malvolio's yellow stockings: coding illicit sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled...

13
Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in Early Modem London LOREEN L. GIESE In her survey of the symboUsm of yellow for apparel in early modem En- gland, M. Channing Linthicum argues that "Certainly, yellow was not lim- ited to the costume of one type or condition of person" ("Malvolio," 93). So too, stockings in this period were also not limited since they varied in terms of material, design, color, and usage. As Joan Thirsk points out, "many dif- ferent kinds of stockings were made to suit all purses and purposes" ("Fan- tastical," 59).' Nevertheless, the wearing of yellow stockings had particular resonance, as two well-known usages suggest. The wearing of yellow stock- ings may be most commonly associated with two contexts: the children at Christ's Hospital, which opened in 21 November 1552 and was officially founded on 26 June 1553, and the dramatic figure MalvoUo in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night, the first performance of which was 6 January 1601/2. Indeed, evidence of this sartorial practice from other literary and legal texts supple- ments and refines our understanding of their meaning by indicating the sexual symbolism of wearing yellow stockings in early modem London. Specifi- cally, this evidence indicates that some early modem Londoners understood the wearing of yellow stockings to signal illicit sexuality and marital betrayal. While precisely when the children at Christ's Hospital started wearing yel- low stockings remains hazy, the use of this sartorial practice by Shake- speare's Malvolio is easier to date.^ In act 2, scene 5 of Twelfth Night, while Malvolio fantasizes about being "Count Malvolio . . . sitting in my state . . . in my branched velvet gown, having come from a day-bed, where I have left Olivia sleeping . . . telhng them I know my place, as I would they should do theirs" (35-54),^ he leams of Ohvia's supposed desire for this attire in the letter Maria dropped to bait him: If this fall into thy hand, revolve. In my stars I am above thee, but be not afraid of greatness. Some are bom great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thmst upon'em. Thy fates open their hands, let thy blood and spirit embrace them, and to inure thyself to what thou art like to be, cast thy humble slough, and appear fresh. Be opposite with a kinsman, surly with servants. Let thy tongue tang argu- 235

Upload: hacong

Post on 26-May-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding IllicitSexuality in Early Modem London

LOREEN L. GIESE

In her survey of the symboUsm of yellow for apparel in early modem En-gland, M. Channing Linthicum argues that "Certainly, yellow was not lim-ited to the costume of one type or condition of person" ("Malvolio," 93). Sotoo, stockings in this period were also not limited since they varied in termsof material, design, color, and usage. As Joan Thirsk points out, "many dif-ferent kinds of stockings were made to suit all purses and purposes" ("Fan-tastical," 59).' Nevertheless, the wearing of yellow stockings had particularresonance, as two well-known usages suggest. The wearing of yellow stock-ings may be most commonly associated with two contexts: the children atChrist's Hospital, which opened in 21 November 1552 and was officiallyfounded on 26 June 1553, and the dramatic figure MalvoUo in Shakespeare'sTwelfth Night, the first performance of which was 6 January 1601/2. Indeed,evidence of this sartorial practice from other literary and legal texts supple-ments and refines our understanding of their meaning by indicating the sexualsymbolism of wearing yellow stockings in early modem London. Specifi-cally, this evidence indicates that some early modem Londoners understoodthe wearing of yellow stockings to signal illicit sexuality and marital betrayal.

While precisely when the children at Christ's Hospital started wearing yel-low stockings remains hazy, the use of this sartorial practice by Shake-speare's Malvolio is easier to date.^ In act 2, scene 5 of Twelfth Night, whileMalvolio fantasizes about being "Count Malvolio . . . sitting in my state . . .in my branched velvet gown, having come from a day-bed, where I have leftOlivia sleeping . . . telhng them I know my place, as I would they should dotheirs" (35-54),^ he leams of Ohvia's supposed desire for this attire in theletter Maria dropped to bait him:

If this fall into thy hand, revolve. In my stars I am above thee, but be not afraid ofgreatness. Some are bom great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatnessthmst upon'em. Thy fates open their hands, let thy blood and spirit embrace them,and to inure thyself to what thou art like to be, cast thy humble slough, and appearfresh. Be opposite with a kinsman, surly with servants. Let thy tongue tang argu-

235

Page 2: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

236 LOREEN L. GIESE

ments of state; put thyself into the trick of singularity. She thus advises thee, thatsighs for thee. Remember who commended thy yellow stockings, and wished to seethee ever cross-gartered: I say, remember. Go to, thou art made, if thou desir'st tobe so. If not, let me see thee a steward still, the fellow of servants, and not worthyto touch Fortune's fingers. Farewell. She that would alter services with thee.(2.5.143-58)"

The letter confirms Malvolio's own suspicions, as he comments on the stock-ings: "She did commend my yellow stockings of late, she did praise my legbeing cross-gartered, and in this she manifests herself to my love, and with akind of injunction drives me to these habits of her liking" (2.5.166-70).'

The scholarly debate about the meaning attached to the color of Malvolio'sstockings in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night is more varied than for the childrenat Christ's Hospital. Yet, in the many discussions of Malvolio, surprisinglymany readers do not comment on the apparel OUvia supposedly requests,leaving the particular color of his stockings to "what you will." Of those fewscholars who do address the color of Malvolio's stockings, some, for in-stance, attempt to contextualize the color with respect to contemporary atti-tudes to yellow. Leshe Hotson, for example, interprets this issue within thecontext of contemporary politics: "Queen Elizabeth (whose own personalcolours were white and black) abhorred yellow. For six years yellow hadbeen the colour of danger in her Court—being fiaunted by the faction of theDuke of Norfolk until his attainder and execution in 1572. And the fiag ofher arch-enemy, Spain, was yellow" (113). Because yellow stockings couldalso suggest marital status, J. M. Lothian and T. W. Craik, the editors of theArden Twelfth Night, note the incongruity of Malvoho wearing yellow stock-ings—which they identify as the attire of the " 'jolly young bachelor'" (71)—when he so clearly desires not to be a bachelor, but to be "Count Malvolio"by marrying up the social hierarchy.*

However, other readers interpret the color with respect to the dramatic con-texts. Terence Hawkes, for example, sees them as part of the "camivalesqueregalia" (172), while C. L. Barber comments that they are "part of the ven-geance taken . . . to make him try to be festive" (255). Rodney StenningEdgecombe argues that the yellow stockings are part of an outfit, which sug-gests that Malvolio is "translated" into an insect, specifically a "wasp" (200).Yet other readers of the play argue that the color of his stockings indicatesthe love for himself and Ohvia. Alexander Leggatt calls the stockings part of"the external shows of love" (245), while Cristina Malcolmson maintainsthey are indicative of Malvoho's "self-love" (48). Linthicum's position onwhy Malvoho's stockings are yellow points in the direction of what contem-porary literary and legal evidence suggests. While she notes that "Yellow inhose or footwear had three meanings in drama: love, marriage, and jealousyafter marriage," she concludes that "Malvolio's yellow hose of course indi-cate love" (Costume, 48).

Page 3: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

MALVOLIO'S YELLOW STOCKINGS 237

Other Uterary works employ the symbol of yellow hose as well. The topicof marital relationships and yellow hose appears in a contemporary balladentered in the Stationers' Register in 1586 entitled a "Merry Jest of JohnTomson and Jakaman his wife, / Whose jealousy was justley the cause of alltheir strife." Unlike Linthicum—who notes this ballad in her study of yellowbut does not interpret it as a key to Malvoho's sartorial practice—Hotson andJames O. Wood point to it as a gloss on Malvolio's jealousy. Hotson, forinstance, identifies yellow as "the proper wear for jealous-foolish husbands"(113).^ However, rather than yellow hose denoting a jealous husband in theballad, they seem to signal a husband's desire to return to bachelorhood andhis wife's jealousy. As the opening verse of the ballad states:

When I was a BatchelourI liv'd a merry life;

But now I am a married man,and troubled with a wife,

I cannot doe as I have done,because I live in feare;

If I goe but to Islington,my wife is watching there.

Give me my yellow hose againe,give me my yellow hose;

For now my wife she watcheth me—see, yonder! where she goes.

(Roxburghe, 2:137)

This explanation of the man's wearing of the yellow hose as a marker of hisdesire to be a bachelor again follows all eighteen verses. Additionally, in oneverse, the jealous wife dons the yellow stockings as well:

For yellow love is too-too bad,without all wit or pollicie;

And too much love hath made her mad,and fiU'd her full of jealousie.

Shee thinkes I am in love with thoseI speake to, passing by;

That makes her weare the yellow hoseI gave her for to dye.

(Roxburghe, 2:Ul)

Wood interprets the wearing of yellow stockings by the wife in this ballad(along with another instance included in Thomas Dekker's IIHonest Whore)in terms of domestic jealousies. According to Wood, the yellow-stockingedwife in the ballad serves "as a possible prototype for Malvolio, the hoveringspoilsport woman in yellow stockings" (14).

Page 4: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

238 LOREEN L. GIESE

Other early modem literary and legal evidence contributes further to theunderstanding of wearing yellow stockings as a signal of jealousy and illicitsexuality by pointing to its gendered meaning. More specifically writers usethis device in order to show that private matters have been exposed to pubhcscrutiny. In this context, a wife dons yellow hose in order to signal the ilUcitsexual practices of her husband. One early modem lyric, c. 1550, reprintedin Sir John Hawkins's A General History of the Science and Practice ofMusic (3:39), suggests the possible threat to a husband if his wife wears yel-low stockings:

I.The bachelor most joyfullye,

In pleasant plight dotfi passe his daies.Good fellowshipp and companie

He doth maintaine and kepe alwaie.

n.With damsells braue he maye well goe.The maried man cannot doe so.If he be merie and toy with any.His wife will frowne, and words geue manye.

Her yellow hose she strait will put on.So that the married man dare not displease his wife Joane.

(Hawkins, 3:37-38)

This lyric indicates that wives could both reveal and disguise the infidelity oftheir husbands and their own consciousness of that infidelity. In this context,they could conceal the stockings beneath their long skirts, but reveal, at anymoment, a sign that they are aware of their husbands' extramarital activities.This lyric not only provides a literary instance assigning meaning to thewearing of yellow stockings, but also makes clear that the practice was sowell known so as to be used in popular culture.

The practice of wearing yellow stockings as a pubhc nonverbal marker ofa husband's adulterous activity, exposing him and his behavior to publicscmtiny and ridicule, reverses the usual direction of pubhc humiliation. Un-like husbands of unfaithful wives, who were conventionally made the butt ofhumor by their wives' behavior, a betrayed wife could, by wearing yellowstockings, both expose her husband and make him the object of public levity.Thus, this lyric illustrates one way in which wearing yellow stockings canserve as a marker of female cuckoldry.

London Consistory Court deposition evidence points to a similar culturalmeaning for the wearing of yellow stockings. In a deposition repeated beforethe London Consistory Court on 4 November 1597, from a defamation suit,one of the witnesses, Agnes Lambert, exposes a contemporary understanding

Page 5: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

MALVOLIO'S YELLOW STOCKINGS 239

of yellow stockings as a garment wom to signal a wife's jealousy and herknowledge of her husband's iUicit sexual activities. In this case brought byJohn Crosbie against Roger Johnson and Elizabeth Page, Johnson, the defen-dant, instmcted John Crosbie's wife, Joan, to "putt on . . . [her] yealowehose," since her husband has dallied with her maids and even kissed herdaughter while Joan was working. Agnes, aged thirty-four or thirty-five, aservant to the plaintiff John Crosbie, testified that:

as she this deponent was standing by her mistris the wief of tharricwlate John Cros-bie in her shopp in the blakfryers tiiaiticulate Roger Johnson . . . (who dwelleth inthe next howse to her this deponentei maister John Crosbie) Came into the shoppwhear she this deponent and her mistris was and sayd unto John Crosbies wief. . .theis worde,y or to the like effect Joane thou sittest scraping here in thy shopp andthy husband within . . . a playing with your mayde^ for I sawe* him take upp thydawghter Sara in the yard and . . . kisse her therfore thou maist . . . goe in and putton thy yealowe hose againe.

"Againe" suggests that Joan has wom yellow hose before in similar circum-stances; however, this passage is the only one in the extant testimony fromthis lawsuit that includes a suggestive reference to wearing yellow hose. ThatAgnes's mistress Joan Crosbie has wom the hose for the same reason beforethis incident is in keeping with the rest of the case still, for the claim of defa-mation does not center on this particular incident between the daughter andher stepfather, but on another, later encounter. Robert Garland testified thatElizabeth Page told Johnson that, while looking through "a little Crevis of awall or a pale out of . . . his the same Johnsons howse into John Crosbieshowse," she saw John Crosbie "kneehng before [Sara] in his kitchen . . . takeupp h[er] Clothes above her knees and ther with his hand . . . feele and gropeher" (DL/C/215/440.

In the case of Crosbie v. Johnson and Page, the deposition does not posethe wearing of yellow hose as a threat to the husband, as in the lyric recordedby Hawkins. Nevertheless, the fact that the wife of the lawsuit has wom thehose before, in similar circumstances, in order to expose her husband's illicitbehavior to pubhc scmtiny, indicates that such humiliation did not work suf-ficiently well enough to stop his behavior. In this passage, Johnson suggeststhat the wife take action by putting on her yellow hose in reaction to herhusband's extramarital activities. In addition, the deposition clearly suggeststhe shame, embarrassment, or betrayal that a wife could experience in suchcircumstances; and it is unclear as to whether Johnson's report is meant to behelpful to Joan Crosbie or to embarrass her. Moreover, Agnes Lambert's useof the verb "maist" (in that Joan "maist . . . goe in and putt on . . . [her]yealowe hose") suggests that the decision to do so is hers. However, if shechooses to do so, wearing the hose will not only call attention to her hus-band's illicit sexual behaviors but also serve as her own personal admission

Page 6: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

240 LOREEN L, GIESE

of betrayal. Yet despite the ambiguities in Lambert's testimony, the case sug-gests a larger cultural understanding of wearing yellow hose, which mightwell have been famihar to playgoers in early modem London.

Knowledge of the ways in which this coded behavior functioned in earlymodem London helps to open up the meaning of Malvolio's wearing of yel-low hose. Reading his sartorial practice in light of other literary and legalevidence both satirizes and subverts his desire for social and sexual domi-nance. Some scholars, particularly John Astington and Edward Cahill, offerprovocative studies regarding the "unresolved mascuhne identity" of Mal-volio (Cahill, 79). While Cahill does not include Malvolio's clothing in hisdiscussion, Astington ties part of Malvolio's attire into his discussion on themocking of Malvolio's "sexual ambition and incapacity" (32). Consequentlyhe sees the cross-gartering as indicative of Malvolio's impotent sexuality al-though he does not discuss the color of Malvolio's stockings in his reading.Similarly, Dympna Callaghan argues that "Malvolio's cross-gartering, his'transvestism' is, then, structurally and symbolically related to gender inver-sion" (433), but she does not tie in the color of his stockings as part of this"gender inversion.""* John W. Draper's comments on the color of the stock-ings relate to Malvolio's misdirected class aspirations. After noting that"About 1600, Malvolio's yellow stockings" seem to have a "plebeian conno-tation" (93) in that "Yellow stockings seem to have been the sign manual ofa boorish country yeoman" (94), he argues that Maria's urging of MalvoUoto wear yellow stockings embarrasses him with respect to his desire to be-come "Count Malvoho." Draper writes: "Malvolio then, in the very act ofhis social apotheosis, is gulled into donning the habiUments, partly of thehumble yeomanry whence he seems to have sprung, and partly of the house-hold servitor, the very class from which he is trying to escape" (94).

The above-mentioned contemporary legal and literary evidence informsthe wearing of yellow stockings with a different and previously undetectedsymbolic irony in alluding to both sexuality and sexual roles. As the lyricrecorded by Hawkins suggests, wearing yellow stockings can empower thewife whose husband engages in iUicit sexual activities by exposing him toridicule. In Shakespeare's Twelfth Night, Maria's letter to Malvolio suggeststhat wearing yellow stockings will empower Malvolio in his love suit forOlivia. In addition, as both the Lambert deposition and lyric suggest, wearingyellow stockings can serve as a tacit admission of having been betrayed. Inthat case, the stockings can be seen in the context of Twelfth Night as a sym-bol of Malvolio's betrayed affections. After all, Olivia woos Cesario, notMalvolio.

Of course, rather than empowering Malvoho in his love suit for Olivia,wearing the yellow stockings disempowers him and renders him symbohcallyimpotent. First of all, as Maria points out they are a color that Olivia "ab-hors" (2.5.200). But, the shame that Malvolio experiences in front of Olivia,

Page 7: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

MALVOLIO'S YELLOW STOCKINGS 241

while wearing the yellow stockings, fits in with the pranksters' plan to exposehim. Second, even if one interprets MalvoUo's stockings as exposing his be-trayal by Olivia, this interpretation still presents Malvoho as shamed. He be-comes caught up in a kind of role and gender reversal that ultimately behttleshim. After all, it was wives who wore yellow stockings as an admission of ahusband's betrayal. When Malvolio wears them, he takes on the role of thewife, not the dominant role—whether socially, domestically, or sexually—that he desires. The failure of this desire becomes fully visualized in act 3,scene 4 when Malvolio, parading in front of Ohvia in his yellow stockings,offers to "thrust" his "greatness upon her." Her response is hardly the onehe desired. Rather, the stockings help to convince Olivia that Malvolio ismad, a belief that ultimately results in his being incarcerated. Thus, an audi-ence such as Shakespeare's, with such a cultural understanding of this mean-ing of wearing yellow hose, would have appreciated more fully the way thepranksters' plan satirizes and subverts Malvolio's desire for sexual domina-tion. Instead, his yellow stockings communicate subservience and embarrass-ment.

The threads of evidence provided by contemporary legal and hterary textsexamined here weave a richly textured, well-knit fabric indicating the com-plexities associated with the symbolic language of yellow stockings. As theAmerican song suggests, "in olden days, a glimpse of stocking was looked onas something shocking"—and never more so than in early modem London,especially if the stockings were yellow.

Notes

I wish to thank Susan Cerasano, Marsha Dutton, and Earl Knies for their generosityin reading drafts of this paper and offering insightful suggestions for its improvement.I also would like to thank Caroline M. Barron and Vanessa Harding for kindly invitingme to present a version of this paper at the Medieval and Tbdor London History Semi-nar, Institute of Historical Research, University of London, on 30 May 2002.1 greatlyappreciate the helpful suggestions of Professor Barron, Dr. Harding, and the seminarmembers. In addition, I wish to thank the staff at Christ's Hospital, particularly TraceyButler, Dot Mariner, and Rhona Mitchell, former archivist, and at the London Metro-politan Archives, especially Deborah Jenkins, Geoff Pick, Nicola Avery, Sally Bevan,and David Tennant. This project was completed with the kind assistance of MartinDevereux, Hazel Forsyth, Rhys Griffith, Sharon Huge, and Barbara Reeves. Researchfunding was generously provided by a National Endowment for the Humanities Sum-mer Stipend and the Baker Fund, Ohio University.

1. For more information on the making and wearing of stockings, see Carlo MarcoBelfanti, S. D. Chapman, Pauline Croft, A. W. Eley, F W. Fairholt, Jeremy Farrell,Milton and Anna Grass, James Robinson Planche, Richard Rutt, Kay Staniland, JoanThirsk, C. Willett and Phillis Cunnington, and David L. Wykes. In regard to yellow

Page 8: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

242 LOREEN L. GIESE

Stockings in the later sixteenth century, Willett and Cunnington point out that "Brightcolours were popular, and worn by all classes. Yellow was very common, also blue,red, green and violet" {Sixteenth, 124). Similarly, Thirsk conunents that in the six-teenth and seventeenth centuries stockings "could be yellow, red, green, blue or vio-let, as well as white, black or grey" ("Fantastical," 58). For discussions of the yellowstockings kept at Hatfield House, which are alleged to have belonged to Queen Eliza-beth, see, for example, Farrell, 10, and Rutt, 67.

2. Scholars identify different dates on which the students at Christ's Hospitalcommence wearing yellow stockings. Peter Bloomfield, Rosie Howard, and Pam Leg-ate in Christ's Hospital in the Year 2000 cite a date of 1553 as the beginning of thissartorial practice (205). However, in The Historic Dress of the English Schoolboy,Wallace Clare parenthetically notes that yellow stockings for Christ's Hospital chil-dren were "introduced in 1638" (12). For further discussions of this sartorial practice,see, for example, Eric Bennett, Alastair Bruce, 120; Phillis Cunnington and CatherineLucas, 289-304; Rosie Howard, Valentine Knapp, Carol Kazmierczak Manzione,E. H. Pearce, John Stow, 1:319; and William TroUope.

3. All citations to Twelfth Night are from the Arden Editon, ed. J. M. Lothian andT. W. Craik.

4. For discussions focusing on the cross-gartering, see John Gouws and James F.Forrest, who connect cross-gartering with Puritan attire. John Astington also focuseson the cross-gartering, but reaches a different conclusion: "his binding is a symbolicsign of his impotence, of his having been made a festival eunuch" (29). In light ofcontemporary usage, one could also see the color of his stockings as a demasculiniza-tion of Malvolio.

5. Some readers note the contradiction in Malvolio remembering that Olivia "didcommend my yellow stockings of late, she did praise my leg being cross-gartered"(2.5.166-68) and Maria's later comments that "lie will come to her in yellow stock-ings, and 'tis a colour she abhors, and cross-gartered, a fashion she detests" (2.5.198-200). Paul N. Siegel explains this apparent contradiction in terms of Malvolio's stateof mind: "Malvolio is so carried away, put 'in such a dream' (189) by the letter, thathe actually imagines remembering Olivia complimenting him on his yellow stockingsand cross-garters" (222).

6. Barbara Everett also notes that "Malvolio's investment in yellow stockingsmay bring with it all the by now (in 1601 or 2) accreted ambiguity of the fashionablecourtly love-romanticism, a mode always 'out of date', distasteful, to those of truerefinement and sensibility" (192). Some readers of the play point out that the colorsupports Malvolio as a Puritan. J. L. Simmons maintains that Malvolio "reveals him-self to be a Puritan both in the sober black attire and in the absurd yellow stockingsand crossed garters" (194). However, here Simmons suggests it is more the contrastin the colors than a behef connected with yellow that suggests Malvolio's religion.Siegel argues just the opposite in regard to this color reflecting Malvolio's Puritanism."The Puritans in their sedate sobriety objected to the showy new fashions of dress.Possibly, yellow stockings, also old-fashioned, were, therefore, one of the items inwhich they were not 'conformable' in their apparel and were, with cross-garters, partof their attire when they wished to appear in their best clothes" (222). Contrastingly,G. P. Jones notes that the stockings are "of an unpuritanically colorful hue" (23). In

Page 9: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

MALVOLIO'S YELLOW STOCKINGS 243

fact, Maria's later reference suggests that yellow indicates his heathenism, rather thanPuritanism: "Yond gull Malvolio is turned heathen, a very renegado; for there is noChristian that means to be saved by believing rightly can ever believe such impossiblepassages of grossness. He's in yellow stockings" (3.2.66-70).

7. Also see Wood, 11-15. For other discussions of this song in relation to TwelfthNight, see Hotson, 106; Linthicum, "Malvolio," 88; and Gustav Ungerer, 96-97.

8. In the manuscript an inkblot obscures the original word the scribe began towrite; sawe is inserted following the blot.

9. In the manuscript passages, ellipses mark omissions, and square brackets indi-cate my insertions.

10. Other readers who discuss Malvolio's sexuality include Jean E. Howard, RuthNevo, and Ungerer, but they do not connect the particular color of his stockings to hissexuality. In her discussion of clothing and sexual identity in early modem England,Howard comments on the shame that can result when a male wears female attire: "Fora man, wearing women's dress undermined the authority inherently belonging to thesuperior sex and placed him in a position of shame" (25). When she addresses theplay, she identifies the source of Malvolio's humiliation in terms of class aspirationsratiier than gender reversals and does not connect the particular color of his stockingsto her argument: "The class-jumper Malvolio, who dresses himself up in yellowstockings and cross garters, is savagely punished and humiliated, echoing the morecomically managed humiliation of Olivia, the woman who at the beginning of the playjumped gender boundaries to assume control of her house and person and refusedher 'natural' role in the patriarchal marriage market. The play disciplines independentwomen like Olivia and upstart crows such as Malvolio" (34-35). Nevo discusses thedisruption of sexual identity in Twelfth Night: "Sexual identity has been in some waydisordered, frustrated, displaced, diverted or deficient in every one of the chief drama-tis personae, and in the chief buffoon-imposter Malvolio" (214). However, she doesnot include Malvolio's stockings as part of that inversion. Nevo writes: "And Mal-volio strutting and preening and being unctuously coy in yellow stockings and crossgarters is doubly ludicrous to the extent that he is doubly deluded" (211). Ungererpoints to the references in the play in which dramatic figures identify Malvolio with awoman suggesting Malvolio's "sexual and moral perversion" (97).

Works Cited

Manuscript Sources

London Consistory Court Depositions, DL/C/215London Metropolitan Archives

Printed Sources

Astington, John. "Malvolio and the Eunuchs: Texts and Revels in Twelfth Night."Shakespeare Survey 46 (1993): 23-34.

Barber, C. L. Shakespeare's Eestive Comedy. 1959. Cleveland: Meridian, 1966.Belfanti, Carlo Marco. "Fashion and Innovation: The Origins of the Italian Hosiery

Page 10: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

244 LOREEN L. GIESE

Industry in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries." Textile History 27 (1996)-132-47.

Bennett, Eric. "The Beginnings." The Christ's Hospital Book. London: Hamish Ham-ilton, 1953. 3-15.

Bloomfield, Peter, Rosie Howard, and Pam Legate. Christ's Hospital in the Year 2000.Horsham, West Sussex: Christ's Hospital, 2001.

Bruce, Alastair. Keepers of the Kingdom; The Ancient Offices of Britain. London:Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1999.

Cahill, Edward. "The Problem of Malvolio." College Literature 23:2 (1996): 62-82.Callaghan, Dympna. " 'And all is semblative a woman's part'; body politics and

Twelfth Night." Textual Practice 7 (1993): 428-52.Chapman, S. D. "The Genesis of the British Hosiery Industry, 1600-1750." Textile

History 3 (1972): 7-50.Clare, Wallace. The Historic Dress ofthe English Schoolboy. London: Society for the

Preservation of Ancient Customs, n.d.Croft, Pauline. "The Rise of the English Stocking Export Trade." Textile History 18

(1987): 3-16.Cunnington, Phillis and Catherine Lucas. Charity Costumes of children, scholars; al-

msfolk, pensioners. New York: Barnes and Noble, 1978.Draper, John W. The Twelfth Night of Shakespeare's Audience. Stanford, Calif.: Stan-

ford University Press, 1950.Edgecombe, Rodney Stenning. "Shakespeare's Twelfth Night." Explicator 55 (1997):

200-202.Eley, A. W. Stockings; Silk, Cotton, Rayon, Nylon. Leicester: Hosiery Trade Journal

1953.Everett, Barbara. "Two Damned Cruces: Othello and Twelfth Night." RES n s 37

(1986): 184-97.Fairholt, F. W Costume in England: A History of Dress to the End ofthe Eighteenth

Century. 1885. 2 vols. Detroit: Singing Tree Press, 1968.Farrell, Jeremy. Socks and Stockings. London: B. T. Batsford, 1992.Forrest, James F. "Malvolio and Puritan 'Singularity.'" English Language Notes 11

(1974): 259-64.Fyfe, WiUiam Hamilton. "The Old Bluecoat School." The Bamwell Addresses. Ed.

John Louis Haney. Vol. 2. Philadelphia: Mary Gaston Bamwell Foundation, 1937.289-304.

Gouws, John. "Dressing Malvolio for the Part." Nand Q 38 (1991): 478-79.Grass, Milton and Anna. Stockings for a Queen: The Life ofthe Rev. William Lee, the

Elizabethan Inventor. 1967. Cranbury, New Jersey: A. S. Barnes and Co., 1969.Hawkes, Terence. "Comedy, Orality and Duplicity: Twelfth Night." Shakespeare's

Comedies. Ed. Gary Waller. London: Longman, 1991. 168-74.Hawkins, Sir John. A General History ofthe Science and Practice of Music. London-

T. Payne and Son, 1776.Hotson, Leshe. The First Night o/Twelfth Night. New York: Macmillan, 1954.Howard, Jean E. "Cross-Dressing, the Theater, and Gender Struggle in Early Modem

England." Crossing the Stage; Controversies on Cross-Dressing. Ed. Lesley FerrisLondon: Routledge, 1993. 20-46.

Page 11: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

MALVOLIO'S YELLOW STOCKINGS 245

Howard, Rosie. "The Uniform ofthe Boys of Christ's Hospital." Costume 35 (2001):82-91.

Jones, G. P. "Malvolio Flouted and Abused." English Language Notes 42 (2004):20-26.

Knapp, Valentine. "Blewe" Clothes of Christ's Hospital. London: Knapp, Drewettand Sons, 1928.

Leggatt, Alexander. Shakespeare's Comedy of Love. 1974. London: Methuen, 1983.Linthicum, M. Channing. Costume in the Drama of Shakespeare and His Contempo-

raries. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1936.. "Malvolio's Cross-Gartered Yellow Stockings." Modern Philology 25

(1927-28): 87-93.Malcolmson, Cristina. "'What You Will': Social Mobility and Gender in Twelfth

Night." The Matter of Difference: Materialist Feminist Criticism of Shakespeare.Ed. Valerie Wayne. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1991. 29-57.

Manzione, Carol Kazmierczak. Christ's Hospital of London, 1552-1598. Cranbury,N.J.: Associated University Press, 1995.

Nevo, Ruth. Comic Transformations in Shakespeare. London: Methuen, 1980.Pearce, E. H. Annals of Christ's Hospital. London: Methuen, 1901.Planche, James Robinson. A Cyclopaedia of Costume or Dictionary of Dress. 2 vols.

London: Chatto and Windus, 1876-79.Roxburghe Ballads. Vol. 2, part 1. New York: AMS Press, 1966.Rutt, Richard. A History of Hand Knitting. Loveland, Colo.: Interweave Press, 1987.Shakespeare, William. Twelfth Night. Ed. J. M. Lothian and T. W. Craik. Arden Edi-

tion. 1975. London: Routledge, 1994.Siegel, Paul N. "Malvolio: Comic Puritan Automaton." New York Literary Forum 5-6

(1980): 217-30.Simmons, J. L. "A Source for Shakespeare's Malvolio: The Elizabethan Controversy

with the Puritans." Huntington Library Quarterly 36 (1972-73): 181-201.Staniland, Kay. "Getting There, Got It: Archaeological Textiles and Tailoring in Lon-

don, 1330-1580." The Age of Transition; The Archaeology of English Culture,1400-1600. Ed. David Gaimster and Paul Stamper. Oxford: Oxbow Books, 1997.239-49.

Stow, John. A Survey of London. Ed. Charles Lethbridge Kingsford. 2 vols. Oxford:Clarendon Press, 1908.

Thirsk, Joan. Economic Policy and Projects: The Development of a Consumer Societyin Early Modem England. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1978.

. "The Fantastical Folly of Fashion: The English Stocking Knitting Industry,1500-1700." Textile History and Economic History: Essays in Honour of MissJulia de Lacy Mann. Ed. N. B. Harte and K. G. Ponting. Manchester: ManchesterUniversity Press, 1973. 50-73.

TroUope, William. A History ofthe Royal Foundation of Christ's Hospital. London:William Pickering, 1834.

Ungerer, Gustav. "'My Lady's a Catayan, We are Politicians, Maluolios a Peg-a-Ramsie."' Shakespeare Survey 32 (1979): 85-104.

Willett, C, and Phillis Cunnington. Handbook of English Costume in the SeventeenthCentury. 1955. London: Faber and Faber, 1963.

Page 12: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow

246 LOREEN L. GIESE

. Handbook of English Costume in the Sixteenth Century. London: Faber andFaber, 1954.

Wood, James O. '''Maluolios a Peg-a-Ramsie.'" English Language Notes 5 (1967):11-15.

Wykes, David L. "The Origins and Development of the Leicestershire HosieryTrade." Textile History 23 (1992): 23-54.

Page 13: Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: Coding Illicit Sexuality in ...home.uchicago.edu/~jorgea/untitled folder/Stockings.pdf · Malvolio's Yellow Stockings: ... the jealous wife dons the yellow