modern slavery in india bonded labour cases final 17 sept 2012

40
"#$%&' ()*+%&, -' -'$-* .*(%( #/ 0#'$%$ )*0#1&

Upload: sohailkhan-advocate

Post on 08-Jul-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

research proposal

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!

"#$%&'!()*+%&,!-'!-'$-*!

.*(%(!#/!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&'!()*+%&,!-'!-'$-*!

Page 2: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012
Page 3: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!"

© 2012 - Franciscans International (FI) Acknowledgments - FI would like to thank CORDAID for its generous financial contribution to this publication. Authors - Silvia Palomba, Sr. Namrata Joseph cfmss Contributors - Sr. Denise Boyle fmdm, Fráncesca Restifo, Enkeleda Papa, Budi Tjahjono, Sanjay Gathia, Ruth M. Kilcullen Copyrights - Photos and illustrations as specified. Sharing, photocopying and distribution through the Internet for non-commercial purposes of Modern Slavery in India: Cases of Bonded Labour is permitted and encouraged provided all such copies include complete citation. Franciscans International would appreciate receiving a copy of any publication that uses this publication as a source. No use of this publication may be made for resale or for any commercial purpose whatsoever. Cover Picture C redit: Sr. Namrata Joseph cfmss, for Clara Seva Kendra. Citation - This publication may be cited as: Franciscans International, !"#$%&'()*+$%,'-&'.&#-*/'0*1$1'"2'3"&#$#'4*5"6%, Geneva, 2012. T ranslation - Requests for permission to reproduce this publication in its entirety or for translations should be addressed to: F ranciscans International 37-39 Rue de Vermont 1211 Geneva Switzerland Web: www.franciscansinternational.org Email: [email protected]!

Page 4: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

#"

"#$%&!'(!)'*"&*"+!!$%&'(%&)!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!*!

+,-&%)./-0%,!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!1!

2'/-0%,"3"4"5%)'&,"2678'&9"0,"+,)07!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!:!

-,-!./01!23!456789!+:0;78<=!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!>!

-,?!"/7!+5@25A7@595B2@!)5917C1!5D!+:0;78<!29!E9620!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!>!

-,F!"80DD2@G29H!29!I783593J!09!#;79K7!15!456789!+:0;78<!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!L!

2'/-0%,";"4"$%&/')"<7=%.&"7,)">%,)')"<7=%.&"0,"+,)07!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!33!

?,-!./01!087!(58@76!%0M5K8!096!$59676!%0M5K8=!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!--!

?,?!I80@12@0:!N2B7932593!5D!$59676!%0M5K8!29!E9620!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!--!

?,F!#!O:2BP37!01!1/7!)0K373!5D!$59676!%0M5K8!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!-?!

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!-F!

2'/-0%,"!" "?7@'@"%A">%,)')"<7=%.&"0,"+,)07!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!31!

F,-!$59676!%0M5K8!29!#H82@K:1K87!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!-Q!

F,?!$59676!%0M5K8!29!1/7!E9D58B0:!+7@158,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!-R!

F,F!O79678!N2B7932593!5D!$59676!%0M5K8!A!+7:7@176!E33K73,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!-R!

F,FS-T!"/7!+KB09H0:2!+@/7B7!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!?U!

F,F!S?T!I853121K1259!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!?-!

2'/-0%,"#"4"?B06)"<7=%.&"0,"+,)07!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!;!!

V,-!"/7!W7@8K21B791!5D!)/2:6!%0M5K8783!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!?X!

V,?!)/2:6!N5B7312@!%0M5K8!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!?Q!

V,F!&C180@12;7!E96K318<!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!?L!

V,V!)/2:6!$7HH083!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!FU!

V,X!!)/2:6879!29!)59D:2@1!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!FU!

2'/-0%,"*" ">&0,C0,C"7=%.-"?B7,C'!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!!;!

X,-!$59676!%0M5K8J!0!Y25:01259!5D!ZKB09!N2H921<!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!F?!

X,?!!$59676!%0M5K8J!"/7!W5:7!5D!"/7!)2;2:!+5@271<!096!#6;5@0@<,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!F?!

X,F!!+KHH7312593!D58!&DD7@12;7!#6;5@0@<!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!FF!

D,,'E!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,!!*!!

Page 5: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

*"

/#&%2#&$!!E! @5K:6! 951! M7:27;7! 1/01! 1/7! <5K9H! [5B09! 3P70G29H! 15! B7! 87@791:<! [03! 0! 3K8;2;58! 5D!180DD2@G29H,!Z78!@0:B!@5BP53K87\!:5;7:<!3B2:7!096!1/7!87:0C76![0<!3/7!H877176!K3!M7:276!1/7!D0@1!1/01!3/7!/06!M779!180PP76!2915!37CK0:!3:0;78<!29!0!:08H7!E10:209!@21<!D58!37;79!<7083,!!#3!3/7! 673@82M76! 1/7! /58858! 5D! D29629H! /7837:D! 0! P8235978! 29! 0! D5872H9! @5K918<![21/! 95! :7H0:!65@KB7913!096!95!5P12593\!7C@7P1!15!M7!0!P853121K17!58!D0@7!P5332M:7!6701/!01!1/7!/0963!5D!0!P2BP\!0!P85D5K96!3069733!7B090176!D85B!/78,!"/7!3:0;7A:2G7!@596212593!3/7!096!1/7!51/78!<5K9H![5B79![21/!/78![787!D58@76!15!796K87![787!35!M06!1/01!3/7!18276!15!@5BB21!3K2@267!37;780:!12B73,!!.21/!0![09!3B2:7!3/7!7CP:02976!1/01!21![03!'K8!%06<![/5!30;76!/78!M7@0K37!/78!M281/!B51/78![03!P80<29H!15!451/78!408<!15!G77P!/78!30D7,!!!!

0M5K1!1/7!233K7!5D!"80DD2@G29H!29!I783593!096!51/78!)5917BP5808<!(58B3!5D!+:0;78<!S)(+T\![/2@/! 29@:K67! D58@76! 096! M59676! :0M5K8,! ./2:7! P85H8733! /03! M779! B067! [21/! B09<!H5;789B7913! 291856K@29H! :7H23:01259! 15! P87;791! 3K@/! /7295K3! 0@13! 096! 15! P8517@1! 1/7!;2@12B3\!1/7!9KBM783![/5!087!M729H!180DD2@G76!099K0::<!180H2@0::<!@59129K73!15!8237,!"/23!23!

! 1/7!8551!@0K373!5D!67B096! 096! P5;781<! /0;7! 951! M779! 067]K017:<! 066873376,! ^912:! 1/7<! 087! 066873376! M<!7;78<!31017!29!1/7![58:6\!180DD2@G783![2::!@59129K7!15!MK<!096!37::!/KB09!M729H3!:2G7!H5563!29!0!3/5P,!!!"/23!PKM:2@01259\!P856K@76!M<!1/7!#6;5@0@<!"70B!5D!(E\!23!12B7:<,!!E1!D5@K373!59!)(+!29!E9620\!H2;29H! 0! @5BP87/7932;7! 5;78;27[! 5D! 1/7! 321K01259\! [/2@/\! 59! 1/23! 3KMA@59129791\! 10G73!B<8206! D58B3,! +71! 29! 1/7! @5917C1! 5D! 0! :7H0:! D80B7[58G\! [7! /5P7! 1/01! 8706783! [2::! M7!@/0::79H76\!7982@/76!096!P85BP176!15!0@1259!03!1/7<!8706!1/85KH/!1/737!P0H73,!!!!"/7! @5::7@12;7!/5P7!5D! (E! 23! 1/01!70@/! 870678![2::! 3/087! 1/23! PKM:2@01259_! 096![2::! 0@12;7:<!79H0H7! 29! 802329H! 0[0879733! 0M5K1! )(+\! 951! `K31! 29! E9620! MK1! 29! 7;78<! @5K918<! [/787!(809@23@09A/708176! P75P:7! :2;7,! &8062@01259! 5D! )(+! [2::! 59:<! M7! 0@/27;76! 2D! [7! [58G!

B092D73176\!096!79@5K80H7!;2H2:09@7!29!5K8!@5BBK921273,!#96!:71!K3!951!D58H71\!15!K9217!29!P80<78!D58!1/7!;2@12B3\!3K8;2;583!096!1/7!180DD2@G783,,,!!!+8,!N79237!$5<:7!DB6B!!&C7@K12;7!N287@158!(E!!

!

Page 6: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

1"

-'3&#$1.3-#'!

(809@23@093!E91789012590:!S(ET!23!09!291789012590:!959AH5;789B7910:!58H092301259![58G29H!59!/KB09!82H/13\!1/7!79;2859B791\!096!P70@7AMK2:629H,!!(E!79H0H73![21/!1/7!^92176!*012593!S^*T! 096! P:0@73! 873P7@1! D58! /KB09! 62H921<\! 7]K210M:7\! 096! 3K310290M:7! 3/0829H! 5D!79;2859B7910:!8735K8@73\!096!P70@7!01!1/7!/7081!5D!213!0@1259,!

(E!23!29!@5910@1![21/!(809@23@093!096!P0819783![58G29H!01!1/7!H803385513!29!0PP85C2B017:<!-QU!@5K918273! 29!7;78<!P081!5D! 1/7![58:6_! 1/728! 29;0:K0M:7! 29PK1!0::5[3!(E! 15!5P78017!03!0!M826H7!M71[779! 1/7!H803385513!096! 1/7!^*,! !(E! 0:35! 3KPP5813!(809@23@093!096! 51/78! :5@0:!P0819783! 1/85KH/!3793212a29H! 1/7B!15!/KB09!82H/13! 233K73!096!B5M2:2329H! 1/7B!D58!M71178!P8517@1259! 5D! /KB09! 82H/13\! [21/! 1/7! H50:! 5D! 31879H1/7929H! 1/7! 2BP0@1! 5D! 1/728! 06;5@0@<!318017H273! 096! 0@12593,! "/7! )5917BP5808<! (58B3! 5D! +:0;78<! S)(+T! I85H80BB7\! [21/29![/2@/!1/23!/096M55G!/03!M779![821179\!02B3!01!802329H!0[0879733!0M5K1!B56789!D58B3!5D!3:0;78<\!096!1/728!@0K373!096!@5937]K79@73\!D58!67@232;7!096!7DD7@12;7!0@1259,!

E9!1/23!37937\!D08!D85B!M729H!7C/0K312;7\!1/23!/096M55G!3182;73!15!M7!0!155:!5D!7BP5[78B791!D58! 1/7! (809@23@093! 096! P0819783! [58G29H! 01! 1/7! H803385513! :7;7:! 096\! 29! H79780:\! D58! 0::!1/537![/5![58G!15!@5BM01!1/23!P80@12@7!602:<,!

"/7!@/52@7!5D!D5@K329H!59!E9620!23!1[5AD5:6,!!(2831!096!D587B531\!21!23!87:0176!15!1/7!59H529H!BK:12P859H76!@5::0M5801259!M71[779!(E!096!(809@23@093! 29! E9620! D58! 1/7!P8517@1259!5D! 1/7!B531! ;K:9780M:7,! ! +7@596:<\! E9620\! 1/85KH/! 213! ;031! 62;78321<\! P85;2673! 0! D03@290129H! @037!31K6<! [/79! M7H29929H! 15! 0PP850@/! 233K73! 87:0176! 15! )(+\! [21/! P0812@K:08! 87D7879@7! 15!M59676!:0M5K8,!!

+7@1259!-!291856K@73!1/7!@59@7P1!5D!7"#$%&'1)*+$%,!03![7::!03!1/7!D0@1583![21/29!1/7!35@25A7@595B2@! @5917C1! 5D! E9620! [/2@/! 087! @596K@2;7! 15! 8%*22-9:-&;' -&' <$%1"&1! 096! B56789!3:0;78<,! ! +7@1259!?! 7C0B2973! 1/7! @59@7P13!5D! 2"%9$#'096' 5"&#$#' )*5"6%! 096! @59326783! 1/7!:01178![21/29!1/7!E96209!@5917C1\!@8212@0::<!090:<329H!213!P80@12@0:!62B7932593\!213!@0K373\!096!1/7! O@0373! 5D! M59676! :0M5K8! 096! 5D! @/2:6! :0M5K8! 29D58B76! M<! 1/7! 602:<! 7CP78279@73! 5D!(809@23@093! [58G29H! 59! 1/7! 233K7! 096! 1/728! KPA15A6017! 29D58B01259! M0376! 59! @5931091!B59215829H! 5D\! 096! 873708@/! 2915\! 1/7! @K88791! 321K01259! 29! E9620,! +7@1259! X! P85P5373!3KHH7312593!D58!7DD7@12;7!06;5@0@<![58G,!!

!

!

!

Page 7: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

:"

(%.3-#'!4!5!"#$%&'!()*+%&,!-'!-'$-*!

464!27*3!-(!"#$%&'!()*+%&,8!

"806212590::<\! 1)*+$%,! 87:0173! 15! 1/7! 3:0;7! 18067! 096! 15! 090:5H5K3! 321K012593! 3K@/! 03!180DD2@G29H! 29! P783593\! 67M1! M5960H7\! D58@76! P853121K1259\! D58@76! :0M5K8! A! 29@:K629H! @/2:6!:0M5K8! A!P853121K1259!096!P5895H80P/<\! 1/7! 30:7!5D! @/2:6879\! 1/7!K37!5D! @/2:6879! 29!08B76!@59D:2@13\!096!P80@12@73!87:0176!15!@K315B3\!87:2H259\!096!@5:5920:!87H2B73,-!!!*5[060<3\!/5[7;78\!3:0;78<A:2G7!P80@12@73!A!0:35!@0::76!9"&8$7<"%*%,'2"%71'"2'1)*+$%,'S)(+T!58! 7"#$%&' 1)*+$%,! A! 7;5:;7! 35! 80P26:<! 1/01! M732673! 90B73! 096! 67D29212593\! 29! 58678! 15!7310M:23/!2D!0!P78359!23!0!;2@12B!5D!B56789!3:0;78<!21!23!2BP581091!15!7;0:K017J!S0T!1/7!67H877!

D!/23!P783590:!M7:59H29H3_!096!S@T!1/7!7C23179@7!5D!29D58B76!@593791!096!0!DK::!K96783109629H!5D! 1/7! 901K87! 5D! 1/7! 87:012593/2P! M71[779! 1/23! P78359! 096! 1/7! 51/78! P081273! 29;5:;76,?!!Y2@12B3!087!K3K0::<!0B59H!1/7!B531!;K:9780M:7!29!35@271<\!3K@/!03![5B79!096!@/2:6879,!!

469!37%!(#.-#5%.#'#"-.!.#'3%:3!#/!()*+%&,!-'!-'$-*!

.21/! 0! P5PK:012 @5K918<,!';78!1/7!P031!67@067\!21!/03!H597!1/85KH/!2BP87332;7!7@595B2@!H85[1/!096!B067!P85H8733!

29! 876K@29H! P5;781<,! #@@58629H! 15! 1/7! .58:6!$09G\! P5;781<! 67@:2976! D85B! F>,?b! 29! ?UUVA?UUX! 15! ?R,Lb! 29! ?UURA?U-U\! 73P7@20::<! 29! 1/7!8K80:!08703,F!!!!Z5[7;78\! [/2:7! 67@:2973! /0;7! M779! 7;26791! 29!1/7!310173!5D!Z2B@/0:!I80673/\!406/<0!I80673/\!40/0803/180\! '82330\! +2GG2B\! "0B2:! *06K\!c089010G0! 096! ^11080G/096\! 1/7! 6010! 87;70:3!1/01!P5;781<!/03!29@870376!29!1/7!*581/A7031789!310173! 5D!#330B\!47H/0:0<0\!4092PK8\!42a580B!096!*0H0:096,!+5B7!5D!1/7!M2HH78!310173\!3K@/!03!$2/08\! )//01123H08/! 096! ^1108! I80673/! /0;7!3/5[9!59:<!0! :211:7!67@:297!29!1/7!P5;781<!80125\!P0812@K:08:<!29!8K80:!08703,!!!!+@/76K:76! "82M73! D0@7! 1/7! /2H/731! :7;7:! 5D!P5;781<! 01! V>,Vb\! D5::5[76! M<! 1/7! +@/76K:76!

SI2@1K87!)87621J!#::A29620180;7:,@5B

)

Page 8: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

F"

!1(;!<6=!0-))-#'!-(!37%!,%*&),!%(3-"*3%$!>&#/-3!

/&#"!3&*//-.?%$!/#&.%$!)*0#1&!-'!37%!*(-*!

>*.-/-.!

!

27#!?'#2(!37%!/*"-),@!(#"%#'%!

37%,!.*'!3&1(3@!(#"%#'%!/&#"!37%-&!

#2'!+-))*A%@!*'$!>&%/%&*0),!

!S.5863!5D!0!180DD2@G78\!"/7!Z296K3109!"2B7T

)03173!S1/23!178B!23!5D179!29178@/09H70M:7![21/!N0:213!58!^915K@/0M:73T!01!V?,Fb!096!51/78!)03173! 01! F-,Rb,! E9! K8M09! 08703\! 1/7! +@/76K:76! )03173! /0;7! 0! P5;781<! 80125! 5D! FV,-b\!D5::5[76!M<!1/7!+@/76K:73!"82M73!01!FU,Vb\!096!51/78!)03173!01!?V,Fb\!03!5PP5376!15!?U,Rb!D58!1/7!1510:!P5PK:01259,!V!!#! :08H7! P78@7910H7! 5D! 1/7! E96209! P5PK:01259! 23! 312::! :2;29H! 29! 7C187B7:<! P87@0825K3!@596212593\!5D179!B067![5837!M<\!58!29!@59`K9@1259![21/\!@K315B3\!@0317!623@82B2901259\!096!87:2H25K3!M7:27D3!096!P80@12@73,!E9!D0@1\!1/7!@5BM2901259!5D!1/737!D0@1583!:7063!D87]K791:<!15!/KB09! 180DD2@G29H\! D58@76! :0M5K8! 096! 51/78! G2963! 5D! 7CP:52101259,! ! "/23! 312::! /0PP793!951[21/3109629H!1/7!317P3!E9620!/03!0:8706<!10G79!01!1/7!9012590:!096!291789012590:!:7;7:3X!15[086!1/7!0M5:21259!5D!3:0;78<,!!!46B!3&*//-.?-'A!-'!>%&(#'(C!*'!*+%'1%!3#!"#$%&'!()*+%&,!!

"/7! E%'! /03! 87@791:<! 7312B0176! 1/01! -,FQU,UUU! P783593! 29! +5K1/! #320! 796! KP! 29! 09!7CP:521012;7! 321K01259! 0D178! M729H!180DD2@G76,!E9620! 23! 95! 7C@7P1259,Q! ! N73P217! 1/7!P85H8733!0@/27;76\!1/23!@5K918<!/03!951!

B067! 3KDD2@2791! P85H8733! 29! [21/78! 213! P87;791259! 58! P8517@1259! 7DD5813! 15! 0668733!180DD2@G29H!096!@0373!5D!B56789!3:0;78<!873K:129H!D85B!21,!E9! E9620\! 180DD2@G29H!5D!/KB09!M729H3! 23!597!5D! 1/7!B0`58![0<3! 1/85KH/![/2@/!;2@12B3!087!D58@76!15![58G!29!3:0;7A:2G7!@596212593,!!.21/29!1/7!#3209!@59129791\! E9620!23!0!35K8@7\!67312901259\!096!1809321!@5K918<!D58!P783593![/5!087!180DD2@G76\!B531:<!D58!D58@76!:0M5K8!096!37CK0:!7CP:52101259,!!./2:7!21!23!62DD2@K:1!15!G95[!1/7!B0H921K67!5D!1/7!P85M:7B!0DD:2@129H!1/7!@5K918<!M7@0K37!5D!1/7!@:096731297!901K87!5D! 180DD2@G29H! 096! M7@0K37! E9620! /03! 951! <71!PKM:23/76!KP60176!31012312@3!59!M59676!:0M5K8\>!21! /03! M779! 7312B0176! 1/01! 0:B531! RUb! 5D!/KB09!180DD2@G29H!23!2917890:,L!!!!409<! 7BP:5<B791! 58! P:0@7B791! 0H79@273\!0H7913\! 096!B266:7!B79\!B531:<! :5@0176! 29! 1/7!31017!@0P210:3!096!29!N7:/2\!P:0<!0!G7<!85:7!29!1/7!180DD2@G29H!296K318<,!!./2:7!1/728!P85D73376!PK8P537!23!15!P:0@7!B2H80913!29!7BP:5<B791\!29!B09<!293109@73!1/7<!087!0@1K0::<!29;5:;76!29![7::A58H092376!180DD2@G29H,!!

Page 9: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

G"

.*(%!(31$,C!!"-(1(%!#/!&%)-A-#1(!(,"0#)(!

E9!N7:/2\!)/8231209!H28:3!087!87@8K2176!M<!B266:7AB79![/5!K37!MK329733!@0863!3/5[29H!0!P2@1K87!5D!d73K3\!408<\!096!451/78!"78730,!!E9!1/23![0<\!1/7!H28:3!096!1/728!D0B2:273!087!B067!15!M7:27;7!1/01!1/7!87@8K21783!096!1/728!0H79@273!087!@:537:<!0335@20176![21/!)01/5:2@!)/K8@/!58H092a012593!15!@088<!5K1!1/728!35@20:![58G\!096!1/7<!65!951!870:2a7!1/01!1/7<!087!0@1K0::<!M729H!182@G76!2915!180DD2@G29H,!!"/7! K37! 5D! D0:37! 066873373! 096! 87:2H25K3! 3<BM5:3! 01180@1! )/8231209! 182M0:! 096! #62;032! H28:3,! E1! 23!0:[0<3!62DD2@K:1!15!180@G!1/737!2::7H0:!0H79@273!096!D296!1/7!<5K9H![5B79!59@7!1/7<!087!B23329H,!S$8,!+09153/!&GG0!5DBT!

"/7!B71/563!096!17@/92]K73! 1/7<!K37!087! 291781[2976![21/!1/7!8551!@0K373!5D! 180DD2@G29H,!!O28:3!087!180DD2@G76!03!0!@5937]K79@7!5D!09@73180:! 87:2H25K3!P80@12@73!3K@/!03! 1/7!=$+*#*1-!3<317B!S377!0:35!37@1259!F,F!S?TT\!096!@/2:6879!087!35:6!01!0K@12593!15!#80M!096!E96209!B79![/5! M7:27;7! 1/01! /0;29H! 29178@5K837! [21/! ;28H293! /70:3! 37CK0::<! 18093B2332M:7! 62370373,R!!I558! P087913\! 67P82;76! 5D! 09<! `5M! P853P7@13\! 5D179! 37::! 1/728! 60KH/1783! 59! D80K6K:791!P85B2373! 5D!B08820H7! 58! D58! 7BP:5<B791! 29! 15[93,! "/7! 870:21<! /5[7;78! 23! 1/01! H28:3! 087!M85KH/1!15!M851/7:3\!:5@G76!KP!D58!60<3\!3108;76\!096!M70179!K912:!1/7<!0@@7P1!1/7!67B0963!5D!1/7!180DD2@G783,!"/7<!087!D58@76!15!791781029!0!B0C2BKB!9KBM78!5D!@:27913!7;78<!60<,!

Y2@12B3! 087! H79780::<! [5B79! 096! @/2:6879!M7:59H29H! 15! 1/7! +@/76K:76! )03173! 096! "82M73!096!:2;29H!29!62306;0910H76!87H2593,!#D178!M729H!180DD2@G76\! 1/7<! 087! 7CP:52176! 29! 321K012593! :2G7!M82@G! G2:93\! 7BM852678<! D0@158273\! 096! 1/7!0H82@K:1K80:! 37@158,! '1/783! 087! 37CK0::<!7CP:52176\!D58@76!2915!B08820H7\!58!D0::!P87<!15!1/7!58H09!18093P:09129H!80@G71,-U!!"82M0:! 065:73@791! H28:3! D85B! 8K80:! 08703! 5D! 1/7! +10173! 5D! $2/08\! d/08G/096\! )//01123H08/\!'82330\! .731! $79H0:\! 096! #330B! 087! 67@72;76\! 180DD2@G76\! 096! 1/79! 35:6! D58! 37CK0:!7CP:52101259! 29! N7:/2\! 4KBM02\! c5:G010\! )/79902\! O50\! 096! $09H0:587,! .2673P8706!@588KP1259! 0B59H! P5:2@7! 096! 08B76! D58@73\! 0:59H! [21/! 1/7! :0@G! 5D! P85P78! 1802929H! 096!65@KB79101259!59!;2@12B3!5D!180DD2@G29H\!7C0@78M017!1/7!P85M:7B,!!

!#3!87H0863!291789012590:!180DD2@G29H\!@5BB59!673129012593!087!1/7!4266:7!&031\!&K85P7\!096!1/7! ^92176! +10173! D58! 1/7! PK8P5373! 5D! 65B7312@! :0M5K8,! )/2:6879! 087! B029:<! D58@76! 15!M7@5B7!D0@158<!096!0H82@K:1K80:![58G783\!65B7312@!378;0913\!096!M7HH083,--!

$732673!M729H!0!@5K918<!5D!582H29\!E9620!23!0:35!0!67312901259!@5K918<!D58!180DD2@G76!P783593!D85B!$09H:0673/!096!*7P0:,!!E1!/03!M779!7312B0176!1/01!085K96!X\UUU![5B79!087!180DD2@G76!

!

!>&*$%(7@!

?*&'*3*?*@!*'$!3*"-)!'*$1!*&%!

7-A7!(1>>),!D#'%(@!27-)%!?#)?*3*@!

"1"0*-@!$%)7-@!*'$!A#*!*&%!"*E#&!

!S48,!O,!c,!I2::02\!^9259!Z5B7!+7@87108<\!

O5;789B791!5D!E9620T!

Page 10: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3H"

.*(%!(31$,C!/*)(%!>&#"-(%(!#/!0%33%&!E#0(!!W09`090\!0!1[791<AD5K8A<708A5:6!B51/78!5D!1[5!@/2:6879!@5B29H!D85B!1/7!P5;781<A826679!+5K1/!?V!I08H0903!5D!.731!$79H0:\![03!M7HK2:76!2915!0!180P!:026!M<!0!180DD2@G78,!Z7!0PP850@/76!W09`090![21/!0! :K@8012;7!5DD78!5D!0!M71178! `5M! 29!c5:G010!096\!/5P29H! D58!0!M82H/1! DK1K87\! 3/7!0H8776! 15!H5![21/!

M729H! 10G79\!/7!3108176! D2H/129H![21/!B7,!"/7!@5AP03379H783!5M`7@176\! 01![/2@/!P5291!/7!@:02B76!1/01!E![03!/23![2D7,!E!3@870W09`090,!!+/7![03!D2831!10G79!15!0!/5K37!29!c51:0!4KM080GPK8!29!+5K1/!N7:/2![/787!3/7![03!G7P1!

87DK376!15!!

(5::5[29H!0!B23329H!87P581!:56H76!M<!/78!/K3M096\!1/7!.731!$79H0:!P5:2@7!@0B7!0@8533!1/7!B5M2:7!P/597!9KBM78!5D! 0! 3K3P7@1! 3/5[29H! 1/7! :5@01259!5D! 1/7!P:0@7![/787!W09`090![03!G7P1,!W09`090![03!D290::<!D5K96!:5@G76!KP!29!0!@:5371\!@:708:<!3/5[29H!7;2679@7!5D!1581K87!59!/78!M56<,!

29! c5:G010![/787! E!B71! 0! <5K9H!B09![/5! M7D8279676!B7,! I85B2329H! 0! M71178! 30:08<! 01! 0951/78!/5K37! 29!c5:G010\!/7!B067!B7!M5086!0! 18029,!W70:2a29H! 1/01! E![03!M729H! 10G79!35B7[/787!7:37\! E!@59D859176!/2B,!Z7! 1/79!155G!B7!15! 1/7! :0;0158<!096!M701!B7!KP,!"/23!/0PP7976!01! 1/7!Z5[80/!

[03!M85KH/1! 15!N7:/2\!G7P1! 29!0!/5K37!096!1/79!35:6!5DD! 15! 1/7!5[978!5D!1/7!M851/7:![/787!3/7![03!P/<32@0::<!1581K876,!

./79!c0;210e3!M851/78!G97[! 1/01! 1/7!P5:2@7!5D!.731!$79H0:![787!0M5K1! 15!H5! 15!N7:/2! 15! 873@K7!W09`090!/7!P:70676!15!M7!0::5[76!15!0@@5BP09<!1/7!P5:2@7!03!/7!3K3P7@176!1/01!/23!323178!/06!0:35!B71! 1/7!30B7! D017,!W2H/1!0D178! 1/7!P5:2@7! D8776!W09`090\!c0;210e3!M851/78!3/5[76!/78!/23! 323178e3!P/515H80P/,! ! ./2:7! W09`090! 2931091:<! 87@5H92a76! c0;210\! 1/7! P5:2@7! 67@2676! 15! [021! D58! 09!5PP581K97!12B7!15!873@K7!/78!096!W09`090!0H8776!15!/7:P!1/7B,!!./79!c0;210![03!D5K96!096!10G79!15!0!9708M<!/53P210:\!1/7!65@1583!623@5;7876!1/01!3/7!/06!M779!H2;79!0M581259!P2::3,!

SE9D5)/09H7!*7[3!f!(701K873T!

D85B! *7P0:! 15! E9620! 70@/! <708\! 096! 1/01! 29! 5;78! -\UUU! 876A:2H/1! 623182@13! 0::! 5;78! E9620\!P853121K173!087!B531:<!B29583!D85B!*7P0:!096!$09H:0673/,-?!

E1!B2H/1!0:35!/0PP79!1/01![5B79!096!H28:3!B2H8017!;5:K91082:<!096!:0178\!1/85KH/!0!809H7!5D!@28@KB3109@73\!M7@5B7!;2@12B3!5D!180DD2@G29H!096!7CP:52101259,!!

!

!

!

Page 11: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

33"

(%.3-#'!9!5!/#&.%$!)*0#1&!*'$!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!-'!-'$-*!

964!27*3!*&%!/#&.%$!)*0#1&!*'$!0#'$%$!)*0#1&8!

!"#$%&' ()*"+#' @09! M7! 673@82M76! 03! [58G! 58! 378;2@7![/2@/! 23! 5M102976! D85B! 09<! P78359!K9678! 1/7!B790@7!5D!0!P790:1<!096! D58![/2@/! 1/23!P78359!/03!951!5DD7876!/7837:Dg/2B37:D!;5:K91082:<,-F!!"/7!P790:1<!B2H/1!@593231!5D!0!:533!5D!82H/13!096!P82;2:7H73\!P/<32@0:!;25:79@7\!8731802913\!1/87013\!096g58!7@595B2@!P790:1273,!!,"-&).%/'*"-&' ()*"+#/' "#'*"-&%&' ()*"+#! 087! 0PP85P82017! 178B3! 15!K37![/79! 7@595B2@!P790:1273!087! :29G76! 15! D58@76! :0M5K8,! !$59676! :0M5K8! 23! 0! 3581!5D! P018590H7! 29![/2@/! 1/7!B292BKB![0H7!23!M087:<!795KH/!15!@5;78!1/7!:2;29H!@5313!5D!1/7!7BP:5<77!096!1/7!87:01259!M71[779! 7BP:5<78! 096! 7BP:5<77! 23! 5D179! @/080@1782a76! M<! K9D2C76! 096! 7CP:521012;7!P0<B791! 0H877B7913![/2@/!M797D21! 1/7! 7BP:5<78,! -V!*51! 0::! M59676! :0M5K8! 23! D58@76\! MK1!B531! D58@76! :0M5K8! P80@12@73! /0;7! 0! M59676! 901K87\! 87H086:733! 5D! [/71/78! 1/7! [58G!29;5:;73!@/2:6879!58!06K:13,!!

969!>&*.3-.*)!$-"%'(-#'(!#/!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!-'!-'$-*!!3"&#$#')*5"6%!23! A7@595B2@!096!@K:1K80:!318K@1K87_!1/787!23!0!;2::0H7! 29! 1/7!+1017!5D!^1108!I80673/!@0::76!$096/K0\![/2@/! :21780::<!B7093! M59676 ,!!$59676! :0M5K8! 23! G95[9! [21/! 62DD78791! 90B73! 0@8533! 1/7! @5K918<,! (58! 293109@7\! 29! 1/7!D08B29H! 37@1583! 29! OK`0801! 096!^1108! I80673/! 21! 23! G95[9! 03!Z0:2,! ! c02BK12\! d095K82\! 096!c0B20/! 087! 178B3! K376! 29! 1/7! 31017! 5D! $2/08,! E9! '82330\! 21! 23! G95[9! 03! O51/2\! 29! #96/80!I80673/!21!23!O0332AOK::K\!096!29!"0B2:!*06K!21!23!I090:!I01/2809,-X!!$59676!:0M5K8!7C2313!P8765B29091:<!29!1/7!29D58B0:!096!K987HK:0176!37@1583![/2@/!7BP:5<!085K96!92971<!P78!@791!5D!1/7!E96209!:0M5K8!D58@7,-Q!"/23!B56789!D58B!5D!3:0;78<!K376!15!M7!B587! @5BB59! 29! 8K80:! 1/09! K8M09! 08703! M7@0K37! 21! [03! :08H7:<! [2673P8706! 29! 1/7!0H82@K:1K80:!096!B2929H!37@1583,!!Z5[7;78\!21!23!95[!;78<!@5BB59!15!D296!M59676!:0M5K8783![58G29H!29!/5K37/5:63\! 29!1/7!P856K@1259!5D!32:G3\!@08P713\!B01@/73\!@2H0871173\!096!M82@G3\!096!29!B09K0:!3@0;79H29H!29!0::!B0`58!@21273,!!!

Page 12: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3;"

7-A7)-A73!-'$-*!*3!37%!-'3%&'*3-#'*)!)%+%)!

!E9620! /03! 951! <71! 8012D276! 1/7! .&8$%&*8-"&*)' 4*5"6%'>%;*&-?*8-"&' @.4>A' 0"&+$&8-"&' B"/' CDE' "&' 8F$'7-&-767'*;$' 2"%'*#7-11-"&' 8"'$7<)",7$&8'*&#'G"%:\!!"#$\! 58! 1/7' .4>' 0"&+$&8-"&' B"/' CEH' "&' 8F$' I"%18'J"%71'"2'0F-)#'4*5"6%K'CLLL,!#@@58629H! 15! 1/7! E96209!H5;789B791\![/2:7! 1/7! 3P2821!5D! 1/7! )59;7912593! 23! [267:<! 3/0876\! 1/7! 35@25A7@595B2@! @596212593! 5D! E9620! [5K:6! B0G7! 1/7!8012D2@01259!62DD2@K:1,!

"<P2@0::<\! 1/7! M596! M71[779! 1/7!7BP:5<78! 096! 1/7! 7BP:5<77! 23!7310M:23/76! D85B! 1/7! M7H29929H! 5D!1/7! 87@8K21B791! P85@733,! ! "/23! 23!@/080@1782a76! M<! 1/7! :0@G! 5D! :0M5K8!310960863\! 1/7! K97;79! @59180@1K0:!P5[78!M71[779!1/7!1[5!P081273\!096!1/7! 2967D29217! 6K801259! 5D! 1/7!0H877B791,! E1! /0PP793! ;78<!D87]K791:<!1/01!0![58G78\!0D178!35B7!<708 \! P03373! 5DD! /23!M59676! 18*861! 15! 51/78! D0B2:<!B7BM783\!5D179!<5K9H78!32M:29H3,->!!#6K:13! 096! @/2:6879! D85B! N0:21!@5BBK921273! B0G7! KP! 1/7! B0`5821<!5D! 1/537! 180PP76! 29! M59676! :0M5K8,!!E9! E9620\! 1/7!7CP7@101259!5D!@/2:6879!15!@59182MK17!15!1/7!D0B2:<!29@5B7!23!7]K0:!15!1/01!5D!06K:13!096!1/7!/70:1/!/0a0863! 1/7<! D0@7! 7;78<! 60<! H5!K96787312B0176,! ! E9! 06621259\! [/2:7!

1/7! MK8679! 5D! P85;2629H! P8517@1259! 15! 1/7B! 3/5K:6! M7! 0B59H! 1/7! P825821273! D58! 09<!H5;789B791\!@/2:6879!29!E9620!377B!15!79`5<!7;79!:733!P8517@1259!1/09!06K:13![21/!87H0863!15!:0M5K8!:0[3,!!!!96B!*!A)-">(%!*3!37%!.*1(%(!#/!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!

"/787!087!B09<!62DD78791!8703593! D58!M59676! :0M5K8! 29! E9620,! (587B531!0B59H! 213!@0K373!087! [2673P8706! P5;781<\! 297]K0:21<\! @0317AM0376! 623@82B2901259! 096! 1/7! 29067]K017!76K@01259!3<317B,!!%08H7!P85P5812593!5D!1/537![/5!087!P558!29!E9620!087!@/8592@0::<!P558,!"/23!23!1/7!H85KP!5D![/2@/!1/7!B0`5821<!5D!M59676!:0M5K8783!23!@5BP5376,!)/8592@!P5;781<!87D783!15!P75P:7![/5!087! P558! D58! 32H92D2@091! P782563! 5D! 1/728! :2;73\! [/5! B0<! P033! 1/23! @59621259! 59! 15! 1/728!@/2:6879\! 096! D58! [/5B! 73@0P29H! D85B! P5;781<! 23! 9708:<! 2BP5332M:7,! )/8592@0::<! P558!P75P:7!0@@7P1!09<![58G!0;02:0M:7!K9678!09<!@596212593!58!178B3,!"/7<!65!1/23!M7@0K37!5D!D708! 5D! K97BP:5<B791! 58\! 03! 5D179! /0PP793! 29! E9620\! M7@0K37! 1/7<! /0;7! 15! @59D58B![21/!

Page 13: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3!"

!

7-A7)-A73!!'%2!/#&"(!#/!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!

!

"/787! 23! 32H92D2@091! 7;2679@7! 1/01! M59676!:0M5K8! 23! 7;5:;29H! 096! 10G29H! 97[! D58B3!0@8533! E9620,! "/7! P853121K1259! 296K318<! 23!

[70:1/<!E96209!@K315B783!096!15K82313,!"80DD2@G783! 087!95[!@0P210:2a29H!59! 1/7! D0@1!1/01! @/2:6! 65B7312@! [58G! 23! 7;79! B587!:K@8012;7! 1/09! P853121K1259,! #3! 0!@5937]K79@7\! P:0@7B791! 0H79@273! 5DD7829H!@/2:6! [58G783! 5D! 09<! 0H7! 087! H85[29H!80P26:<!29!N7:/2,!

35@20:!096!@K:1K80:!958B3\!3K@/!03!/53129H!0! [76629H! 58! DK9780:\! [/2@/! [5K:6! M7!51/78[237!2BP5332M:7!D58!1/7B!15!0DD586,!!^3K0::<!1/7<!65!951!5[9!58!/0;7!0@@733!15!033713! 3K@/! 03! :096\! [0178\! 58! D587313,!)5937]K791:<! 1/728! 59:<! P5332M2:21<! D58!3K8;2;0:! 23! 15!79H0H7! 29!M59676! :0M5K8,! -L!!"/7! P85M:7B! 23! 7C0@78M0176! [/79! 1/7!P558! M7:59H! 15! 1/7! 5K1@031! @5BBK921<! 5D!E96209! 35@271<\! 1/7! N0:213\! 58! 15! B295821<!71/92@!H85KP3!3K@/!03! 1/7!#62;032,! !"/737!H85KP3! 087! K3K0::<! G95[9! 03!^ ! 2BP:273\! 0B59H!51/78! 1/29H3\! 1/7! D0@1! 1/01! 1/7<! @09951!M7!7BP:5<76! 29! @781029! `5M! 37@1583! S3K@/! 03!

1/7!37::29H!5D!D556!096!P856K@13!K376!29![583/2PT,!! !087!1/7!59:<!P75P:7![/5!P78D58B!B7920:!103G3!3K@/!03!B09K0:!3@0;79H29H,-R!!!

96F!*!.&-3-.*)!+-%2!#/!-'$-* (!&%(>#'(%!3#!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!

$59676!:0M5K8![03!5K1:0[76!M<!1/7!O5;789B791!5D!E9620![21/!MF$'3"&#$#'4*5"6%'(,18$7'@N5")-8-"&A' N98! S34(NT! 29! -R>Q,?U! ! E9! 06621259\! 1/7' 0"&18-868-"&' HK08091773! 0! D877! 096!62H92D276!7C23179@7!15!0::!E96209!@212a793!096!21!P85/2M213!M59676!:0M5K8!1/85KH/!#812@:73!?-\!?FS-T!096!?V,!!"/7!34(N!3P7@2D2@0::<!67D2973!M59676!:0M5K8!03!0!321K01259![/787!1/7!67M158!0H8773![21/! 1 ! 0! :509! D58!0!P5179120::<! K967D2976! P78256! 5D! 12B7,! ?-! "/7! 02B! 5D! 1/7! 34(N! 23! 15! D0@2:21017! 1/7!267912D2@01259\!87:7037\!096!87/0M2:2101259!5D!M59676!:0M5K8783,!!409<! 51/78! P85;232593\! 01! 1/7! @79180:! 096! 31017! :7;7:3\! 793K87! 1/7! P85/2M21259! 5D! 1/23!B56789! D58B! 5D! 3:0;78<\! 096! HK0809177! /KB097! [58G! @596212593\! 1/7! P8517@1259! 5D! 1/7!/70:1/!5D![58G783\!096!1/7!62H921<!5D!0::!P783593,??!!!!"/7! 31017! H5;789B7913! 096! 1/7! @5K813! 087! H79780::<! @5BP71791! 15!B592158\! 79D58@7\! 096!2BP:7B791!1/7!34(N!096!1/7!;0825K3!3101K173,!!"/7!34(N!P85;2673!D58!Y2H2:09@7!)5BB211773!01!1/7!N23182@1!096!3KMA62;232590:!:7;7:3![/537!85:7!23!15!06;237!N23182@1!40H23180173!59!@0373!5D!M59676!:0M5K8,!!Z5[7;78\!B09<!@59@7893!/0;7!M779!7CP873376!0M5K1!1/7!297DD7@12;79733!5D!1/7!Y2H2:09@7!)5BB211773!29!;0825K3!310173,?F!!!!

Page 14: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3#"

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h5`090!15!P85;267!8K80:!/5K329H\!096!1/7!E917H80176!)/2:6!N7;7:5PB791!+78;2@73!/0;7!P85;79!15!M7!297DD7@12;7,?Q!!!E9! ?UU-\![/79! 1/7!*ZW)!P87379176! 213! 87P581! 59! M59676! :0M5K8\?>! ! 1/7! :0@G! 5D! 0! 329@787!P5:212@0:![2::![03! 267912D276!03! 1/7!P82B08<!@0K37! D58! 1/7!310H9091!321K01259,! !#9!067]K017!H:5M0:! 318017H<! [/2@/! 2962@0173! 0! 31859H! P5:212@0:! @5BB21B791! 15! 0M5:23/! 1/23! D58B! 5D!3:0;78<!23!95[!97@73308<,! !)593267829H!1/01!M59676!:0M5K8!23!951!0!P85M:7B!29!2137:D!MK1!0!:08H78!233K7!5D![7:D087! 29!E9620!03!0![/5:7\!P85H80BB73!3/5K:6!H5!M7<596!3<BP15B3!096!:55G! 01! 066873329H! 1/7! 8551! @0K373! 5D!1/23! B56789! 3:0;78<,! ! %0M5K8! B08G71!37HB79101259\! 35@20:! 623@82B2901259\! 0!:0@G!5D! :096\! 0! :0@G!5D! D2909@20:! 378;2@73!096! 1/7! @5937]K79120:! 7@595B2@!;K:9780M2:21<\!0B59H!51/78!35@20:!233K73\!87]K287! :59HA178B! 67;7:5PB791!B703K873! 096! 7DD7@12;7! P5;781<!0::7;201259!318017H273,!!4587! 1/09! 179! <7083! :0178\! 1/7!@5BB21B791!15!78062@017!M59676!:0M5K8!6573! 951! 0PP708! 15! M7! 32H92D2@091:<!@/09H76! 096! 1/7! H50:3! 5D! 267912D2@01259\!87:7037!096! 87/0M2:2101259!5D!M59676! :0M5K8783!7CP873376! 29! 1/7!$%+#!087! D08! D85B!M729H!0@@5BP:23/76,! !W7H08629H!267912D2@01259\!0!/5:2312@!0PP850@/!15!1/7!233K7!5D!M59676!:0M5K8!

$0C.&'"3"4"D(7&','@@"&70@0,C"I''-0,C"0,"?6'I',-"J%(,K"L'B&7).,K"M--&7NB7,)"

Page 15: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3*"

7-A7)-A73!MOP'=P4O.'QR.SNMP'Q4N0P!PBM'NTPB0.P('@RPTU4NM.>BA'3.44K'HVCH!

!"/23!$2::!23!3@/76K:76!D58!P87379101259!15!1/7!#337BM:<!D58!0PP85;0:!29!(7M8K08<!?U-F!096!21!3/5K:6!P85;267!D58!87HK:01259!5D!1/7!0H79@273!P85;2629H!65B7312@![58G783,!!E9!D0@1\!1/23!680D1!:0[!3/5K:6!873P596!15!P:0@7B791!0H79@273!29@870329H:<!29;5:;76!29!1/7!180DD2@G29H!5D![5B79!096!@/2:6879!D58!65B7312@!096!D58@76!:0M5K8!D85B!1/7!+10173!5D!d/08G/096\!)/01123H08/\!.731!$79H0:\!#330B\!096!$2/08!15!1/7!@0P210:!N7:/2,!Z5[7;78\!0@@58629H!15!7CP7813\!1/23!M2::\!2D!0PP85;76!03!21!23!95[\![2::!951!/7:P!15!0668733!1/7!233K7!7DD2@2791:<,!E9!P0812@K:08\!1/7!$2::!6573!951!P85;267!D58\!0B59H!51/78!233K73J!0T!0!B292BKB![0H7_!MT!0!35@20:!37@K821<!3@/7B7!D58!65B7312@![58G783!096!1/7!@58873P59629H!:20M2:21<!5D!1/7!P:0@7B791! 0H79@273! 15! 793K87! 213! 2BP:7B79101259_! @T! 1/7! 82H/13!5D! 1/7![58G783! 01! 1/7![58G!P:0@7_! 6T! 0! @:708! 5K1:297!5D! 1/7! 6K1273!5D! 1/7! 7BP:5<78! 15[0863! 1/7! 65B7312@![58G783_! 7T! 0!B7@/0923BgP85@76K87! [/787M<! 65B7312@! [58G783! @09! :56H7! @5BP:02913! 5D! 37CK0:!/08033B791!58!0330K:1!P78P7180176!!M<!P:0@7B791!0H7913_!DT!0!B59215829H!B7@/0923B_!HT!@:708!HK267:2973! 29! 87:01259! 15! 1/7! 79121:7B791! 5D! P:0@7B791! 0H79@273! 29! N7:/2! 15! 87@8K21! P783593!

3/0::!M7!233K76!0!P/515!2679121<!@087CP537! 1/7! [58G783! 15! 066212590:! 0MK373! 2D! 1/7! P:0@7B791! 0H79@273! @5B7! 15! @59185:! 1/728!2679121<!65@KB7913,!!

[5K:6! 87]K287\! 03! 0! D2831! 317P\! 15! 0@@KBK:017! 096! PKM:23/! KP60176! 31012312@0:! 6010! 096!29D58B01259!59!@0317!096!87:0176!623@82B2901259! 29!G7<3!08703!3K@/!03!M59676! :0M5K8!096!@/2:6!:0M5K8,!!#1!P873791\!3K@/!@5BP87/7932;7!9012590:!3K8;7<3!/0;7!<71!15!M7!P856K@76,!!E9! 87H086! 15! 87:7037! 096! 87/0M2:2101259! 5D! M59676! :0M5K8783\! 1/7! )79180::<! +P5935876!+@/7B7! D58! 87/0M2:2101259! 5D! 87:70376! M59676! :0M5K8783! /03! P85;79! 15! M7! 297DD7@12;7,! ! #!@5BB59:<!95176!P85M:7B! 23! 1/7!67:0<!M71[779!87:7037!096!87/0M2:2101259![/2@/\! @5KP:76![21/! 1/7! :0@G! 5D! B7093! 5D! 3K8;2;0:\! 5D179! 682;73! :0M5K8783! 15! 871K89! 15! 1/728! 7CP:521783,!!45875;78\!B09<!310173!9776!15!@87017!0[0879733!5D!1/7!233K7!5D!M59676!:0M5K8\!03![7::!03!1/7!35@25A7@595B2@!:7H23:01259!096!P85H80BB73!87:0176!15!21,!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!

Page 16: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

31"

(%.3-#'!B! !.*(%(!#/!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!-'!-'$-*"!!B64!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!-'!*A&-.1)31&%!E9! E9620\! 0! 9KBM78! 5D! 35@20:! 87D58B3! 29;5:;29H! :096! 096! 17909@<! /0;7! M779! 790@176!1/85KH/5K1! 1/7! :031! D2D1<! <7083! 29! 58678! 15! 7:2B29017! 378D65B! 096! K9P026! :0M5K8! 29! 1/7!1806212590:! 0H808209! 3<317B,?L! ! Z5[7;78\! P5;781<! 096! 2967M1769733! /0;7! D58@76! 09!29@870329H!9KBM78!5D!P75P:7!2915!0!P5321259!5D!;K:9780M2:21<!15!0H82@K:1K80:!M59676!:0M5K8\![/2:7! 1/7! 1806212590:! :0M5K8! 3<317B! /03!7;5:;76! 2915! 97[! D58B3\! 87D:7@129H! 1/7!@/09H73! 87:0176! 15! 29@870329H:<!@0P210:2312@!0H82@K:1K80:!67;7:5PB791,!

E9! E9620\! *O'3! 096! 1/7! @2;2:! 35@271<! 01!:08H7! 087! 0@12;7:<! 29;5:;76! 29! @5K937:29H\!3KPP58129H\! 096! 873@K29H! M59676!:0M5K8783\!5D179!10G29H!7958B5K3!823G3,!

E9! 35B7! @0373\! M59676! :0M5K8! @59180@13!/0;7! M779! B562D276! 15! 0PP708! 29!@59D58B21<![21/!1/7!:0[\!MK1!29!3KM3109@7!1/7<! B0291029! 1/728! B029! D701K873! 5D!@578@259! 1/85KH/! 2967M1769733! 096! 1/7!67;0:K01259! 5D! 1/7! [58G! @088276! 5K1! M<!1/7!7BP:5<77,!

E9! ^1108! I80673/! 096! )//01123H08/\! D58!7C0BP:7\! 1/7! [58G783! 0PP708! 15! M7!2967P796791! 1790913\! MK1! 29! 870:21<! 1/7<!087! M59676! :0M5K8783,! ! "/7<! M5885[!B597<! D85B! 1/728! :096:5863! 15! 0DD586! 0::!1/7!7CP79373!87:0176!15!1/7!8K9929H!5D!1/7!D08B! S2,7,! MK<29H! 37763\! D7812:2a783! 71@T,!"/23!B597<! 0663! 15! 1/7! 3/087! 1/01!BK31!M7! 872BMK8376! 15! 1/7! :096! 5[9783,! ! "/23!321K01259! B0G73! 21! 2BP5332M:7! D58! 1/7!1790913! 15! P0<! 5DD! 1/728! 67M13! 1/787M<!67@870329H! 1/7! :2G7:2/556! 5D! 1/728! M729H!D8776!M<! 1/7! :096!5[9783,?R! ! "/737![58G!87:012593! 087! P081:<! 09! 7CP8733259! 5D! 1/7!

.*(%!(31$,C!&%(.1%@!&%7*0-)-3*3%!*'$!&%-'3%A&*3%!+-.3-"(!!!"/7!*O'!):080!+7;0!c79680!S[/2@/!B7093!):080!378;2@7! @79187T\! :5@0176! 29! ):7B791! "5[9\!N7/806K9\! ^1180G/096\! 23! 8K9! M<! 0! H85KP! 5D!):0823!3231783J!+8,!*0B8010!d537P/!@DB33!23!597!5D!1/737!M80;7!096!67;5176![5B79,!):080!+7;0!c79680![58G3! 15! 873@K7\! 87/0M2:21017!096! 872917H8017! M59676! :0M5K8783\! 670:29H!6287@1:<! [21/! 1/7! 7BP:5<783,! ! +108129H! D85B! 1/7!033KBP1259! 1/01! 066873329H! 1/7! 233K7! 5D!180DD2@G29H! 29! 1/7! 31017! 5D! 582H29! 23! M7<596! 213!@0P0@21<\! 1/23!*O'! 108H713! 7BP:5<783! 59@7! 1/7<!

23! 29D58B76! 5D! 1/7! 0882;0:! 29! 15[9! 5D! 97[![58G783\! 1/7! 3231783! 87]K731! 0!B77129H![21/! 1/7!2917873176!7BP:5<78,!!"/728!H50:!23!15!793K87!1/7!P8517@1259!5D!1/7!M032@!82H/13!5D!1/7![58G783,!!!):080! +7;0! c79680! 87]K731! 59! M7/0:D! 5D! 1/537!1/7<!87P873791J!-,!'97!/5:260<!P78![77G_!?, 4292BKB! [0H73\! B0C2BKB! [58G29H! /5K83\!P026!099K0:!096!32@G!:70;7_!

F, 4591/:<![0H73!P026!6287@1:<!15!1/7![58G783!58!15!1/7!*O'_!

V, #!P85P78!096!30D7!P:0@7!15!8731_!X, 5D!1/7!60<_!

Q, 'PP581K921273! D58!1/7![58G78!15!P0812@2P017! 29!@K:1K80:!096!87:2H25K3!P80@12@73,!

Page 17: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3:"

35@25A7@595B2@!65B2909@7!5D!@781029!H85KP3,!

$59676!:0M5K8783!29!0H82@K:1K87!H79780::<!M7:59H!15!1/7!+@/76K:76!)03173\!087!959A4K3:2B\!5D179! B2H80913\FU! 096! 0B59H! 1/7B\! [5B79! 096! @/2:6879! 087! P0812@K:08:<! 7CP5376! 15!;25:79@7!P78P7180176!M<!1/728!:096:5863!58!7BP:5<783,!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

E9! 1/7! 31017! 5D! IK9`0M\! [/787! 0H82@K:1K87! 23! ;78<! 67;7:5P76\! 1/7! :0M5K8783! 29;5:;76! 29!M59676! :0M5K8!087!G95[9!03!(-%-,!"/7<!H79780::<!M7:59H! 15! 1/7!+@/76K:76!)0317!096! 1/7<!087!951!0M:7!15!D877:<!@/5537!1/728!5[9!7BP:5<B791\!15!B5;7\!58!K37!;2::0H7!@5BB593\!096!087!3KM`7@176!15!:59H![58G29H!/5K83,!"/7![2;73!5D!1/7!(-%-1!087!958B0::<!K376!03!@011:7A3/76!@:709783\! 096! 087! 1/787D587! 296287@1! ;2@12B3! 5D! 1/7! M5960H7! 3<317B,! )/2:6879! 0:35! 033231!1/728!P087913!29!0H82@K:1K80:![58G!096!1/7<!087!G95[9!03!Q*)-,!

E9!428a0PK8!N23182@1\!+5K1/789!^1108!I80673/\!0!31K6<!/03!87;70:76!1/01!B7BM783!5D!1/7!W")!182M7!087!29!35B7!@0373!2967M176!15!1/728!:096:586!D58!B587!1/09!597!H797801259,!"/7!292120:!:5093! SK3K0::<! 10G79! D58! B08820H73T! [787! 958B0::<! 87:012;7:<! 3B0::\! MK1! 1/7! W")1! [787!K90M:7! 15! 87P0<! 1/7B! M7@0K37! 5D! 1/728! :5[! [0H73! 096! /2H/! @5BP5K96! 29178731! SQU! b!099K0::<T,! ! E1!0:35!7B78H76!1/01! 1/7!M59676! :0M5K8783![787!35:6!15!51/783\!096!1/728!67M1!18093D78876!15!1/7!97[!7BP:5<783,!!"/737!:0M5K8783![787!H79780::<!P026!?GH!5D!@50837!H8029!P78!60<! 096!H2;79! 0! 129<!P:51! 5D! :096! S597! 37;791/!5D! 09! 0@87T! 15!B771! 1/728! 3KM323179@7!87]K287B7913,! ! #951/78! [2673P8706! 3<317B! 5D! M5960H7! 29! 1/7! 0H82@K:1K80:! 37@158! 23! 1/7!:*7-*X7*)-:'3<317B\![/2@/!23!7BP:5<76!29!1/7!623182@13!5D!W02PK8!096!W02H08/!S)//0123H08/!+1017T,!!"/7!:*7-*\!0!B0:7!D08B!378;091\!0:59H![21/!/23!D0B2:<!B7BM783\!P85;2673!:0M5K8!29!1/7!/5B7!096!D08B!5D!1/7!7*)-:K'1/7!B03178\!K912:!/23!67M1!23!P026!5DD,!F-!

$0C.&'";"4"O0/-.&'"?&')0-P"O.,Q7=R7,%&7I7S=6%C@R%-"

Page 18: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3F"

!

.*(%!(31$,C!.#'3&*.31*)!2#&?%&(!!'9! 0! @:708\! @5:6!B58929H! 29! 40930\! IK9`0M\! /K968763! 5D! 3/065[<! D2HK873\! B531! 5D!

A<708A5:6!#`B78!+29H/!8KM3!/23!/0963!15H71/78!096!:713!5K1!0!32H/,!Z23!7<73\!:2G7!1/01!5D!7;78<597!7:37\! 087! D2C76! 59! 1/7! B029! 8506,! (08B783\! 682;29H! `77P3! 096! 180@1583\! [5K:6! M7!0882;29H!01!09<!12B7!15!P2@G!KP!B79!:2G7!#`B78!+29H/!D58![58G!29!1/728!D27:63,!&;79!59!0!H556!60<\!59:<!QUb!5D!1/7B![2::!H71![58G,!%2D7!23!/086,!$K1!D58!#`B78!+29H/\!21!23!M:233!03!@5BP0876!15!1/7!:2D7!/7![03!D58@76!15!:706!D58!<7083!29!/23!;2::0H7!*09H0:!c/K86,!!#`B78! +29H/![03!@0KH/1! 29! 0! ;2@25K3![7M!5D! M59676! :0M5K8! 0D178! 0! D08B78! D85B!/23!;2::0H7!7BP:5<76!/2B!03!0!@59180@1K0:!:0M5K878!D58!-?\UUU!8KP773!P78!099KB,!'9!:733!1/09!FX!8KP773!0!60<\!/7![58G76!37;79!60<3!0![77G\! D58!-?A-V!/5K83!7;78<!60<,!'9!1/7!60<3!/7![03!K90M:7!15!@5B7!15![58G!6K7!15!2::9733\!1/7!D08B78![5K:6!03G!#`B78!+29H/!15!P0<!0!D297!5D!-UU!8KP773,!.21/29!0!<708\!/7![03!0:35!D58@76!15!10G7!35B7!:5093!D85B!1/7!D08B

03G76!B7!15!M829H!B<!-XA<708A5:6!359!0:59H![21/!B7!15![58G,!"/787![03!951!7;79!0!329H:7! /5K8! 5795KH/!15!M7!D8776!M<!:0M5K8!0@12;2313,!Z7!70893!QUA>U!8KP773!0!60<!95[\![58G29H!59!0!602:<!M0323!29!D08B3,!!"/7!B292BKB!602:<![0H7!8017!29!IK9`0M!23!R>!8KP773,!$K1!312::!#`B78!+29H/!23!H8017DK:!D58! /23! 87@791:<A0@]K2876! D87765B,! #@@58629H! 15! 09! 7312B017\! 1/787! 087! 01! :7031!-UU\UUU!S597! :0G/T![58G783! 29!IK9`0M![/5!087!M59676! :0M5K8783,! E9! D0@1\! 1/737!087!@59180@1K0:! :0M5K8783! [/5! H71! @0KH/1! 29! 1/7! 67M1! 180P! 096! 796! KP! 03! M59676!:0M5K8783,!E9!IK9`0M\!1/787!23!09!29@870329H!18796!5D!/2829H!0H82@K:1K80:![58G783!59!0!@59180@1K0:!M0323\![/787!1/7<!H71!09!06;09@76!P0<B791!5D!-?\UUUA-L\UUU!8KP773!D58!1/7!791287!<708,!"/7!P558![58G783!796!KP!M5885[29H!3B0::!0B5K913! D58!M032@!97763!3K@/!03!/70:1/!@087,!"/7!29178731!8017!D58!3K@/!:5093!23!03!/2H/!03!QUb!P78!099KB,!#3!0!873K:1\!1/7!67M1!180P!@59129K73!D58!<7083\!35B712B73!P03329H!59!D85B!597!H797801259!15!0951/78,!E9!B531!5D!1/7!@0373\!51/78!B7BM783!5D!1/7!D0B2:<!0:35!H71!31K@G,!!"/787!/0;7!M779!@0373![/787! 1/7!B597<A:79629H! D08B783!/0;7! 10G79! 1/7!/5K373!5D!1/737!:0M5K8783!329@7!1/787!23!95!:096!15!0997C,!"/728!:2;7315@G!23!0:35!10G79!0[0<!096!1/7<! 796! KP! :2;29H! 29! 5P79! 3P0@73! 58! 29! @5BBK921<! P:0@73! :2G7! HK8K6[0803,! "/7!:096:5863! /0;7! 0:35! 67;2376! 0951/78! B71/56! 15! 793:0;7! :096:733! :0M5K8783_! 1/7<!P85;267! $/KGG2! SI5PP<!ZK3GT! 15![/2@/! 1/7! :0M5K8783! 1/79! M7@5B7! 0662@176,! #D178!@593KB29H!1/7!68KH\!1/7!:0M5K8783!M7@5B7!5M:2;25K3!15!D012HK7!096![58G!1287:733:<!29!1/7!D08B3!5D!1/728!:096:5863,!

SIK9`0MP09580B0,M:5H3P51,@/T

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

Page 19: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

3G"

$0C.&'"!"4"T%I',"&'4-&70,')"-%"I7N'"=&%%I@"U2&S"L''R7"/AI@@V"

B69!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!-'!37%!-'/#&"*)!(%.3#&!!"/7! 29@2679@7! 5D! M59676! :0M5K8! 23! 7C187B7:<! /2H/! 29! 1/7! 29D58B0:! 37@158\! P0812@K:08:<! 29!296K318273! [/2@/! 87]K287! B09K0:! P85@73373\! 087! 3182@1:<! :29G76! 15! 3703593\! 087! M0376! 29!87B517!P:0@73\!58![/2@/!/70;2:<!7BP:5<!B2H80913,!!iK088273!096!B2973\!M82@G!G2:93\!P5[78!:55B3\!/096:55B3\!82@7!B2::3\!3782@K:1K87!096!32:G![70;29H\![55:79!@08P71!P856K@1259\! D23/!P85@73329H\!096!@59318K@1259!087!1/7!296K318273![/787!M59676!:0M5K8!23!B531!P85B29791,!!!"/7!M82@G!G2:9!296K318<!@09!M7!K376!15!7C7BP:2D<!1/7!321K01259!5D!M59676!:0M5K8783![58G29H!29!1/7!29D58B0:!37@1583!5D!1/7!E96209!7@595B<,!!W7@8K21B791!5D!1/7!;2@12B3!5D!1/23!B56789!D58B!5D!3:0;78<! 23!@088276!5K1!1/85KH/!29178B76208273![/5!87@72;7!@5BB2332593!676K@176!D85B!1/7!:0M5K 58!32C!15!72H/1!B591/3!P78!<708!096!087!P026!P081!5D!1/728![0H73!59!0![77G:<!58!B591/:<!M0323\![21/!06`K31B7913!B067!01!1/7!796!5D!1/7!370359\!35!03!15!G77P!1/7![58G78!S096!/23!D0B2:<T!M5K9676!6K829H!1/7![/5:7!370359,!!.58G29H!/5K83!087!:59H!096!P0<B7913!M7:5[!1/7!:7H0:!B292BKB,!!)578@259!23!5D179!K376!15!623@2P:297!1/7![58G783!096!15!32:79@7!1/728!H827;09@73,F?!!

E9!1/7!O0K10B!$K6/0!N23182@1!5D!1/7!+1017!5D!^1108!I80673/![58G783!087!B531:<!B2H80913!D85B!&031789!^1108!I80673/\!$2/08\! 096!.731! $79H0:\! 29@:K629H! [5B79! 096! @/2:6879![/5! 087! 951! P026! D58! 1/728! [58G,! ! .58G29H! 096! :2;29H!@596212593! 29! 1/7! M82@G! G2:93! 087! H79780::<! ;78<! P558_!87HK:012593! 087! :0@G29H,! "/7! M82@G! G2:93! 087! K3K0::<!/70;2:<! HK08676! 096! 873182@12593! 087! 0:35! P:0@76! 59! 1/7!D87765B!5D!B5;7B791!5D!1/7![58G783,FF!!!!!

!

B6B!A%'$%&!$-"%'(-#'(!#/!0#'$%$!)*0#1&!5!(%)%.3%$!-((1%(!!"/7!62306;0910H7!5D!M7:59H29H!15!0!:5[!@0317!58!182M7\!58!M729H!0!;2@12B!5D!6287@1!58!296287@1!M59676! :0M5K8! 23!32H92D2@091:<!B587!P8595K9@76!D58! E96209![5B79!6K7!15!1/7!P5321259!5D![5B79!29!35@271<!29!H79780:,!

-GHIJKLM! NOGHKH! PQNORJ! 23! 1<P2@0::<! :29G76! 15! 1/7! 0H82@K:1K87! 096! M82@G! G2:9! 37@1583,!!.5B79!096!1/728!@/2:6879!087!M59676!6K7!15!1/7! D0@1! 1/01! 1/7!B0:7!5D! 1/7!/5K37/5:6! 23!0!M59676!:0M5K878M729H! 7CP5376! 15! :59H![58G29H! /5K83\! 1/7<!B0<! D0::! ;2@12B! 15! P/<32@0:! 096! 37CK0:! 0MK37!

Page 20: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;H"

.*(%!(31$,C!$#"%(3-.!2#&?!!

401/7[!D3B\!D85B!$09H0:587,!)/2:6879!087!0:35!7BP:5<76!03!65B7312@![58G783\!5D179!29!3:0;7A:2G7!@596212593,!"/7<!087!7CP7@176!15![58G!;78<!:59H!/5K83!096!D87]K791:<!87@72;7!37;787!PK923/B791!

@5A/53176!6K829H!1/7!^*!ZKB09!W2H/13!)5K9@2:!SZW)T!29!O797;0,!+/7!3P5G7!0M5K1!1/7!(809@23@09!P85H80BB7!6732H976!15!5M1029!`K312@7!D58!65B7312@![58G783!01!:5@0:!096!9012590:!:7;7:,!#D178!1/7!

B<! !

D85B!1/7!:096:586,!!.5B79!096!1/728!@/2:6879!@09!0:35!M7!35:6!15!1/286!P081273![21/5K1!7;79!M729H!29D58B76!2D!1/7!:096:586!67@2673!15!18093D78!1/7!@87621!/7!5[93!59!1/7!B0:7![58G78,!

$IJKLM!NOGHKH!PQNORJ!23!317062:<!29@870329H!D58![5B79!096!B0<!10G7!1/7!D5::5[29H!D58B3,!

!!F,FS-T'MOP'(U!NBTN4.'(0OP!P''!4587! 096! B587! [5B79! 096! H28:3! 087! D58@76! 2915! M59676! :0M5K8! K9678! 1/7! 35A@0::76!(67*&;*)-' (9F$7$\! [/2@/! 23! M7:27;76! 15! /0;7! 3108176! 29! 1/7! :017! -RLU3,! ! "/7! [586!(67*&;*)-!29!"0B2:!87D783!15!09!K9B088276!H28:!M7@5B29H!0!873P7@10M:7![5B09!M<!7917829H!2915! B08820H7,! ! "/7! 3@/7B7! 23! 0:35! G95[9! 03! 1/7!@5BB59!Z296K!B08820H7096!/03!15!M708!1/7!7CP79373!5D!1/7![76629H,!!(0B2:<!D85B!1/7!:5[!@03173![/5!@09951!M708!1/737! @5313! 087! P783K0676! M<! 0H7913\! K9678! 1/7!(67*&;*)-'(9F$7$\!15!32H9!0!@59180@1![/2@/!M2963!1/728!60KH/178!15![58G!D58!01!:7031!1/877!<7083!29!0!D0@158<\!29!7C@/09H7!D58!1/7!06;09@7!5D!1/7!B597<!977676!D58!1/7![76629H,! ! '9@7! 1/7! @59180@1! 23! 32H976\! 1/7! H28:3! 087!K9678!1/7!@59185:!5D!1/7!M85G78!58!1/7!D0@158<!096!1/728!@596212593!;08<!32H92D2@091:<\!67P79629H!59!D0@1583!3K@/!03![0H73! 096![58G29H! @596212593,! ! "/23! 23! 1/7! 870359![/<!1/7!(67*&;*)-'(9F$7$!B2H/1!951!M7!87@5H92a76!03!M59676! :0M5K8! 01! D2831\! MK1! 21! 23! 29! D0@1! 09! 7C0BP:7! 5D!B56789!3:0;78<,FV!!!!

$0C.&'"#"4"J&70,0,C"@'@@0%,"A%&"(%I',"80/-0I@"%A"=%,)')"67=%.&"

Page 21: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;3"

7-A7)-A73!0%(3!>&*.3-.%(!

E9! d02PK8\! 1/7!P5:2@7!H70876!KP! 15! :0K9@/!0!@0BP02H9!0H02931!/517:3! 29;5:;76! 29! 1/7!80@G71!5D!P853121K1259,!#[087!5D!1/7![2673P8706!K37!5D!@/2:6!P853121K173!29!/517:3\!1/7!d02PK8!P5:2@7!/0;7!

MK6H71!5973,!S"/7!"2B73!5D!E9620T!!

E9!dK:<!?U-?\!1/7!+296/KP0:@/5[G!N23182@1!)5K81!379179@76!0!P78359!0@@K376!5D!/0;29H!35:6!32C!H28:3! 15!M851/7:3! 29!#H80! 15!->U!<7083! 29! `02:,! !"/23! 23! 1/7! 37;78731! `02:! 178B!7;78! 29D:2@176!59!

@20:!/23158<,!S"/7!Z2B0:0<09T!

F,F!S?T'QR>(M.MUM.>B''!N73P217!29@59323179@273!29!1/7!6010!0;02:0M:7\!21!/03!M779!3P7@K:0176!1/01!0M5K1!179!B2::259!P853121K173![58G!29!E9620,!!"/7<!@5B7!P8765B29091:<!D85B!1/7!310173!5D!c089010G0\!#96/80!I80673/\!40/0803/180\!096!"0B2:!*06K\FX!096!D85B!972H/M5829H!*7P0:!096!$09H:0673/,!!'K1!5D!1/7!7312B0176!1[5!/K96876!H28:3!096![5B79![/5!79178!P853121K1259!29!E9620!7;78<!60<\!LUb!087!1/5KH/1!15!M7!D58@76! 2915! 21,FQ! !(2HK873!@59@78929H!@/2:6879! 29!P853121K1259!809H7!D85B!>U\UUU!15!XUU\UUU,F>!!.5B79!096!@/2:6879!087!7]K0::<!;2@12B3!5D!1/7!P853121K1259!296K318<\!096!$09H0:587!23!95[!597!5D!1/7!D2;7!B0`58!@21273! 29!E9620!D58!@/2:6!P853121K1259,! !)/2:6879!5D!P853121K176![5B79!087!;2@12B3!5D!0MK37!03![7::\!5D179!D58@76!15!P78D58B!609@73!096!359H3!D58!B0:7!MK<783!58!15!/0;7!37CK0:!29178@5K837![21/!1/7B,!!"/7! B029! P85;23259! [/2@/! 87HK:0173! P853121K1259! 29! E9620! 23! 1/7! .77"%*)' M%*22-9'@Q%$+$&8-"&A'N98'CLYZ,! ! #@@58629H! 15! 1/23! :0[\!P853121K173! @09!P80@12@7! 1/728! 18067!P82;017:<!MK1!@09951!:7H0::<!35:2@21!58!e376K@7e!@K315B783!29!PKM:2@,!):27913!@09!M7!PK923/76!D58!37CK0:!0@12;21<!29!P85C2B21<! 15! 0! PKM:2@! P:0@7,! '8H092a76! P853121K1259! SM851/7:3\! P853121K1259! 829H3\! P2BP29H\! 71@,T! 23!

2::7H0:,! I853121K1259! 03! 0! MK329733\! /5[7;78\! 23! 3K@/!0!B0`58! 233K7! 1/85KH/5K1! 1/7! @5K918<!1/01! 213! :7H0:2a01259! 096! 1/7! [58G29H! @596212593! 5D! 1/7! P853121K173! 087! @K88791:<! M729H!67M0176,!!W7@791:<\! 1/7!+KP87B7!)5K81! @:082D276! 1/01![/2:7! 21! 23!951! 377G29H! 15! :7H0:2a7!P853121K1259\!1/7!M79@

FL!!"/7! :08H731! 876A:2H/1! 623182@1! 29! E9620! 23! 1/7! (0:G:096! W506! c0B012PK80! 0870! 29! 4KBM02,!$851/7:3!087!3182@1:<!@59185::76!35!1/01![5B79!096!H28:3!@09951!73@0P7,!!"/7<!087!@5931091:<!

Page 22: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;;"

1/87017976!096!M70179!096!1/7<!@09951!87:<!59!1/7!/7:P!5D!1/7!P5:2@7,!!$732673!1/7!D0@1!1/01![5B79! @09951! 8K9! 0[0<\! 1/787! /0;7! M779! B09<! 293109@73! 5D! P5:2@7! 5DD2@783! 87HK:08:<!D87]K79129H!1/7!M851/7:3!096!5P780129H!29!@5::K3259![21/!1/7!5[9783!096!1/7!180DD2@G783,!!I5;781<\!297]K210M:7!623182MK1259!5D!29@5B7\!@K315B3\!623@82B2901259![21/29!1/7!D0B2:<\!096!1/7! :0@G! 5D! P85P78! 872917H801259! 378;2@73! 087! 1/7! B029! D0@1583! :70629H! [5B79! 15!P853121K1259,! !W7:2H259!B2H/1!0:35!M7!1/7!8551!@0K37!5D!35B7!D58B3!5D!P853121K1259\!3K@/!03!1/7!=$+*#*1-,!FR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 23: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;!"

(%.3-#'!F!5!.7-)$!)*0#1&!-'!-'$-*!

(58! 1/7! P78256! ?UUUA?UUR\! ^*E)&(! 7312B0173VU! 1/01! -?b! 5D! E96209! @/2:6879! [/5! [787!M71[779!D2;7!096!D5K81779!<7083!5:6!01!1/7!12B7!5D!1/7!3K8;7<!/0;7!M779!29;5:;76!29!@/2:6!:0M5K8,V-!

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a76! [21/! 1/7! B587! P85H87332;7![6+$&-)$'[618-9$'N98!S?UUUT!096!1/7!R-;F8'8"'P#69*8-"&'N98!S?UURT,!!!!!!Y25:79@7\! @58P580:! PK923/B791\! @/2:6! :0M5K8\! 096! 37CK0:! 0MK37! 5D! @/2:6879! 7BP:5<76! 03!65B7312@! [58G783! /0;7! M779! /2H/:2H/176! M<! 62DD78791! ^*! /KB09! 82H/13! B7@/0923B3,XU!!

$0C.&'"*"4"2&S"W.)0-B"/AI@@"R&%80)'@"')./7-0%,"-%"/B06)"

M--7&R&7)'@BS"

!"#$%&'('!)'%'*)'*"'!#*!(+'!'$%&#,'-!'.+/0/(!"+1-1"('-/2(/"2!3+/"+!1$#4*(!(#!!

"#*('$%#-1-,!1042'2!/2!!*#(!#*&,!/$$')/1('5!04(!+12!&#*67('-$!+1-$84&!-'%'-"422/#*2!!

!9:'*';15!<=!>4*'!=?<=@!

Page 24: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;#"

!

.*(%!(31$,C!!

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

*5971/7:733\! 97[3! @59@78929H! B2318701B791! 5D! @/2:6! 65B7312@! [58G783! D2::3! 1/7! E96209!97[3P0P783!7;78<!60<,!!!

!!

!

!

!

Page 25: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;*"

F64!37%!&%.&1-3"%'3!#/!.7-)$!)*0#1&%&(!!

#3![21/!06K:13\!@/2:6! :0M5K8! 23!@:537:<\!MK1!951!K92]K7:<\! :29G76!15!180DD2@G29HJ!@/2:6879!087!D58@2M:<!0M6K@176\! 182@G76\!58! :K876![21/!P85B2373!5D![58G![/2@/!97;78!M7@5B7!0!870:21<,!'9@7! 1/7! 180DD2@G76! @/2:6879! 087! M85KH/1! 15! 1/728! D290:! 67312901259! 1/7<! M7@5B7!P081! 5D! 0![58:6!5D! 2::7H0:21<\![58G29H! 29! 3:0;7A:2G7! @596212593! D85B![/2@/! 21! 23!9708:<! 2BP5332M:7! 15!73@0P7,X-!!)/2:6879!087!@5BB59:<!7BP:5<76!29!65B7312@!:0M5K8\!1/7!37C!296K318<\!B2:2108<!378;2@7\!03!M7HH083\! 096! 29! 1/7! 0H82@K:1K80:\! 7C180@12;7\! 096!B09KD0@158<! 37@1583,! ! E9! 1/7! :01178! @037\!$7762! 85::29H\! @08P71![70;29H\! 870829H!5D! 32:G! @5@5593\! 32:G![70;29H\! :701/78! D0@158273\! 096!1/7! P856K@1259! 5D! 30823\! 32:;78! `7[7:8<\! 096!3<91/712@! H7B315973! 087! 35B7! 5D! 1/7! 37@1583!29![/2@/!@/2:6! :0M5K8! 23! 7CP:52176,! "/787! 23! 0!@5BB59! 01121K67! 1/01\! 73P7@20::<! 29! 1/7!$7762\X?! @08P71\! 096! 32:G! 296K318273\! @/2:6879!B0G7!1/7!M731!P856K@13!M7@0K37!5D!1/728!3B0::!/0963,!!Y2@12B3! 087! 180DD2@G76! 2917890::<! SD85B!c089010G0\!#96/80!I80673/\!096!40/0803/180!15! 4KBM02\! D58! 293109@7T\! 03! [7::! 03! 0@8533!9012590:!M586783!D85B!*7P0:!096!$09H:0673/,!!E9! 35B7! @0373\! 180DD2@G783! 096! B266:7B79!D58@2M:<! 0M6K@1! @/2:6879_! 51/78! 180DD2@G783!10G7!06;0910H7!5D! 1/728!P783590:!87:012593/2P![21/! P558! D0B2:273! 15! @59;29@7! P087913! 15!

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

!

7-A7)-A73!!'%2!3&%'$(!

#! :08H7! 9KBM78! 5D! H28:3! 096! <5K9H![5B79! 180DD2@G76! D85B!62DD78791! P0813!5D! 1/7! @5K918<! 15! N7:/2! 087! M729H! 87A180DD2@G76! 15! M851/7:3! 29! 4778K1! 29!^1108! I80673/! 15! 7;067! 6717@1259,!!"/787! 087! 0:35! 293109@73! 5D! H28:3! 87A180DD2@G76!0@8533!01!:7031!D5K8!62DD78791!310173,!

h5K9H! [5B79! 087! 29! 35B7! @0373!D58@2M:<!68KHH76!M7D587!M729H! 35:6! D58!37C,! ! ^90M:7! 15! 873231! 58! 67D796!1/7B37:;73\! 1/7<! :537! 1/728!379373!096!@09951!87@0::![/01!/0PP7976,!

Page 26: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;1"

!

7-A7)-A73!!.7-)$!$#"%(3-.!2#&?%&(!

!E9! 1/7! +1017! 5D! )/0962H08/\! 1/7!7BP:5<B791! 5D! @/2:6879! 03! 65B7312@![58G783!D5::5[3!1/7!B562D276!)/2:6!%0M5K8!SI85/2M21259! 096! W7HK:01259T! #@1! -RLQ\![/2@/! /03! M779! 7CP09676! 15! 29@:K67! 03!/0a0865K3! 1/7! 7BP:5<B791! 5D! @/2:6879! 29!65B7312@! [58G! 096! 51/78! 08703\! 3K@/! 03!87310K80913\! /517:3\!B517:3\! 170! 3/5P3\! 096!8735813,! ! E9! 3P217! 5D! 1/7! M09\! 21! 23! 312::! 951!K9@5BB59! 15! D296! @/2:6879! 7BP:5<76! 03![021783!58!623/[03/783\!D58![/2@/!@/2:6879!7089!W3!?U!S:733!1/09!^+N!XU!@791T!096!1[5!B70:3!P78!60<,!!!!E9! )/0962H08/! 096! 3K885K9629H! 08703\!/K968763! 5D! @/2:6879! 087! 29! 7BP:5<B791_!951! 5K1! 5D! @/52@7! MK1! 5K1! 5D! @5BPK:3259,!+23178! *0B8010! d537P/! @DB33\! [/2:7![58G29H! [21/! 1/7! *012590:! N5B7312@!.58G783!45;7B791\!@596K@176!0!3K8;7<!5D!@/2:6! 378;0913! 29! D2;7! @5:59273! 5D!)/0962H08/! S40K:2! d0H809\! E96280! )5:59<\!)5:59<! *5,! X\! $/03G08! )5:59<! 096! $0PK!N/0BT,! ! +/7!B02910293! 1/01! @/2:6879![091!15! 011796! 3@/55:! MK1! 1/7<! @09951! M7@0K37!1/728! D0B2:273! 087! 155! P558! 15! :537! 1/7!29@5B7!1/7<!7089,!!

)0K373!5D! 1/23! @5917BP5808<! D58B!5D!3:0;78<!087!0!677P:<!855176!371!5D!B<1/3\! 1806212593\!096!87:2H2593,!!"/737!087!87:0176!15! A3@0:7!:5093!D58!1/7!8K80:!096!K8M09!P558!096!1/7!:0@G!5D!0!@59@78176!35@20:![7:D087!3@/7B7!15!30D7HK086!0H02931!/K9H78! 096! 2::9733\! 0! 959A@5BPK:358<! 096! K97]K0:! 76K@012590:! 3<317B\! 1/7! :0@G! 5D!7BP:5<B791!5PP581K921273!096!:2;29H![0H73!D58!06K:13\!@588KP1259!096!2962DD7879@7!0B59H!H5;789B791!5DD2@20:3\! XV!!!

F69!.SIPH!$OTKUMIL!)QNORJ**!!)/2:6! :0M5K8783! 087! 267912D276! 03! P783593! K9678! -L![/5! [58G! 29! /5K37/5:63! 51/78! 1/09!1/728! 5[9!096![/5!H79780::<!65!65B7312@! @/5873\! 10G7! @087! 5D! 1/7 ! @/2:6879\!

096! 8K9! 7880963,! ! E1! 0PP7083! 1/01! 103G3!P78D58B76!M<!@/2:6!65B7312@![58G783!1796!15!M7! 62;2676! 0@@58629H! 15! 1806212590:! H79678!85:73\!35!1/01!H28:3!087!B587!:2G7:<!15!M7!D5K96!P78D58B29H! 296558! [58G! 096! M5<3\! D58!7C0BP:7\!:55G!0D178!1/7!:2;7315@G,!!)/2:6879![58G!085K96!1/7!@:5@G!096!1/7<!087!5D179! ;2@12B3! 5D! ;25:79@7! 096! 623@82B2901259!D87]K791:<!87:0176!15!1/7!D0@1!1/01!1/7<!M7:59H!15! +@/76K:76! )03173! 58! +@/76K:76! "82M73,!!^3K0::<\!1/7<!65!951!/0;7!0@@733!15!76K@01259!MK1! [/79! 1/7<! 65\! 1/7! :59H! [58G29H! /5K83!B0G7!21! 2BP5332M:7!D58!1/7B!15!P78D58B![7::!01!3@/55:,!!E96209! @/2:6879! M7@5B7! 65B7312@! :0M5K8783!M7@0K37! 5D! ;0825K3! 8703593! 0::! :29G76! 15!P5;781<\! 3K@/! 03! P0<29H! M0@G! D0B2:<! :5093\!73@0P29H! D85B! 0! 185KM:76! /5B7A:2D7\! 096! 1/7!:0@G!5D!0!M71178!5P1259!15!3K8;2;7,!!!!O79678! 096! 71/92@! 623@82B2901259\! 35@20:!7C@:K3259\! :0@G! 5D! 76K@012590:! 5PP581K921273\!623P:0@7B791\! 096! B2H801259! 087! 2BP581091!D0@1583! 1/01! PK3/! @/2:6879! 2915! 65B7312@!:0M5K8,!!

!

Page 27: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;:"

.*(%!(31$,C!*'!%:>%&-%'.%$!.7-)$!$#"%(3-.!2#&?%&!!+K@/2910!23!95[!D5K81779!096!/03!M779!7BP:5<76!03!0!65B7312@![58G78!D58!37;780:!<7083!95[,!!!+K@/2910!H87[!KP![21/!1[5!3231783!096!1/877!M851/783!29!0!;2::0H7!29!d/08G/096_!/78!B51/78!23!

P087913! @5K:6! 951! 87P0<! 0! :509! 1/7<! 155G! 15! MK<! 0! 97@73308<!B0@/297,! !67@2676! 15! [21/680[! /78! D85B! 3@/55:! 35! 3/7! @5K:6! [58G! 59! 1/7! D0B2:<! :096,! ! +/7! 35:6!;7H710M:73\! @5::7@176! D287[556! 096! H80a76! 1/7! @011:7\! 29! 06621259! 15! [58G29H! D58! 0951/78!D08B78,!!"/7!B597<![03!97;78!795KH/!15!/7:P!/78!D0B2:<!35!1/7!:096![03!PK1!KP!D58!8791!096!+K@/2910!67@2676!15!M7@5B7!0!65B7312@![58G78!15!3KPP581!/78!D0B2:<,!!+/7!]K2@G:<!D5K96!0!`5M!

!!+K@/2910!673@82M73!/5[!1/7!D0B2:<!PK1!/78!15!31879K5K3![58G!D85B!X0B!15!--!PB,!!&;78<!12B7!3/7!685PP76!0!H:033!58!M85G7!0!P:017![/2:7!6529H!1/7!623/73!1/7!@531![03!676K@176!D85B!/78!0:8706<!B70H87!30:08<,!!"/7!D0B2:<!3108176!15!M701!/78!096!3@5:6!/78!D58!09<!P711<!870359\!:2G7!951! @:70929H! 1/7! D7BP:5<783!23!1/01!1/7<!9776!09!5M`7@1!59![/2@/!15!10G7!5K1!0::!1/728!D8K318012593,!N73P217!1/7!321K01259\!+K@/2910!23!312::!1/787\!M7@0K37!3/7!23!67178B2976!15!B0G7!795KH/!B597<!15!H71!/78!

B01K821<!096!/78!67178B2901259! 15! 3KPP581!/78! D0B2:<!B0G7!/78!09!5K13109629H!H28:! D58!/78!0H7,!!$K1!3/7!23!312::!0!H28:\!096!0!65B7312@![58G78,!!S)037!670:1![21/!M<!1/7!*012590:!N5B7312@!.58G783!45;7B791\!*N.4T

!!

"/7!321K01259!5D!@/2:6!65B7312@![58G783!23!1/K3!0! ;2@25K3! @<@:7\! 29! [/2@/! 1/7! 0MK373! [/2@/!682;7! @/2:6879! 2915! 65B7312@! [58G! ! ! ! 796! KP!M729H!1/7!G7<!D0@1583![/2@/!180P!1/7B!1/787,!!!!

!

!

!

$0C.&'"1"4"?B06)")%I'@-0/"(%&N'&@"-&90,C"-%")&7("-B'0&"R&%=6'I@"7-"-B'"(%&NR67/'"%,"R7R'&"

Page 28: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;F"

.*(%!(31$,C!.7-)$!"-'%&(!!E9! 1/7!+1017!5D!47H/0:0<0\!N23182@1!5D! d029120!Z2::3\!@/2:6879!673@796!P87@0825K3! :066783! 2915!

G977:29H!M7@5B73!2BP5332M:7!35B712B73,!!"/7<!:27!/582a5910::<!096!/0@G!@50:!D85B!1/7![0::3![21/!P2@G3!58!1/728!M087!/0963\![21/5K1![70829H!09<!G296!5D!P8517@1259,! !)/2:6!B29783!31081![58G29H! [/79! 1/7<! 087! 085K96! 1[7:;7,! Z5[7;78\! 1/5K30963! 5D! @/2:6879! 5D! 0::! 0H73! 087!M7:27;76!15![58G!0:59H3267!1/728!P087913!M7@0K37!1/728!3B0::!M56273!D21!2915!1/7!90885[!@50:!370B3,!

"/7! *012590:! ZKB09! W2H/13! )5BB233259! 5D! E9620! S*ZW)T! /03! 5P7976! 0! @037! S)037! *5,!??g-XgFg?U-UT! 096! 03G76! 1/7! 31017! H5;789B791! 15! 87P581! 59! 1/7! 0::7H01259! 1/01! 0M5K1!>U\UUU! @/2:6879! D85B! *7P0:\! $09H:0673/\! 096! ;0825K3! E96209! 310173! S#330B\! $2/08! 096!d/08G/096T![58G!29!1/7!P82;017!@50:!B2973!5D!d029120!Z2::3,!

F6B!%:3&*.3-+%!-'$1(3&,!

E9620! P856K@73! 085K96! 92971<! 62DD78791! 1<P73! 5D! B29780:! 096! 1/7! 7C180@12;7! 296K318<!87P !7@595B2@!H85[1/,!"/23!37@158!23!H85[29H!01!0!80P26! P0@7! 096! 21! 23! :2G7:<! 15! H85[! 01! 0! BK@/! D03178! 8017! 29! 1/7! @5B29H! <7083,! +29@7!P82;012a01259!3108176!29!1/7!708:<!-RRU3!S15H71/78![21/!D5872H9!6287@1!29;731B791T\!B2929H!23!95[! @088276! 5K1\!291789012590:!67B096\![21/!)/290!03!0!B0`58!B08G71!D58!E96209!B29780:3,XQ!

./01!23!1/7!2BP0@1!5D!B2929H!59! <=!

+1012312@3! 3KPP581! 1/7! 033781259! 1/01!B2929H! 29@870373! P5;781<,! +10173! 3K@/! 03! d/08G/096\!)//01123H08/\!096!'82330!67P796!/70;2:<!59!B29780:!8735K8@73!MK1!7CP78279@7\!@5BP0876!15!51/78! +10173\! :5[78! P78! @0P210! 29@5B73\! H870178! P5;781<\! :5[78! H85[1/! 80173! 096! /2H/78!:7;7:3!5D!B5810:21<\!B0:9K1821259!096!B58M2621<,!

"/7! B29780:A82@/! 623182@13! 5D! 1/7! @5K918<! 087! 0:35! 35B7! 5D! 1/7! P558731! 096! B531!K967867;7:5P76! 29! E9620,!(58!7C0BP:7\!c759`/08\![/2@/!P856K@73!597A 9!587\! 23! 809G76! ?V1/! 5K1! 5D! 1/7! FU! 623182@13! 29! '82330! 29! 1/7! ZKB09! N7;7:5PB791! E967C_!OK:M08H0\!1/7!:08H731!:2B731597!P856K@78!29!E9620\!23!1/7!37@596!:031!29!c089010G0_!c580PK1\![/2@/! P856K@73! B587! 1/09! VUb! 809G3! ?>1/! 5K1! 5D! '82623182@13,X>!

!

!

Page 29: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

;G"

./01!23!1/7!2BP0@1!5D!B2929H![21/!3P7@2D2@!87H086!15!@/2:6879=!

"/7!E%'!/03!@:082D276!1/01!P75P:7!:2;29H!29!B2929H!79;2859B7913!087!7CP5376!15!3KM/KB09!@596212593\! 0! 67H80629H! 79;2859B791! S@82B290:21<! 096! P853121K1259T\! @5BP:2@0176!67P79679@<!87:012593\!#EN+\!+7CK0::<!"8093B21176!N2370373\!;25:791!M7/0;2583\!096!0!:0@G!5D!:0[!096!58678,XL!!)/2:6879!@593121K17!VUb!5D!1/7!E96209!P5PK:01259!096!B09<!5D!1/7B!A!1/7!P558731! 096!B531!B08H290:2a76! A! :2;7! 29!B2929H! 08703\! 73P7@20::<! 3B0::A3@0:7\! 29D58B0:! 58!08123090:! B2973,XR! #B59H! B29783\! @/2:6879! D0@7! 7;79! H870178! @/0::79H73\! 73P7@20::<! 03!87H0863! 0@@733! 15! D556! 096! 76K@01259\! 623P:0@7B791! 096! 1/7! 2BP0@1! 59! 1/728! /70:1/,QU! "5!1/737\!21!BK31!M7!06676!1/7!823G!5D!M729H!7CP5376!15!29`K8273!096!S;78<!D87]K791T!0@@267910:!6701/3,!

)/2:6879![58G! 29! 0::! G2963!5D! 7C180@12;7! 296K318273\! D85B!@50:! 15!620B5963\! /5[7;78! 1/7<!0:[0<3! K9678H5! 1/7! 30B7! 37825K3! P/<32@0:\! 35@20:\! 37CK0:\! 096! P3<@/5:5H2@0:! 7CP:52101259!096! 87:0176! 180KB03,Q-! "/7! E%'! 096! 1/7! E91789012590:! I85H80BB7! 59! 1/7! &:2B2901259! 5D!)/2:6!%0M5K8! SEI&)T!/0;7! :23176!03!K90@@7P10M:7!0::! 103G3! 1/01! @/2:6879![58G29H! 29!B2973!K3K0::<! K967810G7\! [21/! 35B7! 62DD7879@73! 0B59H! K9678H85K96! B2929H! 5P78012593\! 5P79!@031!B2973\!B29780:!@59@791801259!096!31597!@8K3/29H,Q?!

E9!35B7!7C180@12;7!32173\!@/2:6879![58G!03!D08!03!RU!B71783!M79701/!1/7!H85K96![21/!85P73!58! 3:2PP78<! :066783! 15! @:2BM! 29! 096! 5K1,! ! "/7! ;7912:01259! 23! 29067]K017! 096! 1/7! :2H/129H!3<317B!9597C231791!35!1/7<!/0;7!15!K37!D:03/:2H/13!58!@096:73!15!:2H/1!1/728![0<!29!58!5K1\!03![7::!03!6K829H!1/728![58G,!!!

! 087! 3P8706! 0@8533! B09<! E96209! 310173! M732673!47H/0:0<0,QF! )/70P! @/2:6! :0M5K8! 23! K376! 01! B2973! 29! c089010G0\! 40/0803/180\! W0`031/09\!406/<0! I80673/\! )//01123H08/\! d/08G/096\! '82330\! 096! #96/80! I80673/,QV! ! "/7! $565A+091/0:! @59D:2@1! 5D! -RRQ! /06! 680B012@! 87P78@K332593! D58! BK@/! 5D! 1/7! 9581/A7031789!P5PK:01259\! 096! 7C0@78M0176! 1/7! @/2:6! :0M5K8! 233K7! 29! 1/23! 87H259,!409<! D0B2:273! 3KDD7876!

@5BP79301259!5D!W3,!-UU\UUU!S^+j!-\RR-,VXT!15!D0B2:273!D58@76!15!:2;7!29!87:27D!@0BP3\!1/787!087! 312::! +091/0:! D0B2:273! 0[02129H! 1/728! @5BP79301259,! ^90M:7! 15! 067]K017:<! D776!1/7B37:;73!096!76K@017!1/728!@/2:6879\!1/737!D0B2:273!/0;7!/06!15!79H0H7!29!0!/2H/!:7;7:!5D!@/2:6!:0M5K8,!

!!!!!!!!

Page 30: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!H"

.SIPHJKG!QJK!OVMKG!WIXKG!MYZK!LOJJKLMIOG!VPRIH![3IZZ5%\]!QGH!OGLK!MSKY!QJK!

QHHILMKH!MO!IM@!MSKY!ONKY!MSOUK!IG!LSQJWK!MO!WKM!MSKIJ!HQIPY!HOUK6

F6F!.7-)$!0%AA*&(!!!E9! N7:/2\! M7HH29H! 23! 597! 5D! 1/7!B531! @5BB59! 0@12;21273! @088276! 5K1! M<! @/2:6879\! 5D179! 03!<5K9H!03! D5K8!58! D2;7!<7083!5:6,! !./2:7! `K31!0!;78<!3B0::!P78@7910H7!5D!@/2:6879! 1K8976! 15!M7HH29H! 5D! 1/728! 5[9! ;5:21259\! 1/7!B0`5821<! 5D! 1/7B! 0PP708! 15! M7! D58@76! 2915! 21! 721/78! M<!1/728!P087913!58!M<!1/286!P081273!3K@/!03!180DD2@G783\!@82B290:!H09H3\!58!68KH!670:783,! !"/7!:01178!5D179!K37! 1/7!5:6731!@/2:6879! 15!H71!<5K9H!M5<3!0662@176! 15!68KH3,! ! E9! 1/23![0<\! 1/7!68KH!670:783!7C78@237!P5[78!5;78!1/7B\!87DK329H!15!P85;267!1/7B![21/!B587!68KH3!K9:733!1/7! @/2:6879! M7H! 15! M829H! 1/7B! DK81/78! 29@5B7,! ! E97;210M:<\! @/2:6879! D58@76! 15! M7H! 087!87HK:08:<! ;2@12B3! 5D! 37;787! M70129H3! 096! 0MK373! 2D! 1/7<! 65! 951! @5::7@1! 795KH/!B597<! D58!1/728! P018593,! !./79! 1/7<! 087! D58@76! M<! 1/728! D0B2:273\! ;0825K3! 318010H7B3! 087! K376,! (58!

7C0BP:7\!P087913!K37!5P2KB!15!B0G7!M0M273!@8<!29!58678!15!7;5G7!P21<! 29!P5179120:!659583\!096!0PP:<!@/2:2!P7PP78! 15!1/7!2BP8733259!5D!0!3P77@/!6230M2:21<,!!

)/2:6!M7HH083!/0;7!0:35! 15!67D796! 1/7B37:;73! D85B!51/78!318771!M7HH083! 29!58678! 15!G77P!1/728!3P51!59! 1/7!318771!096!35B712B73!M82M7! 1/7!P5:2@7! 15!0;526!088731,! ! E9!H79780:\! @/2:6!M7HH083! 65! 951! 7089!B597<! D58! 1/7B37:;73\! 65! 951! /0;7! 0@@733! 15! 76K@01259\! 7CP78279@7!:59H! [58G29H! /5K83\! :2;7! 29! /0a0865K3! /70:1/! @596212593! 096\! 2D! 180DD2@G76\! 1/7<! :2;7!37P080176!D85B!1/728!D0B2:273!D58!<7083,QX!!!

F6^!.7-)$&%'!-'!.#'/)-.3!!E9!/23!?U--!W7P581!15!1/7!^*!+7@K821<!)5K9@2:!59!0F-)#%$&'-&'N%7$#'0"&2)-981\!$09!c2A4559\!1/7! ^*! +7@87108<AO79780:\! P529176! 15! 1/7! 87@8K21B791! 096! K37! 5D! @/2:6879! M<! 1/7!405231!08B76!H85KP3\!0:35!G95[9!03!1/7!*0C0:2173\!03!597!5D!1/7!B0`58!P85M:7B3!0DD7@129H!@/2:6879!29! 35B7! 623182@13! 5D! )//01123H08/! +1017,QQ! ! Z7! 95176! 1/7! 0M379@7! 5D! 87:20M:7! 6010! 15!67178B297!1/7!9KBM78!5D!@/2:6879!0DD7@176\!MK1!/7!P802376!1/7!7DD5813!5D! 1/7!O5;789B791\!29@:K629H! 1/728! 0[0879733A802329H! P85H80BB73! 1/85KH/! 1/7! B7620! 096! 0! ;78<! 3P7@2D2@!P85H80BB7! S1/7! $0:! $096/K! +@/7B7T! 15! P8517@1! 1/7! 82H/13! 5D! @/2:6879! 29! *0C0:A0DD7@176!08703\!15!M7!2BP:7B79176!M<!1/7!*012590:!)5BB233259!D58!1/7!I8517@1259!5D!)/2:6!W2H/13!29!179!623182@13!5D!#96/80!I80673/\!#330B\!$2/08\!)//01123H08/!096!40/0803/180,!Q>!

*51[21/3109629H! 1/737! @5BB7960M:7! 7DD5813\! 1/787! 087! 293109@73! 29! [/2@/! 951! 59:<! 1/7!405231! B2:2120! 096! 1/7! +0:[0! dK6KBQL! 87@8K2176! @/2:6879! D58! 1/7! @59D:2@1\! MK1! 1/7!)//01123H08/! O5;789B791! 0:35! B067! K37! 5D! @/2:6879! 29! 1/7! 5DD2@20:! 08B<,! E1! /03! M779!87P58176!1/01![21/29!1/7!+P7@20:!I5:2@7!'DD2@783!S+I'3T!87@8K2176!M<!1/7!O5;789B791!15!D2H/1!

Page 31: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!3"

.*(%!(31$,C!-'(1&A%'3!A&#1>(!!I80B210! 23!09!72H/1779!<708!5:6!H28:! D85B! d/08G/096\!597!5D! 1[5!60KH/1783! 29!0! D08B29H!D0B2:<,!!!

I80B210! 23! 95[![58G29H![21/!451/78! "/78730! )59;791,! ! '97! 60<! 29! #KHK31! ?UUF\! 1[5!;2::0H7! H28:3! 03G76! /78! 2D! 3/7![5K:6! :2G7! 15! 0@@5BP09<! 1/7B! 15! 0! D028! 10G29H! P:0@7! 29! 0!9708M<! ;2::0H7,! ! I80B210! [03! 3K8P82376\! 03! 3/7! 626! 951! G95[! 1/737! H28:3! ;78<! [7::,!!Z5[7;78\!3/7![03!7C@2176!096!626!951!1K89!65[9!1/7!5DD78,!!#D178!1/7![/5:7!60<!3P791![21/!1/737!97[!D827963\!1/7!H85KP!315PP76!59!1/7![0<!M0@G!/5B7!01!0!82;78!15!/0;7!0!8731,!!#D178!/0;29H!870@/76!1/7![0178\!I80B210!1K8976!/78!/706!096!@5K:6!951!D296!1/7!51/78!1[5!H28:3!09<B587_! 1/7<! /06! 6230PP70876! 0:59H! [21/! 1/728! M2@<@:73,! ! I80B210! [03! 0995<76! MK1!B531:<!0D8026!M7@0K37!3/7!870:2a76!21![03!H71129H!608G!096!3/7![03!0:597,!!+K6679:<!1[5!B79!@0B7! 5K1! D85B! 1/7![5563! 096! 318K@G!KP! 0! @59;78301259\! 17::29H! /78! 0M5K1! 0! <5K1/!58H092a01259!096!35B7!1802929H!37332593,! !I80B210!626!951!K967831096!1/728!7CP:0901259\!MK1!3/7!D5::5[76!1/7B!03!1/7<!5DD7876!15!3/5[!/78!1/7![0<!M0@G!/5B7,!E931706\!1/7!1[5!B79!M85KH/1!/78!15!0!@0;7,! !+/7!1/79!K967831556!1/01!1/7!1[5!H28:3!B2H/1!/0;7!87@72;76!B597<! 29! 7C@/09H7! D58!/78,! ! "/7!@0;7! 1K8976!5K1! 15!M7! 1/7!M037!5D! 09! 293K8H791! H85KP\!1802929H!<5K1/3! 29!@82B290:!M7/0;25K8,! !"/7! 29318K@1583\!B79!M71[779!F?!096!FX\! 10KH/1!1/7B!/5[!15!K37!85P73\!82D:73\!096!M5BM3!15!2912B26017!;2::0H783!096!H71!B597<!096!D556!D85B! 1/7B,! ! I80B210\! K9678! 1/8701! 5D! 6701/\! /06! 95! 51/78! @/52@7! MK1! 15! 310<,! ! "/7!3KP78;23583!@5931091:<!G7P1!09!7<7!59!/78\!37;787:<!PK923/29H!/78!096![/57;78!7:37!60876!15! 6235M7<! 586783,! ! "0:G29H! [03! 951! 0::5[76! 096! 1/787! [03! 95! P5332M2:21<! 5D! B0G29H!D827963,!!#D178!32C!B591/3!5D!0MK37!096!2965@182901259\!I80B210!67@2676!15!M870G!5K1!096!B090H76!15!7:K67!1/7!3K8;72::09@7!01!1/7!9708M<!82;78\![/787!3/7![03!3KPP5376!15!M01/7,!!+/7![03!P/<32@0::<!096!B7910::<!7C/0K3176,! !*5[!I80B210!23!0!65B7312@![58G78!D2H/129H!D58! /78! 82H/13_! 1/7! 17882M:7! 7CP78279@7! 3/7! K9678[791! B067! /78! 31859H78! MK1! 0:35!@59;29@76! /78! 1/01! ;25:79@7! 23! 951! 0! 35:K1259,! ! *51!B09<! @/2:6879! /0;7! M779! :K@G<! :2G7!I80B210\!58!/0;7!/78!31879H1/,!

!S)037!670:1![21/!M<!1/7!*012590:!N5B7312@!.58G783!45;7B791\!*N.4T

29! 1/7! @59D:2@1\!B09<!35:62783! @09!M7!7032:<! 267912D276! 03!B29583! @5B29H! D85B! 1/7!#62;032!@5BBK921273![/2@/!P5PK:017!1/7!87H259,!!!

"/7!:0@G!5D!3<317B012@!M281/!87H231801259!B0G73!21!2BP5332M:7!15!8K:7!5K1!1/7!P5332M2:21<!1/01!K9678A-L!<708!5:6!@/2:6879!0@12;7:<!P0812@2P017!29!1/7!@59D:2@1,!!"/737!@/2:6!35:62783\!1802976!M<! 1/7! 31017! P5:2@7! 096! 37@K821<! D58@73\! 3KDD78! D85B! 29`K8273\! 6230M2:21273\! 096! 180KB0! 03! 0!873K:1!5D! 1/7!;25:79@7! 1/7<!7CP78279@7,! !"/7<!087!5D179! D58@2M:<! 87@8K2176\! 37P080176! D85B!1/728!D0B2:273\!096!3KM`7@176!15!29/KB09!PK923/B791!2D!1/7<!@09951!DK:D2::!1/728!6K1273,QR!

!

Page 32: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!;"

(KLMIOG!^! !0&-'A-'A!*0#13!.7*'A%"!

^64!0#'$%$!)*0#1&C!*!+-#)*3-#'!#/!71"*'!$-A'-3,!!$59676!:0M5K8!096!@5917BP5808<!D58B3!5D!3:0;78<!S)(+T!29!H79780:!@593121K17!;25:012593!5D!

!^92;7830:!N7@:0801259!5D!ZKB09!W2H/13!S^NZWT!3713!5K1!29!213!I870BM:7,!!#1!1/7!30B7!12B7\!M59676! :0M5K8! 096! )(+! 087! ;25:012593! 5D! 1/537! 82H/13! S82H/1! 15! :2M781<\! 82H/1! 951! 15! M7!623@82B290176!0H02931\!71@,T! 15![/2@/!7;78<597! 23!79121:76\![21/5K1!623129@1259!5D!09<!G296\!3K@/!03! 80@7\! @5:5K8\! 37C\! :09HK0H7\! 87:2H259\! P5:212@0:!58!51/78!5P29259\!9012590:!58! 35@20:!582H29\!P85P781<\!M281/!58!51/78!3101K3, >U!!E9! 3P217! 5D! 1/7! :7H23:01259! 065P176! 096! 1/7! P85H80BB73! 096!P5:2@273! 2BP:7B79176! 01! 1/7!+1017! 096! @79180:! :7;7:\! 03! [7::! 03! 1/7! 5M:2H012593! E9620! /03! 15[086! 1/7! 291789012590:!@5BBK921<\! M59676! :0M5K8! 87B0293! 0! 870:21<! 1/85KH/5K1! 1/7! @5K918<,! ! (K81/78B587\!M59676! :0M5K8\! 03![7::! 03! 51/78!B092D731012593! 5D!B56789! 3:0;78<! 87HK:08:<! @/09H7! 2915!97[!D58B3!62DD2@K:1!15!K967831096\!6717@1\!096!78062@017,!!!!#! 31859H! 096! K9092B5K3! P5:212@0:! [2::! 15! M829H! 0M5K1! @/09H7! 312::! :0@G3! 096! 155! 5D179!7BP:5<783!79H0H7!M59676!:0M5K8![21/!2BPK921<,!!"/23!0BM2HK5K3!321K01259!79@5K80H73!1/7!;25:01583! 096! D58@73! 1/7! B531! ;K:9780M:7! 2915! 0MK32;7! 096! 7CP:521012;7! 321K012593! D85B![/2@/!1/7<!@09951!73@0P7,!!./2:7! E9620! /03! 29/782176! 318K@1K80::<! 791879@/76! 35@25A7@595B2@\! @K:1K80:\! 096! 87:2H25K3!1806212593\!1/23!3/5K:6!951!M7!0@@7P176!03!0!870359!D58!B029102929H!1/7!18*861'\6"/'!!

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

Page 33: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!!"

!./01!23!06;5@0@<!1/79=!!D)8%/7/9" 0@! 9D:K79@29H!67@232593\! P85H80BB73\! P5:2@273! 096! :7H23:01259! 01! :5@0:\! 9012590:! 096! 291789012590:! :7;7:_!096! 97H5120129H![21/! 0::! 310G7/5:6783! 15! M829H! 0M5K1! @/09H7! 096! 15! 0@/27;7! 0!B587! `K31!35@271<!!D)8%/7/9" 0@! M0376! 59! 0! 677P! K96783109629H! 5D! 1/7! 233K73! 29! ]K731259,! ! "/23! @09951! M7!0@/27;76! [21/5K1! [58G29H! [21/! 1/7! ;2@12B3,! "/7<! /0;7! 1/7! 6287@1! 7CP78279@7! 096!G95[:76H7,!!Z5[7;78\!1/7<!087!5D179!2H95876,!!D)8%/7/9"0@!H2;29H!1/7!;2@12B3!0!;52@7!15!3P70G!KP,!!D)8%/7/9"70I@!15\!6287@1:<!58!296287@1:<\!2BP85;7!1/728!]K0:21<!5D!:2D7,!!!!!

^6B!!!(1AA%(3-#'(!/#&!%//%.3-+%!*$+#.*.,"!

0K! Q_QJK! OV! MSK! IUURK,! ! c95[29H! [/01! M59676! :0M5K8! 096! 51/78! 3:0;78<A:2G7!P80@12@73! 087! 23! DK960B7910:! 15! M729H! 0M:7! 15! 87@5H92a7! 1/7B! 03! 3559! 03! <5K! D0@7!1/7B,!"/23!/096M55G!02B3!15!291856K@7!D58B3!096!@0K373!5D!M59676!:0M5K8!096!)(+!35!03!15! H2;7! 1/7! 870678! 09! 2670!5D! 1/7! ;0825K3! D58B3!M59676! :0M5K8! @09! 10G7! 29! 870:21<,!!"/7!/5P7! 23! 1/01! 1/7! 870678![2::!M7!B067!B587!0[087!5D! 1/23! 233K7!096!M7!0M:7! 15!6717@1!D58B3!5D!)(+!29!/23!@5BBK921<\!;2::0H7\!@21<\!31017\!71@,!

! &KUKQJLS! QGH! PKQJG! 0M5K1! :7H23:01259\! P5:2@273\! 096! P85H80BB73! 01! 1/7! :5@0:\!9012590:!096!@79180:!:7;7:3,!!"/23!23!5D!1/7!K1B531!2BP58109@7!D58!06;5@0@<!0@12;21273\!P0812@K:08:<![/79!D58BK:0129H!0@1259!P:093!096!97H5120129H![21/!1/537!29!P5[78,!!!

! 1GHKJUMQGH!/5[!<5K!@09!M731!K37!1/7!G95[:76H7!096!29D58B01259!0@]K2876,!!c95[!<5K8!:7H0:!82H/13!096!:2B213!29!87H086!15!<5K8!S58!<5K8!58H092a01259 T!29;5:;7B791!29!06;5@0@<,!

! (SQJK!YORJ!`GO_PKHWK!096!B0G7!03!BK@/!P75P:7!03!<5K!@09!0[087!0M5K1!M59676!:0M5K8!096!51/78!)(+,!E1! 23! 2BP581091! 15!G77P! 29!B296! 1/01\! 73P7@20::<! 29! 321K012593![/787!M59676! :0M5K8!/03!180939012590:!096!2917831017!D701K873\!1/7!@/0::79H73!D0@76!01!1/7!:5@0:!:7;7:!087!

Page 34: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!#"

951! K92]K7,! ! Y78<! 5D179! 51/78! @5BBK921273! D0@7! 32B2:08! P85M:7B3,! ! '8H092a29H!B77129H3! 01! 1/7! :5@0:\! 87H2590:\! 58! 9012590:! :7;7:![21/! 51/78! @5BBK921273! 15! 3/087!@59@7893! 096! M731! P80@12@73! B2H/1! 2BP85;7! 1/7! @/09@7! 15! M7! /7086! 01! 1/7! S:5@0:\!9012590:\!@79180:T!H5;789B791!:7;7:\!096!B2H/1!M829H!97[!26703,!

! 0K!IGLPRUIXK,!!O71!P75P:7!59!M5086!D85B!0::!37@1583!5D!1/7!35@271<J!!B79!096![5B79\!@/2:6879\! P75P:7! 5D! 62DD78791! 87:2H259\! M0@GH85K96! 096! 35@20:! 3101K3_! 959AP85D21\!H5;789B791!096!P82;017!37@158!0@1583\!71@,!!!E9! 3KB\! 1/7!M850678! <5K8! @50:21259! 1/7![2678! 213! :29G![21/! 1/7! @5BBK921<! 096! 1/7!@/09@7!15!M7!3K@@733DK:![/2:7!06;5@0129H!0H02931!M59676!:0M5K8!096!)(+,!

! 0K! UMJQMKWIL,! ! +/087! [/01! <5K! G95[! [21/! 7:7@176! 5DD2@20:3! <5K! 58! <5K8! 971[58G!G95[3_!011796!5DD2@20:!B77129H3_!K967831096![/5!/03!1/7!P5[78!15!10G7!67@232593!35!03!15!D5@K3!<5K8!011791259!59!1/23!P78359_!58H092a7!0!@50:21259!5D!@59@78976!P75P:7!29!<5K8!@5BBK921<,!

! 3SK!ITZOJMQGLK!OV!IGMKJGQMIOGQP!QHXOLQLY,!!#:1/5KH/!87P87379129H!:5@0:!@59@7893!01!1/7!9012590:!:7;7:!23!1/7!D2831!06;5@0@<!317P\!21!23!35B712B73!97@73308<!15!M829H!1/7!30B7! @59@7893! 15! 1/7! 291789012590:! :7;7:! 15! M7! /7086,! ! E1! 23! P5332M:7! 15! 5;78@5B7!9012590:!M0882783!096!PK1!P8733K87!59!H5;789B7913!1/85KH/!291789012590:!06;5@0@<,!!(809@23@093! E91789012590:! S(ET! 23! 1/7! 29318KB791! D58! (809@23@093! 096! P0819783! 15!M829H! 0M5K1! @/09H7_! (E! 23! 0! M826H7! 1/01! :29G3! 1/7! H803385513! 15! 1/7! 291789012590:!@5BBK921<\!29!P0812@K:08!1/7!^92176!*012593,!!)5931091:<!7CP09629H!213!971[58G!096![7:@5B29H!97[!P5332M2:21273! D58! @5::0M5801259\!(E![58G3! 15! 31879H1/79! 1/7!;52@7!5D!1/7!B531!;K:9780M:7,!

!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 35: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!*"

*''%:!5!#+%&+-%2!#/!37%!*>>)-.*0)%!-'3%&'*3-#'*)!)%A*)!/&*"%2#&?!

46!#&-A-'(!!!

"/7!P85/2M21259!5D!3:0;78<!096!3:0;78<A $%;*'"7&$1' 23!0!6K1<!1/01!70@/!31017!/03!15[086!1/7!291789012590:!@5BBK921<!03!0![/5

!>-!

!"/7! D2831! 67D2921259! 5D! 3:0;78<! 23! 793/82976! 29! 1/7! 0-12%&' 3)21"-4' 5()6%#7' 8"-6%-21"-\![/2@/![03!065P176!K9678!1/7!0K3P2@73!5D!1/7!%70HK7!5D!*012593!29!O797;0!59!?X!+7P17BM78!-R?Q,!"/7!)59;791259![03! 0B79676!M<! 1/7!I8515@5:! 065P176! 01! 1/7!Z706]K081783! 5D! 1/7!^92176!*012593\!*7[!h58G\!59!>!N7@7BM78!-RXF!096!8012D276!M<!E9620\![/2@/![03!312::!K9678!1/7!$82123/!&BP287\!3101K3!58!@59621259!5D!0!P78359!5;78![/5B!09<!58!0::!5D!1/7!P5[783!0110@/29H!15!1/7!82H/1!5D!

0@]K2321259!58!623P530:!5D!0!P78359![21/!291791!15!876K@7!/2B!15!3:0;78<_!0::!0@13!29;5:;76!29!1/7!0@]K2321259!5D!0!3:0;7![21/!0!;27[!15!37::29H!58!7C@/09H29H!/2B_!0::!0@13!5D!623P530:!M<!30:7!58!7C@/09H7!5D!0!3:0;7!0@]K2876![21/!0!;27[!15!M729H!35:6!58!7C@/09H76!096\!29!H79780:\!

!!#D178!.58:6!.08!EE\!1/7!P8517@1259!5D!/KB09!82H/13!M7@0B7!597!5D!1/7!B029!P825821273!5D!1/7!291789012590:! @5BBK921<! 096! 0:35! 1/7! 0M5:21259! 5D! 3:0;78<! 096! 3:0;78<! 87:0176! P80@12@73,!!#812@:7! V! 5D! 1/7! -RVL'0-16%#4)(' 9%$()#)21"-' ":';+<)-'=1.>24!

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a73\! 29!#812@:7!Q\! 1/01! 1/7!82H/1! 15!

[0H73!096!87BK978012593!1/01!70@/!31017!/03!1/7!5M:2H01259!15!P8517@1!S#812@:73!X\!>\!096!LT,!C>%'="<%'52)2+2%'":'2>%'A-2%#-)21"-)('8#1<1-)('8"+#2!!SE))T!29! 1/7! :231! 5D! @82B73! 0H02931! /KB0921<! D0::29H! 2915! 1/7! `K82362@1259! 5D! 1/7! )5K81! S#812@:7!>S@TS?T,!!

Page 36: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!1"

96!$%+%)#>"%'3(!!

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a01259!0@8533!291789012590:!M586783! !21!H573!M7<596!1/7!1806212590:!67D29212593!5D!3:0;78<,!!E9!1/23\!1/7!I8515@5:!B288583!1/7!18*861'\6"!5D!3:0;78<!95[060<3,!!#812@:7! F! 5D! 1/7! Q*)$%7"' Q%"8"9")! 18093D78\!

5D! P0<B7913! 58! M797D213! 15! 0@/27;7! 1/7! @593791! 5D! 0! P78359! /0;29H! @59185:! 5;78! 0951/78!! ! (K81/78B587\! 1/7! 30B7! P85;23259' @:082D273! 1/01\!

7CP:52101259\!D58@76!:0M5K8!58!378;2@73\!3:0;78<!58!P80@12@73!32B2:08!15!3:0;78<\!378;21K67!58!! 1/7! %*8-"'5D! 1/7! I8515@5:! 23! @:708:<! 15! 79@5BP033! 0::!

B56789!D58B3!5D!3:0;78<!096!3:0;78<A87:0176!P80@12@73,!!!

@591297913!096!B531!@5K918273!5D! 1/7![58:6\>F 1/01! 1/7!B0960173!5D!7C23129H!+P7@20:!

)5K9@2:! SZW)T! 87P:0@76! 1/7!.58G29H!O85KP! 59! )5917BP5808<! (58B3! 5D! +:0;78<![21/! 1/7!!5?%$1)(' =)??"#2%+#' "-' 8"-2%<?"#)#7' :"#<4' ":' 5()6%#7/' 124' 8)+4%4' )-&' 8"-4%I+%-$%4![/537! B096017! 29@:K673! 67M1! M5960H7\! 378D65B\! D58@76! :0M5K8\! @/2:6! 3:0;78<\! 37CK0:!3:0;78<\!D58@76!58!708:<!B08820H73!096!1/7!30:7!5D![2;73,!!"/7! 7DD5813! 15! @5BM01! 0::! D58B3! 5D! 3:0;78<! 087! 0:35! PK1! D58[086! M<! 51/78! 291789012590:!58H092a012593\! [21/29! 1/728! 873P7@12;7! D27:63! 5D! 0@1259,! ! "/7! E91789012590:! %0M5K8!'8H092a01259! SE%'T\! D58!7C0BP:7\!/03!065P176!096!3KP78;2373! 2BP581091! 29318KB7913!3K@/!03! 1/7! AJE' !"#$%&' J)*"+#' 8"-6%-21"-' ":' KLMN' O3"PQLR@! MSK! AJE' @*"(121"-' ":' !"#$%&'J)*"+#' 8"-6%-21"-/' KLST' O3"P' KNSR@! QGH! MSK! AJE' H"#42' !"#<4' ":' 8>1(&' J)*"+#'8"-6%-21"-/'KLLL'O3"P'KUQA'''

Page 37: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!X,)"Y%-'@"-!^92176!*012593\!(0@1!+/771!*5,!-V\!97+-/>?7;*;<)@7;>8)7A)BC*D/;<\!-,!?!'DD2@7!5D! 1/7!^92176!*012593!Z2H/!)5BB23325978! D58!ZKB09!W2H/13\!N0;26!.7233M8561! 096!#912A+:0;78<! E91789012590:\!EF7C58.5+G)BC*D/;<)*+,)5-8)97+-/>?7;*;<)@7;>8\!?UU?\!>,!F!"/7!.58:6!$09G\!H+,5*)ID/;D5/J\!01!/11PJgg[[[,[58:6M09G,58Hg79g@5K918<g29620g5;78;27[,!V!N02:<!*7[3!096!#90:<323\!K7D/;-<),5?8)-7)0"L&M)5+)011"N!1O)KC*++5+G)97>>58857+\!-R!408@/!?U-?\!01!/11PJgg[[[,69029620,@5Bg29620g87P581kP5;781<A62P3A15A?RALP@1A29A?UURA-UAP:09929HA@5BB233259k-QQVF>X,!X! E9620!/03!8012D276!B09<!5D! 1/7!B0`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c01/B096K! 59! X! d09K08<! ?UU?T,! ! +77! #PP7962C! -! D58! 09! 5;78;27[! 5D! 1/7!291789012590:!096!9012590:!:7H0:!D80B7[58G3!@59@78929H!1/7!P85/2M21259!5D!3:0;78<!096!3:0;78<A:2G7!P80@12@73!0PP:2@0M:7!15!E9620,!Q!E91789012590:!%0M5K8!'8H092a01259!SE%'TT)HUI)EP-57+)EG*5+8-)=;*AA5PQ5+G)5+)V:>*+)W/5+G\!?UUL\!F\!096!E%'!(58@76!%0M5K8!+1012312@3\!01!/11PJgg[[[,2:5,58HgPKM:2@g79H:23/g87H259g7K8P85gB53@5[g97[3g?UUXgD0@13/771G7<31012312@379,P6D,!>!E%'!'M378;01259!S)&#)WT!A!065P176!?U--\!PKM:23/76!-U-31!E%)!3733259!S?U-?T\!(58@76!%0M5K8!)59;791259\!-RFU!S95,!?RT!A!E9620!SW012D2@01259J!-RXVT,!L!+//!"/7!^92176!+10173!5D!#B782@0\!N7P081B791!5D!+1017\!=;*AA5PQ5+G)5+)K/;87+8)S/?7;-\!H+,5*!S-R!dK97!?U-?T,!R! N5990! 4,! ZKH/73\! %0K80! d5<! +P58@2@\! *06297! l,! 47967:35/9\! Y097330! )/28H[29\! =./) @*P-F77Q) 7+) XC7F*C) B/Y:*C)ZY?C75-*-57+\!)50:21259!#H02931!"80DD2@G29H!29!.5B79\!-RRR\!01!/11PJgg[[[,K82,76Kg0813@2g[B3g/KH/73g29620,/1B,!-U!H,L!--!+0803K!&,!"/5B03\!S/8?7+8/8)-7)V:>*+)=;*AA5PQ5+G)5+)W*+GC*,/8.T)H+,5*T)6/?*C)*+,)B;5)U*+Q*L))U/G*C)*+,)K7C5P<)S/D5/J\!^92176!*012593!'DD2@7!59!N8KH3!096!)82B7\!?U--\!?X,!-?!)50:21259!#H02931!"80DD2@G29H!29!.5B79!S)#".T\!B7:-./*8-)E85*)*+,)K*P5A5P\!01!/11PJgg[[[,@01[291789012590:,58HgD0@1M55Gg#320k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a76!37@158,!+77!E9D58B0:!+7@158!E9620J!#PP850@/73!D58!+5@20:!+7@K821<\!01!/11PJgg:0M5K8,92@,29g33gE*('W4#%+&)"'WE*E*NE#A0PP850@/73D58+5@20:+7@K821<,P6D,!->! N,! (299\! $59676! %0M5K8! 29! E9620\! 29! "5P2@0:! W73708@/!N2H731J! ZKB09! W2H/13! 096! )5917BP5808<! +:0;78<\! ?UUL\! Q\! 01!/11PJgg[[[,6K,76KgG58M7:g/8/[g873708@/62H731g08@/2;7,/1B:,!-L!#,!c0PK8\!!#,!+/7P/786\!+,!$/267\!#,!+/0/\!!#,!c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c0B20K12! #@1\! -R?U\! 1/7!406803! N7M1! $5960H7!#M5:21259!#@1\!-RVU_!1/7!'82330!N7M1!$5960H7!#M5:21259!W7HK:01259!-RVL_!1/7!W0`031/09!+0H82!+<317B!#M5:21259!#@1\!-RQ-_!1/7! '862909@7! P85BK:H0176! M<! O5;789B791! 5D! #96/80! I80673/! S?L,UL,>XT\! 406/<0! I80673/! S?X,UR,>XT! 096! c089010G!S?U,-U,>XT,!?F!+77!E%'!'M378;01259!S)&#)WT!A!065P176!?UUR\!PKM:23/76!RR1/!E%)!3733259!S?U-UT!096!E%'!'M378;01259!S)&#)WT!A!065P176!?U--\!PKM:23/76!-U-31!E%)!3733259!S?U-?T\!(58@76!%0M5K8!)59;791259\!-RFU!S95,!?RT!A!E9620!SW012D2@01259J!-RXVT,!?V!*012590:!ZKB09!W2H/13!)5BB233259\!*7[!N7:/2\!E9620!01!/11PJgg[[[,9/8@,92@,29g,!!?X!I782562@!W7;27[,!?Q!H,L!

Page 38: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?>!W7P581!5D!1/7!&CP781!.58G29H!O85KP!59!$59676!%0M5K8\!+71!KP!M<!1/7!9012590:!ZKB09!W2H/13!)5BB233259!A!40<!?UU-,!?L! E%'\!W7P581!5D! 1/7!N287@158AO79780:\!B-7??5+G) A7;P/,)U*F7:;\! @2176,! !+77\!87@791:<! 1/7!40/01B0!O096/2!*012590:!WK80:!&BP:5<B791!OK0809177!#@1\!?UUX!S4O*W&O#T,!?R!#912A+:0;78<!E91789012590:\!K7D/;-<T)[58P;5>5+*-57+)*+,)BC*D/;<L))@2176\!-AL,!FU! "/7! E%'! 87P5813! 1/01! 29! IK9`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`5G;*-57+) *+,) U*F7:;) K;7P/88/8\! *'EN#\! Y,! Y,! O282! *012590:!%0M5K8!E93121K17\!B2B75\!@2176!29!W0;2!+,!+82;0310;0\!W7+,/,)U*F7;)5+)H+,5*\!@2176\!-R,!FV! (028! .708! (5K9601259\! +7P17BM78! ?U-U\! B:>*+G*C5) BP./>/) *+,) F7+,/,) C*F7:;) 5+) H+,5*\! 01!/11PJggD028[708,58Hg2B0H73g?U-UAURgD[DkkAk29620kAk3KB09H0:2k3@/7B7,P6D!!FX!N5990!4,!ZKH/73\!=./)@*P-F77Q)7+)XC7F*C)B/Y:*C)ZY?C75-*-57+\!@2176,!FQ!R7;8-)@7;>8)7A)9.5C,)U*F7:;)[*-*T)H+,5*\!01!/11PJgg[[[,H:5M0:B08@/,58Hg[5831D58B387P581g[58:6g29620,/1B:!,!F>!^*'N)\!^*OE("\!E*NE#\!B7:-.)E85*)S/G57+*C)97+A/;/+P/O)S/8?7+,5+G)-7)=;*AA5PQ5+G)A7;)B/Y:*C)ZY?C75-*-57+)5+)B7:-.)E85*T)S/8?7+,5+G)-7)=;*AA5PQ5+G)A7;)B/Y:*C)ZY?C75-*-57+)5+)B7:-.)E85*\!W7H2590:!^*,OE("!477129H\!*7[!N7:/2\!-UA--!'@15M78!?UU>,!FL! U*J) H8) X;//QL) U*<>*+) -7) U*J>*+T! H+,5*+) U*J8) 7+) K;78-5-:-57+O) B.7:C,) 5-) F/) C/G*C5a/,\! ?Q! 40<! ?U-U\! 01!/11PJgg[[[,:0[23H877G,@5Bg296209A:0[3A59AP853121K1259A296K318<A3/5K:6A21AM7A:7H0:2a76_! E9620! "560<\! B:?;/>/) 97:;-)P7+85,/;8) ;/G:C*-5+G) ?;78-5-:-57+\! ?U! dK:<! ?U--\! /11PJgg296201560<,291560<,29g3158<g3KP87B7A@5K81AP853121K1259g-g-VXX?-,/1B:_!"/7!Z296K\!B/Y)J7;Q/;8)>:8-)+7-)F/)*CC7J/,)-7)7?/;*-/T)9/+-;/)-/CC8)B:?;/>/)97:;-\!-F!dK:<!?U-?\! 01! /11PJgg[[[,1/7/296K,@5Bg1560<3AP0P78g1PA9012590:g0812@:7FQFFQUX,7@7_! "/7! "2B73! 5D! E9620\! R/) *;/) +7-)/+P7:;*G5+G) 8/Y) J7;Q/;8T) B:?;/>/) 97:;-) PC*;5A5/8\! ?Q! dK:<! ?U-?\! /11PJgg0812@:73,12B735D29620,2962012B73,@5Bg?U-?AU>A?Qg29620gF?LQLUR>k-k[58G783A0P7CA@5K81AP853121K1259!,!FR!.2::20B!N0:8<BP:7\!B/;D5+G)-./)X7,,/88L))=./),*+G/;7:8)C5A/)7A)*)8*P;/,)8/Y)J7;Q/;\!?UUL\!"/7!*7[!h58G78\!01!/11PJgg[[[,97[<58G78,@5Bg87P58129Hg?UULgULgUVgULULUVD0kD0@1k60:8<BP:7_!ZKB09!W2H/13!.01@/\!W;7Q/+)K/7?C/O)9*8-/)_57C/+P/)EG*5+8-)H+,5*b8)4+-7:P.*FC/8\!-RRR\!01J!/11PJgg[[[,K9/@8,58Hg87D[58:6g65@26g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`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cBP./,:C/,) =;5F/8) K;/D/+-57+) 7A)E-;7P5-5/8)EP-)5D!-RLR_! H+-/;NB-*-/)`5G;*+-)R7;Q>/+) %S/G:C*-57+)7A)Z>?C7<>/+-)*+,)97+,5-57+8) 7A) B/;D5P/()EP-)5D!-R>R_!97+-;*P-) U*F7:;) %S/G:C*-57+) *+,) EF7C5-57+() EP-)5D! -R>U\!`5+5>:>)R*G/8) EP-) 5D! -RVL_!KC*+-*-57+) U*F7:;) EP-) 5D! -RX-_!E??;/+-5P/8)EP-)5D!-RQ-_! 1/7!B.7?8)*+,)Z8-*FC58.>/+-8)EP-)5D!-RQ-_! 1/7! d:D/+5C/) d:8-5P/)EP-! 5D!-RLQ,! !+77!ZKB09!W2H/13!.01@/\!=./)B>*CC)V*+,8)7A)BC*D/;<L))W7+,/,)9.5C,)U*F7:;)5+)H+,5*\!-RRQ\!-?A?U!D58!09!29!67P1/!;27[!5D!1/7!P85;232593,!VL!"/7!H+,5*+)K/+*C)97,/\!#@1!*,!VX!5D!-LQU,!VR! +77! /11PJgg:0M5K8,92@,29g@[:g@/2:6:0M5K8,/1B! 096! 1/7! *012590:! W7P581! +KMB21176! 29! 5@@03259! 5D! 1/7! ^IW! 5D! E9620! 29!?UUL!S#gZW)g.O,Qg-gE*Ng-T,!!XU!97>?5C*-57+)K;/?*;/,)F<)-./)IAA5P/)7A)-./)V5G.)97>>58857+/;)A7;)V:>*+)S5G.-8T)#gZW)g.O,Qg-gE*Ng?T!?>!408@/!?UUL!096!#gZW)g.O,Qg-FgE*Ng?\!-?!#P82:!?U-?,!X-!^*E)&(\! )H+D585FC/\!?UUQ\!XU,!!X?!$7762!23!0!@5BB59!M8096!5D!@2H0871173!P856K@76!096![267:<!@593KB76!29!E9620,!XF!(877!"/7!+:0;73\!S/P7D/;5+G)9.5C,.77,8L))97>F*-5+G)9.5C,)=;*AA5PQ5+G)5+)67;-./;+)H+,5*\!'@15M78!?UUX\!FFAFV,!XV!ZKB09!W2H/13!.01@/\!=./)B>*CC)V*+,8)7A)BC*D/;<T)@2176\!L!XX!"/7!H79780:! 29D58B01259!P85;2676! 29! 1/23!P080H80P/!/0;7!M779! 10G79! D85B! d,!$:0HM85KH/\!=./<) ;/8?/P-) -./5;) *+5>*C8)>7;/L))_75P/8)7A)P.5C,),7>/8-5P)J7;Q/;8\!#912A+:0;78<!E91789012590:\!?UU>,!

Page 39: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!XQ! "/7! )79187! D58! +@279@7! 096! &9;2859B791! S)+&T\! 01! /11PJgg[[[,@3729620,58Hg9567gFLV_! 377! 0:35! N/00182! W735K8@7!)79187! D58!.5B79!096!)/2:6879! !+0B010\!Z#iJ!)79187! D58!)/2:6!W2H/13\!H>?*P-8)7A)`5+5+G)7+)9.5C,;/+)5+)H+,5*\!?U-U\!Q,!X>!"/7!)79187!D58!+@279@7!096!&9;2859B791\!@2176,!!!XL! E%'\! E91789012590:! I85H80BB7! 59! 1/7! &:2B2901259! 5D! )/2:6! %0M5K8! SEI&)T\! ZC5>5+*-5+G) 9.5C,) U*F7:;) 5+) `5+5+G) *+,)e:*;;<5+GL))W*PQG;7:+,)[7P:>/+-\!.58:6!N0<!0H02931!)/2:6!%0M5K8\!-?!dK97!?UUX\!-F,!XR!E9D58B0:!B2929H!87D783!15!K9@59185::76!B2929H!0@12;21273!5D179!5P780176!M<!D0B2:<!B7BM783!58!5D!@:537!87:012;73![21/5K1!09<! :2@7937! 58! D58B0:! P78B233259,! "/7!B587! 87B517! 096!B587! 29D58B0:! 0! 3B0::A3@0:7!B2929H! 0@12;21<\! 1/7!B587! :2G7:<!@/2:6879! 087! 15! M7! 29;5:;76\! [/2:7! 1/7! :08H7A3@0:7! D58B0:! B2929H! 37@158! 6573! 951! H79780::<! 7BP:5<! @/2:6879! 29! 213!5P78012593\!377!E%'!EI&)!ZC5>5+*-5+G)9.5C,)U*F7:;)5+)`5+5+G\!@2176\!?,!QU! #! 87@791! 31K6<! 87;70:76! 1/01! B587! 1/09! /0:D! 5D! 1/7! @/2:6879! [58G29H! 29! 0! 31597! ]K088<! 29! 453/2\! IK97! N23182@1!S40/0803/180T!/0;7! 876K@76! :K9H! DK9@12593!096!0::! 1/7! 3<BP15B3!5D! 031/B0,! ! +77!"/7!"2B73!5D! E9620\! 21M)9.5C,;/+)*-)`78.5) e:*;;<) V*D/) E8-.>*\! -L! *5;7BM78! ?UUR\! 01! /11PJgg0812@:73,12B735D29620,2962012B73,@5Bg?UURA--A-LgPK97g?LURVX>>k-k31597A]K088<A:K9HADK9@1259AB53/2,!Q-! N8,! IK3P09`0:2! I08260\!43!406/K3B210!423/80\!43!*28`/08092! W01/0\!48,! N2:2P! I0960\! I:;)`5+5+G) *+,) B-7+/) 9;:8./;)9.5C,;/+L)E)S/?7;-) 7A) -./)@*P-) @5+,5+G)=/*>)7+) -./)9.5C,)U*F7;/;8) 5+) -./) B-7+/)9;:8./;8) T) H;7+)I;/)*+,)X;*+5-/)`5+/8) 5+)I;588*\!-LA?-!#P82:!?UUX\!V,!Q?!E%'gEI&)\!EP-57+)*G*5+8-T)9.5C,)U*F7:;)5+)B>*CCNBP*C/)`5+5+G)f)e:*;;<5+GL)E)=./>*-5P)ZD*C:*-57+\!40<!?UUV\!Q,!QF!"/7!873708@/!/03!M779!582H290::<!@596K@176!M<!1/7!EBPK:37!*O'!*71[58G\!M037!29!+/2::59H\! 1/7!@0P210:!5D!1/7!+1017!5D!47H/0:0<0!S/11PJgg[[[,2BPK:370320,58Hg2967C,P/P=5P1259m@5BkD8591P0H7fE17B26m-!T,!!"/7!*ZW)!155G!KP!1/7!233K7!03!0!@5937]K79@7!5D!B7620!87P5813,!!"/7!5DD2@20:![7M!3217!5D!1/7!*ZW)!6573!951!623P:0<!KP!15!6017!29D58B01259!59!1/7!@037\!MK1!`K31!0!3/581!P8733!87:7037\!0;02:0M:7!01!/11PJgg[[[,9/8@,92@,29g,!!QV!(58!0!67102:76!87P581!59!70@/!5D!1/737!310173\!377! !@2176\!I081!EE,!QX!&,!N7:0P\!W/GG5+G)A7;)9.*+G/L))S/8/*;P.)A5+,5+G8)*+,);/P7>>/+,*-57+8)7+)A7;P/,)P.5C,)F/GG5+G)5+)ECF*+5*cX;//P/T)H+,5*)*+,)B/+/G*C\!#912A+:0;78<!E91789012590:\!?UUR,!QQ!#9!08B76!P703091!KP82329H!29!40<!-RQ>!29!*0C0:M082!S.731!$79H0:T!B08G76!1/7!M7H29929H!5D!1/7!405231!87;5:K125908<!P5:212@0:!B5;7B791!29!E9620,!"/7!B5;7B791!23!90B76!0D178!1/7!87H259!096!1/K3!@0::76!1/7!*0C0:217!B5;7B791,!*0C0:2173!@0::! D58!0! 1510:! 18093D58B01259!5D! 1/7!7C23129H!P5:212@0:! 3<317B!15!@87017!0!97[!35@20:!58678!79629H![/01! 1/7<!377!03! 1/7!7CP:52101259! 5D! B08H290:2a76! 096! ;K:9780M:7! @5BBK921273,! *0C0:2173! @088<! 5K1! 1/728! P5:212@0:! 0H7960! 1/85KH/! ;0825K3!B7093!29@:K629H!08B76!0110@G3!0H02931!1/7!31017!S+77!ZKB09!W2H/13!.01@/\![*+G/;7:8)[:-<L)9.5C,;/+)*+,)-./)9..*--58G*;.)97+AC5P-\!+7P17BM78!?UUL\!-VT,!Q>!^*!O79780:!#337BM:<\!9.5C,;/+)*+,)*;>/,)P7+AC5P-O);/?7;-)7A)-./)B/P;/-*;<NX/+/;*C\!?F!#P82:!?U--\!#gQXgL?U!A!+g?U--g?XU\!0;02:0M:7!01J!/11PJgg[[[,K9/@8,58Hg87D[58:6g65@26gV660FL?M?,/1B:!S0@@73376!-!N7@7BM78!?U--T\!P08,!-QXA-QQ,!QL!E1!23!1/7!90B7!5D!1/7!:5 !QR!^,!l7BP2\!+,!45/0P018022\! N@5+,5+G)[7P:>/+-*-57+)*+,)E,D7P*P<\!01!/11PJgg[[[,51/7829620,58Hg67;g2B0H73g3158273gD760k@/2:6,P6D,!+77!0:35!"/7!)50:21259!15!+15P! 1/7! ^37! 5D! )/2:6! +5:62783\! 9.5C,) B7C,5/;8) XC7F*C) S/?7;-T) H+,5*\! ?UUL\! 01! /11PJgg[[[,@/2:6A35:62783,58Hg87H2593g@5K918<=26mRR_! ZKB09! W2H/13! .01@/\! [*+G/;7:8) [:-<L) ) 9.5C,;/+) *+,) -./) 9..*--58G*;.) 97+AC5P-\!+7P17BM78!?UUL,!>U!^92;7830:!N7@:0801259!5D!ZKB09!W2H/13\!#81,!?,!>-!W*;P/C7+*) =;*P-57+T) U5G.-) *+,) K7J/;) 97T) U-,L) %W/CG5:>) DL) B?*5+(\! dK6HB791! 5D! X! (7M8K08<! -R>-\! E,),d,! W7P5813\! -R>U\!I080H80P/3! FFAFV,! +77! 0:35\! ^92176! *012593\! [:;F*+) [/PC*;*-57+) *+,) KC*+) 7A) EP-57+T) E,7?-/,) *-) -./)R7;C,) 97+A/;/+P/)EG*5+8-)S*P58>T)S*P5*C)[58P;5>5+*-57+T)g/+7?.7F5*)*+,)S/C*-/,)_57C/+P/\!L!+7P17BM78!?UU-\!01!F!>?! 4+5-/,) 6*-57+8) 97+D/+-57+) *G*5+8-) =;*+8+*-57+*C) I;G*+5a/,) 9;5>/\! 065P176! L! d09K08<! ?UU-_! K;7-7P7C) -7) K;/D/+-T)B:??;/88)*+,)K:+58.)=;*AA5PQ5+G)5+)K/;87+8T)Z8?/P5*CC<)R7>/+)*+,))/2:6879\!+KPP:7B79129H!1/7!^92176!*012593!)59;791259!0H02931! "80939012590:! '8H092a76! )82B7\! 096! K;7-7P7C) *G*5+8-) -./) B>:GGC5+G) 7A) `5G;*+-8) F<) U*+,T) B/*) *+,) E5;T)B:??C/>/+-5+G)-./)4+5-/,)6*-57+8)97+D/+-57+)*G*5+8-)=;*+8+*-57+*C)I;G*+5a/,)9;5>/\!-X!*5;7BM78!?UUU_!K;7-7P7C)*G*5+8-)-./) HCC5P5-)`*+:A*P-:;5+G)7A)*+,)=;*AA5PQ5+G) 5+)@5;/*;>8T)=./5;)K*;-8)*+,)97>?7+/+-8)*+,)E>>:+5-57+T)B:??C/>/+-5+G)-./)4+5-/,)6*-57+8)97+D/+-57+)*G*5+8-)=;*+8+*-57+*C)I;G*+5a/,)9;5>/\!L!dK97!?UU-,!>F>F!ZKB09!W2H/13!)5K9@2:!W735:K1259!Qg-V\!5D!?L!+7P17BM78!?UU>,!!!!!!!!!!

Page 40: Modern Slavery in India Bonded Labour Cases FINAL 17 Sept 2012

Franciscans International Regional Offices

FI Bangkok

St. Gabriel's Foundation Building 2,Soi Thong Lor 25 Sukhumvit 55 Road Bangkok 10110 Thailand T +66 27 12 79 76 F +66 27 12 79 74 bangkok@fi op.org

FI Geneva

37-39 rue de Vermont P. O. Box 104 CH-1211 Geneva 20 Switzerland T +41 22 9 19 40 10 F +41 22 7 40 24 33 geneva@fi op.org

FI New York

246 E. 46th St. #1F New York, NY 10017-2937 USA T +1 2 12 4 90 46 24 F +1 2 12 4 90 46 26 newyork@fi op.org

www.franciscansinternational.org