maternal substance abuse, child development and … count... · maternal substance abuse, child...

90
MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and Mental Health Court Conference May 18-20, 2010 Atlanta, Georgia

Upload: vunguyet

Post on 09-Mar-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN

Claire D. Coles, Ph.D.

2010 Drug, DUI and Mental Health Court Conference May 18-20, 2010

Atlanta, Georgia

Page 2: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Dr. Coles’ Affiliations

Fetal Alcohol Center, at the Marcus Center of Children’s Health Care of Atlanta

Departments of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences and Pediatrics, Emory University School of Medicine

Page 3: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

MANY, DIFFERENT, DEVELOPMENTAL AND BEHAVIOR PROBLEMS ARE NOTED IN CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS WHOSE PARENTS ABUSE DRUGS AND ALCOHOL

Page 4: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Why are we concerned about the effects of substance use on neurodevelopment?

Prevalence of Substance Use by Pregnant Women

Teratogenic effects of exposure

Relationship between Substance Use and Postnatal Environmental problems

Behavior and Developmental Problems noted in Children of Substance Abusers

Page 5: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Alcohol and Drugs in

PREGNANCY:

Mother

Page 6: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Why the Concern for Prenatal Drug Exposure?

1 - 5% in U.S. have tried cocaine

10% of U.S. are alcoholics

20% of women smoke in pregnancy

40% of women report some alcohol use during pregnancy

60 - 80% of DFCS referrals in GA involve substance abuse; 78% nationwide

Estimates range from 0.6 to 31% prenatally exposed children

Page 7: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Why the Concern for Prenatal Drug Exposure, continued

Exposure higher in some SES groups already at risk

Public belief that cocaine, methamphetamine and other drug exposure causes birth defects and developmental problems

Page 8: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Reality?

The majority of women who use alcohol/drugs

in pregnancy, use more than one drug.

Cigarettes and alcohol the most common.

Next are marijuana and prescription drugs

Cocaine, maybe Methamphetamines, are next

Finally Opiates, like Heroin

Genetic loading? Antisocial personality?

And then there is the postnatal environment!

Page 9: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Lifetime Prevalence (%) of Substance Use Reported by Young Women (18-25)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

1972 1982 1992 2002

Alcohol

Cigarettes

Cocaine

SAMHSA, National Survey on Drug Use and Health, 2002

Page 10: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Drug Use During Pregnancy

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Marijuana Cocaine Other Alcohol Cigarettes

Ebrahim, SH, & Gfroerer, J (2003) Obstetrics and Gynecology, 101, p374-378

%

Page 11: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

0 5 10 15 20 25

Any illicit drug

Marijuana

Cocaine

Alcohol

Cigarettes

Hispanic

Whites

Afr-Amer

Percent of Women Using Drugs During

Pregnancy by Racial and Ethic Groups, 1992

NIDA

Notes

J/F

1995

Page 12: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

FACTORS INFLUENCING DRUG USE

A. EXTERNALIsolation

Poverty

Violent Crime

Drug Related Lifestyle

Unstable Family / Social

Environment

Inadequate Social Services

Solitary Caregiver or Provider

B. INTERNALPoor Coping Skills

Depression

Boredom

Anger

Page 13: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS:Social Problems Associated

With Substance Abuse

Poverty

Violent crime

Parent’s drug-related life style

Parent’s poor physical and mental health

Disorganized / dysfunctional families

Lack of stable social environment

Inadequate medical services

Inadequate social services

Page 14: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

MEDICAL PROBLEMS COMMONLY

ASSOCIATED WITH ALCOHOLISM

Liver: Alcoholic steatosis

(fatty liver)

Alcoholic hepatitis

and fibrosis

Cirrhosis

Cardiovascular

InjuryAlcoholic

cardiomyopathy

Hypertension

Hemorrhagic strokes

Page 15: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Neurological disorders:

Wernicke - Korsakoff syndrome

Alcoholic dementia

Organic mental disorder

MEDICAL PROBLEMS COMMONLY

ASSOCIATED WITH ALCOHOLISM

Immune system impairment:

Cancers of mouth and upper respiratory tract

Liver cancer

Pancreatitis

From: “Effects of Alcohol on Health and Body Systems” (1993). Secretary of Health and

Human Services, 8th Special Report to the U.S. Congress on Alcohol and Health, Rockville,

MD., USDHHS, NIA, NIAAA, 1993.

Page 16: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

PSYCHIATRIC CONDITIONS OFTEN CO-MORBID

WITH ALCOHOL / DRUG ABUSE

Depression

Conduct Disorder

Personality Disorders:Antisocial Personality DisorderBorderline Personality Disorder

Posttraumatic Stress Disorder

Psychotic Conditions

Anxiety Disorders Sexual Dysfunction

Page 17: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Figure 1: Survival Curve for Drinkers and

Nondrinkers

0.9

0.91

0.92

0.93

0.94

0.95

0.96

0.97

0.98

0.99

1

1.01

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

Years between Childbirth and Mother's Death

%

A

l

i

v

e

Alcohol

Control

41 (7%) of the

583 women were

deceased, 6

controls and 35

alcohol users ,

with alcohol

users

significantly

more likely to

die, X2 (1) =7.59, p<.006.

Page 18: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

ALCOHOLISM IN WOMEN VS. MENDifference in Signs Associated

with Alcohol Abuse

Fewer reports of academic / work difficulties

Less antisocial behavior

Fewer legal problems

Fewer DUI‟s, auto accidents

More physical problems

Spouse/partner leaves more often

More suicide attempts

More depression

More neurological damage

Roman, 1988; Tamerin et al., 1986

Page 19: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

ALCOHOLISM IN WOMEN

Effects on Reproductive Function

• Amenorrhea or severe oligomenorrhea

• Dysmenorrhea

• Anovulation/luteal phase dysfunction

• Increased premenstrual discomfort

• Spontaneous abortion

• Increased gynecological problems

• Fetal alcohol effects

• Sexual disorderMello, 1986

Page 20: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Obstetrical Complications for Which Drug Abusing Women

Are at Increased Risk

Impaired Fertility

Spontaneous Abortion

Poor Maternal Weight Gain

Intrauterine Growth

Retardation (IURG)

Intrauterine Death

Placental Insufficiency

Retroplacental Hemorrhage

Abruptio Placenta

Septic Thrombophlebitis

Uterine Irritability

Preterm Labor & DeliveryPremature Rupture of

Membranes (PROM)AmnionitisPrecipitous LaborEmergency Caesarian

SectionIncreased Anesthesia

AdministrationForceps DeliveryFetal DistressPostpartum HemorrhageMaternal Mortality

Page 21: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Economic Barriers

• lack of health insurance

• lack of transportation

• lack of caretakers for children

Limited Availability of Treatment Services

• lack of women-oriented treatment models

Individual Barriers

• Maternal psychopathology

• Family dysfunction

BARRIERS TO TREATMENT

Page 22: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

IDENTIFYING WOMEN AT RISK

Self Report Measures

Quantity / frequency indices

Forced choice ordinal scales

Time sampling

Diary

Open-ended response format

Page 23: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

How do we measure Drug Use?

Maternal Self Report.

Did you drink/use drugs in pregnancy?

How often did you use “crack”?

How many cigarettes do you smoke a day?

How many joints do you smoke?

How many drinks do you have on each occasion when you drink?

Page 24: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

How did we measure Drug Use?

Urine (EMIT) Screens

During prenatal care

At delivery

Postpartum

Infants in the nursery

Page 25: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Alcohol and Drugs in

PREGNANCY:

Child

Page 26: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

POSSIBLE MECHANISMS OF DRUGS/ALCOHOL

IN PREGNANCY:

Teratogenic (Single Factor) Model

Teratogenic

SubstanceFetus

OutcomeSIDS

Fetal wastage

Behavioral

effects

Birth Defects

Growth

retardation

Coles, 1995,

Mother

Page 27: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

SOME POSSIBLE MECHANISMS OF EFFECTS

OF DRUGS/ALCOHOL IN PREGNANCY:

Toxic (interactive) Model

Toxic

Substance

Mother

Fetus

OUTCOMES

Reduced fertility

Fetal wastage

Preterm birth

Birth defects

Growth retardation

Behavior effects

SECONDARY OUTCOMESMedical & behavioral

problems

SIDSColes, 1995

Page 28: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Prenatal Environment

Social Factors

Legal Issues

Prenatal Care

Substance Use & Abuse

Maternal Characteristics

Genetics

OUTCOMES• Reduced fertility• Fetal wastage• Preterm birth• Birth defects• Growth Retardation

MOTHER

FETUS SECONDARY OUTCOMES

• Developmental & Medical

Effects

• SIDS

POSTNATAL EVIRONMENT

Maternal Status/ Legal

issues/ Social Factors/

Nutrition/ Substance Use

Abuse/ Education / Social

Services/et cetera

MULTI-FACTOR MODEL

Coles, 1995

Page 29: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

MODEL OF ENVIRONMENTAL INFLUENCE

Greater Society

Social Supports

Family

Child

Page 30: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

TYPE OF DRUG EXPOSURE: Critical Periods of Development

Embryonic period (in weeks) Fetal period (in weeks)

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 16 20-36 38 40

FullTerm

Major morphological abnormalitiesPhysiological defects and minor

morphological abnormalities

Central Nervous System

Heart

Eyes

Limbs

Digestive System

PalateExternal Genitalia

EarsDevelopment and Descent of Thyroid

Adapted from The Developing Human by K. L. Moore, 1993

Page 31: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

PERINATAL COMPLICATIONS

SEEN IN DRUG EXPOSED NEONATES

Preterm birth, with associated

problems

Respiratory distress

Intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH)

Necrotizing endocolitis (NEC)

Asphyxia Neonatorum

Meconium staining

Meconium aspiration

Page 32: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

PERINATAL COMPLICATION SEEN INDRUG EXPOSED NEONATES

Pneumonia Hypoglycemia Hypocalcemia Tachypnea Apnea Respiratory alkalosis HyperbilirubinemiaRespiratory distress syndrome

(RDS)

Page 33: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS: Effects of Substance Abuse on Caretaking / SES

Death of parent

Loss of custody

Depressed mother

Neglect / Abandonment

Abuse

Inconsistent parenting

Failure of attachment

Failure to use social /

medical services

Page 34: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

AGENCIES INVOLVED

WITH EXPOSED CHILDREN

PRENATALWIC

Health CentersPrenatal Clinics

Physicians/MidwivesA&D Programs

INFANCY/PRESCHOOLWIC

HospitalsHealth Centers/Well Baby Clinics

High Risk Nurses

CourtsSocial Services AgenciesChild Protective ServicesCounty Welfare Agencies

Educational ProgramsTreatment ProgramsParenting Programs

SCHOOL AGECourts

SchoolsSpecial Education Programs

Hospital & Health CentersCounty Welfare Agencies

Page 35: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Physical/

Health/MotorDevelopmental/

Cognitive

Behavioral/

Social

Academic/

Vocational

Alcohol and Drug Affected children

may have problems in the

following areas:

Page 36: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

What are the effects of various drugs?

Alcohol Global cognitive deficits Specific neurodevelopmental impact Academic deficits

Cocaine Arousal regulation Emotional development Executive Functioning

Smoking/Nicotine Auditory perception Language development Conduct Disorders

Page 37: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Alcohol

Page 38: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Prenatal Alcohol Exposure

Fetal Alcohol Syndrome (FAS)

Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders (FASD)

Page 39: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

THE TIP OF THE ICEBERGFETAL ALCOHOL Spectrum Disorders

Partial FAS

Alcohol-related Birth Defects

Alcohol-related Neurobehavioral Effects

FAS 1 per 1000

5 per 1000

1 per 100

73,000 Alcohol-Affected Georgia Citizens , 0 to 21years

Page 40: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

How is FAS Diagnosed?

Prenatal Alcohol Exposure

Face

Growth

Brain

FAS

Page 41: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Facial Features Microcephaly

Short palprebral fissure

Thin upper vermillion

Absent philtrum

Hypoplastic midface

Low nasal bridge

Page 42: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Effect of Alcohol Exposure on Birth Weight

(N = 368)

3,300

3,200

3,100

3,000 -

2,900 -

2,800 -

2,700 -

0 --

Never

Drank

Stopped

Second

Trimester

Page 43: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Controls,

n=7

Alcohol,

n=7

Coronal Sagittal Axial

Prenatal Alcohol Exposure Affects the Brain:White Matter in Young Adults (sMRI) Li, et al,

(2008) Brain Imaging and Behavior.

Page 44: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

(Neuro) Behavioral Outcomes Examined in FASD

General Cognitive/Learning Skills (IQ) Executive Functioning Skills Attentional regulation Memory,Planning and organization

Motor skills Visual/spatial skills Academic Achievement Adaptive Behavior Social Behavior Mental Health/Behavioral Disorders

Page 45: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

FAS Neurocognitive Deficits

FAS is associated with a clinically significant level of general intellectual impairment.

IQ range: 40-110; X=70’s across many studies of children with FAS

Deficits related to neurological damage

Additional clear, but unacknowledged, environmentalcomponent to functional deficits

Page 46: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Effects on Educational Functioning

Global functioning- global limitations on learning abilities

Arousal regulation/Attention

Executive Functioning Skills-metacognition

Visual/Spatial Skills

Memory (or metamemory and strategy use)

Speed of processing

Specific deficits in math

Depression

Page 47: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Is there a ‚Pattern‛ of Learning and Behavior that affects Education?

Although hard to find against this complicated background, patterns are emerging.

Cognitive: Both Global and Specific deficits

Behavior: “Arousal Dysregulation”.

Early deficits in motor and visual/motor

Commonly find secondary disabilities in achievement, behavior.

Page 48: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Clinical Presentations 0 to 5 years Significantly Developmental Delayed with

complex medical histories. Asthma.

Behavioral disturbances with mild delays and significant histories of abuse/neglect.

Arousal dysregulation beginning with sleep problems progressing to behavior problems.

Need for PT, OT, Speech and social work services. More motor than other areas.

Page 49: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Clinical Presentations: School Age

Mild Intellectual Disabilities (IQ=50 to 69) with significant physical findings. Occasionally lower.

Borderline IQs with history of foster care and specific learning deficits. Frequent behavior problems.

International adoption with emotional (attachment) problems and specific language disabilities. IQ varies.

Nonverbal learning disabilities. V/P split with significantly higher language than performance scores.

Page 50: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

ADHD and FASD

Many (many) children with FASD are diagnosed with ADHD.

Questionable diagnosis due to history of exposure, arousal dysregulation, parenting problems, custody issues.

In clinical observation, medications do not seem to improve outcomes. Little systematic research on this.

Page 51: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Effects of Disadvantage on Development in Alcohol and Control Samples*

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

6 Mon 12 Mon 24 Mon 5 years 7 years 15 years

Norms SES Controls Alcohol

Ab

ility S

tan

dard

Sco

re

Child’ Age at Testing (*Various N’s)

Page 52: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Source: Lynch, et al. (2003) Examining delinquency in adolescents differentially prenatally exposed to alcohol.J Stud Alcohol

Predicting Adolescent Delinquency (N=250)

Variable Std Beta t p

Life Stress .363 6.6 .000

Child Drug Use

.265 4.4 .000

Parenting: Supervision

-.222 -3.7 .000

Prenatal Exposure

.01 .16 .96,ns

However, it is

also widely

reported that

prenatal alcohol

exposure is

associated with

later criminal

behavior.

But most

studies didn’t

controlled for

environmental

factors.

Page 53: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Specific Deficits:e.g., Math Disabilities

Math skills more impaired than language

Probably related to visual/spatial deficits

Probably related to executive functioning problems

Can be observed in preschool period and persists through adulthood

Page 54: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Academic (WIAT) Scores for Exposure Groups

55

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

Reading Spelling Math

Control FAS-E Exposed Special Ed

Howell, et al, 2006

Page 55: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

SFr: Superiorfrontal

RMF: Rostralmiddlefrontal

CMF: Caudalmiddlefrontal

PTr: Parstriangularis

POr: Parsorbitalis

LOF: Lateralorbitofrontal

PrC: Precentral

PoC: Postcentral

SuM: Supramarginal

SPa: Superiorparietal

STe: Superiortemporal

ITe: Inferiortemporal

LOc: Lateraloccipital,

CAC: Caudalanteriorcingulate

PCu: Precuneus

Cun: Cuneus

PCa: Pericalcarine

Lin: Lingual

Fus: Fusiform

PHi: Parahippocampal

RAC: Rostralanteriorcingulate

IPa: Inferiorparietal

POp: Parsopercularis.

Chen, et al., (2008) Systematic Investigation of Volume Changes Induced by

Prenatal Alcohol Exposure in Cortical and Sub-cortical Regions, in review

Cortical regions exhibiting PAE effects

Page 56: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Cbr: Cerebral Cortex

Cbe: Cerebellum Cortex

Tha: Thalamus Proper

Hip: Hippocampus

Put: Putamen

Pal: Pallidum

Amy: Amygdala

Cau: Caudate

Acu: Accumbens

Area.

R: Right Hemisphere,

L: Left Hemisphere.

Sub-cortical regions exhibiting PAE effects

Chen, et al., (2008) Systematic

Investigation of Volume Changes

Induced by Prenatal Alcohol

Exposure in Cortical and Sub-cortical

Regions, in review

Page 57: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Why study corpus callosum (CC)? Agenesis of CC found at higher rate in FAS

patients

Previous studies have identified CC abnormalities (e.g., Riley et al, 1995, Johnson et al., 1996, Swayze

et al, 1997, Sowell et al, 2001, Bookstein et al. 2001)

Large, white matter tract often associated with efficiency of information processing

Page 58: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

. Segmentation of the corpus callosum (A), in which some

portions (1, 4 and 5) exhibited the general PAE effect (B). 1:

Anterior, 2: Mid-Anterior, 3: Central, 4: Mid-Posterior, 5:

Posterior.

Chen, et al., (2008) Systematic Investigation of Volume

Changes Induced by Prenatal Alcohol Exposure in Cortical

and Sub-cortical Regions, in review

Effects of Prenatal Alcohol Exposure on Corpus Callosum Volume

Page 59: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

LI, Coles, Lynch, & Hu, Human Brain Mapping, 2009

Page 60: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Interhemispheric Transfer of Information Authors:

P. Santhanam1, X. Hu1, S.J. Peltier1, Z. Li1, C.D. Coles2, M.E. Lynch2

Experimental Design:

7 dysmorphic PAE, 7 non-dysmorphic PAE, 7 Controls: 20-24 yrs old from longitudinal cohort

PAE: identified by reported alcohol consumption by mother during pregnancy

Page 61: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Results: ‘Same’ Condition

Controls Non-Dys PAE Dys PAE

Controls Non-Dys PAE Dys PAE

Left hand

response to

Same side

stimulation

(LS)

Right hand

response to

Same side

stimulation

(RS)

No significant difference seen between groups in the „same‟ condition

Page 62: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Results: ‘Opposite’ ConditionControls Non-Dys PAE Dys PAE

Controls Non-Dys PAE Dys PAE

Left hand

response to

Opposite side

stimulation (LO)

Right hand

response to

Opposite side

stimulation (RO)

Significant difference between Dys-PAE and Control groups in

primary motor (arrows) and premotor areas

Significant difference between Dys-PAE and Control groups in premotor area

Page 63: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Skeletonized FA difference between Control and Non-Dysmorphic PAE groups (green=skeleton, purple=anatomically defined ROI, pink=region of significant difference). Similar differences were seen between control and dysmorphic PAE groups. Santhanam, et al, 2009, in preparation.

Using TBSS for DTI analysis, voxel-wise statistics on the skeletonized FA data reveal subregions of the cingulum with significantly lower FA values in both PAE groups versus control subjects.

Page 64: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Caudate

Pallidum Putamen

AmygdalaHippocampus

Page 65: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Trial by Group

F(4,553)=2.3,

p<.006

Con vs Dys,

p<.03

vs EtOH,

<.08

Page 66: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Verbal Selective Reminding-Total Recall (N=82)

Trial by Group

F(4,539)=1.65,

p=.06

Con vs Dys,

p<.01

vs EtOH,

NS

Page 67: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Mediation Model

Assumptions:

1. Memory function is affected by prenatal alcohol exposure

2. Memory deficits are the result of alterations in brain associated with prenatal alcohol exposure

3. Regions of brain showing volumetic reductions in alcohol affected individuals will be found to mediate memory performance.

Page 68: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Alternate Hypotheses

Direct effect Mediated effect

EtOH

Brain Volume

Recall EtOH

Brain Volume

Recall

IV must be related to DV; IV must be related to Mediator; Mediator must be related to DV.

If mediated, adding Mediator to equation must significantly reduced IV-DV correlation.

Page 69: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Hippocampus Mediates effects of Alcohol Exposure

Dysmorphia Score

Spatial Learning

Slope

HippocampalVolume

b=-.03, SEb=.02, β=-.18,p<.10, ns

b=-56.6, SEb=.14.62 β=.38,p<.000

b=.000, SEb=.00, β=.26,p<.017

Page 70: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Overall Conclusions: Alcohol

Evidence for persistent, global deficits even when SES and post natal environment accounted for.

In addition to global deficits, there may be specific cognitive problems in the following areas: Motor functioning, visual spatial skills, math, memory.

MRI (and fMRI) suggest neurological basis for behavioral findings.

Page 71: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Cocaine

Page 72: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Weight over first 8 years

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Birth I year 2 years 8 years

Cocaine

Control

EBD

P

o

u

n

d

s

Child’s Age

Page 73: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Mental Development Standard Scores and Cocaine Exposure

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

1 year 2 years 8 years

Cocaine

Control

EBD

Standard

Score

BSID MDI DAS

Page 74: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

CBCL Summary T-Scores at

8 Years

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Total Externalizing Internalizing Sex Problems

Cocaine Control Behavior

T-Scores * *

* p<.000

* *

Page 75: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Slope of Skin Conductance Level During Stressors

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

Controls Cocaine BD

Kable, Coles, Lynch, & Platzman (2008) Physiological responses to social and cognitive challenges in 8-year olds with a history of prenatal cocaine exposure. Dev Psychobiol 50, 251-265.

Page 76: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Conclusions

The BD group demonstrated elevated heart rate across all conditions but no differences in change in HR as a function of stress

The BD group demonstrated a pattern of “hypo-responsiveness to stressors”

The cocaine group demonstrated a pattern of “hyper-responsiveness to stressors”

Page 77: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Linda Mayes’ Neurochemical Regulatory Switch Hypothesis Cocaine alters reuptake of monoamines

(Norepinephrine, dopamine, & serotonin)

Neural regions involved in gating regulation of arousal by mesolimbic systems and prefrontal cortex involving executive mediation of arousal disrupted to that set point of the neurochemical regulatory switch is altered making cocaine-exposed children vulnerable to hyperarousal responses

Page 78: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Bilateral Amygdala area(brain images) comparing activation between Cocaine exposed and Controls (bar graphs). Activation level is the produce of mean regression coefficient (representing the fMRI signal amplitude) and number of activated voxels in the ROI (representing the activation volume). With “NEU0” value as the baseline (zero). The error bars represent standard error.

Prenatal cocaine exposure and emotional arousal in adolescents: Neuroimaging and N-Back task

Li, Coles, Lynch, Hamann, Peltier, LsConte and Hu, (2008, submitted) Prenatal cocaine exposure alters emotional arousal regulation and its effects on working memory. In Review

Page 79: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Left dorsal lateral prefrontal area(brain images) and the activation amount comparison between groups (bar graphs). As in the previous slide, there is an interaction between Condition (Neuo.Neg) and Exposure Group.

Cocaine exposed adolescents do not show the usual balance between cognitive and emotional arousal

Page 80: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Cocaine does not have the same teratogenic effect as alcohol

No effects on growth

No effects on cognition

What about behavior?

It may affect psychophysiology (that is, arousal and attention).

Psychophysiology may interaction with environmental factors to produce developmental psychopathology.

Page 81: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

MATERNAL SMOKING: DEVELOPMENTAL CONSEQUENCES

•Behavior Disturbances

•Language Development

•Medical Consequences

Page 82: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Medical Consequences

Lower Birthweight

SGA

Increased weight as older children and adults

Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS)

Respiratory problems in infancy

Asthma or aggravation of asthma symptoms

Otitis Media

Page 83: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Studies of Behavior Problems Following Maternal Tobacco Use During Gestation

Reports of ADHD

Criminal Behavior in Young Adults (Brennan, Grekin,

& Mednick, 1999, Maternal smoking during pregnancy and adult male criminal outcomes. Arch Gen Psychia 56, 215.)

Developmental Psychopathology (Wakschlag,

Lahey, Loeber, Green, Gordon, & Leventhal (1997). Maternal smoking during pregnancy and the risk of conduct disorder in boys. Archives of General Psychiatry, 54(7), 670-6.)

Page 84: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Auditory Processing and Language Development Fried (1998) Cigarette smoke exposure and

hearing loss, JAMA, 280, 963

Fried, O’Connell, Watkinson (1992) 60 and 72 month follow-up of children prenatally exposed to marijuana, cigarettes, and alcohol: Cognitive and language assessment. J Dev Beh Peds, 13, 383

Fried, Watkinson, & Siegel (1997) Reading and language in 9 to 12-year olds prenatally exposed to cigarettes and marijuana. Neurtox Teratol, 14, 299.

Page 85: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Previous Links Between Maternal Smoking and Language Development

Early teratology studies found deficits in auditory habituation items of the Brazelton

Fried found deficits in language development among toddlers and preschoolers

Deficits in phonemic and phonetic processing in Middle Childhood

Fried: Suggested that prenatal tobacco smoke caused an auditory processing deficits

Page 86: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Emory Language Development Study

Proposed looking at auditory processing skills and language development in children of smokers between 6-months and 2-years Using:

Bayley Scales of Infant Development , 2nd, 3rd Ed Sequence Inventory of Communication Development

(SCID) Natural Language Protocol for assessing phonetic

expression (tapes to Georgia State) (15 & 24 mos) Parent report of language development (MacArthur

CDI) ABERs and Information Processing Paradigm

Page 87: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Early Language: % showing language delays on BSID Language Facet

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

% Language Delayed

Control

Low Dose

Hi Dose

*

*

* Linear trend,

p<.05

Page 88: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

CID/Words and Gestures: Number of Words Said and Understood

0

50

100

150

200

250

Said Understood

Control

Low Dose

Hi Dose

* *

*Linear trend, p<.006

Page 89: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Effects of Multiple Risk Factors

Poverty Disability

Behavior

Disorder

Prenatal exposure

Family

Dysfunction

Other drug Use

Genetics

Poor Schools

Inadequate Medical Care

Bias

Page 90: Maternal Substance Abuse, Child Development and … Count... · MATERNAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE, CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND DRUG ENDANGERED CHILDREN Claire D. Coles, Ph.D. 2010 Drug, DUI and

Conclusions

Parental Substance Abuse, perhaps, particularly abuse by mothers, affects child development.

Effects are seen across a broad range, including motor, cognitive, behavioral, social and academic functioning.

It is clear that there are teratogenic effects (direct effects of the substances); however, many problems are the results of environmental and social factors, as well.

Prevention and treatment are both necessary.