mummy's silence broken at last

1
Carol Marzuola Astrophysicists awaiting the Pierre Auger Observatory’s high-energy cosmic-ray data are keeping a nervous eye on the political and economic crisis in Argentina, where the Southern Hemisphere arm of the observa- tory is due to be completed by 2005. Two hundred and fifty researchers from 19 countries are involved in the US$50-million project to build the world’s largest cosmic- ray observatory. It will study cosmic radiation — the flow of charged particles from space that streams through the Earth’s atmosphere — and, in particular, the rare and mysterious particles of very high energies. The southern part of the observatory, in Argentina’s Mendoza province, is being built first. The northern arm, to be located in the United States, will come later. Argentina had pledged $15 million to the project, but since December 2001, when the Argentinian peso was devalued, the country has plunged deeper into economic and political crisis (see Nature 415, 104; 2002) and is unlikely to fulfil all of its obligations. High-energy cosmic rays intrigue physi- cists because they cannot identify astro- physical objects or events, such as colliding galaxies, that are sufficiently violent to explain the rays’ origins. But high-energy particles of 10 20 electron volts or more hit the Earth’s atmosphere only rarely — about once per km 2 per century. The Auger observatory will use two sets of detectors to find these cosmic rays. At each site, 1,600 surface detectors — large above- ground water tanks equipped with photo- multipliers — will identify secondary cosmic -ray showers produced in the atmosphere by incoming rays. Additionally, 24 special telescopes will detect fluorescence produced by the particles as they pass through the atmosphere. A prototype array of 30 detectors and two telescopes was completed last year in Argentina and has already produced useful data, says James Cronin of the University of Chicago, a joint leader of the Auger project. Alberto Etchegoyen, an official at Argen- tina’s atomic-energy commission and the project’s southern spokesman, says that the transitional Argentinian government has no clear long-term plans for science or tech- nology, and admits that the project may have to find some of the promised funding from other sources. Project supporters in Argenti- na and Brazil, for example, are jointly seeking a $3-million grant from an international development bank fund for Brazil to enable them to participate. Optimists also point out that the devalua- tion of the peso will make the dollars and euros of the project’s other contributing nations go further in Argentina. Paul Mantsch, a project manager for Auger at the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory in Batavia, Illinois, says: “We’re really opti- mistic that when the time comes to make up what’s missing, we can do that.” Nonetheless, Auger’s participants contin- ue to worry. At the April meeting of the American Physical Society in Albuquerque, news NATURE | VOL 417 | 13 JUNE 2002 | www.nature.com/nature 679 New Mexico, physicist Michael Turner of the University of Chicago urged US funding agencies to “ensure timely completion and operation” of the observatory in case there was a problem. “The whole future of this field hinges upon the result of the southern Auger,” he said. www.auger.org Argentine crisis rattles cosmic-ray hunters Cosmic detection: a surface detector (left) and telescope camera (above) in place in Mendoza. Rex Dalton, Tucson The lock on a 2,000-year-old mummy’s scientific secrets has been opened by a South African archaeologist — after a three-year wrangle with local tribes and landowners over its custody. Johan Binneman, archaeology curator at the Albany Museum in Grahamstown, found the mummy in 1999, during an approved expedition at a hunter-gatherer shelter site in the Kouga Mountains in South Africa’s Eastern Cape province. But government officials refused to let Binneman, whose work was publicly funded, present scientific data on the Kouga mummy until last month, when he attended the biennial conference of the Society of Africanist Archaeologists at Tucson, Arizona. Last September, Maryna Steyn, a physical anthropologist at the University of Pretoria who worked with Binneman, was unable to present a manuscript on the specimen at the fourth World Congress on Mummy Studies in Greenland, pending approval by South African government officials. The mummy is 145 cm tall and is thought to be a male of 50–55 years of age, possibly a shaman or a tribal chief. It was found in a near-fetal position — with its feet bound — and wrapped in leaves of a poisonous plant (Boophane disticha), a well-known coagulant. Researchers say that this discovery is the first of its age in southern Africa. As well as problems with landowners, the find set off a tussle between local tribes. Two, the Inqua and the Gonaqua, laid claim to the mummy as a former leader. But provincial government officials — many of them from a third tribe, the Nguni — would not accept their claims. “The mummy symbolizes our culture for centuries,” says Jean Burgess, chief of the Gonaqua, claiming that provincial officials had dragged their feet in allowing its full examination. The officials could not be reached for comment. Binneman says the disputes are deterring archaeologists from exploring the Kouga Mountains site further. Mummy’s silence broken at last PIERRE AUGER OBSERVATORY ALBANY MUSEUM Habeas corpus: disputed ownership has delayed scientific description of the Kouga mummy. © 2002 Nature Publishing Group

Upload: rex

Post on 21-Jul-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Mummy's silence broken at last

Carol MarzuolaAstrophysicists awaiting the Pierre AugerObservatory’s high-energy cosmic-ray dataare keeping a nervous eye on the politicaland economic crisis in Argentina, where theSouthern Hemisphere arm of the observa-tory is due to be completed by 2005.

Two hundred and fifty researchers from 19countries are involved in the US$50-millionproject to build the world’s largest cosmic-ray observatory. It will study cosmic radiation— the flow of charged particles from space thatstreams through the Earth’s atmosphere —and, in particular, the rare and mysterious particles of very high energies.

The southern part of the observatory, inArgentina’s Mendoza province, is being builtfirst. The northern arm, to be located in theUnited States, will come later. Argentina hadpledged $15 million to the project, but sinceDecember 2001, when the Argentinian pesowas devalued, the country has plunged deeper into economic and political crisis (see Nature 415, 104; 2002) and is unlikely tofulfil all of its obligations.

High-energy cosmic rays intrigue physi-cists because they cannot identify astro-physical objects or events, such as collidinggalaxies, that are sufficiently violent toexplain the rays’ origins. But high-energyparticles of 1020 electron volts or more hit theEarth’s atmosphere only rarely — aboutonce per km2 per century.

The Auger observatory will use two sets ofdetectors to find these cosmic rays. At eachsite, 1,600 surface detectors — large above-ground water tanks equipped with photo-multipliers — will identify secondary cosmic-ray showers produced in the atmosphere byincoming rays. Additionally, 24 special telescopes will detect fluorescence producedby the particles as they pass through theatmosphere.

A prototype array of 30 detectors and two telescopes was completed last year inArgentina and has already produced usefuldata, says James Cronin of the University ofChicago, a joint leader of the Auger project.

Alberto Etchegoyen, an official at Argen-tina’s atomic-energy commission and the project’s southern spokesman, says that thetransitional Argentinian government has noclear long-term plans for science or tech-nology, and admits that the project may haveto find some of the promised funding fromother sources. Project supporters in Argenti-na and Brazil, for example, are jointly seekinga $3-million grant from an internationaldevelopment bank fund for Brazil to enablethem to participate.

Optimists also point out that the devalua-tion of the peso will make the dollars andeuros of the project’s other contributingnations go further in Argentina. Paul

Mantsch, a project manager for Auger at theFermi National Accelerator Laboratory inBatavia, Illinois, says: “We’re really opti-mistic that when the time comes to make upwhat’s missing, we can do that.”

Nonetheless, Auger’s participants contin-ue to worry. At the April meeting of the American Physical Society in Albuquerque,

news

NATURE | VOL 417 | 13 JUNE 2002 | www.nature.com/nature 679

New Mexico, physicist Michael Turner of the University of Chicago urged US fundingagencies to “ensure timely completion andoperation” of the observatory in case therewas a problem. “The whole future of this field hinges upon the result of the southernAuger,” he said. ■

➧ www.auger.org

Argentine crisis rattles cosmic-ray hunters

Cosmic detection: a surface detector (left) andtelescope camera (above) in place in Mendoza.

Rex Dalton, Tucson The lock on a 2,000-year-old mummy’sscientific secrets has been opened by a SouthAfrican archaeologist — after a three-yearwrangle with local tribes and landownersover its custody.

Johan Binneman, archaeology curator atthe Albany Museum in Grahamstown, foundthe mummy in 1999, during an approvedexpedition at a hunter-gatherer shelter sitein the Kouga Mountains in South Africa’sEastern Cape province.

But government officials refused to letBinneman, whose work was publicly funded,present scientific data on the Kouga mummyuntil last month, when he attended thebiennial conference of the Society ofAfricanist Archaeologists at Tucson, Arizona.

Last September, Maryna Steyn, a physicalanthropologist at the University of Pretoriawho worked with Binneman, was unable topresent a manuscript on the specimen at thefourth World Congress on Mummy Studiesin Greenland, pending approval by SouthAfrican government officials.

The mummy is 145 cm tall and is thoughtto be a male of 50–55 years of age, possibly ashaman or a tribal chief. It was found in anear-fetal position — with its feet bound —and wrapped in leaves of a poisonous plant(Boophane disticha), a well-known coagulant.

Researchers say that this discovery is the firstof its age in southern Africa.

As well as problems with landowners, thefind set off a tussle between local tribes.Two, the Inqua and the Gonaqua, laid claimto the mummy as a former leader. Butprovincial government officials — many ofthem from a third tribe, the Nguni — wouldnot accept their claims.

“The mummy symbolizes our culture forcenturies,” says Jean Burgess, chief of theGonaqua, claiming that provincial officialshad dragged their feet in allowing its fullexamination. The officials could not bereached for comment.

Binneman says the disputes are deterringarchaeologists from exploring the KougaMountains site further. ■

Mummy’s silence broken at last

PIE

RR

E A

UG

ER

OB

SER

VA

TO

RY

AL

BA

NY

MU

SEU

MHabeas corpus: disputed ownership has delayedscientific description of the Kouga mummy.

© 2002 Nature Publishing Group