investigations of playa basins as point source...

29
Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017 INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE RECHARGE TO THE HIGH PLAINS AQUIFER Randy L. STOTLER 1 , Kait SALLEY 1 , William C. JOHNSON 2 , Dakota J. BURT 2 , and Mark W. BOWEN 3 1 Department of Geology, University of Kansas, 1475 Jayhawk Blvd., Lawrence, KS 66045 2 Department of Geography and Atmospheric Science, University of Kansas, 1475 Jayhawk Blvd., Lawrence, KS 66045 3 Geography and Urban Planning, University of Wisconsin Oshkosh, 800 Algoma Blvd, Oshkosh, WI 54901

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE RECHARGE TO THE HIGH

PLAINS AQUIFER

Randy L. STOTLER1, Kait SALLEY1, William C. JOHNSON2, Dakota J. BURT2, and Mark W. BOWEN3

1 Department of Geology, University of Kansas, 1475 Jayhawk Blvd., Lawrence, KS 66045

2 Department of Geography and Atmospheric Science, University of Kansas, 1475 Jayhawk Blvd., Lawrence, KS 66045

3 Geography and Urban Planning, University of Wisconsin Oshkosh, 800 Algoma Blvd, Oshkosh, WI 54901

Page 2: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Introduction

• High Plains (Ogallala) aquifer and Playas

• Types of recharge

– Diffuse

– Focused

• Timing of recharge

– Environmental tracers

– Agricultural contaminants

Page 3: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Buried playa (Kearny County)

“buffalo wallow” (Haskell County)

>22,000 playas in Kansas

Page 4: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

4

From USGS Circular 1333

Note: Sandhills lakes not included in this assessment

Page 5: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Portals to the High Plains Aquifer?

Page 6: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Goal of this phase of playa research is one of determining if playas indeed serve as point sources for recharge of the High Plains Aquifer (in Kansas)

Approaches Vadose zone geochemistry and other proxies of water flux Groundwater modeling Surface water balance analyses Related issues, e.g., accelerated sedimentation of playa basins

Page 7: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Ehmke Playa

Page 8: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Temporal and Spatial Changes

Page 9: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Playa instrumentation

Page 10: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Tower array (recording every 10 minutes)

Wind velocity and direction Temperature and humidity Solar radiation (pyranometer) Rain Radiation (net) Surface water level (acoustic) Still and video imagery

Sub-surface sensors (upper 3 m)

Soil heat flux (thermocouples and heat flux plates) Temperature, EC, water content Water potential sensors

Page 11: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Instrumented pit profile characterization

0

50

100

150

200

250

0 50 100

L*

0 1 2 3

a*

0 5 10 15

b*

AMS 14C ages (cal yrs BP)

3320 ± 30

3835 ± 30

4145 ± 30

5300 ± 30

Page 12: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Dust collection

Page 13: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Drone-based monitoring

Page 14: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

What about accelerated sedimentation?

Page 15: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Vegetation Buffers

Courtesy of Dave Haukos KSU

Sedimentation and playa function?

Page 16: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

210Pb sediment dating half life = 22.2 years atmospheric deposition

Full-core analyses: Color imagery Geochemistry (XRF) Magnetic susceptibility Gray-scale imagery L*a*b* and Munsell colors Micromorphology Particle size distribution Stable isotopes

Crack filling?

Page 17: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Chemical tracers: Chloride Bromide Nitrate Isotope analyses: δ2H and δ18O, 3H

(wet and dry atmospheric fallout)

(precipitation and plant-soil interactions)

Vadose Zone Geochemistry

(groundwater source and age)

Page 18: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Vadose Zone

Core is sealed in the field, and returned to the lab for fluid extraction

Page 19: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Sample Preparation

Page 20: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

PROJECT STATUS

1. Instrument station active

2. Waiting for sufficient rainfall to inundate playa

3. Hydraulic conductivity studies and infiltration tests

4. Continuous coring of the vadose zone underway

• Chemostratigraphy (tracers - Cl, Nitrates; isotopes – 13C, 15N, 18O, 3H) • Lithostratigraphy (physical and chemical characterization) • Magnetostratigraphy (susceptibility, IRM) • Pedostratigraphy (modern and buried soils)

Page 21: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Regional Results

Page 22: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Vadose Zone Chemistry

22

Nitrate concentration (μg-N/g)

Tritium concentration (TU)

McMahon et al., 2006

Page 23: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017 23

GMD #3

GMD #4

GMD #5

GMD #1

GMD #2

Rangeland vadose zone; recharge = 5 mm/yr Irrigated farmland vadose zone; recharge = 40-50 mm/yr Irrigated farmland vadose zone; recharge = 100 mm/yr

Page 24: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Regional Study

• Environmental tracers – Stable isotopes: climate

– Tritium (3H), CFCs: recharge since 1950

– Radiocarbon (14C): recharge 500 – 35,000 years ago

• Agricultural contaminants – Recharge since 1950s

• Nitrate

• Pesticides

• Fertilizers

• New data and literature review

24

Tritium and CFCs in HPA groundwater

Red = detect

Blue = non-detect

Page 25: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Playa Recharge Pathways

25

From PLJV

Page 26: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017 26

From USGS Circular 1333

Page 27: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017 27

From USGS Circular 1333

Chemical Transit

Page 28: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Summary

• Playas provide: – Important recharge pathways to HPA

– Chemical transit rates increase

• Sedimentation issues

• Results vary playa to playa – (size, geology, climate, etc.)

• Work on-going to upscale results from individual playas to regional HPA

Page 29: INVESTIGATIONS OF PLAYA BASINS AS POINT SOURCE …rwbjv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/Playa-Basins-as-Point-Source-Recharge.pdfPlayas and High Plains Recharge; rstotler@ku.edu Rainwater

Playas and High Plains Recharge; [email protected] Rainwater Basin Joint Venture 2017

Thank You . . .

Funding and other support: EPA, KU, KGS, UW-Oshkosh, Conoco-Phillips, PLJV, US Fish & Wildlife, NRCS, KWO