low flow anesthesia dr. paul zilberman dr. paul zilberman israel, 2010 israel, 2010...

LOW FLOW ANESTHESIALOW FLOW ANESTHESIALOW FLOW ANESTHESIALOW FLOW ANESTHESIA

LOW FLOW ANESTHESIALOW FLOW ANESTHESIA








Dr. Paul ZilbermanDr. Paul Zilberman Israel, 2010Israel, 2010

[email protected]@yahoo.com

……or the long way of the oxygen from its or the long way of the oxygen from its discovery till our patientsdiscovery till our patients……

JOSEPH PRIESTLEYJOSEPH PRIESTLEY

1733-18041733-1804On August 1, 1774, he produced the “dephlogisticated air”, known later as OXYGEN

A SHORT HISTORYA SHORT HISTORY

Inhalational anesthesia and closed system anesthesia are almost the same age. Almost/closed anesthesia systems have been in use since 1850. At that time the anesthetic agent was cloroform, administrated via a closed system, where KOH was utilized as a CO2 absorber. However, that kind of CO2 absorption did not gain acceptance. Later, a quick and effective method of CO2 absorption was developed when the first soda-lime absorber was introduced in 1917.

A SHORT HISTORY (con’t…)A SHORT HISTORY (con’t…)

In the mid 50’s, when HAL was brought forth, the use of LFA and closed system anesthesia diminished significantly.

This was largely due to the inherent problem of the first generation HAL vaporizers, which was the unreliable delivery of vapor at low FGF.

A SHORT HISTORY (con’t…)A SHORT HISTORY (con’t…)

Introduction of ISO in the early 1980’s gave way to a renewed interest in LFA and closed circuit anesthesia. It was further enhanced by the fact that anesthetic agents are atmospheric pollutants, especially N2O, HAL, ENF,

and to some extent ISO .

The introduction of new low solubility agents, like DES and

SEVO, have initiated a renaissance in the use of LFA, in order to contain costs associated with adapting FGF to patient demand.

A FEW DEFINITIONSA FEW DEFINITIONS……Low Flow Anesthesia (LFA) has been variously defined as an inhalation technique in which a circle system with absorbent is used with a fresh gas inflow of :- less than the patient’s alveolar minute volume- less than 1-1.5 l/min- 3 l/min or less- 0.5 – 2 l/min- less than 4 l/min- 500 – 1000 ml/min- 0.5 – 1 l/minClosed System Anesthesia is a form of LFA in which the FGF = uptake of anesthetic gases and oxygen by the patient and gas sampling. No gas is vented by the APL valve. Dorsch and Dorsch Understanding Anesthesia Equipment

A FEW DEFINITIONS (con’t)A FEW DEFINITIONS (con’t)……LFA:Anesthesia delivery, where FGF is below 1.5 l/min, but maintained slightly above the uptake of the patient. In addition, there is a low flow of excess gas that leaves the circuit through the excess gas valve.

Closed Circle Anesthesia:Anesthesia whereby FGF matches patient gas uptake and there is no excess gas leaving the circuit by way of excess gas valve.

Minimal Flow Anesthesia:Anesthesia whereby FGF is 0.5 l/min. www.clinicalwindow.net Ola Stenqvist MD. PhD Anest. And Intensive Care Goteborg, Sweden, Sponsored by GE Health Care

Reproduced with permission from “Low Flow Anesthesia with Draeger machines” by Prof.J.A.Baum

Professor Samuel Brody

The kind of laboratory used by Prof. Brody. It seems that excellent minds can extract a lot from apparently little.

Graph relating metabolism to body size“Bioenergetics and growth” 1945

Brody Formula for Oxygen Brody Formula for Oxygen UptakeUptake

VO2 = 10 x KG [kg] 3/4 [mL/min]

Where BW is body weight in kilogramsHowever, for clinical purposes, oxygen consumption can be more easily calculated as:

VO2 = 3.5 x BW [ml/min]

John W. Severinghaus

UPTAKE OF NITROUS OXIDEUPTAKE OF NITROUS OXIDE

VN2O = 1000 t-1/2 [mL/min]Having 70% in N2O, with a BW of 70 kg.

That gives a – 1st minute uptake of 1000mL - 200 mL/min uptake after 25 minutes - 140 mL/min uptake after 50 minutes - 90 mL/min uptake after 2 hours (120 minutes)

Source: Severinghaus JW, The rate of uptake of nitrous oxide in man. J. Clin. Invest 1954

UPTAKE OF INHALATIONAL UPTAKE OF INHALATIONAL AGENTSAGENTS

Independent of the agent employed uptake can be calculated using Lowe’s formula:

Van= f * MAC * λB/G * Q * t-1/2 [mL/min]

f = factor that defines the inhalation concentration that is sufficient for unresponsive skin incision at ~MAC 1.3

λB/G = blood/gas partition coefficient

Q = cardiac output

t = time

THE REBREATHING SYSTEMSTHE REBREATHING SYSTEMS

REBREATHING describes a technique in which non-consumed gases, contained in the exhaled air are partially or completely re-routed back to the patient during the following inspiration, purified from CO2 AND admixed with a certain amount of fresh gas.

THE REBREATHING SYSTEMSTHE REBREATHING SYSTEMS

Semi-open: VF ≥ MV

Semi-closed: MV > VF > Uptake

Closed: VF = Uptake

Where:

VF = FGF

MV = Minute Ventilation

Uptake = Total gas uptake of the patient

THE “CATCHTHE “CATCH””

Using a FGF of 5 LPM and a vaporizer setting of 1%, we give to the patient:

5000mL/min x 0.01 = 50 mL/min

What would be the vaporizer setting if we would use a FGF of 1 LPM for the same 50 mL to be delivered?

1000mL/min X ? = 50 mL/min

? = ……

? = 0.05

That means that the vaporizer should be opened to 5%!

Sounds bizarre, isn’t it! It really does, because we are not used to it! And yet, mathematics is all what it is about!

Under these circumstances the patient receives EXACTLY the same amount of gas, in fact the same amount of MEDICINE! This is called : BIOAVAILABILITY!

All over the world 5 X 1=

1 X 5=

TECHNICAL ASPECTSTECHNICAL ASPECTSIn LFA there are a few technical requirements. Typically they are rather generic and more or less independent of anesthesia machines used.

1. Circle rebreathing system with CO2 absorption2. Accurate flow meters for adjustments of FGF below 1L/min3. Gas tight breathing system. Recommended test leakage should be below 150 mL/min at 30 cm H2O test pressure.4. Ascending bellows, not rising up to the top of the bellows chamber may indicate breathing system leakage. The same is true for other alarms (LOW PRESSURE, spirometry loop).

5. The breathing system should have minimal internal volume and a minimum number of components and connections.

6. Continuous gas monitoring MUST be employed. From the clinical standpoint the measurement of expiratory gas concentrations close to the Y-piece is of crucial importance. That information is essential in controlling the patient’s alveolar gas concentrations, whereas Fi reflect the adequacy of gas concentrations into the breathing circuit.

Hey! Does it sound very familiar with our usual anesthesia machine?

“Introduction to low flow anesthesia” ppt. 2004, author unreachable

ADVANTAGES OF THE LFAADVANTAGES OF THE LFA1. QUALITY OF PATIENT CAREAnesthetic gases delivered using high FGF are usually dry and cold. Reducing FGF makes gases recirculating in the circle system more humid and warmer.With low FGF the gases repeatedly circulate through the CO2 absorber. Consequently more heat and humidity is produced through the chemical CO2 absorption process.Breathing warm and humid gases is beneficial for the patient because they help maintaining body heat, prevent postoperative shivering and airway and bronchial drying during ETT use.

Tracheal intubation bypasses the upper airways, thus, eliminating the main effect of the inhaled gases : warming and humidification. In the spontaneously breathing patient the isothermic saturation boundary of the inspiratory mixture (the point where the gases reach 370C and 100% humidity) is located at the 4-5th generation of bronchi.

After tracheal intubation, as a consequence of the upper airway bypass, this isothermic point is shifted down about 10cm in a bronchial region not suited to deal with dry and cold gases and not suited to physiologically condition the respiratory mixture (do you think now about the LMA in a

new way?).

2. ECONOMIC BENEFITS

Over 80% of anesthetic gases are wasted when flows of 5 L/min are used.

Several studies also prove that the use of low and minimal flow anesthesia techniques can dramatically reduce the (annual) costs of volatile anesthetics. Typically the reduction of FGF from 3 L/min to 1 L/min results in savings of about 50% of the total consumption of any volatile agent.

clinicalwindow.net

Total cost of anesthesia depend on complex interactions between anesthesia providers, patients, payers, techno-

logy and facility. Money makes the world go round?!These costs comprise direct, indirect and intangible costs.

Direct costs, the ones that can be influenced by the anesthesia provider represent 3-5% of the total healthcare costs in the US. (1993). If we consider the PACU expenses related to the anesthesia process than the costs may go up to 10%.

While it is difficult to measure exactly the volatile agent cost (mL/hour, different producers, vapor/mL liquid, delivery in excess of uptake) as opposed to IV drugs, a larger survey demonstrated that economies in volatile use going up to 90% can be achieved.

Pharmacoeconomics 2000,

June 17(6), 585-590

Definitions of different types of costsType of cost DefinitionCosts Irreversible use of a resourceDirect costs Costs of the material and labor used for productionFixed Costs that remain the same no matter many goods or services are

producedVariable Costs that change with the number of goods or services that are producedIndirect costs Costs related to the consequences of an event to society or an individualIntangible costs Costs of pain and suffering as a result of illness or treatment

This is where unused gases ($,€,£,¥,etc.), including O2, N2O go…

33.. ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITSENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS

High flow anesthesia inevitably results in pollution of the environment. N2O, for example, is a significant “green house gas”, and is estimated to be responsible for about

10% of this effect. Hmmm, not so green after all…Reduced FGF releases a lower amount of anesthetic agents into the environment, resulting in less pollution.

All gases delivered from the anesthesia machines are lost to the atmosphere. HAL, ENF, ISO contain chlorine. They are believed to have significant ozone (O3) depleting potential. The stability of these molecules permits their passage to the stratosphere where increasing UV radiation causes dissocia- tion to liberate free chlorine, which acts as a catalyst in the break down of O3. This reaction is the major cause of destruc tion of the O3 layer, especially over the South Pole.

N2O is also a catalyst in an analogous reaction.While anesthetists thus have a clear duty to minimize the use (release) of these chemicals, it has to be admitted that our practice’s contribution to the global release is minimal. DES and SEV contain no chlorine and appear to have no greenhouse gas effects.

THE OTHER SIDE OF THE COINTHE OTHER SIDE OF THE COIN

Disadvantages of LFA:

1.Limitations of currently used vaporizers: Modern vaporizers are little different from those used in the ’60s. They are designed for use with high FGF with a consequent requirement for high thermal capacity, temperature compensation and high accuracy. The use of LFA makes these characteristics unnecessary but it also introduces the problem of delivering an adequate quantity of volatile agent into the breathing system.

2.Accumulation of unwanted gases into the breathing system:

If you put little gas into the breathing system, little (or none) will come out. As a result of this failure to flush gases out of the system, any gases introduced which are not taken up by the patient or absorbed chemically will tend to accu mulate.

Such gases may be exhaled by the patient, be a contami- nant of the medical gases or result from a reaction with the

chemical agents used for CO2 absorption.

Substances exhaled by the patient:

- Alcohol -Acetone

-CO -CH4

Therefore the use of LFA is contraindicated in patients who are intoxicated, in uncompensated diabetic states or who are suffering from CO intoxication.

Specific safety features of anesthetic Specific safety features of anesthetic techniques with techniques with reducedreduced FGF FGF

1 .Improved equipment maintenance

2 .The long time constant: sometimes the “good is imbedded in the bad!”

3 .Improved knowledge of the theory and practice of

inhalational anesthesia.

SO, HOW DO WE DO “ITSO, HOW DO WE DO “IT?”?”

PRACTICALLYPRACTICALLY!!

HOW TO ADJUST FGF AT HOW TO ADJUST FGF AT DIFFERENT PHASES OF LFADIFFERENT PHASES OF LFA

Premedication, pre-oxygenation and induction of sleep are performed according to the usual practice. Concerning adjustment of FGF anesthesia can be divided into 3 phases:

1. Initial HIGH flow

2. Low flow

3. Recovery

1.1.Initial HIGH flow phaseInitial HIGH flow phase

At the beginning of anesthesia high FGF of 5-6 LPM is necessary to wash out nitrogen (N2) from the patients body tissues.

High initial flow facilitates the filling of the breathing system with the desired gas composition which in turn influences patient uptake and distribution of the anesthetic agents. (Remember the formulas in the beginning? The patient takes , after all, what he/she needs, provided the provider is providing enough!)

22 . .Low flow phaseLow flow phase

After the high flow phase of 5-15 min, or when the target gas concentrations has been achieved FGF can be reduced at the desired low flow level. The lower the FGF the greater the difference between the vaporizer setting and inspired concentration of the anesthetic agent in the breathing circuit will be.

With low FGF, time to reach the desired concentration in the inspiratory gas will be prolonged.

Hence, monitoring of oxygen and anesthetic agent concentration is essential and necessary in LFA.

If the flow provided is too small for the patient’s needs the bellow will gradually go down, down

down...

Low Fresh Gas FlowLow Fresh Gas FlowOxygen and Agent ConsiderationsOxygen and Agent Considerations

JAMES H. Philip MEE MD CCEJAMES H. Philip MEE MD CCEAnaesthesiologist and Director of Bioengineering Anaesthesiologist and Director of Bioengineering

Department of Anaesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain Department of Anaesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain Medicine Brigham and Woman’s HospitalMedicine Brigham and Woman’s Hospital

Medical Liaison for AnesthesiaMedical Liaison for Anesthesia Department of Anaesthesia Department of Anaesthesia Harvard Medical School Harvard Medical School Author of GasMan® and President of MedMan Simulations Inc., a Author of GasMan® and President of MedMan Simulations Inc., a

charitable Organization distributing gas man charitable Organization distributing gas man http://gasmanweb.comThe following X slides have been added with the author’s permissionThe following X slides have been added with the author’s permission

33 . .Recovery phaseRecovery phase

At the end of anesthesia high FGF, usually 100% O2, is necessary, to facilitate the washout of the anesthetic agent from the patient and to remove the agent to the scavenging system.

SOME COMMENTSSOME COMMENTS……Today, LFA is such a safe and simple procedure that there are no reasons not to use it routinely. It can be even argued that the use of unnecessary FGF should be regarded as inappropriate. However, it is still possible to find anesthesia departments where LFA is not used in special situations (prone position, thoracic surgery) or simply not at all.The most common misconception about is that it cannot be used in spontaneous breathing patients or with those having an LMA. There is, however, no rationale for such a view. The LMA has been shown to be effective both in pediatric and adult LFA. www.clinicalwindow.net

The majority of anesthesiologists, during their clinical practice usually avoid working with FGF < 1 LPM due to their cultural and practical beliefs including:

- requirement of in depth knowledge on gas laws and physics applied to clinical anesthesia (oof, learn again?) -pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic features of haloge

nated agents used until the mid 90’s -lack of accuracy, expense and limited performance of anes

thesia machines utilized in anesthesia up to the end of the 90’s.

In 1994, in the United States, 90% of anesthesiologists utilized 2-5 l/min of FFG and only 12% of physicians used an FFG infe

rior to 1l/min.

The recent introduction on the market of low solubility halogena- ted agents and the technological development of high- performing anesthesia ventilators, supplied with feed-back control systems and high precision monitoring systems, make LFA/CSA safe and feasible on a daily basis. This occurrence represents a great advantage as far as clinical practice, cultural, environmental, pharmacological, technological and cost savings concerns.

As with any other anaesthetic technique, LFA has its relative and absolute contraindications, and anaesthetists have to know the risks and limitations of this method. The potentialrisks associated with low-flow anaesthesia are accidentalhypoxia, hypercapnia, inadequate depth of anaesthesia and the accumulation of potentially toxic trace gases. A basic knowledge of the uptake and distribution of anaesthetic gases and appropriate patient monitoring such as pulse oxymetry, capnometry, inspired oxygen monitoring and anaesthetic gas analysis are required for safely delivering general anaesthesia with low fresh gas flows.

The extent of patient monitoring, however, is similar to that for any other anaesthetic technique. Sounds familiar again?

Awareness during Awareness during anesthesiaanesthesia

“It can’t be! You should be sleeping”!

The end? Not quite…A few The end? Not quite…A few answers fromanswers from……

FINLAND, Dr. Riku AantaaMD, DMedSci

former President of the Finnish Society of Anesthesiologists

“…I have the understanding (we even did a survey some 5 years ago) that low flow (FGF 0.5-1.5 LPM) is standard care throughout my country”.

USA, Dr. Jerrold LermanJerrold Lerman MD,

Clinical Professor of Anesthesia

Women and Children's Hospital of Buffalo, SUNY at Buffalo, and

University of Rochester, Rochester, New York

“I use flows about 1-1.5 LPM”

NORWAY, Dr. Per MeinichPresidentThe Norwegian Society of Anaesthesiology

“…has approximately 50 surgical hospitals, and with the exception of some small, private clinics, they all perform gas anesthesia. Each hospital decides on which machines they want to use, and each hospital has its own guidelines. To my knowledge, all hospital which utilize gas anesthesia do so in close loop, low flow systems”.

SOUTH KOREA, Dr. Hong Seuk Yang :MD, Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Asan Medical

Center, College of Medicine, University of Ulsan “Low flow anesthesia technique is more popular in Korea from 5 years ago, after the introduction of SEVO and DES. Flow rate is maintained at 2LPM (O2: N2O 1:1). Usually we don’t decrease the flow rate below 2 LPM”

CANADA, Dr. Glenn McGuireDepartment of Anesthesia Toronto Western Hospital

“The circuit is checked at the beginning of the day for leaks (leak must be under 180mL/min). I use DES with N2O and O2 at a total flow of 1 LPM for both mechanical ventilation and spontaneous breathing. Years ago anesthetists used to turn up the flows for spontaneous breathing. This is an outdated concept and is no longer practical. Of course, with spontaneous breathing I always use CPAP”

UNITED KINGDOM, Dr. Andrew McHutchonMB ChB FRCA, Anesthesia & Intensive Care. Northumbria Healthcare , UK .

In my hospital we have a very strict approach to gas economy. The reason for no recent publications is that virtually all the information we need is already known. Anyone who uses high flows is wasting money and polluting the environment without any benefit to patients. If we need more information we should ask the question:" what happens to inhalational agents in the upper atmosphere?” A similar question for TIVA, “what substances do the manufacturers of Propofol and Remifentanil release into the environment?” If the anesthetist understands the kinetics of his system, the patient gets a good anesthetic with enough agent.

ITALY, Dr. Amato del Monte:Dr. Amato De MonteDirector of Anaesthesia & I.C.U. DepartmentAzienda Ospedaliero Universitaria S. M. Misericordia – Udine

“The breaking method to introduce closed system anesthesia in my hospital was the implementation of our anesthesia machines with the ZEUS…This fact obliged my colleagues to face the topic. I can’t give [you] an answer of the penetration [of LFA] in Italy. Anyway, the majority of a small group, 400 anesthesiologists, interviewed with the simple question considered low flow a FGF of 3 LPM”.

It’s up to you

If you want to be

Like the guy in the figure

All the time

With the finger on the trigger…

Or enjoy a cozy sleep

While the machine does gently “beep”……

In a simple way, we can say…The LFA is the mathematical art of volatile

anesthesia …

Questions anyone?

low flow anesthesia dr. paul zilberman dr. paul zilberman israel, 2010 israel, 2010...

Documents