long –term care financing reform what role for states? hunter mckay us department of health and...
TRANSCRIPT
Long –Term Care Financing Reform What Role For States?
Hunter McKay
US Department of Health and Human ServicesOffice of Assistant Secretary for Planning And Evaluation
Contact Information: 202-205-8999
Long Term Care Financing
• The Status Quo: The current financing system allows retirees and pre-retirees to remain blissfully ignorant of how long term care is financed until it is too late for anything but draconian measures.
impoverishment – welfare – loss of control
• The Problem Ahead: The size and characteristics of the soon to be retiring baby boom generation makes this approach unworkable – unaffordable – perhaps even unnecessary.
Sources and Types of Funding
• Three public sources of financing:Medicaid Medicare pay as you go – no pre-
fundingVeterans
• Multiple Private SourcesOut-of-Pocket pay as you go + some pre-
funding InsuranceAnnuity pre-fundingHome equity conversion
An Alternative Perspective
• Long term care financing reform is not just a Medicaid problem.
• Future Medicaid long term care users are not strangers.
• States have a vested interest in helping residents to: 1) understand their risk, and 2) meet the financing challenge.
• No silver bullet – a multi-faceted approach has the best chance for success.
• Increasing pre-funding must happen now.• States Are Key
Why Worry About Pre-Funding Now?
• Oldest baby boomer is aged 58 and the youngest is 39.
• Opportunities for pre-funding diminish as boomers retire.
• Among those boomers are an indeterminate number of “tweeners”; those for whom planning for long term care would make difference between using and not using Medicaid.
What Can States Do?
1. Change The Culture/ExpectationsNo longer should pre-retirees and early
retirees remain unaware of their risk and their options.
2. Expand Financing OptionsConsumers should have a number of different
ways to finance their own long-term care using a variety of different financial instruments.
3. Focus on MedicaidStates must know who is on Medicaid for long
term care and how they got there.
Change The Culture/Expectations
• Goal: Increase awareness of long term care risk and options for planning ahead.
• Mechanisms:1. Public awareness campaign, (PSAs, mailings, press
events);2. Aging agencies offer to assist boomers in planning;3. SHIP program offers assistance in buying insurance;4. Recruit corporate partners to carry message;5. Publish state guide to LTC insurance plans sold in
state.
• Bottom Line: State conveys a consistent message on personal responsibility for financing long term care.
Expand Financing Options
• Goal: Increase options for consumers to pre-fund long term care.
• Mechanisms: 1. Tax incentives consumers;2. Tax incentives for businesses;3. LTC insurance for state employees;4. Partnership For Long-Term Care;5. Housing agency offers reverse mortgage;6. Single purpose loans - family loan
programs.
• Bottom Line: Consumers need more options to meet this challenge.
Medicaid
• Goal: Clarify expectations for the role that Medicaid plays in financing care.
• Mechanisms:1. Review up front eligibility screens – make
excessive transfer of assets difficult;2. Review estate recovery programs to
ensure follow-through and fairness;3. Research: Who is spending down, Medicaid
qualifying trusts, Medicaid friendly annuities;
• Bottom Line: Consistent and fair determination of Medicaid eligibility that provides incentives for planning.
A Systems Approach
• Significant state innovation already exists in isolated program areas.
• What works for some states will not work for others.
• Long term care financing likely to remain a shared public-private responsibility.
• A systems approach uses multiple components to align consumer incentives, coordinate with public benefits and present a consistent message.
• Innovation within the context of fully developed strategy.
State Examples
• Minnesota Statewide educational
campaign State tax credit LTC insurance for
state employees Transfer of assets
waiver Milbank/EBRI project Expanded planning
process Family loan program* Partnership for long
term care*
• Connecticut LTC insurance for
state employees Statewide educational
campaign Partnership for long
term care Home equity
conversion program Transfer of assets
waiver
Summary
• States play a key role in changing the way retirees and pre-retirees plan for long term care.
• State leadership is critical is the following areas: Awareness among pre-retirees and society in general New financing options designed to maximize flexibility
and consumer control A clear sense of how public and private funding will be
coordinated to align incentives and preserve Medicaid.
• The best chance for success is through a complementary set of strategies tailored for state characteristics, and oriented toward the long term.