international summer water resources research …...international summer water resources research...
TRANSCRIPT
2011
International Summer Water Resources Research School
Dept. of Water Resources Engineering, Lund University
Decolorization of C.I. Reactive Red 180 by immobilized
Citrobacter sp. CK3
By
Embla J. Mýrdal
Embla J. Mýrdal
2
Instructor: Dr. Xiaojing Xiong Research assistant: Hehua Fu Lab partner: Congru Li
Embla J. Mýrdal
3
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................ 4
Keywords: .............................................................................................................................................................. 4
INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................................... 5
Aim of project ........................................................................................................................................................ 5
Description ............................................................................................................................................................ 5
Restrictions ............................................................................................................................................................ 5
BACKGROUND AND THEORY ............................................................................................................. 5
Immobilization....................................................................................................................................................... 6
Previous experiments ............................................................................................................................................ 7
EXPERIMENT ........................................................................................................................................... 7
Material and reagents ........................................................................................................................................... 7
Method .................................................................................................................................................................. 8
Preparation of cell-entrapped gel beads ................................................................................................................... 8
De-coloring experiments ........................................................................................................................................... 9
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION .............................................................................................................. 10
Results of pH experiment .................................................................................................................................... 10
Results of salinity experiment .............................................................................................................................. 12
Results of glucose experiment ............................................................................................................................. 13
Detection of gel bead’s absorptive capacity to RR-180; the four hour experiment .............................................. 15
Mini extra experiment ......................................................................................................................................... 16
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDED IMPROVEMENTS ............................................................ 18
Acknowledgments ............................................................................................................................................... 19
REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................................... 20
Pictures ................................................................................................................................................................ 20
Embla J. Mýrdal
4
Abstract In this experiment Citrobacter sp. CK3 bacteria were immobilized in PVA and sodium alginate gel beads
and the bacterial capability to remove the azo dye C.I. Reactive Red 180 was tested for various
conditions such as pH, salinity and glucose concentration. The experiment was done by a series of batch
experiments repeated five times for each factor with each test cycle being 24 hours. Absorption values
were determined using a spectrophotometer and the de-coloration efficiency was calculated.
It was observed that cell-free gel beads can hold some amount of dye and this ability changes with time.
The pH results indicate that the de-coloration efficiency is higher at a high pH although this was though
hard to determine since the gel beads easily expanded and broke in high pH environments. The results
from the salinity tests imply that a higher saline concentration is better for the de-coloration process.
From the glucose test results it was hard to determine the concentration that would result in the highest
de-coloration efficiency. An expansion of the gel beads was also noticed in the saline and glucose tests,
but this was not found to be as sensitive to different concentrations as in the pH test.
Keywords: Immobilized cell gel beads, CK3 bacteria, azo dye, pH, salinity, glucose, absorption, de-coloration
efficiency
Embla J. Mýrdal
5
Introduction Dyes are used in many industries such as textile, food and pharmaceutical industries. Many dyes are
poisonous and since many are water soluble they can be hard to remove from industrial waste water. If
these dyes are not removed from the waste water this could lead to damage of ecosystems and become
poisonous for humans and animals. To be able to remove unwanted dye surplus from waste water
immobilized bacteria can be utilized.
Aim of project The aim of this project is to investigate the bacterial strain, Citrobacter sp. CK3’s ability to degrade the
azo dye Reactive red 180 (RR-180). In this experiment the parameters pH, salinity and glucose
concentration are investigated in terms of how they affect the CK3’s ability to degrade the dyestuff RR-
180.
Description The experiments are performed by a series of batch experiments containing immobilized CK3 bacteria in
dye waste water at different conditions of pH, glucose and salinity content. Each experiment is repeated
for five cycles, each cycle being 24 hours. After each cycle the absorption of the waste water is
measured and compared with a reference value in order to obtain how the de-coloration efficiency
changes with time at the different conditions. Also a small four hour experiment was done to investigate
cell-free beads ability to contain and hold the dyestuff.
Restrictions The project will focus on the parameters pH, salinity and glucose content one by one and not in
combinations. Other restrictions are that only one bacterial strains effect of degradation is investigated
on one kind of dyestuff, the RR-180. Also the experiment will only show how much RR-180 that is
degraded or absorbed by the gel beads and no investigations are conducted to detect possible by-
products.
Background and theory Azo dyes are synthetically made compounds containing a double bound nitrogen group and are the
most commonly used dyes in industries. There are about 3000 different kinds of azo dyes and they have
a wide variety of colors and shades and are easy to use for industrial purposes. Unfortunately many of
them are known to be toxic and even carcinogenic (Chen et al. 2003). Azo dyes are often highly water
soluble and are therefore hard to remove from waste water. Because of this it is important to
investigate possible treatment methods to minimize the amount released into ecosystems. Since many
azo dyes have similar chemical structures one could assume that the degrading effects would be
somewhat similar for other types of azo dyes1.
1 Mail discussion with Dr. Xiaojing Xiong (May 4 2011).
Embla J. Mýrdal
6
Figure 1. Chemical structure of the azo dye Reactive Red 180.
CK3 is a gram negative facultative anaerobe rod which has in previous experiments showed to be
particularly good at degrading the azo dye RR-180 (Wang et al. 2009). There are many advantages of
utilizing bacteria to degrade unwanted chemical substances from industrial waste water. Other methods
such as adsorption and oxidation are often very expensive and could also generate poisonous by-
products. When using bacteria to degrade these substances there is a possibility of almost totally
degrading the substance and thus remove the hazardous substance and also unwanted, possibly
dangerous, by-products as well. Using bacterial degradation is also relatively cheap and effective
compared with many other methods (Wang et al. 2009). It is therefore important to investigate the
optimal conditions for the bacteria to get an as efficient degradation as possible. By providing the most
optimal conditions for the bacteria the risk for the hazardous dyestuff to reach the surrounding
environment can be minimized.
Immobilization When bacteria are immobilized they are stuck to or inside a material, often a gel matrix or bead, which
inhibits the bacteria from flowing freely in the bioreactor. In this experiment the bacteria are trapped
inside small PVA and sodium alginate beads. The beads are created by cross linking an embedded
medium made of dissolved PVA in an acid solution (the method is described later in the report). As the
PVA comes in contact with the cross linking solution the polymer gels hydrophilic hydroxyl groups will
turn inwards against each other creating a small bead (Li 2009).
Immobilizing bacteria will increase the density of bacteria within the bioreactor which in terms will
increase the rate of degradation within the bioreactor (Chen et al. 2005). In a bioreactor containing
immobilized bacteria the substrate will diffuse through the gel surface allowing the bacteria to degrade
the substance in laminar flowing conditions inside the gel bead. Having the bacteria stuck to or inside a
carrying surface network has other advantages as well, such as the possibility for bacteria to be washed
out of the system is reduced and therefore the bacteria can be reused. The carrier can also provide
anaerobic conditions for the bacteria which in degradation of azo dyes has been shown to be of great
importance. This because when azo dyes are degraded the degradation can be inhibited by enzymatic
reduction in presence of oxygen (Chen et al. 2003).
Embla J. Mýrdal
7
An important thing to keep in mind is that the rigidity of the gel bed needs to be suitable for the
conditions or else it might be damaged and reduce the efficiency in the reactor Also, as is done in
previous experiments the gel beads structure, size, rigidity and proportion to waste water need to be
analyzed (Chen et al. 2007). The shape and size is needed to obtain the suitable density of bacteria and
diffusivity of media around the carrier surface within the reactor. Size and shape tests are not
performed in this experiment due to shortage of time.
Previous experiments Previous experiments of CK3 bacteria degradation of RR-180 have been conducted, for example by
Wang et al. (2008). In the experiment it was found that if the glucose concentrations were very low (0, 5
g/L) this would inhibit the growth of bacteria and could even stop the degradation of dye completely. On
the other hand if the glucose concentration was very high (>12 g/L) it would more preferable for the
bacteria as energy source which also reduced the degradation of dyestuff.
The pH is also a parameter important to study since too acidic or alkaline environments could inhibit
the bacterial growth. The CK3 bacteria were in Wang’s experiment found to grow and degrade the
dyestuff best at a range of pH 6-7. For pH-values between 8 and 10 the degradation took longer time. In
another experiment performed by Li (2009) the optimum pH was found to be weekly acid. Since many
coloring agents are bound to fibers at alkaline conditions the waste water from coloring industries is
often quite alkaline, about pH 8-9, and therefore the bacteria used at such facilities need to be able to
withstand such conditions (Wang et al. 2008).
Experiment
Material and reagents Electronic balance, autoclave, heating and drying oven, clean bench, constant temperature magnetic
stirrer, thermostatic water bath cauldron, low speed large capacity centrifuge and UV-Vis
spectrophotometer.
Table 1. Chemicals and their concentrations used in the experiment. All concentrations are in relation to preparation of 500 ml of embedding medium.
Substance Chemical formula Concentration
Disodium Hydrogen Phosphate Na2HPO4∙12 H2O 31.7 g/L
Potassium Dihydrogen Phosphate KH2PO4 3 g/L
Ammonium Chloride NH4Cl 0.5 g/L
Sodium Chloride NaCl Standard 0.5 g/L, but
varies in the salinity test
Calcium Chloride Dihydrate CaCl2∙2 H2O 4 mg/L (dye substrate),
90g (crosslinking reagent)
Magnesium Sulfate MgSO4 0.12 g/L
Vitamin B1 0.15 mg/L
Glucose C6H12O6 8 g/L
Dye RR-180 50 mg/L
Embla J. Mýrdal
8
Sodium Hydroxide NaOH Varies in pH test
Hydrochloric Acid HCl Varies in pH test
Polyvinyl Alcohol: PVA-124 (CH2 CHOH)n 10% (w/v)
Sodium Alginate (C6H7O6Na)n 1% (w/v)
Boric Acid H3BO3 Added until crosslinking
reagent solution is
saturated
Method The experiment can be divided into two parts, one being the preparation of gel beads and the other the
de-colorization experiments.
Preparation of cell-entrapped gel beads
Intermediate cultivation of CK3
Sterilize clean bench for 20 min and blow for 15 min. Prepare dye substrate by mixing Na2HPO4, KH2PO4,
NH4CL, NaCl, CaCl2∙2H2O, MgSO4, vitamin B1 and RR-180 dye. Sterilize at 121°C for 20 min. Add glucose
by filtrating it through a 0,22 µm membrane. Transfer activated2 bacteria into dye substrate inoculum
size about 10% inside clean bench close to burner. The bacterium is cultivated at a constant
temperature of 37°C for about 2-3 days until the dye color has faded. This amplification is carried out
every third day in order to have enough bacteria for the different parts of the experiment.
Preparation of synthetic dye waste water
The dye waste water synthetic waste water made of tap water. Its components are KH2PO4, Na4Cl, NaCl,
CaCl2∙2H2O, MgSO4, glucose and RR-180 dye. The pH needs to be adjusted with HCl and NaOH before
the pH test. NaCl and glucose concentrations also need to be adjusted for the saline and glucose tests.
Preparation of cross linking reagent
Dissolve CaCl2 into 1 L of saturated boric acid solution and place in refrigerator until temperature
reaches 4°C.
Preparation of embedding medium
Open thermostat cauldron and heat to 92°C. Add 500 ml of de-ionized water into a beaker and place it
into the cauldron. Add PVA (10% w/v) and of sodium alginate (1% w/v). As the solid substances melt in
the hot water mix carefully with glass stick, avoid getting air bubbles in the gel. When all the solids are
dissolved let the gel cool to room temperature.
Preparation of bacterial culture3
Sterilize clean bench for 20 minutes and blow for 15 minutes. Also sterilize centrifuge tubes at 121°C for
20 min. Pour cultivated germ solution into centrifuge tubes close to burner inside the clean bench to
avoid contamination. Centrifuge tubes at 5000 rpm for 10 minutes. Remove supernatant and take
bacteria from the bottom of the tubes and add into the cold embedded medium. Mix carefully.
2 The activation was prepared by lab assistant and lab partner.
3 One series of gel beads are for investigation of the absorption of the gel beads and thus should no bacterial
culture be added.
Embla J. Mýrdal
9
Making of cell-entrapped gel beads
Put the mixed medium into injectors and fix injectors to an iron stand. Let the medium drop into cross
linking reagent from 10 cm height. Stir the cross linking reagent with magnetic stirrer to form beads of
the medium. The beads should be about 3 mm in diameter and not have a long tail. When all embedded
medium has dropped into the cross linking reagent keep the gel beads in the cross linking reagent and
let them harden in a refrigerator at 4°C for 24 h.
Before usage wash gel beads with physical saline 3 times.
De-coloring experiments
Detection of gel bead’s absorptive capacity to RR-180; the four hour experiment
Add 30 ml of beads without germs into 100 ml synthetic dye waste water into sixteen flasks, eight
samples with two parallel samples each and zeal with aluminum foil. The dye concentration should be
about 20 mg/L and the pH 7. Also prepare two blank samples of dye water without gel beads. Put the
bottles into a shaker with 50 rpm and temperature 30°C. Take a pair of sample out of the shaker after
10, 30, 60, 90, 120, 150, 180 and 240 minutes and centrifuge. Determine the absorbance of the
supernatant at wavelength 543 nm and draw the absorbance variation curve depending on time for the
bacteria free beads. At each time interval also determine the absorbance of the blank samples and draw
absorbance variation curve.
Procedure of determining effect of pH
Add 30 ml of cell-entrapped beads and 100 ml of synthetic waste water into twelve flasks, dye
concentration 50 mg/L. Set two parallel samples of pH at 3, 5, 7, 9 and 11 by adjusting the pH with HCl
or NaOH. Also prepare one set of blank samples. Zeal all flasks with aluminum foil and place into a
shaker at 50 rpm and 30°C. Set 24 h as one period. As one period ends take all samples and centrifuge
the liquid at 5000 rpm for 20 min and determine the absorption at wavelength 543 nm. Then clean the
gel beads with new waste waster of corresponding pH and place in shaker for next period. Repeat for
five periods.
Procedure of determining effect of salinity
Do as in determining of pH, but instead prepare ten flasks. Set two parallel samples of NaCl
concentration at 0, 2, 6 and 12 g/L and blank samples. Perform analysis as in pH test. Then clean the gel
beads with new waste waster of corresponding NaCl concentration and place in shaker for next period.
Repeat until five periods.
Procedure of determining effect of glucose concentration
Do as in determining of pH and salinity, but instead prepare twelve flasks. Set two parallel samples of
glucose concentration at 0, 2, 4, 6 and 8 g/L and blank samples. Perform analysis as in previous tests.
Then clean the gel beads with new waste waster of corresponding glucose concentration and place in
shaker for next period. Repeat until five periods.
Embla J. Mýrdal
10
Results and discussion In order to investigate the reduction of dyestuff the absorbance is measured and the color removal is
calculated by the following equation.
removal % = (initial dye conc. absorption value – residual dye conc. absorption value)/(initial dye conc.
absorption value) x 100
This gives percentage values of dyestuff removed by bacterial degradation which gives a good overview
of the different condition effects. If the absorption is lower than the reference value this should give a
positive result of color removal efficiency. The blank samples are supposed to work as a reference, i.e.
the initial dye concentration, for the normal degradation rate of the dyestuff with no CK3 bacteria
present.
Results of pH experiment The different pH of the samples influenced the shape of the gel beads strongly. In all samples the gel
beads became obviously weaker and softer but in the high pH samples, such as pH 9 and 11, almost all
the gel beads were completely destroyed after only 3 days, see figure 2. This could explain the
decreasing de-coloration efficiency values of the high pH samples, see figure 3. The gel beads effect on
the results could be due to two reasons in the pH test; one is the obvious swelling that was noticed in all
parts of the experiment (also in the glucose and salinity tests). The swelling and softening of the gel
beads made the beds release particles which affected the absorbance measurements of the samples.
The other was that in the pH test, the high pH environments changed the inner structure of the gel
beads. In the high pH conditions, the gel beads were more affected by the swelling and broke more
easily creating spongy materials when released particles joined together. In the other tests, such as
salinity and glucose concentration tests, the gel beads softening and breaking would not make the
particles join together.
Figure 2. Gel beds on day 3 of pH test. As can be seen the beads from the pH 9 and 11 samples are almost completely destroyed. (Photo: Congru Li July 2011)
From figure 3 it can be seen that all lines increase from day 3 to day 4 in the pH test. This might
implicate that the de-coloration rate on the fourth day is higher than the other days. An uncertainty is
though that the blank sample also increased on day 4.
Embla J. Mýrdal
11
Figure 2. De-coloration efficiency of the pH experiment.
What the de-coloration efficiency actually was is hard to detect because of all particles that would
appear in all samples as the gel beads swelled and became softer. As can be seen in figure 2 the pH 3
and 5 are almost always above the blank sample even though there are some fluctuations of these
curves. The reason for the fluctuations could be due to two reasons; one is the error that presents by
making new samples every day and the other is that the gel beads also expanded and became weaker in
the pH 3 and pH 5 samples influencing the results. The strange declining value of the pH 3 in day 2 is
thought to be a measuring error since all the other values of pH 3 and 5 are above the blank one.
Since all the pH samples show negative values another way of determining the de-coloration is to study
the color of the different samples, see figure 4. The pH 11 and pH 9 had much lighter color than the
other pH samples every day indicating that a high pH is good for the biodegradation. This correlates
somewhat with results from previous experiments such as Wang et al.’s study.
Figure 3 Day 4 of pH test. Ph values from left to right: blank, pH 3, 5, 7, 9 and 11. (Photo: Congru Li July 2011)
-600
-550
-500
-450
-400
-350
-300
-250
-200
-150
-100
-50
0
50
100
1 2 3 4 5 d
eco
lora
tio
n e
ffic
ien
cy (
%)
Time (days)
pH 3
pH 5
pH 7
pH 9
pH 11
Blank
Embla J. Mýrdal
12
Results of salinity experiment The salinity test did not affect the shape and strength of the gel beads as much as the pH test,
compare figures 3 and 5. The gel beads did though become softer and swelled therefore releasing
particles into the salinity samples which would affect the absorption values. Another reason which could
affect the result is that the blank samples also gave negative de-coloration values. One improvement is
to perform all preparations of the experiment in a sterile environment and not use tap water, but
instead use de-ionized and sterilized water. The tap water used in the preparation of synthetic waste
water containing microorganisms from the environment might affect the results. The external
microorganisms present might be able to magnify with the nutrients present in the samples affecting
the absorption.
Figure 4. Gel beads on day 3 of the salinity test. It can clearly be seen that the gel beads from all salinity samples have expanded. (Photo: Congru Li July 2011)
For low concentrations of saline, 0-6 g/L, the salinity concentrations do not seem to affect the de-
coloration differently, see figure 6. This might also be due to the softening of the gel beads which could
cover the differences in de-coloration efficiency. On average the high salinity concentration, 12 g/L,
seems to have a better affect than the lower concentrations. On the fifth day all of the salinity samples
de-coloration efficiency decline which is believed to be due to the expansion of the gel beads and the
loss of bacteria caused by the cleaning procedures between cycles.
Embla J. Mýrdal
13
Figure 5. De-coloration efficiency of the salinity experiment.
To investigate the different de-coloration affects the color differences of the samples could be
investigated. As can be seen in figure 7 there are some color differences between the samples with the
higher salinity concentrations being somewhat lighter than the lower concentrations.
Figure 6. Day 4 of salinity test. Salinity concentrations from left to right: blank 0, 2, 6, 12 g/L NaCl.
(Photo: Congru Li July 2011)
A thing that also can be seen in figure 6 is that the de-coloration efficiency in the 12 g/L group shows a
higher efficiency than the other samples. This may imply that the CK3 bacteria have a high salinity
tolerance which is a good property for bacteria used in waste water treatment facilities4.
Results of glucose experiment On the third day of the glucose test the color of the samples was noticeable lighter the higher
the concentration of glucose they contained. In the sample with glucose concentration 8 g/L there was
also noticeable white suspended mater floating on the surface. This is believed to be multiplied bacteria
colonies or particles from the gel beads. Another possible source of the material could be
macromolecules of by-products created by the biodegradation of glucose. As the gel beads break and
release particles these particles could flocculate creating the white substance. As the PVA pieces from
the gel beads conjoin they create a network trapping other matter such as free-flowing bacteria5.
4 Discussion with Dr. Xiaojing Xiong (July 12 2011).
5 Discussion with Dr. Xiaojing Xiong (July 12 2011).
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
1 2 3 4 5
de
colo
rati
on
eff
icie
ncy
(%
)
Time (days)
0 g/L
2 g/L
6 g/L
12 g/L
Embla J. Mýrdal
14
On the fourth day this was also seen in the other glucose samples, see figure 8. More suspended matter
could be noticed the higher the glucose concentration of the sample. In the 8 g/L sample the amount of
suspended matter was greatly reduced from the third to the fourth day. This may be due to that the
bacteria are washed away during preparations for the fourth day experimental cycle. On the fifth day
the 2 g/L test still contained white suspended material but none of the other samples, see figure 10.
Figure 7. Day 4 of glucose test. Glucose concentrations from left to right; blank, 0, 2, 4, 6 and 8 g/L. (Photo: Embla J. Myrdal July 2011)
The results from the glucose test show that all the samples follow a similar pattern, see figure 9. On the
second day the de-coloration efficiency declines for all samples, which is believed to be due to bacteria
and small particles released from the gel beads as they softened. These particles were perhaps not big
enough to deposit in the centrifuge and could thus affect the results. The de-coloration efficiency
obviously increases during the third and the fourth day for all samples. The decline for most samples on
the fifth day is believed to be the result of that the gel beads have expanded and softened releasing
many particles that would affect the results.
Figure 8. Decoloration efficiency of the glucose experiment.
-180
-160
-140
-120
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
1 2 3 4 5
colo
rati
on
eff
icie
ncy
(%
)
Time (days)
0 g/L
2 g/L
4 g/L
6 g/L
8 g/L
Blank
Embla J. Mýrdal
15
From the results of the glucose test it is hard to see which concentration results in the highest de-
coloration. It can easily be seen that the higher glucose concentrations result in better bacterial growth.
In figure 10 it can be seen that the color does not vary much between the different glucose
concentrations. Also the gel beads shape was not affected by the different glucose concentrations as
much as in the pH test.
Figure 9 Day 5 of glucose test. Glucose concentrations from left to right: blank, 0, 2, 4, 6 and 8 g/L. (Photo: Embla J. Myrdal July 2011)
Using absorption as a method to evaluate the de-coloration efficiency is obviously not enough for these
experiments. The de-coloration mechanism is a very complicated process involving many parameters
such as biodegradation, flocculation and the absorbance of dyestuff to the gel beads. The damage of gel
beads is responsible for the flocculation and high absorption and covers thus the effect of the
biodegradation.
Detection of gel bead’s absorptive capacity to RR-180; the four hour
experiment The de-coloration of the waste water is not only due to the biodegradation by the CK3 bacteria but also
by the physical absorption of the bead itself. This means that the gel bead can “hold” dyestuff within
itself. Therefore the main reason of de-coloration cannot be confirmed from day to day. A small four
hour experiment was performed in order to investigate the cell-free beads absorption ability.
The results from this small experiment suggest that there is no distinct pattern of the cell-free
absorption test, see figure 11. After 4 hours the gel beads had already become transparent and they had
already begun to expand. The low efficiency at 120 min might be caused by external factors.
Figure 10 Decoloration efficiency of cell-free gel beads.
0
20
40
60
80
100
10 30 60 90 120 150 180 240
de
colo
rati
on
eff
icie
ncy
(%
)
Time (min)
Cell-free gel beads
Embla J. Mýrdal
16
In the first two to three hours the de-coloration efficiency increases on average, despite fluctuations in
data. After about three hours the observed de-coloration efficiency started to decline. This is believed to
be due to that the gel beads already started to become soft and release particles into the samples. This
phenomenon might also explain the fluctuations of the data. The releasing of particles might conceal the
actual absorption effect of the samples.
Mini extra experiment
Part 1: Expansion test
Since it was observed in all samples that the gel beads swelled and released particles, which in turn
influenced the results of the entire experiment, two small extra experiments were made. In the first one
different volumes of bacterial liquid were mixed into the embedding medium during the preparation of
gel beads to see if this would affect their strength.
The different relations in the embedding medium were:
1. Embedding medium made by 80 ml of distilled water and 20 ml of concentrated bacterial liquid.
2. Embedding medium made by 90 ml of distilled water and 10 ml of concentrated bacterial liquid.
3. Embedding medium made by 100 ml of distilled water and no concentrated bacterial liquid.
The second (2) proportion is the one used during all other parts of the experiment.
As can be seen in figure 12 the gel beads with different mixing proportions have different appearance
after hardening in cross linking reagent. The 80 ml gel beads have almost no tail and are light yellow
with a rough and viscous surface. The 100 ml have the longest tail and are white and have a much
harder and smother surface than the other two kinds. The 90 ml gel beads are a mixture of the others
with long tails and a soft, but not viscous, surface.
Figure 11. Different shape of different prepared gel beads. (Photo: Congru Li July 2011)
After the first 24 hours of the experiment with the different gel beads in synthetic waste water no
obvious difference was seen between the different samples. Therefore the samples were left to stand
Embla J. Mýrdal
17
for another 24 hours. After 48 hours obvious differences were seen between the samples, see figure 13
and 14.
Figure 12. Size and shape differences between different gel beads after 48 hours in synthetic dye waste water. (Photo: Congru Li July 2011)
Figure 13 Close-up of gel beads after 48 hours. (Photo: Congru Li July 2011)
After 48 hours the 80 ml gel beads were sticky, fragile and had lost most of their original shape. They
had also lost most of their color and were almost transparent. The 90 ml gel beads had also expanded
and lost most of their color but were not as transparent as the 80 ml gel beads. The 90 ml gel beads
were not as fragile as the 80 ml beads, but would also break easily. The 100 ml beads kept most of their
original shape and were much harder than the other two.
For further experiments it is recommended that different proportions are tested in order to reduce the
bacteria liquid to gain stronger gel beads without reducing the de-coloring efficiency. Also more
experiments are needed to research the bacterial content within the beads since the number and
activity of bacteria may not have been enough for the entire experiment6.
6 Discussion with Dr. Xiaojing Xiong (July 12 2011).
Embla J. Mýrdal
18
Part 2: Filtration test
Since all results were strongly influenced by gel bead particles a small filtration experiment was
conducted to try to remove some particles. This experiment was done by filtering all glucose samples on
day 2 of the glucose experiment with common filter paper. As can be seen in figure 6 the lines are
almost parallel indicating that the filtration works equally for all samples. It can also be seen in the figure
15 that this filtration method was not efficient enough to remove all particles since most values are still
negative. So unfortunately this method could not be used to improve the experiment.
Figure 14 Effect of filtration on glucose test day 2.
Another filtering method with vacuum filtration, membrane size 0, 45 nm, was also conducted. But this
method could not be used since dye particles were suspected to stick to the membrane which would
give incorrect results. The observed dye particles in the membrane could also be dye stuck to larger
particles released from the gel beads. More filtering methods should be tested in order to remove
particles without threaten to remove dye.
Conclusion and recommended improvements The main conclusion from the experiment is that in order to get more accurate and well-founded results
of the different parameters effect on the de-coloration more testing of the gel beads are needed. Since
the gel beads swelling and releasing of particles strongly affected all results the results are inconclusive
and hard to draw any conclusions from.
This experiment can be seen as a pre-experiment for de-colorization tests. In order for future
experiments to become more successful the main improvement that needs to be done is to make the
gel beads stronger. Therefore should a much larger experiment than the mini extra experiment be
performed in order to investigate a better relation between the embedding medium and bacterial liquid
content without minimizing the de-coloring ability.
Also a more efficient experimental method should also be investigated. The many steps in each part of
the experiment might increase the source of error since small differences could occur between the
sample preparations. Some errors in our experiment are also due to human error and apparatus failure.
In order to improve the experiment further test would be needed on various combinations of the
parameters and also new parameters such as temperature and dye concentration could be tested. It is
hard to imitate a real waste water treatment facility in the lab since so many parameters have to be
-200
-150
-100
-50
0
50
0 2 4 6 8 blank
de
colo
rati
on
eff
icie
ncy
(%
)
glucose sample day 2
Unfiltrated
Filtrated
Embla J. Mýrdal
19
taken in to account which would lead to difficulties analyzing data. Though are experiments like this
valuable for the understanding of the importance of certain parameters.
Acknowledgments Thanks to Dr. Xiaojing Xiong for valuable thoughts and discussion about the results, Hehua Fu for all help
with the experimental work, preparations and translations and a special thanks to Congru Li for being a
great and patient group member. I would also like to thank the sponsors ITT, Sweco and Tyréns for the
financial support making this experience a possibility.
Embla J. Mýrdal
20
References Wang et al. (2009), Bacterial decolorization and degradation of the reactive dye Reactive Red 180 by
Citrobacter sp. CK3, International Biodeterioration & Biodegradation 63: 395–399
Chen et al. (2003), Decolorization of azo dye using PVA-immobilized microorganisms, Journal of
Biotechnology 101: 241-252
Chen et al. (2007), Decolorization of azo dye by immobilized Pseudomonas luteola entrapped in
alginate–silicate sol–gel beads, Process Biochemistry 42: 934–942
Chen et al. (2005), Immobilized cell fixed-bed bioreactor for wastewater decolorization, Process
Biochemistry 40: 3434–3440
Bo Li (2009), Decolorization of Reactive Red Azo Dyes by Immobilized Citrobacter sp.CK, Xiamen
University (Chinese)
Pictures Figure 1: http://www.lookchem.com/cas-728/72828-03-6.html (July 10 2011)