mechanisms to molecules - home - the giovanni … · armenise-harvard symposium 2014 mechanisms to...

37
ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda Italy About the Symposium L1050036The gentle brush strokes of a XVIII century oil painting seemed to make up the setting of the 15th Armenise-Harvard Symposium. A mélange of olive trees, cypresses and oleanders surrounded by green hills and reflected in the shimmering blue of the Garda Lake: in this bucolic scenario, 80 scientists met to discuss the latest advancements in cell biology. Between June 22 and 24, the symposium held in the luxurious Poiano Resort brought together researchers working on the cutting edge of science. “Interdisciplinary” and “heterogeneity” were the main keywords: this was already pretty clear from the symposium title, “Mechanisms to Molecules”. From single proteins activity to complete cell systems, from basic research to clinical application: the two-and-a-half-day meeting was an exciting opportunity for cross-disciplinary discussions and high-level scientific exchanges. Twenty-one researchers, all leaders of their research groups in Italy and the United States, talked about their latest results, in many cases presenting preliminary and unpublished data. The friendly and free dialogue led to sharp debates about the most fascinating engines of our body: human cells. The outstanding talks, very different from each other, had a common challenge: making long stories short. In fact each presented research began many years ago, when most of the cellular mechanisms discussed during the symposium were unknown. Today, new technological tools and highly advanced microscopic techniques are making “visible” what was previously unseen; but at the same time, it is important not to lose the bigger picture. This is what emerged from the enthralling keynote speech given by Harvard Professor Stephen Harrison, who deliberately juxtaposed the symposium name, entitling his presentation “Molecule to Mechanisms”. He outlined various ways to think of molecular activity starting from the paradigmatic example of influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA), whose binds receptor can defeat our immune response. This started the discussion about the incredible number of interactions happening from molecular to cell mechanism level, and vice versa. The first symposium session, entitled “Mechanisms Regulating Epigenetic Regulation”, opened up the door to investigate this intriguing cellular complexity. Danesh Moazed and Stephen Buratowski talked about two fundamental ingredients of

Upload: vuongdieu

Post on 16-Feb-2019

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

ARMENISE-HARVARDSYMPOSIUM2014

MECHANISMSTOMOLECULES

15thBiennialSymposiumJune22-24,2014,PoianoResortHotel,LakeGardaItaly

AbouttheSymposium

L1050036ThegentlebrushstrokesofaXVIIIcenturyoilpaintingseemedtomakeupthesettingofthe15thArmenise-HarvardSymposium.Amélangeofolivetrees,cypressesandoleanderssurroundedbygreenhillsandreflectedintheshimmeringblueoftheGardaLake:inthisbucolicscenario,80scientistsmettodiscussthelatestadvancementsincellbiology.

BetweenJune22and24,thesymposiumheldintheluxuriousPoianoResortbroughttogetherresearchersworkingonthecuttingedgeofscience.“Interdisciplinary”and“heterogeneity”werethemainkeywords:thiswasalreadyprettyclearfromthesymposiumtitle,“MechanismstoMolecules”.

Fromsingleproteinsactivitytocompletecellsystems,frombasicresearchtoclinicalapplication:thetwo-and-a-half-daymeetingwasanexcitingopportunityforcross-disciplinarydiscussionsandhigh-levelscientificexchanges.

Twenty-oneresearchers,allleadersoftheirresearchgroupsinItalyandtheUnitedStates,talkedabouttheirlatestresults,inmanycasespresentingpreliminaryandunpublisheddata.Thefriendlyandfreedialogueledtosharpdebatesaboutthemostfascinatingenginesofourbody:humancells.

Theoutstandingtalks,verydifferentfromeachother,hadacommonchallenge:makinglongstoriesshort.Infacteachpresentedresearchbeganmanyyearsago,whenmostofthecellularmechanismsdiscussedduringthesymposiumwereunknown.

Today,newtechnologicaltoolsandhighlyadvancedmicroscopictechniquesaremaking“visible”whatwaspreviouslyunseen;butatthesametime,itisimportantnottolosethebiggerpicture.

ThisiswhatemergedfromtheenthrallingkeynotespeechgivenbyHarvardProfessorStephenHarrison,whodeliberatelyjuxtaposedthesymposiumname,entitlinghispresentation“MoleculetoMechanisms”.Heoutlinedvariouswaystothinkofmolecularactivitystartingfromtheparadigmaticexampleofinfluenzavirushemagglutinin(HA),whosebindsreceptorcandefeatourimmuneresponse.

Thisstartedthediscussionabouttheincrediblenumberofinteractionshappeningfrommoleculartocellmechanismlevel,andviceversa.Thefirstsymposiumsession,entitled“MechanismsRegulatingEpigeneticRegulation”,openedupthedoortoinvestigatethisintriguingcellularcomplexity.DaneshMoazedandStephenBuratowskitalkedabouttwofundamentalingredientsof

Page 2: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

cellregulation,chromatineandnoncodingRNA.DiegoPasiniexposedtheactivitiesofpolycombgroupproteinsinproliferationanddevelopmentalcontrol,whileGiuseppeTestabroadenedthefieldbyexplaininghowcellreprogrammingrevolutionizedbiologyoverthelastyears.

Thesecondsession,“MechanisticInsightsfromSingleMoleculeAnalysis”,tooktheaudiencebacktothemolecularlevel.SamaraReck-PetersonandAndreasLeschzinertalkedaboutafundamentalaspectforcells’survival,themechanicsbehindmolecularmotors.JosephLoparogaveastimulatingtalkaboutDNA“intelligence”,showinghowourgenesstrivetoovercomeobstacles.SherefMansychallengedtheaudiencewithaverynovelfrontierofbiotechnology,theintegrationbetweenartificialandnaturalcells.

Anotherimportantaspectisthecommunicationamongstdifferentcells,andthiswasthetopicofthethirdsession,“MechanismsRegulatingTrafficking”.RobertoSitiaexplainedhowthequalitycontrolworkswithinthesignaturepathway.TomasKirchhausenshowedtheexceptionalpotentialitiesofthemodern3Dmicroscopytostudyendocytosis.DanielaCordaandAlbertoLuinigavetwointerestingtalksaboutmembranetraffickingandtransportapparatus.

Withthebackdropoftherelevanceofthisresearchtomedicalapplications,thefourthsessionfocusedon“DegradationMechanisms”.SimonaPolotalkedaboutcellmigrationundernormalandpathologicalconditions.AlfredGoldbergpresentedthesysteminvolvedinproteindegradationbyproteasomes.AndreaMusacchioshowedhislatestresultsonthereconstructionofmitoticsignaling,whileFrancescoCecconidiscussedtheimplicationofoneofthemostincrediblebehaviorofourcells,autophagy.

Thisledtothefifthandlastsession,“TransductionMechanisms”,openedbyGianniCesareni’stalkaboutthesignalingmechanismsunderlyingtheanti-tumoractivityofmetformin.StephenBlacklowandMichaelEckrespectivelypresentedthesignalingintheNotchcellandthecontroloftheepidermalgrowthreceptor.PierPaolodiFioreclosedthesessiondiscussingtheconnectionsbetweencellfatedeterminationandtumorsuppressioninmammarystemcells.

Thetaskofclosingthe15thArmenise-HarvardSymposiumfelltoTomasKirchhausen,whowrappedupthegeneraltake-homemessageofthemeeting:thatweareconstantlydealingwithanumberofcomplexinteractions,fromcellularmechanismstomolecularcommunication.Unfoldingthemysteriesoftheseinteractionsisthemainchallengeofcellbiology,fascinatingandever-growingfieldexploringthefundamentalunitsoflife.

Page 3: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Moleculetomechanisms—acasehistory

StephenHarrison

DepartmentofBiologicalChemistry&MolecularPharmacology,HarvardMedicalSchool,Boston,USA

Thetitleofthesymposiumwasreversedbythekeynotespeech:frommolecule–intentionallysingular–tomechanisms.Withthistalk,StephenHarrison“setthetoneforallthefollowingpresentations”,aswouldhavelaterobservedTomasKirchhausenduringthemeetingclosingremarks.

Harrisonisoneoftheworld’sleadingexpertsonviruses.JeffreyFlier,PresidentoftheArmenise-HarvardFoundationandDeanofHarvardMedicalSchool,brieflyintroducedHarrison’soutstandingscientificactivity:“Hehasmadeimportantcontributionstostructuralbiology,mostnotablybydeterminingandanalyzingstructuresofvirusesandviralproteins,andbycrystallographicanalysisofprotein-DNAcomplexes,aswellasstructuralstudiesofprotein-kinaseswitchingmechanisms.Hisworkhasbeenwidelyrecognized,andhehasmadepioneeringresearchestoaddressarangeoffundamentalproblems”.

Oneoftheseproblemsconcernstheinfluenzavirushemagglutinin(HA).TheHarrisonlabatHarvardMedicalSchoolstudieshowinfluenzaviruspenetratescellsbyfusionofviralandendosomalmembranescatalyzedbytheviralhemagglutinin.

SoHarrisonusedthisvirusasthecasehistoryofhispresentation–averyeffectivewaytodevelopthethemeofthemeetingattheoutset.

“Thehemagglutininisatrimericstructurewiththreefunctions”heexplained.“Itbindsthevirustoitsreceptor,catalyzesthemembranefusionprocess,andhasstructuresontheoutsidethatcanvarywithoutcompromisingitstwootheressentialfunctions”.

Inthiswaytheviruscanevolvetoescapeneutralizationbytheimmunesystemofitshost.

Intheinfluenza,theproteinhemagglutininsticksoffofthevirussurfacealongwithanotherprotein,whichisanenzyme,calledtheneuraminidase(NA).

Harrisonfocusedontwoparticularmechanisms:HA-mediatedfusionandHAantigenicity.

Membranefusionisthermodynamicallyfavorable,butitgenerallypresentsahighkineticbarrier.Fusionproteinslowerthisbarrier,sotheyarecatalystsforthemergeroftwobilayers;inthecaseofviralfusionproteins,theybecome“suicide”catalysts.Afterseveralexperimentssetuptomeasurefusionkinetics,Harrisonandcolleaguesshowedthatforinfluenzavirusfusionrequiresengagementwiththetargetbilayeroffusionpeptidesfrom3or4neighboringHAtrimmers.

“Thecasehistorylessonissummarizedhere”saidHarrison,“Thatthereisacontactpatchbetweenthevirusandthetargetmembrane.”

Thisintermediateisafundamentalaspectofthefusionmechanism.ButhowdoesHAantigenicityreacttothismechanism?

Antigenicityisthecapacitytostimulatetheproductionofantibodies.Duringtheimmuneresponse,theprocessbywhichBcellsproduceantibodieswithincreasedaffinityforantigeniscalledaffinitymaturation.

Page 4: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

“Antibodystructures,fromB-celllineagesinhumanresponsestoinfluenzavirusvaccines,mapevolutionofproteininteractionsduringantibodyaffinitymaturation”explainedHarrison.

Thefuturechallenge,heconcluded,isthereforetounderstandtheaffinitymaturationmechanismswellenoughtodesignmodifiedimmunogensthatmightselectivelyelicitbroadimmuneresponses.

Frommoleculetomechanisms,then:theinspiringexampleofinfluenzahemagglutiningotstraighttotheheartofthesymposiumtheme.Showingfirstofallhowbiologycantravelbetweenthemicroandthemacrolevelofourcells.

Geneon,geneoff.Ineukaryoticcells,DNAactivationisoftenamatterofswitches.Butwhatarethebiologicaltriggerscapableofunchaininggeneexpression?ThisisoneofthecorequestionsaddressedbyDaneshMoazedatHarvardMedicalSchool.

HislaboratoryfocusesonunderstandingthemechanismsthatmediatetheformationofoneofthemosttightlypackedformsofDNA:heterochromatin,whichplaysacrucialroleingenesilencing.Forthisreason,thestudyofheterochromatin–alsocalledsilentchromatin–helpsunderstandingthemechanismsthatkeepgenesintheirrightonoroffstate.

Theformationofthesesilentdomainsisalsoresponsiblefortheso-calledepigeneticmemory,whichmaintainscellidentityduringdevelopmentanddifferentiation.

Biologistsknowthateverysinglecellofourorganismonlyturnsonthesubsetofgenesnecessarytocarryoutparticularfunctions.Thisisthereasonwhy,forexample,thegenesofnerveimpulsetransmissionremainshutoffinlivercells:theyarejustnotusefulinlivercellsandcaninterferewithliverfunction.

Moazedandcolleaguesaimatunderstandinghowcellssilenceunnecessarygenestomaintaintheirspecificidentities.

Theyapplyacombinationofapproaches:frombiochemistrytocellbiology,fromproteomicstogenomics,withthecommongoalofidentifyingthefactorsabletomediateheterochromatinassemblyandfunction.

Analyzingsilentdomainsinyeast–single-celledfungithatreproducebyfission–researchersidentifiedaspecialingredientplayingacentralrolesintheformationofrepressiveheterochromatin:noncodingRNAs.

“NowadaystherearealotofideasaboutwhatsmallRNAsarecapableofdoing,andsomemechanismsareclearerthanothers”Moazedexplained.“ThewaytheseRNAsaregeneratedisafundamentalquestion,becausetheyspecifythepartsofthegenomethatshouldbesilenced”.

Inparticular,histeamshowedthatsmallRNAmolecules(overall,about20nucleotides)workthroughtheRNAinterference(RNAi)toregulategenesilencingandexpression.Developingmanybiochemicalexperimentsinfissionyeast,theypurifiedtheRNA-InducedTranscriptionalSilencing(RITS)complex,whichdirectlylinkstheRNAipathwaytoheterochromatinassembly.

Moazed’slabfocusedontwocriticalprocessesformaintenanceofheterochromatin,histonemethylationandsiRNAamplification.Thesetwoprocesseswereshowntobemutuallydependent

Page 5: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

andtoformself-reinforcingpositivefeedbackloopsofcrucialimportanceformaintenanceofsilentdomains.

SuchnoncodingRNA-basedmechanismsmaybeinvolvedinregulatingheterochromatinformationandgeneexpressioninotherorganisms.Andthisisexactlywhatstudiesinotherlaboratoriesarebeginningtoreveal.

“Futureapplications?UsingsmallRNAstosilencegenesandreprogramtheepigenome”hesaid.“Itmaybepossibletoturn-offgenesatthetranscriptionallevel,althoughmanytechnicalchallengeshavetobeovercomebeforethiscanbedoneinsystemsoutsidesimplermodelorganismslikeyeast”.

Thenextstep,then,istheinvestigationofotherbiologicalpathwaysthatplaymajorrolesinregulatingheterochromatin:inordertounderstandbetterandbetterthecomplex,fascinatingswitchesofDNA.

Page 6: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Shapingtheeukaryotictranscriptomewithchromatinandnon-codingRNA

StephenBuratowski

DepartmentofBiologicalChemistryandMolecularPharmacology,HarvardMedicalSchool,Boston,USA

Thehugedictionarybuildingupourgenomehasaverycomplexpunctuation.DNAsequencesarejustsmallstringsofletters,butunderstandingtheirrulesisabigchallenge.

AtHarvardMedicalSchool,theBuratowskiLabstudiesthemarksofgeneexpressions:inparticular,theenzymesthat“write”thesemarks,aswellastheproteinsthat“read”them.

Usingyeastasamodelsystem,researchersanalyzethemechanismofgeneexpressionineukaryotes,workingonRNApolymeraseIItranscriptioninitiationandthesubsequentprocessingofthemRNA.Severaldozenproteinsarerequiredsimplytoinitiatetranscription,andmanymoretakeactionsinotherprocesseslinkedtotranscription.Forthisreason,understandingtranscriptionmeansdecipheringthefunctionsofeverysinglefactor.

Duringthe15thArmenise-HarvardSymposiumStephenBuratowski,headofthelaboratory,presentedhisapproachtounfoldthemysteriesoftranscription’spunctuation.Hisresearchteamfocusesonthecommunicationbetweenchromatinandthetranscriptionmachinery.

Theyshowedthattheactoftranscriptioncausesmajorchangesinthenucleosomesthatpackagethegene.UsingtheyeastSaccharomycescerevisiae,theydiscoveredthatSet1(atypeofhistonemethyltransferases,orHMT)proteinlevelsarecarefullycalibratedtotheamountoftranscriptionoccurringinthecell.Set1issubjecttodegradationbytheubiquitin-proteasomesystemunlessitisstabilizedbyongoingtranscriptionandhistonemethylation.Disruptionofthisfeedbackloopcausesaberrantmethylationpatternsandgenemisregulation.

Thismechanismmayhaveclinicalrelevance,asmanyleukemiaandlymphomascontaintranslocationsinthemammalianMLL1gene,anHMTrelatedtoSet1.

Carryingoutgenome-wideexpressionscreenstoanalyzeachromatin“reader”calledSet3,Buratowskiandcolleaguesfoundthatthemajorityofgeneswhoseexpressionlevelschangedwererepressedbythisfactor.Butwhatwasmoreunexpected,theydemonstratedthattheseeffectsstronglycorrelatewithoverlappingnon-codingtranscription.Thisdoesnotmeanthatnon-codingRNAsthemselvesmediatethegeneexpressionchanges;instead,thelatterdependonhistonemethylationsplacedovergenepromotersbyoverlappingtranscription.

Andthisisexactlywhereclinicalmedicinecouldfindnewapplications:“Ithinkitiscertainlyworththinkingabouthowchangesintranscriptioncanaffectdiseaseslikecancer”Buratowskiconcluded.“Thisisbecausemanydiseasesarecausedbyproblemsineitherwritingorreadingthemarksofgeneexpressions”.

Page 7: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

ActivitiesofPolycombGroupProteinsinProliferationandDevelopmentalControl

DiegoPasini

DepartmentofExperimentalOncology,EuropeanInstituteofOncology,Milan,Italy

Manyhumandiseasesarecausedbythelossofcellularidentity.Canceristheclearestexample:inalltumors,cellsacquirefeaturesthatleadtoabnormalgrowthanddifferentiationdefects.

Buthowhappensthatcellsstartlosingtheiridentity?Andwhatarethemechanismsregulatingcellfateduringdevelopmentanddifferentiation?

DiegoPasini’scurrentresearchattheEuropeanInstituteofOncologyrevolvesaroundthesequestions.Heaimstounderstandhowdiseaseslikecancercanform,maintainanddevelop.

DuringtheArmenise-HarvardSymposium,PasiniexplainedthathislabisinterestedinstudyingthesemechanismsbyfocusingonPolycombGroup(PcG)proteins.

PcGareafamilyofproteinsresponsibleforcellulardifferentiationduringdevelopmentviatranscriptionalrepression.

“PolycombGroupproteinsaremasterregulatorsofcelldevelopment”saidPasini.“Theyarealsoessentialforcellularproliferation,andplayanactiveroleincancerformation”.

ThefirsttodescribethepolycombgroupwasgeneticistEdwardB.Lewis,whoin1978observedinDrosophilathatPcGwasinvolvedinthesilencingofHoxgeneexpression.

Sincethen,theseproteinshavebeenthesubjectofintensestudyasitisclearthattheyarevitalformaintenanceofcell-typeidentityanddifferentiation.

“Atthebiochemicallevel,mostPcGproteinsformtwomajorpolycombrepressivecomplexes:PRC1andPRC2”explainedPasini.

PRC1andPRC2represstranscriptionrespectivelybyUbiquitylatingHistoneH2Alysine(K)119andbytri-methylating(me3)HistoneH3K27.DeregulationofbothPRC1andPRC2activitiesisacommonfeatureofhumantumors.

TostudytheroleofPcGproteinsinregulatingnormalandcancercellsproliferation,Pasiniandcolleaguescombinecellcultureandinvivostudies.TheirexperimentsdemonstratedthatPRCsindependentlyregulatecellularproliferationandtransformation.

SotheabilityofPRC1andPRC2topromoteproliferationisamainfeaturethatlinksPolycombGroupproteinsactivitytocancer.

Forthisreason,PcGinhibitionhasbeenproposedasastrategyfortumortreatment.

Page 8: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

JoiningtheZoo:Cellreprogrammingandtheriseofhumandiseasemodels

GiuseppeTesta

DepartmentofExperimentalOncology,EuropeanInstituteofOncology,Milan,Italy

Haveyoueverthoughtofyourbodyasarovinglaboratory?Intheverylatestyears,thisisexactlywhathashappened.Atruerevolutionoccurredincellularbiology:itiscalled“cellreprogramming”,anditallowsscientiststodirectlystudydiseasesinhumantissues.

Cellreprogrammingdependsontheseminalderivationofhumaninducedpluripotentstemcells(iPSC)fromsomaticcells.Bornin2007,thistechniquehasalreadydeeplychangedtheprospectsnotonlyofregenerativemedicinebutalso,andlikelyinanevenshortertimeframe,ofourcapacitytodissectthegeneticcontributiontohumandiseases.

AttheEuropeanInstituteofOncology,GiuseppeTestaisworkingonthiscutting-edgelineofresearch.Hislaboratoryfocusesontheepigeneticsofgenomeprogrammingandreprogramming,inparticularthemechanismsenablinglineagecommitmentandtheiraberrationsincancerandneurologicaldiseases.

DuringtheArmenise-HarvardSymposium,Testagaveabrilliantoverviewofwhathecalledthe“zoojoining”:withpluripotentstemcellsonboard,themenagerieofavailabletissuesamplesbecamepotentiallyinfinite.

Thiswasunimaginableuntilthebeginningofourcentury,whenmodelorganismswerethemainresourcetointerrogatehumandiseasepathogenesis.Obtainingprimarysamplesdirectlyfrompatientswasverydifficult;andwhenithappened,mostofthetimeitwastoolate,postmortemoratnotsomeaningfulstagesofdiseasehistory.

Testaexplainedhowcellreprogrammingallowed,forthefirsttimeinthehistoryofmedicine,tomakehumangeneticvariationexperimentallytractablethroughthecreationofgeneticallymatchedcelllineages.Ontheselineagesitisnowpossibletodecipherandtargetdiseasepathogenesis,biologicalstand-insor“avatars”ofourselves.

Sowearethenewmodelstoworkon:thismeansthatone’sdiseaseisdirectlystudiedinvitroonone’sDNA,andpersonalizedtreatmentsaremorelikelytobedeveloped.

TheTestaLabharnessesthispotentialtodevelopphysiopathologicallymeaningfulmodelsofbothcancerandneurodevelopmentaldisorders.

Incancer,researchersaimatthedissectionofthegenomicversusepigenomiccomponents:sincetumorshavethemboth,cellreprogrammingallowstoseewhichcomponentispredominantineveryphaseofthedisease.

Withinneurodevelopmentaldisorders,theyfocusonauniquerangeofintellectualdisabilitysyndromes(includingautismspectrumdisorders)causedbymutationsordosagealterationsinepigeneticregulatorsandtranscriptionfactors.AfterreprogrammingandanalyzingiPSCandtheirdifferentiatedderivativeswiththesemutations,itisalsopossibletoscreendrugsonthemataverylargescale.

Page 9: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Theseexperimentalsettings,togetherwiththeirimportantclinicalapplications,areagreatexampleofhowcellularphenomenahavebecomeaninterfacebetweenmolecularbiologyandmedicine.

TestaquotedwhatbiologistHaroldKincaidcalledthe“placeholders”,processesforwhichwehavegoodevidence,butwhosenatureisunknown.Nowcellreprogrammingisprobablybringingthis“unknown”tolight.

Page 10: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

SpatialRegulationofMolecularMotors

SamaraReck-Peterson

DepartmentofCellBiology,HarvardMedicalSchool,Boston,USA

Thecellsthatmakeupourbodyareconstantlybusy:theymove,divide,andcommunicatewithneighboringcells.Atthesametime,theyneedtomaintainhomeostasis,sothattheinternalcellularconditionsremainstableandrelativelyconstant.Molecularmotors,whichtransportcellularcargos,areresponsibleforallofthesefunctions.Transportoccursalongtwotypesoftracks,calledactinfilamentsandmicrotubules.

Alleukaryoticcellsusemotorsfortransportalongactinfilamentsandmicrotubules,anddamagetothesetransportmechanismscanleadtoseriousdiseases.Forexample,neurodegenerativeandneurodevelopmentaldiseasesareknowntoresultfromdefectsinmicrotubule-basedtransport.

Forthisreason,explaininghowmicrotubule-basedintracellulartransportworkscouldrepresentasignificantbreakthroughinclinicalmedicine.

TheReck-PetersonLabatHarvardMedicalSchoolismovinginthisdirection.“Wewanttounderstandhowthemotorsofthecellwork”explainedSamaraReck-Peterson,headofthelaboratory.“Inparticular,wearefocusingonthedyneinmotor”.

Cytoplasmicdyneinisthemainmotorproteindrivingmicrotubule-basedintercellulartransport,togetherwithanotherfamilyofmotorscalledkinesins.Dyneinmotorsmoveonlytowardstheminus-endsofmicrotubules(towardsthecellcenter),whilekinesinmotormovetowardstheplus-endsofmicrotubules(towardsthecellperiphery).

“Wehaveover40kinesingenesthathostdiversefunctions,butdyneinisalittlebitdifferent”explainedReck-Peterson.“Wehave15differentdyneinsinthehumangenomeand14oftheseareonlyfoundincellsthathaveciliaorflagella.Theremainingcytoplasmicdyneinmotorhashundredsofcargos,manyofwhicharestilltobeidentified;weknowthatduringinterphasedyneinhasmanyfunctionsincludingthetransportofmRNAs,RNPs,proteins,andorganelles.Virusesareanotherimportantcargo,theycanhijackdyneintogettothecenterofthecell”.

Tounderstandthemolecularmechanismsunderlyingthesefunctionsofdynein,theReck-PetersonLabusesahighlyinterdisciplinaryapproach,fromcelltosystemsbiology,frombiophysicstosyntheticbiology.

Therearefourgenesimplicatedinlocalizingdyneintotheplus-endofmicrotubule.Intheirexperiments,theypurifiedthesefourproteinsandreconstitutedinvitrothetransportofdyneintotheplus-endofthemicrotubule.

Theyfoundthattwoproteins–homologsofLis1andClip170–aresufficienttocoupledyneintoKip2,aplus-end-directedkinesin.Kip2transportsdyneintothemicrotubuleplusend,butnotasapassivepassenger:dyneinresistsitsownplus-end-directedmotionthoughitsmicrotubule-bindingdomain.

Twoothersmicrotubule-associatedproteins,homologsofClip170andEB1,actasprocessivityfactorsforKip2,helpingitovercomedynein’sintrinsicminus-end-directedmotility.

Page 11: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Thus,therearefourmainplayersinvolvedindyneinspatialregulation:twoproteinsthatarerequiredtocouplethedyneintokinesin,andthentwomoreproteinsthatmakethekinesinabettermotor.Thisrevealshowaminimalsystemofproteinstransportsamolecularmotortothestartofitstrack.

“Ourmaingoalnowistounderstandhowthismotorworksandisregulated,”saidReck-Peterson.“Andifweunderstandthat,weareastepclosertodiscoveringwhythemutationsinthetransportmachinerycausediseases”.

Page 12: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Mechanismsandregulationofcytoplasmicdynein

AndresLeschziner

Dept.ofMolecularandCellularBiology,HarvardUniversity,Boston,USA

Stepafterstep,walkingtakesprettyadvancedcoordinationabilities.Legs,muscles,nerves,brain:everysingleingredientfindsitsrole,buildingupthecomplexandharmoniousactionofmoving.

Atmicroscopiclevel,almostthesamethinghappensinyourcells,asexplainedAndresLeschzinerduringtheArmenise-HarvardSymposium.“Molecularmotorsaretheproteinmachinesthat‘walk’alongcytoskeletaltracks”hesaid.“Inparticular,cytoplasmicdyneinisresponsiblefortransportingmostcellularcargofromtheperipherytowardsthecellinterior.Itscomplexmotoractivityisessentialformanyfunctionsineukaryotes,suchaschromosomesegregationandintracellulartransport”.

Togetherwithkinesinsandmyosins,dyneinsmakeupthethreefamiliesofmolecularmotors.However,dyneinsarethelargestandmostcomplexgroup,andmanyoftheirregulatingmechanismsarestillunknown.

OneofthebiggestunsolvedquestionsconcernsLis1,aconserveddyneinregulator.Lis1isknowntokeepdyneinboundtomicrotubules,butitisnotunderstoodhowitaccomplishesthisaction.

AtHarvardMedicalSchool,theLeschzinerLabteamedupwiththeReck-PetersonLabtounfoldthemysteriesofdyneinusing3Delectronmicroscopy,single-moleculeimaging,biochemistryandinvivoassays.

Leschzinerandcolleagueswereparticularlyinterestedinunderstandinghowdyneinmovesalongmicrotubules,componentsofthecytoskeletonfoundthroughoutthecytoplasm.

A3Dstructureofthedynein-Lis1complexwasobtained.ThismodelrevealedthatbindingofLis1todynein’sAAA+ring(whichbelongstoasuperfamilyofring-shapedproteins)physicallyblocksdynein’smainmechanicalelement,the“linker”,frommakingcriticalinteractionswiththering.

“Lis1isaubiquitousdyneinco-factor,actingasaclutchtouncoupledynein’scyclesofATPhydrolysisandmicrotubulebindingandrelease”explainedLeschziner.

Sotherearetwodifferentcyclesinvolved:thefirst(acycleofforce-generatingATPhydrolysis)occursinthering-shapedAAA+motordomain;thesecond(acycleofmicrotubulebindingandrelease)occursinthemicrotubulebindingdomain,locatedattheendofdynein’slong“leg”.

Thesetwocyclesoccur25nmawayfromeachother,yettheirfunctioncriticallydependsontheircoordination.

Regulationofdyneinisthereforeoneofthecrucialaspectsforthecomplex,articulatedworldofmovementoccurringatthecellularlevel.AndapparentlyahugeresponsibilityfallsonLis1,playingacentralroleinregulatingdynein’smovements.

Page 13: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Overcomingobstacles:Single-moleculestudiesofDNArepair

JosephJ.Loparo

DepartmentofBiologicalChemistryandMolecularPharmacology;HarvardMedicalSchool

WecanthinkofDNAastheinstructionmanualpackedinsideourcells.IfourDNAbecomesdamaged,thenourcellsmaygetthewronginstructions,whichcanleadtodiseases.Forthisreason,whenaDNAlesionoccurs,ourcellsimmediatelyactivatetheirDNArepairmechanismstofixtheproblem.

Buttherearesomelesionsthattherepairmachineryfailstofind.InthiscasetheproteinmachinerythatcopiesourDNAcancollidewiththesedamagedDNAbases,stoppingtheDNAreplicationmachineryinitstracks.Itisthenthatourcellshaveatoughdecisiontomake:donothingandperhapsdieorutilizeanerrorproneDNAcopyingenzymethatcansynthesizethroughthedamagebutcouldintroducediseasecausingmutationsintoourDNA.

“ThisishowcellsovercomeDNAobstacles:sometimes,itisbetterforthemtotaketherisk”saidJosephLoparo,headofalaboratoryatHarvardMedicalSchoolworkingonDNAdamagetoleranceandrepair.

Gamblingasageneticstrategy,inotherwords.Loparoandcolleaguesareworkingtounravelhowbacterialcellschoosetousetheseerrorproneenzymes:“Mostbacteriahaveasinglecircularchromosomewhichtheycopywithamulti-proteinmachineknownasthereplisome,theirreplicationmachinery”heexplained.“ThereplisomeiscomposedoftworeplicativepolymerasecomplexeswhichquicklyandaccuratelycopyeachparentalstrandofDNA”.

IfDNAbecomesdamagedandtheDNArepairmachineryisunabletocorrectthelesion,thiscanbeablocktothereplisome.

“TranslesionpolymerasesarespecializedDNApolymerasescapableofsynthesizingovercertainDNAlesionsthatstallthereplicativeDNApolymerase”saidLoparo.“Mylabisinterestedinunderstandingthemechanismsofthisprocess,andhowtranslesionpolymerasesarerecruitedtothereplicationmachinery”.

Byreconstitutingtranslesionsynthesis(TLS)andobservingitoccuronsingleDNAmoleculesinrealtime,theLoparoLabshowedthattheEscherichiacolibclamp,aring-shapedmoleculethatencirclesDNAandtetherspolymerasestotheirsubstrates,cansimultaneouslybindtwokindsofpolymerases,thereplicativepolymerasePolIIIandtheerror-pronetranslesionpolymerase,PolIV.ThisenablesanexchangeofthetwopolymerasesandarapidbypassofaDNAlesionwhichisinmanywaysanalogoustohowonemaintainsasparetireinthetrunkoftheircar.

Furthermore,theyfoundthatadditionalbindingsitesbetweenPolIVandbacttolimitPolIVdependentDNAsynthesisundernormalconditions,yetfacilitatesthedisplacementofPolIIIfromtheDNAuponthedetectionofDNAdamage.

Theseresultssupportanewmodelinwhichinteractionsbetweenpolymerasesandthebclampacttobothinactivateandactivateerror-pronepolymerases.Withinthisregulatorynetwork,itislikethecellissaying:“Icantellthatthereplicationmachineryisintrouble.Itisworthutilizinganerrorpronepolymeraseasitismyonlyhopeforsurvival”.

Page 14: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Thismechanismisalsoveryinterestingfromahumanhealthperspective,becausemanyofthebasicmechanismsofthispolymeraseregulationlikelyoccurinhumancells.Understandinghowgeneticmutationsarisewillleadtoabetterunderstandingofdiseaseslikecancer.

“Thenextstepsforusaretolookattheseprocessesinlivebacteriacells,wherewehaveallthephysiologicalcomplexity”concludedLoparo.“Additionally,wearereconstitutingthereplicationmachineryinitsentiretyinatesttube”.

Thiscouldansweronceandforalltheodd,yetimportantquestion:howproneareourcellstowardsgeneticgambling?

Page 15: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Integratingartificialwithnaturalcells

SherefMansy

UniversityofTrento,ViadelleRegole,101,Mattarello(TN)Italy

Crossingtheboundarybetweenlivingandnon-living,bringingartificialsystemstolife.Sciencefiction?Probablynot.AttheCentreforIntegrativeBiology(CIBIO)oftheUniversityofTrento,biochemistSherefMansyhastakenastepforwardtowardsmakinganartificialcell“breath”.Thiswouldbeatruerevolutionfortraditionalcellularbiology,whichcouldeventuallyleadtochangethedefinitionitselfoflife.

“Achickisalivingorganism,astoneisnot.Everybodycanclearlyseethedifference.Butisthereanythinginthemiddle?”askedMansyattheArmenise-Harvardsymposiumaudience.Hethenpresentedthelatestresultsofhisresearch,showinganewwaytoaddressthechallengeofartificiallife.

Thecontrolofcellularbehaviorlargelyreliesongeneticengineering,butartificialcellscouldbedesignedtobetterregulatecellprocessesthroughchemicalcommunication.WithhisteamatCIBIO,MansydevelopedanartificialcellwhichisabletotranslateachemicalmessageintoasignalthatcanbesensedbyEscherichiacoli.Thiscouldactivateacellularresponseotherwiseimpossibletobedetected.

Withinthissystem,theartificialcellsworkaschemicaltranslators,sensingmoleculesthatE.colialonecannotsense.Asaconsequence,theartificialcellsreleaseamoleculefamiliartoE.coli,therebytranslatinganunrecognizedchemicalmessageintoawell-knownone.

Thisallowsa“dialogue”betweentheartificialandthenaturalcells,expandingthesensorycapabilitiesofE.coliwithoutalteringthegeneticcontentofthebacterium.

Mansy’sartificialcellhasacomplexstructure,bothfromengineeringandbiologicalpointofviews.Itisbuiltwithaphospholipidvesiclecontainingisopropylb-D-1-thiogalactopyranoside(IPTG),DNA,andtranscription-translationmachinery.TheDNAtemplatecodesforapreviouslyselectedriboswitch,activatingtranslationinresponsetothepresenceoftheophylline.Thetheophyllineriboswitchcontrolsthesynthesisoftheporeformingproteina-hemolysin(aHL).

colialonedoesnotrespondtotheophylline,andIPTGdoesnotcrossthevesiclemembraneoftheartificialcellintheabsenceofthepore.Andhere’sexactlywheretheartificialcellscometoaction:theyallowE.colitoreceivethechemicalmessage,thusbecomingIPTG-responsive.

“Bacteriadonaturallycommunicatetoeachother”saidMansy.“Ourgoalwastoseeifasinglebacteriumcouldstillcommunicateincaseoneofthecellsisartificial.Apparently,theanswerisyes.”

Theseresults,publishedinNatureCommunications,areapromisingbasisforpossiblemedicalapplications.“Ourartificialcellsdegradeinacoupleofhours:therearenolong-termconsequences.Thisimpliesthattheycouldbeusedinbiologicalsystems–forexample,toidentifypollutants–withoutgeneticintervention”explainedMansy.Sofarthisisthefirstartificial,cell-likesystemcapableofcreatingacommunicationpathwaybetweenartificialandlivingcells.Thenextstepwillbebroadeningthisapproach,makingartificialcellsableto“talk”withcomplexbiologicalsystems.

Page 16: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

“Ifwehadartificialcellsthatcandetectallthesignalsofthelivingcells,theycouldalsorecognizethesignalsexpressedbyproblemcells,likecancer”concludedtheresearcher.

Thedefinitionof“livingcell”isthusbecomingmoreandmorefoggy:butthiscouldnotbeaproblem,asfaraswechangethequestionstobeaddressed.JustasAlanTuringdidabout60yearsago,whenhegavebirthtothefieldofArtificialIntelligence.

Page 17: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Biogenesisandqualitycontrolofoligomericproteinsintheearlysecretorypathway

RobertoSitia

UniversitàVita-SaluteSanRaffaele,DivisionofGeneticsandCellBiology,SanRaffaeleScientificInstitute,Milan,Italy

Prestoebeneraroavviene.ThistypicalItalianproverb,meaningthatitisdifficulttoworkfastandwellatthesametime,isbroadlydisregardedbyourcells.

AsRobertoSitiaexplainedduringtheArmenise-HarvardSymposium,manybiologicalprocessessuchasproteinsecretionmusthavehighfidelityandefficiency.

AtSanRaffaeleScientificInstitute,Sitiaaddressesafundamentalquestionincellbiology:howarethesizeandactivityofthedifferentcompartmentsconstantlycoordinated?

Inmulticellularorganisms,cellsmustpromptlyrespondtomultiplestimuli.Totaketherightdecision,theyneedtocontinuouslyexchangeinformationamongsteachotherandwiththeexternalworld,andtounambiguouslyintegratethecorrespondingsignals.

Thistaskbecomesparticularlydemandingduringdifferentiationorinresponsestoenvironmentalchanges.Sitiaandcolleaguesinvestigatedthemolecularmechanismsthatallowcellstointegratesignalling,proteinqualitycontrolandsortingintheearlysecretorycompartment.

“Theearlysecretorypathwayisemergingasakeyhub,performingmanydifficulttasksatthesametime”saidSitia.“Itensuresefficienthigh-qualityreleasebytheproteinfactory”.

Theendoplasmicreticulum(ER)isamultifunctionalcompartmentfoundinalleukaryoticcells.“FromtheER,secretoryproteinsbegintheirjourneytowardstheirfinaldestinations,theorganellesoftheexocyticandendocyticcompartments,theplasmamembraneortheextracellularspace”Sitiaexplained.HisresearchteamdiscoveredthatERp44,amultitaskproteinattheER-Golgiinterface,isamasterregulatorinthishub.

Fidelityofprotein-basedintracellularcommunicationisguaranteedbyqualitycontrol(QC)mechanismslocatedattheER–Golgiinterface,whichrestrictforwardtransporttonativeproteins.

AndhereiswhereERp44comestoaction:Sitiafoundthatitisakeyregulatorofproteinsecretion,Ca2+signallingandredoxregulation.

“IfthesignalsconveyedbytheERp44-centeredmolecularhubarenotworking,cellssuffer;butiftheyaretoomuch,thecell’sfunctionarealsocompromised”hesaid.

WearebeginningtounderstandwhatmakesERp44capableofsatisfyingitsmultipletasks,allowingtheproteinfactorytoperformprestoebene.

Page 18: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Imagingendocytosiswithhighspatiotemporalresolution

TomasKirchhausen

DepartmentofCellBiology,HarvardMedicalSchool,Boston,USA

“Seeingisbelieving.Biologyisbasedonobservation.ButwhatIwanttodoisalsomeasuring:thisquantificationcanbesize,canbelength,canbevolume,canbenumberofmolecules,canbewherearethemoleculesinagivenmoment”.

BiologistTomasKirchhausenknowswhathe’stalkingabout.HislaboratoryatHarvardMedicalSchoolisoneofthefewintheworldtocombinestandardand3Dmicroscopycapableofgivingrapid,high-precisionthree-dimensionalimagingoflivingcells.

Thiscutting-edgetechnologyisputattheserviceofunderstandingthemovementofmembraneproteinsthroughoutcells.Thesemechanismsareofkeyimportanceforthecell’ssortingmachineries,andcanbehijackedbytoxins,virusesandbacterialpathogens.

Studyinghowcellscanbeattacked,KirchhausenLabaimsatfindingtreatmentfordiseasesdependingonviralinfectionandpathogeninvasion:fromcancertoLGMD2B/Miyoshimusculardystrophies,fromAlzheimerdiseasetoALS(amyotrophiclateralsclerosis),aswellasotherneurologicaldiseases.

Inpreparationtothesestudies,hisgroupdeterminedthefirststructureatnearatomicresolutionofclathrin,aproteinplayingamajorroleinthecreationofcoatedvesicles.Clathrinhasatriskelionshapecomposedofthreeclathrinheavychainsandthreelightchainsandtheyformthecoatsurroundingthevesicleswhoselatticeoftenappearsastheseemofasoccerball.

Live-cellandsinglefluorescencemicroscopyimagingwereusedto“see”inthreedimensionsthemoleculareventsandtheintracellularcompartmentsresponsiblefortheformationofclathrin-coatedpitsandcoatedvesicles–aconserved“nano-machine”thatgeneratesintracellularvesicularcarriersinallanimalsandplants.

“Inourstudieswehavetwooppositeextremes”explainedKirchhausen.“Thefirstoneistheuseofmethodsgivingacompletepicture,likecrystallographyorNMR;thesecondextremeistheuseoffluorescencemicroscopyvisualizationmethodsgoingtoaverylowresolution,withalotofdynamics”.

“Sotheideaistocombinethesetwoextremestohaveaclearerviewofthemechanismofendocytosis”hesaid.

Endocytosis,theprocessthatcellsusetoingestmolecules(likeLDL–thebadcholesterolandcertainviruses)byengulfingthem,wasobservedwiththemicroscopyvisualizationtechniques.Theyallowedsufficienttemporalandspatialresolutiontofollowthelifeofasingleclathrincoatedpit.

“Theinitiationprocessofendocytosisishighlystochastic”continuedKirchhausen.“Weobservedthattheclathrinadaptors,proteinsthatconnectclathrinwiththemembranesurroundingtheclathrincoatarriveanddepartfromthemembranewithverylowbinding.Whenwehavetheadaptorsintherightplace,thetriskelioncanmapthisinteraction,thatstabilizesthestructureforafewsecondsandformationofthepitensues”.

Page 19: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

ThelevelofdetailreachedbyKirchhausen’sobservationispioneerinquantitativebiology.“Nowthatwehavetherighttechniques,wecancounthowmanymoleculesofacertaintypearerequiredforthedifferentstepsofendocytosis:aquestionthathadremainedunansweredfor30years”commentedEmanueleCocucci,postdocworkinginKirchhausenLab.“Thenextstepswillbeunderstandingthetotalnumberofmoleculesinvolvedinendocytosis,includingallthereceptors.Sowehavetogoevendeeper”.

Inthenearfuture,temporalresolutionandspatialprecisionof3Dmicroscopycouldthenreachhigherdetails.ButasKirchhausenpointedout,itiscrucialnottolosethebiggerpicture.“It’slikethecartraffic”hesaid.“WecanseetheglobaldifferencesbetweenthetrafficofRomeandMilan,orwecancountthedetails,likethecoloursofthecar,thedrivers,thenumberofpassengers,andsoon.Bothtypeofquantificationsareimportant”.

Page 20: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Mono-ADP-ribosylationandmembranetrafficking

DanielaCorda

InstituteofProteinBiochemistry,NationalResearchCouncil,Napoli,Italy

Between20.000and25.000:thisisapproximatelythenumberofgenesinyourgenome.Butifyouthinkthisquantityishigh,youshouldprobablylookatyourproteome.Infactthenumberofproteinsmakingupthehumanproteomeisestimatedatover1million.

Overthelastdecades,scientistshavediscoveredthatsinglegenesencodemultipleproteins,andthismakestheproteomefarmorecomplexthanthegenome.

Butthereisasecretingredientwhichcanfacilitatestudyingthiscomplexity:itistheprocesscalledproteinpost-translationalmodifications(PTMs).Thisisafundamentalstepoccurringafterproteinbiosynthesis,playingakeyroleindeterminingtheregulationandfunctionofproteinsandothercellularmolecules.

Mostoftenmediatedbyenzymaticactivity,post-translationalmodificationscanoccuratanystepduringthe“lifecycle”ofaprotein,sounderstandingtheseprocessesiscrucialtounfoldthecomplexityofproteome.

AttheInstituteofProteinBiochemistryoftheItalianNationalResearchCouncil,DanielaCordaisleadingpioneeringresearchonPTMs.Amongthevariouspost-translationalmodifications,sheisfocusingonmono-ADP-ribosylation(mono-ADPR).Thisreactionhasanimportantphysiologicalroleincellularprocessessuchasmembranetraffic,immuneresponse,DNArepairandsignalling.

Cordawasoneofthefirstscientiststolookatmono-ADP-ribosylationasakeymechanismincellbiology.

“Formanyyearsithasbeenconsideredatoxicreaction”sheexplained.“Buttogetherwithothercolleagues,Ithoughtthatifatoxinmodifiesaprotein,perhapsthismodificationisinterferingwithaphysiologicalmechanism.Ithoughtthatifatoxinmodifiesaprotein,perhapsthismodificationisinterferingwithaphysiologicalmechanism.Thismeansthatisolatedpathologicalmechanisms(withouttheirphysiologicalcounterpart)donotexist”.

Thisintuitionshookuptheunderstandingoftheproteinenzymaticactivity.StudyinghowtoxinsinducetheADP-ribosylationofproteins,Cordaandothercolleaguescouldidentifyspecificcellmechanismsthatwerepreviouslyunknown.

Inparticular,theCordalaboratorystudiedbrefeldinA(BFA),afungaltoxincausingthedisassemblyoftheGolgicomplexmembranes.BFAinducestheADP-ribosylationofBARS,aproteininvolvedinthefissionofmembranesatseveraltrafficstepsofthesecretoryandendocyticpathways.

TheproteinBARSwasdiscovered20yearsagobyDanielaCordateam,andnowturnedouttobeanessentialelementofthemembranefissionmachinery.

SelectivelyanalyzingthebrefeldinAactivity,researchersidentifiedanintermediatethatcovalentlybindsBARS,calledBFA-ADP-riboseconjugate(BAC).

Page 21: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

“BACmodifiesthisproteinonly,itisveryspecific”saidCorda.“SoifwecanmimicBAC,wecaninhibitasingleprotein,BARS.Thisiswhatweareworkingon:synthetizingBACanalogues,andperformingvirtualscreeningstoselectsothersmallmoleculeswithsimilaractivity”.

Theinhibitionbysmallmoleculesofproteinsknowntocauseadiseasemayeventuallyleadtoclinicalapplications,incancerasinotherpathologies.

“Wearetestingthesesmallmoleculesinvitrohopingtosoonfindanapplicationintumorssuchaslymphomaandbreastcancer”Cordaconcluded.

BARS,arelativelynewentryinscientificlabs,isthereforesheddinganewlightonthecellularfunctionscontrol.Andthisproteincouldsoonbecomeapharmacologicaltargetforanticancertherapies.

Page 22: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

ControlsystemsofmembranetransportattheinterfacebetweentheendoplasmicreticulumandtheGolgi.

AlbertoLuini

IstitutodiBiochimicadelleProteine(IBP),CNRNapoli,Italy;TelethonInstituteofGeneticsandMedicine(TIGEM),Napoli,Italy.

Ifyouloseyourbalance,youwillprobablyfall.Yourcellsbehaveprettymuchthesameway:theyhaveaninternalequilibriumthatneedstoremainconstant,otherwisethey“fall”.Thiscellularbalanceiscalledhomeostasis,whichguaranteesthecells’internalstability.

Maintaininghomeostasisdespitethevariationofinternalandexternalconditionsisafundamentaltaskourcellularsystemneedstofulfill.Sounderstandingthistaskcanrevealimportantaspectsofourcellactivity.

AttheItalianNationalResearchCouncil,AlbertoLuiniandhisresearchgroupstudytheprocessofhomeostasisstartingfromthecomplexcellmembranetransportapparatus.

Withinthissystem,variationsinmembranefluxesfromtheendoplasmicreticulum(ER)totheGolgicomplexarebalancedbyoppositefluxesfromtheGolgitotheER,tomaintainhomeostasisbetweenthetwoorganelles.

AsLuiniexplainedtotheArmenise-HarvardSymposiumaudience,heandhisteamdescribedamoleculardevicethatbalancestransportfluxesbyintegratingsignaltransductioncascadeswiththetransportmachinery.

Inparticular,theyfoundthatER-to-GolgitransportactivatestheKDELreceptorattheGolgi.ThistriggersacascadeinvolvingGsandadenylylcyclaseandphosphodiesteraseisoforms,andthenPKAactivation,andresultsinthephosphorylationofproteinsinvolvedinretrogradetraffic.ThisinducesrecyclingtotheERandtendstobalancetransportfluxesbetweenERandGolgi.

Moreover,theKDELreceptoractivatesCREB1andothertranscriptionfactorsthatup-regulatetransport-relatedgenes.InthiswayaGolgi-basedcell-autonomouscontrolsystemmaintainstransporthomeostasisthroughbothsignalingandtranscriptionalnetworks.

Anotherinterestingthingisthatthismodelwasobtainedusingveryadvancedmicroscopyincludinganextremelypowerfultechnique:correlativemicroscopy.ItwasdevelopedforthefirsttimeinLuini’slaboratory,anditisusedtostudyinvivodynamicsandultrastructureofintracellularstructuresatincrediblelevelsofdetail.

Combiningcorrelativelightandelectronmicroscopy,researcherswereabletoseedynamicfunctionalassaysinlivecellsdirectlywithhighresolution3Dmorphology.

Thiswayitbecamepossibletoobservethecontrolsystemsofmembranetransportintegratinginformationondynamics,ultrastructureandmolecularcompositionassemblyofmolecularmachinery.Atthesametime,“seeing”theenginethatallowsourcellstomaintaintheirbalance.

Page 23: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

MyosinVIBridgesUbiquitinSignalingandCellMigration

SimonaPolo

IFOMFondazioneIstitutoFIRCdiOncologiaMolecolare,20139Milan,Italy;DipartimentodiScienzedellaSalute,UniversitàdegliStudidiMilano,Milan,Italy.

Humancellscannotfreelytravelaroundthebody:theirmovementistightlyregulatedandnormallyquitelimited.Butcancercellscanlosethiscontrol,travellinginthebloodstreamthroughthewell-knowprocessofmetastasis.MyosinVIisamotor-proteinableto“travel”alongactinfilamentsandisinvolvedintumorformationandmetastasis.

AttheIFOM–FIRCInstituteofMolecularOncologyofMilan,SimonaPoloandcolleaguesarenowinvestigatingthecontrolsystemofMyosinVIfromanalternativepointofview.ThiswasthefocusofthefascinatingtalkgivenbyDr.PoloduringtheArmenise-HarvardSymposium:MyosinVIplaysanexplicitroleincellmigration,underbothpathologicalandnormalconditions.

DrPoloistheleaderofaresearchgroupinvestigatingthemechanismsofregulationmediatedbyubiquitin.Ubiquitinisaregulatoryproteinthathasbeen“ubiquitously”foundinalmostalltissues;itsaddictiontootherproteinscanaffecttheminmanyways.

“Thebest-knownfunctionofubiquitinisthedegradationviatheproteasome,butabout10yearsagoanovelfunctionofubiquitinationinsignallingwasdiscovered”sheexplained.“Wearestudyingthismechanism,andshowedthatMyosinIVharboursaparticularubiquitinbindingdomain(UBD)differentfromanypreviouslydescribedUBD”.

UBDsareacollectionofmodularproteindomainsthatnon-covalentlybindtoubiquitin;thenewUBDidentifiedbyPolo’steamwasgiventhenameofMyosinVIUbiquitinBinding(MyUb)domain.

Ubiquitincancomeindifferentflavoursandtheyallperformdifferentfunctionsintothecells,mostofwhicharestillunknown.

“Wefoundoutthat,differentlyfromthevastmajorityoftheUBDsthatshownobindingspecificity,MyUbdomainshaveaclearpreferenceforK63dimersimplicatingthatMyosinVIandubiquitininteractionisnotforproteindegradation”saidPolo.

ThesefindingspreparedthegroundtoexplaintheroleofUbandMIU-MyUbdomainsinthephysiologicalandpathologicalregulationofMyosinVI.

“IthasbeenobservedanoverexpressionofMyosinVIintumortissues”saidPolo.“Butwefoundoutthatthisisnotagenericoverexpression:itislimitedtothespecificformabletointeractwithubiquitin.Wearenowdissectingindetailstheunprecedentedroleplayedbyubiquitinincellmigration”.

Page 24: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Newinsightsintoproteasomemechanismsinnormalanddiseasestates

AlfredGoldberg

DeptCellBiology,HarvardMedicalSchool,Boston,USA

“Proteasomeissmarterthanyouthink!”ThisexclamationcrownedtheconclusionofthesharpandbrightpresentationbyAlfredGoldberg,duringthethirddayoftheArmenise-HarvardSymposium.

HislaboratoryatHarvardMedicalSchoolstudieshowproteinsinourbodyareconstantlybeingfabricatedandthenbrokendownintoaminoacids.Proteasomestakeprideofplaceinthisprocess:theyareproteincomplexeswhosemainfunctionistodegradeunneededordamagedproteinsbyproteolysis,achemicalreactionthatbreakspeptidebonds.

ThesmartproteasomeGoldbergreferredtoisthe26Sproteasome,themajorsiteforproteindegradationinmammaliancells.Inrecentyears,inhibitorsofits20Speptidaseactivities(e.g.bortezomib)havegreatlyadvancedthetreatmentofmultiplemyeloma.

Moreover,theprocessingofubiquitin(asmallregulatoryproteinfoundinalmostalltissuesofeukaryoticorganisms)conjugatesby26Sproteasome’s19Sregulatoryparticleinvolvesmanyenzymaticstepsthatmaybetargetsfordrugdevelopment.

Sothestudyof26Sproteasomehasimmediateapplicationalsoinclinicalmedicine,andthisisoneofthereasonswhyAlfredGoldbergtookitasthe“maincharacter”ofhisresearchandhistalk.Herethischaracterbecametheprotagonistoffourshortstories:foursurprisingmechanismscontrollingproteasomefunction.

“Thefirststoryisthattheproteasomeistightlyregulated”heexplained.“Wenowthinkweunderstoodthemechanism,theoveralllinkagebetweentheubiquitinchainandthebreakingdownoftheproteins:theregulationthatoccursinthatprocess”.

InfactGoldberdLabdiscoveredthatwhenmammalian26Sproteasomesareinhibited,theubiquitin-receptorsubunit,Rpn13,becomespolyubiquitinatedbya26S-associatedubiquitinligase.Thismodificationpreventsbindingofubiquitinatedsubstrates,andpresumablyevolvedtopreventbuild-upofconjugateswhenproteasomefunctionisstalled.

Andherewecometothesecondstory.“Thesurpriseisthatproteasometriggersunexpectedresponses”Goldbergtold.“Whentheproteasomeisinhibited,ithasamechanismsaying:‘don’tgivemeanymoreubiquinatedproteins!’It’saveryadvancedself-regulatedmechanism”.

Proteasomeregulationconcernsthethirdstoryaswell:“Wefoundthatwhentheproteasomeispartiallyinhibited,evenjustalittlebit,thesignalsofproductionofnewproteasomesevolveveryspecifically.Thisisaverysmartstructurethatknowshowtogetthecelltocompensatepossibleproblems”.

Thefourthstoryisaboutproteasomeanddisease.“Proteasomeisreallyaffectedincommonneurodegenerativediseases:thishadbeensuggestedmanytimes,butwithnoclearevidences”saidGoldberg.“Wehaveusednewtechniquestoshowinmousemodeldiseaseoffrontotemporaldementia,whichisveryclosetoAlzheimerdiseasebecausehasmutationsinTaugene”.

Page 25: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Inthiscasetheproteasomesaredefected:thisistightlyboundwithdiseasedevelopmentinmice.“Ourhypothesisisthatinalltmajorneurodegenerativediseasesthereisaprogressivefailuretodegradetheubiquinatedconjugates,andthisconditionisassociatedtotheaccumulationoftauandphospho-tau”concludedGoldberg.

Connectingthesefourstoriescouldgettheproteasomemechanismtoworkbetter,improvingNeurodegenerativediseasestherapies.Takingatthesametimeadvantageoftheproteasome’sunexpectedsmartness.

Page 26: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Towardsinvitroreconstitutionofspindlecheckpointsignaling

AndreaMusacchio

DepartmentofMechanisticCellBiology,Max-Planck-InstituteofMolecularPhysiology,Dortmund,Germany

Thedistributionoftheparentalgenometotwodaughtercellsduringmitosisandmeiosisistheessenceofgeneinheritanceandthereforeoflifeitself.Notsurprisingly,therefore,thisprocessinvolveswhatisprobablythemostcomplexensembleofcellularmolecularmachineryandprovidesanastoundingexampleoftheabilityofbiologicalmattertoself-organize.

Themitoticspindle,astructuremadeofmicrotubules,molecularmotorsandtheirregulators,hostsacruciallylargefractionofthemachineryofcelldivision.Thisbipolar,elongated,andremarkablydynamicstructuredefinesthedivisionplaneofthemothercell,anddevotesitselftothecaptureofchromosomes,totheirclusteringinthemiddleplane,andtotheirsubsequentsegregationtothedaughtercells.Thus,themitoticspindleiscrucialtoensurethatthedaughtercellsinheritexactlythesamenumberandtypeofchromosomes,thereforeguaranteeingcellularandorganismalviability.

Despitetheimportanceofthespindleforcelldivision,theexactmolecularbasisofitsfunctionremainspoorlyunderstood.TryingtounfoldthismysteryisthemaingoalofAndreaMusacchioattheMax-Planck-InstituteofMolecularPhysiologyinDortmund,Germany.Musacchioleadsaresearchteamfocusedoncomplexproteinscaffoldsknownaskinetochores.Kinetochoresarelargeproteinaceousstructuresbuiltonthecentromereregionofchromosomes.Theirprimaryfunctionistoprovideasiteofattachmentofchromosomestothemitoticspindle.

Kinetochoresplayasecond,subtlerfunctionthatishowevercrucialforaccuratecelldivision:theycontrolafeedbackmechanismknownasmitoticcheckpoint,orspindleassemblycheckpoint(SAC).Thefunctionofthischeckpointistopreventseparationoftheduplicatedchromosomes–thesisterchromatids–untiltheyhaveproperlyattachedtothespindleapparatus.DysfunctionoftheSACmayresultinincorrectpartitioningofthesisterchromatidstothedaughtercells,creatingapathologicalcellconditionknownasaneuploidy.Suchconditionstronglycorrelateswithtumorigenesis,supportingthespeculationthatcheckpointdysfunctionmaybe–amongothers–aprominentcauseoftransformation.

Overthelastyears,Musacchio’slaboratoryhasmadesignificantcontributionstothefield:“Wereconstitutedseveralkinetochoresub-complexesintheinnerandtheouterkinetochore,theregionsofthekinetochoreimplicatedincentromerebindingandmicrotubulebindingandcheckpointcontrol,respectively”,saidtheresearcher.

Indeed,biochemicalreconstitution,coupledwithmedium-orhigh-resolutionstructuralinvestigationsisplayingaleadingroleindevelopinganunderstandingofkinetochoreorganization.Forinstance,Musacchioandcolleagueswererecentlyableforthefirsttimetogainadetailedviewofacrucialkinetochoresub-complexmadeoffoursubunits,theCENP-HIKMcomplex.

Thenextchallengeisexplainingtherelationshipbetweenkinetochoresandcheckpointcontrol:thisiswhatMusacchiocalledthe“thirddecadeofcheckpointstudies”,afterthediscoveryofthemaincheckpointcomponents(1991-2000)andtheinvestigationoftheirinteractions(2001-2010).Toaddressthischallenge,hisresearchgroupisapproachingthereconstitutioninvitroofspindle

Page 27: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

checkpointsignalling.Thiseffortfollowsatraditionalpathof“reductionist”studiesthatinterprettheemergenceofcomplexbiologicalfunctionsasaresultofspecificinteractionsofthemacromolecularbuildingblocksthatpopulatecells.

ThescaleofambitionimplicitinMusacchio’splans,however,transcendsthatofmostcurrentefforts.“Theword‘towards’isveryimportant:we’restillnotthere”pointedoutMusacchio.“Butwebelievethatitispossibletoreconstitutethecatalyticapparatusofthecheckpointonreconstitutedkinetochores”.Invitroreconstitutionofthiscomplexbiologicalstructurewillrevolutionizetheunderstandingofchromosomesdivisionduringmitosis,sheddinganewlightononeofthemostexcitingexamplesofself-organizationinlivingmatter.

Page 28: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Theautophagysignalingnetworkinthecoordinationofacell’sresponse

FrancescoCecconi

UnitofCellStressandSurvival,DanishCancerSocietyResearchCenter,2100Copenhagen,Denmark;DepartmentofBiology,UniversityofRomeTorVergata,Rome,Italy

Theworld“cannibalism”usuallyconjuresupimagesofprimitiveandbrutalpractices.Butdeepdown,weareallcannibals:ourcellsareconstantlyeatingthemselves,discardingoftheirredundantmoleculargarbagethroughaprocessknownasautophagy.

DerivingfromaGreektermmeaning“selfeating”,autophagyismostofthetimesasurvivingmechanism,allowingcellsto“recycle”theirbiologicalwaste.Andtomanyscientists’surprise,recentdiscoverieshaveshownthatfaultyautophagymechanismscontributetothedevelopmentofvariousdiseases.

FrancescoCecconi’slaboratoryiscommittedtounravelingtheupstreamregulationofautophagyandelucidatingtheroleitplaysinthreedifferentpathologicalconditions:neurodegeneration,autoimmunityandcancer.

Thelatterinparticularisstillobjectofdiscussion:“Incancerthereisasortofcontroversygoingonabouttheroleofautophagy”explainedCecconi.“Ifweknock-outanautophagygene,thenwegetaccumulationsoftoxiccompoundsthatautophagycan’thelpgettingridof.Forexample,damagedtissuescanoverproduceROS,whichcandamageDNAcausingchromosomeinstabilityandcancer.Inthiscase,mutationsintheautophagygenessetareresponsibleforcancerogenesis”.

Ontheotherside,autophagycanhavetheoppositefunction,beingevendetrimentalforthepatient.“Ifatumororiginatesfromacompletelydifferentsetofmutationsandwehavetheautophagysystemperfectlyworkingwithinthecells,thentheautophagyishelpingcancercellstosurvive”.

Thereisthenincanceradualfunctionofautophagy:dependingonthetumororigin,autophagyshouldeitherbepushedtoworkorblocked.

Inthiscontext,Cecconi’slabhasidentifiedanovelproteincalledAmbra1(ActivatingMoleculeinBeclin1-RegulatedAutophagy),playingmultiplerolesasascaffoldfactorinautophagycontrol.

“WearestudyingthefunctionofAmbra1incellcycleregulationanditsimplicationsintumorinsurgence”saidCecconi.

Togetherwithhisresearchteam,hedevelopedanexperimenttounderstandtheroleofAmbra1incancer.Theresultscouldshedanewlightonthelinkbetweenautophagyandtumordevelopment.

“IhopeIconvincedyouabouttheimportanceofthisprotein”concludedCecconitotheArmenise-Harvardaudience,andheprobablydid.

Page 29: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Thesignalingmechanismsunderlyingtheanti-tumoractivityofmetformin

GianniCesareni

DepartmentofBiology,UniversityofRomeTorVergata,RomeItaly

Fightingcancerwithawell-knownmedicine.Afewyearsago,thishypothesisdominatedmanyscientificmagazines,asanewpossiblefrontierfortumortreatment.

Thepromisingmedicinewasmetformin,themostfrequentlyprescribeddrugfortype2diabetespatients.Thesefindingsimmediatelytriggeredseveralclinicaltrials.Butthemechanismsunderlyingtheanti-tumoractivityofmetforminweren’tfullyclarified,anditsroleasacancersuppressorisstillunderexamination.

AttheUniversityofRome,TorVergata,GianniCesareniusedanewapproachtoaddressthesequestions.Togetherwithhisresearchgroup,hedecidedtolookatthebehaviorofacancercellasasystemandnotasasimplelinearcombinationofitsparts.Theserelativelynewapproachiscommonlyreferredtoassystemsbiology,asexplainedduringthe15thArmenise-HarvardSymposium.

“Welookatthecellinitsentirety,aimingatdescribinghowmetforminperturbsthephysiologicalprocessesofthecancercelltherebypreventingitsproliferation”heexplained.“Thisisanewapproachinmodernbiology,aimingtodescribethecellasasystemandnotsimplyasthesumofitsparts”.

Inordertoworkoutmetformin’sroleincancer,theCesareniLabappliedacombinationofhighcontentmulti-parametricanalysiswithlogicmodelingandsimulationtechniques.Theobjectivewastomapcellperturbationsoncomplexlogicnetworks.

Inthiswaytheyobtainedapredictivecell-specificlogicmodel,laterappliedtofunctionallycharacterizethemolecularmechanismunderlyingtheanti-canceractivityofmetformin.

“Weanalyzedhowsignalingnetworksarerewiredinbreastcancercellsuponmetformintreatment”saidCesareni.“First,wemonitoredtheactivationofabout20keysignalingproteinsincancercellstreatedwithavarietyofperturbationsbeforeandaftermetformintreatment.Next,webuilttwocellspecificnetworkmodelsofmetforminfortreatedanduntreatedcells”.

Theresultswereextremelyinteresting:theexperimentsshowedthatmetforminrewiresthesignalingnetworks,modifyingdifferentconnectionsbetweensignalingproteins.

“Wefoundthatmetforminchangesthestructureofthenetworksunderlyingsomecellpathways”explainedtheresearcher.“Sothecellsbecomemoresensitivetotopictreatmentsandlesspronetoproliferation”.

Tosumup,metformindoesn’tkillthetumorcells,butmakethemweaker.Andthisiscertainlyquiteagoodstartingpoint.

Page 30: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Mechanisticeventsregulatingnotchsignaltransduction

StephenC.Blacklow

HarvardMedicalSchool,Boston,MA,USA;DanaFarberCancerInstitute,Boston,USA

Thisstorybeginsin1917,whenThomasHuntMorganidentifiedallelesofageneresponsiblefornotchingofthewingsinfruitflies.Subsequentwork,ledinlargepartbySpyrosArtavanis-TsakonasofHarvardMedicalSchool,revealedthatthegeneresponsibleforthisphenotype,calledNotch,isahighlyconservedreceptorinasignaltransductionpathwaythatcontrolnumerouscellfatedecisionsinorganismsrangingfromfliestohumans.WhereasnormalNotchsignalingmakesitpossibleforadjacentcellstocommunicateeffectivelywitheachother,dysregulatedNotchsignalingoftenasaresultofmutationsintheNotchreceptorsortheirligands,contributestoavarietyofhumandiseases,includingneurodegenerationandcancer.

Thus,understandinghownormalandaberrantNotchsignalingtakesplacehasimportantimplicationsforclinicalmedicine.AtHarvardMedicalSchool,thisisonetaskoftheBlacklowLab:tounderstandthemolecularlogicofcell-surfacereceptorssuchasNotchproteins,whicharehighlyrelevanttohumanphysiologyanddisease.

“Amajorfocusofthelaboratoryistounderstandhownormalnotchsignalingtakesplace.ThisknowledgewillalsoyieldimportantinsightsintotheeffectsofaberrantNotchsignalingincancerandotherdiseases”saidStephenBlacklow,headofthelaboratory.

Hiseffortsaremainlydirectedtowardunderstandinghowactivationisinducedbyligandsandhownotchcooperateswithotherfactorstoregulatetargetgenetranscription.

“Onecentralunansweredquestioninsignalingishowthebindingsiteforligandscancommunicatewitharegulatoryswitchthatis600Angstroms(alongdistanceinmolecularterms)away,andhowligandstimulationnormallyrelievesautoinhibition”saidBlacklow.

Oneimportantcluetoansweringthisquestionisthatsignal-sendingcellsrelyonendocytosisoftheligandstodeliverthesignaltotheNotchreceptorsonthesignal-receivingcells.Twopossibilitiesmightexplainthisdependence:oneisthatligandendocytosisexertsmechanicalforcetopullontheNotchreceptorinordertoexposeametalloproteasecleavagesitetoactivatingproteolysis,andthesecondisthatligandsrelyonendocytosisforan“activating”modificationthatrendersthemcompetentforsignaling.Inotherwords,endocytosisandrecyclingofligandmayberequiredforconversionofligandsfromalatentstateintoanactiveform.

Thelaboratoryiscurrentlyworkingondistinguishingbetweenthesetwopossibilities.“Itispossibletosubstitutethenormalligand-receptorinteractionwithasyntheticsystem,whichretainsthedependenceonligandendocytosisinsendingcells,andontheactivationswitchinreceivingcells,”saidBlacklow.“Sotheworkingmodelthatcanbetestedinthesyntheticsystemisthatendocytosisisactuallysupplyingtheforcethatopenstheregulatoryswitch”.

Page 31: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

MechanismofinhibitionoftheepidermalgrowthfactorreceptorbyMig6

MichaelJ.Eck

DepartmentofBiologicalChemistry&MolecularPharmacology,HarvardMedicalSchool;CancerBiology,Dana-FarberCancerInstitute,Boston,USA

Lungcanceristheleadingkillerintheworldamongtumors.AccordingtotheWorldHealthOrganization1,59millionofdeathsforlungcancerwereregisteredin2012.

Althoughlungcanceriscloselylinkedtosmoking,everyyearitaffectstensofthousandsofpeoplewhoneversmoked.

Inrecentyears,scientistscontinuedtounravelgeneticfactorsinvolvedincancerdevelopment.Andforlungcancerinnonsmokers,thereisanincreasedlikelihoodoffindingasomaticmutationoftheepidermalgrowthfactorreceptor(EGFR).EGFRisthecell-surfacereceptorformembersoftheepidermalgrowthfactorfamily(EGF-family)ofextracellularproteinligands.

AtHarvardMedicalSchool,MichaelEckisworkingonthestructureofsignalingcomplexesthatunderliecancer,withaparticularfocusonlungcancer-derivedmutationsintheepidermalgrowthfactorreceptor.Hislab’sstructuralapproachesarealsousedtofacilitatedevelopmentofanti-cancerdrugs.

“About15%oflungcancersarecausedbyEGFRmutations”explainedEckduringtheArmenise-HarvardSymposium.“Inparticular,somaticmutationsinEGFRareamajorcauseofnon-smallcelllungcancer”.

Hepresentedthelatestresultsofhislaboratory:thediscoveryofaquiteunexpectedmechanismofinhibitionofEGFRbyanendogenousregulator,Mig6.

Mig6(Mitogen-inducedgene6,alsocalledRALT)isafeedbackinhibitorofEGFRfamilymembersthatactsbydirectlybindingactivatedEGFR,inhibitingitscatalyticactivityanddirectingitsinternalizationanddegradation.

Mig6isprobablyatumorsuppressor:thismeansthatitslossleadstotumorformation.Inparticular,focaldeletionsspanningitschromosomallocusoccurinGBM(Glioblastomamultiforme)andlungcancer.

HisstudiesrevealedthatMig6isactuallya“mechanism-based”inhibitorofEGFR.“EGFRistrappedintheactofphosphorylatingMig6”explainedEck.“OncetheEGFRkinasephosphorylatesMig6,itiseffectivelyirreversiblyinhibited”.

ThesefindingsmayleadtonewtherapeuticstrategiesforlungandothercancerscausedbymutantEGFR.

Page 32: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Connectingthemachineriesofcellfatedeterminationandtumorsuppressioninmammarystemcells

PierPaoloDiFiore

FondazioneIFOM-IstitutoFIRCdiOncologiaMolecolare,MilanItaly

Itishardtoimaginethatstemcells,themost“immaculate”biologicalexistingmaterial,couldleadtocancer.Butaccordingtoarecenttheory,“stem-like”cancercellsareresponsibleforthegenerationoftumorsandforsustainingtumorgrowth.

Thismodelpredictstheexistenceofcancerstemcells(CSCs)withpropertiescharacteristicallyassociatedtonormalstemcells,suchasself-renewal,multipotencyandquiescence.

AttheInstituteofMolecularOncologyFoundation,PierPaoloDiFioreisexploringthischallengingstem-celltheoryofcancer.Heisinvestigatingthemolecularmechanismsgoverningthemaintenanceofthestemcellcompartmentinnormaltissues,andhowthesemechanismsaresubvertedincancer.

DuringtheArmenise-HarvardSymposiumclosingtalk,heexplainedhowislabisaddressingthisstudyperformingbothbasicandtranslationalcancerresearch.

“Theexistenceofcancerstemcellshasbeenprovedforanumberofcancertypes,includingbreastcancer”hesaid.“However,thebreaststemcellcompartmentremainspoorlycharacterizedduetothelackofreliabletechniquesfortheiridentificationandisolation.Wehavedevelopedanewtechniquetospecificallylabelandpurifybreaststemcellsfrommammaryglandtissue”.

Thistechniqueexploitsboththepropensityofbreaststemcellstogeneratemammospheres(3Dclustersofcells)insuspensionculture,andtherelativequiescenceofstemcellscomparedtootherbreastcelltypes,whenpropagatedinvitro.

DiFioreandcolleaguesareusingpurifiednormalandcancerstemcellstoisolatea“stemness”signaturefromwhichtheycanextractdiagnostic,prognosticandtherapeuticmarkersthatcanthenbeevaluatedfortestinginclinicaltrials.

Inthiscontext,acrucialroleisplayedbythemechanismsofasymmetriccelldivision.Inparticular,researchersareinvestigatingwhether,andhow,Numbandendocytosis-basedmechanismsareinvolvedintheregulationofasymmetriccelldivisionofhumanbreaststemcells.

“Numbisacellfatedeterminantthatbyasymmetricallypartitioningatmitosiscontrolsbinarycellfatedecisions”explainedDiFiore.“Inhumanbreastcancers,thereisfrequentlossofNumbexpression,duetoitsexaggeratedubiquitinationandensuingdegradation”.

ThisNumblosscausesalterationsintwomajordownstreampathways.Ontheonehand,lackofNumballowsforuncheckedsignalingactivityoftheNotchreceptor.Ontheother,lackofNumbcausesattenuationofthep53signalingpathway.Tumorsdisplayingloss-of-Numbexpressionareaddictedtothiseventandtoitsmolecularconsequences.

DiFioreclaimedthatthisleadstoafirstimportantconclusion,whichalsoconstitutedthe“take-homemessage”ofhistalk:“WhenyouhavehighNumb,youhavehighp53;whenyouhavelowNumb,youhavelowp53”.

Page 33: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

ThissuggestsadoubleroleofNumb:itisprobablyatumorsuppressor,anditsactioncausesdecreasedp53activityinbreastcancers.Therefore,Numbcontrolsbothanoncogenicpathwayandatumorsuppressorpathway,andthismayleadtonewpromisingclinicalapplicationstofightcancerstemcells.

Page 34: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Armenise-HarvardSymposiumandyoungresearchers:theCareerDevelopmentAward

“Myfatherbelieved,andsodoI,thatsuperbresultsmostoftencomefromcollaboration.TheFoundationintendstocontinuelookingforwaystoenhanceconversationandcooperativeworkonbothsidesoftheAtlantic”.

WiththesewordstheArmenise-HarvardFoundation’sChairman,CountGiampieroAulettaArmenise,gaveatributetohislatefather,founderCountGiovanniAulettaArmenise,onthelastdayofthesymposium.HegreatlysummarizedtheFoundation’smission:establishingamultidisciplinary-basedscienceresearch.

The15thArmenise-HarvardSymposiumfullyreflectedthisvision.Intheend,everyoneagreedithadbeenanexcitingmeeting,withastronginterdisciplinaryapproach.

Alongwiththescientificsessions,over30scientistspresentedposters.Thisgavegroupleadersandyoungerresearchersthechancetotalkovertheirwork,findingnewcollaborationopportunities.

ThisisthespiritofthewholeFoundation,bestexpressedbyitsmostforward-lookinggrantprogram:theCareerDevelopmentAward(CDA).Since2001,theArmenise-HarvardFoundationhasfundedthedevelopmentoftalentedyoungscientists,establishingcollaborativerelationshipsbetweenItalianresearchersandHarvardMedicalSchool.

Inthelast14years,20scientistshavemovedtoItalyfromelsewherearoundtheworld,supportedbytheFoundation.Theysetuptheirownlabsalloverthecountry,fromPalermotoTrento.

The15thArmenise-HarvardSymposiumwitnessedthesuccessofthisfundingprogram.8CareerDevelopmentAwardeesattendedthemeeting:VincenzoCostanzo,FedericoForneris,ClaudiaLodovichi,MarieLaureBaudet,RosellaVisintin,TizianaBonaldi,StefanoGustincichandSherefMansy,whoalsowasoneofthespeakers.Allofthemaredevelopingapromisingcareerinscience.

“ThisisoneofthefewopportunitiestoindependentlyworkinItalyonaspecificresearchprogram”commentedVincenzoCostanzo,winnerofthe2013CDAgrant.HerecentlymovedtotheVertebrateGenomeStability,IFOMIstitutoFIRCdiOncologiaMolecolareinMilan,whereheisworkingontheroleofDNAdamageresponsefactorsinvertebrateDNAreplication.

“WestudyhowDNArepairsitself,andwhytumorcellsarenotcapableoffulfillingthistask”heexplained.“Cellsarelikeplanes:everysinglemechanismisrelatedtomanyothers.Ifoneofthesemechanismsisdamaged,aDNAdamageresponseisactivated.Wewanttounderstandhowtoselectivelyinterveneontumorcells,whichdefectsinthespecificgenesoftheDNAdamageresponse”.

Tothisend,VincenzoCostanzoisapplyingamultidisciplinaryapproach–thesamevisionbroadlypromotedduringthe15thArmenise-HarvardSymposium.

AsCountGiampieroAulettaArmenisestated:“Ourfoundersbelievedinlookingatproblemsfrommultipleangles,andtheFoundationwillcontinuetopursuethisgoal”.

Page 35: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Glossary

Actin:aglobularmulti-functionalproteinfoundthatformsmicrofilaments.Itisthemonomericsubunitoftwotypesoffilamentsincells:microfilaments,oneofthethreemajorcomponentsofthecytoskeleton,andthinfilaments,partofthecontractileapparatusinmusclecells.Actinparticipatesinmanyimportantcellularprocesses,includingmusclecontraction,cellmotility,celldivisionandcytokinesis,vesicleandorganellemovement,cellsignalling,andtheestablishmentandmaintenanceofcelljunctionsandcellshape.

Autophagy:anevolutionarilyconservedcatabolicmechanismthatinvolvescelldegradationofunnecessaryordysfunctionalcellularcomponentsthroughtheactionsoflysosomes.Althoughoriginallyclassifiedasatypeofprogrammedcelldeath,autophagyismorewidelyviewedasabasiccellsurvivalmechanismtocombatenvironmentalstressors

Chromatin:acomplexofmacromoleculesfoundincells,consistingofDNA,proteinandRNA.Itsprimaryfunctionsare:topackageDNAintoasmallervolumetofitinthecell;toreinforcetheDNAmacromoleculetoallowmitosis;topreventDNAdamage;4tocontrolgeneexpressionandDNAreplication.

Clathrin:aproteinthatplaysamajorroleintheformationofcoatedvesicles.Itformsatriskelionshapecomposedofthreeclathrinheavychainsandthreelightchains.

Dynein:amotorproteinconvertingthechemicalenergycontainedinATPintothemechanicalenergyofmovement.Ittransportsvariouscellularcargoby“walking”alongcytoskeletalmicrotubulestowardstheminus-endofthemicrotubule,whichisusuallyorientedtowardsthecellcenter.

Endocytosis:anenergy-usingprocessbywhichcellsabsorbmolecules(suchasproteins)byengulfingthem.

Epidermalgrowthfactorreceptor:thecell-surfacereceptorformembersoftheepidermalgrowthfactorfamily(EGF-family)ofextracellularproteinligands.

Heterochromatin:atightlypackedformofDNA,whichcomesindifferentvarieties.Thesevarietieslieonacontinuumbetweenthetwoextremesofconstitutiveandfacultativeheterochromatin.Bothplayaroleintheexpressionofgenes,whereconstitutiveheterochromatincanaffectthegenesnearthem(position-effectvariegation)andwherefacultativeheterochromatinistheresultofgenesthataresilencedthroughamechanismsuchashistonedeacetylationorpiRNAthroughRNAi.

Histone:ahighlyalkalineproteinfoundineukaryoticcellnucleithatpackagesandorderstheDNAintostructuralunitscallednucleosomes.Histonesarethechiefproteincomponentsofchromatin,actingasspoolsaroundwhichDNAwinds,andplayaroleingeneregulation.

Histonemethylation:aprocessbywhichmethylgroupsaretransferredtoaminoacidsofhistoneproteinsofchromosomes.Dependingonthetargetsite,methylationcanmodifyhistonessothatdifferentportionsofchromatinareactivatedorinactivated.Thisprocessiscriticalfortheregulationofgeneexpressionthatallowsdifferentcellstoexpressdifferentportionsofthegenome.

Histonemethyltransferases(HMT):histone-modifyingenzymesthatcatalyzethetransferofone,two,orthreemethylgroupstolysineandarginineresiduesofhistoneproteins.

Page 36: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

Kinesin:aproteinbelongingtoaclassofmotorproteinsfoundineukaryoticcells.Kinesinsmovealongmicrotubulefilaments,andarepoweredbythehydrolysisofATP.Mostkinesinswalktowardstheplusendofamicrotubule,which,inmostcells,entailstransportingcargofromthecentreofthecelltowardstheperiphery.

MessengerRNA(mRNA):alargefamilyofRNAmoleculesthatconveygeneticinformationfromDNAtotheribosome,wheretheyspecifytheaminoacidsequenceoftheproteinproductsofgeneexpression.

Metformin:anoralantidiabeticdruginthebiguanideclass.Itisthefirst-linedrugofchoiceforthetreatmentoftype2diabetes,inparticular,inoverweightandobesepeopleandthosewithnormalkidneyfunction.

Microtubule:acomponentofthecytoskeleton,foundthroughoutthecytoplasm.Microtubulesareformedbythepolymerizationofadimeroftwoglobularproteins,alphaandbetatubulin;theyareinvolvedinmaintainingthestructureofthecelland,togetherwithmicrofilamentsandintermediatefilaments,theyformthecytoskeleton.

Myosin:aproteinofATP-dependentmotorfamily,bestknownforitsroleinmusclecontractionanditsinvolvementinawiderangeofothereukaryoticmotilityprocesses.Myosinsareresponsibleforactin-basedmotility.

Notch-1:ahumangeneencodingamemberoftheNotchfamily.Notchfamilymembersplayaroleinavarietyofdevelopmentalprocessesbycontrollingcellfatedecisions.

Notchproteins:afamilyoftransmembraneproteinswithrepeatedextracellularEGFdomainsandthenotch(orDSL)domains.Theseproteinsareinvolvedinlateralinhibitioninembryogenesis.

Notchsignalingpathway:ahighlyconservedcellsignalingsystempresentinmostmulticellularorganisms.Notchsignalingpromotesproliferativesignalingduringneurogenesis,anditsactivityisinhibitedbyNumbtopromoteneuraldifferentiation.

Numb:aproteinthatinhumansisencodedbytheNUMBgene.Itplaysaroleinthedeterminationofcellfatesduringdevelopment.

Phosphorylation:theadditionofaphosphate(PO43−)grouptoaproteinorotherorganicmolecule.Phosphorylationturnsmanyproteinenzymesonandoff,therebyalteringtheirfunctionandactivity.Proteinphosphorylationisonetypeofpost-translationalmodification.

Proteasomes:proteincomplexesinsidealleukaryotesandarchaea,andinsomebacteria.Ineukaryotes,theyarelocatedinthenucleusandthecytoplasm.Themainfunctionoftheproteasomeistodegradeunneededordamagedproteinsbyproteolysis,achemicalreactionthatbreakspeptidebonds.

Reactiveoxygenspecies(ROS):chemicallyreactivemoleculescontainingoxygen.ROSareformedasanaturalbyproductofthenormalmetabolismofoxygenandhaveimportantrolesincellsignalingandhomeostasis.

Page 37: MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES - Home - The Giovanni … · ARMENISE-HARVARD SYMPOSIUM 2014 MECHANISMS TO MOLECULES 15th Biennial Symposium June 22-24, 2014, Poiano Resort Hotel, Lake Garda

RNAinterference(RNAi):abiologicalprocessinwhichRNAmoleculesinhibitgeneexpression,typicallybycausingthedestructionofspecificmRNAmolecules.

RNA-inducedtranscriptionalsilencing(RITS):aformofRNAinterferencebywhichshortRNAmolecules–suchassmallinterferingRNA(siRNA)–triggerthedownregulationoftranscriptionofaparticulargeneorgenomicregion.

Yeast:single-celledfungithatreproducebybudding.Yeastsizecanvarygreatlydependingonthespecies,typicallymeasuring3–4µmindiameter,althoughsomeyeastscanreachover40µm.