massive passive house: bringing deep energy savings to ... · rcw 19.27a.160 “…..residential...

83
1 Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to Multi-Family Buildings BUILDING ENCLOSURE DESIGN: STRATEGIES FOR ACHIEVING PASSIVE HOUSE PERFORMANCE FEBRUARY 5 & 6, 2019 PRESENTED BY DAN WHITMORE, CPHC Disclaimer: This presentation was developed by a third party and is not funded by WoodWorks or the Softwood Lumber Board.

Upload: others

Post on 12-Jun-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

1

Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to Multi-Family BuildingsBUILDING ENCLOSURE DESIGN: STRATEGIES FOR ACHIEVING PASSIVE HOUSE

PERFORMANCE

FEBRUARY 5 & 6, 2019

PRESENTED BY DAN WHITMORE, CPHC

Disclaimer: This presentation was developed by a third party and is not funded by WoodWorks or the Softwood Lumber Board.

Page 2: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

2

Passive House: Building Climate Action

Page 3: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

3

Passive House: Building Climate Action

Page 4: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Images: Seattle Times

Page 5: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Albert Righter & TittmannArchitects

“Here is one of the few effective keys to the Design problem: The ability of the Designer to recognise as many of the constraints as possible;

his willingness and enthusiasm for working within these constraints.”-Charles Eames

Page 6: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Keeping the Outside Out & the Inside In, Passively

Albert Righter & TittmannArchitects

Page 7: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Superior Interior Air Quality

Page 8: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Superior Interior Environmental Quality

Page 9: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Superior Energy Performance

Page 10: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

10 of 97

What to we need to deliver?

Building as a

System

• Keep the outside out

• Keep the inside in

• Keep the in-between healthy and stable

Page 11: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

11 of 97

What to we need to deliver?

Building as a

System

Control Heat

Control Moisture

Control Solar Gains

Control Air

Page 12: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

12 of 97

Page 13: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

13

Page 14: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

14

What is Passive House?

Engineering buildings to use ~ half the energy…

Page 15: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

15

What is Passive House?

Images: Onion Flats

Page 16: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Building Scienceand

Best Practices

• Building Form• Orientation

• Comprehensive management of • Heat• Air• Moisture

• Balanced Ventilation• Right-Sized and Very

Efficient Mechanical Systems

16

What is Passive House?

Page 17: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

17

Building Form

Page 18: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

18

Building Form

à 1:1 surface-floor ratio à Increase of 10%

Page 19: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

19

HeatAirMoisture

Page 20: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

20

Ventilation

condensation drain

exhaust

section

cold in

cold out warm in

exteriorexterior interior

warm out

2'6"

exhaust air

exhaust air

air intake

exhaust airsupply air

supply air

supply air

roof

level 6

level 5

// zehnder comfoair 550

plan

2'10" 1'8"

2'2"

10"

Page 21: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

21

Efficient Mechanical Systems

Page 22: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

22

What is Passive House?

Page 23: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

phius.org

23

passivehouse.com

Page 24: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

24Passive House Toolkit - PHIUS

WUFI - Passive

Page 25: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

25Passive House Toolkit - PHI

PHPP

Page 26: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

26

àRule #1: Primum Non Nocere

Do No Harm

Passive House: Delivery is in the Details

Control Moisture

Page 27: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

27

Page 28: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Control Functions & Critical Barriers

Page 29: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Site Climate - Wetting Risk with Drying Potential

Page 30: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve
Page 31: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

31

Image: REACH CDC

Page 32: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Massive Opportunities

---------1 – 12”

-----------12 – 24”

------------Over 24”

ü

Massive Possibilities

Page 33: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Potential Possibilities

àEnclosure to usable area ratio

àCentralized mechanical systems

àBuilding

à Formà Details

àCommercial systems

à Envelopeà Product deliveryà Quality Control

àLong-term value 2nd & Delaware, Kansas City, MO

Photo: Chris Benedict, RA

Page 34: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

34

Photo: REACH CDC

Break!

Page 35: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Passive House Enclosure Mantra

1. Super-Insulated

2. Air-Tight

3. Thermal Bridge Free

Photo: Walsh Const.

Page 36: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

1: Super-Insulated

Page 37: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Just Enough

In ALL the right places

Page 38: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Starting Points: Effective R & U-Values

Windows & Doors

Floor Wall Roof

Mid-Atlantic U-0.20 to 0.24

R-12 (slab) R-24 to 30 R-40 to 60

North East U-0.18 to 0.22

R-16 (slab)R-30

(suspended)

R-28 to 32 R-50

Pacific NorthWest

U-0.18 to 0.24

R-12 (slab)R-30

(suspended)

R-26 to 30 R-50

• >20,000ft2

• ‘Good Form’• <35% Window to Wall Ratio

Page 39: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Effective R-Value

Page 40: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

40

Page 41: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

41Photo: Walsh Const.

Page 42: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

42

Page 43: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

2: Air -Tight

Page 44: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Why the Air Barrier is so important

Page 45: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

But Passive House is a different level

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

0123456789

1011121314151617181920

1945 1955 1965 1975 1985 1995 2005 2015

Airt

ight

ness

[cfm

/ft²

@ 7

5 Pa

]

Airt

ight

ness

[L/(

s.m²)

@ 7

5 Pa

]

Construction of Building [year]

Airtightness Vs Year of Construction of All Buildings

Sample of 179 Buildings

Airtightness versus Year of Construction

Page 46: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

2: Air –Tight: Massive How?

Design InstallationQC & Testing

Page 47: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Delivery is in the Details

Page 48: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Delivery is in the Details

Page 49: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Which Material???

Page 50: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

50

**** An Air Barrier is not a product but is a system of products installed over an array of materials

****

Page 51: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

What materials have worked?

Generally Air-tight

à Structural Concrete

à Engineered Lumber

à Air Sealing Tapes

à Building Sealants

à Polyethylene sheet

à SASM

Usually Air-Tight

à Plywood

à OSB

à Sheet Membranes

à Fluid-Applied Barriers

Page 52: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

What materials are subject to failure?

à Unreinforced Concrete, esp flatwork

à Mechanically fastened membranes

à WRB Tapes

à Some roofing underlayments

à Spray foam (open and closed-cell)

à Standard Entry Doors

Likely to fail

à Dimensional lumber

à CMU and masonry à Drywall

à Emergency Egress Entry Doors

à Wishful thinkingà ???

May work

Page 53: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

53

**** An Air Barrier is not a product but is a system of products installed over an array of materials

by a series of individuals ****

Page 54: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Sequencing is a part of detailing

Page 55: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

55

**** An Air Barrier is not a product but is a system of products installed over an array of materials

by a series of individuals and it’s integrity must be confirmed by a knowledgeable individual ****

Page 56: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Preliminary Testing

Page 57: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

57

-if you wait,

you’re too late

Page 58: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

58

Pax Futura ApartmentsPhoto: Vivian Usu

Page 59: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

1st test: 0.013 cfm/ft2 @75Pa !!!

Page 60: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

3: Thermal-Bridge “Free”

à Exterior Insulation Attachments

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Fiberglass Clip No Through Screws

Stainless Steel Screws

Fiberglass Clip SS Screws

Galvanized Screws

Fiberglass Clip Galv. Screws

Isolated…

Stainless Steel Clip

Intermittent…

Aluminum T-Clip

Continuous…

Continuous…

Page 61: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

“If you must build something stupid, for

God’s sake, build it with

wood.”~ Scott Kennedy

Cornerstone Architecture

Page 62: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

62

And when it’s not of wood,

be diligent

Page 63: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

63

Continuous shelf angles~50% R-value loss

Shelf angle on stand-offsonly ~15% R-value loss

Page 64: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve
Page 65: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

65

-Passive House Process: ”But how is this going to affect me?”

Page 66: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

66

-Passive House Process

”But how is this going to affect me?”

Page 67: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

67

-Passive House Process: ”But how is this going to effect my

projects?”

Design and Development

PROPOSED WINDOW MODIFICATIONS

Original Window Layout Suggested Revision for Passive House

Page 68: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

68

-Passive House Process: ”But how is this going to effect my

projects?”

Design and Development

Page 69: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

69

-Passive House Process: ”But how is this going to effect my

projects?”

Design and Development

1. Design Development

Feasibility and Preliminary Studies

2. Design Stage Review

Comprehensive review of a complete submission.

Page 70: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

70

-Passive House Process: ”But how is this going to effect my

projects?”

DeliveryPhotos: Walsh Construction and RDH

Page 71: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

71

-In our immediate

future: Passive House

and Oregon Energy Code

Executive Order No. 17-20“…to establish an aggressive timeline to achieve net zero energy

ready buildings as standard practice in buildings across the state.”

Image: Weber Thompson Architects

Page 72: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

72

-In our immediate

future: Passive House

and Energy Code

RCW 19.27a.160“…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under

the 2031 state energy code must achieve a seventy percent reduction in annual net energy consumption, using the adopted

2006 Washington state energy code as a baseline.”

Image: Weber Thompson Architects

Page 73: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

73

-In our immediate

future: Passive House

and Energy Code

RCW 19.27a.160“…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under

the 2031 state energy code must achieve a seventy percent reduction in annual net energy consumption, using the adopted

2006 Washington state energy code as a baseline.”

Page 74: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

MASSIVE PASSIVEin the Pacific

Northwest

ORCHARDS AT ORENCO Phase IIHillsboro

REACH CDCAnkron-Moison ArchitectureWalsh COnstruction

Page 75: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

MUNICIPAL PASSIVE HOUSEFIRE HALL 17Vancouver

City of VancouverHCMA Architecture

Page 76: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

BRECHIN REDEVELOPMENTNanaimo

Church & 74 rental aptsVIA Architecture

Page 77: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

77

SKEENA DORM Six stories, 220 roomsUBC Okanagan

UBC Properties TrustPublic Architecture

Page 78: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

THE HEIGHTS85-unit market rentalVancouver

8th Avenue Development Cornerstone ArchitecturePeak Construction Group

Page 79: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

Solis45-unit Market-Rate CondominiumsSeattle

Weber-Thompson ArchitectsSolterra DevelopmentCascade Built

Page 80: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

PASSIVE HOUSE PORTFOLIO

320 Queen Anne

Nicholson Kovalchick Architects / nkarch.com

Page 81: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

1488 ALBERNI48 storeys, 490 unitsVancouver

Landa GlobalAsia Standard AmericasRobert A.M. Stern ArchitectsMusson Cattell Mackey

Page 82: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

82

-If you wait,

you’re too late

Passive House: Building Climate Action-Don’t wait

Page 83: Massive Passive House: Bringing Deep Energy Savings to ... · RCW 19.27a.160 “…..residential and nonresidential construction permitted under the 2031 state energy code must achieve

83

Discussion + Questions

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION PLEASE VISIT

à www.rdh.com à www.buildingsciencelabs.com

OR CONTACT US AT

à [email protected]