joachim martillo: judonia rising: the israel lobby and american society

7/31/2019 Joachim Martillo: JUDONIA RISING: THE ISRAEL LOBBY AND AMERICAN SOCIETY

1/26

Krmgdci Pczcdo; ]lb Czpibh Hg``s idm Iabpcjid Zgjcb}s_li} }lb Czpibh Hg``s Pbihhs Cz

Lgw C} Lrp}z }lb RZI_li} }g Mg I`gr} C}

I _gpncdo VivbpVip} C; ]lb Z}i}b ge }lb Hg``s

`sKgijlca Aip}chhg ,]lgpzVpgugdcFigh$jga#

l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga

Cd}pgmrj}cgd

Cd Eihh 0665 Hims Nczlwbp @ipgdbzz Eihndbp ge Aiopiucdb( wlg cz i hc`bpih aba`bp ge }lb Lgrzbge Hgpmz hbim i z}rms opgrv i} }lb Lipuipm Nbddbms Zjlggh ge Ogubpdabd}$ C} wiz bd}c}hbmMbagjpijs egp }lb Czhiacj _gphm7( RZ % @pc}czl Egpbcod Vghcjs Ie}bp Cpiy ,l}}v;''www$cgv$lipuipm$bmr'z}rmsWopgrvz'65Weihndbp$vme#$ Lipuipm Vpgebzzgp Z}bvlbd _ih}( wlgjg!wpg}b ]lb Czpibh Hg``s idm RZ Egpbcod Vghcjswc}l Rdcubpzc}s ge Jlcjiog Vpgebzzgp KgldAbipzlbcabp( wiz }lb hiz} orbz} zvbinbp$

@bjirzb }lb zbzzcgdz wbpb gee }lb pbjgpm( C jiddg} pbvgp} Vpgebzzgp _ih}/z mczjrzzcgd ge RZ

mbagjpi}c{i}cgd vghcjs( `r} C mcm }ihn wc}l lca i`gr} }lb mceecjrh}s ge rdmbpz}idmcdo }lb CzpibhHg``s wc}lgr} i }lgpgrol rdmbpz}idmcdo ge Biz}bpd Brpgvbid Kbwczl zgjcih idm vghc}cjih jrh}rpb$Lb }ghm ab }li} lb wiz dg} ogcdo }g hbipd Scmmczl i} }lcz vgcd} cd lcz jipbbp$ ]lb pbzvgdzb cz dg}rdpbizgdi`hb$ Pbihcz} egpbcod vghcjs idihszcz mgbz dg} mbhub arjl cd}g lcz}gpcjih ìjnopgrdmz(idm agz} lcz}gpcgopivls iuichi`hb i`gr} Kbwz }g Bdohczl!zvbincdo pbimbpz cz mpbimerh idm ubpobzgd liocgopivls$

Dg} gdhs lim Dgpaid Ecdnbhz}bcd( Kgzbvl Aizzim( idm Dgia Jlgazns ihpbims b|vpbzzbmzcodcecjid} mcziopbbabd} wc}l }lb Abipzlbcabp idm _ih} idihszcz iz c} lim ivvbipbm cd }lbHgdmgd Pbucbw ge @ggnzidm cd i Lipuipm Nbddbms Zjlggh wgpncdo vivbp `s }lcz }cab vbpcgm( `r}Vlchcv _bczz lim `bord mczjrzzcdo }lb Czpibh Hg``s gd lcz Agdmgwbczz Dbw Sgpn G`zbpubp`hgocd i wis }li} zcarh}idbgrzhs iopbbm idm mcziopbbm wc}l }lb }wg ir}lgpz `bjirzb _bczz mcm dg}aicd}icd i jhbip mcz}cdj}cgd `b}wbbd }lb Czpibh Hg``s( }lb gpoidc{bm Kbwczl jgaardc}s idm }lb

Dbw Kbwczl Bhc}b( wlcjl _bczz iporbz liz zrvvhid}bm }lb ghm _IZV bhc}b$

_lbpbiz Vpgebzzgp Jlgazns jpc}cjc{bz _ih} idm Abipzlbcabp `bjirzb ge }lb hijn ge jhipc}s cd}lbcp mbecdc}cgd ge }lb Czpibh Hg``s( cd i zbdzb _bczz `rchmz gd }lb mceerzbdbzz ge }lb Hg``s$ Cd idsjizb( i RZI( wlgzb mgacdid} bhc}b cz Kbwczl( cz dg} dbjbzzipchs `bdmcdo }g }lb Czpibh Hg``s wlbdc} vrpzrbz ge vpg!Czpibh egpbcod vghcjs$

Abipzlbcabp( _ih}( Ecdnbhz}bcd(9

Aizzim( Jlgazns idm _bczz ipb ihh jgppbj}$ ]lbcpmcziopbbabd}z pbzrh} epga vpg`hbaz ge epiabwgpn( hidoriob idm hijn ge lcz}gpcjih jgd}b|}$@bjirzb i jgavhb}b pbwgpncdo ge }lb Abipzlbcabp idm _ih} }lbzcz wgrhm pbyrcpb i }b|} i} hbiz}}wcjb iz hgdo iz ]lb Czpibh Hg``s idm RZ Egpbcod Vghcjs( }lb eghhgwcdo vivbp zlgrhm gdhs `bjgdzcmbpbm i `pcbe cd}pgmrj}cgd }g i pcogpgrz rdcecbm idihszcz ìzbm cd i dgd!b|jbv}cgdihcz}rdmbpz}idmcdo ge Biz}bpd Brpgvbid Kbwczl lcz}gps$

]lb Czpibh Hg``s idm RZ Egpbcod Vghcjs

9 Ecdnbhz}bcd liz vgcd}bm gr} }li} zrvvgp}cdo Czpibh cz krz}ceci`hb iz i ai}}bp ge egpbcod vghcjs`bjirzb Czpibh vpgucmbz i z}i`hb ìzb epga wlcjl }lb RZI jid vpgkbj} c}z vgwbp( `r} }lb [cgdcz}z}i}b cz dg} gùcgrzhs zg arjl agpb z}i`hb }lid c}z dbcol`gpz( wlgzb aikgp cd}bpdih }lpbi}z }gz}i`chc}s ge}bd cd ids jizb pbhi}b }g }lb b|cz}bdjb ge }lb Z}i}b ge Czpibh$ Zcdjb }lb z}i`chc}s ge }lb gch!vpgmrjcdo z}i}bz cz i aikgp cd}bpbz} ge }lb RZI( }lb `bdbec}z ge }lb vgzzc`hs zhcol}hs opbi}bpz}i`chc}s ge Czpibh iz i RZ ìzb ucz!!ucz Kgpmid gp Bosv} ipb dbohcoc`hb ce }lbs bubd pbihhs b|cz}$


2/26

Vpgebzzgpz Abipzlbcabp idm _ih} liub mgdb i zbpucjb egp Iabpcjid vr`hcj vghc}cjih mczjrzzcgd `siporcdo }lbcp gvcdcgd iz egpbcod vghcjs pbihcz}z

}li} Czpibh vpg}bj}z dg cavgp}id} RZ cd}bpbz}z( }li} c} cz i egpbcod vghcjs hci`chc}s( }li} c} ipori`hs dbubp liz `bbd i z}pi}bocj izzb} mbzvc}b }lb jhicaz ge Gpoidcjn cd ]lb :5

@chhcgd Mghhip @ipoicd( idm }li} }lb mczivvbipidjb ge }lb [cgdcz} z}i}b epga }lb Acmmhb Biz} wgrhm i} wgpz} lipa }lb

RZI cd dg zcodcecjid} wis wli}zgbubp$

Vpgebzzgp Jlgazns wgrhm jgppbj}hs vgcd} gr} }li} gdb jgrhm ainb i oggm jizb egp }lb gvvgzc}b ge}lb i`gub izzbp}cgdz( `r} mbì}cdo }lb i`gub jhicaz aczzbz }lb aicd czzrb$ ]lb pbih vpg`hba cz}lb hijn ge i obdrcdbhs gvbd mbì}b cd _izlcdo}gd gp cd }lb abmci i`gr} }lb RZ ihhcidjb wc}lCzpibh$

]lb }wg zjlghipz rdmbpzjgpb }lcz czzrb idm vpgucmb zgab oggm jgacj pbhcbe wlbd }lbs jhica }li}}lbpb cz i z}pgdo agpih jizb egp zrvvgp}cdo Czpibh bubd }lgrol i oggm vip} ge }lb `ggn jhipcecbzkrz} lgw uijrgrz i `bhcbe cd }lb krz}cjb ge [cgdcza idm cd }lb agpihc}s ge Czpibhc vpij}cjbz pbihhs cz$

Sb}( }lb `ggn cz ehiwbm `s ijjbv}idjb ge }gg aids [cgdcz} idm Kbwczl jhicaz i} eijb uihrb$

_lbd }lb vpgebzzgpz wpc}b( "]lbpb cz dg yrbz}cgd }li} Kbwz zreebpbm opbi}hs epga }lb mbzvcji`hbhboijs ge id}c!Zbac}cza idm }li} Czpibh/z jpbi}cgd wiz id ivvpgvpci}b pbzvgdzb }g i hgdo pbjgpm gejpcabz(" }lbs ipb pbvbi}cdo `g}l b}ldcj Izlnbdi{c vpcagpmcihcz} bzzbd}cihcza idm ihzg }lb ìzcjjpbbm ge }lb zg!jihhbm "vgopga idm vbpzbjr}cgd" ubpzcgd ge Kbwczl lcz}gps$ Dbc}lbp izzrav}cgdlghmz rv rdmbp zjpr}cds$

]lb zbjgdm jbd}rps Pgaid Lcz}gpcid Mcg Jizzcrz wpg}b "ihh wlg g`zbpub Krmicj hiw ais `bjihhbm Krmbidz( mbzvc}b }lb b}ldcj opgrv epga wlcjl }lbs gpcocdi}b$"

]lb uiz} aikgpc}s ge Pgaid Cavbpcih Kbwz ,agpb vpgvbphs Krmbidz# lim dg idjbz}pih jgddbj}cgd}g }lb vgvrhi}cgdz }li} hcubm cd }lb Lizagdbid gp Lbpgmcid Ncdomgaz ge Krmbi$ Agmbpd b}ldcj

Izlnbdi{ca ,Kbwz ge Biz}bpd Brpgvbid Scmmczl!zvbincdo gpcocdz# liub hbzz jgddbj}cgd idm dggùcgrzhs hboc}cai}b jhica gd Vihbz}cdb wli}zgbubp$ ,Zbb l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'6='lgw!}g!}ihn!i`gr}!{cgdcza!dbw!cavpgubm$l}ah( l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'0662'6


3/26

wbpb lcolhs mczieebj}bm `bjirzb ge b|jhrzcgd epga }lb z}i}rz idm ijjbzz }g wlcjl }lbs `bhcbubm}lbs wbpb bd}c}hbm( `r} }lbs wbpb dg} g`ucgrzhs agpb gvvpbzzbm }lid }lb aikgpc}s ge }lb J{ip/zzr`kbj}z idm hbzz gvvpbzzbm }lid g}lbpz$

Srpc Zhb{ncdb `bhcbz }lb as}l ge Kbwczl vgwbphbzz mrpcdo }lb hbim!rv }g __0 cd ]lb KbwczlJbd}rps$ ,Zbb l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'60'vi}}bpd!ge!b}ldcj!izlnbdi{c$l}ah$#

Abipzlbcabp idm _ih}/z jizrih aczjgdjbv}cgdz i`gr} Kbwczl lcz}gps ijjgavids i zcachip hijn gecd}bpbz} cd }lb zgjcghgos ge }lb Kbwczl jgaardc}s$

Bubd }lgrol Lgw Kbwz @bjiab _lc}b Eghnz % _li} }li} Zisz I`gr} Pijb cd Iabpcji`s Nipbd@pgmncd izzbp}z gd v$ 9=? }li}

C}ihcid jrh}rpb cz dg} vpbecorpi}cubhs wlc}b( cd }lb wis Kbwczl jrh}rpb wlcjl Ohi{bpmbzjpc`bm iz hcnb Idohg!Zi|gd Vpg}bz}id} jrh}rpb cd uihrcdo cdmcucmrihc}s idm ia`c}cgd cz(

lcz}gpcjihhs Biz}bpd Brpgvbid Kbwczl jrh}rpb z}pgdohs jgd}pghhbm zgjcih idm cd}bhhbj}rih mbuci}cgd$

Aids ge }lb zgjcih jgd}pgh abjlidczaz jgd}cdrb }g b|cz}( liub bughubm cd }lb Iabpcjidbducpgdabd}( idm ais lbhv b|vhicd wls hc`bpih Kbwz liub zg bavgwbpbm }lb Dbgjgdz }g }lbmb}pcabd} ge RZ egpbcod vghcjs cd}bpbz}z iz Kiabz Vb}piz liz mbzjpc`bm$ ,Zbbl}}v;''www$vlchcvwbczz$gpo'agdmgwbczz'066?'90'kiabz!vb}piz!li$l}ah $#

]lb Vpgebzzgpz mg dg} bubd izn wlb}lbp z}i}bm pbizgdz egp zrvvgp}cdo Czpibh ipb }lb pbih gp }lbziab pbizgdz egp ihh Czpibh imugji}bz }lpgrolgr} }lb "Czpibh Hg``s$" Mg }lb hbimbpz idm eghhgwbpzbubd zlipb }lb ziab gubpihh ogihz7

Cd jgd}piz}( wlbd Jghra`ci Vpgebzzgp Acjlibh Z}idczhiwznc cdubz}coi}bz }lb 9


4/26

wc}l Czpibh( `r} wc}l vlchg!Zbac}cza$ _li} sgr zbb i} }li} iddrih ICVIJ jgdebpbdjbwlbpb Mbagjpi}z idm Pbvr`hcjidz hcdb rv }g nczz izz cz i opivlcj mbagdz}pi}cgd ge }lbeij} }li} ICVIJ dg hgdobp bubd dbbmz }g og ie}bp }lb vghc}cjcidz( }lbs jgab }g ICVIJ jivcd lidm$"

]lrz }lb vpcaips Czpibh imugjijs gpoidc{i}cgd liz beebj}cubhs `bjgab id Iabpcjid vghc}cjih

cdz}c}r}cgd }li} Iabpcjidz ijjbv} wc}lgr} pbzbpui}cgd egp ebip ge }lb ijjrzi}cgd ge id}c!Zbac}cza$

@r} Vrpvgzberh Aczmcpbj}cgd wc}l Zisifdca ,Zhbbvbp gp Lbhvbp Iobd}z#

Iz _ih} idm Abipzlbcabp vgcd} gr}( }lb ijlcbubabd} ge Czpibh imugjijs cz cavpbzzcub `s idsz}idmipm$ ]lb zrjjbzz pbzrh}z epga jghhi`gpi}cgd ge id b|}pbabhs mcubpzb wb` ge gpoidc{i}cgdzidm cdmcucmrihz }li} zvbjcihc{b cd mceebpbd} izvbj}z ge }lb hg``scdo vpgkbj} idm }li} wgpn }gob}lbpgd id iz dbbmbm ìzcz$

I aba`bp ge }lb wb` jid `b jhizzcecbm cd gdb mcabdzcgd `s abzziob }pidzvipbdjs idm cdidg}lbp mcabdzcgd `s cdmcucmrih gp gpoidc{i}cgdih }pidzvipbdjs$

Nipgdz jgaabd} i`gub cdmcji}bz }li} ICVIJ liz dg dbbm egp i hg} ge gviyrbdbzz( `r} cd aidszc}ri}cgdz jgdjbihabd} ge izvbj}z ge }lb Czpibh Imugji}b ais cdjpbizb beebj}cubdbzz ge iabzziob$ Kgld Liobbz Jlpcz}cidz Rdc}bm egp Czpibh( ih`bc} zbjpb}hs erdmbm idm prd `s Kbwz( czihagz} b|jbzzcubhs vr`hcj i`gr} c}z hg``scdo beegp}z `bjirzb c} vpgì`hs b|cz}z }g vpgub }li} Czpibhimugjijs cz dg} i Kbwz!gdhs vpgmrj}cgd$ ,Kbwczl!mgacdi}bm echa idm arzcj cdmrz}pcbz pgr}cdbhsjpbi}b z}ipz$ C} ivvipbd}hs jgz}z i oggm mbih hbzz agdbs idm beegp} }g vr} zgabgdb gd }lb I!hcz} geJlpcz}cid Czpibh hg``scdo$#

Eghhgwcdo }lb hbim ge ICVIJ zgab }lcdn }idnz hcnb KCDZI ,Kbwczl Cdz}c}r}b egp Di}cgdih Zbjrpc}sIeeicpz# idm _CDBV ,_izlcdo}gd Cdz}c}r}b egp Dbip Biz} Vghcjs# ainb dg beegp} }g jgdjbih }lbcpCzpibh egjrz( `r} g}lbpz hcnb }lb Egrdmi}cgd egp }lb Mbebdzb ge Mbagjpijs }ps }g jgdjbih Dbgjgd[cgdcz} iobdmiz `blcdm i abzziob ge vi}pcg}cza idm id}c!}bppgpcza ge}bd jga`cdbm wc}l zjipb!agdobpcdo idm id}c!Ipi` gp id}c!Arzhca cdjc}babd}$

Lgdbz}Pbvgp}cdo cz i abmci wi}jl mgo hcnb JIABPI `r} g`zjrpbz c}z gpoidc{i}cgdih z}prj}rpb

idm bzvbjcihhs c}z jgddbj}cgd }g Iczl Li}gpil( wlcjl bdjgrpiobz Kbwz }g `bjgab g`zbpuid} idm}lbd bdabzlbz zrjl Kbwczl pb}rpdbbz cd id gjjrh} asz}cjih di}cgdihcz} [cgdcz} iobdmi$

]lb Miucm Vpgkbj} vpb}bdmz }g `b i Kbwczl jgaardih gpoidc{i}cgd }li} }bijlbz Kbwczl bmrji}gpzlgw }g }ihn i`gr} Czpibh wlchb Z}idm_c}lRz jhicaz }g piczb }lb Czpibh jgdzjcgrzdbzz ge z}rmbd}zgd jiavrz( `r} `g}l ij} iz i}}ijn mgoz }li} ivvipbd}hs piczb agdbs cd vpgvgp}cgd }g }lb hbubh ge}lbcp diz}cdbzz$

]lb Miucm Vpgkbj} gpjlbz}pi}bm id i}}ijn gd }lb Pg|`rps Agzyrb iz vip} ge id gdogcdo vpgopiage mcacdczlcdo }lb cavij} ge Czpibhz mb}pij}gpz `s dgpaihc{cdo Czhiagvlg`ci zg }li} IabpcjidArzhca jpc}cjcza ge Czpibh wchh `b mczaczzbm gr} ge lidm$ ,Zbbl}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'0665'69'ì}}hb!wiobm!cd!`gz}gd!gubp!dbw!agzyrb$l}ah$#

Z}idm_c}lRz ainbz i zvbjcih beegp} }g jgrd}bpij} Kbwczl jpc}cjz ge Czpibh cd }lb rdcubpzc}sbducpgdabd}$ ]lb gpoidc{i}cgd wiz zg rvzb} wc}l Gubpjgacdo [cgdcza`s Kgbh Ngubh }li} c} liz`bbd }pscdo }g mbds mcz}pc`r}cgd }g ihh `ggnz epga Vhr}g Vpbzz }li} pbijl }lb Iabpcjid Vr`hcj uci}lb Rdcubpzc}s ge Acjlcoid Vpbzz$ ,Zbb l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'96'{cgdcz}!i}}ijn!gd!vhr}g!vpbzz$l}ah( l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'6='`gz}gd!ohg`bz!vpg`hba!wc}l!arzhcaz$l}ah $#

Ijimbaci idm Czpibh Hg``scdo


5/26

@g}l }lb Miucm Vpgkbj} idm Z}idm_c}lRz wgpn eicphs jhgzbhs wc}l Czpibhc jgdzrhi}bz cd }lb jgd}b|}ge }lb Czpibh gd Jiavrz Jgihc}cgd$ Pizlcm Nlihcmc mczjrzzbz }lb di}rpb ge Czpibhc ijimbaci gd v$?2 ge ]lb Cpgd Jiob$

Vbplivz }lb agz} bacdbd} ge }lb egrp( Pbrubd [izhidc( bubd}rihhs `bjiab }lb egrdmbp geCzpibhz b|}bpdih bzvcgdiob iobdjs( }lb Agzzim$ [izhidc hi}bp jlidobm lcz diab }gZlchgijl( idm }lb Acmmhb Biz} Jbd}bp i} ]bh Iucu Rdcubpzc}s ,dgw }lb Agzlb MisidJbd}bp# wiz diabm egp lca egp i }cab$ ]lb }wg diabz }li} }lcz jbd}bp liz `gpdb chhrz}pi}b}lb cd}cai}b ,idm }lgpgrolhs rdzbhejgdzjcgrz# pbhi}cgdzlcv wc}lcd Czpibh cdz}c}r}cgdz`b}wbbd ijimbacj z}rms ge }lb pbocgd gd }lb gdb lidm( idm `g}l cd}bhhcobdjb wgpn idmwipeipb mcpbj}bm ioicdz} }lb Ipi`z gd }lb g}lbp$

[cgdcz} opgrvz wgrhm hcnb }g rzb Iabpcji ijimbaci cd }lb ziab wis( idm }lb Czpibhc aczzcgd }g}lb RZ vhisz i hipob pghb cd }lb ì}}hb egp }lb jgd}pgh ge ijimbacj mczjgrpzb i`gr} }lb AcmmhbBiz}$

Zgab lcol vpgechb ijimbacj Czpibh cdmcucmrih imugji}bz hcnb Ihid Mbpzlgwc}{ ipb eicphs }pidzvipbd}cd abzziob idm ieechci}cgd( g}lbpz hcnb Bhcb _cbzbh( wlg }pcbz }g ij} iz lcol vpcbz} ge Lghgjirz}pbhcocgd( wgpn }lpgrol g}lbp jirzbz$ Pr}l _czzb( wlgzb lrzìdm cz Jlicpaid ge }lb @gipm geMcpbj}gpz ge JIABPI rzbz lbp ijimbacj vgmcra }g z}pbb}!ecol} egp [cgdcza$ ,Zbb

l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'63'kbwz!idm!vgwbp!ubpzrz!czpibh!hg``s!idm$l}ah(l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'96'vgczgdcdo!i}agzvlbpb!i}!lipuipm$l}ah$#

Hi}bhs Pr}l _czzb liz `bbd eijrh}s imuczgp }g Dbw Zgjcb}s; ]lb Lipuipm Jghhbob Z}rmbd} AcmmhbBiz} Kgrpdih$ Lbpb cz }lb mbzjpcv}cgd,l}}v;''www$jghhbob$lipuipm$bmr'z}rmbd}'gpoidc{i}cgdz'gpomb}ich7cm1?=0#$

Dbw Zgjcb}s wchh `b i egpwipm!hggncdo `ciddrih kgrpdih ge zjlghipzlcv idm gvcdcgd gd }lblcz}gps( vghc}cjz idm jrh}rpb ge }lb Acmmhb Biz}$ C} wchh bdjgrpiob z}rmbd}z idm eijrh}saba`bpz }g mbì}b vgzc}cub uczcgdz egp }lb er}rpb ge }lb pbocgd$ Mpiwcdo c}z cmbiz epga iwcmb pidob ge jgd}pc`r}gpz( }lb kgrpdih wchh ebi}rpb i jga`cdi}cgd ge hgdo( zjlghiphsbzzisz( zlgp}bp gv!bm z}shb ip}cjhbz( pbucbwz ge `ggnz( agucbz idm jgdjbp}z( vlg}gopivlzidm ip}wgpn( wpc}b!rvz ge bubd}z gd jiavrz( idm cd}bpucbwz$ C} wchh vr`hczl z}rmbd}z(

eijrh}s aba`bpz( idm izzgjci}bm zjlghipz ìzbm gd }lb yrihc}s ge }lbcp zjlghipzlcv idmwpc}cdo( `r} }lb kgrpdih wchh egjrz gd drp}rpcdo idm vpgag}cdo rdmbpopimri}b wpc}bpz idmbmc}gpz cd vip}cjrhip$

]lb kgrpdihz jgd}bd} cz vpbmcj}i`hs [cgdcz}cjihhs jgppbj}$ ,Zbb l}}v;''dbwzgjcb}skgrpdih$jga'$#

Ac|cdo Czpibh Hg``scdo wc}l G}lbp Ij}cuc}cbz

Hcnb _czzb( Z}bubd Zvcbh`bpo liz Kbwczl cd}bpbz}z `bsgdm Czpibh( `r} }lb bdmcdo ge ZjlcdmhbpzHcz}wiz zcavhs [cgdcz} vpgvioidmi }li} cavhcjc}hs krz}cecbm }lb }lbe} ge Vihbz}cdb epga }lb di}cubvgvrhi}cgd$ ,Zbb l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'96'aippcbm!}g!idg}lbp!aid!aippcbm!}g$l}ah$#

Hcnb _czzb idm Zvcbh`bpo( }lb Jgdebpbdjb ge Vpbzcmbd}z ge Aikgp Iabpcjid Kbwczl Gpoidc{i}cgdz

cz dg} b|jhrzcubhs egjrzbm gd Czpibh imugjijs( `r} }gmis c}z agz} vr`hcj pghb jgdzcz}zge pbvpbzbd}cdo }lb jgdjbpdz ge }lb gpoidc{bm Kbwczl jgaardc}s }g }lb Vpbzcmbd} ge }lb Rdc}bmZ}i}bz$

Hcnb }lb Jgdebpbdjb vpij}cjihhs bubps g}lbp opgrv wc}lcd }lb gpoidc{bm Kbwczl jgaardc}svpgucmbz zgab mbopbb ge gubp} Czpibh imugjijs dg ai}}bp lgw zaihh i pghb Czpibh vhisz cd }lbgpoidc{i}cgdz geecjcih aczzcgd z}i}babd}$ B|iavhbz prd epga

prddcdo achhcgd mghhip jiavicodz ioicdz} Zgabpuchhb Mcubz}abd} epga Czpibh iz }lb @gz}gdKbwczl Jgaardc}s Pbhi}cgdz Jgrdjch mcm }g


6/26

vpgucmcdo Kbwczl zbhe!cdmgj}pcdi}cgd zbacdipz idm hbj}rpbz i} hgjih zsdiogorbz$

@bhgw cz i }svcjih cdz}idjb cd }lb @gz}gd ipbi$

Agdmis( Gj}g`bp 92( 066??;92 VA ]gwd Lihh Abb}cdo wc}l Egpabp Czpibhc Ia`izzimgp C}iaip Pi`cdgucjl

C}iaip Pi`cdgucjl wiz }lb egpabp Ia`izzimgp ge Czpibh }g }lb R$Z$( viz} Vpbzcmbd} ge ]bhIucu Rdcubpzc}s( idm Jiav Miucm Zspcid Dbog}ci}gp( idm jrppbd}hs cz i hbj}rpbp i} Lipuipm$Ie}bp }lb `pcbecdo( sgr wchh `b ocubd }lb gvvgp}rdc}s }g zlipb sgrp }lgrol}z idm jgdjbpdzi`gr} Czpibh cd id gvbd jgaardc}s mczjrzzcgd$ I mbzzbp} pbjbv}cgd wchh eghhgw ,mcb}ipshiwz g`zbpubm#$ I} ]bavhb Gli`bc Zlihga cd @pggnhcdb$ PZUV pbyrcpbm$ ]g pbocz}bp gpegp agpb cdegpai}cgd( vhbizb jihh gp baich$

99


7/26

]lbd }lbpb ipb ihh zgp}z ge opgrvz idm cdmcucmrihz }li} jgubp}hs idm cdegpaihhs ij} iz Czpibhimugji}bz$ Kbwczl jhcyrbz wc}lcd Cd}bpeic}l mczjrzzcgd opgrvz0 ge}bd bdoiob cd zr`}hb Czpibhimugjijs gp bdabzlabd} wlchb }lb ge}bd!}pidzdi}cgdih Kbwczl db}wgpnz cd ijimbaci( ijpgzzuipcgrz vpgebzzcgdz idm cd }lb ecdidjb cdmrz}ps ge}bd zbpub [cgdcz} vrpvgzbz ge b|jhrzcgd geIpi`z( Arzhcaz idm id}c![cgdcz}z gp ge jgd}pgh ge mczjgrpzb$ ]lb Miucm Vpgkbj}( wlcjl wgpnz wc}lcdegpaih db}wgpnz ge Kbwczl mgj}gpz( liz cdzbp}bm [cgdcz} vpgvioidmi cd}g }lb Lipuipm AbmcjihZjlggh }lpgrol c}z zr`zcmcips \!Pis Vpgkbj}$

:

]lb aba`bpz ge }lb Kbwczl ecdidjb db}wgpnz }pimb cdzcmbp cdegpai}cgd idm vpg}bj} bijl g}lbp$Aba`bpzlcv obdbpihhs pbyrcpbz vghc}cjihhs jgppbj} i}}c}rmbz }gwipmz Czpibh$ B|vpbzzcgdz gezsavi}ls }gwipm Vihbz}cdcidz jid bdm jipbbpz i} hbiz} rd}ch Orhe idm Zirmc Ipi`z `rs bdgrolge }lb DS cdubz}abd} ìdnz( `r} }lb db}wgpnz acol} aidiob }g vbpzcz} wc}l opbi}bp zbjpbjs$

Iz }lb wgpn ge pbzbipjlbpz hcnb Ihczgd _bcp ,l}}v;''www$ceiabpcjidzndbw$gpo# idm Hirpbh Hbee,@rpcbm `s }lb ]cabz( ]lb Lghgjirz} idm Iabpcjiz Agz} Cavgp}id} Dbwzvivbp# jhbiphs cdmcji}bz(}lb abmci cdmrz}ps cz erhh ge ihh zgp}z ge eijchc}i}gpz idm oi}bnbbvbpz( wlg liub i jhbip beebj} gd }lbjgubpiob ge }lb jgdehcj} gubp Vihbz}cdb bubd cd jizbz wlbpb }lb abmci gwdbpz ipb }lbazbhubzrd`cizbm$

Bubd }lgrol Zvcbh`bpo lcazbhe cz id Czpibh imugji}b( lb z}pisbm epga [cgdcz} vghc}cjih jgppbj}dbzz

cd Ardcjlidm wiz zr`kbj}bm }g i jgdjbp}bm abmci i}}ijn$ ]lb Lghhswggm Jpgwm og} }lbabzziob( idm }lb aipnb}cdo ge Ardcjl pid cd}g ihh zgp}z ge rdegpbzbbd vpg`hbaz$ Iz i pbzrh}(}lb agucb vpgì`hs gdhs aimb gdb }lcpm ge pbizgdi`hb b|vbj}i}cgdz cd opgzz }cjnb} pbjbcv}z( idm c}wchh vpgì`hs `b i hgdo }cab `begpb Zvcbh`bpo mbuci}bz epga }lb [cgdcz} dippi}cub }g ocubVihbz}cdcidz idg}lbp 06 zbjgdmz ge zsavi}ls$

@bsgdm }lb eijchc}i}gpz idm oi}bnbbvbpz }lbpb ipb }lgrzidmz }g }bdz ge }lgrzidmz ge}bdz}rmbd}z gp pb}cpbbz wlg wchh ainb ei|bz( hb}}bpz( jihhz( baichz gp jgab }g oi}lbpcdoz gd `blihege gpoidc{i}cgdz jgddbj}bm wc}l Czpibh imugjijs$

Czpibh Imugjijs( }lb RZ Ogubpdabd}( idm }lb Gjjrvi}cgd ge Cpiy

]lb Dbgjgd Agubabd}( wlcjl cz }lb jrppbd} cdjipdi}cgd ge }lb Iabpcjid Pbuczcgdcz} gp

Ki`g}cdzncid agubabd}( cz dg} id Czpibh imugjijs opgrv gp gpoidc{i}cgd( `r} c}z aba`bpzmcz}pc`r}b }lbazbhubz bc}lbp

}lpgrolgr} }lb ai}pc| ge gpoidc{i}cgdz }li} }inb vip} cd hg``scdo }lb RZ ogubpdabd} gd`blihe ge Czpibh gp

0Kbwczl jhcyrbz cd Cd}bpeic}l Ij}cgd opgrvz }li} rdmbp}inb obdrcdb jlipc}s wgpn ipb hbzz hcnbhs }g

aczrzb }lb egpra( `r} }lb gpoidc{bm Kbwczl jgaardc}s liz rzbm cd}bpdi}cgdih cd}bpeic}l ij}cgd cd}lb Zrmid iz i ublcjhb }g jgd}pgh obdgjcmb mczjgrpzb idm }g mbeiab Ipi`z gp Arzhcaz$Agliaaim I`r!Dcabp liz z}rmcbm mcihgorb idm jgdehcj} pbzghr}cgd `b}wbbd Ipi`z idm Kbwz cd}lb Czpibhc jgd}b|}$ ,Zbb Mcihgorb( Jgdehcj} Pbzghr}cgd( idm Jlidob; Ipi`!Kbwczl Bdjgrd}bpz cdCzpibh`s Agliaaim I`r!Dcabp#$ Iz cd Iabpcjid mcihgorbz `b}wbbd Jlpcz}cidz idm Kbwz gp`b}wbbd Arzhcaz gp Ipi`z idm Kbwz }lbpb pipbhs cz i abb}cdo ge acdmz( idm Kbwczl vip}cjcvid}z

}bdm }g i}}bav} }g bz}i`hczl vbpzgdih pbhi}cgdz }g cavbmb ids zbpcgrz mczjrzzcgd gp ij}cgd gdobdrcdb cdkrz}cjbz$ Epga }lb z}idmvgcd} ge dgd!Kbwczl vip}cjcvid}z zrjl cd}bpij}cgdz pipbhs zbba}g vpgmrjb arjl cd }lb wis ge jlidob cd }lb Kbwczl vip}cjcvid}z$ ,Zbbl}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066


8/26

}lpgrolgr} }lb ogubpdabd} c}zbhe( wlbpb ijjgpmcdo }g K$ @pims Ncbzhcdo,l}}v;''www$`pimsncbzhcdo$jga'# }lbs zg ba`gms }lb [cgdcz} gp Czpibhc ucbwvgcd} }li} }lbsij} iz ce cdebj}bm `s Czpibh jhcbd}c}cz$

Epcbmaidc}bz liub `bbd zg vpgacdbd} cd }lb bjgdgacj pbocab }li} }lb gjjrvi}cgd liz i}}bav}bm}g cavgzb gd Cpiy }li} }lb jgaagd cmbd}cecji}cgd ge Ach}gd Epcbmaid/z bjgdgacj }lcdncdo abpbhs

wc}l Ji}g Cdz}c}r}b hc`bp}ipcidcza hggnz cdjgppbj}$ Cd }gmis/z vghc}cjih cd}bhhbj}rih bducpgdabd}Epcbmaidcza hggnz agpb hcnb id imkrdj} ge Dbgjgdzbpui}cza$

Czpibh Hg``scdo cd Jgavipczgd wc}l Gpmcdips Hg``cbz

]lb jgavhb| jgavgzc}b z}prj}rpb ge Czpibh imugjijs cz rdrzrih iagdo hg``scdo beegp}z `r} dg}rdndgwd$

Bducpgdabd}ih idm g}lbp vr`hcj cd}bpbz} opgrv imugjijs( rdhcnb jgpvgpi}b idm egpbcod ogubpdabd}hg``scdo( }bdmz }g mcucmb }iznz iagdo i zb} ge gpoidc{i}cgdz }li} bijl liub }lbcp gwd zgrpjbz geerdmcdo$

Egp i ocubd hg``scdo vpgkbj}( hg``cbz wc}l i jgavhb| gpoidc{i}cgdih z}prj}rpb obdbpihhs izzcod i}bavgpips jggpmcdi}cgd jbd}bp$ ]lb Kbwczl Ebmbpi}cgd liz i hgdo lcz}gps ge jggpmcdi}cdo

pbzgrpjbz wc}lcd }lb Kbwczl jgaardc}s idm zbbaz }g vpgucmb i vbpaidbd} jggpmcdi}cgd jbd}bpegp Czpibh hg``scdo epga }lb di}cgdih hbubh ge gvvgzcdo id I_IJZ zihb mgwd }g vpbzzrpcdo i@ipdbz idm Dg`hb z}gpb egp lgz}cdo i Vihbz}cdcid ir}lgp hcnb Zrzid I`rhliwi$ ,Zbbl}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066?'62'hg``s!ij}cuc}cbz!c}z!krz}!epoocd!dgubhW0


9/26

zc}ri}cgdz$ ]lb hgdobuc}s ge Kbwczl Ebmbpi}cgd gpoidc{i}cgdz jid ocub Czpibh Hg``scdo beegp}z iobdbpi}cgdih izvbj} dg} zbbd bhzbwlbpb$ Egp b|iavhb( Czpibh Imugjijs gpoidc{i}cgdz wgpnbm egpece}s sbipz }g mbhboc}cac{b Ipi`cz} vgcd}z ge ucbw cd }lb egpbcod zbpucjb idm z}i}b mbvip}abd}( mpcubgr} Ipi`cz} geecjbpz gp `rpbirjpi}z idm pbvhijb }lba wc}l Czpibh zsavi}lb}cj vbpzgddbh ,zbb ]lbAipocdihc{i}cgd ge R$Z$ Acmbiz} B|vbp}z( l}}v;''www$wizlcdo}gd!pbvgp}$gpo'`ijnczzrbz'9632'32966


10/26

@i}!Iac [rjnbp vgcd}z gr} cd Li!Abzgpb} Li!Aczlvi}c} ub!Li![cgdc} zlbh Hgrcz M$ @pidmbcz ^]lbHboih idm [cgdcz} ]pimc}cgd ge Hgrcz M$ @pidmbcz( cd Lb`pbw Q}li} @pidmbcz icabm }g mbagdz}pi}b}li} [cgdcz}z wbpb jgavhb}b idm `b}}bp Iabpcjidz$ Cd g}lbp wgpmz [cgdcza i} hbiz} egp @pidmbczidm vbgvhb hcnb lca wiz vip} ge }lb Obpaid Kbwczl Iabpcjidc{i}cgd vpgkbj} ,idm vpgucmbm idih}bpdi}cub }g Kbwczl pimcjihcza gp jgaardcza lbpb cd }lb RZI#$

Bcol}s sbipz Iabpcjid Kbwz liub agubm `bsgdm abpb izzcachi}cgd$ ]lb Dbw Kbwczl Bhc}b }li}zrvvhid}bm }lb ghmbp Dbw Sgpn Obpaid Kbwczl bhc}b liz `bbd izzcachi}cdo RZ zgjcb}s idm jrh}rpb}g Kbwczl z}idmipmz egp }lb hiz} obdbpi}cgd(= idm Kbwczl opgrvz ipb dgw i} }lb jbd}bpz geIabpcjid vgwbp$

= Krz} jgdzcmbp }lb zbyrbdjb ge echaz( Oggm`sb( Jghra`rz( Bhicdb Aisz gpcocdih ubpzcgd ge ]lbLbip}`pbin Ncm( Mbzvbpi}bhs Zbbncdo Zrzid( ]lb Eippbhhs @pg}lbpz pbainb ge ]lb Lbip}`pbinNcm( idm _ic}pbzz$

]lb `ggn Oggm`sb( Jghra`rzwiz i pi}lbp ijbp`cj cdubz}coi}cgd ge Kbwczl izzcachi}cgd idmjrh}rpih dgpaz cd zb|rih pbhi}cgdzlcvz$ ]lb agucb }gdbm mgwd }lb Kbwczldbzz ,Scmmczlnbs}# ge }lbz}gps ,vip} ge }lb izzcachi}cgd vpgkbj}#( `r} lcd}z ge Kbwczl mceebpbdjb idm mczjgaegp} wbpb z}chh}lbpb$ ^Dgwimisz Pi``c Jggvbp ge }lb _cbzbd}lih Jbd}bp jbp}cecbz agucbz egp Kbwczl

ijjbv}i`chc}s( `r} cd }lb viz} zgab zgp} ge cdegpaih jgdzbdzrz abjlidcza wiz vpgì`hsgvbpi}cub$Q

]lb Lbip}`pbin Ncm,BA# vgnbz zgab erd i} z}bpbg}svbz iz c} mbvcj}z i Kbwczl cduizcgd ge }lbobd}chb bhc}b$

Cd Mbzvbpi}bhs Zbbncdo Zrzid}lb Kbwczl zr`rpìdc}bz( wlg ipb eicphs jizrihhs `r} `hidmhsvpgaczjrgrz( ipb jhbiphs wbih}lcbp }lid }lb obd}chb Zrzid idm lbp epcbdmz( wlg b|vpbzz }lbogsczlidcaihcz}cj vizzcgd egp wlcjl }lb Kbwczl Pg`bp}i hgdoz$

]gmis( Obd}chb!Kbwczl }bdzcgdz ipb vizz$ Bubd }lgrol Bmms Nid}pgw( wlg cz }lb aihbvpg}iogdcz} ge ]lb Lbip}`pbin Ncm,E@# cz z}chh Kbwczl ih`bc} hbzz gùcgrzhs }lid Hbdds Nid}pgw ge}lb BA ubpzcgd( }lb Eippbhhs @pg}lbpz idm Zvcbh`bpo wpg}b gr} }lb Kbwczl!Obd}chb jgdehcj} }lbab$Bmms cz dg hgdobp i sgrdo zlhbv zbhhcdo zvgp}cdo oggmz `r} cz }lb bz}i`hczlbm =6!zgab}lcdo

vpgvpcb}gp ge i zvgp}cdo oggmz z}gpb$

]lb z}gps( wlcjl dgw `bocdz cd Zid Epidjczjg cdz}bim ge Dbw Sgpn( cz gd }lb wlghb oisbp idmagpb aczgosdcz}cj }lid }lb gpcocdih$ Gdb jgrhm zsavi}lc{b arjl agpb wc}l }lb sgrdobp HbddsNid}pgw bubd wlbd lb cz hscdo i} i achb i} acdr}b `bjirzb lb cz i eggh egp hgub$ Cd }lb ziabzc}ri}cgd( Bmms Nid}pgw zbbaz i} `bz} i zlarjn idm agpb ge}bd zcavhs vpbmi}gps$

Acpidmi( wlg pbvhijbz Nbhhs Jgpjgpid ge }lb gpcocdih( idm lbp eiachs ipb geebdmbm }li} Bmms }pcbm}g vcjn rv Acpidmi mrpcdo lcz lgdbsaggd( `r} bubd}rihhs Acpidmi mravz lbp lrzìdm }g zbbn gr}Bmms( wlg pbzvgdmz idm ivvipbd}hs cd}bdmz }g mrav lcz zbjgdm wceb$ C} cz i eicphs diz}s pbvpczb ge}lb zgp} ge zbpcih vghsoias }li} jlipij}bpc{bm Biz}bpd Brpgvbid b}ldcj Izlnbdi{c jrh}rpb wc}ldgdb ge }lb ac}coi}cdo jcpjraz}idjbz izzgjci}bm wc}l biphs aippciob idm i lcol hbubh ge eiachsvpbzzrpb$

Cd Impcbddb Zlbhhsz _ic}pbzz( wlcjl cz b|jbv}cgdihhs lgz}chb }g abd( }lbpb ipb dg Kbwczljlipij}bpz( `r} }lb Zgr}lbpd obd}chbz dgw liub }lb Dbw Sgpn Kbwczl agpihc}s izzgjci}bm wc}lZb| idm }lb Jc}s( idm ie}bp id ieeicp }li} ocubz lbp zbhe!jgdecmbdjb( }lb lbpgcdb mravz lbplrzìdm }g z}ip} lbp gwd `rzcdbzz$ ]lb agucb pbvpbzbd}bm }lb ecdih izzcachi}cgd ge Iabpcjiddgd!Kbwz }g Kbwczl dgpaz( idm c} pbjbcubm piub pbucbwz$

C} wiz cd}bpbz}cdo }li} }lb agucb lim }lb }pcvhb Ogmmbzz zr`}lbab }li} wiz vpbzbd} cd }lb agucbBdbacbz( I Hgub Z}gps( wlcjl wiz imiv}bm epga Zgdca( I Obzlcnl} erd i Hcb``s Cziij @izlbuczZcdobp$ ,Zbb l}}v;''bii{c$`hgozvg}$jga'066


11/26

Agp} [rjnbpaid pbjbd}hs aimb id cavgp}id} g`zbpui}cgd cd i K]I dbwz pbvgp},l}}v;''www$k}i$gpo'joc!`cd'cgwi'`pbincdo'965??2$l}ah#$

[rjnbpaid; Czpibh i /jhcbd} z}i}b/ ge R$Z$

Vr`hczlbm; 60'6:'066

,j# Mbhc`bpi}bhs cdehcj}cdo gd }lb opgrv jgdmc}cgdz ge hceb jihjrhi}bm }g `pcdo i`gr} c}zvlszcjih mbz}prj}cgd cd wlghb gp cd vip}>

,m# Cavgzcdo abizrpbz cd}bdmbm }g vpbubd} `cp}lz wc}lcd }lb opgrv>

,b# Egpjc`hs }pidzebppcdo jlchmpbd ge }lb opgrv }g idg}lbp opgrv$

C}baz i( `( idm j liub ivvhcbm }g Vihbz}cdb zcdjb pijcz} Biz}bpd Brpgvbid Izlnbdi{ca `boid }g

cduimb Vihbz}cdb egp }lb vrpvgzb ge z}bihcdo c} epga }lb di}cub vgvrhi}cgd i} }lb bdm ge }lb 93}l

jbd}rps$ Obdgjcmih [cgdcz} cd}bd} ioicdz} }lb di}cub vgvrhi}cgd ge Vihbz}cdb jid `b }pijbm `ijn iz

eip iz 9


25/26

,l}}v;''www$ikj$jga'ab}pg'jgd}bd}'ab}pg'owcddb}}'z}gpcbz'066?'96'69'di{cW9660Wwb`$l}ah7j|d}dcm1`dW066?!96!69W90W::Wcm:65Wb#

Ijjgpmcdo Krz}cjb Mbvip}abd} idm Lgabhidm Zbjrpc}s geecjcihz( Virh Lbdzz( id


26/26

Bubd}rihhs( ij}cucz}z arz} wgpn }g jpbi}b Vihbz}cdcid!zsavi}lb}cj gp Vihbz}cdcid VGU Lghhswggm!z}shb jcdbai egp Iabpcjid irmcbdjbz$ ,Zbbl}}v;''aba`bpz$igh$jga']lgpzVpgugdc'Dbw]wg_bmmcdoz$vme(l}}v;''aba`bpz$igh$jga']lgpzVpgugdc'}wgwbbnz$vme egp vpgge ge jgdjbv}$#Sb}( iz jghm iz c} cz }g z}i}b( }lb pbih czzrb cz dg} Vihbz}cdb$

Rdhbzz }lbs ipb dbr}pihc{bm( Czpibh hg``scdo opgrvz( Czpibh imugji}bz( [cgdcz}z( Dbgjgdzbpui}cubz(idm Epcbmaidc}bz wchh z}bih Iabpcji idm beebj}cubhs i`ghczl }lb Jgdz}c}r}cgd cd ihh `r} diab }gjpbi}b i zgjcb}s ge zbpuc}rmb egp ihh Iabpcjidz b|jbv} egp }lgzb `bhgdocdo }g }lb lsvbp!wbih}ls}pidzdi}cgdih [cgdcz} vghc}cjih bhc}b$

joachim martillo: judonia rising: the israel lobby and american society

Documents