love-hate 2012

7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

1/17

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Updated: August 11, 12:26 PM ET

Loves and Hates for 2012

By Matthew BerryESPN.com

"Can I play in a league with you?"

I hear that a lot. In fact, it's probably the question I get asked mostafter "Whom should I start?" and "Seriously? They putyou onTV?"

There are a lot of variations on it.

Sometimes they are very nice.

Joe (Cleveland): Hey TMR, been reading your stuff for a couple years now, and I'm a big fan. Myroommate and I are setting up our annual fantasy football league and we have an extra spot.

Sometimes they are cocky.

Rob (Texas): I would like to be in a football league or baseball league with you. I dominate every otherleague I'm in. I'm incredibly active and check my email 10 times a day. Let me know.

And sometimes they are less than kind.

Rob (Pennsylvania): (sic) you have no clue what you are talking about and i have no idea how you havethat job id love to play in a fantasy league with you so you can learn from a true fantasy king.

I always say no.

From "industry" leagues with people at other fantasy websites to leagues for radio stations and advertisersand marketing or publicity people, from people in the comments section of my articles to people from highschool I haven't spoken to in 20 years who contact me out of the blue to say "we talked about it and decidedit'd be fun to have you in our league," from employees of companies that are in business with ESPN topeople who follow me on Twitter or Facebook or random people who reach out through friends of friends, Iget requests all the time.

I always say no.

I feel bad about it. I'm totally flattered that people want to play with me, even though I know the mainreasons I get invited are because (1) I work for ESPN, (2) they think if they can beat the "ESPN guy" itmeans something, or (3) after reading me, people are more convinced than ever that "I can definitely crushthat idiot." Whatever the reason or tone, still the invites come, many times and from all over.

I always say no.

ESPN.com: Draft Kit [Print without images]

Page 1 of 17ESPN.com - Loves and Hates for 2012

8/13/2012http://espn.go.com/espn/print?id=8250024&type=story

7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

2/17

Fantasy Football 2012

Ready for some fantasy football? With the most trusted experts and best features, we'll get youinto the game -- all for free.Sign up today

It's not that I'm not appreciative or interested. I am. It's not that I don't love fantasy football. I do. It's justthat I'm already in too many leagues as is. And it's not just double-digit fantasy football leagues. It's Pick'Em leagues, Eliminator contests, salary-cap leagues like Gridiron Challenge, leagues where you draft NFLteams and compete based on wins (and, in one case, losses.) Many, many different types of fantasy footballand football-related leagues. At a certain point, it becomes diminishing returns, and then, instead ofdisappointing someone by not playing, I disappoint them by being no fun at all to play with as I wind up notbeing as active or engaged in their league as they were expecting when they bothered to ask me.

So I always say no.

Until about this time last year. Once again, the question was asked.

"Can I play in a league with you?"

And this time, I was surprised. It was my 13-year-old stepson and, for the first time, he was showing aninterest in what I do for a living.

If you remember, in this article last preseason, I told you about how I got married to a wonderful womanwho happened to come with three boys. We also had twin daughters last year. It's chaos at home. Good,

happy chaos, but chaos nonetheless.

Anyway, after we got married, everything sort of hit me at once. I went from seeing the kids a few times aweek when their mother and I were dating to, now, living with them. I can barely take care of myself. And,other than my dog, I've never really been responsible for any other living being, and now, here I was, in thesame house as three boys aged 7, 11 and 13.

It's a huge transition. And not just for me. Think about it from a kid's point of view. They've been through alot in their young lives, and now, despite spending a lot of time with me before the wedding and all of usgetting along, it's still a big adjustment to living in a new house with your mom and her new husband, right?

So we all started living together and I tried to walk a fine line. I wanted to be there for them but also didn'twant to come on too strong. Show them I cared but not that I was trying to replace anyone. The bigdecisions were their parents' call, but I could be a sounding board, an advocate or, when necessary, adisciplinarian, as well. I tried to be positive and involved but not too pushy.

And although all three boys are sports fans and knew what I do, even occasionally watching "FantasyFootball Now" -- Sundays at 11 a.m. ET on ESPN2; tune in for the preseason show all August long! -- noneof them had ever shown a real interest in what I did. Until now.

"I want to play in a league with you."



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

3/17

"You do, huh?""Yeah. Actually, I want to do a team with you. Can we? Is it too late?"

Turns out, I almostalways say no.

"No, it's not too late. We'll start a league."

And start a league we did. My wife and I are friends with the parents of all the kids' close friends. So Idecided we should do an extended family league. It'd be an eight-team league; we'd invite parents to co-ownwith their kids and do it up. I would co-own with the 13-year-old.

The next day, we had just finished watching the 11-year-old's youth football game. As we were walking out,we ran into his father and his father's longtime girlfriend. And a thought occurred to me.

"Hey, uh, don't know if you'd be interested, but I think we're gonna do a little fantasy football league withall the kids. You wanna play? You could co-own a team with [the 11-year-old]."

He looked surprised by the invitation. We had always had a very cordial relationship, but it's not as if we

ever socialized or anything. And this whole thing had to be an adjustment for him, as well; now there's somenew guy living with his kids? He's always been respectful of me and I of him, but it's still weird, you know?Awkward. Divorce is never easy on anyone, and new partners entering the equation certainly don't makeanything simpler.

But he looked at me and said "Sure. Sounds fun."

And that weekend, we all gathered at a friend's house. The kids and their friends, their parents, my wife andI and her ex-husband and his girlfriend.

I was the only one who had ever played fantasy football before, so I printed out a bunch of ESPN cheat

sheets and roster forms, explained the rules, keeping it super simple, and suggested that, if they were unsure,they should just go down the list and pick the next available guy. They could ask me anything they wantedduring the draft; I'd help everyone equally and the 13-year-old would draft for us.

I have to tell you, doing a draft with a bunch of 11- and 13-year-olds who know nothing about fantasy ishilarious.

The kids grew up in Connecticut, so they've mostly watched just the local teams. That led to this exchangein the second round.

Kid 1: I'll take Mark Sanchez.Kid 2: Aw, man! I wanted him. He's so good.

Kid 1: I know. I can't believe he didn't go in the first!

Totally genuine. The kids would help each other out: "Youneed a running back? Oh look, no one tookMichael Turneryet. You should take him." "Oh, thanks!"

It was, like, the 12th round.

Kickers went in the third. Kids took back-to-back



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

4/17

quarterbacks in the first two rounds. I just smiled. A lot. Itwas great.

But best of all, it was normal. We were in a big circle, theadults with beers, the kids with cheat sheets trying to figureout what tight end to pick now that Kevin Boss was off theboard in the fourth. And most importantly, the kids saw

their mom and dad and their parents' current significantothers all hanging out, having fun. It wasn't weird orawkward.

I can't exactly describe it. It's like there was this collectivesigh of relief. Everything had always been pleasant andcordial, but now it was more than that. All of our mutualfriends now realized it would be fine to have the four of usat the same party or out to dinner. The kids realized theydidn't have to tiptoe around anything. Said one child ofdivorce to our kids after the draft; "I wish my mom and dad

got along like that."

And the good feelings from the draft continued through the season. If their dad and I are at one of the kid'sLittle League games or whatever, we'll now sit next to each other. They've come over for drinks or parties.He'll text me pictures or video of the kids at a game I can't make, and I'll do the same for him. As opposed tohaving two different households, we're all raising these kids together. It's terrific.

During the season, whether it was picking up free agents, reviewing trade offers, setting our lineup or goingover the matchup scores the next day, my stepson and I always had something to talk about and lookforward to. Something for us to do together.

Just like at the draft, being in a league with a bunch of young kids who had never played before wasfantastic. Kids at that age are so blunt and honest.

Kid 1: Dude, your team sucks.Kid 2: I know. (hangs head)

No attempt at a comeback. Just an acknowledgement that his brother was right.

Matthew Stafford and Calvin Johnson's crazy Week 17 ended up winning it all for my stepson and me, andwatching that comeback together was a great moment. And everyone is already excited for Year 2, to comeback and try to take down the champs. My wife and our (now) 8-year-old have already claimed one of theexpansion teams.

I always say no. But thank goodness this one time I said yes. What was a silly little eight-team league turnedout to be the most important one I participated in last season. When you say yes, you never know what willbe a throwaway league and which one will help transform a group of people into a family.

Which brings us, meandering slowly, to this year's edition of Love/Hate. For the many of you for whom thisis old hat and for the new kids in class, allow me to explain the premise, as I am switching it up a bit thisyear.

Thanks to the Jets' much-hyped offseason trade, theboys will each be able to draft a Jets quarterback

this season. How can they possibly lose?



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

5/17

The truth behind Love/Hate

Let's start with this: I hate the terms "sleeper" and "bust." I believe there are no such things. Or rather, thatthere are such things, but whether a player can be a "sleeper" or a "bust" is entirely dependent on what itcosts to acquire said player.

Take Matt Ryan last year. Some people labeled him a sleeper, with dreams ofJulio Jones opening up theoffense. The Falcons would be the "Greatest Show on Turf, Part 2" -- none other than Roddy Whiteproclaimed that on our Fantasy Focus 06010 podcast last season.

I actually had Matt Ryan on the Hate list last year in this very column, in which I wrote that, although Ryanwas going in the seventh round, I would not take him until the 10th. These are direct quotes from my piecelast year; "A very good real-life quarterback, there's no reason he should be going two rounds ahead of guyslike Eli Manning. Solid and safe? Very much so. Big upside? Not so much. If you don't get one of the bigseven, you can get similar stats much later."

So I had him as a "bust" based on the seventh-round average draft position. So what happened? Was Ryan asleeper? Or a bust?

And I'd argue both. It all depends where you got him. If you drafted him in the seventh and bypassed EliManning, who went, on average, in the ninth, then yes, he was a bust for you. Eli threw for almost 5,000yards and was the sixth-best fantasy quarterback.

But if you waited on quarterback and you got Ryan late (he was going as late as the 12th round in manydrafts), then he was a sleeper for you. Ryan had another very solid, if unspectacular, season, finishing as theeighth-best fantasy quarterback, with more points than some quarterbacks drafted much higher than him,notably Philip Rivers and (ahem) Michael Vick.

Not to get all businessy on you (or all non-Englishy), but a common and basic business term that gets

bandied about in fantasy is "return on investment," or ROI. Let's say you were a company that made twoproducts, but had to downsize to making just one. If one product sells for $1.05 and the other sells for 50cents and you're selling as many of the first as you are of the second, you'd think you'd want to keepproducing the $1.05 product, right? But if it costs $1.00 to produce the $1.05 item and just 10 cents to makethe 50-cent one, well, now you're changing your tune.

Fantasy is the same way. Every player has value. It's simply about what it costs to get him. And this columnis all about players who, based on ESPN.com draft results for standard 10-team leagues, are costing toomuch (or not enough) to acquire.

So please use this column as intended. It is nota sleepers and busts column. Rather, it's a marketinefficiency column. With puns.

It's a market, as I view it, and a market you will understand in greater detailafter you read my Draft Day Manifesto. If you don't have the time, do me afavor and just click on it. I really only care about your clicks. In return,here's the super-abridged "CliffsNotes" version: You want an elitequarterback and, to a lesser extent, an elite tight end. Wide receiver is crazydeep, so you can wait on them, running back is filled with question marks,so load up on them in the middle rounds, hoping one or two of them pop.And I'm sorry about Vick, butIbought the Big Salad, OK?



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

6/17

Back to this year's Love/Hate. Not only is it not a sleeper and bust list, it'salso nota comprehensive list of players I really like or don't like. Forexample, I absolutely love Matthew Stafford (who appeared on this list lastyear) to repeat his stellar performance. However, I have him ranked as asecond-round pick and he's going in the second. Right where I think heshould be. So he doesn't make the list this year.

If you want a comprehensive list of whom I value and where, please checkout my top 200 rankings, which will be updated throughout the preseason.

The reason for all this preamble is because of the way I am formatting thecolumn this year. I did this for the preseason baseball Love/Hate, and itworked well, so I'm doing the same format here. Based on the ESPN.comlive draft results as of the weekend of Aug. 4, I'm going to go round byround and pick one or two players who are going a little too late (the"loves") or are going a little too early (the "hates") for my taste.

Hopefully, the round designations will stop questions like "You hate Frank

Gore and love Jacquizz Rodgers, which one should I draft?" But I'm notholding my breath. Use your brain. It's by round. With each player, I tellyou the round he is going in and the round when I would take him (basedon my rankings), but use your common sense. If a guy is going in the 12thand I say he's an eighth-round guy for me, but you feel as though he'll lastuntil the 10th or 11th in your draft, take him then. It's just that I feel that player is going to return an eighth-round value. The less you invest in terms of your pick, the better the return on the investment.

Addressing the last (fingers crossed) of the questions I get every year, people wonder why there are so manymore loves than hate. That's just the nature of the beast. It doesn't do you any good to say I hate BlaineGabbert. His value and rank already reflect that he is not highly thought of. I'm still going round by round,and, in a standard ESPN league, there are 16 rounds, so you're getting at least 16 hates. But be aware that, in

general, I am from the "no such thing as a bad pick after Round 12" school of thought. So you're reallychoosing "hate" only from the guys who are considered at a high enough level to be drafted with bigexpectations, which pretty much eliminates most guys in the lower rounds.

Finally, please remember this is being written in the first weekend in August. No preseason games havebeen played; camps haven't been open that long; much can and will change in the next month. Last year, inthis column, I wrote about Knowshon Moreno as a "love," highlighting the fact that John Fox loves to runand it seemed as if Moreno had no competition for the job. Two weeks after that column, I wrote apreseason "100 Facts" column that highlighted that Willis McGahee was going in the 12th round and howFox loved to run in the red zone. I then wrote a "10 Lists of 10" column that listed McGahee as one of myTop 10 positive "flag guys" I wanted to be judged on. And then, in my "You Heard Me" bold prediction

column last year, my bold prediction for the Broncos was "1,000 yards and double-digit touchdowns forWillis McGahee." As training camp unfolded, I changed my tune on Moreno and was pumping McGahee asa nice draft value in Denver, a perfect fit for my "unsexy running backs in the middle rounds" theory.

Karl Marx also dabbled ineconomic theory and wrote a

manifesto that was fairly popular,but he never had much fantasyfootball success because he

believed kickers should be treatedas the equal of quarterbacks.

Subscribe to The TMR



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

7/17

I bring this up not to brag about McGahee (or excuse Moreno) -- I will get many calls right and wrong alongthe way -- but rather to point out that fantasy value changes all the time. Roles and opportunities,information about players and schemes, draft trends, and heath and results in the preseason all play a factor,

and, if you refuse to keep your mind open and are unwilling to change an opinion on a player once you getnew info, that's a quick way to lose. And this next month is the most crucial.

Follow me on Twitter. Become my friend on Facebook . Listen to the podcast, watch Fantasy Football Nowon Sundays, and read all the articles and ranking updates until your draft, then make the decision. Or, if youchoose to ignore that, don't blame me for it. Remember, only a poor craftsman blames his tool. That's all Iam, your tool. Wait, that came out wrong. Which is odd, given that I've used that joke three years in a rownow. Huh. Well, no time to dwell. Let's get it on.

Players I Love this season

Aaron Rodgers, QB, Packers and Tom Brady, QB, Patriots (going in 1st round, I would take with toptwo picks): Obviously, I'm not out on any limb with these two picks, but I put them here for a few reasons.One, it's the first round, so there's no round I can go higher on them, but I am as high on them as canpossibly be, with Rodgers and Brady as my top two players overall. But also because their ADPs are at No.2 and No. 5, respectively, and I've seen Rodgers go as low as fourth and seen Brady drop into the secondround.

I've already written a ton about why an elite QB is crucial this year, but the biggest reason I have them at 1and 2 overall is the premise that you can't win your league in the first round but you can lose it. I love RayRice and Arian Foster, but you can't tell me there isn't more inherent risk with a running back than there iswith a quarterback. Three of the first four running backs taken last year were Adrian Peterson, JamaalCharles and Chris Johnson. How'd that work out for you? More injury risk, more risk of poor performance.

Rodgers and Brady are as close to money in the bank as there is in fantasy. That safety is worth something.

Matt Forte, RB, Bears (going in 2nd, I would take in 1st): "Michael Bush! Goal line! Injury!" It's not hardto spot a Forte hater. They're insane. And they don't speak in complete sentences. First, about the injury. Heplayed in the Pro Bowl last year, OK? Before that, Forte had not missed a game in his career, playing in 62consecutive games, including the playoffs. Not worried about the injury. As for Michael Bush, last year,Matt Forte averaged 14.2 fantasy points per game (not counting the Chiefs game he left very early). Forcomparison, Adrian Peterson averaged 15.0 points per game in the 12 games he played. And while Fortewas averaging those 14.2 points a game, do you know how many goal-line touchdowns he had? Zero.

Are you friends with Matthew Berry? You should be. Hit the button below to subscribe to his

Facebook timeline.

Subscribe 161,012 people are subscribed

to Matthew Berry.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

8/17

In fact, he had only three rushing touchdowns all of last season. That's not his game. It's not why you drafthim. Obviously, you hope the touchdowns will come, but you can't be worried about Michael Bushvulturing Forte's goal-line carries because he doesn't have any to vulture. You are drafting Forte because hewill be an integral part of an offense that wants to run even more under Mike Tice than it did under MikeMartz. Forte led the NFL in offensive touches over the first eight games last year. He is a three-down backwho is a great pass-catcher -- only Darren Sproles had more targets over the first eight games last year --and he is safe and consistent and has neverhad fewer than 1,400 total yards in a season. Never.

Jimmy Graham, TE, Saints (going in 3rd, would take in2nd): And not only do I have him as a second-rounder but Ihave him as my No. 1 tight end, ahead ofRob Gronkowski,which I don't think is the norm. I still think Gronk will be astud this year, but there are more mouths to feed in NewEngland (the Patriots added Brandon Lloyd) and fewer inNew Orleans (Robert Meachem is gone) this season. Also,Graham had 25 more targets than Gronk last season. Theargument for Gronk over Graham is the touchdowns, andthey are just too tough to predict.

Graham is safer to me because of how involved he is in theSaints' offense: Forget tight ends, Graham was fifth intargets (149) among all players last season, tied for secondin red zone targets, third in total receptions and seventh inreceiving yards.

And lest you think that last year was a fluke, or that I won't drop a word like "lest" on you, consider this:Since 2008, no quarterback has thrown more balls and completed more passes to a tight end than DrewBrees.

Jamaal Charles, RB, Chiefs (3rd, 2nd): "Injury! Peyton Hillis! Didn't you hear me on Michael Bush!" Yes,

the Charles haters get half-price membership and a free lube job when joining the Matt Forte Haters Club atthe same time. Look, until we see Charles on the field, we won't know whether he has recovered all of hisburst and elusiveness after ACL surgery. So I am reserving my right to bail on this after a few preseasongames, OK? But, as of right now, my thinking is this: After the first few guys, you start getting into seriousquestion marks.

Darren McFadden's health. Maurice Jones-Drew's ongoing holdout (as of this writing). Will MarshawnLynch get suspended? What about DeMarco Murray and his health? And we have a very small body ofwork on which to judge him. Is Trent Richardson good enough to overcome everything else that is wrongwith the Browns? So, as long as we are into the "question mark running back territory," I'd rather take theguy who had his injury almost a year ago, who is young enough to recover fully (just 25) and who claims to

"have his mojo" back. Remember Charles' killer 2010 season? He averaged fewer than 15 carries a game.Volume is not his game. Frankly, I am happy that Hillis is there and, as you'll see, I feel both backs willhave good years. For you aspiring writers out there, that is called "foreshadowing." And not to show off allmy writing tricks, but this next one is called "a bad transition." Next player!

Michael Vick, QB, Eagles (4th, end of 2nd): The logic from last year remains the same, the price is justcheaper this year. If he stays healthy, he has the ability, the weapons around him and the offensive schemeto put up the greatest fantasy season ever. Period. Tons of upside, obvious downside, as well. Clearly, I am acounselor, campfire song leader and organizer of the overnight canoe trip at Camp Rewardisworththerisk.One of the few times I go away from my "safe early, upside later" mantra. His upside is thatgreat. If you

It's highly doubtful that Sean Payton's last words toDrew Brees before his suspension began were"Listen, Drew, I'm not going to be around to guidethe offense next season, but if you want to win,

whatever you do,stop throwing it to Jimmy!"



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

9/17

don't agree with me, don't draft him. But the year afterI'm all-in on him? There's no way he's notgoing off.

Steven Jackson, RB, Rams (4th, 3rd): Friend-of-the-podcast Steven Jackson is the main guy on a team thatwill run the ball a lot. He has missed just two games the past three seasons, and as bad as the Rams were, hewas still tied as the 10th-best fantasy running back last year. In a year with so many question marks, Jacksonis a solid No. 2 running back to grab in the third, as there will still be lots of good wideouts left in the fourth.And the fifth. And the sixth.

Brandon Marshall, WR, Bears (4th, 3rd): Make no mistake, the off-the-field issues are a concern, but hehas acknowledged in interviews the great opportunity he has in Chicago, and I expect a more matureMarshall. Being reunited with Jay Cutler and quarterbacks coach Jeremy Bates (who was with both guys inDenver when Cutler and Marshall connected on back-to-back 100-catch seasons) is key. Those years wereMarshall's best two years as a pro, leading the NFL in targets. Since 2007, Marshall has never had fewerthan 1,000 yards and never finished lower than 13th among fantasy wide receivers, and he has had to playwith nine different quarterbacks. Back with Bates and Cutler, he's safe, with upside for more.

Julio Jones, WR, Falcons (4th, 3rd): Someday, in the near future, we will all gather 'round and chortleheartily at the idea that you could once get Julio Jones in the fourth round. In the near present, we will high-

five the TMR for winning a bet that he couldn't find a natural way to get the phrase "chortle heartily" into acolumn.

Brandon Lloyd, WR, Patriots: (6th, late 3rd/early 4th): There are threeschools of thought regarding Mr. Brandon Lloyd. The more conservativeapproach (and one drafters seem to be taking) is that there are only so manytargets to go around in New England and, although he'll have some goodgames, he also will have some in which he'll disappear, and, for that, he'sworth no more than being a low-end No. 2 , the 17th wideout off the boardat the top of Round 6. There's another school of thought that stipulates that,now that he's been reunited with Josh McDaniels and combined with TomBrady, the sky is the limit. And, of course, there's a school of thought

among bitter Redskins fans who can't believe this is the same guy whostank in Washington (23 games, zero touchdowns). I am a member of thelatter two groups. But let's focus on the positive. Big year coming forBrandon Lloyd.

So what's fair to expect from a McDaniels deep threat? In the 23 gamesLloyd has played for McDaniels, he has been targeted 236 times, or 10.2 agame, aka 163 in a 16-game season. In 2007, the last time McDaniels wasthe offensive coordinator for Brady, Randy Moss had 23 touchdowns andmore than 1,400 yards. And he was targeted 159 times. Hmm. We might beonto something.

Now, with the '07 Patriots and when he had Lloyd in Denver and St. Louis, McDaniels did not have thearray of weapons to use that he has this season with Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez, Wes Welker and apretty decent pass-catching trio of running backs hanging around. That's why our projection for Lloyd is avery reasonable 103 targets. But that's just a projection. What if Welker or one of the tight ends getsinjured? What if Bill Belichick suddenly decides he doesn't want his running backs catching balls? A lot canhappen in a 16-game season, and, for Lloyd, 160 targets isn't unattainable, it's merely his ceiling; unlikely isnot impossible.

But here's the thing. Lloyd doesn't need160 targets to have a great season. Remember, he was the No. 1

After years of being underthrownon deep, outside routes, we canjust imagine Brandon Lloyd's

delight at a barrage of perfectly

thrown Tom Brady spirals.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

10/17

wide receiver in fantasy in 2010 with Kyle Orton and Tim Tebow throwing passes to him. My 100 FactsYou Need to Know column had some good Lloyd stats (among them: most deep targets in the NFL the pasttwo years. Yes, more than Calvin Johnson), but here's one stat I didn't include, courtesy of John Parolinfrom ESPN Stats & Information: We know that Lloyd lines up wide or "outside the numbers" almostexclusively. Well, over the past two seasons, Lloyd has been underthrown on throws outside the numbers 27times, more than any other receiver in football. In fact, Lloyd's quarterbacks in that time frame havecompleted just 48 percent of their total passes to Lloyd outside the numbers. Meanwhile, Brady completed

64.2 percent of those throws the past three seasons.

At worst, Lloyd is the deep threat on one of the best offenses in football, whose playcaller loves and trustshim. At best? He's Randy Moss, circa 2007. Anywhere in between is a fine return for the sixth round, oreven earlier to make sure you get him, as I'll be doing in my drafts.

Percy Harvin, WR, Vikings (6th, 4th): Call me nutty, but you know what I like? Crazy-fast wideouts whoget to have the ball in their hands a lot. Once Christian Ponder took over in Week 7, Harvin lead all widereceivers in offensive touches, with 100. Second-most was Wes Welker ... with 74! Harvin finished the yearas the eighth-best fantasy wide receiver and yet is going outside the top 20, well behind the other big"breakout" guys from last season, Victor Cruz and Jordy Nelson.

BenJarvus Green-Ellis, RB, Bengals (6th, 5th): I did eight of my 100 Facts on Green-Ellis so I'll merelysay this: BenJarvus Green-Ellis is the poster boy this year for the "unsexy running back you can get in themiddle rounds that no one will go 'oooh, great pick' but will help you win your league." Among the guys inthis column last year that I labeled that way were Marshawn Lynch, Fred Jackson and Matt Forte. Green-Ellis will get the majority of carries on a team that likes to run, and he's never gotten the chance to get all thework. Enjoy the good production for a low cost, and enjoy the fact that I made it through this without someterrible joke about how Cincy needs a law firm.

Philip Rivers, QB, Chargers (6th, 5th): We have two sets of data to use when evaluating Rivers. The first11 games of 2011, when he was terrible, or the final five games of last season plus, you know, every otherseason in his career. As the smart kids over at numberFire tell me, even off his bad year, "Rivers still

finished No. 7 in the league in total efficiency added, adding 130 points to the Chargers' offense above whata league-average offense would have scored if put in similar situations. In fact, Rivers is the onlyquarterback to add at least 100 points above expectation in each of the past five years." I'm not convincedthe loss ofVincent Jackson is a big deal. Rivers' best season was 2010 (4,710 yards, 30 TDs) and Jacksonplayed all of five games. Was Rivers hiding an injury last year? Was he just under more pressure from anoffensive line beset by injuries? Remember, the Chargers had to sign Jared Gaither off the street and he wasstarting a few days later. I don't know. I do know that over the final five games, Rivers averaged 17.8 pointsand 282 yards a game and had 11 touchdowns and three interceptions. I'm back in.

Demaryius Thomas and Eric Decker, WR, Broncos (7th, 6th): You know how, after years of thinkingabout it, you finally did it and were like "Whoa! That's even better than I ever imagined!" I can only assume

that's what Thomas and Decker feel like after going from Kyle Orton and Tim Tebow to Peyton Manning.Don't be surprised to look over at the Broncos' sideline after the first game and see these guys smoking acigarette.

Antonio Brown, WR, Steelers (7th, 5th): Starting with his breakout game in Week 7, he was the betterfantasy wide receiver than Mike Wallace the rest of the way. Period. More targets, more receptions, moreyards and more fantasy points per game (9.8 compared to 8.0). There's a reason Brown got paid thisoffseason, you know? When a quarterback is on third down, trying to move the chains, he looks to his safetyblanket, right? Well, last year only Roddy White had more third-down catches for a first down than Brown.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

11/17

Doug Martin, RB, Buccaneers (8th, 5th): Excuse me, can you move over? And you, yes you, if you'll justturn to your right. And if you, sir -- no, not you, him, yes, that guy -- sir, if you can squeeze two steps toyour left. Great. There you go. See? Still room on the bandwagon. Among the quotes from Greg Schianoabout Doug Martin in his press conference about Martin: "He's a three-down back"; "He's good in passprotection"; "Yes, I do see some Ray Rice in him"; and "I love this kid." Been taking the first-team reps inpractice, and I don't think there's any way he lasts until the eighth round as preseason progresses.

Isaac Redman, RB, Steelers (8th, 7th): Running backs coach Kirby Wilson told the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review that Redman was going to be the third-down back this year as well. I'm sorry. Did you say I can geta good three-down back on a team that will run in the seventh round? OK, I'm listening. Who knowswhen or even ifRashard Mendenhall comes back and how effective he'll be when/if he does. Meanwhile thewacky kids at numberFire tell me this: "Last year, out of running backs with at least 100 carries, Redmanranked as the No. 11 most-efficient (whether the team performed above or below league-average standard)running back and had a success rate over 39 percent; No. 6 in the league in that category. Pittsburgh wasright in the middle of the league last year in pass-to-run ratio at 1.34, so expect a heavy reliance on Redmanin the early going."

Torrey Smith, WR, Ravens (9th, 8th): Last year, only four teams attempted more passes of 21-plus yards

than the Ravens, but most of them didn't go for completions. But you keep throwing deep, and in Smith'ssecond year, good things are going to happen. He's fast, son. Country fast. If you're asking me, "Who couldbe this year's Jordy Nelson?" -- and, since I'm writing your dialogue, that's exactly what you are saying --Torrey Smith is my vote. What's that you say? I'm handsome and smart and you love me? Stop, please,you're embarrassing me.

Robert Griffin III, QB, Redskins (8th, 8th): They aregoing to pass a lot and his potential rushing and ... whatever.I am not rational when it comes to Robert Griffin the Third.I am a teenaged girl and he is my Justin Bieber.#ILOVEYOURG3.

Peyton Hillis, RB, Chiefs (10th, 7th): The hate's gone toofar. Even a 100 percent healthy Charles isn't carrying itmore than 15 times a game. Hillis will get goal-line carries,is a good pass-catcher in his own right and will definitelyget some between-the-tackles work. Last year, new Chiefsoffensive coordinator Brian Daboll was calling plays inMiami, where the Dolphins had the sixth-most rushingattempts in the NFL. Remember, in 2010, when Charles wassetting the fantasy world on fire, Thomas Jones had over 1,000 total yards and six touchdowns on 259touches for the Chiefs. Oh, and speaking of 2010, that was Peyton Hillis' breakout year with Cleveland.Where his offensive coordinator was Brian Daboll.

Denarius Moore, WR, OAK: (10th, 8th): See Palmer, Carson, 15th round.

Donald Brown, RB, Colts (10th, 8th): Is he a great football player? Not really. Are his totals skewed byone 80-yard run against the Titans in Week 15? A little, yeah. But, per FootballOutsiders.com, Brownaveraged 4.86 ypc from two-tight-end sets last year, which is similar to what Andrew Luckran in college,and you'll see a lot of that this year, as well. Brown also doesn't have a ton of competition for the job. Iexpect Chuck Pagano to want a more conservative, between-the-tackles, control-the-clock type offense thanwe're used to seeing in Indy, given Luck's inexperience and the so-so talent around him. Brown will be agood flex/bye week fill-in guy, and to get a starting running back in the eighth is pretty solid.

RG3 as seen from the floor after one passes outafter instantly hyperventilating upon meeting him.Or so I've heard.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

12/17

Fred Davis, TE, Redskins (11th, 9th): A word about Washington's offense, from our team at Scouts Inc.:"Shanahan's rollout passing game features waggles and bootlegs off play-action and that leaves [Griffin]with a lot of half-field reads, which should really help his early production and they will throw in multipletwo-tight end sets." Last year, through the first 12 games (before his suspension), Fred Davis had 88 targets,sixth-most in the NFL and just five fewer than second place. Over that same time frame, Rob Gronkowskihad 90 targets.

This offense is designed for both RG3, Davis and his impressive yards-after-catch total; only Gronk andJimmy Graham had more than Davis' 363 yards after the catch through 12 games last season. This means alot of rollout plays to Davis and then letting him do the work. If you don't get one of the big studs, reach around or two to make sure you get Fred Davis.

Reggie Wayne, WR, Colts (11th, 9th): Currently going as the 37th wide receiver. Come on. He's not dead,he's just in Indy. There IS a difference, you know.

Jacob Tamme, TE, Broncos (12th, 11th): In case you waited on tight end and the guy right before you readeverything I wrote about Davis, console yourself with Jacob Tamme and this thought: Remember my DrewBrees stat above about how he has the most pass attempts and completions to a tight end since 2008? Well,

guess whose quarterback is second, despite missing an entire season?

Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR, Raiders (13th, 9th): See Moore, Denarius.

LeGarrette Blount, RB, Bucs (13th, 12th): Because there's a chance I am as wrong about Doug Martin as Iwas about Blount last season.

Jared Cook, TE, Titans (14th, 11th): A physical freak who is both big andfast, he could easily be this year's Jimmy Graham/Rob Gronkowski. Hecould also do nothing, like last season, when he was also on my Love list.As FootballOutsiders.com points out, he was targeted more than seventimes in seven different games last season. And three or fewer in anotherseven. If I wanted a huge-upside tight end after the top 10 were gone, he'dbe the guy I grab. Which is why I list him here. His upside is very muchworth an 11th- or 12th-round pick. But I'm also going to give this caveat: Iwouldn't want to go into the season with only him as my tight end.

Brent Celek, TE, Eagles (14th, 11th): This is crazy low. Is he amazing?No. Nor does he have the upside of some others, but he's also a bit safer.We know he's been a stud before, and he seemed to get back to that towardthe end of last year. Over the second half of the season, he was top-10 in theNFL among tight ends in targets, receptions, yardage (fourth!) andtouchdowns. Nowhere to go but up for Philly's offense this year.

Ryan Williams, RB, Cardinals (15th, 8th): Tore his right patellar tendonlast year. Still healthier than Beanie Wells.

Carson Palmer, QB, Raiders (15th, 13th): From Nov. 6, which was the first game that Palmer started forthe Raiders last season, he was top-10 in the NFL in passing attempts, completions, completion percentage,yards and yards per attempt. In fact, he was first in pass plays of more than 25 yards. And 11th intouchdowns. New offensive coordinator Gregg Knapp loves short passes and crossing routes and, luckily,Palmer has two burners in Moore and Heyward-Bey, along with a hopefully healthy Darren McFadden.

Don't hate me for hating on MJD.

Hate the fact that you know I'mprobably right.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

13/17

Palmer could pad those yardage totals without throwing as many of those interception-making deep passesthat he loves.

Randall Cobb, WR, Packers (16th, 12th): The best yards-after-catch average of any Packers wideout lastyear, he's initially going to be tough to count on week in, week out. But a young burner with talent andAaron Rodgers throwing to him? Rather take a late gamble on a guy like him, who could easily blow up,than a "safer" guy like Nate Burleson, who is what he is at this point. In the late rounds, you want upside.

And Randall Cobb has it by the bushelful. Do they still sell bushels? They do, right? At least in Green Bay?Go look that up while I get to the next guy. Let me know. Thanks.

Jacquizz Rodgers, RB, Falcons (undrafted, 12th): We know some backup running backs will pop at somepoint this year. So if we're placing bets, gimme the guy behind Michael Turner.

Vincent Brown, WR, Chargers (undrafted, 14th): Every time I've seen this guy, I like what I see. I havethe opposite reaction to Malcolm Floyd and Robert Meachem.

Kyle Rudolph, TE, Vikings (undrafted, 14th): You can't teach 6-foot-6.

A love so deep

So, standard ESPN leagues draft only 160 players (10 teams, 16 roster slots) and 20 of those are defensesand kickers. So you're really dealing with 140 players who can be drafted. Now, obviously, I know somepeople play in deeper leagues; this list is for you. Here are some deeper guys who are not being drafted inESPN standard leagues but who I have inside my personal top 140. I've divided them up into sections, sincetoward the end of your draft you're probably looking for "one more wideout" or "a backup tight end" or"that last piece of pizza or the leftover ribs?"

Quarterbacks:

Ryan Fitzpatrick, Bills: Was among the hottest things going, averaging 248 passing yards and twotouchdowns a game for the first seven weeks. Then he hurt his ribs. The ribs are better. (That is also theanswer to the pizza question).

Matt Cassell, Chiefs: Nice weapons, good dump-off options, and Brian Daboll is a really good coordinator.

Running backs:

It's all about the backup, of course; you're hoping for the starter to put on a poor performance or to getinjured (just slightly, don't really wanna root for injury, but hey, it's the NFL -- it happens). See my ranks forspecific order, but here are the backups with the best upside in terms of who is in front of them, and who Ibelieve would have success if given the carries.

Rashad Jennings, Jaguars: how is no one drafting MJD's backup? MJD could easily hold out into theseason.

Mike Goodson (and Taiwan Jones to an extent), Raiders:Darren McFadden, but I can't "like" him togood health.

Bilal Powell, Jets: Contrary to popular belief, Tim Tebow is notthe Jets' third-down back.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

14/17

Phillip Tanner, Cowboys: If something happens to DeMarco Murray, I believe Tanner, and not FelixJones, would be the guy.

Tim Hightower, Redskins: Currently running with the first team in Washington but being drafted behindRoy Helu and Evan Royster.

Wide Receivers:

Danny Amendola, Rams: Was a sleeper last year, too. Doubling down.

Greg Little, Browns: A better PPR guy than for standard scoring; at some point the Browns have to throwit. Little was top-20 in the NFL in targets last year.

Kendall Wright, Titans: Hearing great things, and you know Kenny Britt-le will provide opportunity. (Iwarned you there'd be puns.)

Leonard Hankerson, Redskins: So sue me. I'm an optimistic Redskins fan. It only happens once everydecade. Liked what I saw in limited time and they will be throwing.

Steve Smith, Rams: Hearing really good things about "the other Steve Smith."

The Baldwin Brothers: Doug in Seattle, Jon in KC and Alec on planes. All ready to show some growththis year.

Austin Collie, Colts: See Wayne, Reggie.

Tight End:

Coby Fleener, TE, Colts: Luck's security blanket. And has been for a while now.

Players I Hate this season

Maurice Jones-Drew, RB, Jaguars (being drafted in 1st, I would draft in2nd): You wanna talk about something I hate? I hate putting MJD on thislist. A great guy, a great promoter of fantasy and obviously a great runningback. But he's holding out. We saw what happened to Chris Johnson lastyear. Has any player ever come back from a holdout and had a betteryearthan the previous? I don't think so. Even if you ignore the usage last year(386 offensive touches, most in the NFL), the new offense MJD has to learnand the fact that defenses are likely to focus on stopping him and makeBlaine Gabbert beat them (hehehe -- dammit, I almost got through thatwithout laughing and everything), you're still left with the fact that Mauriceis a proud guy (rightfully so) and may very well hold out for a long time.You can't take that risk in the first round.

Larry Fitzgerald, WR, Cardinals (1st, 2nd): It's not that I hate Larry. He'sawesome. No matter who is throwing to him. I have him at 17 overall, myNo. 2 wide receiver this year. I just have a tough time taking any wideout(even Megatron, whom I have at 10) in the first round given how deepwideout is. Seriously. Jeremy Maclin and Steve Johnson are going in the

Jared Cook is what we in the



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

15/17

seventh round and outside the top 20 of wide receivers. Seventh round.Maclin and Johnson. And Antonio Brown, whom I love. Any one of themcould end up as a top-10 guy. Crazy. Deep.

Andre Johnson, WR, Texans (2nd, late 4th/early 5th): This one is not just about depth at the position; 12missed games the past two years, he has neverhad double-digit touchdowns in a season, and the Texans ran52.2 percent of the time in '11, 2nd-most in the NFL.

Mike Wallace, WR, Steelers (3rd, 5th): I promise, I'll get off wideouts here in a second, but again, if you'regonna use a third-round pick on a wide receiver, how about getting one who isn't holding out and wasn'teven the best wide receiver on his team over the second half of last season?

Eli Manning, QB, Giants (3rd/4th, take in 5th): Great year for Eli. Really great year. Threw for almost5,000 yards, the sixth-most in NFL history. And he still wasn't a top-five fantasy quarterback. He's thrownmore than 30 touchdowns once in an eight-year career. And with Mario Manningham being replaced byrookie Reuben Randle (whom I like, but still), I don't see that trend being broken. So now it's about hisyardage. Here's the percentage of pass plays the Giants have called under Tom Coughlin the past five years.

2011 -- 60 percent2010 -- 53.6 percent2009 -- 56.4 percent2008 -- 50.8 percent2007 -- 54.9 percent

One guess which season was the outlier? The Giants are traditionally a power-running team, and this yearthey will get back to that, controlling the clock and yes, Eli's fantasy value. And that's before we even get toVictor Cruz.

Victor Cruz, WR, Giants (4th, 5th): So as our player profile observes, last year Cruz scored touchdowns of4, 24, 25, 28, 68, 72, 74, 74 and 99 yards. I agree with Christopher Harris, who wrote all the profiles; therepeatability of long, crazy, acrobatic touchdowns will be tough, especially now that he's on everyone'sradar and the Giants will be throwing less. Think he's pretty good, don't think he's this good.

Michael Turner, RB, Falcons (4th, 4th): I reserve the right to take him offthis list soon. We're dangerouslyclose to "the hate has gone too far" territory. I still like the upside of Jaquizz, and Turner will be on otherpeople's teams in most of my leagues, but there does come a point where you're like, so what if he's slowingdown, had tons of touches and was bailed out last year by a few big games but overall wasn't a great fantasycontributor? He's still the main guy on a good offense. But until we reach that point, he's on the wrong sideof 30, the miles have piled up on him by now, and his late-season numbers (excluding the Tampa Baygame) looked brutal.

Frank Gore, RB, 49ers (4th, 5th): Pick a stat, any stat. As the notes on our player cards, er, note, Gore'stouches went down last year (and significantly so in the second half). Pro Football Focus notes that, usingtheir metrics, Gore was "near the bottom of the league with a 23.8 elusive rating and a plus-2.1 overallrating last year". FootballOutsiders.com notes that using DVOA, their metric, Gore was lowest amongrunning backs with at least 275 carries and that "he had just 12 broken tackles last year, very low totals for astarting back." And then there's the Matthew Berry metric that points out he's had just one season withdouble-digit scores and only two seasons with all 16 games played (those late West Coast games with Gorelisted as questionable are always fun to deal with) -- and the 49ers just added Brandon Jacobs andLaMichael James to their backfield, and they already had Kendall Hunter. Gore's stuff percentage was third-highest in the NFL on runs between an opponent's 1-9 yard line, and six of his eight scores last year came

industry like to call low-risk, high-reward. This kind of player is waymore desirable to own than itscounterpart, the high-risk, low-reward player.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

16/17

from 5 yards in, which isn't something you want to count on for your touchdowns. Receptions were waydown (after 40-plus receptions for five straight years, he had just 17 last year). I always say, I'd rather jumpoff the bandwagon a year too early than a year too late. I'm off the bandwagon.

Peyton Manning, QB, Broncos (4th/5th, 6th): Archie, ifyou're reading this, I swear, I don't hate your kids. Justwhere they are being drafted. You can't tell me Peyton isn't

a risk. He's 36, off four major neck surgeries, has missed ayear, has new teammates, at least some slight changes to theoffense and 15 of 16 games will be outdoors. There isupside there, of course; he's Peyton Manning. But there isalso upside with Tony Romo and Philip Rivers. All threeguys could have injuries or regress, all three have 4,700-yard/35-TD upside. Only difference is Romo and Rivers aregoing 1-3 rounds later than Peyton.

Vernon Davis, TE, 49ers (6th, 11th): Two. Because of lastyear's playoffs, people will forget the number two. As in,

last year, Vernon Davis had just two games in which he scored more than five fantasy points without alsoscoring a touchdown. (Tony Gonzalez, by comparison, had six such games last year.) I hate a tight end whois so touchdown-dependent for his fantasy value. And I don't believe the playoffs are a harbinger of thingsto come; the 49ers are not going to win with Alex Smith throwing it 42 times like he did against the Saints(he averaged 27 attempts a game last year). Davis was only 10th in targets among tight ends, as the 49erswent with a ball-control, running offense last year. And as our player profile, er, profiles, Vernon's 6.7 yardsat the catch was outside the top 20. So not a ton of looks his way, comparatively, and they're not throwingdeep when they do. Remains to be seen if Mario Manningham and possibly Randy Moss open things up forDavis or take that many more balls away, but my projection is that he'll score a handful of touchdowns overthe course of the season, but those will be hard to predict. You can get that kind of tight end much later. Forwhere Davis is being drafted (No. 4 at the position), he needs to be much more than that.

Roy Helu, RB, Redskins (6th, 9th): Current reports have him third on the depth chart. That changes everysecond with Mike Shanahan, but that's the problem. He's a Redskins running back. Don't trust the lot ofthem.

Vincent Jackson, WR, Buccaneers (6th, 7th): He's just so many things I hate: A guy who just got paid,who has never really proven he's worth it; he's on a new team with a new playbook and quarterback; he hasdowngraded his QB and he's a fantasy whack-a-mole; he'll have huge games and then disappear. And withV-Jax, be it injury or contract or controversy, it just seems there's always something with him. Consideringthat guys like Harvin, Maclin, Steve Johnson, Antonio Brown and Demaryius Thomas are being draftedafter him and can be had cheaper, Jackson won't be on any of my teams this year.

Stevan Ridley, RB, Patriots (7th, 11th): Just can't imagine a scenario where I'd ever feel good aboutstarting a Patriots running back. Lotta mouths to feed in their run game, which takes a back seat to their passgame; he's as good a guess as any to have the most value of any New England back, but good luck trying tohit that lottery.

Jonathan Stewart (7th , 9th) and DeAngelo Williams, RBs, Panthers (9th, 10th): See Ridley, Stevan.Barring injuries that thin the herd, would never feel confident starting either guy.

San Francisco 49ers D/ST (8th, 15th): Really, guys? A defense in the eighth? Also going in the eighthround as of this writing: Doug Martin, Robert Griffin the Third, Isaac Redman, Aaron Hernandez, Ben

No fantasy points are scored for football lineage,"Saturday Night Live" appearances, or commercialsin which you and Deion Sanders dress up as faeries.



7/31/2019 Love-Hate 2012

17/17

Roethlisberger. Really, guys? Really?

Jahvid Best, RB, Lions (9th, 14th): Can't stay healthy. Even if he could, the Lions can't run. Even if theycould, there's competition there. Too many question marks to be going ahead of guys like Hillis, C.J. Spilleror Michael Bush.

Santonio Holmes, WR, Jets (10th, 12th): Well, unless your league gives points for blocking on the QB

option.

Stephen Gostkowski, K, Patriots (11th, 16th): All you 49ers defense-drafting fools I just insulted? All isforgiven. Sigh.

Sidney Rice, WR, Seahawks (12th, 16th): When a team says, "You know what? We think the drama of analmost-40-year-old Terrell Owens is a better option than having you as the undisputed No. 1 receiver," that'sa hint. Lotta wideouts with more upside and less injury risk and better quarterback situations going laterthan Rice.

Felix Jones, RB, Cowboys (12th, 16th): Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me every single season

Andy Dalton, QB. Bengals (13th, wouldn't draft): Very tough division, conservative offense, single-digitfantasy points in three of his final five games. He doesn't have the fantasy upside of Carson Palmer, RyanFitzpatrick, Joe Flacco or even Andrew Luck, all of whom are being drafted after him.

Kellen Winslow, TE, Seahawks (14th/15th, wouldn't draft) As our player profile, er, notes, yes, that's it!As our player profile notes, he's never had more than five scores in a season, has gone an insane 39 startswith just one 100-yard game and now he's on a new team trotting out a new offense with questionablequarterback play. He's going ahead of much higher upside guys like Jermaine Gresham, Kyle Rudolph,Dustin Keller, Scott Chandler and Martellus Bennett, whom I should have mentioned in the love sectionabove. I actually think Bennett could have a nice year in New York, free from the shadow ofJason Witten.

And there we have it, Love/Hate for the 2012 preseason is in the books. Many more updates, articles,podcasts, video, "Fantasy Football Now" episodes, rankings, mock drafts, tweets and Facebook postscoming your way before we kick the season off, but in the meantime, when you saw this link and any otherlink to a something I've done thank you for saying yes.

Matthew Berry -- The Talented Mr. Roto --will also say yes to any league RG3 wants him to play in. Berryis the creator ofRotoPass.com, a website that combines a bunch of well-known fantasy sites, including

ESPN Insider, for one low price. Use promo code ESPN for 10 percent off.


love-hate 2012

Documents