karst subsidence and associated risk€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic...

10
2014/02/03 1 URBAN HYDROLOGY: WATER IN THE CITY OF TSHWANE High Performance Centre, University of Pretoria 23 – 24 January 2014 THARINA OOSTHUIZEN COUNCIL FOR GEOSCIENCE KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK WHAT IS DOLOMITE A carbonate rock type(2,3 billion years old), which dissolves (very slowly) to form cavities which leads to sinkhole formation Highly variable over short distances 2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 2

Upload: others

Post on 20-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

1  

U R B A N H Y D R O L O G Y : WAT E R I N T H E C I T Y O F T S H WA N E H i g h P e r f o r m a n c e C e n t r e , U n i v e r s i t y o f P r e t o r i a

2 3 – 2 4 J a n u a r y 2 0 1 4

T H A R I N A O O S T H U I Z E N C O U N C I L F O R G E O S C I E N C E

KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK

WHAT IS DOLOMITE

•  A carbonate rock type(2,3 billion years old), which dissolves (very slowly) to form cavities which leads to sinkhole formation

•  Highly variable over short distances

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 2

Page 2: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

2  

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 3

• Dolomite is soluble, i.e. dissolves in water.

•  The dissolution of the dolomite has given rise to cave systems and voids in the rock. Soils covering the rock can collapse into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences.

•  Results in wad: a highly compressible and erodible material immediately above bedrock surface

DISSOLUTION OF DOLOMITE

 

IMPLICATIONS OF DOLOMITE

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 4

Pretorius Avenue - 2013 The Pines (Jean Avenue) - 2013

Lyttelton Manor - 2008

Pretorius Avenue - 2012 Jean Avenue - 2011

Alto Complex (Basden Street) - 2008

Page 3: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

3  

DISTRIBUTION OF DOLOMITE IN SOUTH AFRICA

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 5

DOLOMITE IN TSHWANE

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 6

Page 4: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

4  

SINKHOLE FORMATION

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 7

Karst landscape

2 Main Triggering Mechanisms: •  Ingress water (leaking services, poor stormwater management, etc.) •  Lowering of the groundwater level

HOW DO THEY FORM?

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 8

SINKHOLE

SUBSIDENCE

Page 5: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

5  

9 2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane

SINKHOLES IN TSHWANE

~1400 sinkholes /

subsidences to date

98% related to

man’s influence

2014/02/03 10 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane

SINKHOLES ARE:

Page 6: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

6  

INCREASED SINKHOLES ARE RELATED TO INCREASED DEVELOPMENT

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 11

Smallholdings -1950’s

Multi storey - >2010’s? Townhouses-1990’s

SINKHOLE STATISTICS

•  3 people have died as a result of sinkholes (during remediation thereof)

•  >60% of the sinkholes are sized between 2 m and 15 m in diameter

•  >60% of the sinkholes are less than 5 m deep •  Average of 7,58 events per km2 •  0,13 sinkholes / km2 / year •  8 residential dwellings demolished in central Centurion area •  No sinkholes have formed as a result of dewatering

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 12

Page 7: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

7  

HOW DO WE INVESTIGATE?

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 13

Hard Rock

Soil Void

CLASSIFICATION OF DOLOMITIC LAND

•  Using the Method of Scenario Supposition (Buttrick et al., 2001) •  Based on the properties of the

overburden •  General assumption – the deeper the

dolomite bedrock, the larger the expected sinkhole

•  Classify a site for both ingress and a dewatering scenario

•  8 Inherent Hazard Classes (IHC)

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 14

Page 8: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

8  

IHC TABLE

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 15

CLASSIFICATION

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 16

Site specific Regional

Page 9: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

9  

APPROPRIATE LAND USE

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 17

•  Based on the SANS 1936-1(2012) documents

•  Dolomite Area Designation

(D-designation) assigned to each site, which specifies the required precautionary measures

Residential development in Centurion

PRECAUTIONARY MEASURES

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 18

•  Although there is always a risk in dolomitic areas, the risk can be managed by the implementation of appropriate precautionary measures.

Raft Foundations

Storm water management

Concrete aprons

HDPE Pipes

Gutters & Downpipes

Page 10: KARST SUBSIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED RISK€¦ · into these caves or voids resulting in catastrophic ground movement on the surface such as sinkholes or subsidences. • Results in wad:

2014/02/03  

10  

CONCLUSION

•  In Tshwane, all sinkholes are caused by water ingress

•  Generally a low hazard in terms of a dewatering

scenario •  Groundwater relatively deep, and mostly within dolomite

bedrock •  Only limited areas where a high hazard in a dewatering

scenario has been identified

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 19

THANK YOU

2014/02/03 © www.up.ac.za/watertshwane 20

Tharina Oosthuizen Council for Geoscience

[email protected]

012 841 1160

www.geoscience.org.za

Never R.I.P…..