kamal r. mahtani€¦ · evans et al (2011) testing treatments: better research for better...

18
Kamal R. Mahtani

Upload: others

Post on 22-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Kamal R. Mahtani

Page 2: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 3: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 4: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 5: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Baby and Child Care” has actually sold more that 50 million copies, only outmatched in sales by the Bible

Page 6: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

‘…disadvantages to a baby’s sleeping on his back. If he vomits he’s more likely to choke on the vomitus. ..I think it is preferable to accustom a baby to sleeping on his stomach from the start.’

Dr Benjamin Spock

Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Page 7: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Over four fold increase risk of sudden infant death

syndrome

Page 8: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 9: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 10: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Causes harm Does not causes harm

1970

1980

1990

2000

On average – inconclusive

The importance of considering a summary of all available the evidence

Page 11: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Causes harm Does not causes harm

1970

1980

1990

2000

On average – does not cause harm

The importance of considering a summary of all available the evidence

Page 12: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Causes harm Does not causes harm

1970

1980

1990

2000

On average – inconclusive

The importance of considering a summary of all available the evidence

Page 13: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

The importance of considering a summary of all available studies

BUT….. How many studies are carried out but not published?

≈50%

Page 14: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Causes harm Does not causes harm

1970

1980

1990

2000

On average – no difference

The importance of considering a summary of all available the evidence

Four more studies – never published!

On average – causes harm!

Page 15: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 16: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 17: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare
Page 18: Kamal R. Mahtani€¦ · Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare . Evans et al (2011) Testing Treatments: Better Research for Better Healthcare

Patients with atrial fibrillation

Old blood thinners (warfarin)

New blood thinners (NOACs)

Risk Risk