mother jones – smart, fearless journalism · 8/6/2018 · case 1:16-cr-00376-rmb document 91-2...

$: Mother Jones – Smart, fearless journalism · 8/6/2018 · Case 1:16-cr-00376-RMB Document 91-2 Filed 03/02/18 Page 18 of 24 o.. (")vS\1~1 b ii l\-ltll\S ~~\t~C th-J \$
Case 1:16-cr-00376-RMB Document 91-2 Filed 03/02/18 Page 1 of 24

./ ~r

-·- 't·~"

.i


I

i t·------~~~~~~~~~--~~~~~~~~~-i

l ~:--------~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-------

' I

~~~'"-----~ .J...,.II.fii.IL.."-...u..&.--u.~~~~~1,_jll..l.,'-Ld.....:>l.s :l.o.Lc1.1.¥o91o!.l.\ ~.Ww~..4~ ...... ~UAl C_pt:)~(e,~ ±· Tbt $tvJe..ol\· o.JI ±ce ~it.d _:e CACb a+1ec

I r I

....

---- .

' -·

Case 1:16-cr-00376-RMB Document 91-2 Filed 03/02/18 Page 3 of 24II


b

$."~ ·~· ~~~~~--L..::;:.....V...:.~L.f-1-lvi a. s T ex~ e c:\e J1 .!.;-, -~-.j\e tA · ' Jec.\ I, I be.~ Ss\ ~ !A 1.!


fwst be


be\ie.Ve

t .

Case 1:16-cr-00376-RMB Document 91-2 Filed 03/02/18 Page 9 of 24II

I .

I

\ .0

\ II


__ -=...uJ,...,..._--::.u.J...,.__~>11--I.....lJ--5J.L!_t. 1 9 Me) I , felt I; Ke, T k." J f pvO ·~ J bvft loJ Mvi'tfrk Cqo'f t t J qlj i hvf-

--....L.l,..L..,--'--'-'----"~----'-~----'T J I .t'n t ~ ~ ± qO~ V ( VI J <' C Ce.e& I,' S tl C

--~ ............... ~ .J......!........w.._~:.--..;:;..:;..:~~..::l.!.l.,_--=!:..+--J.~u,u...l..-W~v :t,...J:...J.· .u..~ M ~ br.dhroc M

· . +k c~u CJ h the. i~o .

II

ll ·II 'I

,


Jl


e .


\-~...,_+-.....lo.I0:..'-4.......;.:~~~- . £ ± ~ \ f n" \ o c · \w o ~ 1 D ,_, C:J "' Sy, I £ . \1 v \: . "!: e It b e C

1Q1o..S tp§l . ~·"'\ a~V\ +a ~Co s g_fiJ hJ ~u·m;J \t. . ·


II

~~~:.l..:.-...lo:O.::..:~~('Iip th\<:. -\-\ 1"\ i'c )1~~-1+---

~ 1 EtC + o,J lr~,s ~r.in\-, a. ~~ h vf',J Sor:\!.1' 1'.~ If\


-.-. \\ / i. • • \ · Cci.Jd(\J \tf)l\ '?))t\e.


. .,.. ... , 1 .I

I

Case 1:16-cr-00376-RMB Document 91-2 Filed 03/02/18 Page 17 of 24I I I I I I I I I

---.....:r>-~'"-~W.I.of-....... de.lleJ, M_.y 1 fo{to±'5 -\eJ± ll ·~ T :> Ssed With rJCu?>.5 . gO~ n a Ce AAd

IQ ±bere. T I

~ Cea±lj cbM,~d1 Wo S


o.. (") v S\1~1 b ii l\- ltll\S ~~\t~C th-J \<J~ ~ - ~ ~t_sc_J t~~ s_ k,~~~ ... _ -r st., r.kd _ ·~~ (.re _t\~j ~'s L \e0.rrt!.l '\b·l Jt :r s11\t1 L'\t'ld t'h e. _

Gl.~r\~_ hole. l: \t.c,~e.. i r~er e~l~ J i() t 'o;e re\lo~ •. ~ Q~d \,e,~n

(~s~c,(c~,_£'~ ~b~vt._\\._1 \e~\ tzeJj TSL:w: \-JLlulci f ix 1\\\ _-\h-e. frob\en$ lC'\ $oc. ie+~ ~r_the. \.]<'\\~ 1 in ~e f\~r(d; O..nd n.0t its S!3 ~:en .'\nd \ .ire ~t-~l,e. lrkuiJ ~ . "-v e. Jtrevent~d the. ~lfr. 1 \ \ ~e A.

____ ~-1. 1~/),~L(\e.J h.c1J tj,~- World ~Jov be 1f t~e >~t~M _nrJ ..k-0dS _ -~-o'i Gol W tf to (vie no~-\\ ft.l ( not th.:. S J S h>.M .-.f M~n •. The.. s~~t~. ~.f. ·- G,L ~rpf~~Y~.te s r·cd )J)d ~I'~SkVe.r~ot 1>_the.

_ _ \,r d J not 0.~ne. c( ~fl~th·,f\2} , e~se , \'~Cine . Wil \ \l~e to_ P L~~\5"e, --- - _h\n_l~J) J b e~ htt'l (\()<) JQ. ~~J I ~e~ w:>e i1 one. i 5 {let e.nshve~ to

Go~ 1 he _w ll e(\~ vP b~~s ~o51J 'kd ·tc ~o r~~ ~t'nln~ e.\ ~e. . ~1 hethe\ It \,: tc . _ .~l!~ In bd05; ·'~objcL) o( .hi:/ 1oC <>~o_ddfvc.+i V

_ __ Jes1reS. 1 1S .. L.S 1~ ~ r~ ~""M1.; J ~ l,nh ,~P·!)~ r,c d i d~ but _

B\lo_\,_ (:..,4)' :.J\:s i5 -~~<!. t'lt'S;,,t ·111 o} \\,e_ ~ro~he1 > C.I\\'.1 \C .

·\--l 'Jh1 _i ().c\v iC\~ N<1Ah /I ~ \.().hlr.t1 ~G._,~ ) ; J e.Su S 1 !AI\~ Mvh~M tvl•\d __ ( ffl·'\~ · ~ et\ ·e. J,$\J b\6 S\n35 b-t vY.-. (\ tht.n o..\l) .This cvr\enr ·.

· .s ~ ~te\J '-M \l~ i~ '\\~ rv\e o11 1\-.e. ~~c~lt. l"'(_ ·~c~\\\~~ j~ t1·~2\\G . '\(\~ -\\~t~c{")) i \e~ •10 1o t~- e. et'~iL\V ~nen± of

__ ~V~\~1bl n ~- but _GoJ1

Je ~tr n~ i ~ £ .. cl_~t~. ~ ~,rt irof'l_jhe

_:: r,\~ G.fH' .. --:-' ~' .. \ rvn C.qJ\t.:vr\en\ ~ \rJ\!'r:. \w~H\C'\ nl\\ur~, "n.d C-...0 k1Ve c; , ,G\tt~ (u(l .ill h~\[ ~~~~· -1 U f1T tV~ &o~ ~)c\Lt~ _

'1~\~~ \( \ 1!, v(iliJeD~t:.1 w'htr t _s .~(.l.r~ 1 J'I0m.U rA!)j n"rur-c. o.\\ _

Wo\~ l() 0.. w~li (\ !)_d ;~st~I'JO.ti t fi\~~ic0 . \..J\Tb 119 Cnoi(£Ahl\\(){$/

his \c~~~s f12c f<IL~.u J·l"uld th~t!. s,~\r.-\:·~ L\n ~ t1 ,ns c\\~L\~rs lun i ~ hr~,n~ \'"Q· N•ne J I Go~> ·1.,\JS 'i,r \""n ,;_b,v\: bt c;IJ'o~ 1u r~~ ~r c\\,\ll~.J 1 W!c~\J)~:. 1.\-..-< ~~~\~ 1"" \1-Qv'~ \~s ~ '.s \-r{n o(,lj , 'JuSt {), '') n: (\ \ l\\..1 ~r~ \\·,t · ijn~vel\t.

- . I


. Were. to 'o chc~()~0-d (\iKe 9(0JVit~ for e>(qMrle)) eve.\~th1ll3 ~~o\1.\~ bee Me. (\e ,: rr')Jc.~. lhrJ j i~ L~h~ fYla()-M ~~-e. lo.'.-1 ~an1ro..dlc\5 JJ~e\f StJ_ri)\J(.~.i CAnd D.~ l L [e~u\t; deStlo~\~J ~~.c.\tt'j• So ~M)~_

C~i\~(e Jar:t even Koot--1 wh~ _ t~.ere. d·\d iS' (~u-e ttl UI\MC\\Iie6

-\o\f\.J( (\~ '\Jf\)/ C\~~il...+tc())C\)M?;5Vi ~ ld~ O.,()J d~Vt\o~t,d _ fl€.A\o,\ __ ·- __

i !\ness o,re v.\1 ~o Cof')i)o() 1 ~nJ Sc. f'lUC.~. <-l Sot\·(\-~ iS de£-\ro~~ ~

Jes~\rt ~"'w ·r~l!.r~ ~'1 (~1e\ iu\Ktlc .dVM'ICe.t'1e.n1s ML'Y ~e. ·The~ · Co"~-\t .. o1\~ C(lM-c. u? \-1\~h lie~ I'J ,d)·M!t~e ) c.,W~ t.., ~~x t~ese _ ~ro'L\eMSJ

~ but ~A-~,=> i~ eve\ {\xeJ . ~es-t ~~~ . Tbe~ ~noW r~(\t "\-~.~ so\u1ian \ .S \rl It T~e. \€.J15\c,tic:-CJ ~f GdJ1 ~-l ·h" t:rc.:dej ·theM .xo.J e.ver~ thir,~ c,.\oll{)j

fn~M. T I veJ t'he s~ steM ~f . IGoJ and Seen, tMr M(\fl s·hcuiJ neve( be. ' ~()$, (\ ~ ·~ tQ r'lo.Cl cr 1:\0~thi ~~ ~th~r th.~n G-<:>~1 bu~- 0.':> 1 ~t Jf)to

~ .. hhc,,_\ )tt: L"\·) 1 :t fovr,J <.\. \ lttle. tS~uc . feo~J~ If) t\, 1.;, t.-tcr\J \d<.e to · h'\Ve th~ ~J r VO on th·ef~ s·~f) ~InS J o.nJ rf 'the.~ St:t. flQr\e U~-L t~\!1 .S .th <( t~. th,r 1'. o\All i th<:J vs~ I Vi~'l ence 0.0 ~ fer~ e' \he ,),I l" I I I lr o~e,~te -T'ni ~'~:P X\IC.jt t \. et'11 lu.bt!l theM~ anJ U5e VJolenc.e to >+S th~M· Th,~ 15 hoH

i >teo \-be u.s l\n ~ \'n~re. ~\ l 1eS Lehl\Ve. t'.l\.b\~5 1h.e. 1s\<l.t')i(. ~~.s-hn1 . I . 1~e.~ s e. i\ o.~ s!:Mc.\hin:J t'nf\1 Jc-tSnr ~ '.4ith th~re.. te\~~ : 1he.

Our\,n ~\~~ in· (?.,/\?-.c) t~~t j '"\he. .iews anJchri<>tinos t,.,Ji\1 ()!.l-}- he ~\e~\'JL!~ \r \ t~. ~c\1 unle ~ S ~cv .foH, \·1 tb~re Uc\~S '~ and lfljet?.-~/ thelj We\ e.. noT

~\eo.s~~. ' 1r\-. .;.'{ ~rrl"~s aJ'J ~q~bs T~f!~ ~e.H\c:~J hcMlS; Ki \It~ 1he.. I n{la c.~oi

_ _,\~l .. '\e$o ize! ~~\i re. Mvl<.~'riorls - 'ro l'otAI\t ~~o~le .,bide \,~ 1\.elt -1<\\'\S .""~ -WO.'::\r> i t~c. wo.~S ,1 C.ll\(u~tl<'f\ f\1) e(')) \.-,Vc,Meri\ t .. ('11hc:.\. 1hCA$ Go~. I hen ·t\..rou.)'h ne\ e. Me.rt(\ i\e~ \,\11\J~~ e\fe\~n l\ t_ b~ n~~~~C\\\1\') · 1o.\~e~cLo.n1 r·i'IS ·IrSolrH 1'1"f"• ;\~ "~ \ tht. Is\1\i'\tC £L\~\ e~ 1~ , 6C\rb <\\ic.~' a\ '' ierrorl~\s' '

oC "_ o.bu~ ·1~ \-.vMCl.()S,\ln\~''1 on Jhe:i . \Q~~\e~ (\nd \ .\b~\e ~ f1C\Me~ O. C\d _? . iM ':'1 ~~ k'T \ ,,,Je \) '' \ e \ ~VM·,r c, 1-a t \ n\1i"h\ t1~ 1 c~vs ir,~) Mv~\iM~ t\.-ehSe.\VeS

t~ \.v ~ T \.<>e . r ;\i bioO "nl '\r.p \, 1 ef,r n \ t. R S in~<~~; 11-e ti~" \ ~~.~he\ (Mo.~ ~e ctt u.rJ b\t:~.~'~"!>.:.. 6t. \J~c:) hi~ ) i,nid · I.s\o,\'' S\(,\t~J •\ > ~- M~Thlf\~~ 5tro.Me.


o.nJ ~"ill rr!\urn -.,_ l~ Se c.n r;._:._ '~_oJ1dklo~ -strtd)~)c.'', \H,k ~ (s e.Xf\t. TI~ t\..e_

\.Jhf\T ~' 1\ntnG~ J e.. t .. 1~e ~-Jests ~e.~ rr,~ct$'f\ t>\-"Ts i£\ niL: su~tcf"l ''"·,j rhel.e ~ot'hP.MCe. (\ ~~ the. t-JQ\\J . I Wo.~ Ver~ frvs1(~td o.S 'I 5!-e()

the fq\~eh~o~ ¢ 1-'he 5~ste.f'\ onJ- Tcjt'LS ·+be.. U,S C\n~ t~elt C\\\1-e.S ~±r~ 1-o i.M~se 1 b th1S \e~ ne. 1-n IY'ilir~r~ Jihr\~• "I t~C'v3ht 1$;),t the~

vse. t~c.1H .. ~ .cf. ,\isrvPtl[\3 "J\ IJft fl n~ f'tv\de..\i(\~ cu r ci vi ll it\OS

_ ·,~ _1fn recKless \iL~l-n\~e. - (\~htthe[ ~~iPoSe\ :1 co \ n9!\- \1u\Po~e.\~) 1 .1\r'ld +'ned JT t-J ~ v..??f"aPric\te to UH. si~v\(\( l"l~lhc-~ ~) h'\C.\\ V{)\i\

1\d vnle:~s -ihe_hl sts, C c\{)'\t\' ~f\~ . r e.ce.n1\ ~ ~ 1('? ~e~ \1\S\r)\<e.t

o.r ft c. . ·ht"e1 ~~~ t A··~~\ \"',,\\e l~en:;-2. tJ tr.·o5~\~S~ .b•,c't< ~() ;C))-\_."\\e\'L_

\() S.uL. \-. '\ W\~ Hn\ i.s w\,:\ T {!C\M<=. T9 1-~e. u.s (to\ "\he~\ .-,).

M~ Jti'\\i\tJ \.:: S ~110!) C\.br:.lJT t\15 l-1 \0 -''f . .\ lt\}j r, jiJ)htiLo..tif)(\ 1"cr it1 t.

1\t'\ l'<)e\t\'~ exrhl ll'_\ r2~ \'h.,u-}\-:\- ~~~-e~S A1 1'he. 1i n~1 jvn h~w. 'I ~x~t~\rl t.

it •\1 ol\~c_sh~~s ,:\ t1~ _ hft . .Ail'j,J'\I_1, Si~l·c \ 11 vc. he~(\ r~.rr6 Le.A r ~le:l\t '•\''\r~·Dh • 1:1 1 •- 1 ' • l ' 1 : ) 1 I r j i f'l)'\f\~J uf.) ill..J Jd,!\S ~/llh. t',l\ 1~.e.\~ 1\~·1 Hcll:!..!Jl,r''; h(~V1n1 b\<K M' fo[1tW rV\ \

·------ - __ t\~~!,_h ·,c:,_ Vt!(~ (.,ffi Jl) ,} '-t~. \t' :r wL\~ ~ .. \".~!I. ~r~·. r 1'he y .. r~r ..:o.1-~k _1-\r,s _ . \./<\~ ~1\· eC\ 1:' ~~~!I It\ is"\"_1),.1). 'I1 \-l'\; .tJr.Lt r thlje '~l!nl:~ \ 1..f\ure fo( r-1e !;, ~\\J e. • ·

n.,_foh .n Co• he t ~~ \ .. {_\ " ! '~I u; \, ll"<f"'- "i ,,, "r hili Ia r !{,,~ ;th•r

J;t,,.lii\ c,se; tJ<f< Kt~l I$, \l·\ f,r ~ ··r; lol Y~<,rsi , .. M, J;c,.\el r on.l 1:

· C f'vll~.\ ~{') \ ~~~c: ~\!C'Il'-' ~ i t\.r\\ ). ~ \k ..ce.ll i::i~\ L \I'~ t:h ~~I!J .n ~\ V.l'\.~ 1-:j io(fvfc ~· U 1

w\~r, cVI!(!)\h~n:.~ ·~ ~ ·•.\~ o \ .:.Ls.~ u\.~rt ~c.\1 l\r1 s\.l. nin,,\l'j (;~l!ciS\(t\\1~ I he: t:-e )\$ ·In (Z \1~1) , lJttO {U)c. n!.l \l ,.r)o IS. t• · l".c~ ~t•l { r·on; t\111 \'ne ~ •..!!\~ .af

S;k~~L .,IJ l ~~ . l"l M< l,<'lf~r.~ . \\.;mi. 0e. 1k~. t<\,;1< ;~ lk ;, \1:U1 I ' '·',s bt:1n5 ·hKt!() h (..,•JI \lhw \1') n1Ji'-t![ 0(\1'1~~ b>1~1\n e\lL'\::J r.\.. tnrX he. Kills f'JV ~ \1 t'IS \n ~ r ~:, ?~ s ~~ v ~-\I r"l I t-1" ~I)N), 1'h,s ~Jn c r·~ ~eC his oi1 tC ~f 1\ er)d () r~t~ed ~1 ·t<. l d Iii r'] 1-hn.t T we;.

11

lhe. tJL\fri\Le I.srs'', 1 A11r\1 \J(\~1!.(\\-r,",d $. -l ht! l,!\le!\ ::._ ,\ ~t ·1u t\\\1 t>rJ\v?lcC\1 c> ~ T

\ 1€.\Je.C ·tc:\rl b\v, .. . \ ()~_\, \-~(\~ 1 C\6 IJ 1 rt1~\ cc.,s.e ("\_.ll~ ir r.


---:----h-'~~..___..."'--+'>~f-1Jt1) J <k S "I ~ oi-• \a j· t~ ( ~ t \1 J: f oV() J \t q\\ cte S!fo ~~~.J ( be\" Oy i !\ 9.)

~ nil aVt'C tbe -tl"i) nod M':) G.vC\1"\ io the. ~r&bQ.S-\1.!

-------.:~~.J........,;I.U£l.!..ldl. :..,C.lif.. e~ ·UP, A£h•C tbcJ .1 dn~ -r W()"ld . ~It if'l L?\j Ce.\1 q\\ rl'~

~----+t-L-'<l<4-=::~l.U.IJI-..L--I~.J..J..I.l:· ~1 -~-~....!y~()·~ . t\Le·bstine, 1 \-e o, rd fn~ Souoj J \\e.y.S ace.L T~tn Whea it Wo..S \vl'lc,b ti(\'1£ I . I


\ ~


---------+--------~----------~----;

mother jones – smart, fearless journalism · 8/6/2018 · case 1:16-cr-00376-rmb document 91-2...

Documents