modulation in central station of a radio a thesis...
TRANSCRIPT
MODULATION IN CENTRAL STATION OF A RADIO
OVER FIBER DOWNLINK SYSTEM FOR GENERATING
DUAL FREQUENCY MM-WAVE SIGNAL
A Thesis
Submitted in partial fulfilment of the
Requirements for the award of the degree of
MASTERS OF ENGINEERING
IN
ELECTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION ENGINEERING
BY
SOUMYADEEP DAS
(ME/ECE/10021/2013)
Department of Electronics and Communication Enginee ring
Birla Institute of Technology
Mesra-835215, Ranchi
2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI i i
DECLARATION CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the work presented in the thesis entitled
“Modulation in central station of a Radio Over Fiber Downlink
System For Generating a Dual Frequency mm-Wave Sign al” in
the partial fulfilment of the requirement for the award of Degree of
Masters of Engineering in Electronics and Communica tion of
Birla Institute of Technology Mesra, Ranchi is an authentic work
carried out under my supervision and guidance.
To the best of my knowledge, the content of this thesis does not
form a basis for the award of any previous Degree to anyone else.
DATE:
Head,
Dept. of Electronics and Communication Engineering
Birla Institute of Technology Mesra, Ranchi-835215
Dr. S.K.Ghorai
Professor Dept. of Electronics and Communication Engineering
Birla Institute of Technology Mesra, Ranchi-835215
Dean
(Post Graduate Studies)
Birla Institute of Technology Mesra, Ranchi-835215
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI ii ii
CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL
The foregoing thesis entitled “Modulation in central station of a
Radio Over Fiber Downlink System For Generating a D ual
Frequency mm-Wave Signal” , is hereby approved as a
creditable study of research topic and has been presented in
satisfactory manner to warrant its acceptance as prerequisite to
the degree for which it has been submitted.
It is understood that by this approval, the undersigned do not
necessarily endorse any conclusion drawn or opinion expressed
therein, but approve the thesis for the purpose for which it is
submitted.
(Internal Examiner) (External Examiner)
(Chairperson)
Head of the Department
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI iii iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to take this opportunity to express my profound gratitude and indebtness
to my guide Dr. S.K.Ghorai, Professor, Department of Electronics and
communication Engineering, B.I.T, Mesra for his outstanding guidance, excellent
support, complete belief and inspiring suggestions throughout the course of this
investigation. His encouragement and motivation have been invaluable during my
studies at B.I.T, Mesra.
I would like to thank our Head of the Department, Dr. (Prof.) V.R.Gupta, for
providing all the departmental facilities required and extending kind co-operation
during the entire study period.
I am immensely thankful to Dr. M.K.Mishra, Vice Chancellor, B.I.T, Mesra, Ranchi
for providing all the institutional facilities and infrastructure during M.E. course.
It gives me immense pleasure to acknowledge Dr. N. Gupta, Dr. N. Chattoraj and
my entire respected faculty members of ECE department, for their interest and direct
or indirect co-operation throughout my project.
I also like to thank my senior Mainak Basu for his encouragement and suggestions
during this investigation.
I wish to thank all non-teaching staff of the department for their direct and indirect
help extended during my M.E. course.
I would like to acknowledge AICTE for providing me fellowship during M.E.
studies.
I would like to express my sincere gratitude and love to my parents ,Soma Das and
Dipak Kumar Das, along with my entire family for their patience, belief and
consistent motivation.
I am glad to express my love and gratitude to all of my friends with a special mention
of Parikhit Dutta, Aakash and Rajmita Chakraborty for their enthusiastic presence
and encouragement throughout my M.E. studies as well as entire life.
I would like to dedicate my thesis to my aunt Late Sumita Das for her contributions
in my life and my studies.
Date: SOUMYADEEP DAS
(ME/ECE/10021/2013)
Abstract 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI iv iv
ABSTRACT
The sheer need for higher data rates and also high channel capacity has introduced
various new technologies in wireless domain. Micro and pico-cellular architecture are
redefining communication system. It is true that increase in the carrier frequency
increases bandwidth but it results in to complicated end user units. Optical fibres on
the other hand have an infinity bandwidth theoretically and have advantages of
immunity to electromagnetic interference (EMI) and reduced attenuation of signals
propagating through an optical fibre. Utilizing the mobility of wireless technology and
bandwidth advantages of optical communication, Radio-over-Fibre (RoF) promises to
be a redefining technology. RoF systems also result in simplified Remote Antenna
Units. In this project work, a novel, cost effective and simplified Central Station (CS)
for a dual frequency RoF downlink system is proposed and designed. The various
modulation schemes for central station has been studied and compared. External
modulation using Mach-Zehnder Modulator is described in detail. Apart from
communication another aim of this proposed architecture is to generate dual
frequency millimeter wave carrier signal for baseband data and to transmit it into
wireless medium to the end user units. Optical to Electrical re-conversion at the Base
Station (BS) is obtained by means of coherent photo detection resulting in frequency
multiplication. Due to this we can go in the range of mm wave transmission, having
advantages of low atmospheric attenuation beyond 60 GHz. Thus integrating optical,
microwave and millimetre wave technology to design a RoF system and study the
performance of this system is aimed at.
TABLE OF CONTENTS 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI v v
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1 ............................................................................................................................. 1
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Problem Statement ........................................................................................................... 1
1.2 Motivation ........................................................................................................................ 1
1.3 Objective .......................................................................................................................... 1
1.4 Background and overview ............................................................................................... 2
1.5 Scope of the Project ......................................................................................................... 6
1.6 Organization of Thesis ..................................................................................................... 6
CHAPTER 2 .............................................................................................................................8
LITERATURE REVIEW........................................................................................................8
CHAPTER 3 ........................................................................................................................... 11
RADIO OVER FIBER .......................................................................................................... 11
3.1 Microwave Photonics .................................................................................................... 11
3.2 Generalized Study of ROF ............................................................................................. 13
3.2.1 Basic architecture .................................................................................................... 14
3.2.2 Advantages and Disadvantages (RoF general system) ........................................... 15
3.3 Central Station ............................................................................................................... 16
3.3.1 Optical – Electrical (RF signal) Modulation ........................................................... 16
3.3.2 Optical Interleaving ................................................................................................ 20
3.3.3 Baseband Modulation ............................................................................................. 22
3.4 Millimeter Wave Generation ......................................................................................... 25
CHAPTER 4 ........................................................................................................................... 28
PROPOSED SYSTEM .......................................................................................................... 28
4.1 Proposed Central Station ................................................................................................ 28
4.2 Component Analysis ...................................................................................................... 29
4.2.1 Mach Zehnder Modulator ....................................................................................... 29
4.2.2 Optical Interleaver .................................................................................................. 30
4.2.3 Fiber Brag Grating .................................................................................................. 31
CHAPTER 5 ........................................................................................................................... 33
THEORETICAL MODELLING ......................................................................................... 33
TABLE OF CONTENTS 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI vi vi
5.1 Frequency Domain Analysis .......................................................................................... 33
5.2 Bessel Function .............................................................................................................. 35
5.3 Mathematical Modelling of Proposed Central Station ................................................... 40
CHAPTER 6 ........................................................................................................................... 47
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ............................................................................................ 47
6.1 Analysis of Central Station ............................................................................................ 47
6.1.1 Mach Zehdner Modulator ....................................................................................... 48
6.1.2 Optical Interleaver .................................................................................................. 49
6.1.3 Baseband Data Modulation ..................................................................................... 50
6.1.4 Optical Coupler ....................................................................................................... 51
6.2 Analysis of Laser Source ............................................................................................... 52
6.2.1 Variation of Linewidth ............................................................................................ 52
6.3 Variation of Baseband Data ........................................................................................... 54
6.3.1 Type of Pulses ......................................................................................................... 54
6.3.2 Variation of Data Rate ............................................................................................ 56
6.4 Millimeter Wave Generation ......................................................................................... 57
6.4.1 Experimental Setup ................................................................................................. 57
6.4.2 Simulation Analysis ................................................................................................ 60
CHAPTER 7 ........................................................................................................................... 62
CONCLUSION AND FUTURE SCOPE ............................................................................. 62
7.1 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................... 62
7.2 Flexibility of dual frequency mm wave ......................................................................... 62
7.3 Future Scope .................................................................................................................. 63
LIST OF FIGURES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI vii vii
LIST OF FIGURES
Fig. 1.1: ROF technology used for domestic purposes 3
Fig. 1.2: Basic Block Diagram of ROF 5
Fig: 3.1. Schematic diagram of a simple RoF downlink system 14
Fig 3.2: Left: absorption of a semiconductor as a function of wavelength with and
without an external applied electric field. Right: typical loss versus applied voltage
curves for an electro-absorption modulator 18
Fig. 3.3: Principle of operation of a Mach-Zehnder modulator. 19
Fig. 3.4: (a) optical interleaver technique; (b) optical de-interleaver technique 21
Fig. 3.5: NRZ and RZ data stream 23
Fig. 3.6: Single Drive Mach-Zehdner Modulator 25
Fig. 3.7: Attenuation for microwave and millimeter wave range (1GHz to 300GHz
27
Fig. 4.1: Block Diagram of the proposed ROF downlink Central Station 28
Fig. 4.2: Unbalanced Mach Zehnder Modulator (MZM) 30
Fig. 4.3 Working principle of a Fibre Bragg Grating[36] 32
Fig. 5.1: Basic representation of Fourier Transform 35
Fig 5.2: Plot of Bessel function of the first kind, Jα(x), for integer orders α = 0, 1, 2
37
Fig. 5.3: Plot of Bessel function of the second kind, Yα(x), for integer orders α = 0, 1,
2. 38
Fig. 5.4: Modulated signal after MZM1 and MZM2 43
Fig. 5.5: PRBS (NRZ) data; Baseband data 44
Fig. 5.6: Response after FBG (Baseband data modulates the freq component) 45
Fig. 5.7: Output of the Central Station (towards base stations) 46
Fig. 6.1: Design of the Central station of ROF downlink in Optiwave 13.0 48
Fig. 6.2: (a) Output of MZM1; suppressing the even order sidebands; (b) Output of
MZM2; suppressing the odd order components along with the carrier 48
Fig. 6.3: (a) Filtered output of MZM1; (b) Filtered output of MZM2 49
Fig. 6.4: (a)-(b) Combination of selected order of sidebands after interleaver setup
50
Fig. 6.5: NRZ PRBS data sequence with bitrate 2.5Gbps 50
Fig. 6.6: Baseband data, modulated with (a) +4 component; (b) -4 component 51
LIST OF FIGURES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI viii viii
Fig. 6.7: Final output signal of Central Station transmitted towards (a) BS1 and
(b) BS2 52
Fig. 6.8: Output signal of ROF Central Station with various Laser Linewidth; 53
Fig. 6.9: (a) data pattern of NRZ; (b) data pattern of RZ; Frequency domain
representation (c) NRZ; (d) RZ 54
Fig. 6.10: Fourth order sideband being modulated by (a) NRZ data; (b) RZ data; The
final output of the CS when the baseband data pulses are (c) NRZ & (d) RZ 55
Fig. 6.11: Baseband modulation done with various datarate; (a)2.5Gbps; (b) 5Gbps;
(c) 25Gbps; (d) 40Gbps 56
Fig. 6.12: WDM setup with Laser source and internal PIN detector and Digital
Storage Oscilloscope 58
Fig. 6.13: Tunable Laser source 58
Fig. 6.14: OSA shows the optical spectrum of both the laser sources after combining
using a 3dB coupler 58
Fig. 6.15: Setup of the central station with TLS and OSA for mm wave generation
59
Fig. 6.16: Setup of the CS continued… with FBG and optical couplers. 59
Fig. 6.17: Final Frequency spectrum of the mm wave signal after BS 59
Fig. 6.18: Simulation data for the single Laser and the combined Lasers after the 3dB
coupler with the laboratory specifications 60
Fig. 6.19: Simulated frequency profile of the generated mm wave with laboratory
specifications 60
Fig. 6.20: Combining two laser sources with narrower linewidth 61
Fig. 6.21: Simulation result for the generated mm wave signal with a frequency of
37.5GHz 61
LIST OF TABLES Table 6.1: Important design parameters for downlink system 47
Table. 6.2: Observed signal power at the end of the CS 55
Table. 6.3: Components used for experiments and their specifications 57
LIST OF SYMBOLS 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI ix ix
LIST OF SYMBOLS
Eg Electron Band Gap
Ν Frequency
Λ Wavelength
Η Refractive Index
Ø(t) Phase shift
Vπ Half Wave Voltage
f0 Optical Carrier Frequency
ω0 Optical Carrier Frequency (angular)
fRF RF signal frequency
ωRF RF signal frequency (angular)
Jn(m) nth order Bessel Function of first kind
A0 Amplitude of the optical field
M Modulation index
ABBREVIATIONS 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI x
ABBREVIATIONS
CS Central Station
BS Base Station
FBG Fiber Bragg Grating
RF Radio Frequency
HAN Home Area Network
HDMI High Definition Multimedia Interface
EDFA Erbium Doped Fiber Amplifier
SSMF Standard Single Mode Fiber
HFC Hybrid Fiber Coaxial
FTTH Fiber To The Home
PON Passive Optical Network
MMW Millimeter Wave
QPSK Quadrature Phase Shift Keying
M-QAM M-ary Quadrature Amplitude Modulation
OFDM Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing
ROF Radio Over Fiber
MWP Microwave Photonics
EVM Error Vector Magnitude
MZM Mach-Zehnder Modulator
TW Travelling wave
PD Pin Diode
NF Noise Figure
DR Dynamic Range
MMF Multi Mode Fiber
DML Direct Modulating Laser
EAM Electro Absorption Modulator
DWDM Dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing
IM Intensity Modulator
ABBREVIATIONS 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI xi
NRZ Non Return to Zero
RZ Return to Zero
ASK Amplitude Shift Keying
EHF Extreme High Frequency
DSB Double Side Band
SSB Single Side Band
OCS Optical Carrier Supression
CW Continuous Wave
OSA Optical Spectrum Analyzer
DSO Digital Storage Oscilloscope
TLS Tuneable Laser Source
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 1
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Problem Statement Communication is one of the most interesting and important field in modern
day electronics. It defines day to day life and each and every step of our progress.
Starting from the telephonic conversations to video conferences, from weather
predictions to live telecast of important incidents communication has a key role to
play. It is difficult to priorities the type of communication, say wired or wireless.
Each of them has its own pros and cons. Hence it is essential for the future
communication to integrate these two methods of communication to gain
maximum benefit for the mankind. Hence wireless communication in Radio
Frequency domain may be integrated with Optical Fiber Communication to create
architecture of efficient, cost effective, secure communication as well as to
generate high frequency millimeter wave signals with ease.
1.2 Motivation Disadvantages of the current fiber- wireless communication are the limitation
of frequency, complex and bulky architecture, limitation of data rate of the
baseband data, etc. In this thesis we wish to overcome these drawbacks by
investigating the actual cause and proposing the possible solutions.
In this thesis work Radio Frequency is being used to enhance the frequency
range. Also we use frequency multiplication and frequency reuse to make the
system compact and also flexible to the end users. We also generate the millimeter
wave signal in a cost effective and efficient way.
1.3 Objective In this work, the design and performance of a dual frequency full duplex RoF
system Central Station is attempted. The main objective is to design a simple and
cost effective CS. External modulation at the CS is used to achieve a dual
frequency signal containing 72 and 84 GHz (mm wave) frequency components at
base station (BS).
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 2
The objectives are
• To modulate RF signal with optical carrier frequency efficiently. Here
Mach-zehnder modulator is used.
• To extract sideband harmonics using Fiber Bragg Grating (FBG)
techniques.
• Frequency multiplication (six times and seven times in our case) of RF
signals to be done at the Base Stations.
• To connect multiple (at least two) base stations to a single central station.
• To reuse some frequency components for uplink, so that base stations
remain mobile and less complicated and no separate laser source is
needed.
• To design the interleaver setup using add-drop multiplexing.
• Experimentally generate millimeter (mm) wave from optical source.
1.4 Background and overview Since the late 1990s, wireless technologies have been developed to replace
the wires installed in the Home Area Networks (HAN). One of the most successful
interfaces is the IEEE 802.11 standards also known as Wi-Fi. The current
generation can achieve theoretically up to 600Mbps, but in the coming years higher
data rates will be needed. Indeed, the ability to deliver high bit rate services
through the optical access networks and the increasing needs in terms of device
interconnection inside the home will boost the throughput requirements. And this
tendency will keep growing as new usage models arrive continuously: thus, the
instantaneous data rate in the HAN could reach 10Gbps. As a result, these last
years, new wireless technologies appeared.
The current Wi-Fi technologies exploit the 2.4 or the 5 GHz unlicensed
bands, but because these frequencies know a huge success, they tend to become
very saturated. To preempt this and increase the connection speeds, the industrials
are going towards the unlicensed millimeter-wave band, from 57 to 66 GHz. This
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 3
band is widely available around the world, it is not yet massively used, it offers
large channels of 2.16GHz bandwidth with high authorized emitted powers and it
allows advanced integration into radio terminals thanks to miniaturization at such
frequencies. Thus, wireless systems able to achieve data rate up to 7Gbitps and
dedicated to HAN are emerging or are under development. With this speed, users
can really start to replace every domestic cable they use, even High Definition
Multimedia Interface (HDMI) cables that convey uncompressed High Definition
(HD) video signals.
Fig. 1.1: ROF technology used for domestic purposes
The society as we know today has been greatly influenced by the
development of telecommunications technology and the invention of internet and
its multimedia rich applications like YouTube, HULU, Facebook, and others. Now
it goes beyond the HAN. The Internet has led to the exponential growth in data
transmission [1] in telecommunication networks, which in turn has led to
development of new technologies, and vice versa. The majority of
telecommunication networks are based on fiber optic communications, which with
the invention of Erbium-doped fiber amplifiers (EDFA) [2] has become the
favourite technology for long haul data transport [3, 4]. Optical communication
systems are widely deployed all over the world, mainly for long haul (> 1000 km)
and regional/metro communication links. Until recently, the last mile user
connectivity was provided mostly by cable TV, or through twisted pair (ADSL),
which have a very limited bandwidth distance product (around 10 Mb/s*km). The
most recent access technology, the hybrid fiber coaxial (HFC) can only provide a
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 4
few tens of Mb/s to each user, and all these technologies do not meet the
bandwidth requirements of the future. Recently, fiber optics is entering the last
mile segment with the passive optical network (PON) technology also called as
fiber to the home (FTTH), where 2.5 Gbps connectivity using a time-division-
multiplexed PONs [5] are already under implementation. The current state of the
art standard for optical access network is a 10 Gbps Ethernet based connectivity
called 10GEPON [6], and optical access networks with 40 Gbps [7] are being
investigated. This sudden increase in the access networks' capacity is well
supported by the advances in metro and core segment where systems for 100 Gbps
[8-12] or more [13] are being investigated, with a few of them in deployment.
With the rapid growth in optical access networks, there is a digital divide
emerging where remote areas, and emerging isolated residential complexes and it
hard to have the last mile fiber for either cost or logistical reasons. In such cases,
wireless access has always played a crucial role in expanding the reach of access
networks in a cost-effective manner. On the other hand, wireless access through
wireless LANs, WiMAX, LTE, etc are evolving rapidly, and capacity of 100 Mbps
per user are already under consideration. But for the wireless technology to support
the current optical access, data rates up to 10 Gbps or more are currently needed,
for extending the reach of the optical access networks. Some other applications of
such high capacity wireless links are inter-building gigabit connectivity,
emergency service deployment, redundancy links, etc.
To provide multi-Gbps wireless links, new frequency bands like the
millimetre wave (mmW) bands have to be considered [14]. The advantages of the
mmW bands are the availability of a few GHz of bandwidth, which may provide
wireless links with Gbps capacity. Another advantage is the low beam-width of the
higher mmW bands, which in combination with high gain antennas enable higher
spatial multiplexing and frequency reuse [15]. Of the mmW band spectrum, the 60
GHz (57-64 GHz) band, and the 70/80 GHz (71-76/81-86 GHz) are mostly
considered by various wireless system developers. The frequency bands of 120
GHz or 140 GHz (both unregulated) are under investigation for very high capacity
wireless. To provide 10 Gbps wireless links in these frequency bands, spectral
efficient modulation formats like quadrature phase shift keying (QPSK),m-ary
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 5
quadrature amplitude modulation (M-QAM), or even orthogonal frequency
division multiplexing (OFDM) based modulation must be considered especially in
a bi-directional link scenario.
Recently, in 2009, the IEEE 802.11ad group has been created dealing with
60GHz components for IEEE 802.11 family systems. It should lead the
competition that occurs between industrials thanks to Wi-Fi certification.
Additionally, the first Wi-Fi 60GHz chipsets are expected at the second half of
2013, and by 2016 they could account for more than 40% of the total Wi-Fi market
[16]. However, these wireless systems have a coverage limited to a single room
and to a small indoor open area due to the high propagation attenuation at 60GHz
and to non-propagation of millimeter-waves across the walls. Therefore, the main
challenge to be resolved by this thesis consists in finding solutions to extend the
radio coverage to the entire HAN, and to interconnect wireless devices located in
different rooms.
Fig. 1.2: Basic Block Diagram of ROF
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 6
1.5 Scope of the Project Radio-Over-Fiber (R-o-F) technology gives the solution for the needs of the
future generation communication system. By designing a full duplex R-o-F system
architecture we may achieve the required data rate of the transmitted data as well
as the solution of the problem of last mile fiber. All the frequency domain analysis
by Fourier Transform is being done to get the frequency components. Generation
of millimeter wave signal can also be done with this architecture. Dual frequency
millimeter wave carrier signal gives the flexibility to the Base Stations. In the due
course of the project the designing of the optical interleaver system using add-drop
multiplexers adds to the options of various interleaver systems. This R-o-F system
is aiming to provide a high data rate up to 40Gbps or even more.
1.6 Organization of Thesis This following thesis describes the executed work:
Chapter 1: Introduction: It gives the overview and introduction of the project
along with the problem statement.
Chapter 2: Literature Review: Brief discussions of the works, already done by
several researchers and authors, have been included in this chapter.
Chapter 3: Radio Over Fiber: This chapter focuses on the basic concept of
Microwave Photonics and also the detailed study on Radio Over Fiber technique. It
gives stress on the modulation at the Central Station (CS) of the R-o-F system.
Generation of millimeter wave is also being described in this chapter.
Chapter 4: Proposed System: In this chapter we discuss about our proposed
system architecture. Based on Radio Over Fiber technology we are introducing
the novel architecture of a downlink central station for generating a dual
frequency mm wave at the end of Base Station.
Chapter 5: Theoretical Modeling: The main focus of this chapter is the detailed
modeling of the Radio Over Fiber technology along with the mathematical tools
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 7
and functions we required. It gives idea of Fourier Transformation and Bessel
Function. It also models the R-o-F central station mathematically.
Chapter 6: Results and Discussion: Results are obtained and analyzed in this
chapter. Both the simulation and the experimental setup are discussed in this
chapter.
Chapter 7: Conclusion and Future Scope: This chapter covers conclusions and
future scopes. The concluding remarks are made for the project. Suggestions for
further improvements in analysis and simulation results are included in this
chapter.
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 8
CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW
Radio-Over-Fiber technology comes under the broader area of Microwave
Photonics. The very term Microwave Photonics (MWP) was coined in 1991. Since
then this area of research has been witnessing regular progress and development in
architecture.
Researcher named Jäger. D described novel and innovative components
based upon the interaction of travelling optical waves and microwave signals [17-
18]. He used Microwave Photonics as a tool. It introduced a new era in the field of
already known Non-Linear photonics.
In the year of 1992 Polifko, D. and Ogawa, H. had foreseen that the merging
of microwave and photonic technologies could gain real commercial interest,
where the RF signal is optically transmitted along extremely low-loss glass fibers
[19].
In the last decade MWP added a new dimension to the multi and
interdisciplinary researches. Seeds, A.J. , Vilcot, A. et al. and Yao, J. are
developing their researches based on MWP and developing the less known theory
of the field also [20-23].
Hong Wen, et al. came up with a new idea called radio-over-fiber technology
full duplex system using frequency reuse. The modulate the laser directly with the
help of RF signal and tried to achieve less than 2 dB power penalty for a 2.5Gbps
dta over a 40km standard Optical Fiber Cable (OFC). [24]
One year later in 2009 J.He et al. overcome the limitations of direct
modulation of the laser and introduced external modulation using Mach-Zehdner
Modulator (MZM). [25] They also generated millimeter wave signal by
quadrupling the RF signal frequency at the Base Stations (BS).
This external modulation opened up the field of ROF for the researchers as
well as commercial manufacturers. In 2010 to till now various techniques of
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 9
modulation and frequency multiplication are being used. Someone does a octupling
or a dual quadrupling [26] of the frequency; some researchers observe a decupling
[27]. Also Single side band modulation [28] and double sideband modulation for
MZM [29] have been carried out to obtain the most suitable combination for ROF
technology.
The most recent paper that we have studied is authored by Guangming
Cheng, Banghong Guo, Songhao Liu and Weijin Fang. In their 2014 Optik paper
they mentioned about frequency octupling to achieve W-band range mm wave
signal. Also they successfully obtained a less than 0.6dB power penalty for a
5Gbps data sequence over a 60km standard single mode fiber (SSMF).[30]
Vishal Sharma, Amarpal Singh and Ajay K. Sharma studied the challenges
and how to mitigate those for a better performance of the ROF system. [31, 32]
Zaid Al-Husseini et al. makes 60GHz ROF system for future generation
wireless system. They measured the phase noise of the system and most
importantly the effect of residual carrier signal. [33]
B. Cabon, F. Brendel and J. Poette investigate the performance of various
possible architectures, built for 60GHz transmission channel. They concluded that
Error Vector Magnitude (EVM) is more or less same for all architectures. But,
conversion gain depends on the architecture. Best conversion gain is obtained with
mode-locked laser diode and external modulation, while the worst value is
obtained for a cascade of external modulators. [34]
Laser Phase noise and linewidth affect the ROF transmission due to
incoherency of the laser source. For efficient communication these to aspects of
laser sources should be taken care of. Linewidth should be narrow for efficient
transmission and generation of mm wave. [35-39]
For any kind of optical communication including ROF technology one of the
main components is Fiber Bragg Grating (FBG). Kenneth. O. Hill and Gerald
Meltz gave an overview of FBG technology in their 1997 paper. [40]
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 10
Chung-Ting Lin et al. studied and observed the effects of nonlinear transfer
function of MZM on optical up-conversion. They also consider imperfect splitting
ratio of MZM. They used double sideband carrier suppression modulation. [41]
Millimeter wave generation is one of the main aspects of ROF technology.
MM wave can be generated efficiently usinf ROF technology and frequency
multiplication. Mohmoud Mohamed et al. designed three architectures to analyse
the performance. It was observed the frequency doubling with dual drive MZM
may have got the maximum power transmission but not good for mm wave
generation. [42]
Po-Tsung Shih et. Al, compared the FFTx communication with ROF. They
used WDM for modulating MZM.[43]
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 11
CHAPTER 3 RADIO OVER FIBER
3.1 Microwave Photonics Within the last two decades, the field of optic–microwave interactions and
the attractive integration of the best concepts of both domains have attracted
growing interest worldwide. The specific term of “microwave photonics” was first
introduced in 1991 and used to describe novel and innovative optoelectronic
components based upon the interaction of traveling optical and microwaves [1,2], a
concept already known from nonlinear optics or traveling wave (TW) tubes in
radio frequency (RF) electronics. In the following, it was foreseen that the merging
of microwave and photonic technologies could gain real commercial interest, and
would develop and become a new approach for future phased array or fiber radio
communication systems, as two examples of major interest, where the RF signal is
optically transmitted along extremely low-loss glass fibers [3]. Since then, the field
of RF optoelectronics and microwave photonics (MWP) rapidly broadened.
Today, MWP is already a most innovative and commercially interesting new
multi- and interdisciplinary field combining and transferring different beneficial
technologies [4–7]. This means that microwave technologies are used and
employed in photonics and, vice versa, photonic technologies are utilized in
microwave techniques. Most important, however, is that in specific areas novel
synergistic concepts have been developed by merging both technologies, which
particularly holds for the field of optoelectronics and its devices as their interface.
Even more and as a result of ever-increasing frequencies (see e.g., the field of
wireless communications), the term microwave stands here not only for GHz and
millimeter waves but also for THz frequencies in the frequency domain and,
equivalently, for picosecond or femtosecond timescales in the time domain [7].
The general field of optic–microwave interactions, initially called RF
optoelectronics, goes back to the study of high-speed photonic devices operating
at microwave or millimeter-wave frequencies [2] and their corresponding use in
RF, microwave, millimeter wave, THz, or photonic systems. This
multidisciplinary field is located at the interface between microwave techniques,
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 12
ultrafast electronics, and photonic technologies, and typical investigations include,
for example, high-speed and microwave signal generation, signal processing, and
conversion as well as the distribution and transmission of microwave signals via
broadband optical wired or wireless links such as glass or polymer fibers or even
free space. From first and pioneering ideas and experiments in the 1970s, the field
of MWP has dramatically broadened and paved the way for an enabling novel
technology with a number of innovative and, nowadays, more and more
commercially important applications.
This chapter is intended to give an exemplary overview together with some
recent typical results in this multidisciplinary field of MWP, ranging from basic
concepts, devices, and technologies to systems under investigation and
applications of worldwide interest. In particular, the following topics will be
addressed by way of characteristic examples showing the synergetic mixture of
the two technologies involved:
• Monolithic integration technologies and packaging aspects
• Ultrafast photonic components such as optical modulators,
photodetectors (PDs), photonic mixers, and transceivers with special
emphasis on TW devices using the distributed interaction between
traveling microwave and optical signals in order to avoid otherwise
limiting RC time constant.
• Concepts and examples of microwave signal generation and processing
by way of using photonic technologies
• Broadband and analog optical links for high-speed interconnects
• Microwave photonic systems based on the merging of microwave and
optical technologies. Examples here are optical links for wireless
communication techniques such as cellular radio systems or field
sensor applications and optically controlled phased array antenna
systems
Recent results, especially in this field of high-speed optical interconnects,
clearly demonstrate the synergetic mixture and advantages of the different
technologies involved in MWP.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 13
Generation and transmission of radio signals was previously performed using
electrical technology, where the bandwidth and transmission distances were not in
comparison with today's requirements. With the invention of the laser [44], and
hence the birth of optical communications, the bandwidth and the distances started
to increase drastically. In parallel, the use of optical communications for
transmission of radio wireless signals started to gain a lot of interest [45-48] owing
to the great advantages of photonic technologies like high bandwidth, flexibility,
and low transmission losses. This field of using photonic technologies for
microwave applications is named as Microwave Photonics (MWP) [49-52] and its
applications for transmission and distribution of radio signal is referred to as
Radio-over-Fiber (RoF). Some of the main applications of MWP include high
performance analog links [53, 54], cellular/ mobile links [55-57], RADAR, Cable
TV [58, 59] etc. All these applications are possible because of the advantages of
MWP technology like low cost, small form factor, low attenuation, higher
operational frequencies, etc [51]. Another application of MWP technology is Gbps
wireless, which will be introduced in the next section.
3.2 Generalized Study of ROF
Radio over Fiber (RoF) refers to a technology whereby light is modulated by
a radio signal and transmitted over an optical Fiber link to facilitate wireless
access, such as 3G and WiFi simultaneous from the same antenna. In other words,
radio signals are carried over Fiber-optic cable. Thus, a single antenna can receive
any and all radio signals (3G, Wifi, cell, etc..) carried over a single-Fiber cable to a
central location where equipment then converts the signals; this is opposed to the
traditional way where each protocol type (3G, WiFi, cell) requires separate
equipment at the location of the antenna.
In RF-over-Fiber architecture, a data-carrying RF (radio frequency) signal
with a high frequency is imposed on a lightwave signal before being transported
over the optical link. Therefore, wireless signals are optically distributed to base
stations directly at high frequencies and converted from the optical to electrical
domain at the base stations before being amplified and radiated by an antenna. As a
result, no frequency up–down conversion is required at the various base stations,
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION
thereby resulting in simple and r
the base stations.
Fig: 3.1. Schematic diagram of a simple RoF downlink system
3.2.1 Basic architecture Figure 3.1 shows a typical RF signal (modulated by analog or digital
modulation techniques)
RF signal may be baseband data, modulated IF, or the actual modulated RF
signal to be distributed. The RF signal is used to modulate the optical source
in transmitter. The resulting optical signal is lau
At the other end of the fiber, we need an optical receiver that converts the
optical signal to RF again. The generated electrical signal must meet the
specifications required by the wireless application be it GSM, UMTS,
wireless LAN, WiMax or other. By delivering the radio signals directly, the
optical fiber link avoids the necessity to generate high frequency radio
carriers at the antenna site. Since antenna sites are usually remote from easy
access, there is a lot to gain from
can carry information in one direction only (simplex) which means that we
usually require two Fibers for bidirectional (duplex) communication.
However, recent progress in wavelength division multiplexing makes i
possible to use the same Fiber for duplex communication using different
wavelengths. WDM can be use to combine several wavelengths together to
send them through a Fiber optic network, greatly increasing the use of the
available Fiber bandwidth and maximi
to meet future wireless bandwidth requirements.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION 14
thereby resulting in simple and rather cost-effective implementation is enabled at
Fig: 3.1. Schematic diagram of a simple RoF downlink system
3.2.1 Basic architecture Figure 3.1 shows a typical RF signal (modulated by analog or digital
modulation techniques) being transported by an analog fiber optic link. The
RF signal may be baseband data, modulated IF, or the actual modulated RF
signal to be distributed. The RF signal is used to modulate the optical source
in transmitter. The resulting optical signal is launched into an optical fiber.
At the other end of the fiber, we need an optical receiver that converts the
optical signal to RF again. The generated electrical signal must meet the
specifications required by the wireless application be it GSM, UMTS,
s LAN, WiMax or other. By delivering the radio signals directly, the
optical fiber link avoids the necessity to generate high frequency radio
carriers at the antenna site. Since antenna sites are usually remote from easy
access, there is a lot to gain from such an arrangement. Usually a single fiber
can carry information in one direction only (simplex) which means that we
usually require two Fibers for bidirectional (duplex) communication.
However, recent progress in wavelength division multiplexing makes i
possible to use the same Fiber for duplex communication using different
wavelengths. WDM can be use to combine several wavelengths together to
send them through a Fiber optic network, greatly increasing the use of the
available Fiber bandwidth and maximizing total data throughput that in order
to meet future wireless bandwidth requirements.
2015
B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI
effective implementation is enabled at
Fig: 3.1. Schematic diagram of a simple RoF downlink system
Figure 3.1 shows a typical RF signal (modulated by analog or digital
being transported by an analog fiber optic link. The
RF signal may be baseband data, modulated IF, or the actual modulated RF
signal to be distributed. The RF signal is used to modulate the optical source
nched into an optical fiber.
At the other end of the fiber, we need an optical receiver that converts the
optical signal to RF again. The generated electrical signal must meet the
specifications required by the wireless application be it GSM, UMTS,
s LAN, WiMax or other. By delivering the radio signals directly, the
optical fiber link avoids the necessity to generate high frequency radio
carriers at the antenna site. Since antenna sites are usually remote from easy
such an arrangement. Usually a single fiber
can carry information in one direction only (simplex) which means that we
usually require two Fibers for bidirectional (duplex) communication.
However, recent progress in wavelength division multiplexing makes it
possible to use the same Fiber for duplex communication using different
wavelengths. WDM can be use to combine several wavelengths together to
send them through a Fiber optic network, greatly increasing the use of the
zing total data throughput that in order
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 15
3.2.2 Advantages and Disadvantages (RoF general system) 3.2.2.1 Benefits of ROF
The transmission of radio signal over Fiber is preferable because
the enormous bandwidth that offered by optical Fiber, which is up to
THz. Many data formats such as videos, data, telephony and etc. could
be transferred via a single Fiber link. The high optical bandwidth also
enables high speed signal processing to be implemented. This might be
more difficult or impossible to be done electronically. Furthermore,
optical Fiber has low loss transmission (0.3 dB/km at 1550 nm and
0.5dB/km at 1310 nm wavelengths) which is very beneficial to
distribute wireless data transmission. The minimum losses occurred at
the three wavelengths, which are 850 nm, 1310 nm and 1550 nm. The
combination of bandwidth from these three regions is huge that made
the mm wave as a viable solution. RoF also immune to radio frequency
interference since the transmission of signal is in the form of light. This
also will provide the much needed privacy and security measures. At
the hardware implementation, complex and expensive equipments are
kept at the CS. Simpler, smaller and lighter remote antenna units are
located at the BSs. This contributes to easy installation and
maintenance processes. These easier tasks reduce the system cost. At
the management level, centralized control of the resources is possible.
Therefore, resources such as bandwidth can be dynamically allocated
depending on the demands and priorities.
So in summarized form the advantages are,
• A large transmission bandwidth
• Immunity to electromagnetic interference and other atmospheric
impairments
• A simplified BS ensures reduced cost
• The losses are minimized
• Extremely high data rates
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 16
3.2.2.2 Limitations of ROF
Since RoF is fundamentally an analog transmission, the
limitations could be caused by noise and distortion. It is resulted from
the nonlinear condition of the devices used in the link such as laser .
This limits the noise figure (NF) and dynamic range (DR) of radio
signal transmission. These two parameters are very important in radio
transmission. A method to suppress noise and distortion must be
properly applied in order to have an improved NF and DR. Besides
that, Fiber link itself has limitations. Chromatic dipersion in SMF
limits the Fiber link length. It may also cause the de-correlation leading
to increased RF carrier phase noise. In MMF, modal dispersion limits
the available bandwidth and distance.
So in summarized form the disadvantages are,
• A bottleneck between the optical and electrical components
• Chromatic dispersion in optical fibers limit transmission
distances.
3.3 Central Station Central Station (CS) of a ROF downlink system comprises of Laser source,
External Modulator, Optical Interleaver system and Optical couplers. For a
downlink system, CS to BS communication, the CS does the electrical to optical
conversion and sends the optical-mm wave signal over the optical fiber medium
towards the Base Station. A Central Station also does the processing of the
message data or baseband data. This baseband data is modulated with that
generated optical-mm wave signal.
In this thesis we will discuss the Central Station of a RoF downlink system in
details.
3.3.1 Optical – Electrical (RF signal) Modulation In optical-electrical modulation a laser source can be modulated
directly by using a RF signal. This kind of laser is called Directly Modulated
Laser (DML) sources. The ability of directly modulating a laser is an
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 17
attractive cost-effective solution for RoF links. DMLs were extensively
studied for their use in optical communication systems for metro applications
[60, 61]. The limiting factors of a DML are its modulation bandwidth,
extinction ratio, chirp and linearity, but for baseband data modulation these
parameters do not greatly affect the performance in a typical RoF link. In
directly modulated semiconductor lasers when the carrier density is changed
due to the changes in the modulation current, changes the refractive index in
the active area resulting in a frequency deviation also called as frequency
chirp [62]. The effect of chirp in an optical communication system is spectral
broadening due to dispersion in a SMF, which limits the total transmission
distance [63].
When data rates were in the low gigabit range and transmission
distances were less than 100 km or so, most fiber optic transmitters used
directly modulated lasers. However, as data rates and span lengths grew,
waveguide chirp, caused by turning a laser on and off, limited data rates.
Dispersion problems resulted when the wavelength chirp widened the
effective spectral width of the laser. A laser source with no wavelength chirp
and a narrow linewidth provide one solution to the problem. This solution
took the form of external modulation which allows the laser to be turned on
continuously; the modulation is accomplished outside of the laser cavity.
This modulation technique is called external modulation. There are mainly
two types of external modulation technique is available depending on the
nature of modulator materials.
• Electro- absorption modulation
• Electro- optic modulation
Electro Absorption Modulation (EAM) technique is based on the
change of the absorption coefficient of the material used as modulator. This
type of modulator relies on the fact that the effective bandgap Eg of a
semiconductor material decreases when an external voltage is applied.
Consequently, if the frequency ν of an incoming lightwave is chosen so that
its energy E = hν is smaller than the bandgap when no voltage is applied, the
material will be transparent. On the other hand, when an external voltage is
applied, the effective bandgap will be reduced, meaning that the lightwave
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 18
will be absorbed by the material when E > Eg. Such a shift of the absorption
edge of a semiconductor under the influence of an external voltage is
represented in Fig. 3.2. By properly selecting the signal wavelength so that it
experiences a significant change in absorption when the voltage is applied, it
thus becomes possible to achieve optical modulation controlled by an
electrical signal. A typical absorption versus applied voltage transfer function
for an electro-absorption modulator is also shown in Fig. 3.2.
Fig 3.2: Left: absorption of a semiconductor as a function of wavelength with and without an external applied electric field (adapted from [64]). Right: typical loss versus applied voltage
curves for an electro-absorption modulator (adapted from [65]).
Electro-optic modulators are based on the change of refractive index of
the material used for the modulation. The refractive index of some materials
can be modified by applying an external electric field to them through the
linear electro-optic effect. Since the phase shift experienced by a lightwave
of wavelength λ propagating through a length L of a medium with refractive
index η is
∅ = ��� �� (3.1)
A straightforward application is the realization of phase modulators
made from an electro-optic waveguide subjected to a time dependent electric
field. The applied voltage will modulate the refractive index of the
waveguide material, hence the phase shift experienced by a lightwave
propagating along the waveguide. However, legacy optical communication
systems typically rely on intensity modulation of light. This can be achieved
by transforming phase modulation induced by the electro-optic effect to
intensity modulation using an interferometric structure.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 19
Fig. 3.3: Principle of operation of a Mach-Zehnder modulator.
In order to illustrate the principle, we consider the simple
interferometric structure represented in Fig. 3.3. It is based on a Mach-
Zehnder interferometer including one electro-optic material in one of the
arms. In practice, this interferometer is realized by implanting waveguides
into an electro-optic crystal, typically lithium-niobate (LiNbO3). Assuming a
power splitting and combining ratio of 1:2 for the input and output couplers
of the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, the power at the output of the
interferometer depends on the phase shift difference, ∆∅ = ∅�� −∅�experienced by the light propagating in the upper and lower arms of the
structure according to,
���� = ��� cos� ∆∅2 3.2� The phase shift induced in the upper arm of the interferometer depends
on its refractive index, which itself depends on the applied external electric
field through the electro-optic effect. If a time-dependent voltage V (t) is
applied to the upper waveguide of the modulator, its refractive index will
become time-dependent and, in turn the transmission of the Mach-Zehnder
interferometer will also depend on time. If a continuous optical wave is
applied to the input of the modulator, the output power will thus be
modulated according to the electrical data V (t). The value of the phase shift
created by an applied external voltage depends upon many parameters,
including the choice of the electro-optic material, the orientation of the
crystal with respect to the external electric field, as well as to the polarisation
of the incoming lightwave, the geometry and dimensions of the waveguide.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 20
In any case it is possible to make abstraction of the actual physical
implementation of the modulator and describe the ability of the material and
chosen configuration to respond to an applied voltage by introducing a
quantity known as the half-wave voltage Vπ. Applying a voltage of Vπ to the
electrode of an electro-optic waveguide will result in a voltage-induced phase
shift of π. The voltage-induced phase shift ϕ (t) can therefore be related to the
applied voltage V (t) according to
��� = � ����� 3.3�
Through eq. (3.2) and (3.3), it is then possible to calculate the transfer
function Pout/Pin of the modulator as a function of the applied voltage. Such
a transfer function, where the applied voltage has been normalised to the
half-wave voltage, is also represented in Fig. 3.3. It can easily be shown that,
if the Mach-Zehnder configuration of Fig. 3.3 is used, the optical modulated
signal will be chirped. The problem can be solved by applying two
complementary modulating signals to the two arms of the Mach-Zehnder
modulator. If one arm is driven with a voltage corresponding to the data to be
transmitted d(t), while the second arm is driven with a voltage corresponding
to the complementary data d(t), then it can be shown that the chirp can be
suppressed. Mach-Zehnder modulators are usually employed this way, a
technique known as push-pull modulation, either by driving the two arms of
the interferometer with complementary signals, or by creating phase shifts of
opposite signs in each arm by a proper configuration of the crystal and
electrodes.
3.3.2 Optical Interleaving
An optical interleaver is a 3-port passive fiber-optic device that is used
to combine two sets of dense wavelength-division multiplexing (DWDM)
channels (odd and even channels) into a composite signal stream in an
interleaving way. For example, optical interleaver takes two multiplexed
signals with 100 GHz spacing and interleaves them, creating a denser
DWDM signal with channels spaced 50 GHz apart. The process can be
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 21
repeated, creating even denser composite signals with 25 GHz or 12.5 GHz
spacing.
The device can be used in a reverse direction, forming an optical de-
interleaver that separates a denser DWDM signal into odd channels and even
channels. See schematic diagram.
For example, in most DWDM equipment, the standard channel spacing
is 100 GHz. But spacing the signal-carrying frequencies every 50 or even 25
GHz can double or even quadruple the number of channels per fiber. Thus,
optical interleaver can expand the number of channels per fiber, and devices
and/or networks can be upgraded without requiring that all devices be
upgraded.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 3.4: (a) optical interleaver technique; (b) optical de-interleaver technique
Optical interleaver is based on multiple-beam interference. Currently,
there are two approaches to building optical interleaver: 1) Step-phase
Michelson interferometer, and 2) Birefringent crystal networks. The former
is based on Michelson interferometer combined with Gires-Tournois
interferometer.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 22
In this thesis we use a third technique to realize the optical interleaver.
Add-drop multiplexing is used for this purpose. WDM drop module
differentiates all the frequency components and the WDM add module adds
them up according to the required set of frequencies.
3.3.3 Baseband Modulation Baseband data is the message signal which contains the entire
information which we wish to transmit through our communication channel.
It is an electric pulse as we are considering the baseband data as digital data
stream. Now the medium of transmission is optical fiber and so we have to
generate optical pulses corresponding to the baseband data pulses. The
stringent requirements on various aspects of pulses, and their respective
modulation formats, have forced research groups across the world to look
into many different ways of generating optical pulses that are: first of all
short enough to enable very high repetition rates; and secondly capable of
providing conditioned pulses with a good extinction ratio, both temporally
and spectrally, exhibiting low timing jitter, and preferably transform limited
characteristics. Two low-cost ways of generating short optical pulses suitable
for optical telecommunication are studied in this chapter: gain switching of a
semiconductor laser, and pulse carving with a Mach-Zehdner modulator,
working as an intensity modulator (IM).
There are two basic ways of using the time slot for transmitting data
through intensity modulation. The first one is return to zero (RZ), in which
the signal always returns to a rest state (i.e. zero) during a port ion of the bit
period. The second possibility is non-return to zero (NRZ), where the signal
level can only make a transit ion at the borders of the bit period when the bit
value changes. For a given bit period, the bandwidth of an RZ signal will
thus be broader than that of an NRZ signal. However, RZ pulses are
advantageous as they allow for passive optical interleaving to higher
aggregate bit rates. RZ also becomes less sensitive to nonlinearities and
dispersion than NRZ for bit rates of 40 Gbps and higher [66 - 68].
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 23
3.3.3.1 Data Format and Modulation Scheme
The Non-Return to Zero (NRZ) format is a normal and
commonly used pulse coding modulation format in optical
communication systems as shown in Figure 2. This format is sending a
signal during the bit period for a '1' and null signal during a '0'. NRZ
has potential pulse spreading problems. It also does not efficiency on
using bandwidth. The Return to zero (RZ) of Figure 2 has half of the
bit period for a '1' when the pulse signal is The Non-Return to Zero
(NRZ) format is a normal and commonly used pulse coding
modulation format in optical communication systems as shown in
Figure 3.5. This format is sending a signal during the bit period for a '1'
and null signal during a '0'. NRZ has potential pulse spreading
problems. It also does not efficiency on using bandwidth. The Return
to zero (RZ) of Figure 3.5 has half of the bit period for a '1' when the
pulse signal is high and null signal for a '0' and is more tolerant towards
pulse dispersion. The bandwidth required by RZ is twice larger than
that of NRZ; therefore it only requires half of NRZ power in
transmission.
Fig. 3.5: NRZ and RZ data stream
The random binary data is a binary data signal in which the pulse
is either 1 or 0 shaped (like square wave). However this random binary
pulses data requires a wider bandwidth. It is used to modulate the
carrier signal. Amplitude Shift Keying (ASK) is a well known
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 24
modulation technique that allows digital signal m(t) multiply with a
carrier wave fc. It can be mathematically defined by,
!� = "#!�$% &'($!,(%*� < � < ,3.4�
where A is an amplitude envelop, m(t) is the binary signal state of
“1 or 0”, fc is the optical carrier frequency and T is the bit period. The
frequency spectrum of an ASK signal can be represented by the
baseband spectrum of the modulation m(t) but shifted to the carrier
frequency fc.
3.3.3.2 Modulation Technique
Modern optical communication systems employ two types of
external modulators for ASK modulation formats, the interferometric
or electro-absorption (EA) types. However the most popular one is the
LiNbO3 MZIM waveguide modulator configuration because of its low
optical loss and high electro-optic coefficient while the EA
semiconductor waveguide modulator does not offer the flexibility in
modulation and linearity [1]. The structure of the single drive MZIM is
shown in Figure 3.6 in which the incoming lightwaves is equally split
into the two waveguide arms forming an optical inteferometer. An
external voltage is applied onto one electrode generating a change in
the refractive index of the optical waveguide branch via the electro-
optic effect. Depending on the orientation of the crystal substrate chirp
or chirp free optical modulation can be achieved.
For lithium niobate the X-cut Z-propagating is usually preferred
to obtain chirp free modulation. When a phase difference between two
optical arms is 180 degree the lightwave paths combine destructively
and hence the output is at its minimum point or “0-state”. When the
lightwaves from the upper and lower arms recombine at the output of
MZI modulator, if the carriers of two arms are in phase, a maximum
constructively output is formed. In the case of dual electrode drive,
voltages can be applied to both paths and hence one could inject a
phase bias to generate either double or SSB property of the lightwaves
in the frequency domain.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 25
Fig. 3.6: Single Drive Mach-Zehdner Modulator
Fiber chromatic dispersion accumulates along the fiber
propagation path. Thence pulse spreading is influence by the sideband
spectrum components of the modulated signals. Therefore a reduction
of the total bandwidth of a carrier modulated wideband signals is
critical. In additional, with DSB transmission system, the data signals
contained in the upper sideband is identical to the information
contained in the lower sideband. Thence in order to minimize the
effects of the fiber chromatic dispersion and to increase the optical
bandwidth efficiency, the optical SSB modulation can be used [3]
provided that complexity in implementation at ultra-speed operation is
not the constraint.
3.4 Millimeter Wave Generation
Millimeter wave signals are also defined as Extremely High Frequency
(EHF). It is the ITU designation for the band of radio frequencies in the
electromagnetic spectrum from 30 to 300 gigahertz, above which electromagnetic
radiation is considered to be low (or far) infrared light, also referred to as terahertz
radiation. Radio waves in this band have wavelengths from hundred to one
millimeter.
Compared to lower bands, radio waves in this band have high atmospheric
attenuation; they are absorbed by the gases in the atmosphere. Therefore they have
a short range and can only be used for terrestrial communication over about a
kilometer. In particular, signals in the 57–64 GHz region are subject to a resonance
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 26
of the oxygen molecule and are severely attenuated. Even over relatively short
distances, rain fade is a serious problem, caused when absorption by rain reduces
signal strength. In climates other than deserts absorption due to humidity also has
an impact on propagation. While this absorption limits potential communications
range, it also allows for smaller frequency reuse distances than lower frequencies.
The short wavelength allows modest size antennas to have a small beam width,
further increasing frequency reuse potential.
One of the main facades of ROF is mm wave generation. Due to complex
technique and expense of electrical components – mixers, amplifiers – in high
frequency, say above 40GHz [30], an effective technique was required for mm
wave generation. ROF technology gives a solution to it. Broadly speaking about
this technology, we modulate a laser source by an intensity as well as phase
modulator. Modulating frequency is a low range RF signal (10 to 15 GHz
approximately). Generated mm wave at the BS will depend on this modulating
frequency and the modulation technique only. This external modulation includes
the techniques like Double side band (DSB), Single side band (SSB) and Optical
carrier Suppression (OCS) [30]. The order of these sidebands decide the factor,
after multiplying with which the modulating RF signal generates the high
frequency mm wave at the BS.
On the wireless side, the broadband wireless technology has an interest in
the use of mm-wave, specifically radio frequency of71–76 GHz and 81–86 GHz
[33,34]. Due to wireless systems operating in the 71–76 GHz and 81–86 GHz
bands owing a narrower radiation pattern of antennas, mm-wave technology could
provide minimal interference to other adjacent links except those lying directly
along the intended path. At conventional microwave frequencies up to 20 GHz,
atmospheric absorption is reasonably low. However, when microwave frequencies
rise to around 60 GHz, the absorption by oxygen molecules results in a peak
attenuation of 15 dB/km. As a consequence, conventional microwave system is
seriously limited by radio transmission distances. After 60 GHz, a large frequency
window opens, where the attenuation drops to less than 1 dB/km (effectively
negligible) before rising again due to other molecular effects. Thus, the spectrum
band from around 70 GHz to around 120 GHz exhibits low atmospheric
attenuation and other advantages for broadband wireless application.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 27
Fig. 3.7: Attenuation for microwave and millimeter wave range (1GHz to 300GHz)
Hence we are concentrating on this window. There are two targeted band to
be worked on. Those bands are 70-76GHz and 81-88GHz. Hence we choose the
two frequencies of our aimed dual frequency mm wave as 72GHz and 84GHz.
CHAPTER 3: RADIO OVER FIBER 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 28
CHAPTER 4 PROPOSED SYSTEM
4.1 Proposed Central Station Here, my proposed system is a downlink system in RoF communication
consisting one Central station (CS) and two Base Stations (BS). Downlink in RoF
system refers to the flow of data from CS to BS. In my system, a 1550nm Laser
source is being modulated by the RF frequency of 12GHz. A local oscillator is
used for this RF signal. This modulation is done by external modulator. In this case
the external modulator is Mach Zhender Modulator (MZM). We take one
unbalanced MZM to modulate 193.548THz (1550 nm wavelength) optical signal
with 12GHz RF signal. The modulation is basically an intensity modulation as well
as phase modulation. After modulation various sideband harmonic components is
available and we use one such component to be modulated with the baseband data,
generated by CS. This RF modulated optical signal acts as carrier and carry the
baseband NRZ data towards the specific BS. This transmission is done via optical
fibre cable. In a BS , the obtained data modulated optical signal is fed to a photo
detector. The output of the photo detector would be the NRZ baseband data
modulated RF signal at certain frequency. This frequency will be determined by
the sideband components allowed to pass. Using a filter the required frequency RF
signal can be taken and transmitted via antenna over a wireless medium.
Fig. 4.1: Block Diagram of the proposed ROF downlink Central Station
CHAPTER 4: PROPOSED SYSTEM 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 29
4.2 Component Analysis Here we analyse the proposed system block wise. There are four distinct
blocks in the proposed Central station of this RoF downlink system. These blocks
are,
• Modulator (MZM)
• Interleaver
• Fibre Bragg Grating
• Coupler
We may discuss each block separately with its mathematical interpretation.
Relevant block diagrams also be given.
4.2.1 Mach Zehnder Modulator In a central station electrical signal is converted into optical signal.
External modulator MZM modulates the 1550nm Laser light signal with
12GHz RF signal. Local oscillator generates this RF signal. 12GHz RF
signal is fed to unbalanced MZM. This MZM has a unique property to
suppress either odd or even order sideband harmonics.
Let the optical signal frequency be denoted by ω and RF signal
frequency is ωRF.
So an MZM will give an output containing side bands ω±n*ωRF ;
Where n is either odd integer or even integer, depending on the transfer
function of that particular MZM. An unbalanced MZM modulates an optical
signal with a RF signal when subjected to bias voltage. This bias voltage
governs the interference pattern of Mach Zhender Interferometer (MZI), thus
controls the phase modulation of the signal. In this way in an unbalance
MZM both the intensity and phase modulation are taken place.
CHAPTER 4: PROPOSED SYSTEM 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 30
Fig. 4.2: Unbalanced Mach Zehnder Modulator (MZM)
The most common modulator used in RoF systems is the
Mach{Zehnder modulator, which is based on a Mach Zehnder
interferometric structure. In a MZM an electrical voltage induces phase shift
between the two arms of the interferometer and depending upon the quantity
of phase shift, constructive or destructive interference occurs. This
interference results in intensity modulation of the optical signal by the
electrical voltage applied.
Figure 4.2 shows the schematic of a MZM. The electrical voltage
induced optical phase shift can be expressed as:
∅t� = �� .
�/012�� + �45
�� . 6782�9:;��< (4.1)
where Vп is the voltage required to induce a п phase shift. The
parameter Vп is an intrinsic property of the modulator which depends on
various design parameter and the material used. Considering an unbalanced
MZ modulator with a finite extinction ratio ε the optical field at the output of
the MZM can be written as:
=��� = =�� cos>∅��? cos2�9@�� (4.2)
Now after replacing ∅t� in the above equation we get;
=��� = =�� cos A�� .�/012�� + �45
�� . 6782�9:;��<B cos2�9@�� (4.3)
4.2.2 Optical Interleaver After MZM the modulated signal is passed through an interleaver
setup. Basic work of this setup is to first drop some desired component from
CHAPTER 4: PROPOSED SYSTEM 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 31
the main signal and then combined those dropped components to a separate
channel. Interleaver in this case is a 1X2 port device. It means one signal
input is processed and divided into two channels of output.
Interleaver setup acts as add-drop multiplexer. Here we take the input
in a single channel with 2*ωRF GHz separation of the sideband components.
This input is nothing but the output of the unbalanced MZM. Interleaver first
drops the frequency components with a separation of 4*ωRF, which is double
the separation of the input channel. Now the dropped components are added
to an output channel, say channel 1. The remaining frequency components of
that modulated signal will pass through the output channel 2.
Hence in this interleaver the separation bandwidth of the frequency
components of the input channel is say ω GHz and that of two output channel
is twice of ω GHz. In this way we separate out frequency components from
the same modulated signal for two different Base Stations (BS).
4.2.3 Fiber Brag Grating Fiber Bragg grating (FBG) is a periodic perturbation of the refractive
index along the Fibre length which is formed by exposure of the core to an
intense optical interference pattern.
Now in the particular system proposed, some modifications are done to
achieve a dual frequency signal at a single BS. The baseband data can be
transmitted with both the carrier RF signal. To achieve this kind of signal
some changes in the CS design are incorporated.
It is important to know the term “uniform Fibre Bragg grating”. A
grating is a device that periodically modifies the phase or the intensity of a
wave reflected on, or transmitted through, it [35]. The propagating wave is
reflected, if its wavelength equals Bragg resonance wavelength, λBragg
, in the
other case is transmitted. The uniform means that the grating period, Λ, and
the refractive index change, δη, are constant over whole length of the grating.
The equation relating the grating spatial periodicity and the Bragg resonance
wavelength is given by [35, 36]:
CHAPTER 4: PROPOSED SYSTEM
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION
where ηeff is effective mode index.
A typical uniform bragg grating can be explained in the diagram below;
Fig. 4
Here in our system Both the say Interleaver ‘b’.
FBGs separate the fourth order sideband harmonic components and fed those signal to respective intensity modulators (MZMs in this case).
4.1.1 Optical Coupler
A Fibre optic coupler
or more input Fibres and one or several output Fibres.
Fibre can appear at one or more outputs and its
depending on the
fabricated in different ways, for example by thermally fusing Fibres so that
their cores get into intimat
(supporting only a single mode per polarization direction for a given
wavelength), there are certain physical restrictions on the performance of the
coupler. In particular, it is not possible to combine two
same optical frequency into one single
significant excess losses.
CHAPTER 4: PROPOSED SYSTEM
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION 32
CDEFGG = 2�HIIΛeffective mode index.
A typical uniform bragg grating can be explained in the diagram
Fig. 4.3 Working principle of a Fibre Bragg Grating[36]
Here in our system Both the FBGs are connected to the 2say Interleaver ‘b’.
FBGs separate the fourth order sideband harmonic components and fed those signal to respective intensity modulators (MZMs in this case).
Optical Coupler
Fibre optic coupler is a device used in optical Fibre
or more input Fibres and one or several output Fibres. Light
Fibre can appear at one or more outputs and its power distribution
depending on the wavelength and polarization. Such couplers can be
fabricated in different ways, for example by thermally fusing Fibres so that
their cores get into intimate contact. If all involved Fibres are single
(supporting only a single mode per polarization direction for a given
wavelength), there are certain physical restrictions on the performance of the
coupler. In particular, it is not possible to combine two or more inputs of the
same optical frequency into one single-polarization output without
significant excess losses.
2015
B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI
(4.4)
A typical uniform bragg grating can be explained in the diagram
Working principle of a Fibre Bragg Grating[36]
FBGs are connected to the 2nd interleaver,
FBGs separate the fourth order sideband harmonic components and fed those signal to respective intensity modulators (MZMs in this case).
optical Fibre systems with one
Light entering an input
power distribution potentially
. Such couplers can be
fabricated in different ways, for example by thermally fusing Fibres so that
e contact. If all involved Fibres are single-mode
(supporting only a single mode per polarization direction for a given
wavelength), there are certain physical restrictions on the performance of the
or more inputs of the
polarization output without
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 33
CHAPTER 5 THEORETICAL MODELLING
5.1 Frequency Domain Analysis
In electronics, control systems engineering, and statistics, the frequency
domain refers to the analysis of mathematical functions or signals with respect to
frequency, rather than time. Put simply, a time-domain graph shows how a signal
changes over time, whereas a frequency-domain graph shows how much of the
signal lies within each given frequency band over a range of frequencies. A
frequency-domain representation can also include information on the phase shift
that must be applied to each sinusoid in order to be able to recombine the
frequency components to recover the original time signal.
A given function or signal can be converted between the time and frequency
domains with a pair of mathematical operators called a transform. An example is
the Fourier transform, which converts the time function into a sum of sine waves of
different frequencies, each of which represents a frequency component. The
'spectrum' of frequency components is the frequency domain representation of the
signal. The inverse Fourier transform converts the frequency domain function back
to a time function. A spectrum analyzer is the tool commonly used to visualize
real-world signals in the frequency domain.
The Fourier transform decomposes a function of time (a signal) into the
frequencies that make it up, similarly to how a musical chord can be expressed as
the amplitude (or loudness) of its constituent notes. The Fourier transform of a
function of time itself is a complex-valued function of frequency, whose absolute
value represents the amount of that frequency present in the original function, and
whose complex argument is the phase offset of the basic sinusoid in that
frequency. The Fourier transform is called the frequency domain representation of
the original signal. The term Fourier Transform refers to both the frequency
domain representation and the mathematical operation that associates the
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 34
frequency domain representation to a function of time. The Fourier transform is not
limited to functions of time, but in order to have a unified language, the domain of
the original function is commonly referred to as the time domain. For many
functions of practical interest one can define an operation that reverses this: the
inverse Fourier transformation, also called Fourier synthesis, of a frequency
domain representation combines the contributions of all the different frequencies to
recover the original function of time.
Linear operations performed in one domain (time or frequency) have
corresponding operations in the other domain, which are sometimes easier to
perform. The operation of differentiation in the time domain corresponds to
multiplication by the frequency, so some differential equations are easier to
analyze in the frequency domain. Also, convolution in the time domain
corresponds to ordinary multiplication in the frequency domain. Concretely, this
means that any linear time-invariant system, such as a filter applied to a signal, can
be expressed relatively simply as an operation on frequencies. After performing the
desired operations, transformation of the result can be made back to the time
domain. Harmonic analysis is the systematic study of the relationship between the
frequency and time domains, including the kinds of functions or operations that are
"simpler" in one or the other, and has deep connections to almost all areas of
modern mathematics. The spectrum of the signal x(t) can be obtained using fourier
transform. We can define the Fourier Transform as,
KLM� = N O��PQRS�T�UQU (5.1)
The time domain signal can be retrieved using Inverse Fourier Transform. It
can be formulated as,
O�� = 12�W KLM�PRS�TM5.2�
U
QU
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 35
Fig. 5.1: Basic representation of Fourier Transform
5.2 Bessel Function There are mainly two types of Bessel Function.
• Bessel Function of first kind
• Bessel Function of second kind
The third kind of Bessel Function is known as Henkel Function. It is not an independent function. It is a mathematical combination of Bessel Function of first kind and second kind.
Bessel functions, first defined by the mathematician Daniel Bernoulli and
generalized by Friedrich Bessel, are the canonical solutions y(x) of Bessel's
differential equation,
O� T�Y
TO� + OTYTO + O� − Z�� = 05.3�
for an arbitrary complex number α (the order of the Bessel function). Although α
and −α produce the same differential equation for real α, it is conventional to
define different Bessel functions for these two values in such a way that the Bessel
functions are mostly smooth functions of α.
The most important cases [73] are for α, an integer or half-integer. Bessel
functions for integer α are also known as cylinder functions or the cylindrical
harmonics because they appear in the solution to Laplace's equation in cylindrical
coordinates. Spherical Bessel functions with half-integer α, are obtained when the
Helmholtz equation is solved in spherical coordinates.
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 36
Bessel's equation arises when finding separable solutions to Laplace's
equation and the Helmholtz equation in cylindrical or spherical coordinates. Bessel
functions are therefore especially important for many problems of wave
propagation and static potentials. In solving problems in cylindrical coordinate
systems, one obtains Bessel functions of integer order (α = n); in spherical
problems, one obtains half-integer orders (α = n+1/2).
For example:
• Electromagnetic waves in a cylindrical waveguide
• Pressure amplitudes of inviscid rotational flows
• Heat conduction in a cylindrical object
• Modes of vibration of a thin circular (or annular) artificial membrane
(such as a drum or other membranophone)
• Diffusion problems on a lattice
• Solutions to the radial Schrödinger equation (in spherical and cylindrical
coordinates) for a free particle
• Solving for patterns of acoustical radiation
• Frequency-dependent friction in circular pipelines
• Dynamics of floating bodies
• Angular resolution
Bessel functions of the first kind, denoted as Jα(x), are solutions of Bessel's
differential equation that are finite at the origin (x = 0) for integer or positive α, and
diverge as x approaches zero for negative non-integer α. It is possible to define the
function by its series expansion around x = 0, which can be found by applying the
Frobenius method to Bessel's equation;[74]
\]O� = ^ −1�_`!b` + Z + 1� c
O2d
�_e] U
where Γ(z) is the gamma function, a shifted generalization of the factorial function
to non-integer values. The Bessel function of the first kind is an entire function if α
is an integer, otherwise it is a multi-valued function with singularity at zero. The
graphs of Bessel functions look roughly like oscillating sine or cosine functions
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION
that decay proportionally to 1/
their roots are not generally periodic, except asymptotically for large
indicates that −J1(x) is the derivative of
cos(x); more generally, the d
by the identities below
Fig 5.2: Plot of Bessel function of the first kind,
For non-integer
are therefore the two solutions of the differential equation. On the other hand, for
integer order α, the following relationship is valid (note that the Gamm
has simple poles at each of the non
This means that the two solutions are no longer linearly independent. In this
case, the second linearly independent solution is then found to be the Bessel
function of the second kind, as discussed below
Another definition of the Bessel function, for integ
using an integral representation:
Another integral representation is:
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION 37
that decay proportionally to 1/√x (see also their asymptotic forms below), although
their roots are not generally periodic, except asymptotically for large
) is the derivative of J0(x), much like -sin(x) is the derivative of
); more generally, the derivative of Jn(x) can be expressed in terms of
below.)
: Plot of Bessel function of the first kind, Jα(x), for integer orders α
integer α, the functions Jα(x) and J−α(x) are linearly independent, and
are therefore the two solutions of the differential equation. On the other hand, for
, the following relationship is valid (note that the Gamm
has simple poles at each of the non-positive integers):[75]
\Q�O� = −1��\�O�
This means that the two solutions are no longer linearly independent. In this
case, the second linearly independent solution is then found to be the Bessel
second kind, as discussed below
Another definition of the Bessel function, for integer values of
using an integral representation:[76]
\�O� = g� N cosh�i − O8jki�lTi�
@
Another integral representation is:[76]
\�O� = g�� N P�mnQo pqrn��Ti�
Q�
2015
B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI
(see also their asymptotic forms below), although
their roots are not generally periodic, except asymptotically for large x. (The series
) is the derivative of
) can be expressed in terms of Jn±1(x)
orders α = 0, 1, 2
) are linearly independent, and
are therefore the two solutions of the differential equation. On the other hand, for
, the following relationship is valid (note that the Gamma function
5.5�
This means that the two solutions are no longer linearly independent. In this
case, the second linearly independent solution is then found to be the Bessel
er values of n, is possible
5.6�
5.7�
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION
This was the approach that Bessel used, and from this definition he derived
several properties of the function. The definition may be extended to non
orders by (for Re(x
\]O� � 1�W�
@
The Bessel functions of the second kind, denoted by
denoted instead by
have a singularity at the origin (
called Weber functions as they were introduced by
Neumann functions after
Fig. 5.3: Plot of Bessel function of the second kind,
For non-integer α
In the case of integer order
non-integer α tends to
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION 38
This was the approach that Bessel used, and from this definition he derived
several properties of the function. The definition may be extended to non
x) > 0), one of Schläfli's integrals:[76]
W cosZi O8jki� Ti sinZ��� W PQo pqrwU
@
The Bessel functions of the second kind, denoted by Y
denoted instead by Nα(x), are solutions of the Bessel differential equation that
have a singularity at the origin (x = 0) and are multivalued. These are sometimes
called Weber functions as they were introduced by H. Weber
Neumann functions after Carl Neumann.
Plot of Bessel function of the second kind, Yα(x), for integer orders
integer α, Yα(x) is related to Jα(x) by:
x]O� � \]O� cosZ�� \Q]O�sinZ��
In the case of integer order n, the function is defined by taking the limit as a
tends to n:
x�O� � lim]→�x]O�
2015
B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI
This was the approach that Bessel used, and from this definition he derived
several properties of the function. The definition may be extended to non-integer
pqrw��Q]�T�5.8� [41-43]
Yα(x), occasionally
Bessel differential equation that
. These are sometimes
H. Weber (1873), and also
), for integer orders α = 0, 1, 2.
5.9�
, the function is defined by taking the limit as a
5.10�
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 39
There is also a corresponding integral formula (for Re(x) > 0),[74]
x�O� � 1�W sinO8jk
�
@~ − k~�T~ − 1
�W >P�� + −1�PQ��?PQo�����U
@
5.11�
Yα(x) is necessary as the second linearly independent solution of the Bessel's
equation when α is an integer. But Yα(x) has more meaning than that. It can be
considered as a 'natural' partner of Jα(x). See also the subsection on Hankel
functions below.
When α is an integer, moreover, as was similarly the case for the functions of
the first kind, the following relationship is valid:
xQ�O� = −1��x�O�5.12) Both Jα(x) and Yα(x) are holomorphic functions of x on the complex plane cut
along the negative real axis. When α is an integer, the Bessel functions J are entire
functions of x. If x is held fixed at a non-zero value, then the Bessel functions are
entire functions of α.
The Bessel functions of the second kind when α is an integer is an example of
the second kind of solution in Fuchs's theorem.
Another important formulation of the two linearly independent solutions to
Bessel's equation are the Hankel functions of the first and second kind, Hα(1)(x)
and Hα(2)(x), defined by:[75]
�](g)(O) = \](O) + jx](O)(5.13) �](�)(O) = \](O) − jx](O)(5.14)
where i is the imaginary unit. These linear combinations are also known as Bessel
functions of the third kind; they are two linearly independent solutions of Bessel's
differential equation. They are named after Hermann Hankel.
The importance of Hankel functions of the first and second kind lies more in
theoretical development rather than in application. These forms of linear
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 40
combination satisfy numerous simple-looking properties, like asymptotic formulae
or integral representations. Here, 'simple' means an appearance of the factor of the
form eif(x). The Bessel function of the second kind then can be thought to naturally
appear as the imaginary part of the Hankel functions.
The Hankel functions are used to express outward- and inward-propagating
cylindrical wave solutions of the cylindrical wave equation, respectively (or vice
versa, depending on the sign convention for the frequency).
Using the previous relationships they can be expressed as:
�]g�O� � \Q]O� PQ]��\]O�jsin(Z�) (5.15)
�](�)(O) = \Q](O) − P]��\](O)−jsin(Z�) (5.16)
If α is an integer, the limit has to be calculated. The following relationships are
valid, whether α is an integer or not:
�Q](g)(O) = P]���](g)(O)(5.17) �Q](�)(O) = PQ]���](�)(O)(5.18)
In particular, if α = m + 1/2 with m a nonnegative integer, the above relations
imply directly that
\Qc_eg�d(O) = (−1)_egx_eg�(O)(5.19) xQc_eg�d(O) = (−1)_\_eg�(O)(5.20)
These are useful in developing the spherical Bessel functions .
5.3 Mathematical Modelling of Proposed Central Station Central Station of a ROF downlink system is being designed here.
Mathematical realization of the central station and the corresponding plotting of
the obtained equation are shown in this chapter.
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 41
External modulation of this ROF downlink system is done with two MZMs.
Continuous Wave (CW) laser source gives optical signal of angular frequency ω0.
The field of this signal can be given as E0=A0exp(jω0t). Amplitude of the field is
A0. External modulators modulate the intensity of the lightwave. As we use
balanced MZM we need a driving RF signal. Local oscillator generates this RF
signal with an angular frequency of ωLO. The Rf signal can be represented as
V(t)=VLOcos(ωLOt).
DC bias voltage Vbias is used for the required phase modulation of the MZM,as
it is an intensity as well as phase modulator.
So, we can write the governing equation of MZM as,
=��� � =@ cos(ω@t) cos[Φ(V(t))] (5.21)
Where, �(�(�)) = п� .�/012�� + ����� . cos(2п9:;�)< (5.22)
As we know Vп is the half wave voltage. That means at Vп bias voltage the
phase difference between two arms of the MZM is п.
Let us assume � = �� . �/012�п
And ̀ = �� . ����п
So, we can write the MZM equation as,
=��� = =�� cos(� + `. cos(M���)) . cos(M@�)
= =��[cos(�) . cos(`. cos(~) − sin(�) . sin(`. cos(~))] . cos(M@�) (5.23)
Where, ~ = M��� We can further simplify the equation as,
=��� = =���678�. cos(`. 678~)�. cos(M@�) − =���sin �. sin(`. 678~)�. cos(M@�) = =��[cos ��cos(`. 678 ~). 678(M@�)�. sin ��sin(`. 678~). cos(M@�)�]
(5.24)
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 42
Hence the equation will be,
=��� � =�� cos ��\@(`) cosM@�+^[\��(`) cos(M@� + 2kM��� − k�)+ \��(`) cos(M@� − 2kM��� + k�)+ =�� sin b �^\��Qg(`) cos(M@� + (2k − 1)M�� = k�)+ \��Qg(`)cos(M@� − (2k − 1)M��� + k�)�
(5.25)
Jn(m) is the nth order Bessel function of the first kind.
As we have two MZMs for external modulation, the outputs are, say Eout1 and
Eout2 for MZM1 and MZM2 respectively. Now MZM1 suppresses the odd order
sidebands. Hence for MZM1 sin b value should be 0 and the cos b value should be
1.
If,
Cos b=1; b=nπ;
So the output from the MZM1 is,
=���g = =���\@(`) cosM@�+^[\��(`) cos(M@� + 2kM��� − k�)+ \��(`) cos(M@� − 2kM��� + k�)]�
(5.26)
For MZM2, the output will only be the odd order sidebands,
=���� = =���^[\��Qg(`) cos(M@� + (2k − 1)M��� − k�)+ \��Qg(`) cos(M@� − (2k − 1)M��� + k�)]�
(5.27)
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 43
Fig. 5.4: Modulated signal after MZM1 and MZM2
Here we are taking an approximation and hence neglecting the higher order
terms. We neglect the sidebands starting from the 5th order. Hence the equation no
(A) and (B) can be written as
=���g �=��[\@`� cos(M@�) − \�(`) cos(M@� + 2M���)+ \�(`) cos(M@� + 4M���) − \�(`) cos(M@� − 2M���)+ \�(`) cos(M@� − M���)]
(5.28)
And,
=���� ==��[−\g(`) cos(M@� + M���) + \�(`) cos(M@� + 3M���)− \g(`) cos(M@� − M���) + \�(`) cos(M@� − 3M���)]
(5.29)
Hence from MZM1 we get the modulated carrier signal along with its 2nd and
4th order sideband frequencies. MZM2 gives only the 1st and the 3rd order
sidebands and suppressing the optical carrier component itself. Outputs from
MZM1 and MZM2 are fed to the interleaver system Int1 and Int2 respectively.
An optical interleaver system can be designed by add drop multiplexers.
With the help of interleaver specific order sidebands can be selected for a single
channel. Before feeding to the Int1 the carrier component of the frequency ω0 is
dropped using an FBG. Two different output channels of the Int1 gives us the
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 44
signal containing sideband components of the frequency (ω0+2ωLO; ω0 – 4ωLO )
and (ω0 –2ωLO; ω0 +4ωLO). Similarly the Int2 separates the odd order sideband
components and combines in two output channels having (+1, –3) and (–1, +3)
order of sidebands. Now here we consider two BSs, connected to one CS. So these
8 sideband components (±1,±2,±3,±4) will again coupled to the separate channels
designed for the two BSs. After the interleavers we separate out the ±4th order
components from both the channel using FBG. These 4th order sideband signals are
being modulated by baseband data. This baseband data contains the processed
information for the end user. For this data modulation we use a 1Gbps electrical
signal with Pseudo Random Bit Sequence of the length 212-1. Higher order data
could not be plotted using Matlab due to approximation error.
We denote the data sequence by b(t). It is Non-Return to Zero (NRZ) data
and it modulates the 4th order sidebands in two different simple balanced MZMs.
Fig. 5.5: PRBS (NRZ) data; Baseband data
The general equation of the output of the MZMs can be written as;
=�F�F � \�`�=��678[ø��?. cos(M@ ± 4M��)� (5.30)
Where,
ø(�) = �(�)�� . �2
Hence the output of the MZM can be written as,
=�F�F = \�(`)=�� cos ��(�)�� . �2� cos(M@ ± 4M��)� (5.31)
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 45
Fig. 5.6: Response after FBG (Baseband data modulates the freq component)
Optical coupler is used to reconstruct the signal and send those to the BSs via
optical fibre.
For BS1,
=D�g � =��{ \g`� cos(M@� + M���) − \�(`) cos(M@� − 2M���)+ \�(`) cos(M@� − 3M���) + \�(`) cos(M@� + 4M���) cos ��(�)�� . �2�
(5.32)
For BS2,
=D�� = =���−\g(`) cos(M@� − M���) − \�(`) cos(M@� + 2M���)+ \�(`) cos(M@� + 3M���) + \�(`) cos(M@� − 4M���) cos ��(�)�� . �2�
(5.33)
CHAPTER 5: THEORETICAL MODELLING 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 46
Fig. 5.7: Output of the Central Station (towards base stations)
These two signals EBS1 and EBS2 will be transmitted through optical fibre
towards the respective Base Stations. Here the signal is presented in both the dB
scale and linear scale. Power level of the signal is high here. After the transmission
through optical fiber, attenuation will take place due to fiber losses.
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 47
CHAPTER 6 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
6.1 Analysis of Central Station We simulated our proposed design of Central Station for a downlink ROF
system. For that we used Optisystem 13.0 software and get the results. In software
simulation we consider
• Losses due to laser source
• Splitting ratio and extinction ratio of MZM
• Losses due to passive optical components, such as FBG, add-drop
multiplexer,etc.
• Also the optical fibre length and hence losses due to optical fibre
We took the initial parameters as follows,
Parameter Symbol Values
Wavelength of laser sources λ 1550.388nm
Frequency of laser sources fOP 193.5 THz
Frequency of RF signal fRF 12 GHz
Data Signal: PBRS 231- 1; Bit Rate: 2.5 Gbps
Table 6.1: Important design parameters for downlink system
The design of the proposed Central Station in Optiwave 13.0 is shown below
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 48
Fig. 6.1: Design of the Central station of ROF downlink in Optiwave 13.0
6.1.1 Mach Zehdner Modulator This graph Fig. 6.2 (a)-(b) shows the output of both the MZMs (MZM1
and MZM2). For MZM1 even order suppression is applicable. So in the first
part we may see -3,-1,+1,+3 components are there. So we have got peaks at
193.464THz, 193.488THz, 193.512THz and 193.536THz
Second part consists of -4,-2,+2,+4 components along with the carrier
frequency itself. So we have got peaks at 193.452THz, 193.476THz,
193.5THz, 193.524THz and 193.548THz
(a)
(b) Fig. 6.2: (a) Output of MZM1; suppressing the even order sidebands; (b) Output of MZM2;
suppressing the odd order components along with the carrier
Interleaver
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 49
The results in this simulation are quite similar with the theoretical graphs,
plotted in MATLAB. But due to extinction ratio and chirp of the MZMs and
also for the linewidth of the laser source we get some noises along with the
desired frequency components. To eliminate those noises we use here optical
rectangular filters. The filters output for MZM1 and MZM2 are in Fig. 6.3.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 6.3: (a) Filtered output of MZM1; (b) Filtered output of MZM2
6.1.2 Optical Interleaver This graph Fig 6.4 represents both the channels 1 and 2 for the interleaver
‘a’ and ‘b’. Here two interleavers separate the entire signal in different
channels. At first it combines (+1,-3); (-1,+3); (-2,+4); (+2,-4) components of
the modulated signal. Then finally it combines to give the (+1,-2,-3) and
(-1,+2,+3) order of sidebands together. The ±4th order sidebands are separated
for baseband data multiplication.
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 50
(a)
(b)
Fig. 6.4: (a)-(b) Combination of selected order of sidebands after interleaver
setup
6.1.3 Baseband Data Modulation We modulate the electrical baseband data with the ±4th order sidebands of
the modulated optical-millimeter wave signal. The baseband data is a pseudo
random sequence of Non Return to Zero (NRZ) bits with bit rate of 2.5Gbps.
That means with a Spectral Efficiency of 1 the frequency of the baseband data
is 2.5GHz.
Fig. 6.5: NRZ PRBS data sequence with bitrate 2.5Gbps
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 51
Now this baseband data stream modulates the ±4th order sideband of that
optical-mm wave signal.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 6.6: Baseband data, modulated with (a) +4 component; (b) -4 component
6.1.4 Optical Coupler At the end of the central station the fourth order sideband component is
added with other frequency components and those signals are transmitted to
the respective Base Stations via optical fiber cable.
This graph Fig 6.7 shows the output of optical coupler. It’s also the output
of central station. This combined signal will go to base station via OFC.
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 52
(a)
(b)
Fig. 6.7: Final output signal of Central Station transmitted towards (a) BS1 and
(b) BS2
6.2 Analysis of Laser Source Continuous Wave (CW) lasers are used as a source for our proposed ROF
system. Every laser has its own linewidth. By varying linewidth of a laser we
might get different results. Also the variation of the initial laser power is analyzed.
6.2.1 Variation of Linewidth The linewidth (or line width) of a laser, typically a single-frequency laser,
is the width (typically the full width at half-maximum, FWHM) of its optical
spectrum. More precisely, it is the width of the power spectral density of the
emitted electric field in terms of frequency, wave number or wavelength.
The spectral coherence depends on the linewidth of the laser. The narrower
the linewidth the more spectrally coherent the laser is. Hence in Optiwave 13.0
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION
we change the linewidth values of both the laser to 1 MHz,
500MHz. We obtained the following results, shown in the figure
Fig. 6.8: Output signal of
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION 53
the linewidth values of both the laser to 1 MHz,
500MHz. We obtained the following results, shown in the figure
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 6.8: Output signal of ROF Central Station with various Laser Linewidth;
(a) 1MHz; (b) 100MHz; (c) 500 MHz
2015
B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI
the linewidth values of both the laser to 1 MHz, 100MHz and
500MHz. We obtained the following results, shown in the figure
ROF Central Station with various Laser Linewidth;
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 54
As we may infer from the results that the lower the linewidth the more the
coherency of the frequency components. We get sharp peaks for 1MHz
linewidth, which gradually flattens in lasers with the linewidth of 100MHz and
500M
6.3 Variation of Baseband Data As mentioned earlier, we have used PRBS data stream with NRZ pulses. The
bit rate was 2.5Gbps and the order of the PRBS is 231-1. Now we varied both the
bit rate and the type of data pulses to observe the corresponding effect on the
proposed ROF downlink system.
6.3.1 Type of Pulses We initially used the Non Return to Zero (NRZ) data pulses. With the
predefined spectral efficiency 1 the 2.5Gbps data gives us the frequency of
2.5GHz. To observe the differences we replaced the NRZ data pulses with
Return to Zero (RZ) pulses. Observations are as follows.
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Fig. 6.9: (a) data pattern of NRZ; (b) data pattern of RZ; Frequency domain representation (c) NRZ; (d) RZ
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 55
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Fig. 6.10: Fourth order sideband being modulated by (a) NRZ data; (b) RZ data; The final output of the CS when the baseband data pulses are (c) NRZ & (d) RZ
From these graphs we can say that the RZ data with similar bit rate and
similar spectral efficiency observes almost twice the frequency of the NRZ
data pulses. As it has higher frequency, after modulation with optical-mm
wave it overlaps with frequency components other than fourth order
component. Hence RZ data increases noise as well as power attenuation.
Observed power for RZ data pulses is almost half of the observed power for
NRZ data pulses. We have got the following observation at the end of the
central station.
Type of Pulses Power in mW Power in dBm
NRZ data 18.579 -17.310
RZ data 9.942 -20.025
Table. 6.2: Observed signal power at the end of the CS
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 56
6.3.2 Variation of Data Rate Initially we successfully used a data rate of 2.5Gbps. But the future
objective of the proposed ROF system is to achieve data rate of 40Gbps and
more. Hence in simulation we vary the data rate from 2.5Gbps to 40Gbps and
observe the changes. Four distinct values of data rate are given below.
Fig. 6.11: Baseband modulation done with various datarate; (a)2.5Gbps; (b) 5Gbps;
(c) 25Gbps; (d) 40Gbps
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 57
As we can witness the higher the data rate be the more the overlap between
two frequency components is happening. Hence in future to attain such higher
rate through ROF system we have to increase the spectral efficiency, so that the
overlapping doesn’t occur.
6.4 Millimeter Wave Generation One of the important aspects of the ROF technology is to generate mm-wave
signal generation. Though mm-wave is generated at the Base Station, Central
Station provides the required frequency components and suppresses the others.
6.4.1 Experimental Setup In our Fiber Optic Research Lab, BIT, Mesra, we setup an experimental
arrangement to generate mm-wave signal with the help of available Laser
source, FBGs, Optical Couplers, Attenuators, Optical Spectrum Analyser
(OSA) and Digital Storage Oscilloscope (DSO).
Components used Specification Purpose
Tunable Laser Source (TLS) AQ321D Model
Range: 1520nm – 1620nm
Resolution: 0.001nm
Use as a laser source
WDM setup Inbuilt 1550nm Laser source and PIN detector
Use as a laser source and also use for detection
Fiber Bragg Grating (FBG) 1550.4nm with 0.25nm FWHM
Use for filtering the noise
Optical Coupler NeST photonics 2X2 3dB coupler
Use to combine two laser sources
Optical Spectrum Analyser (OSA)
Wavelength range:
600nm -1750nm
Resolution: 0.015nm
To observe the optical spectrum
Digital Storage Oscilloscope ScienTECH 7040M To observe the generated mm wave
Table. 6.3: Components used for experiments and their specifications
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 58
The experimental setup is given below.
Fig 6.12: WDM setup with Laser source and internal PIN detector and Digital Storage
Oscilloscope
Fig. 6.13: Tunable Laser source
Fig. 6.14: OSA shows the optical spectrum of both the laser sources after combining
using a 3dB coupler
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 59
Fig. 6.15: Setup of the central station with TLS and OSA for mm wave generation
Fig. 6.16: Setup of the CS continued… with FBG and optical couplers.
Now we take the readings from DSO and it is observed in Fig. 6.17.
Fig. 6.17: Final Frequency spectrum of the mm wave signal after BS
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 60
6.4.2 Simulation Analysis Experimentally we did not get the exact frequency peak of 20GHz for the
aimed mm-wave. Then we simulate the experimental setup in Optiwave 13.0
to find out exact problem.
Fig. 6.18: Simulation data for the single Laser and the combined Lasers after the 3dB
coupler with the laboratory specifications
Fig. 6.19: Simulated frequency profile of the generated mm wave with laboratory
specifications
CHAPTER 6: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 61
Here we can see that the simulation results and the experimental results are
same. Both could not show the frequency peak. Now we simulate the same
setup with a laser source with narrow linewidth.
Fig. 6.20: Combining two laser sources with narrower linewidth
Fig. 6.21: Simulation result for the generated mm wave signal with a frequency of
37.5GHz
Now with the same laser wavelength and narrow laser linewidth we have
got the frequency peak of the mm-wave signal, which was aimed. Hence we
can infer due to very large linewidth of the lasers available in our laboratory
the power got distributed and we could not obtain the exact frequency
component.
CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION AND FUTURE SCOPE 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 62
CHAPTER 7 CONCLUSION AND FUTURE SCOPE
7.1 Conclusion A simplified Central Station in RoF downlink system is designed. It uses
external modulation technique to modulate a laser optical source with RF local
oscillator frequency. This modulated signal itself acts as carrier in RoF technology.
For this carrier to modulate there is a baseband NRZ data stream. This data
generated in central station is transmitted via this modulated signal. We design CS
in such a way, so that we get two frequency components after frequency
multiplication at Base Stations. Central Stations can be a little complicated, but
Base stations are less complicated and mobile. We target to get dual band around
70GHz to 110GHz as in this window the signal attenuation is less. Instead of
unbalanced MZM we may use the LiNbO3 crystal MZM for modulation.
The aim of the downlink system is to provide exact modulation and
interleaving technique so that desired frequency multiplication can be obtained at
the Base Station. Here in the proposed system the initial RF signal frequency is
getting multiplied by factors of 6 and 7 to generate a dual frequency millimeter
wave at the Base Station. A dual frequency mm wave signal having frequency
components at 72 GHz and 84 GHz were generated by means of a PIN diode.
A phase shift in the data signal was observed which occurs due to dispersive
nature of the optical fibre. A good performance of the system for transmitting the
data over 80km of SSMF is aimed at. For the 2.5Gbps baseband data the power
penalty for the downlink system should be approximately less than 0.6 dB for a
BER of 10-9.
7.2 Flexibility of dual frequency mm wave One of the uniqueness of the proposed ROF system is the flexibility in the
range of the generated mm wave. As the generated mm wave signal has dual
frequency components with a separation equal to the initial RF signal in the range
of tens of GHz, the single system can be used for multiple purposes. Data
transmission will be more secure and accurate.
CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION AND FUTURE SCOPE 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 63
Also we can vary the frequency components just changing the value of a
single RF signal which is initially present at CS. Every other components and the
entire technique will be the same. Hence it increases the flexibility of the system.
7.3 Future Scope Broadband wireless links integrated with optical access networks need to
mature before becoming a reality. The integration of wireless and wired services
will be the crucial motivation for implementation of such network architectures.
Photonic generation techniques offer the flexibility, but transparency at higher
network protocol layers must be considered. The optical downlinks carrying these
high capacity wireless links mainly rely on the electro-optic modulator, which
operates at the mm Wave frequency.
Currently modulators up to 100 GHz are available, but when higher
frequency bands are considered, devices working at such high frequencies must be
investigated. Optical coherent detection is maturing and commercial
implementation of such devices will happen in the near future. Coherent detection
in radio over fiber will play a crucial link, especially demonstrating the ability of
direct conversion of optical baseband to RF signal. New algorithms can be
investigated which will provide more robustness to phase noise, and higher
linewidth devices like VCSELS can be used to reduce the cost of the systems.
ROF technology is a relatively new area of research. So there are lot of
detailed aspects which can be explored in recent future. Regarding our proposed
system various scopes of work are there for future.
The future scope of work in our proposed system is;
• To realize the entire system in experimental setup.
• To design and fabricate each components of the system.
• Introducing phase noises and laser fabrication defects into the studies.
• Designing of Dual Band antenna for transmission of the signal from
the Base Station.
• Designing of Wide Band filter or Dual band Notch filter.
• To make our proposed architecture a duplex system.
• To enhance the data rate beyond 40Gbps efficiently.
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 64
REFERENCES
[1] A. M. Odlyzko, “Internet traffc growth: sources and implications, in Optical
Transmission Systems and Equipment for WDM Networking II”, (Orlando,
FL), 2003.
[2] R. J. Mears, L. Reekie, I. M. Jauncey, and D. N. Payne, “Low-noise Erbium
doped fiber ampli_er operating at 1.45 µm,” Electron. Lett., vol. 23, no. 19,
pp. 109-111, 1987.
[3] P. R. Trischitta and W. C. Marra, “Global undersea communication
networks," IEEE Commun. Mag., vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 20{21, 1996.
[4] N. S. Bergano, “Undersea Communication Systems.” Academic Press,
Optical Fiber Telecommunications IVB Components ed., 2002.
[5] ITU Recommendation, “Gigabit-capable passive optical networks (GPON).”
ITU-T, 2003.
[6] IEEE P802.3av Task Force, IEEE Std 802.3av-2009 “10 Gbps Ethernet
passive optical network.” IEEE, New York.
[7] P. P. Iannone, K. C. Reichmann, C. R. Doerr, L. L. Buhl, M. A. Cappuzzo, E.
Y. Chen, L. T. Gomez, J. E. Johnson, A. M. Kanan, J. L. Lentz, and R.
McDonough, “A 40 Gbps CWDM-TDM PON with a cyclic CWDM
multiplexer/demultiplexer," in 32nd European Conference on Optical
Communications, ECOC'09, (Vienna, Austria), 2009. Paper 8.5.6
[8] P. J. Winzer, G. Raybon, and M. Duelk, “107-Gbps optical ETDM
transmission for 100 G Ethernet transport," in 31st European Conference on
Optical Communications, ECOC'05, (Glasgow, Scotland), 2005. Paper
Th.4.1.1.
[9] IEEE P802.3ba “40Gbps and 100Gbps Ethernet Task Force”, IEEE Std.
802.3ba-2010. IEEE, New York.
[10] D. van den Borne, S. L. Jansen, E. Gottwald, E. D. Schmidt, G. D. Khoe, and
H. de Waardt, “DQPSK modulation for robust optical transmission,” in
Conference on Optical Fiber communication/National Fiber Optic Engineers
Conference, 2008. OFC/NFOEC 2008., (San Diego, CA), 2008. Paper OMQ1.
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 65
[11] P. Bo_, M. Ferrario, L. Marazzi, P. Martelli, P. Parolari, A. Righetti, R. Siano,
and M. Martinelli, “Stable 100-Gb/s POLMUX-DQPSK transmission with
automatic polarization stabilization,” IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 21, no.
11, pp. 745-747, 2009.
[12] A. Sano, E. Yoshida, H. Masuda, T. Kobayashi, E. Yamada, Y. Miyamoto, F.
Inuzuka, Y. Hibino, Y. Takatori, K. Hagimoto, T. Yamada, and Y. Sakamaki,
“30 × 100-Gbps all-optical OFDM transmission over 1300 km SMF with 10
ROADM nodes," in 33rd European Conference on Optical Communications,
ECOC'07, (Berlin, Germany), 2007. Postdeadline Paper PD 1.7.
[13] S. Chandrasekhar and X. Liu, “Experimental investigation on the
performance of closely spaced multi-carrier PDM-QPSK with digital coherent
detection," Optics express, vol. 17, no. 24, pp. 21350-213061, 2009.
[14] J. A. Wells, “Faster than fiber: the future of multi-Gbps wireless," IEEE
Microw. Mag., vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 104-112, 2009.
[15] X. Hao, V. Kukshya, and T. S.Rappaport, “Spatial and temporal
characteristics of 60-GHz indoor channels," IEEE J. Sel. Areas Commun., vol.
20, no. 3, pp. 620-630, 2002.
[16] I. P. Kaminow and E. H. Turner, “Electro-optic light modulators,” Appl.
Optics., vol. 5, no. 10, pp. 1612-1620, 1966.
[17] Jäger, D., “Traveling-wave optoelectronic devices for microwave and optical
applications”, in Proceedings of the Progress in Electromagnetics Research
Symposium (PIERS), Beijing, China, 1991, p. 327.
[18] Jäger, D., “Microwave photonics, in Optical Information Technology,” Smith,
S.D. and Neale, R.F., Eds., Springer-Verlag, New York, 1993, p. 328.
[19] Polifko, D. and Ogawa, H., “The merging of photonic and microwave
technologies,” Microwave J., 35, 75, 1992.
[20] Seeds, A.J., “Microwave photonics,” IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory
Technol., 50, 877, 2002.
[21] Vilcot, A., Cabon, B., and Chazelas, J., “Microwave Photonics,” Kluwer
Academic Publishers, Boston, MA, 2003.
[22] Jäger, D. and Stöhr, A., “Microwave photonics—From concepts to
applications,” in Proceedings of German Microwave Conference (GeMiC
2005), Menzel, W., Ed., Ulm, Germany, 2005, p. 136.
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 66
[23] Yao, J., “A tutorial on microwave photonics,” IEEE Photon. Soc. Newslett.,
26, 4, 2012.
[24] Hong Wen, Lin Chen, Cheng Huang, Shuangchun Wen., “A full-duplex radio-
over-fiber system using direct modulation laser to generate optical millimeter-
wave and wavelength reuse for uplink connection”, Optics Communications
281 (2008) 2083–2088
[25] J. He, L. Chen, Z. Dong, S. Wen, J. Yu, “Full-duplex radio-over-fiber system
with photonics frequency quadruples for optical millimeter-wave generation”,
Optical Fiber Technology 15 (2009) 290–295
[26] Jia Hu Zhu, Xu Guang Huang, Jin Ling Xie, “A full-duplex radio-over-fiber
system based on dual quadrupling-frequency”, Optics Communications 284
(2011) 729–734
[27] Jia Hu Zhu, Xu Guang Huang, Jin Tao, Jin Ling Xie, “A full-duplex radio-
over-fiber system based on frequency decupling”, Optics Communications
284 (2011) 2480–2484
[28] Jin Tao, Xuguang Huang, Jinling Xie, JiaHu Zhu, “Full-duplex radio-over-
fiber system based on a modified single-side band modulation”, Optics
Communications 283 (2010) 5130–5134
[29] Xie Jin-Ling, Huang Xu-Guang, Tao Jin, “ A full-duplex radio-over-fiber
system based on a novel double-sideband modulation and frequency
quadrupling”, Optics Communications 283 (2010) 874–878
[30] Guangming Cheng, Banghong Guo, Songhao Liu, Weijin Fang, “ A novel
full-duplex radio-over-fiber system based on dualoctupling-frequency for 82
GHz W-band radio frequency andwavelength reuse for uplink connection”,
Optik 125 (2014) 4072–4076
[31] Vishal Sharma, Amarpal Singh, Ajay K. Sharma, “Challenges to radio over
fiber (RoF) technology and its mitigation schemes – A review”, Optik 123
(2012) 338– 342
[32] R. Herschel, C. G. Schäffer, “Radio-over-Fiber Systems for Next Generation
Wireless Access”, 2011 International Students and Young Scientists
Workshop „Photonics and Microsystems
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 67
[33] 2011 International Students anZaid Al-Husseini, Niels Neumann, Dirk
Plettemeier, “Residual Carrier Influence on System Performance of a 60 GHz
Radio over Fiber System”, 2013 2nd International Workshop on Optical
Wireless Communications (IWOW) 978-1-4799-1188-2/13/$31.00 ©2013
IEEE
[34] B. Cabon & F. Brendel & J. Poette, “Comparisons of system architectures for
microwave-photonics transmissions at 60 GHz”, Ann. Telecommun. (2013)
68:41–48 DOI 10.1007/s12243-012-0328-5
[35] Chia-Chien Wei, Chun-Ting Lin, Ming-I Chao, and Wen-Jr Jiang,
“Adaptively Modulated OFDM RoF Signals at 60 GHz Over Long-Reach
100-km Transmission Systems Employing Phase Noise Suppression”, IEEE
Photonics Technology Letters, VOL. 24, NO. 1, January 1, 2012
[36] Kazuro Kikuchi, “Effect of llf-Type FM Noise on Semiconductor Laser
Linewidth Residual in High-Power Limit”, IEEE Journal Of Quantum
Electronics. Vol. 25. No. 4. April 1989
[37] Yang Zhao, Qiang Wang, Fei Meng, Yige Lin, Shaokai Wang, Ye Li, Baike
Lin, Shiying Cao, Jianping Cao, Zhanjun Fang, Tianchu Li, and Erjun Zang,
“High-finesse cavity external optical feedback DFB laser with hertz relative
linewidth”, November 15, 2012 / Vol. 37, No. 22 / Optics Letters
[38] Charles H. Henry, “ Phase Noise in Semiconductor Lasers”, Journal Of
Lightwave Technology, Vol. Lt-4, No. 3, March 1986
[39] Bjame Tromborg, Henning Olesen, and Xing Pan, “Theory of Linewidth for
Multielectrode Laser Diodes with Spatially Distributed Noise Sources”, IEEE
Journal Of Quantum Electronics, Vol. 27, No. 2, February 1991
[40] Kenneth O. Hill and Gerald Meltz, “Fiber Bragg Grating Technology
Fundamentals and Overview”, Journal Of Lightwave Technology, Vol. 15,
No. 8, August 1997
[41] Chun-Ting Lin, Jason (Jyehong) Chen, Sheng-Peng Dai, Peng-Chun Peng, and
Sien Chi, “Impact of Nonlinear Transfer Function and Imperfect Splitting
Ratio of MZM on Optical Up-Conversion Employing Double Sideband With
Carrier Suppression Modulation”, Journal Of Lightwave Technology, Vol. 26,
No. 15, August 1, 2008
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 68
[42] Mohmoud Mohamed, Xiupu Zhang, Bouchaib Hraimel and Ke Wu, “Analysis
of frequency quadrupling using a single Mach-Zehnder modulator for
millimeter-wave generation and distribution over fiber systems”, ©2008
Optical Society of America
[43] Po-Tsung Shih, Chun-Ting Lin, Wen-Jr Jiang, Jason (Jyehong) Chen, Han-
Sheng Huang, Yu-Hung Chen, Peng-Chun Peng, Sien Chi, “WDM up-
conversion employing frequency quadrupling in optical modulator”, ©2009
Optical Society of America
[44] T.H. Maiman, “Stimulated Optical Radiation in Ruby”, Nature, Vol.
187,pp.493-494,1960.
[45] W. Stephens and T. Joseph, “System characteristics of direct modulated and
externally modulated RF fiber-optic links,” J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 5, no. 3,
pp. 380-387, 1987.
[46] G. K. Gopalakrishnan, W. K. Burns, and C. H. Bulmer, “ Microwave-optical
mixing in LiNbO3 modulators,” IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., vol. 41,
no. 12, pp. 2383-2391, 1993.
[47] C. Cox III, E. Ackerman, R. Helkey, and G. E. Betts, “Techniques and
performance of intensity-modulation direct-detection analog optical links,”
IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., vol. 45, no. 8, pp. 1375-1383, 1997.
[48] T. Kurniawan, A. Nirmalathas, C. Lim, D. Novak, and R. Waterhouse,
“Performance analysis of optimized millimeter-wave fiber radio links,” IEEE
Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., vol. 54, no. 2, pp. 921-928, 2006.
[49] A. J. Seeds, C. H. Lee, E. Funk, and M. Nagamura, “Guest editorial:
Microwave photonics,” IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 21, no. 12, pp.
2959-2961, 2003.
[50] A. J. Seeds and K. J. Williams, “Microwave photonics,” J. Lightw. Technol.,
vol. 24, no. 12, pp. 4628-4641, 2006.
[51] D. Capmany, J. Novak, “Microwave photonics combines two worlds,” Nature
Photonics, vol. 1, pp. 319-330, 2007.
[52] C. H. Cox III and E. I. Ackerman, “Microwave photonics: Past, present and
future,” in 2008 International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics
jointly held with the 2008 Asia-Pacific Microwave Photonics Conference,
(Gold Coast, Australia), 2008
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 69
[53] E. I. Ackerman, W. K. Burns, G. E. Betts, J. X. Chen, J. L. Prince, M. D.
Regan, H. V. Roussell, and C. H. Cox III, “RF-Over-Fiber Links With Very
Low Noise Figure,” J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 26, no. 15, pp. 2441-2448, 2008.
[54] E. I. Ackerman and C. H. Cox III, “RF Fiber-optic link performance,” IEEE
Microw. Mag., vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 50-58, 2001.
[55] S. Hunziker and W. Baechtold, “Cellular remote antenna feeding: optical fiber
or coaxial cable?," Electron. Lett., vol. 34, no. 11, pp. 1038-1040, 1998.
[56] R. E. Schuh, A. Alping, and E. Sundberg, “Penalty-free GSM-1800 and
WCDMA radio-over-fiber transmission using multimode fiber and 850 nm
VECSEL,” Electron. Lett., vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 512-514, 2003.
[57] M. Sauer, A. Kobyakov, and J. George, “Radio over fiber for picocellular
network architectures,” J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 25, no. 11, pp. 3301-3320,
2007.
[58] T. E. Darcie, “Subcarrier multiplexing for lightwave networks and video
distribution systems,” IEEE J. Sel. Areas Commun., vol. 8, pp. 1240-1248,
1990.
[59] P. M. Hill and R. Olshansky, “A 20-channel optical communication using
subcarrier multiplexing for the transmission of digital video signals,” J.
Lightw. Technol., vol. 8, pp. 554-560, 1990.
[60] J. Downie, L. Tomkos, N. Antoniades, and A. Boskovic, “Effects of filter
concatenation for directly modulated transmission lasers at 2.5 and 10 Gb/s,”
J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 218-228, 2002.
[61] B. Dagens, A. Martinez, D. Make, O. L. Gouezigou, J.-G. Provost, V. Sallet,
K. Merghem, J.-C. Harmand, A. Ramdane, and B. Thedrez, “Floor free 10-
Gbps transmission with directly modulated GaInNAs-GaAs 1.35- µm laser for
metropolitan applications,” IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., vol. 17, no. 5, pp.
971-973, 2005.
[62] F. Koyama and K. Iga, “Frequency chirping in external modulators,” J.
Lightw. Technol., vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 87-93, 1988.
[63] T. Koch and J. Bowers, “Nature of wavelength chirping in directly modulated
semiconductor lasers,” Electron. Lett., vol. 20, no. 25, pp. 1038-1040, 1984.
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 70
[64] A. Ramdane, F. Devaux, N. Souli, D. Delprat, and A. Ougazzaden,
“Monolithic integration of multiple-quantum-well lasers and modulators for
high-speed transmission,” IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum
Electronics, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 326–335, Jun. 1996.
[65] T. Ido, S. Tanaka, M. Suzuki, M. Koizumi, H. Sano, and H. Inoue, “Ultra-
high-speed multiple-quantum-well electro-absorption optical modulators with
integrated waveguides,” Journal of Lightwave Technology, vol. 14, no. 9, pp.
2026–2034, Sep. 1996.
[66] G. Bosco, A. Carena, V. Curri, R. Gaudino, and P. Poggiolini, “On the use of
NRZ, RZ, and CSRZ modulation at 40 Gbps with narrow DWDM channel
spacing,” Journal of Lightwave Technology 20, 1694 – 704 (2002).
[67] H. Sunnerud, M. Karlsson, and P. Andrekson, “A comparison between NRZ
and RZ data formats with respect to PMD-induced system degradation,” IEEE
Photonics Technology Letters 13, 448 – 50 (2001).
[68] SPP, “Planning of the 71–76 GHz and 81–86 GHz bands for millimeter wave
high capacity fixed link technology,” Australian Communication and Media
Authority, 2006
[69] P. Winzer and A. Kalmar, “Sensitivity enhancement of optical receivers by
impulsive coding,” Journal of Lightwave Technology 17, 171 – 7 (1999).
[70] C. Colombo, M. Cirigliano, “Next-generation access network: a wireless
network using E-band radio frequency (71–86 GHz) to provide wideband
connectivity”, Bell Labs Tech. J. 16 (1) (2011) 187–206.
[71] Chi. H. Lee, “Microwave Photonics”, CRC Press, 2007
[72] Guohua Qi, Jianping Yao, Joe Seregelyi, Stéphane Paquet, and Claude Bélisle,
“Generation and Distribution of a WideBand Continuously Tunable
Millimeter-Wave Signal With an Optical External Modulation Technique”,
IEEE Transactions On Microwave Theory And Techniques, Vol. 53, No. 10,
October 2005
[73] Temme, Nico M. (1996). “ Special functions : an introduction to the classical
functions of mathematical physics” (2. print. ed.). New York [u.a.]: Wiley. pp.
228–231. ISBN 0471113131.
[74] Janković,Knežević-Miljanović (2007). Diferencijalne jednačine I : zadaci sa
elementima teorije (4. print. ed.). Beograd: Beograd Matematički fakultet. pp.
259–261. ISBN 978-86-7589-065-2.
REFERENCES 2015
DEPT. OF ELCTRONICS AND COMMUNICATION B.I.T. MESRA, RANCHI 71
[75] M.Kh.Khokonov, “Cascade Processes of Energy Loss by Emission of Hard
Photons,” JETP, V.99, No.4, pp. 690-707 (2004).
[76] C. Truesdell, "On the Addition and Multiplication Theorems for the Special
Functions", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Mathematics,
(1950) pp.752–757.
[77] N. M. Temme, “Special Functions. An Introduction to the Classical Functions
of Mathematical Physics,” John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, 1996. ISBN
0-471-11313-1. Chapter 9 deals with Bessel functions.
[78] Watson, “G.N., A Treatise on the Theory of Bessel Functions,” Second
Edition, (1995) Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521 48391-3.
[79] Weber, H. (1873), "Ueber eine Darstellung willkürlicher Functionen durch
Bessel'sche Functionen", Mathematische Annalen 6 (2): 146–161,
doi:10.1007/BF01443190