jbipl volume 17 issue 3 final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7...

63
:$.( )25(67 -2851$/ 2) %86,1(66 $1' ,17(//(&78$/ 3523(57< /$: ŗŝ ŘŖŗŝ ř $'$37,1* 7+( 86372¶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

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

:$.(�)25(67�-2851$/�2)�%86,1(66

$1'�,17(//(&78$/�3523(57<�/$:

������ȱŗŝ �����ȱŘŖŗŝ ������ȱř

$'$37,1*�7+(�86372¶6�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�)25�7+(�)('(5$/�&28576

%HWKDQ\�5DEH�

,� ,1752'8&7,21������������������������������������������������������������� ���

,,� '(9(/230(17�2)�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�$7�7+(�86372 $1'�02'(51�81/$:)8/�86(�&$6(�/$:�,1�7+(�)('(5$/�&28576������������������������������������� ���$� %$&.*5281'����������������������������������������������������������� ����� 7UDGHPDUN�/DZ�LQ�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV����������������������� ����� $FTXLULQJ�DQG�3URWHFWLQJ�7UDGHPDUN�5LJKWV ���������� ����� 7KH�5ROH�RI�86372��77$% ���������������������������������� ����� 7KH�5ROH�RI�WKH�)HGHUDO�&RXUWV ������������������������������� ���

%� 7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(������������������������������� ����� 7KH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�DW�WKH�86372 ������������� ����� 7KH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�LQ�WKH�)HGHUDO�&RXUWV ����������������������������������������������������������������������� ���

,,,� $33/,&$7,21�2)�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�,1�7+(�)('(5$/�&28576 ���������������������������������������������� ���$� ,6�7+(5(�$�+,6725,&$/�%$6,6�)25�7+(�'2&75,1(�

,1�7+(�)('(5$/�&28576" ����������������������������������������� ����� 3UH�/DQKDP�$FW�7UHDWPHQW�RI�8QODZIXO�8VH���������� ����� 8QODZIXO�8VH�8QGHU�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW ��������������������� ����� 3UH�&UH$JUL�)HGHUDO�&DVH�/DZ ������������������������������ ���

� %HWKDQ\�5DEH�LV�DQ�DWWRUQH\�SUDFWLFLQJ�LQ�/DV�9HJDV��1HYDGD���0DQ\�WKDQNV�WR�WKH�SHRSOH�ZKR� WRRN� WKH� WLPH� WR�FRPPHQW�RQ�GUDIWV�RI� WKLV�SDSHU�RU�RWKHUZLVH� VXSSRUW�WKLV� HIIRUW�� � &KULVWRSKHU� %DYLW]�� 5HEHFFD� 7XVKQHW�� -DQH� %HVWRU�� 6XVDQQDK� %DUWRQ�7RELQ��/DXUL�7KRPSVRQ��0DUN�7UDWRV��6KDXQD�1RUWRQ��DQG�WKH�HGLWRUV�RI�WKH�:DNH�)RUHVW�-RXUQDO�RI�%XVLQHVV�DQG�,QWHOOHFWXDO�3URSHUW\�/DZ���$Q\�HUURUV��KRZHYHU��DUH�PLQH�DORQH���

Page 2: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

ŘŞŝ

%� ,6�$'237,1*�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�

*22'�32/,&<" ����������������������������������������������������������� ����� &RQVXPHU�3URWHFWLRQ�DV�D�3ROLF\�2EMHFWLYH ����������� ����� 'HWHUUHQFH�DQG�RU�3XQLVKPHQW�DV�D�3ROLF\�2EMHFWLYH ������������������������������������������������������������������� ���

,9� 35$&7,&$/�&216,'(5$7,216�)25�$33/<,1*�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�,1�7+(�)('(5$/�&28576 ��������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���$� &28576�0867�5(62/9(�7+(�,668(�2)�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(¶6�,17(5$&7,21�:,7+�

67$7(�$1'�)('(5$/�/$:����������������������������������������� ����� 'RHV�WKH�8QODZIXO�8VH 'RFWULQH�2SHUDWH�WR�3XW�6WDWH�/DZ�2YHU�)HGHUDO�/DZ" ���������������������������������� ���

�� 'RHV�WKH�$SSOLFDWLRQ�RI�WKH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�0DNH�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�D�³%DFN�'RRU´�IRU�(QIRUFHPHQW�RI�6WDWXWHV�:LWK�1R�3ULYDWH�&DXVH�RI�$FWLRQ"������������������������������������������������������� ���

%� 35$&7,&$/�&216,'(5$7,216�)25�&28576�

$33/<,1*�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�$1'�

68**(67,216�)25�$''5(66,1*�7+(0���������������������� ����� 'LVWULFW�&RXUWV�0XVW�EH�0LQGIXO�RI�WKH�(IIHFW�RI�WKH�'RFWULQH �������������������������������������������������������������� ���

�� 'LVWULFW�&RXUWV�0XVW�$SSO\�D�&OHDU��7KRXJKWIXO��DQG�&RQVLVWHQW�6WDQGDUG������������������������������������������� ���

�� (YLGHQFH�3URFHGXUH ������������������������������������������������ ����� :KDW�HIIHFW�VKRXOG�D�ILQGLQJ�RI�WKH�86372�KDYH"������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���

�� :KHQ�DQG�+RZ�&RXUWV�6KRXOG�0DNH�WKH�'HWHUPLQDWLRQ ����������������������������������������������������������� ���

9� &21&/86,21 ��������������������������������������������������������������� ���

Page 3: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŞŞ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

$EVWUDFW

7KLV�SDSHU�H[DPLQHV� WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH� LQ� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ��IRUPHUO\�FRQILQHG�WR�WKH�86372��DV�QRZ�EHLQJ�DSSOLHG�LQ�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�� � 6SHFLILFDOO\�� WKLV� SDSHU� ORRNV� DW� WKH� H[SORVLRQ� RI� FDVHV� WKDW�KDYH� LQYROYHG� WKH� GRFWULQH� VLQFH� WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW� ILUVW� DQQRXQFHG�D�IHGHUDO�FRXUW� YHUVLRQ� LQ� ������ � ,W� ILUVW� H[DPLQHV� ZKHWKHU� WKHUH� LV� D�KLVWRULFDO�� VWDWXWRU\�� RU�SROLF\� EDVLV� IRU� WKH� GRFWULQH¶V� DSSOLFDWLRQ� LQ�WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV�� � 7KHQ�� LW� LGHQWLILHV� VHYHUDO� LVVXHV� WKDW� VKRXOG� EH�DGGUHVVHG� EHIRUH� WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� PRYH� IRUZDUG� ZLWK� EURDG�DSSOLFDWLRQ� RI� WKH� GRFWULQH�� DQG� LW� H[DPLQHV� VRPH� SUDFWLFDO� LVVXHV�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�VKRXOG�FRQVLGHU��

*LYHQ�WKDW�WKHUH�LV�OLWWOH�KLVWRULFDO��VWDWXWRU\��RU�SROLF\�VXSSRUW�IRU�WKH�GRFWULQH¶V�DSSOLFDWLRQ�LQ�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV��DQG�HVSHFLDOO\�WKDW�WKH�GRFWULQH� ZRXOG� VHHP� WR� FUHDWH� UHVXOWV� FRXQWHU� WR� WKH� FRQVXPHU�SURWHFWLRQ�IXQFWLRQ�RI�WUDGHPDUN�ODZ��,�DUJXH�WKDW�WKH�GRFWULQH�VKRXOG�EH�FDUHIXOO\�FRQVLGHUHG�DQG�UDUHO\�DSSOLHG��

Page 4: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

ŘŞş

,� ,1752'8&7,21

6XSSRVH� ,� KDYH� EHHQ� XVLQJ� WKH� RWKHUZLVH�YDOLG�DQG�SURWHFWDEOH�PDUN� $&0(� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� D� QXWULWLRQDO� VXSSOHPHQW� IRU� PDQ\�\HDUV�� � ,�KDYH�D� OR\DO�FXVWRPHU�EDVH�DQG�KDYH� LQYHVWHG� LQ� WKH�TXDOLW\�DQG� UHSXWDWLRQ� RI� P\� JRRGV�� � $� QHZ� PDUNHW� HQWUDQW� HPHUJHV�� DOVR�XVLQJ� $&0(� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� VXSSOHPHQWV�� � &RQFHUQHG�� ,� ILOH� D�WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW� ODZVXLW�� WKH� QHZ� HQWUDQW� GHIHQGV� E\� DUJXLQJ�WKDW� ,� KDYH�QR� ULJKWV� DW� DOO�� �+RZ�FRXOG� ,�KDYH� QR� ULJKWV"� � ,¶YH�EHHQ�XVLQJ�D�YDOLG�DQG�SURWHFWDEOH�PDUN�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�P\�VXSSOHPHQWV�IRU� \HDUV�� � &RQVXPHUV� NQRZ�P\� SURGXFW� DQG� UHO\� XSRQ� WKH� $&0(�PDUN� DV� DQ� LQGLFDWLRQ� RI� RULJLQ� DQG� TXDOLW\�� � %XW� ,� KDYH� RYHUORRNHG�VRPHWKLQJ� LQ� WKH� FRXUVH� RI� VWDUWLQJ� P\� EXVLQHVV�� WKH� ODEHO� RQ� P\�SURGXFW�GRHV�QRW�FRPSO\�ZLWK�IHGHUDO�ODZ���

:LOO�P\�RSSRQHQW�VXFFHHG�LQ�YRLGLQJ�P\�ULJKWV�DQG�EHFRPLQJ�WKH�VHQLRU� XVHU"� � 7KH� DQVZHU� GHSHQGV� RQ� ZKHWKHU� DQG� KRZ� WKH� FRXUW�DSSOLHV�WKH�³XQODZIXO�XVH´�GRFWULQH���)RUPHUO\�FRQILQHG�WR�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV�3DWHQW�DQG�7UDGHPDUN�2IILFH��³86372´���ZKHUH�WKH�VWDNHV�DUH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RQO\�DQG�WKH�GRFWULQH�LV�QDUURZO\�DSSOLHG�� LQ�UHFHQW�\HDUV�WKH� GRFWULQH� KDV� EHJXQ� WR� PLJUDWH� WR� WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV�� ZKHUH� LW� LV�EHLQJ� XVHG� LQ� D� PXFK� EURDGHU� FRQWH[W� WR� DIIHFW� SULRULW\� RI� XVH���8QIRUWXQDWHO\� IRU� FRQVXPHUV� ZKR� UHO\� XSRQ� WKH� $&0(� PDUN�� LW� LV�TXLWH�SRVVLEOH�WKDW�P\�LQDGYHUWHQW�ODEHOLQJ�YLRODWLRQ�FRXOG�VWULS�PH�RI�P\�ULJKWV��OHDYLQJ�RQO\�WKH�MXQLRU�XVHU�LQ�WKH�PDUNHWSODFH�

2QH� RI� WKH� ILUVW� WKLQJV� D� EXGGLQJ� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ\HU� OHDUQV� LV� WKH�GLIIHUHQFH�EHWZHHQ�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�DQG�XVH���5HJLVWUDWLRQ�SHUPLWV�VRPHRQH�XVLQJ��RU� LQWHQGLQJ�WR�XVH��D� WUDGHPDUN�WR�UHJLVWHU�WKDW�PDUN�ZLWK�WKH�86372�� DQG� WKHUH� DUH� FHUWDLQO\� EHQHILWV� WR� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� WKDW� PDNH�GRLQJ� VR� ZRUWKZKLOH�� +RZHYHU�� WKHUH� LV� QR� UHTXLUHPHQW� WR� UHJLVWHU�WKH�PDUN�LQ�RUGHU�WR�XVH�LW��RU�HYHQ�WR�HQIRUFH�ULJKWV�LQ�LW�� 0RUHRYHU��WKH� PHUH� IDFW� WKDW� D� PDUN� KDV� SURFHHGHG� WR� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� LV� QRW� D�JXDUDQWHH� WKDW� WKH� PDUN� LV� QRW� LQIULQJLQJ�� (YHQ� LI� WKHUH� ZHUH� QR�VLPLODU�PDUNV�RQ�WKH�UHJLVWHU��SHUVRQV�ZLWK�XQUHJLVWHUHG��FRPPRQ�ODZ��ULJKWV� LQ� WKH�PDUN� FDQ� VXH� IRU� LQIULQJHPHQW� DQG�� GHSHQGLQJ� RQ�ZKR�VWDUWHG�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�ILUVW��FDQ�SRWHQWLDOO\�VWULS�WKH�UHJLVWUDQW�RI�ERWK�KLV�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�DQG�KLV�ULJKW�WR�XVH�WKH�PDUN��

7KLV�SDSHU�IRFXVHV�RQ�D�GRFWULQH�WKDW�LPSDFWV�ERWK�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�DQG�

� 8�6� 3$7(17� 75$'(0$5.�2)),&(� 3527(&7,1*�<285�75$'(0$5.�(1+$1&,1*�<285�5,*+76�7+528*+�)('(5$/�5(*,675$7,21 �±�����������KWWS���ZZZ�XVSWR�JRY�VLWHV�GHIDXOW�ILOHV�WUDGHPDUNV�EDVLFV�%DVLF)DFWV�SGI�>KHUHLQDIWHU�3URWHFWLQJ�<RXU�7UDGHPDUN@�

� ,G�� ,G� DW���� ,G�

Page 5: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘşŖ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

XVH�� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�� � $V� D� SROLF\� RI� WKH� 86372�� LW� FDQ�RSHUDWH�WR�SUHYHQW�D�PDUN�IURP�UHJLVWHULQJ�ZKHUH�WKH�PDUN LV�XVHG�LQ�D�ZD\�WKDW�LV�FRQVLGHUHG�XQODZIXO�� 7KLV�FRXOG�EH�DQ�DWWHPSW�WR�UHJLVWHU�D� PDUN� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� KHURLQ�� RU� LW� FRXOG� EH� WKDW� WKH� VSHFLPHQ�VXEPLWWHG�ZLWK�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�LV�QRW�LQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�)'$�ODEHOLQJ�UHJXODWLRQV�� � 7KH�86372� FRQVWUXHV WKH� GRFWULQH� IDLUO\� QDUURZO\� DQG�ZKHQ�LW�GRHV�DSSO\�WKH�GRFWULQH��WKH�UHVXOW�LV�WKDW�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�LV�HLWKHU�GHQLHG� RU� FDQFHOOHG�� 7KH� XVHU¶V� DELOLW\� WR� DFWXDOO\� XVH� WKH�PDUN� LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� KLV� RU� KHU� JRRGV� DQG� VHUYLFHV� LV� QRW� DIIHFWHG� E\� D�86372�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ�RI�XQODZIXOQHVV��

,Q�UHFHQW�\HDUV��KRZHYHU��WKLV�FRXVLQ�RI�WKH�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�GRFWULQH�KDV� PDGH� LWV� ZD\� IURP� WKH� 86372� WR� IHGHUDO� FRXUW�� ZKHUH� LWV�LPSOLFDWLRQV� DUH� PXFK� EURDGHU�� � 7KH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW� KDV� HVVHQWLDOO\�DGRSWHG� WKH� 86372¶V� GRFWULQH�� EXW� KDV� DSSOLHG� LW� WR� LQIULQJHPHQW�LQVWHDG�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� 1RZ��XQODZIXO�XVH�RI�D�PDUN�DIIHFWV�QRW�MXVW�ZKHWKHU�D�PDUN�FDQ�EH�UHJLVWHUHG��EXW�ZKHWKHU�D�PDUN�FDQ�EH�XVHG�DW�DOO�� WKH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW� KDV� LQ� HIIHFW� KHOG� WKDW� ULJKWV� FDQQRW� GHYHORSGXULQJ� SHULRGV RI� WLPH� ZKHQ� D� XVH� LV� XQODZIXO�� 7KLV� UHSUHVHQWV� D�VLJQLILFDQW�H[SDQVLRQ�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH��MXQLRU�XVHUV�FRXOG�EHFRPH�VHQLRU�XVHUV��DQG�VHQLRU�XVHUV�FRXOG�SRWHQWLDOO\�ILQG�WKHPVHOYHV�ZLWKRXW�ULJKWV�LQ� PDUNV� WKDW� WKH\¶YH� XVHG� IRU� \HDUV�� � &RQVXPHUV²WKH� VXSSRVHG�EHQHILFLDULHV� RI� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ²FRXOG� IDFH� FRQIXVLQJ� PDUNHW�FRQGLWLRQV�� RIWHQ� LQ� DUHDV� ZKHUH� WUDGHPDUN� SURWHFWLRQ� LV� PRVW�LPSRUWDQW�VXFK�DV�QXWULWLRQDO�VXSSOHPHQWV��IRRG��RU�GUXJV�

'HVSLWH�WKH�VHULRXVQHVV�RI�WKH�FRQVHTXHQFHV��WKHUH�KDV�QRW�EHHQ�DQ�LQ�GHSWK� DQDO\VLV� RQ� WKLV� WRSLF�� � $V� VXFK�� LQ� WKLV� SDSHU�� ,� H[DPLQH�ZKHWKHU� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� FDQ� DQG� VKRXOG� EH� DSSOLHG� LQ� WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV��LQ�OLJKW�RI�KLVWRU\�DQG�SROLF\���,�DOVR�H[DPLQH��SUDFWLFDO�FRQVLGHUDWLRQV� IRU� FRXUWV� IDFHG� ZLWK� DSSO\LQJ� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH�GRFWULQH�� VXFK� DV� ZKLFK� DVSHFWV� RI� WKH� 86372¶V� SROLF\� VKRXOG� EH�LPSRUWHG� DQG� ZKLFK� VKRXOG� QRW�� HYLGHQWLDU\� FRQVLGHUDWLRQV� VXFK� DV�EXUGHQ� RI� SURRI� DQG� ZKDW� HYLGHQFH� ZLOO� VXSSRUW� DQ� XQODZIXO� XVH�DUJXPHQW�� WLPLQJ� ZLWKLQ� D� ODZVXLW�� DQG�ZKHWKHU� 86372� ILQGLQJV� LQ�WKLV� DUHD� VKRXOG� KDYH� D� SUHFOXVLYH� HIIHFW�� � 2YHUDOO�� ,� DUJXH� WKDW� WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH�LQ�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�VKRXOG�EH�FDUHIXO�DQG�UDUH����

� .LHUDQ�*��'R\OH��7UDGHPDUN�6WUDWHJLHV�IRU�(PHUJLQJ�0DULMXDQD�%XVLQHVVHV�:(67/$:�-� ,17(//� 3523�� 0D\�����������DW����

� ,G�� 6HH�LG� DW����� &UH$JUL��,QF��Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6FLV���,QF�������)��G������������WK�&LU��������� ,G� DW���������±�����WK�&LU���������6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q�Y��=DIILQD������)��G�

�����������WK�&LU��������

Page 6: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

Řşŗ

,,� '(9(/230(17�2)�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�$7�7+(�

86372 $1'�02'(51�81/$:)8/�86(�&$6(�/$:�,1�7+(�)('(5$/�&28576

$� %DFNJURXQG

7R�IXOO\�XQGHUVWDQG�WKH�FRPSOH[LWLHV�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�DQG�WKH�UROH��LI�DQ\��LW�VKRXOG�SOD\�LQ�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV��LW�LV�LPSRUWDQW�WR�XQGHUVWDQG� WKH�VWUXFWXUH�RI� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ�LQ� WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV�� �$�FRPSOHWH�UHYLHZ�RI�WKLV�WRSLF�LV�EH\RQG�WKH�VFRSH�RI�WKLV�SDSHU��EXW�D�EULHI�VXPPDU\�ZLOO�VHUYH�WR�RULHQW�WKH�UHDGHU�VR�DV�WR�EHWWHU�XQGHUVWDQG�WKH�GLVFXVVLRQ�DQG�VXJJHVWLRQV�LQ�VXEVHTXHQW�VHFWLRQV���

�� 7UDGHPDUN�/DZ�LQ�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV

³7UDGHPDUN� ODZ´� UHIHUV� WR� WKH� ERG\�RI� ODZ� JRYHUQLQJ� WKH� XVH� RI�WUDGHPDUNV���$�WUDGHPDUN�LV�HVVHQWLDOO\�DQ\WKLQJ²DOWKRXJK�PRVW�RIWHQ�D� ZRUG� RU� V\PERO²WKDW� VRPHRQH� VHOOLQJ� JRRGV� RU� VHUYLFHV� XVHV� WR�VLJQDO� WKH� RULJLQ� RI� WKRVH� JRRGV� RU� VHUYLFHV� WR� FRQVXPHUV� �� ,Q�OD\PDQ¶V�WHUPV��PRVW�WUDGHPDUNV�DUH�EUDQG�QDPHV�RU�ORJRV���

:KLOH�RWKHU�SURWHFWLRQV� IRU� LQWHOOHFWXDO�SURSHUW\� �L�H��� SDWHQWV� DQG�FRS\ULJKWV��ULJKW�RI�SXEOLFLW\��WUDGH�VHFUHW��VHUYH�ODUJHO\�WR�SURWHFW�WKH�RZQHU�RI� WKDW� LQWHOOHFWXDO� SURSHUW\�� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ�SULPDULO\� VHUYHV� D�FRQVXPHU� SURWHFWLRQ� IXQFWLRQ��� (VVHQWLDOO\�� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ� DWWHPSWV�WR� HQVXUH� WKDW�ZKHQ� D� FRQVXPHU� HQFRXQWHUV� D� SDUWLFXODU�PDUN� LQ� WKH�PDUNHWSODFH��VKH�FDQ�UHO\�RQ�WKDW�PDUN�WR�LQIRUP�KHU�WKDW�WKH�JRRGV�VKH�LV� SXUFKDVLQJ� FRPH� IURP� D� SDUWLFXODU� VRXUFH� �� 7KH� SXUSRVH� RI�WUDGHPDUN�ODZ�LV�WR�³SURWHFW�WKH�SXEOLF�VR�LW�PD\�EH�FRQILGHQW�WKDW��LQ�SXUFKDVLQJ� D� SURGXFW� EHDULQJ� D� SDUWLFXODU� WUDGH�PDUN� ZKLFK� LW�IDYRUDEO\�NQRZV��LW�ZLOO�JHW�WKH�SURGXFW�ZKLFK�LW�DVNV�IRU�DQG�ZDQWV�WR�JHW�´�� ,W�DOVR�SURWHFWV�WUDGHPDUN�RZQHUV��LQ�WKDW�³ZKHUH�WKH�RZQHU�RI�D� WUDGH�PDUN�KDV� VSHQW� HQHUJ\�� WLPH�� DQG�PRQH\� LQ�SUHVHQWLQJ� WR� WKH�SXEOLF� WKH� SURGXFW�� KH� LV� SURWHFWHG� LQ� KLV� LQYHVWPHQW� IURP� LWV�PLVDSSURSULDWLRQ�E\�SLUDWHV�DQG�FKHDWV�´��

�� 3URWHFWLQJ�<RXU�7UDGHPDUN��VXSUD QRWH����DW����� ,G��� *UDHPH�%��'LQZRRGLH��7KH�'HDWK�2I�2QWRORJ\��$�7HOHRORJLFDO�$SSURDFK�7R�

7UDGHPDUN�/DZ�����,2:$�/� 5(9����������±������������ 0LFKDHO�6��0LUHOHV��-U���7RZDUGV�5HFRJQL]LQJ�DQG�5HFRQFLOLQJ�WKH�

0XOWLSOLFLW\�RI�9DOXHV�DQG�,QWHUHVWV�LQ�7UDGHPDUN�/DZ�����,1'� /� 5(9�������������������FLWLQJ�7ZR�3HVRV��,QF��Y��7DFR�&DEDQD��,QF�������8�6����������±�����������

�� 7ZR�3HVRV� ,QF��Y��7DFR�&DEDQD��,QF�������8�6�����������Q������������6WHYHQV��-���FRQFXUULQJ���TXRWLQJ�6� 5(3� 12�����������DW�����������

�� ,G���

Page 7: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘşŘ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

�� $FTXLULQJ�DQG�3URWHFWLQJ�7UDGHPDUN�5LJKWV

,Q� WKH� 8QLWHG 6WDWHV�� WUDGHPDUN� ULJKWV� GHYHORS� EDVHG� RQ� XVH� LQ�FRPPHUFH�� UHJDUGOHVV� RI�ZKHWKHU� RU� QRW� D� SHUVRQ� UHJLVWHUV� WKDW�PDUN�ZLWK� WKH� IHGHUDO� RU� VWDWH� JRYHUQPHQW� �� 7KHVH� ULJKWV� DUH� FDOOHG�³FRPPRQ� ODZ´� WUDGHPDUN� ULJKWV� �� 8QOLNH� D� FRS\ULJKW� RZQHU�� IRU�H[DPSOH�� D� WUDGHPDUN� RZQHU� PD\� VXH� WR� HQIRUFH� KLV� FRPPRQ� ODZ�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV�ZLWKRXW�D�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��� 2I�FRXUVH��WKHUH�DUH�EHQHILWV�WR�IHGHUDO�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��WKH�PRVW�VLJQLILFDQW�EHLQJ�WKH�H[FOXVLYH�ULJKW�WR�XVH�WKH�PDUN�QDWLRQZLGH�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�WKH�JRRGV�DQG�VHUYLFHV�LQ�WKH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� DV� ZHOO� DV� D� OHJDO� SUHVXPSWLRQ� RI� YDOLGLW\� RI� WKH�PDUN��� 2WKHU�LPSRUWDQW�EHQHILWV�LQFOXGH��SXEOLF�QRWLFH�RI�WKH�FODLP�WR�RZQHUVKLS�RI� WKH�PDUN�� WKH� DELOLW\� WR� UHFRUG� WKH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�ZLWK� WKH�&XVWRPV� DQG� %RUGHU� 3URWHFWLRQ� 6HUYLFH� WR� SUHYHQW� LPSRUWDWLRQ� RI�LQIULQJLQJ� JRRGV�� DQG� WKH� DELOLW\� WR� XVH� WKH� PDUN� WR� IDFLOLWDWH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ� LQ� IRUHLJQ� FRXQWULHV� �� ,Q� WKH� ODVW� WZHQW\� \HDUV� RU� VR��DQRWKHU� NH\� EHQHILW� KDV� EHHQ� WKH� DELOLW\� WR� XVH� WKH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� DV� D�EDVLV� IRU� VSHHG\� UHPRYDO� RI� LQIULQJLQJ� GRPDLQ� QDPHV� DQG� RWKHU�LQIULQJLQJ�FRQWHQW�RQOLQH���

:KHWKHU� UHJLVWHUHG� RU� QRW�� WKH�PRVW� LPSRUWDQW� GDWH� LQ� WUDGHPDUN�ODZ� LV� WKH� GDWH� RI� ILUVW� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH�� � %HFDXVH� WKH� SULQFLSOH�XQGHUO\LQJ� WUDGHPDUN� SURWHFWLRQ� LV� WKDW� GLVWLQFWLYH� PDUNV FDQ� KHOS�FRQVXPHUV� GLVWLQJXLVK� RQH� DUWLVDQ¶V� JRRGV� IURP� DQRWKHU�� WKH� SHUVRQ�ZKR�XVHV�WKH�PDUN�LQ�FRPPHUFH�ILUVW�DFTXLUHV�SULRULW\�ULJKWV�LQ�DQG�WR�WKH�PDUN��� 7KLV�SHUVRQ�LV�RIWHQ�UHIHUUHG�WR�LQ�WUDGHPDUN�ODZ�DV�EHLQJ�WKH� ³VHQLRU� XVHU´� RU� KDYLQJ� ³SULRULW\ RI� XVH�´ �� ,Q� WKH� HYHQW� RI� D�FRQIOLFW� EHWZHHQ� WZR� SDUWLHV�ZKR� DUH� XVLQJ� VLPLODU�PDUNV�� WKH� SDUW\�

�� 8�6� '(37�2)�&200(5&(� 8�6� 3$7� 75$'(0$5.�2))�� 75$'(0$5.�

0$18$/�2)�(;$0,1,1*�352&('85(�� ������ �������KWWSV���WPHS�XVSWR�JRY�5'06�70(3�FXUUHQW��FXUUHQW�70(3����G�H��KWPO�>KHUHLQDIWHU�70(3@�

�� &RPPRQ�/DZ�7UDGHPDUN�5LJKWV� %,7/$:��KWWS���ZZZ�ELWODZ�FRP�WUDGHPDUN�FRPPRQ�KWPO��ODVW�YLVLWHG�)HE�������������

�� 7UDGHPDUN��3DWHQW��RU�&RS\ULJKW"��8�6� 3$7� 75$'(0$5.�2))��KWWSV���ZZZ�XVSWR�JRY�WUDGHPDUNV�JHWWLQJ�VWDUWHG�WUDGHPDUN�EDVLFV�WUDGHPDUN�SDWHQW�RU�FRS\ULJKW��ODVW�YLVLWHG�)HE������������

�� 6HH %��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF��Y��+DUJLV�,QGXV���,QF�������6��&W��������������������

�� 3URWHFWLQJ�<RXU�7UDGHPDUN��VXSUD QRWH����DW��±����� 6HH ,Q�UH 7DP������)��G�����������)HG��&LU���������QRWLQJ�WKH�DELOLW\�WR�

SUHYHQW�F\EHUVTXDWWHUV�IURP�PLVDSSURSULDWLQJ�GRPDLQ�QDPH���� %��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF�������6��&W��DW��������������� :KDW�LV�7UDGHPDUN�3ULRULW\�DQG�:K\�6KRXOG�,�&DUH"��7,1*(1�:,//,$06��

KWWSV���WLQJHQZLOOLDPV�FRP������WUDGHPDUN�SULRULW\�FDUH�������ODVW�YLVLWHG�)HE������������

Page 8: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

Řşř

ZLWK�WKH�HDUOLHU�GDWH�RI�XVH�LV�VDLG�WR�KDYH�SULRULW\�RI�XVH�DQG�FDQ�VWRS�FRPSHWLQJ�XVHUV�IURP�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN��� 7KLV�GDWH�LV�KRWO\�FRQWHVWHG�LQ�OLWLJDWLRQ��DV�HDFK�SDUW\�DWWHPSWV�WR�VKRZ�WKDW�LW�EHJDQ�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�EHIRUH�LWV�ULYDO���

7KHUH�LV�WKXV�DQ�LQFHQWLYH�IRU�WUDGHPDUN�XVHUV�WR�FODLP�WKH�HDUOLHVW�VXSSRUWDEOH� GDWH� RI� ILUVW� XVH� DQG� WKHUH� LV� DOVR� DQ� LQFHQWLYH� IRU� WKRVH�FRQWHVWLQJ�WKDW�GDWH�WR�FKDOOHQJH�LW�E\�DQ\�PHDQV�SRVVLEOH���)UHTXHQWO\��D�FKDOOHQJHU�ZLOO�FODLP�WKDW�KLV�ULYDO¶V�ILUVW�XVHV�ZHUH�³WRNHQ´�XVHV��RU�LQFRQVLVWHQW��RU�QRW�XVHG�DV�DQ�DFWXDO�WUDGHPDUN��RU�XVHG�LQ�D�GLIIHUHQW�IRUP� WKDW� VKRXOGQ¶W� ³FRXQW´� WRZDUG� WKH� GHYHORSPHQW� RI� KLV� ULJKWV���

7KLV� SDSHU� IRFXVHV� RQ� RQH� SDUWLFXODU�PHWKRG� RI� FKDOOHQJLQJ� SULRULW\�WKDW�KDV�EHFRPH�YHU\�SRSXODU� LQ� WKH� ODVW� WHQ� \HDUV�� FODLPLQJ� WKDW� WKH�XVH� WKDW� JLYHV� ULVH� WR� SULRULW\� ZDV� LQ� VRPH� ZD\� XQODZIXO�� EHFDXVH�DFFRUGLQJ� WR� WKH�PRGHUQ� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�� XQODZIXO� XVH� FDQQRW�JLYH�ULVH�WR�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV���

�� 7KH�5ROH�RI�86372��77$%

%HFDXVH�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�ZDV�RULJLQDOO\�D�FUHDWXUH�RI�WKH�86372� DQG� WKH� 7UDGHPDUN� 7ULDO� DQG�$SSHDO� %RDUG� �³77$%´��� DQG�EHFDXVH� VR�PDQ\�RI� WKH� GHFLVLRQV� WKDW� DUH� LQIOXHQWLDO� LQ� WKLV� DUHD� DUH�77$%�GHFLVLRQV��LW�LV�LPSRUWDQW�WR�EULHIO\�UHYLHZ�KRZ�WKH�77$%��DQG�E\�H[WHQVLRQ��WKH�86372��ILWV�LQWR�WKH�RYHUDOO�IUDPHZRUN�RI�WUDGHPDUN�ODZ�LQ�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV���

7KH� 86372� LV� D� IHGHUDO� DJHQF\� WKDW� IDOOV� XQGHU� WKH� H[HFXWLYH�EUDQFK�RI� JRYHUQPHQW��� :KHQ� D� EXVLQHVV� RZQHU� GHFLGHV� WR� DGRSW� D�SDUWLFXODU�PDUN�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�KHU�JRRGV��VKH�FDQ�DSSO\�WR�UHJLVWHU�KHU� WUDGHPDUN� ZLWK� WKH� 86372��� ,I� WKH� PDUN� LV� DOUHDG\� LQ� XVH� LQ�FRPPHUFH��WKH�DSSOLFDQW�PXVW�DWWDFK�HYLGHQFH��FDOOHG�D�³VSHFLPHQ´� WR�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�VKRZLQJ�KRZ�WKH�PDUN�LV�XVHG�LQ�FRPPHUFH��� ,I�VKH�KDV� QRW� EHJXQ� XVLQJ� WKH� PDUN�� VKH� FDQ� ILOH� DQ� LQWHQW�WR�XVH�DSSOLFDWLRQ��� $Q�LQWHQW�WR�XVH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�EDVLFDOO\�UHVHUYHV�WKH�PDUN��VR�WKDW�LI�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�GRHV�SURFHHG�WR�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��WKH�SULRULW\�GDWH��WKH� GDWH� IURP�ZKLFK� WKH� UHJLVWUDQW� KDV� H[FOXVLYH� QDWLRQZLGH� ULJKWV��

�� &RPPRQ�ODZ�ULJKWV�DUH�OLPLWHG�WR�WKH�JHRJUDSKLF�DUHD�RI�XVH���$�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�ZLOO�RSHUDWH�WR�SUHYHQW�XVH�E\�RWKHUV�DFURVV�WKH�QDWLRQ��,G�

�� 0DUJUHWK�%DUUHWW� $UWLFOH��(VVD\��)LQGLQJ�7UDGHPDUN�8VH��7KH�+LVWRULFDO�)RXQGDWLRQ�)RU�/LPLWLQJ�,QIULQJHPHQW�/LDELOLW\�7R�8VHV�³,Q�7KH�0DQQHU�2I�$�0DUN´�����:$.(�)25(67�/� 5(9� ����������������

�� 6HH LQIUD 6HFWLRQ�,,,��� 6HH�JHQHUDOO\ 3URWHFWLQJ�<RXU�7UDGHPDUN��VXSUD QRWH ���� ,G��DW��±���� ,G��DW���±����� ,G�

Page 9: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘşŚ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

ZLOO�EH�WKH�GDWH�RI�ILOLQJ�RI�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ���

$IWHU� VKH� ILOHV� KHU� DSSOLFDWLRQ�� DQ� H[DPLQLQJ� DWWRUQH\� UHYLHZV� LW�DQG� DOHUWV� KHU� WR� DQ\� SUREOHPV��� ,I� WKHUH� DUH� QR� SUREOHPV�ZLWK� WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ� �RU� LI� DOO� SUREOHPV� DUH� UHVROYHG� LQ� WKH� FRXUVH� RI� WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�SURFHVV���WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�LV�SXEOLVKHG�IRU�RSSRVLWLRQ�LQ�WKH�2IILFLDO�*D]HWWH�RI�WKH�86372��GXULQJ�WKLV�WKLUW\�GD\�ZLQGRZ��DQ\RQH�ZKR�EHOLHYHV� WKDW�KH�RU�VKH�ZRXOG�EH�GDPDJHG�E\� WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI�WKH�PDUN�FDQ�ILOH�DQ�RSSRVLWLRQ��GLVFXVVHG�LQIUD���� ,I�QR�RQH�RSSRVHV��WKH� DSSOLFDWLRQ� SURFHHGV� WR� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� �� 7KH� QH[W� VWHS� LQ� WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ� SURFHVV� GLIIHUV� VOLJKWO\� GHSHQGLQJ� RQ� ZKHWKHU� WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�LV�DQ�LQWHQW�WR�XVH�RU�XVH�EDVHG�DSSOLFDWLRQ�

7KH� 77$%� LV� DQ� DGPLQLVWUDWLYH� WULEXQDO� RI� WKH� 86372� WKDW� LV�HPSRZHUHG� WR� GHWHUPLQH� WKH� ULJKW� WR� UHJLVWHU� D� PDUN��� ,W� FDQ� EH�WKRXJKW�RI�DV�WKH�MXGLFLDO�EUDQFK�RI�WKH�86372��DOWKRXJK�LW�LV�QRW�DQ�$UWLFOH� ,,,�FRXUW�� DQG� LVVXHV�ZULWWHQ�RUGHUV�PXFK� OLNH�D� IHGHUDO�FRXUW�ZRXOG��� )RU�WKH�SXUSRVHV�RI�WKLV�SDSHU��WKH�77$%�HQWHUV�WKH�SURFHVV�LQ�VHYHUDO�GLIIHUHQW�ZD\V�����

)LUVW�� WKH� 77$%� VRPHWLPHV� DFWV� DV� DQ� DSSHOODWH� FRXUW��� ,W� KDV�MXULVGLFWLRQ� RYHU� H[� SDUWH� DSSHDOV�� L�H��� DSSHDOV� IURP� WKH� H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\¶V� UHIXVDO� WR� UHJLVWHU� WKH� PDUN� �� $V� QRWHG� DERYH�� DV� WKH�WUDGHPDUN� DSSOLFDWLRQ� SURFHHGV� WKURXJK� WKH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� SURFHVV�� LW� LV�UHYLHZHG�E\�WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\��� ,I�WKHUH�DUH�SUREOHPV�ZLWK�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ��WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\�PD\�LVVXH�DQ�RIILFH�DFWLRQ�GHQ\LQJ�UHJLVWUDWLRQ� �� 6RPH� RI� WKHVH� RIILFH� DFWLRQV� DUH� HDVLO\� IL[HG�� IRU�H[DPSOH�� WKH� GHVFULSWLRQ� RI� WKH� JRRGV� DQG� VHUYLFHV� PD\� QHHG� WR� EH�DPHQGHG���6RPH��KRZHYHU��DUH�PRUH�FRPSOH[��WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\�

�� ,G��DW������ ,G� DW������ ���8�6�&���������D����������8�6� '(37�2)�&200(5&(� 3$7� 75$'(0$5.�

2))�� 75$'(0$5.�75,$/�$1'�$33($/�%2$5'�0$18$/�2)�352&('85(��� ������������� �������KWWSV���PSHS�XVSWR�JRY�5'06�7%03�FXUUHQW��FXUUHQW�WEPSG�H���KWPO >KHUHLQDIWHU�7%03@�

�� 7UDGHPDUN�3URFHVV��8�6� 3$7� 75$'(0$5.�2))��KWWSV���ZZZ�XVSWR�JRY�WUDGHPDUNV�JHWWLQJ�VWDUWHG�WUDGHPDUN�SURFHVV��ODVW�YLVLWHG�)HE�����������

�� 7%03��VXSUD�QRWH���� � ��������� +RSH�+DPLOWRQ��3DUVLQJ�WKH�6WDQGDUG�RI�5HYLHZ�3X]]OH��+RZ�0XFK�

'HIHUHQFH�6KRXOG�)HGHUDO�'LVWULFW�&RXUWV�$IIRUG�7UDGHPDUN�7ULDO�DQG�$SSHDO�%RDUG�'HFLVLRQV"�����)('� &,5� %� -� ����������������

�� (�J���� -� 7+20$6�0&&$57+<� 0&&$57+<�21�75$'(0$5.6�$1'�81)$,5�

&203(7,7,21 ���������WK HG���������� ,G��� 7UDGHPDUN�3URFHVV��VXSUD�QRWH������ ,G�

Page 10: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

Řşś

PLJKW�ILQG�WKDW�WKH�PDUN�LV�OLNHO\�WR�UHVXOW�LQ�FRQVXPHU�FRQIXVLRQ�ZLWK�DQRWKHU� UHJLVWHUHG� PDUN��� $OWKRXJK� WKH� DSSOLFDQW� KDV� WKH� ULJKW� WR�UHVSRQG�WR�WKH�RIILFH�DFWLRQ��LI�WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\�GRHV�QRW�FKDQJH�KHU� PLQG� EDVHG� RQ� WKH� DSSOLFDQW¶V� DUJXPHQWV� LQ� UHVSRQVH�� WKH�H[DPLQLQJ� DWWRUQH\� ZLOO� LVVXH� D� ILQDO� RIILFH� DFWLRQ� GHQ\LQJ�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��� $W�WKDW�SRLQW��WKH�DSSOLFDQW�PD\�ILOH�DQ�H[�SDUWH�DSSHDO�WR� WKH�77$%��� ,Q� WKLV� FLUFXPVWDQFH�� WKH�77$%�DFWV� DV� DQ� DSSHOODWH�FRXUW��WKH�DSSOLFDQW�LV�WKH�DSSHOODQW��DQG�WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\�DFWV�DV�WKH� DSSHOOHH� �� 1R� QHZ� HYLGHQFH� LV� VXEPLWWHG�� WKH� 77$%� VLPSO\�FRQGXFWV�DQ�DSSHOODWH�UHYLHZ�RI�WKH�H[DPLQHU¶V�GHFLVLRQ���

6HFRQG�� WKH� 77$%� VRPHWLPHV� DFWV� DV� D� WULDO� FRXUW�� � ,W� KDV�MXULVGLFWLRQ�RYHU�RSSRVLWLRQ�SURFHHGLQJV� �ZKHUH�RQH�SDUW\� FKDOOHQJHV�DQRWKHU� SDUW\¶V� DSSOLFDWLRQ� WR� UHJLVWHU� D� PDUN�� DQG� FDQFHOODWLRQ�SURFHHGLQJV� �ZKHUH� RQH� SDUW\� FKDOOHQJHV� DQRWKHU� SDUW\¶V� ULJKW� WR�PDLQWDLQ� LWV� WUDGHPDUN� DIWHU� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� �� 7KHVH� SURFHHGLQJV� DUH�VLPLODU� LQ� IHHO� WR� D� FLYLO� DFWLRQ� LQ� FRXUW�� WKH� RSSRVLQJ� SDUW\� ILOHV� D�FRPSODLQW�� WKH� DSSOLFDQW� ILOHV� DQ� DQVZHU�� DQG� WKH�PDWWHU� SURFHHGV� WR�GLVFRYHU\� �� 7KH� 77$%� WDNHV� HYLGHQFH�� LQFOXGLQJ� WUDQVFULEHG�WHVWLPRQ\��DQG�WKH�SDUWLHV�FDQ�UHTXHVW�RUDO�DUJXPHQW���

)LQDOO\�� DQG� OHVV� FRPPRQO\�� WKH� 77$%� KDV� MXULVGLFWLRQ� RYHU�FRQFXUUHQW� XVH� SURFHHGLQJV� �� ,Q� D� FRQFXUUHQW� XVH� SURFHHGLQJ�� DQ�DSSOLFDQW��ZKR�NQRZV�RI�RWKHUV�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN��ILOHV�DQ�DSSOLFDWLRQ�IRU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ� WKDW�SURYLGHV� LQIRUPDWLRQ�UHJDUGLQJ�RWKHUV�ZKR�DUH�XVLQJ�WKH�VDPH�RU�VLPLODU�PDUN��� $VVXPLQJ�WKDW�WKHUH�DUH�QR�RWKHU�SUREOHPV�ZLWK�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ��SURFHHGLQJV�EHIRUH�WKH�77$%�ZLOO�FRPPHQFH�WR�GHWHUPLQH�ZKHWKHU�WKH�FRQFXUUHQW�XVH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�ZLOO�EH�JUDQWHG��IRU�

�� 3RVVLEOH�*URXQGV�IRU�5HIXVDO�RI�D�0DUN��8�6� 3$7� 75$'(0$5.�2))���KWWSV���ZZZ�XVSWR�JRY�WUDGHPDUN�DGGLWLRQDO�JXLGDQFH�DQG�UHVRXUFHV�SRVVLEOH�JURXQGV�UHIXVDO�PDUN���ODVW�YLVLWHG�)HE�����������

�� 7%03��VXSUD QRWH������������� ���8�6�&�����������������³$Q�DSSHDO�PD\�EH�WDNHQ�WR�WKH�7UDGHPDUN�7ULDO�

DQG�$SSHDO�%RDUG�IURP�DQ\�ILQDO�GHFLVLRQ�RI�WKH�H[DPLQHU�LQ�FKDUJH�RI�WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI�PDUNV�XSRQ�WKH�SD\PHQW�RI�WKH�SUHVFULEHG�IHH�´���7%03��VXSUD QRWH���������������³7KH�%RDUG�DOVR�KDV�MXULVGLFWLRQ�RYHU�H[�SDUWH�DSSHDOV��WKDW�LV��DSSHDOV�IURP�DQ�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\¶V�ILQDO�UHIXVDO�WR�UHJLVWHU�D�PDUN�LQ�DQ�DSSOLFDWLRQ�´��

�� 6HH�7%03��VXSUD QRWH�������������� 6HH�0&&$57+<� VXSUD QRWH���� � ������� ���8�6�&�����������������7%03��VXSUD QRWH������������������������� 7%03��VXSUD QRWH���������������� %��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF��Y��+DUJLV�,QGXV���,QF�������6��&W���������������������� 7KH�77$%�DOVR�KDV�MXULVGLFWLRQ�RYHU�LQWHUIHUHQFH�SURFHHGLQJV��6HH 7%03��

VXSUD QRWH���������������+RZHYHU��VLQFH�WKHVH�SURFHHGLQJV�DUH�QRW�UHOHYDQW�WR�WKLV�SDSHU��WKH\�DUH�QRW�GLVFXVVHG�KHUH���

�� ,G������������

Page 11: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘşŜ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

H[DPSOH��YLD�HYLGHQFH�RI�SULRU�XVH�LQ�D�OLPLWHG�JHRJUDSKLF�DUHD����

�� 7KH�5ROH�RI�WKH�)HGHUDO�&RXUWV��

7KH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�FRPH�LQWR�SOD\�LQ�WZR�ZD\V��DV�FRXUWV�RI�DSSHDO�IURP�WKH�77$%�DQG�DV�FRXUWV�RI�ILUVW�LQVWDQFH���%RWK�DUH�UHOHYDQW�KHUH���

D� 7KH�)HGHUDO�&RXUWV�DV�&RXUWV�RI�$SSHDO�IURP�WKH�77$%

7KH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�VRPHWLPHV�DFW�DV�FRXUWV�RI�DSSHDO�DIWHU�D�77$%�SURFHHGLQJ�� �$� SDUW\� WKDW� LV� GLVVDWLVILHG�ZLWK� D� 77$%� GHFLVLRQ�PD\�DSSHDO� WR�HLWKHU�D�8�6��'LVWULFW�&RXUW�RU� WKH�)HGHUDO�&LUFXLW�&RXUW�RI�$SSHDOV��� ,Q� WKH� )HGHUDO� &LUFXLW�� WKH� UHYLHZ� LV� RQ� D� FORVHG� UHFRUG��PHDQLQJ� QR� DGGLWLRQDO� HYLGHQFH� LV� SUHVHQWHG��� 7KH� UHYLHZ� RI� OHJDO�GHWHUPLQDWLRQV�LV�GH�QRYR��DQG�WKH�UHYLHZ�RI�IDFWXDO�GHWHUPLQDWLRQV�LV�FRQGXFWHG�SXUVXDQW�WR�WKH�$GPLQLVWUDWLYH�3URFHGXUH�$FW���

,Q� WKH� GLVWULFW� FRXUW�� WKHUH� LV� DQ� RSSRUWXQLW\� WR� SUHVHQW� DGGLWLRQDO�HYLGHQFH� DQG� UDLVH� DGGLWLRQDO� FODLPV� �� ³7KH� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� KDV�DXWKRULW\�LQGHSHQGHQW�RI� WKH�372�WR�JUDQW�RU�FDQFHO�UHJLVWUDWLRQV�DQG�WR� GHFLGH� DQ\� UHODWHG� PDWWHUV� VXFK� DV� LQIULQJHPHQW� DQG� XQIDLU�FRPSHWLWLRQ�FODLPV�´�� :KHUH�QHZ�HYLGHQFH�LV�VXEPLWWHG�� WKH�GLVWULFW�FRXUW�UHYLHZV�WKH�HQWLUH�UHFRUG�GH�QRYR���

E� 7KH� )HGHUDO� &RXUWV� DV� &RXUWV� RI� )LUVW� ,QVWDQFH�&RQFXUUHQW�:LWK�RU�6HSDUDWH�)URP�WKH�86372

7KH� RWKHU� ZD\� LQ� ZKLFK� WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� FDQ� EH� LQYROYHG� LV�WKURXJK� ODZVXLWV� UHJDUGLQJ� LQIULQJHPHQW� WKDW� DULVH� LUUHVSHFWLYH� RI� �RU�FRQFXUUHQWO\� ZLWK�� SURFHHGLQJV� EHIRUH� WKH� 86372� RU� 77$%�� � )RU�H[DPSOH��D�FRPSHWLQJ�EXVLQHVV�PD\�EHJLQ�XVLQJ�D�PDUN�WKDW�LQIULQJHV�XSRQ�D�UHJLVWHUHG�PDUN��FDXVLQJ�WKH�UHJLVWHUHG�PDUN�RZQHU�WR�VXH�IRU�

�� 70(3��VXSUD QRWH���������������H���� ,W�LV�ZRUWK�QRWLQJ�WKDW�VWDWH�FRXUWV�FDQ�DOVR�KHDU�WUDGHPDUN�GLVSXWHV�LQYROYLQJ�

IHGHUDOO\�UHJLVWHUHG�PDUNV���+RZHYHU��DV�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�DUH�WKH�IRFXV�RI�WKLV�DUWLFOH��,�OLPLW�WKLV�GLVFXVVLRQ�WR�WKH�UROH�RI�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV���

�� ���8�6�&������������������ 9RVN�,QW¶O�&R��Y��=DR�*UXSSD�3UHGSUL\DWLM�2VW��1R��&��±����56/�������:/�

���������DW� ���:�'��:DVK���������� ��8�6�&��������������� 0&&$57+<� VXSUD QRWH���� ������������� 9RVN�������:/����������DW� ������ 6ZDWFK�$*�Y��%HHKLYH�:KROHVDOH��//&������)��G������������WK�&LU���������� ,G� DW������FLWLQJ�.DSSRV�Y��+\DWW������6��&W�����������������������7KLV LV�D�

UHODWLYHO\�QHZ�UXOH��SULRU�WR�WKH�.DSSRV FDVH�LQ�������FRXUWV�DFWHG�DV�DSSHOODWH�UHYLHZHUV�RI�WKH�IDFWV�IRXQG�E\�WKH�77$%�DQG�IDFW�ILQGHUV�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�QHZ�HYLGHQFH�VXEPLWWHG���6HH 0&&$57+<��VXSUD QRWH ��� ��������

Page 12: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

Řşŝ

WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�XQGHU�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�ZLWKRXW�HYHU�LQYROYLQJ�WKH�86372�LQ�WKH�VXEVWDQFH�RI�WKH�FDVH���2U��D�SDUW\�FDQ�VXH�DQRWKHU�SDUW\� IRU� WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW� LQ� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� ZKLOH� 86372�SURFHHGLQJV�DUH�RQJRLQJ���

7KHUH�DUH�PDQ\�UHDVRQV�ZK\�D�OLWLJDQW�ZRXOG�FKRRVH�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�RYHU�PHUHO\� SURFHHGLQJ� EHIRUH� WKH�86372� �� RQH� NH\� IDFWRU� �WKDW� LV�SDUWLFXODUO\� UHOHYDQW� KHUH�� LV� WKDW� WKH� 86372� RQO\� FRQWUROV�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��� $IWHU� D� 77$%� DFWLRQ�� WKH� UHVXOW� LV� WKDW� D� SUHYDLOLQJ�WUDGHPDUN�RZQHU�KDV�HLWKHU�VXFFHVVIXOO\�NHSW�D�PDUN�IURP�UHJLVWHULQJ�RU� KDV� VXFFHHGHG� LQ� UHPRYLQJ� WKH�PDUN� IURP� WKH� UHJLVWHU�� KRZHYHU��GDPDJHV� DQG� LQMXQFWLYH� UHOLHI� DUH� QRW� DYDLODEOH� IURP� WKH�77$%�� DQG�EHFDXVH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� LV� VHSDUDWH� IURP� XVH�� WKH� 86372� FDQQRW� VWRS�DQ\RQH�IURP�XVLQJ�D�SDUWLFXODU�PDUN��� %\�WKH�VDPH�WRNHQ� FDXVHV�RI�DFWLRQ�RYHU�ZKLFK�WKH�86372�ZRXOG�KDYH�QR�DXWKRULW\��VXFK�DV�FODLPV�IRU� XQIDLU� FRPSHWLWLRQ�� ULJKW� RI� SXEOLFLW\�� RU� VWDWH� ODZ� WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�FDQ�EH�EURXJKW�LQ�IHGHUDO�FRXUW��� 6SHHG�LV�DOVR�D�IDFWRU��IRU� VRPHRQH� ZKR� QHHGV� DQ� LQIULQJLQJ� XVH� WR� VWRS� QRZ�� D� WHPSRUDU\�UHVWUDLQLQJ�RUGHU�DQG�SUHOLPLQDU\�LQMXQFWLRQ�FDQ�LVVXH�TXLFNO\��� 7KHUH�LV� QR� DQDORJXH� DW� WKH� 86372�� � ,W� LV� ZRUWK� QRWLQJ�� KRZHYHU�� WKDW�DOWKRXJK� WKH� 86372� FDQQRW� GR� ZKDW� WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� FDQ� GR�� WKH�IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� FDQ� LQ� VRPH�ZD\V� GR�ZKDW� WKH�86372�GRHV�� QDPHO\��FDQFHO�UHJLVWUDWLRQV�GXULQJ�WKH�FRXUVH�RI�LQIULQJHPHQW�OLWLJDWLRQ���

�� 6HH��H�J���%��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF��Y��+DUJLV�,QGXV���,QF�������6��&W��������������������

�� 6HH��H�J���(OL]DEHWK�&��%XFNLQJKDP��77$%�RU�)HGHUDO�&RXUW��:KHUH�WR�/LWLJDWH�D�8�6��7UDGHPDUN�'LVSXWH"��3DUW�7ZR��&LYLO�/DZVXLWV�LQ�)HGHUDO�&RXUW��,17$ %8//(7,1 �)HEUXDU\������������KWWS���ZZZ�LQWD�RUJ�,17$%XOOHWLQ�3DJHV�77$%RU)HGHUDO&RXUW:KHUHWR/LWLJDWHD867UDGHPDUN'LVSXWH3DUW7ZR)HGHUDO&RXUW�DVS[�

�� ,G��� ,G���VHH�DOVR $ERXW�WKH�7UDGHPDUN�7ULDO�DQG�$SSHDO�%RDUG��8�6� 3$7�

75$'(0$5.�2))�� KWWS���ZZZ�XVSWR�JRY�WUDGHPDUN�ODZV�UHJXODWLRQV�WUDGHPDUN�WULDO�DQG�DSSHDO�ERDUG��ODVW�YLVLWHG�)HE����������� �³7KH�%RDUG�LV�QRW�DXWKRUL]HG�WR�GHWHUPLQH�ZKHWKHU�\RX�KDYH�WKH�ULJKW�WR�XVH�D�WUDGHPDUN��MXVW�ZKHWKHU�\RX�KDYH�WKH�ULJKW�WR�UHJLVWHU�LW��$GGLWLRQDOO\��WKH�%RDUG�LV�QRW�DXWKRUL]HG�WR�GHWHUPLQH�TXHVWLRQV�RI�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�RU�XQIDLU�FRPSHWLWLRQ�RU�WR�DZDUG�PRQH\�GDPDJHV�RU�DWWRUQH\V�IHHV��)RU�DQ\WKLQJ�RWKHU�WKDQ�GHWHUPLQLQJ�WKH�ULJKW�RI�IHGHUDO�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��\RX�PXVW�ILOH�D�FDVH�LQ�IHGHUDO�RU�VWDWH�FRXUW�´��

�� ,G����� %XFNLQJKDP��VXSUD QRWH������ 6HH��H�J������8�6�&�����������������³,Q�DQ\�DFWLRQ�LQYROYLQJ�D�UHJLVWHUHG�PDUN�

WKH�FRXUW�PD\�GHWHUPLQH�WKH�ULJKW�WR�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��RUGHU�WKH�FDQFHODWLRQ�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQV��LQ�ZKROH�RU�LQ�SDUW��UHVWRUH�FDQFHOHG�UHJLVWUDWLRQV��DQG�RWKHUZLVH�UHFWLI\�WKH�UHJLVWHU�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQV�RI�DQ\�SDUW\�WR�WKH�DFWLRQ�´���%��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF��Y��+DUJLV�,QGXV���,QF�������6��&W���������������������)RU�DQ�H[SODQDWLRQ�RI�ZK\�RQH�PLJKW�FKRRVH�WKH�77$%�RYHU�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�SURFHHGLQJV��VHH

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 13: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘşŞ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

)HGHUDO� FRXUW� LQIULQJHPHQW� FDVHV� SURFHHG� OLNH� DQ\� RWKHU� IHGHUDO�FRXUW� FDVH� DQG� DUH� VXEMHFW� WR� DSSHDOV� LQ� WKH� VDPH�ZD\� DV� DQ\� RWKHU�FDVH�� � )RU� WKH� PRVW SDUW�� WKH� WZR� SURFHHGLQJV²86372� DQG� IHGHUDO�FRXUW²DUH� VHSDUDWH� IURP� RQH� DQRWKHU� �� /LNHZLVH�� DOWKRXJK� WKH�H[DPLQHU� LV� DVNLQJ� D� VLPLODU� TXHVWLRQ� ZKHQ� VKH� H[DPLQHV� WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ²LV� WKHUH� D� OLNHOLKRRG� RI� FRQVXPHU� FRQIXVLRQ"²WKH�LQTXLULHV� DUH� FRQGXFWHG� XVLQJ� VOLJKWO\� GLIIHUHQW� IDFWRUV� �� DQG� WKH�86372�ORRNV�DW�WKH�PDUNV�LQ�LVRODWLRQ��QRW�EDVHG�RQ�DFWXDO�XVH�LQ�WKH�PDUNHWSODFH���

,Q�UDUH�FDVHV��77$%�GHFLVLRQV�FDQ�EH�ELQGLQJ�LQ�IHGHUDO�FRXUW��EXW�RQO\� LI� WKH� IDFWRUV� VXSSRUWLQJ� LVVXH� SUHFOXVLRQ� DUH� SUHVHQW� �� ,Q D�UHFHQW� 6XSUHPH� &RXUW� FDVH�� WKH� &RXUW� KHOG� WKDW� D� GHFLVLRQ� DV� WR�OLNHOLKRRG�RI�FRQIXVLRQ�E\�WKH�77$%�ZDV�ELQGLQJ�RQ�WKH�GLVWULFW�FRXUW�LQ�D�FRQFXUUHQW�LQIULQJHPHQW�SURFHHGLQJ���

%� 7KH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�

7KH�PRGHUQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH��DV�DGRSWHG�E\�WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�LQ� ������ KDV� LWV� RULJLQV� LQ� WKH� 86372�� � 7KLV� VHFWLRQ� GLVFXVVHV� WKH�GHYHORSPHQW��DQG�VXEVHTXHQW�OLPLWDWLRQ��RI�WKH�86372¶V�GRFWULQH�DQG�WKHQ� FRQVLGHUV� WKH� PRGHUQ� DSSOLFDWLRQ� RI� WKH� GRFWULQH� LQ� WKH� 1LQWK�&LUFXLW�DQG�HOVHZKHUH���

�� 7KH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�DW�WKH�86372

7KH� FXUUHQW� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� LV� FRGLILHG� LQ� WKH� 86372¶V�UHJXODWLRQV��� +RZHYHU�� WZR� FDVHV� WKDW� SUHFHGHG� WKH� DGRSWLRQ� RI� WKH�UHJXODWLRQ�IRUPHG�WKH�IRXQGDWLRQ�RI�WKH�PRGHUQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�

%XFNLQJKDP��VXSUD�QRWH������ +RZHYHU��LW�LV�FRPPRQ�IRU�WKH�77$%�WR�JUDQW�D�UHTXHVW�WR�VXVSHQG�

SURFHHGLQJV�SHQGLQJ�WKH�RXWFRPH�RI�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�SURFHHGLQJV���6HH 7%03��VXSUDQRWH��������������D����)HGHUDO�FRXUWV�FDQ�DOVR�VXVSHQG�WKHLU�RZQ�SURFHHGLQJV�WR�DZDLW�77$%�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ���6HH�LG���

�� 7KH�77$%�HYDOXDWHV�WKH�WKLUWHHQ�'X3RQW IDFWRUV�ODLG�RXW�LQ�,Q�UH�(�,��'X3RQW�'H1HPRXUV��&R�������)��G�������������&�&�3�$���������6HH %��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF�������6��&W��DW��������7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW��IRU�H[DPSOH��XVHV�WKH�HLJKW�IDFWRU�WHVW�IURP�$0)�,QF��Y��6OHHNFUDIW�%RDWV������)��G���������±�����WK�&LU��������

�� 6HH %��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF�������6��&W��DW�����±����� ,G��DW�����±����� ,G��DW�������� 7KHUH�PD\�EH�YDOLG�DUJXPHQWV�WKDW�WKH�86372�VKRXOG�QRW�KDYH�DQ�XQODZIXO�

XVH�GRFWULQH�DW�DOO��DIWHU�DOO��WKHUH LV�QR�H[SUHVV�FRUROODU\�LQ�SDWHQW�RU�FRS\ULJKW�ODZ���1HYHUWKHOHVV��WKLV�SDSHU�WDNHV�DV�D�JLYHQ�WKH�H[LVWHQFH�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�LQ�WKH�86372�VHWWLQJ���

�� �� &�)�5� ������

Page 14: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

Řşş

D� (DUO\�0DQLIHVWDWLRQV�RI�WKH�'RFWULQH

7KH�ILUVW�FDVH�WR�DGGUHVV�WKH�LVVXH�DV�VXFK�ZDV�&RDKRPD�&KHPLFDO�&R���,QF��Y��+RZHUWRQ�*RZHQ�&R���,QF���GHFLGHG�LQ�������� 7KHUH��WZR�UHJLVWUDWLRQV� IRU� %/$&.�3$17+(5� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK� LQVHFWLFLGHV�ZHUH�FDQFHOOHG�XQGHU�ZKDW�ZRXOG�EHFRPH�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH���

7KH� $VVLVWDQW� &RPPLVVLRQHU� QRWHG� WKDW� WKH� LVVXH� ZDV� ³RQH� RI� ILUVW�LPSUHVVLRQ�� QDPHO\�� GRHV� WKH� XVHU� RI� D� WUDGHPDUN� RQ� JRRGV� ZKLFK�FRXOG� QRW� EH� ODZIXOO\� VKLSSHG� LQ� LQWHUVWDWH� FRPPHUFH� DFTXLUH�UHJLVWUDEOH� ULJKWV� VXSHULRU� WR� WKRVH� RI� D� ODWHU XVHU�ZKRVH� JRRGV�ZHUH�ODZIXOO\� VKLSSHG� LQ� LQWHUVWDWH� FRPPHUFH"´ �� 7KH� $VVLVWDQW�&RPPLVVLRQHU� H[DPLQHG� ZKHWKHU� WKH� SDUW\� XVLQJ� WKH� %/$&.�3$17+(5�PDUN�KDG�DFTXLUHG�ULJKWV�³HLWKHU�DW�FRPPRQ�ODZ�RU�XQGHU�WKH�)HGHUDO�WUDGHPDUN�VWDWXWH��DV�D�UHVXOW�RI�LWV�XQODZIXO�VKLSPHQWV«LQ�YLRODWLRQ�RI�WKH�1RUWK�&DUROLQD�,QVHFWLFLGH�)XQJLFLGH�DQG�5RGHQWLFLGH�$FW� RI� ������� DQG� VKLSPHQWV� LQWHUVWDWH� LQ� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKH� )HGHUDO�(FRQRPLF�3RLVRQV�$FW>�@´�� 2Q�WKH�EDVLV�RI� WKH�FRQFOXVLRQ�WKDW�³XVH�RI� D� PDUN� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� XQODZIXO� VKLSPHQWV� LQ� LQWHUVWDWH�FRPPHUFH�LV�QRW�XVH�RI�D�PDUN�LQ�FRPPHUFH�ZKLFK�WKH�3DWHQW�2IILFH�PD\� UHFRJQL]H�´� WKH� SHWLWLRQHU�ZDV� GHHPHG� WKH� ILUVW� WR� XVH� LWV�PDUN��DQG�WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQV�ZHUH�FDQFHOOHG���

1H[W�� WKH� 77$%� GHFLGHG� ,Q� UH� 7D\ORU LQ� ������ � 7KHUH� WKH�DSSOLFDQW� VRXJKW� WR� UHJLVWHU� &+8&.�$�%85*(5� IRU� YDULRXV�UHVWDXUDQW�DQG�WDNH�RXW�IRRG�LWHPV��� 7KH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�ZDV�UHIXVHG��DQG�WKH� DSSOLFDQW� DSSHDOHG� �� $PRQJ� LWV� UHDVRQV� IRU� DIILUPLQJ� WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\¶V�GHFLVLRQ� WR� UHIXVH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� WKH�77$%�QRWHG�WKDW�WKH�VSHFLPHQV�VXEPLWWHG�ZLWK�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�GLG�QRW�FRPSO\�ZLWK�WKH� )RRG�� 'UXJ�� DQG� &RVPHWLF� $FW¶V� UHTXLUHPHQWV��� $V� VXFK�� WKH�77$%� FRQFOXGHG�� ³WKHLU� XVH� LQ� LQWHUVWDWH� FRPPHUFH� FDQQRW� EH�

�� &RDKRPD�&KHP��&R���,QF��Y��+RZHUWRQ�*RZHQ�&R���,QF�������8�6�3�4�������&RP¶U�3DW���7UDGHPDUNV��������DII¶G�RQ�RWKHU�JURXQGV������)��G������&�&�3�$����������+RZHYHU��WKH�6PLWK�Y��&RDKRPD�&KHP��&R�������)��G������&�&�3�$���������GHFLVLRQ�QRWHV�WKDW�WKHUH�ZHUH�QXPHURXV�RWKHU�FDVHV�WRXFKLQJ�RQ�VLPLODU�LVVXHV�

�� 6HH�&RDKRPD�&KHP��&R���,QF�� ����8�6�3�4��������� ,G� DW������6HH�DOVR�6PLWK������)��G�DW������� &RDKRPD�&KHP��&R���,QF�������8�6�3�4��DW������,QWHUHVWLQJO\��WKH�GHFLVLRQ�

PHQWLRQV�WKLV�YLRODWLRQ�RI�VWDWH�ODZ�DQG�VKLSPHQWV�LQ�LQWUDVWDWH�FRPPHUFH���7KH�86372¶V�GRFWULQH�KDV�XOWLPDWHO\�HYROYHG�WR�HQFRPSDVV�IHGHUDO�ODZ�RQO\���:KHWKHU�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV¶�YHUVLRQ�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH�FDQ�HQFRPSDVV�VWDWH�ODZ�LV�DQ�RSHQ�TXHVWLRQ��GLVFXVVHG�LQIUD���

�� ,G��� ,G��� ,Q�UH 7D\ORU������8�6�3�4�������7�7�$�%���������� ,G��� ,G��DW������

Page 15: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŖŖ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

FRQVWUXHG�WR�EH�D�ODZIXO�XVH���7KHUHIRUH��VXFK�XVH�FDQQRW�DIIRUG�D�EDVLV�IRU�IHGHUDO�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�´��

E� 7KH�86372�)RUPDOO\�$GRSWV�WKH�'RFWULQH

7KH� 86372� ILUVW� DGRSWHG� D� IRUPDO� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� LQ�������� 7KH�UHJXODWLRQ��FRGLILHG�DW����&�)�5��������VWDWHG�WKDW�

:KHQ� WKH� VDOH� RU� WUDQVSRUWDWLRQ� RI� DQ\� SURGXFW� IRU�ZKLFK�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI�D�WUDGHPDUN�LV�VRXJKW�LV�UHJXODWHG�XQGHU� DQ� $FW� RI� &RQJUHVV�� WKH� 2IILFH� PD\�� EHIRUH�DOORZDQFH��PDNH� DSSURSULDWH� LQTXLU\� DV� WR� FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK� VXFK� DFW� IRU� WKH� VROH� SXUSRVH� RI� GHWHUPLQLQJ�ODZIXOQHVV�RI�WKH�FRPPHUFH�UHFLWHG�LQ�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ���

1RW�ORQJ�DIWHU��LQ�������WKH�77$%�KDG�WKH�RFFDVLRQ�WR�FRQVLGHU�WKH�UHODWLYHO\� QHZ� UXOH�� � 7KHUH�� DQ� H[DPLQHU� UHIXVHG� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� RQ� WKH�JURXQGV� WKDW� WKH� SURGXFW�� D�PRXWK� IUHVKHQHU� VSUD\�� IDLOHG� WR� FRPSO\�ZLWK� WKH�)RRG��'UXJ�� DQG�&RVPHWLF�$FW¶V� SURYLVLRQV� RQ� FRVPHWLFV���

7KH�DSSOLFDQW�DSSHDOHG���7KH� 77$%� VXPPDUL]HG� WKH� LVVXH� DV� ZKHWKHU� WKH� IDFW� WKDW� WKH�

DSSOLFDQW� KDG� QRW� LQFOXGHG� D� TXDQWLW\� WHUP� RQ� WKH� ODEHOV� WKDW� ZHUH�VXEPLWWHG� DV� VSHFLPHQV� WR� WKH� 86372� UHQGHUHG� WKH� VKLSPHQWV�XQODZIXO�VKLSPHQWV�IURP�ZKLFK�QR�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV�FDQ�EH�GHULYHG�

>7@KH� IDLOXUH� RI� DSSOLFDQW� WR� VHW� IRUWK� DQ� LQGLFDWLRQ� RI�WKH�TXDQWLW\�RI�FRQWHQWV�RQ�WKH�ODEHOV�VXEPLWWHG�ZLWK�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�UHQGHU�WKH�VKLSPHQWV�RI�JRRGV�EHDULQJ�WKHVH�ODEHOV� ³XQODZIXO� VKLSPHQWV´� LQ� LQWHUVWDWH� FRPPHUFH�IURP�ZKLFK�QR�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV�FDQ�EH�GHULYHG�DQG�� LI�VR�� LV� DSSOLFDQW� EDUUHG� IURP� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� RQ� WKH� LQVWDQW�DSSOLFDWLRQ�IRU�WKLV�UHDVRQ"��

�� ,G��� &RPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�2WKHU�/DZV�����)HG��5HJ����������������2FW�������������� ,G���7KH�FXUUHQW�UHJXODWLRQ�LV�VXEVWDQWLDOO\�VLPLODU��

:KHQ� WKH� VDOH� RU� WUDQVSRUWDWLRQ� RI� DQ\� SURGXFW� IRU� ZKLFK�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI�D� WUDGHPDUN� LV� VRXJKW� LV� UHJXODWHG�XQGHU�DQ�$FW�RI�&RQJUHVV��WKH�3DWHQW�DQG�7UDGHPDUN�2IILFH�PD\�PDNH�DSSURSULDWH�LQTXLU\� DV� WR� FRPSOLDQFH� ZLWK� VXFK� $FW� IRU� WKH� VROH� SXUSRVH� RI�GHWHUPLQLQJ�ODZIXOQHVV�RI�WKH�FRPPHUFH�UHFLWHG�LQ�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ��

�� &�)�5� �������� ,Q�UH 6WHOODU�,QW¶O��,QF�������8�6�3�4������7�7�$�%���������� ,G��DW������

Page 16: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŖŗ

$OWKRXJK�WKH�DSSOLFDQW�DUJXHG�WKDW������ZDV�QRW�PHDQW�WR�RSHUDWH�VXFK� WKDW� D� YLRODWLRQ� RI� RWKHU� ODZV� ZRXOG� SUHFOXGH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� WKH�77$%�UHMHFWHG� WKLV�SRVLWLRQ��H[SODLQLQJ� WKDW� LI� WKH�86372�FRXOG�QRW�UHIXVH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� ³XQWLO� DQG�ZKHQ� FRPSOLDQFH� LV� HIIHFWHG�´� WKH� UXOH�³ZRXOG� EH� LQHIIHFWLYH� DQG� DQ� LQTXLU\� WKHUHXQGHU� ZRXOG� EH� QRWKLQJ�PRUH�WKDQ�D�ZDVWH�RI�WLPH�DQG�HIIRUW�´��

+RZHYHU�� WKH� 77$%� OLPLWHG� LWV� RZQ� DJHQF\¶V� DXWKRULW\� E\� WKHQ�VWDWLQJ� WKDW� WKH� DXWKRULW\� VKRXOG�EH� ³H[HUFLVHG� VSDULQJO\�´� H[SODLQLQJ�WKDW�

7KLV� GRHV� QRW� PHDQ� WKDW� WKH� 3DWHQW� 2IILFH� VKRXOG�XQGHUWDNH� WR�SROLFH�DOO� WKH�GLIIHUHQW� UHJXODWRU\�VWDWXWHV�WR� HQVXUH� FRPSOLDQFH� WKHUHZLWK� IRU� WKDW� LV� PDQLIHVWO\�QRW� LWV� IXQFWLRQ� QRU� LV� LW� SURSHUO\� HTXLSSHG� WR� GR� VR���+RZHYHU�� LI� VSHFLPHQ� ODEHOV� VXEPLWWHG� ZLWK� DQ�DSSOLFDWLRQ�VKRZ�RQ�WKHLU�IDFH�WKDW�WKH�DSSOLFDQW�KDV�QRW�FRPSOLHG� ZLWK� WKH� ODEHOLQJ� SURYLVLRQV� RI� D� UHJXODWRU\�VWDWXWH� JRYHUQLQJ� WKH� VKLSPHQW� LQ� FRPPHUFH� RI� JRRGV�EHDULQJ� VXFK� ODEHOV�� D� TXHVWLRQ� PD\� EH� UDLVHG� XQGHU�5XOH������WR�DVFHUWDLQ�ZKHWKHU�RU�QRW�WKH�DSSOLFDQW�KDG�FRPSOLHG� ZLWK� WKH� DSSOLFDEOH� VWDWXWH� ZKHQ� WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�ZDV�ILOHG�DQG�WKDW�WKHUHIRUH�WKH�VKLSPHQW�RI�JRRGV� EHDULQJ� WKH� PDUN� ZDV� ODZIXOO\� PDGH� LQ�DFFRUGDQFH�ZLWK�WKH�VWDWXWH�FRQWUROOLQJ�WKH�VKLSPHQW�RI�VXFK�JRRGV�LQ�FRPPHUFH���

)URP�D�SROLF\�SHUVSHFWLYH��WKH�77$%�QRWHG�WKDW�WR�DJUHH�ZLWK�WKH�DSSOLFDQW�WKDW�XQODZIXO�XVH VKRXOG�QRW�EDU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�³ZRXOG�WR�EH�WR�SODFH� WKH� 3DWHQW� 2IILFH� LQ� WKH� DQRPDORXV� SRVLWLRQ� RI� DFFHSWLQJ� DV� D�EDVLV�IRU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�D�VKLSPHQW�LQ�FRPPHUFH�ZKLFK�LV�XQODZIXO�XQGHU�D� VWDWXWH� VSHFLILFDOO\� FRQWUROOLQJ� WKH� IORZ� RI� VXFK� JRRGV� LQ�FRPPHUFH�´��

7KH� QH[W� PDMRU� 77$%� GHFLVLRQ� RQ� XQODZIXO� XVH� ZDV� 6DWLQLQH�6RFLHWD�LQ�1RPH�&ROOHWWLYR�'L�6�$��(�0��8VHOOLQL�Y��3�$�%��3URGXLWV�HW�$SSDUHLOV�GH�%HDXWH��GHFLGHG�LQ�������� 7KHUH��WKH�77$%�UXOHG�RQ�WKH�XQODZIXO� XVH� TXHVWLRQ� LQ� WKH� FRQWH[W� RI� D� FDQFHOODWLRQ� SURFHHGLQJ���

7KH�SHWLWLRQHU�DUJXHG�WKDW�WKH�PDUN�3$%�KDG�EHHQ�DEDQGRQHG��DQG�WKDW�

�� ,G� DW���������� ,G���� ,G����� 6DWLQLQH�6RFLHWD�LQ�1RPH�&ROOHWWLYR�'L�6�$��(�0��8VHOOLQL�Y��3�$�%��3URGXLWV�

HW�$SSDUHLOV�GH�%HDXWH������8�6�3�4�������7�7�$�%���������� ,G��DW�����

Page 17: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŖŘ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

DQ\� XVH� RI� WKH�PDUN� KDG� EHHQ� XQODZIXO��� $OWKRXJK� WKH� GHFLVLRQ� LV�XQUHPDUNDEOH�LQ�LWV�RXWFRPH²WKH�%RDUG�GHWHUPLQHG�WKDW�WKH�SHWLWLRQHU�KDG�QRW�PHW�LWV�EXUGHQ�WR�VKRZ�XQODZIXO XVH��²LW�LV�IDVFLQDWLQJ�IRU�LWV�LQ�GHSWK�DQDO\VLV�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH���

(DFK�PHPEHU� RI� WKH� %RDUG� ZURWH� KLV� RZQ� RSLQLRQ�� DOWKRXJK� DOO�FRQFXUUHG� LQ� WKH� MXGJPHQW�� DQG� WZR� FRQFXUUHG� LQ� WKH� RSLQLRQ� ��

0HPEHU� 5LFH�� ZULWLQJ� IRU� WKH� %RDUG�� H[DPLQHG� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH�GRFWULQH�DV�LW�KDG�GHYHORSHG�WKXV�IDU��DQG�VKDUSO\�FULWLFL]HG�LW��JRLQJ�VR�IDU� DV� WR� QRWH� WKDW� ³D� YHU\� SHUVXDVLYH� DUJXPHQW´� H[LVWV� DJDLQVW� WKH�GRFWULQH�

$� YHU\� SHUVXDVLYH� DUJXPHQW� FDQ� EH� PDGH� IRU� WKH�SURSRVLWLRQ� WKDW� WKHUH� LV� LQ� IDFW� QR� VWDWXWRU\� EDVLV� IRU�UHIXVLQJ� WR� JUDQW� D� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� RU� IRU� FDQFHOOLQJ� D�VXEVLVWLQJ� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� RQ� WKH� JURXQG� RI� ³XQODZIXO�XVH�´ L�H��� XVH� RI� WKH� PDUN� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK�JRRGV�VHUYLFHV� ZKLFK� PD\� QRW� ODZIXOO\� EH�VKLSSHG�SHUIRUPHG�LQ�FRPPHUFH�EHFDXVH�WKH\�DUH�QRW�LQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�VRPH�IHGHUDO�UHJXODWRU\�DFW�SHUWDLQLQJ�WKHUHWR�� DQG� WKDW� XQGHU� 5XOH� ����� WKH� 7UDGHPDUN�$WWRUQH\� VKRXOG� GR� QR� PRUH� WKDQ� FDOO� WKH� DSSOLFDQW¶V�DWWHQWLRQ� WR� IHGHUDO� VWDWXWHV� UHJXODWLQJ� WKH� IORZ� RI� KLV�JRRGV� RU� VHUYLFHV� LQ� FRPPHUFH� DQG� SRLQW� RXW� DQ\�QRQFRPSOLDQFH� WKHUHZLWK� VR� WKDW� WKH� DSSOLFDQW�PD\�EH�DZDUH�RI�WKH�H[LVWHQFH�RI�VXFK�VWDWXWHV�DQG�WDNH�VWHSV�WR�FRPSO\�ZLWK�WKHP���

0HPEHU�5LFH�QRWHG�WKDW�QHLWKHU�&RDKRPD QRU�6WHOODU UHOLHG�XSRQ�DQ\� VWDWXWRU\� DXWKRULW\�� RQ� WKH� FRQWUDU\�� ZKLOH� WKH /DQKDP� $FW�PHQWLRQV�³ODZIXO�XVH´�LQ�VRPH�FRQWH[WV��QR�VXFK�UHIHUHQFH�DSSHDUV�LQ�WKH�VHFWLRQV�UHOHYDQW�WR�UHJLVWHULQJ�WUDGHPDUNV��UHIXVDO�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��FDQFHOODWLRQ� RI� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� RU� LQ� WKH� GHILQLWLRQV� RI� WKH� WHUPV�³WUDGHPDUN´� DQG� ³XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH�´ �� ,QGHHG�� VKH� QRWHG� WKDW�³>L@QDVPXFK�DV�WKH�WHUP�µODZIXO¶�LV�VSHFLILFDOO\�XVHG�LQ�FHUWDLQ�VHFWLRQV�RI�WKH�6WDWXWH�� WKH�VXJJHVWLRQ�WKDW� WKLV� WHUP�VKRXOG�EH�UHDG�LQWR�WKRVH�VHFWLRQV� ZKHUH� LW� LV� QRW� XVHG� ZRXOG� DSSHDU� WR� EH� D� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKH�EDVLF� UXOHV�RI� VWDWXWRU\� FRQVWUXFWLRQ�´�� +RZHYHU�� VKH�QRWHG� WKDW� WKH�

�� ,G��DW������� ,G��DW����±����� ,G��� ,G� DW ����Q����� ,G��� ,G�

Page 18: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŖř

77$%� IHOW� ERXQG� E\� WKH� DSSHOODWH� FRXUW¶V� DIILUPLQJ� RI� &RDKRPDZLWKRXW�UHIHUHQFH�WR�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH���

0HPEHU�5LFH� DOVR� ODPHQWHG� WKH� ³DOPRVW� HQGOHVV� QXPEHU� RI� VXFK�DFWV�ZKLFK�WKH�%RDUG�PLJKW�LQ�WKH�IXWXUH�EH�FRPSHOOHG�WR�LQWHUSUHW�LQ�RUGHU� WR� GHWHUPLQH�ZKHWKHU� D� SDUWLFXODU� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� LV� ODZIXO�´�DQG�H[SODLQHG�WKDW�LW�PD\�QRW�EH�DGYLVDEOH�WR�SODFH�WKH�LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ�RI�P\ULDG�IHGHUDO�VWDWXWHV�LQ�WKH�KDQGV�RI�WKH�77$%�

,QDVPXFK�DV�ZH�KDYH�OLWWOH�RU�QR�IDPLOLDULW\�ZLWK�PRVW�RI� WKHVH� DFWV�� WKHUH� LV� D� VHULRXV� TXHVWLRQ� DV� WR� WKH�DGYLVDELOLW\� RI� RXU� DWWHPSWLQJ� WR� DGMXGLFDWH�ZKHWKHU� D�SDUW\¶V� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� LV� LQ� FRPSOLDQFH� ZLWK� WKH�SDUWLFXODU� UHJXODWRU\� DFW� RU� DFWV� ZKLFK� PD\� EH�DSSOLFDEOH� WKHUHWR�� � 5DWKHU�� LW� VHHPV� WKDW� WKH� EHWWHU�SUDFWLFH� ZRXOG� EH� WR� KROG� WKDW� D� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� LV�XQODZIXO� RQO\� ZKHQ� WKH� LVVXH� RI� FRPSOLDQFH� KDV�SUHYLRXVO\� EHHQ� GHWHUPLQHG� �ZLWK� D� ILQGLQJ� RI�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�� E\� DQ� HQWLW\�� VXFK� DV� D� FRXUW� RU�JRYHUQPHQW� DJHQF\�� KDYLQJ� FRPSHWHQW� MXULVGLFWLRQ�XQGHU�WKH�VWDWXWH�LQ�TXHVWLRQ��RU�ZKHQ�WKHUH�KDV�EHHQ�D�SHU� VH� YLRODWLRQ� RI� D� VWDWXWH� UHJXODWLQJ� WKH� VDOH� RI� D�SDUW\¶V� JRRGV�� RU� WKH� UHQGHULQJ� RI� KLV� VHUYLFHV�� LQ�FRPPHUFH�� DV�� IRU� H[DPSOH��ZKHQ� D� UHJXODWRU\� VWDWXWH�UHTXLUHV�WKDW�D�SDUW\¶V�ODEHOV�PXVW�EH�UHJLVWHUHG�ZLWK�RU�DSSURYHG� E\� WKH� UHJXODWRU\� DJHQF\� FKDUJHG� ZLWK�DGPLQLVWHULQJ�WKH�VWDWXWH�EHIRUH�KLV�JRRGV�PD\�ODZIXOO\�HQWHU�WKH�VWUHDP�RI�FRPPHUFH��DQG�WKH�SDUW\�KDV�IDLOHG�WR�REWDLQ�VXFK�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RU�DSSURYDO��DV�KDSSHQHG�LQ�WKH�&RDKRPD FDVH����

&RQFXUULQJ� LQ� WKH� MXGJPHQW� RQO\�� 0HPEHU� /HINRZLW]� �ZKR�DXWKRUHG�WKH�RSLQLRQ�LQ�6WHOODU��GLVDJUHHG�ZLWK�0HPEHU�5LFH¶V�WDNH�RQ�WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�� SDUWLFXODUO\� WKDW� WKH� %RDUG� GRHV� QRW� KDYH�H[SHUWLVH�WR�GHFLGH�VXFK�PDWWHUV�DQG�WKDW�XQODZIXO�XVH�VKRXOG�RQO\�EH�FRQVLGHUHG�LI� WKH�TXHVWLRQ�KDV�SUHYLRXVO\�EHHQ�GHWHUPLQHG�E\�D�FRXUW�RU� DJHQF\���� ,QVWHDG��0HPEHU�/HINRZLW]� DUJXHG� WKDW� WKH�%RDUG�KDV�MXVW� DV� PXFK� H[SHUWLVH� DV� WKH� FRXUWV�� WKDW� ³DOO� LVVXHV� LQYROYLQJ�

�� ,G���,W�LV�VRPHZKDW�VXUSULVLQJ�WKDW�0HPEHU�5LFH�UHDG�VR�PXFK�LQWR�WKH�DIILUPLQJ�&RDKRPD RSLQLRQ��ZKLFK��DV�VKH�VWDWHV��GRHV�QRW�PHQWLRQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�DW�DOO���,I�VKH�KDG�QRW�IHOW�ERXQG�E\�WKH�RSLQLRQ��SHUKDSV�WKLV�FDVH�ZRXOG�KDYH�EHHQ�D�WXUQLQJ�SRLQW�IRU�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH���

�� ,G��DW���������� ,G��DW�������/HINRZLW]��0HPEHU��FRQFXUULQJ�LQ�MXGJPHQW�RQO\��

Page 19: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŖŚ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

UHJLVWUDWLRQ´�VKRXOG�EH�EHIRUH� WKH�%RDUG�� DQG� WKDW�³WKH�VDIHJXDUGV�RI�DSSHDO� DUH� DOZD\V� DYDLODEOH� WR� D� SDUW\� LI� KH� EHOLHYHV� WKDW� WKH� %RDUG�H[FHHGHG�LWV�VWDWXWRU\�DXWKRULW\�´���

)LQDOO\��0HPEHU�.HUD�DOVR�ZURWH�D�FRQFXUULQJ�RSLQLRQ�� WR�³DGG�D�WKRXJKW� WR� WKH� SULQFLSDO� DQG� FRQFXUULQJ� RSLQLRQV�´��� +H� VXJJHVWHG�WKDW�DOWKRXJK�WKH�SROLF\�FRQVLGHUDWLRQV�EHKLQG�WKH�GRFWULQH�DUH�VWURQJ��

>:@H� VKRXOG� QRW� UHIXVH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� RU� RUGHU� WKH�FDQFHOODWLRQ� RI� D� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� EHFDXVH� RI� VRPH� SXUHO\�FROODWHUDO� GHIHFW«WKHUH� PXVW� EH� VRPH� QH[XV� EHWZHHQ�WKH�XVH�RI WKH�PDUN�DQG� WKH�DOOHJHG�YLRODWLRQ�EHIRUH� LW�FDQ� EH� VDLG� WKDW� WKH� XQODZIXOQHVV� RI� WKH� VDOH� RU�VKLSPHQW�KDV�UHVXOWHG�LQ�WKH�LQYDOLGLW\�RI�DQ�DSSOLFDWLRQ�RU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ����

0HPEHU� .HUD� DOVR� QRWHG� WKH� LQFRQJUXLW\� EHWZHHQ� WKH� /DQKDP�$FW¶V� UHTXLUHPHQW�RI� ODZIXO�XVH� IRU� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RQ� WKH�6XSSOHPHQWDO�5HJLVWHU�DQG�WKH�ODFN�RI�VXFK�UHTXLUHPHQW�RQ�WKH�3ULQFLSDO�5HJLVWHU����

F� 7KH�0RGHUQ�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�DW�WKH�86372

'HVSLWH� WKH� GLVVHQWLRQ�� ODWHU� 77$%� FDVHV� DGRSWHG� WKH� UHDVRQLQJ�IURP� 6DWLQLQH�� XOWLPDWHO\� UHVXOWLQJ� LQ� WKH� GHYHORSPHQW� RI� D� IDLUO\�FRKHVLYH�VWDWHPHQW�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH���,Q�*HQHUDO�0LOOV�Y��+HDOWK�9DOOH\�)RRGV��WKH�%RDUG�KHOG�WKDW�ZKHQ�³D�SDUW\�VHHNV�WR�VKRZ�WKDW�XVH�E\�WKH�DGYHUVH�SDUW\�ZDV�XQODZIXO�E\�YLUWXH�RI�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�D�ODEHOLQJ�VWDWXWRU\� SURYLVLRQ�´� WKDW� SDUW\� PXVW� VKRZ�� E\� FOHDU� DQG� FRQYLQFLQJ�HYLGHQFH��QRW�RQO\� WKDW� WKHUH�ZDV�DQ� LQVWDQFH�RI�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�DSSOLFDEOH� ODZ�� EXW� DOVR� WKDW�� ���� WKH� QRQFRPSOLDQFH� ZDV� PDWHULDO��³WKDW� LV��ZDV�RI� VXFK�JUDYLW\�DQG�VLJQLILFDQFH� WKDW� WKH�XVDJH PXVW�EH�FRQVLGHUHG�XQODZIXO±VR�WDLQWHG�WKDW��DV�D�PDWWHU�RI�ODZ��LW�FRXOG�FUHDWH�QR� WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV±ZDUUDQWLQJ�FDQFHOODWLRQ�RI� WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI� WKH�PDUN�LQYROYHG�´��� DQG�����³WKDW�WKHUH�PXVW�EH�VRPH�QH[XV�EHWZHHQ�WKH�XVH�RI�WKH�PDUN�DQG�WKH�DOOHJHG�YLRODWLRQ�EHIRUH�WKH�XQODZIXOQHVV�RI�D�VKLSPHQW�FDQ�EH�VDLG�WR�UHVXOW�LQ�WKH�LQYDOLGLW\�RI�D�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�´�VXFK�WKDW� D� ³FROODWHUDO� GHIHFW´� LV� QRW� HQRXJK���� 7KH�³SHU� VH´� UHTXLUHPHQW�

��� ,G���� ,G��DW�������.HUD��FRQFXUULQJ�LQ�RSLQLRQ�RI�0HPEHU�5LFH����� ,G���� ,G���� *HQ��0LOOV�,QF��Y��+HDOWK�9DOOH\�)RRGV�����8�6�3�4��G�������������7�7�$�%��

��������� ,G� DW������

Page 20: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŖś

KDV�DOVR�EHHQ�DGRSWHG��VXFK�WKDW�DQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�ZLOO�RQO\�EH�IRXQG�³LI�WKH� LVVXH� RI� FRPSOLDQFH� KDV� SUHYLRXVO\� EHHQ� GHWHUPLQHG� �ZLWK� D�ILQGLQJ� RI� QRQFRPSOLDQFH�� E\� D� FRXUW� RU� JRYHUQPHQW� DJHQF\� KDYLQJ�FRPSHWHQW� MXULVGLFWLRQ�XQGHU� WKH�VWDWXWH� LQYROYHG��RU�ZKHUH� WKHUH�KDV�EHHQ� D� SHU� VH� YLRODWLRQ� RI� D� VWDWXWH� UHJXODWLQJ� WKH� VDOH� RI� D� SDUW\¶V�JRRGV�´��� 7KLV�IRUPXODWLRQ�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH�LV�LQ�XVH�WRGD\����

'HVSLWH� WKH� RULJLQDO� PHQWLRQ� LQ� &RDKRPD RI� 1RUWK� &DUROLQD¶V�VWDWXWH�� WKH� FXUUHQW� IRUPXODWLRQ� RI� WKH� 77$%¶V� GRFWULQH� �FRQVLVWHQW�ZLWK�������SURYLGHV�WKDW�RQO\�³VWDWXWHV�DQG�UHJXODWLRQV�LVVXHG�SXUVXDQW�WR�$FWV�RI�&RQJUHVV´�DUH�WR�EH�FRQVLGHUHG�ZKHQ�GHWHUPLQLQJ�ZKHWKHU�D�XVH� LV� ODZIXO�� QRW� VWDWH� RU� IRUHLJQ� VWDWXWHV���� /LNHZLVH�� WKH� FXUUHQW�7UDGHPDUN� 0DQXDO� RI� ([DPLQLQJ� 3URFHGXUH� �³70(3´�� GLVFXVVHV�ODZIXO�XVH�LQ�D�QXPEHU�RI�SODFHV��EXW�VSHFLILFDOO\��VHFWLRQ�����SURYLGHV�GHWDLOHG�JXLGDQFH�WR�H[DPLQHUV�RQ�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH���� $OWKRXJK�LW�SURYLGHV�WKDW�³>X@VH�RI�D�PDUN�LQ�FRPPHUFH�PXVW�EH�ODZIXO�XVH�WR�EH�WKH�EDVLV� IRU� IHGHUDO� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI� WKH�PDUN� �� �� �� >W@KXV�� WKH�JRRGV�RU�VHUYLFHV� WR� ZKLFK� WKH� PDUN� LV� DSSOLHG�� DQG� WKH� PDUN� LWVHOI�� PXVW�FRPSO\�ZLWK�DOO�DSSOLFDEOH�IHGHUDO�ODZV�´��� LW�DOVR�VWDWHV�WKDW�WKH�XVH�LV�JHQHUDOO\� SUHVXPHG� ODZIXO�� DQG� WKDW� XQODZIXO� XVH� ZLOO� QRW� IRUP� WKH�EDVLV� RI� D� UHIXVDO� WR� UHJLVWHU� XQOHVV�� FLWLQJ� .HOORJJ�� ³D� YLRODWLRQ� RI�IHGHUDO� ODZ� LV� LQGLFDWHG� E\� WKH� DSSOLFDWLRQ� UHFRUG� RU� RWKHU� HYLGHQFH��VXFK� DV�ZKHQ� D� FRXUW� RU� WKH� UHVSRQVLEOH� IHGHUDO� DJHQF\� KDV� LVVXHG� D�ILQGLQJ�RI�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�XQGHU� WKH� UHOHYDQW� VWDWXWH�RU� UHJXODWLRQ�� RU�ZKHQ� WKHUH� LV� D� SHU� VH� YLRODWLRQ� RI� D� IHGHUDO� ODZ�´��� 7KH� 70(3�IXUWKHU�OLPLWV�WKH�DXWKRULW\�RI�WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\V�E\�UHTXLULQJ�WKDW�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\V�³REWDLQ�DSSURYDO�IURP�WKHLU�PDQDJLQJ�DWWRUQH\�RU�VHQLRU� DWWRUQH\�� ZKR� PD\� VHHN� DGGLWLRQDO� JXLGDQFH� IURP� WKH�$GPLQLVWUDWRU�IRU�7UDGHPDUN�3ROLF\�DQG�3URFHGXUH´�EHIRUH�LVVXLQJ�DQ�LQTXLU\� RU� UHIXVDO� ³SHUWDLQLQJ� WR� WKH� ODZIXOQHVV� RI� JRRGV� RU�VHUYLFHV�´���

7KH�70(3�JRHV�RQ�WR�VWDWH�WKDW�LQ�GHWHUPLQLQJ�ZKHWKHU�WR�IXUWKHU�LQTXLUH� RU� UHIXVH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� ³WKH� 86372� ZLOO� QRW� UHJDUG� DSSDUHQW�WHFKQLFDO� YLRODWLRQV�� VXFK� DV� ODEHOLQJ� LUUHJXODULWLHV� RQ� VSHFLPHQV�� DV�

��� ,G��DW��������� 6HH��H�J�� 1HWFORXG�//&�Y��(DVW�&RDVW�1HWZRUN�6HUY��//&��1R������������

�����:/����������7�7�$�%��0DU�������������QRW�SUHFHGHQWLDO���VHH�DOVR &KXUFKLOO�&HOODUV��,QF��Y��*UDKDP��1R�����������������:/����������2FW�������������QRW�SUHFHGHQWLDO��

��� 6HH��H�J���1HWFORXG��//&�������:/����������DW� ���FLWLQJ�:��:RUOGZLGH�(QWHUV��*US��,QF��Y��4LQTGDR�%UHZHU\�����8�6�3�4��G�������7�7�$�%���������

��� 6HH�70(3��VXSUD QRWH�������������� ,G���� ,G���� ,G�

Page 21: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŖŜ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

YLRODWLRQV�´��� ,W�IXUWKHU�VWDWHV�WKDW�

)RU� H[DPSOH�� LI� D� SDFNDJH� IDLOV� WR� VKRZ� DOO� UHTXLUHG�ODEHOLQJ�LQIRUPDWLRQ��WKH�H[DPLQLQJ�DWWRUQH\�VKRXOG�QRW�WDNH� DQ\� DFWLRQ�� � /LNHZLVH�� WKH� 86372� GRHV� QRW�URXWLQHO\� VROLFLW� LQIRUPDWLRQ� UHJDUGLQJ� ODEHO� DSSURYDO�XQGHU� WKH� )HGHUDO� $OFRKRO� $GPLQLVWUDWLRQ� $FW� RU�VLPLODU�DFWV�� �+RZHYHU�� LI� WKH� UHFRUG� LQGLFDWHV� WKDW� WKH�PDUN�LWVHOI�RU�WKH�JRRGV�RU�VHUYLFHV�YLRODWH�IHGHUDO�ODZ��DQ� LQTXLU\� RU� UHIXVDO� PXVW� EH� PDGH�� � )RU� H[DPSOH��HYLGHQFH�LQGLFDWLQJ�WKDW�WKH�LGHQWLILHG�JRRGV�RU�VHUYLFHV�LQYROYH� WKH� VDOH� RU� WUDQVSRUWDWLRQ� RI� D� FRQWUROOHG�VXEVWDQFH� RU� GUXJ� SDUDSKHUQDOLD� LQ� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKH�&RQWUROOHG�6XEVWDQFHV�$FW��³&6$´������8�6�&�������������ZRXOG�EH�D�EDVLV�IRU�LVVXLQJ�DQ LQTXLU\�RU�UHIXVDO���6XEMHFW�WR�FHUWDLQ�OLPLWHG�VWDWXWRU\�H[FHSWLRQV��WKH�&6$�PDNHV� LW� XQODZIXO� WR� PDQXIDFWXUH�� GLVWULEXWH�� RU�GLVSHQVH� D� FRQWUROOHG� VXEVWDQFH�� SRVVHVV� D� 6FKHGXOH� ,�FRQWUROOHG�VXEVWDQFH��RU� VHOO��RIIHU� IRU� VDOH��RU�XVH�DQ\�IDFLOLW\� RI� LQWHUVWDWH� FRPPHUFH� WR� WUDQVSRUW� GUXJ�SDUDSKHUQDOLD�� � 1RWH� WKDW�� UHJDUGOHVV� RI� VWDWH� ODZ��PDULMXDQD� DQG� LWV� SV\FKRDFWLYH� FRPSRQHQW�� 7+&��UHPDLQ�6FKHGXOH� ,� FRQWUROOHG� VXEVWDQFHV� XQGHU� IHGHUDO�ODZ�DQG�DUH�VXEMHFW�WR�WKH�&6$¶V�SURKLELWLRQV����

,Q�ERWK�WKH�JXLGDQFH JLYHQ�WR�WKH�H[DPLQHUV�DQG�WKH�77$%¶V�PRUH�UHFHQW� GHFLVLRQV�� WKH� SRVLWLRQ� RI� WKH� 86372� LV� QRZ� FRQVLGHUDEO\�UHVWUDLQHG�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH����

��� ,G���� ,G���LQWHUQDO�FLWDWLRQV�RPLWWHG����� ,W�LV�ZRUWK�QRWLQJ�WKDW�LQ�-XO\�RI�������DIWHU�WKLV�SDSHU�ZDV�FRPSOHWHG��WKH�

77$%�LVVXHG�D�SUHFHGHQWLDO�GHFLVLRQ�GHWHUPLQLQJ�WKDW�XVH�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�DQ�LOOHJDO�VXEVWDQFH��PDULMXDQD��ZDV�D�³SHU�VH´�XQODZIXO�XVH�DQG�DIILUPHG�WKH�GHQLDO�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��GHVSLWH�WKH�IDFW�WKDW�PDULMXDQD�LV�OHJDO�XQGHU�:DVKLQJWRQ�ODZ��ZKHUH�WKH�DSSOLFDQW�ZDV�EDVHG���6HH�0RUJDQ�%URZQ��6HULDO�1R������������7�7�$�%���������KWWS���WWDEYXH�XVSWR�JRY�WWDEYXH�WWDEYXH����������(;$����SGI���7KH�77$%�KHOG�WKDW�EHFDXVH�WKH�DSSOLFDQW¶V�VHUYLFHV�LQFOXGHG�WKH�SURYLVLRQ�RI�DQ�LOOHJDO�VXEVWDQFH��HYHQ�WKRXJK�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�ZDV�QRW�VRXJKW�IRU�PDULMXDQD�VSHFLILFDOO\��EXW�IRU�³UHWDLO�VWRUH�VHUYLFHV�IHDWXULQJ�KHUEV´���WKH�XVH�ZDV�XQODZIXO��6HH�LG� 7KLV�DSSHDUV�WR�EH�FRQVLVWHQW�ZLWK�WKH�70(3�ODQJXDJH�FLWHG�VXSUD�QRWH������³LI�WKH�UHFRUG�LQGLFDWHV�WKDW�WKH�PDUN�LWVHOI�RU�WKH�JRRGV�DQG�VHUYLFHV�YLRODWH�IHGHUDO�ODZ��DQ�LQTXLU\�RU�UHIXVDO�PXVW�EH�PDGH�´�7KH�VSHFLPHQV�LQ�0RUJDQ�%URZQ LQGLFDWHG�WKDW�WKH�PDUN�ZDV�LQ�XVH�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�PDULMXDQD���/LNHZLVH��LQ�2FWREHU�RI�������WKH�77$%�LVVXHG�D�SUHFHGHQWLDO�GHFLVLRQ�UHMHFWLQJ�D�QXPEHU�RI�UDWLRQDOHV�IRU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI�ZKDW�LW�UHIHUUHG�WR�DV�³GUXJ�SDUDSKHUQDOLD´��ZKDW�WKH�DSSOLFDQW�FKDUDFWHUL]HG�DV�

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 22: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŖŝ

�� 7KH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�LQ�WKH�)HGHUDO�&RXUWV

$OWKRXJK�D�KDQGIXO�RI�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�KDG�FRQVLGHUHG�RU�DSSOLHG�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�SULRU�WR��������� WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW¶V�GHFLVLRQ�LQ�&UH$JUL��� �DV�ODWHU�FODULILHG�E\�6RXWKHUQ�&DOLIRUQLD�'DUWV��� LQ�������PDUNHG�D�WXUQLQJ�SRLQW�IRU�WKH�GRFWULQH���6LQFH�&UH$JUL��DQ�LQFUHDVLQJ�QXPEHU�RI�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�KDYH�DGGUHVVHG�WKH�LVVXH�

D� &UH$JUL

,Q�&UH$JUL��WKH�SODLQWLII�PDQXIDFWXUHU�RI�D�GLHWDU\�VXSSOHPHQW�VXHG�D� FRPSHWLWRU� IRU� WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW�� XQIDLU� FRPSHWLWLRQ�� DQG�XQMXVW�HQULFKPHQW��DQG� WKH�FRPSHWLWRU�FRXQWHUFODLPHG�IRU�GHFODUDWRU\�UHOLHI� DQG� FDQFHOODWLRQ� RI� WKH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ���� 7KH� SODLQWLII� DGPLWWHG�WKDW� GXULQJ� WKH� UHOHYDQW� WLPHIUDPH� �URXJKO\�� WKH� \HDU� SULRU� WR� WKH�GHIHQGDQW¶V�SULRULW\�RI�XVH�GDWH���WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�ODEHOV�ZHUH�LQDFFXUDWH��FODLPLQJ� WKH� VXSSOHPHQW� FRQWDLQHG� PRUH� RI� WKH� NH\� LQJUHGLHQW� WKDQ�ZDV�DFWXDOO\�SUHVHQW���� 7KH�GLVWULFW�FRXUW�JUDQWHG�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�RQ� WKH� LVVXH� RI� XQODZIXO� XVH� DQG� GLVPLVVHG� WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� FODLPV��HQWHUHG� GHFODUDWRU\� MXGJPHQW� LQ� IDYRU� RI� WKH� GHIHQGDQW�� DQG� RUGHUHG�WKH�PDUN�FDQFHOOHG�IURP�WKH�6XSSOHPHQWDO�5HJLVWHU����

7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�DIILUPHG��KROGLQJ�WKDW�³WKH�LQTXLU\�GRHV�QRW�VWRS�ZLWK� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH�� � ,W� KDV� ORQJ� EHHQ� WKH� SROLF\� RI� WKH� 372¶V�7UDGHPDUN�7ULDO�DQG�$SSHDO�%RDUG�WKDW�XVH�LQ�FRPPHUFH�RQO\�FUHDWHV�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV�ZKHQ�WKH�XVH�LV� ODZIXO�´��� 7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�QRWHG�WKDW� WKH� 7HQWK� &LUFXLW� ³KDV� DGRSWHG� DQG� DSSOLHG� WKLV� UXOH�´� FLWLQJ� WR�8QLWHG� 3KRVSKRUXV���� DQG� KHOG� WKDW� ³ZH� DOVR� DJUHH� ZLWK� WKH� 372¶V�SROLF\� DQG� KROG� WKDW� RQO\� ODZIXO XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� FDQ� JLYH� ULVH� WR�WUDGHPDUN�SULRULW\�´���

7KH� FRXUW� JDYH� WZR� UDWLRQDOHV� IRU� WKH� SROLF\�� ILUVW�� WKDW� ³WR� KROG�RWKHUZLVH�ZRXOG� SXW� WKH� JRYHUQPHQW� LQ� WKH� µDQRPDORXV� SRVLWLRQ¶� RI�

³VPRNHOHVV�FDQQDELV�YDSRUL]LQJ�DSSDUDWXV��RUDO�YDSRUL]HUV�IRU�VPRNLQJ�SXUSRVHV��YDSRUL]LQJ�FDQQDELV�GHOLYHU\�GHYLFH��QDPHO\��RUDO�YDSRUL]HUV�IRU�VPRNLQJ�SXUSRVHV´���6HH�--�����//&��6HULDO�1RV����������������������7�7�$�%���������KWWS���WWDEYXH�XVSWR�JRY�WWDEYXH�WWDEYXH����������(;$����SGI��

��� 6HH�LQIUD 6HFWLRQ�,,,�$������ 6HH�&UH$JUL��,QF��Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6FL���,QF�������)��G���������±�����WK�

&LU����������� 6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q�Y��=DIILQD������)��G���������±�����WK�&LU����������� &UH$JUL������)��G�DW�������� 6HH�LG� DW�������� 6HH�LG� DW�������� ,G� DW���������� 7KH�IODZV�LQ�WKLV�SUHFHGHQW�DUH�GLVFXVVHG��6HH LQIUD 6HFWLRQ�,,,�$���D������� &UH$JUL������)��G�DW�����

Page 23: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŖŞ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

H[WHQGLQJ� WKH�EHQHILWV�RI� WUDGHPDUN�SURWHFWLRQ� WR�D�VHOOHU�EDVHG�XSRQ�DFWLRQV� WKH� VHOOHU� WRRN� LQ� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKDW� JRYHUQPHQW¶V� RZQ� ODZV�´�DQG� VHFRQG�� ³WR� JLYH� WUDGHPDUN� SULRULW\� WR� D� VHOOHU� ZKR� UXVKHV� WR�PDUNHW� ZLWKRXW� WDNLQJ� FDUH� WR� FDUHIXOO\� FRPSO\� ZLWK� WKH� UHOHYDQW�UHJXODWLRQV� ZRXOG� EH� WR� UHZDUG� WKH� KDVW\� DW� WKH� H[SHQVH� RI� WKH�GLOLJHQW�´���

7KH� SODLQWLII� DUJXHG� WKUHH� WKLQJV� LQ� UHVSRQVH�� WZR RI� ZKLFK� DUH�UHOHYDQW�KHUH�� ILUVW�� WKDW� WKH�QH[XV�EHWZHHQ� WKH� ODEHOLQJ�YLRODWLRQ�DQG�WKH�XVH�RI�WKH�PDUN�ZDV�WRR�DWWHQXDWHG�WR�MXVWLI\�GHSULYLQJ�WKH�SODLQWLII�RI� WUDGHPDUN� SURWHFWLRQ�� DQG� VHFRQG� WKDW� WKH� YLRODWLRQ� ZDV� QRW�PDWHULDO���� :LWK� UHVSHFW� WR� WKH� QH[XV� DUJXPHQW�� WKH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW�IRXQG� WKDW� ³WKH� QH[XV� EHWZHHQ� D� PLVEUDQGHG� SURGXFW� DQG� WKDW�SURGXFW¶V�QDPH��SDUWLFXODUO\�RQH�GHVLJQHG�IRU�KXPDQ�FRQVXPSWLRQ��LV�VXIILFLHQWO\� FORVH� WR� MXVWLI\�ZLWKKROGLQJ� WUDGHPDUN�SURWHFWLRQ� IRU� WKDW�QDPH� XQWLO� DQG� XQOHVV� WKH� PLVEUDQGLQJ� LV� FXUHG�´ ��� 7KH� FRXUW�VSHFLILFDOO\�VWDWHG�WKDW�LW�ZDV�QHLWKHU�DGRSWLQJ�QRU�UHMHFWLQJ�WKH�QH[XV�UHTXLUHPHQW�� KRZHYHU� ��� $V� WR� PDWHULDOLW\�� WKH� SODLQWLII� FLWHG� WKH�77$%¶V�*HQHUDO�0LOOV GHFLVLRQ��DUJXLQJ�WKDW�GH�PLQLPLV�XVHV�ZLOO�QRW�SUHYHQW� WKH� DFTXLVLWLRQ� RI� WUDGHPDUN� ULJKWV� ��� +RZHYHU�� WKH� FRXUW�IRXQG� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� ODEHOLQJ� HUURU� ZDV� PDWHULDO�� DQG� WKHUHIRUH�GHFOLQHG� WR� GHWHUPLQH� ZKHWKHU� WR� DGRSW� WKH� *HQHUDO� 0LOOV WHVW� IRU�PDWHULDOLW\���� ,Q� D� IRRWQRWH�� WKH� FRXUW� QRWHG� WKDW� WKH� FDQFHOODWLRQ� RI�WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� ³GRHV� QRW� QHFHVVDULO\´� UHQGHU� WKH� PDUN�³IRUHYHU� LQFDSDEOH� RI� EHLQJ� UHJLVWHUHG� RQ� HLWKHU� WKH� SULQFLSDO� RU�VXSSOHPHQWDO�UHJLVWHUV�´���

E� 3RVW�&UH$JUL�8QODZIXO�8VH�'HFLVLRQV

:KHWKHU� WKH�1LQWK� &LUFXLW� NQHZ� LW� ZDV� EUHDNLQJ� QHZ� JURXQG� RU�QRW��WKH�&UH$JUL GHFLVLRQ�VHW�RII�D�IOXUU\�RI�OLWLJDWLRQ�RQ�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH���/DWHU�WKDW�\HDU��WKH�H[SORVLRQ�LQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�DVVHUWLRQV�

��� ,G���� ,G� DW������7KH�WKLUG�DUJXPHQW�ZDV�WKDW�EHFDXVH�LW�ZDV�WHFKQRORJLFDOO\�

LQIHDVLEOH�WR�PHDVXUH�WKH�DPRXQW�RI�WKH�NH\�LQJUHGLHQW�DW�WKH�WLPH�RI�WKH�PLVODEHOLQJ��DQG�EHFDXVH�WKH�)'$�SURYLGHV�IRU�DQ�H[HPSWLRQ�ZKHQ�WKDW�LV�WKH�FDVH��WKH�VDOH�ZDV�QRW�XQODZIXO��+RZHYHU��DV�WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�SRLQWV�RXW��WKLV�DUJXPHQW�LV�QRW�YHU\�SHUVXDVLYH�VLQFH�WKH�SODLQWLII�GLG�QRW�HYHQ�DSSO\�IRU�WKH�H[HPSWLRQ���,G� DW����±�����

��� ,G� DW����±������ ,G� DW�������� ,G� DW�������� ,G���� 6HH LG��DW�����Q������$�UHYLHZ�RI�WKH�86372¶V�ZHEVLWH�YLD�WKH�7UDGHPDUN�

(OHFWURQLF�6HDUFK�6\VWHP��³7(66´��VHDUFK�IXQFWLRQ�RQ�-DQXDU\����������UHYHDOHG�WKDW�&UH$JUL¶V�GHVLJQ�PDUN�IRU�2/,9(12/�ZDV�LQ�IDFW�UHJLVWHUHG�DJDLQ�DQG�LV�QRZ�RQ�WKH�3ULQFLSDO�5HJLVWHU�

Page 24: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŖş

EHJDQ���7KH�6RXWKHUQ�'LVWULFW�RI�1HZ�<RUN��UHO\LQJ�RQ�RQH�RI�WKH�RQO\�SUH�&UH$JUL XQODZIXO�XVH�GHFLVLRQV���� UXOHG�RQ�D�PRWLRQ�IRU�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW� WKDW�XQODZIXO�XVH�ZDV� DQ�DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH� WKDW�FRXOG�EH�SURYHQ�E\�VKRZLQJ��E\�FOHDU�DQG�FRQYLQFLQJ�HYLGHQFH��WKDW�����D�SHU�VH�YLRODWLRQ� �RU� D� FRXUW�DJHQF\� ILQGLQJ�� KDG� RFFXUUHG�� DQG� ���� WKH� QRQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZDV�PDWHULDO���� 7KH�FRXUW�GLG�DQ�LQ�GHSWK�DQDO\VLV�RI�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V� DOOHJHG� PLVODEHOHG� IUDJUDQFH�� EXW� GHQLHG� WKH� PRWLRQ� IRU�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�DQG�UHMHFWHG�WKH�UHTXHVW�WR�FDQFHO�WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��ILQGLQJ� WKDW� WKH� GHIHQGDQWV� KDG� QRW� PHW� WKHLU� EXUGHQ� RI� SURRI DV� WR�PDWHULDO�QRQ�FRPSOLDQFH����

6KRUWO\�WKHUHDIWHU��LQ�������WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�DJDLQ�FRQVLGHUHG�WKH�GRFWULQH� LQ�&DVK�3URFHVVLQJ�6HUYLFHV�//&�Y��$PELHQW�(QWHUWDLQPHQW��,QF� ��� 7KLV� QRW�IRU�SXEOLFDWLRQ� GHFLVLRQ� PDGH� EULHI� PHQWLRQ� RI�XQODZIXO� XVH�� QRWLQJ� WKDW WKH� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� SURSHUO\� UHMHFWHG� WKH�DUJXPHQW� ZKHUH�� DOWKRXJK� WKH� SODLQWLII� FRPSDQLHV� ³REWDLQHG� WKH�EXVLQHVV�LQ�DQ�XQODZIXO�PDQQHU��DQG�FRPPLWWHG�YDULRXV�FULPHV�GXULQJ�WKH� SHULRG� RI� RZQHUVKLS�� WKLV� FRQGXFW� ZDV� XQUHODWHG� WR� WKH�WUDGHPDUN�´��� 7KH� FRXUW� QRWHG� WKDW� WKH� WUDGHPDUN� LWVHOI� ³ZDV� QRW�REWDLQHG�WKURXJK�IUDXG��QRWKLQJ�DERXW�LWV�XVH�ZDV�LOOHJDO��DQG�WKHUH�LV�DQ�LQVXIILFLHQW�QH[XV�EHWZHHQ�>WKH�FRPSDQLHV¶@�FULPLQDO�DFWLYLWLHV�DQG�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�WR�MXVWLI\�D�ILQGLQJ�RI�LQYDOLGLW\�´���

,Q�������WKH�1RUWKHUQ�'LVWULFW�RI�&DOLIRUQLD�FRQVLGHUHG�WKH�GRFWULQH�DQG�DJDLQ�XVHG�LW�WR�JUDQW�D�PRWLRQ�IRU�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�LQ�IDYRU�RI�DQ�DOOHJHGO\� MXQLRU�XVHU�EDVHG�RQ� WKH�VHQLRU�XVHU¶V�XQODZIXO�XVH�RI�D�PDUN���� 7KHUH��WKH�FRXUW�KHOG�WKDW�ZKHUH�RQH�SDUW\¶V�SUHGHFHVVRU�KDGYLRODWHG� WKH� )RRG�� 'UXJ�� DQG� &RVPHWLFV� $FW� E\� QRW� DSSO\LQJ� IRU�DSSURYDO�SULRU�WR�LQWURGXFLQJ�WKH�GUXJ�LQWR�LQWHUVWDWH�FRPPHUFH��LWV�XVH�ZDV�XQODZIXO�DQG�LWV�ULYDO�ZDV�HQWLWOHG�WR�SULRULW\����

,Q������� DQRWKHU�&DOLIRUQLD� IHGHUDO� FRXUW�KDG�RFFDVLRQ� WR� UXOH�RQWKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� LVVXH�� � 7KHUH�� WKH� SODLQWLII� VRXJKW� WR� VWULNH� WKH�DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH��EXW� WKH�FRXUW�GHQLHG� WKH�PRWLRQ��

��� (UYD�3KDUP���,QF��Y��$P��&\DQDPLG�&R�������)��6XSS����������'��3�5���������VHH�GLVFXVVLRQ�LQIUD 6HFWLRQ�,,,�$���E�

��� 'HVVHUW�%HDXW\��,QF��Y��)R[������)��6XSS���G�����������6�'�1�<����������� ,G� DW���������� &DVK�3URFHVVLQJ�6HUY���//&�Y��$PELHQW�(QWP¶W��,QF�������)�$SS¶[��������WK�

&LU����������� ,G� DW�������� ,G���� *R&OHDU�//&�Y��7DUJHW�&RUS���1R��&���±�����00&�������:/��������

�1�'��&DO��-DQ�������������,QWHUHVWLQJO\��WKLV�FDVH�ZDV�GHFLGHG�E\�WKH�VDPH�GLVWULFW�FRXUW�MXGJH�ZKR�GHFLGHG�&UH$JUL�

��� ,G� DW� ��

Page 25: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŗŖ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

SHUPLWWLQJ�WKH�GHIHQVH�WR�SURFHHG����

,Q� ������ WKH�:HVWHUQ�'LVWULFW� RI�0LFKLJDQ� HQFRXQWHUHG� WKH� LVVXH�ZKHQ� D� GHIHQGDQW�PRYHG� WR� GLVPLVV� WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� FRPSODLQW� RQ� WKH�JURXQGV� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� RQO\� ULJKWV� ZHUH� EDVHG� RQ� XQODZIXO�DFWLYLW\���� 7KH�RZQHU�RI�WKH�SODLQWLII�FRPSDQ\�KDG�EHHQ�QDPHG�DV�DQ�XQLQGLFWHG�FR�FRQVSLUDWRU��LQ�D�IHGHUDO�LQGLFWPHQW�DJDLQVW�WKH�VXSSOLHU�RI� WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� SURGXFW�� RQ� FKDUJHV� RI� FRQVSLUDF\� WR� LQWURGXFH�PLVEUDQGHG� GUXJV� LQWR� LQWHUVWDWH� FRPPHUFH�� ZLUH� IUDXG�� DQG� PDLO�IUDXG� ��� 7KLV� FDVH� ZDV� WKH� ILUVW� WR� QRWH� WKDW� WKH� GRFWULQH� LV�FRQWURYHUVLDO�� H[SODLQLQJ� WKDW� ³>L@WV� DSSOLFDWLRQ� LQ� LQIULQJHPHQW� FDVHV�KDV� DOVR� EHHQ� TXHVWLRQHG� E\� OHDGLQJ� VHFRQGDU\� DXWKRULWLHV�´��� 7KH�FRXUW�QRWHG�WKDW�WKHUH�KDG�EHHQ�RQO\�DQ�DFFXVDWLRQ��YLD�WKH�LQGLFWPHQW���DQG� QR� SHU� VH� YLRODWLRQ�� DQG� GHFOLQHG� WR� DSSO\� WKH� GRFWULQH���� 7KH�FRXUW�DOVR�QRWHG�WKDW�EHFDXVH�XQODZIXO�XVH�LV DQ�DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH��LW�ZDV�SUHPDWXUH�WR�UDLVH�WKH�LVVXH�RQ�D�PRWLRQ�WR�GLVPLVV����

2Q� WKH� VDPH� GD\� LQ� ������ WZR� FRXUWV� RQ� GLIIHUHQW� VLGHV� RI� WKH�FRXQWU\� DOVR� LVVXHG�RSLQLRQV� LQYROYLQJ�XQODZIXO� XVH�� �$�FRXUW� LQ� WKH�:HVWHUQ�'LVWULFW�RI�1RUWK�&DUROLQD�KHOG WKDW�D�XVHU�ZKR�EHJDQ�VHOOLQJ�ZLQH� ZLWKRXW� DQ� DSSURYHG� &HUWLILFDWLRQ� RI� /DEHO�%RWWOH� $SSURYDO��³&2/$´�� XQGHU� WKH� )HGHUDO� $OFRKRO� $GPLQLVWUDWLRQ� $FW� FRXOG� QRW�FRXQW� WKDW�SUH�&2/$�XVH�WRZDUG�LWV�SULRULW\�GDWH���� 7KLV�GLIIHUHQFH��DOWKRXJK�LW�RQO\�DPRXQWHG�WR WKUHH�PRQWKV��ZDV�VXIILFLHQW�WR�PDNH�WKH�FRPSHWLWRU�WKH�VHQLRU�XVHU����

0HDQZKLOH�� D� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� LQ� :DVKLQJWRQ� 6WDWH�� DFWLQJ� LQ� LWV�FDSDFLW\�DV�DQ�DSSHOODWH�UHYLHZLQJ�FRXUW�RI�WKH�77$%���� DIILUPHG�WKH�

��� 6HH :LQH�*US��//&�Y��/���5��:LQH�&R���1R������±FY±�����±0&(±.-1�������:/����������(�'��&DO��0DU������������

��� ,PSXOVDULD��//&�Y��8QLWHG�'LVWULE��*US���//&��1R������±&9±�����������:/����������DW� ���:�'��0LFK��2FW������������

��� ,G���� ,G� �FLWLQJ�0&&$57+<� VXSUD QRWH ��� �����������³,�EHOLHYH�WKDW�WKH�1LQWK�

&LUFXLW�>LQ�&UH$JUL@�HUUHG�LQ�XQWKLQNLQJO\�ZUHQFKLQJ�D�GUDFRQLDQ�YHUVLRQ�RI�WKH�8�6�3�7�2�¶V�µXQODZIXO�XVH¶�SROLF\�RXW�RI�LWV�DGPLQLVWUDWLYH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�VHWWLQJ�DQG�LQVHUWLQJ�LW�LQWR�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�LQIULQJHPHQW�ODZVXLWV�´��

��� ,G���� ,G� DW� ������� 7DVVHO�5LGJH�:LQHU\��//&�Y��:RRGPLOO�:LQHU\��,QF���1R������±FY±�����±

5/9±'6&�������:/����������DW� ���:�'�1�&��2FW�������������� ,G� :KDW¶V�HVSHFLDOO\�LQWHUHVWLQJ�DERXW�WKLV�FDVH�LV�WKDW�WKH�77$%�KDV�IRXQG�

QR�XQODZIXO�XVH�RQ�YHU\�VLPLODU�IDFWV���6HH��H�J���&KXUFKLOO�&HOODUV��,QF��Y��*UDKDP��1R�����������������:/����������DW� �±���7�7�$�%��2FW�������������QRW�SUHFHGHQWLDO����

��� 6HH�9RVN�,QW¶O�&R��Y��=DR�*UXSSD�3UHGSUL\DWLM�2VW��1R��&��±����56/�������:/����������:�'��:DVK��2FW������������,W�LV�ZRUWK�QRWLQJ�WKDW�WKLV�GHFLVLRQ�ZDV�XQGHU�WKH�ROG�V\VWHP�ZKHUH�7�7�$�%��ILQGLQJV�UHFHLYHG�GHIHUHQFH�IURP�WKH�GLVWULFW�FRXUWV�

Page 26: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŗŗ

77$%¶V� UHMHFWLRQ� RI� DQ� XQODZIXO� XVH� DUJXPHQW� DQG� UHMHFWHG� WKH�GHIHQVH�XQGHU�GH�QRYR�UHYLHZ�RI�QHZ�HYLGHQFH�DV�ZHOO���� 7KH�FRXUW�IRXQG�WKDW�WKH�GHIHQGDQW�VLPSO\�KDG�QRW�PHW�LWV�EXUGHQ�RI�SURRI�ZLWK�UHVSHFW� WR� WKH� DOOHJHG� XQODZIXOQHVV� �WKH� DOOHJHG� SUHVHQFH� RI� D�SURKLELWHG�LQJUHGLHQW�LQ�YLRODWLRQ�RI�)'$�UHTXLUHPHQWV�����

,Q� ������ XQODZIXO� XVH�ZDV� LQYRNHG� LQ� D� GLIIHUHQW� FRQWH[W�� �$IWHU�UHFHLYLQJ� FHDVH�DQG�GHVLVW� OHWWHUV�� WKH� SODLQWLII� �D� PHGLFDO� PDULMXDQD�GLVSHQVDU\��ILOHG�DQ�DFWLRQ�IRU�GHFODUDWRU\�UHOLHI�DQG�FDQFHOODWLRQ�RI�WKH�PDUNV�DW�LVVXH���� 7KH�GHIHQGDQWV�ILOHG�D�PRWLRQ�IRU�MXGJPHQW�RQ�WKH�SOHDGLQJV��FODLPLQJ�WKDW�WKH�SODLQWLIIV�ODFNHG�VWDQGLQJ�WR�VHHN�WR�FDQFHO�WKH� UHJLVWUDWLRQV� EHFDXVH� WKH� SODLQWLII� VKRXOG� QRW� EH� DEOH� WR� XVH� WKH�/DQKDP�$FW� WR�SURWHFW� DFWLYLWLHV� WKDW�DUH� LOOHJDO�XQGHU� IHGHUDO� ODZ����

7KH�FRXUW� UHMHFWHG� WKLV�DUJXPHQW��KRZHYHU�� ILQGLQJ� WKDW� WKH�SODLQWLIIV�KDG� VWDQGLQJ� DV� VRPHRQH� ³ZKR� EHOLHYHV� WKDW� KH� LV� RU� ZLOO� EH�GDPDJHG«E\� WKH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� RI� D� PDUN´� SXUVXDQW� WR� WKH� /DQKDP�$FW���� 7KH�FRXUW�GLVWLQJXLVKHG�&UH$JUL��H[SODLQLQJ�WKDW��

8QOLNH� &UH$JUL�� ZKLFK� LQYROYHG� D� VHOOHU� VHHNLQJ� WR�EHQHILW IURP� DFWLRQV� WDNHQ� LQ� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKH� ODEHOLQJ�ODZ� LQ� DQ� HIIRUW� WR� PDLQWDLQ LWV� WUDGHPDUN�� SODLQWLII��KHUH�� VHHNV� WR� GHIHQG LWVHOI� DJDLQVW� WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�� �2XU�SODLQWLII�GRHV�QRW�VHHN�WR�FKDOOHQJH�GHIHQGDQWV¶�PDUNV�EDVHG�RQ� LWV� VDOH�RI�DQ� LOOHJDO�GUXJ���5DWKHU�� LQ� PDUVKDOLQJ� LWV� GHIHQVH� WR� GHIHQGDQWV¶�FRXQWHUFODLPV�� RXU� SODLQWLII� KDV� LQFOXGHG� FDQFHOODWLRQ�FODLPV� GLUHFWHG� DW� FKDOOHQJLQJ� WKH� YDOLGLW\� RI� WKH�DVVHUWHG�WUDGHPDUNV���,W�ZRXOG�EH�XQIDLU�WR�VWULS�SODLQWLII�RI�WKLV�DYHQXH�RI�GHIHQVH�

7DNHQ� RQH� VWHS� IXUWKHU�� LI� ZH� ZHUH� WR� UHFRJQL]H�GHIHQGDQWV¶� WKHRU\�� WKHQ�HYHU\�WUDGHPDUN�DFWLRQ�ZRXOG�GHYROYH� LQWR� D� VLGH� VKRZLQJ� ZKHUHLQ� WKH� WUDGHPDUN�RZQHU� GUHGJHV� XS� YDULRXV� RWKHU� IHGHUDO� ODZV�VXSSRVHGO\�YLRODWHG E\�WKH�DFFXVHG���7KLV�FDQQRW�EH����

,Q� RWKHU� ZRUGV�� D� GHIHQGDQW� VKRXOG� QRW� ORVH� WKH� RSSRUWXQLW\� WR�

��� ,G��DW� �±������� ,G� DW� ����� 3XUSOH�+HDUW�3DWLHQW�&WU���,QF��Y��0LOLWDU\�2UGHU�RI�WKH�3XUSOH�+HDUW��1R��

&��±������:+$�������:/���������DW� ���1�'��&DO����������� ,G���� ,G��DW� ���FLWLQJ����8�6�&������������������� ,G� DW� ����

Page 27: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŗŘ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

GHIHQG�KLPVHOI�YLD�WKH�DYHQXHV�DYDLODEOH�WR�KLP�VLPSO\�EHFDXVH�KH�LV�DQ�XQODZIXO�XVHU���

7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW� UHYLVLWHG� WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH� LQ������DV� ZHOO�� � ,Q� 6RXWKHUQ� &DOLIRUQLD� 'DUWV� $VV¶Q� Y�� =DIILQD�� WKH� FRXUW�GHFOLQHG� WR� ILQG� XQODZIXO� XVH�ZKHUH� WKH� SODLQWLII� KDG� IDLOHG� WR� SD\� D�VWDWH� FRUSRUDWH� IUDQFKLVH� WD[� ��� 8QFHUHPRQLRXVO\� �SHUKDSV�XQZLWWLQJO\�� DGRSWLQJ� WKH� 77$%� VWDQGDUGV� LW� KDG� FDUHIXOO\� DYRLGHG�DGRSWLQJ� LQ� ������ WKH� FRXUW� IRXQG� QR� XQODZIXO� XVH�� ILQGLQJ� WKDW� WKLV�SDUWLFXODU� YLRODWLRQ� ZDV� ERWK� LPPDWHULDO� DQG� FROODWHUDO� �PHDQLQJ� QR�VXIILFLHQW� QH[XV����� 7KH� FRXUW� DOVR� UHMHFWHG� WKH� DUJXPHQW� EHFDXVH��³PRUH�VLJQLILFDQWO\�´�WKH�DFFXVDWLRQV�ZHUH�XQVXEVWDQWLDWHG����

$OVR�LQ�������WKH�&HQWUDO�'LVWULFW�RI�&DOLIRUQLD�ZDV�IDFHG�ZLWK�WKH�LVVXH� DQG� GHFOLQHG� WR� DSSO\� WKH� GRFWULQH���� 7KHUH�� WKH� FRXUW� GHQLHG�VXPPDU\� MXGJPHQW�RQ� WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH�� ILQGLQJ� WKDW� WKH� ODZ�ZDV�XQVHWWOHG�DV�WR�ZKHWKHU�YLRODWLRQV�RI�VWDWH�ODZ��WKH�LQVXUDQFH�FRGH��FRXOG�VXSSRUW�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH��DQG�WKDW�LW�ZDV� ³VXIILFLHQWO\� XQFOHDU� WKDW� WKH� YLRODWLRQV� DW� LVVXH�ZHUH� µPDWHULDO¶�UDWKHU�WKDQ�µWHFKQLFDO«¶´���

,Q� ������ D� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� LQ� *HRUJLD� DSSOLHG� WKH� GRFWULQH� LQ )1�+HUVWDO�6�$��Y��&O\GH�$UPRU\�� ,QF���� 7KH�FRXUW�DSSOLHG� WKH�77$%¶V�YHUVLRQ� RI� WKH� GRFWULQH�� EXW� DOVR� QRWHG� WKDW� ³>W@KH�1LQWK�� 7HQWK�� DQG�)HGHUDO�&LUFXLWV�KDYH�H[SUHVVO\�DGRSWHG�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH�´���

7KHUH��DW� LVVXH�ZDV�ZKHWKHU�WKH�SODLQWLII�KDG�XQODZIXOO\�DWWHPSWHG�WR�DVVRFLDWH� LWV� ULIOH� VDOHV� ZLWK� WKH� 8�6�� 6SHFLDO� 2SHUDWLRQV� )RUFHV� E\�GLVSOD\LQJ� WKH� 6SHFLDO� 2SHUDWLRQV� HPEOHP� RQ� LWV� DGYHUWLVHPHQWV����

$OWKRXJK�WKH�SODLQWLII�KDG�DSSDUHQWO\�VROG�ULIOHV�WR�WKH�PLOLWDU\�IRU�XVH�LQ� WKH�6SHFLDO�2SHUDWLRQV�)RUFHV�� D� IHGHUDO� UHJXODWLRQ�SURKLELWV� WKRVH�

��� 6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q�Y��=DIILQD������)��G���������±�����WK�&LU����������� ,G���� ,G� DW��������� 9HURQLFD¶V�$XWR�,QV��6HUY���,QF��Y��9HURQLFD¶V�6HUY���,QF���1R��('&9���±

������''3�������:/����������DW� ���&�'��&DO��'HF��������������,Q�WKH�LQWHUHVW�RI�GLVFORVXUH��WKH�DXWKRU�ZDV�SDUW�RI�WKH�WHDP WKDW�UHSUHVHQWHG�WKH�SODLQWLII���

��� ,G� DW� ����� )1�+HUVWDO��6�$��Y��&O\GH�$UPRU\��,QF���1R������±&9±����������:/�

��������DW� ���0�'��*D��-DQ�������������� ,G� 7KLV�LV�QRW�DFFXUDWH���7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�KDV�H[SUHVVO\�DGRSWHG�WKH�

GHIHQVH��7KH�7HQWK�&LUFXLW�PHQWLRQV�LW�LQ�8QLWHG�3KRVSKRURXV��EXW�WKH�DXWKRULWLHV�LW�FLWHV�WR�GR�QRW�VWDQG�IRU�WKH�SURSRVLWLRQ�RI�D�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH���8QLWHG�3KRVSKRURXV�Y��0LGODQG�)XPLJDQW��,QF�������)��G���������������WK�&LU����������7KH�)HGHUDO�&LUFXLW�FDVH�FLWHG��*UD\�Y��'DII\�'DQ¶V�%DUJDLQWRZQ������)��G�����������)HG��&LU���������LV�QRW�RQ�SRLQW��7KH�SUREOHPV�ZLWK�UHO\LQJ�RQ�8QLWHG�3KRVSKRURXV DQG�'DII\�'DQ¶V WR�VXSSRUW�D�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH�DUH�GLVFXVVHG�LQIUD�6HFWLRQ�,,,�$���D���

��� )1�+HUVWDO�������:/���������DW� �����

Page 28: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŗř

ZKR� FRQWUDFW� ZLWK� 6SHFLDO� 2SHUDWLRQV� &RPPDQG� IURP� GUDZLQJ� WKDW�DVVRFLDWLRQ�ZLWKRXW� SULRU� DXWKRUL]DWLRQ���� +RZHYHU�� WKH� FRXUW� IRXQG�WKDW�WKH�GHIHQGDQW�IDLOHG�WR�HVWDEOLVK�WKDW�WKH�RULJLQDO�FRQWUDFW�EHWZHHQ�WKH� SODLQWLII� DQG� WKH� JRYHUQPHQW� LQFRUSRUDWHG� WKDW� UHJXODWLRQ�� DQG�6SHFLDO� 2SHUDWLRQV� &RPPDQG� DFNQRZOHGJHG� WKDW� WKH� UHJXODWLRQ¶V�DSSOLFDELOLW\� WR� WKH� FRQWUDFW� ZLWK� WKH� SODLQWLII� ZDV� XQFOHDU� ���

$FFRUGLQJO\�� WKH�FRXUW�KHOG�WKDW� WKH�DGYHUWLVHPHQWV�ZHUH�QRW�D�SHU�VH�YLRODWLRQ� RI� IHGHUDO� UHJXODWLRQ���� )XUWKHU�� WKH� FRXUW� IRXQG� WKDW� WKH�YLRODWLRQ�ZDV�LPPDWHULDO��DV�WKHUH�ZDV�QR�FRQVXPHU�SURWHFWLRQ�FRQFHUQ�LPSOLFDWHG����

,Q������� WKH�6RXWKHUQ�'LVWULFW�RI�1HZ�<RUN�ZDV�FRQIURQWHG�ZLWK�WKH�GRFWULQH�LQ�9DQWRQH�*URXS�//&�Y��<DQJSX�1*7�,QGXVWULDO�&R���/WGLQ�WKH�FRQWH[W�RI�FDQFHOODWLRQ�RI�D�UHJLVWUDWLRQ���� 7KH�FRXUW�QRWHG�WKDW�³FRXUWV� ZLWKLQ� WKLV� GLVWULFW´� KDYH� UHFRJQL]HG� WKH� GHIHQVH�� FLWLQJ�'HVVHUW�%HDXW\ DQG�/DQH�&DSLWDO��EXW�GHWHUPLQHG�WKDW�WKH�GRFWULQH�ZDV�QRW� DSSOLFDEOH� ZKHUH� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� KDG� IDLOHG� WR� RIIHU� HYLGHQFH� RI�HLWKHU�D�SULRU�FRXUW�RU�DJHQF\�ILQGLQJ�RU�D�SHU�VH�YLRODWLRQ�RI�D�VWDWXWH�UHJXODWLQJ�WKH�VDOH�RI�D�SDUW\¶V�JRRGV����

F� 6XPPDU\�� WKH� 86372¶V� 'RFWULQH� 9HUVXV� WKH� )HGHUDO�&RXUWV¶�'RFWULQH

7R� VXPPDUL]H�� WKH� 86372¶V� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� DQG� WKH�GRFWULQH�DV�DGRSWHG�E\�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�DUH�VLPLODU�EXW�GLIIHU�LQ�VFRSH�DQG� DSSOLFDWLRQ�� � 8QGHU� WKH� 86372¶V� GRFWULQH�� WKH� SDUW\� FODLPLQJ�XQODZIXO� XVH� PXVW� VKRZ� E\� FOHDU� DQG� FRQYLQFLQJ� HYLGHQFH� WKDW� ����WKHUH�ZDV� DQ� LQVWDQFH�RI�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK� DSSOLFDEOH� IHGHUDO� ODZ������WKH�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�ZDV�PDWHULDO��DQG�����WKHUH�LV�D�QH[XV�EHWZHHQ�WKH�XVH�RI�WKH�PDUN�DQG�WKH�DOOHJHG�YLRODWLRQ���� )XUWKHU��XQODZIXO�XVH�ZLOO� RQO\� EH� IRXQG� LI� WKH� LVVXH� RI� FRPSOLDQFH� KDV� SUHYLRXVO\� EHHQ�GHWHUPLQHG�E\�D�FRXUW�RU�JRYHUQPHQW�DJHQF\��RU�ZKHUH�WKHUH�KDV�EHHQ�D� ³SHU� VH´� YLRODWLRQ� ��� 7KH� 86372¶V� GRFWULQH� DIIHFWV� RQO\�

��� ,G����� ,G���� ,G���� ,G���� 9DQWRQH�*URXS�//&�Y��<DQJSX�1*7�,QGXVWULDO�&R���/WG��������&9��������

�����:/����������DW� ���6�'�1�<��-XO\���������������� ,G��DW� �±����� *HQ��0LOOV��,QF��Y��+HDOWK�9DOOH\�)RRGV�����8�6�3�4��G�����������±���

�7�7�$�%����������� ,G� DW������

Page 29: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŗŚ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

UHJLVWUDWLRQ��QRW�XVH�RI�WKH�PDUN����

2Q�WKH�RWKHU�KDQG��WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�KDYH�QRW�DGRSWHG�D�FRQVLVWHQW�UXOH�� � 7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW KDV� DSSDUHQWO\� DGRSWHG� WKH� UHTXLUHPHQWV� RI�PDWHULDOLW\� DQG� QH[XV�� EXW� QRW� WKH� ³SHU� VH´� UHTXLUHPHQW� �DOWKRXJK� LW�GHFOLQHG� WR� FRQVLGHU� ³XQVXEVWDQWLDWHG´� DOOHJDWLRQV����� 2WKHU� FRXUWV�KDYH�DSSOLHG� WKH�HQWLUH�86372�IUDPHZRUN���� 0RVW� LPSRUWDQWO\�� WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�UXOH�DSSOLHV�LQ�WKH�EURDGHU�FRQWH[W�RI�XVH�RI�D�PDUN��QRW�VLPSO\�UHJLVWUDWLRQ����

,,,� $33/,&$7,21�2)�7+(�81/$:)8/�86(�'2&75,1(�,1�7+(�

)('(5$/�&28576

7KH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV¶�DSSOLFDWLRQ�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�KDV�QRW�EHHQ� ZLWKRXW� FULWLFLVP���� 7KLV� VHFWLRQ H[DPLQHV� VRPH� RI� WKH� PDLQ�TXHVWLRQV�WKDW�DULVH�ZKHQ�PRYLQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�IURP�WKH�86372�WR�WKH�IHGHUDO� FRXUWV�� QDPHO\�� LV� WKHUH� D� KLVWRULFDO� RU� VWDWXWRU\� EDVLV� IRU�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�LQ�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV��DQG�IURP�D�SROLF\�SHUVSHFWLYH��LV�LW�ZLVH�WR�GR�VR"

��� $QQH�*LOVRQ�/D/RQGH��-HURPH�*LOVRQ��7KH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV�6XSSOHPHQWDO�5HJLVWHU��6RODFH��6XEVWDQFH��RU�-XVW�([WLQFW"������75$'(0$5.�5(3� ��������±����������>KHUHLQDIWHU�*LOVRQ@�

��� 6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q�Y��=DIILQD������)��G���������±�����WK�&LU����������� 6HH��H�J���)1�+HUVWDO��6�$��Y��&O\GH�$UPRU\��,QF���1R������±&9±����������

:/���������DW� ����0�'��*D��-DQ������������'HVVHUW�%HDXW\��,QF��Y��)R[������)��6XSS���G�����������6�'�1�<��������

��� $V�QRWHG�DERYH��WKHUH�DUH�PDQ\�EHQHILWV�WR�IHGHUDO�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��RQH�RI�ZKLFK�LV�WKH�DELOLW\�WR�EULQJ�D�IHGHUDO�FDXVH�RI�DFWLRQ�IRU�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW���,W�LV�ZRUWK�QRWLQJ�WKDW�RZQHUV�RI�XQUHJLVWHUHG�PDUNV�PD\�VWLOO�EULQJ�D�IHGHUDO�FDXVH�RI�DFWLRQ�XQGHU�6HFWLRQ����D��RI�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW� ���8�6�&���������D����������+RZHYHU��WKHUH�LV�FXUUHQWO\�VRPH�GLVSXWH�DV�WR�ZKHWKHU�PDUNV�WKDW�ZRXOG�EH�RWKHUZLVH�LQHOLJLEOH�IRU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�DUH�VXEMHFW�WR�SURWHFWLRQ�XQGHU����D���6HH �±��$11(�*,/621�/$/21'(� *,/621�21�75$'(0$5.6 ���������������*LYHQ�WKLVGLVSXWH��LW�LV�EH\RQG�WKH�VFRSH�RI�WKLV�DUWLFOH�WR�HYDOXDWH�ZKHQ�D�XVH�VXEMHFW�WR�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�FRXOG�EH�VXEMHFW�WR�SURWHFWLRQ�XQGHU����D����

��� )RU�H[DPSOH��LQ�KLV�WUHDWLVH�RQ�WUDGHPDUNV�DQG�XQIDLU�FRPSHWLWLRQ��3URIHVVRU�0F&DUWK\�FULWLFL]HG�WKH�&UH$JUL GHFLVLRQ�DV�³XQWKLQNLQJO\�ZUHQFKLQJ�D�GUDFRQLDQ�YHUVLRQ�RI�WKH�8�6�3�7�2�¶V�µXQODZIXO�XVH¶�SROLF\�RXW�RI�LWV�DGPLQLVWUDWLYH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�VHWWLQJ�DQG�LQVHUWLQJ�LW�LQWR�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�LQIULQJHPHQW�ODZVXLWV�´�0&&$57+<� VXSUD�QRWH ��� ����������0F&DUWK\�IXUWKHU�QRWHG�WKDW�WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�DGRSWHG�WKH�GRFWULQH�ZLWKRXW�DGRSWLQJ�WKH�77$%¶V�OLPLWV�WR�WKH�GRFWULQH��QDPHO\��WKDW�XQODZIXO�XVH�LV�IRXQG�RQO\�ZKHUH�WKHUH�LV�D�³SHU�VH´�YLRODWLRQ�RU�DQ�DJHQF\�FRXUW�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ�RI�WKH�VDPH��DQG�WKDW�WKH�³QH[XV´�DQG�³PDWHULDOLW\´�UHTXLUHPHQWV�DUH�DOVR�VDWLVILHG��,G� +H�DOVR�QRWHG�WKDW�WKH�GRFWULQH�FRXOG�UHVXOW�LQ�³VKHOWHU>LQJ@�D�XVH�ZKLFK�ZRXOG�EH�OLNHO\�WR�FRQIXVH�WKH�SXEOLF�´�,G� )LQDOO\��0F&DUWK\�QRWHV�WKDW�WKH�&UH$JUL�GHFLVLRQ�³WXUQV�HYHU\�IHGHUDO�MXGJH�KHDULQJ�D�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�VXLW�LQWR�D�SRWHQWLDO�FROODWHUDO�HQIRUFHU�RI�KXQGUHGV�RI�ODEHOLQJ�DQG�OLFHQVLQJ�ODZV�´�,G�

Page 30: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŗś

$� ,V� 7KHUH� D� +LVWRULFDO� %DVLV� IRU� WKH� 'RFWULQH� LQ� WKH� )HGHUDO�&RXUWV"

:KHQ� WKH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW� DGRSWHG� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� LQ�&UH$JUL�� LW� ORRNHG� WR� WKH� 86372¶V� SROLF\� DQG� WKH� 77$%¶V�MXULVSUXGHQFH� RQ� WKH� LVVXH� ��� 2WKHU� WKDQ� PHQWLRQLQJ� RQH� 7HQWK�&LUFXLW� FDVH� �DV� GLVFXVVHG� LQIUD�� WKLV� FDVH� LV� QRW� VWURQJ�SUHFHGHQW��� LW�GLG�QRW�UHO\�XSRQ�IHGHUDO�FDVH�ODZ�DOWKRXJK�WKHUH�ZHUH�VRPH�FDVHV�WKDW�KDG� GLVFXVVHG� DQG� DGRSWHG� WKH� GRFWULQH� SULRU� WR� �������� +RZHYHU��WKHUH�LV�VRPH�KLVWRULFDO�FDVH�ODZ�EDVLV�IRU�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�

�� 3UH�/DQKDP�$FW�7UHDWPHQW�RI�8QODZIXO�8VH

D� 5HYLHZ�RI�(DUO\�&DVHV

3ULRU�WR�WKH�SDVVDJH�RI�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�LQ�������WUDGHPDUN�ODZ�LQ�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV�ZDV�JRYHUQHG�E\�VHYHUDO�WUDGHPDUN�VWDWXWHV��VRPH�RI�ZKLFK�� RQ� WKHLU� IDFH�� DSSHDUHG� WR� GHDO� H[SUHVVO\� ZLWK� XQODZIXO� XVH���7KH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV¶�ILUVW�WUDGHPDUN�VWDWXWH�ZDV�SDVVHG�LQ�������FUHDWLQJ�D� UHJLVWU\� RI� WUDGHPDUNV� DQG� D� FDXVH� RI� DFWLRQ� IRU� WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW� ��� 7KLV� VWDWXWH� LQFOXGHG� ODQJXDJH� SURKLELWLQJ� WKRVH�

��� &UH$JUL��,QF��Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6HUY���,QF�������)��G���������±�����WK�&LU��������

��� ,G� DW�������)RU�FDVHV�GLVFXVVLQJ�DQG�DGRSWLQJ�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH��VHH��H�J���/DQH�&DSLWDO�0JPW���,QF��Y��/DQH�&DSLWDO�0JPW���,QF������)��6XSS���G�����������6�'�1�<���������DII¶G������)��G�������G�&LU���������VXJJHVWLQJ�WKDW�D�GHIHQGDQW�PLJKW�EH�DEOH�WR�DVVHUW�DQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH�ZLWK�SURSHU�HYLGHQFH���(UYD�3KDUP���,QF��Y��$P��&\DQDPLG�&R�������)��6XSS����������'�3�5���������GHQ\LQJ�D�SHWLWLRQHU�VWDQGLQJ�EHFDXVH�WKH�XVH�RQ�ZKLFK�SHWLWLRQHU�EDVHG�LWV�FODLP�RI�SULRULW\�ZDV�LOOHJDO�XQGHU�WKH�)RRG��'UXJ��DQG�&RVPHWLF�$FW���,QWUDZHVW�)LQ��&RUS��Y��:��1DW¶O�%DQN�RI�'HQYHU������)��6XSS������������'��&ROR���������KROGLQJ�WKDW�WKH�XVH�RI�D�IRUPHU�FKDUWHG�WUDGH�QDPH�RI�D�EDQN�WR�LGHQWLI\�RQH�GLVFUHWH�EDQNLQJ�VHUYLFH�IDLOV�WKH�ODZIXO�XVH�VWDQGDUG��EXW�GHFOLQLQJ�WR�³HVWDEOLVK�D�JHQHUDO�UXOH�GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ�SHUPLVVLEOH�XVH�RI�VHUYLFH�PDUNV�IURP�LPSHUPLVVLEOH�XVH�´��

��� $Q�$FW�WR�5HYLVH��&RQVROLGDWH�DQG�$PHQG�6WDWXWHV�5HODWLQJ�WR�3DWHQWV�DQG�&RS\ULJKWV��FK����������6WDW��������������6HH�DOVR ��/28,6�$/70$1��0$//$�

32//$&.��&$//0$11�21�81)$,5�&203(7,7,21� 75$'(0$5.6� $1'�021232/,(6����� ��WK�HG���������7KH�FDXVH�RI�DFWLRQ�IRU�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�ZDV�ODLG�RXW�DV�IROORZV���³7KDW�DQ\�SHUVRQ�RU�FRUSRUDWLRQ�ZKR�VKDOO�UHSURGXFH��FRXQWHUIHLW��FRS\��RU�LPLWDWH�DQ\�VXFK�UHFRUGHG�WUDGH��PDUN��DQG�DIIL[�WKH�VDPH�WR�JRRGV�RI�VXEVWDQWLDOO\�WKH�VDPH�GHVFULSWLYH�SURSHUWLHV�DQG�TXDOLWLHV�DV�WKRVH�UHIHUUHG�WR�LQ�WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��VKDOO�EH�OLDEOH�WR�DQ�DFWLRQ�LQ�WKH�FDVH�IRU�GDPDJHV�IRU�VXFK�ZURQJIXO�XVH�RI�VDLG�WUDGHPDUN��DW�WKH�VXLW�RI�WKH�RZQHU�WKHUHRI��LQ�DQ\�FRXUW�RI�FRPSHWHQW�MXULVGLFWLRQ�LQ�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV��DQG�WKH�SDUW\�DJJULHYHG�VKDOO�DOVR�KDYH�KLV�UHPHG\�DFFRUGLQJ�WR�WKH�FRXUVH�RI�HTXLW\�WR�HQMRLQ�WKH�ZURQJIXO�XVH�RI�KLV�WUDGH��PDUN�DQG�WR�UHFRYHU�FRPSHQVDWLRQ�WKHUHIRU�LQ�DQ\�FRXUW�KDYLQJ�MXULVGLFWLRQ�RYHU�WKH�SHUVRQ�JXLOW\�RI�VXFK�ZURQJIXO�XVH�´������������6WDW������

Page 31: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŗŜ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

XVLQJ�D�PDUN�³LQ�DQ\�XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV´�IURP�EULQJLQJ�DQ�DFWLRQ�IRU�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW���

>Q@R�DFWLRQ�VKDOO�EH�PDLQWDLQHG�XQGHU�WKH�SURYLVLRQV�RI�WKLV� DFW� E\� DQ\� SHUVRQ� FODLPLQJ� WKH� H[FOXVLYH� ULJKW� WR�DQ\� WUDGH�PDUN� ZKLFK� LV� XVHG� RU� FODLPHG� LQ� DQ\�XQODZIXO� EXVLQHVV�� RU� XSRQ� DQ\� DUWLFOH� ZKLFK� LV�LQMXULRXV� LQ� LWVHOI�� RU� XSRQ� DQ\� WUDGH�PDUN� ZKLFK� KDV�EHHQ� IUDXGXOHQWO\�REWDLQHG��RU�ZKLFK�KDV�EHHQ� IRUPHG�DQG�XVHG�ZLWK�WKH�GHVLJQ�RI�GHFHLYLQJ�WKH�SXEOLF�LQ�WKH�SXUFKDVH�RU�XVH�RI�DQ\�DUWLFOH�RI�PHUFKDQGLVH����

7KH�$FW�RI������ZDV�VKRUW�OLYHG��KRZHYHU��DV� WKH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW�UXOHG� LW�XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDO� MXVW�QLQH�\HDUV� ODWHU� �DV�D� UHVXOW�RI�&RQJUHVV�UHVWLQJ� LWV� DXWKRULW\� XSRQ� WKH� 3DWHQWV� DQG� &RS\ULJKWV� &ODXVH� DV�RSSRVHG�WR�WKH�&RPPHUFH�&ODXVH�����

7ZR� \HDUV� DIWHU� WKH� RULJLQDO� $FW� ZDV� UXOHG� XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDO��&RQJUHVV�SDVVHG�D�WUDGHPDUN�VWDWXWH�EDVHG�XSRQ�LWV�&RPPHUFH�&ODXVH�SRZHU���� 7KLV�$FW�ZDV� IDLUO\� OLPLWHG� LQ� VFRSH�� EXW� VWLOO� UHWDLQHG� WKH�OLPLWDWLRQ�IRU�XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV�LQ�VLPLODU�WHUPV�DV�WKH�RULJLQDO�$FW��

>Q@R� DFWLRQ� RU� VXLW� VKDOO� EH� PDLQWDLQHG� XQGHU� WKH�SURYLVLRQV�RI�WKLV�DFW�LQ�DQ\�FDVH�ZKHQ�WKH�WUDGH��PDUN�LV�XVHG� LQ�DQ\�XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV��RU�XSRQ�DQ\�DUWLFOH�LQMXULRXV� LQ� LWVHOI�� RU� ZKLFK�PDUN� KDV� EHHQ� XVHG�ZLWK�WKH� GHVLJQ� RI� GHFHLYLQJ� WKH� SXEOLF� LQ� WKH� SXUFKDVH� RI�PHUFKDQGLVH�� RU� XQGHU� DQ\� FHUWL¿FDWH� RI� UHJLVWU\�IUDXGXOHQWO\�REWDLQHG����

6LPLODU�ODQJXDJH�ZDV�LQFOXGHG�LQ�WKH�$FW�RI��������� 7KH�$FW�RI��������� ZKLFK� ZDV� ³VXSSRVHG� WR� FRUUHFW� WKH� SUREOHP� RI� $PHULFDQ�

��� ���������6WDW�������HPSKDVLV�DGGHG����� ,Q�UH 7UDGH�0DUN�&DVHV������8�6��������±������������� $Q�$FW�WR�$XWKRUL]H�WKH�5HJLVWUDWLRQ�RI�7UDGH�0DUNV�DQG�WR�3URWHFW�WKH�

6DPH��FK����������6WDW��������������VHH�DOVR $/70$1 32//$&.��VXSUD QRWH����� ������

��� ,G� DW������HPSKDVLV�DGGHG����� $FW�RI�)HE���������������8�6�&��� ������������VHH�DOVR $/70$1 32//$&.��

VXSUD QRWH������� ����� �³7KDW�QR�DFWLRQ�RU�VXLW�VKDOO�EH�PDLQWDLQHG�XQGHU�WKH�SURYLVLRQV�RI�WKLV�DFW�LQ�DQ\�FDVH�ZKHQ�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�LV�XVHG�LQ�XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV��RU�XSRQ�DQ\�DUWLFOH�LQMXULRXV�LQ�LWVHOI��RU�ZKLFK�PDUN�KDV�EHHQ�XVHG�ZLWK�WKH�GHVLJQ�RI�GHFHLYLQJ�WKH�SXEOLF�LQ�WKH�SXUFKDVH�RI�PHUFKDQGLVH��RU�KDV�EHHQ�DEDQGRQHG��RU�XSRQ�DQ\�FHUWL¿FDWH�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�IUDXGXOHQWO\�REWDLQHG�´��

��� $FW�RI�0DU������������3XE��/��1R�������FK���������6WDW��������������$OVR�DYDLODEOH�DW�

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 32: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŗŝ

FLWL]HQV�UHJLVWHULQJ�PDUNV�LQ�IRUHLJQ�FRXQWULHV�´��� PDGH�QR�PHQWLRQ�RI�³XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV�´�

9HU\� IHZ� FDVHV� ZHUH� GHFLGHG� XQGHU� WKH� ³XQODZIXO� EXVLQHVV´�SURYLVLRQV� RI� WKHVH� DFWV���� DOWKRXJK� PDQ\� FDVHV� LQ� WKDW� WLPH� SHULRG�LQYRNHG�WKH�UHODWHG�HTXLWDEOH�GHIHQVH�RI�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV��KH�ZKR�FRPHV�WR� HTXLW\�PXVW� FRPH�ZLWK� FOHDQ�KDQGV²LQ�RWKHU�ZRUGV�� EDG�FRQGXFW�RQ�WKH�SDUW�RI�WKH�SODLQWLII�FRXOG�EH�JURXQGV�IRU�WKH�FRXUW�WR�UHIXVH�WR�JUDQW� WKH�SODLQWLII� UHOLHI��� �7KH�FDVHV�WKDW�ZHUH�GHFLGHG�XQGHU�6HFWLRQ�����KRZHYHU��FRQVWUXHG�LW�QDUURZO\��HVVHQWLDOO\�FRH[WHQVLYHO\�ZLWK�WKH�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�GHIHQVH���

2QH RI�WKH�HDUOLHVW�FDVHV�WR�DSSO\�WKH�SURYLVLRQ��$PHULFDQ�7KHUPRV�%RWWOH� &R�� Y�� :�7�� *UDQW� &R��� DIILUPHG� D� ILQGLQJ� IRU� WKH� GHIHQGDQW�XQGHU�6HFWLRQ����RI� WKH�$FW���� 7KHUH�� WKH�SODLQWLII��ZKR�RZQHG�DQG�XVHG�WKH�PDUN�7+(5026�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�YDFXXP�ERWWOHV��VXHG�D�GHIHQGDQW� ZKR� ZDV� SDVVLQJ� RII� WKH� GHIHQGDQW¶V� ERWWOHV� DV� 7KHUPRV¶�ERWWOHV���� $OO� DFNQRZOHGJHG� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII�ZDV� WKH� RZQHU� RI� WKH�7+(5026�PDUN�DQG�WKDW�WKH�PDUN�ZDV�YDOLG���� 7KH�FRXUW�IRXQG�IRU�WKH� GHIHQGDQW�� KRZHYHU�� EHFDXVH� 7+(5026�ZDV� QRW� LQ� FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�ODEHOLQJ�ODZV�UHTXLULQJ�PDUNLQJ�RI�IRUHLJQ�RULJLQ����

7KH�ODZ�VWDWHG�WKDW�DUWLFOHV�RI�IRUHLJQ�PDQXIDFWXUH�PXVW�EH�PDUNHG�FRQVSLFXRXVO\�ZLWK�WKH�FRXQWU\�RI�RULJLQ��DQG�WKDW�WKLV�PDUNLQJ�VKRXOG�EH�DV�SHUPDQHQW�DV�WKH�QDWXUH�RI�WKH�DUWLFOH�ZRXOG SHUPLW���� 7KHUPRV��KRZHYHU�� ZDV� IRXQG� WR� EH� LQWHQWLRQDOO\� PDUNLQJ� LWV� LPSRUWHG� LWHPV�LQFRQVSLFXRXVO\� DQG� ZLWK� ODEHOV� WKDW� FRXOG� EH� UHPRYHG�� DOO� ZKLOH�DGYHUWLVLQJ� WR� WKH� SXEOLF� WKDW� ³$PHULFDQ�PDGH� JRRGV� IRU� $PHULFDQ�SHRSOH� NHHS� $PHULFDQ� ZRUNPHQ� EXV\�´ ��� 7KH� DSSHOODWH� FRXUW�DIILUPHG�WKH�ORZHU�FRXUW¶V�GHFLVLRQ�QRW�WR�HQIRUFH�7KHUPRV¶�ULJKWV����

,Q�WKH�SURKLELWLRQ�HUD�GLVWULFW�FRXUW�FDVH�$QKHXVHU�%XVFK�Y��&RKHQ��WKH� FRXUW� FRQVWUXHG� 6HFWLRQ� ��� QDUURZO\�� � 7KHUH�� WKH� RZQHU� RI� WKH�

KWWS���LSPDOO�LQIR�KRVWHGBUHVRXUFHV�OLSD�WUDGHPDUNV�3UH/DQKDP$FWB���B$FWBRIB�����KWP��VHH�DOVR $/70$1 32//$&.��VXSUD QRWH������� ������

��� � - 7+20$6�0&&$57+<� 0&&$57+<�21�75$'(0$5.6�$1'�81)$,5�

&203(7,7,21 ��������WK�HG����������� )RU�DGGLWLRQDO�UHYLHZ�RI�SUH�/DQKDP�$FW�FDVHV��VHH ,YHU�3��&RRSHU��

³8QFOHDQ�+DQGV´�DQG�³8QODZIXO�8VH�LQ�&RPPHUFH´��7UDGHPDUNV�$GULIW�RQ�WKH�5HJXODWRU\�7LGH�����75$'(0$5.�5(3� ������������

��� $PHULFDQ�7KHUPRV�%RWWOH�&R��Y��:�7��*UDQW�&R�������)�������������VW�&LU��������

��� ,G���� ,G� DW�������� ,G� DW�������� ,G� DW����±������ ,G� DW������$V�EDFNJURXQG��UHFDOO�WKDW�:RUOG�:DU�,�KDG�HQGHG�MXVW�D�IHZ�\HDUV�

EHIRUH������� ,G� DW�����

Page 33: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŗŞ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

%8':(,6(5� PDUN�� ZKR� ZDV� XVLQJ� WKH PDUN� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK�EDUOH\�PDOW�V\UXS��EURXJKW�VXLW�DJDLQVW�D�SDUW\�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�%8''�:,6(�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�PDOW�VXJDU�V\UXS���� 7KH�GHIHQGDQW�FODLPHG�WKDW� EHFDXVH� WKHUH� ZHUH� QR� OHJLWLPDWH� XVHV� IRU� WKH� %8':(,6(5�SURGXFW�RWKHU�WKDQ�WKH�LOOHJDO�PDQXIDFWXUH�RI�KRPH�EUHZ��WKH�SODLQWLII�FRXOG�QRW�SUHYDLO����

7KH�FRXUW�KHOG�WKDW�VHFWLRQ����ZDV�PHUHO\�D�VWDWHPHQW�RI�WKH�³ORQJ�HVWDEOLVKHG� HTXLWDEOH� SULQFLSOH´� WKDW� LOOHJDO� FRQGXFW� RQ� WKH� SDUW� RI� D�SODLQWLII� PD\� EH� D� GHIHQVH� ��� ,QWHUHVWLQJO\�� WKH� FRXUW� GLVPLVVHG�RXWULJKW�WKH�LGHD�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH�RI�D�PDUN�DV�D�EDU�WR�WKH�GHYHORSPHQW�RI� ULJKWV�� QRWLQJ� WKDW� ³>X@QODZIXO� XVH� RI� D� WUDGH�PDUN� FDQ� JLYH� QR�OLFHQVH�WR�WKH�JHQHUDO�SXEOLF�WR�LQIULQJH�WKDW�WUDGH�PDUN��UHJDUGOHVV�RI�ZKHWKHU�WKH�LQIULQJHPHQW�EH�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK�OHJLWLPDWH�RU�XQODZIXO�WUDGH�´���

7KH� FRXUW� ZHQW� RQ� WR� QRWH� WKDW� ³>W@KH� UHVWULFWLRQ� RQ� DFWLRQV� IRU�LQIULQJHPHQW��FRQWDLQHG�LQ�WKH�SURYLVLRQ�RI�WKH�VWDWXWH�DERYH�TXRWHG��LV�LQWHQGHG� WR�EH� FRQILQHG� WR� VXFK�FDVHV�ZKHUH� WKH� XQODZIXOQHVV�RI� WKH�SODLQWLII¶V� EXVLQHVV� LV� DQ� HVWDEOLVKHG� IDFW�´� DQG� H[SODLQHG� WKDW� PHUH�DOOHJDWLRQV� RI� LOOHJDOLW\� DUH� QRW� VXIILFLHQW���� 7KH� FRXUW� HQMRLQHG� WKH�GHIHQGDQWV� IURP� IXUWKHU� XVH� RI� %8''�:,6(� DQG� DZDUGHG� GDPDJHV�DQG� SURILWV� ��� 7KLV� UHTXLUHPHQW� WKDW� WKH� XQODZIXOQHVV� EH� DQ�HVWDEOLVKHG�IDFW�ZDV�SUHVFLHQW�RI�WKH�77$%¶V�ODWHU�DGRSWLRQ�RI�WKH�³SHU�VH´�UHTXLUHPHQW�IRU�XQODZIXO�XVH���

,Q�������WKH�6HFRQG�&LUFXLW�UHYLHZHG�WKH�FDVH�ODZ�RQ�WKH�LVVXH�LQ�UXOLQJ� RQ� D� FDVH� LQYROYLQJ� 752-$1� EUDQG� FRQGRPV���� 7KHUH�� WKH�SODLQWLII� FRQWUDFHSWLYH� PDQXIDFWXUHU� VRXJKW� UHOLHI� LQ� WKH� FRXUWV� IRU�WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW�� EXW� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� UDLVHG� WKH� ³XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV´� GHIHQVH�� DV� FRQGRPV� ZHUH� DW� WKH� WLPH� LOOHJDO� XQOHVV�SUHVFULEHG� E\� D� SK\VLFLDQ���� 7KH� GHIHQGDQW� SUHVHQWHG� HYLGHQFH� WKDW�WKH� SODLQWLII� ZDV� DZDUH� RI� LOOHJDO� UHVDOH� RI� LWV� SURGXFWV�� WKRXJK� WKH�SODLQWLII�ZDV�QRW�UHVHOOLQJ�WKH�FRQWUDFHSWLYHV�WKHPVHOYHV����

7KH�FRXUW� WKRURXJKO\�UHYLHZHG� WKH�³XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV´�SURYLVLRQ�RI� WKH� $FW�� ILQGLQJ�� DV� $QKHXVHU�%XVFK KDG� IRXQG�� WKDW� ³VHFWLRQ� ���JLYHV� D� GHIHQGDQW� LQ� HTXLW\� QR� QHZ� RU� JUHDWHU� GHIHQVH´� WKDQ� WKH�

��� $QKHXVHU�%XVFK��,QF���Y��&RKHQ�����)��G�����������'��0G����������� ,G� DW����±������� ,G� DW�������� ,G���� ,G���� ,G� DW���������� <RXQJV�5XEEHU�&RUS���,QF��Y��&�,��/HH��&R������)��G�������G�&LU������������� ,G� DW ���±������ 6HH�LG� DW����

Page 34: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŗş

DOUHDG\�H[LVWLQJ� HTXLWDEOH� GHIHQVH� RI� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� ��� 7KH� FRXUW�LPSRVHG� ZKDW� ZRXOG� WRGD\� EH� FDOOHG� D� QH[XV� UHTXLUHPHQW� �DOVR� D�UHTXLUHPHQW� RI� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV��� QRWLQJ� WKDW� ³>Q@XPHURXV� FDVHV� KDYH�KHOG� WKDW� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKH�6KHUPDQ�$FW� GRHV� QRW� EDU� D� SODLQWLII� IURP�HQMRLQLQJ�DQ�LQIULQJHU�RI�KLV�WUDGH�PDUN«´�����LQ�RWKHU�ZRUGV��JHQHUDO�LOOHJDOLW\� RU� LPSURSHU� FRQGXFW� LV� QRW� VXIILFLHQW�� ³WKH� WDLQW� WKDW� LV�UHJDUGHG�PXVW�DIIHFW�WKH�SDUWLFXODU�ULJKWV�DVVHUWHG�LQ�KLV�VXLW´�DQG�QRW�PHUHO\�³DIIHFW>@�WKH�GHIHQGDQW�RQO\�DV�LW�GRHV�WKH�SXEOLF�DW�ODUJH�´���

6SHFLILFDOO\��WKH�FRXUW�QRWHG���

,Q�WKH�FDVH�EHIRUH�XV�WKH�SODLQWLII�KDV�D�YDOLG�WUDGH�PDUN�DQG� XQGHU� JHQHUDO� HTXLWDEOH� SULQFLSOHV� LV� HQWLWOHG� WR�SURWHFW�LWV�VDOHV��VR�IDU�DV�WKH\�DUH�OHJDO��DJDLQVW�XQIDLU�FRPSHWLWLRQ� E\� SLUDF\� RI� WKH� PDUN�� � ,Q� RXU� RSLQLRQ�VHFWLRQ����JLYHV�D�GHIHQGDQW�LQ�HTXLW\�QR�QHZ�RU�JUHDWHU�GHIHQVH�� � ,I� WKH� GHIHQGDQWV¶� XQIDLU� FRPSHWLWLRQ� ZHUH�VKRZQ� WR� GHSULYH� WKH� SODLQWLII� RI� WKH� RSSRUWXQLW\� WR�PDNH� RQO\� VDOHV�ZKLFK�ZHUH� LOOHJDO�� D� FRXUW� RI� HTXLW\�PLJKW�SURSHUO\�UHIXVH�UHOLHI«�

«� ,I�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� SODLQWLII�ZHUH� VHOOLQJ� GLUHFW� WR� WKH�SXEOLF�ZLWKRXW� D� SK\VLFLDQ¶V� SUHVFULSWLRQ�� LW� FRXOG� QRW�FRPSODLQ� EHFDXVH� GHIHQGDQWV� E\�PDNLQJ� VLPLODU� VDOHV�XQGHU� SLUDF\ RI� SODLQWLII¶V� WUDGH� PDUN� GHSULYHG� LW� RI�VXFK�LOOHJDO�EXVLQHVV����

+RZHYHU��WKH�FRXUW�OLPLWHG�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�UHFRYHU\�WR�RQO\�WKRVH�VDOHV�³LW�PLJKW�OHJDOO\�KDYH�PDGH�´���

E� 'R�7KHVH�(DUO\�&DVHV�3URYLGH�6XSSRUW�IRU�WKH�0RGHUQ�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH"

$V� QRWHG� DERYH�� WKH� HDUOLHVW� WUDGHPDUN� VWDWXWHV� LQ� 8QLWHG� 6WDWHV�KLVWRU\�VSHFLILFDOO\�FRQWHPSODWHG�WKDW�WKRVH�XVLQJ�PDUNV�³LQ�XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV´�ZRXOG� EH� XQDEOH� WR� EULQJ� DQ� DFWLRQ�� QRW� VLPSO\� XQDEOH� WR�UHJLVWHU���� $OWKRXJK�³XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV´�RQ�LWV�IDFH�VRXQGV�DV�WKRXJK�LW�FRXOG�EH�OLPLWHG�WR�VRPHRQH�XVLQJ�D�PDUN�LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�JRRGV�

��� ,G� DW���������� ,G� DW���������� ,G� DW���������� ,G� DW��������� ,G������ ,G� DW������

Page 35: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŘŖ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

RU� VHUYLFHV� WKDW� DUH� DFWXDOO\� LOOHJDO� �H�J��� LOOHJDO� GUXJV��� RQH� RI� WKH�HDUOLHVW� FDVHV� GHFLGHG�XQGHU� WKH� ³XQODZIXO� EXVLQHVV´� SURYLVLRQ� ORRNV�UHPDUNDEO\� OLNH�FXUUHQW�FDVH�ODZ�UHIXVLQJ�WR�HQIRUFH�ULJKWV� LQ�D�PDUN�EDVHG� RQ� YLRODWLRQV� RI� WKH� )'&$� RU� RWKHU� VWDWXWHV�� � ,Q� $PHULFDQ�7KHUPRV�� WKH� FRXUW� UHIXVHG� WR� DOORZ� D� SODLQWLII� WR� HQIRUFH� LWV� ULJKWV�DJDLQVW�DQ�LQIULQJLQJ��MXQLRU�XVHU�GHIHQGDQW�ZKHUH�WKH�SODLQWLII�KDG�QRW�FRPSOLHG�ZLWK�ODEHOLQJ�ODZV�UHJDUGLQJ�PDUNLQJ�RI�FRXQWU\�RI�RULJLQ����

,Q� IDLUQHVV�� WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� DSSDUHQW� GHVLUH� WR�PLVOHDG� FRQVXPHUV� LQWR�EHOLHYLQJ� WKDW� LWV� SURGXFWV� ZHUH� $PHULFDQ�PDGH� SOD\HG� LQWR� WKH�FRXUW¶V�GHFLVLRQ��EXW�WKH�IDFW�UHPDLQV�WKDW�WKH�EXVLQHVV��VHOOLQJ�YDFXXP�ERWWOHV��ZDV�QRW�LWVHOI�LOOHJDO���� 7KH�FRXUW�FRXOG�KDYH�VLPSO\�IRFXVHG�RQ� WKH� IDFW� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII� ZDV� DWWHPSWLQJ� WR� PLVOHDG� FRQVXPHUV��UHJDUGOHVV� RI� RWKHU� VWDWXWHV�� DWWHPSWLQJ� WR� PLVOHDG� FRQVXPHUV� FDQ�YLWLDWH� WUDGHPDUN� ULJKWV� RQ� LWV� RZQ�� HLWKHU� YLD� WKH� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV�GRFWULQH�RU�XQGHU� WKH� UHOHYDQW� WUDGHPDUN�VWDWXWH�� �+RZHYHU�� WKH�FRXUW�LQVWHDG�ZHQW� WKURXJK� WKH� HIIRUW� RI� LGHQWLI\LQJ� WKH� ODEHOLQJ� VWDWXWH� DW�LVVXH�DQG�SRLQWLQJ�RXW�KRZ�WKH�SODLQWLII�KDG�QRW�FRPSOLHG����

7KLV�LQGLFDWHV�WKDW�IURP�DQ�HDUO\�WLPH��FRXUWV�VRPHWLPHV�FRQVWUXHG�WKH� XQODZIXO� EXVLQHVV� SURYLVLRQV� RI� WKH� RULJLQDO� WUDGHPDUN� DFWV� WR�LQFOXGH� QRW� MXVW�PDUNV� XVHG� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� XQODZIXO� JRRGV� DQG�VHUYLFHV�� EXW� DOVR� D� IDLOXUH� E\� D� ODZIXO� EXVLQHVV� WR� FRPSO\� ZLWK�VWDQGDUGV�DQG�UHJXODWLRQV�VXFK�DV�ODEHOLQJ�UHTXLUHPHQWV���1HYHUWKHOHVV��WKH� H[LVWHQFH� RI� WKHVH� FDVHV� LV� QRW� QHFHVVDULO\� HYLGHQFH� RI� DQ� HDUO\�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�DV�ZH�NQRZ�LW� WRGD\�� �(DFK�RI� WKH�FDVHV� OLNHO\�FRXOG�KDYH�UHDFKHG�WKH�VDPH�UHVXOW�RQ�WKH�EDVLV�RI�WKH�³XQFOHDQ�KDQGV´�GRFWULQH� DORQH�� DQG� LQGHHG� VHYHUDO� RI� WKH� FDVHV� H[SOLFLWO\� FRQVWUXHG�6HFWLRQ� ��� DV� DQ� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� SURYLVLRQ�� � )URP� WKH� HDUOLHVW� WLPHV��FRXUWV� URXWLQHO\� UHIXVHG� WR� HQIRUFH� WKH� DVVHUWHG� ULJKWV� RI� SODLQWLIIV�EDVHG�XSRQ�WKH�SODLQWLIIV¶�RZQ�PLVFRQGXFW����

+LVWRULFDO� FDVHV� DUH� OHVV� FOHDU� DERXW� WKH� LVVXH� RI� GHYHORSPHQW RI�

��� $PHULFDQ�7KHUPRV�%RWWOH�&R��Y��:�7��*UDQW�&R�������)����������±�����VW�&LU��������

��� ,G��DW�������� ,G���� ,Q�DGGLWLRQ�WR�WKH�DERYH�FLWHG�FDVHV��VHH 0DQKDWWDQ�0HG��&R��Y��:RRG������

8�6��������������������7KHUH��WKH�FRXUW�QRWHG�WKDW��,I� >SODLQWLIIV@� FODLP� UHOLHI� DJDLQVW� WKH� IUDXGV� RI� RWKHUV�� WKH\�PXVW�WKHPVHOYHV�EH� IUHH� IURP� WKH� LPSXWDWLRQ�� ,I� WKH� VDOHV�PDGH�E\� WKH�SODLQWLII� DQG� KLV� ILUP� DUH� HIIHFWHG�� RU� VRXJKW� WR� EH�� E\�PLVUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ�DQG� IDOVHKRRG�� WKH\�FDQQRW�EH� OLVWHQHG� WR�ZKHQ�WKH\� FRPSODLQ� WKDW�� E\� WKH� IUDXGXOHQW� ULYDOU\�RI� RWKHUV�� WKHLU� RZQ�IUDXGXOHQW� SURILWV� DUH� GLPLQLVKHG�� $Q� H[FOXVLYH� SULYLOHJH� IRU�GHFHLYLQJ�WKH�SXEOLF�LV�DVVXUHGO\�QRW�RQH�WKDW�D�FRXUW�RI�HTXLW\�FDQ�EH� UHTXLUHG� WR� DLG� RU� VDQFWLRQ�� 7R� GR� VR� ZRXOG� EH� WR� IRUIHLW� LWV�QDPH�DQG�FKDUDFWHU�

Page 36: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŘŗ

ULJKWV� �DV�RSSRVHG� WR�PHUHO\� WKH�HQIRUFHPHQW�RI� ULJKWV��EDVHG�RQ� WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�RI�D�PDUN�� �7KLV�GLVWLQFWLRQ�LV� LPSRUWDQW�� LI� WKH�GRFWULQH�SUHYHQWV� WKH� GHYHORSPHQW RI� ULJKWV�� D� MXQLRU� XVHU� FDQ� ZLQ� DQ�LQIULQJHPHQW� ODZVXLW� DJDLQVW� WKH� VHQLRU� �XQODZIXO�� XVHU�� IRUFLQJ� WKH�VHQLRU�XVHU�WR�VWRS�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�DOWRJHWKHU���� ,I�WKH�GRFWULQH�VLPSO\�SUHYHQWV� WKH� HQIRUFHPHQW RI� ULJKWV�� WKH� UHVXOW� LV� WKDW� WKH� VHQLRU��XQODZIXO��XVHU�FDQQRW�ZLQ�DQ�LQIULQJHPHQW� ODZVXLW�DJDLQVW�WKH�MXQLRU�XVHU�� WKH� VHQLRU� XVHU� PD\� QRW� EH� DEOH� WR� HQIRUFH�� EXW� KH� LV� DEOH� WR�FRQWLQXH� XVLQJ� WKH�PDUN���� +H�PD\� DOVR� EH� DEOH� WR� HQIRUFH� DJDLQVW�IXWXUH�XVHUV�RQFH�KH�LV�LQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�WKH�ODZ����

7KH�$QKHXVHU�%XVFK FRXUW� QRWHG� WKDW� ³>X@QODZIXO� XVH� RI� D� WUDGH�PDUN�FDQ�JLYH�QR� OLFHQVH� WR� WKH�JHQHUDO�SXEOLF� WR� LQIULQJH� WKDW� WUDGH�PDUN�� UHJDUGOHVV� RI� ZKHWKHU� WKH� LQIULQJHPHQW� EH� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK�OHJLWLPDWH� RU� XQODZIXO� WUDGH�� � ,I� WKH� SODLQWLII� LV� LQ� IDFW� YLRODWLQJ� WKH�FULPLQDO�ODZ��KH�FDQ�EH SXQLVKHG�LQ�WKH�SURSHU�IRUXP�´��� 7KLV�ZRXOG�VHHP�WR�LQGLFDWH�WKDW�ULJKWV�FDQ�GHYHORS�GHVSLWH�XQODZIXO�XVH��L�H���WKDW�RQH¶V�SULRULW\�RI�XVH�GDWH�LV�QRW�DIIHFWHG�E\�ZKHWKHU�WKH�XVH�ZDV�ODZIXO�DW� WKH� WLPH�� � ,W¶V� DOVR�ZRUWK� QRWLQJ� WKDW� WKH� LVVXH� LQ� WKLV� FDVH ZDV� D�EXVLQHVV� WKDW� ZDV� DFWXDOO\� XQODZIXO±DOFRKRO�UHODWHG� SURGXFWV� GXULQJ�SURKLELWLRQ±DV�RSSRVHG�WR�D�PHUH�ODEHOLQJ�YLRODWLRQ���,Q�DQRWKHU�FDVH��KRZHYHU��D�FRXUW�KHOG�WKDW�VDOHV�PDGH�ZLWKRXW�D�OLFHQVH�GLG�QRW�FRXQW�WRZDUG�HVWDEOLVKLQJ�SULRULW\�RI�XVH���� WKLV�ZRXOG�VHHP�WR�LQGLFDWH�WKDW�SULRULW\�RI�XVH�ZDV�DIIHFWHG�E\�ZKHWKHU�WKH�XVH�ZDV�ODZIXO�RU�QRW����

$OWKRXJK�WKH�FRQFHSW�RI�GHQ\LQJ�WKH�DELOLW\�WR�HQIRUFH�ULJKWV�EDVHG�RQ�D�WUDGHPDUN�RZQHU¶V�PLVFRQGXFW�LV�DV�ROG�DV�WUDGHPDUN�ODZ�LWVHOI����

LW� LV� OHVV� FOHDU� ZKHWKHU� WKHVH� ROGHU� FDVHV� VSHFLILFDOO\� FRQWHPSODWH� D�FKDQJH�LQ�SULRULW\�RI�XVH�EDVHG�RQ�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�UHJXODWLRQV�

�� 8QODZIXO�8VH�8QGHU�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW

7KH� /DQKDP�$FW� ZDV� SDVVHG� LQ� ����� DQG� UHSHDOHG� WKH� SUHYLRXV�WUDGHPDUN� DFWV� ��� ,QWHUHVWLQJO\�� GHVSLWH� WKH� H[SOLFLW� SURKLELWLRQ�

��� ,G� �HPSKDVLV�DGGHG������ $QKHXVHU�%XVFK��,QF���Y��&RKHQ�����)��G�����������'��0G���������HPSKDVLV�

DGGHG������ ,G���� ,G���� -DFNPDQ�Y��&DOYHUW�'LVWLOOHUV�&RUS������1�(��G�����������0DVV����������� ,G��)URP�D�SUDFWLFDO�VWDQGSRLQW��D�NH\�GLVWLQFWLRQ�EHWZHHQ�WKHVH�FDVHV�LV�WKDW�

%XGZHLVHU�KDG�ULJKWV�SULRU�WR�SURKLELWLRQ�DQG�ZDV�VHHNLQJ�WR�PDLQWDLQ�WKRVH�ULJKWV�GXULQJ�SURKLELWLRQ��&DOYHUW�PDGH�KLV�ILUVW�VDOHV�RI�ZKLVNH\�GXULQJ�SURKLELWLRQ�ZKHQ�WKH\�FRXOG�QRW�KDYH�EHHQ�ODZIXO�

��� 6HH��H�J���0DQKDWWDQ�0HG��&R��Y��:RRG������8�6���������������� 6HH 0&&$57+<� VXSUD�QRWH���� $SSHQGL[�$��7LWOH�;,�

Page 37: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŘŘ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

DJDLQVW�XVH�LQ�³XQODZIXO�EXVLQHVV´�LQ�ERWK�WKH������DQG�WKH������$FW��&RQJUHVV�LQFOXGHG�QR�VLPLODU�SURYLVLRQ���

,QGHHG�� DOWKRXJK� WKH�/DQKDP�$FW� UHTXLUHV� ³XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH´� WR�UHJLVWHU� D�PDUN�� ³ODZIXO� XVH´� LV� RQO\�PHQWLRQHG� WZLFH���� 6HFWLRQ� ��PDNHV�PHQWLRQ� RI� D� ³ODZIXO´� XVH� UHTXLUHPHQW� RQO\� LQ�6HFWLRQ� ��G�¶V�FRQFXUUHQW�XVH�SURYLVLRQ��ZKHUH�LW�VWDWHV�WKDW��

>,@I�WKH�'LUHFWRU�GHWHUPLQHV�WKDW�FRQIXVLRQ��PLVWDNH��RU�GHFHSWLRQ�LV�QRW�OLNHO\�WR�UHVXOW�IURP�WKH�FRQWLQXHG�XVH�E\�PRUH�WKDQ�RQH�SHUVRQ�RI� WKH�VDPH�RU�VLPLODU�PDUNV�XQGHU�FRQGLWLRQV�DQG�OLPLWDWLRQV�DV�WR�WKH�PRGH�RU�SODFH�RI� XVH� RI� WKH�PDUNV� RU� WKH� JRRGV� RQ� RU� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK� ZKLFK� VXFK� PDUNV� DUH� XVHG�� FRQFXUUHQW�UHJLVWUDWLRQV�PD\�EH� LVVXHG� WR�VXFK�SHUVRQV�ZKHQ� WKH\�KDYH�EHFRPH� HQWLWOHG� WR�XVH� VXFK�PDUNV�DV� D� UHVXOW� RI�WKHLU FRQFXUUHQW� ODZIXO� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH SULRU� WR� ����WKH� HDUOLHVW� RI� WKH� ILOLQJ� GDWHV� RI� WKH� DSSOLFDWLRQV�SHQGLQJ�RU�RI�DQ\�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�LVVXHG�XQGHU�WKLV�FKDSWHU����������

7KH�RQO\�RWKHU�SODFH�ZKHUH�VXFK�D�UHTXLUHPHQW�LV�PHQWLRQHG�LV�LQ�WKH�6XSSOHPHQWDO�5HJLVWHU�SURYLVLRQV�RI����8�6�&���������� 7KHUH��WKH�$FW�VWDWHV�WKDW�³>D@OO�PDUNV�FDSDEOH�RI�GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ�DSSOLFDQWV�JRRGV�RU�VHUYLFHV�DQG�QRW�UHJLVWUDEOH�RQ�WKH�SULQFLSDO�UHJLVWHU�SURYLGHG�LQ�WKLV�FKDSWHU�������ZKLFK�DUH�LQ�ODZIXO�XVH�LQ�FRPPHUFH E\�WKH�RZQHU�WKHUHRI�������PD\�EH�UHJLVWHUHG�RQ�WKH�VXSSOHPHQWDO�UHJLVWHU�������´�DQG�JRHV�RQ�WR�VD\�WKDW��

>Q@RWKLQJ�LQ�WKLV�VHFWLRQ�VKDOO�SUHYHQW�WKH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RQ�WKH� VXSSOHPHQWDO� UHJLVWHU� RI� D� PDUN�� FDSDEOH� RI�GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ�WKH�DSSOLFDQWV�JRRGV�RU�VHUYLFHV�DQG�QRW�UHJLVWUDEOH�RQ� WKH�SULQFLSDO� UHJLVWHU�XQGHU� WKLV�FKDSWHU��WKDW� LV� GHFODUHG� WR� EH� XQUHJLVWUDEOH� XQGHU� VHFWLRQ������H�����RI�WKLV�WLWOH��LI�VXFK�PDUN�KDV�EHHQ�LQ�ODZIXO�XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� E\� WKH� RZQHU� WKHUHRI�� RQ� RU� LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� DQ\� JRRGV� RU� VHUYLFHV�� VLQFH� EHIRUH�'HFHPEHU������������

��� 6HH�JHQHUDOO\ ���8�6�&���������G������������ ���8�6�&���������G����������HPSKDVLV�DGGHG����� ���8�6�&������������������� ,G� �HPSKDVLV�DGGHG���WKHUH�LV�RQH�RWKHU�PHQWLRQ�RI�WKH�WHUP�³ODZIXO´�LQ�WKH�

/DQKDP�$FW���7KLV�LV�LQ�WKH�FRQWH[W�RI�F\EHUSLUDF\��SURYLGLQJ�D�VDIH�KDUERU�ZKHUH�D�UHJLVWUDQW�³EHOLHYHG�DQG�KDG�UHDVRQDEOH�JURXQGV�WR�EHOLHYH�WKDW�WKH�XVH�RI�WKH�GRPDLQ�

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 38: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŘř

+RZHYHU�� WKH� FRXUWV� LQWHUSUHWLQJ� WKHVH� SURYLVLRQV� KDYH� QRW�H[DPLQHG�ZKHWKHU�WKH�XVH�LV�³ODZIXO´�LQ�WKH�VHQVH�RI�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�WKH�XQLYHUVH�RI�ODZV��EXW�LQVWHDG�³ODZIXO´�ZLWK�UHVSHFW�WR�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW¶V� RZQ� SURYLVLRQV�� � )RU� H[DPSOH�� LQ� GLVFXVVLQJ� WKH� FRQFXUUHQW�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�SURYLVLRQV��RQH�FRXUW�QRWHG�WKDW�³>D@�µODZIXO�XVH¶�LV�WKH�XVH�RI� D� PDUN� LQ� FRQQHFWLRQ� ZLWK� JRRGV� DQG� VHUYLFHV� LQ� D� WHUULWRU\� QRW�FRYHUHG� E\� DQRWKHU� SDUW\¶V� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�´ ��� /LNHZLVH�� LQ� WKH�VXSSOHPHQWDO�UHJLVWHU�FRQWH[W��³ODZIXO�XVH´�KDV�ODUJHO\�EHHQ�FRQVWUXHG�DV�³H[FOXVLYH�XVH�´���

2QH�OLNHO\�SODFH�IRU�D�PHQWLRQ�RI�VXFK�D�UHTXLUHPHQW�ZRXOG�EH�LQ�WKH�GHILQLWLRQV�VHFWLRQ�RI�WKH�$FW���1HYHUWKHOHVV��QR�PHQWLRQ�RI�ODZIXO�XVH�LV�SUHVHQW���³8VH�LQ�FRPPHUFH´�LV�GHILQHG�DV�³WKH�ERQD�ILGH�XVH�RI�D�PDUN�LQ�WKH�RUGLQDU\�FRXUVH�RI�WUDGH��DQG�QRW�PDGH�PHUHO\�WR�UHVHUYH�D� ULJKW� LQ� D� PDUN�´ ��� $OWKRXJK� ³FRPPHUFH´� LV� GHILQHG� DV� ³DOO�FRPPHUFH�ZKLFK�PD\�EH�ODZIXOO\�UHJXODWHG�E\�&RQJUHVV�´�WKLV�ZRXOG�DSSHDU�WR�EH�D�UHVWULFWLRQ�XSRQ�ZKDW�FDQ�EH�UHJXODWHG��QRW�D�UHVWULFWLRQ�RQ�WKH�ULJKWV�RI�PDUN�RZQHUV����

$V� GLVFXVVHG� DERYH�� RQH� 77$%� PHPEHU� ZDV� VNHSWLFDO� RI� WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�SURYLGLQJ�D�EDVLV�IRU�D�ODZIXO�XVH�UHTXLUHPHQW��QRWLQJ�WKDW�³>D@ YHU\� SHUVXDVLYH� DUJXPHQW� FDQ� EH� PDGH� IRU� WKH� SURSRVLWLRQ� WKDW�WKHUH�LV�LQ�IDFW�QR�VWDWXWRU\�EDVLV�IRU�UHIXVLQJ�WR�JUDQW�D�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��RU�IRU� FDQFHOOLQJ� D� VXEVLVWLQJ� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� RQ� WKH� JURXQG� RI� µXQODZIXO�XVH�´��� 7KH�PHPEHU�SRLQWHG�RXW� WKDW� WKH�FDVH� WKDW�JDYH�ELUWK� WR� WKH�SUDFWLFH�RI�GRLQJ�VR�FODLPHG�QR�VWDWXWRU\�EDVLV��DQG�WKDW�³LQDVPXFK�DV�WKH�WHUP�µODZIXO¶�LV�VSHFLILFDOO\�XVHG�LQ�FHUWDLQ�VHFWLRQV�RI�WKH�6WDWXWH��WKH�VXJJHVWLRQ�WKDW�WKLV�WHUP�VKRXOG�EH�UHDG�LQWR�WKRVH�VHFWLRQV�ZKHUH�LW� LV� QRW� XVHG� ZRXOG� DSSHDU� WR� EH� D� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKH� EDVLF� UXOHV� RI�VWDWXWRU\� FRQVWUXFWLRQ�´ ��� )XUWKHU�� VKH� QRWHG�� ZLWK� UHVSHFW� WR� WKH�VWDWXWRU\� LQWHQW� WR�PDNH� DFWLRQDEOH� GHFHSWLYH� DQG�PLVOHDGLQJ� XVHV� RI�PDUNV��³WKH�IDFW�WKDW�D�SURGXFW�ODEHO��IRU�H[DPSOH��LV�QRW�LQ�FRPSOLDQFH�

QDPH�ZDV�D�IDLU�XVH�RU�RWKHUZLVH�ODZIXO´���VHH����8�6�&���������G�����%��LL���*LOVRQ��VXSUD QRWH������DW�����

��� )OHPLQJ�&RV���,QF��Y��7KULIWZD\��,QF�������)��6XSS����������6�'��2KLR��������VHH�DOVR *LOVRQ��VXSUD QRWH������DW�����

��� *LOVRQ��VXSUD QRWH������DW���������� ���8�6�&������������������7KH�GHILQLWLRQ�RI�³XVH�LQ�FRPPHUFH´�ZDV�DPHQGHG�

WR�LQFOXGH�WKLV�ODQJXDJH�LQ�������³WR�HOLPLQDWH�µWRNHQ�XVH¶�DV�D�EDVLV�IRU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�´�6HH &KDQFH�Y��3DF�7HO�7HOHWUDF�,QF�������)��G��������������WK�&LU��������

��� ���8�6�&������������������� 6DWLQLQH�6RFLHWD�LQ�1RPH�&ROOHWWLYR�GL�6�$��H�0��8VHOOLQL�Y��3�$�%��3URGXLWV�

HW�$SSDUHLOV�GH�%HDXWH������8�6�3�4�����������Q����7�7�$�%���������/HINRZLW]��0HPEHU��FRQFXUULQJ���

��� ,G�

Page 39: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŘŚ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

ZLWK� D� UHJXODWRU\� VWDWXWH� SHUWDLQLQJ� WKHUHWR� GRHV� QRW� PHDQ� WKDW� WKH�PDUN�DSSOLHG�WR� WKH�JRRGV�LV�EHLQJ�XVHG�LQ�D�GHFHSWLYH�RU�PLVOHDGLQJ�PDQQHU� EXW� UDWKHU� RQO\� WKDW� WKH� ODEHO� PD\� EH� GHFHSWLYH� RU�PLVOHDGLQJ�´��� $QRWKHU�PHPEHU��KRZHYHU��SRLQWHG�RXW�WKDW�³LW�ZRXOG�EH�ZKROO\� FRQWUDGLFWRU\� WR� UHTXLUH� µODZIXO� XVH¶� IRU� DQ� DSSOLFDWLRQ� WR�UHJLVWHU� D� PDUN� XSRQ� WKH� 6XSSOHPHQWDO� 5HJLVWHU� EXW� QRW� WR� UHTXLUH�µODZIXO� XVH¶� IRU� DQ� DSSOLFDWLRQ� WR� UHJLVWHU� D�PDUN� XSRQ� WKH�3ULQFLSDO�5HJLVWHU��ZKLFK�FRQIHUV�PXFK�JUHDWHU�ULJKWV�XSRQ�WKH�UHJLVWUDQW�´���

$V� VXFK�� WKH� /DQKDP� $FW²ZKLOH� LW� GRHV� QRW� FOHDUO\� SHUPLW� WKH�GHYHORSPHQW� RI� ULJKWV� EDVHG� RQ� XQODZIXO� XVH²GRHV� QRW� FOHDUO\�SURKLELW�WKHP�HLWKHU�

�� 3UH�&UH$JUL�)HGHUDO�&DVH�/DZ

$V�QRWHG�DERYH��D�KDQGIXO�RI�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�FDVHV�KDG�DGGUHVVHG�WKH�XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� LQ� VRPH� PDQQHU� SULRU� WR� WKH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW¶V�DGRSWLRQ� RI� LW� LQ� &UH$JUL�� DOWKRXJK� WKH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW� GLG� QRW�DFNQRZOHGJH� PRVW� RI� WKHVH� FDVHV� LQ� LWV� RSLQLRQ���� 6RPH� RI� WKHVH�FDVHV�DUH�GLVFXVVHG�EHORZ�

D� 8QLWHG� 3KRVSKRUXV� DQG� 'DII\� 'DQ¶V�� 7KH� 3UHFHGHQWV�7KDW�$UHQ¶W

7KH�RQH� IHGHUDO� FDVH� WKDW� WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW� FLWHG� LQ�&UH$JUL ZDV�8QLWHG� 3KRVSKRURXV� /WG�� Y�� 0LGODQG� )XPLJDQW� ,QF� ��� 7KHUH�� WKH�7HQWK� &LUFXLW� DIILUPHG� D� GLVWULFW� FRXUW¶V� GHFLVLRQ� QRW� WR� JLYH� DQ�XQODZIXO� XVH� MXU\� LQVWUXFWLRQ� ZKHUH� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� KDG� ³IDLOHG� WR�SUHVHQW�RQH�SLHFH�RI�HYLGHQFH�DW�WULDO�WHQGLQJ�WR�VKRZ�8QLWHG¶V�SURGXFW�ZDV�VROG�RU�GLVWULEXWHG�LOOHJDOO\�´��� 5HO\LQJ�RQ����8�6�&����������WKH�GHILQLWLRQV�VHFWLRQ�RI�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW���'DII\�'DQ¶V �D�)HGHUDO�&LUFXLW�FDVH�GLVFXVVHG�EHORZ��DQG�D������77$%�GHFLVLRQ���� WKH�FRXUW�QRWHG�WKDW�LW�ZDV�D�FRUUHFW�VWDWHPHQW�RI�WKH�ODZ�WKDW�³LQ�RUGHU�WR�REWDLQ�ULJKWV�LQ� WKH�4XLFN�3KRV� WUDGHPDUN�� 8QLWHG� QHHGHG� WR� VKRZ� WKDW� WKH� QDPH�ZDV� ODZIXOO\�XVHG� LQ�FRPPHUFH�´��� 7KH�FRXUW�GLG�QRW�H[SDQG�RQ�LWV�DQDO\VLV�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�GRFWULQH���

1RQH� RI� WKH� FLWHG� DXWKRULWLHV� VHHP� WR� VWDQG� IRU� WKDW� SURSRVLWLRQ��

��� ,G���� ,G� DW������.HUD��0HPEHU��FRQFXUULQJ����� 6HH &UH$JUL��,QF��Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6FLV���,QF�������)��G�������WK�&LU����������� ,G� DW�������� ,G� DW�����±������ &ORUR[�&R��Y��$UPRXU�'LDO��,QF�������8�6�3�4�������7�7�$�%����������� 8QLWHG�3KRVSKRUXV�Y��0LGODQG�)XPLJDQW��,QF�������)��G���������������WK�

&LU����������

Page 40: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŘś

KRZHYHU���$V�QRWHG�DERYH��WKH�GHILQLWLRQV�VHFWLRQ�RI�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�PDNHV� QR� PHQWLRQ� RI� XQODZIXO� XVH���� 7KH� 77$%� GHFLVLRQ� ZDV� E\�QHFHVVLW\� DGGUHVVLQJ� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� RQO\�� QRW� WKH� GHYHORSPHQW� RI�ULJKWV� ��� 7KH� FLWDWLRQ� WR� 'DII\� 'DQ¶V LV� HUURQHRXV� EHFDXVH� 'DII\�'DQ¶V LV�QRW�DQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�FDVH�

*UD\� Y�� 'DII\� 'DQ¶V� %DUJDLQWRZQ LV� D� )HGHUDO� &LUFXLW� GHFLVLRQ�DIILUPLQJ� D� 77$%� GHFLVLRQ� LQ� D� FRQFXUUHQW XVH� SURFHHGLQJ�� EXW� WKH�LVVXH�RI�³ODZIXO�XVH´�RQO\�DULVHV�EHFDXVH�RI� WKH� ODQJXDJH�XVHG�LQ� WKH�FRQFXUUHQW� XVH� SRUWLRQ� RI� WKH� VWDWXWH�� LW� LV� QRW� GLVFXVVHG� LQ� WKH� VDPH�VHQVH� DV� LW¶V� XVHG� LQ� &UH$JUL RU� HYHQ� LQ� WKH� 77$%¶V� XQODZIXO� XVH�GRFWULQH���,Q�'DII\�'DQ¶V��WKH�FRXUW�QRWHG��ZLWKRXW�GLVFXVVLRQ��WKDW�³>D@�YDOLG� DSSOLFDWLRQ� FDQQRW� EH� ILOHG� DW� DOO� IRU� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� RI� D� PDUN�ZLWKRXW� µODZIXO� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH�¶� DQG�� ZKHUH� D� FODLP� LV� PDGH� RI�FRQFXUUHQW� ULJKWV�� VXFK�XVH�PXVW�EHJLQ�SULRU� WR� WKH�ILOLQJ�GDWH�RI�DQ\�DSSOLFDWLRQ�E\�D�FRQIOLFWLQJ�FODLPDQW�WR�WKH�PDUN�´���

7KH� %RDUG� LQ� WKDW� FDVH� ZDV� WDVNHG� ZLWK� GHWHUPLQLQJ� ZKHWKHU� D�MXQLRU�XVHU�ZKR�ZDV�XVLQJ�KLV�PDUN�LQ�WKH�VDPH�JHRJUDSKLF�DUHD�DV�WKH�VHQLRU� XVHU� FRXOG� REWDLQ� D� FRQFXUUHQW� XVH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ���� 7KH� MXQLRU�XVHU�DUJXHG�WKDW�EHFDXVH�WKH�%RDUG�KDG�IRXQG�WKDW�WKH�MXQLRU�XVHU�KDG�LQLWLDOO\�EHJXQ�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�LQ�JRRG�IDLWK�RXWVLGH�WKH�WHUULWRU\�RI�WKH�VHQLRU� XVHU� SULRU� WR� WKH� VHQLRU� XVHU¶V� ILOLQJ� GDWH�� WKH� MXQLRU� XVHU�ZDV�HQWLWOHG�WR�D�FRQFXUUHQW�XVH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ���� 7KH�)HGHUDO�&LUFXLW�QRWHG�WKDW�ZKLOH�DQ�DSSOLFDQW�PXVW�EH�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�LQ�FRPPHUFH�RXWVLGH�RI�WKH�FRQIOLFWLQJ�FODLPDQW¶V�DUHD�SULRU�WR�WKH�VHQLRU�XVHU¶V�ILOLQJ�GDWH�LQ�RUGHU� WR� REWDLQ� D� FRQFXUUHQW� XVH� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� WKDW� ZDV� RQO\� RQH� RI�VHYHUDO�UHTXLUHPHQWV�WKDW�PXVW�EH�PHW�IRU�D�FRQFXUUHQW�XVH�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��WKH� NH\� DGGLWLRQDO� UHTXLUHPHQW� EHLQJ� WKDW� WKHUH� LV� QR� OLNHOLKRRG� RI�FRQIXVLRQ�� DV� WKH� SXEOLF¶V� ULJKW� WR� DYRLG� FRQIXVLRQ� LV� DOVR�SDUDPRXQW�����

:KDW� GRHV� WKLV� KDYH� WR� GR� ZLWK� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� DV�GLVFXVVHG� LQ� WKLV� SDSHU"� � 1RWKLQJ�� � 7KH\� DUH� VLPSO\� QRW� UHODWHG���%HFDXVH� WKH� VWDWXWH� PHQWLRQV� ³ODZIXO� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH�´� WKH� FRXUW�TXRWHG�WKDW�WHUP��EXW�WKH�VHQWHQFH�DW�LVVXH�GRHV�QRW�UHYROYH�DURXQG�WKH�ZRUG�³ODZIXO´²QR�RQH�LQ�'DII\�'DQ¶V ZDV�TXHVWLRQLQJ�ZKHWKHU�HLWKHU�XVHU¶V�XVH�ZDV�³ODZIXO´�XQGHU�DQ\�ODZ²WKH�VHQWHQFH�UHYROYHV�DURXQG�WKH� WHUP�³XVH� LQ�FRPPHUFH�´��� 7KH�FRXUW�ZDV�HVVHQWLDOO\�VD\LQJ�³RI�

��� 6HH ���8�6�&�����������������IDLOLQJ�WR�GHILQH�XQODZIXO�XVH����� 6HH &ORUR[������8�6�3�4��DW������VXVWDLQLQJ�RSSRVLWLRQ�DQG�UHIXVLQJ�

UHJLVWUDWLRQ����� *UD\�Y��'DII\�'DQ¶V�%DUJDLQWRZQ������)��G�����������)HG��&LU����������� 6HH�LG��DW�������� 6HH�LG� DW����±������ 6HH�LG� DW�������� 'DII\�'DQ¶V�%DUJDLQWRZQ������)��G�DW�����

Page 41: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŘŜ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

FRXUVH�\RX¶YH�JRW�WR�KDYH�XVH�LQ�FRPPHUFH²\RX�DOZD\V�QHHG�WKDW�WR�JHW� D� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� � $QG�� LI� \RX� ZDQW� FRQFXUUHQW� ULJKWV�� \RXU� XVH� LQ�FRPPHUFH�KDV�WR�SUHGDWH�WKH�RWKHU�JX\¶V�DSSOLFDWLRQ�´��

,Q�DQ\�HYHQW��HYHQ�DVVXPLQJ�WKDW�����WKLV�ZDV�DQ�DFWXDO�KROGLQJ�RI�WKH�FRXUW�DQG�����WKH�FRXUW�LQWHQGHG�WR�PDNH�D�VWDWHPHQW�DERXW�ODZIXO�XVH� LQ�FRPPHUFH��DOO� WKH�FRXUW� LV�VD\LQJ� LV� WKDW�³>D@�YDOLG�DSSOLFDWLRQ�FDQQRW�EH�ILOHG�DW�DOO�IRU�UHJLVWUDWLRQ RI�D�PDUN�ZLWKRXW�µODZIXO�XVH�LQ�FRPPHUFH�¶´ ��� &RPLQJ� IURP� WKH� )HGHUDO� &LUFXLW�� VLWWLQJ� DV� DQ�DSSHOODWH� FRXUW� UHYLHZLQJ� WKH� 77$%�� WKLV� ZDV� QRWKLQJ� QHZ�� � 7KH�86372� KDG� DGRSWHG� WKH� SROLF\� WKDW� DQ� DSSOLFDWLRQ� IRU� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�PXVW� EH� EDVHG� RQ� ODZIXO� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� \HDUV� EHIRUH�� � (YHQ�6DWLQLQH��ZKLFK�UHILQHG�WKH�GRFWULQH��ZDV�GHFLGHG�\HDUV�HDUOLHU����

E� 2WKHU�SUH�&UH$JUL�FDVHV�DGGUHVVLQJ�XQODZIXO�XVH

6RPH� HDUO\� SRVW�/DQKDP�$FW� FDVHV� DSSOLHG� WKH� GRFWULQH� ZLWKRXW�PXFK�GLVFXVVLRQ��RU�DV�LQWHUWZLQHG�ZLWK�WKH�GHIHQVH�RI�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV���)RU� H[DPSOH�� LQ� 6WUH\� Y�� 'HYLQH¶V�� ,QF�� ��� GHFLGHG� LQ� ������ WKH�6HYHQWK� &LUFXLW� DIILUPHG� D� GHFLVLRQ� GHQ\LQJ� UHOLHI� IRU� WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW� WR� D� SODLQWLII� RQ� WKH� EDVLV� RI� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV�� EXW� DOVR�DIILUPHG� EHFDXVH� WKH� SODLQWLII¶V� SURGXFW� ZDV� D� GUXJ� WKDW� GLG� QRW�FRPSO\�ZLWK�IHGHUDO�ODEHOLQJ�UHTXLUHPHQWV���� 7KH�FRXUW�KHOG�WKDW�³WKH�PLVUHSUHVHQWDWLRQV�PDGH� WKH� E\� WKH� SODLQWLII� LQ� WKH� XVH� RI� KLV� WUDGH�PDUN� DQG� WKH� PLVEUDQGLQJ� RI� KLV� FUHDP� LQ� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKH� )HGHUDO�)RRG��'UXJ��DQG�&RVPHWLF�$FW��³)'&$´��ZHUH�VXIILFLHQW�UHDVRQV�IRU�WKH�'LVWULFW�&RXUW�WR�GHQ\�KLP�UHOLHI�´���

,Q�&DPHR� Y�� 3ORXJK�� GHFLGHG� LQ� ������ D� IHGHUDO� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� LQ�2KLR� RUGHUHG� D� SODLQWLII¶V� WUDGHPDUN� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� FDQFHOOHG� DIWHU�ILQGLQJ�WKDW�WKH�SODLQWLII�KDG�VKLSSHG�D�PLVEUDQGHG�GUXJ��WKH�ODEHOLQJ�IDLOHG� WR� GLVFORVH� WKDW� WKH� DFWLYH� LQJUHGLHQW� ZDV� IRUPDOGHK\GH�� LQ�LQWHUVWDWH�FRPPHUFH� LQ�YLRODWLRQ�RI� WKH�)'&$���� 7KLV�ZRXOG�QRW�EH�HVSHFLDOO\�QRWDEOH��DV�XQODZIXO�XVH�DV�D�EDU�WR�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��RU�JURXQGV�IRU� FDQFHOODWLRQ�� LV� ZLWKLQ� WKH� SXUYLHZ� RI� WKH� 86372¶V� SROLF\� ���

��� ,G���HPSKDVLV�DGGHG������� 6HH 6DWLQLQH�6RFLHWD�LQ�1RPH�&ROOHWWLYR�'L�6�$��(�0��8VHOOLQL�Y��3�$�%��

3URGXLWV�HW�$SSDUHLOV�GH�%HDXWH������8�6�3�4�������7�7�$�%����������� ����)��G�������WK�&LU����������� ,G���� ,G��DW������7KH�YLRODWLRQ�ZDV�D�IDLOXUH�WR�OLVW�DOO�RI�WKH�LQJUHGLHQWV��LQ�YLRODWLRQ�

RI�WKH�)RRG��'UXJ��DQG�&RVPHWLF�$FW��,W�LV�QRW�FOHDU�ZKHWKHU�WKH�SODLQWLII�ZDV�LQWHQWLRQDOO\�DYRLGLQJ�WKH�UHTXLUHPHQWV�RI�WKH�$FW�

��� &DPHR��,QF��Y��3ORXJK��,QF�������8�6�3�4������������1�'��2KLR�-DQ�������������� 6HH��H�J�� 'DYLGRII�([WHQVLRQ�6�$��Y��'DYLGRII�,QW¶O��,QF�������)��6XSS����

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 42: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŘŝ

+RZHYHU�� WKH� FRXUW� ZHQW� EH\RQG� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� DQG� VWDWHG� WKDW�³>W@UDGHPDUN�ULJKWV��HLWKHU�DW�FRPPRQ�ODZ�RU�XQGHU� WKH�/DQKDP�$FW��DUH�DFTXLUHG�DQG�PDLQWDLQHG�RQO\�E\�ODZIXO�XVH�´�DQG�DOVR�VWDWHG�WKDW�³3ODLQWLII¶V� WUDGHPDUN� �� �� �� LV�� WKHUHIRUH�� LQYDOLG� DQG� VR� LV� LWV�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�´��� 7KLV�GHFLVLRQ�ZDV�ODWHU�YDFDWHG�ZLWKRXW�RSLQLRQ����

,Q� ������ WKH� FRXUW� LQ� ,QWUDZHVW� )LQDQFLDO� &RUS�� Y�� :HVWHUQ�1DWLRQDO�%DQN KHOG��ZLWK�OLWWOH�GLVFXVVLRQ��WKDW�WZR�EDQNLQJ�FRPSDQLHV�FRXOG� QRW� GHIHQG� DJDLQVW� DEDQGRQPHQW� DOOHJDWLRQV� E\� FODLPLQJ� WKH\�KDG�XVHG�WKH�PDUN��ZKHQ�WKHLU�RQO\�XVH�RI�WKH�PDUN�GXULQJ�WKH�WLPH�LQ�TXHVWLRQ�ZDV�LQ�YLRODWLRQ�RI�QDWLRQDO�EDQNLQJ�ODZV����

,Q� ������ D� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� LQ�3XHUWR�5LFR� LQ�(UYD�3KDUPDFHXWLFDOVDFFHSWHG� DQ� XQODZIXO� XVH� GHIHQVH�� GLVPLVVLQJ� D� SODLQWLII¶V� FRPSODLQW�IRU� WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW� DIWHU� JUDQWLQJ� VXPPDU\� MXGJPHQW� IRU� WKH�GHIHQGDQW�DV� WR� WKH� LVVXH�RI� WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�XQODZIXO�XVH�RI�D�PDUN����

7KHUH�� WKH� SODLQWLII� ZDV� VHOOLQJ� 6835$� EUDQG� HUHFWLOH� G\VIXQFWLRQ�WUHDWPHQW�DQG�WKH�GHIHQGDQW�ZDV�VHOOLQJ�6835$;�EUDQG�HDU�LQIHFWLRQ�WUHDWPHQW� ��� 7KH� SODLQWLII� EURXJKW� VXLW� XQGHU� WKH� 3XHUWR� 5LFR�7UDGHPDUN�$FW�RQO\��ZKHUHDV�WKH�GHIHQGDQW FRXQWHUFODLPHG�XQGHU�WKH�/DQKDP� $FW� DV� ZHOO� ��� 7KH� 3XHUWR� 5LFR� VWDWXWH� VWDWHV� WKDW� QR�WUDGHPDUN�VKDOO�EH�UHJLVWHUHG�³ZKLFK�ZDV�QRW� ODZIXOO\ XVHG�LQ�3XHUWR�5LFR�E\�WKH�DSSOLFDQW�RU�KLV�SUHGHFHVVRU�SULRU�WR�WKH�GDWH�RI�ILOLQJ�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�´ ��� %HFDXVH� RI� WKLV� ODQJXDJH�� WKH� FRXUW� UHDVRQHG� WKDW�³>W@KXV�� LQ�RUGHU� WR� DVVHUW� SURWHFWLRQ�RI� WKH� WUDGHPDUN� ODZV�� WKH�SULRU�XVH�XSRQ�ZKLFK�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�ZDV�EDVHG�PXVW�KDYH�EHHQ�ODZIXO� �� �� ��´�DQG�SHUKDSV�DOVR�EHFDXVH�RI� WKDW� ODQJXDJH�LQ� WKH�3XHUWR�5LFR�VWDWXWH��ODWHU��³>L@Q�RUGHU�WR�HQIRUFH�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV��WKH�SULRU�XVH�PXVW�EH�ODZIXO�´���

7KH�FRXUW� UHOLHG�XSRQ� WKH�77$%¶V�6DWLQLQH GHFLVLRQ�� ILQGLQJ� WKDW�6835$�ZDV�PLVODEHOHG���� 7KH�YLRODWLRQV�DW�LVVXH�FRQFHUQHG�W\SHVL]H�DQG� SODFHPHQW� RI� LQIRUPDWLRQ�� KRZHYHU�� WKH� FRXUW� VSHFLILFDOO\� IRXQG�

�6�'��)OD���������UHMHFWLQJ�WKH�GHIHQGDQWV¶�DUJXPHQW�WKDW�D�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�VKRXOG�EH�FDQFHOOHG�GXH�WR�XQODZIXO�XVH�ZKHUH�WKH�GHIHQGDQWV�FRXOG�QRW�VKRZ�WKDW�WKH�SODLQWLII�KDG�EHHQ�VKLSSLQJ�FLJDUV�FRQWDLQLQJ�&XEDQ�WREDFFR�LQ�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV��DQG�UHO\LQJ�XSRQ�6DWLQLQH���7KHUH�LV�QR�LQGLFDWLRQ�WKDW�WKH�UXOLQJ�ZHQW�EH\RQG�WKH�86372¶V�SROLF\�RI�GHQ\LQJ�RU�FDQFHOOLQJ�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RQ�WKH�JURXQGV�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH���

��� &DPHR������8�6�3�4��DW��������� &DPHR��,QF��Y��3ORXJK��,QF�������)��G��������WK�&LU����������� ,QWUDZHVW�)LQ��&RUS��Y��:��1DW��%DQN�RI�'HQYHU������)��6XSS����������±���

�'��&ROR����������� (UYD�3KDUP���,QF��Y��$P��&\DQDPLG�&R�������)��6XSS������'�3�5����������� ,G� DW������� ,G���� ,G� DW�����FLWLQJ����/�3�5�$��������I�����������HPSKDVLV�DGGHG����� ,G���� ,G� DW����

Page 43: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŘŞ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

WKDW�WKH�YLRODWLRQV�ZHUH�QRW�GH�PLQLPLV��H[SODLQLQJ�

$OWKRXJK� WKH� ³6835$´� ODEHO� PD\� FRQWDLQ� DOO� WKH�LQIRUPDWLRQ� UHTXLUHG� XQGHU� WKH� $FW�� &RQJUHVV�VSHFLILFDOO\�DPHQGHG�WKH�VWDWXWH�VR�WKDW�WKH�DSSHDUDQFH�RI� WKH� ODEHO�� ZKLFK� PD\� FRQWDLQ� WKH� QHFHVVDU\�LQIRUPDWLRQ�� EH� YLVXDOO\� GHVLJQHG� LQ� D� FHUWDLQ� ZD\� LQ�RUGHU� WR� SURWHFW� FRQVXPHUV� �GRFWRUV� DQG�SDWLHQWV��ZKR�PD\�SD\�PRUH�EHFDXVH� WKH\�GR�QRW� UHDOL]H� WKH�SURGXFW�WKH\�DUH�EX\LQJ�LV�D�ZHOO�NQRZQ�GUXJ�ZKLFK�WKH\�FRXOG�SXUFKDVH�IRU D�FKHDSHU�SULFH���7KXV��SODLQWLII¶V�ODEHOLQJ��DV�ILOHG�ZLWK�WKH�3XHUWR�5LFR�6HFUHWDU\�RI�6WDWH�ZKHQ�LW�DSSOLHG� WR� UHJLVWHU� IRU� D� WUDGHPDUN�� IDLOHG� WR� FRPSO\�ZLWK� WKHVH� UHTXLUHPHQWV� RI� WKH� VWDWXWH� DQG� FOHDUO\�YLRODWHG�WKH�VWDWXWH�RQ�LWV�IDFH��LQVRIDU�DV�LW KDV�GLUHFWO\�YLRODWHG����8�6�&��������H���6XSS���������0RUHRYHU��LWV�DGPLWWHG� YLRODWLRQV� RI� WKH� DSSOLFDEOH� UHJXODWLRQV�FRQFHUQLQJ� W\SHVL]H�DQG�SODFHPHQW�RI� LQIRUPDWLRQ��DUH�QRW� GH� PLQLPLV�� DQG� FRQVWLWXWH� D� VXIILFLHQW� EDVLV�� LQ�FRQMXQFWLRQ�ZLWK�LWV�SHU�VH�YLRODWLRQ�RI�WKH�)'��&�$FW��XSRQ�ZKLFK� WR� FRQFOXGH� WKDW� LWV� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH�ZDV�XQODZIXO�SULRU�WR�LWV�UHJLVWHULQJ�WKH�WUDGHPDUN����

7KH� FRXUW� DOVR� QRWHG� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII� KDG� IDLOHG� WR� UHJLVWHU� DV� D�GUXJ� HVWDEOLVKPHQW�� SURYLGLQJ� VHSDUDWH� JURXQGV� IRU� D� ILQGLQJ� RI�XQODZIXO�XVH����

7KH�(UYD FDVH� LV� D�ELW� RI� DQ�RXWOLHU�� �$W� D� WLPH�ZKHQ� IHZ�FRXUWV�ZHUH�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�DW�DOO��DQG�HYHQ�WKH�77$%�ZDV�OLPLWLQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�LQ�LWV�RZQ�QDUURZ�FRQWH[W�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ��WKH�(UYD FRXUW�FKRVH�WR� UHIXVH� WR� HQIRUFH� D� SODLQWLII¶V� ULJKWV� EDVHG� RQ� IDLUO\� LQQRFXRXV�YLRODWLRQV�RI� WKH�)'&$���� ,Q� DQ\� HYHQW�� WKLV� UHPDLQV�RQH�RI�RQO\� D�KDQGIXO�RI� FDVHV� WR� DFFHSW� DQ�XQODZIXO�XVH� DUJXPHQW� DQG�XVH� VXFK� D�ILQGLQJ�WR�UHIXVH�WR�HQIRUFH�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�ULJKWV����

7KDW� VDPH� \HDU�� D� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� LQ� ,OOLQRLV� GHQLHG� D� GHIHQGDQW¶V�PRWLRQ� WR� DGG� DQ� DIILUPDWLYH� GHIHQVH� RI� XQODZIXO� XVH� ZKHUH� WKH�GHIHQGDQW� DUJXHG� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII� KDG� REWDLQHG� VWDWH� OLFHQVHV� WR� XVH�WKH� WUDGHPDUNV� IRU� PDQXIDFWXULQJ� DQG� VHOOLQJ� ORWWHU\� WLFNHWV� WKURXJK�IUDXGXOHQW�UHSUHVHQWDWLRQV���� 7KH�FRXUW�UHMHFWHG�WKLV�DUJXPHQW��QRWLQJ�

��� ,G� DW������� ,G� DW���±������ ,G� DW������� ,G���� 8QLYHUVDO�0IJ��&R��Y��'RXJODV�3UHVV��,QF�������)��6XSS�������1�'��,OO��������

Page 44: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŘş

WKDW� ³>Z@KHUH� FRXUWV� KDYH� EDUUHG� SODLQWLIIV� IURP� DVVHUWLQJ� WKHLU�WUDGHPDUN� DQG� FRS\ULJKW� ULJKWV� EHFDXVH� RI� WKHLU� XQODZIXO� DFWV��SODLQWLIIV¶�XVHV�RI� WKHLU� WUDGHPDUNV�DQG� FRS\ULJKWV� WKHPVHOYHV�� UDWKHU�WKDQ� WKHLU� FRQGXFW� LQ� REWDLQLQJ� WKHP�� ZHUH� XQODZIXO�´��� +RZHYHU��WKLV�ZDV� QRW� EDVHG� RQ� WKH� 77$%¶V� SUHFHGHQW� SHU� VH�� EXW� LQVWHDG� WKH�FRXUW�FLWHG�WR�IHGHUDO�FDVHV�DQG�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�JHQHUDOO\����

,Q������� WKH�6HFRQG�&LUFXLW�DIILUPHG�D�GLVWULFW�FRXUW¶V�GHQLDO�RI�D�PRWLRQ� WR� DPHQG� DQ� DQVZHU� WR� DGG� WKH� GHIHQVH� RI� XQODZIXO� XVH����

7KHUH�� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� DUJXHG� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII� ZDV� DQ� LQYHVWPHQW�DGYLVHU�ZKR�ZDV� UHTXLUHG� WR� UHJLVWHU�ZLWK� WKH�6(&�� \HW� GLG� QRW�� DQG�WKDW� ³WKLV� IDLOXUH� UHQGHUHG� >SODLQWLII¶V@� XVH� RI� WKH� PDUN� LQ� LQWHUVWDWH�FRPPHUFH� XQODZIXO� DQG�� WKXV�� WKDW� >SODLQWLII¶V@� PDUN� ZDV�XQSURWHFWDEOH�´��� +RZHYHU��WKH�DSSHOODWH�FRXUW�HVVHQWLDOO\�IRXQG�WKDW�WKH�GHIHQVH�ZDV�XQWLPHO\�DQG�GLVFODLPHG�DQ\�VXEVWDQWLYH�HYDOXDWLRQ�RI�WKH�PHULWV��H[SODLQLQJ�WKDW�³LQ�DIILUPLQJ��ZH�KDYH�QRW�FRQVLGHUHG��DQG�ZH� H[SUHVV� QR� YLHZ� UHJDUGLQJ�� WKH� PHULWV� RI� WKH� GHIHQVH� RU� -XGJH�&KLQ¶V�GLVFXVVLRQ�WKHUHRI�´���

,Q� ������ D� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� LQ� ,OOLQRLV� FRQVLGHUHG� WKH� LVVXH� DIWHU�GHIHQGDQWV�PRYHG�IRU�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�RQ�WKH�LVVXH�RI��DPRQJ�RWKHU�WKLQJV�� XQODZIXO� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� RI� WKH� SODLQWLIIV¶� SHUIXPH� ���

$OWKRXJK�WKH�FRXUW�DJUHHG�ZLWK�WKH�GHIHQGDQWV�WKDW�WKHUH�ZHUH�VHYHUDO�SHU� VH� VWDWXWRU\�YLRODWLRQV�RI� WKH�)RRG��'UXJ�� DQG�&RVPHWLF�$FW�� WKH�FRXUW� GLVWLQJXLVKHG� (UYD DQG� IRXQG� WKDW� WKH� YLRODWLRQV� ZHUH� GH�PLQLPLV����

8QWLO�&UH$JUL��QR�RWKHU�FDVH�KDG�FRQVLGHUHG�WKH�LVVXH�LQ�GHSWK���$V�VXFK�� DOWKRXJK� WKHUH� LV� VRPH� SUHFHGHQW� IRU� XVLQJ� WKH� GRFWULQH� RU�VRPHWKLQJ�VLPLODU�WR�DIIHFW�GHYHORSPHQW�RI�ULJKWV��&UH$JUL HVVHQWLDOO\�EURNH�QHZ�JURXQG�E\�IRUPDOO\ DGRSWLQJ�VXFK�D�UHTXLUHPHQW�

%� ,V�$GRSWLQJ�WKH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�*RRG�3ROLF\"

$OWKRXJK�WKHUH�KDYH�EHHQ�D�KDQGIXO�RI�FDVHV�WKDW�KDYH�DSSOLHG�WKH�GRFWULQH��RQH�ZD\�RU�DQRWKHU�� LQ� WKH�\HDUV� OHDGLQJ�XS� WR�&UH$JUL�� WKH�KLVWRULFDO�EDVLV�IRU�D�IHGHUDO�FRXUW¶V�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�LV�IDU�IURP�VROLG���7KH�GRFWULQH�VXIIHUV�IURP�VRPH�SROLF\�VKRUWFRPLQJV�DV�ZHOO���

��� ,G� DW�������� ,G��DW����±������ /DQH�&DSLWDO�0JPW���,QF��Y��/DQH�&DSLWDO�0JPW���,QF�������)��G�������G�&LU��

��������� ,G��DW�������� ,G� DW�������� $GYHUW��WR�:RPHQ��,QF��Y��*LDQQL�9HUVDFH�6�S�$���1R����&�����������:/�

���������DW� ���1�'��,OO��$XJ��������������� ,G� DW� ����

Page 45: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řřŖ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

�� &RQVXPHU�3URWHFWLRQ�DV�D�3ROLF\�2EMHFWLYH

&UH$JUL ODLG� RXW� WZR� SROLF\� FRQVLGHUDWLRQV� LQ� IDYRU� RI� D� IHGHUDO�FRXUW¶V� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�� � )LUVW�� ³DV D� ORJLFDO� PDWWHU�� WR� KROG�RWKHUZLVH�ZRXOG�EH�WR�SXW�WKH�JRYHUQPHQW�LQ�WKH�µDQRPDORXV�SRVLWLRQ¶�RI� H[WHQGLQJ� WKH� EHQHILWV� RI� WUDGHPDUN� SURWHFWLRQ� WR� D� VHOOHU� EDVHG�XSRQ� DFWLRQV� WKH� VHOOHU� WRRN� LQ� YLRODWLRQ� RI� WKDW� JRYHUQPHQW¶V� RZQ�ODZV�´��� 6HFRQG��³WR�JLYH WUDGHPDUN�SULRULW\�WR�D�VHOOHU�ZKR�UXVKHV�WR�PDUNHW� ZLWKRXW� WDNLQJ� FDUH� WR� FDUHIXOO\� FRPSO\� ZLWK� WKH� UHOHYDQW�UHJXODWLRQV� ZRXOG� EH� WR� UHZDUG� WKH� KDVW\� DW� WKH� H[SHQVH� RI� WKH�GLOLJHQW�´ ��� 7KHVH� SROLF\� FRQVLGHUDWLRQV� DUH� UHDVRQDEOH�� EXW� WKH\�DGGUHVV� RQO\� WZR SHUVSHFWLYHV�� WKDW� RI� WKH� JRYHUQPHQW� �KDYLQJ� WR�H[WHQG�SURWHFWLRQ�WR�WKRVH�ZKR�IORXW�LWV�ODZV��DQG�WKDW�RI�FRPSHWLWRUV��ZKR�DUH�KDUPHG�ZKHQ� D� FRPSHWLWRU�EHJLQV�XVLQJ� D�PDUN�GXULQJ� WKH�WLPH�LW�WDNHV�WR�UHYLHZ�DQG�FRPSO\�ZLWK�IHGHUDO�UHJXODWLRQV����

2QH�NH\ SHUVSHFWLYH�LV�PLVVLQJ��FRQVXPHUV���,W�LV�KDUG�WR�LJQRUH�D�PDMRU� VKRUWFRPLQJ� LQ� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�� LW� ZRXOG� VHHP� WR�KDUP� FRQVXPHUV�� � 8VLQJ� WKH� IDFWV� IURP� &UH$JUL DV� DQ� H[DPSOH��FRQVXPHUV� ZKR� ZHUH� XVLQJ� WKH� 2/,9(12/� EUDQG� QXWULWLRQDO�VXSSOHPHQW� ZHUH� DEOH� WR� SXUFKDVH� WKDW� VXSSOHPHQW� EHJLQQLQJ� LQ� WKH�VSULQJ� RI� �������� 0RUH� WKDQ� D� \HDU� ODWHU�� LQ� $XJXVW� RI� ������ LWV�FRPSHWLWRU� EHJDQ� VHOOLQJ� QXWULWLRQDO� VXSSOHPHQWV� FRQWDLQLQJ� DQ�LQJUHGLHQW�FDOOHG�2/,92/���� $IWHU� WKH�PDNHUV�RI�2/,9(12/�VXHG�IRU� WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW�� WKH� FRXUW� FDQFHOOHG� WKH� PDNHUV� RI�2/,9(12/¶V� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� GXH� WR� LWV� PLVODEHOLQJ� DQG� KHOG� WKDW� WKH\�FRXOG�QRW�PDLQWDLQ�D�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�DFWLRQ�DJDLQVW�WKH�PDNHUV�RI�2/,92/���� $VVXPLQJ�WKHVH�PDUNV�DUH�FRQIXVLQJO\�VLPLODU��DV�WKH�PDNHUV RI� 2/,9(12/� DOOHJHG�� FRQVXPHUV� DUH� QRZ� OHIW� ZLWK� D�FRQIXVLQJO\�VLPLODU�SURGXFW�RQ�WKH�PDUNHW��EXW�LW¶V�QRW�WKH�SURGXFW�WKH\�WKLQN�LW�LV���7KLV�LV�D�PDMRU�FRQVHTXHQFH�

�� 'HWHUUHQFH�DQG�RU�3XQLVKPHQW�DV�D�3ROLF\�2EMHFWLYH

$QRWKHU� SROLF\� TXHVWLRQ� LV� ZKHWKHU� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�FDSWXUHV� EHKDYLRU� WKDW� RWKHU� GRFWULQHV� GR� QRW�� DQG� LI� VR�� LV� WKDW�DGGLWLRQDO� EHKDYLRU� FDSWXUHG� E\� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GHIHQVH� VRPHWKLQJ�WKDW� ZH� ZDQW� WR� GHWHU� DQG�RU� SXQLVK"� � 6SHFLILFDOO\�� WKH� GRFWULQHV� RI�

��� &UH$JUL��,QF��Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6FLV���,QF�������)��G������������WK�&LU���������TXRWLQJ�,Q�UH�6WHOODU�,QW¶O��,QF�������8�6�3�4����������7�7�$�%����������

��� ,G���� ,G� DW�������� ,G� DW�������� ,G� DW�����

Page 46: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řřŗ

XQFOHDQ�KDQGV��� DQG� IUDXG�RQ� WKH�3DWHQW� DQG�7UDGHPDUN�2IILFH�EHDU�RQ�VLPLODU�EHKDYLRU���

$V� WR� WKH� GHIHQVH� RI� ³IUDXG� RQ� WKH� 372´� RU� ³IUDXGXOHQW�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�´� WKDW� GHIHQVH� DOORZV� D� GHIHQGDQW�� XSRQ� SURYLQJ� WKDW� WKH�SODLQWLII� IUDXGXOHQWO\� REWDLQHG� D� WUDGHPDUN� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� WR� UHPRYH� D�PDUN¶V�³LQFRQWHVWDEOH´�VWDWXV�DQG�FDQFHO�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�UHJLVWUDWLRQ����

7KH�ZHLJKW�RI�WKH�DXWKRULW\�KROGV�WKDW�SURRI�RI�IUDXGXOHQW�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�GRHV�QRW�DIIHFW�FRPPRQ�ODZ�ULJKWV��PHDQLQJ�WKDW�WKH�PDUN�LV�VWLOO�YDOLG�DQG�ULJKWV�LQ�WKH�PDUN�FDQ�VWLOO�EH�HQIRUFHG�LQ�FRXUW���� $V�WKLV�GHIHQVH�DIIHFWV� RQO\� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� DQG� QRW� XVH�� LW�ZRXOG� QRW� VHHP� WR� KDYH� DQ\�UHDO� RYHUODS� ZLWK� WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� YHUVLRQ� RI� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH�GRFWULQH���

8QODZIXO�XVH�LV�RIWHQ�FDOOHG�D�FDWHJRU\�RI�RU�FRUROODU\�WR�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV���� ³8QFOHDQ� KDQGV´� LV� D� VKRUWKDQG� ZD\� RI� UHIHUULQJ� WR� WKH�PD[LP�WKDW�³KH�ZKR�FRPHV�WR�HTXLW\�PXVW�FRPH�ZLWK�FOHDQ�KDQGV�´�LQ�RWKHU� ZRUGV�� FRXUWV� FDQ� GHFOLQH� WR� JUDQW� UHOLHI� WR� D� SODLQWLII� WKDW� LV�DFWLQJ� LPSURSHUO\²DW� OHDVW� LQ� UHJDUGV� WR� WKH� VXEMHFW� PDWWHU� RI� WKHOLWLJDWLRQ� ��� )RU� H[DPSOH�� LQ� RQH� RI� WKH� ROGHVW� DQG� PRVW� IDPRXV�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�WUDGHPDUN�FDVHV��WKH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW�KHOG�WKDW��

ZKHQ� WKH� RZQHU� RI� D� WUDGH�PDUN� DSSOLHV� IRU� DQ�LQMXQFWLRQ� WR� UHVWUDLQ� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� IURP� LQMXULQJ� KLV�SURSHUW\�E\�PDNLQJ�IDOVH�UHSUHVHQWDWLRQV�WR� WKH�SXEOLF��LW� LV� HVVHQWLDO� WKDW� WKH�SODLQWLII� VKRXOG�QRW� LQ�KLV� WUDGH�PDUN��RU� LQ�KLV� DGYHUWLVHPHQWV�RU�EXVLQHVV�� EH�KLPVHOI�JXLOW\�RI�DQ\�IDOVH�RU�PLVOHDGLQJ�PLVUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ��WKDW�LI� WKH� SODLQWLII� PDNHV� DQ\� PDWHULDO� IDOVH� VWDWHPHQW� LQ�FRQQHFWLRQ�ZLWK�WKH�SURSHUW\�ZKLFK�KH�VHHNV�WR�SURWHFW��KH� ORVHV�KLV� ULJKW� WR� FODLP� WKH�DVVLVWDQFH�RI� D� FRXUW� RI�HTXLW\�� WKDW� ZKHUH� DQ\� V\PERO� RU� ODEHO� FODLPHG� DV� D�WUDGH�PDUN� LV� VR� FRQVWUXFWHG�RU�ZRUGHG� DV� WR�PDNH�RU�FRQWDLQ�D�GLVWLQFW�DVVHUWLRQ�ZKLFK� LV� IDOVH��QR�SURSHUW\�FDQ�EH�FODLPHG�RQ�LW��RU��LQ�RWKHU�ZRUGV��WKH�ULJKW�WR�WKH�H[FOXVLYH�XVH�RI�LW�FDQQRW�EH�PDLQWDLQHG����

��� 7KH�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�GHIHQVH�LV�DOVR�VRPHWLPHV�FDOOHG�³WUDGHPDUN�PLVXVH�´�6HH�H�J���0&&$57+<��VXSUD QRWH�������������

��� 6HH 0&&$57+<��VXSUD QRWH���������������� 6HH LG���VHH�DOVR 'HSW�RI�3DUNV��5HFUHDWLRQ�IRU�&D��Y��%D]DDU 'HO�0XQGR�

,QF�������)��G��������������WK�&LU���������³>(@YHQ�LI�%D]DDU�GHO�0XQGR�ZHUH�VKRZQ�WR�KDYH�IUDXGXOHQWO\�REWDLQHG�IHGHUDO�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�RI�WKH�PDUNV��LWV�FRPPRQ�ODZ�ULJKWV�LQ�WKH�PDUNV�ZRXOG�FRQWLQXH�XQDEDWHG�´��

��� 6HH��H�J���0&&$57+<� VXSUD QRWH���������������� ,G���� &OLQWRQ�(��:RUGHQ��&R��Y��&DO��)LJ�6\UXS�&R�������8�6������������������

Page 47: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řřŘ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

7KHUH�� WKH� FRXUW� FROOHFWHG� DXWKRULWLHV�� QRWLQJ� WKDW� FRXUWV� KDYH�GHFOLQHG�WR�DLG�WUDGHPDUN�KROGHUV�ZKR�PLVUHSUHVHQW�WKH�PDQXIDFWXUHU�DQG WKH� SODFH� WKH� SURGXFW� LV� PDQXIDFWXUHG� RU� WKH� FRQWHQWV� RI� WKH�SURGXFW���� 7KH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW�H[SODLQHG�WKDW�LQ�WKH�FDVH�EHIRUH�LW��WKH�SODLQWLII� DUJXHG� WKDW� LWV� 6<583�2)� ),*6�PDUN�ZDV� QRW� GHVFULSWLYH�EHFDXVH� LW� FRQWDLQHG� YHU\� OLWWOH� ILJ� MXLFH�� EXW� LQVWHDG� GHULYHG� LWV�OD[DWLYH� SURSHUW\� IURP� VHQQD�� DQG�ZDV� WKXV� D� IDQFLIXO�PDUN���� 7KH�&RXUW�IRXQG�WKDW�WKH�PLVUHSUHVHQWDWLRQV�RQ�WKH�SDFNDJLQJ��WKH�QDPH�DV�ZHOO� DV� WKH� LPDJH� RI� D� ILJ� WUHH� DQG� RWKHU� PDUNLQJV�� ³DUH� VR� SODLQO\�GHFHSWLYH� DV� WR� GHSULYH� WKH� FRPSODLQDQW� FRPSDQ\� RI� D� ULJKW� WR� D�UHPHG\�E\�ZD\�RI�LQMXQFWLRQ�E\�D�FRXUW�RI�HTXLW\�´���

$V� RQH� DXWKRULW\� H[SODLQV�� WKHUH� DUH� VHYHUDO� UHTXLUHPHQWV� IRU� D�VXFFHVVIXO� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� GHIHQVH� LQ� D� WUDGHPDUN� FDVH�� ILUVW�� WKH�SODLQWLII¶V� FRQGXFW� PXVW� EH� LQHTXLWDEOH� �QRW� QHFHVVDULO\� LOOHJDO���VHFRQG�� WKH� PLVFRQGXFW� PXVW� EH� LQWHQWLRQDO�� WKLUG�� ³>W@KH� GHIHQGDQW�PXVW� VKRZ� IUDXG�� XQFRQVFLRQDELOLW\� RU� EDG� IDLWK� RQ� WKH� SDUW� RI� WKH�SODLQWLII´��DQG�ILQDOO\��WKHUH�PXVW�EH�³D�ORJLFDO�FRQQHFWLRQ�EHWZHHQ�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKW�WKH�SODLQWLII�LV FODLPLQJ�DQG�WKH�DFWLYLW\�WKDW�JLYHV�ULVH�WR� WKH�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�GHIHQVH�´��� 7KH�GRFWULQH� WHQGV� WR�EH�FRQVWUXHG�QDUURZO\��WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW��IRU�H[DPSOH��KDV�LPSRVHG�WKH�UHTXLUHPHQW�³WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII� XVHG� WKH� WUDGHPDUN� ZLWK� WKH� VSHFLILF� LQWHQW� WR�GHFHLYH� FRQVXPHUV�´ ��� $� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� LQ� 1HZ� <RUN� QRWHG� WKDW�³FRXUWV� W\SLFDOO\� RQO\� EDU� UHFRYHU\� XQGHU� D� WKHRU\� RI� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV�ZKHQ� D� SODLQWLII¶V� FRQGXFW�ZDV� HJUHJLRXV�� �� �� �� RU� FOHDU�� XQHTXLYRFDO�DQG�FRQYLQFLQJ´�EHFDXVH�WUDGHPDUN�ODZ�LQYROYHV�SURWHFWLQJ�WKH�SXEOLF�LQWHUHVW����

2QH� FDVH�� GHFLGHG� LQ� WKH� ����V�� KHOG� WKDW� WKH� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV�GHIHQVH� ZRXOG� QRW� EDU� D� SODLQWLII� HQJDJHG� LQ� WKH� VDOH� RI� GUXJ�SDUDSKHUQDOLD� IURP� REWDLQLQJ� UHOLHI� LQ� WKH� FRXUWV� ��� 7KH� FRXUW�H[SODLQHG� WKDW� WKH� GHIHQGDQWV� IDLOHG� ³WR� HVWDEOLVK� DQ\� ORJLFDO� QH[XV�EHWZHHQ�WKHLU�FODLP�WKDW�>WKH�SODLQWLII@�VHOOV�FLJDUHWWH�SDSHU�WR�WKH�GUXJ�

��� ,G� DW����±������ ,G� DW�������� ,G� DW�������� ��52%(57�-� -266(1� 1(,/�$� 67(,1(5��%86,1(66�$1'�&200(5&,$/�

/,7,*$7,21�,1�)('(5$/�&28576 ����������WK�HG����������� �GLH�NRXUW�Y��+LOODLU�&DSLWDO�0JPW���//&��1R��6$&9����������

-96�')0[�� �����8�6��'LVW��/(;,6���������DW� ��±����&�'��&DO��$XJ�������������FLWLQJ�-DSDQ�7HOHFRP��,QF��Y��-DSDQ�7HOHFRP�$P���,QF�������)��G������������WK�&LU���������

��� 3DWV\¶V�,WDOLDQ�5HVW���,QF��Y��%DQDV������)��6XSS���G�����������(�'�1�<���������LQWHUQDO�FLWDWLRQV�DQG�TXRWDWLRQV�RPLWWHG��

��� %DPEX�6DOHV��,QF��Y��7HVWLQL�����8�6�3�4��G�������������(�'�1�<����������

Page 48: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řřř

WUDGH� DQG� WKH� DOOHJDWLRQV� DJDLQVW� GHIHQGDQWV� WKDW� WKH\� KDYH� YLRODWHG�>WKH�SODLQWLII¶V@� WUDGHPDUN�´��� +RZHYHU�� WKH� FRXUW� IROORZHG�<RXQJ¶V�5XEEHU LQ�KROGLQJ�WKDW�LOOHJDO�VDOHV�FRXOG�EH�WDNHQ�LQWR�DFFRXQW�ZKHQ�FRPSXWLQJ�GDPDJHV���� 7KHUH�DUH�VHYHUDO�NH\�GLIIHUHQFHV�EHWZHHQ�WKH�WZR� GRFWULQHV�� � )LUVW�� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� ZLOO� SUHYHQW� D� WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�SODLQWLII�IURP�HQIRUFLQJ�KLV�ULJKWV�DJDLQVW�WKDW�SDUWLFXODU�GHIHQGDQW��ZKHUHDV�XQODZIXO�XVH�SUHYHQWV�WKH�GHYHORSPHQW�RI�ULJKWV�DW�DOO �LQ�RWKHU�ZRUGV��WKH�SODLQWLII�FDQQRW�HQIRUFH�DJDLQVW�DQ\�GHIHQGDQW�LI� WKH�LQIULQJHPHQW�RFFXUUHG�GXULQJ�D�WLPH�ZKHQ�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�XVH�LV�³XQODZIXO´����� 6HFRQG��XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�ORRNV�DW�WKH�LQWHQW��JRRG�IDLWK�RU� EDG� IDLWK�� RI� WKH� SODLQWLII�� ZKHUHDV� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRHV� QRW� ���

$OWKRXJK�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�FDQ�UHDFK�EHKDYLRU�WKDW�LV�PHUHO\�LQHTXLWDEOH�DQG�QRW� LOOHJDO�� WKH� DGGLWLRQDO� LQWHQW� UHTXLUHPHQW�PDNHV� LW� OLNHO\� WKDW�XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� ZLOO� UHDFK� D� VPDOOHU� �RU� DW� OHDVW� GLIIHUHQW�� VXEVHW� RI�SODLQWLIIV�� � ,Q�RWKHU�ZRUGV��XQODZIXO�XVH�DSSHDUV� WR�EH�D�PRUH�VHYHUH�YHUVLRQ� RI� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV�� WKH� SXQLVKPHQW� LV� PRUH� VHYHUH�� DQG� WKH�EHKDYLRU� LW� FDSWXUHV� PD\� EH� ³LQQRFHQW´� ZURQJGRLQJ�� � ,Q� D� 9HQQ�GLDJUDP�� XQODZIXO� XVH� DQG� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV�ZRXOG� RYHUODS��ZLWK� VRPH�FRQGXFW�WKDW�ZRXOG�IDOO�XQGHU�HLWKHU�WKHRU\��VRPH�FRQGXFW�WKDW�ZRXOG�IDOO� RQO\� XQGHU� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� �FRQGXFW� WKDW� LV� LQHTXLWDEOH� EXW� QRW�LOOHJDO�� DQG� VRPH� FRQGXFW� WKDW� ZRXOG� IDOO� RQO\� XQGHU� XQODZIXO� XVH��FRQGXFW�WKDW�LV�³LOOHJDO�´�EXW�QRW�LQ�EDG�IDLWK����

'RHV� LW�PDNH� VHQVH� WR� SXQLVK� XQODZIXO� XVH"� � 3HUKDSV�� EXW� WKRVH�ZKR�ZRXOG�LQWHQWLRQDOO\�IORXW�WKH�ODZ�DUH�DOUHDG\�ZLWKLQ�WKH�JUDVS�RI�XQFOHDQ�KDQGV���3XQLVKLQJ�WKRVH�ZKR�ODFN�LQWHQW�WR�IORXW�WKH�ODZ�PRUH�VHYHUHO\� �E\� ORVV�RI�DOO� ULJKWV�� WKDQ� WKRVH�ZKR�DFW� LQ�EDG�IDLWK�VHHPV�LQFRQVLVWHQW�� � )XUWKHU�� EHFDXVH� WKH� GRFWULQH� LV� QRW� ZHOO�NQRZQ� �DQG�LQFRQVLVWHQWO\�DSSOLHG���LW�VHHPV�XQOLNHO\�WR�GHWHU�QRQFRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�UHOHYDQW�ODZ�

,9� 35$&7,&$/�&216,'(5$7,216�)25�$33/<,1*�7+(�81/$:)8/�

86(�'2&75,1(�,1�7+(�)('(5$/�&28576�

+LVWRULFDO�� VWDWXWRU\�� DQG� SROLF\� VXSSRUW� IRU� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH�GRFWULQH� DUH� PL[HG�� � +RZHYHU�� DVVXPLQJ� WKDW� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� ZLOO�FRQWLQXH� WR� DSSO\� WKH� GRFWULQH�� WKH\� VKRXOG� GR� VR� WKRXJKWIXOO\��FRQVLVWHQWO\��DQG�UDUHO\��JLYHQ� WKH�VHULRXV�QDWXUH�RI�FRQVHTXHQFHV�IRU�ERWK� WKH�SODLQWLII�DQG�FRQVXPHUV�� � ,Q� WKLV� VHFWLRQ�� ,� ILUVW� LGHQWLI\� WZR�LVVXHV�WKDW�VKRXOG�EH�DGGUHVVHG�EHIRUH�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�PRYH�IRUZDUG�

��� ,G���� ,G� DW���������� &RRSHU��VXSUD QRWH������DW���±������ ,G� DW��������

Page 49: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řřŚ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

ZLWK� EURDG� DSSOLFDWLRQ� RI� WKH� GRFWULQH²QDPHO\�� LWV� UHODWLRQVKLS� WR�VWDWH� ODZ�DQG� LWV� UHODWLRQVKLS� WR�RWKHU� IHGHUDO� ODZV�� �7KHQ�� ,� H[DPLQH�VRPH�SUDFWLFDO�LVVXHV�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�VKRXOG�FRQVLGHU�ZKHQ�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�LQ�OLWLJDWLRQ�

$� &RXUWV�0XVW�5HVROYH�WKH�,VVXH�RI�WKH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH¶V�,QWHUDFWLRQ�:LWK�6WDWH�DQG�)HGHUDO�/DZ

&RQVSLFXRXVO\� DEVHQW� IURP� WKH�1LQWK� &LUFXLW¶V�&UH$JUL GHFLVLRQ��DQG� DQ\� GHFLVLRQ� VLQFH�� LV� WKH� TXHVWLRQ� RI� KRZ� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH�GRFWULQH� LQWHUDFWV� ZLWK� VWDWH� DQG� IHGHUDO� ODZ�� � 7ZR� TXHVWLRQV� DULVH��ZKHWKHU� VWDWH� ODZ� FDQ� RSHUDWH� WR� UHVWULFW� IHGHUDO� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ�� DQG�ZKHWKHU� WKH� DSSOLFDWLRQ� RI� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� LV� PDNLQJ� WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�D�³EDFN�GRRU´�IRU�HQIRUFHPHQW�RI�IHGHUDO�VWDWXWHV�ZLWK�QR�SULYDWH�FDXVH�RI�DFWLRQ��VXFK�DV�WKH�)'&$�

�� 'RHV�WKH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�2SHUDWH�WR�3XW�6WDWH�/DZ�2YHU�)HGHUDO�/DZ"

7KH� ILUVW� TXHVWLRQ� LV� ZKHWKHU� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� UHVWULFWV�IHGHUDO� WUDGHPDUN� ODZ� E\� PDNLQJ� FRPSOLDQFH� ZLWK� D� VWDWH� VWDWXWH� D�SUHUHTXLVLWH� WR� UHFRYHU\�XQGHU� WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�� �7KLV�VLWXDWLRQ�DULVHV�ZKHQ�D�SODLQWLII� LV�YLRODWLQJ� �RU�KDV�YLRODWHG��VWDWH� ODZ�LQ�VRPH�ZD\��EXW� LV� VHHNLQJ� WR� HQIRUFH� LWV� WUDGHPDUN� ULJKWV� XQGHU� IHGHUDO� ODZ���6HYHUDO� FRXUWV� KDYH� GLVFXVVHG� WKLV� LVVXH� LQ� WKH� FRQWH[W� RI� XQFOHDQ�KDQGV���)RU�H[DPSOH��LQ�RQH�HDUO\�FRS\ULJKW�FDVH��/HR�)HLVW�Y��<RXQJ��WKH� 6HYHQWK� &LUFXLW� UHYHUVHG� D� GLVWULFW� FRXUW¶V� ILQGLQJ� RI� XQFOHDQ�KDQGV� ��� 7KH� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� KDG� IRXQG� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� ZKHUH� WKH�SODLQWLII� KDG� IDLOHG� WR� FRPSO\� ZLWK� D�:LVFRQVLQ� OLFHQVLQJ� VWDWXWH����

��� /HR )HLVW��,QF��Y��<RXQJ������)��G������������WK�&LU������������� ,G� DW����±�����5HJDUGLQJ�WKH�VWDWXWH�

7KH�VWDWXWH��ZKLFK�LV�FDSWLRQHG�µ0XVLF�EURNHUV�¶�SURYLGHV�WKDW�QR� SHUVRQ�� DVVRFLDWLRQ� RU� FRUSRUDWLRQ� RWKHU� WKDQ� WKH� µWUXH� RU�RULJLQDO� FRPSRVHU¶� VKDOO� GLUHFWO\� RU� LQGLUHFWO\� LVVXH� OLFHQVHV� RU�RWKHU� DJUHHPHQWV� IRU� WKH� SXEOLF� UHQGLWLRQ� RI� FRS\ULJKWHG�PXVLFDO�QXPEHUV� E\� SHUVRQV� ZLWKLQ� :LVFRQVLQ�� XQOHVV� VDLG� SHUVRQV��DVVRFLDWLRQ� RU� FRUSRUDWLRQ� VKDOO� ILUVW� REWDLQ� D� OLFHQVH� IURP� WKH�6HFUHWDU\� RI� 6WDWH� WR� WUDQVDFW� VXFK� EXVLQHVV�� WKDW� DQ\� DSSOLFDQW�GHVLULQJ�VXFK�OLFHQVH��VKDOO� ILOH�ZLWK�WKH�6HFUHWDU\�RI�6WDWH�FHUWDLQ�LQIRUPDWLRQ��DQG�DW�WKH�WLPH�RI�WKH�ILOLQJ�VKDOO�SD\�D�IUDQFKLVH�WD[�HTXLYDOHQW�WR�WZHQW\�ILYH�SHU�FHQW�RI�KLV�RU�LWV�JURVV�UHFHLSWV�IURP�SHUVRQV� ZLWKLQ�:LVFRQVLQ� IRU� RU� RQ� DFFRXQW� RI� OLFHQVHV� RU� RWKHU�DJUHHPHQWV� IRU� WKH� SXEOLF� UHQGLWLRQ� RI� FRS\ULJKWHG� PXVLFDO�QXPEHUV�ZLWKLQ�:LVFRQVLQ� IRU� WKH� SUHFHGLQJ� \HDU�� 7KH� OLFHQVH� LV�UHTXLUHG�WR�EH�UHQHZHG�DQQXDOO\��DQG�WKH�6HFUHWDU\�RI�6WDWH��DFWLQJ�

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 50: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řřś

7KH�6HYHQWK�&LUFXLW� UHYHUVHG��QRWLQJ� WKDW�³LW� LV� IDPLOLDU�GRFWULQH� WKDW�WKH�SURKLELWLRQ�RI�D�IHGHUDO�VWDWXWH�PD\�QRW�EH�VHW�DW�QDXJKW�E\�D�VWDWH�VWDWXWH� �� �� ��&RUUHODWLYHO\�� WKH�EHQHILWV�RI�D� IHGHUDO�VWDWXWH�PD\�QRW�EH�GHQLHG�E\�D�VWDWH�VWDWXWH�´���

0RUH� UHFHQWO\�� LQ� WKH� WUDGHPDUN� FRQWH[W�� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� LQ� DQ�LQIULQJHPHQW� DFWLRQ VRXJKW� WR� DGG� DQ� DIILUPDWLYH� GHIHQVH� WKDW� WKH�SODLQWLII� ³KDV� ZLOOIXOO\� FRQFHDOHG� WKH� WUXH� RZQHU� RI� 3ODLQWLII� LQ�YLRODWLRQ� RI� QXPHURXV� VWDWXWHV� DQG� WKHUHIRUH� XVH� RI� LWV� DOOHJHG�WUDGHPDUNV�DQG�FRS\ULJKWV�KDV�QRW�EHHQ�ODZIXO�DQG�GRHV�QRW�HVWDEOLVK�OHJDO�ULJKWV�WKHUHWR�IRU�3ODLQWLII�´��� 7KH�FRXUW�QRWHG�WKDW�WKH�GHIHQGDQW�ZDV� DWWHPSWLQJ� WR� DVVHUW� DQ� ³XQFOHDQ� KDQGV´� GHIHQVH� EDVHG� RQ�YLRODWLRQV� LQ� REWDLQLQJ� VWDWH� OLFHQVHV���� +RZHYHU�� WKH� FRXUW� UHMHFWHG�WKLV� DUJXPHQW�� DSSO\LQJ� /HR� )HLVW�� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� ³LV� DWWHPSWLQJ� WR�PDNH� >WKH� SODLQWLII¶V@� FRPSOLDQFH� ZLWK� VWDWH� OLFHQVLQJ� VWDWXWHV� D�FRQGLWLRQ�SUHFHGHQW� WR�>WKH�SODLQWLII@�DVVHUWLQJ�LWV�IHGHUDO�ULJKWV�XQGHU�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�DQG�FRS\ULJKW�DFWV�´��� 7KH�FRXUW�UHIXVHG�WR�SHUPLW�WKH�DGGLWLRQ�RI�WKH�DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH����

$OWKRXJK� WKH� 86372¶V� YHU\� ILUVW� FDVH� LQYROYLQJ� XQODZIXO� XVH�DGGUHVVHG� D� VWDWH� VWDWXWH���� WKH�86372¶V� SROLF\� H[SUHVVO\� OLPLWV� WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH� WR� IHGHUDO�VWDWXWHV���� $V� WKH�77$%�KDV�QRWHG��³µXQODZIXO¶�PXVW�EH�KHOG�WR�LPSO\�RQO\�VXFK�FRPPHUFH�DV�LV�XQODZIXO�XQGHU� WKH� $FWV� RI� &RQJUHVV�´ ��� 7KH� 77$%� KHOG� WKDW� ZKHUH� D�SHWLWLRQHU�IRU�FDQFHOODWLRQ�KDG�IDLOHG�WR�SOHDG�WKDW�D�XVH�ZDV�³XQODZIXO�XQGHU�DQ\�VWDWXWH�RI�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV�´�WKH�³XVH�FDQQRW�EH�FRQVLGHUHG�WR�YLRODWH�WKH�µLQ�FRPPHUFH¶�UHTXLUHPHQWV������ ´���

+RZHYHU��LW�LV�OHVV�FOHDU�ZKHWKHU�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�LQWHQG�WR�LPSRUW�WKLV� UHVWULFWLRQ�� � ,Q�GHYHORSLQJ� LWV�GRFWULQH� WKXV� IDU�� WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�KDV�QRW�DGGUHVVHG�WKLV�LVVXH���,Q�WKH������FDVH�WKDW�VROLGLILHG�WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW¶V� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH� WKH� FRQGXFW� WKDW� ZDV� DOOHJHG� WR� EH�

VROHO\�DV�D�PLQLVWHULDO�RIILFHU��LV�UHTXLUHG�WR�LVVXH�WKH�OLFHQVH�XSRQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�WKH�IRUHJRLQJ�SURYLVLRQV���

,G���� ,G� DW������VHH�DOVR %HOO�Y��&RPELQHG�5HJLVWU\�&R�������)��6XSS�������������

�1�'��,OO���������VWDWLQJ�³WKH�RSHUDWLRQ�RI�VWDWH�ODZ�FDQQRW�GHIHDW�WKH�YDOLGLW\�RI�D�IHGHUDO�FRS\ULJKW´��

��� 8QLYHUVDO�0IJ��&R��Y��'RXJODV�3UHVV��,QF�������)��6XSS������������1�'��,OO��������

��� ,G� DW����������� ,G���� ,G���� 6HH &RDKRPD�&KHP��&R��Y��6PLWK������8�6�3�4������������3�7�2����������� ���&�)�5�������������������� :��:RUOGZLGH�(QWHU��*US��,QF��Y��4LQTGDR�����8�6�3�4��G������������

�7�7�$�%������������ ,G�

Page 51: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řřŜ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

XQODZIXO� ZDV� WKH� IDLOXUH� WR� SD\� D� VWDWH� FRUSRUDWH� IUDQFKLVH� WD[� ���

$OWKRXJK�WKH�FRXUW�UHMHFWHG�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH��LW�GLG�VR�RQ�WKH�PHULWV��KROGLQJ�WKDW�WKH�DOOHJHG�XQODZIXO�FRQGXFW�ZDV�XQUHODWHG�WR�WKH�SXUSRVHV� RI WKH� WUDGHPDUN� ODZV� DQG� WKDW� WKH� DOOHJDWLRQV� RI� XQODZIXO�FRQGXFW� ZHUH� XQVXEVWDQWLDWHG���� 2QH� ZRXOG� WKLQN� WKDW� LI� WKH� 1LQWK�&LUFXLW� LQWHQGHG� WR� DGRSW� WKH� VWDWH� DQG� IHGHUDO� GLVWLQFWLRQ�� LW� ZRXOG�KDYH� GRQH� VR� DW� WKH� RXWVHW�� ZLWKRXW� ORRNLQJ� DW� WKH� VXEVWDQFH� RI WKH�DOOHJHG� YLRODWLRQV�� \RX� FDQ¶W� VXFFHHG� RQ� \RXU� XQODZIXO� XVH� GHIHQVH�EHFDXVH�\RX¶UH�RQO\�DOOHJLQJ�YLRODWLRQV�RI�VWDWH�ODZ���7KDW�ZRXOG�KDYH�EHHQ� D� FOHDQHU� DQG� HDVLHU� ZD\� WR� UHVROYH� WKH� LVVXH�� � ,QVWHDG�� LW�H[DPLQHG�WKH�DOOHJHG�YLRODWLRQV�DQG�KHOG�WKDW�WKH\�ZHUH�XQUHODWHG�DQG�XQVXEVWDQWLDWHG� ��� $W� OHDVW� RQH� FDVH� KDV� UHIHUHQFHG� FULPLQDO� ODZ�ZLWKRXW�QRWLQJ�LI�WKH�ODZ�DW�LVVXH�LV�VWDWH�RU�IHGHUDO���� 2QH�FDVH�QRWHG�WKDW�LW�ZDV�QRW�FOHDU�ZKHWKHU�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�FRXOG�UHVW�XSRQ�VWDWH� ODZ� ��� 1R� RWKHU� XQODZIXO� XVH� FDVHV� KDYH� FRQVLGHUHG� VWDWH�VWDWXWHV���

,I� WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� DUH� LQFOLQHG� WR� SHUPLW� VWDWH� VWDWXWHV� DQG�UHJXODWLRQV� WR� IRUP� WKH� EDVLV� RI� WKH� DSSOLFDWLRQ� RI� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH�GRFWULQH��WKH\�VKRXOG�ILUVW�UHFRQFLOH�ZKHWKHU�WKLV�LV�SHUPLVVLEOH�

�� 'RHV� WKH�$SSOLFDWLRQ�RI� WKH�8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�0DNH�WKH� /DQKDP� $FW� D� ³%DFN� 'RRU´� IRU� (QIRUFHPHQW� RI�6WDWXWHV�:LWK�1R�3ULYDWH�&DXVH�RI�$FWLRQ"

7KH�VHFRQG�TXHVWLRQ�LV�ZKHWKHU�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�PDNHV�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�D�³EDFN�GRRU´�IRU�WKH�HQIRUFHPHQW�RI�VWDWXWHV� ZLWK� QR� SULYDWH� FDXVH� RI� DFWLRQ�� � ,Q� WKH� FRQWH[W� RI� XQFOHDQ�KDQGV�� VHYHUDO� FRXUWV� KDYH� UHIXVHG� WR� ILQG� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� ZKHUH� WKH�SXUSRUWHG�³XQFOHDQOLQHVV´�FRPHV�IURP�QRQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK�WKH�)RRG��'UXJ��DQG�&RVPHWLFV�$FW��ZKLFK�FRQWDLQV�QR�SULYDWH�FDXVH�RI�DFWLRQ���,Q� RQH� FDVH�� WKH� FRXUW� H[SODLQHG� WKDW� ³>W@KH� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� GRFWULQH�VKRXOG�QRW�EDU�/DQKDP�$FW�FODLPV�ZKHQ� WKH�GRFWULQH� LV�SUHPLVHG�RQ�DOOHJDWLRQV�RI�QRQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK� WKH�)'&$�EHFDXVH�VXFK�D�XVH�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH�ZRXOG�HVVHQWLDOO\�SHUPLW�D�SULYDWH�HQIRUFHPHQW�DFWLRQ²D�SRZHU� UHVHUYHG� IRU� WKH� )'$�´��� /LNHZLVH�� LQ� ,QPXQR� 9LWDO�� ,QF�� Y��

��� 6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q�Y��=DIILQD������)��G������������WK�&LU����������� ,G� DW����±������ ,G� DW��������� 6HH��H�J���&DVK�3URFHVVLQJ�6HUYV��//&�Y��$PELHQW�(QWP¶W��,QF�������)��

$SS¶[�������������WK�&LU���������QRW�IRU�SXEOLFDWLRQ����� 9HURQLFD¶V�$XWR�,QV��6HUYV��Y��9HURQLFD¶V�6HUYV���,QF���1R��('&9����������

''3��'7%[��������:/����������DW� ���&�'��&DO��'HF����������������� +HDOWKSRLQW��/WG��Y��(WKH[�&RUS�������)��6XSS���G�����������:�'��7H[��

������

Page 52: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řřŝ

*ROGHQ�6XQ�� ,QF��� WKH�FRXUW� UHMHFWHG�QRQ�FRPSOLDQFH�ZLWK� UHJXODWLRQV�DV� D� GHIHQVH�� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� DUJXHG� WKDW� ³VLQFH� WKH� JRRGV� DUH�PLVEUDQGHG��WKH\�DUH�QRW�ODZIXOO\�XVHG�LQ�FRPPHUFH�DQG�FDQQRW�EH�WKH�EDVLV�IRU�UHJLVWHULQJ�D�WUDGHPDUN�´��� 7KH�FRXUW�UHMHFWHG�WKLV�DUJXPHQW��KROGLQJ�WKDW�

>W@R� WKH� H[WHQW� WKDW�*ROGHQ�6XQ� UHOLHV�RQ� WKHVH� IHGHUDO�VWDWXWHV�� LWV� FODLPV� IDLO� DV� D�PDWWHU� RI� ODZ� EHFDXVH� QR�SULYDWH� ULJKW� RI� DFWLRQ� H[LVWV� WR� UHGUHVV� DOOHJHG�YLRODWLRQV�RI�WKH�)'&$�������5DWKHU��WKH�ULJKW�WR�HQIRUFH�WKH�SURYLVLRQV�RI�WKH�)'&$�OLHV�H[FOXVLYHO\�ZLWKLQ�WKH�IHGHUDO� JRYHUQPHQW¶V� GRPDLQ�� E\� ZD\� RI� HLWKHU� WKH�)'$�RU�WKH�'HSDUWPHQW�RI�-XVWLFH����

7KH� FRXUW� QRWHG� WKDW�(UYD� 3KDUPDFHXWLFDOV ZDV� D� FRQWUDU\� KROGLQJ��EXW�FLWHG�D�QXPEHU�RI�FDVHV�LQ�VXSSRUW����

7KH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW¶V�UHFHQW�GHFLVLRQ�LQ�320�:RQGHUIXO GRHV�QRW�UHVROYH� WKH� LVVXH�� DOWKRXJK� LW� PD\� EH� LQVWUXFWLYH�� � 7KHUH�� WKH� &RXUW�FRQVLGHUHG� ³ZKHWKHU� D� SULYDWH� SDUW\�PD\� EULQJ� D� /DQKDP�$FW� >IDOVH�DGYHUWLVLQJ@� FODLP� FKDOOHQJLQJ� D� IRRG� ODEHO� WKDW� LV� UHJXODWHG� E\� WKH�)'&$�´ ��� 7KH� GHIHQGDQW� DUJXHG� WKDW� VLQFH� LWV� ODEHOV� ZHUH� LQ�FRPSOLDQFH� ZLWK� WKH� )'&$�� WKH� SODLQWLII� FRXOG� QRW� EULQJ� D� IDOVH�DGYHUWLVLQJ� DFWLRQ� EDVHG� RQ� WKH� FRQWHQW� RI� WKRVH� ODEHOV� EHFDXVH� WKH�)'&$�SUHFOXGHV�/DQKDP�$FW� FODLPV� FKDOOHQJLQJ� IRRG� DQG�EHYHUDJH�ODEHOV���� 7KH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW�GLVDJUHHG��ILQGLQJ�WKDW�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW�DQG� WKH� )'&$�PHUHO\� FRPSOHPHQW� RQH� DQRWKHU�� LW� XOWLPDWHO\� IRXQG�WKDW� ³>W@KH�SRVLWLRQ� >GHIHQGDQW@� WDNHV� LQ� WKLV�&RXUW� WKDW�EHFDXVH� IRRG�DQG�EHYHUDJH�ODEHOLQJ�LV�LQYROYHG�LW�KDV�QR�/DQKDP�$FW�OLDELOLW\�KHUH�IRU� SUDFWLFHV� WKDW� DOOHJHGO\� PLVOHDG� DQG� WULFN� FRQVXPHUV�� DOO� WR� WKH�LQMXU\�RI�FRPSHWLWRUV��ILQGV�QR�VXSSRUW�LQ�SUHFHGHQW�RU�WKH�VWDWXWHV�´���

(YHQ�DVVXPLQJ�WKDW�/DQKDP�$FW�IDOVH�DGYHUWLVLQJ�ZRXOG�EH�WUHDWHG�LGHQWLFDOO\� WR� /DQKDP� $FW� WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW�� WKH� FDVH� LV� QRW�GLUHFWO\�RQ�SRLQW�EHFDXVH�LW�LV�WKH�UHYHUVH�RI�WKH�VLWXDWLRQ�DGGUHVVHG�E\�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�� � ,Q�XQODZIXO XVH�FDVHV��D�SDUW\�DUJXHV�WKDW�LWV�FRPSHWLWRU�KDV�QR�ULJKWV�LQ�D�PDUN�RQ�WKH�EDVLV�WKDW�WKH�FRPSHWLWRU¶V�ODEHOV� GR� QRW FRPSO\� ZLWK� WKH� )'&$� ��� ,Q� WKH� 320 FDVH�� WKH�

��� ,QPXQR�9LWDO��,QF��Y��*ROGHQ�6XQ��,QF������)��6XSS���G�������������6�'��)OD��������

��� ,G���� ,G���� 320�:RQGHUIXO�//&�Y��&RFD�&ROD�&R�������6��&W����������������������� 6HH��H�J���LG���� ,G� DW��������� 6HH�JHQHUDOO\�+HDOWKSRLQW��/WG��Y��(WKH[�&RUS�������)��6XSS��G������:�'��

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 53: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řřŞ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

GHIHQGDQW�VRXJKW�WR�GHIHQG�RQ�WKH�EDVLV�WKDW�LWV�RZQ�ODEHOV�GLG FRPSO\�ZLWK� WKH� )'&$���� 7KH 6XSUHPH� &RXUW� KHOG� WKDW� HYHQ� LI� WKH� ODEHOV�FRPSOLHG�ZLWK� WKH� )'&$�� WKH� ODEHOV� FRXOG� VWLOO� EH�PLVOHDGLQJ� XQGHU�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW���� +RZHYHU�� WKH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW� QRWHG� WKDW�� ³320�VHHNV�WR�HQIRUFH�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW��QRW�WKH�)'&$�RU�LWV�UHJXODWLRQV�´���

'HVSLWH�WKH�FDVHV�WKDW�KROG�WKDW�PLVEUDQGLQJ�FDQQRW�EH�UDLVHG�LQ�WKH�FRQWH[W�RI�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW��QXPHURXV�FDVHV�KDYH�DFFHSWHG�WKH�XQODZIXO� XVH� RU� XQFOHDQ� KDQGV� GHIHQVH� EDVHG� RQ� WKH� )'&$�ZLWKRXW�PHQWLRQLQJ�DQ\�VXFK�SUREOHP���� $V�VXFK�� LW� LV�QRW�FOHDU�ZKHWKHU�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�LPSHUPLVVLEO\�SHUPLWV�³EDFN�GRRU´�HQIRUFHPHQW�RI� WKH� )'&$�� EXW� LW� LV� VRPHWKLQJ� FRXUWV� VKRXOG� FRQVLGHU� EHIRUH�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�

%� 3UDFWLFDO� &RQVLGHUDWLRQV� IRU� &RXUWV� $SSO\LQJ� WKH� 8QODZIXO�8VH�'RFWULQH�DQG�6XJJHVWLRQV�IRU�$GGUHVVLQJ�7KHP�

,Q� WKLV� VHFWLRQ�� ,� VXJJHVW� VRPH� EHVW� SUDFWLFHV� IRU� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV�DSSO\LQJ� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�� � 1DPHO\�� ,� VXJJHVW� WKDW� GLVWULFW�FRXUWV�PXVW�EH�PLQGIXO�RI�WKH�KDUVK�HIIHFWV�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH�DQG�WKDW�WKH�GRFWULQH� VKRXOG� EH� DSSOLHG� FRQVLVWHQWO\�� ,� DOVR� GLVFXVV� HYLGHQWLDU\�LVVXHV��SUHFOXVLRQ��DQG�WLPLQJ�RI�WKH�LQTXLU\�GXULQJ�OLWLJDWLRQ�

�� 'LVWULFW� &RXUWV� 0XVW� EH� 0LQGIXO� RI� WKH� (IIHFW� RI� WKH�'RFWULQH

$V� DQ� LQLWLDO� PDWWHU�� GLVWULFW� FRXUWV� IDFHG� ZLWK� DQ� XQODZIXO� XVH�VLWXDWLRQ� PXVW� EH� PLQGIXO� RI� ZKDW� H[DFWO\� LV� DW� LVVXH�� � ,Q� WKH� SDVW��FRXUWV� KDYH� FLWHG� WR� 77$%� SUHFHGHQW� UHJDUGLQJ� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� ZLWKRXW�GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ� EHWZHHQ� WKH� VWDNHV� ��� EXW�� DV� GLVFXVVHG� DERYH��UHJLVWUDWLRQ�LV�YHU\�GLIIHUHQW�IURP�XVH���� 1RW�EHLQJ�DEOH�WR�UHJLVWHU�D�PDUN�LV�DQ�LQFRQYHQLHQFH��QRW�EHLQJ�DEOH�WR�XVH�D�PDUN��EHFDXVH�\RX�DUH�QRZ�WKH�MXQLRU�XVHU��FRXOG�EH�GLVDVWURXV���8QODZIXO�XVH�DSSOLHV�QRW�MXVW� WR� SUHYHQW� WKH� WUDGHPDUN� KROGHU� IURP� HQIRUFLQJ� DJDLQVW� WKDW�SDUWLFXODU� GHIHQGDQW� LQ� WKDW� SDUWLFXODU� LQVWDQFH�� EXW� FRXOG� DOWHU� WKH�

7H[���������HPSKDVLV�DGGHG������ 320������6��&W��DW�������HPSKDVLV�DGGHG������ 6HH�JHQHUDOO\ LG� DW����������� ,G� DW��������� 6HH��H�J���+HDOWKSRLQW��/WG�������)��6XSS���G�DW���������� 6HH��H�J���&UH$JUL��,QF��Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6FLV��,QF�������)��G�������WK�&LU��

�������(UYD�3KDUPV���,QF��Y��$P��&\DQDPLG�&R�������)��6XSS������'�3�5���������$GYHUW��WR�:RPHQ��,QF��Y��*LDQQL�9HUVDFH��1R�����&������������:/����������1�'��,OO��$XJ��������������

��� 6HH�JHQHUDOO\ VXSUD 6HFWLRQ�,,�$���

Page 54: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řřş

SODLQWLII¶V�ULJKWV�JRLQJ�IRUZDUG����

&RXUWV� PXVW� EH� PLQGIXO� WKDW� ZKHQ� WKH\� DFFHSW� DQ� XQODZIXO� XVH�DUJXPHQW�� WKH\� DUH� FKDQJLQJ� WKH� SULRULW\� RI� XVH�� D� MXQLRU� XVHU� LV�EHFRPLQJ� D� VHQLRU�XVHU�� DQG�D� VHQLRU�XVHU� LV� ORVLQJ� LWV� ULJKW� WR�XVH�D�PDUN�WKDW�LW�PD\�KDYH�XVHG�IRU�D�ORQJ�WLPH���1RW�RQO\�GRHV�WKLV�KDYH�D�PDMRU� HIIHFW� XSRQ� WKH� SDUWLHV� WKHPVHOYHV²D� VHQLRU� XVHU� ZKR� KDV�LQYHVWHG�WLPH�DQG�PRQH\�LQWR�GHYHORSLQJ�JRRGZLOO�LQ�D�PDUN�LV�ORVLQJ�KLV� LQYHVWPHQW²EXW� FRQVXPHUV�PD\� DOVR� EH� FRQIXVHG�� � ,I� WKH� VHQLRU�XVHU� LV� IRUFHG� WR� VWRS� XVLQJ� WKH� PDUN�� FRQVXPHUV� ZLOO� IDFH� D�PDUNHWSODFH�ZLWK�RQO\�WKH�MXQLRU�XVHU¶V�VLPLODU�PDUN���7KH�VWDNHV�LQ�DQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ�DUH�KLJK��DQG�FRXUWV�VKRXOG�UHPHPEHU�WKDW�IURP�WKH�RXWVHW���

,Q� 6RXWKHUQ� &DOLIRUQLD� 'DUWV�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� WKH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW�DIILUPHG� WKH� GLVWULFW� FRXUW¶V� GHWHUPLQDWLRQ� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII� GDUWV�DVVRFLDWLRQ�KDG�EHHQ�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�ODZIXOO\��WKH�SODLQWLII�ZDV�DEOH�WR�REWDLQ� VXPPDU\� MXGJPHQW� DJDLQVW� D�GLVJUXQWOHG� IRUPHU�PHPEHU�ZKR�VHW� RXW� WR� FUHDWH� KLV� RZQ�� LGHQWLFDOO\�QDPHG� GDUWV� DVVRFLDWLRQ� ���

+RZHYHU��LPDJLQH�LI�WKH�FRXUW�KDG�IRXQG�RWKHUZLVH��DQ�DVVRFLDWLRQ�WKDW�KDG�EHHQ�XVLQJ�WKH�PDUN�VLQFH�WKH�����V�ZRXOG�KDYH�ORVW�LWV�ULJKWV�LQ�WKH�PDUN��EHFRPLQJ�WKH� MXQLRU�XVHU�YLV�D�YLV�DQ�RUJDQL]DWLRQ�IRXQGHG�LQ��������

,I� WKH� QHZ� DVVRFLDWLRQ� LV� LQIHULRU� �DIWHU� DOO�� LQ� WKLV� LQVWDQFH� LW�VRXQGHG�PRUH�OLNH�UHYHQJH�WKDQ�WKH�DFWXDO�GHVLUH�WR�KDYH�D�YLDEOH�GDUWV�DVVRFLDWLRQ��� FRQVXPHUV� DUH� JHWWLQJ� DQ� LQIHULRU� SURGXFW� DQG�PD\� QRW�UHDOL]H� WKDW� WKH\�DUH�QR� ORQJHU�GHDOLQJ�ZLWK� WKH� HVWHHPHG� DVVRFLDWLRQ�WKDW�KDV�H[LVWHG�IRU����\HDUV��EXW�LQVWHDG�DQ�XSVWDUW���$V�WR�WKH�SODLQWLII��LW� ZRXOG� UHEUDQG� DQG� SHUKDSV� UHFRYHU� �RU� QRW��� EXW� JRRGZLOO� ZRXOG�FHUWDLQO\� EH� ORVW� DORQJ� WKH�ZD\�� � 3HUKDSV� KDUP� VHHPV�PLQRU� LQ� WKLV�FLUFXPVWDQFH�� DIWHU� DOO�� LI� FRQVXPHUV� VKRZ�XS�DW� WKH�ZURQJ�EDU� IRU� D�GDUWV� FRPSHWLWLRQ� RU� VHQG� WKHLU� GXHV� WR� WKH�ZURQJ�RUJDQL]DWLRQ�� RU� LI�WKH�RULJLQDO�6RXWKHUQ�&DOLIRUQLD�'DUWV�$VVRFLDWLRQ�JRHV�EHOO\�XS�� LW¶V�XQIRUWXQDWH��EXW�LW¶V�QRW�OLIH�RU�GHDWK���+RZHYHU��LW�LV�HDV\�WR�LPDJLQH�WKH� VDPH� VFHQDULR�RFFXUULQJ� LQ� D� ILHOG�ZKHUH� WKH� VWDNHV� DUH�KLJKHU²GUXJV�RU�VXSSOHPHQWV��IRU�H[DPSOH�

�� 'LVWULFW� &RXUWV� 0XVW� $SSO\� D� &OHDU�� 7KRXJKWIXO�� DQG�&RQVLVWHQW�6WDQGDUG

2YHU� WKH� \HDUV�� FRXUWV� KDYH� DSSOLHG� D� YDULHW\� RI� VWDQGDUGV� WR� WKH�XQODZIXO� XVH� LVVXH�� IURP� VLPSO\� VWDWLQJ� WKDW� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRHV� QRW�

��� &UH$JUL��,QF�������)��G�DW�������� 6HH 6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q�Y��=DIILQD������)��G����������±�����WK�&LU���������

Page 55: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŚŖ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

FUHDWH� WUDGHPDUN� ULJKWV� ��� WR� SDUWLDOO\� DGRSWLQJ� WKH� 77$%¶V�VWDQGDUG���� WR� LPSRUWLQJ� WKH� 77$%� VWDQGDUG�ZKROHVDOH���� ,� VXJJHVW�WKDW� WKH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW¶V� DSSURDFK�� DV� UHFHQWO\� VWDWHG� LQ� 6RXWKHUQ�&DOLIRUQLD�'DUWV�� LV�PRVW�FRUUHFW� LQ� WKH�VHQVH�WKDW� LW�DSSHDUV�WR�DGRSW�WKH� ³QH[XV´� DQG� ³PDWHULDOLW\´� SURQJV� RI� WKH� 77$%� WHVW�� EXW� QRW� WKH�³SHU�VH´�FRQVWUDLQW���$OWKRXJK�DGRSWLQJ�WKH�86372¶V�WHVW��DV�LV��ZRXOG�FUHDWH� DQ� LPPHGLDWH� ERG\� RI� SUHFHGHQW� WR�ZKLFK� FRXUWV� DQG� OLWLJDQWVFRXOG� ORRN� IRU� SHUVXDVLYH� DXWKRULW\�� WKH� LQDSSOLFDELOLW\� RI� WKH� SROLF\�UDWLRQDOH�EHKLQG�WKH�³SHU�VH´�FRQVWUDLQW��GLVFXVVHG�LQIUD��ZRXOG�PDNH�WKLV�FRXUVH�XQZLVH�

D� 1H[XV�&ROODWHUDO�5HTXLUHPHQW

7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW�KDV�VWDWHG�WKDW�³WUDGHPDUN�SURWHFWLRQ�PLJKW�QRW�EH�ZLWKKHOG�RQ�DFFRXQW�RI�XQODZIXO�FRQGXFW�WKDW�LV�µFROODWHUDO�¶�QDPHO\�ZKHUH� WKHUH� LV� DQ� LQVXIILFLHQW� QH[XV� EHWZHHQ� WKH� XQODZIXO� EHKDYLRU�DQG� WKH� XVH� RI� WKH� PDUN� LQ� FRPPHUFH�´��� ,Q� 6RXWKHUQ� &DOLIRUQLD�'DUWV�� DOOHJDWLRQV� RI� XQSDLG� WD[HV� ZHUH� GHHPHG� XQUHODWHG� WR� WKH�SXUSRVHV� RI� WKH� IHGHUDO� WUDGHPDUN� ODZV� ��� 6LPLODUO\�� LQ� &DVK�3URFHVVLQJ� 6HUYLFHV�� WKH� IDFW� WKDW� WKH� SODLQWLII� FRPPLWWHG� FULPHV�GXULQJ� WKH�SHULRG�RI�RZQHUVKLS�RI� WKH�EXVLQHVV�EHDULQJ� WKH�PDUN�GLG�QRW� DIIHFW� RZQHUVKLS� ��� 7KH� QH[XV� UHTXLUHPHQW� IRUFHV� OLWLJDQWV²EHIRUH� VSHQGLQJ� WRR� PXFK� WLPH� DQG� PRQH\� GLJJLQJ� XS� REVFXUH�YLRODWLRQV� RI� WDQJHQWLDO� UHJXODWLRQV²WR� DVN� WKHPVHOYHV� ZKHWKHU� WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�LV�WUXO\�UHODWHG�WR�WKH�SXUSRVHV�RI�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�ODZV���,I�WKHUH� LV� QR� QH[XV�� WKH� FRXUW� FDQ� VWRS� LWV� DQDO\VLV� WKHUH�� DV� XQUHODWHG�XQODZIXO� DFWLRQV� ZLOO� QRW� EDU� WKH� HVWDEOLVKPHQW� RU� HQIRUFHPHQW� RI�WUDGHPDUN�ULJKWV����

E� 0DWHULDOLW\

7KH� 1LQWK� &LUFXLW� KDV� KHOG� WKDW� ³XQODZIXO� FRQGXFW� >ZLOO@� QRW�SUHFOXGH� WUDGHPDUN�SURWHFWLRQ� LI� LW� >LV@� µLPPDWHULDO�¶�QDPHO\� LI� LW� >LV@�

��� 6HH�8QLWHG�3KRVSKRUXV�Y��0LGODQG�)XPLJDQW��,QF�������)��G���������������WK�&LU����������

��� 6HH 6��&DO��'DUWV������)��G�DW������&UH$JUL��,QF�������)��G�DW����±������ 6HH 7DVVHO�5LGJH�:LQHU\�Y��:RRGPLOO�:LQHU\��,QF���1R�������FY�������

5/9�'6&�������:/����������:�'�1�&��2FW������������$GYHUW��WR�:RPHQ��,QF��Y��*LDQQL�9HUVDFH�6�3�$���1R�����&������������:/����������1�'��,OO��$XJ������������

��� 6��&DO��'DUWV������)��G�DW�������� ,G���� &DVK�3URFHVVLQJ�6HUYV���//&�Y��$PELHQW�(QWP¶W��,QF�������)�$SS¶[�������

������WK�&LU������������� ,G�

Page 56: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŚŗ

QRW� µRI� VXFK�JUDYLW\�DQG�VLJQLILFDQFH� WKDW� WKH�XVDJH�RI� WKH�PDUN�DV�D�PDWWHU� RI� ODZ�� FDQ� FUHDWH� QR� WUDGHPDUN� ULJKWV�¶´ ��� )HGHUDO� FRXUWV�VKRXOG� DOVR� DGRSW� WKLV� UHTXLUHPHQW�� � 0DWHULDOLW\� VSHDNV� WR� WKH�VHULRXVQHVV�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�FRQGXFW���3HUKDSV�WKH�VWDWXWHV�KDYH�D�FORVH�FRQQHFWLRQ�WR�WKH�SXUSRVHV�RI�WUDGHPDUN�ODZV²VXFK�DV�ODEHOLQJ²EXW�WKH�YLRODWLRQV�WKHPVHOYHV�DUH�PLQRU���7KLV�UHTXLUHPHQW�JLYHV�WKH�FRXUW�GLVFUHWLRQ� WR� GHFOLQH� WR� ILQG� WKDW� VXFK� YLRODWLRQV� SUHYHQW� WKH�GHYHORSPHQW�RI�ULJKWV�

)RU� H[DPSOH�� LQ�'HVVHUW� %HDXW\� ,QF�� Y�� )R[�� WKH� FRXUW� KHOG� WKDW�FHUWDLQ� ODEHOLQJ� YLRODWLRQV� ZHUH� LPPDWHULDO�� GHVSLWH� WHFKQLFDOO\�YLRODWLQJ�WKH�)'&$���� 7KH�FRXUW�SRLQWHG�WR�ODQJXDJH�LQ�WKH�77$%¶V�*HQHUDO�0LOOV GHFLVLRQ�WKDW�³GUHZ�D�GLVWLQFWLRQ�EHWZHHQ�PDWHULDO�QRQ�FRPSOLDQFH�DQG�D�YLRODWLRQ� WKDW�ZDV�µSXUHO\� WHFKQLFDO� LQ�QDWXUH�¶�DQG�ZKLFK� µPD\� EH� UHODWLYHO\� KDUPOHVV� DQG� PD\� EH� VXEVHTXHQWO\�FRUUHFWHG�¶´��� 7KH�FRXUW�H[SODLQHG� WKDW� WKLV� UHTXLUHPHQW�FRXOG� VHUYH�DV�D�FKHFN�DJDLQVW�FDQFHOODWLRQ�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�IRU�PLQRU�YLRODWLRQV����

,Q� (UYD�� KRZHYHU�� WKRXJK� QRW� GLVFXVVLQJ� PDWHULDOLW\� E\� QDPH�� WKH�FRXUW�IRXQG�WKDW� ODEHOLQJ�YLRODWLRQV�UHJDUGLQJ�W\SHVL]H�DQG�SODFHPHQW�RI� LQIRUPDWLRQ� �WKRXJK� DOO� UHTXLUHG� LQIRUPDWLRQ� ZDV� SUHVHQW� RQ� WKH�ODEHO��ZHUH�VXIILFLHQW�WR�VXSSRUW�D�ILQGLQJ�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH����

7KH� LPSRUWDQFH� RI� WKH�PDWHULDOLW\� UHTXLUHPHQW� LV� HYLGHQFHG� E\� D�FRPSDULVRQ�RI�WZR�FDVHV��ERWK�LQYROYLQJ�WKH�VDOH�RI�ZLQH�DQG�D�IDLOXUH�WR�REWDLQ�WKH�SURSHU�&HUWLILFDWLRQ�RI�/DEHO�%RWWOH�$SSURYDO��³&2/$´��EHIRUH�VDOH���,Q�&KXUFKLOO�&HOODUV�Y��%ULDQ�*UDKDP��D�77$%�FDVH��DQ�RSSRVHU�DUJXHG�WKDW�DQ�DSSOLFDQW¶V�SULRULW\�GDWH�PXVW�EH�RQ�RU�DIWHU�WKH�GDWH� WKDW� WKH� &2/$� ZDV� LVVXHG�� LQ� RWKHU� ZRUGV�� VDOHV� SULRU� WR� WKH�LVVXDQFH�RI� WKH�&2/$�FRXOG�QRW�FRXQW� WRZDUG�HVWDEOLVKLQJ�DQ�HDUOLHU�GDWH�RI�ILUVW�XVH���� 7KH�77$%�GLVDJUHHG��KROGLQJ�WKDW�WKH�YLRODWLRQ²ZKLFK� ZDV� UHFWLILHG� D� IHZ� PRQWKV� ODWHU²ZDV� QRW� PDWHULDO� ���

3HUPLWWLQJ�WKH�HDUOLHU�SULRULW\�GDWH�WR�VWDQG�ZDV�GLVSRVLWLYH���� 2Q�WKH�FRQWUDU\�� LQ� 7DVVHO� 5LGJH� :LQHU\�� D� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� LQ� 1RUWK� &DUROLQD�KHOG� WKDW� ³DQ\� VDOH� RI� �� �� �� ZLQH� SULRU� WR� >WKH� LVVXDQFH� GDWH� RI� WKH�

��� 6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q������)��G��DW������LQWHUQDO EUDFNHWV�DQG�PRGLILFDWLRQV�RPLWWHG���TXRWLQJ�*HQ��0LOOV�,QF��Y��+HDOWK�9DOOH\�)RRGV�����8�6�3�4��G�������������7�7�$�%���������

��� ����)��6XSS���G�����������6�'�1�<����������� ,G� �TXRWLQJ�*HQ��0LOOV�,QF������8�6�3�4��G�DW���������� ,G���� (UYD�3KDUP���,QF� Y��$P��&\DQDPLG�&R�������)��6XSS����������'�3�5����������� &KXUFKLOO�&HOODUV��,QF��Y��*UDKDP��2SSRVLWLRQ�1R�����������������:/�

���������DW� ���7�7�$�%��2FW��������������� ,G� DW� ������� ,G� DW� �����

Page 57: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŚŘ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

&2/$@��ZDV�QRW�ODZIXO�IRU�SXUSRVHV�RI�GHWHUPLQLQJ�SULRULW\�´��� 7KLV�ZDV�VR�HYHQ�WKRXJK��DV�LQ�&KXUFKLOO�&HOODUV��WKH�YLRODWLRQ�ZDV�UHFWLILHG�D�IHZ�PRQWKV�ODWHU����

7KH�PDWHULDOLW\� UHTXLUHPHQW�SUHYHQWV�PLQRU�YLRODWLRQV�RI� UHOHYDQW�VWDWXWHV� IURP� KDYLQJ� WKH� HIIHFW� RI� UHQGHULQJ� HVWDEOLVKHG� ULJKWV�XQHQIRUFHDEOH�� DQG� DOORZV� FRXUWV� WR� XVH� WKHLU� GLVFUHWLRQ� WR� UHIXVH� WR�DSSO\� WKH� XQODZIXO� XVH� GRFWULQH�� �$V� VXFK�� WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� VKRXOG�DGRSW� LW�� � )XUWKHU�� ERWK� DV� WR� PDWHULDOLW\� DQG� DV� WR� WKH� ³QH[XV´�UHTXLUHPHQW�� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� VKRXOG� ORRN� WR� 77$%� SUHFHGHQW� IRU� LWV�SHUVXDVLYH�YDOXH�LQ�PDNLQJ�WKHVH�GHWHUPLQDWLRQV�

F� 3HU�6H

7KHUH�PD\�EH�DOOHJDWLRQV�RI�D�PDMRU�YLRODWLRQ�RI�D�VWDWXWH�UHOHYDQW�WR� WKH�SXUSRVH�RI� WKH� WUDGHPDUN� ODZV��EXW�KRZ�VKRXOG�D�FRXUW�KDQGOH�WKH�VLWXDWLRQ�LI�WKHUH�KDV�QRW�EHHQ�D�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ�WKDW�WKH�DFWV�DOOHJHG�RFFXUUHG��RU�LI�WKH�SDUWLHV�DJUHH�WKDW�FHUWDLQ�DFWV�RFFXUUHG��EXW�GLVDJUHH�DV� WR�ZKHWKHU� WKH� DFWV� DPRXQW� WR� D� YLRODWLRQ"� � 7KH�PRGHUQ 86372�DQVZHU�LV�HDV\��LI�WKHUH�LV�DQ\�XQFHUWDLQW\��WKH�YLRODWLRQ�GRHVQ¶W�FRXQW��DQG�WKH�ULJKWV�DUH�XQDIIHFWHG���� $OWKRXJK�LQLWLDOO\�WKH�SROLF\�ZDV�QRW�DV� VWULQJHQW� ��� WKH� GRFWULQH� ZDV� HYHQWXDOO\� QDUURZHG�� 7KH� 86372�IHDUHG�SODFLQJ�DXWKRULW\�WR�LQWHUSUHW�DQG DSSO\�WKH�PXOWLWXGH�RI�IHGHUDO�VWDWXWHV�DQG�UHJXODWLRQV��IURP�DOO�PDQQHU�RI�DJHQFLHV��RQ�WKH�WUDGHPDUN�H[DPLQHU�ZKR�VSHFLDOL]HV�RQO\�LQ�WUDGHPDUN�ODZV���� $FFRUGLQJO\��WKH�86372�LPSRVHG�D�VHYHUH�UHVWULFWLRQ²WKDW�WKH�YLRODWLRQ�PXVW�EH�³SHU�VH´²RQ�WKH�GRFWULQH���� 6RPH�FRXUWV�KDYH�DGRSWHG�WKLV�UHTXLUHPHQW�DV�ZHOO�� IRU� H[DPSOH�� WKH� ,PSXOVDULD FRXUW�QRWHG� WKDW� ³WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH�LV�QRW�JHQHUDOO\�DSSOLHG�DEVHQW�D�ILQGLQJ�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH�E\�D�FRXUW�RU�DSSURSULDWH�JRYHUQPHQW�DJHQF\��RU�D�FOHDU�SHU�VH�YLRODWLRQ�´���

+RZHYHU��DV�D�SUDFWLFDO�PDWWHU��D�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�QHHG�QRW�EH�VXEMHFW�WR� VXFK� D� UHVWULFWLRQ�� � )HGHUDO� FRXUWV� GR� QRW� VXIIHU� IURP� WKH� VDPH�OLPLWDWLRQV�DV�D� WUDGHPDUN�H[DPLQHU� �RU� HYHQ� WKH�77$%�� LQ�DSSO\LQJ�IHGHUDO� ODZV�DQG�UHJXODWLRQV�� �$�IHGHUDO�FRXUW�KDV�WKH�NQRZOHGJH�DQG�UHVRXUFHV�DYDLODEOH�WR�LQWHUSUHW�IHGHUDO�VWDWXWHV�DQG�UHJXODWLRQV��DQG�LV�

��� 7DVVHO�5LGJH�:LQHU\ Y��:RRGPLOO�:LQHU\��,QF���1R�������FY�������5/9�'6&�������:/����������DW� ���:�'�1�&��2FW�������������

��� ,G���� 6HH 0&&$57+<��VXSUD QRWH���� ������������ 6HH GLVFXVVLRQ�VXSUD�6HFWLRQ�,,�%������ 0&&$57+<� VXSUD�QRWH����������������� ,G���� ,PSXOVDULD�//&�Y��8QLWHG�'LVWULE��*US���//&��1R�������&9������������:/�

���������DW� ���:�'��0LFK��2FW������������

Page 58: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŚř

RIWHQ�FDOOHG�XSRQ�WR�GR�VR���� 7KH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW¶V�DSSURDFK�GRHV�QRW�LQTXLUH� DV� WR� ZKHWKHU� WKH� YLRODWLRQ�ZDV� D� ³SHU� VH´� YLRODWLRQ�� VLPSO\�UHTXLULQJ�WKDW�WKH�HYLGHQFH�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH�EH�VXEVWDQWLDWHG���� 7KLV�LV�SUREDEO\�HQRXJK�

�� (YLGHQFH�3URFHGXUH

D� :KR�KDV�WKH�EXUGHQ�RI�SURRI"

0RVW� FRXUWV� KDYH� DGGUHVVHG� XQODZIXO� XVH� LQ� WKH� FRQWH[W� RI� DQ�DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH���� PHDQLQJ�WKDW�HYHQ�LI�WKH�GHIHQGDQW�LV�RWKHUZLVH�OLDEOH�� LI� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� FDQ� SURYH� WKH� HOHPHQWV� RI� WKH� DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH��LW�ZRXOG�QHJDWH�WKH�OLDELOLW\���7KH�LVVXH�XVXDOO\�DULVHV�ZKHQ�D�GHIHQGDQW�LV�VXHG�IRU�WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�DQG�GHIHQGV�E\�FODLPLQJ�WKDW�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�XVH�LV�XQODZIXO�DQG�WKHUHIRUH�WKH�SODLQWLII�GRHV�QRW�KDYH� WKH� ULJKWV� LW� FODLPV�� �7KH� FRXUW� UHTXLUHV� WKH� GHIHQGDQW� WR� SURYH�WKDW�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�XVH�LV�XQODZIXO���

7KH�DOWHUQDWLYH�ZRXOG�EH�WR�LQFOXGH�ODZIXO�XVH�DV�SDUW�RI�WKH�SULPD�IDFLH�FDVH���$�SODLQWLII�FODLPLQJ�SULRULW\�RI�XVH�ZRXOG�KDYH�WR�VKRZ��DV�SDUW� RI� LWV� SULPD� IDFLH� FDVH�� WKDW� WKH� XVH� ZDV� ODZIXO�� � $V� WKH� 1LQWK�&LUFXLW� KDV� KHOG�� ³RQO\� ODZIXO XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH� FDQ� JLYH� ULVH� WR�WUDGHPDUN�SULRULW\�´��� 7KHQ�� D�GHIHQGDQW� UDLVLQJ� WKH� LVVXH�ZRXOG�EH�VLPSO\�UDLVLQJ�D�GHIHQVH��L�H���WKH�SODLQWLII�ZRXOG�KDYH�WR�SURYH�WKDW�LW�FRPSOLHG� ZLWK� WKH� DSSOLFDEOH� UHJXODWLRQV�� � ,Q� DVVHUWLQJ� WUDGHPDUN�LQIULQJHPHQW�� D� SODLQWLII� PXVW� VKRZ� ³���� LW� KDV� D� YDOLG� DQG� OHJDOO\�SURWHFWDEOH�PDUN������LW�RZQV�WKH�PDUN��DQG�����WKH�GHIHQGDQWV�XVH�RI�WKH� PDUN� WR� LGHQWLI\� JRRGV� RU� VHUYLFHV� FDXVHV� D� OLNHOLKRRG� RI�FRQIXVLRQ�´��� 7\SLFDOO\��D�IHGHUDO�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�LV�SULPD�IDFLH�HYLGHQFH�WKDW� WKH� ILUVW� WZR� HOHPHQWV� KDYH� EHHQ�PHW���� $� IHGHUDO� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�FRXOG�DOVR�EH�SULPD�IDFLH�HYLGHQFH�RI�ODZIXO�XVH���3HUPLWWLQJ�D�IHGHUDO�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�WR�VHUYH�DV�SULPD�IDFLH�HYLGHQFH�RI�ODZIXOQHVV�ZRXOG�PDNH�VHQVH�� DV� WKH� 86372� LV� DEOH� WR� HYDOXDWH� ODZIXOQHVV� GXULQJ� WKH�

��� 6HH�/$55<�0� (,*��&21*� 5(6($5&+�6(59�����������67$78725<�,17(535(7$7,21� *(1(5$/�35,1&,3/(6�$1'�5(&(17�75(1'6 ���������

��� 6HH�6��&DO��'DUWV Y��=DIILQD������)��G������������WK�&LU����������� 6HH�H�J���*R&OHDU�//&�Y��7DUJHW�&RUS���1R��&���������00&�������:/�

��������DW� ���1�'��&DO��-DQ�������������UHIHUULQJ�WR�WKH�GRFWULQH�DV�DQ�DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH��

��� &UH$JUL�Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6FLV���,QF�������)��G������������WK�&LU���������HPSKDVLV�LQ�RULJLQDO��

��� 6HH��H�J���(�$��6ZHHQ�&R��Y��'HOL�([S��RI�7HQDIO\��//&�����)��6XSS���G�����������'�1�-���������TXRWLQJ�$��+�6SRUWVZHDU��,QF��Y��9LFWRULD¶V�6HFUHW�6WRUHV��,QF������)��G������������G�&LU���������

��� 6HH�LG� DW������

Page 59: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŚŚ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

UHJLVWUDWLRQ�SURFHVV�DQG�FDQFHO�RU�UHIXVH�UHJLVWUDWLRQV�WKDW�GR�QRW�VKRZ�ODZIXO�XVH�RI�WKH�PDUN���

2YHUDOO�� LW� VHHPV� WKDW� WKH� SDUW\� DVVHUWLQJ� WKDW� WKH� FRQGXFW� LV�XQODZIXO� VKRXOG� KDYH� WKH� EXUGHQ� RI� SURRI�� � )URP� D� SUDFWLFDO�SHUVSHFWLYH�� WKLV�ZLOO� RSHUDWH� WR� HQVXUH� WKDW� WLPH�DQG�PRQH\� LV� VSHQW�ORRNLQJ�LQWR�XQODZIXO�XVH�RQO\�ZKHUH�LW�LV�ZDUUDQWHG��DQG�WKDW�WKH�FRVWV�DUH�ERUQH�E\�WKH�SHUVRQ�VHHNLQJ�WR�DVVHUW�LW�

E� 0XVW�LW�EH�D�GHIHQVH"

$OWKRXJK� PRVW� XQODZIXO� XVH� VFHQDULRV� DULVH� DV� D� GHIHQVH� WR�WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW�� DQG�PDQ\�FRXUWV� UHIHU� WR� LW� DV� WKH�³XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH�´�PXVW�WKH�GRFWULQH�RSHUDWH�WKDW�ZD\"��,Q�RWKHU�ZRUGV��WKH�GRFWULQH� LV� W\SLFDOO\� D� VKLHOG�� D� GHIHQGDQW� LQ� DQ� LQIULQJHPHQW� DFWLRQ�VD\V�³\RX�FDQ¶W�HQIRUFH�DJDLQVW�PH�EHFDXVH�\RX�GRQ¶W�KDYH�WKH�ULJKWV�\RX� FODLP�� VLQFH� \RX¶UH� XQODZIXOO\� XVLQJ� WKH�PDUN�´� � %XW�� LQ� PDQ\�FDVHV�LW�LV�DOVR�D�VZRUG��SURRI�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH�FDQ�HOLPLQDWH�WKH�VHQLRU�XVHU¶V� ULJKWV� E\� PRYLQJ� LWV� SULRULW\� GDWH� EHKLQG� WKH� MXQLRU� XVHU¶V��OHDGLQJ�WR�FDQFHOODWLRQ�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQV�RU�HYHQ�D�MXQLRU�XVHU�WDNLQJ�WKH�VHQLRU� XVHU¶V� SRVLWLRQ���� &RXOG� D� MXQLRU� XVHU� VXH� D� VHQLRU� XVHU� IRU�WUDGHPDUN� LQIULQJHPHQW� DQG� FODLP� WKDW� WKH� VHQLRU� XVHU¶V� XVH� LV�LQIULQJLQJ�EHFDXVH�LW�GRHV�QRW�KDYH�WKH�ULJKWV�LW�FODLPV"��,W�ZRXOG�VHHP�VR�� �$FFRUGLQJO\�� LW� LV�SUREDEO\�QRW�FRPSOHWHO\�SURSHU� WR� UHIHU� WR� WKH�GRFWULQH�DV�WKH�³XQODZIXO�XVH�GHIHQVH´�H[FHSW�ZKHQ�LW�LV�EHLQJ�XVHG�DV�VXFK�

F� :KDW�NLQG�RI�SURRI�ZLOO�VXIILFH"

7KH�DOUHDG\�H[LVWLQJ�UXOHV�JRYHUQLQJ�WKH�DGPLVVLELOLW\�RI�HYLGHQFH�VKRXOG� EH� VXIILFLHQW� WR� DGGUHVV� SURRI� RI� XQODZIXO� XVH�� QDPHO\�� WKH�HYLGHQFH� VKRXOG�EH� DGPLVVLEOH� HLWKHU�EHFDXVH� LW� LV� VXEMHFW� WR� MXGLFLDO�QRWLFH��LQ�WKH�FDVH�RI�D�JXLOW\�YHUGLFW�RU�DQ�DJHQF\�ILQGLQJ��RU�EHFDXVH�LW�LV�D�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ�PDGH�LQ�WKH�ILUVW�LQVWDQFH�E\�WKH�FRXUW�LWVHOI�EDVHG�RQ�DUJXPHQW�RI� WKH�SDUWLHV���� 1R�DGGLWLRQDO�IUDPHZRUN�LV�QHFHVVDU\���+RZHYHU��WKH�DOOHJDWLRQV�PXVW�EH�VXEVWDQWLDWHG����

:KDW�W\SHV�RI�HYLGHQFH�DUH�DYDLODEOH�WR�VXEVWDQWLDWH�DOOHJDWLRQV�RI�XQODZIXO� XVH"� � ([SHUW� WHVWLPRQ\� FRXOG� EH� RQH� RSWLRQ�� DOWKRXJK� WKH�H[SHUW� WHVWLPRQ\�SURIIHUHG� LQ�9RVN ZDV� UHMHFWHG���� 7KH� FRXUW� IRXQG�

��� 6HH�&UH$JUL������)��G�DW����±������ 6HH�)('� 5� (9,'� �������������� 6��&DO��'DUWV�$VV¶Q�Y��=DIILQD������)��G������������WK�&LU����������� 9RVN�,QW¶O��&R��Y��=DR�*UXSSD�3UHGSUL\DWLM�2VW��1R��&�������56/�������:/�

���������DW� ���:�'��:DVK��2FW�����������

Page 60: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŚś

WKDW� WKH� H[SHUW� GLG� QRW� PHHW� WKH� W\SLFDO� UHTXLUHPHQWV�� DOWKRXJK� DQ�H[SHUW�LQ�)'$�LPSRUW�RSHUDWLRQV��VKH�ZDV�QRW�DQ�H[SHUW�LQ�WKH�UHOHYDQW�ILHOG� �EHYHUDJH� PDQXIDFWXULQJ��� WKH� RSLQLRQ� ZDV� QRW� WKH� SURGXFW� RI�UHOLDEOH�SULQFLSOHV�DQG�PHWKRGV��DQG�GLG�QRW�DGGUHVV�WKH�UHOHYDQW�WLPH�SHULRG���� 3HUKDSV�PRUH� KHOSIXOO\�� WKH� FRXUW� IRXQG� WKDW� D� FRQFOXVLRQ�WKDW� ODEHOV� ZULWWHQ� LQ� 5XVVLDQ� YLRODWH� )'$� UHJXODWLRQV� ³SURYLGHV� QR�DGGLWLRQDO�LQVLJKW�EH\RQG�WKH�GRFXPHQW�RQ�ZKLFK�VKH�UHOLHV�´���

,Q�*R&OHDU��WKH�FRXUW�H[SODLQHG�WKDW�*R&OHDU�KDG�RIIHUHG�HYLGHQFH��LQ� WKH� IRUP� RI� SKRWRJUDSKV� DQG GHFODUDWLRQV�� WKDW� &/($5� ;� ZDV�DGYHUWLVHG�DV�D�SURGXFW�WR�WUHDW�DFQH��WKDW�WKH�SURGXFW�ZDV�GHOLYHUHG�WR�PXOWLSOH� VWDWHV�� DQG� WKDW� WKH� SURGXFW� ZDV� QRW� WKH� VXEMHFW� RI� D� ³QHZ�GUXJ´� DSSOLFDWLRQ� ZLWK� WKH� )'$���� 7KLV� ZDV� HQRXJK� IRU� VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�LQ�*R&OHDU¶V IDYRU��DV�WR�D�FDQFHOODWLRQ�FODLP����� /LNHZLVH��LQ� (UYD� 3KDUPDFHXWLFDOV�� WKH� FRXUW� IRXQG� XQODZIXO� XVH� EDVHG�DSSDUHQWO\�XSRQ� ORRNLQJ�DW� WKH� ODEHO� IRU� WKH�GUXJ�DQG�QRWLQJ� WKDW� WKH�IRQW�VL]H�ZDV�LQFRUUHFW��WKH�FKHPLFDO�QDPH�GLG�QRW�DSSHDU�ZKHUH�LW�ZDV�VXSSRVHG�WR��DQG�RWKHU�VLPLODU�ILQGLQJV����

�� :KDW�HIIHFW�VKRXOG�D�ILQGLQJ�RI�WKH�86372�KDYH"

,W�LV�SRVVLEOH�WR�LPDJLQH�D�VLWXDWLRQ�ZKHUH�D�SDUW\�KDV�EHHQ�XVLQJ�D�PDUN� IRU� \HDUV�� DQG� ILQDOO\� GHFLGHV� WR� UHJLVWHU� WKH� PDUN� ZLWK� WKH�86372�� � 7KH� SDUW\� DSSOLHV� IRU� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� EXW� WKH� 86372� GHQLHV�UHJLVWUDWLRQ� EHFDXVH� RI� D� ODEHOLQJ� GHIHFW�� RU� DQRWKHU� SDUW\� RSSRVHV�UHJLVWUDWLRQ� RQ� WKH� JURXQGV� WKDW� WKH� SDUW\� KDV� EHHQ� XVLQJ� WKH� PDUN�XQODZIXOO\���7KH�86732�GHWHUPLQHV�WKDW�WKH�PDUN�VKRXOG�QRW�UHJLVWHU�EHFDXVH� WKHUH� KDV� EHHQ� QR� ODZIXO� XVH� LQ� FRPPHUFH�� � :KDW� HIIHFW�VKRXOG� WKLV� GHWHUPLQDWLRQ� KDYH� LQ� D� VXEVHTXHQW� IHGHUDO� FRXUW�LQIULQJHPHQW�SURFHHGLQJ"��2U��PRUH�RPLQRXVO\��LV�WKLV�ILQGLQJ�D�ORWWHU\�WLFNHW� WKDW� WKH� RSSRVHU� FDQ� FDVK� LQ� LQ� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� IRU� WKH� SUL]H� RI�EHFRPLQJ�WKH�VHQLRU�XVHU"��

7KLV� VFHQDULR� UDLVHV� WKH� LVVXH� RI� FROODWHUDO� HVWRSSHO� �QRZ� FDOOHG�LVVXH�SUHFOXVLRQ����7KH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW�UHFHQWO\�DGGUHVVHG�WKH�LVVXH�LQ�DQRWKHU� FRQWH[W� LQ� %� � %� +DUGZDUH�� ,QF�� ��� ILQGLQJ� WKDW� D�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ� RI� WKH� 77$%� UHJDUGLQJ� OLNHOLKRRG� RI FRQIXVLRQ� ZDV�ELQGLQJ� RQ� WKH� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� LQ� D� FRQFXUUHQW� LQIULQJHPHQW�

��� ,G� DW� �������� ,G� DW� ����� *R&OHDU�Y��7DUJHW�&RUS���1R��&���������00&�������:/���������DW� ��

�1�'��&DO��-DQ����������������� ,G� DW� ����� (UYD�3KDUP���,QF��Y��$P��&\DQDPLG�&R�������)��6XSS��������±����'�3�5��

��������� %��%�+DUGZDUH�Y��+DUJLV�,QGXV���,QF�������6��&W��������������������

Page 61: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŚŜ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

SURFHHGLQJ� ��� 7KHUH�� VRPH� RI� WKH� PDLQ� FRQFHUQV� ZHUH� WKDW� WKH�77$%¶V� GHWHUPLQDWLRQ� RQ� OLNHOLKRRG� RI� FRQIXVLRQ� VKRXOG� QRW� EH�ELQGLQJ� XSRQ� WKH� GLVWULFW� FRXUW� ZKHUH� WKH� 77$%� LV� WDVNHG� ZLWK�GHWHUPLQLQJ� UHJLVWUDWLRQ�� QRW� LQIULQJHPHQW�� DQG� WKH� 77$%� XVHV�GLIIHUHQW� IDFWRUV� WKDQ� WKH� (LJKWK� &LUFXLW� WR� GHWHUPLQH� OLNHOLKRRG� RI�FRQIXVLRQ���� +RZHYHU�� WKH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW�KHOG� WKDW�QHLWKHU�RI� WKHVH�WKLQJV� PDWWHUHG�� FDOOLQJ� WKH� ³UHDO� TXHVWLRQ´� ³ZKHWKHU� OLNHOLKRRG� RI�FRQIXVLRQ� IRU� SXUSRVHV� RI� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� LV� WKH� VDPH� VWDQGDUG� DV�OLNHOLKRRG� RI� FRQIXVLRQ� IRU� SXUSRVHV� RI� LQIULQJHPHQW�´��� 7KH�&RXUW�GHWHUPLQHG�WKDW�WKH�VWDQGDUG�ZDV�WKH�VDPH���� 7KH�&RXUW�DOVR�UHMHFWHG�RWKHU�DUJXPHQWV�DWWHPSWLQJ�WR�GLIIHUHQWLDWH� WKH�WZR�YHQXHV�� LQFOXGLQJ�WKH� IDFW� WKDW� WKH� 77$%� KDV� SURFHGXUDO� GLIIHUHQFHV� �VXFK� DV� QR� OLYH�ZLWQHVV� WHVWLPRQ\�� DQG� WKH� LGHD� WKDW� WKH� VWDNHV� IRU� UHJLVWUDWLRQ� DUH�PXFK� ORZHU� WKDQ� WKH� VWDNHV� IRU� LQIULQJHPHQW� ��� 0DQ\� RI� WKHVH�DUJXPHQWV�DUH�VLPLODU�WR�WKRVH�WKDW�FRXOG�EH�UDLVHG�LQ�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�FRQWH[W���

,W� LV� ZRUWK� QRWLQJ�� KRZHYHU�� WKDW� WKH� %� � %� +DUGZDUH�� ,QF�GHFLVLRQ� ZDV� ORRNLQJ� DW� WKH� HIIHFW� RI� D� ILQDO� GHWHUPLQDWLRQ� E\� WKH�77$%�LQ�DQ�RSSRVLWLRQ�SURFHHGLQJ��ZKHUH�WKH�SDUWLHV�WR�WKH�RSSRVLWLRQ�ZHUH�WKH�VDPH�SDUWLHV�OLWLJDWLQJ�WKH�LVVXH�RI�OLNHOLKRRG�RI�FRQIXVLRQ�LQ�IHGHUDO� FRXUW���� ,W� LV� OHVV� FHUWDLQ� WKDW� LVVXH� SUHFOXVLRQ� ZRXOG� DSSO\�ZKHUH� WKH�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ�DW� LVVXH�ZDV�DV�D� UHVXOW�RI�DQ�DSSHDO� IURP�D�GHFLVLRQ�RI�D�WUDGHPDUN�H[DPLQHU���7KH�IDFWV�WKDW�WKH�SDUWLHV�DUH�QRW�WKH�VDPH� DQG� WKH� VWDNHV� DUH� PXFK� ORZHU� WKDQ� LQ� DQ� RSSRVLWLRQ�SURFHHGLQJ ��� VHHPV� OLNHO\� WR� LPSDFW� WKH� DSSOLFDWLRQ� RI� LVVXH�SUHFOXVLRQ���

7KH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW¶V� ERWWRP� OLQH� LQ�%��%�+DUGZDUH�� ,QF� ZDV�³>V@R�ORQJ�DV�WKH�RWKHU�RUGLQDU\�HOHPHQWV�RI� LVVXH�SUHFOXVLRQ�DUH�PHW��ZKHQ�WKH�XVDJHV�DGMXGLFDWHG�E\�WKH�77$%�DUH�PDWHULDOO\�WKH�VDPH�DV�WKRVH�EHIRUH� WKH�GLVWULFW� FRXUW�� LVVXH�SUHFOXVLRQ� VKRXOG� DSSO\�´��� $V�VXFK��GLVWULFW�FRXUWV�IDFHG�ZLWK�WKH�LVVXH�RI�ZKHWKHU�WR�JLYH�SUHFOXVLYH�HIIHFW� WR� D� 77$%� UXOLQJ� RQ� XQODZIXO� XVH� VKRXOG� HYDOXDWH� WKH�FRQVLGHUDWLRQV� IURP� %� � %� +DUGZDUH�� ,QF��� DV� ZHOO� DV� WKH� W\SLFDO�

��� ,G� DW��������������� 6HH JHQHUDOO\�LG��DW���������������� ,G� DW��������� ,G���� ,G� DW�����±������ 6HH�LG� DW��������� ,G� DW�������UHMHFWLQJ�WKLV�³ORZHU�VWDNHV´�DUJXPHQW�LQ�%��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF�

DV�UHODWHV�WR�RSSRVLWLRQ�SURFHHGLQJV���7KH�FRXUW�QRWHG�WKDW�WKH�VWDNHV�DUH�KLJK�LQ�DQ�RSSRVLWLRQ�SURFHHGLQJ�EHFDXVH�³>Z@KHQ�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�LV�RSSRVHG��WKHUH�LV�JRRG�UHDVRQ�WR�WKLQN�WKDW�ERWK�VLGHV�ZLOO�WDNH�WKH�PDWWHU�VHULRXVO\�´��

��� ,G�

Page 62: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

ŘŖŗŝǾ �������ȱ��ȱ�����Ȃ� ��������ȱ���ȱ��������

řŚŝ

HOHPHQWV�RI� LVVXH�SUHFOXVLRQ� LQ� WKH� UHOHYDQW� MXULVGLFWLRQ��DQG�SURFHHG�DFFRUGLQJO\���*LYHQ�WKDW�LW�PD\�EH�KDUGHU�WR�SURYH�XQODZIXO�XVH�DW�WKH�77$%� WKDQ LQ� IHGHUDO� FRXUW� �VLQFH� WKH� 77$%� KDV� WKH� ³SHU� VH´�UHTXLUHPHQW���D�ILQGLQJ�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH�PD\�EH�PRUH�OLNHO\�WR�KDYH�D�SUHFOXVLYH� HIIHFW� WKDQ� D� ILQGLQJ� WKDW� D� XVH� LV� ODZIXO�� �$QG�� VLQFH� WKH�86372�GRHV�QRW�URXWLQHO\�LQTXLUH�LQWR�WKH�ODZIXOQHVV�RI�PDUNV���� WKH�PHUH�IDFW�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�VKRXOG�QRW�KDYH�DQ\�SUHFOXVLYH�HIIHFW�ZLWKRXW�D� VSHFLILF� LQTXLU\� LQWR� WKDW� WRSLF� �DOWKRXJK�� DV� QRWHG� LQ� %� � %�+DUGZDUH��,QF���LW�PD\�EH�DSSURSULDWH�WR�WUHDW�WKH�IDFW�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�DV�SULPD� IDFLH� HYLGHQFH� RI� ODZIXO� XVH�� VXEMHFW� WR� UHEXWWDO� E\� WKH�GHIHQGDQW�����

$V�ZLWK�%��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF���WKH�SRVVLELOLW\�RI�JLYLQJ�SUHFOXVLYH�HIIHFW� WR� 77$%� GHWHUPLQDWLRQV� RQ� WKLV� LVVXH�PD\� KDYH� WKH� HIIHFW� RI�UDLVLQJ�WKH�VWDNHV�RI�77$%�SURFHHGLQJV���+RZHYHU��%��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF� LQGLFDWHV�WKH�6XSUHPH�&RXUW�LV�FRPIRUWDEOH�ZLWK�WKDW�ULVN���� DQG��DV� VXFK�� FRXUWV� DQG� OLWLJDQWV� VKRXOG� EH� SUHSDUHG� WR� DSSO\� WKH� VDPH�SULQFLSOHV�LQ�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�VHWWLQJ�

�� :KHQ�DQG�+RZ�&RXUWV�6KRXOG�0DNH�WKH�'HWHUPLQDWLRQ

7KH�ILQDO�SUDFWLFDO� FRQVLGHUDWLRQ�IRU�FRXUWV�DSSO\LQJ� WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH� GRFWULQH� LV� ORJLVWLFDO��ZKHQ� DQG� KRZ� WR�PDNH� WKH� GHWHUPLQDWLRQ���$OWKRXJK�DW� OHDVW� RQH� FRXUW� KDV� OHIW� WKH� LVVXH� IRU� WULDO���� PRVW� FRXUWV�WKDW�KDYH� IDFHG�DQ�XQODZIXO�XVH� LQTXLU\�KDYH�GRQH� VR� DV� D�PDWWHU�RI�ODZ� ��� 7KLV� PDNHV� VHQVH� JLYHQ� WKDW� WKH� ILQGLQJV� XVXDOO\� LQYROYH�DSSO\LQJ� D� VWDWXWH� RU� UHJXODWLRQ� WR� XQGLVSXWHG� IDFWV� �H�J��� WKH� SDUWLHV�DJUHH�WKDW�D� ODZ�H[LVWV�� WKDW� WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�ODEHO� LV�ZKDW� LW� LV��DQG�WKDW�WKH�ODZ�JRYHUQV�WKH�SODLQWLII¶V�ODEHO��EXW�GLVDJUHH�DV�WR�WKH�DSSOLFDWLRQ�RI�WKH�GRFWULQH�����

6LQFH� WKH� LVVXH� LV� D�PDWWHU� RI� ODZ�� WKH� XVXDO� UXOHV� LQ� WKDW� UHJDUG�DSSO\���$�PRWLRQ�WR�GLVPLVV�LV�SUREDEO\�WRR�HDUO\�WR�UDLVH�WKH�LVVXH����

��� 70(3��VXSUD QRWH�������������� %��%�+DUGZDUH��,QF�������6��&W��DW����±������7KRPDV��-���GLVVHQWLQJ��

�SURYLQJ�WKH�IDFW�RI�UHJLVWUDWLRQ�FRXOG�JLYH�ULVH�WR�D�UHEXWWDEOH�SUHVXPSWLRQ�RI�ODZIXO�XVH��

��� ,G� DW��������� 'HVVHUW�%HDXW\��,QF��Y��)R[������)��6XSS���G�����������6�'�1�<��������

�UHIXVLQJ�WR�HQWHU�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�RQ�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�LVVXH�³EHFDXVH�D�UHDVRQDEOH�MXU\�FRXOG�ILQG�WKDW�WKH�QRQ�FRPSOLDQFH�LV�QRW�PDWHULDO´����

��� 6HH��H�J���*R&OHDU�//&�Y��7DUJHW�&RUS���1R��&���������00&�������:/���������DW� �±���1�'��&DO��-DQ�������������JUDQWLQJ�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�RQ�XQODZIXO�XVH���&UH$JUL��,QF��Y��86$1$�+HDOWK�6FLV���,QF�������)��G���������±�����WK�&LU���������DIILUPLQJ�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�RQ�XQODZIXO�XVH����

��� 6HH��H�J���,PSXOVDULD��//&�Y��8QLWHG�'LVWULE��*US���//&��1R�������&9������������:/����������DW� �±���:�'��0LFK�2FW�������������GHQ\LQJ�D�PRWLRQ�WR�GLVPLVV�

FRQWLQXHG �����

Page 63: JBIPL Volume 17 Issue 3 Final (1) (1)ipjournal.law.wfu.edu/files/2017/05/Rabe.pdf · 8 6 3 $7(17 7 5$'(0$5. 2)),&( 3 527(&7,1* < 285 7 5$'(0$5. (1+$1&,1* < 285 5,*+76 7 +528*+

řŚŞ �� �ȱ������ȱ�ǯ���ǯȱǭȱ������ǯȱ����ǯ �ǯ

ǽ���ǯȱŗŝ

2I�FRXUVH��WKH�HDUOLHU�WKH�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ�FDQ�EH�PDGH��WKH�EHWWHU��DV�WKH�UXOLQJ� ZLOO� LQ� VRPH� FDVHV� HQG� WKH� OLWLJDWLRQ� DOWRJHWKHU���� +RZHYHU��GLVFRYHU\�PD\�EH�QHFHVVDU\�RQ�VRPH�LVVXHV��VXFK�DV�ZKHQ�WKH�SUREOHP�ZDV�XOWLPDWHO\�FRUUHFWHG��LI�DW�DOO��DQG�ZKHWKHU�WKH�SUREOHP�DIIHFWHG�DOO�RI�WKH�JRRGV�RIIHUHG�XQGHU�WKH�PDUN���6XPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�VHHPV�WR�EH�DQ� DSSURSULDWH� VWDJH� RI� OLWLJDWLRQ� IRU� WKH� W\SLFDO� XQODZIXO� XVH�GHWHUPLQDWLRQ���

0DNLQJ� D� GHWHUPLQDWLRQ� EHIRUH� WULDO� ZLOO� KHOS� WR� DYRLG� WKH�LQWURGXFWLRQ�RI�SRWHQWLDOO\�GDPDJLQJ�DQG�SUHMXGLFLDO�HYLGHQFH�DERXW�D�EXVLQHVV¶�SUDFWLFHV�WKDW�DUH�LUUHOHYDQW�WR�WUDGHPDUN�LVVXHV��VXFK�DV�WD[�HYDVLRQ�� DQG� ZLOO� DOVR� KHOS� SUHYHQW� ³PLQL� WULDOV´� RQ� XQODZIXO� XVH�GXULQJ�WULDO�

9� &21&/86,21

7KLV�SDSHU�WUDFHG�WKH�GHYHORSPHQW�RI�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH�LQ�WKH� IHGHUDO� FRXUWV� DQG� WKH� 86372� ZKLOH� UDLVLQJ� LVVXHV� RI� SUDFWLFDO�LPSRUWDQFH� WR�FRXUWV�DQG� OLWLJDWRUV�� �7KH�KLVWRULFDO�EDVLV� IRU�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�LQ�WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV�LV�QRW�DLUWLJKW���,Q�SDUWLFXODU��WKH�ODFN�RI�VXSSRUW�LQ�WKH�WH[W�RI�WKH�/DQKDP�$FW��WKH�1LQWK�&LUFXLW¶V�UHOLDQFH�RQ�WKH�TXHVWLRQDEO\�VXSSRUWHG�8QLWHG�3KRVSKRUXV GHFLVLRQ��WKH�IHGHUDO�FRXUWV¶� LPSRUWDWLRQ� RI� WKH� 86372¶V� XQLTXH� GRFWULQH� ZLWKRXW�FRQVLGHULQJ� WKH� FRQWH[WXDO� GLIIHUHQFHV�� DQG� WKH� VHHPLQJ� ODFN� RI�FRQFHUQ�IRU�FRQVXPHU�LQWHUHVWV�LQ�DSSO\LQJ�WKH�GRFWULQH�DUH�WURXEOLQJ���6WULSSLQJ�VHQLRU�XVHUV�RI� ULJKWV�DQG� OHDYLQJ� MXQLRU�XVHUV� WR� WDNH� WKHLU�SODFH� VKRXOG� QRW� EH� XQGHUWDNHQ� OLJKWO\�� �1HYHUWKHOHVV�� DVVXPLQJ� WKDW�FRXUWV�ZLOO�FRQWLQXH�WR�DSSO\�WKH�XQODZIXO�XVH�GRFWULQH��,�VXJJHVW�WKDW�WKH\� GR� VR� FDUHIXOO\� DQG� UDUHO\�� LQ� OLQH� ZLWK� WKH� SURSRVDOV� GHWDLOHG�DERYH�

EDVHG�RQ�XQODZIXO�XVH�ZKHUH�WKH�GHIHQGDQW�GLG�QRW�SUHVHQW�VXIILFLHQW�HYLGHQFH�RI�XQODZIXO�XVH�DQG�ZKHUH�WKH�DSSOLFDELOLW\�RI�DQ�DIILUPDWLYH�GHIHQVH�PXVW�DSSHDU�RQ�WKH�IDFH�RI�WKH�FRPSODLQW��

��� 6HH��H�J���&UH$JUL��,QF�������)��G�DW����±����DIILUPLQJ�VXPPDU\�MXGJPHQW�RI�GLVWULFW�FRXUW�HQGHG�OLWLJDWLRQ��