mie2013 dag1 why5_research_dela
TRANSCRIPT
Neuro-Diagnostic Research The perfect marriage between biology and
psychology
Madeleine Janssens – WHY5 Marysia Kluppels – DELA
MIE 2013
1 What is this all about?
“Let biologists do their job and we, psychologists, will do ours. One day, we’ll meet each other along the way.”
Sigmund Freud
Traditional research
relies on declarations and interpretation of
declarations
Measuring brain waves allows us to get ahead of
these declarations
Even those that are derived via projections
etc
Neuro diagnostics =
Biometric evidence +
Psychological analysis
Developed in collaboration with a radiologist (Dr. L. Denis), electrical engineers and the WHY5 team of
consumer psychologists
Neuro-Diagnostics is the matchmaker between:
human Brain activities as the response to a stimulus
and the psychological interpretation of the stimulus
Today biology and pyschology meet: Neuro-Diagnostic Research
Gives strong objective foundation to
psychological, diagnostic analysis
Measures the brain waves that are
the result of autonomic functions,
out of control of the individual itself
Have an objective reality one can
not “cheat” with
Rational
Emotional
Instinctual
Added value vs. current qualitative research
Classical MR Diagnostic
MR
Neuro diagnostic
MR
Market Research Territories
Instinctive reaction
Universal
OLD BRAIN
REPTILLIAN
INSTINCTUAL
Emotional behaviour
Assigns values
MIDDLE BRAIN
LIMBIC
EMOTIONAL
Conscious
Gives meaning, Provides reason
NEW BRAIN
NEOCORTEX
RATIONAL
Rational
Emotional
Instinctual
Added value vs. current qualitative research
Classical MR Diagnostic
MR
Neuro diagnostic
MR
Market Research Territories
Instinctive reaction
Universal
OLD BRAIN
REPTILLIAN
INSTINCTUAL
Emotional behaviour
Assigns values
MIDDLE BRAIN
LIMBIC
EMOTIONAL
Conscious
Gives meaning, Provides reason
NEW BRAIN
NEOCORTEX
RATIONAL
The location of origin of the waves as such is not of most importance. It is about the total activity resulting from the cooperation of the different parts of the brain
that results in a particular reaction. All the waves that are send by the neurons in the brain are measured together but
can be identified particularly as well
2 How do we do it?
• Detect & measure brain activity via blood flow
• BUT is also “slow in registration”: fastest reaction time (and measurement) of FMRI is 5 sec
• Detects and measures brain activity
via electrical impulses from the brain
• Device that measures the fluctuations
and patterns in electrical processes
within the brain.
• Can detect changes within
milliseconds
Choice between fMRI and EEG was a no-brainer
Problematic from several points of view
• Data aggregated into 4 fundamental brain activity waves
• Where basically detected by Hans Berger (German Psychiatrist and Neuro sciencist)
• Re-defined for marketing by WHY5Research and approved by our radiologist
4 fundamental brain activity waves
Approval naming waves by radiologist
Empathic openness wave
Mental receptivity wave
Active processing wave
Subconscious reactions wave
Is a state of awareness in which one is not focused on specific things in the environment
Logical, concentrated thinking, mental effort and assessment
Empathic Openness Wave provides intuition, empathetic attunement, and instinctual insight
The subconscious mind Intuition and GUT feelings
Areas of application
Can be applied both in the context of development as well as for finalized stimuli
Is recommended for different research objectives:
Communication pre-testing:
Commercials (also narratives)
Radio spots
Print advertising
TV programs
Communication post-testing of TVC’s, print advertising,…
New packaging and label designs
Smell and taste research
Result: a more accurate insight in consumer motivations and market dynamics
• Embedding diagnostic insights:
• Scientific support to and grounding of motivations
• Actionable results
• EXAMPLE: communication research
• Insight in how the product/brand is presented in this communication: overall
emotional experience and rational processing
• Clear understanding of which attributes or characteristics are seen, which of
them are stressed or reinforced: subconscious reactions, peaks of attention,
mental alertness or empathic openness
• Analysis of the way it succeeds in constructively supporting deeper lying
motivations:
• How symbols, signals, meanings, … succeed in connecting with the
fundamental drives of the target
OUR APPROACH: BIOMETRIC EVIDENCE + PSYCHOLOGICAL ANALYSIS
5 steps ® &
EEG
(Electro-encephalo-
graphy) measurement
of brain reaction to
stimuli
Real time identification
of key events in the brain (peaks of activity)
Qualitative Diagnostic of
Key events
Interpretation and analysis of
integrated brain wave
results
Integrated with the diagnostic
analysis
Insights in consumer motivations and market dynamics
1. 3. 4. 2. 5.
Individual level Aggregated level
STEP 1: REAL TIME IDENTIFICATION OF KEY EVENTS ON THE INDIVIDUAL LEVEL
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Identification of key events: the moments with significant peaks in brain activity
Event 2 Event 1 Event 4
Event 3 Event 5 Relative
power of brain waves*
Mental receptivity wave
Active processing wave
Empathic openness wave
Subconscious reactions wave
Time of exposure to stimuli (in sec)
*Is calculated individually for each brain wave relative to the highest value reached during the stimuli exposure. For each wave the value of 100% indicates the moment when the highest brain power is achieved
1.
Step 1: interpretation and analysis of brain wave results
A E R A
• EEG results
• Key analytical dimensions: AERA model – Each dimension is connected to a combination of
waves
When does the stimulus get
respondents’ full attention?
What kind of emotion is triggered?
Rational
processing: does
the stimulus
activate people to
take action
(consideration,
buying
intention,….)
What is the final affective
resonance?
1.
AERA analytical model: Attention, Emotion, Rational processing and Affective resonance
3 DELA case
• Algemene perceptie en beleving, boodschap en relevantie
• Detailanalyse: analyse van de verhaallijn, settings, personages….
• Analyse van de wijze waarop het de gewenste beleving neerzet van DELA:
• In welke mate is de campagne in lijn met de essentie van de DELA strategie en positionering?
• Het moet de bekendheid van het merk verhogen
• Het moet de dood / begrafenis naar het publieke forum brengen en bespreekbaar maken
• Het moet identificatie van de ontvanger met de boodschap mogelijk maken
• Mag wel “wakker schudden”, de feiten onder ogen durven zien, maar geenszins choqueren of bruuskeren
• Moet zorg uitstralen, moet emotionele betrokkenheid tonen zonder echt sentimenteel te worden
• Het moet aanzetten tot nadenken / bij voorkeur zelfs actie (informeren / afsluiten)
• Analyse van de wijze waarop de campagnevoorstellen erin slagen aan te sluiten bij de onderliggende noden en behoeften van de doelgroep:
• In welke mate kan dit sympathie voor het merk creëren voor de target die nog geen begrafenisverzekering heeft afgesloten
• In welke mate zet dit aan tot actie (informeren / afsluiten)
• Wat zijn de krijtlijnen voor verdere uitwerking
DELA - Onderzoekstopics
• De doelstelling:
• In kaart brengen van de inhoudelijke communicatieve bijdrage van
• de verschillende executies van deze campagne
• algemene campagne
DELA – Objectief en benadering van het onderzoek
Test materiaal:
• Narratives DELA
• Steenezel
• Bomma Koekenpan
• Supermarkt
• Afwas
Benadering:
• Brain waves measurement
• Qualitative Diagnostic Research
Executies van eenzelfde route
Executies van eenzelfde route
21
Steenezel Supermarkt Bomma Koekenpan Afwas
40% 45% 42% 40%
41% 39% 35% 31%
59% 41% 34% 28%
33% 27% 23% 22%
DELA RESEARCH - NARRATIVES
General outcome
Aggregated values:
Steenezel scores high on 3 of the 4 waves
Steenezel is a balanced and warm story that inspires people and offers trust
which is why the brand is in the consideration set
Supermarkt is a surprising story in a rather banal and familiar context but is not
really able to anchor the message at the fullest
Bomma Koekenpan is a rather neutral story
Afwas scores lowest on all waves. This story is not able to attract the attention nor
to bring the brand into the consideration set
Blue – higher than average Red – lower than average
DELA RESEARCH – NARRATIVE STEENEZEL
DELA RESEARCH – NARRATIVE STEENEZEL: WAVEFLOW / HIGHLIGHTS
Overall strong emotional engagement
Final message is well captured and makes people reflect on it
2
3 Strong attention and alertness as from 3” 1
DELA RESEARCH – NARRATIVE STEENEZEL
Strong dominance of empathic openess wave with high peaks :
Sequence 11” tot 33” (“Mom deserves a statue for living with dad”)
Is the sequence in which the story about the “steenezel” is told
Evokes deep basic emotions of warmth and respect
Strong empathic attunement
Sequence 36”- 44”: (“When we bought our house, he helped us out with the painting. And
he brought his own paint! “)
Emotional comprehension, care and empathy as central emotions
Sequence 51”-53” (“he paid the bill without me noticing. So stubborn… )
Waves show identification but also a feeling of positive surprise
Sequence 67”-72” (“a voice says: only leave good memories behind…)”
Indication of empathic attunement with strong active resonance
Strong attention as from sec 3-5:
“He stands on the podium
and speaks...”
Indication of strong
relaxed alertness
High subconscious
reactions wave shows
not only curiosity but
also the fact it inspires
people on a more
subconscious level
ATTENTION EMOTION
Sequence (“no extra costs with DELA... More on WWW….)”
Indicates people’s receptiveness for the
information next to the fact that they are willing
to think about it or reflect on it
DELA RESEARCH – NARRATIVE STEENEZEL
Dominance of empathic
openess wave till final
end indicate openess
and receptiveness
for the final message
RATIO AFFECTIVE IMPACT
DELA RESEARCH – NARRATIVE AFWAS
DELA RESEARCH – NARRATIVE AFWAS: WAVEFLOW / HIGHLIGHTS
Very low level of empathic engagement 2
Weak start indicating poor attention and openess to the story
1
28
DELA RESEARCH – NARRATIVE AFWAS
Poor attention as from the
beginning
Nothing particular that
attracts people:
Shows undirected
focus
Exception: sequens
sec 50”-51” (“DELA de
uitvaartspecialist…)”:
indicating some
alertness or interest
in brand name
• Some recognition in a
classic, traditional
context
• Twist in the story
is not picked up
(overall same
wave pattern)
• No conscious
information up
take
• The openess for the brand
is an isolated sequence,
disconnected from the rest
of the story
ATTENTION AFFECTIVE IMPACT EMOTION RATIO
Resultaten
Het moet aanzetten tot nadenken / bij voorkeur zelfs actie (informeren / afsluiten): Spot werkte heel activerend
Stijgend aantal oproepen liepen samen met zendschema van de spot
Tijdens zendperiode van de campagne begin 2012 lag het aantal oproepen 46,73% hoger dan voor dezelfde periode 2011 waarin ook campagne gevoerd werd
Het grootste aandeel van de oproepen komt van klanten & potentiële
klanten. 96% van de klanten die inbellen worden doorgeschakeld – voornaamste
vragen: generieke info over contract, info over betalingen & adres wijzingen
De potentiële klanten bellen voornamelijk om een afspraak te maken, in 2de instantie brochure en vervolgens vragen over uitvaartzorgplan (totale oproepen over de periode van april tot juni 2012)
Meer personeel op Call Center diende voorzien te worden bij uitzending
spot
Stijgend aantal bezoekers op website
Stijgend aantal leads
Resulteerde ultiem in een verhoogde bruto productie
Resultaten
Mag wel “wakker schudden”, de feiten onder ogen durven zien, maar geenszins
choqueren of bruuskeren Amper klachten
In tegenstelling tot vorige uitingen/Jep Ondanks hoge sensitieve geladenheid van het onderwerp op zich
Het moet de dood / begrafenis naar het publieke forum brengen en bespreekbaar maken Geslaagd!
Steeds meer info op radio/TV/krant over uitvaartverzekeringen Steeds meer info omtrent wat te doen ingeval van overlijden, hoe zich erop voorzien
Algemene perceptie en beleving van DELA
Resultaten van brandfame tracker zijn positief
4 Intensity of the waves Benchmarks Tailored approach
Intensity of the waves Not an absolute datum
Need to be interpreted in view of:
The objective of the stimulus
The psychological territory it is intending to
address
E.g. Overall waves will be lower when
addressing the motivational territory of
“COMFORT US!” and need to be more intense
when addressing the motivational territory of
“I AM!
Also the combination – “playing together” - of the
waves counts
E.g. a higher blue wave can be positive news –
if supported by a yellow wave and a red wave
– in case the stimuli is intending to address a
relaxing motivation (COMFORT US!) but it is
as bad news when intending to address an
energetic motivation (I AM!)
Mental receptivity wave
Active processing wave
Empathic openness wave
Subconscious reactions wave
33
Benchmarking versus average of previously tested commercials makes no sense
SEE TOUCH HEAR TASTE
Primary colors Pain Warmth
Cold Softness
Warm milk (mother)
Musk (father) acetylcysteine
(decay) Morning dew
(life)
Music Intervals:
Excitement
Happiness
Melancholy
Hate
Salt Sour
Sweet Bitter
Umami
Pre/post TVC, print, pack
Tactile (pack, product) Radio, TVC Taste & Olfactory
SMELL
Recommendation:
Best in market benchmark
Absolute benchmarks
Tailor-made approach
Marketing is bridging – Communication is the bridge
Research is conducted on specific target the communication is addressing – NOT with Mr Average Deeper lying motivations (driving force behind behavior) can only by researched by those who expose behavior or intend to do so
References
Bell, V. (2012). A bridge over troubled waters for fMRI?. Mind Hacks blog.
http://mindhacks.com/2012/05/28/a-bridge-over-troubled-waters-for-fmri
Bruce, A.S., Bruce, J.M., Black, W.R., Lepping, R.J., Henry, J.M., Cherry, J.B.C., Martin, L.E., Papa, V.B., Davis, A.M., Brooks, W.M. and Savage, C.R. (2012).
Branding and a child’s brain: an fMRI study of neural responses to logos. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience Advance Access.
http://scan.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2012/12/13/scan.nss109.full.pdf+html?sid=074e1b71-d794-4f62-a2b5-c7dda9043435
Castermans, T. (2011). Detecting biosignals with the Emotiv EPOC headset : a review. Université de Mons.
Hill, D. (2009). Emotionomics. Leveraging Emotions for Bussiness success. (summary)
Hupé, J., Bordier, C. and Dojat, M. (2012). The Blinking Brain – A Problem for fMRI?. Neuroskeptic.
http://neuroskeptic.blogspot.be/2012/03/blinking-brain-problem-for-fmri.html
Jain, K., Manghirmalani, P., Dongardive, J. and Abraham, S. (2009). Computational Diagnosis of Learning Disability. International Journal of Recent Trends in
Engineering. Vol 2, No 3, 64-66.
Keil, A., Costa, V., Smith, C.J., Sabatinelli, D., McGinnis M.E., Bradley M.M. and Lang, P. J. (2011). Tagging Cortical Networks in Emotion: A Topographical
Analysis. Human Brain Mapping. Vol 33, No. 12, 2920-2931
Koelstra, S., Mühl, C., Soleymani, M., Lee, J., Yazdani, A., Ebrahimi, T., Pun, T., Nijholt, A. and Patras, I. (2012). DEAP: A Database for Emotion Analysis
using Physiological Signals. IEEE Trans. Affective Computing
http://www.eecs.qmul.ac.uk/mmv/datasets/deap/doc/tac_special_issue_2011.pdf
Koelstra, S., Yazdani, A., Soleymani, M., Mühl, C., Lee, J., Nijholt, A., Pun, T., Ebrahimi, T. and Patras, I. (2010). Single Trial Classification of EEG and
Peripheral Physiological Signals for Recognition of Emotiosn Induced by Music Videos.
http://sanderkoelstra.nl/media/postPdfs/paper.pdf
Kropotov, J.D., (2009). Quantitative EEG, Event-Related Potentials and Neurotherapy. Elsevier Inc. USA, 542 pp
Lin, Y.P., Wang, C.H., Jung, T.P., Wu T.L., Jeng, S.K., Duann, J.R. and Chen, J.H. (2010). EEG-Based Emotion Recognition in Music Listening. IEEE
Transactions on Biomedical Engineering. Vol 57, NO. 7.
Makeig, S., Leslie, G.,Mullen, T., Sarma, D., Bigdely-Shamlo, N. and Kothe, C. (2011). First Demonstration of a Musical Emotion BCI.
http://sccn.ucsd.edu/~scott/pdf/FirstDemoMusicEmotionBCI.pdf
References
Matthies, D.J.C., Antons, J., Heidmann, F., Wettach, R. and Schleicher, R. (2012), NeuroPad: Use Cases For A Mobile Physiological Interface.
http://www.qu.tu-berlin.de/fileadmin/fg41/download/Team/Robert_Schleicher/Matthies_Schleicher_2012_NordiCHI_Neuropad.pdf
Reid, A. (2011). Mapping the consumer mind: discovering the true drivers of behavior through Neuroscinence. Sentient Decision Science – The Business of
Insight. Merlien Institute
Reid, A. and Perille, M.A. (2010) Hot State Decision Making. Understanding Consumer Emotion and Rationality. Sentient Decision Science.
Schmidt, L.A. and Trainor L.J., (2001). Frontal brain electrical activity (EEG) distinguishes valence and intensity of musical emotions. Cognition and Emotion.
15 (4), 487-500
http://psycserv.mcmaster.ca/ljt/schmidt_trainor_2001.pdf
Soleymani, M., Koelstra, S., Patras, I. and Pun T. (2011). Continuous Emotion Detection in Response to Music Videos
http://sanderkoelstra.nl/media/postPdfs/emospace_FG2011.pdf
Verheggen, P.P. and de Munnik, M. (2012). Insights based on innersight. Motivaction Research and Strategy – Neurensics Neuroeconomic Research.
Wang, J.Y., (2012). A primer on the problem with fMRI
http://jeremyywang.com/a-primer-on-the-problem-with-fmri