looking into the future - ycc.vision · looking into the future: which is more aesthetically...

1
Adjustment Task An Inward Bias in Aesthetics Why do we have aesthetic experience? Inward biases can be driven by minimal directional cues This aesthetic preference may help us 'look into the future' Aesthetic preferences can be adaptive! Yi-Chia Chen 1,2 , Clara Colombatto 2 , & Brian Scholl 2 ( 1 Harvard University & 2 Yale University) An inward bias in aesthetic experience driven only by gaze cues Stimuli An inward bias driven only by averted gaze! Looking into the future: Which is more aesthetically pleasing? (Palmer et al., 2008, Spatial Vision) Looking into the Future? “Position the person so that the photo looks maximally aesthetically pleasing” % position shift = Main Difficulty Global shape confounds Solution Gaze: Minimal changes -100 -50 0 50 100 Direct* Averted % Position Shift Maximum Inward Shift Maximum Outward Shift *Signs defined by the corresponding averted images p < .001 mechanical turk beta N=240 single trial Individual Responses Group Data This is driven by perceived gaze direction per se Individual Responses Group Data Control for Geometric Factors Chen, Y. -C., Colombatto, C., & Scholl, B. J. (2018). Looking into the future: An inward bias in aesthetic experience driven only by gaze cues. Cognition, 176, 209-214. VISION SCIENCES LABORATORY 2018 VSS Experiment 1 Dependent Measure position shift maximum shift x 100 % Inward (+) Outward (-) Experiment 2 M averted M direct Question An Adaptive Feature? Manipulate perceived gaze direction -100 -50 0 50 100 Direct Averted Facing inward Facing outward Conclusions We prefer viewpoints that will let us see predicted future events unfold A v e r t e d - G a z e T r i a l s D i r e c t - G a z e T r i a l s Color Intact Color Inverted p < .001 p = .008 % Position Shift Maximum Inward Shift Maximum Outward Shift Reprint?

Upload: others

Post on 30-Sep-2020

12 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Looking into the future - ycc.vision · Looking into the future: Which is more aesthetically pleasing? (Palmer et al., 2008, Spatial Vision) Looking into the Future? “Position the

Adjustment Task

An Inward Bias in Aesthetics

Why do we have aesthetic experience? Inward biases can be driven

by minimal directional cues

This aesthetic preference may help us 'look into the future'

Aesthetic preferencescan be adaptive!

Yi-Chia Chen1,2, Clara Colombatto 2, & Brian Scholl

2 (1Harvard University & 2 Yale University)An inward bias in aesthetic experience driven only by gaze cues

Stimuli

An inward bias drivenonly by averted gaze!

Looking into the future:

Which is more aesthetically pleasing?

(Palmer et al., 2008, Spatial Vision)

Looking into the Future?

“Position the person so that the photo looks maximally aesthetically pleasing”

% position shift =

Main Difficulty

Global shape confounds

Solution

Gaze: Minimal changes

-100

-50

0

50

100

Direct* Averted% P

ositi

on S

hift

MaximumInward Shift

MaximumOutward Shift

*Signs defined by the corresponding averted images

p < .001

mechanical turkbeta

N=240single trial

Individual Responses

Group Data

This is driven by perceived gaze direction per se

Individual Responses

Group Data

Control for Geometric Factors

Chen, Y. -C., Colombatto, C., & Scholl, B. J. (2018). Looking into the future: An inward biasin aesthetic experience driven only by gaze cues. Cognition, 176, 209-214.

VISION SCIENCESLABORATORY

2018VSS

Experiment 1

Dependent Measure

position shiftmaximum shift

x 100 %Inward

(+)Outward

(-)

Experiment 2

Maverted Mdirect

Question

An Adaptive Feature?

Manipulate perceived gaze direction

-100

-50

0

50

100

Direct Averted

Facing inwardFacing outward

Conclusions

We prefer viewpoints that will let us see predicted future events unfold

Averted-GazeTrials

Direct-GazeTrials

Color Intact Color Inverted

p < .001p = .008

% P

ositi

on S

hift

MaximumInward Shift

MaximumOutward Shift

Reprint?