initial technical and navigation analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 wind...

23
Technical Analyses: Results from Cables, Radar, and Wind Resource Analyses RENEWABLE ENERGY LEASING PROCESS IN THE NY BIGHT | September 17‐20 Arianna Baker Technical Coordinator, Office of Renewable Energy Programs

Upload: others

Post on 19-Aug-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1

Technical Analyses:Results from Cables, Radar, and Wind Resource Analyses

RENEWABLE ENERGY LEASING PROCESS IN THE NY BIGHT  | September 17‐20

Arianna BakerTechnical Coordinator, Office of Renewable Energy Programs

Page 2: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

22

Cables

Comments:

• Burying power cables at a sufficient depth to avoid interactions with fishing gear

• Separation from existing cables of 750 m

• Coordination with existing cable owners

Page 3: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

33

Cables

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 4: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

44

Cables

Recommendations:

• No areas suggested for removal on the basis of cables, though less contested areas should be prioritized

• Maintain a separation between existing cable infrastructure and new renewable energy infrastructure

• Bury cables at an adequate target depth (1.5-2 m) to avoid interaction with fishing gear

Page 5: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

55

Radar

Comments:

• Potential for marine radar scattering for vessels within wind turbine arrays

• Potential for impact on high frequency land-based ocean observing radars

Page 6: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

66

Radar

Page 7: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

77

Radar

Recommendations:

• After coordination with federal partners, no areas are recommended for removal on the basis of radars

• Work in the later stages to implement mitigation techniques such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms

Page 8: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

88

Wind Resource and Wake Effect

Findings:• The wind resource in the Bight is sufficient to support projects on a

commercial scale

• Distance between turbines needs to be approximately 10x the diameter of a turbine to ensure upwind turbines don’t rob downwind turbines of power

• Most frequent wind flow is from the SW, followed by a less frequent though stronger wind flow from the WNW

Page 9: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

99

Wind Resource

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 10: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1010

Wind Direction

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 11: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1111

Wind Resource and Wake Effect

Recommendations:

• Adjacent facilities should not be leased in a direct N-S or E-W orientation

• Wind facilities of 800 MW will require an area of 80,000 acres

Page 12: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

12

Vessel Navigation in the New York Bight

RENEWABLE ENERGY LEASING PROCESS IN THE NY BIGHT  | September 17‐20

Arianna BakerNavigation Analyst

Page 13: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1313

Comments Received

Groups Captured:• American Waterways Operators

• World Shipping Council

• Maritime Association for the Port of NY and NJ

• USCG

• Area Pilot and Towboat Associations

Page 14: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1414

Comments Received

Main Points:• Implementation of Atlantic Coast Port Access Route Study Marine

Planning Guideline Buffers

• Including a navigation corridor from Delaware Bay to Montauk for Tug and Tow Vessels

• Maritime concerns are safety concerns

Page 15: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1515

All Vessels

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 16: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1616

Tug & Tow Traffic

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 17: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1717

Tug & Tow Traffic

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 18: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1818

Deep Draft-Cargo Traffic

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 19: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

1919

Deep Draft-Cargo Traffic

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 20: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

2020

Deep Draft-Tanker Traffic

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 21: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

2121

Deep Draft-Tanker Traffic

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 22: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

2222

Recommended Areas

DELIBERATIVE DRAFT

Page 23: Initial Technical and Navigation Analysis...such as infill radars or mitigation algorithms. 8 8 Wind Resource and Wake Effect ... 9 9 Wind Resource DELIBERATIVE DRAFT. 10 10 Wind Direction

2323

Arianna Baker

[email protected]

703-787-1677