linking pollinator behavior to selfing rate for three prinng · selfing can decrease the level of...

1
Linking pollinator behavior to selfing rate for three distinct pollinators of alfalfa Emmanuel Santa-Martinez 1 and Johanne Brunet 1,2 1 Department of Entomology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2 United States Department of Agriculture, ARS Abstract Insect pollinators are important to seed production but little is known about their impact on pollen dispersal and the amount of selfed seeds produced on a plant. Selfing can decrease the level of heterozygosity within populations and increase genetic differences among populations. High selfing can reduce fitness and yield, especially when inbreeding depression is high. Pollinator movements on a plant can affect selfing. We examined how the differences among pollinators in foraging behavior and pollen deposition patterns can affect a plant’s selfing rate. Selfing rate was measured on an alfalfa field pollinated with distinct pollinators. Fieldwide selfing rate was estimated at 27%. To compare the impact of these pollinators on selfing rate in alfalfa, we conducted individual greenhouse experiments with honey bees, common eastern bumble bees, and alfalfa leafcutting bees. We measured the number of open flowers per raceme, and number of racemes per plant to assess the effect of different floral displays on bee behavior and the impact on selfing rate. The results showed that large amount of flowers available on a plant can increase attractiveness and visitation rates of pollinators. Visiting more flowers in succession on a plant increases the selfing rate. An increase in the total number of open flowers per raceme and in the number of racemes per plant increase selfing rates with the three bee species studied. This study will shed light on how distinct pollinators affect plant mating systems and the genetic structure of plant populations. Introduction Decrease in heterozygosity Deleterious alleles in homozygous plants Negatively impact plant fitness Inbreeding depression = reduction in seed yield Methodology Results Selfing rate in the field was 27%, which is high for a plant that relies mainly on outcross pollination. Pollinator type does not influence selfing. Fields using different managed pollinators may not exhibit differences in selfing rate. Large amount of flowers available on a plant can increase attractiveness and the visitation rates of pollinators. Visiting more flowers in succession on a plant increase selfing rate (geitonogamous selfing). Higher selfing rates in plants with larger floral displays: Selfing rate increases with the number of racemes per plant. Selfing rate increases with the number of flowers per plant In well-managed alfalfa seed production fields we expect geitonogamous selfing in plants with larger floral displays. Large floral displays > increase visitation rates > higher selfing rate = inbreeding depression = decrease in seed yield. Acknowledgements This project was supported by a Biotechnology Risk Assessment Grant Program, competitive grant no. 2013-33522-20999 from the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture to J. Brunet. Special thanks to Dr. Heathclife Riday for providing the microsatellite marker. Contact information: E. Santa: [email protected] , J. Brunet: [email protected] Discussion Selfing Selfing rate Selfing rate: the proportion of the seeds on the plant that result from self pollination. High selfing rate = reduce gene flow. Selfing in agricultural crops is affected by how pollinators forage on plants and plants floral display size. Pollinators visiting more flowers in succession on a plant can increase the level of geitonogamous (within plant) selfing. Study species Alfalfa, Medicago sativa Outcrossed perennial legume Tripping mechanism Seed and hay production Relies on insect pollinators for seeds 28 million kg of seeds per year in USA Bombus impatiens Bumblebee Apis mellifera Honeybee Megachile rotundata Alfalfa Leafcutting bee 1) Before bee behavior experiments: Selected thirty alfalfa plants with unique genotypes • 3 clones per plant (one per bee species) • 10’x10’x6’ cages in a large greenhouse Each plant had a different floral display: • Count the number of racemes per plant. • Count the number of flowers in marked racemes 2) Bee behavior experiments: For each bee species foraging bout (n=20) we measured: • The number of plants visited • The number of racemes visited per plant • The number of flowers visited per raceme 3) After bee behavior experiment: Counted fruits and seeds developed in marked racemes: • 24 seeds selected to genotype per plant (30 plants) Estimating Selfing Rate in Field and Bee Greenhouse Experiments Used Microsatellites (SSR) for paternity analysis DNA extracted from leaf tissue (mother) and seeds (offspring) Genotypes of DNA samples were scored with 12 SSRs Multilocus genotypes of mothers and offspring analyzed using an Exclusion-based paternity - SAS code developed by Heathcliffe Riday Fig 1. Example of comparing mother and offspring genotypes. If alleles observed in progeny = alleles observed in maternal plants, self- fertilization may occur. Multiple loci are needed for a better estimation of selfing rate. Results 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 Outcross Self # of seeds (progeny) Modes of pollination 73% 27% Fig 2. Selfing rate in an alfalfa field setting pollinated by the three distinct pollinators Fig 3. The impact of three bee species on selfing rate in alfalfa (bee greenhouse experiments). p= <0.0001 p= 0.005 p=0.02 p=0.005 Fig 4. Total # of flowers visited per pollinator type in plants with different numbers of flowers available. Fig 5. The effect of the number of flowers visited per plant on selfing rate per bee species. Fig 6. The effect of the number of racemes per plant on selfing rate per bee species. Fig 7. The effect of the total number of flowers per plant on selfing rate per bee species. Greenhouse setting for each bee type Thirty unique alfalfa plants with different genotypes and floral display size. Fig 4. Fig 5. Fig 6. Fig 7.

Upload: others

Post on 24-Oct-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Prin%ng:This  poster  is  48”  wide  by  36”  high.  It’s  designed  to  be  printed  on  a  large-‐format  printer.

    Customizing  the  Content:The  placeholders  in  this  poster  are  formaFed  for  you.  Type  in  the  placeholders  to  add  text,  or  click  an  icon  to  add  a  table,  chart,  SmartArt  graphic,  picture  or  mul%media  file.

    To  add  or  remove  bullet  points  from  text,  click  the  Bullets  buFon  on  the  Home  tab.

    If  you  need  more  placeholders  for  %tles,  content  or  body  text,  make  a  copy  of  what  you  need  and  drag  it  into  place.  PowerPoint’s  Smart  Guides  will  help  you  align  it  with  everything  else.

    Want  to  use  your  own  pictures  instead  of  ours?  No  problem!  Just  click  a  picture,  press  the  Delete  key,  then  click  the  icon  to  add  your  picture.

    Linking pollinator behavior to selfing rate for three distinct pollinators of alfalfa

    Emmanuel Santa-Martinez1 and Johanne Brunet 1,2 1Department of Entomology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2United States Department of Agriculture, ARS

    Abstract Insect pollinators are important to seed production but little is known about their impact on pollen dispersal and the amount of selfed seeds produced on a plant. Selfing can decrease the level of heterozygosity within populations and increase genetic differences among populations. High selfing can reduce fitness and yield, especially when inbreeding depression is high. Pollinator movements on a plant can affect selfing. We examined how the differences among pollinators in foraging behavior and pollen deposition patterns can affect a plant’s selfing rate. Selfing rate was measured on an alfalfa field pollinated with distinct pollinators. Field‐wide selfing rate was estimated at 27%. To compare the impact of these pollinators on selfing rate in alfalfa, we conducted individual greenhouse experiments with honey bees, common eastern bumble bees, and alfalfa leafcutting bees. We measured the number of open flowers per raceme, and number of racemes per plant to assess the effect of different floral displays on bee behavior and the impact on selfing rate. The results showed that large amount of flowers available on a plant can increase attractiveness and visitation rates of pollinators. Visiting more flowers in succession on a plant increases the selfing rate. An increase in the total number of open flowers per raceme and in the number of racemes per plant increase selfing rates with the three bee species studied. This study will shed light on how distinct pollinators affect plant mating systems and the genetic structure of plant populations.

    Introduction

    Decrease in heterozygosity • Deleterious alleles in homozygous plants

    Negatively impact plant fitness •  Inbreeding depression = reduction in seed yield

    Methodology Results

    Selfing rate in the field was 27%, which is high for a plant that relies mainly on outcross pollination.

    Pollinator type does not influence selfing. Fields using different managed pollinators may not exhibit differences in selfing rate.

    Large amount of flowers available on a plant can increase attractiveness and the visitation rates of pollinators.

    Visiting more flowers in succession on a plant increase selfing rate (geitonogamous selfing).

    Higher selfing rates in plants with larger floral displays:

    • Selfing rate increases with the number of racemes per plant. • Selfing rate increases with the number of flowers per plant

    In well-managed alfalfa seed production fields we expect geitonogamous selfing in plants with larger floral displays.

    Large floral displays > increase visitation rates > higher selfing rate = inbreeding depression = decrease in seed yield.

    Acknowledgements This project was supported by a Biotechnology Risk Assessment Grant Program, competitive grant no. 2013-33522-20999 from the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture to J. Brunet. Special thanks to Dr. Heathclife Riday for providing the microsatellite marker.

    Contact information: E. Santa: [email protected], J. Brunet: [email protected]

    Discussion

    Selfing

    Selfing rate Selfing rate: the proportion of the seeds on the plant that result from self pollination.

    High selfing rate = reduce gene flow.

    Selfing in agricultural crops is affected by how pollinators forage on plants and plants floral display size.

    Pollinators visiting more flowers in succession on a plant can increase the level of geitonogamous (within plant) selfing.

    Study species

    Alfalfa, Medicago sativa

    Outcrossed perennial legume

    Tripping mechanism

    Seed and hay production

    Relies on insect pollinators for seeds

    28 million kg of seeds per year in USA

    Bombus impatiens Bumblebee

    Apis mellifera Honeybee

    Megachile rotundata Alfalfa Leafcutting bee

    1) Before bee behavior experiments:

    Selected thirty alfalfa plants with unique genotypes • 3 clones per plant (one per bee species) • 10’x10’x6’ cages in a large greenhouse

    Each plant had a different floral display: • Count the number of racemes per plant. • Count the number of flowers in marked racemes

    2) Bee behavior experiments:

    For each bee species foraging bout (n=20) we measured: • The number of plants visited • The number of racemes visited per plant • The number of flowers visited per raceme

    3) After bee behavior experiment:

    Counted fruits and seeds developed in marked racemes: • 24 seeds selected to genotype per plant (30 plants)

    Estimating Selfing Rate in Field and Bee Greenhouse Experiments

    Used Microsatellites (SSR) for paternity analysis

    DNA extracted from leaf tissue (mother) and seeds (offspring)

    Genotypes of DNA samples were scored with 12 SSRs

    Multilocus genotypes of mothers and offspring analyzed using an Exclusion-based paternity

    - SAS code developed by Heathcliffe Riday

    Fig 1. Example of comparing mother and offspring genotypes. If alleles observed in p rogeny = a l l e les observed in maternal plants, self- fertilization may occur. Multiple loci are needed for a better estimation of selfing rate.

    Results

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    600

    Outcross Self

    # of

    see

    ds (p

    roge

    ny)

    Modes of pollination

    73%

    27%

    Fig 2. Selfing rate in an alfalfa field setting pollinated by the three distinct pollinators

    Fig 3. The impact of three bee species on selfing rate in alfalfa (bee greenhouse experiments).

    p=