maximizing fire and life safety program effectiveness in a challenging economy stacie durham fire...
TRANSCRIPT
Maximizing Fire and Life Safety Program Effectiveness in a
Challenging Economy
Stacie DurhamFire & Life Safety Education Coordinator
McKinney Fire Department
13th Annual Texas Fire Marshals’ ConferenceOctober 17-21, 2011
Austin, Texas
Fire in the U.S.A. – 2010 1
• During 2010, U.S. fire departments reported responding to a total of 1,331,500 fires, which resulted in:– 3,129 civilian fire deaths– 17,720 civilian fire injuries– $11.6 billion in property damage.
1 Source: Fire Loss in the United States During 2010 by Michael J. Karter, Jr., NFPA, Quincy, MA
• During 2010, U.S. fire departments reported responding to 482,000 structure fires, which resulted in:– 2,755 civilian fire deaths– 15,420 civilian fire injuries– $9.7 billion in property damage.
1 Source: Fire Loss in the United States During 2010 by Michael J. Karter, Jr., NFPA, Quincy, MA
Fire in the U.S.A. – 2010 1
Fire in the United States• Fire in the USA is a much larger problem than acknowledged. The cost to society is staggering, creating a significant national issue.
• Property damage for 2010 estimated at more than $11 billion. (Wildfires in 2011 will likely increase this number significantly.)
• The United States has the highest fire death rate in the western world and nearly the highest in the entire world.
• USA has fire property losses among the largest of industrialized nations.
Fire in the United States• As a rule, fire causes more direct
and indirect loss (human and property) than all other natural disasters combined.
• Average 200 deaths annually from natural disasters.
• Average 4,000 deaths annually from fires.
• Many civilian fire injuries go unreported, so injury numbers are likely exponentially higher than we know.
How does Texas measure up?
• In 2006, Texas had the second highest number of civilian fire deaths in the country – behind only California (292 vs. 298.)
• In 2010, Texas reported:– 175 civilian fire deaths– 65 % of civilian fire deaths occurred in residential
structures– 24% of civilian fire deaths involved the elderly (65+
years of age)– $510 M+ in property damage
Reality…• The economy is making it more difficult than
ever to sustain fire prevention/fire safety education efforts– Commonly viewed by leaders as non-mandated
service– Exacerbated by “9-11” effect– Often the first program offered in budget cuts
• We must cut expenditures while maintaining core services and mission critical programs
Barriers to success• Budgets today require tough decisions
rapidly – Decision makers must understand long- and
short-term impact of cuts– Accurate program data is imperative!– MARKET your programs and successes
• Creating a fire service culture that embraces prevention and education as a core service– Recognizing that preventing the emergency is
top priority, rather than focusing the bulk of time and resources after the fact
• Reinventing the perception of the job of a “firefighter”
Reality…• Crisis makes opportunity
– We’re not the only ones in this situation
• Other government agencies• For profit businesses• Non-Profit agencies• Civic clubs• Churches
– We share many common goals– We often compete for the same
dollars, i.e., grants, in-kind donations, etc…
NOT the answer…
Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting
different results.
Albert Einstein
How do we proceed?• Identify and work proactively with community
partners to provide highest level of protection and community services– Embrace and expand “partnerships”– Achieve more with less– Work smarter not harder– Collaborate to achieve
mutual/complementary goals
Getting started…• Collaborative efforts begin because individuals/agencies
reach out to like minded people/groups to address issues affecting their “customers”– Analyze community emergency response data to identify risks– Prioritize identified risks– Identify target audience– Identify likely partner agencies– Determine if program is mutually beneficial
Getting started
• Recognize and agree on need– Develop vision– Identify goals– Identify definition of success– Identify barriers to success– Share ownership
• Determine level of commitment for each agency
• Identify lead agency
Now what?
• Cooperatively determine strategies & tactics to reach audience and mitigate risks
• Prepare a “program plan” with clearly measurable results
• Implement the plan• Monitor• Evaluate• Modify
Examples from McKinney
• Remembering When• We’re Out to Alarm Texas• Beat the Heat • McTown Klownz• Holiday Outreach• Children’s Fire Safety House• Fun with the Son Back to School Safety
Remembering WhenTM
• Partners– Committee on Aging– Meals on Wheels– Senior Center– Housing Services– Home Health Agencies– Seniors Helping Seniors
We’re Out to Alarm Texas• Partners
– Texas Department of Insurance– Seniors Helping Seniors– Committee on Aging– Development Services– Citizens Fire Academy Alumni– Community Lifeline Center (Ministerial Alliance)
Beat the Heat
• Partners– TXU Energy– Community Lifeline Center– McKinney Noon Lions Club– McKinney Professional
Firefighters’ Association– McKinney Ladies Association– CFA Alumni Association
McTown Klownz
• Partners– McKinney ISD– McKinney CVB– McKinney Performing
Arts Center
McKinney Holiday Outreach
• McKinney ISD• Community Lifeline Center• 3E McKinney• Volunteer McKinney Center• McKinney Housing Authority• Salvation Army• Local churches• Citizens
Fire Safety House & Community Outreach
• Citizens Fire Academy Alumni• Local Businesses• Service Clubs
The future…
Market your successes!
Bottom line
• Successful collaborations must– Clearly identify lead agency– Have a common understanding of the program– Have a clearly identified purpose (i.e., install 250
smoke alarms in CY 2012)– Have open communication– Have measurable program results– Be mutually beneficial for all organizations
The future
Have we really considered new or different ways to do business, or are we wrapped up in “doing things the way we always have?” Some of our public safety competitors are innovating more rapidly than we are – do we want to be followers in public safety or leaders?
Weathering the Economic StormFiscal Challenges in Fire and Emergency Medical Services
International Association of Fire Chiefswww.iafc.org
The future…
The USA historically places more emphasis on suppression than on prevention– The U.S. must take a more proactive approach to fire and
life safety through Community Risk Reduction (CRR)– CRR must be recognized by the U.S. fire service as a core
service, as vital as emergency response – Work proactively with community partners
• Expansion of non-traditional volunteer roles can assist with program delivery
The North American fire service seems to be the lone holdout worldwide in taking a much more aggressive approach to fire and life safety education and prevention... Change will be slow at first; but, it will gain momentum quickly. Given a choice of taking a new, more cost effective approach, or raising taxes to maintain the status quo, local elected officials will opt for change.
William PetersonFire Chief, Retired
Plano, Texas
The future…
Resources:• Vision 20/20: Community Risk Reduction Planning Report
www.strategicfire.org • Fire Loss in the United States During 2010 by Michael J.
Kanter, Jr., NFPA, Quincy, MA• Global Concepts in Residential Fire Safety
http://www.sysplan.com/capabilities/fire_ems/index.html • Weathering the Economic Storm: Fiscal Challenges in Fire and
Emergency Medical Services www.iafc.org• Fire in the United States 2003-2007 www.usa.fema.gov• Building Collaborative Partnerships www.ncrel.org
Stacie DurhamFire & Life Safety Education Coordinator
McKinney Fire Department
www.mckinneyfire.org