mithras and the early christians

Upload: ben-rogaczewski

Post on 30-May-2018

224 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    1/21

    1

    Ben Rogaczewski

    Ancient Roman Monuments/Cities, Towns and Villas

    Prof. Koehler

    November 29, 2009

    As you walk about the streets of modern day Rome, you will see many

    amazing things, things such as the ancient forum or the old temples of the gods,

    many of which turned into catholic churches. You may even see a statue or two of

    forgotten Roman officials. However, one does not realize the secrets that this

    ancient city holds. What may seem to be a tourist haven from above may hold

    shocking surprises below its ancient rubble.

    When one enters a church, such as the Church of Santa Prisca, one may find

    something they did not expect within a catholic church, or should I say below a

    catholic church. In such places as this, one needs only to ask to gain entrance to the

    lower underground to see what was Ancient Rome. As you descend a staircase to

    reach your destination, you come to an entrance way adorned by what seems to be

    two figures: one holding what appears to be a torch up, the other holding his torch

    downwards. As you enter you notice that if not for artificial light, you would not see

    anything within this dark cave of sorts. You look around and see stone benches on

    each side, possibly primitive pews for a service, with what looks to be a stone altar

    in the middle of the dark room. The walls have Latin inscriptions written upon them

    and with what little knowledge you have from your undergraduate Latin courses,

    you are able to make out some of the inscriptions. They seem to speak of someone

    shedding eternal blood. You put the pieces together and figure that its an ancient,

    secret area of ritual for the ancient Christians. You look around more, but something

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    2/21

    2

    at the back of the room seems to catch your eye, creating some surprise and possibly

    conflict with your original thoughts. Upon the back wall, you see paintings of a man

    in different scenes. In one he is causing water to gush from a rock, while in another

    he is being born from a rock. Finally, your eyes catch a strange scene in which the

    man is sacrificing a bull surrounded by a dog, a snake, and a scorpion. This seems to

    puzzle you because in all your Christian studies, there were never stories of Jesus

    being born from a rock, or Jesus killing a bull. You look closer at the fresco of the

    sacrifice and see the name Mithras with other titles along with it. It is most certain

    that many people have encountered this scene at least once when they have

    traversed through Rome, but not very many are given an explanation or granted a

    better understanding of this strange deity who lives in caves underneath Rome,

    Ostia, and other areas of the Roman frontier. Through my help and studies, I will

    help to explain this misunderstood gods origins, Roman popularity, religious

    rivalrys, and subsequent downfall. Let me take you through a Mithraeum that

    spans from about the late 1stcentury AD, to the late 4th century AD.

    Part I: Mithras, Savior Born from a Rock

    We find Mithras origins far back before the Roman Empire was created.

    Archaeological evidence shows us that the Persians had been worshipping this sun

    god from around the time of 5th century BC, but he was praised under a slightly

    different name. The Persians worshipped a supreme sun god whom they called

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    3/21

    3

    Mitra in their prayers.1However, the Roman cult that gained its popularity in the 2nd

    century AD up until about the 4th century seems to be strictly a western cult. We

    only find the Mithraic caves in the Roman Empire provinces and not within areas

    such as the Parthian Empire or Syria. Although, we do find Persian concepts within

    Mithraism (one of the grades or ranks is called Persian; nama means hail in

    Persian) and the myths from the east seem to have effected the main portion of the

    Mithraic cult, the Tauroctony.2

    However, this should not surprise anyone, because of how the eastern

    religion reached the Italian peoples. Plutarch gives us some evidence to possibly the

    earliest know reference to Mithraic contact with an Italian official. He states in his

    account of Pompey, that when Pompey took his fleet against Mithradates VI in 67

    BCE, he conquered the Cilician pirates who allied with Mithradates. He took many of

    these pirates back as prisoners and it was in their captivity in Rome that they

    planted the seeds of Mithraism. Plutarch states that these Cilician pirates

    celebrated secret rites and mysteries devoted to Mithras, which are still celebrated

    today.3 Plutarch lived in the years 46-120 AD, so it is definitely probable that the

    Mithraic mysteries that he speaks of relate to the Roman cult. We even find coins

    1 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 62 Mary Beard, John North and Simon Price, Religions of Rome: A History, Vol. 1, 2 vols.

    (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998). Pg. 279.3 Marvin W. Meyer, The Ancient Mysteries: A Sourcebook(New York, New York:

    Harper and Row, 1987). Pg. 205.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    4/21

    4

    minted in the mid-third century in Tarsus the capitol of Cilicia, that show Mithras

    killing the primordial bull (figure 1).4

    From this main time onward, the Mithraist cult seemed to not be very

    popular and instead stood in the shadow of the imperial cult. However, soon this

    warrior of light and virtue would rise in popularity among the Roman population,

    especially within the military.

    Part II: Mithras, the True Soldier of Rome

    Of course, it may seem confusing that a Persian deity could possibly

    gain appeal from the Roman population, seeing that the Persians were seen as one

    of the main enemies of the ancient world. Yet so many Roman citizens pledged their

    life to Mithras. Why though? How did Mithras gain so much appeal amongst the

    people, even so much as to rival with Christianity? The answer, as always, is a very

    complex one and so we must first tackle the demographics of this cult. Where was

    he worshipped in the Empire, and who worshipped him? To find these answers, we

    must first take a look at the frontiers of the Empire.

    Our earliest evidence of a mithraeum comes from the Danube river area

    around the city of Carnuntum. It was here around 100 AD, that we find a mithraeum

    created by a Marcus Aurelius Decimus, a legionnaire or centurion from the

    Germanian troops.5It is no surprise then that our first group of Mithraists has to be

    found within the military. However, we can judge from the amount of mithraea

    4 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 4-5.5 Robert Turcan, The Cults of the Roman Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Wiley-

    Blackwell, 1996). Pg. 241.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    5/21

    5

    found north of Rome, in comparison to the amount found in Syria or Parthia, that

    the cult had the majority of its members from the Gallic and Germanian troops near

    the Rhine and Danube rivers.6 At these legionary camps in the north, we find

    inscriptions for prefects, troopers, centurions, and even legates, all Mithraists.

    Turcan even states that some records show that a certain Marcus Valerius

    Maximianus commanded legions that were comprised of mainly Mithraists.7But why

    would these soldiers give their praise to a Persian deity? What about Mithras

    would have appealed to them? In order to find these answers we must look at

    Mithras himself and the stories about him.

    Mithras was said to be the great warrior of virtue and truth, and was the

    conqueror of evil. When he had slain the cosmic bull (a metaphor for chaos), he

    restored order to the world and made it prosperous by its eternal blood. Every

    Mithraist was to look to Mithras as an icon to follow in their lives. He was the Light

    of the World and the Prince of Peace. For the soldiers, he was a sign of the warrior

    you must be in order to be victorious in battle. To have him on your side would

    ensure victory. When a Mithraist reached the rank of Miles or soldier, he was

    literally inducted as a Legionnaire for Mithras. Each of the Mithraists swore to

    defend against evil and lead a life of purity, a life of celibacy.8 These oaths were not

    very difficult for a soldier to make since a soldier was supposed to be celibate while

    on campaign, and of course, every soldier had to have seen themselves defending

    6 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 26-27.7 Robert Turcan, The Cults of the Roman Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Wiley-

    Blackwell, 1996). Pg. 243.8 Mary Beard, John North and Simon Price, Religions of Rome: A History, Vol. 1, 2 vols.

    (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998). Pg. 289.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    6/21

    6

    the Empire against evil. Also, it was found that being a Mithraist might even raise

    your rank among the troops. The cult only allowed men to know their mysteries.

    However there are some inscriptions for sacrifice found in mithraeums in Rome that

    show women attended Mithraic rituals.9Therefore, it was even more appealing

    when you could join your brothers in arms and be brothers in Mithras as well.

    This soon lead Mithraic popularity to rise and soon it attracted the attention

    of the Emperor himself. We have several instances in which the emperor was

    involved with some Mithraic happenings. Commodus, the son of Marcus Aurelius

    and emperor of Rome from 180-192 AD, was said to have been an unworthy

    follower of Mithras since he committed a real murder rather than a fake

    murder.10 It was also found that certain mithraeums around the empire carried

    inscriptions dating to Marcus Aurelius and Commodus that ask Mithras to protect

    the health of the emperor. The emperors loved the god Mithras for the main

    reasoning that it helped the troops to basically be better troops in battle. It

    especially became popular when the Severans and other militaristic emperors came

    to power in Rome. When Septimius Severus brought his Gallic troops from Pannonia

    down to Rome to take power from Julianus, there was a good chance he had already

    been initiated into the mysteries of Mithras. Soon after he came to power in 193

    AD, he allowed the Roman military to own land where they were stationed. This

    would allow many more soldiers to create mithraeums if they owned the land. One

    of the final times when we see imperial popularity of Mithras comes in 307 AD when

    9 Ibid. , 298.10 Robert Turcan, The Cults of the Roman Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Wiley-

    Blackwell, 1996). Pg. 243.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    7/21

    7

    the emperors Diocletian, Galerius, and Licinius restored a Mithraic cavern, granted

    the title fantor imperii sui to the god Mithras. This title states, protector of their

    imperial power a clear devotion, or even, a last chance for these emperors to

    restore the old pagan ways.11Several emperors like Aurelian and Licinius held

    worship for the god Sol Invictus, whose personage was close (if not even the same

    deity) and the two sun gods were seen as one in the same.12

    Of course, with the emperors showing increased attention to cults such as

    that of Mithras, many of the Roman citizens began to flock to worship these very

    cults. Within Italy we find about one third of the Mithraic population and

    predominately within Rome and its port city of Ostia.13 It can be understood why the

    soldiers and emperors appreciated the worship of Mithras; but why did these

    Roman citizens worship Mithras? What about the cult seemed to appeal to them?

    Evidence that has been found within the mithraeums has shown several reasons for

    an appeal to the normal Roman citizen.

    First, one of the Roman mithraeums held several heads of other deities

    including Sarapis, Venus, Fortuna, and Dionysus. It appears that Mithraists were

    allowed to worship other Roman deities along with Mithras. Several inscriptions

    even evoke prayer upon deities such as Pales

    and Helios as well.14 The fact that

    during Pales festival, the Parilia, in which cattle were purified by running through a

    11 Ibid. , 244.12 Ramsay MacMullen, Paganism in the Roman Empire (New Haven: Yale UniversityPress, 1983). Pg. 127.13 Ibid. , 119.

    Pales was the Roman god of shepherds and his festival was the Parilia14 Marvin W. Meyer, The Ancient Mysteries: A Sourcebook(New York, New York:

    Harper and Row, 1987). Pg. 207.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    8/21

    8

    fire, may have something to do with the cult of Mithras in which praise for the

    sacrifice of the cosmic bull was common within the mithraeums.15There are even

    images from the Santa Prisca mithraeum that show Mithras shaking hands with the

    sun god Helios and another scene in which Mithras and Helios feast on the sacrificial

    bull (figures 2-3). Clearly, the Mithraic cult was appealing to the polytheistic Roman

    citizens.

    The second appeal to the Roman citizens was that of the mithraeum, the

    cavern of the Mithraists. Every one of the mithraeums were built deep

    underground and were not made public, as other cults were. Many saw the secretive

    cult as interesting and even more; the mithraeums of Rome were counted as some of

    the most decorated mithraeums of Mithraism. Many people would be drawn to the

    design of a beautiful secret cult that promised salvation through its warrior of truth

    and good. The other area of the mithraeum that impressed many of the Romans was

    the Tauroctony. As I have said earlier, the Tauroctony(figure 4) was a main

    centerpiece for the mystery cult. It showed the god Mithras sacrificing the cosmic

    bull of heaven. Beneath the bull are three animals trying to help take down the bull:

    a dog, a snake, and a scorpion. Each one of these images within the Tauroctonyhas a

    different meaning behind them. Scholars believe that they correspond with a certain

    astrological constellation: Canis Major for the dog, Hydra for the snake, Scorpio for

    the scorpion, Taurus for the bull, and Perseus or Leo may represent Mithras.16 Many

    of the Romans found astrology to be fascinating for centuries and may have been

    15 Mary Beard, John North and Simon Price, Religions of Rome: A History, Vol. 1, 2

    vols. (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998). Pg. 175.16 Mary Beard, John North and Simon Price, Religions of Rome: A History, Vol. 1, 2

    vols. (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998). Pg. 286.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    9/21

    9

    disappointed when several of the emperors outlawed divination and astrology. With

    this newfound learning of astronomy, Romans would have flocked to the secret

    meetings and rituals.

    The third and final appeal found in Mithraism for the Roman people would

    be Mithras correlation to the god of time or Aion. Many of the ancients saw

    several notions in which Mithras was timeless and could guarantee possible

    everlasting life.17 The evidence for these notions comes from written ancient

    sources, and archaeological evidence as well. Many of the ancient writers saw the

    calculation, numerically, for the Greek name , in which the final product

    came out to 365, the amount of days within a Julian year. Mithras name in Greek

    held the promise of being the god of the passing of years, and could control the

    passing of time in this way.18 There also seems to be a correlation with zodiac and

    the god of time as well. On a relief found in Rome (but now moved to Modena), there

    is an image of what is believed to be the god of time. Upon this image, there stands a

    winged man with cloven feet (almost like a cattle) and he bears a lion-head on his

    chest (Mithras was often called the lion-headed god, and one of the ranks within

    Mithraism was the lion). Surrounding him is the entire zodiac, a display of the

    Julian year with astrological symbols (figure 5).19 There is a mithraeum in which a

    relief was discovered that showed the Tauroctony, but with the zodiac surrounding

    17 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 165.18 Ibid. , 165.19 Ibid. , 166.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    10/21

    10

    the sacrifice (figure 6).20 This clearly shows that many people, including

    Mithraists,saw Mithras already as a god of time.

    Through all these different means, many Roman citizens were drawn to the

    Mithraic cult and its savior, Mithras.

    Part III: Mithras vs. Christus

    From all the different cults and religions within the Empire, no other

    contended so well with the Mithraic cult as that of the Christians. Both cults rose in

    popularity against each other, and some modern scholars, such as Ernest

    Renan,claim if Christianity had been arrested in its growth by some fatal malady,

    the world would have become Mithraist.21 However, it is clear from the Christian

    apologists writings that Early Christians felt threatened by this mystery cult from

    the caves. So many of their rituals, beliefs, and even the deity were similar that there

    could definitely be a rivalry between the two cults.

    First, Tertullian the Christian apologist, who wrote in the 3rd century, writes

    that the devil imitates the same rituals as the Christians. Devil seemed to be a

    correlationwith Mithras.22He wrote that the Mithraists performed their ritual meal

    as a means of celebrating the resurrection. Apparently, Mithraists spoke about

    eternal life, just as the Christians had done. They believed that they would be reborn

    by the consumption of the food and wine.23 However, the ritual meal of bread and

    20 Ibid. , 89.21 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 168.22 Ibid. , 108.23 Ibid. , 109.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    11/21

    11

    wine was used throughout the ancient world. The Mithraists saw it as means of

    celebrating Mithras victory over the cosmic bull. When Mithras had slain the great

    bull, it was said that wheat came from its tail and wine came from its blood. Through

    the bulls flesh and blood, the world was saved and given prosperous nourishment.24

    By eating the body and blood of Christ, Christians believed that they were saved

    from the judgment day that they believed would be upon them. The Mithraists

    would also speak their sacred texts over the ritual food, just as the Christians did.25

    Tertullian also writes that the Mithraists use water as a means of purifying the

    initiate, just as the early Christians did with their baptisms.

    Finally, there is a strange similarity between the Christians sign of the cross

    on the forehead and the Mithraic mark on some of the Mithraists foreheads.

    Tertullian states the Christians made a sign of the cross upon their foreheads, but it

    was made with a thumb and made no imprint upon the skin. One can only imagine

    that this cross was a representation of the cross that Christ was crucified upon.

    However, Tertullian goes on to say that Mithras marked his soldiers with his mark.

    He does not explain what this mark was, but some archeological evidence may

    point to the Mithraic mark. Upon the Grand Ludovisi sarcophagi (figures 7), it was

    noted by an art historian that one of the soldiers (Most likely the commander of the

    troops since he is defended by the other troops and the only one to not be wearing a

    helmet) had a strange mark upon his forehead. Sure enough there on the soldiers

    24 Ibid. , 110.25 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 110.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    12/21

    12

    forehead was an X (figure 8).26 Turcan does not seem to be definite about this

    mark being a Mithraic mark, but there are some pieces of information that this artist

    may have wished to put within this work that we are not picking up that make this

    THE Mithraic mark Tertullian wrote about. First, the sarcophagi shows a battle

    fought against what appear to be Gallic warriors or Germanian warriors, two groups

    of enemies that militaristic Mithraic soldiers would have fought. Second, the

    sarcophagi dates to about 249-251 AD, during which the emperor Decius reigned

    and issued his persecution of Christians in 250 AD. This edict declared that all

    peoples in the Empire needed to sacrifice to the gods, with written proof that they

    had done it. During this persecution, no one would wish to let anyone know that

    they would be a Christian, let alone a soldier of the Empire.27 Also, you may find it

    very interesting that the bust of Decius has a mallet mark near the top of his

    forehead, the same area where the sarcophagi soldier has his mark (figure 9).

    Perhaps a Christian wished to hide something about this mark, or was just very

    upset with this persecutor of Christians. The third and final reason is that the mark

    is an X. The Christian cross strictly looked like a T and could be death for a

    soldier if it was found on his head. It stands to reason that the Mithraist soldier

    would want their mark to be different from that of their rivals, the Christians.

    Crosses in the shape of an X seem to be prevalent amongst the east where the

    Persians first created crucifixion. Therefore, by all this reasoning, it stands that this

    mark could be considered the Mithraic mark of Tertullian.

    26 Robert Turcan, The Cults of the Roman Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Wiley-

    Blackwell, 1996). Pg. 244.27 Mary Beard, John North and Simon Price, Religions of Rome: A History, Vol. 1, 2

    vols. (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998). Pg. 239.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    13/21

    13

    Now with these two cults, there must have been several differences between

    the two, otherwise they could be considered one in the same. There are many

    differences between the two found in their meeting areas, their demographics, and

    their leadership and sacred texts.

    When it comes to the meeting places of the Christians and that of the

    Mithraists, there was a definite difference between the two. The Christians seemed

    to worship publically and only went into secret when Diocletian set the great

    persecutions in place. Some of the Christian apologists wrote that it was suspicious

    for the Mithraists to hold their rituals in secret underground. Many of the Mithraists

    were accused of human sacrifice, which is why they held their rituals in secret.

    However, this was a fictitious rumor spread by the Christians to try and defame

    Mithraism.28

    Another difference was within their initiations and rituals. As I have said

    before, women were not initiated into Mithraism, but were allowed to make

    dedications to the god Mithras. Women were seen as an anti-thesis of civilized

    values, which may have also tied in with the pledge of celibacy as well.29 Women

    were allowed to worship Christ and some were also allowed to be church leaders or

    deaconesses. However, celibacy was also found within Christianity, but it was for

    the reasoning that one should not hold on to earthly ties with the judgment day

    coming, rather than a moral conviction, which dealt with Mithraism. Finally, as far as

    we know, there are no surviving pieces of evidence that show that Mithraism had

    28 Robert Turcan, The Cults of the Roman Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Wiley-

    Blackwell, 1996). Pg. 239.29 Mary Beard, John North and Simon Price, Religions of Rome: A History, Vol. 1, 2

    vols. (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998). Pg. 298.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    14/21

    14

    sacred texts. A surviving papyrus from Paris gives possible evidence to a Mithraic

    liturgy but other than that we do not have any other forms of sacred texts.30

    Whereas the Christians survived, and their sacred texts were praised and copied

    many times.

    This all leads to of course sadly, the fall of one of these rivals, because one

    cannot survive while the other survives unfortunately. This being said, we have

    reached the final part of this Mithraic saga.

    Part IV: Mithras, the Forgotten Sun

    With the decline of Christianity by many of the emperors persecutions,

    Mithraism was able to rise. However, it would not be able to survive due to internal

    issues and external issues. The internal issues as I have stated earlier, were mainly

    that women were not allowed within the cult and thus would have dwindled their

    numbers drastically, especially in the long run. The other main internal reason was

    its low-scale focus on the future. With small ranges of demographics for their cult,

    Mithras was really only popular in areas such as Rome, Gallia, and Germania.

    Christianity was able to spread all over from Syria in the east to areas of Spain in the

    Iberian lands. When Constantine came to power, Mithraism was already dwindling

    from the rise of Christianity and the move of the capital to Constantinople rather

    than Rome. However, our decline of Mithraism begins before Constantine and brings

    us to what we call the Third Century Crisis.

    30 Marvin W. Meyer, The Ancient Mysteries: A Sourcebook(New York, New York:

    Harper and Row, 1987). Pg. 211.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    15/21

    15

    Within this period of the Empire, many emperors such as Decius persecuted

    the Christians and soon Mithraism saw a slight rise with traditional cults being

    promoted. Even when Valerian exiled many of the Christians for not sacrificing, and

    threatened them with death for practicing their rituals in 257 AD, Mithraism could

    see a light of hope in survival.31 That light however was soon dimmed slightly when

    a humiliating tragedy befell the Empire. In 260 AD, Valerian engaged the Persian

    king of the Sassanid Empire in battle in what used to be Parthian lands. It was in this

    battle that Valerian was defeated and his armies decimated. Valerian was captured

    by the Sassanids and was executed after humiliation by their king. The early

    Christians were quick to blame the Mithraists for the defeat, seeing that their god

    came from the Persian lands, and soon many of the Mithraists began to see their

    future slowly dissipating.32 Thankfully, the Mithraists found another ray of hope in

    the future emperors.

    Emperors such as Aurelian brought a new deity from the east and the people

    saw that this new deity was involved with all of Aurelians victories in the east and

    the north. This new deity was called Sol Invictus or Unconquered Sun. Many

    people soon began to correspond the sun god Mithras with this new deity, and it

    was not long before the two of them were fused together. This lasted till about the

    time of the Tetrarchy in which four men ran the Empire: Diocletian as head

    emperor, Maxentius, Licinius, and Constantine.

    31 Mary Beard, John North and Simon Price, Religions of Rome: A History, Vol. 1, 2

    vols. (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998). Pg. 241.32 Robert Turcan, The Cults of the Roman Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Wiley-

    Blackwell, 1996). Pg. 245.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    16/21

    16

    After Constantine had defeated Maxentius at the Milvian Bridge in 312 AD,

    Constantine began to institute that a new divinity had aided him in the battle. He

    claimed that the god of the Christians had helped him win the battle, and he slowly

    became the Christians new patron. In 313 AD, Constantine and Licinius legalized

    Christianity, but also legalized all other religions as well. There was now religious

    tolerance in the Empire. However, this would soon change when Constantine

    wished to rise above the other rulers. Diocletian had died, and he saw his

    opportunity against Licinius. They engaged in battle, Licinius running his banners

    with Mithras and Constantine running his banners with the symbol for the Christian

    god.33 Constantine won the battle, and the Mithraic cult now saw its decline coming

    to a sharp ending. Under Constantines sons, pagan cults soon all felt a tightening

    noose upon their life.

    There was however, one last peak of hope for all the pagan cults. When Julian

    came to power in 361 AD, he sought to revive the traditional pagan ways of Rome.

    He limited the churchs power within Rome and tried to strengthen the power of the

    pagan cults. However, in 363 AD he was killed in battle and all hope for the pagan

    traditions was gone.

    After Julians reign, the Christians attacked mithraeums all over and took out

    statues of Mithras. An iconoclasm took place against the Mithraists and they would

    not survive this persecution. Within a decade, the cult seemed to have disappeared

    by means of the Christians, and their use of Roman power. By the edict of

    Theodosius around 380 AD outlawing all religions except Christianity and Judaism.

    33 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 170.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    17/21

    17

    Mithraism was a forgotten religion spoken of by the Christian apologists such as

    Tertullian and Justin Martyr, and by the pagan apologists who defended the already

    dead religions. Many of these pagan apologists asked Christian leaders how their

    religion differed from the pagan religions when they had a similar savior religion.

    The Christian apologists stated that the Devil created these other messiahs in

    order to stray the world until the true Messiah came. It seems that the early

    Christians made up this excuse to merely refute the possibility of error. Christians

    used tales of Jesus to show their domination over pagan religions. For instance, one

    will definitely look at the three kings very differently after reading these words.

    Early depictions of the three kings or magi coming to give praise to Jesus show

    the three kings with the stereotypical Phrygian cap found on mostly all

    depictions of Mithras (figure 10).34 The magi were considered the priests of

    Mithraism from the east in Persia. The Christians used this as a means of

    propaganda showing the true sun god, Christus.

    Well we have reached the final area of our tour. Mithras was officially ended

    along with the other ancient religions in 380 AD, and the early Christians desecrated

    his sacred places. However, many apologists seemed to still go against the

    Christians, whether it is a sculptor from the 3rd century, or even the Christians with

    their depictions of the Magi. One cannot help but wonder though and play what if?

    history: what would this world be like if Constantine had lost against Licinius? What

    if Julian had not been killed in battle? What if Valerian had defeated the Sassanids?

    34 Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries , trans.

    Richard Gordon (New York, New York: Routledge, 2001). Pg. 169.

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    18/21

    18

    What if the Roman Empire chose the wrong Messiah? With all the evidence in

    place, its very hard to keep ones beliefs straight. However, a great man once told

    me that history is about fact, not truthif you want truth, philosophy is right down

    the hall, and with archaeology, fact is all you can find.

    Illustrations Found Within

    Figure 1

    Figure 2

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    19/21

    19

    Figure 3

    Figure 5

    Figure 4

    Figure 6

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    20/21

    20

    Figure 7

    Figure 8

    Figure 9

    Figure 10

  • 8/9/2019 Mithras and the Early Christians

    21/21

    Bibliography

    Beard, Mary, John North, and Simon Price. Religions of Rome: A History. Vol. 1. 2 vols.

    Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1998.

    Clauss, Manfred. The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries . Translated

    by Richard Gordon. New York, New York: Routledge, 2001.

    MacMullen, Ramsay. Paganism in the Roman Empire. New Haven: Yale UniversityPress, 1983.

    Meyer, Marvin W. The Ancient Mysteries: A Sourcebook. New York, New York: Harper

    and Row, 1987.

    Turcan, Robert. The Cults of the Roman Empire. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Wiley-

    Blackwell, 1996.