ieceu m6... · 2020. 2. 3. · d1.2 analy preventive impr d lead bene delivery da revision:...

D1.2 Analy

preventive

Impr

D

Lead bene

Delivery da

Revision:

Dissemin

PU: Publi

PP: Restr

RE: Restr

ysis of the c

activities

roving the

D1.2 Ana

eficiary:

ate:

nation Leve

c

ricted to oth

ricted to a g

current

e Effective

alysis o

Crisis

M6

6.0

el

her program

group specif

PRO

eness of C

of the cu

Manageme

mme particip

fied by the c

Public

OJECT TITL

Capabilitie

urrent p

ent Centre F

pants (includ

consortium

LE:

s (IEC) in

preventi

Finland (CM

ding the Co

(including t

S

EU conflic

ve activ

MC Finland)

mmission)

the Commis

Contract

Start date:

Duration:

ct prevent

vities

)

ssion)

IECEU

no 653371

01/05/2015

33 months

tion

X

5

s

Analysis of

T

Revision

Rev. D

1.0 0

2.0

3.0

4.0 0

5.0 2

Master 2

Master 2

Master 2

Master 2

Master 3

6.0 0

f the curren

This project has rece

n history

Date

03/07/2015

13/08/2015

14/08/2015

05/09/2015

2/10/2015

22/10/2015

27/10/2015

28/10/2015

29/10/2015

30/10/2015

09/10/2015

nt preventive

eived funding from the

Autho

5 CMCF

CMCF

CMCF

CMCF

CMCF

CMCF

CMCF

CMCFMänty

UNILJ

CMCF

LAU,

e activities

e European Union’s

or

Fi, J. Musto

Fi, J. Musto

Fi, J. Musto

Fi, J. Musto

Fi, J. Musto

Fi, J. Musto

Fi, J. Musto

Fi, J. Mustoymäki

JU, R. Zupa

Fi, J. Musto

K. Hyttinen

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

onen

onen

onen

onen

onen

onen

onen

onen & E.

ančič

onen

rch and innovation pr

Notes

Template c

Formulatinfirst texts: iavailable b

Inserting ch

Inserting chactivities by

Adding the

Inserting EConclusion

Incorporatiworkshop f

Final comm

Final comm

Finalisation

Final Versi

S

rogramme under gra

creation

g the contentroductiony 31 Augus

hapter on P

hapter 2 ony Rok

intro text

xecutive Suns -chapters

ng the survfindings

ments to the

ments to the

n of the deli

on to be su

CSA projeStart date:

Duration:

ant agreement No 653

ent, insertingn texts to best

PS by Arnold

n Preventive

ummary ands

vey and

e draft

e draft

iverable

ubmitted

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 2

g the e

d

e

d

5 s

2

Analysis of

T

Content

EXECUTIV

ACRONYM

1 INTROD

1.1 PREVE

1.2 STR

2 EU PREV

2.1 CUR

2.2 CHA

2.2.1 P

2.2.2 M

2.2.3 D

2.2.4 Cpreven

2.2.5 O

2.2.6 R

2.2.7 R

2.3 CON

3 POOLIN

3.1 INTR

3.2 DEF

3.3 POO

3.4 THE

3.5 CUR

3.6 CON

4. CONCL

BIBLIOGR

ANNEXES

f the curren


ts

VE SUMMA

MS

UCTION

ENTIVE AC

UCTURE O

VENTIVE A

RRENT PRE

ALLENGES

Planning an

Mandates

Deployment

Cooperationntion and cr

One nation’s

Relations be

Relations be

NCLUSION

G AND SHA

RODUCTIO

INITIONS A

OLING AND

FOUR LEV

RRENT DEB

NCLUSION

USIONS

RAPHY

S

nt preventive


ARY

CTIVITIES A

OF THE DE

ACTIVITIES

EVENTIVE

IN CSDP M

nd setting up

t

n of CSDPrisis manage

s or the EU

etween the

etween the

ARING WIT

N

AND FORM

SHARING

VELS OF P

BATES AND

e activities


AND CONFL

LIVERABLE

S AND CHA

INSTRUME

MISSIONS A

p a mission

P missions ement

’s mission o

CSDP miss

CSDP miss

THIN THE E

MS OF COO

WITHIN ED

OLITICAL R

D FUTURE

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

LICT PREV

E

ALLENGES

ENTS AND

AND OPER

or operatio

and operat

or operation

sion or oper

sion/operati

EU

OPERATION

DA

RISKS IN P

POSSIBILI


VENTION

AHEAD

ACTIVITIE

RATIONS: K

on

tions with o

n?

ration and “

ion and the

N

P&S

ITIES IN P&

S

rogramme under gra

S

KEY OBSER

other actors

Brussels”

local stake

&S


Duration:


RVATIONS

s involved

eholders

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 3

5

6

8

8

1

1

1

1

1

2

2

in conflict 2

2

2

3

3

3

3

3

3

4

4

5

5

5

6

5 s

3

0

2

3

9

9

1

3

5

6

9

1

2

5

5

7

9

2

8

1

4

7

3

Analysis of

T

Annexe

Annex 1. O

Annex 2. O

Annex 3. PFixed Resp

Annex 4. PResponse S

List of f

Figure 1. E

Figure 2. E

Figure 3. P

Figure 4. T

f the curren


s

Online Surv

Online Surv

Presentationponse Segm

PresentationSegments

figures

Excerpts of t

Excerpts of t

Priority list o

The levels o

nt preventive


vey on EU c

vey on EU p

n of results oments

n of results o

the civilian

the military

of the Capa

of political r

e activities


conflict prev

pooling and

of the Onlin

of the Onlin

CSDP miss

y CSDP ope

ability Deve

isk in pooli

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

vention instr

sharing

ne Survey o

ne Survey o

sions' mand

erations' ma

elopment Pla

ing and shar


ruments

n EU Confl

n EU Poolin

dates

ndates

an

ring

S

rogramme under gra

lict Preventi

ng and Shar


Duration:


ion Instrum

ring - Fixed

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 4

ments -

d

5 s

4

Analysis of

T

EXECUT

The purpo

the Delive

(IECEU) p

preventive

crises. In a

activities, t

The report

prevention

analysis d

surveys, in

tanks expr

and sharin

The curren

term, conf

activities o

assessmen

conducted

and Defen

visible par

role as a to

a clearer m

One possi

and conce

and foremo

around na

application

manageme

logistics ha

capabilities

f the curren


TIVE SUM

se of the re

rable 1.1 o

project and

activities t

addition, in

the report w

t is based

activities b

eriving from

n which EU

ressed their

g within the

nt preventiv

flict prevent

of the EU c

nts, diplo

as part of t

ce Policy (C

rt of the EU

ool of EU co

mandate and

bility to imp

pt of poolin

ost, pooling

tional sove

n. Utilising

ent and con

ave been id

s.

nt preventive


MMARY

eport "Analy

of the “Imp

to presen

that the EU

relation to i

will introduce

on the rev

by the EU,

m this desk

officials, m

r perception

e EU.

ve activities

tion and op

can be outli

omatic mea

the Commo

CSDP) miss

U's conflict p

onflict preve

d improving

prove the a

ng and shar

g and sharin

ereignty - o

the princip

nflict preven

dentified as

e activities


lysis of curr

roving Effe

nt the curre

U employs

mproving th

e the conce

view of exi

including p

k study pha

ember state

ns of the EU

s of the EU

perational, s

ined as inc

sures, med

on Foreign a

sions and o

prevention

ention, coul

g their cohe

activities of

ing which a

ng applies to

r the loss t

ple could b

ntion where

s potential

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

rent preven

ectiveness o

ent activitie

as part of

he utilisatio

ept of poolin

isting literat

pooling and

ase is com

e represent

U conflict pre

can be ca

short-term c

cluding, but

diation, dem

and Securit

operations.

activities, t

ld be furthe

rence as pa

the EU in c

aims to impr

o defence c

thereof - ha

be expand

e, inter alia,

areas that


ntive activitie

of Capabili

es of the E

its respons

n of EU con

ng and shari

ture and re

sharing of

plemented

tatives and

evention ac

ategorised a

conflict prev

not limiting

marches, st

ty Policy su

Whilst CSD

he conduct

er developed

art of overa

conflict pre

rove the av

cooperation

ave been th

ded also to

training an

could bene

S

rogramme under gra

es of the E

ties of EU

EU in confl

se to intern

nflict preven

ing within th

esearch on

capabilities

with the fin

members o

ctivities and

as represen

vention. Th

g to: Early

tatements,

ch as the E

DP actions a

t of CSDP

d for instanc

ll EU contrib

vention is t

ailability of

in which co

he key con

o the conte

nd recruitme

efit from po


Duration:


EU" is to co

Conflict Pr

flict prevent

national con

ntion capab

he EU.

n the curren

s within the

ndings of tw

of the acade

the other o

nting structu

he current p

warning an

as well as

EU Common

are but one

missions, a

ce by provid

bution.

to foster the

EU capabil

ontext cons

nstraint for

ext of civil

ent of perso

ooling and s

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 5

mplement

revention”

tion - the

nflicts and

bilities and

nt conflict

e EU. The

wo online

emia/think

on pooling

ural, long-

preventive

nd conflict

s activities

n Security

e although

as well as

ding them

e practice

ities. First

iderations

its proper

lian crisis

onnel and

sharing of

5 s

5

Analysis of

T

ACRONY

AAR

AWACS

BENESAM

CDP

CFSP

CMPD

CPCC

CSDP

DEVCO

DRC

ECHO

EDA

EEAS

ENP

ESDC

ESDP

ESCPC

EUMC

EUMS

EULEX

EUSR

HTP

HR/VP

f the curren


YMS

Air

Air

M Bel

Cap

Com

Cri

Civ

Com

Dir

The

HuCom

Eur

Eur

Eur

Eur

Eur

Eur

Eur

EU

Eur

Eur

He

Hig

Pol

nt preventive


r to air refue

rborne Warn

lgian-Dutch

pability Dev

mmon Fore

isis Manage

vilian Plann

mmon Secu

rectorate Ge

e Democrat

umanitarian mmunity H

ropean Defe

ropean Exte

ropean Neig

ropean Secu

ropean Secu

ropean Sate

ropean Unio

U Military S

ropean Unio

ropean Unio

licopter Tra

gh Represen

licy/Vice-Pr

e activities


elling

ning and Co

h Naval Coo

velopment P

eign and Sec

ement and P

ning and Con

urity and De

eneral for In

tic Republic

Aid and Humanitarian

ence Acade

ernal Action

ghbourhood

urity and De

urity and De

ellite Comm

on Military

taff

on Rule of L

on Special R

aining Progr

ntative of th

resident of t

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

ontrol Syste

operation

Plan

curity Polic

Planning Dir

nduct Capa

efence Polic

nternational

c of the Con

Civil Proten Aid Offic

emy

n Service

d Policy

efence Coll

efence Polic

munications

Committee

Law Missio

Representat

ramme

he Union for

the Europea


em

cy

rectorate

ability

cy

l Cooperatio

ngo

ection (forme)

lege

cy

Procuremen

e

on in Kosov

tive

r Foreign A

an Commiss

S

rogramme under gra

on and Deve

merly know

nt Cell

vo

Affairs and S

sion


Duration:


elopment

wn as the

Security

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 6

European

5 s

6

Analysis of

T

IcSP

IECEU

ISR

MARSUR

MONUC

NATO

NORDEFC

OHQ

OPCEN

OSCE

P&S

PESCO

PFCA

PSC

R&D

RAF

RCA

SATCOM

SSR

TEU

UAV

UN

VAT

WP

f the curren


Ins

Imp

Inte

Ma

Un

No

CO No

Op

Op

Org

Poo

Per

Pol

Pol

Res

Roy

Cen

Sat

Sec

Tre

Un

Un

Va

Wo

nt preventive


strument con

proving the

elligence, S

aritime Surv

nited Nation

orth Atlantic

ordic Defenc

peration Hea

perations Ce

ganisation f

oling and sh

rmanent Str

litical Fram

litical and S

search and D

yal Air Forc

ntral Africa

tellite Comm

curity Secto

eaty on Euro

nmanned aer

nited Nation

lue-added t

orking Pack

e activities


ntributing to

Effectivene

Surveillance

veillance

ns Organizat

c Treaty Org

ce Cooperat

adquarters

entre

for Security

haring

ructured Coo

mework for C

Security Com

Developme

ce

an Republic

munications

or Reform

opean Unio

rial vehicle

ns

ax

kage

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

o Stability a

ess of Capa

e and Recon

tion Mission

ganisation

tion

y and Co-op

operation

Crisis Appro

mmittee

ent

(Républiqu

s

on


and Peace

abilities in E

nnaissance

n in the Dem

eration in E

oach

ue centrafric

S

rogramme under gra

EU Conflict

mocratic Re

Europe

caine)


Duration:


t Prevention

epublic of th

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 7

n

he Congo

5 s

7

Analysis of

T

INTROD

1.1 PREV

Conflict pre

as accord

strengthen

the horrors

conflicts is

successful

rights, just

As an inte

EU's Com

Security an

since the

capacities

manageme

interventio

The EU in

prevention

conflict pre

only one li

term activit

The overa

part of the

activities u

conflict pre

1 Article 21 o2 Draft Europ2001. 3 Janina JohPublication o57. 4 The definitio

f the curren


UCTION

VENTIVE A

evention is

ding to the

n internation

s of the Se

s by default

example o

ice and soli

gral part of

mmon Forei

nd Defence

outset aim

in conflict p

ent has bee

ns within th

terpretation

, and on th

evention.3 It

mited instru

ties, CSDP

ll objective

e project, th

under the E

evention ins

f the Lisbon T

pean Union Pr

hannsen, Theof the Institute

ons have been

nt preventive


ACTIVITIE

considered

e Lisbon T

nal security"

econd World

t at the ver

of conflict p

darity, econ

f the extern

ign and Se

e Policy (sin

med at stre

prevention a

en primarily

he framewor

n is that cris

he other han

t must be e

ument of th

instrument

of the IEC

e task at h

European E

struments. W

Treaty. ogramme for t

e EU's Compre for Peace Re

n presented in

e activities


ES AND C

d a key obje

Treaty "the

"1. It can be

d War, and

y heart of t

prevention,

nomic prosp

nal relations

ecurity Poli

nce 2009 th

engthening

and crisis m

y – but not e

rk of the CS

sis manage

nd, CSDP c

emphasised

e EU in reg

s contribute

EU project

and aims to

External Ac

Whilst the lo

the Prevention

rehensive Apesearch and S

n detail in the

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

ONFLICT

ective of the

EU shall…

e said that

d therefore

the Union a

based on

perity and s

s of the EU

icy (CFSP)

he Common

the capac

managemen

exclusively

SDP, and th

ement in its

capabilities

d, however

gard to con

e to the so c

is to enha

o address a

ction Servic

ong-term co

n of Violent Co

pproach to CrSecurity Policy

project deliver


PREVENT

e EU's exter

…preserve

the historic

the idea of

and its acti

democratic

sustainable

, conflict pr

) and the

n Security a

ity of the

nt. In the E

– used in r

he IECEU p

s broad inte

are by and

r, that CSD

flict preven

called opera

nce EU con

and presen

ce (EEAS),

onflict preve

onflicts, Coun

risis Managemy at the Unive

rable 1.1.

S

rogramme under gra

TION

rnal relation

peace, pr

cal roots of

f preventing

ons. The E

values and

developme

revention h

developme

and Defence

EU to take

EU context,

reference to

roject follow

erpretation a

d large inten

P missions

tion. Prima

ational conf

nflict preven

t the curren

including s

ention instru

cil of the EU, 9

ment. Premisersity of Hamb


Duration:


ns and forei

revent con

the EU are

g further br

EU prides it

d respect f

ent"2.

has also bee

ent of the

e Policy, C

e action th

the concep

o military an

w this unde

also include

nded to con

s and opera

rily linked w

flict prevent

ntion capab

nt conflict p

short and

uments will

9537/1/01 RE

ses, Ambitionsburg: Volume

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 8

ign policy,

flicts and

e linked to

reakout of

tself as "a

for human

en part of

European

SDP) has

hrough its

pt of crisis

nd civilian

rstanding.

es conflict

ntribute to

ations are

with short-

ion4.

bilities. As

prevention

long term

be briefly

EV 1, 7 June

s, Limits (A 204, 2011),

5 s

8

Analysis of

T

presented,

in line with

examples

can be use

better con

practices b

missions a

This task w

EU policy

and aims t

prevention

missions a

considered

prevention

security th

task in gen

more cybe

also have

East.5

The surve

increase, a

regarding

borders of

as an instr

identified f

general, it

at the foref

Furthermo

context of

aims to id

5 IECEU Onli6 Ibid.

f the curren


, the focus

h the objec

of success

ed to suppo

ntributing to

by which th

and operatio

will build on

priorities, i

to identify a

. In this reg

and operatio

d. As part

capabilitie

reats and c

neral sugge

er and relat

religious o

ey responde

and that cris

CSDP miss

Europe. It

rument migh

future threa

was observ

front of CSD

re, the deliv

the EU. In

dentify the

ine Survey on

nt preventive


of this stud

ctives of the

sful EU ope

ort and stre

o conflict p

e EU has a

ons. Therefo

the review

nstruments

areas of fu

gard, the po

ons to incre

of the proj

es and CSD

conflict scen

est that futu

te to migrat

r cultural o

ents also f

ses and con

sions theref

was also n

ht not be pr

ats, such a

ved that ma

DP activities

verable at h

addition to

potential of

EU Conflict P

e activities


y yet rema

e IECEU pr

erations and

engthen EU

prevention.

already bee

ore, this asp

and analys

and capab

rther streng

otential of, a

asingly con

jects' forwa

DP instrum

narios. The

ure conflict

tion. Accord

origins and

foresaw tha

nflicts are b

fore is that

oted that th

repared to d

as uncontro

aritime secu

s.6

hand will pr

o introducing

f increased

Prevention Ins

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

ins on the o

roject; one

d mission in

missions a

This woul

en contribut

pect will be

sis, conduct

bilities in co

gthening an

and opportu

ntribute to c

ard looking

ments also

results of t

scenarios

ding to the

their geogr

at "non-stat

becoming clo

new missio

he Petersbe

deal with no

ollable flow

urity and/or

resent the c

g the conce

d applicatio

struments.


operational

of which is

n order to i

and operatio

d include

ed to confli

addressed

ted under T

onflict prev

nd developi

nities for cu

onflict preve

g stance, th

needs to ta

the online e

concerning

survey res

raphical foc

te" threats

oser to the

ons might h

erg tasks w

on-state thre

w of refuge

border ma

concept of

ept of pooli

on of poolin

S

rogramme under gra

conflict pre

s to identify

dentify way

ons in the f

identifying

ct preventio

in the study

ask 1.1 of t

ention and

ng of EU c

urrent CSDP

ention will a

he develop

ake accoun

expert surve

g the EU wi

pondents, f

cus will be

such as te

EU. One of

have to be c

ere still vali

eats. With re

es or large

nagement w

pooling and

ng and sha

ng and sha


Duration:


evention. Th

y and collec

ys and met

future, with

good meth

on through

y.

the project,

preventive

capabilities

P crisis man

also be iden

pment of E

nt of possi

ey conducte

ill be more

future confl

in Africa an

errorism co

f the future

conducted

id but that t

regard to so

e scale mi

would conti

d sharing (P

aring, the d

aring princip

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 9

his is also

ct positive

thods that

a view to

hods and

its CSDP

of current

e activities

in conflict

nagement

ntified and

U conflict

ble future

ed for this

complex,

licts could

nd Middle

ontinue to

scenarios

within the

the CSDP

ome of the

gration in

inue to be

PS) in the

eliverable

ple in the

5 s

9

Analysis of

T

context of

primarily li

potentially

would be

manageme

pooling an

better cont

1.2 STRU

The delive

activities o

provides a

EU, and f

analysing

missions a

emerging

Working P

effectivene

Asia. Buil

opportuniti

prevention

expert pan

manageme

themes tha

Chapter 3

defining th

7 As part of thwithin the EUwere sent viaand Europeaof Septemberather low, brespondents Responses a

8 A small scanon-EU coun

f the curren


f civilian cr

inked with

be utilised

in line wit

ent: instead

d sharing (

tribute to co

UCTURE O

erable will i

of the EU (C

an outline o

focuses on

lessons ide

and operatio

lessons fro

Packages (W

ess of selec

lding on t

es and po

and crisis

nel8; utilisin

ent. This p

at can be ad

will introdu

he concept

he report, two

U - were conda email to key an think-tanks er, and reportsbetween 20-25

to the surveyand remarks in

ale expert panentries, was org

nt preventive


risis manag

military cri

d outside of

th the prom

d of merely

of not just C

onflict preve

OF THE DE

in its main

Chapter 2)

of the long-t

the short-

entified and

ons and the

om the mis

WP) of the

cted CSDP

the introdu

otential for

manageme

ng the expe

art will serv

ddressed w

ce the conc

and prese

online surveyucted. The suEEAS officialwho took part

s from the surv5%, and the y on EU confln these survey

el or workshopganized in Got

e activities


gement and

sis manage

f the "milita

minent idea

coordinatin

CSDP instru

ention.

ELIVERAB

chapters a

and poolin

term (struct

term (opera

d key obse

eir contribut

ssions and

e project (W

missions a

uction, the

future de

ent, will be

ertise of pro

ve the purp

when assess

cept of poo

nting the c

ys - one conceurvey questions and Membet in the surveyveys were comrandom sampict prevention

ys are integrat

p, comprising tenica, Sloven

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

d conflict p

ement at t

ary sphere"

a of a full

ng different

uments but

BLE

address tw

ng and sha

tural) confli

ational) con

ervations an

tion to conf

operations

WP2, WP3

nd operatio

identificat

velopment

e primarily c

ominent ex

pose of pro

sing the mis

oling and sh

current form

erning EU conns can be founer state represys anonymousmpiled on 8 Ople of the surn, and 12 respted throughou

17 participantnia, on 21 Octo


prevention.

he nationa

". Better ut

y compreh

CSDP instr

t other capa

wo primary

ring within

ct preventio

nflict preve

nd challeng

flict prevent

s, this chap

3 and WP4

ons in the B

tion and a

and actio

conducted t

xperts in EU

oviding a s

ssions and o

haring, and

ms of coope

nflict preventiond as annexesentatives as wsly. The surveOctober 2015. rveys subseqpondents to tht the chapters

ts representinober 2015.

S

rogramme under gra

The conce

l (Member

ilisation of

hensive EU

ruments and

abilities of th

themes: the

the EU (Ch

on instrume

ention instru

ges from th

tion. By pre

pter will con

4) that focu

Balkans, Afr

analysing o

ns, both in

through on

U conflict p

napshot of

operations.

its applicati

eration, as

n and the othes to the reportwell as represeeys were launc

The responseuently remainhe survey on s.

g eight EU me


Duration:


ept, which

States) lev

pooling an

U approach

d activities,

he EU as w

e current p

hapter 3). C

ents availab

uments, in

he conduct

esenting so

ntribute to

us on asse

rica, Middle

of the po

n regard t

line survey

prevention a

possible to

ion within th

well as the

er on pooling t. The links to entatives of thched during the rate to the s

ned relatively EU pooling a

ember states a

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 10

has been

vel, could

d sharing

to crisis

optimally

well) could

preventive

Chapter 2

ble for the

particular

of CSDP

me of the

the latter

essing the

East and

ossibilities,

to conflict

ys7 and an

and crisis

opics and

he EU, by

e different

and sharing the surveys

he academia he last week surveys was modest: 10

and sharing.

and three

5 s

0

Analysis of

T

discourses

also beyo

compleme

what exten

far and h

manageme

on which

Assessme

also take s

conduct of

The prepa

also drafte

University

designing

the Survey

Centre for

prepared t

Once appr

partners w

including u

f the curren


s. Additiona

ond the "tr

nted with th

nt, and in w

ow pooling

ent and con

the remain

nt of selecte

stock on ho

f current mis

aration of th

ed the follow

of Ljubljan

the content

ys. Universi

r European

he Bibliogra

roved and p

will be encou

utilising soci

nt preventive


lly, the cha

raditional"

he results o

which areas

g and shar

nflict preven

ing Workin

ed CSDP m

ow pooling

ssions and

he deliverab

wing chapte

a drafted C

t of the Onl

ty of Mayno

n Perspect

aphy.

public, the

uraged to sh

ial media pl

e activities


pter takes s

military/def

of the online

, the poten

ring could

ntion. The p

g Package

missions and

and sharin

operations.

ble was coo

ers: the Exe

Chapter 2 a

ine Surveys

ooth, Irelan

tive planne

deliverable

hare the info

atforms.

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

stock on the

fence coop

e survey w

ntial of pool

be further

purpose of t

es will build

d operation

ng has bee

ordinated b

ecutive Sum

and AIES d

s, launched

nd, analysed

ed and con

will be dow

formation ab


e future pos

peration re

which shed l

ing and sha

r utilised in

this chapter

d upon in r

s, within W

en, or could

by Crisis Ma

mmary, Intr

drafted Cha

d the Surve

d and repor

nducted th

wnloaded o

bout the pu

S

rogramme under gra

ssibilities of

mit. The d

ight on two

aring has b

n the conte

r is also to

elation to p

orking Pack

be increas

anagement

roduction an

pter 3. Enq

ys and com

rted the find

e Expert p

onto the pro

blication thr


Duration:


pooling an

desk study

o primary a

been implem

ext of civil

provide a f

pooling and

kages 2, 3 a

singly, utilis

t Centre Fin

nd Conclus

quirya partic

mpiled the f

dings of the

panel/works

oject websit

rough their

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 11

d sharing,

y will be

spects: to

mented so

lian crisis

oundation

d sharing.

and 4, will

sed in the

nland that

sions. The

cipated in

findings of

e Surveys.

shop and

te. WP1.2

networks,

5 s

Analysis of

T

2 EU PR

Based on l

prevention

operations

in details,

aid of the E

exceed the

conducted

through the

extensively

The main a

the lens of

operations

sides of t

activities),

CSDP mis

the art) and

This chapt

the Expert

operations

when the t

immensely

and militar

conduct of

9 As noted bcivilian ESDPKempin, "ES(2011), 178-1Price, JenseProcess (Bru10 New typeimplementatipiracy etc. Seof Comparati11 Muriel AssInternational

f the curren


REVENTIV

literature re

activities o

s. Thus, the

into which a

EU, the EU

e scope of t

. The instit

eir preventi

y analysed

aim of this c

f conflict pre

s, and seco

the CSDP

with presen

sions and o

d the norma

ter would se

t Panel, w

s, as one p

tasks were

y in more th

ry crisis man

f missions a

by Asseburg aP/CSDP missiDP in Practice199. For anot

e Van der Waussels: Directoes of CSDP on of ceasefiree: Marhic, Give and Internaseburg and RoPeacekeeping

nt preventive


VE ACTIV

eview, this c

of the EU.

outline will

also other a

Neighbour

the IECEU

tutions of th

ve activities

in the Deliv

chapter is tw

evention ins

ond, derivin

missions a

nting a cros

operations.

ative docum

erve as a p

which will b

art of the E

to be imple

an a decad

nagement w

and operatio

and Kempin, tons was prepe: Crisis Manather example al, Marlene G

orate-General missions and

re agreementsilles, ‘Recent ational Law 2 onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1

e activities


VITIES A

chapter aim

The main f

not discuss

activities of

hood Policy

project, an

he EU task

s, as the ro

verable 1.1 o

wofold: first

struments a

ng from this

and operat

ss-sectoral c

The study,

ments adopt

pool of the i

be conducte

EU’s preve

emented.10

de, when the

were ready

ons will ser

the first compared for the magement withoof lessons lea

Gottwald, Nicofor External Pd operations s, strengtheninDevelopments(2014): 283."ESDP in Pra78-199.

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

ND CHAL

s at outlinin

focus of thi

s the EU’s c

the EU can

y instrumen

d second, d

ked with co

le of the EU

of this proje

, to analyse

available to

s framewor

tions (as a

comparative

based on t

ted by the E

deas for th

ed within t

ntive engag

However, t

e EU back

to be deplo

rve as a sta

prehensive asmeeting of GAout Strategic arned in CSDole Koenig, C

Policies of the are emergin

ng of aviation s in European

actice: Crisis M


LLENGES

ng the past

is chapter w

conflict prev

n be catego

nts etc.). Su

detailed stu

nflict preve

U’s conflict

ect.

e the preven

the EU in th

rk, to scruti

an importan

e analysis o

the review o

EU, is by no

e questions

the Delivera

gement in t

the complex

in 2003 dec

oyed.11 Und

arting point

ssessment of ERC in DecemPlanning", JouP missions anCSDP MissionUnion – Direc

ng, and the security, cap

n Union crisis m

Management

S

rogramme under gra

S AHEAD

and the cur

will be the

vention inst

orized (such

ch an analy

udies on tha

ntion will b

prevention

ntive activiti

he realm of

inize the po

nt part of t

of the lesso

of the existi

o means the

s of both the

able 1.2. C

the world, w

xity of the m

clared its in

erstanding

for the field

best practicesmber 2009; Murnal of Internnd operationsns and Operactorate B, PolicEU nowadayacity building,management

without Strate


Duration:


D

rrent releva

CSDP miss

truments an

h as the dev

ysis would,

at have alre

be mentione

institutions

ies of the E

f CSDP mis

ositive and

the EU’s p

ns learned

ng literature

e first such s

e Online Su

CSDP miss

were never

mandates h

nstruments f

the lessons

d work, whi

s and lessonsuriel Asseburg

national Peace, see: Elisa Dations: Lessocy Departmen

ys has to de, the preventiooperations’, IL

egic Planning"

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 12

ant conflict

sions and

nd policies

velopment

first, fairly

eady been

ed merely

has been

U through

ssions and

d negative

preventive

in various

e (state of

study.9

urvey and

sions and

r at ease,

has grown

for civilian

s from the

ich will be

s learned in g and Ronja ekeeping 15 Dari, Megan

ons Learned nt, 2012). eal with the on of acts of LSA Journal

", Journal of

5 s

2

Analysis of

T

conducted

upon the c

missions a

opportuniti

prevention

The chapte

analysed t

second pa

presenting

2.1 CURR

With regar

and operat

done in o

applying ot

Among lon

the most v

Union, trea

developme

measures

products fr

sector, su

addressing

prone regio

12Javier NiñoEuropean UnZupančič, "Mthe EuropeaScience 1 (20term developemphasising

f the curren


within the

completion o

and operati

es for the

potentials

er consists

through the

art dwells on

the key ob

RENT PRE

rd to the cur

tions are th

other delive

ther conflict

ng-term (or

visible and

aties betwe

ental and

for the org

rom non-EU

pport for h

g the root c

ons.12

o Pérez, "EU nion and Con

Modern "don-qn Union and 010): 71–94. T

pment cooperathe importanc

nt preventive


selected ca

of these tas

ons in the

current a

will be iden

of two part

e prism of c

n the CSDP

bservations

EVENTIVE

rrent preven

he most vis

erables of t

t prevention

structural) c

used: pros

een the EU

humanitaria

anizations w

U countries

human righ

causes of po

instruments f

nflict Preventiquixotism" or a

the OrganizaThe respondeation as well ace of timely en

e activities


ase-studies

sks, which w

Balkans, A

nd future C

tified.

ts. In the fir

conflict pre

P missions a

from the im

E INSTRUM

ntive activiti

ible. Nevert

the IECEU

n instrumen

conflict prev

pects and

U and third

an aid etc

working on

to access

hts protectio

otential con

for conflict preon: policy anan emerging ation for Secuents to the onlias economic cngagement thr

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

of the IEC

will draw mo

Africa, the

CSDP miss

rst part, the

evention ins

and operati

mplementatio

MENTS A

es of the E

theless, it m

project th

ts, which w

vention inst

promises to

countries o

c.), initiativ

nuclear no

the EU ma

on etc. Th

nflicts, and

evention", in Vnd legal aspecnorm of intern

urity and Cooine survey on cooperation arough the diffe


CEU project

ostly from th

Middle Eas

sions and

current pre

struments th

ions throug

on of past a

ND ACTIV

U, diplomat

must be em

at the EU

will be briefly

truments of

o neighbou

on various

ves for reg

on-proliferat

arket, progr

hese instrum

thus contrib

Vincent Kronects, 93–117 (national relatio

operation in EEU conflict ps important eerent activities

S

rogramme under gra

(WP2, WP

he lessons

st and Asia

operations

eventive ac

he EU has

h the scope

and current

VITIES

tic activities

mphasized a

engages p

y described

the EU the

ring countr

issues (ec

gional coo

tion, financi

rammes for

ments are

buting to th

enberger and Haag: TMS Aons? Preventiurope," Romarevention instrlements of EU

s of conflict pre


Duration:


P3, and WP

learned in t

a, the poten

s embodyin

ctivities of th

at its disp

e of lessons

missions.

s and CSDP

again, as it

preventively

in this subc

following a

ries to acce

conomic coo

peration, s

ial assistan

r a reform o

primarily m

he stability i

Jan Wouters Asser Press, tion of Armed anian Journalruments cons

U conflict prevevention.

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 13

4). Based

the CSDP

ntials and

ng conflict

he EU are

posal. The

s learned,

P missions

has been

y also by

chapter.

are among

ede to the

operation,

supportive

ce for the

of security

meant for

n conflict-

(eds.), The 2004); Rok Conflicts in

l of Political idered long-

vention, also

5 s

3

Analysis of

T

On the oth

on a short

applied in

not been

prevention

measures,

diplomatic

finding mis

armed forc

armed forc

The import

expert resp

diplomatic

conflict pre

The officia

from 2009

going crisi

where the

instrument

measures

The princip

issues is In

crisis resp

13 Ibid. 14 IECEU On15 Council of Council of http://www.ee16 IECEU On17 Andrew Bybuilding and on 3rd SePrevention.pd18 Andrew Bybuilding and on 3rd SePrevention.pd

f the curren


her hand, th

t-time basis

the cases w

applied in

n instrument

issuing de

envoys to

ssions, obse

ces, threat

ce.13

tance of the

pondents to

measures

evention ins

al line of th

, argues th

s shall be

responden

t of EU co

to strengthe

pal financia

nstrument c

ponse oper

line Survey onthe European

the Europeas.europa.euline Survey onyrne, The EuMediation Ins

eptember 20df. yrne, The EuMediation Ins

eptember 20df.

nt preventive


he EU has a

s, when the

where long-

the first p

ts the follow

marches or

a crisis are

erver or mo

with the us

ese operatio

o the online

and media

struments.14

e EU, build

hat the use

promoted i

nts regarde

onflict preve

en mediatio

al EU instru

contributing

ations and

n EU Conflict n Union, Concpean Union u/cfsp/conflict_n EU Conflict uropean Unionstruments; Dir015, http://eu

uropean Unionstruments; Dir015, http://eu

e activities


a variety of

e outburst

-term preve

lace. Amon

wing are mo

r declaration

ea, mediatio

onitoring mis

se of armed

onal conflict

e survey, wh

ation and C4

ding on the

of mediatio

in the first

ed diplomat

ention. 16 Th

on capabiliti

ument direc

to Stability

long-term

Prevention Inscept on Streng

on 10th _prevention/doPrevention Insn and Conflicrectorate for Sukonvent.org/w

n and Conflicrectorate for Sukonvent.org/w

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

other, more

of conflict

entive meas

ng the so

ost often us

ns calling fo

on in peace

ssions, eco

d force or,

t prevention

ho consider

CSDP all a

e EU Conce

on as a too

place.15 Th

tic measur

he current

es of the EU

ctly address

y and Peace

stabilizatio

struments, resgthening EU M

November ocs/concept_sstruments, res

ct PreventionSecurity Policywp-content/up

ct PreventionSecurity Policywp-content/up


e concrete

is imminen

sures have e

called ope

ed by the E

or a peacef

e talks, mec

onomic or po

at last and

n measures

red early wa

as either im

ept on Med

ol of primar

is is also s

es and me

preventive

U.17

sing conflict

e (IcSP), wh

on measure

sponses to quMediation and2009. Acce

strengthening_sponses to qu(Brussels: Di

y and Conflictploads/2014/10

(Brussels: Diy and Conflictploads/2014/10

S

rogramme under gra

instruments

nt. In other

either failed

rational (or

EU: political

ful resolutio

chanisms of

olitical sanc

d rarely use

s was also a

arning and

mportant or

diation and

ry response

supported b

ediation as

activities a

t prevention

hich implem

es.18 The in

estion numbed Dialogue Capessed on 2_eu_med_en.estion numbevision for CoPrevention –

0/8.-The-Euro

vision for CoPrevention –

0/8.-The-Euro


Duration:


s that can b

words, the

d or where

r short-term

l dialogue, d

n of conflic

f early-warn

ctions, deplo

ed, the actu

acknowledg

conflict ass

r very impo

Dialogue C

e to emergi

by the expe

the most

also involv

n and peac

ments both s

nstrument

er 2. apabilities, ado2nd Septempdf.

er 2. onflict Prevent– EEAS, 2015opean-Union-a

onflict Prevent– EEAS, 2015opean-Union-a

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 14

be applied

ey can be

they have

m) conflict

diplomatic

t, sending

ning, fact-

oyment of

ual use of

ged by the

sessment,

ortant EU

Capacities

ing or on-

ert survey

important

ve various

ce-building

short-term

has been

opted by the mber 2015,

tion, Peace-). Accessed

and-Conflict-


and-Conflict-

5 s

4

Analysis of

T

discussed

that the Ic

conflict pre

The EU als

instrument

more cohe

of conflict

for more co

(i)

(ii)

(iii)

(iv)

An interes

prevention

overall EU

security". T

coherence

a problem

strategic c

indicated a

the need

responden

19 Regulationinstrument http://ec.euro20 Andrew Bybuilding and on 3rd SePrevention.pd21 Ibid.

f the curren


more exten

cSP is by fa

evention pro

so aims for

ts. The mai

erent, multi-

prevention

oherent and

Early warn

Crisis Res

Diplomatic

demarches

New multi-

Combining

long term

developme

Foreign an

sting observ

activities d

U aim of

The most re

e - a compre

atic feature

coherence

a lack of un

for clearer

nt noted: "I

n (EU) No 23

contributinopa.eu/dgs/fpi/yrne, The EuMediation Ins

eptember 20df.

nt preventive


nsively with

ar the most

ojects so far

closer co-o

in institution

dimensiona

instrument

d comprehe

ning and co

ponse Platf

c measures

s, statemen

-annual Fina

g external a

m developm

ent instrum

nd Security

vation, gain

described a

"preserving

ecurring cha

ehensive ap

e of EU ca

between E

derstanding

r linkages b

In particula

0/2014 of theng to /documents/14

uropean Unionstruments; Dir015, http://eu

e activities


in the Deliv

t comprehe

r, with the b

operation be

n for preve

al and effect

ts (the EU o

ensive confl

onflict asse

form (inform

s, includin

nts, mediatio

ancial Fram

ssistance in

ment meas

ments; them

Policy, inclu

ned through

bove were

g peace, p

allenge for t

pproach - be

pabilities a

EU conflict

g of conflict

between E

r CSDP in

e European Pstability

40311_icsp_rn and Conflicrectorate for Sukonvent.org/w

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

verable 1.1.

ensive and

budget €2.3

etween diffe

entive enga

tive EU exte

officials rath

ict preventi

essment (E

mal);

ng (formal)

on/facilitatio

mework 201

nstruments

sures; hum

matic instrum

uding CSDP

h the onlin

assessed a

preventing

the EU was

etween the

as the onlin

prevention

t prevention

U political

nstruments

Parliament andand pe

reg_230_2014ct PreventionSecurity Policywp-content/up


.19 Hence, a

financially s

billion for 2

erent conflic

gement is

ernal action

her call the

on:

U Delegatio

) policy d

on of dialog

4-2020;

and action

manitarian

ments, and

P missions.

ne survey,

as only hav

conflicts a

s described

different in

ne survey a

and peac

n and peace

goals and

have to be

d of the Couneace. Ac4_en.pdf. (Brussels: Di

y and Conflictploads/2014/10

S

rogramme under gra

at this point

strong instr

2014–2020.

ct prevention

EEAS, whi

n’.20 Overall

em ‘tools’) w

on reports,

dialogue w

ue, etc.;

s to link reli

aid instru

d last, but 21

is that the

ving a limite

and strengt

as the lack

nstruments a

also reveale

cebuilding t

ebuilding thr

operationa

e carefully

ncil of 11 Marcessed o

vision for CoPrevention –

0/8.-The-Euro


Duration:


t it is sufficie

rument of th

.

n and peac

ch aims ‘to

, the EU ha

which can b

EU Situat

with third

ief, rehabilit

ument; geo

not least,

e current E

ed contribut

thening int

k of coordin

and activitie

ed a need

thinking. Th

roughout th

al missions

linked to l

rch 2014 estaon 29th

onflict Prevent– EEAS, 2015opean-Union-a

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 15

ent to say

he EU for

ce-building

o facilitate

as a range

be utilized

ion room,

countries,

tation and

ographical

Common

U conflict

tion to the

ernational

nation and

es. This is

for better

he survey

he EU and

s. As one

long term

ablishing an August,


and-Conflict-

5 s

5

Analysis of

T

developme

and locally

As mention

are CSDP

both in aca

activities. T

of the over

strategic c

a country

twofold in

in this cha

important i

the other h

the curren

and militar

of overall E

This obse

IECEU pro

learning fro

propose ne

to long-ter

instrument

Currently

manageme

conceptua

project, an

the mission

22 IECEU OnWorkshop on23 IECEU On24 European and-operatio

f the curren


ent strategie

y owned."22

ned earlier

missions a

ademic circ

They shall a

rall conflict

onflict prev

or a regio

this regard

apter, the re

instrument

hand, howe

t CSDP mi

ry, only had

EU conflict p

ervation em

oject, one

om the ong

ew solution

rm stability

ts - in the re

there are

ent mission

lization of

nd shortly ex

ns and ope

line Survey on

n the current pline Survey onUnion – EEASns/ (Accessed

nt preventive


es in a mo

in the intro

and operati

les and the

also be und

prevention

ention fram

on. The ex

. On one ha

espondents

of the EU i

ever, the res

ssions and

d demonstra

prevention a

mphasises

of the ob

oing CSDP

s to enhanc

- also thr

egions and c

7 ongoing

s.24 The cu

conflict pre

xplained als

rations’ ma

n EU Conflict preventive actin EU Conflict S. Ongoing md 23 October 2

e activities


ore systema

ductory par

ons, which

EU institut

erstood tha

policy of th

mework of th

pert survey

and, and as

considered

in conflict p

spondents e

operations

ated a limite

activities.23

the impor

bjectives of

P missions a

cing the EU

rough the

countries it

g CSDP m

rrent preven

evention –

so within thi

ndates.

Prevention Insvities of the EPrevention Insissions and op2015).

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

atic way so

rt of this cha

are, as we

ions as only

at way – as

he EU, whic

he EU towa

y findings

s noted ear

d CSDP as

prevention.

estimated t

s, both civil

ed role as p

rtance of

f which is

and operatio

U's contribut

use of CS

engages in

military op

ntive CSDP

as establis

is deliverab

struments, resEU, Gotenica, struments, resperations. Ava


o as to mak

apter, the m

e have see

y one of the

one, but ve

ch shall be

rds

are

rlier

an

On

that

lian

part

the

by

ons

tion

DP

n.

perations a

P activities o

shed within

le – can be

sponses to quSlovenia, 21 Osponses to quailable at: http

"Th

m

unand

inpr

denot

(Re

S

rogramme under gra

ke EU inter

main focus o

n in this su

e aspects of

ery importan

put in the f

nd 10 ong

of the EU, w

Deliverabl

seen by ha

estion numbeOctober 2015.estions numbe

p://www.eeas.e

he main obstaof the EU c

mechanisms] cfollows: l

nderstanding d peacebuildinsufficient lirevention povelopment at sufficient li

longer t

espondent to on EU Co

Ins


Duration:


rventions su

of the IECE

ubchapter,

f the EU’s p

nt type of in

framework o

going civil

which fall in

e 1.1 of th

aving a clos

er 2 and 3; IEC. er 2, 4 and 5. europa.eu/csd

acles [to the conflict prevcan be summlack of a comof conflict ping throughoinks between

olicies and acand humanitainks betweenterm measure

IECEU Onlonflict Prevestruments)

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 16

ustainable

EU project

perceived

preventive

struments

of a wider

ian crisis

to a wider

he IECEU

ser look to

CEU

dp/missions-

functioning vention marized as mmon prevention out the EU; n conflict ctions and arian ones; n short and es."

ine Survey ntion

5 s

6

Analysis of

T

Figure 1: E

Civilian CSDP missions EUAM Ukraine

EUMM Georgia

EUPOL Afghanista

EUBAM R

EUPOL COPPS PalestiniaTerritorieEULEX Kosovo EUBAM L

EUCAP SMali

EUCAP SNiger

EUCAP NESTOR

f the curren


Excerpts o

Man

AssiprovaccoStabpartiadjacand

an AssiAfghinstitcrimcrim

Rafah Monwithcontrbuildcapafor f

an es

AssiPalein adeveAssithe p

Libya Suppthe coper

Sahel Imprminireinfmannorth

Sahel Helpopercomband inter

EnhaIndiacounmariprosment

nt preventive


f the civilia

ndate (excer

sting Ukrainviding strateountable secuilisation, nories to prevencent to the ASouth Ossetisting in instihan Nationaltutions; supp

minal justice aminal investignitoring, verih regard to thributing to Pd confidenceabilities for afuture operatisting the Pastine in the a

accordance welopment of tsting and sup

police, judiciporting the Lcountry’s lanrational levelroving operaistries of defforcing the agement andh of the counping Niger's rating stratebating terrorlogistics m

rnational coo

ancing maritan Ocean (nter-piracy anitime securitecutors, judtoring, and tr

e activities


an CSDP m

rpts)

ne in securitegic advice urity servicesrmalisation at any return t

Administrativia safe and seitutional refol Police, incluporting improactors such agations ifying and ehe implementPalestinian cae and mediaa quick redeping there (woalestinian Auareas of policwith the bethe police anpporting the iary and custLibyan authond, sea and l through advational efficifence and secrole of judi

d supervisionntry

security foegies; Strengrism and org

management ordination in

ime capaciti(Djibouti, Knd maritime ty in each hdges and oraining)

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

missions’ m

ty sector reffor the d

s and confidento armed con

ve Boundary ecure for the

orm of the Muding the devoved interactas cooperatio

evaluating thntation of theapacity buildating betweeployment to orkshops, trauthority in bcing and crimest internationd judicial in

Kosovo authtoms areas orities in dev

air bordersvising, traininiency of intecurity; re-esticial and adn of their mi

orces in achigthening thganised crimpolicies; Suthe fight aga

es of five coKenya, Som

governance;host countryother actors;


andates

form (includdevelopment

nce-building mnflict, as welLines of the

e local populaMinistry of Int

velopment otion among A

on between p

he performane Agreed Prinding in all aspen the confli

the Rafah Caining sessionbuilding the minal justiceonal standarstitutions horities in th

veloping bor; capacity-bung and mentoernal securittablishing thedministrativeissions; facil

ieving interohe Nigerien me; Improvinupporting thainst terrorism

ountries in thmalia, Seych

; working wi (coast guar; mission e

S

rogramme under gra

ding police aof effectiv

measures; wll as to help mbreakaway r

ation terior; profesf local traini

Afghan law eolice officers

nce of the Pnciples for Rpects of bordicting parties

Crossing Poinns and studyinstitutions under Palesrds; support

he rule of law

rder manageuilding manoring Libyanty forces andeir respectivee authorities litating their

operability asecurity s

ng the humae developmm and organ

e Horn of Afelles and Tth the main ard, navy, civexperts main


Duration:


and the rule ve, sustaina

working with make the areregions of A

ssionalizationing capacity enforcement s and prosec

Palestinian ARafah Crossinder control; hs; enhancingnt and PA’s

y trips) of a future

stinian ownerting the ref

w area, speci

ement and sendate at stratn counterpartd the officiae hierarchica

s with regarr redeployme

and developsector's expan resources,

ment of regionised crime

frica and theTanzania), iactors responvilian coastanly provide

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 17

of law); able and

all eas Abkhazia

n of the and and utors in

Authority ng Point;

helping to g the PA potential

State of rship and

form and

ifically in

ecurity at tegic and ts als at the al chains; rd to the ent to the

ping their ertise in , training onal and

e Western including nsible for al police, e advice,

5 s

7

Analysis of

T

Figure 2: E

Military operationEUFOR ALTHEA B

EUNAVFOMedditeraSea EUMAM Central African Republic EUTM Somalia

EU NAVAtalanta (Somalia)

EUTM Ma

EUSEC Congo

As already

the preven

only preve

institutions

overall, ca

causes of

seen from

category o

refugees in

within the

structural c

protect all

f the curren


Excerpts o

ns Man

BiH Capasuppover

OR anean

DisruMed

Suppwith

Traincompof Dadm

VFOR

ProteAfricpiracSoma

ali Restmap theirterro

DR Suppcondauthhum

y explained

ntive activitie

entive activit

s and agenc

n have stab

conflicts (e

both figures

of direct pr

n the Medit

current CS

conflict prev

the people

nt preventive


f the milita

ndate

acity-buildinporting BiH rall EU compupting the b

diterranean; c

porting the Ch respect to th

ning activitieponent on bu

Defence and Ginistration, aecting World Fcan Union Miscy and armed rali coast on a toring constit

adopted byr sovereigntyorist threats porting the ditions condorities in ta

man rights, int

, the IECEU

es, as purs

ties of the E

cies of the

bilization eff

economic a

s, some pre

reventive a

terranean S

DP mission

vention (tra

of the coun

e activities


ary CSDP o

ng and trainefforts to m

prehensive stbusiness modcontribute to

Central Afriche armed for

es of nationauilding long General Staffand legal affaFood Programssion on Somarobbery at seacase by case btutional and

y the Nationy over the w

Congolese ducive to a ailoring the ternational h

U project ta

ued within

EU. On the

EU, also h

fects in vola

assistance,

eventive act

ctivities (pr

Sea etc.), w

ns and oper

ining armed

ntry; training

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

operations’

ning to the Amaintain the trategy for Bdel of humanreducing the

can authoritierces of the Ce

al armed forcterm capabilf with regardairs).

mme vessels dealia shipping;

a off the Somabasis; monitordemocratic oal Assemblywhole of the

authorities ireturn to esecurity sec

humanitarian

akes a wide

CSDP miss

e contrary, c

have an imp

atile regions

developme

tivities of th

reventing p

while the m

rations, hav

d forces tha

g judges, po


’ mandates

Armed Forcsafe and seciH n smugglinge further loss

es in preparinentral Africa

ces (focus onlity and capad to the areas

elivering aid tdeterring, pre

ali coast; protering of fishingorder throughy; helping the country; n

in rebuildingeconomic anctor reform law and goo

er approach

sions and o

certain instr

pact on the

s, as many

ent aid, hum

e CSDP mi

piracy and

majority of p

ve an indire

at will be pr

olice etc.).

S

rogramme under gra

ces of Bosnicure environm

g and trafficks of lives at s

ng a reform an Republic

advisory anacity within th of operation

to displaced peventing and recting vulnerag activities offh the implemhe Malian auneutralizing o

g armed fornd social de

to foster dod governanc

h to conflic

operations, a

ruments of

e reduction

of them try

manitarian

ssions and

armed rob

reventive a

ect impact,

rofessional,


Duration:


nia and Herznment; suppo

king networsea

of the securi

nd mentoringthe Somali Mns, plans, log

persons in Somrepressing actable shipping of the coast of Smentation of uthorities to organized cr

rces and in evelopment; democratic sce

ct preventio

are by no m

the EU, led

of risks fac

to deal with

assistance

operations

bbery at se

activities, as

and as suc

and as suc

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 18

zegovina; orting the

rks in the

ity sector

Ministry gistics,

malia, and s of off the Somalia the road-exercise

rime and

creating assisting tandards,

n. Hence,

means the

d by other

ctors and,

h the root-

etc.). As

s fall in the

ea; saving

s pursued

ch fall into

ch able to

5 s

8

Analysis of

T

2.2 CHAL

2.2.1 PLA

Despite th

deploymen

...), the CS

conflict pre

inherent co

operations

UN, NATO

activities w

conflict cyc

An importa

finding exe

proposed e

concerning

reasons fo

capabilities

However,

beginning

the local e

lesson the

member st

resources.

Another le

deploymen

25 Muriel AssInternational 26 Emil Kirchnlearned", Eur

f the curren


LLENGES

ANNING A

he absence

nt of a CSD

SDP deploym

evention (a

omplexity o

s require effe

O and the O

with from th

cle.

ant lesson le

ercise prior

effort, an ev

g the appro

or that is t

s.25

the recent

of CSDP m

environment

e EU has le

tates not on26

esson learn

nts usually

seburg and RoPeacekeepingner, "Commonropean Securi

nt preventive


IN CSDP

AND SETT

e of clear c

DP mission

ments have

and crisis m

of such env

ective coop

OSCE are of

e very begi

earned rega

r to the lau

valuation of

priate time

that the EU

missions a

military and

t, where the

earned is th

nly to approv

ned, which

proceeds m

onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1n Security andity 1 (2013): 3

e activities


MISSION

TING UP A

criteria for

or operatio

e been in pla

managemen

vironments,

peration amo

ften found a

inning, as a

arding the p

nch of the

f appropriat

frame in wh

U still fund

and operatio

civilian eng

e mission w

hat it is wis

ve the miss

h is not su

more smoot

"ESDP in Pra97.

d Defence Pol6-54.

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

NS AND O

A MISSION

deciding w

on (e. g. num

ace for mor

nt) actors in

, the plann

ong various

among the ‘

also they try

planning is t

mission, c

te instrume

hich the inte

damentally

ons have b

gagement,

was to be d

e to invest

sion, but als

urprising, i

thly and qu

actice: Crisis M

licy peace ope


PERATIO

N OR OPE

what constit

mber of dea

re than a de

n conflict- a

ing and co

s actors alre

‘usual susp

y to addres

that there is

concerning

nts to cond

ervention is

lacks indep

been, comp

better equip

deployed. In

igate thorou

so to contrib

s that the

ickly, comp

Management

erations in the

S

rogramme under gra

NS: KEY O

ERATION

tutes the p

aths, degre

ecade. Due

and post-co

ordinating

eady at the

ects’ the EU

s most or a

s almost nev

the aims a

duct the mis

s to be impl

pendent (c

paring to th

pped with th

n this regar

ughly the w

bute human

process

aring to the

without Strate

e Western Balk


Duration:


OBSERVA

precondition

ee of violenc

to the conu

onflict zones

CSDP miss

planning ph

U shall coo

all of the ph

ver enough

and objectiv

ssion, and a

emented. O

common) in

hose launch

he informat

rd, another

willingness

, financial o

of setting

e large dep

egic Planning"

kans: impact

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 19

ATIONS

ns for the

ce, region

undrum of

s and the

sions and

hase. The

rdinate its

hases of a

h of a fact-

ves of the

a decision

One of the

ntelligence

hed at the

tion about

important

of the EU

or material

up small

ployments,

", Journal of

and lessons

5 s

9

Analysis of

T

regardless

Asseburg a

»on thmembpoliticaadditiorecruitpopula

Another le

operations

experience

efficient p

missions’

taken this

the EU Mil

Centre tha

operations

civil and m

numerous

CSDP sha

states wer

hesitant w

Centre.28 It

time in Ma

CSDP mis

implement

some diffic

Operations

Horn of Afr

27 Muriel AssInternational 28 Fiona SchAffairs Revie

f the curren


s of whethe

and Kempin

he one handber states hal will is givonal difficuting and seations.«27

esson learne

s, which is

ed in the fie

planning an

and operat

decision a

itary Staff w

at would b

s, in particu

military res

declaration

all be stre

re, as argu

with regards

t took almo

arch 2012 i

ssions and

ation. The e

culties, the

s Centre we

rica.

seburg and RoPeacekeepingnell and Fabiw 20 (2015) -

nt preventive


r the civilia

n mention s

d, recruitinghave direct ven), while clties in fednding civilia

ed with reg

based on

eld, is that a

nd impleme

tions’ mand

already in D

was asked t

be able to

ular in thos

ponse was

ns of the m

engthened,

ed by Schn

s to the u

ost 8 years

in order to

d operation

experiences

activities an

ere an impo

onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1ien Terpan, "Special Issue

e activities


an missions

ignificant di

g personneaccess to

civilian persderal systean staff is g

gard to the

the difficu

a joint opera

entation of

date. The

December

to set up an

plan and

se cases w

s required.

member sta

those sam

nell and Te

use of the

to activate

coordinate

ns in the H

s, on which

nd the coor

ortant step t

"ESDP in Pra91-192. Member State

e: 63–82.

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

s or military

ifferences b

el for militarthese pers

sonnel cannems such agenerally ea

planning a

ulties the fi

ational cent

f the CSD

Council ha

2004, whe

n Operation

run CSD

where a join

Despite th

ates that th

me membe

erpan, rathe

Operation

e the Opera

activities a

Horn of A

h the lesson

rdination of

towards gre

actice: Crisis M

es Resistance


operations

between the

y operationsonnel resonot just be das Germanasier to jus

nd impleme

rst CSDP

tre needs to

P

as

en

ns

P

nt

he

he

er

er

ns

ations Centr

and increas

Africa from

ns can be le

missions a

eater synerg

Management

e to the EU O

"Havof

councoor

(Resp

S

rogramme under gra

s are in que

e two:

ns is easier ources (at ldrafted and ny). On thtify to the m

entation of

missions a

o be establ

re, which w

se synergie

the planni

earned, have

nd operatio

gy of variou

without Strate

Operations Ce

ing one cenf the all EU try would mrdinating the

insti

pondent to IEon EU Conf

Instr


Duration:


estion. Nev

r in principleleast when deployed (e other ha

member sta

CSDP mis

and operati

ished for th

was used fo

es between

ing phase

e shown th

ons conduct

us EU activi

egic Planning"

entre", Europe

ntre for cooactivities on

make more be tasks of eitution."

ECEU Onlinflict Preventruments)

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 20

vertheless,

e as the

with and, ates’

sions and

ons have

he sake of

or the first

the three

until the

at despite

ted by the

ties at the

", Journal of

ean Foreign

rdination n one benefit in each EU

ne Survey tion

5 s

0

Analysis of

T

The online

order to lin

coordinatio

and Kemp

particular t

on. Namel

member st

general po

the missio

activities o

should be

contribute

Better linka

society..."3

This is inhe

a CSDP m

EU. If the E

not sufficie

planning p

supported

employing

Balkans, w

prevention

2.2.2 MA

If the EU w

impact, it

29 IECEU On30 Muriel AssInternational 31 Responden32 Annemarie(2012): 414-4

f the curren


e survey rev

nk EU actio

on among E

in, referring

taken into c

ly, it has to

tates, that

olicy and ap

on or opera

of the EU wa

put into pla

to the wid

ages with n31

erently linke

mission or o

EU wishes

ent to add

phase of the

by a wide

a few of th

which is, co

engageme

NDATES

wishes to pu

must en

line Survey on

seburg and RoPeacekeepingnt to IECEU O

e Rodt and St430.

nt preventive


vealed that

ons with oth

EU offices

g to the ana

consideratio

o be repea

CSDP miss

pproach (po

ation is to

as also ech

anning cap

der national

national acto

ed with the

operation is

to make a d

ress the ro

e mission,

e spectrum

he instrume

ompared to

ent, more st

ursue a sus

sure that

n EU Conflict onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1

Online Survey tefan Wolff, "

e activities


t planning p

her actors.

in the miss

lysis of the

on, when th

ated to the

sions and o

litical, econ

be deploy

oed by one

acities as w

l and intern

ors, UN act

underpinnin

only one o

difference o

oot causes

it is recomm

m of compl

ents availab

o the other

able place t

stainable co

the mand

Prevention Ins"ESDP in Pra90. on EU ConflicEuropean Un

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

phase is oft

Responden

sion area.29

EU, empha

he planning

e wider aud

operations

nomic, secu

yed. 30 This

e of the resp

well as into

national eff

tors, region

ng logic of t

of the confl

on the groun

of the co

mended tha

lementary

ble. This ha

r regions w

than it used

onflict preve

date, resou

struments. actice: Crisis M

ct Prevention Iion Conflict M


ten superfic

nts also sta9 In addition

asizes that o

g of a CSDP

dience man

cannot ser

rity etc.) tow

linkage be

pondents in

o thinking h

forts of pea

al actors, d

the IECEU

ict preventi

nd, the CSD

nflicts in a

at the CSD

EU peaceb

as, for exam

where the E

d to be in th

ention missio

urces (both

Management

Instruments. Management i

S

rogramme under gra

cial and ne

ted the imp

n to this, the

one lesson

P mission o

ny times, a

ve as a su

wards the re

etween the

the online

ow CSDP a

ace-building

developmen

project, wh

ion instrum

DP mission

n appropria

DP missions

building ac

mple, happe

EU is invol

e 1990s.32

on or opera

h financial

without Strate

n the Wester


Duration:


eeds more t

portance of

e study of

learned sh

or operation

nd especia

urrogate for

egion/count

different p

survey: "Mo

activities at

g and state

nt banks, do

ich presupp

ents availa

or operatio

ate way. D

s and opera

ctivities, no

ened in the

lved with it

ation with a

and hum

egic Planning"

rn Balkans", C

IECEU ect: 65337101/05/2015 33 months

3371 21

thought in

improved

Asseburg

ould be in

n is going

ally to the

r the EU’s

try, where

preventive

ore efforts

t best can

e-building.

onors, civil

poses that

ble to the

on alone is

During the

ations are

t only by

e Western

ts conflict

long term

man) and

", Journal of

Civil Wars 3

5 s

Analysis of

T

implement

as well as

sustainable

operation

lesson wa

needed – a

the long pe

One of the

Asseburg a

knowledge

institutions

The EU ha

and opera

occasional

operation,

value of th

been. Suc

between th

much inde

that the go

or distorted

One of the

institutions

make a be

33 Muriel AssSystematic AWissenschafOctober 201534 Emil Kirchnlearned", Eur35 Muriel AssInternational 36 Responden37 There areprocess, hasthe EU as thmission (Ass

f the curren


ation strate

s the needs

e and long

not to be o

s learned i

at the peak

eriods.34

e challenges

and Kempin

eable on th

s that have

as a Specia

ations were

lly present

possess a

his expertis

ch consider

he Commis

ependency

oals of the m

d assumpti

e key poin

s are subor

etter use of t

seburg and RAssessment oft und Politik, 25. ner, "Commonropean Securiseburg and RoPeacekeepingnt to the IECE, of course, e

s been very mird party for theburg and Ke

nt preventive


egy of each

s on the gr

g enough.

overambitio

in Kosovo,

k EULEX ha

s with rega

n.35 They d

he conflict

a primary s

al Represen

e or are d

in the vola

lot of usefu

se has often

rations wer

ssion and th

and not int

mandates a

ons about

ts identified

rdinate eve

their expert

Ronja Kempinof ESDP Mis2009); IECEU

n Security andity 1 (2013): 3onja Kempin, g 15 (2011): 1

EU Online Survexceptions to uch involved he Rafah bord

empin, "ESDP

e activities


mission and

round.33 In

On the oth

us, or lavis

when it se

ad 3000 per

rd to the de

escribe how

zones, hav

say in the de

ntative in al

eployed. F

atile area e

ul informatio

n not been

re also not

he EEAS w

terconnecte

are often no

the politica

d in this re

n in the pr

ise.37

n, "The EU asions and Opworkshop on

d Defence Pol6-54. "ESDP in Pra90. vey on EU Cothe rule. Ma

in preparing thder crossing ain Practice", 1

PU

Horizon 2020 resear

d operation

other word

her hand, i

sh, in terms

eems reaso

rsonnel – a

evising of

ieceu m6... · 2020. 2. 3. · d1.2 analy preventive impr d lead bene delivery da revision:...

Documents