in the high court of south africa - saflii · in court gc at 10:00 before the honourable justice...
TRANSCRIPT
/
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
NORTH GAUTENG DIVISION PRETORIA)
PRETORIA THIS 30 TH
DAY OF JULY 2015
THURSDAY
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KOLLAPEN IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TEFFO
IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLOPA
THE STATE V
HYDE MOPHOSHO
URGENT COURT
IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE J W LOUW IN COURT 8E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FOURIE
Page 2 of 16
CRIMINAL APPEALS
IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKUME
No. Case no. Name of appellant Jail/Bail
1. A650/14 L Stassen bail
2. A9/14 S M Mabaso + 2 jail
3. A118/15 T Mahlangu jail
4. A123/15 L S Nkosi jail
5. A99/15 N S Sithole jail
CIVIL APPEALS
IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAGARDIE CALVIN MPADI MASHELE VS SINAH MLOTSHWA
A141/15
VIPER SECURITY CC VS MOSEPE PILOT SEEMA
A687/14
Page 3 of 16 ADMISSIONS
IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKUME
1. KEITH AGREEMENT THUMBU ADV 40970/15
2. NATASHA SEWPERSAD ATT 47533/15
3. SEAN LEROI FEZILE NGCUKANA ATT 42602/15
4. MFANUZILE JERRY ATT 42480/15
5. NOLUFEFE FELICIA SAMALENGE ATT 41970/15
6. LETJUBANA TIRELO CHOKOE ATT 42146/15
7. BOY-BOY JUNIOS RAMATSHEKGISA ATT 42682/15
IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAGARDIE
1. NAKEDI ELIZABETH RIBANE ADV 41785/15
2. MATSOBANE JACK SHIKA ATT 42375/15
3. PRINCE RAMARUMO ATT 41848/15
4. LYLA MCLACHLAN ATT 42120/15
5. M C F RODRIGUES ATT 42204/15
6. BENETT KAREN ATT 42193/15
7. KARABELO LAWRENCE MMELESI ATT 42560/15
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 2A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE AA LOUW IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSEN IN COURT 2C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HASSIM AJ
Page 4 of 16
OPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MSIMEKI IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES
IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE WRIGHT IN COURT 8B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOKOTA AJ
JUDGMENTS
IN COURT 8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN
1. B Z Mangisi // The State A936/09 2. 3. T Ramasodi // The State A414/14 4. 5. F Stone // The Stone A628/14 6. 7. Trackstar Trading 20 CC vs. Aquatan
Case no: A453/13
IN COURT 6F A9;30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI
1. WESTERN CROWN PROPERTIES / THE TRUSTEES FOR TIME TO TIME 13699/13
2. LETSOALO M J / PRETORIA SOCIETY OF ADVOCATES 34315/12
IN COURT 4F AT 9;30
Page 5 of 16 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE
ASE NO: 36600/2011
EKURHULENI METROPOLITAN MUNICIPALITY
Applicant
and GERMISTON MUNICIPAL RETIREMENT FUND Respondent _____________________________________________________________________________________________________
CASE NO: 27572/2013
PIPE JACK GAUTENG (PTY) LTD Plaintiff And THE RANDFONTEIN LOCAL MUNICIPALITY First Defendant MKWANAZI CONSTRUCTION (PTY) LTD Second Defendant ___________________________________________________________________________________
CASE NO: 23786/2013
ADVOCATE A J DU TOIT N.O. o. b.o. DYLON HELGA SEDRAS
Plaintiff
and
THE ROAD ACCIDENd FUND ____________________________________________________________________
Defendant
CASE NO: 53656/2012
ADVOCATE ALEXANDER POLITISI N.O. Plaintiff and MEC FOR HEALTH LIMPOPO Defendant
Page 6 of 16 LEAVE TO APPEALS
IN COURT 8F AT 9.30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KRUGER AJ CC46/12 JERMAIN MABELS
IN COURT 8A AT 9;:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABENA AJ
Case No: 35330/12
M D JANSEN VAN VUUREN
AND
ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 UNTIL 4/08 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE POTTERILL IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 UNTIL 7/08 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE
Page 7 of 16 3
RD COURT MOTIONS
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNGQIBISA THUSI IN COURT 8F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KEIGHTLEY AJ
CIVIL TRIALS THAT STOOD DOWN
IN COURT 6E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P A MM MOTHUDI VS RAF 25885/11 B V S PHOLOGE VS RAF 118/13 C A B MASEKO VS RAF 76696/14 D K LOUDENS VS RAF 67640/11 E T F MOULAHENI VS RAF 82464/14 F S J MAJALI VS RAF 15342/12 G SS MAYEKISO VS RAF 67508/12 H V MFHILO VS RAF 50192/11 I N J RAMOSHABA VS RAF 64388/13 J Z MSOLO VS RAF 62784/14 K J R RUDZANI VS RAF 8112/11 L M L MALAPANE VS RAF 74260/13` M H J KHAMBULE VS RAF 35874/15 N B G SEBOTSENG VS RAF 80726/14 O A J WAKEFIELD VS RAF 25231/13 P L TALANE VS RAF 56935/14 Q J M BAIKE VS RAF 59485/13
Page 8 of 16 R D E THEUNISSEN VS RAF 49740/13 S M GROBLER VS RAF 61488/13 T H MALULEKE VS RAF 10210/14 U C M S ESPAG VS RAF 69339/13 V S G MALHERBE VS RAF 26950/13 W E N MBHAZIMA VS RAF 9556/13 X M J KUTUMELA VS RAF 74053/13 Y J A MDAKA VS RAF 68267/10 Z A DILIKA VS RAF 65712/13 Z1 B P SENGWAYO VS RAF 54386/13
CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT 6E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P 1A T H MAKHATINI VS RAF PREFDATE 32441/14 1B MA MOKOTO VS RAF PREFDATE 53577/14 1C S M MTEMBU VS RAF PREFDATE 60887/13 1D L M MAKOPO VS MIN OF POLICE PREFDATE 5349/11 1E M J NARE VS RAF PREFDATE 45653/11 1F SS BALOYI VS RAF PREFDATE NO FILE 12863/14 1g MANALE N VS RAF 62983/12 1H G D K MOTAU VS RAF PREFDATE 54182/14
30 JULY 2015
1. MAXASE S M VS RAF 33891/13 2. MPHAHLELE T T VS RAF 32010/13
3. NGWENYA J C OBO MINORS VS RAF 36524/13
4. MAFEREKA M E VS RAF 38927/13
Page 9 of 16 5. NGWIRA M VS RAF
67805/12
6. MPHONYO M V VS RAF 67272/13
7. RAMPHAKA M E VS RAF 2961/14
8. AUGUST S VS RAF 74250/13
9. JEFFRIES E R VS RAF 8307/14
10. HLATSWAYO S E VS RAF REMOVED 60900/13
11. ADV VAN ROOYEN OBO MS MASILELA VS RAF 45276/12
12. LETSOALO A D VS RAF 73581/13
13. BOTHA I J VS RAF 39289/12
14. DU PLESSIS J VS RAF 73992/13
15. GLADYS S B VS RAF 70606/13
16. VAN DER MERWE F VS RAF 72209/13
17. B G MBULI VS RAF 49483/14
18. NMBUNGUKA VS RAF NO FILE 3358/14
19. A T LETSWALO VS RAF 44656/13
20. N P KHUMALO vs RAF 29374/14
21. MAKGATHO M M VS RAF 72205/13
22. SEBOLAI M E VS RAF 35979/13
23. STEENKAMP R J VS RAF 36137/13
24. FRANKLIN G M VS RAF 54380/12
25. CV I DUVENHAGE VS RAF 73870/14
26. P W ROODT VS RAF 50011/11
27. D MAGOLELA VS RAF 69698/13
28. MOREMI S P VS RAF 63259/13
29. RAMMUTLA O OBO KATLEGO RMMUTLA VS RAF 310/14
30. GAEGAKE K VS RAF 76384/13
Page 10 of 16 31. MATLAMA T J VS RAF 75734/13
32. RANGWATO M A VS RAF 28193/13
33. MSIZA M D VS RAF 56276/13
34. DE BEER H J VS RAF 63497/12
35. THWALA G E VS RAF 70394/13
36. S G CHIBAKA ` VS RAF 54198/12
37. MNISI N O NMS P W MNISI VS RAF 33144/12
38. L CHAUKE VS RAF 9425/09
39. MATHSHEPO M L VS RAF 28470/12
40. LETSOALO R E VS RAF 64527/13
41. BAHUMA K VS RAF 69908/13
42. MOHAMED S OBO MOHAMED F O VS RAF 73338/13
43. KOYO L S VS RAF 73938/13
44. MAKGATA M P VS RAF 65877/13
45. MOGOMOGANE M C VS RAF 27193/12
46. MBUNGELE T I VS RAF 59561/13
47. NGOBENI M J VS RAF 68554/13
48. C T LEMAO VS RAF 28370/11
49. NGWENDANA M D VS RAF 45246/13
50. SEDIBE E D VS RAF 27719/13
51. JACOB F Z VS RAF 64080/13
52. MASENYA K L VS RAF NO FILE 64086/13
53. VAN WYK O A VS RAF 3178/14
54. HALL N B Y VS RAF 7523/14
55. MASILELA E L VS MAUBANE M C 63850/11
56. MNGOMEZULU V S VS RAF 32259/12
57. LEPITLA M E VS RAF 31015/04
Page 11 of 16 58. MAMAKOKO T M VS RAF
29687/12
59. MNDAWU J T VS RAF 41498/12
60. MLAUDZI P VS RAF 52721/12
61. NGWENYA M S VS RAF 45385/12
62. MASETA P VS RAF 58021/12
63. MOKGOTHO T A VS RAF 38309/12
64. KOKATAY A VS RAF 44928/13
65. KHOSA V S OBO MINORS VS RAF 35830/13
66. BOTSEHLO CONFIDENCE DANKE VS RAF 20971/11
67. MTHETHWA C M VS RAF 9406/14
68. COANGAE M P VS RAF 9449/14
69. SEGAOLE A M VS RAF 68736/12
70. MOSEKI I M VS RAF 38461/13
71. BOWKER H VS RAF 34193/13
72. MOLOANTOA M J VS RAF 12004/13
73. HLONGWANE M S VS RAF REMOVED 40497/13
74. SEKGALA M P OBO MINOR VS RAF 12495/14
75. FILIPE J S VS RAF 32803/13
76. MULDER S L VS RAF 70372/12
77. MALEBWE S J VS RAF NO FILE 2340/14
78. KHOZA M A VS RAF 53651/12
79. BOSHOFF M VS RAF NO FILE 64286/13
80. VAN WYK A S VS RAF 59638/13
81. BOIKANYO J M VS RAF 2795/14
82. MAHLULO C D VS RAF 3856/14
83. MINYUKU T L VS RAF 68371/13
Page 12 of 16 84. MTHOMBENI S E VS RAF 35151/13
85. MASHIKA P T VS RAF 58371/13
86. MAHLANGU B L VS RAF 45224/13
87. NKOSI K E NMS J G DLAKAMA VS RAF 50863/13
88. HAYI T S VS RAF 38275/13
89. HOLLAND S E VS RAF 36937/13
90. N M MDLULI OBO 4 MINORS VS RAF 26545/13
91. MOGALI S B VS RAF NO FILE 55054/13
92. XOKWANA E VS RAF 66792/12
93. JANSE VAN VUUREN M A VS RAF 41975/13
94. OLIPHANT S C VS RAF 47676/08
95. LANGA L M VS RAF 67098/11
96. MASHAI M T VS RAF 1693/12
97. MOKOENA O E VS RAF 27867/11
98. LESHABANE M R OBO M F LESHABANE VS RAF 13308/12
99. S B KHUMALO VS RAF NO FILE 16543/12
100. E L MATSHIKA VS RAF 10053/12
101. NDLALA M C VS RAF 16656/12
102. NGALO V VS RAF 44041/13
103. DAWSON H VS RAF 40480/13
104. MASEKO F F VS RAF 4706/10
105. LEKGADIMANE L MALEPE OBO MAKHUBEDU M N VS RAF 2599/14
106. MAKASANA N T VS RAF 4620/14
107. DHLAMINI J M VS RAF 47662/13
108. REED J L VS RAF 27863/12
109. MAKHANYA D B VS RAF 69741/11
110. RITCHIE C J VS RAF 56078/10
Page 13 of 16 111. MAVUNDLA S T VS RAF REMOVED
12935/12
112. THAANYANE M O VS RAF 26972/13
113. CHAUKE J T VS RAF 29859/11
114. AKANI RETIREMENT FUND ADMIN VS GEORGE X + 1 REMOVED 44287/08
115. AFRICA SUN OIL REFINERIES VS RAWJEE K C 54485/13
116. LETSOALO F VS MIN OF SAFE & SEC + 1 60100/12
117. DE VILLIERS G VS LOMBARD W + 1 73431/13
118. ABSA BANK LTD VS MOTSE TRANSPORT CC + 3 22426/13
119. LECUONA L J O VS LECUONA L M + 1 74362/13
120. MOILA L VS CITY OF TSHWANE 76403/10
121. SHUTE D VS SEVEN FALLS TRADING 59 + 2 69824/13
122. MIN OF ARTS & CULTURE VS BRUWER H REMOVED 69082/10
123. ABSA BANK LTD VS VILJOEN VAN ZYL CRAFFERT + 2 REMOVED 62348/13
124. APRIL N X F VS RAF REMOVED 42697/13
125. VILANCULOS A S OBO NELUCIA VS RAF 42857/13
126. MOGALE A M VS RAF 37699/14
127. MBONANI F F VS RAF NO FILE 51885/10
128. MAHLANGU S +1 VS RAF NO FILE 68175/09
129. CHARLIE P P VS RAF NO FILE 14626/10
130. SKOSANA C Z VS RAF NO FILE 29734/08
131. ADV MOGASWA VS RAF NO FILE 35057/12
132. K M MATHE VS RAF 46544/11
133. P B NDLOVU VS RAF 35508/09
134. N K MASIMULA VS RAF NO FILE 66793/11
135. NKAMBULA R J VS RAF 25720/14
136. M MOTAUNG VS RAF 2806/14
Page 14 of 16 137. T G MTHAPHULI VS RAF NO FILE 43530/14
138. M MAKHANYA VS RAF 45982/14
139. M E NKAMBULE VS RAF 9933/14
140. J M MAGANE VS RAF 18676/14
141. S L MOROKE VS RAF NO FILE 59706/14
142. B E MASOMBUKA VS RAF 34367/13
143. J A J VAN DER BERG VS RAF 72537/14
144. MOLOTO K T VS RAF 32349/14
145. BOTHA C M VS RAF 9714/14
146. JANSEN A VS RAF 13235/14
147. MOGALE M P VS RAF 42988/12
148. MPHAHLELE S S VS RAF 54794A/13
149. BOIKANYO H K VS RAF 12866/13
150. PETERSEN N N VS RAF 37085/13
151. FUMBA N +1 VS RAF NO FILE 47847/11
152. MOKOENA B S +1 VS RAF NO FILE 35719/11
153. SEMARA M R+1 VS RAF NO FILE 48264/09
154 D S SOLOMON ` VS RAF MERITS 64498/14 155 JAJ VANDER BERG VS RAF MERITS NO FILE 72573/14 156 M SPENSER VS RAF MERITS 32914/14 157` ADV BADENHORST VS RAF READINES 65063/12
158 N B MOHLANKANA VS RAF 38199/13 159 BORARE K VS RAF NO FILE 14059/13 160 GROENEWALD M VS R B C HOLDINGS (PTY)LTD 70780/11 161 GROENEWALD M VS MAAS G M 62263/12
162 B RUWENDE VS RAF READINES 70339/14
Page 15 of 16 163 MYAMBO C D VS RAF MERITS 471/15 164 DUMANI F VS RAF 69300/11 165 VS MABUNDA VS RAF 57634/12 166 CHAUKE C VS RAF 9079/13 167 L P FAASEN VS RAF 60938/13 168 I D MUNYAI VS RAF 39385/14
CIVIL TRIAL JUDGES
IN COURT A AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI IN COURT 6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAVUNDLA IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD IN COURT 4E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KHUMALO IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE STRIJDOM AJ
Page 16 of 16 IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DE KLERK AJ IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
COURTS AVAILABLE