethermalimagesshowsomevariation(primarilyduetoatmosphericconditionsandscattering/absorptionofIRradiation),butarenotoutsideofnormalranges.AlltemperaturesreportedbelowinTable5aretheresultofbasiccorrectionsforatmospherictemperatureandhumidity,anddistancetofeature.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
CumulapveRFCount
DailyRFCo
unt
DATE
DailyCumulapve
![Page 45: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 45
Location MaxT(°C) LastimagedGasVent,2010collapsescar 422 21Sept2016Headwall,2010collapsescar 356 21Sept2016
23March2012crater,(inside2010collapsescar) 64 26Aug2016
TarRiver 372 16June2016SummitCrater - 30Sept2015
Summit2006-7dome - 31March2015EandNflankofGalway’sMtn - 25February2015
Southflankofdome - 30Sept2015
Table5: Maximumrecordedtemperaturesoffumarolesonthelavadomederivedfromthermalimagesacquiredduringtheperiod1Mayto30September2016.
![Page 46: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 46
2DiscussionofActivityandComparisonwithPastActivity
2.1PauseinDomeGrowthThecurrentpause,thefifthsincetheonsetofactivityinJuly1995,isnowmorethan79monthslong.
Aswithpreviousperiods,thisreportingperiodhasbeenoneofverylowactivitywithnorestartoflavaextrusionordomegrowth.DegradationrockfallshavebecomeextremelyrareandtherehavebeennopyroclasticflowssinceSeptember2012.
Figure32showsthekeymonitoringdata(seismiccounts,GPSandSO2flux)fortheSoufrièreHillsVolcanofrom1995to30April2016.Figure33showsthesamedatafortheperiodsincetheendofPhase5inFebruary2010.Althoughthecurrentpauseisthelongestbyfar,thedataissimilartothatduringthepreviouspauses;seismicityislow,island-wideradialinflationcontinuesandthegas(uptoSeptember2015whenmonitoringstopped)isconsistentlyabovebackgroundlevels,maintainingdailyfluxesinexcessof300t/d.
Figure32: Seismic,GPSandSO2monitoringdatafortheperiod1January1995–30September2016.Extrusivephasesandpausesareinshownredandgreenrespectively.Top:Numberofseismiceventsdetectedandidentifiedbytheseismicsystem.Middle:RadialdisplacementofcGPSstationsMVO1(red)andGERD(blue)smoothedwith7-dayrunningmeanfilter,Black:GPSHeightofHARR.Bottom:MeasureddailySO2flux,filteredwith7-dayrunningmedianfilter.Green:COSPEC,Blue:DOAS.Nodataavailablesincemid-September2015.
![Page 47: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 47
Figure33: Seismic,GPSandSO2monitoringdatafortheperiodsincetheendofPhase5:12February2010–30April2016.Top:Numberofseismiceventsdetectedandidentifiedbytheseismicsystem.Middle:RadialdisplacementofcGPSstationsMVO1(red)andGERD(blue)smoothedwith7-dayrunningmeanfilter.Bottom:DailySO2fluxmeasuredbytheDOASnetwork,filteredwith7-dayrunningmedianfilter.
Thisprolongedperiodofpersistentlow-levelunrest,(i.e.,continuedinflation,sporadicseismicityandpersistentde-gassing)clearlydemonstratesthatthemagmaticsystemhasnotshutdown.Thus,thepotentialforarestartremains.
2.2DomeStabilityThelavadomeatSoufrièreHillsvolcanoremainsstabledespitecontainingheavilyfracturedregions,particularlyontheeastflankwhererepeatedfracturinginducedbycoolingandweatheringgeneratesoccasionalrockfalls.Therehavebeennopyroclasticflowsinthecurrentreportingperiodandthenumberofrockfallevents,whileslightlyelevatedcomparedtothepreviousreportingperiod,isstillextremelylow(seeabove).Clearly,thedomehasbecomeverystable.However,itisclearthevariationsinRFactivity,showninFigure31,indicatethatthedomemaybecapableofrespondingtoexternalfactors,suchasheavyorprolongedrainfall.Researchintopossiblelinksbetweentherockfallcounts,rainfallandseismicitycontinues.
![Page 48: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 48
Thepersistentincandescentfeaturesobservedinsidethe2010collapsescararefurtherevidenceforastabledome.ThepersistenceofthesefumarolesandothersonthesummitofthedomeandontheTarRiverflank,indicatesthatverystablepathwaysexistinthedomeandmaterialsurroundingtheconduitallowinggastoescape,suggestingthatthesecouldbesuitablepathwaysformagmatoreachthesurface,shouldtherebearestart.Anyrestartofextrusioncouldpossiblycausesignificantdisruptiontothepresentdome,assuggestedbytheincreaseinRFactivitypriortotheonsetofashventinginMarch2012(seeMVOOFR12-01).
2.3CriteriaforContinuationofActivitySinceSAC16(November2011),thepotentialforcontinuingactivityhasbeenconsideredagainstthefollowingthreecriteriathatindicatethepotentialforfutureactivity:
1. Seismicity–thepresenceoflowfrequencyseismicswarmsandofseismictremor2. Gas–dailySO2ratesabove50tonnesperday3. Grounddeformation–significantgrounddeformation
Asdiscussedbelow,Criteria3iscurrentlybeingmet.Althoughthereisnodatafromthepast11months,itisassumedthat,basedonvisualobservations,Criteria2isalsobeingmet.Therefore,thereisevidencethatthedeepplumbingsystembeneaththevolcanoisstillactive.
2.3.1SeismicityThepresenceofswarmsoflow-frequencyseismicityorthepresenceofseismictremorindicatethepotentialforfuturevolcanicactivity.
Low-frequencyseismicityhascontinuedtobeextremelylowandhasbeencompletelyabsentduringthecurrentreportingperiodwithnolow-frequencyswarmsortremorobserved.
2.3.2GasDailySO2ratesabove50tonnesperdayindicatethepotentialforfuturevolcanicactivity.
Duetoinstrumentfailure,therehasbeennoSO2fluxmeasuredduringthecurrentreportingperiod.However,intheperiod1May2015to31October2015,SO2levelsaveraged436tonnesperdaywithspikesinthefluxabove1,000tonnesperday.Visualobservationsinthecurrentreportingperiodindicateastronggasplumeisstillpresent.
2.3.3GrounddeformationSignificantgrounddeformationindicatesthepotentialforfuturevolcanicactivity.
ThecGPSnetworkcontinuestoshowsignificantslowinflation,similartothatduringpreviouspauses.
![Page 49: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 49
2.4PhasesandPauseTable6liststhephasesandpausesoftheeruptionoftheSoufrièreHillsVolcano,upto30September2016,andfollowsthetraditionaldefinitionofaPhaseasaperiodwhenlavaisbeingextrudedatthesurface.
Phase # Start End Duration(days) Duration(months)
Seismic 0 01-Jan-92 17-Jul-95 1,294 42.5Phreatic 18-Jul-95 14-Nov-95 120 3.9Extrusion 1 15-Nov-95 10-Mar-98 847 27.8Pause 1 11-Mar-98 26-Nov-99 626 20.6
Extrusion 2 27-Nov-99 01-Aug-03 1,344 44.2Pause 2 02-Aug-03 14-Apr-05 622 20.4
Transition 15-Apr-05 31-Jul-05 108 3.5Extrusion 3 01-Aug-05 20-Apr-07 628 20.6Pause 3 21-Apr-07 04-May-08 380 12.5
Transition 05-May-08 07-Aug-08 95 3.1Extrusion 4a 08-Aug-08 08-Oct-08 62 2.0Pause 4a 09-Oct-08 01-Dec-08 54 1.8
Extrusion 4b 02-Dec-08 03-Jan-09 33 1.1Pause 4b 04-Jan-09 04-Oct-09 274 9.0
Transition 05-Oct-09 07-Oct-09 3 0.1Extrusion 5 08-Oct-09 11-Feb-10 127 4.2Pause 5 12-Feb-10 Ongoing 2,423 79.7
Table6: PhasesandpausesoftheeruptionoftheSoufriereHillsvolcano,withdurationscalculateduptoandinclusiveof30September2016.
![Page 50: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 50
3HazardsandRisks
3.1RiskAssessmentThepresentlavadome,estimatedat190Mm3(Stintonetal.,2014),isstillofconsiderablesize.SincethebeginningofPause5,nomorethanafewpercentofthedomehasbeenremovedbyrockfallsandpyroclasticflows.Consequently,withlittlematerialremovedovertheinterveningperiod,thedomestillrepresentsasignificanthazard.
Withsolittlematerialshedfromthedomeoverthepastsixmonths,thestabilityofthedomeandthequantityofmaterialavailableremainsvirtuallyidenticaltothatdiscussedinSACs17-20.Therefore,wecontinuetoholdtheviewthatlittlehaschangedinregardstotheHazardandRiskassociatedposedbytheSoufriereHillsvolcanosinceSAC20(November2015,Neubergetal.,2015).
3.2HazardLevelSystemTherehavebeennochangesmadetotheHazardLevelSystemsincethecurrentversionwasreleasedinAugust2014.TheHazardLevelremainsatLevel1.
3.3AccesstoZoneVMVOcontinuestoworkcloselywithDMCAandotherauthoritiestocontrolaccesstoZoneV.
Todate,accesshasbeenarrangedforthefollowingactivities:
• ExportofsandandgravelusingPlymouthJetty.• ReclamationofmetalsfromLoversLane.• GeothermalwellMON#3(seebelow).• ControlofferallivestockbyDepartmentoftheEnvironment.• TouristsvisittoPlymouth(seebelow).
NoaccesshasyetbeenallowedforanyactivitiessouthofPlymouthJetty.
3.4TouristVisitstoPlymouthBetweenAprilandSeptember2016,thenumberoftouristvisitstoPlymouthdecreasedsignificantly,primarilyduetotheendofvisitsbycruiseshipsinMarch2016.Oncehurricaneseasonisoverandcruiseshipvisitsbeginagain,thenumberofvisitsshouldincreaseagain.
Therehavebeenafewoccasionswhereagreedsafetyproceduresfortouristvisitswerenotproperlyadheredto.MVOisworkingcloselywithDMCAtoensurethatpropersafetyproceduresarefollowedatalltimes.
![Page 51: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 51
3.5GeothermalWellMON#3MVOhavebeenheavilyinvolvedinthesafetyproceduresassociatedwiththedrillingofgeothermalwellMON#3.
ThedrillingrigarrivedbyshipatPlymouthJettyinlateAugust2016.MVOhelpedwritethesafetyproceduresfordredgingatPlymouthJettyandforunloadingtherig.TheMVOOperationsRoomwasmannedcontinuouslyduringtheseoperations.
ThelocationofthedrillingsiteisjustinsidetheZoneVboundaryonthenorthernsideofStGeorgesHill.MVOhelpdevelopsafetyproceduresandevacuationplansfortherigsite.TheMVOOperationsRoomisnotcontinuouslymannedduringthedrilling,butcommunicationsprotocolshavebeenestablishedtoenablerapidnotificationoftheneedforanevacuationbythedutyscientist.
MVOhashostedorientationcoursesforalmostallofthecrewworkingonMON#3.ThesecoursesincludeawarenessofthevolcanichazardslikelyfromtheSoufrièreHillsVolcano.
![Page 52: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 52
4MVOMonitoringNetworks
4.1SeismicMonitoring TheMVOseismicnetworkhascontinuedtoperformadequatelyduringthisreportingperiod.
On14May2016aproblemwithabreakerboard/panelintheserverroomledtoalossofpowerintheserverroomwhichresultedincompletedatalossforallstationsforseveralhours.
On7September2016anunknownissuecausedasimultaneouslossofnetworkconnectivityforseveraloftheLantronixserial-to-LANconverterboxes,resultinginminordatalossforseveralstations.
Lossofexternalnetworkaccessduringpowercuts(duetoproblemsattheOlvestonrepeatersite)hasmeantfrequentdatalossfromthestationsroutedviaSilverHillsduringpoweroutages.
Also,otherongoingtelemetryproblems,particularlywiththeSpidersandstationsroutedviaSilverHills,haveagaincompromiseddataqualityatsomeofthestationsinthenetwork.
Alackoffunctioningspareequipmenthascontinuedtoimpactonmonitoringcapacity,notablyforsomeofthemoreproximalstations,suchasMBFRandMBLG,whichhavesufferedextendedoutages.Thishasmeantareducedtriggeringthreshold,andanoverrelianceonthetwomostproximalstationsMBLYandMSS1fordetectingsmallevents.
4.1.1SoftwareandacquisitionchangesTherewerenosoftwarechangestotheseismicacquisitionandprocessingsystemsduringthisreportingperiod.
4.1.2InstrumentalchangesatstationsTable7belowliststhechangestoinstrumentsthathavetakenplaceatindividualseismicstationsduringtheperiodcoveredbythisreport,aswellasspecificissuesthathavebeenresolved.
Station Date Detailsofchanges
MBBYBroderick’sYard 03-Oct-2016 Fixed3dayoutageduetolossofcommunications.
Ongoingtelemetryissues,causingregularsmalldatagaps
MBFRFergusRidge
18-Nov-2015 Nodataacquiredsincethisdate.
MBGHSt.George’sHill 15-Sep-2016
Sinceatleastthisdatetherehasbeenatimingerrorofuptoseveralseconds.
ProblemislikelyduetoafaultyGPSantennaorcable,currentlyunresolved
MBLGLongGround 05-Dec-2015 Nodataacquiredsincethisdate.
![Page 53: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 53
MBRYRoche’sYard 29-Jun-2016
Nodatawasreceivedfromthisstationforseveraldays,betweenapproximately25-Jun-201612:44UTCand15:37UTCon29-Jun.LinkrestoredfollowingsitevisitbyMF.
Ongoingtelemetryissues,causingregularsmalldatagaps
MBWHWindyHill
05-May-2016
FollowingsitevisitbyMFcommunicationswererestored-problemappearstohavebeenwaterinconnector
followingrecentheavyrainfall.Transmissionissuesfirstarisinginmid-Aprilappeartohavenowbeenresolved.
MSCPChance’sPeak 01-Oct-2015
Nodataacquiredsincethisdate.DamagetoSpiderduetocorrosion.Electronicsretrievedfortesting,framestill
awaitingretrieval.
MSUHUpperHermitage
11-May-201601-Aug-2016
Communicationsrestoredfollowingsitevisit.Nodatareceivedfromthisdate.Stationcurrentlyoffline
withongoingtelemetryissues
Table7: Changesmadetoinstrumentsatindividualseismicstations.
4.1.3Ongoingproblemsandknownissues4.1.3.1SeismometermassproblemsInstrumentT4344installedatMBLYhascontinuedtosufferfrommassproblems,withpersistentlong-periodnoiseontheN-Shorizontalcomponent.
4.1.3.2SpidersInOctober2015theSpideratChance’sPeak(MSCP)ceasedfunctioning.Theelectronicswererecoveredfortestingwhiletheframeisstillawaitingsuitableconditionsforretrieval.
MSUHatUpperHermitagehassufferedfromseveralprolongedcommunicationoutagesduringthisreportingperiod.
MSS1inthecollapsehasfunctionedwell,operatingmoreorlesscontinuouslythroughoutthisreportingperiodwithnomajorproblems.
StationMSNWdeployedneartotheSinkholeclosetoNorthWestBluff,alsofunctionednormallyduringthisreportingperiod,althoughsuffersfromhighnoiselevelsduetoitsproximitytothecoast.
4.1.3.3TelemetryissuesSeveralstationshavecontinuedtobeaffectedbytelemetryandcommunicationsproblemsduringthisreportingperiod.StationsontheEasternsideoftheislandinparticular(MBHAandMBRY)aswellasMBBYandtheSPIDERshavesufferedmostoftenwithdatagaps.Evensmalldatagapscanhaveaknock-oneffectintermsofeventtriggeringinearthworm,especiallyformoreproximalstations(e.g.MBFRorMBLG).
![Page 54: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 54
4.1.4Futuredevelopments4.1.4.1ShorttermgoalsThemainissuescurrentlyaffectingtheperformanceofthenetworkaretelemetryproblemsandalackoffunctioningspareseismometersanddigitiserstoreplacethosewithmassproblemsorotherissues.SeveralinstrumentsanddigitisersarestillawaitingreturntoGuralpforrepair.Thiswouldhelp,intheshort-term,toresolvetheinstrumentmassproblemsatsomestationsandalleviatepressureonresources,particularlywiththecurrentoutagestoimportantproximalstationssuchasMBFRandMBLG.Intheslightlylongerterm,issuessuchasthisshouldbesolvedbytheplannedseismicnetworkupgradewhichwillprovidemuchgreatersparecapacity.
4.1.4.2SpidersAnothermoreimmediateshort-termgoalistotryandretrievetheSpiderfromMSCPandalsotodeployoneofremaininginstruments,withthesiteatGalwaysincludingatiltmeterbeingthepriority;althoughthetimingofthisisheavilydependentonfavourableweatherconditionsandhelicopteravailabilitywhichhasyettooccur.
TheacquisitionsoftwareforthedatafromtheSpidersisalsoplannedtobemovedfromitscurrentpositiononalaptopandmigratedovertoadedicatedvirtualserverassoonasthisresourceismadeavailable.
4.1.4.3LongertermplansIntheirproposaltomanageMVOin2008,SRCandIPGPsuggestedthattheseismicmonitoringsystemshouldbereviewedbeforetheendofthefirstfive-yearcontract(April2013).TherecommendationsfromthisreviewformedpartoftheproposalsubmittedfortherenewalofthecurrentMVOmanagementcontract.ThisreportwascompletedandformedpartofthenewMVOmanagementcontractwhichwasfinallysignedinSeptember2016.Weareawaitingfinalcostingsforinstrumentsandadditionaltelemetryhardware,buttheequipmentfortheupgradeshouldbeorderedwithinthecomingweeks.
Theproposalsinclude:
• Standardisingequipmentandinstallations,includinginstrumentperiodsandgainsetctoalloweaseofswappingbetweensites.
• Replacingolder/brokenequipmentandincreasingstockofspareparts.• Upgradingverticalshort-periodstationstobroadbandwherepossible.Hopefully,dependingon
cost,toincludeatleastone120sultra-broadbandinstrumentfordetectionofVLPsignals.• InstallationoftwonewbroadbandstationsatSouthSoufriere(collocatedwithcGPS),andJack
BoyHill(re-occupyingexistingsite)• Establishingseveralnewnear-domestationstohelpwithdepthconstraintsanddetectionof
smallermagnitudeevents.CandidatesitesareHermitage,GalwaysandGagesMountain.ThequalityandusefulnessofdatafromtheadditionalSpidersthathavebeenorareplannedtobedeployedinsimilarlocationstothesemayinfluencethedecisiononfinallocationsandwhetherpermanentstationsinsuchlocationsarenecessaryordesirable.Currentresearchintotheimpactofnearfieldstationsontheprecisionoflocatedearthquakedepthssuggestedproximalhaveanimportantpositiveeffectonthequalityofthehypocentres.
![Page 55: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 55
• IntegrationoftwoSRC-fundedstations(atsitesinthenorthofMontserrat/SilverHillsandRedonda)andpotentiallyonemoreLeedsUniversitystation(boreholesensorinOlveston)
• Minorrevisionsandupgradestosoftwareandsomecomputerhardware.
4.2GroundDeformationMonitoring
4.2.1ContinuousGPS(cGPS)On-goingissueswiththecGPSnetwork:
• HERM:issuewithGPSantennahascausedlossofdatasince19thMay2015.• SGH1:receivernotworkingssincethe13thJan2015.OneNetR9receivergivenbySRC,andwill
beusedtoreplaceSGH1receiver,oncethesiteisready(thereceiverneedstobeinstalledinsideabuildingratherthanoutsideasitwas).
ThecGPSnetworkhasexperiencedotherissuesduringthereportingperiod;whichhavebeensolved:
• RCHY:damagedauxiliaryequipmentcausedlossofdatabetween11Februaryand25May2016.• NWBL:theantennaLNAhadtobereplacedwhichcausedlossofdatabetween30Julyand18
August2016.
TelemeteredaccesstomostoftheMVOcGPSstationshasremainedgoodthroughoutthereportingperiod.However,theaccesstoSSOUhasbeenparticularlydifficultinthelast2months.
InadditionofbeingincorporatedintheMVOdailyprocessing,datagatheredattheUNAVCO-andNASA-fundedsites(RDON,NWBL,RCHY),andatthefourstationsoperatedbytheCALIPSOproject(AIRS,GERD,OLVN,TRNT)arebeingtransferreddailytotheUNAVCOFTPsite,wheretheyaremadepubliclyavailable.
4.2.2CampaignGPS(eGPS)Eightbenchmarksarebeingoccupiedepisodically,foraweekapproximatelyeverysecondmonth.Ashortthreadedrodwasinstalledatfourstations(NorthWhiteRiver,LongGround,DryGhaut,Bransbypoint)tofacilitatedeploymentandimprovedataaccuracy.NochangestotheeGPSnetworkhavebeenmadeduringthereportingperiod.
OneNetR9receiverhasbeenborrowedfromSRCtoreplacetheNetRSreceiverswhichfailedinDec.2014.Thecampaignmeasurementshavebeenresumedonthe5May2016,howeverproblemswiththeauxiliaryequipment(battery,cable)hascausedlossoffewweeksofdata.Theseissuesarenowsolved.
4.2.3GPSArchivingandProcessingAfterbeingdownloaded,rawdataareconvertedwiththeUNAVCOteqcutilityintoRinexformat,tobeprocessedusingtheGAMIT/GLOBKsoftwaresuite.AseriesofMATLABscriptsthenreadtheGAMIT/GLOBKoutput,applycorrectionandremoveacommon‘tectonic’trend,rotateeachstationtime-seriesintoaradial,tangentialandverticallocalcoordinateframecenteredonthevolcanicvent,andproduceplotsassomeofthosepresentinthisreport(e.g.Figure13).
![Page 56: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 56
4.2.4EDMTherewerenochangesintheEDMnetworkmonitoringthevolcanicactivityduringthereportingperiod.
TwoEDMbaselineshavebeenestablishednexttothesinkholeinordertomeasureanypossiblesubsidencenearthesinkholeorlandslidedowntheslopefromthesinkhole.Nodeformationhasbeenobserved.
Thecoordinatesofthetotalstationandofthetworeflectorsarethefollowing:
North(m) East(m) Elevation(m)
Totalstation(SKTS) 1859990.584 585337.755 43.397
Reflector1(SKH1) Bysinkhole 1859841.173 585388.457 35.462
Reflector2(SKH2) Downslope 1859837.618 585366.120 25.941
TwoEDMbaselineshavebeenestablishedfromtheMVOhelipad(EDM2)tothegeothermalsite,inordertomonitoranypotentialmovements(inparticularlandslide)relatedtodrilling.TheEDMreflectorssitearealsomeasuredevery2ndweekusingthekinematicGPS.Nodeformationhasbeenobserved.
Thecoordinatesofthetworeflectorsarethefollowing:
North(m) East(m) Elevation(m)
Reflector1(GEO1) 1849784.403 584638.199 144.765
Reflector2(GEO2) 1849821.175 584581.988 135.936
4.2.5TiltMVOcurrentlyhasnooperationaltiltmeters.ItisplannedtodeployonetiltmeterwiththeSPIDERonGalwaysMountain,whichisprovingverydifficulttoaccessduetoweatherandlogisticalproblems.MVOhastwoothertiltmetersthancanbedeployedatseismicstations.Thedeploymentofthesewillbeconsideredintheseismicupgradescheduledfor2018.
4.2.6StrainStraindataaremeasuredatthefourCALIPSOstations(OLVN,AIRS,TRNT,GERD)andaretransferredtotheUNAVCOFTPsite,andtotheMVO.Asignificantamountofdataisatthemomentmissing,becauseofdatatransmissionissues.
![Page 57: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 57
4.2.7Spidersstations:single-frequencyGPS,EDMandTiltmeterInJuneandDecember2014,incollaborationwiththeUSGS,threeadditionalcontinuousGPSstations,so-called‘spiders’,weredeployedclosetothe2010collapsescar(MSS1andMSUH),andonChance’sPeak(MSCP).
Thespidershavebeenrecordingandtransferringdatadailysincedeployment.Duringthereportingperiod,therehavebeenissueswithMSUHandMSCP,withdeteriorateddataornodataatall,since28thNov.2015and02ndOct2015,forMSUHandMSCPrespectively.
TherawdatafromtheSpiderGPSstationsareprocessedwithasimilarmethodologytothatoftheotherGPSstations.TherawdataareconvertedintorinexformatusingtheteqcutilityandthenprocessedbyGAMIT/GLOBK.TheSpidersareprocessedusingGAMIT/GLOBKincombinationwiththerestofthenetwork,althoughthroughamorecomplexprocedure,duetohavingadifferenttypeofreceiver.
InFebruary2016,aspiderwasdeployedneartheNorthWestBluffsinkholetomonitorforanyfurthergroundfailures.ThespiderisalsoequippedwithaGPSanddatahavebeencollectedsince25February2016.UnliketherestoftheSpidernetwork,itsdataareprocessedusingakinematicapproachusingthecontinuousGPSstationNWBLasabasestation.ThespidercodeisMSNWandislocatedatNorth1859991.699m,East585202.883m,Up62.290m(UTM20).
Finally,itisexpectedthat,oncetheequipmentisavailableandtheweatherallows,atiltmeterwillbeincludedwithGPSandseismicinstrumentsonaSpidertobedeployedtoGalway’sMountain.
4.3GasMonitoring
4.3.1MultigasTheMVOmultigaswastakentoItalyforrepairsinFebruary2016.INGVrecentlybegandevelopinganew,morecompactversionofthemultigas.Consequently,itwasdecidedthatMVOacquiretwoinstruments;onewouldbearefurbishedversionoftheoldermodelusingthesameLICORspectrometerandtwonewsulphursensors.ThisinstrumentwouldbeputtogetherbyaprivatecompanyinItalyundercontractfromINGVPalermo.ThesecondinstrumentwouldbebuiltfromscratchbyINGVPalermo.AtpresentthereisachangeinthedirectorshipofINGVPalermothusthereisaslightdelayonthisnewinstrument.However,therefurbishedinstrumentfromtheprivatecompanyhasbeenshippedbyINGVandshouldarriveonMontserratbytheendofOctober.
4.3.2DOASUVspectrometernetworkSincethecurrentnetworkoftwoS2000spectrometersfailed,MVOhasbeenunabletocollectSO2fluxdataforapproximatelyoneyear.Priortothis,theSO2networkwasrunningononeinstrumentfor18months,thustheSO2fluxdatahasbeenoflimitedutilitysinceFebruary2013.ThemostrecentventuretoputinanewnetworkofnewUSB2000+instrumentswiththeCambridgegroupdidnotbearfruit.
FollowingavisitbyDrT.ChristophertotheUVgroupatINGVPalermo,MVOisintheprocessofpurchasingthreeboxestohousecalibratedspectrometersfromBoGalle.Preparationoftheboxestakes6months,afterwhichtheywillbedeliveredtoFabioVita,INGVPalermo.FabioVitaandothercolleaguesfromtheINGVgroupwillthenbringthecompletedinstrumentboxestoMVOtosetupthe
![Page 58: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 58
networkandtraintherelevantMVOstaffinmaintainingthenetworkandprocessingtherawdatatoobtainSO2flux.Thisislikelytotakeplaceduringthefirsthalfof2017.
4.4DomeVolumeTwomethodsareemployedformonitoringdomegrowthandgeologicmapping:aerialphotogrammetryandtheAVTIS3radarinstrument.
AerialphotographyforphotogrammetrystudiesiscurrentlycollectedusingaGoProHero3actioncamera.Whilethiscameraiseasytouseandprogramforhigh-framerateacquisition,theimagesacquiredareofmoderatequality.Thisisduetotheverywide(172°)fieldofviewofthecamera’slens.Ahigherqualitysystemiscurrentlyunderdevelopmentinhouse.InSeptember,followingdiscussionwithCaribbeanHelicopters,theprototypehousingunderwentatestflighttoensuretherewasnosignofthehousingbecomingdetachedfromthehelicopter.Thistestwassuccessful.Thenextstageistoacquireandtestasuitablecamera,afterwhichthewholesetupwillbetestedbeforebeingpressedintoservice,mappingthelavadomeandsurroundingflanks.
TheAVTIS3radarinstrumentiscurrentlynon-operational.BoththeradarinstrumentandtheremotePCusedtocontrolitareinstorageatMVOawaitingrefurbishmentbyDrDavMacFarlane,UniversityofStAndrews.DrAdamStintonandPyikoWilliamsareworkingcloselywithDrMacFarlaneontheAVTISinstrument,whichwillincludetwoplannedvisitsbyDrMacFarlaneinDecember2016andearly2017.
4.5FumaroleMonitoringCurrently,thetemperatureoffumarolesonandadjacenttothelavadomearemonitoredonanadhocbasis,principallywhenweatherconditionsallow,usingaeitherahandheldFLIRThermalIRcamerafromthehelicopter,orusingJ-typethermocouplesinsertedtoatleast50cmdepth.Onlylow-temperaturefumarolesaremeasuredonthegroundwiththermocouplesduetoaccessandsafety.TemperaturesarepresentedinTable5,Section1.5.4above.
InSeptember2016,MVOacquiredthreeGeminiTinytagPlus2temperatureloggersforthepurposeofdevelopingacontinuoustime-seriesoffumaroletemperatures.Theloggers,capableofrecordingtemperatureevery60secondsandstoring32,000readings,arecurrentlyundergoingtestingandwhencompleted,willbeinstalledonGalway’sMountainwherethreelow-temperaturefumaroles(~100°C)arelocatedincloseproximitytothelavadome.Shouldtheseprovetobesuccessful,additionalloggersmaybeacquiredandinstalledinhighertemperaturefumaroleslocatedontheSWflankofthelavadome.
4.6RemoteCamerasCurrently,MVOhasonlyoneremotecamerainoperation,locatedatHarrisLookout,inadditiontoanetworkIPcameraatMVO.
On1July,thenetworkcamerapreviouslyinstalledatGaribaldiHillsufferedafailureofthewallmountbracket,suchthatthecamerawaslefthangingfromtheroofbythepowercable.Themounthadsufferedseverecorrosionduetotheweatherandgas.Thecamerahasbeenremovedandthereareasyetnoplanstodeployanewcameratothesite.
![Page 59: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 59
TheHarbortronicstime-lapsecamerakitinstalledatHarrisLookouthascontinuedtoacquireimages.However,twomajorissueshaveaffectedthesetup.Firstly,inAugust2016,itwasnoticedthatsomedaytimeimageswereoverexposed,i.e.,toobright.TheproblemwastracedtothemeteringsysteminsidetheCanonDSLR.Itwasalsofoundthatthecamerahadclockedupmorethan220,000shutteractuations.Thecamerawasswappedforaspare,whichalsoappearstosufferfromthesamemeteringissues.BothCanonDSLRsaremorethan6yearsoldandhavefarsurpassedtheofficialratingofjust100,000shutteractuations.Asaresult,replacementcamerasarebeingsourced.
Asecondissuedevelopedshortlyafterthemeteringissue.InearlySeptember,thedigisnapcontrollerusedtotriggerthecamerabegantriggeringthecameraatrandomintervalsofupto150minutes,insteadoftheprogrammedevery15minutes.Similarissueshaveoccurredinthepast,andwereresolvedbysimplyrebootingthedigisnapcontroller.However,thishadlittleeffectonthetimingissue,whichappearstobecausedacommunicationserrorbetweenthelensandthecamerabody.Itisanticipatedthatthenewcameraandlenswillresolvethisissue.
ContinuousvideorecordingfromtheStardotnetworkIPcameraatMVOhasbeentestedusingsoftwarefromthecameramanufacturer.Thesetup,whichrecordsduringdaylighthoursonly,providesinvaluablevideocoverageintheeventofrenewedactivity.Dataiskeptforaperiodof21daysbeforebeingautomaticallydeleted.ThisgivesMVOstaffampletimetosavesuitablevideoclipsofactivity.
4.7ThermalCamerasMVOcontinuestooperatetwothermalcameras:afixedcameraatMVOandahandheldFLIRT650scwhichisusedduringobservationflights.Therehavebeennoissueswitheitherinstrumentduringthisreportingperiod.
4.8RemoteSensingDataAcquisitionofTerraSAR-XradarimageryceasedattheendofJuly2015whenthetwo-yearextensiontotheoriginalprojectended.DuetothelackofsurfaceactivityatSHV,therewillbenomoreacquisitionofthedataasithasprovedtobeoflimiteduseduringthecurrentperiodofquiescence.
4.9InfrasonicMonitoringTherehavebeennochangestotheMVOinfrasonicnetworkduringthereportingperiod.
TheinfrasoundarrayaroundMVOoperatedbytheUniversityofFlorencehasbeeninoperativesinceitwasdamagedbyalightningstrikeon17September2011.MVOisstillwaitingforavisitbystafffromtheUniversityofFlorencetorepairand/orreplacetheinstruments.
MVOstilloperatesandmaintainsitsownnetworkoffourinfrasoundsensorsatthefollowingseismicstations:MBFL(Flemmings),MBGB(GaribaldiHill),MBGH(St.George’sHill)andMBLG(LongGround).
![Page 60: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 60
4.10WEBOBSTheWEBOBSsystemcontinuestofunctionwellasthemainportaltoMVOmonitoringdata.ThereareoccasionalissueswithWEBOBS,oftenassociatedwithnetworkconnectivity.MVOnowmaintainsthisinstallationofWEBOBSwithoutsupportfromIPGP.
![Page 61: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 61
5MVOOperations
5.1StaffingKristofferHellbeganworkasSoftwareEngineerinAugust2016.OneofhismaintasksduringhisfirstmonthsatMVOisthedevelopmentofanewMVOwebsite.
5.2EducationandOutreachEducationandOutreachCoordinatorNatalieEdgecombehadathree-monthworksecondmenttotheIncorporatedResearchInstituteforSeismology(IRIS)inWashingtonDC.ItprovidedanopportunitytoobservemanagementoftheIRISUndergraduateInternshipProgramandalsoonlinecoursedevelopment.TheexperienceandcontactsgainedatIRISwillhelpfacilitatethedevelopmentofsimilarprogramsandcoursesatMVO.ThenextstepinthisprocesswillbecollaboratingwiththeprincipalandstaffatMontserratSecondarySchoolandMontserratCommunityCollegetocreateMVObasedprogrammesformathsandscienceeducation.SRCisexpectedtoprovidevaluablesupportinestablishingtheseeducationalprograms.
Workisalmostcompleteonanillustratedchildren'sstorybookfeaturingwinningstoriesfromthe2013MVOCreativeWritingCompetition.Thelaunchisanticipatedtobebeforetheendof2016.
WhiletheMVOCreativeWritingCompetitionwillnotbeheldthisyearduetoNatalie'sworkintheUS,MVOwillpartnerwiththeMinistryofEducationintheplanningandexecutionofMathandScienceWeek,scheduledforNovember28-December2.MathandScienceWeekisoneofMVO’smostvisibleeducationandoutreachevents.
5.3HelicopterHelicoptersupportcontinuestobeprovidedonceperweekbyCaribbeanHelicopters,Antigua.ThecurrentcontractendsinApril2017and,attherequestoftheGovernmentofMontserrat,MVOwillbecallingforbidsforanewmulti-yearcontract.Thecontractingprocessiscurrentlyunderway.
5.4Volunteers/PhDstudents/VisitorsOswenCartyandMarissaAllen,GeologystudentsatKingstonUniversity,UK,andtheUniversityoftheWestIndiesrespectively,carriedouttheirfinal-yearprojectworkonMontserratduringthesummer,withassistancefromDrA.Stinton.
ProfessorDaleWebber,Pro-ViceChancellorforGraduateStudiesandResearchattheUniversityoftheWestIndiesvisitedMVOinSeptember2016.HeisthemostseniorUWIstaffmembertovisitMVO.ProfessorWebberwasveryimpressedbyworkofthestaffatMVOandwillbelookingatwaystobringmoreUWIactivitiestoMontserratandtoinvolveMVOstaffmoreinUWI.
ProfessorJurgenNeuberg(Leeds,UK)andJ.Saltzer(GFZ,Germany),visitedMVOfrom16-20MaytodiscusspotentialcollaborationsonInSARandphotogrammetry.
![Page 62: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 62
5.5InternshipsTheMVOinternshipprogrammehasbeensuspendedtemporarily.Thiswasduetotheneedtoprovidepositionsforwork-experiencestudentsfromMontserratSecondarySchoolandforstudentsontheirsummerbreakfromscholarshipstostudyGeologyatuniversity.
Theprogrammewillre-startinOctober,butMVOmayhavetolimitthenumbers.
5.6CollaborationandExternalProjectsMVOcontinuestoworkwithexternalresearchersonawidevarietyofprojects.Atthelastcount,therewereover40suchprojectseitherfundedorwithfundingappliedfor.Someofthesearecollaborationsandsomesimplyinvolvetheprovisionofdataunderadatalicence.
Highlightsfromthecurrentlistofcollaborationsaregivenbelow.
On-goingcollaborationsforK.Pascal:
• WithProfessorJ.NeubergandDrA.Collinson(UniversityofLeeds):modellingofalternativesourceofdeformation(tectonic,secondboiling)whichcouldcontributetotheMontserratdeformationfield
• WithDrK.Palamartchouk(UniversityofNewcastle):combinedprocessingofSpidersingle-frequencydataandMVOdualfrequencydata
• WithDrH.Odbert(UniversityofBristol):modellingofthedeformationinducedbyloading/unloadingoftheedifice.
• WithDrS.Hautmann(UniversityofZurich):modellingofgroundwaterflowtriggeredbypressurizedmagmaticsources,usingdeformationandgravitydata.
NewcollaborationsforK.Pascal:
• WithDrGrahamRyan(UniversityoftheWestIndies):IntegrationofInSAR(ALOS,ALOS2)dataandoftheGPSdataonMontserrat.
• WithProf.GuyNason(UniversityofBristol),DrSouravNason(UniversityofBristol),DrHenryOdbert,DrPatrickSmith(MVO):investigatingpatternsofnon-stationarityinvolcanologicaltimeseries
DrAdamStintonisinvolvedwithtwopendingprojects(bothawaitingfundingconfirmation):
• AnalysisofcorematerialfromGeothermalWellMON#3,withDrSteveSparks(Bristol,UK)andDrGrahamRyan(SRC/UWI,Trinidad);
• ModellinglaharhazardandlandscapedisturbancefollowingavolcaniceruptionontheislandofMontserrat–proposedPhDprojectwithDrGeorginaBennett(Supervisor,UEA,UK),DrJennyBarclay(Co-supervisor,UEA)andDrAdamStinton(Co-Supervisor).
Projectsunassignedtoanystaffmember:
• STREVA• VUELCO
![Page 63: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 63
• DocumentingtheculturalmemoryoftheeruptionsonMontserratandStVincent(withUniversitiesofEastAngliaandOxford).
• CoringandanalysisofgeothermalwellMON#3(GrahamRyan,SteveSparks).• ProvisionofdatatoWOVOaspartofWOVOdat.
5.7MVOArchiveWorkontheMVOArchivehasslowedrecently.Itshouldpickupatthestartof2017withnewresourcesandthesupportoftheMVOSoftwareEngineer.Thenextstageoftheprojectistodesignaportalthatcanbeusedbyresearchersandthegeneralpublic.
5.8MVOWebsiteMVOcontinuestomaintainaminimalwebsitefollowingaservercrashmorethantwoyearsagothatresultedinlossofboththeprimarywebsiteandbackupdata.WiththeappointmentofanewSoftwareEngineer,developmentofanewwebsitehasbegun.ThedesignisexpectedtobecompletedinNovember2016andthewebsiteshouldbepopulatedforreleaseenoughbytheendoftheyear.Intheinterim,MVOmakesextensiveuseofFacebookandthelocalradiostationZJBtopubliciseeventsanddistributeinformationaboutthevolcano.
![Page 64: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 64
ReferencesChristopher,T.,Edmonds,M.,Taisne,B.,Odbert,H.,Costa,A.,Hards,V.,Wadge,G.,2014.PeriodicsulphurdioxidedegassingfromtheSoufriereHillsVolcanorelatedtodeepmagmasupply.Geol.Soc.London,Spec.Publ.410,123–141.doi:10.1144/SP410.11
Neuberg,J.W.,Aspinall,W.P.,Barclay,J.,Calder,E.,Rivalta,E.,Sparks,S.,andStewart,R.,2015.20thReportoftheScientificAdvisoryCommitteeonMontserratVolcanicActivity,PartII:FullReport,10December2015,52pp.
Reasenberg,P.andOppenheimer,D.,1985.Fpfit,fpplot,andfppage:Fortrancomputerprogramsforcalculatinganddisplayingearthquakefaultplanesolutions.U.S.Geol.Surv.Open-FileReport85-739,109p.
Stinton,A.J.,Cole,P.D.,Stewart,R.C.,Odbert,H.M.,Smith,P.,2014.The11February2010partialdomecollapseatSoufriereHillsVolcano,Montserrat,in:Wadge,G.,Robertson,R.E.A.,Voight,B.(Eds.),TheEruptionofSoufriereHillsVolcano,Montserrat,from2000to2010.GeologicalSociety,London,Memoirs,39,pp.133–152.doi:10.1144/M39.7
![Page 65: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 65
AppendixA:25June2016RFeventP.Smith,A.Stinton,T.Christopher,K.Pascal
A1IntroductionOn27June2016,MVOreceivedreportsofrecentashfallintheUpperAmershamareafromGregScott,apilotwithCaribbeanHelicopters.Priortothis,anddespitetheabsenceofthermalimageryandvisualobservationduetocloudyconditions,MVOhadnotobservedorrecordedanyunusualactivitycapableofgeneratingashfall.
Followingthereportsofpossibleashfall,ashwasobservedonthegroundintheUpperAmershamareaduringafieldvisiton29June.Asearchoftheseismiceventsdatabsaealsoidentifiedalargerockfalleventon25June2016.
A2SeismicsAsearchoftheseismiccatalogueidentifiedalargetriggeredrockfallsignalrecordedataround01:59UTCon25Juneasalikelysourceoftheobservedash.ThiseventwasrecordedacrosstheMVOseismicnetwork,andthesignalwaveformsareshowninFigureA1.TherewasalsoacoincidentinfrasoundsignalrecordedbythepressuresensoratMBFL(Flemmings).
A2.1InfrasoundTherecordatstationMBFLshowsaninfrasonicsignalfollowingtheseismicsignal,withthepressuresignalonsetbeginningaround15secondsaftertheseismicP-wavearrival.
Usingthesearrivaltimes,anapproximatedistance,d,ofthesourcefromstationMBFLwascalculatedusingthefollowingformula:
𝑑 = 𝑡! − 𝑡! 𝑣!!! − 𝑣!!!!!
(2)
Where𝑡! istheinfrasoundarrivaltime,𝑡!theP-wavearrivaltime,vitheacousticvelocityandvptheP-wavevelocity.
Usingthepickedarrivaltimes(showninFigureA2)andvelocitiesvi=348m/sandvp=2.5km/s,resultedinanapproximatedistancebetweenthesourceandstationMBFLof5.9km.Unfortunately,duetostationoutages,noadditionalinfrasounddatafromotherstationswereavailabletocorroboratethesignalseenatMBFL,sonoisecannotbecompletelyruledout.However,thecoincidenttimingandthetimedelaybetweentheseismicandinfrasoundarrivalsstronglysuggestotherwise.
A2.2LowfrequencyonsetInadditiontotheinfrasonicsignal,spectralanalysisshowsthattheseismicwaveformsalsocontainsignificantlow-frequencyenergy(inthe0.1-1Hzrange)inthesignalonset(FigureA3),similartothat
![Page 66: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 66
seeninprevioussmallexplosionsatSHV(FigureA4).TheexamplesshownareforminorexplosiveeventsthatprecededtheonsetofextrusioninPhases3and4respectively(Coleetal.,2014).
FigureA1: Seismic(andinfrasonic)waveformsfortherockfalleventon25June2016.Therawverticalcomponentvelocityseismogramsareshownfromeachstation,alongwithaccompanyingamplitudespectra.Timeaxisisinsecondsafter01:59:27UTCandforthespectrathefrequencyaxisisfrom0to10Hz.NotethatthesignalamplitudeclippedonthetwoSPIDERs(MSS1andMSUH)
![Page 67: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 67
FigureA2: Seismicandinfrasonicwaveformsfortherockfalleventon25June2016recordedatstationMBFL.Thetoppanelshowstheseismicsignal,withtheP-waveonsetmarked.Thelowerplotsshowtherawandfilteredinfrasoundsignalsassociatedwiththeseismicsignal.Themarkedarrivaltimesandappropriateseismicandacousticvelocitieswereusedtoderiveanapproximatedistancetothesourceof5.9km
![Page 68: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 68
FigureA3: SeismicsignalanditsassociatedS-transformfortherockfalleventon25June2016,recordedatstationMBGH.Thetopplotshowstheverticalcomponentseismogram,andthelowerplottheassociatedS-transform–highlightingthelowfrequencysignalonsetwithenergyinthe0.1–1Hzrange.Notethelogfrequencyscaleinthetime-frequencytransform.
FigureA4: SeismicsignalsandassociatedspectrogramsforfourdifferentsmallexplosiveeventsatSHV,recordedatstationMBGH.TheexamplesshownarefromprecursoryexplosiveactivitytoPhases3and4(seeColeetal.,2014).Thetopplotsineachpanelshowtheverticalcomponentseismogram,andthelowerplotstheassociatedspectrograms,withlowfrequencysignalonsetswithenergyinthe0.1–1Hzrange.
![Page 69: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 69
FigureA5: Onehourofseismicandstraindatafortherockfall/explosiveeventon25June.ThetopplotshowstheverticalcomponentseismogramfromstationMBGH.Thelowertwoplotsshowtheavailable50Hzand1Hzstraindatarecordedat2CALIPSOstations:AIRS(AirStudios)andGERD(Gerald’s).Straindataamplitudeshavebeencorrectedtounitsofnanostrain.Nofilteringwasapplied,butalineartrendwasremovedfromthe24hrsofstraindatatoaccountfordrift,andthemeansubtractedfromthedatashownintheplots.Nosignificantstraintransientassociatedwiththeseismicsignalisseeninthestraindata.
![Page 70: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 70
A3FieldobservationsFollowingthereportsofashfallintheUpperAmershamarea,MVOstaffcarriedoutafieldinvestigationon27June.Onlanding,ashwasobservedblowingaroundandalsoontheleavesofsomeplants.Someofitwascakeduntotheplantssuggestingitmayhaverainedeitherduringoraftertheashwasdeposited.AsmallsampleoftheashwascollectedandbroughttoMVOforanalysis.
Observationsoftheashunderabinocularmicroscopeshowedthatitisveryfinegrainedandpalecoloured.Theashappearedtocontainahighproportionofalteredmaterial,aswellassomecrystalfragments(FigureA6).AsmallsubsamplewassenttoDrJenniBarclay,UEA,forfurtheranalysis,whichconfirmedthelackofjuvenilematerialintheash(J.Barclay,pers.comms.,2016).
FigureA6: PhotographoftheashfallsamplecollectedfromtheUpperAmershamareafollowingtherockfalleventon25June2016.Theashappearstocontainahighproportionofalteredmaterialandnosignofanyjuvenilefragments.
A4SummaryOn25June2016,at01:58UTC,alargerockfalloccurredonthelavadomeatSHV.Thepresenceofaninfrasonicsignal,alongwiththelow-frequencyonsettotheseismicsignal,stronglysuggestsatleastsome(small)explosivecomponenttotheeventandthatthiseventwasthereforetheprobablesource
![Page 71: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 71
oftheashfalldepositsobservedintheUpperAmershamarea.Aviewshedanalysis,combinedwiththe5.9kmdistancederivedfromtheseismicsignaltimingssuggeststhatthesourceoftheinfrasoundsignal,andthereforetheashandrockfall,islocatedsomewhereonthesummitorupperwesternflankofthelavadome(FigureA7).Anumberofhightemperaturefumaroles(temps>400°C)arelocatedatboththeeastern(2006-7dome)andwesternendsofthelavadomesummit,aswellasinsidethesummitcraterandtheupperpartoftherearheadwallofthe2010collapsescar.AllofthesefumaroleshavebeenpresentsincethestartofPause5andaresurroundedbyalteredmaterial.Thelackofvisualobservationsdirectlyaftertheeventhaspreventedtheidentificationofanexactlocationfortherockfall.
FigureA7: Mapshowingacircleof5.9kmradiuscentredonstationMBFLatFlemmings,indicatingthatthis(approximate)distanceisconsistentwiththesourceofthesignalbeingfromsomewhereclosetothedome.Theredshadingshowsthelandscapethathasanuninterruptedlineofsightfromtheinfrasoundstation,indicatingthatthesourceofthesignalmayhavecomefromsomewhereonthesummitorupperreachesofthewestflankofthelavadome.
AnalysisoftheavailablestraindatafromtheCALIPSOboreholesshowsthatnosignificantshort-termstrainsignalwasobservedcoincidentwiththisseismicity(FigureA5),suggestingthatanyexplosivecomponenttothesignalwasprobablysmallinmagnitude.
![Page 72: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 72
AppendixB:TrendsinVTearthquakedepthssincePhase5P.Smith(updatedOctober2016)
B1IntroductionThisinvestigationwaspromptedbytheobservationthatVThypocentresatSHVappeartoshowatrendofincreasingdepthoverthelastfewyears.ThisobservationwasreportedinthepreviousMVOactivityreport,sothissectionservesasanupdatetothepreviousanalysisandtopromotefurtherdiscussionnowthatanadditionalfewmonthsofdataareavailable.
DepthsoflocalcrustalearthquakessuchasVTs,withfewstationspicksandapoorlyknownvelocitymodel,arenotoriouslybadlyconstrained;butidentifyingademonstrablyrobusttrendovertimemaywellprovidesomeusefulandimportantinformationaboutlongtermchangesinthestressconditionsandhencetheshallowvolcanicsystem.
B2DataanalysisFigureB1showsaplotofthedepthsofVTsrecordedsincePhase5,withtherighthandpanelzoomingintotheperiodsinceMarch2012.Despitesomescatterinthedata,thereappearstobeageneraltrendofshallowingVTdepthsfromFebruary2010untilMarch2012,followedbyincreasingVTdepthswithtimesinceMarch2012(verticaldashedblackline),gettingdeeperbyaround1kmoverthisperiod.ThistrendisobservedmoreclearlyinthemeanandmedianfilteredmovingaverageplotsinFigureB1,whichshowthedepthsfilteredwithasliding50-daytimewindow.
Inordertoassesshowrobustthistrendis,andwhetheritisanartefactofeitherthelocationprocessornetworkbias,FigureAX.1alsoshowstheerrorinthedepth(asgivenbytheoutputoftheHYPOCENTERprogram)andthenumberofstationpicks(P-waves)usedinobtainingthelocation.
Asexpected,asthenumberofstationpicksincreasestheerrorinthedepthsisreduced,particularlyfollowingtheintroductionoftheSPIDERStotheMVOseismicnetworkinJune2014,shownbythereddashedline.Animportantpointtonotehoweveristhatitisnotnecessarilyjustthenumberofstationsthatisrelevant,assomestations–suchasforexamplemoreproximalstationswithbettersignal-to-noiseratioforsmallerevents–willhaveagreaterimpactonthehypocenteruncertaintythanothers.However,thisissomethingthatisdifficulttoassessherewithoutamuchmoredetailedandindepthstudy,althoughthisispotentiallyanimportanteffectandshouldbeconsideredagoalforfutureworktoaddress.
![Page 73: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 73
FigureB1 PlotofVThypocentraldepthsvstime.Lefthandpanelshowspost-Phase5,right-handpanelshowspost-March2012.BlackdashedverticallinerepresentsthelargemagnitudeVTstringon23March2012,reddashedverticallinemarkstheintroductionoftheSpiderstotheMVOseismicnetwork.Topplotshowsthehypocenterdepths,followedby:theerrorinthedepth,thenumberofstation(P-wave)picksusedforthelocation,a50-daymovingaveragefilterofthedepths,minimumandmaximumdepthsinasliding50-daywindowandfinallythebottomplotshowsthe50-daystandarddeviationofthedepths.
FigureB2showsthefrequencydistributionsoftheVThypocenterdepthsandtheirassociatederrors,withthedepthsapproximatelynormallydistributedaroundameandepthofjustover1km.Thedeptherrorsaretypically1-2km,butcanbemuchhigherinafewcases.
Inordertoeliminateeventswithlargeuncertaintieswhenassessingthedepthtrends,earthquakehypocenterswitherrorsgreaterthanacut-offdeptherrorof±4.5kmwerediscarded.ThisthresholdwaschosenfromthedeptherrordistributiontoremoveoutliersandismarkedbythedashedredlineontheplotsinFigureB2.Ascanbeseeninthelower-rightpanelofFigureB2,theseweremostlyeventswith8picksorfewer.Thedatasetwiththeseearthquakeswithlargeuncertaintiesremovedisre-plottedinFigureB4,andshowsthatthetrendremainsclearwhilstsomeofthescatterhasbeenreduced–particularlybyremovingsomeoftheshallowestevents.
![Page 74: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 74
FigureB2: FrequencydistributionsofhypocenterdepthsandtheirassociatederrorsforVTearthquakesrecordedsinceMarch2012.Thelowerpanelsshowthedepthsandtheirerrorsasafunctionofthenumberofstationpicks(P-waves)usedinthelocations.Thereddashedline(s)inthetworight-handplotsmarkthechosencut-offof4.5kmforthemaximumdeptherrorinfurtheranalysis.
Foreachnumberofpossiblestationpicks(from4to14)themeanandmedianoftheearthquakedepthsandtheirassociateddepthswerecalculated,withtheresultsshowninFigureB3.Theerrorsdecreaseapproximatelyexponentiallyasthenumberofpicksincreases;whilstthedepthsappeartoincreasealmostlinearly(theendmembersof4and14probablycontaintoofeweventsforreliableestimates).However,asboththenumberofpicksandthedepthsaretime-dependent(wearelookingattemporaltrends)itisdifficulttoseparatetheseeffectsandconfidentlyattributethechangeindepthtoacausalresultofthenumberofstationpicksused.
Thedepthofthefirstinterfaceinthe1-Dseismicvelocitymodelusedbythelocationprogramisalsoplotted,markedbytheblackdashedlineatapproximately2.5kmdepth,togaugewhetherthedepthsaresimplyconvergingtowardsthedepthofthisinterface–althoughwithoutfurtherdataitisdifficulttoconcludeonewayortheother.
![Page 75: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 75
FigureB3: Hypocentraldepthsandassociatederrors,asafunctionofthenumberofstationpicksusedinthelocation.Foreachnumberofpicks,themean(left)andmedian(right)ofthedepthandassociatederrorfortheearthquakes(asshowninlowerpanelofFigureB1–includingallVTs)areplotted.Thedashedhorizontallineindicatesthedepthofthefirstinterfaceinthe1-Dvelocitymodelusedbythelocationprogram.
FigureB4: PlotofVThypocentraldepthsvstime.PanelsareasinFigureB1,exceptwithearthquakeswithlargeuncertainties(deptherror>4.5km)removedfromthedataset.
![Page 76: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 76
AfurthercheckforbiasinthedatasetiswhethertheresultsareaffectedbytheoccurrenceoftheVTstringsduringthistimeperiod.Thesecanbeseenasshort-termincreasesindepthvariability–eitherduetophysicaleffectsorincreasedscatteranderrorduetothehigheventratesreducingthenumberandqualityofP-wavepicksandhencelocationquality.
FigureB5showsthesamedatasetasinFigureB4(outliersremoved),plusadditionallywithearthquakesoccurringaspartofVTstringsremoved–leaving‘normal’or‘background’VTs.Thisshowsthatthetrendremainslargelyunchanged,perhapsevenshowingagreaterincreaseindepthsinthelastyearorso.
OneofthesuggestionsinthepreviousreportwastoincludealongertimeseriesincludingVTseismicityoccurringpriortoPhase5,andthisisshowninFigureB6.Thisshowsthatdeptherrorsandscatterinthedatasetaremuchlargerpriortoaround2010,likelytobeduetothereducedstationcoverage.Henceitthismakesconfidentassessmentdifficult,althoughthereiscertainlynoclearortrendsuchasseensince2012,andthedepthscouldbearguedtohaveremainedrelativelystableovertime.
FigureB5: PlotofVThypocentraldepthsvstime.PanelsareasinFigureB1,exceptwith(1)earthquakesoccurringaspartofVTstrings,and(2)eventswithlargeuncertainties(deptherror>4.5km),removedfromthedataset.
![Page 77: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 77
FigureB6: PlotofVThypocentraldepthsvstime.PanelsareasinFigureB1,exceptthatthetimescalehasbeenextendedtoincludeallVTeventsrecordedatSHVsinceDecember2004(left)andJuly2008(right).Theblackdashedlineontheleft-handplotrepresentsthestartoftimeperiodshownintheright-handplot.
B3DiscussionRecentVTseismicityatSHVappearstoshowatrendofdeepeninghypocenters,withtheaveragedepthsincreasingbyaround1000m,from1to2km,inthe4.5yearsorsosinceMarch2012.ThissuggeststhelargemagnitudeVTstringandassociatedeventsinMarch2012mayhavehadasignificantimpactonthesystem.TheadditionaldatafromrecentVThypocentersacquiredsincethepreviousMVOreporthascontinuedtofollowthesametrendofincreasingdepths.
Overall,theresultsoftheanalysisandinvestigationintopossibleeffectsofnetworkbiasareinconclusive.Despitetheobviouscorrelationbetweenincreasingstationpicksandincreasingdepths(withdecreasederrors),itcanbearguedthatthetrendisphysicallyrealforthefollowingreasons:
• Thetrendremainspresentonceoutliersandeventswithlargeuncertaintiesareremoved
• ThepatternisnotafunctionofbeingbiasedbytheVTstrings(withhighereventratesandhigherlocationuncertainties)
• BetweenFebruary2010andMarch2012thereisapatternofshallowingdepthsthatoccurswhilethenumberofstationpicksremainsroughlyconstant(arguesagainstbias)
![Page 78: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 78
• Thetrendofincreasingdepthhascontinuedduringlast12-18month,despitethenumberofstationpicksavailablereducingduetosomeextendedstationoutages
Severalpossibleinterpretationsofthistrendare:coolingoftheedificeandupperconduitsystem;anincreased/moreestablishedhydrothermalsystemanddegassingpathways,aswellothertectonicornon-volcaniceffects.Howeverasyettheseexplanationsarefairlyspeculative,andthissuggestsfurtherinvestigationintopossiblecausesiswarranted.
AninterestingobservationisthatthereappearstobenoobviouschangefollowingtheVTstringon8March2014,despitethisbeingalmostaslargeintermsofenergyreleaseandmagnitudeasthatinMarch2012.
ItmayalsobeinstructivetolookatincludingthenumberofS-wavepicksratherthanjustP-waves,asthesearealsolikelytohaveasignificantimpactondepthresolution.Thehorizontalhypocentralcoordinatescouldalsobeinvestigatedforanycorrespondingspatialpatterns.
ThisanalysishighlightsthatthepatternanddistributionofVTseismicityhypocentersshouldalsocontinuetobemonitoredinthefuture,toseeifthetrendcontinues,asanychangesmaybeanindicatorofafurtherchangeinthevolcanicsystemandhencepossiblefuturebehaviour.
References
Reasenberg,P.andOppenheimer,D.,1985.Fpfit,fpplot,andfppage:Fortrancomputerprogramsforcalculatinganddisplayingearthquakefaultplanesolutions.Technicalreport,U.S.Geol.Survey.
![Page 79: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 79
AppendixC:AdditionalGPSData
FigureC1: TangentialdisplacementsrecordedatcampaignsitesduringPause5(February2010-September2016).Thereportingperiodisboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.HighenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline,andthestrongestevents(27October2010,9July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted(reddashedline).Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.SeeFigure19: Radial(top)andVertical(bottom)displacementsrecordedatcampaignsitesduringPause5(February2010-September2016).Thereportingperiodisboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.HighenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline,andthestrongestevents(27October2010,9July2011,22March2012,8March2014)havebeenhighlighted(reddashedline).Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.SeeAppendixC:AdditionalGPSDatafortangentialdisplacements.forradialandverticalcomponents.
![Page 80: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 80
FigureC2: ComparisonofthetangentialdisplacementsmeasuredatnineMVOcontinuousGPSstationsduringPause3,Pause4bandPause5(solidlines)andsubsequentextrusionphases(dashedlines).A60-daylow-passfilterwasappliedtothedata.SeealsoFigure19forradialandverticaldisplacements.
![Page 81: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 81
FigureC3: Radialextensionrelativetothevolcanicventsincethe1stJun.2015.Thereportingperiod(May-September2016)isboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HigherenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline.Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 82: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 82
FigureC4: Tangentialdisplacementsrelativetothevolcanicventsincethe1June2015.Thereportingperiod(May-September2016)isboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HigherenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline.Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.
![Page 83: MVO Scientific Report for Volcanic Activity between 1 May and 30](https://reader031.vdocuments.site/reader031/viewer/2022030323/58a1a11b1a28abb24d8c3d88/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
MVOOFR16-03:MVOScientificReportforSAC21 83
FigureC5: Verticaldisplacementsobservedsincethe1stofJun.2015.Thereportingperiod(May-September2016)isboundedbythetwobluelines.Thestation-volcanodistanceincreasesfrombottomtotopoffigure.Abackgroundplatevelocityof[E1.06,N1.40]cm/yrwasremovedfromthedata.Displacementsduetoantennachangeshavebeencorrected.HigherenergyVTstringsareindicatedwithagreyline.Thedistanceseparatingthegridlinescorrespondstoadisplacementof1cm.