minutes of the 307th meeting of the registration … · web viewminutes of the 307th meeting of the...

Minutes of the 307 th meeting of the Registration Committee held on 24.02.2010 at 10.00 A.M. in Committee Room No.142, Krishi Bhavan, New Delhi.

The 307th meeting of the Registration Committee (RC) was held under the Chairmanship of Dr. Gurbachan Singh, Agriculture Commissioner on 24-02-2010 at 10.00 a.m. in Room No.142, Krishi Bhavan, New Delhi. Dr. P. S. Chandurkar, Plant Protection Adviser to the Government of India, Directorate of PPQ&S, Dr. T.P. Rajendran, ADG(PP), ICAR, New Delhi, Shri S.K.G.Rahate, I.A.S., Secretary, Central Insecticide Board and Registration Committee (CIB&RC) and Shri Madhav Chakraborty, Co-opted Member from Indian Institute of Packaging, Delhi, attended the meeting. Following Officers from the Secretariat of CIB&RC were also present:

(i) Dr. Sushil K. Khurana, Ex Secretary (CIB&RC) and Specialist Grade-I(ii) Dr. Hari Prasad, Joint Director (Chem.)(iii) Dr. A.K. Sinha, Joint Director (PP)(iv) Dr. B.S. Phogat, Joint Director (Bio.)(v) Dr. R.M. Shukla, Deputy Director (Ento.)(vi) Sh. Rajvir Singh, Deputy Director(Chem.)(vii) Sh. G.Sankar, Deputy Director(Packaging),NIPM,Hyderabad.(viii) Dr. Subhash Kumar, Assistant Director (WS)(ix) Dr. Vandana Seth, Assistant Director (Chem.)(x) Ms. Kamlesh Miglani, Assistant Director (Chem.)(xi) Sh. S.K. Verma, Section Officer (CIR-II)(xii) Sh. S.K. Sharma,Section Officer(CIR-I)(xiii) Sh. D.S. Sehrawat, PPO(Packaging)(xiv) Sh. Niraj Kulshrestha, Assistant (Legal)

At the outset, the new Chairman Dr. Gurbachan Singh, Agriculture Commissioner and new Secretary, Shri S.K.G. Rahate, were welcomed. The contribution of the then Chairman Shri N.B. Singh was appreciated and put on record. Similarly, the contribution of Dr.P.N. Maji, Special Invitee and the then Secretary Dr. Sushil K. Khurana was also appreciated. Thereafter, Chairman requested Secretary, CIB&RC to take up the agenda item wise for discussions and the following decisions were taken by the RC :

Agenda item No.

Particulars of Agenda

1.0 Confirmation of minutes of the 306th meeting of the Registration Committee.

Minutes of 306th Meeting were confirmed with decision at Agenda Item No.9.17 taken as “Noted”.

1

2.0 Follow up action on the decision taken by the Registration Committee in its 306th meeting.

Noted with satisfaction.

2.1 Applications pending under various sub-sections of the Insecticides Act, 1968.

Noted with satisfaction.

2.2 Presentation by the representative of M/s. Willowood Chemicals Private Limited, New Delhi regarding registration requirements of Technical Import of Pesticides

The representative of M/s. Willowood Chemicals Private Limited, New Delhi presented the case before the Registration Committee. RC decided that the issues raised in the presentation may be examined in the Secretariat of CIB&RC and put up in the next RC meeting.

2.3 Presentation by the representative of M/s. Total Petroleum India Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai on Petroleum Derived Spray Oil - a Natural Mineral Oil product.

The representative of M/s. Total Petroleum India Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai presented the case before the Registration Committee. RC decided that the issues raised in the presentation may be examined in the Secretariat of CIB&RC and put up in the next RC meeting.

2.4 Presentation by the representative of M/s Multiplex Biotech Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore regarding application for registration of Trichoderma viride 30% liquid formulation under section 9(3B).

The representative of M/s Multiplex Biotech Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore presented the case before the Registration Committee. RC decided the matter may be examined in the Secretariat of CIB&RC and put up to RC

Government Business

3.1 Deferred agenda items of 306th meeting

2

3.1.1 Review of guidelines for grant of registration under section 9(4) for indigenous manufacture of pesticide formulations.

The Committee deliberated the agenda in detail and decided that Form- I is a statuary document therefore applicant should mention the correct chemical composition on the product for which the application has been made and the same may be verified with the 9(3) registrant and label claim be given accordingly from data bank.

3.1.2 Data requirement for registration of import of formulation of pesticide from new source where import of formulation has been registered without registration of Technical under Section 9(3).

The Committee deliberated the agenda in detail and decided to approve the guidelines as proposed in 303rd meeting of RC

3.2 Restriction/Ban on use of Lindane

The Committee deliberated the agenda in detail and decided to phase out the import, manufacture and use of Lindane in the country.

3.3 Request from M/s. Syngenta India Ltd. for change in the approved dose of Pirimiphos methyl 50% EC for control of immature mosquitoes in polluted water under National Vector Borne Disease control Programme.

The Committee deliberated the agenda in view of letter received from the Director, NVBDCP, New Delhi and decided to nominate Director, VCRC, Pondicherry as Chairman of the Committee. The other members will remain same.

3.4 Proposal for inclusion of data on performance of containers during storage stability tests in the guidelines for packaging endorsement.

If the applicant requires a different pack size, which does not conform to BIS and the material remains the same, the applicant have to generate data on transport worthiness test.

3

3.5 Minutes of the meeting with Bio-Pesticide Manufacturer Association held on 02.02.2010 to discuss the revised guidelines / data requirement for registrations of bio pesticides.

The Committee noted the decision of the meeting with Bio-pesticides Manufacturer Association and decided that acceptance of microbial pesticides applications as per the old guidelines shall be continued till the decision of DAC for implementing the revised guidelines.

3.6 Preliminary scrutiny of applications for registration of pesticides.

Deferred. May be brought in the forthcoming RC meeting.

3.7 Report of sub-committee on generation of bio-efficacy data for registration of bio-pesticides U/s. 9(3).

The Committee deliberated the agenda in detail and accepted the decision of Sub-Committee except the date of implementation of the revised guidelines for registration of bio-pesticides in view of the decision at Agenda Item No.3.5 mentioned above. Report is attached at Annexure-‘A’.

3.8 Steps taken to improve the efficiency and Transparency of CIB & RC in respect of consideration of application for issue of NOC for import of Chemical not included in schedule to the IA, 1968.

The Committee noted that those products which are not included in the Schedule does not fall under the purview of Insecticides Act, 1968. Accordingly, based on end-use, a letter may be issued by the Secretariat of CIB&RC to the applicants that “the chemical is not included in the Schedule to the Insecticides Act 1968 and therefore, does not fall under its purview as on date.” It has also been decided that caption word of `NOC’ may be replaced by `Clarification’.

4.0 Export Cases

4.1 List of applications under section 9(3) Export.

List is approved.

4.2 Star Export – Ex-post-facto approval.

4

Approved

4.2.1 Ex-post-facto approval for issuance of Certificate of Registration to M/s. Aarti Industries Ltd., Vapi, Distt. Valsad for export of Prodiamine technical under section 9(3) for export only.

Approved.

4.3 Consideration of application of M/s. Aarson Crop Care Pvt. Ltd., Valsad for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Prodiamine technical under section 9(3) for export only

Approved.

4.4 Consideration of application of M/s. United Phosphorus Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Beta-Cypermethrin 27% TC under section 9(3) for export only.

Approved.

4.5 Consideration of application of M/s. United Phosphorus Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Sulphur 70% + Tebuconazole 4.5% WG under section 9(3) for export only.

Approved.

4.6 Consideration of application of M/s. Meghmani Industries Ltd., Ahmedabad for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Flutriafol technical under section 9(3) for export only.

Approved.

5.09(3B) Cases

5

5.1 Consideration of application of M/s. Ramel Industries Limited, Kolkata for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Trichoderma viride 1% WP under section 9(3B).

Approved for a period of two years with commercialization .

5.2 Consideration of application of M/s Liebigs Agro Chem Pvt. Ltd., Kolkata for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Trichoderma harzianum 1% WP under section 9(3B).

Approved for a period of two years with commercialization.

5.3 Consideration of application of M/s Advance Crop Care (India) Pvt. Ltd., Indore for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Trichoderma harzianum 1% WP under section 9(3B).


5.4 Consideration of application of M/s Khodke Agro Products Ltd., Amaravati for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Pseuodomonas fluoresens 0.5% WP under section 9(3B).


5.5 Consideration of application of M/s Shree Jee Biotech Agriculture & Equipments, Wardha, for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Pseuodomonas fluoresens 0.5% WP under section 9(3B).


5.6 Consideration of application of M/s advance Cropcare (India) Pvt., Ltd., Indore for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Paecilomyces lilacinus 1% WP under section 9(3B).


5.7 Consideration of application of M/s. Liebigs Agro Chem Pvt. Ltd., Kolkata for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of

6

Paecilomyces lilacinus 1% WP under section 9(3B).

Approved for a period of two years with commercialization

5.8 Consideration of application of M/s. Gujarat Eco Microbial Tech. Pvt. Ltd., Vadodara for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Paecilomyces lilacinus 1% WP under section 9(3B).


5.9 Consideration of application of M/s. Agro Bio Tech Research Centre Ltd., Kottayam for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Trichoderma viride 1% WP under section 9(3B).


5.10 Consideration of application of M/s. Biosys Agrotech Pvt. Ltd., Mandsaur for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Trichoderma viride 1% WP under section 9(3B).


5.11 Consideration of application of M/s. Ramel Industries Limited, Kotkata for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Pseudomonus fluorescens 0.5% WP under section 9(3B).


5.12 Consideration of application of M/s. Haryana Biotech Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Trichoderma viride 1% WP under section 9(3B).

7

The Committee deliberated the agenda and decided that the clarification from the applicant is to be sought regarding generation of data through BCIL, New Delhi for the consideration of RC in its next meeting.

5.13 Request for 1st time extension of M/s. Gujarat Life Sciences (P) Ltd., Vadodara for validity period of provisional Certificate of Registration of Trichoderma viride 1% WP for two years with commercialization under section 9(3B).

Extension is granted up to 28-08-2010 with commercialization.

5.14 Request for 1st time extension of M/s. Insecticides India Limited, Delhi for validity period of provisional Certificate of Registration of Trichoderma viride 1% WP for one year with commercialization under section 9(3B).

Extension is granted up to 05-08-2010 with commercialization.

5.15 Request for 1st time extension of M/s. Ashwamedh Agritech & Farm Solution Systems, Dist. Ahmednagar for validity period of provisional Certificate of Registration of Trichoderma viride 1% WP for one year with commercialization under section 9(3B).

Extension is granted up to 15.11.2010 with commercialization.

5.16 Request for 1st time extension of M/s. Maharashtra Insecticides Ltd., Akola for validity period of provisional Certificate of Registration of Trichoderma viride 1% WP for one year with commercialization under section 9(3B).


5.17 Request for 1st time extension of M/s. Sri Biotech Lab India Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad for validity period of provisional Certificate of Registration of Trichoderma harzianum 1% WP for one year with commercialization under Section 9(3B).

The Committee deliberated the agenda and decided to seek 8

clarification from the applicant for seeking the extension of registration after a gap of more than three years.

5.18 Request of M/s. INORA (Institute of Natural Organic Agriculture), Pune for 1st extension of validity period of provisional registration of Verticillium lecanii 1.15% WP (CFU count 1x108 /gm.min) under section 9(3B) for controlling Mealy bugs and Scales in Citrus.


5.19 Request of M/s. Avishkar Biofarm (P) Ltd., Ahamednagar for 1st

extension of validity period of provisional registration of Verticillium lecanii 1.15% WP (CFU count 1x108 /gm.min) under section 9(3B) for controlling Mealy bugs and Sales in Citrus.


5.20 Request of M/s. Jai Kissan Agro, Indore for 1st extension of validity period of provisional registration of Verticillium lecanii 1.15% WP (CFU count 1x108 /gm.min) under section 9(3B) for controlling Mealy bugs and Scales in Citrus.


5.21 Request of M/s. Avishkar Biofarm (P) Ltd., Ahmednagar for 1st

extension of validity period of provisional registration of Beauveria bassiana 1.15% WP (CFU count 1x108 /gm.min) under section 9(3B) for controlling Rice leaf folder in Rice crop.


5.22 Request of M/s. Jai Kissan Agro Indore for 1st extension of validity period of provisional registration of Beauveria bassiana 1.15% WP (CFU count 1x108 /gm.min) under section 9(3B) for controlling Rice leaf folder in Rice crop.


9

5.23 Request of M/s. Bacto Power India Pvt. Ltd., Coimbatore for extension of validity period of provisional registration of Bacillus Thuringiensis var-Israelensis 5%AS under section 9(3B) for controlling larvae of different mosquitoe species on different habitat.


5.24 Request of M/s. Romvijay Bio Tech Private Limited, Pondicherry for 2nd time extension of validity period of provisional registration of Pseudomonas fluorescens 0.5% WP (under section 9(3B) for one year with commercialization.


5.25 Request of M/s. Basarass Biocon (India) Pvt. Ltd., Chennai for 2nd

time extension of validity period of provisional registration of Beauveria bassiana 1.15% WP under section 9(3B) for one year with commercialization.

Extension is granted up to 21.08.2010 with commercialization

5.26 Request for 2nd time extension of M/s. Romvijay Bioo Tech Private Ltd., Pondicherry for validity period of provisional registration of Trichoderma viride 1.15% WP under section 9(3B) for one year with commercialization..


5.27 Request for 2nd time extension of M/s. Basarass Biocon (India) Pvt. Ltd., Chennai for extension of validity period of provisional registration of Trichoderma viride 1% WP under section 9(3B) for one year with commercialization.


5.28 Request for 2nd time extension of M/s. Basarass Biocon (India) Pvt. Ltd., Chennai for extension of validity period of provisional registration of Trichoderma harzianum 1% WP under section 9(3B) for one year with commercialization.


10

5.29 Consideration of an application of M/s. Vestergaard Frandsen (India) Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi for extension of the validity period of provisional registration of Deltamethrin Impregnated Bed-net 55 mg/m2 (0.0018% w/w) for import under section 9(3B).

The Committee decided to grant provisional registration U/s.9(3B) with commercialization up to 03-06-2010 for use of these LLIN in public health programme subject to approval of the Competent Authority in Department of Agriculture & Cooperation (DAC).

6.0 9 (3) Cases

6.1 Consideration of application of M/s. Bayer Crop Science Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration for import of Tebuconazole 50% + Trifloxystrobin 25% WG under section 9(3).

Approved.

6.2 Consideration of application of M/s. Isagro (Asia) Agrochemicals Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration for import of Tetraconozole 3.8% EC under Section 9(3).

The RC deliberated the agenda in detail and decided that data on toxicity to bird ‘Pigeon’ as per existing guidelines and clarification on metabolism in plant may be provided by the applicant.

6.3

6.4

6.5

Consideration of application of M/s.Syngenta India Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration for import of Pinoxaden technical under section 9(3).

Consideration of application of M/s Syngenta India Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Pinoxaden 9.7% EC under section 9(3).Consideration of application of M/s Syngenta India Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration for indigenous manufacture of Pinoxaden 5.1% EC under section 9(3).

11

The Committee deliberated the Agenda in detail and decided that applicant may be requested to present their case in the next meeting of RC on following aspects:

i) Results of Mutagenicity Studies.ii) Reason for withdrawing the higher formulation.iii) Request for approval for non-BIS standard packaging.

6.6 Consideration of application of M/s Excel crop Care Ltd., Mumbai for grant of registration of indigenous manufacture of Glyphosate Ammonium salt 20% SL under section 9(3).

Approved.

7.0 9(4) Cases

7.1 List of applications for registration U/s. 9(4).

The Committee deliberated the agenda in detail and approved the applications which are completed from Chemistry angle and in addition to that MRLs are fixed or partially fixed or not required.

8.0 Endorsement Cases

8.1 Deferred agenda items of 306th meeting

8.1.1 Request from M/s. Excel Industries Ltd., Mumbai for the endorsement of additional packaging of Glyphosate Technical.

Approved.

8.1.2 Request from M/s Punjab Pesticides Industrial Coop. Society Ltd., Punjab for the endorsement of additional packing of PET bottles for Chlorpyriphos 20%EC.

Approved.

8.1.3 Request from M/s. E.I. Dupont India Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon for the endorsement of new/additional pack size of 10 MT capacity for Indoxacarb Technical.

12

Deferred.

8.1.4 Request from M/s. Saraswati Agro Chemicals (India) Pvt. Ltd., Jammu for the endorsement of additional packing of 20 gm capacity in LDPE pouch and alternate packing in Trilaminated pouch for Dimethomorph 50% W.P.

Approved.

8.1.5 Request from M/s. Rallis India Limited, Bangalore for the endorsement of additional packaging system for flubendiamide technical

Approved.

8.1.6 Request from M/s. United Phosphorus Ltd., Mumbai for the endorsement of alternate pack size of 120 gm for Tricyclazole 75% WP.

Approved.

8.2 Request from M/s. Dhanuka Agri Tech Limited, New Delhi for the endorsement of new/alternate packing in PET bottles for Bifenthrin 10%EC.

Approved.

8.3Request from M/s Crystal Phosphate Ltd., Delhi for the endorsement of additional/alternate packaging of Emamectin Benzoate 5% SG.

Approved.

8.4 Request from M/s Crop Care Pesticides (India) Pvt. Ltd., Chandigarh for the endorsement of alternate packaging of Piroxafop-propinyl (Clodinafop-Propargy) 15% WP in 20gms PVA pouch.

Approved.

13

8.5 Request from M/s. Agrimas Chemical Ltd., New Delhi for endorsement of name of supplier alongwith changed name already approved source of import of Validamycin technical.

The Committee deliberated the Agenda and decided that the technical grade used to be supplied from approved source to the applicant, clarification for adding of new supplier may be sought from the applicant.

8.6 Request from M/s Atharva Agro Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., Durg for endorsement of change in name & style of company.

Approved

8.7 Label expansion of Oxadiargyl 6% EC u/s 9(3) on mustard crop -Application from M/s. Bayer Crop Science Ltd., Mumbai.

Approved.

9.0 Miscellaneous Items

9.1 Consideration of expansion of bioefficacy claims of Deltamethrin 11% w/w EC (10% w/v EC) on rice in favour of M/s Bayer Crop Sciences Ltd., Mumbai.

Approved.

9.2 Data requirement for label extension of pesticides for use on Jatropha (Jatropha curcas) – waiver of data w.r.t. residue and persistence in plant by M/s Bayer Crop Science Ltd., Mumbai.

The Committee deliberated the agenda in detail and not allowed waiver of data w.r.t. residue and persistence in Jatropa in general. However, the specific proposal based on the requirement may be considered.

14

9.3 Consideration of a request of M/s Jai Biotech Industries, Nasik for extension of shelf-life of Verticillium lecannii 1.15% WP

Deferred

9.4 Consideration of a request of M/s Pravara Agro Bio-the, Ahmednagar for enhancement of shelf-life of Trichoderma viride 1.0% WP

Deferred.

9.5 Consideration of a request of M/s Maa Bhagwati Biotech & Chemicals Ltd., Wardha for enhancement of shelf-life of Pseudomonus fluorescens 0.5% WP

Approved.

9.6 Consideration of applications for enhancement of shelf-life under Section 9(4) of the Insecticides Act, 1968.

List is approved.

9.7 Request from M/s Dhanuka Agritech Ltd., New Delhi for prior concurrence regarding bio-efficacy testing of herbicides for registrations in sugarcane at Non-ICAR/SAU Institutes.

The Committee deliberated the Agenda in detail and decided that applicant may generate data as per the existing guidelines from SAU/ICAR Institutes.

9.8 Revalidation of Registration Certificate issued under section 9(4) of the Act – request from M/s Unique Farm Aid Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi.

The Registration Committee deliberated the agenda and decided that registrant/applicant may be asked to submit justification for non-inclusion of the certificates in the manufacturing license and commence production.

15

9.9 Revalidation of Registration Certificate issued under section 9(4) of the Act – request from M/s Reliance Agro Industries, Bahraich.

Registration Committee deliberated the agenda and decided that registrant/applicant may be asked to submit justification for non-inclusion of the certificates in the manufacturing License and commence production.

9.10 Decision of Appeal No.08 of 2009 filed by M/s PNP & Associates Pvt. Ltd., Faridabad under section 10 of the Insecticides Act, 1968.

Noted.

9.11 Ex-post facto approval of RTT permit issued for approval of Registration Committee.

Approved.

9.12 Consideration of applications for import permits for Boric acid and other substances for non-insecticidal use.

Approved as per Annexure ‘B’ (Part-I, Part-II & Part-III).

9.13 Consideration of applications for import permits for Boric acid and other substances for non-insecticidal use (already considered in 306th RC meeting).

Noted.

9.14 Modification in preparation of agenda and placing to the RC for issuance of import permits for import of insecticides for non-insecticidal use.

The proforma may be revised in the Secretariat of CIB&RC and put up in the next meeting of Registration Committee.

9.15 Finalization of Format for recommending import of Boric Acid by the Nodal Agency.

16

Approved the format and desired to put it on the Website for comments.

The Meeting ended with the Vote of Thanks to the Chair.

17

ANNEXURE-‘A’

Phone & Fax No. 011-2413985

F.No. AD (WS)/2010/CIR

Government of IndiaMinistry of Agriculture

(Department of Agriculture & Cooperation)DIRECTORATE OF PLANT PROTECTION, QUARANTINE & STORAGE CENTRAL

INSECTICIDES BOARD AND REGISTRATION COMMITTEEN.H.-IV, Faridabad-121 001

Subject: Report of Sub–Committee on generation of bio efficacy data for registration of Biopesticides u/s 9(3).

The report of Sub–Committee constituted by Registration Committee in its 303 rd

meeting held on 05-08-2009 on generation of bioefficacy data for registration of biopesticides u/s 9(3) is enclosed herewith. The meeting of the Sub-Committee was held on 12-01-2010 at Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi.

sd/-Secretary, CIB&RC (P. S. Chandurkar) Plant Protection Advisor

to the Government of India & Chairman Sub-Committee

Dated: 23-02-2010

18

REPORT OF SUB–COMMITTEE UNDER THE CHAIRMANSHIP OF DR P. S. CHANDURKAR, PPA TO GOI, ON GENERATION OF BIOEFFICACY DATA FOR REGISTRATION OF BIOPESTICIDES U/S 9(3).

Registration Committee (RC) in its 303rd meeting held on 05-08-2009 constituted a Sub-Committee under the Chairmanship of Dr P. S. Chandurkar, Plant Protection Advisor, to the GOI, on “generation of bioefficacy data for registration of bio-pesticides U/s 9(3)” while deliberating a letter from M/s. Yash Krishi Takniki Evam Vigyan Kendra, Allahabad vide Agenda item No 9.2.2. In the letter applicant has sought the following information(s).

(1) Can bioefficacy data be generated from other SAU/Institutes with TNAU isolate as per the guidelines U/s. 9(3).

(2) If 4/5 such members who initially got the data for Trichoderma viride registrations U/s.9(3b) through TNAU, pool up their resources for data generation for their registration U/s.9(3) and submit in a group or individually for registrations, would it be acceptable?

(3) Details of requirement of bioefficacy data for registration U/s. 9(3) i.e., how many locations? How many seasons? How many crops (any maximum number of crops)?

The meeting of the Sub committee was held on 12//1/2010 in the Chamber of Plant Protection Advisor to GOI, Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi. The following attended the meeting.

Dr. P. S. Chandurkar, Plant Protection Advisor to Government of India - ChairmanDr. T.P. Rajendran, Asst. Director General (Plant Protection), ICAR, New Delhi-Member, Dr. A.K. Sinha, JD(PP), CIB&RC-Special Invitee Dr. Subhash Kumar, AD(WS), CIB&RC –Member Convenor

The committee also deliberated the representations from the followings -1) M/s. Pravara Agro Biotech, Ahmednagar (MS)2) M/s. R.B. Herbal Agro, Satna, Nashik3) M/s. Jai Biotech Industries, Satpur, Nashik

These representations also contained the letter from TNAU No. HDPP/BIopesticides/Trchoderma Permanent Registration / 2009-10 dated 03-09-2009 issued to them regarding data generation. The decisions of the meeting are enumerated in the minutes (enclosed).

19

MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE SUB-COMMITTEE UNDER THE CHAIRMANSHIP OF DR. P.S. CHANDURKAR, PPA TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ON GENERATION OF BIO-EFFICACY DATA FOR REGISTRATION OF BIOPESTICIDES U/s. 9(3) HELD ON 12-01-2010 IN ROOM NO. 409, ‘B’-WING , SHASTRI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI.

The meeting of the Sub-Committee under the Chairmanship of Dr. P. S. Chandurkar, Plant Protection Advisor to Government of India, constituted by Registration Committee (RC) in its 303rd meeting held on 05-08-2009 on generation of bioefficacy data for registration of biopesticides U/s.9(3) was held on 12-01-2010 in Room No. 409, ‘B’-Wing, Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi. The following officials attended the meeting.

Dr. P. S. Chandurkar, Plant Protection Advisor to Government of India - ChairmanDr. T.P. Rajendran, Asst. Director General (Plant Protection), ICAR, New Delhi-Member, Dr. A.K. Sinha, JD(PP), CIB&RC-Special Invitee Dr. Subhash Kumar, AD(WS), CIB&RC, Faridabad –Member Convenor,

The Chairman welcomed the participants and requested the Member Convenor to present the Agenda. The Agenda was deliberated in detail and the following decisions were taken:-(1) The data generation for registration of biopesticides shall be done by originator of the

microbial isolate/strain and who has developed the data, required for provisional registration U/s. 9(3B). This could be undertaken by the concerned institution independently or in collaboration with the applicant(s).

(2) In accordance with the decision of 297th meeting of Registration Committee held on 29-01-2009, the revised guidelines for registration of biopesticides have come into force and no application as per old guidelines shall be accepted w.e.f. 01-01-2010. Applicant(s) are required to submit the data for regular registration of biopesticides U/s. 9(3) as per the revised guidelines. Field data on bioeffectiveness is required to be submitted for two seasons/years from a minimum of three agro-climatic conditions, generated on the crops for which label claims have been applied.

(3) RC has already approved the sharing of data among the members of Association or on authorization by the organization/Institution that has generated the data. 9(3)/9(3B) registrants who isolated the microbial strain and generated the data may only authorize other companies / organizations who propose to apply for registration by sharing the data.

(4) The above decisions shall be applicable for registration of all the microbial biopesticides U/s. 9(3) of the Insecticides Act 1968.

The meeting ended with vote of thanks to the chair.

20

Annexure –B.Part – I.

STATUS OF PENDING APPLICATIONS FOR IMPORT PERMIT OF BORIC ACID

S.No

Name of Factory Address of applicant

Decision or RC

1 M/s.Welsuit Glass & Ceramic Pvt. Ltd.,Nr. D.G.S. Gas Station, Padra, Jambusar Highway, Opp. Haldyn Glass, Gavasad-391430, Dist.-Baroda.Letter No. NIL,Dt.19-11-09.

Approved for 600MT, in view of the recommendation of DIC, Vadodara and the average consumption pattern of the last 18 months.

2. M/s. Sahaj Cerchem Private Limited, 47, Vijay Nagar Colony (Old), Agra-282 004 .Lt. No.2008-09/AGRA/887, dt. 09-12-09

The applicant may be asked to apply fresh on the prescribed format approved by the RC in its 303rd meeting.

3. M/s. Raj Borax Limited, 40-44A, Dheeraj Heritage, 4th

Floor, S.V. Road, Santacruz(West), Mumbai-400 054.Lt .No.NIL,Dt. 10-12-09

The applicant may be asked to apply fresh on the prescribed format approved by the RC in its 303rd meeting.

4.$ M/s.Laser Glass Industries, 8-A, National Highway, Lakhdhirpur Road, Opp. Gas Terminal, MORBI-363 642 (Guj.)Ltr.No.NIL, dt., 24-11-09

The applicant may be asked to submit:(a) Original recommendation on the prescribed proforma approved by the RC in its 294th meeting.

(b) Notarized copy of proof of the Unit being Small Scale Industry(c) Calculation sheet with the recommendation letter

5. M/s. Svm Cera Tea Ltd., Plot No.4802/B, G.I.D.C., Ankleshwar-393 002, Dist. Bharuch (Guj.)Letter No.NIL, dt. 16-12-2009 & 24-07-09

Approved for 700MT, in view of the recommendation of DIC, Bharuch and the average annual consumption pattern in the preceding years.

21

6. M/s. Sami Labs Limited, 19/1 & 19/2, I Main, II Phase, Peenya Industrial Estate, Bangalore-560058Ltr. No.NIL, dt. 25-09-09 & 18-12-09

The applicant may be asked to submit:

(a) Original recommendation on the prescribed proforma approved by the RC in its 294th meeting.

(b) Copy of complete application made to DIC for obtaining end-use/recommendation Certificate.

(c)Calculation sheet with the recommendation letter].

7. M/s. Prime Ceramics Pvt. Ltd., Padara-Jamubusar Road, Gavasad-391430, Ta.: Padara, Dist.: Vadodara (Guj.).L:tr. No.PCPL/2009-10/CIB&RC,Dt.08-07-2009 & 25-09-09Received in the office on 15/01/2010.

Approved in view of the recommendation of DIC, Vddodara i.e 72.96MT.However ,keeping in view of the size of container the quantity approved for import 80MT.

8. M/s. LaOpala Solitaire RG Ltd., “Chitrakoot”, 10th Floor, 230A, A.J.C. Bose Road, Kolkata-700 020.Tr. No.LORG:KOL;2009, Dt.29-12-09


(1) Notorized copy of valid consent letter from State Pollution Control Board.

(2) Original Certificate for the quantity imported/consumed during the last five years duly certified by Central Excise Authorities.

(3) Original recommendation letter from Nodal Agency.

9. M/s. R.K. International, 72, Cotton Street, 1st Floor, Kolkata-700 007.Lr.No. Nil dt. Nil

The applicant may be asked to apply fresh on the prescribed format approved by the RC in its 303rd Meeting and route through the recommending Authority

22

Part-II.

STATUS OF PENDING APPLICATIONS FOR IMPORT PERMIT OF DUAL USE INSECTICIDES (EXCEPT BORIC ACID).

S.No

Name of Factory Address of applicant

Decision or RC

1. M/s. DCM Shriram Industries Ltd., Kanchenjunga, 18, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi 110001.

Approved for 600MT of Sodium cyanide in view of the recommendation of Nodal Agency and the average annual consumption pattern in the preceding years.

2. M/s. Kudos Chemie Ltd., Village Kuranwala, Derabassi-Barwala Road, Derabassi (Sas Nagar)Punjab-140507.Letter No.KCL/SC/CIB/PER/2009, dt. 17-11-2009.

Approved for 650MT of Sodium cyanide in view of the recommendation of Nodal Agency and the annual average consumption pattern in the preceding years.

3. M/s. Aarti Industries Limited, Udyog Kshetra, 2nd Floor, Mulund Goregaon Link Road, Mulund (W), Mumbai-400 080.Letter No.NIL, dt. 17-11-09


1) Notorized copy of Valid License to work a Factory & English Version.

2) Original Certificate for the quantity imported/consumed during the last five years duly certified by Central Excise Authorities.

3) Notarized copy of valid advance license for export.

4. M/s. Hemani Intermediates Pvt. Ltd., 706, 710, Reena Complex, 7th Floor, Ramdev Nagar Road, Vidhya Vihar (W), Mumbai 400 086.Letter N o. NIL, dt. 18-11-09

The applicant may be asked to submit: 1) Original Certificate for the quantity imported/consumed during the last five years duly certified by Central Excise Authorities.

2) Original recommendation letter from The nodal Agency.

23

5. M/s. Ideal Dye Chem Industries, 706-710, Reena Complex, 7th Floor, Ramdev Nagar Road, Vidhya Vihar (W), Mumbai 400 086.Letter N o. NIL, dt. 18-11-09


Original Certificate for the quantity imported/consumed during the last five years duly certified by Central Excise Authorities].

6. M/s. Videocon Industries Limited, ‘Videocon Tower’, Block E-1, Jhandewala Extension, New Delhi110055.Letter No. NIL,Dt.07-12-09 &07-08-09

Approved for 10000MT of Barium Carbonate in view of the recommendation of Nodal Agency and the average annual consumption pattern in the preceding years.

7. M/s. Kores (India) Limited, Kores House, Plot No.10, Off Dr. E. Moses Road, Worli, Mumbai-400018.Letter No.NIL, Dt.02-11-09

Approved for 130MT of Sodium cyanide in view of the recommendation of Nodal Agency and the average annual consumption pattern in the preceding years.

8. M/s. Excel Crop Care Ltd., 13/14, Aradhana Indl. Development Corp., Near Virwani Indl. Estate, Goregaon (E), Mumbai-400063, Letter No. MKT/AVD/610, dt. 03-12-09 & 07-01-2010

Approved for 600MT of Acrylonitrile in view of the recommendation of Nodal Agency and the average annual consumption pattern in the preceding years.

9. M/s. Andhra Sugar Limited, Venkatarayapuram, Tanuku-534215, Andhra Pradesh.Letter No.D/ASL/09/9, dt. 09-12-09


10. M/s. Saral Chem, C/302, Angelina Co-op, Hsg. Soc., Corner of Sargini Rd., & Old Police St. Rd., Vile Parle (W), Mumbai-400056.Ltr. No.NIL,Dt.14-12-09

The applicant may be asked to clarify whether they are authorized for import of Barium Carbonate by the Poison License Issuing Authority and to route their clarification through the License Issuing Authority.

11. M/s. Hikal Ltd., 717718, Maker Chamber-V, Nariman Point, Mumbai-400 021.Ltr.No.NIL, dt.06-12-09.

Approved for 200MT of Amitrol in view of the recommendation of Nodal Agency.

24

12. M/s. Sunflower Chemicals (P) Ltd., 34, Patti Street, Sivakasi-626123,Ltr. No.NIL,16-12-09 &19-09-09


(a) Original recommendation letter from DIC.

(b) Notorized copy of English version of Factory/Work License].

13. M/s. Sree Rayalaseema Alkalies and Allied Chemicals Ltd., P-101, Ground Floor, Pandav Nagar, Mayur Vihar Phase-I, New Delhi-110 091.Ltr. No.NIL,Dt. 16-12-09.


14. M/s. Shree Ganesh Chemcials, 29 Ramdev Estate, Opp. Bhatt Brothers, Nagarvel Hanuman Road, Rakhial, Ahmedabad-380 026.Letter No.NIL,Dt. NIL

The applicant may be asked to submit separate applications for each product on the prescribed proforma approved by the RC in its 303rd meeting.]

15. M/s. Jaggo Overseas, B-35/3A, G.T. Karnal Road Industrial Area (Behind Shakti Nagar Telephone Exchange), Delhi-110 033.Letter No.NIL,Dt. 24-12-09.

The applicant may be asked to clarify whether they are authorized for import of Sodium cyanide by the Poison License Issuing Authority and to route their clarification through the License Issuing Authority.

16. M/s. Euro Labs, 212, Maker Bhavan No.III 2nd Floor, Above Balvas Hotel, 21, New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400 002.Ltr. No. EL: 151, dt. 16-12-09 &11-05-09.

The applicant may be asked to submit Revised Original recommendation/End-use Certificate from DIC, Raigarh with quantity recommended for import.

17. M/s. Eurofine Chemicals,212, Maker Bhavan No.III 2nd

Floor, Above Balvas Hotel, 21, New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400 002.Ltr. No. EF: 190, dt. 16-12-09 &11-05-09


(a) Revised Original recommendation/End-use Certificate from DIC, Raigarh with the quantity recommended for import.

(b) Notorized copy of valid Factory/Work License].

25

18. M/s. Sri Pandian Nitrates Pvt. Ltd., D.No.2/2/354, Subramaniapuram (P.O.), Salvarpatti Panchayat, Vembakottai Union, Sivalkasi (T.K.), Virudhunagar (Dt.)-626 128.Ltr. No.NIL,Dt. 2/11/09 received on 21-01-2010.

The applicant may be asked to submit copy of application made to DIC, Chennai for obtaining end-use/recommendation certificate.

19.

M/s. Peekay Agencies Pvt. Ltd., 7/1, Lord Sinha Road, Lords 506, Kolkata-700 071.Lr.No.PAP/463/GK/09-10 dt. 14.01.2010.

The applicant may be asked to submit fresh application on the prescribed format approved by the RC in its 303rd meeting.

20 Bhagiradha Chemicals&Industries ltd. Plot No.3,Sagar Society ,Road No.2,Banjara Hills, Hyderabad-500 034 Lt. No. MOC&F/3675 dt. 21.01.2010.

The applicant may be asked to submit fresh application on the prescribed format approved by the RC in its 303rd meeting.

26

Part – III.

Representations for Issuance of Import Permit for Dual Use Insecticides

S.No

Name of the Applicant (M/s) Decision of RC

1 2 31. M/s. La Opala RG Ltd,

“Chitrakoot”, 10th Floor, 230A, A.J.C. Bose Road, Kolkata-700 020.

Approved for extension of validity period of import permit No.21-14/2008-CIR-II issued on 11.11.2008 for import of Barium Carbonate for one year.

2. M/s. H.& R. Johnson (India) Limited, Windsor, 7th Floor, C.S. T. Road, Kalina, Santacruz(East), Mumbai-400 098.Letter No.NIL, dt.16-11-2009.

Approved for further 100MT of Boric Acid, in addition to the quantity permitted earlier vide the import permit No.21-9/2009-CIR-II issued on 29.09.2009.

3. M/s. Isagro (Asia) Agrochemicals Pvt. Ltd., 101, Solitaire Corporate Park, 151, M. Vasanji Road, Chakala Andheri (East), Mumbai-400093Letter No. NIL, dt. 07-12-09

The applicant may be asked to explain why he has not imported Sodium Cyanide within two years, as one extension has already been granted vide letter No.21-6/2008-CIR-II dated 29.09.2009?

4. M/s. Sujitha Chemicals, B-7, Sidco Industrial Estate, Mettur Dam-636 402, Salem Dist. Tamil Nadu,Letter No.NIL, dt. 07-12-09.

Approved for extension of validity period of import permit No.21-18/2008-CIR-II issued on 13.01.2009 for import of Barium Carbonate for one year.

5. M/s. Belgium Glass & Ceramics (P) Ltd., “Green Ford” Site-Baroda-Jambusar, National High Way Road, Dabhasa, Padra-391 440-Baroda, (Gujarat).Letter .BGCPL/BMV/CIBRC-BA/09-10/163, dt. 11-12-09.

Approved for further 100MT of Boric Acid, in addition to the quantity permitted earlier vide the import permit No.21-9/2009-CIR-II issued on 29.09.2009.

6. M/s.Devanshi Impex Pvt. Ltd., 84, V.V. Chandan Street, 2nd

floor, Vadgadi, Masjid (West), Mumbai-400003.Letter No.NIL, dt. 15-01-2010.

The applicant may be asked to clarify whether they are authorized for import of Barium Carbonate by the Poison License Issuing Authority to route their clarification through the License Issuing Authority.

7. M/s.Devanshi Impex Pvt. Ltd., The applicant may be asked to 27

84, V.V. Chandan Street, 2nd


clarify whether they are authorized for import of Sodium Cyanide by the Poison License Issuing Authority and to route their clarification through the License Issuing Authority.

8. M/s.Devanshi Impex Pvt. Ltd., 84, V.V. Chandan Street, 2nd


The applicant may be asked to clarify whether they are authorized for import of Thiourea by the Poison License Issuing Authority and to route their clarification through the License Issuing Authority.

9* The Hutti Gold Mines Company Ltd., (Govt. of Karnataka Enterprises)3rd Floor, KHB, New Shopping Complex, National Games Village, Koramangla (Post), Bangalore-560 076Lr.No.PS/2072/HGML/Cyanide/2009 dt. 23.10.2009. Forwarded by DAC vide Lr. No.17-11/2009-PP.I dt. 15.01.2010

The applicant may be asked to justify why he has not imported Sodium Cyanide with supporting documents within the extended period and also provide Notarized copy of Import permit issued by this office vide letter No.21-7/2006-CIR-II dated 21.11.2006.

10* M/s.Shaj Cerchem Pvt. Ltd., 47, Vijay Nagar Colony (Old), Agra-282 004Letter No.2009-10/AGR/1040, dt. 27-01-2010.

Approved for further 100MT of Boric Acid, in addition to the quantity permitted earlier vide the import permits No.21-7/2009-CIR-II issued on 27.07.2009 & 21-1/2009-CIR-II dated 09.02.2009 for 100MT each.

Note :- (*) The cases at serial no9&10 could not be incorporated in the Agenda item due to the duplicity of page no.405 (agenda item no 9.12.3.)Due to the directions of the Hon’ble High Court to dispose off Boric Acid cases within a stipulated time period, the above cases were deliberated on 25.02.2010 in the chamber of The Chairman of RC and the decision of RC is included at serial No. 9 &10.

Phone & Fax No. 011-2413985

F.No. 4-1(307)/2009/CIR-II

Government of IndiaMinistry of Agriculture

(Department of Agriculture & Cooperation)DIRECTORATE OF PLANT PROTECTION, QUARANTINE & STORAGE

CENTRAL INSECTICIDES BOARD AND REGISTRATION COMMITTEEN.H.-IV, Faridabad-121 001(Haryana)

28

Date: 11th March, 2010.

CORRIGENDUMSubject: Corrigendum to the Minutes of the 307 th meeting of the Registration

Committee held on 24.02.2010 at 10.00 A.M. in Committee Room No.142, Krishi Bhavan, New Delhi.

The following Corrigendum is issued to the Agenda Items already mentioned in the Minutes of 307th RC meeting:-

Agenda item No.

Particulars of Agenda

8.1.3 Request from M/s. E.I. Dupont India Pvt. Ltd., Gurgaon for the endorsement of new/additional pack size of 10 MT capacity for Indoxacarb Technical.

The applicant should submit Performance Test Report or Test Certificate (if any), along with packaging details for evaluation.

9.3Consideration of a request of M/s Jai Biotech Industries, Nasik for extension of shelf-life of Verticillium lecannii 1.15% WP

The case can be re-visited at the level of Secretariat of CIB&RC and put up to RC.

9.4Consideration of a request of M/s. Pravara Agro Bio-tech, Ahmednagar for enhancement of shelf-life of Trichoderma viride 1.0% WPThe case can be re-visited at the level of Secretariat of CIB&RC and put up to RC.

(Sushil K. Khurana)Secretary (CIB&RC)

29

minutes of the 307th meeting of the registration … · web viewminutes of the 307th meeting of the...

Documents