khan and the (chicago) skyscraper · the (chicago) skyscraper themes: ... stiffness in skyscrapers....

87
photo credit: Richard Seaman Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: Tension between architectural and structural expression in buildings Fazlur Khan and expression of structure in buildings Stiffness in skyscrapers

Upload: others

Post on 26-Aug-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

photo credit: Richard Seaman

Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper

Themes:Tension between architectural and structural expression in buildingsFazlur Khan and expression of structure in buildingsStiffness in skyscrapers

Page 2: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 3: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 4: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Chicago 1930-1970

Page 5: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

“The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten years later only by a massive pro-gram of military procurement was a disaster for the nation as a whole but an absolute and unmitigated calamity for Chicago. It was not only the collapse of the public and private economy; it was the Sopho-clean reversal of fortune, from the expansive force of the twenties … to the impotence and hopeless-ness of the thirties.” “It was 12 years after WWII ended before a new building would be built in the Chicago CBD.”

Chicago 1930-1970, Carl Condit

Page 6: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 7: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/Pointe/8431/skyride.html

Page 8: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

image0-rubylane.s3.amazonaws.com/shops/carolynstt/3093.1L.jpg

Page 9: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

cityofchicago.org

Page 10: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 11: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

www.greatbuildings.com

cityofchicago.org

Ludwig Mies van der Rohe

2nd Chicago School(now more Arch.)

Page 12: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Seagram Building, New York.

Photo by Jean Alejandro di Bergerac Stephenson Davilus www.structurae.de

Page 13: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Seagram Building, New York.

Photo by Jean Alejandro di Bergerac Stephenson Davilus www.structurae.de

Structural Columns Structural Beams Architectural Mullions

Page 14: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 15: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Load Path?

B

B

B

B

B

B

CC

C

Page 16: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Load Path?

BB

CC

Page 17: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Marina city

Page 18: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 19: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 20: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 21: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 22: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 23: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

cityofchicago.org

Chicago Civic Center – now the Daley center

Page 24: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

cityofchicago.org

Page 25: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

cityofchicago.org

Page 26: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

John HancockBuilding

Page 27: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 28: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 29: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 30: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 31: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 32: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 33: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Lateral load on building frame

Page 34: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Deflected Shape

Page 35: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Bending Moment Diagram

Page 36: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Axial Force Diagram

Page 37: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Gravity load

Page 38: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Page 39: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Wind load

Page 40: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Page 41: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Frame Braced frame

Page 42: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 43: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Khan1929-1982

Page 44: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 45: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

1965

Page 46: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

image for academic use onlyhttp://www.emporis.com/en/il/lv/?id=203434

1965

Page 47: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 48: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 49: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

marine midland bank

Page 50: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

2 ShellPlaza

Page 51: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

1 ShellPlaza

Page 52: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 53: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 54: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

54

Page 55: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 56: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 57: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 58: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 59: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 60: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 61: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 62: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 63: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 64: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 65: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

65

Page 66: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 67: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

780 Third Avenue

Page 68: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

780 Third Avenue

Page 69: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 70: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 71: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Onterie Building

Page 72: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Onterie Building

Page 73: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 74: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 75: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 76: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Classification of tall building structural systems by Khan

Page 77: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Updated by Ali and Moon in 2007 paper, focusing on tall building forms with exterior stiffening structures

Page 78: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Updated by Ali and Moon in 2007 paper, focusing on tall building forms with interior stiffening structures

Page 79: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

79

Page 80: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 81: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 82: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 83: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

83

Page 84: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 85: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 86: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten
Page 87: Khan and the (Chicago) Skyscraper · the (Chicago) Skyscraper Themes: ... Stiffness in skyscrapers. Chicago 1930-1970 “The depression that began in the 1930’s and was ended ten

Mike Gustafon