measurement of conducted emi using a three-phase active ......measurement of conducted emi using a...

33
Pascal S. Niklaus, M. Antivachis, D. Bortis, J. W. Kolar Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) Zurich Power Electronic Systems Laboratory www.pes.ee.ethz.ch [email protected] Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

Pascal S. Niklaus, M. Antivachis, D. Bortis, J. W. KolarSwiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) Zurich

Power Electronic Systems Laboratorywww.pes.ee.ethz.ch

[email protected]

Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator

Page 2: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

2/ 33

► Motivation

■ Switched-Mode Converters must comply with CISPR Standards for Conducted EMI ■ Fundamental Component + Switching Harmonics / Noise CM and DM

► Three-Phase PV Inverter ► Fundamental Frequency

► Fundamental + Switching Frequency ► EMI Equivalent Circuit

CM

DM

Page 3: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

3/ 33

► Motivation

■ Switched-Mode Converters must comply with CISPR Standards for Conducted EMI ■ Output Filter to reduce Switching Harmonics / Noise

► Optimize for Minimum Volume, Cost, Losses, Weight, …

► e.g. PV Inverter

CM Noise

DM Noise

► Combined CM/DM Filter ► Separate CM and DM Filter

Page 4: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

4/ 33

Agenda

Realization Performance Evaluation

5 Slides 5 Slides 2 Sl.

Design Considerations

3 Slides7 Slides

Measurement Setup Conclusions

Page 5: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

5/ 33

Introduction:Measurement Setup

Page 6: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

6/ 33

► Motivation

■ Standard Meas. Setup only gives Total Conducted EMI Noise from EUT■ Total EMI Noise composed of CM and DM Parts

► Optimize Each Filter Stage for Minimum Volume, Cost, Losses, Weight, …

► Separation of Total Noise into CM and DM Part

Page 7: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

7/ 33

► Motivation

■ Three-Phase CM/DM Separator between LISN and Test Receiver■ Attribute Exceeding to CM and/or DM Noise

► Optimize Each Filter Stage for Minimum Volume, Cost, Losses, Weight, …

► Separation of Total Noise into CM and DM Part

Page 8: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

8/ 33

► Three-Phase CM/DM Decomposition

■ CM Component Common to all Phases Geometric Mean■ DM Component = “Not CM” Add up to zero

► Phasor Representation

► Derive CM Component and therefrom DM Components

► Circuit Representation for these Operations

Page 9: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

9/ 33

► Performance Metrics

■ Transfer from each Input to each Output Direct and Cross Coupling ■ General Multi-Port Notation

► Three-Phase System Three DM Inputs and Outputs

► Three DMTFs and CMRRs

Page 10: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

10/ 33

Realization1. Passive Separator

2. Active Separator

Page 11: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

11/ 33

► Passive Noise Separator

■ Y/∆ Transformer Flux Addition / Cancellation■ Very High Coupling Factor Required

► Matching of Passive Components

► Active Realization preferred

► Hardware Demonstrator

Source: Heldwein et al. 2009

Page 12: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

12/ 33

► Passive Noise Separator

■ Y/∆ Transformer Flux Addition / Cancellation■ Very High Coupling Factor Required

► Active Realization preferred

► Hardware Demonstrator

Source: Heldwein et al. 2009

► Matching of Passive Components

Page 13: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

13/ 33

► Passive Noise Separator

► Hardware Demonstrator

■ Y/∆ Transformer Flux Addition / Cancellation■ Very High Coupling Factor Required

► Active Realization preferred

Source: Heldwein et al. 2009

► Matching of Passive Components

Page 14: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

14/ 33

► Active Noise Separator

■ Active Components (Operational Amplifiers) + Passives No Magnetics!■ Subtract Phase Voltage from CM Voltage -vDM at Outputs

► Hardware Demonstrator

► Realization on PCB Controlled Parasitic Elements Influence?

► Reproducible and Simple Manufacturing

Page 15: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

15/ 33

► Active Noise Separator

■ Active Components (Operational Amplifiers) + Passives No Magnetics!■ Subtract Phase Voltage from CM Voltage -vDM at Outputs

► Hardware Demonstrator

► Realization on PCB Controlled Parasitic Elements Influence?

► Reproducible and Simple Manufacturing

Page 16: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

16/ 33

► Active Noise Separator

■ Active Components (Operational Amplifiers) + Passives No Magnetics!■ Subtract Phase Voltage from CM Voltage -vDM at Outputs

► Hardware Demonstrator

► Realization on PCB Controlled Parasitic Elements Influence?

► Reproducible and Simple Manufacturing

Page 17: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

17/ 33

Design Considerations• Influence of Parasitic Elements

• Length Matching

• Trimming

Page 18: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

18/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (I)

■ Assume pure CM Input Signal■ Parasitic Capacitances due to Layout + Components

► Hardware Demonstrator

Page 19: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

19/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (I)

■ Assume pure CM Input Signal■ Parasitic Capacitances due to Layout + Components

► Hardware Demonstrator

Page 20: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

20/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (I)

■ Assume pure CM Input Signal■ Parasitic Capacitances due to Layout + Components

► Hardware Demonstrator

Page 21: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

21/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (II)

■ Assume pure CM Input Signal■ Parasitic Capacitances due to Layout + Components

► Selection of High Performance Amplifiers

► Symmetric Layout absolutely Essential! < 0.06° Phase Mismatch for 60dB CMRR

► Difference Amplifier Crucial for CMRR

Equal Source Impedances

Equal Source Path Lengths

Finite CMRR of Amplifier

Page 22: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

22/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (II)

■ Assume pure CM Input Signal■ Parasitic Capacitances due to Layout + Components

► Selection of High Performance Amplifiers

► Symmetric Layout absolutely Essential! < 0.06° Phase Mismatch for 60dB CMRR

► Difference Amplifier Crucial for CMRR

Equal Source Impedances

Equal Source Path Lengths

Finite CMRR of Amplifier

Page 23: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

23/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (II)

■ Assume pure CM Input Signal■ Parasitic Capacitances due to Layout + Components

► Selection of High Performance Amplifiers

► Symmetric Layout absolutely Essential! < 0.06° Phase Mismatch for 60dB CMRR

► Difference Amplifier Crucial for CMRR

Equal Source Impedances

Equal Source Path Lengths

Finite CMRR of Amplifier

Page 24: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

24/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (II)

■ Assume pure CM Input Signal■ Parasitic Capacitances due to Layout + Components

► Selection of High Performance Amplifiers

► Symmetric Layout absolutely Essential! < 0.06° Phase Mismatch for 60dB CMRR

► Difference Amplifier Crucial for CMRR

Equal Source Impedances

Equal Source Path Lengths

Finite CMRR of Amplifier

Page 25: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

25/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (III)

■ Simplified Test Circuit for Initial CMRR Test■ Single Channel with Trimming Capacitor at CM Node

► Almost at Amplifier Limit for f > 10MHz

► Very Simple Trimming Procedure Results in Superior CMRR

Page 26: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

26/ 33

► Influence of Parasitic Elements (III)

■ Simplified Test Circuit for Initial CMRR Test■ Single Channel with Trimming Capacitor at CM Node

► Almost at Amplifier Limit for f > 10MHz

► Very Simple Trimming Procedure Results in Superior CMRR

Page 27: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

27/ 33

Results:Performance Evaluation

Page 28: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

28/ 33

► Common-Mode Excitation

■ Evaluation of Transfer Functions and Rejection Ratios■ Dedicated CM Input Signal Adapter

► >50dB CMRR for CE EMI Range

► Significantly Better Compared to Passive Realization

Page 29: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

29/ 33

► Differential-Mode Excitation

■ Evaluation of Transfer Functions and Rejection Ratios■ Dedicated DM Input Signal Adapters

► >50dB DMRR for CE EMI Range

► HF DMRR Limited by Adapter

Page 30: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

30/ 33

Conclusions

Page 31: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

31/ 33

Active CM/DM Separator CircuitFlat CMTF and DMTF

CMRR & DMRR > 50dB up to 30MHzNo Magnetic Components

Three-Phase Conducted EMINoise Separation

Page 32: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

32/ 33

Active CM/DM Separator CircuitFlat CMTF and DMTF

CMRR & DMRR > 50dB up to 30MHzNo Magnetic Components

Three-Phase Conducted EMINoise Separation

► Consider Impact of LISNs, Cables, Etc. !

!!

Page 33: Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active ......Measurement of Conducted EMI using a Three-Phase Active CM/DM Noise Separator 2/ 33 Motivation Switched-Mode Converters

33/ 33

Thank You!

Author Contact:Pascal S. Niklaus

Power Electronic Systems Laboratorywww.pes.ee.ethz.ch

[email protected]