infraday panel session on airports - tu berlin · infraday panel session on airports dr. mathias...

11
INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. Rechtsanwalt und Fachanwalt für Verwaltungsrecht Berlin, October 7th, 2011

Upload: others

Post on 17-May-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports

Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. Rechtsanwalt und Fachanwalt für Verwaltungsrecht Berlin, October 7th, 2011

Page 2: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

1

FRA – Startbahn West (1965-1984)

Page 3: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

MUC – Airport Munich (1974-1992)

2

Page 4: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

BER – Berlin-Schönefeld (1998-2012?)

3

Page 5: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

NIMBY – Not in my backyard

4

Page 6: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

Location vs. Flight paths

5

Page 7: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

Location vs. Flight paths

6

1997 – First judicial review 2000 – Only arbitrariness 2004 – Fair balance 2012 – ?

Page 8: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

Protection of trust – “Planning is not russian roulette“

7

Page 9: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

How should planners react?

8

Page 10: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

How should the legislator react?

9

On the ground: Planning permission by state authority

In the air: Flight paths

by federal authority

Page 11: INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports - TU Berlin · INFRADAY Panel Session On Airports Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. ... bei Berlin (Mar Großer Tett Potsdam Stahnsdorf Nuth sfelde Blankenfelde

10

Dr. Mathias Hellriegel LL.M. Rechtsanwalt und Fachanwalt für Verwaltungsrecht

Beisheim Center Berliner Freiheit 2 10785 Berlin Germany

Telefon (+49 30) 59 00 30 4-39 Telefax (+49 30) 59 00 30 4-48

[email protected] www.eggers-malmendier.com