lincoln v daylight chemical, et al. - transcript of hearing - 3-7-11

8/7/2019 LINCOLN v DAYLIGHT CHEMICAL, et al. - Transcript of Hearing - 3-7-11

1/7

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTCENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

HONORABLE ANDREW J . GUILFORD, JUDGE PRESIDING; COURTROOM 100

CERTIFIED TRANSCRIPTCHARLES EDWARD LINCOLN I I I ,

P l a i n t i f f ( s ) ,

v s . No. SACV 10-1573-AG(PLAx)

DAYLIGHT CHEMICAL INFORMATIONSYSTEMS INCORPORATED, ET AL.,

Defendant(s) .

REPORTER'S DAILY TRANSCRIPT OF PRETRIAL PROCEEDINGSSANTA ANA, CALIFORNIATHURSDAY, MARCH 3, 2011

DENISE PADDOCKCSR 10199, CMRS, RMR, CRRt r ansc r ip t s@ocrecord . com

U.S. DISTRICT COURT REPORTER


2/7

A P P EA RAN C E S030711 DCCD GUILFORD 10D LINCOLNSACV 10 -1573 -AG(PLAx )

IN BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF:

IN BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANT:

No Appearance

Katherine M HarwoodFord Walker Hagger ty BeharOne World Trade Cente r27th FloorLong Beach, CA 90831-2700562-983-2512Email : [email protected] A RossBradley and Gmelich700 N Brand Blvd, 10th FloorGlendale , CA 91203-1202818-243-5200Fax: 818-243-5266Email : [email protected]

Orly TaitzLaw Off ices o f Dr. Orly Ta i tz26302 La Paz, Sui te 211Mission Viejo , CA 92691949-683-5411Email : dr t a i t z@yahoo .com


3/7

1

234

11:03 56789

11041011121314

11041516171819

11042021222324

110425

030711 DCCD GUILFORD 10D LINCOLN SACV 10-1573-AG(PLAx)

SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA; THURSDAY, MARCH 3, 2011THE CLERK: I tem 14, SACV 10-1573-AG(PLAx):

Char les Edward Lincoln , I I I v. Dayl igh t Chemical Informat ionSystems, I n c . , e t a l .

MR. ROSS: Good morning, Your Honor.Jonathan Ross on b eh a l f o f Defendant Yosef Tai tz

and Dayl igh t Chemical Informat ion Systems.MS. HARWOOD: Good morning, Your Honor.Kather ine Harwood on b eh a l f o f the Law Off ices of

Orly Tai tz and Or ly T ai t z .MS. TAITZ: Good morning, Your Honor.Or ly Tai tz and I am represen t ing Defend Our

Freedoms Foundation and Orly T ai t z , Incorpora ted .THE COURT: And what was your name again?MS. HARWOOD: Kather ine Harwood.THE COURT: Harwood?MS. HARWOOD: H-a- r -w-o-o-d .THE COURT: A ll r i g h t . Have we heard from th e

p l a i n t i f f a t a l l concerning t h i s motion?MS. TAITZ: Well , not rega rd ing t h i s motion,

Your Honor.THE COURT: I 'm j u s t asking if anyone ' s heard and

ap p aren t ly no one has heard .MS. HARWOOD: No, Your Honor.THE COURT: A ll r i g h t . That might be because the

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

1


4/7

1

234

11:04 56789

11041011121314

11051516171819

11052021222324

110525

030711 DCCD GUILFORD 10D LINCOLN SACV 10-1573-AG(PLAx)2

p l a i n t i f f i s in need o f ge t t ing new counsel a t the moment.So I w i l l be keeping t h a t in mind.When d id you rece ive th e t en t a t i v e from the defense

s ide?MS. HARWOOD: Sunday n ig h t , Your Honor.THE COURT: A ll r i g h t . So who would l i k e to

address the t e n t a t i v e ?MS. HARWOOD: It's your mot ion .MS. TAITZ: Yes, Your Honor.I submi t on th e t en t a t i v e and so do o t h e r

a t t o rn ey s .We have no problem. And as a mat te r o f fac t , I ' v e

a l read y f i l ed a one-page reques t fo r c l a r i f i c a t i o n where Is t a t ed t h a t I unders tood t h a t t h a t motion would be moot dueto your p r i o r ru l i n g .

I j u s t d i d n ' t hear on t h a t - - on t h a t reques t fo rc l a r i f i c a t i o n . That ' s why we ' re he r e .

THE COURT: Oh, I see .I ap p rec i a t e t h a t .A ll r i g h t .

MS. TAITZ: I f - - t he on ly t h in g t h a t I wantedto - - to s t a t e , we a l l submi t on th e t e n t a t i v e . There i s noproblem t h e re . I j u s t wanted to prov ide Your Honor with ano rd e r by anothe r f ed e ra l judge in rega rd to th e sameP l a i n t i f f in a s imi l a r proceed ing where he r ep ea t ed ly did no tshow up.



5/7

1

234

11:05 56789

11061011121314

11061516171819

1106 2021222324

1106 25


This i s th e second t ime he i s no t he re .THE COURT: Oh, bu t , Ms. Tai t z , you moved to

d i squa l i f y h is lawyer , so you ' r e not now going to make s t rongarguments t h a t h is f a i l u r e to appear here has consequences .

Let me tell you, when I d i squa l i f y a lawyer , I 'mgoing to g ran t them a little b i t o f len iency if t h e re i s acou r t appearance requ i red a few days l a t e r .

MS. TAITZ: Oh, I under s tand , Your Honor .I j u s t wan ted to l e t you know wh a t ensued in t h a t

case - -THE COURT: Let me ask , how i s t h a t r e l evan t to

wha t we ' r e doing here today?MS. TAITZ: I f I might ge t j u s t one minute .THE COURT: You know, I occas iona l ly give you these

"one minutes" and t hen f ive minutes l a t e r I f ind t ha t we ' renot r e a l l y address ing what ' s before us; bu t I'll give you oneminute and we 'll see if it's r e l evan t to anyth ing n ow pendingbefore t h i s cou r t .

Go ahead .MS. TAITZ: It was a s imi l a r case .I do have an o rd e r by Judge Jack in Texas wh e r e he

s im i l a r l y fo rc ed s igna tu re o f anothe r a t t o rney .He d i dn ' t show up a couple t imes ; t h e re was an

o rd e r o f contempt. He d i dn ' t show up; there wa s an orde r fo rh is a r r e s t . He wen t on the run. F ir s t to Canada,



6/7

1

234

11:07 56789

11071011121314

11071516171819

11072021222324

1108 25

030711 DCCD GUILFORD 10D LINCOLN SACV 10-1573-AG(PLAx)

l a t e r to Mexico.Mr. Lincoln has a t r u s t e e by th e name o f

Peyton Freeman, and Mr. Freeman was apprehended on US/Canadaborder wi th a book on th e Unabomber and - - who made as t a t e m e n t , "domest ic t e r r o r i s t i s board ing a plane toTexas" - - excuse me - - "to Mexico, where he was a r r e s t e d ,ex t r ad i t ed to US, was i n c a r c e r a t e d here in Cal i fo rn i a andex t r ad i t ed to Texas here again."

Mr. Lincoln has f i l ed h is compla in t pro se . Hef i l ed it a year a f t e r

THE COURT: Okay. So your minute i s up, I ' v el i s t e n e d to what you 've sa i d , and t h e re fo re I should - -

MS. TAITZ: I f you would c ons i de r reques t ing - - inl i g h t of t he f a c t t h a t he has t endency to run, if you wouldc ons i de r reques t ing t h a t the p l a i n t i f f pos t a bond before hef i l e s any fu r t h e r - -

4

THE COURT: I f you want t h a t , I hate to say it, bu tyou 'd have to do it by a mot ion .

Sure ly you d o n ' t th ink t h a t here , wi thou t himp resen t , me having r ecen t l y - - I sh o u l d n ' t say I"d i sq u a l i f i ed " h is l awyer . I d id not g ran t him pro hac v i ce .I d id not g ran t h is pro hac vice req u es t , so I d o n ' t b e l i ev et h e re ' s anyth ing pending .

I would only do t h a t on f i l i n g o f a mot ion .At t h i s p o i n t , based on what you 've s a i d , I would



7/7


1 not be i n c l i n ed to do it.2 Anything fu r th e r?3 MS. TAITZ: One o th e r4 THE COURT: My goodness , we ' r e here on your mot ions

11:08 5 to s t r i k e , which are denied . We do not have the p l a i n t i f f6 r ep resen ted .7 I th ink you j u s t sa id a moment ago "one other" and8 we got the "one other ," so I th ink we ' r e concluded here .9 MS. TAITZ: Okay.

11:08 10 THE COURT: Thank you.11 The t en t a t i v e w i l l be th e ru l i n g of the co u r t .12 MS. HARWOOD: Thank you, Your Honor.13 (End o f proceed ings . )14 ***15 C er t i f i c a t e16 I hereby c e r t i f y t h a t th e fo regoing i s a t rue and17 c o r r e c t t r a n s c r i p t of the s t en o g rap h i ca l l y recorded18 proceed ings in th e above mat t e r .19 Fees charged fo r t h i s t r a n sc r i p t , l e s s any c i r c u i t20 fee reduc t ion and /or d ep o s i t , a re in conformance with the21 regu la t ions of the j u d i c i a l confe rence of the United Sta te s .2223

~ 04/06/2011DENISE PADDo ; RMR, CRR, CSR 10199 DATE2425


lincoln v daylight chemical, et al. - transcript of hearing - 3-7-11

Documents