in conversation with joshua a. berman, created equal - journal of

49
! !"# %&'()*+ &, -#.(#/ 01(234'(#5 !""# %&'()%*+& #$$%&''((()*#+,-./-0),12 3-4 #$$%&''%51.),12'*#+ 61$/7.0+ /- 89: 310 ;0/-2 /-40<04 /- $#0 6=>6 ?0./2/,- @3$3;3+0A ?6BCD A 3-4 C/CD> ) =#0/1 3;+$137$+ 3%%031 /- ?0./2/,5+ 3-4 =#0,.,2/73. 6;+$137$+) =#0 *,51-3. /+ 317#/E04 ;F $#0 G3$/,-3. >/;131F ,H I3-343A 3-4 /+ 3770++/;.0 H,1 7,-+5.$3$/,- 3-4 10J +0317# 3$ $#0 K.07$1,-/7 I,..07$/,- +/$0 L3/-$3/-04 ;F =#0 G3$/,-3. >/J ;131F ,H I3-343 ) 6789:; <=> ?@!AB8; C 0?98 :D 78E?F> ;GD AF B7F6;@0?!A7F HA!- %70-9? ?D I;@:?F> ,-./0.1 .23/45678 06. 9!94. 9-7:. 8!06 /#,!.#0 ;74!0!,/4 0673<60 J7KL7@G 9FA6;@0A!E M@;00> N==OPD

Upload: others

Post on 28-Feb-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

!

!"

!"#$%&'()*+$&,$-#.(#/$01(234'(#5$!""#$%&'()%*+&$

#$$%&''((()*#+,-./-0),12"3-4"

#$$%&''%51.),12'*#+"

61$/7.0+" /-" 89:" 310" ;0/-2" /-40<04" /-"$#0" 6=>6" ?0./2/,-" @3$3;3+0A"?6BCDA" 3-4" C/CD>)" =#0/1" 3;+$137$+"3%%031" /-" ?0./2/,5+" 3-4" =#0,.,2/73."6;+$137$+)"=#0"*,51-3."/+"317#/E04";F"$#0"G3$/,-3.">/;131F",H"I3-343A" 3-4"/+" 3770++/;.0" H,1"7,-+5.$3$/,-"3-4" 10J+0317#" 3$" $#0" K.07$1,-/7" I,..07$/,-"+/$0" L3/-$3/-04" ;F" =#0"G3$/,-3." >/J;131F",H"I3-343)""

$6789:;$<=>$?@!AB8;$C$$0?98$:D$78E?F>$;GD$$AF$B7F6;@0?!A7F$HA!-$%70-9?$?D$I;@:?F>$,-./0.1$.23/45$678$06.$9!94.$9-7:.$8!06$/#,!.#0$;74!0!,/4$0673<60$J7KL7@G$9FA6;@0A!E$M@;00>$N==OPD$

Page 2: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

R"

$AF$B7F6;@0?!A7F$HA!-$%70-9?$?D$I;@:?F>$,-./0.1$.23/45$678$06.$9!94.$9-7:.$8!06$/#,!.#0$;74!0!,/4$0673<60$J7KL7@G$9FA6;@0A!E$

M@;00>$N==OP$

:6N>"B)"M>S6GA"K@)"C?MPG"NGDTK?:D=S"

"

!)":35."B)"M.F3-A"UD-$1,457$/,-)!"R)"8,+#53"6)"C01L3-A"U"#$%&$'()*+%,&"B3/-"I.3/L+"3-4"B0$#,J4,.,2/73."6++5L%$/,-+)V"W)":5+3-"67X01L3-A"UM-.F"B0-"310"I103$04"KY53.)V"Z)" G,1L3-" [,$$(3.4A" UC0$(00-" @/37#1,-/7" 3-4" :F-7#1,-/7"6%%1,37#0+)!"\)":35."B)"M.F3-A"UKY53./$F"3-4"D-0Y53./$F"/-"$#0":,7/,JQ,./$/73."T/+/,-+",H"$#0"Q0-$3$057#]+":,5170+)!"^)"8,+#53"6)"C01L3-A"U6"?0+%,-+0&"=#100"Q,/-$+",H"B0$#,4,.J,2F)V" "

Page 3: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

W"

!#0-713,0!7#$

:6N>"B)"M>S6G"C?MPG"NGDTK?:D=S"

"=#0" %3%01+" %10+0-$04" #010" H/-4" $#0/1" ,1/2/-" /-" 3" +%07/3." 7,LJ;/-04" +0++/,-" ,H" $#0" :,7/0$F" ,H" C/;./73." >/$013$510]+" 90;10("C/;.0" 3-4" Q,./$/73." =#0,1F" :07$/,-" 3-4" Q0-$3$057#" :07$/,-"(#/7#" $,,X" %.370" 3$" $#0" 6--53." B00$/-2" /-" G0(" M1.03-+"_R``ab)"=#0"+0++/,-A"40E,$04"$,"3"71/$/73."3++0++L0-$",H"8,+#53"6)"C01L3-]+""#$%&$'()*+%,4(567(&8$(9:;,$(9#6<$(7:&8(.=>:$=&(?6,:&:@>%,( /86+A8&" _M<H,14" N-/E01+/$F" Q10++A" R``cbA" /-7.5404"0E3.53$/,-+" ,H" $#0" ;,,X" ;F" :5+3-" 67X01L3-A" G,1L3-" [,$$J(3.4A" C01-314" >0E/-+,-" 3-4" LF+0.H)" =#,52#" >0E/-+,-]+"7,LL0-$+"310"-,$"%5;./+#04"#010"_$#0F"#34"3.1034F";00-"%1,LJ/+04"$,"$#0"B6+#=%,(6C(/8$6,6A:>%,(D&+':$E";0H,10"$#0"+0++/,-"3-4"(/.."3%%031"3+"%31$",H"3"10E/0("0++3F"/-"/++50"^!)R"dM7$,;01"R`!`ebA"C01L3-]+"10+%,-+0"/-7.540+"#/+"1037$/,-+"$,">0E/-+,-]+"71/$/Y50)"M-"3"H/-3."-,$0A"(0"(,5.4"./X0"$,"0<%10++",51"$#3-X+"$,":$0E0-"[1,+;FA"f,-134":7#L/4"3-4"=#,L3+"@,g0L3-A"$#0",123-/g01+",H"$#0"+%07/3."+0++/,-)"" "

Page 4: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

Z"

,-./0.1$.23/4Q$:?AF$B8?A:0$?FG$:;!-7G787RAB?8$?009:M!A7F0$

8M:9N6"6)"CK?B6G"C6?JD>6G"NGDTK?:D=S"

"=#1,52#,5$" $#0" 3-7/0-$" (,1.4" $#0" $15$#" (3+" +0.HJ0E/40-$&" 6.."L0-"(010" =6&" 7103$04" 0Y53.)" D-""#$%&$'()*+%," D" 7.3/L" $#3$" $#0"Q0-$3$057#"/+"#/+$,1F]+"H/1+$";.50%1/-$"H,1"3"+,7/0$F"(#010"$#0,.J,2FA" %,./$/7+A" 3-4" 07,-,L/7+" 0L;1370" 023./$31/3-" /403.+A" ;F"107,-+$/$5$/-2"3-7/0-$"-,1L+"3-4"/-+$/$5$/,-+)"

M-"$#0"H370",H"/$A"$#0"7.3/L"+00L+"5-H,5-404)"=#0"Q0-$3J$057#"$0..+"5+",H"3"#/2#.F"+$13$/H/04",1401"(/$#"X/-2+A"%1/0+$+"3-4">0E/$0+" 20$$/-2"L,10" $#3-" 0E01F,-0" 0.+0A" (#/.0" +01E3-$+A" 10+/J40-$"3./0-+A"3-4"H,10/2-01+"20$".0++"$#3-"0E01F,-0"0.+0)"6-4"$#/+"/+" ;0H,10" (0" 0E0-" 20$" $," $#0" 4/+$/-7$/,-+"L340" ;0$(00-"L0-"3-4"(,L0-)""O,1"LF"7.3/L"$,"L3X0"3-F"+0-+0A"+,L0"40H/-/$/,-+"310"/-",1401)"

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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!":00"G,1L3-"[,$$(3.4A"U:,7/3."I.3++"3+"3-"6-3.F$/7"3-4"901L0J

-05$/73."I3$02,1F"/-"C/;./73.":$54/0+AV"B93"!!R"_!aaWbA"^)"D-"3"+/L/.31"E0/-"+00"D)" 8)"[0.;A"UO1,L"O1004,L"$,":.3E01FAV"@)"M)"K4g314" _04)b"H$E$,,E>8%C&E<,%EE$=( ( :F(.,&$=( (I7$:E&#6F,%='(+='( :=('$=(%=A#$=J$='$=(H$;:@$&$=4(KLMMM(-$=>6=&#$( %EEN#:6,6A:*+$( :=&$#=%&:6=%,$O(P+=>8$=O(QRS( B+=:( ;:E( TS(B+,:( URVW" _B5-7#0-&" T01.32" 401" C3F01/+7#0-" 6X340L/0" 401"P/++0-J+7#3H$0-A"!ahRbA"aRA"3-4"@3-/0."I)":-0..A"3:C$( :=( &8$(.=>:$=&(X$%#()%E&4(TUWW@TTQ(9S"S)S"_G0("93E0-&"S3.0"N-/E)"Q10++A"!aahbA"!Z^)"

R"P#/.0" $#0" $01L/-,.,2F"#010" /+" $#3$",H"[,$$(3.4A" $#0"%#0-,L0J-,-" /+" 7,-+/40104" 0-40L/7" $," %10JL,401-" 32131/3-" +,7/0$/0+)" :00"[01#314" K)" >0-+X/A" ?67$#( %='( ?#:Y:,$A$4( .( /8$6#N( 6C( D6>:%,( D&#%&:C:>%&:6="_G0("S,1X&"B7[13(J9/..A"!a^^bA"RZW)"O,1" $#0"+$157$510",H"B0+,%,J

Page 5: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

\"

=#0"Q0-$3$057#A"D"L3/-$3/-A",HH01+"3";.50%1/-$"H,1"3"+,7/3."3-4" 10./2/,5+",1401" $#3$" 10*07$+" $#0" +,7/3." +$13$/H/73$/,-" $#3$"4/JE/40+" $#0" 4,L/-3-$" $1/;5$0J/L%,+/-2" 7.3++" 3-4" $#0" 4,L/-3$04"$1/;5$0J;031/-2" 7.3++)"CF" 10*07$/-2" E6>:%,( E&#%&:C:>%&:6=A" D"L03-" 10J*07$/-2" $#0" %01L3-0-$" 3-4" /-+$/$5$/,-3./g04" %,(01" 2/E0-" $,"%31$/75.31"7.3++0+"$,"7,-$1,."$#0"07,-,L/7A"L/./$31FA"3-4"%,./$/73."10+,5170+",H"+,7/0$F)W"D-"7,-$0L%,131F"%31.3-70A"$#0"$01L"$A%,:@&%#:%=" /+"5+04"%1/L31/.F"(/$#" 10+%07$" $,"20-401"0Y53./$FA" 3-4" /-"$#/+" +0-+0A" ,H" 7,51+0A" /+" 3-" /-3%%1,%1/3$0" 40+71/%$/,-" ,H" $#0"Q0-$3$057#]+"+,7/3.",1401)"D-"LF";,,XA"#,(0E01A"D"5+0"$#0"$01L"$A%,:&%#:%=" -,$" /-" /$+" ./L/$04A" L,10" 7,..,Y5/3." +0-+0" ,H" 20-401"0Y53./$FA" ;5$" L,10" ;1,34.F)" " O,1" LF" %51%,+0+A" 3-" $A%,:&%#:%=(+,7/0$F"/+"",-0""/-"(#/7#"$#0""#/01317#F",H"%01L3-0-$"3-4"/-+$/J$5$/,-3./g04"+$13$/H/73$/,-"/+"4/++/%3$04)Z"

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

D"L3X0" $#/+"7.3/L"(/$#"3"X00-"3(310-0++" $#3$"LF"4/+$/-7J$/,-"%01$3/-+"%1/L31/.F" $," D+130./$0"L0-A" 3-4"-,$"-070++31/.F" $,"D+130./$0"(,L0-)"6$"+,L0"*5-7$510+A"3+"/-"$#0"7,..07$/E0"34410++",H"$#0"0-$/10"%,./$F"_$#0"+07,-4"%01+,-"%.513."US,5VbA"/$"L3F";0"$#3$"L0-"3-4"(,L0-"310"34410++04"/-"0Y53."H3+#/,-)"S0$A"/$"/+"3$".03+$"3+"7.031"$#3$"$#0"Q0-$3$057#"+00+"(,L0-"3+"+5;,14/-3$0"$,"L0-"/-"3103+"+57#"3+"$#0"*54/7/31FA"$#0"75.$A"$#0"L/./$31FA"3-4"/-".3-4",(-01+#/%A" $,"-3L0" *5+$"3" H0()\"KY53./$F" /+"-,$"0<#/;/$04"#010";0$(00-"L0-"3-4"(,L0-)"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""$3L/3-" +,7/0$F" 3.,-2" $#0+0" ./-0+A" +00" [102,1F" I)" I#/1/7#/2-,A"0$;&@D,%Y$#N( :=( ME#%$,( %='( &8$( .=>:$=&( X$%#( )%E&" _8:M=:5%A" !Z!i" :#0HH/0.4&"8:M="Q10++A"!aaWbA"Za)"

W" B/7#30." B3--A" /8$( D6+#>$E( 6C( D6>:%,( ?67$#A" R" E,.+)" _I3L;1/420&"I3L;1/420"N-/E)"Q10++A"!ac^bA"!&Wc)"

Z" D"(,5.4"3+X" 103401+" $,"X00%" /-"L/-4"#,("D" 3L"5+/-2" $#0" $01L"$A%,:&%#:%=" (#0-" 1034/-2" :5+3-" 67X01L3-]+" 71/$/Y50" ,H" LF" (,1X)" D$"(,5.4" 3%%031" $#3$"67X01L3-" 4/4" -,$" $3X0" -,$0" ,H"LF" 40H/-/$/,-" ,H"$01L+)"

\"6"E,.5L/-,5+"./$013$510"/+"40E,$04"$,"$#0"1,.0",H"$#0"(,L3-"/-"$#0"C/;.0"3-4" /-" $#0"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$)"=#0"5+0",H"L3$01/3." H/-4+"3+"$#0";3+/+"H,1"3"107,-+$157$/,-",H"(,L0-]+"./E0+"/-"%10L,-317#/7"D+130."

Page 6: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

^"

D$" /+" 3.+," 7.031" $#3$" $#0" Q0-$3$057#" 3++/2-+" 3" 4/L/-/+#04"1,.0"$,"$#0"10+/40-$"3./0-"_ b"3-4"$#0"H,10/2-01"_ b)"=#5+A"LF"0-403E,1" /+" 3" ./L/$04" ,-0&" $," +#,("#,(" $#0"Q0-$3$057#" 0-E/J+/,-04" 3" 7,10" D+130./$0" 7/$/g0-1F" ,H" H100" %01+,-+" $#3$" +$,,4" /-"7,-$13+$"$,"$#0"%10E3/./-2"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$01-"-,1L"$#3$"4/7J$3$04" +$13$/H/73$/,-" ;0$(00-" $#,+0" $#3$" /L%,+04" $1/;5$0" 3-4"$#,+0"$#3$";,10"$1/;5$0)""

D"+#,5.4"0L%#3+/g0"$#3$"D"3L"0<3L/-/-2";:;,:>%,(#$,:A:6=A"3-4"-,$" %137$/704A" ./E04A" #/+$,1/73.A" ME#%$,:&$( #$,:A:6=)^" D" $3X0" /$" 3+" 3"2/E0-"$#3$"L3-F"%3++320+",H"$#0"Q0-$3$057#"4,"-,$"10H.07$"$#0"+,7/3.A" 10./2/,5+A" 3-4" %,./$/73." 103./$F" ./E04" ;F" $#0" L3*,1/$F" ,H"3-7/0-$"D+130./$0+"3$"3-F"*5-7$510",H"$#0/1"#/+$,1F)"=#0+0"$0<$+A"/-"%137$/70A"L3F" 10H.07$" $#0" 75+$,L+A";0./0H+A" 3-4" -,1L+",H"L010"/-4/E/453.+A" +7#,,.+A" ,1" +%07/H/7" +02L0-$+" ,H" $#0" +,7/0$F)" D-"3++0++/-2" ;:;,:>%,( #$,:A:6=" $#0-A" D"L03-" $#0" E/+/,-j/403./g04A" 3$"$/L0+j,H"$#0"7,-70%$+"3-4"$#0"/-+$/$5$/,-3.";.50%1/-$"H,1"D+130J./$0"+,7/0$F"$#3$",-0"L3F"401/E0"H1,L"3"1034/-2",H"$#0"$0<$+)h"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""L3F";0"H,5-4"/-"I31,."B0F01+A"0:E>6Y$#:=A()Y$4(.=>:$=&(ME#%$,:&$(Z6F$=(:=("6=&$[&( _G0("S,1X&"M<H,14"N-/E)"Q10++A"!accb)"6"1070-$"7,L%10J#0-+/E0" ,E01E/0(" ,H" ;/;./73." /L320+" ,H" (,L0-" /-" 3-7/0-$" G031"K3+$01-"7,-$0<$" /+"H,5-4"/-"90--/0"8)"B31+L3-A"Z6F$=( :=(2A%#:&(%='(ME#%$,4(/8$:#(D6>:%,(%='(-$,:A:6+E(?6E:&:6=( :=( &8$("6=&$[&( 6C( &8$(.=>:$=&(X$%#()%E&A"_M$:$"Zai">0/40-&"C1/..A"R``Wb)"6"+51E0F",H";/;./73.".3("H1,L"$#0"%01+%07$/E0",H"20-401"+$54/0+"/+"H,5-4"/-"I#01F."C)"6-401+,-A"Z6F$=O(M'$6,6ANO( %='(L:6,$=>$4("#:&:>%,( /8$6#N( %='( &8$("6=E&#+>&:6=( 6C(H$='$#( :=( &8$(966<( 6C( &8$( "6Y$=%=&( %='( &8$( 0$+&$#6=6F:>( 3%7( _>,-4,-&" =k=" I.31XA"R``Zb" 3-4" T/7$,1" 9)" B3$$#0(+A" C01-314" B)" >0E/-+,-A" 3-4" =/XE3"O1FL01Jf0-+XF(_04+)bA"H$='$#(%='(3%7(:=(&8$(5$;#$7(9:;,$(%='(&8$(.=>:$=&(X$%#()%E&"_8:M=:5%A"R^Ri":#0HH/0.4&":#0HH/0.4"67340L/7"Q10++A"!aacb)"6"+51E0F",H"3"E31/0$F",H"H0L/-/+$"%01+%07$/E0+",-"$#0"C/;.0"/+"H,5-4"/-"6./70" C37#" _04)bA( Z6F$=( :=( &8$( 5$;#$7( 9:;,$" _G0(" S,1X&" ?,5$.0420A"!aaab)"M-" $#0"L,10" 0Y5/$3;.0"L0$3%#F+/73." +$3$5+" ,H" (,L0-" /-" $#0"C/;.0" 10.3$/E0" $," $#0" +$3-4/-2" 3+71/;04" $," (,L0-" /-" 3-7/0-$" G031"K3+$01-" ./$013$510A" +00"=/XE3" O1FL01Jf0-+XFA" M=( &8$(Z%<$( 6C( &8$(H6'@'$EE$E4(Z6F$=O("+,&+#$O(%='(&8$(9:;,:>%,(/#%=EC6#F%&:6=(6C(?%A%=(PN&8(_G0("S,1X&" O100" Q10++A" !aaRb" 3-4" /40LA"-$%':=A( &8$(Z6F$=( 6C( &8$( 9:;,$4(.(X$7(M=&$#G#$&%&:6=(6C(/8$:#(D&6#:$E"_G0("S,1X&":7#,7X0-A"R``Rb)"

^":00"l/,-F"l0E/$A"/8$(-$,:A:6=E(6C(.=>:$=&(ME#%$,4(.(DN=&8$E:E(6C(?%#%,@,%>&:>( .GG#6%>8$E( _>,-4,-&" I,-$/-55LA" R``!bi" :5+3-"G/4/$7#A".=>:$=&(ME#%$,:&$(-$,:A:6="_G0("S,1X&"M<H,14"N-/E)"Q10++A"!aahbi":5+3-"67X01JL3-A" 2='$#( )Y$#N( H#$$=( /#$$4( ?6G+,%#( -$,:A:6=( :=( D:[&8( "$=&+#N( B+'%8"_6$.3-$3&":7#,.31+"Q10++A"!aaRb)"

h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i"I#0;03250A"B3/-0&"I3+7,"C3F"6++F1/,J.,2/73." D-+$/$5$0A" R```bA" RhZ" 3-4" /-" B,+#0" [100-;012A" D&+':$E( :=( &8$(9:;,$( %='( B$7:E8( /86+A8&" _Q#/.340.%#/3&" 80(/+#" Q5;./73$/,-+" :,7/0$FA"!aa\bA"!!R)"

Page 7: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

h"

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

=#0"-0("%,./$/73."%1,213L";02/-+"(/$#"3"-0("$#0,.,2F)"D-"$#0" 3-7/0-$"(,1.4" 10./2/,-" 3-4"%,./$/7+" 310" /-0<$1/73;.F";,5-4A"3-4" $#0"Q0-$3$057#]+" 023./$31/3-/+L" /+" 1,,$04" /-" 3"L3*,1" $#0,J.,2/73." +#/H$)" =#1,52#,5$" $#0" 3-7/0-$" (,1.4A" (0" H/-4" $#3$" $#0"%,./$/73." +$157$510" ,H" $#0" #03E0-+"L/11,104" $#3$" ,H" $#0" 031$#.F"103.LA"3-4"/$"/+"03+F"$,"+00"(#F)"Q,./$/73."102/L0+"310A";F"40H/-/J$/,-A"31$/H/7/3.A"7,-+$157$04A"3-4"$#010H,10"$0-5,5+)"C5$"3"102/L0"73-"1070/E0" /LL03+513;.0" .02/$/L3$/,-" /H" $#0"L3++0+"5-401H,,$";0./0E0" $#3$" $#0" 102/L0" /+" 1,,$04" /-" 5.$/L3$0" 103./$F" 3-4" 5-J7#3-2/-2" $15$#i" $#3$" $#0" +/2-/H/73-70",H" $#0"%,./$/73." ,1401"#3+"7,+L/7"3-4"+37104";3+/+)"=#5+A" $#0"#03E0-.F",1401"L/11,1+"$#0"031$#.F",1401";0735+0"3-7/0-$"10./2/,-"/+"3"L3+X"$#3$"7,E01+"$#0"#5L3-" 7,-+$157$/,-" 3-4" 0<017/+0" ,H" %,(01)c" =#0" 7,LL,-"%01+,-" /-" $#0" 3-7/0-$" G031" K3+$" /+" 0++0-$/3..F" 3" +01E3-$A" $#0".,(0+$" 15-2" /-"$#0"%,./$/73."#/01317#FA"3+"0E/40-704" /-" $#0"B0J+,%,$3L/3-"7103$/,-"0%/7+)"

CF" 7,-$13+$A" $#0" $#0,.,2F" ,H" 7,E0-3-$" /-" $#0" Q0-$3$057#"+$1/%+"031$#.F"#/01317#/0+",H"$#0/1"+3713.".02/$/L3$/,-)"K.+0(#010A"$#0"2,4+"7,LL5-/73$04",-.F"$,"$#0"X/-2+A"3-4"#34"./$$.0"/-$010+$"/-" $#0" L3++0+)" C5$" 3$" :/-3/A" [,4" +%,X0" ,-.F" $," $#0" L3++0+A"(/$#,5$" 40./-03$/-2" 3-F" 1,.0"(#3$0E01" H,1" X/-2+A" 3-4" $#0/1" 3$J$0-43-$"#/01317#/0+)"D-" ./2#$",H"%313..0.+"(/$#">3$0"C1,-g0"620"+5g013/-$F" $103$/0+A" $#0" 7,E0-3-$" -3113$/E0+" /L%./7/$.F" +5220+$"$#3$"$#0"(#,.0",H"D+130.j-,$" /$+"X/-2A"-,$"#/+"10$/-50A"-,$"$#0"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

c"Q35."?/7,501A"^:A+#:=A(&8$(D%>#$'4(-$,:A:6=O(X%##%&:Y$O(%='(MF%A:=%&:6="_B/--03%,./+&" O,1$10++" Q10++A" !aa\bA" \Z)" :00" 3.+,A" :)" G)" K/+0-+$34$A"UD-$1,457$/,-&" =#0" 6</3." 620" C103X$#1,52#+j=#0/1" I#3137$01/+$/7+"3-4"M1/2/-+AV" :)"G)"K/+0-+$34$" _04)b"/8$(\#:A:=E( %='(0:Y$#E:&N( 6C(.[:%,(.A$(":Y:,:J%&:6=E" _6.;3-F&":$3$0"N-/E01+/$F",H"G0("S,1X"Q10++A"!ac^bA"RmZ)":00"4/+75++/,-"(/$#"102314"$,"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$01-"10./2/,-+"/-"8)"@3E/4":7#.,0-A"/8$(56+E$(6C(&8$(^%&8$#(%E(^%>&(%='(DNF;6,4(?%&#:F6=:%,:EF(:=(2A%#:&( %='( &8$(.=>:$=&(X$%#()%E&" _P/-,-3">3X0A" D-4)&"K/+0-;135-+A"R``!bA"aR)"

Page 8: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

c"

%1/0+$+j;5$" $#0"(#,.0",H"D+130.";031+" $#0"+$3$5+",H"3"+5;,14/J-3$0" X/-2" 0-$0104" /-$," $103$F" (/$#" 3" +,E010/2-" X/-2A" [,4)a"?0E/+/$/-2" $#0" 9/$$/$0" $103$/0+" (#,+0" H,1L" 3-4" .3-25320" 310"%313..0.04" /-" $#0"7,E0-3-$3."L3$01/3." /-" $#0"Q0-$3$057#A" D" 7,-J7.5404"$#3$"-,$",-.F"4,0+"D+130."3+"3"7,..07$/E0"(#,.0"3$$3/-"$#0"+$3$5+",H" 3" +5;,14/-3$0"X/-2A";5$" $#3$A" 0E01F"L3-" /-" D+130.";0J7,L0+"0-4,(04"(/$#"$#/+"+$3$5+"3+"(0..)"=#5+A"H,1"0<3L%.0A"(0"H/-4"$#3$"$#0"E3++3."X/-2" /-"$#0">3$0"C1,-g0"$103$/0+"L5+$"#031"$#0"%01/,4/7"1034/-2",H"$#0"$103$F"+$/%5.3$/,-+)"D-"@05$01,-,LFA"$#/+"+3L0",;./23$/,-"/+"-,("%.3704"5%,-"0E01F"L0L;01",H"$#0"D+130./$0"%,./$F"3$"$#0" "7,-E,73$/,-"_@05$"W!&!`J!Wb)"=#0",;./23$/,-" /-" $#0" 9/$$/$0" $103$/0+" H,1" $#0" E3++3." X/-2" $," %3F" 3"7,51$" E/+/$" $," $#0" +5g013/-" /+" 0<$0-404" /-" $#0" Q0-$3$057#" $,"0E01F" L3.0" 7/$/g0-" ,H" D+130." /-" $#0" ,;./23$/,-" ,H" %/.21/L320"(#,+0" .3-25320" 7.,+0.F" %313..0.+" $#3$" ,H" $#0" E3++3." $103$/0+)"=#0+0"H/-4/-2+"7,110+%,-4"(/$#":35."M.F3-]+"X0F"/-+/2#$"3;,5$"D+130.]+" E3++3.320" E/+JnJE/+" $#0" >,14)" K.+0(#010" /-" $#0" 3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$A"-,$0+"M.F3-A"L3-"0-E/+/,-+"#/L+0.H";0H,10"$#0"2,4+"$#1,52#"%3134/2L+"/-"(#/7#"#,-,1"/+"5-/.3$013..F";0+$,(04&"3+"3"+,-";0H,10"3"H3$#01A",1"3+"3"+01E3-$";0H,10"3"X/-2)">3$0"C1,-g0"620" E3++3.320A" #,(0E01" /+" 3" 10.3$/,-+#/%" /-" (#/7#" #,-,1" ;0J$(00-" +5g013/-" 3-4" E3++3." /+" ;0+$,(04" ;/.3$013..FA" /H" -,$" H5..F"L5$53..F)" D-" 73+$/-2" D+130." 3+" 3" E3++3." $," $#0">,14A"M.F3-" ,;J+01E0+A" $#0"C/;.0"0+$3;./+#04"3"%3134/2L"H,1" $#0"#5L3-"4/E/-0"0-7,5-$01"$#3$"%.3704"L3-X/-4",-"3-"5-%107040-$04"%040+$3.)"G,$" ,-.F" 7,5.4"L3-" #,-,1"[,4A" ;5$" -,("[,4" 7,5.4" #,-,1"L3-)!`"=#0"$#0,.,2/73.";103X$#1,52#",H"$#0"Q0-$3$057#A"$#0-A"/+"$#0"$13-+H,1L3$/,-",H"$#0"+$3$5+"3-4"+$3-4/-2",H"$#0"L3++0+A",H"$#0"7,LL,-"%01+,-A"$,"3"-0("#0/2#$)"Q5$"+577/-7$.FA"0.+0(#010"/-"$#0"3-7/0-$"(,1.4A"$#0"7,LL,-"L3-"(3+"3"X/-2]+"+01E3-$)"D-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#"#0";07,L0+"3"+01E3-$"X/-2)"

P#3$"$#0-"310"$#0"%,./$/73."+$157$510+"$#3$"$#0"Q0-$3$057#".3F+" ,5$" $," 2,E01-" 3" -3$/,-" ,H" +01E3-$" X/-2+o" M-" $#/+" +7,10A"L3-F" #3E0" H,75+04" ,-" @05$01,-,LF" !^m!c)" C5$" 3+" C01-314">0E/-+,-"%,/-$+",5$A"$#0"4/+75++/,-",H"X/-2+#/%"/-"@05$01,-,JLF"/+"-,$"./L/$04"$,"7#3%$01"!hi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g04"%,(01"31,5-4"3"H/2510"+57#"3+"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

a" :00"[0,120" K)"B0-40-#3.." 3-4"[31F" 6)" 901/,-A" UI,E0-3-$AV".90(!&!!haJ!R`Ri"B,+#0"P0/-H0.4A" UI,E0-3-$"B3X/-2" /-"6-3$,./3"3-4"B0+,%,$3L/3AV"B.X)D"RR"_!aaWbA"!W\mWa)"

!`":35."M.F3-A"U9,-,1A":#3L0"3-4"I,E0-3-$"?0.3$/,-+"/-"6-7/0-$"D+130."3-4"D$+"K-E/1,-L0-$AV"B93"!!\"_!aa^bA"R!`)"

!!" C01-314" >0E/-+,-A" U=#0" ?07,-70%$53./g3$/,-" ,H" f/-2+#/%" /-"@05$01,-,LF" 3-4" $#0" @05$01,-,L/7" 9/+$,1F]+" =13-+H,1L3$/,-" ,H"=,13#AV"L/(\!"_R``!bA"\!!mWZ)"

Page 9: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

a"

3"L,-317#A"+,L0"75.$510+"4/+%.3F"(#3$"#0"73..+"3" >6,,$>&:Y$(G67$#(E&#%&$ANS!R"

I,..07$/E0"%,(01"+$13$02/0+"4/E0+$"3"+/-2.0"15.01",H"$#0"7,-J$1,.",H"%,(01)"=#0"E31/,5+",HH/70+",H"%,(01"310"+5;,14/-3$04"$,"3" L3-320L0-$" +$157$510" 40$01L/-04" ;F" 3" 7,40" ,H" .3(A" 3+" (0"H/-4" /-" @05$01,-,LF)" D-" 3" $F13--FA" $#0" L,-,%,.F" ,H" %,(01"%1,4570+" 7,#0+/,-"(/$#/-" $#0" %,./$F" $#1,52#" $#0" 5+0" ,H" H,170"3-4" $#0" 20-013$/,-" ,H" H031)"CF" 7,-$13+$A" +3F+"C.3-$,-A" $#0" 40J70-$13./g3$/,-" ,H" %,(01" /-" 3" 7,..07$/E0" +F+$0L" -070++/$3$0+" $#0"7103$/,-",H"-0("7,-70%$+"3-4" /-+$/$5$/,-+" $,"%1,E/40"$#0";3+/+"H,1"+,7/3."7,#0+/,-)"D-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#"$#/+"/+"37#/0E04"$#1,52#"$#0"73../-2",H"7,E0-3-$A"/$+"+01L,-+"3-4"7,LL3-4L0-$+)"C.3-J$,-" -,$0+" $#3$" 21,5%J,1/0-$04" 75.$510+" H03$510" .3120"317#/$07$513." +%370+" +5/$3;.0" H,1" 21,5%" 1/$53.)" =#0" +3-7$531F"40+71/;04";F"@05$01,-,LF"/+",-0"(#010"$#0"1,.0",H"$#0"%0,%.0"/+" 0L%#3+/g04A" 3-4" $#0" 1,.0" ,H" $#0" 75.$" 3$$0-43-$+" 40J0L%#3+/g04)"

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g0-"/+"0./2/J;.0"$,"#,.4)"

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

=#0"023./$31/3-"+$103X"/-"Q0-$3$057#3."$#,52#$"/+"0+%07/3..F"0E/40-$" /-" /$+"07,-,L/7" .3(+)"=#0"E31/,5+" .023."7,1%,13" H,5-4"/-" $#0" Q0-$3$057#" 7,-701-/-2" .3-4" $0-510A" $3<3$/,-A" .0-4/-2A"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

!R" ?/7#314" K)" C.3-$,-A" UC0F,-4" I0-$13./g3$/,-&" :$0%+" =,(314" 3"=#0,1F" ,H" K23./$31/3-" C0#3E/,1" /-" 617#3/7" :$3$0+AV" /-".#>8%:>( D&%&$E"_04+)"[31F"B)"O0/-L3-"3-4"8,F70"B3175+i":3-$3"O0&":7#,,.",H"6L01/J73-"?0+0317#"Q10++A"!aacbA"!Zh)"

!W"=#,L3+A">)"Q3-2.0A"P6=&$E*+:$+_E(?8:,6E6G8N(6C(3:;$#%,:EF" _I#/73J2,&"N-/E01+/$F",H"I#/732,"Q10++A"!ahWbA"!!cmR`)"

Page 10: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

!`"

,(-01+#/%"1/2#$+A"40;$"03+0L0-$A"3-4"%,E01$F"10./0H"10E03."/--01"$0-+/,-" 3-4" 4/+7,14)"S0$A" (#0-" 7,L%3104"(/$#" $#0" -,1L+" ,H"$#0" 3-7/0-$" G031" K3+$A" 3" $0../-2" $10-4" 0L0120+&" 7,-70%$+" 3-4"/-+$/$5$/,-+" (#,+0" ,1/2/-+" (010" /-" +$3$/+$" 3-4" H0543." ,1401+"0.+0(#010"/-"$#0"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$"310"1073+$"/-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#"/-"377,143-70"(/$#"3"-0("7,LL5-3."320-43)"MH$0-"$#0"10(,1XJ/-2"4/+%.3F+"$#0"3/L",H"0-+51/-2"$#3$"3";1,34"+(3$#",H"$#0"7/$/J7/$/g0-1F" 10L3/-+" .3-404" 3-4" 07,-,L/73..F" +07510)" P#3$"0L0120+"/+"$#0"(0+$01-"$134/$/,-]+"H/1+$"%10+71/%$/,-"H,1"3-"07,J-,L/7",1401"$#3$"+00X+"$,"L/-/L/g0"0<$10L0"34E3-$320"3-4"$#0"4/+$/-7$/,-+",H"7.3++";3+04",-"(03.$#)""

P#3$" $#0" 07,-,L/7" .3(+" ,H" $#0" C/;.0" +,52#$" $," 37#/0E0"(3+" $," 10E3L%" 07,-,L/7" %1/-7/%.0+" $#3$" 0</+$04" 0.+0(#010" /-"$#0" 3-7/0-$" G031" K3+$01-" +,7/3." L/./05)" D$" (3+" 7,LL,-" 0.+0J(#010" $#3$" L0L;01+" ,H" 3" $1/;0" ,1" 3" 7.3-" (,5.4" 7,-457$"07,-,L/7" 3HH3/1+" ;F" %.37/-2" 3" %10L/5L",-" +$10-2$#0-/-2"L5J$53." 10+%,-+/;/./$F" 3-4" X/-+#/%)" =#0" C/;.0]+" 07,-,L/7" .3(+"0<$0-4"$#/+"+0-+0",H"X/-+#/%"3-4"$#/+"H,1L",H"07,-,L/7"37$/E/$F"$,"3"-3$/,-3.".0E0.A"0-7,L%3++/-2"/-4/E/453.+"3$"3"2103$"4/E/40"/-"$01L+",H"20,213%#F"3-4"/-"$01L+",H";.,,4./-0+A";5$"5-/$04"/-"3"7,LL,-A" -3$/,-3.A" 7,E0-3-$3." 7,LL5-/$F)" =#0" ;/;./73." .3(+"+,52#$" $," 0107$" 3-" 07,-,L/7" ,1401" $#3$" /+" -,$" 70-$13..F" 7,-J$1,..04A" 3-4" /-4004" 107,2-/g0+" $#0" .02/$/L37F" ,H" 37Y5/1/-2"(03.$#)"6$"$#0"+3L0"$/L0A"$#0+0" .3(+"+,52#$"$,"0-+510"3"L,4J/75L" ,H" +,7/3." 0Y53./$F" ;F" %.37/-2" 3" %10L/5L" ,-" $#0"+$10-2$#0-/-2",H"10.3$/,-+#/%+"(/$#/-"$#0"7,E0-3-$3."7,LL5-/J$F"3-4"L/-/L/g/-2"0<$10L0"34E3-$320)"

O/-3..F"D"7,-+/401"$#0"1,.0"$#3$"./$0137F"3-4"$#0"%1,L5.23J$/,-" ,H" $0<$+" L3F" #3E0" %.3F04" /-" 34E3-7/-2" $#/+" 023./$31/3-"%.3$H,1L)"=#0"34,%$/,-",H" $#0"3.%#3;0$/7" +71/%$" 3-4" /$+"5+0" /-"7103$/-2"$0<$+"/-"3-7/0-$"D+130."/+"3"10+5.$",H"3"4F-3L/7"10.3$/,-J+#/%" ;0$(00-" $07#-,.,2FA" ,-" $#0" ,-0" #3-4A" 3-4" 3" 4/+$/-7$"$#0,.,2/73." 3-4" +,7/3." L/-4" H13L0" ,-" $#0" ,$#01)" =#0" C/;.0"+00L+"5-3H13/4",H" 04573$/-2" $#0"L3++0+)" D-"B0+,%,$3L/3" 3-4"/-"K2F%$A" ;F" 7,-$13+$A" $0<$+"(010" %1,45704A" 1034A"L0L,1/g04A"3-4" $13-+L/$$04" ;F" +71/;3." 0./$0A" 3-4" 7,L%,+04" /-" +71/%$+" $#3$"(010" /-#010-$.F" 4/HH/75.$" $," L3+$01j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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!Z"M-"$#0"20-013."$,%/7A"+00"@3E/4"I311A"Z#:&:=A(6=(&8$(/%;,$&(6C(&8$(

5$%#&4( \#:A:=E( 6C( D>#:G&+#$( %='( 3:&$#%&+#$" _M<H,14&"M<H,14"N-/E)" Q10++A"R``\bi"631,-"@0L+XFA"U>/$0137FAV"K1/7"B)"B0F01+"_04)bA(\[C6#'()=>N>@

Page 11: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

!!"

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c&R`i"@05$"!c&!JRb)"M-.F"/-"$#0"Q0-$3J$057#" 310" #,.F" $0<$+" 3-4" 75.$/7" %10+71/%$/,-+" +#3104" (/$#" $#0"L3++0+A" 13$#01" $#3-";0/-2"7310H5..F"2531404"+0710$+)"S,51"+5%J%,+04.F" /..5+$1/,5+" H,10;031+" 310" $#0" +5;*07$" ,H" $3.0+" ,H" +7,1-"3.,-0j+57#" 3+" $#0" 377,5-$" ,H"631,-]+" 1,.0" /-" $#0" +/-" ,H" $#0"2,.40-" 73.H" _K<,45+" WRbA" 3-4" $#0" +/-+" ,H" G343;" 3-4" 6;/#5"_>0E/$/75+"!`b)""K.+0(#010"/-"$#0"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$A"+$3$0"$0LJ%.0+"(010"+$1/7$.F",HH" ./L/$+"$,"3..";5$" $0L%.0",HH/7/3$0+)"P/$#/-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#j/-7.54/-2"/-"(1/$/-2+"-,1L3..F"3+71/;04"$,"$#0"%1/0+$.F"+7#,,.j$#0"7,LL,-"L0-"3-4"(,L0-",H"D+130."%.3F"3"L,10"37$/E0"1,.0" /-"$#0"$0L%.0A" $#3-"4,"7,LL,-01+"0.+0(#010"/-"$#0"3-7/0-$"(,1.4)"

S,5" H51$#01"4/+7,E01" $#3$" .0++" +51%.5+" /+" 40L3-404" H1,L"$#0"%0,%.0",H"D+130."H,1"$#0"=0L%.0"$#3-"(3+"75+$,L31F"/-"$#0"/L%01/3." 75.$+" ,H" $#0" 3-7/0-$" G031" K3+$)" K.+0(#010" $0L%.0+"1,5$/-0.F" 3221023$04" 0<70++" 73%/$3.A" 3-4" 0-23204" /-" ;5+/-0++"0-$01%1/+0+A" 3-4" +51%.5+"(,5.4" ;0" .,3-04",5$" 3$" #/2#" 13$0+" ,H"/-$010+$)" S,5" -,$0" $#3$" $#0" =0L%.0" 3$" G/%%51A" H,1" 0<3L%.0A"%1,70++0+"W\`A```"+#00%"3-4"2,3$+"3--53..F)!\"CF"7,-$13+$A"0E0-",-" H0+$/E3.+j3-4" 323/-A" /-" (1/$/-2+" -,1L3..F" 3+71/;04" $," $#0"%1/0+$.F" +7#,,.j$#0" Q0-$3$057#" -0E01" L3-43$0+" 7,LL5-/$F",HH01/-2+"/-"0<70++",H"3"4,g0-",1"+,"3-/L3.+"3"43F)"S,5"H/-4"/-"@05$01,-,LF"$#3$A"3+"3"%1/0+$A"F,51"-,-J75.$/7"H5-7$/,-+"+00L"$,"3.(3F+";0"+#3104"(/$#",$#01"-,-J%1/0+$.F";,4/0+&"$#0"+5%10L0"$1/;5-3." /+" /-4004".,73$04"3$"$#0"$0L%.0A"3-4"/+"+$3HH04";F"U$#0">0E/$/73." %1/0+$+V" _!h&aA" !Rb)" C5$" /$" /+" +$3HH04A" 3+" (0..A" ;F" U$#0"*5420",H"$#3$"$/L0V"_!h&aA"!Rb)"=#0"%10J;3$$.0"#,1$3$,1F"%1,7.3JL3$/,-+"$,"+,.4/01+"310"L340";F"%1/0+$+";5$",-.F"/-"7,-*5-7$/,-"(/$#"-,-J%1/0+$.F",HH/701+" _R`&!Jab)"=#0" 0-37$L0-$",H" $#0" +0%J$0--/3."H0+$/E3.",H" "/+"0-$15+$04"$,"$#0"%1/0+$+A";5$",-.F"/-"7,-*5-7$/,-"(/$#"$#0"0.401+"_W!&aJ!`b)"=,";0"+510A"%1/0+$+"0-*,F"3" +$3$5+" 40-/04" ,$#01+)"C5$"(#0-" +00-" /-" 3-7/0-$" %01+%07$/E0A"$#0" %,(01" 3-4"LF+$/Y50" ,H" $#0" %1/0+$#,,4" /+" 2103$.F" E/$/3$04A"3-4"$#0"+$3$5+",H"$#0"7,LL,-"7/$/g0-"2103$.F"0.0E3$04)"

C3+04",-" $#0" ./-0+" $#3$" D"#3E0"413(-"#010A"(#3$"L3F"(0"+3F"3;,5$"$#0"43$/-2",H"$#0+0"/403+A"3-4"$#0+0"$0<$+o"BF"$#/-XJ/-2",-"$#/+"#3+";00-"+#31%0-04";F"3"1070-$"0++3F"H1,L",5$+/40""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""",6G$':%( 6C(.#>8%$6,6AN( :=( &8$(.=>:$=&(X$%#()%E&" _\"E,.+)i"G0("S,1X&"M<JH,14" N-/E)" Q10++A" !aahbA" W&W^hm^ci" :0$#" >)" :3-401+A" /8$( M=Y$=&:6=( 6C(5$;#$7"_N1;3-3A"D..)&"N-/E01+/$F",H"D../-,/+"Q10++A"R``ab)"

!\"8,#-"O)"?,;01$+,-A"U=#0":,7/3."3-4"K7,-,L/7"M123-/g3$/,-",H"6-7/0-$"B0+,%,$3L/3-"=0L%.0+AV"/-"".X)"!&ZZZmZ^)"

Page 12: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

!R"

,51"4/+7/%./-0)"G,"H/0.4",H"37340L/7"+$54F"$,43F"/+"/-"3+"L57#"$51L,/."3+"$#0"H/0.4",H"07,-,L/7+)""M-.F"3"#3-4H5.",H"4,,L+43F"%1,%#0$+" +,5-404" (31-/-2+" /-" 34E3-70" ,H" $#0" 75110-$" 4,(-J$51-)"6-4"(#0-" $#0F" 4/4A" $#0F"(010" $103$04" ;F"L,+$" ,H" $#0/1"7,..03250+" $," (#3$" (0" /-" ,51" H/0.4" (,5.4" 73.." $#0" 8010L/3#"$103$L0-$&"$#0F"(010"+7,1-04";F"$#0"0+$3;./+#L0-$)"=#0"G,;0.".35103$0" /-" 07,-,L/7+A" Q35."f152L3-A" 3+X+" #,(" /$" /+" $#3$" $#0"0-$/10" 25/.4" ,H" 07,-,L/+$+j#/L+0.H" /-7.5404j2,$" /$" +,"(1,-2)!^" 6-4" #/+" 7,-7.5+/,-" /+" $#/+&" U6+" D" +00" /$AV" f152L3-"(1/$0+A" U$#0"07,-,L/7+"%1,H0++/,-"(0-$" 3+$13F";0735+0"07,-,JL/+$+A"3+"3"21,5%A"L/+$,,X";035$FA"H,1"$15$#)"=#0"70-$13."735+0",H"$#0"%1,H0++/,-]+"H3/.510AV"#0"2,0+",-A"U(3+"$#0"40+/10"H,1"3-"3..J0-7,L%3++/-2A" /-$0..07$53..F" 0.023-$" 3%%1,37#)V" f152L3-"2,0+",-" $,"0<%.3/-"#,(" $#0"-0,7.3++/73.";0./0H" /-"L31X0$+"#34"3-" 3..510" ;0735+0" /$" 3..,(04" +7#,.31+" $," 4," L371,07,-,L/7+"(/$#" 7.31/$FA" 7,L%.0$0-0++" 3-4" (/$#" ;035$F)" =#0" 3%%1,37#"+00L04"$,"0<%.3/-"+,"L3-F"$#/-2+)"

f152L3-]+"3-3.F+/+",H"(#3$"#3%%0-04"$,"3-"0-$/10"25/.4",H"07,-,L/+$+"2/E0+"L0"735+0"H,1"10H.07$/,-"3+"3";/;./7/+$)"M5$",H"40H010-70" $," ,51" 7,..03250+" /-" 07,-,L/7+A" D" 3L" 2,/-2" $," 3+J+5L0" $#3$" (0" /-" C/;.0" +$54/0+" 310" -," L,10" /-$0../20-$A" 3-4"%,++0++"-,"L,10" /-$0..07$53." /-$021/$F" $#3-" $#0F"4,)"I,5.4"(0A"$,,A"(/$#/-",51"4/+7/%./-0"H3.."E/7$/L"$," $#0"3..510",H"L/+$3X/-2";035$F" H,1" $15$#o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o"I,5.4"(0A"$,,A";0"L/+$3X/-2";035$F"H,1"$15$#o"f152L3-"(1/$0+A"U/H"$#0"07,-,L/7+"%1,H0++/,-"/+"$,"10400L"/$+0.HA"/$"(/.."#3E0"$,"107,-7/.0"/$+0.H"$,"3".0++"3..51/-2"E/+/,-AV"3-4"$#3$"U(#3$]+"3.L,+$"701$3/-"/+"$#3$"07,-,L/+$+"(/.."#3E0"$,".031-"$,"./E0"(/$#"L0++/J-0++)V"

MH" 7,51+0A" ,-" $#0" Y50+$/,-" ,H" 43$/-2" $#0" $0<$+" (0"(,1X"(/$#A"(0"-004"$,"4,"$#0";0+$"(0"73-"(/$#"(#3$"(0"#3E0)"P#010"(0"#3E0"H/1L";3+/+"5%,-"(#/7#"$,"43$0"3"$0<$A",1",1401"3"+0$",H"$0<$+A" (0" +#,5.4-]$" #0+/$3$0" $," 4," +,)" C5$" +#,5.4" U4,/-2" $#0";0+$"(0"73-AV";07,L0"3"./70-+0"$,"%,+/$"3"43$0"H,1"3"$0<$",-"$#0";3+/+" ,H" H./L+F" 0E/40-70" ,1" #F%,$#0+/+" 3.,-0o"Q01#3%+" U4,/-2"$#0" ;0+$" (0" 73-V" /-" $01L+" ,H" 43$/-2" $#0" $0<$+" (0" (,1X" (/$#"+#,5.4"L03-"34L/$$/-2"$#3$"(0"*5+$"4,"-,$"#3E0"3"7.031"%/7$510)"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!^"Q35."f152L3-A"U9,("@/4"K7,-,L/+$+"[0$"D$":,"P1,-2oV"X$7(

`6#<( /:F$E( P%A%J:=$A" :0%$0L;01" ^A" R``a)" 6E3/.3;.0" 3$&"#$$%&''((()-F$/L0+)7,L'R``a'`a'`^'L323g/-0'`^K7,-,L/7J$)#$L.)"

Page 13: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

!W"

Q01#3%+"(0A"$,,A"U(/.."#3E0"$,".031-"$,"./E0"(/$#"L0++/-0++V"3-4"3E,/4"$#0"%/$H3..",H"L/+$3X/-2";035$F"H,1"$15$#)"

=#010"310"L3-F"/-",51"H/0.4A"-,"4,5;$A"(#,"310"L,10"7,-JH/40-$" $#3-"D"3L"3;,5$",51"73%37/$F" $,"43$0" $#0+0"+,5170+"3-4"$#0/1"40E0.,%L0-$)"6-4"/$" /+" $,"$#0L"$#3$"D"(,5.4" ./X0"$,"+52J20+$"#,("LF"+$54FA"(#/7#".3120.F"3E,/4+"$#0+0"/++50+A"73-";0",H"5+0A"0E0-"(/$#/-"3"7.3++/73."+,5170J71/$/73."3%%1,37#)"

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j3+"%31$+",H"3-"/-$0213$04"(#,.0)"=#0"(#,.0-0++",H"#5L3-" 0<%01/0-70" L3-43$0+" 3" ;,,X" $#3$" +00X+" $#0" /-$0110.3J$/,-+#/%",H"$#0+0"%#0-,L0-3)"

O/-3..FA" 1034/-2" $#0"Q0-$3$057#" +F-7#1,-/73..FA" 3+" D" #3E0A"-004" -,$" ;0" 7,-+$1504" 3+" 5-71/$/73.A" ;5$" 3+" $#0" H/1+$" +$0%" /-" 3"+,5170J71/$/73." %1,70++)" CF" H/1+$" 1034/-2" $#0" Q0-$3$057#" +F-J7#1,-/73..F"3-4"4/+7,E01/-2"(#3$"D"$3X0"$,";0"+51%1/+/-2"./-0+",H"377,14" 371,++" L3-F" %3++320+A" 3" +,5170J71/$/73." +7#,.31" L3F"7,L0"$,"-0("7,-7.5+/,-+"3;,5$"$#0"H35.$"./-0+";0$(00-"%3++32J0+A"3-4"$#0"10.3$/,-+#/%",H",-0"%3++320"$,"3-,$#01)"

=,"7,-7.540&"[10070"3-4"?,L0"X-0("$#0/1"10+%07$/E0"10JH,1L01+)" S0$" -,(#010" /-" $#0" 3-7/0-$" %01/,4" 4," (0" H/-4"31$/75.3$04"$#0"/403.",H"3"+,7/0$F"(/$#,5$"7.3++"4/E/+/,-+"$#3$"310"H,5-404" ,-" $#0" 7,-$1,." ,H" 07,-,L/7A" L/./$31FA" 3-4" %,./$/73."%,(01)"P/$#" 3.." $#0" 73E03$+" 3-4" 7,-4/$/,-+" $#3$" D" #3E0" 13/+04"#010A"D"(,5.4"./X0"$,"+5;L/$"$#3$"$#0";/1$#%.370",H"$#3$"/403."/+"/-"$#0"O/E0"C,,X+",H"B,+0+)" "

Page 14: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

!Z"

7F8E$:;F$?@;$B@;?!;G$;S9?8$

:N:6G"6IfK?B6G"@6?=BMN=9"IM>>K[K"

8,+#53"C01L3-]+"$#0+/+"/-""#$%&$'()*+%,4(567(&8$(9:;,$(9#6<$(7:&8(.=>:$=&(?6,:&:>%,(/86+A8&" /+" $#3$" $#1,52#,5$" $#0"C/;.0A" 3-4"0+%0J7/3..F" $#1,52#,5$" $#0" Q0-$3$057#" _,1" L,10" +%07/H/73..FA" H,1"C01L3-A"(#,"0+7#0(+"3"+,5170J71/$/73."L0$#,4,.,2FA" $#1,52#J,5$"U$#0"$0<$",H"$#0"Q0-$3$057#"/-"/$+"1070/E04"H,1LVbA!h"$#010"/+".,73$04"U3"+$13-4",H" $#,52#$p$#3$"10*07$+"#/01317#F"3-4"+00X+"$," %1,L,$0" 023./$31/3-/+L)V!c" D-" I#3%$01+" RA" WA" 3-4" Z" ,H" #/+";,,XA"C01L3-"+$1/E0+"$,"40L,-+$13$0"$#0"E3./4/$F",H"$#/+"$#0+/+";F"4,75L0-$/-2"$#0"Q0-$3$057#]+"023./$31/3-"/L%5.+0A"3+"#0"+00+"/$A"/-"$0<$+"$#3$"%01$3/-"$,A"10+%07$/E0.FA"%,./$/7+A"07,-,L/7+A"3-4"+71/;3."$07#-,.,2F)"C01L3-"$#0-"$51-+"/-"I#3%$01"\"$,"7,-+/401"$#0"023./$31/3-"$0-40-7/0+"#0"H/-4+"34410++04"(/$#/-"$#0"Q0-$3J$057#3."+$,1F",H"$#0";3;F"B,+0+]"-031"403$#"/-"$#0"(3$01+",H"$#0"G/.0"_K<,4"R&!J!`b)"

N-401%/--/-2" 3.." ,H" $#/+A" #,(0E01A" /+" C01L3-]+" 40+71/%J$/,-A" /-" I#3%$01" !A" ,H" UK23./$31/3-" =#0,.,2FAV!a" (#/7#" #0"40H/-0+" 3+" 3-"31$/75.3$/,-",H" $#0"L0$3%#F+/73."%3134/2L",H" $#0"[,4J#5L3-" 0-7,5-$01" 3+" 0<%10++04" %1/L31/.F" /-" $01L+" ,H"UD+130." 3+" 3" 7,LL5-/$F" /-" 7,E0-3-$3." 10.3$/,-+#/%"(/$#"[,4AV"3-4"3"7,E0-3-$3." 10.3$/,-+#/%A"L,10,E01A" /-"(#/7#"U$#0"70-$01",H"4/E/-0"3$$0-$/,-p(3+"$#0"%0,%.0"3+"3"(#,.0A"3-4"037#"/-4/JE/453." %01+,-A" -,$" $#0" .03401+#/%)VR`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h"8,+#53"6)"C01L3-A""#$%&$'()*+%,4(567(&8$(9:;,$(9#6<$(7:&8(.=>:$=&(

?6,:&:>%,(/86+A8&"_M<H,14"3-4"G0("S,1X&"M<H,14"N-/E)"Q10++A"R``cbA"c)"!c"D;/4)A"cR)"C01L3-"40H/-0+"#/01317#F"/-"$01L+",H"U+,7/3."+$13$/H/73J

$/,-AV" 3" +F+$0L"(#010;F"U%01L3-0-$" 3-4" /-+$/$5$/,-3./g04"%,(01" d/+e"2/E0-"$,"%31$/75.31"7.3++0+"$,"7,-$1,."$#0"07,-,L/7A"L/./$31FA"3-4"%,./$J/73." 10+,5170+" ,H" +,7/0$FAV" (#0103+" 023./$31/3-/+LA" /-" #/+"5-401+$3-4/-2A"/+"7#3137$01/+$/7",H"+,7/0$/0+"U/-"(#/7#"$#0"#/01317#F",H"%01L3-0-$"3-4"/-+$/$5$/,-3./g04"+$13$/H/73$/,-"/+"4/++/%3$04)V"_D;/4)A"\)b"

!a":00"/;/4)A"!\m!^A"(#010"#0"(1/$0+&"U=#/+"$#0,.,2F"d/)0)A"$#0"023./J$31/3-" $#0,.,2F" C01L3-" +00X+" $," 40+71/;0" /-" I#3%$01" !e" /+" $#0"5-401%/--/-2",H"3"+0$",H"+,7/3."3-4"%,./$/73."%,./7/0+"$#3$"D"0<%.,10"/-"7#3%$01+"R"$#1,52#"\)V""

R`"D;/4)A"^`A"(/$#"344/$/,-3."L3$01/3."%313%#13+04"H1,L"%)"Za)"R!"D;/4)A"Zh)"RR"D;/4)"

Page 15: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

!\"

*5+$" 7/$04" (/$#" 3" 4/+75++/,-" ,H" 3" %3134/2L" 344/$/,-3." $," $#0"%,./$/73..FJ;3+04"%3134/2L",H"7,E0-3-$"$#3$"#0"31250+"/+"5+04"/-";/;./73."(1/$/-2+" U3+" 3"L,40." H,1" $#0" 0-7,5-$01" ;0$(00-"[,4"3-4"D+130.V&" $#/+"344/$/,-3."%3134/2L" /+"U$#0"%3134/2L",H"L31J1/320AV" (#010;F" D+130." 3+" 3" 7,LL5-/$F" /+" 20-40104" 3+" H0L3.0"3-4"40+71/;04"3+"S3#(0#]+"(/H0)RW"=,20$#01A"U$#0"7,E0-3-$"3-4"L311/320"%3134/2L+AV"C01L3-"2,0+",-" $,"7.3/LA"U$0.."5+"L57#"3;,5$p$#0"7,+L/7"H,5-43$/,-+",H"3-"023./$31/3-",1401V"/-";/;J./73."$#,52#$ARZ",1"323/-A"3+"C01L3-]+"I#3%$01"!"$/$.0"(,5.4"#3E0"/$A" $#0" C/;.0]+" UK23./$31/3-" =#0,.,2F)V" O,1" 0<3L%.0A" C01L3-"40+71/;0+" 107/%1,7/$F" 3-4"U3" 10.3$/,-+#/%",H"L5$53./$FV"3+" 7#3J137$01/g/-2" $#0"#5+;3-4J(/H0"L0$3%#,1" $#3$"#0" +00+" 3+" ,-0" ,H"$#0"L,40.+",H"$#0"D+130./$0+]"4/E/-0J#5L3-"0-7,5-$01)R\":/L/.31J.FA"#0"/LL04/3$0.F"H,..,(+"$#0"Y5,$0"3;,5$"7,E0-3-$"$#3$"D"7/$04"3$" $#0" ;02/--/-2" ,H" $#/+" %313213%#" (/$#" 3" 4/+75++/,-" ,H" $#0";,,X" ,H" @05$01,-,LF]+" ./$0131F" +$157$510" U3+" 3" +01/0+" ,H" 34J410++0+" $," D+130." 3+" 3" 7,..07$/E0" qF,5]&" q`6+" +#3.." .,E0" $#0">,14"F,51"[,4"(/$#"3.."F,51"#031$]"_^&\bi"qN6+"+#3.."H03+$"d/-"$#0"$0LJ%.0e";0H,10"$#0">,14"F,51"[,4]"_!R&hbAV"3;,5$"(#/7#"#0"7.3/L+A"U$#010"/+"3"H5-43L0-$3..F"023./$31/3-"+$103X"3$"%.3F"#010)VR^"

K.+0(#010A"L,10,E01A"C01L3-"(1/$0+" $#3$"U3$" +,L0" *5-7J$510+A" 3+" /-" $#0" 7,..07$/E0" 34410++" ,H" $#0" 0-$/10" %,./$F" _$#0"+07,-4"%01+,-"%.513."qF,5]bA"/$"L3F";0"$#3$"L0-"3-4"(,L0-"310"34410++04"/-"0Y53."H3+#/,-VRh"j3+"/-"$#0"Y5,$0"H1,L"@05$"!R&h"7/$04" *5+$" 3;,E0A"C01L3-"L/2#$" ;0" $3X0-" $," /L%.FA"(#010" $#0"7,LL3-4"$,"H03+$" /+"10-40104" /-"$#0"+07,-4J%01+,-"L3+75./-0"%.513.A" )"S0$"C01L3-"3.+,"(1/$0+"/-"#/+"/-$1,457$/,-&"

=#0"%/7$510"D"%3/-$",H"3";/;./73."%,./$F"$#3$"10*07$+"7.3++"4/+J$/-7$/,-" ,-" $#0" ;3+/+" ,H" $#0" 7,-$1,." ,H" 07,-,L/7" 3-4"%,./$/73."%,(01"%01$3/-+"%1/L31/.F"$,"D+130./$0"L0-A"3-4"-,$"$,"D+130./$0"(,L0-p$#0";.50%1/-$"$#0"Q0-$3$057#".3F+",5$"$3X0+" H,1"213-$04"(,L0-]+" +5;,14/-3$/,-" $,"L0-A"0<7.54J/-2" $#0L" H1,L" %31$/7/%3$/,-" /-"L3-F" 3103+A" /-7.54/-2" $#0"*54/7/31FA" $#0" 75.$A" $#0" L/./$31FA" 3-4" .3-4" ,(-01+#/%A" $,"-3L0"*5+$"3"H0()Rc"

:," #,(" 5.$/L3$0.F" 310" (0" $," 0E3.53$0" /++50+" ,H" 20-401" /-" $#0"./2#$",H"C01L3-]+" $#0+/+o"610" $#010A"0E0-"(/$#/-" $#0"Q0-$3$05J7#3." ;.50%1/-$" $#3$" U$3X0+" H,1" 213-$04"(,L0-]+" +5;,14/-3$/,-"$,"L0-AV"$#0"2./LL01+"C01L3-"%,/-$+"$,",H"3"L,10"023./$31/3-"$#15+$"$#3$"(,5.4"/-7.540"(,L0-"3+"3"(#,.0"(/$#/-"3"7,..07$/E0"D+130./$0"UF,5V"3-4"(,5.4"213-$"L311/04"(,L0-"$#0"+3L0"UL5J$53./$FV" /-" $#0/1" 10.3$/,-+#/%+"(/$#"$#0/1"#5+;3-4+"$#3$"C01L3-"%,+/$+"102314/-2"D+130.]+"L0$3%#,1/73."L311/320"$,"S3#(0#o"M1"/+" $#/+" 3-" ,E01.F" ,%$/L/+$/7" /-$01%10$3$/,-" ,H" $#0+0" ;,4/0+" ,H"L3$01/3.o" D-"(#3$" H,..,(+A" D" 31250" H,1" $#0" .3$$01"%,+/$/,-A"%1,J%,+/-2"$#3$"-0/$#01"@05$01,-,LF]+"_,1",$#01"$0<$+]b"5+0",H"$#0"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

RW"D;/4)A"ZZ)""RZ"D;/4)A"ZhmZc)""R\"D;/4)A"ZZA"Z^)""R^"D;/4)A"^`)""Rh"D;/4)A"!W)""Rc"D;/4)""

Page 16: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

!^"

7,..07$/E0"UF,5V"-,1"$#0"L0$3%#,1",H"D+130."3+"S3#(0#]+"+%,5+0",HH01+"$,"(,L0-"3"%.370"/-"3-7/0-$"D+130.]+"+,7/3.",1401"0Y5/E3J.0-$"$,"_,1"0E0-"3%%1,37#/-2b"$#3$"3E3/.3;.0"$,"L0-)"D-"D+130.A"/$"$51-+",5$A",-.F"L0-j/-4004A"3+"(0"(/.."+00A",-.F"+,L0"L0-j310"7103$04"0Y53.)"

>0$"L0";02/-";F" 7,-+/401/-2" $#0"L3$$01",H" $#0" 7,..07$/E0"UF,5AV" H/1+$";F"-,$/-2A"3+" H0L/-/+$";/;./73." +7#,.31+"#3E0"4,75JL0-$04"+/-70"$#0"0L0120-70",H"$#0/1"+5;4/+7/%./-0]+"(,1X"/-"$#0"031.F" !ah`+A" $#0"L3-F" %.370+" (#010" $#0" +07,-4J%01+,-" %.513."UF,5V"73--,$"10H01"$,"L0-"3-4"(,L0-"$,20$#01)"Q01#3%+"L,+$",H$0-"7/$04"/-"$#/+"102314"/+"3-"K<,45+"$0<$"$#3$"7,-701-+"S3#J(0#]+" $#0,%#,1/7" 3%%0313-70" $," $#0" D+130./$0+" 3$"B,5-$" :/-3/A"K<,4" !a&!\)" =#010A" $#0" 7,..07$/E0" UF,5V" 3++0L;.04" 3$" $#0"L,5-$3/-]+" ;3+0" /+" 7,LL3-404" $," %10%310" H,1" S3#(0#]+" /LJ%0-4/-2" E/+/$3$/,-" ;F" -,$" 3%%1,37#/-2" 3" (,L3-)" D-" $#/+"%3++320A" 7.031.FA" $#0" +07,-4J%01+,-" L3+75./-0" %.513." H,1L"

" 34410++0+" +%07/H/73..F" 3-" 3..JL3.0" 354/0-70)Ra" :,L0J(#3$"+/L/.31.FA"/-"K<,4"R`&!hA"3+"%31$",H"S3#(0#]+"40./E01/-2",H"$#0"$0-"7,LL3-4L0-$+A" $#0"UF,5V"(#,"/+"7,LL3-404"-,$"$,"7,E0$A" 3L,-2" ,$#01" $#/-2+A" 3" -0/2#;,1]+" (/H0" L5+$" 3.+," ;0" 3"L3.0" UF,5AVW`" 3.$#,52#" #010" $#0" E01;" H,1L+A" 3+" (0.." 3+" $#0"H,1L+",H"$#0"%1,-,L/-3."+5HH/<0+"_UN6+#"-0/2#;,1]+"#,5+0V"3-4"UN6+#" -0/2#;,1]+" (/H0VbA" 310" 10-40104" /-" $#0" +07,-4J%01+,-"L3+75./-0" +/-25.31)" S0$" (#/.0" $#/+" +#/H$" $," L3+75./-0" +/-25.31"H,1L+"_(#/7#" /+"%1,;3;.F"3$$1/;5$3;.0"$,"3"+#/H$" /-"+,5170+A"H,1"(#/.0"K<,4"!a&!\"/+"8A"$#0"7,LL3-4L0-$+",H"K<,4"R`&!J!h"U4,"-,$" %1,%01.F" ;0.,-2" $," 8A" KA" ,1" QVbW!" L/2#$" +00L" $," .034" 5+"3+$13F"H1,L"$#0"+07,-4J%01+,-"%.513."UF,5V"34410++0+"$,"(#/7#"C01L3-"#3+"4/107$04",5$"3$$0-$/,-A"/$"$51-+",5$"$#3$"3"+0-+/$/E/$F"$," $#0" /L%./04" 10H010-$+" ,H" ;,$#" +/-25.31" 3-4" %.513." UF,5V"H,1L+"(/.."0E0-$53..F";0"10Y5/104"$,"5-401+$3-4"$#0"@05$"!R&h"$0<$"3$"(#/7#"C01L3-"#3+"3.+,"+5220+$04"(0".,,XA"3-4"$#/+"0E0-"$#,52#A"3+"C01L3-]+"Y5,$0"3+"7/$04"031./01"-,$0+A"/$"/+"3"L3+75J""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

Ra"6+"%,/-$04",5$"3.1034F";F"Q#F../+"C/14"/-"UDL320+",H"P,L0-"/-"$#0" M.4" =0+$3L0-$AV" ?,+0L31F" ?34H,14" ?50$#01" _04)b" -$,:A:6=( %='(D$[:EF4(MF%A$E(6C(Z6F$=(:=(&8$(B$7:E8(%='("8#:E&:%=(/#%':&:6=E"_G0("S,1X&":/L,-"3-4":7#5+$01A"!ahZbA"\`i"+00"3.+,"0340LA"U=#0"Q.370",H"P,L0-"/-" $#0" D+130./$0" I5.$5+AV" Q3$1/7X" @)" B/..01A" Q35." @)" 93-+,-A" 3-4" :)"@03-"B7C1/40" _04+)b".=>:$=&( ME#%$,:&$(-$,:A:6=4()EE%NE( :=(56=6#( 6C(^#%=<(P66#$( "#6EE" _Q#/.340.%#/3&" O,1$10++A" !achbA" Z`Ri" 0340LA" UP,L0-]+"?0./2/,-" /-" 6-7/0-$" D+130.AV" C31;313" :)" >0+X," _04)b"Z6F$=_E( )%#,:$E&(-$>6#'E(C#6F(.=>:$=&()ANG&(%='(Z$E&$#=(.E:%4(?#6>$$':=AE(6C(&8$("6=C$#$=>$(6=(Z6F$=(:=(&8$(.=>:$=&(X$%#()%E&O(9#67=(2=:Y$#E:&NO(?#6Y:'$=>$O(-86'$(ME,%='O(X6Y$F;$#(abVO(URcV" _C8:A"!^^i"6$.3-$3&":7#,.31+"Q10++A"!acabA"Rc^A"-)"a)"

W`"6+"323/-"-,$04"3+"031.F"3+"!ahZ";F"C/14A"/-"UDL320+",H"P,L0-"/-"$#0"M.4"=0+$3L0-$AV"ZaA"3-4"3.+,"/-"U=#0"Q.370",H"P,L0-"/-"$#0"D+130./$0"I5.$5+AV"Z`R)":00"3.+,"6$#3.F3"C10--01A"U6-"6H$01(,14&"=#0"@073.,250j6L"D"3-"64410++00oAV"6$#3.F3"C10--01" _04)b".(^$F:=:E&("6FG%=:6=( &6( )[6'+E( &6( 0$+&$#6=6FN" _:#0HH/0.4&" :#0HH/0.4" 67340L/7"Q10++A"!aaZbA"R\\mR\c)"

W!"P/../3L"9)"I)"Q1,%%A")[6'+E(URbdW4(.(X$7(/#%=E,%&:6=(7:&8(M=@&#6'+>&:6=(%='("6FF$=&%#N"_6CA"R6i"G0("S,1X&"@,5;.043FA"R``^bA"!Z\m!Z^)"

Page 17: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

!h"

./-0"%.513."UF,5V"/-"@05$"!R&h"$#3$"/-/$/3..F"7,LL3-4+",51"7,-J+/4013$/,-" 3+" $#0" 7,..07$/E0" $#3$" /+" $,.4" $," H03+$" ;0H,10" D+130.]+"[,4" /-" $#0" %.370" $#3$" S3#(0#" #3+" 7#,+0-" _@05$01,-,LF]+"7/175L.,75$/,-"H,1"$#0"$0L%.0"/-"8015+3.0Lb)WR"

:," (#," /+" $#/+" UF,5AV" 3-4A" L,10" /L%,1$3-$A" 4,0+" /$" /-J7.540A"3+"C01L3-"/L%./0+" /$"L/2#$A"(,L0-o"6$"+,L0".0E0.A" $#0"3-+(01"$,"$#/+"Y50+$/,-"/+"+510.F"F0+A"/-"$#3$"(,L0-"310"701$3/-J.F"/-7.5404"/-"$#0"3++0L;.F"$#3$"377,14/-2"$,"@05$01,-,LF"!R"/+" $," 23$#01" H,1" +371/H/7/3." H03+$+" 3$" S3#(0#]+" $0L%.0)" =#/+" /+"L340",;E/,5+";F"$#0"H37$"$#3$"@05$"!R&h"2,0+",-"$,"2.,++"$#,+0"(#," 310" $," %31$/7/%3$0" /-" $#0" $0L%.0" H03+$" 3+" UF,5" dL3+75./-0"%.513.e" 3-4" F,51" dL3+75./-0" %.513.e" #,5+0#,.4V" _ ! b"3-4" $#3$"@05$" !R&!R" H51$#01" 2.,++0+" $#/+" U#,5+0#,.4V" 3+" 7,-J+/+$/-2" ,H" UF,51" dL3+75./-0" %.513.e" +,-+V" _ bA" UF,51"dL3+75./-0"%.513.e"4352#$01+V"_ bA"UF,51"dL3+75./-0"%.513.e"L3-+01E3-$+V"_ bA"UF,51"dL3+75./-0"%.513.e"L3/4+01E3-$+V"_ bA" 3-4" U$#0">0E/$0"(#," /+" /-" F,51" dL3+75./-0" %.513.e"23$0+V"_ b)":$/..A"3$"$#0"+3L0"$/L0"$#3$"@05$"!R&h"3-4"!R"L3X0" 7.031" $#3$"(,L0-" 310" /-7.5404" /-" $#0" $0L%.0" 23$#01/-2+"$#3$" $#0+0" %3++320+" L3-43$0A" $#0F" 13/+0" 4,5;$+j;F" ./+$/-2"4352#$01+" 3-4" L3/4+01E3-$+" 3L,-2" $#0" L0L;01+" ,H" UF,51"#,5+0#,.4Vj(#0$#01" (,L0-" 310" 3" %31$" ,H" $#0" /-/$/3..F" 7/$04"+07,-4J%01+,-" 7,..07$/E0" ,H" UF,5V" _ b)" >/X0(/+0A" /-" @05$"!R&!cA"$#0"UF,5V"_#010"/-"$#0"+07,-4J%01+,-"L3+75./-0"+/-25.31A!

b"$#3$"/+"$,"23$#01"/-"S3#(0#]+"8015+3.0L"$0L%.0"H,1"+371/H/J7/3." H03+$/-2" /+" ./+$04" 3+",$#01" $#3-" $#,+0"#,5+0#,.4"L0L;01+A"L3.0"3-4"H0L3.0A"(#,"310"$,"*,/-"/-"$#0"H03+$/-2"3+"(0..&"UF,51"dL3+75./-0" +/-25.31e" +,-V" _ bA" UF,51" dL3+75./-0" +/-25.31e"4352#$01V" _ bA" UF,51" dL3+75./-0" +/-25.31e" L3-+01E3-$V"_ bA" UF,51" dL3+75./-0" +/-25.31e" L3/4+01E3-$V" _ bA" 3-4"U$#0">0E/$0"(#,"/+"/-"F,51"dL3+75./-0"+/-25.31e"23$0+V"_ b)"=#/+" +$1,-2.F" +5220+$+" $#3$" _$," 5+0" C01L3-]+" .3-25320bWW" U$#0"%0,%.0"3+"3"(#,.0V" _$#0"%.513.! b"3-4"U037#" /-4/E/453."%01J+,-V" _$#0" +/-25.31! b" ,-" (#,L" U4/E/-0" 3$$0-$/,-V" /+"70-$0104" /-"@05$" !R&hA" !RA" 3-4" !c" _3-4A" ;F" 0<$0-+/,-A" /-" $#0".31201"%01/7,%0",H"@05$"!R&RJRc"3-4"0E0-A";F"H51$#01"0<$0-+/,-A"/-" $#0" 0-$/10" 7,1%5+" ,H" 7,E0-3-$3." ,;./23$/,-+" %10+71/;04" /-"@05$"!R&RJR^&!\b" 310",-.F" 3-7/0-$" D+130./$0"L3.0+" _3-4A" /-4004A",-.F"3-7/0-$"D+130.]+"L3.0"#034+",H"#,5+0#,.4A"3+"+,-+A"L3-+01JE3-$+A" 3-4" $#0" 5-.3-404">0E/$0+" 310" 73$02,1/g04" 3+"L0-",$#01"$#3-"UF,5Vb)"

=,";0"+510A"$#010"310"+7#,.31+"(#,"#3E0"312504",$#01(/+0A"L,+$"-,$3;.F"%01#3%+"[0,12"C135./XA"(#,"#3+"-,$04"$#3$"(#/.0"$#0" @05$" !R&!c" ./+$" ,H" H0+$3." %31$/7/%3-$+" ,;E/,5+.F" /-7.540+"L5.$/%.0"L0L;01+A"/-7.54/-2"(,L0-A"H1,L"3-"0<$0-404"#,5+0J#,.4"7,LL5-/$F"_3"X/-"21,5%"3-4"/$+"3HH/./3$0+b"3-4"/-"344/$/,-"+,L0"10+/40-$+",H"+57#"3"#,5+0#,.4]+" .31201" $,(-A" /$"4,0+"-,$"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

WR"6+"C01L3-A""#$%&$'()*+%,A"!a!m!aRA"-)"WZA"%,/-$+",5$A"$#0"/++50",H"+/-25.31"3+",%%,+04"$,"%.513."+07,-4J%01+,-"34410++"/-"@05$01,-J,LF" /+" 4/+75++04" /-" B,+#0" P0/-H0.4A" 0$+&$#6=6FN( UbUU4( .( X$7(/#%=E,%&:6=(7:&8(M=&#6'+>&:6=(%='("6FF$=&%#N(_6CA"\i"G0("S,1X&"@,5;.0J43FA"!aa!bA"!\m!^)"

WW"=3X0-"H1,L"C01L3-A"/;/4)A"^`)""

Page 18: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

!c"

+%07/H/73..F"L0-$/,-"$#0"(/H0",H"3"#,5+0#,.4)"S0$"C135./X"H/-4+"/$" U#314.F" 7,-70/E3;.0V" $#3$" $#0"(/H0" /+" -,$" 3L,-2" $#,+0"(#,"310"$,"*,/-"/-"$#0"+371/H/7/3."L03."0-*,F04";F"$#/+",$#01(/+0"Y5/$0"7,L%0-4/,5+"23$#01/-2)WZ"I,-+0Y50-$.FA"#0"31250+A"+#0"L5+$";0"+5;+5L04"(/$#/-" $#0"L3+75./-0" +/-25.31"UF,5V",H"@05$"!R&!c)"D$" H,..,(+" /-" $51-" $#3$" $#0"(/H0"L5+$";0" +5;+5L04"(/$#/-" $#0"L3+75./-0"+/-25.31"UF,5V",H"10.3$04"E01+0+"_+57#"3+"@05$"!^&!!"3-4"!ZA"$,";0"4/+75++04"H51$#01";0.,(b"3-4"3.+,"(/$#/-"$#0"L3+J75./-0" %.513." UF,5V" ,H" @05$" !R&h" 3-4" !R)W\" D-4004A" C135./X"(1/$0+" ,H" $#0+0" $0<$+&" U0E/40-$.FA" $#0" qF,5]" _ "!

bp34410++0+"(,L0-" 3+"(0.." 3+"L0-AV" 3+" /$" /+" U#/2#.F" /LJ%1,;3;.0V"$#3$"U$#0"H3L/.F"L,$#01"#34"$,"+$3F"#,L0"3.,-0A"$3X0"7310",H"$#0"#,5+0"3-4"4,"3.."$#0"(,1XA"(#/.0"$#0"(#,.0"H3L/.FA"/-7.54/-2"$#0"+.3E0+A"(0-$",HHp0-*,F04"$#0"+371/H/7/3."L03."3-4"10*,/704" /-" 8015+3.0L)VW^" N-401" $#0" $01L+" ,H" $#/+" .,2/7A" ,-0"(,5.4" 7,-7.540" $#3$A" +,L0(#3$" 3+" C01L3-" /-$/L3$0+A" 3$" .03+$"L3.0" #034+" ,H" #,5+0#,.4" 3-4" $#0/1" (/E0+" 310A" /-" $#0" 73+0" ,H"@05$" !R&h" _3-4" $#5+" %10+5L3;.FA" 323/-" ;F" 0<$0-+/,-A" /-" $#0".31201"%01/7,%0",H"@05$"!R&RJRc"3-4"/-"$#0".31201"+$/.."7,1%5+",H"@05$"!R&RJR^&!\bA" U34410++04" /-"0Y53." H3+#/,-V" /-"U$#0"7,..07J$/E0" 34410++" ,H" $#0" 0-$/10" %,./$F" _$#0" +07,-4" %01+,-" %.513."qF,5]b)VWh"

S0$" 3+" D" #3E0" /-4/73$04A" D" #3E0" 10+01E3$/,-+)" I01$3/-.F"0.+0(#010" /-" Q0-$3$057#3." $134/$/,-A" 3" L3-]+" (/H0" 73-" ;0" 0<J7.5404" H1,L" 3" ./+$" ,H" 3" #,5+0#,.4]+" (,L0-" (/$#" (#,L" $#3$"L3-"/+",$#01(/+0"75.$/73..F"3HH/./3$04&"D"$#/-X"#010",H">0E"R!&!J^A"(#/7#"3..,(+"3"%1/0+$j(#,",$#01(/+0"+#,5.4"3E,/4"$#0"7,-$3JL/-3$/-2"%,..5$/,-"/-751104"$#1,52#"7,-$37$"(/$#"3"7,1%+0j$,"%31$/7/%3$0" /-" $#0"L,1$531F" 1/$0+" ,H" #/+" L,$#01A" #/+" 4352#$01A"3-4"#/+"5-L311/04"+/+$01)"9,(0E01A"U#/+"(/H0"H/-4+"-,"%.370"/-"$#0" ./+$" ,H" 0<70%$/,-+)VWc" D-4004A">0E"R!&Z"L3F" 0<%./7/$.F" +$3$0"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""WZ"[0,12"C135./XA"UP010"(,L0-A"$,,A"3..,(04"$,",HH01"+371/H/70+"/-"

D+130.o"M;+01E3$/,-+",-"$#0"L03-/-2"3-4"H0+$/E0"H,1L",H"+371/H/70" /-"@05$01,-,LFAV"5$#Y6#F'$(&$6,6A:$E$(E&+':$E"\\"_!aaabA"aW^)"

W\" :00" +/L/.31.F" Q#F../+" C/14A" UP,L0-" _M=bAV" /-".90" ^A" a\\;i"I31,."B0F01+A"U@352#$01+"_3-4":,-+b"3-4"O0L3.0"_3-4"B3.0b":.3E0+A"?0*,/7/-2" _@05$" !R&!Ri" !^&!!A" !ZbAV"I31,."B0F01+A"(/$#"=,-/"I13E0-"3-4"?,++":)"f130L01A" _04+)b"Z6F$=( :=(D>#:G&+#$4(.(0:>&:6=%#N(6C(X%F$'(%='(2==%F$'(Z6F$=( :=( &8$(5$;#$7(9:;,$O( &8$(.G6>#NG8%,e0$+&$#6>%=6=:>%,(966<EO( %='( &8$(X$7(/$E&%F$=&( _C,+$,-&"9,52#$,-"B/HH./-A" R```bA" RRZi"Q3$1/7X" @)" B/..01A" /8$( -$,:A:6=( 6C( .=>:$=&( ME#%$," _>/;131F" ,H" 6-7/0-$"D+130.i" >,-4,-&" :QIfi" >,5/+E/..0&" P0+$L/-+$01" 8,#-" f-,<A" R```bA"R`Z)"

W^" [0,12" C135./XA" U=#0" ?0*07$/,-" ,H" $#0" [,440++" 6+#013#" /-"D+130.&"P3+"$#0"?0*07$/,-"3+">3$0"3+"@05$01,-,L/+$/7"3-4"@/4"D$"O51J$#01"$#0"M%%10++/,-",H"P,L0-"/-"D+130.oV"/8$(/8$6,6AN(6C(0$+&$#6=6FN4("6,,$>&$'()EE%NE(;N(H$6#A(9#%+,:<O(\S(DS(9S" _G,1$#"?/7#.3-4"9/..+A"=0<)&"CDC6>"Q10++A"!aaZbA"!c`m!c!i"$#/+"Y5,$0"(3+";1,52#$"$,"LF"3$$0-$/,-";F"B/..01A"/8$(-$,:A:6=(6C(.=>:$=&(ME#%$,A"R`Z)"

Wh"C01L3-A""#$%&$'()*+%,A"!W)""Wc"I3.5L"I31L/7#30.A"U@03$#"3-4":0<53./$F"6L,-2"Q1/0+$+"_>0E/J

$/75+" R!bAV" ?,.H" ?0-4$,1HH" 3-4" ?,;01$" 6)" f52.01" _04+)b"/8$( 966<( 6C(3$Y:&:>+E4( "6FG6E:&:6=( %='( -$>$G&:6=" _T=:5%A" aWi" C,+$,-&" C1/..A" R``WbA"RR^)"

Page 19: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

!a"

$#3$" 3" %1/0+$" >%==6&" #3E0" 7,-$37$" (/$#" #/+" 4034" (/H0]+" 7,1%+0)"[13-$04A" $#0" /-$01%10$3$/,-",H">0E"R!&Z" /+" H1352#$" _/$" 7,-$3/-+"3-"0<%10++/,-"+,"0-/2L3$/7"$#3$"/$"/+"U+3/4"$,";0"$#0"L,+$"4/HH/J75.$p/-" $#0" 0-$/10" ;,,X" ,H" >0E/$/75+VbAWa" 3-4" $#5+" $#0",773+/,-3." 7,LL0-$3$,1" 3++5L0+" $#3$" $#/+" $0<$" 4,0+" -,$" ;031",-"$#0"/++50",H"3"%1/0+$]+"(/H0]+"7,1%+0"3-4"$#3$"#01"4034";,4F"L5+$A";F"/L%./73$/,-A";0"7,5-$04"3L,-2"$#0";,4/0+",H"(,L0-"H3L/.F"L0L;01+"(/$#"(#/7#" 3" %1/0+$" /+" 3..,(04" 7,-$37$)Z`" C5$"-,$04" /-$01%10$01+",H">0E/$/75+" +57#" 3+"C3157#">0E/-0"3-4" 83J7,;"B/.21,L"4/+32100AZ!"3125/-2"$#0"(/H0"/+"-,$"$,";0"/-7.5404"/-"$#0">0E"R!&!J^"./+$",H"%1/0+$.F"X/-)"

D-"@05$01,-,LF"$,,A"D"(,5.4"31250A"3"L3-]+"(/H0"73-";0"0<7.5404"H1,L"3" ./+$",H"3"#,5+0#,.4]+"(,L0-"(/$#"(#,L"$#3$"L3-"/+",$#01(/+0"75.$/73..F"3HH/./3$04"3-4"(/$#"(#,L"#0"0-2320+"/-" 75.$/7" 1/$53.A" 3-4" 0<7.5404" L,10" +%07/H/73..F" /-" @05$" !R&RJR^&!\A"$#0"7,1%5+",H"7,E0-3-$",;./23$/,-+",H"(#/7#"$#0"$0<$+"/-"@05$"!R&hA"!RA"3-4"!c"$#3$"(0"#3E0"+,"H31";00-"7,-+/401/-2"310"3"%31$)"I,-+/401"/-"$#/+"102314"@05$"!^&!!"3-4"!ZA"(#/7#A"5%,-"$#0",773+/,-",H"$#0"%/.21/L320"H0+$/E3.+",H"931E0+$A",1":#3E5 ,$A"3-4" $#0" D-23$#01/-2A" ,1" :5XX,$A" 7,L%0." $#0" %10+0-70" 3$"S3#J(0#]+" 8015+3.0L" $0L%.0",H"3-"0E0-" .31201"21,5%",H"#,5+0#,.4"L0L;01+" 3-4",$#01+" H1,L" $#3$"#,5+0#,.4]+" E/..320"%,%5.3$/,-"$#3-"4/4"@05$"!R&hA"!RA"3-4"!c&"UF,5V"# A"L3+75./-0"+/-25J.31bA" 3.,-2"(/$#" UF,51" dL3+75./-0" +/-25.31e" +,-" 3-4"4352#$01AV"UF,51" dL3+75./-0" +/-25.31e"L3-+01E3-$AV" UF,51" dL3+75./-0" +/-J25.31e"L3/4+01E3-$AV"3-4"$#0">0E/$0A"10+/40-$"3./0-A",1%#3-A"3-4"(/4,("(#,"310"/-"UF,51"dL3+75./-0"+/-25.31e"L/4+$V"3-4"U(/$#J/-" F,51" dL3+75./-0" +/-25.31e" 23$0+)V" P,L0-A" -,$0A" 310"10%10+0-$04"#010"0E0-"L,10"H5..F"$#3-"/-"@05$"!R&hA"!RA"3-4"!c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

I1/$/73." 0E/40-70" /-" +5%%,1$" ,H" $#/+"%,+/$/,-" 7,L0+" H1,L"0.+0(#010" /-" $#0" @05$01,-,L/+$/7" $134/$/,-A" /-" !" :3L50." !AZR"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Wa" D;/4)A" RR^A" 7/$/-2" ?0-r" Qr$01JI,-$0++0" 3-4" 8,#-" K../-2$,-A".(

/#%=E,%&6#_E(5%=';66<( 6=( 3$Y:&:>+E" _G0(" S,1X&"N-/$04" C/;.0" :,7/0$/0+A"!aa`bA"W!^)"

Z`" C,$#" I31L/7#30.A" U@03$#" 3-4" :0<53./$F" 6L,-2" Q1/0+$+AV" RR^A"3-4"837,;"B/.21,LA"3$Y:&:>+E(UVbQQ4(.(X$7(/#%=E,%&:6=(7:&8(M=&#6'+>&:6=(%='( "6FF$=&%#N( _6CA" W6i" G0(" S,1X&" @,5;.043FA" R```bA" !hacA" 7/$0"8,#-"K)"931$.0FA"3$Y:&:>+E"_PCIA"Zi"@3..3+&"P,14"C,,X+A"!aaRbA"WZh)"

Z!"C3157#">0E/-0A"3$Y:&:>+E4(/8$(/#%':&:6=%,(5$;#$7(/$[&(7:&8(&8$(X$7(B?D( /#%=E,%&:6=" _=#0" 8Q:" =,13#" I,LL0-$31Fi" Q#/.340.%#/3&" 80(/+#"Q5;./73$/,-":,7/0$FA"!acabA"!ZRi"B/.21,LO(3$Y:&:>+E(UVbQQA"!hac)"

ZR""6=&#%"#010"C135./XA"UP010"(,L0-A"$,,A"3..,(04"$,",HH01"+371/JH/70+"/-"D+130.oV"aW^A";5$"+00"$#0"+,L0(#3$"+/L/.31"H,1L5.3$/,-"$,"LF"%1,%,+3." $#3$" /+"31$/75.3$04" /-"B3F01"D)"[15;01A"UP,L0-"/-" $#0"I5.$"677,14/-2"$,"$#0"Q1/0+$.F"I,40AV"B3F01"D)"[15;01"_04)b"/8$(P6&8$#866'(

Page 20: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

R`"

(#010"93--3#"3;+0-$+"#01+0.H" H1,L"(#3$"D"(,5.4"5-401+$3-4"$," ;0" $#0" 3--53." D-23$#01/-2':5XX,$" %/.21/L320" ,H" K.Y3-3#]+"H3L/.F" $," :#/.,#" H1,L" $#0" $/L0" ,H" #01" 2/E/-2" ;/1$#" $," :3L50."5-$/."$#0"%,/-$"3$"(#/7#":3L50."(3+"(03-04"_!":3L"!&R`JRWbAZW"3"%1,70++"$#3$"L3F"#3E0"$3X0-"3+".,-2"3+"$#100"F031+"_3+"/+"+52J20+$04A"H,1"0<3L%.0A"/-"R"B377"h&Rhb)ZZ"G,$0"3+"(0.."@05$"W!&!RA"(#010"B,+0+"7,LL3-4+"$#3$"0E01F"+0E0-$#"F031A"3$"$#0"H0+$/E3.",H"D-23$#01/-2':5XX,$A"3..",H"D+130.]+"L0-A"(,L0-A"3-4"7#/.410-"_ ! ! bA"3+"(0.."3+"$#0"10+/40-$"3./0-+"(#,"10+/40"3L,-2" $#0LA"L5+$"23$#01" /-" 8015+3.0L" $,"#031" $#0" 1034/-2",H"$#0"@05$01,-,L/7"&f#g)"9010A"3$"$#/+"+%07/3."+0%$0--/3."70.0;13J$/,-A"@05$01,-,LF]+"35$#,1_+b"+00L_+b"$,"0<%3-4"$#0"L3-43$0"$," 3++0L;.0" ;0F,-4" (#3$" (3+" 31$/75.3$04" H,1" D-23$#01J/-2':5XX,$" /-" !^&!Z" /-" ,1401" $," /-7.540" 3.." (,L0-" 3-4" 3.."7#/.410-A"F,5-2"$,44.01+"_ b"3+"(0.."3+",.401"+,-+"3-4"4352#J$01+)Z\":$/..A"$#0"5+0",H"$#/+".3-25320"/-"@05$"W!&!R"6=,N"+5220+$+"$#3$" 451/-2",$#01" :5XX,$" 70.0;13$/,-+A" $#0" $,44.01+A" 3+"(0.." 3+"$#0" L,$#01+" (#," $,,X" 7310" ,H" $#0L" _$#3$" /+A" $#0" #034J,HJ#,5+0#,.4+]"(/E0+bA"(010"-,$"10Y5/104"$,"*,/-"$#0"%3$01H3L/./3+"3-4",$#01+",H"#/+" 0-$,51320" /-" 8015+3.0L)"I,-E01+0.FA"(,L0-"(#,"73--,$"%,++/;.F";0"7,-+$13/-04";F"7#/.41031/-2"10+%,-+/;/.J/$/0+jH,1" 0<3L%.0A" 3" #,5+0#,.4]+" 3+" F0$" 5-L311/04" 4352#$01+"3-4"3"7,LL5-/$F]+"(/4,(+j4,"+00L"7,L%0..04"$,"3$$0-4"$#0"70.0;13$/,-" ,H" D-23$#01/-2':5XX,$" 3--53..F" _-,$0" #010" $#0"+00L/-2"%10+0-70",H"Q0-/--3#]+"4352#$01+" 3$" $#0":5XX,$"70.0J

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""6C(H6'( %='(\&8$#( D&+':$E" _:,5$#"O.,1/43" :$54/0+" /-" $#0"9/+$,1F" ,H" 85J43/+LA" \hi"6$.3-$3&" :7#,.31+" Q10++A" !aaRbA" \!m\RA" -)" \A" 3-4" /-" /40LA"UC103+$JO004/-2" Q137$/70+" /-" C/;./73." D+130." 3-4" /-" M.4" C3;F.,-/3-"B0+,%,$3L/3AV"3.+,"/-"/8$(P6&8$#866'(6C(H6'(%='(\&8$#(D&+':$EA"h^)"

ZW" D" #3E0" 312504" H,1" $#0" /40-$/H/73$/,-" ,H" D-23$#01/-2':5XX,$" 3+"$#0",773+/,-",H"K.Y3-3#]+"H3L/.F"3--53."%/.21/L320"$,":#/.,#"/-":5+3-"67X01L3-A"Z%##:6#O(0%=>$#O(D$'+>&#$EEO(1+$$=4(Z6F$=(:=(B+'A$E(%='(9:;,:>%,(ME#%$,"_G0("S,1X&"@,5;.043FA"!aacbA"!!WA"R\c)"

ZZ":00"3.+,A"3L,-2"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$01-"+,5170+A"!":3L"!&RZ" _3+"/-$01%10$04" ;F" 8,+0%#" C.0-X/-+,%%A" U=#0" O3L/.F" /-" O/1+$" =0L%.0"D+130.AV"/-"^%F:,:$E(:=(.=>:$=&(ME#%$,"d=#0"O3L/.FA"?0./2/,-A"3-4"I5.$510i">,5/+E/..0&"P0+$L/-+$01" 8,#-"f-,<A"!aaheA"-)"ZR",-"%)"ahA"3-4"[01J#314" QH0/H01A" UK-$(s#-5-2" 5-4" K-$(s#-5-2+H0+$" /L" 6.$0-"=0+$3L0-$&"401":7#.t++0."g5"80+3*3"RcA"hm!WoV"I.Z"cZ"d!ahReA"WZRbi"D+3"h&!\"3-4"Rc&am!`"_3+"/-$01%10$04";F"C.0-X/-+,%%A"U=#0"O3L/.F"/-"O/1+$"=0L%.0"D+130.AV"^ci"[15;01A"UP,L0-"/-"$#0"I5.$AV"^hm^cA"-)"Z`i"/40LA" UC103+$JO004/-2" Q137$/70+" /-" C/;./73." D+130.AV" hamc`i" ?3%#30."Q3$3/A" ^%F:,NO( 36Y$( %='( &8$( 9:;,$" d>,-4,-&" B37[/;;,-kf00A" !a^`eA"!hZi"3-4"QH0/H01A"UK-$(s#-5-2"5-4"K-$(s#-5-2+H0+$"/L"6.$0-"=0+J$3L0-$AV"WZZmWZhbi"Q+"c&W"_3+"/-$01%10$04";F"[15;01A"UC103+$JO004/-2"Q137$/70+" /-" C/;./73." D+130.AV" c`A" 3-4" Q3$3/A"^%F:,NO( 36Y$( %='( &8$( 9:;,$A"!hZbi" 8,+0%#5+A" .A%:=E&( .G:6=A" DDA" !aA" 3-4" .=&:*+:&:$E" DDA" /<A" ^" _3+"%,/-$04" ,5$" ;F" B0-3#0L" 9313-A" UKg0X/0.A" QA" 3-4" $#0" Q1/0+$.F":7#,,.AV"L/"\c"dR``ceA"R!Zbi"3-4"8,#-"6)"P/.+,-A"UK2F%$/3-"D-+$157J$/,-+&" =#0" D-+$157$/,-" ,H" 6-/AV" /-" .X)/" _W4" 04)i" Q1/-70$,-&"Q1/-70$,-"N-/E)" Q10++A" !a^abA" ZR`" _323/-A" 3+" %,/-$04" ,5$" ;F"9313-A"UKg0X/0.A"QA"3-4"$#0"Q1/0+$.F":7#,,.AV"R!Zb)"

Z\"=#/+"5-401+$3-4/-2",H" "/+"51204";F"[15;01A"UP,L0-"/-"$#0"I5.$AV"\W"3-4"-)"^",-"$#3$"%320)"

Page 21: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

R!"

;13$/,-"3$":#/.,#"377,14/-2"$,"!":3L"!&ZbAZ^"3-4"310"7,L%0..04"$," 3$$0-4" 3+" (0.." $#0" 70.0;13$/,-" ,H" 931E0+$':#3E5 ,$)" :.3E0"(,L0-A" ./X0(/+0A" 310" 7,L%0..04" $," 3$$0-4A" %01#3%+" ;0735+0"@05$01,-,LFA"5-./X0" $#0" +.3E0" .3(" /-"K<,4"R!&!J!!A"4,0+"-,$"7,-+/401"$#0"%,++/;/./$F",H"$#0+0"(,L0-]+"L311F/-2"3-4"#3E/-2"7#/.410-o"M1"%01#3%+";0735+0"3"+.3E0"(,L3-]+"7#/.410-"310"-,$",H" 0-,52#"(,1$#" /-"@05$01,-,L/+$/7" $134/$/,-" $,"L01/$" 2/E/-2"$#0/1"7310$3X01+"+%07/3."7,-+/4013$/,-+"3$" $/L0+",H"75.$/7" H0+$/EJ3.+o"

6$"3-F"13$0A"@05$"!^&!!"3-4"!ZA"3+"D"(,5.4"/-$01%10$A"0-E/J+/,-" 3" +70-31/," (#010;F" #,5+0#,.401+]" (/E0+" (#," 310"0-75L;0104";F"7#/.41031/-2"10+%,-+/;/./$/0+"-004"-,$"L3X0"$#0"3--53."%/.21/L320+",H":#3E5 ,$"3-4":5XX,$"$#3$"@05$01,-,LF"10Y5/10+" ,H" ,$#01" L0L;01+" ,H" $#0" D+130./$0" 7,LL5-/$F)" =#0"L3+75./-0"+/-25.31"UF,5V",H"$#0+0"%3++320+"$#5+"10H01+A"3+"4,0+"$#0"L3+75./-0"+/-25.31"UF,5V"/-"@05$"!R&!c"3-4"$#0"L3+75./-0"%.513."UF,5V"H,1L+"/-"@05$"!R&h"3-4"!R"5-401"$#0"$01L+",H"$#/+"3-3.F+/+A",-.F"$,"D+130./$0"L3.0"#034+",H"#,5+0#,.4+)"

6-4"(#3$",H"@05$01,-,LF]+"/-*5-7$/,-+"102314/-2"$#0"3-J-53." Q0+3 " %/.21/L320" 3+" H,5-4" /-" @05$" !^&!Jho" N-./X0"@05$01,-,LF]+"L3-43$0" /-" $#0" .31201" 75.$/7" 73.0-431" ,H"@05$"!^&!J!h",H"(#/7#"@05$"!^&!Jh"/+"3"%31$A"(#010"$#0"%31$/7/%3$/,-",H"3$".03+$"+,L0"(,L0-"/+"10Y5/104"/-"$#0"$(,"2103$"%/.21/L320"H03+$+",H"931E0+$':#3E5 ,$"3-4"D-23$#01/-2':5XX,$"_!^&!!A"!ZbA"(,L0-"310"-,(#010"L0-$/,-04"/-"$#0"@05$"!^&!Jh"%3++320"$#3$"40$3/.+" $#0"70.0;13$/,-",H" $#0" H03+$",H"Q0+3 "3-4" $#0-A" /-"!^&cA"B3 ,$)" Q01#3%+" (0" +#,5.4" 0<%.3/-" ;F" $3X/-2" $#/+" E31/3$/,-"(/$#/-"@05$01,-,LF]+"75.$/7"73.0-431"3+",-.F"3"7,/-7/40-70"3-4"$#5+"3++5L0"$#3$"@05$01,-,LF]+"35$#,1_+b"L03-$"$,"/-7.540"3$".03+$"+,L0"(,L0-"/-"$#0"7,LL5-/$F"$#3$"23$#0104"3--53..F"3$"$#0" 8015+3.0L" $0L%.0" H,1" $#0"Q0+3 " +371/H/70A" 3+" /$" /-7.5404" 3$".03+$"+,L0"(,L0-"/-"$#0"%/.21/L320"7,LL5-/$/0+",H"931E0+$'":#3E5 ,$" 3-4" D-23$#01/-2':5XX,$)" DH" $#/+" (010" $#0" 73+0A" $#0-"$#0" +07,-4J%01+,-"L3+75./-0" +/-25.31" H,1L+" 5+04" $," 40+71/;0"$#0"Q0+3 ",HH01/-2" /-"@05$"!^&!Jh"(,5.4A" 3+"C01L3-"#3+" /-$/JL3$04"3-4"C135./XA"3L,-2",$#01"7,LL0-$3$,1+A"#3+"H,170H5..F"L3/-$3/-04A"U34410++"(,L0-"3+"(0.."3+"L0-)VZh"KE/40-70"H1,L"$#0"G0("=0+$3L0-$"L/2#$" .0-4" +5%%,1$" $," $#/+" /-$01%10$3$/,-A"2/E0-"$#3$"(,L0-"310"+3/4"$,"#3E0"$13E0.04"(/$#"80+5+"H1,L"$#0"[3./.00"(#0-"#0" 73L0" $," 8015+3.0L" $," 70.0;13$0"Q0+3 " 451/-2"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Z^"=#0"4352#$01+"310"3"%31$",H"K.Y3-3#]+"H3L/.F]+"%31$F"377,14/-2"

$,"E"Z",H"$#0"B=A";5$"310"-,$"L0-$/,-04"/-"$#0">uu)"Q)"fF.0"B7I31J$01A"M(D%F+$,4(.(X$7(/#%=E,%&:6=(7:&8(M=&#6'+>&:6=(%='("6FF$=&%#N"_6CA"ci"[3140-" I/$FA" G)S)&" @,5;.043FA" !ac`bA" \!A" +5220+$+" $#0" [100X" %10J+01E0+" $#0";0$$01" 1034/-2"#010" _L03-/-2" $#3$" $#0"4352#$01+"(010"-,$",1/2/-3..F"/-7.5404"/-"$#0":3L50."377,5-$bA";5$"?3.%#"P)"f.0/-]+"-,$0",-"!":3L"!&Z"13/+0+"$#0"%,++/;/./$F"$#3$"$#0":0%$532/-$]+".37X",H"10H01J0-70" $," $#0" U4352#$01+V" 10+5.$+" H1,L" 3" 40./;013$0" ,L/++/,-A"U10%10+0-$d/-2e" 3" 7,1107$/,-" ;F" +,L0,-0" (#," H0.$" 4352#$01+"(,5.4'+#,5.4"-,$"%31$/7/%3$0" /-" $#0"+371/H/70+)V" _U(D%F+$," dPCIA"!`i"P37,A"=0<)&"P,14"C,,X+A"!acWeA"R)b"

Zh" C135./XA" U=#0" ?0*07$/,-" ,H" $#0" [,440++" 6+#013#" /-" D+130.AV"!c`m!c!)"

Page 22: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

RR"

(#3$";073L0"$#0".3+$"(00X",H"#/+"./H0"_B3$$"Rh&\\i"B31X"!\&Z`JZ!i">5X0"RW&ZaA"\\b)"

:$/..A".0$"5+"5+0"$#0+0"G0("=0+$3L0-$"L3$01/3.+"$,"7,-+/401",-70" 323/-"LF"%1,%,+3." $#3$" D+130./$0"(/E0+"L3F" #3E0"-00404"5%,-" ,773+/,-" $," 3;+0-$" $#0L+0.E0+" H1,L" $#0" +371/H/7/3." *,51J-0F+" $," 8015+3.0L" $#3$" @05$01,-,LF" L3-43$0+" H,1" ,$#01"(,L0-" H1,L"3L,-2"$#0/1" H3L/./0+" 3-4" $#0/1" H3L/./0+]" 3HH/./3$0+";0735+0" ,H" $#0" ,;./23$/,-+" ,H" 7#/.41031/-2" 3-4" 7#/.47310" $#0+0"(/E0+"#34" 3$"#,L0)"=,";0" +510A" D"L5+$" Y5/7X.F" 213-$" $#3$" $#0"G0("=0+$3L0-$"$0<$+"310"+/2-/H/73-$.F".3$01"/-"43$0"$#3-"310"$#0"%100</./7"$0<$+",H"@05$01,-,LF"$#3$"310"$#0"H,75+",H"LF"4/+75+J+/,-"#010A"3-4"D"L5+$"213-$"3+"(0.." $#3$"$#0+0"G0("=0+$3L0-$"$134/$/,-+" 310A" 2/E0-" $#0/1" 7,-$0<$"(/$#/-" $#0" 2,+%0."-3113$/E0+",H"I#1/+$/3-"+3.E3$/,-A"3$F%/73."/-"$01L+",H"$#0"Q0+3 ",;+01E3-70"$#3$"$#0F"%10+0-$)"G0E01$#0.0++A"/$"/+"+$1/X/-2"$#3$A"(#/.0"(,L0-"4,"7,L0"(/$#"80+5+"3+"#0"L3X0+"$#0"Q0+3 "%/.21/L320A"$#0+0"310",H$0-"(,L0-"(#,"310"/40-$/H/04"(/$#,5$"10H010-70"$,"3-F"H3L/J.F" $/0+" _L03-/-2" $#3$" $#0F" 310" +00L/-2.F" (/$#,5$" H3L/.F",;./23$/,-+b&" H,1" 0<3L%.0A"B31F"B3243.0-0" _B3$$" Rh&\\i"B31X"!\&Z`b"3-4":3.,L0"_B31X"!\&Z`b)"M$#01"(,L0-"(#,"*,/-"80+5+"310"$#,+0"(#,+0"7#/.410-"310"21,(-"3-4"+,"4,"-,$"10Y5/10"$#0/1"L,$#01]+" 7310&" H,1" 0<3L%.0A" B31FA" $#0" L,$#01" ,H" 83L0+" 3-4"8,+0+'8,+0%#"_B3$$"Rh&\\i"B31X"!\&Z`b"3-4" $#0"L,$#01",H" $#0"+,-+",H"l0;0400"_B3$$"Rh&\\b)"I,-E01+0.FA"7,5.4"(0";0"+,";,.4"$,"+5220+$"$#3$A"(#/.0"$#0"%1/L31F"103+,-"$#3$"80+5+]"L,$#01"(3+"-,$" /-" #/+" 0-$,51320" #34" $," 4," _H1,L" $#0" +F-,%$/7" 2,+%0.+]"%01+%07$/E0b"(/$#" +$13/-04" H3L/.F" 10.3$/,-+#/%+" _B3$$" !R&Z^J\`A"!W&\ZJ\ci" B31X" W&W!JW\i" >5X0" c&!aJR!i" !!&RhJRcbA" $#0" L,$#01"L3F"3.+,"#3E0";00-"7,L%0..04"$,"10L3/-";0#/-4"/-"$#0"[3./.00"13$#01" $#3-" 5-401$3X/-2" %/.21/L320" $," 8015+3.0L" /-" ,1401" $#3$"+#0"L/2#$"7310"H,1"$#0";1,,4",H"80+5+]";1,$#01+"$#3$A"377,14/-2"$,"B3$$"!R&Z^JZhi"B31X"W&W!JWRi"3-4">5X0"c&!aJR`A"$13/.04"3;,5$"$#0"E/7/-/$F",H"G3g310$#"(/$#"#01o"

G004.0++" $," +3FA" $#/+" .3+$" Y50+$/,-" 0-$3/.+" 3" +/2-/H/73-$"1037#)" S0$" D" +$/.." L3/-$3/-" $#3$" $#0" .31201" %,/-$" D" 3L" 3125/-2"#,.4+&" (,L0-" 310" -,$" -070++31/.F" %10+0-$" /-" $#0" Q0+3 " 1/$53."377,5-$",H"@05$"!^&!Jh"/-"$#0"(3F+"(0"L/2#$"$#/-X"$#0F"+#,5.4";0A"3-4",-0"%.35+/;.0"103+,-"H,1"$#0/1"3;+0-70"/+"$#3$"7#/.47310"45$/0+"X00%"$#0L"3$"#,L0)"D"+$10++"#010A"#,(0E01A"U6=$"%.35+/;.0"103+,-AV" H,1" 3+"(0"#3E0" +00-A"@05$" !^&!JhA" 5-./X0"@05$" !^&!!"3-4"!ZA"L3X0+"-,"L0-$/,-",H" 3-F"(,L3-]+"%31$/7/%3$/,-j-,"4352#$01+A" L3/4+01E3-$+A" -,1" (/4,(+j/-" Q0+3 " ,;+01E3-70)"Q01#3%+"$#/+"+5220+$+"$#3$A"(#/.0"7#/.47310"10+%,-+/;/./$/0+"L3F"#3E0" 7,-+$13/-04" $#0" %10+0-70" ,H" 3" L3.0" #,5+0#,.401]+" (/H0"451/-2"3-F",H" $#0"$#100"2103$"%/.21/L320+",H" $#0"D+130./$0" 1/$53."73.0-431" _Q0+3 A" :#3E5 ,$A" 3-4" :5XX,$bA" $#010" L3F" ;0" +,L0"H37$,1"4/+$/-7$/E0"$,"Q0+3 ",;+01E3-70"$#3$A"/-"$#0"L/-4",H"@05J$01,-,LF]+" 35$#,1_+bA" 7,-+$13/-04" $#0"%10+0-70",H"(,L0-"+$/.."L,10" 3$" $#3$" 70.0;13$/,-)" B/.21,Lj-,$/-2" $#3$" @05$" !^&!Jh"3.+,"L3X0+"-,"L0-$/,-",H" $#0"+,-+A"L3.0"+.3E0+A">0E/$0+A" 10+/J40-$" 3./0-+A" 3-4" ,1%#3-+" (#," (010A" #,(0E01A" /-7.5404" /-"@05$01,-,LF]+" ./+$" ,H" :#3E5 ,$" 3-4" :5XX,$" %31$/7/%3-$+j+5220+$+"$#0"103+,-"/+"%132L3$/7&"$#3$"451/-2"$#0";5+F"+03+,-",H"

Page 23: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

RW"

$#0" +%1/-2" #31E0+$A" L,+$" ,H" 3" #,5+0#,.4]+" L0L;01+" (010"-00404"3$"#,L0"3-4"$#5+"3.L,+$"-,-0"3L,-2"3"H3L/.F"3-4"/$+"3++,7/3$0+" 7,5.4" %5.." 5%" +$3X0+" $," $13E0." _3+" @05$01,-,LF"(,5.4"#3E0"/$b"$,"8015+3.0L",-"%/.21/L320)Zc"D-4004A"377,14/-2"$,"@05$"!^&hA"0E0-"$#0"L3.0"#034+",H"#,5+0#,.4"(#,"4/4A"5-401"$#0" $01L+",H" $#/+" /-$01%10$3$/,-A" *,51-0F" $," 8015+3.0L" $,"L3X0"$#0" Q0+3 " +371/H/70" 310" $," 10$51-" 3.L,+$" /LL04/3$0.F" $," $#0/1"#,L0+" $," ,;+01E0" $#0" H,..,(/-2" +/<" 43F+" ,H"B3 ,$" 3-4A" %10J+5L3;.FA" $," *,/-" /-" $#0" (,1X" ,H" $#0" +%1/-2" #31E0+$)Za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h&" /$" -0/$#01" U34410++0+" (,L0-" 3+" (0.." 3+" L0-AV\`"-,1A" /-" H37$A" 4,0+" /$" 34410++"L,+$"L0-)"?3$#01A" $#0"L3+75./-0"+/-25.31"UF,5V",H"@05$"!^&!Jh"323/-"34410++0+A"3+" /-" $#0",$#01"0<3L%.0+A"+/-25.31"3-4"%.513.A"$#3$"(0"#3E0"0<3L/-04A",-.F"L3.0"#034+",H"#,5+0#,.4)"6-4"(#/.0"$#/+"/+"-,$"$,"+3F"$#3$"(0"+#,5.4"7,-7.540" $#3$" $#010" 310" -," ;/;./73." $0<$+" (#010" $#0" 7,..07$/E0"UF,5V"34410++0+"UL0-"3-4"(,L0-p/-"0Y53."H3+#/,-AV\!"/$"/+"$,"L3X0"7.031"$#3$"0<3L%.0+",H"$#/+"%#0-,L0-,-"310"-,$"+,"03+F"$,"H/-4"3+"+,L0"#3E0"3++5L04"3-4"/-4004"310A" /-"LF"L/-4A"3+"F0$"5-4,75L0-$04)"

>0$"L0"$51-"-,("$,"$#0"+07,-4"L3$$01"$#3$"D"-,$04"3;,E0"/$"(3+"LF"/-$0-$/,-"$,"7,-+/401"/-"$#0+0"10L31X+&"$#0"5+0",H"$#0"%3134/2L",H"L311/320"$#3$"/+"0E,X04A"0+%07/3..F"/-"$#0"%1,%#0$/7"$0<$+",H"9,+03A"D+3/3#A"8010L/3#A"3-4"Kg0X/0.A"$,"40+71/;0"[,4]+"10.3$/,-+#/%"(/$#" $#0" %0,%.0" ,H" D+130.)"C01L3-A" 3+" D" #3E0" 3.+,"-,$04"3;,E0A"+00L+"$,"H/-4"L57#"$#3$"/+"%,+/$/E0"/-"$#0"5+0",H"$#/+"%3134/2Li"3+"323/-"D"#3E0"3.1034F"-,$04A"#0"+%03X+",H"L31J1/320"3+"0E,X04"/-"$#0"%3134/2L"3+"U3"10.3$/,-+#/%",H"L5$53./$FV"3-4"H51$#01"(1/$0+",H"$#0"(3F+"/-"(#/7#"U.,E0V"UL3F";0"5-401+J$,,4" 3+" d3-e" 0<%10++/,-" ,H" $#0" L311/320" %3134/2LAV" U/-" $#0"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

Zc" 837,;"B/.21,LA"3$Y:&:>+E(QTbQV4(.(X$7(/#%=E,%&:6=(7:&8( M=&#6'+>@&:6=( %='( "6FF$=&%#N" _6CA" WCi" G0(" S,1X&" @,5;.043FA" R```bA" !ac`A"R```mR``!)"

Za"=#/+" /-$01%10$3$/,-",H"@05$01,-,LF]+"H0+$3."73.0-431" /-"!^&!mc"_,-0"43F" /-"8015+3.0LA"(/$#"$#0"-0<$"+/<"43F+" /-",-0]+"H3L/.F"#,L0+J$034b"#3+"L,+$" 1070-$.F"3-4"%01#3%+"L,+$" H,170H5..F";00-"312504";F"C01-314"B)">0E/-+,-A"0$+&$#6=6FN(%='( &8$(5$#F$=$+&:>E( 6C(3$A%,( M==6Y%@&:6="_G0("S,1X&"M<H,14"N-/E)"Q10++A"!aahbA"\Wm\^A"^aA"hRA"hamc`A"cai"7H)A" #,(0E01A" $#0" 0E0-"L,10" 1070-$" 3-4" H,170H5." 71/$/Y50" ,HH0104" ;F":#/L,-"C31JM-A"U@01"405$01,-,L/+7#0"O0+$X3.0-431AV"[0,12"C135J./X"_04)bA"0%E(0$+&$#6=6F:+F"_MC:A"RWi"O13-XH51$"3L"B3/-&"Q0$01">3-2A"R``WbA"\hm^ci" $#/+"10H010-70"(3+";1,52#$" $,"LF"3$$0-$/,-";F":/L0,-"I#3E0.A"U=#0":07,-4"Q3++,E01A"Q/.21/L320A"3-4"$#0"I0-$13./g04"I5.$AV"5/-"!`R"_R``abA"!hA"-)"hR)"

\`" C135./XA" U=#0" ?0*07$/,-" ,H" $#0" [,440++" 6+#013#" /-" D+130.AV"!c`m!c!)"

\!"C01L3-A""#$%&$'()*+%,A"!W)""

Page 24: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

RZ"

+0-+0" ,H" 3" H3/$#H5.A" /-$/L3$0" 10.3$/,-+#/%" ;0$(00-" L3-" 3-4"(/H0)V\R" B311/320" #0" ./X0(/+0" 40+71/;0+" 3+" 3-" /-+$/$5$/,-" /-"(#/7#" U#,-,1"(3+" 3" E3.50" 107/%1,73..F";0+$,(04";F" 037#"%31J$F)V\W"

D"3L"-,$"+,"+510A"#,(0E01A"$#3$"$#0"+0-+/;/./$/0+",H"U.,E0V"3-4"U#,-,1V"$#3$"C01L3-"0E,X0+"102314/-2"$#0"L311/320"%313J4/2L"103..F"40H/-0"D+130./$0"7,-70%$/,-+",H"L31/$3."10.3$/,-+#/%+)"O,1" 0<3L%.0A" 102314/-2" #,-,1&" /-"(#3$"L5+$" ;0" $3X0-" 3L,-2"+$540-$+" ,H" $#0" G031" K3+$" 3+" 3" H,5-43$/,-3." +$54F" ,H" #,-J,1'+#3L0"75.$510+"/-"$#0";/;./73."(,1.4A"$#0"!ach"04/$04"E,.5L0"56=6#(%='(D8%F$(%='(&8$(2=:&N(6C(&8$(P$':&$##%=$%=A"I31,."@0.3-0F"H,170H5..F" 31250+" $#3$" $#0" 73$02,1/0+" ,H" #,-,1" 3-4" +#3L0A" 3$".03+$" /-"$#0"%3$1/317#3."75.$510",H"$#0"6-3$,./3-"=51X+"$#3$"+#0"+$54/04A" 310" 20-40104"(/$#/-"L311/320)" K+%07/3..F" $#1,52#" $#0"37$",H";020$$/-2"7#/.410-A"#,-,1"/+";0+$,(04"5%,-"L0-";0735+0"$#0F"310" +00-" $,";0" $#0"7311/01+",H" $#0"U+004V"H1,L"(#/7#" $#0"7#/.4" /+"7103$04i"(,L0-A"7,-E01+0.FA"%1,E/40",-.F" $#0"L04/5L"/-"(#/7#"3"7#/.4"73-"21,(A"./X0"3"H/0.4A"3-4"310"$#5+"H5-43L0-J$3..F" +#3L04" ;F" U107,2-/$/,-" ,H" $#0/1" 7,-+$/$5$/,-3."/-H01/,1/$F)V\Z"P#0$#01"$#/+"%107/+0"-,$/,-",H"#,-,1J+#3L0"#0.4"/-"L31/$3."10.3$/,-+";/;./73."D+130."/+A",H"7,51+0A"-,$"-070++31/.F"3"2/E0-i" /-4004A" 377,14/-2" $," 3-7/0-$" D+130.]+" 5-401+$3-4/-2" ,H"20-401"L,10"20-013..FA" U/$" /+"-,$" $#0"73+0" $#3$"#,-,1" /+" 0<7.5J+/E0.F" 3++,7/3$04"(/$#" $#0"L3.0" 3-4" +#3L0"(/$#" $#0" H0L3.0)V\\"G0E01$#0.0++A"(,L0-"310"$F%/73..F"0<%07$04"$,"0<$0-4"#,-,1"$,"$#0/1"#5+;3-4+"_K+$#"!&R`bA\^"(#0103+"3"L3*,1"L03-+";F"(#/7#"3" L3-" 73-" ;0" +#3L04" /-" D+130./$0" $134/$/,-" /+" H,1" #/L" $," ;0"$103$04"3+"3"(,L3-)\h"=#3$"(,L0-"3-4"L0-"L/2#$"107/%1,73..F";0+$,(" #,-,1" 5%,-" ,-0" 3-,$#01" (/$#/-" 3-" D+130./$0" L311/320"$#010H,10"+$1/X0+"L0"3+"5-./X0.Fi"13$#01A"$#0"4F-3L/7",H"D+130./$0"L311/320"D"(,5.4"%,+/$" /+" $#3$"3"#5+;3-4" /+"3+71/;04"#,-,1";F"E/1$50",H"#/+"L3-./-0++A"#/+"L3+75./-/$FA"3-4"#/+"3;/./$F" $,"%1,JE/40"07,-,L/73..F"H,1"#/+"H3L/.FA"F0$"#0"L5+$"7,-+$3-$.F"25314"#/L+0.H"3-4"#/+"3771504"#,-,1"323/-+$"$#0"+#3L0"#/+"(/H0"L/2#$";1/-2"H,1(314j3-4"0+%07/3..F"L5+$"25314"323/-+$"+57#"+#3L/-2";F"0<01$/-2"7,-$1,.",E01"#/+"(/H0]+"+0<53./$F)\c"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

\R"D;/4)A"Z\A"Z^)"""\W"D;/4)A"ZZ)""\Z"I31,."@0.3-0FA" U:004+",H"9,-,1A"O/0.4+",H":#3L0AV"@3E/4"@)"

[/.L,10"_04)b"56=6#(%='(D8%F$(%='(&8$(2=:&N(6C(&8$(P$':&$##%=$%="_P3+#J/-2$,-A"@)I)&"=#0"6L01/73-"6-$#1,%,.,2/73."6++,7/3$/,-A"!achbA"Z`)"

\\"[3.0"6)"S00A"?66#(9%=:E8$'("8:,'#$=(6C()Y$4(Z6F%=(%E()Y:,( :=( &8$(5$;#$7(9:;,$"_B/--03%,./+&"O,1$10++A"R``WbA"ZR)"

\^" =#/+" 10H010-70" ;1,52#$" $,"LF" 3$$0-$/,-" ;F" S00A" ?66#( 9%=:E8$'("8:,'#$=(6C()Y$A"ZR"3-4"-)"h^",-"%)"!ha)"

\h"IF-$#/3"?)"I#3%L3-A"/8$(H$='$#$'(3%=A+%A$(6C(Z%#C%#$(:=(&8$(ME#%$@,:&[email protected]#:%=( )=>6+=&$#" _9:BA" ^Ri" P/-,-3" >3X0A" D-4)&" K/+0-;135-+A"R``ZbA"R`A"Zcm\ci"=)"B)">0L,+A"U:#3L0"3-4"B5$/.3$/,-",H"K-0L/0+"/-"$#0"90;10("C/;.0AV"B93"!R\"_R``^bA"RWRmRW^i"f0-":$,-0A"D$[O(56=6#O(%='(?67$#(:=(&8$(0$+&$#6=6F:E&:>(5:E&6#N"_8:M=:5%A"RWZi":#0HH/0.4&":#0HJH/0.4"67340L/7"Q10++A"!aa^bA"!RRm!RW)"

\c"f0-":$,-0A"U[0-401"3-4"9,L,+0<53./$F"/-"85420+"!a&":5;*07$J9,-,1A"M;*07$J:#3L0oV"BD\/"^h"_!aa\bA"a\i"S00A"?66#(9%=:E8$'("8:,'@#$=(6C()Y$A"Z^A"Zh)"

Page 25: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

R\"

B31/$3."U.,E0AV"/$"$51-+",5$A"3.+,"73--,$";0"+3/4"$,";0"107/J%1,73..F",1"0Y5/$3;.F"7,-+$1504"/-"$#0"C/;.0A"2/E0-"$#3$"$#010"310"-,"37$53."L311/320+"/-"$#0"C/;.0"(#010"(,L0-"0<%10++"U.,E0)V\a"=#5+A"(#/.0" D+337" /+" +3/4" $,"#3E0" .,E04"?0;0X3#" _[0-"RZ&^hbi"837,;" $,"#3E0" .,E04"?37#0." _[0-"Ra&!cA" R`A" W`b" 3-4"%,++/;.FA"3.;0/$"$,"3".0++01"402100A"$,"#3E0".,E04">03#"_[0-"Ra&W`bi":3LJ+,-" $," #3E0" .,E04" @0./.3#" _8542" !^&ZA" !\bi" K.Y3-3#" $," #3E0".,E04"93--3#" _!" :3L"!&\bi" :,.,L,-" $," #3E0" .,E04" #/+"L3-F"H,10/2-" (/E0+" _!" f2+" !!&!A" Rbi" ?0#,;,3L" $," #3E0" .,E04"B3 373#" _R" I#1" !!&R!bi" 3-4" 6#3+5015+" $," #3E0" .,E04" K+$#01"_K+$#"R&!hbA" -,-0",H" $#0+0"(,L0-" /+" 0E01"40+71/;04" 3+" 2/E/-2"#01"+0<53."%31$-01"#01".,E0"/-"10$51-)"G,1A"(/$#",-.F",-0"0<70%J$/,-A" /+"%=N"(,L3-" /-"$#0"C/;.0]+"-3113$/E0"7,1%5+"0E01"+3/4" $,".,E0"3"L3-)"=#0"0<70%$/,-"/+"H,5-4"/-"!":3L50."!cA"(#010"B/J7#3." /+" $(/70" +3/4" $," .,E0" @3E/4" _EE" R`" 3-4" Rcb)" S0$" $#/+"0<70%$/,-"(,5.4";0A" /H"D"L3F"H,..,(",$#01+" /-"L/+5+/-2"3-",H$"L/+5+04"7./7#r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

:,"4,0+"9,+03]+A"D+3/3#]+A"8010L/3#]+A"3-4"Kg0X/0.]+"5+0",H"$#0"L311/320"L0$3%#,1"$,"40+71/;0"$#0"10.3$/,-+#/%",H"S3#(0#"3-4"D+130."103..F"/L%.F"$#0"U107/%1,7/$FV"3-4"U/-$/L37FV",H"$#3$"0-7,5-$01" $#3$" C01L3-" H/-4+o" D" 4,5;$" /$)" D" 4,5;$" /$" H51$#01A"L,10,E01A" 2/E0-" $#0" +%07/H/7" (3F" $#0" L0$3%#,1" /+" ,E01(#0.JL/-2.F" 40%.,F04" /-" 9,+03A" D+3/3#A" 8010L/3#A" 3-4" Kg0X/0.&" $,"40+71/;0" D+130." 3+" $#0" 5-H3/$#H5." (/H0" (#," #3+" +$13F04" H1,L"(#3$"+#,5.4";0"#01"L,-,23L,5+"10.3$/,-+#/%"(/$#"S3#(0#"$,"2," 3H$01" ,$#01" U.,E01+AV" /)0)A" 2,4+" _10%10+0-$3$/E0" $0<$+" /-7.540"D+3"!&R!JRWi"\h&WA"^J!Wi"801"W&!JWi"\&hJai"!W&R`JRhi"RR&R`JRWi">3L"!&cJai"Kg0X"!^&!J^Wi"RW&!JZai"9,+03"!JZi"a&!i"B/7"!&^Jhb)"9,+03A"D+3/3#A" 8010L/3#A" 3-4" Kg0X/0.A" L,10,E01A" 73-"L3X0" $#0"L0$3J%#,1",H" $#0"H0L3.0"3%,+$3$0"7,-710$0"3-4" $#010;F"+00"-,$" *5+$"$#0" L0$3%#,1/73..F" H0L3.0" D+130." 3+" 3%,+$3$0" ;5$" $#0" 37$53."(,L0-" ,H" D+130." 3+" $#0" %0,%.0]+" %1/L31F" _/H" -,$" 0<7.5+/E0b"320-$+",H"3%,+$3+F)"D-"D+3"W&!^JRZi"Z&!i"WR&aJ!Zi"9,+"Z&!Wi"6L,+"Z&!JWi"Kg0X"c&!Zi"3-4"801"h&!ci"ZZ&!\J!aA"R\A"H,1"0<3L%.0A"(,LJ0-"310"+/-2.04",5$"3+"%31$/75.31.F"10+%,-+/;.0"H,1";0#3E/,1+"$#0"%1,%#0$+"400L"10./2/,5+.F"5-3770%$3;.0)"D-4004A"/-"+,L0"$0<$+A"$#0"/40-$/H/73$/,-";0$(00-"$#0"L0$3%#,1/73..F"H0L3.0"3-4"3%,+J$3$0"D+130."3-4"$#0"3..0204"3%,+$3+/0+",H"37$53."(,L0-"/+"L340"+," H37/.0.F" $#3$" 3"%1,%#0$"73-" +./%" 3.L,+$"(/$#,5$"-,$/70" H1,L"40+71/;/-2",-0"$,"$#0",$#01)"=#5+"D+3"W&!^JZ&!";02/-+";F"73+$/J23$/-2" 3" %31$/75.31" +5;+0$" ,H" D+130.]+"(,L0-A" $#0" 4352#$01+" ,H"8015+3.0L'l/,-"/-"EE"!^JRZA"$#0-"+(/$7#0+"/-"EE"R\JR^"$,"7,-J

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""\aD" #3E0" 4/+75++04" $#/+" L3$$01" 0<$0-+/E0.F" /-" :5+3-" 67X01L3-A"

U=#0"Q01+,-3." /+"Q,./$/73.&"I,E0-3-$3."3-4"6HH07$/,-3$0">,E0"# A"b"/-"$#0"90;10("C/;.0AV"L/"\R"_R``RbA"ZWhmZ\c)"

Page 26: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

R^"

40L-" $#0" 3-3.,2,5+" +5;+0$" ,H" $#0" 7,1%,13$0" D+130.A" $#0" H0L/J-/g04"7/$F",H"8015+3.0L'l/,-A";0H,10"10$51-/-2"$,"3"71/$/Y50",H"8015+3.0L]+'l/,-]+"(,L0-" /-"Z&!)":57#"03+F" /40-$/H/73$/,-"0-J7,513204" $#0"%1,%#0$+" 0E0-"L,10" /-" $#0/1" ;.3L/-2",H"(,L0-"3.,-0"H,1"$#0"3%,+$3+/0+"$#3$"_377,14/-2"$,"$#0"7,E0-3-$3.".,2/7",H" ;.0++/-2+" 3-4" 751+0+" $," (#/7#" $#0+0" %1,%#0$+" +5;+71/;04b"10-40104"$#0"0-$/10"%,%5.3$/,-"+5;*07$" $,"S3#(0#]+"(13$#"3-4"*542L0-$)"

=#0"3++/2-/-2",H";.3L0"$,"$#0"L0$3%#,1/73."(,L3-"D+130."H,1" $#0" 4020-013$/,-" ,H" $#0" %0,%.0]+" L311/320" $," S3#(0#" /-"344/$/,-"#3+"$#0"0HH07$j(#0-"$#0"%1,%#0$]+"L0$3%#,1/73." .3-J25320" ;073L0" 7,-710$/g04j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r"D2-37/,"I3;0gv-"/-"#/+"7,-$1/;5$/,-"$,"$#0"!aaR"04/$04"E,.5L0"9+''8:EFO(D$[+%,:&NO(%='(H$='$#&"UL,10"43-201,5+"$#3-"[100X+";031/-2"2/H$+"/+"$#0"%3$1/317#F";031/-2"H0L3.0"+FLJ;,.+)V^`"P#/7#" /+" $,"+3F&" /-" $#0"0-4A" $#0"%3134/2L",H"L311/320"4,0+" -,$" +%03X" $," U3" 10.3$/,-+#/%" ,H"L5$53./$FV" /-" 40+71/;/-2"[,4]+" 10.3$/,-+#/%"(/$#" D+130." ,1" #5+;3-4+]" 10.3$/,-+#/%+"(/$#"$#0/1"(/E0+A^!";5$" /-+$034" $,"3" 10.3$/,-+#/%",H"4,L/-3$/,-)"O,1"$#0"H0L/-/g04"D+130.A"$#3$"/+A"3-4"H,1"D+130./$0"(,L0-A"$#0"L31J1/320"L0$3%#,1"+5220+$+"-,$"3"%31$-01+#/%"21,5-404"/-"L5$53."/-$/L37F" ;5$" /-" (,L0-]+" +5;,14/-3$/,-)" 90-70" $#0" 43-201A"UL,10" 43-201,5+AV" 0E0-A" U$#3-" [100X+" ;031/-2" 2/H$+AV" 3+" $#0";/;./73."%3$1/317#F"%5$+" H,1(314" $#0"+00L/-2.F"3..51/-2"3-4"0-J232/-2"%3134/2L",H"L311/320",-.F" 3+" 3" $13%A"(#,+0" 3/L" /+" $#0"+5;*523$/-2",H"$#0"H0L3.0"+FL;,.",H"$#0"(/H0)"

=#/+".034+"L0"/-"7,-7.5+/,-"$,"3+X&"#,("5-3L;/25,5+"3.+,"/+" $#0"%3134/2L",H"7,E0-3-$"3-4" $#0",$#01";,4/0+",H"0E/40-70"$#3$"C01L3-";1/-2+"$,";031"/-"+5%%,1$",H"#/+"$#0+/+o"6-4"(#3$",H" $#0"Q0-$3$057#3."3-4",$#01" $0<$+" $#3$"C01L3-"4,0+"-,$"34J410++&"(#3$"3L;/25/$/0+"$,"C01L3-]+"$#0+/+"L/2#$"$#0F"/L%,+0o"D"#3E0" 0-$/$.04" $#/+" 10+%,-+0" UM-.F"B0-"610"I103$04"KY53.AV";5$"D"#3E0"3.+,"+5220+$04"3$"+0E013."%,/-$+"$#3$"$#/+"40+71/%$/,-"3%%./0+j7,-$131F" $," C01L3-]+" 3125L0-$j-,$" $," 3.." L0-)"6L,-2"L0-A"$#0"#034",H"#,5+0#,.4A"$#0"%1/0+$A"$#0">0E/$0A"$#0"0.401A"$#0"5-L311/04"+,-A"$#0"10+/40-$"3./0-A"$#0"5-7/175L7/+04A"3-4"+$/.."L,10"310"%.3704A",H$0-"3$"E31/,5+"%01/,4+"3-4";F"E31/J""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

^`"8,+r"D2-37/,"I3;0gv-A"UB,$#01"P/+4,LA"O3$#01">,E0&"[0-401J;3+04" DL3201F" /-" B3#3F3-3" C544#/+$" =#,52#$AV" 8,+r" D2-37/," I3J;0gv-" _04)b" 9+''8:EFO( D$[+%,:&N( %='( H$='$#" _6.;3-F&" :NGS" Q10++A"!aaRbA"!ca)"

^!"C01L3-A""#$%&$'()*+%,A"Z^)""

Page 27: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Rh"

,5+"+,5170+A"3$"5-0Y53."%,+/$/,-+"(/$#/-"3-"D+130./$0"+,7/3."#/0J1317#F)"C01L3-]+";,,X"0+%,5+0+"3-"K-./2#$0-L0-$J013"/403.",H"023./$31/3-/+L"$#3$"/+"#314"H,1"L,+$",H"5+"/-"$#0"K51,J6L01/73-"P0+$"$,"10+/+$)":$/..A"$#0"U%,./$/7+",H"4/HH010-70V"$#3$"7#3137$01/gJ0+"L57#",H"7,-$0L%,131F"6L01/73-"4/+7,51+0"+#,5.4"%01#3%+"%,/-$"5+"$,"3";/;./73." /40,.,2F",H"+,7/3."4/+%31/$/0+"3-4"4/E01+/J$/0+"/-+$034)" "

Page 28: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

Rc"

I;!H;;F$GA?B-@7FAB$?FG$0EFB-@7FAB$?MM@7?B-;0$

GM?B6G"f)"[M==P6>@"Q6IDODI":I9MM>"MO"?K>D[DMGA"

CK?fK>KSA"I6"

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g04" 7,-$1,." ,H" 07,-,L/7A" +,7/3.A" 3-4" %,./$/73." 10J+,5170+"/-"$#0"#3-4+",H"3"%1/E/.0204"0./$0)"

C01L3-"3$$1/;5$0+" $#0"023./$31/3-" $51-" /-"D+130./$0" $#,52#$"$," /$+" 7,E0-3-$3." $#0,.,2F" ;/-4/-2" 40/$F" 3-4" 7,LL5-/$F" /-" 3"L5$53..F",;./23$,1F";,-4" _UK23./$31/3-"=#0,.,2FAV" 7#)"!b)" "90"2,0+" ,-" $," 40L,-+$13$0" $#/+" 023./$31/3-" ;0-$" ;F" $#0" H,1L" ,H"%,./$/73."2,E01-3-70"7#3L%/,-04"/-"@05$01,-,LF"_UK23./$31/3-"Q,./$/7+AV"7#)"RbA";F"$#0"-5L01,5+"07,-,L/73..F" .0E0./-2"L03+J510+"+0$"H,1$#"/-"$#0"=,13#"_UK23./$31/3-/+L"3-4"6++0$+AV"7#)"WbA";F" $#0" L,40+" ,H" ,13." 3-4" (1/$$0-" 7,LL5-/73$/,-" /-" 3-7/0-$"D+130." _UK23./$31/3-"=07#-,.,2FAV" 7#)" ZbA" 3-4" ;F" $#0" %0,%.0" 3+"$#0"7,..07$/E0"+5;*07$",H";/;./73."-3113$/E0"20-10"_UK23./$31/3-/+L"3-4"$#0"KE,.5$/,-",H"G3113$/E0AV"7#)"\b)"

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g0" $#0" 7.,+0" 3HH/-/$F";0$(00-""#$%&$'()*+%,( 3-4"LF",(-"/8$(/#:;$E( 6C(`%87$8S^R"C01L3-"2,0+" +," H31" 3+" $,"Y50+$/,-"(#0$#01"#/+"%1,*07$"7,5.4"#3E0";00-"%,++/;.0"(/$#,5$"$#0";0-0H/$",H"LF"+7#,.31+#/%)"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

^R"G,1L3-"f)"[,$$(3.4A"/8$(/#:;$E(6C(`%87$8S(.(D6>:6,6AN(6C(&8$(-$,:@A:6=( 6C( 3:;$#%&$'( ME#%$,O( UQaWbUWaW( 9S"S)S( _B31FX-,..A" G)S)&" M1;/+"C,,X+A" !ahai" R`$#" 3--/E01+31F" 10%1)A" :#0HH/0.4&" :#0HH/0.4" 67340L/7"Q10++A"(/$#"-0("%10H370A"!aaabi"+5LL31/g04"/-"[,$$(3.4A"/8$(5$;#$7(9:;,$h.( D6>:6,:&$#%#N( M=&#6'+>&:6=( _Q#/.340.%#/3&" O,1$10++" Q10++A" !ac\bA"R^!mRcZ)" ":00"3.+,"?,.3-4"C,01"_04)b"/#%><:=A(i/8$(/#:;$E(6C(`%87$8S!(\=(&8$(/#%:,(6C(%(",%EE:>" _8:M=:5%A"W\!i":#0HH/0.4&":#0HH/0.4"67340L/7"Q10++A"R``Rb)"

Page 29: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Ra"

!-;$B7F6;@R;FB;$7L$0EFB-@7FAB$?FG$GA?B-@7FAB$@;?GAFR0$$

=#0"7.0310+$"3HH/-/$F";0$(00-"$#0"$(,"/+"$#3$";,$#""#$%&$'()*+%,"3-4"/8$(/#:;$E(6C(`%87$8(+#310"$#0";0./0H"$#3$"D+130."(3+"L03+51J3;.F" L,10" 023./$31/3-" $#3-" 3-F" 7,-$0L%,131F" +,7/0$F" /-" $#0"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$)"C01L3-";5/.4+",-"LF"0<%./73$/,-",H"3"7,-J$13+$";0$(00-"&#:;+&$@:FG6E:=A(G6,:&:$E$3-4"&#:;+&$@#$j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

=#0" 4/HH010-70+";0$(00-"/8$(/#:;$E( 6C(`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g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

^W" :)"@03-"B7C1/40" 81)A" UQ,./$F" ,H" $#0"I,E0-3-$"Q0,%.0AV" M=&(Z!"

Page 30: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

W`"

%,./$F" ,H" $#0" 7,E0-3-$" %0,%.0A" /-" 4/+$/-7$/,-" H1,L" $#0" L3*,1"+7#,.31.F"./-0",H"/-$01%10$3$/,-"$#3$"@05$01,-,LF"/+"3"7,..07$/,-",H".3(+"4/437$/73..F"/-75.73$04)^Z"

C01L3-"0L%.,F+"$#0"%,./$/73."$#0,1/+$"I#31.0+"40":07,-43$"B,-$0+Y5/05]+" -,$/,-" $#3$"(#3$" 4/+$/-25/+#0+" 3" 10%5;./73-" 10J2/L0" H1,L" 3-" 35$,713$/7" ,-0" /+" $#0" +0%313$/,-" ,H" %,(01+" /-$,"0<075$/E0A" .02/+.3$/E0" 3-4" *54/7/3." ;13-7#0+A" (/$#" 3" %31$/75.31"+$10++" ,-" 3-" /-40%0-40-$" *54/7/31F)^\"677,14/-2.FA" #0" 3-3.Fg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

=," 43$0A" ,-.F" 3" H0(" 7.,+0" 1034/-2+" ,H" ;/;./73." $0<$+" (/$#"(#/7#" D" 3L" H3L/./31" #3E0" ;00-" 3$" 3.." +#3%04A" ,1" 2103$.F" /-H.5J0-704A";F" .31201"+,7/3.",1"%,./$/73." $#0,1F)"=#0"0<70%$/,-+" $#3$"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""_!achbA"RRamZZ"w"UQ,./$F",H"$#0"I,E0-3-$"Q0,%.0&"=#0"C,,X",H"@05J$01,-,LFAV" 8,#-"=)":$1,-2"3-4":$0E0-":)"=50.." _04+)b""6=E&:&+&:=A( &8$("6FF+=:&NS( D&+':$E( 6=( &8$( ?6,:&N( 6C( .=>:$=&( ME#%$,( :=( 56=6#( 6C( DS( 0$%=(P>9#:'$(B#S(_P/-,-3">3X0A"D-4)&"K/+0-;135-+A"R``\bA"!hmWW)"

^Z" [01#314" E,-" ?34A"\,'( /$E&%F$=&( /8$6,6AN" _E,.)" !i" $13-+)" @)"B)":$3.X01i"G0("S,1X&"931%01A" !a^RbA" !a\mR`WA" R!amRW!i"B31$/-"G,$#A"U=#0">3(+"/-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#&"=#0/1"6++5L%$/,-+"3-4"B03-/-2AV"B)"G,$#A" /8$( 3%7E( :=( &8$( ?$=&%&$+>8( %='( \&8$#( D&+':$E" _$13-+)" @)" ?)" 6%J=#,L3+i"Q#/.340.%#/3&"O,1$10++"Q10++A"!a^^bA"!m!`h)"

^\"I#31.0+"40":07,-43$"B,-$0+Y5/05A"/8$(DG:#:&(6C( &8$(3%7E" _I.31XA"G)8)&"=#0">3(;,,X"K<7#3-20A"R``\bi"$13-+)",H"3_)EG#:&('$E(36:E"_!hZcb)"

Page 31: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

W!"

7,L0"$,"L/-4"310"$#0"(,1X",H"@3E/4"8,;./-2A^^"?,.3-4"C,01A^h"B31E/-"I#3-0FA^c"[3.0"S00A^a"3-4A"$,"3"402100A"?,;01$"Q,.g/-)h`"P#/.0"$#0"7,-$1/;5$/,-",H"037#"#3+";00-"+/2-/H/73-$A",-.F"Q,.g/-"7,E01+" $#0" +3L0" +(00%" ,H" =,13#" $0<$+" 3+" 4,0+" C01L3-" 3-4"Q,.g/-]+"+,7/,%,./$/73."/-H010-70+"310"407/+/E0.F"+5;,14/-3$04"$,"./$0131F"7,-701-+"H,..,(/-2" $#0"L0$#,4",H"C3X#$/-)"MH$0-" /$" /+".0H$" $," $#0" 103401" $," +00" $#0" %,./$/73." /L%./73$/,-+" ,H" Q,.g/-]+"1034/-2+)"

P#3$"4/+$/-25/+#0+"C01L3-]+"1034/-2"/+"$#3$"#0"#3+"H,5-4"/-"@05$01,-,LF"3"7,L%,+/$/,-" $#3$" /+" /-$0-+0.F"%,./$/73." /-" /$+"3/L+A"34E,73$0+"+$1,-2"L03+510+",H"+,7/3."3-4"07,-,L/7"*5+$/70A"3-4"%1,%,+0+"3" H,1L3$" H,1"+$3$0" .03401+#/%)"90"#3+" $3X0-" $#3$"*5-7$510" ,H" %,./$/73." H,1L" 3-4" +5;+$3-70" +01/,5+.F" 0-,52#" $,"7,-70%$53./g0" $#0" 7,1%,13$0" E3.50+" /-#010-$" /-" /$+" 4/+$/-7$/E0";.0-4",H"%10+71/%$/E0" 3-4"#,1$3$,1F" 1#0$,1/7)" D-"LF" *542L0-$A"$#0" /-E0-$/E0"%,./$F"C01L3-"H/-4+" /-"@05$01,-,LF" /+";0+$"5-J401+$,,4"3+" 3-"3$$0L%$" $," 10+51107$" $#0"023./$31/3-/+L",H"031.F"D+130." 3-4" $,"4," +," ;F" $13-+H011/-2" /$+" E3.50+" 3-4"L3-F" ,H" /$+"+%07/H/7"L03+510+"H1,L"$1/;0"$,"+$3$0)"

GA?B-@7FAB$$S9;@A;0$?I79!$$G;9!;@7F7:ET0$M78A!E$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$T01F";1/0H.FA"D"#3E0"3"-5L;01",H"4/37#1,-/7"Y501/0+"3;,5$"C01JL3-]+" 107,-+$157$/,-)" :,L0" ,H" $#0+0" L3$$01+" D" #3E0" .,-2"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""^^" @3E/4" 8,;./-2A" U@07,-+$157$/,-" 3-4" $#0" Q,./$/73." 6-3.F+/+" ,H"

C/;./73."=0<$+&"6"83L0+,-/3-"?034/-2",H"Q+3.L"hRAV"D$F$:%"\a"_!aaRbA"a\m!Rhi"/40LA"U(D%F+$,"_I,..020E/..0A"B/--)&">/$512/73."Q10++A"!aacb)"

^h" ?,.3-4" C,01A" B%F$E6=( %='( B$#6;6%F" _6$.3-$3&" :7#,.31+" Q10++A"!aa^bi" /40LA" U6-$,-/," [13L+7/&" =#0" KL0120-70" ,H" $#0" qQ1/-70]" /-"K<,45+AV" ?,.3-4" C,01( ( _04)b" P%#[:E&( "#:&:>:EF( 6C( &8$( 9:;,$" _>,-J4,-'G0("S,1X&"=k="D-$01-3$/,-3.A"R``WbA"ZRm^Z)"

^c"B31E/-">)"I#3-0FA" U @>JDD" 3-4" $#0" q:,-2",H"@0;,13#]&"=0<J$53.A" Q#/.,.,2/73." 3-4" :,7/,.,2/73." :$54/0+" /-" 85420+" \A" (/$#" :%07/3."?0H010-70" $," $#0"T01;3."M775110-70+",H" @>" /-"C/;./73." "90;10(V"_Q#)@)"4/++)A"931E314""N-/E01+/$FA"!ah^bi"/40LA"UB,40.+"B3$$01&":,L0"DL%./73$/,-+",H"Q,./$/73."K7,-,LF"H,1"$#0"=0<$53."K<020+/+",H"B/73#"^&am!\AV"Q#/./%"O)"K+.01"_04)b".=>:$=&(ME#%$,4(/8$(\,'(/$E&%F$=&(:=":&E(D6>:%,("6=&$[&"_B/--03%,./+&"O,1$10++"Q10++A"R``\bA"!Z\m^`)"

^a"[3.0"6)"S00A"UD40,.,2/73."I1/$/7/+L&"85420+"!hmR!"3-4"$#0"@/+JL0L;0104"C,4FAV"[3.0"6)"S00"_04)b"B+'A$E(%='(P$&86'4(X$7(.GG#6%>8$E(&6(9:;,:>%,(D&+':$E" _B/--03%,./+&"O,1$10++"Q10++A"!aa\bA"!Z^mh`i"0340LA"?66#(9%=:E8$'("8:,'#$=(6C()Y$S(Z6F%=(%E()Y:,(:=(&8$(5$;#$7(9:;,$"_B/--0J3%,./+&"O,1$10++"Q10++A"R``Wb)"

h`"?,;01$"Q,.g/-A"P6E$E(%='(&8$(0$+&$#6=:F:E&S(.(3:&$#%#N(D&+'N(6C(&8$(0$+&$#6=6F:>( 5:E&6#N( _G0(" S,1X&" =#0" :03;51F" Q10++A" !ac`b)" Q,.g/-"5-401+7,10+"$#0"(3F"$#0"$0<$"/+"-01E,5+.F"7,-701-04"(/$#"U0<70%$/,-J3." ,5$+/401+V" ;0F,-4" $#0" %3.0" ,H"L3.0"L0L;01+" ,H" $#0" 7,LL5-/$FA"0)2)A" ?3#3;A" [/;0,-/$0+A" (,L0-A" 40%0-40-$+A" >0E/$0+A" 3-4" 0E0-" $#0"=13-+*,143-/3-"$1/;0+)"Q,.g/-A"0L%.,F/-2"C3X#$/-/3-"/-+/2#$"3;,5$"$#0"L5.$/%.0" E,/70+" /-" $0<$+A" ,;+01E0+" $#3$"@05$01,-,LF" +$31$+" ,5$"(/$#"$#0"5-345.$013$04"E,/70",H"[,4"10%,1$04";F"$#0"E,/70",H"B,+0+A";5$"3+"$#0"-3113$/E0"%3++0+",E01"/-$,"8,+#53Jf/-2+A"$#0"35$#,1/$3$/E0"E,/70",H"[,4" $#1,52#"B,+0+" 107040+" /-" H3E,1",H" $#0" E,/70",H" $#0"#/440-"-3113$,1",H"8,+#53"$#1,52#"f/-2+)"

Page 32: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

WR"

0-$01$3/-04" /-" LF" E/0(" ,H" @05$01,-,LFA" ;5$" +,L0" 310" -0("Y501/0+"3-4"3..",H"$#0L"310"2/E0-"3"407/404"U$(/+$V";F"C01L3-]+"+$54F)"

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

Z8%&(>6=E&:&+&:=A(;6'N(:E(&6(+='$#&%<$(&8:E(#%':>%,(E$G%#%&:6=(6C(A6@Y$#=F$=&%,(G67$#E]$D-"$01L+",H"$#0"35$#,1]+"3-3.F+/+A"$#/+"/+";F"H31"$#0" 7157/3." #/+$,1/73." Y50+$/,-)$6%31$" H1,L" $#0" ./$0131F" H/7$/,-"$#3$" 3"#/+$,1/73."B,+0+",140104" /$A"(0"#3E0"-,",E01$" /-H,1L3J$/,-)"C01L3-"-,$0+"$#3$"$#0"/-352513$/,-",H"$#0"@05$01,-,L/7"+F+$0L",H"2,E01-L0-$" /+"%.3704",-"$#0"+#,5.401+",H"$#,+0"34J410++04" /-" $#0";,,X";F" 3" %.513." UF,5AV" %10+5L3;.F" $#0"(#,.0"L3.0"7/$/g0-1F)"9,(0E01A"-,$#/-2"/+"+3/4"3;,5$"$#0"L07#3-/+L";F"(#/7#"$#3$"#F%,$#0$/73.";,4F" /+"$," .35-7#"$#0"-0("%,./$/73.",1401)"D$"/+"-,$"03+F"$,"+00"#,("3-F",-0",H"$#0"+0%313$04"%,(01+"7,5.4" /-/$/3$0" $#/+" %,./$F" +/-70" 3.." ,H" $#0L" 310" +5;*07$+" ,H" /$+"$01L+)"D-"$#0"377,5-$",H"8,+/3#]+"10/2-"/-"R"f/-2+"#0"4,0+"-,$"0E0-" +#310" %,(01" (/$#" ,$#01" ,HH/701+" ,H" +$3$0A" ,$#01" $#3-" $,"7,-+5.$" $#0" %1,%#0$0++"95.43#)"6.$#,52#" #0" 0-37$+" 75.$/7" 10JH,1L+" 34E,73$04" ;F" @05$01,-,LFA" #0" 4,0+" +," (/$#,5$" 3-F"10H010-70"$,"$#0"+0%313$/,-",H"%,(01+)"

[/E0-"$#3$"(0".37X"3-F"/-4/73$/,-",H"3-"D+130./$0"0Y5/E3.0-$",H" $#0" I,-$/-0-$3." I,-210++" $#3$" %1,%,+04" $#0"N-/$04" :$3$0+"I,-+$/$5$/,-A"(0"310" .0H$"(/$#"L010"250++0+)"I,5.4" /$" 103..F";0"U3.." $#0" 3++0L;.F" ,H" D+130.V" _@05$" \&RRi" RW&!JWi" W!&W`i" WW&ZJ\b"$#3$" /+" 0L%,(0104" $," 0-37$" $#0" %,./$F" /-" (#/7#" X/-2A" %1/0+$+A"*5420+A"3-4"%1,%#0$+"7,-751o"6+"/$"/+A"$#0"3++0L;.F"/+",-.F"%/7J$5104"3+"103HH/1L/-2"$#0"%,./$F"$#3$"#3+"3.1034F";00-"0+$3;./+#04"_@05$"W!&aJ!Wb)"M1"7,5.4" $#0" /-/$/3$,1+",H" $#0"-0("%,./$F"#3E0";00-"$#0"-0;5.,5+" A"3-"3%%310-$";,4F",H"7,-+%/13$,1/3."-,$3;.0+"(#,A"/-";1/-2/-2"$#0"L/-,1"8,+/3#"$,"$#0"$#1,-0A"(010"+/L5.$3-0,5+.F" 3$$0L%$/-2" $," 1073+$" $#0"0-$/10" +$157$510",H" $#0"X/-24,L"_R"f2+"R!&RZbo"

Z8$#$('6$E(&8$(G6,:&N_E('$F%='(&6($=C6#>$(%(E&#:>&(#$,:A:6+E(6#&86'6[N(C:&(:=(ME#%$,_E(8:E&6#N]"6.."$#/-2+"7,-+/40104A"$#0"10./2/,5+"%1,213L",H"@05$01,-,LF" +00L+";0+$" $," H/$" $#0"L,,4",H" %,+$0</./7" 10J7,-+$157$/,-)" C5$" /-" $#3$" 73+0" $#0" ,HH/70" ,H" X/-2" (,5.4" ;0"3-37#1,-/+$/7"3-4"/$"/+"4/HH/75.$"$,"/L32/-0"$#0"Q01+/3-",E01.,14+"3770%$/-2"3"+F+$0L",H"2,E01-3-70"(/$#"3"X/-2A"0E0-" /H"#0";0"3"L57#"(03X0-04"#034",H"+$3$0)"

P#0-"(0"$51-"$,"!JR"f/-2+A",-.F"90g0X/3#"3-4"8,+/3#"3%J%1,</L3$0"34#010-70"$,"$#0"@05$01,-,L/7"%,./$F"3-4"$#0-",-.F"/-" E01F" %31$/3." L3--01)" P#0$#01" ,1" -,$" 0/$#01" L,-317#" 0+J%,5+04"$#0"-0("%,./$FA"$#0"400%0+$"L,$/E3$/,-",H"/$+"317#/$07$_+b"

Page 33: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

WW"

L3F"#3E0";00-"$,"3E,/4"$#0"+3L0"H3$0"3+"-,1$#01-"D+130.)"C01JL3-]+" 7/$3$/,-" ,H" $#0" /-H.50-70" ,H" ;/;./73." %,./$F" ,-" $#0" N):)"H,5-4/-2"H3$#01+",E01.,,X+"$#0"71/$/73."/L%,1$3-70",H"$#0"+0%3J13$/,-",H"7#517#"3-4"+$3$0"$," $#0" .3$$01)"=#0"+,1$",H" $#0,713$/7"+$3$0" 34E,73$04" /-" @05$01,-,LF" /+" L,10" 10L/-/+70-$" ,H" ?0JH,1L3$/,-J;3+04"%,./$/0+"+57#"3+"[0-0E3"3-4"$#0"B3++37#5+0$$+"C3F"I,.,-FA",1"0E0-",H"+$1/7$"D+.3L/7"%,./$/0+A"+57#"3+"$#0"=3./J;3-)"

Z8%&(%#$( &8$( :FG,:>%&:6=E(6C( >+,&:>( >$=&#%,:J%&:6=( C6#(0$+&$#6=6F:>($A%,:&%#:%=:EF]$=#0"0HH07$",H"$#0"-0("%,./$F"(,5.4";0"$,"0.0E3$0"$#0"75.$/7" 3-4"07,-,L/7"%,(01",H" 8015+3.0L" /-",-0" +$1,X0A" 3+"312504"7,-E/-7/-2.F";F"P)"K520-0"I.3;51-Ah!":#/20F5X/"G3X3J-,+0AhR"3-4"K5-":5X"I#,)hW"@0%1/E3$/,-",H"$#0"1513."%,%5.370"7,5.4"03+/.F"73+$" $#0L"3+"U+07,-4J7.3++"7/$/g0-+)V"DH"C01L3-" /+"7,1107$" /-" 3125/-2" $#3$"@05$01,-,LF" +$1/E0+" $," $13-+H01" $1/;3.".,F3.$/0+"$,"-3$/,-3.".,F3.$FA"$#0",-J$#0J21,5-4"0HH07$"(,5.4";0"$,"+5;,14/-3$0"$#0"7,5-$1F+/40"$,"8015+3.0L"3-4"(03X0-"/$"07,J-,L/73..FA" /-" +%/$0" ,H" $#0" +0E013." @05$01,-,L/7" L03+510+" $,"L/$/23$0"+,7/,07,-,L/7"/-0Y53./$F)"

D$" 13$#01" .,,X+" ./X0" $#0" 8015+3.0L" .03401+#/%" /+" 7,-70/E04"3+" 3-" ,./2317#F" $#3$" +$1/E0+" $," /-$1,4570" 3"L03+510" ,H" +#3104"%,(01" 413(-" H1,L" $#0" $1/;3." +F+$0L" ,H" 4070-$0104" 15.0)" D-"4,/-2" +,A" $#0" -0(" %,./$F"L3F" ;0" 3/L04" 3$" 3++51/-2" +,7/,07,J-,L/7"10./0H"H,1"$#0"7,5-$1F+/40"/-"10$51-"H,1"/$+".,++",H"%,./$/73."%,(01" 7,-+5LL3$04" ;F" $#0" 7,-70-$13$/,-" ,H" 75.$/7" 3-4" 07,J-,L/7" %,(01" /-" $#0" 73%/$3.)" =#/+" %1,213L" +%0..+" %1,H/$+" 3-4".,++0+"H,1"$#0"1513."7,5-$1F"H,.XA"(#,"(,5.4"701$3/-.F"(0.7,L0"$#0" 10./0H" L03+510+" H,1" 73-70..3$/,-" ,H" 40;$" ;5$" (#," (,5.4"7#3H0" 3$" $#0" 0.0E3$/,-" ,H" 8015+3.0L" 3$" $#0" 7,+$" ,H" $#0/1" ,(-"./E0./#,,4"3-4"75.$510)"

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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""h!"P)"K520-0"I.3;51-A"U@05$01,-,LF"3-4"I,..07$/E0"C0#3E/,1AV"

_Q#)@)"4/++)A"Q1/-70$,-"N-/E01+/$FA"!a^cbi"U=#0"O/+73."C3+/+",H"8,+/3#]+"?0H,1L+AV"B93"aR"_!ahWbA"!!mRR)"

hR" :#/20F5X/"G3X3-,+0A( B6E:%8_E( ?%EE6Y$#S( D6>:6,6AN( %='( &8$( 3:;$#%&:=A(9:;,$"_B31FX-,..A"G)S)&"M1;/+"C,,X+A"!aaWbA"!m!!R)"

hW"K5-":5X"I#,A"U8,+/3-/7"?0H,1L"/-"$#0"@05$01,-,L/+$/7"9/+$,1F"?07,-+$157$04"/-"$#0">/2#$",H"O37$/,-3./+L"3-4"N+0",H"?,F3."6%,.,J2FAV"_Q#)@)"4/++)A"[13453$0"=#0,.,2/73."N-/,-A"R``Rb)"

Page 34: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

WZ"

BF"#,%0"H,1"$#0"H5$510" /+" $#3$" $#0"10+,5170+"3-4" /-+/2#$+",H" $#0"+0E013."L0$#,4,.,2/0+" /-";/;./73." +$54/0+"73-" *,/-" /-"+0J1/,5+" 7,-E01+3$/,-" 3;,5$" +,7/3." 3-4" %,./$/73." $0<$+" 3-4" $,%/7+"$#3$"#3E0"3.."$,,",H$0-";00-"0<3L/-04";F",-.F",-0"L0$#,4,.,J2F" 3$" 3" $/L0" /-" /+,.3$/,-" H1,L" 3.." $#0" ,$#01+)" =#0" 71,++JH01$/./g3$/,-",H"L0$#,4+"%1,L/+0+"$,"F/0.4"7,-+0Y50-$/3."10+5.$+"H,1" 3" H5..J;,4/04"5-401+$3-4/-2",H";/;./73." %,./$/0+A" ;,$#" /-" /$+"$#0,1F"3-4"%137$/70)" "

Page 35: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

W\"

;S9?8A!E$?FG$AF;S9?8A!E$AF$!-;$07BA7UM78A!AB?8$6A0A7F0$7L$!-;$

M;F!?!;9B-T0$079@B;0V$

:6N>"B)"M>S6G"C?MPG"NGDTK?:D=S"

O,1"$,,".,-2A"$#0"%,./$/73."4/L0-+/,-+",H";/;./73."$#,52#$"#3E0";00-"L3/-.F"-02.07$04";F" +%07/3./+$+" /-";/;./73." +$54/0+)"6+" 8,J+#53"C01L3-"%,/-$+",5$"/-"#/+"0-232/-2"-0(";,,XA"$#,+0"(#,"#3E0" 3$$0L%$04" $," 107,-+$157$" %,./$/73." $#0,1F" /-" $#0"90;10("C/;.0" #3E0" H,1" $#0"L,+$" %31$" ;00-" ,5$+/401+" (/$#" ./$$.0" ,1" -,"+%07/3./g04"X-,(.0420",H"0/$#01" $#0"90;10("C/;.0" /$+0.H",1" $#0".31201"(,1.4",5$",H"(#/7#"/$"0L01204)"I,-+0Y50-$.FA"$#0"10+5.$+",H" $#0/1" /-E0+$/23$/,-+" #3E0" ;00-" ,H" ./L/$04" E3.50" $," +%07/3.J/+$+)hZ" C01L3-A" /-" 7,-$13+$A" +00X+" $," 34410++" $#0" %,./$/73."4/L0-+/,-+" ,H" ;/;./73." $#,52#$" H1,L" $#0" +$3-4%,/-$" ,H" 3" +%0J7/3./+$A"3-4"3$"+,L0".0-2$#)"90"/+"$,";0"7,LL0-404"H,1"+00X/-2"$,"107,E01"3-4"5-401+$3-4"%,./$/73."$#0,1F"/-"$#0"90;10("C/;.0"/-"3"+01/,5+"3-4"7103$/E0"(3FA"3-4"H,1"10.3$/-2"(#3$"#0"#3+" 10J7,-+$157$04";,$#"$,"-,-J;/;./73."P0+$"6+/3-"3-4"B04/$0113-03-"+,7/,J%,./$/73." L,40.+" ,-" $#0" ,-0" #3-4A" 3-4" $," 3-7/0-$" 3-4"031.F"L,401-"%,./$/73." $#0,1F",-" $#0",$#01)" D-"(#3$" H,..,(+A" D"(,5.4" ./X0" $," +5220+$" +,L0" 3.$01-3$/E0" %01+%07$/E0+" $," $#,+0"34E,73$04" ;F" C01L3-A" 3-4" 3.+," #/2#./2#$" +,L0" ,H" #/+" L,10"7,L%0../-2"%,/-$+)"

C01L3-]+"$#0+/+"/+"$#3$"$#0"Q0-$3$057#A"1034"+F-7#1,-/73..F"3+"3"+/-2.0"4,75L0-$Ah\"%10+0-$+"3";.50"%1/-$"H,1"3"UL,10"023./J$31/3-V" U+,7/3.A" %,./$/73." 3-4" 10./2/,5+" ,1401V" $#3$" /-" $#0"L3/-"10*07$+"$#0"X/-4",H"+,7/3."+$13$/H/73$/,-"3-4"#/01317#F",$#01(/+0"3$$0+$04" /-"3-7/0-$"P0+$"6+/3-"+,5170+)h^"90"0L%#3+/g0+"(#3$"#0" +00+" 3+" 3" 10*07$/,-",H" /-0Y53./$F" /-"U$#0"-,$/,-",H" 3"+,7/0$F"(#,+0" 7,10" /+" 3" +/-2.0A" 5-/H,1L.F" 0L%,(0104A" #,L,20-0,5+"7.3++)Vhh"K.+0(#010A"C01L3-"40+71/;0+" $#0"0-E/+/,-04"7,LL5J-/$F"3+"3"U#,L,20-,5+"3-4"023./$31/3-"%,./$F)Vhc"=#0"E/+/,-",H"3"L,10" 023./$31/3-" +,7/0$F" (#/7#" C01L3-" H/-4+" /-" Q0-$3$057#3."$0<$+"/+A"377,14/-2"$,"#/LA"1,,$04"/-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#]+"7,E0-3-$"$#0,.,2FA"(#/7#"73+$+" $#0"7,LL,-"UL3-V" _C01L3-]+" $01Lb"3+"(0.."3+"7,..07$/E0"D+130.A"3+"$#0"0Y5/E3.0-$",H"3"+5;,14/-3$0"X/-2"/-" 3" #5L3-" +5g013/-JE3++3." $103$F" 7,-$0<$A" 0<3.$/-2" #/L" $#010J

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""x"BF" $#3-X+" $,"f310-"C)":$01-" H,1" 34E/70",-"(,14/-2"3$" +0E013."

*5-7$510+A" 3-4" $," C1/3-" ?3/-0F" H,1" 10L/-4/-2" L0" ,H" 0<$13JD+130./$0"0<3L%.0+",H"(,L0-]+",(-01+#/%",H".3-404"%1,%01$F)"

hZ"8,+#53"6)"C01L3-A""#$%&$'()*+%,4(567(&8$(9:;,$(9#6<$(7:&8(.=>:$=&(?6,:&:>%,(/86+A8&"_M<H,14"N-/E)"Q10++A"R``cbA"RcmRa)"

h\"D;/4)A"c)"h^"D;/4)A"^mhA"!^)"hh"D;/4)A"h)"hc"D;/4)A"!^a)"

Page 36: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

W^"

;F)ha" 6+" 3" 10+5.$A" D+130./$0" L0-" 310" H5-43L0-$3..F" 0Y53." 3-4"(,1$#F" ,H" #,-,1A" +," $#3$" $#0/1" X/-2" #3+" 5-%107040-$04" ./L/$+"%.3704",-"#/+"%,(01A"(03.$#"3-4"+$3$5+A"3+"@05$01,-,LF"+$/%5J.3$0+)c`" 6" -5L;01" ,H" C01L3-]+" ,;+01E3$/,-+" +5220+$" $#3$" #0"L/2#$";0",-"$,"+,L0$#/-2)"=#0"10Y5/10L0-$"$#3$"0E01F"D+130./$0"L3.0"3%%031";0H,10"S#(#"$#100"$/L0+"3"F031"(/$#",HH01/-2+"_3+"/-"@05$" !^&!^b" /+" -,$"5-./X0" $#0" 10Y5/10L0-$" $#3$" 3" E3++3." 3%J%031" F031.F" ;0H,10" #/+" +5g013/-A" +5220+$/-2" 3" %313..0." ;0$(00-"E3++3."3-4"D+130./$0A"3+"C01L3-"31250+)c!"O51$#01L,10A"$#010"310"3" -5L;01" ,H"(3F+" /-"(#/7#" $#0"@05$01,-,L/7" X/-2" .37X+" $#0"%101,23$/E0+",H"$#0"$F%/73."L,-317#",H"3-7/0-$"P0+$"6+/3A",1"3$".03+$" $#0" $F%/73." L,-317#" ,H" B0+,%,$3L/3" ,1" K2F%$A" 3;,5$"(#,L"0E/40-70"+51E/E0+"_0)2)A"#0".,+0+"7,-$1,.",H"40;$"10.03+0A"L3-5L/++/,-" ,H" 40;$" +.3E0+A" 3-4" .3-4" 1040L%$/,-A" (#/7#" 310"U407,5%.04"H1,L"$#0"%,./$/73.",1401AV"$,"%313%#13+0"C01L3-b)cR"O/-3..FA" .023." ./L/$+"%.3704" ,-" $#0" 3775L5.3$/,-",H"(03.$#" 3-4",-" 07,-,L/7" 0<%.,/$3$/,-" ,H" $#0" E5.-013;.0" +5220+$" $#0" %10+J0-70",H"3-"023./$31/3-"/L%5.+0"$#3$"L/2#$"(0..";0"5-5+53."/-"$#0".31201"P0+$" 6+/3-" 7,-$0<$)c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g04" ;F" 3" +01/,5+" 213%%./-2"(/$#" $103$JL0-$+",H"(,L0-"3-4"10+/40-$"3./0-+"/-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#A"(#,"310"0<%./7/$.F"/-7.5404"/-"$#0"7,E0-3-$"7,LL5-/$F"/-"+0E013."$0<$+A"3-4" (/$#" %01+,-+" (/$#" 4/+3;/./$/0+A" (#," 310" 5-L0-$/,-04" /-"C01L3-]+"$103$L0-$A"$#,52#"+,L0"310"$#0"H,75+",H"Q0-$3$057#3."/-$010+$)" =#0" 10L3/-401" ,H" LF" 10L31X+" (/.." 34410++" $#0+0"%,/-$+)""

9,("L/2#$"10H010-70"$,"+,5170+"/-7103+0"$#0"%,$0-$/3."H,1"3" 1/7#01" 3-4"L,10" -53-704" 3-3.F+/+o"M-0" +$1/X/-2" 0<3L%.0" /+"$#0" /++50" ,H" #,./-0++A" 3-4" #,(" /$" /+" $103$04" ;F" $#0" E31/,5+"+,5170+)"=#,52#"C01L3-"#3+"./$$.0"$,"+3F"3;,5$"#,./-0++A"3"40J;3$0"/+"0E/40-704"/-"$#0"$0<$";0$(00-"$#,+0"(#,"(,5.4"10+01E0"#,./-0++" H,1" $#0" %1/0+$#,,4" 3.,-0" 3L,-2" %01+,-+A" 3-4" $#,+0"(#," (,5.4" 4/+$1/;5$0" /$" /-" 3" L,10" 023./$31/3-" L3--01)" QA" /-"G5L"!^&!J!h&\A"/+"E0#0L0-$"$#3$"#,./-0++";0.,-2+"$,"$#0"631,J-/4"%1/0+$#,,4"3.,-0A"3-4"f,13#]+"40+$157$/,-";F"S#(#"/-"$#3$"-3113$/E0"+01E0+"$,"%1,E0"$#0"%,/-$)"O,1"QA"#,./-0++"/+"3"*03.,5+J.FJ2531404" 7,LL,4/$F" $#3$" +0$+" $#0" %1/0+$+" 3%31$" H1,L" 3.."""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

ha"D;/4)A"Wa)"c`"D;/4)A"\W)"c!"D;/4)A"ZRmZZ)"cR"D;/4)A"acm!`h)"cW"D;/4)A"c!mac)"

Page 37: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Wh"

,$#01+A" 3-" /L%,1$3-$" L31X01" ,H" $#0/1" %1/E/.020" 3-4" +5%01/,1"+$3$5+)cZ"D-"7,-$13+$A"@05$01,-,LF"+%03X+",H"D+130."3+"3"(#,.0"3+"3-" A"U3"#,.F"%0,%.0AV"$,"S#(#A"7#,+0-";F"S#(#"3+"#/+" "_@05$"!Z&Rb)"9"3.+,"0-E/+/,-+"3"(/40"4/+$1/;5$/,-",H"#,./-0++A"7,LL3-4/-2"D+130."$,";0"#,.F"./X0"S#(#"#/L+0.H"_0)2)A">0E"!a&Ri"R`&hb)">/X0"@A"9"+%03X+",H"D+130."3+"#,.F"/-"$0<$+"+57#"3+">0E"R`&c"_ A"UDA"S#(#A"+3-7$/HF"F,5Vj#010A"D",;E/,5+.F"10*07$"837,;"B/.21,L]+"E/0("$#3$"D+130."/+",-.F"%,$0-J$/3..F"#,.F"377,14/-2"$,"9b)c\"I.031.FA"H,1"@"3-4"9A"/-"7,-$13+$"$," QA" #,./-0++A" $#0" 4/E/-0" Y53./$F" %31" 0<70..0-70A" /+" +,L0$#/-2"+#3104" ;F" $#0" %0,%.0" ,H" D+130." 3+" 3"(#,.0)" D$" +0$+" $#0L" 3%31$"H1,L",$#01"%0,%.0+j/L%./04";F"@"/-"@05$"!Z&R"3-4"9"/-">0E"R`&R^j;5$" 4,0+" -,$" H5-7$/,-" $," 7103$0" #/01317#F" (/$#/-" $#0"D+130./$0"7,LL5-/$F"/$+0.H)"D$"L3F";0"$#3$"$#0"Q"E/+/,-",H"3"#,.F"%1/0+$#,,4" 3-4" 3" 7,LL,-" D+130." 10%10+0-$+" 3" 7,-+01E3$/E0"E/0(%,/-$"3-4"$#3$"$#0"@"3-4"9"E/+/,-+",H"3"(/40.F"4/+$1/;5$04"#,./-0++" 310" $#0" 10+5.$" ,H" 7103$/E0" /--,E3$/,-" 3-4" 3"L,E0" $,J(314" 3" 2103$01" 402100" ,H" 023./$31/3-/+L" $#3-" 0E0-" C01L3-"#/L+0.H"0-E/+/,-+A"3-"023./$31/3-/+L"$#3$"+$1/%+"$#0"%1/0+$#,,4",H"3$" .03+$" +,L0" ,H" /$+" %1/E/.020)" _6$" +0E013." %,/-$+A" C01L3-" 37JX-,(.0420+" 3"%1/E/.0204"%1/0+$#,,4" 3+" $#0"L3*,1" 0<70%$/,-" $,"#/+" $#0+/+A" $#,52#"#0"4,0+"-,$"0<%.,10"%1/0+$.F"%1/E/.020" /-"40J$3/.)c^b" DH" K<,4" !a&^A" 3" $0<$" L0-$/,-04" ;F" C01L3-" 3$" +0E013."%,/-$+A"/+"/-4004"3"@"+5%%.0L0-$"$,"K<,4"!a"3+"G,$#"3-4",$#J01+" #3E0" L3/-$3/-04A" /$" 2,0+" 3" +$0%" H51$#01" $#3-" @05$" !Z&RA"0-E/+/,-/-2" D+130." -,$" ,-.F" 3+" 3" U#,.F" -3$/,-V! " bA" ;5$"3.+,"3+"3"UX/-24,L",H"%1/0+$+V"_ b)ch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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""cZ" :00" H51$#01" :35."B)"M.F3-A"-:&$E( %='(-%=<4(5:$#%#>8N( :=( 9:;,:>%,(

-$G#$E$=&%&:6=E(6C("+,&"_Q1/-70$,-&"Q1/-70$,-"N-/E)"Q10++A"R```bA"RhmW\A",-"#,./-0++"3-4"%1/E/.020"/-"20-013.A"3-4"RcmW`",-"G5L"!^&!m!h&\"/-"%31$/75.31)"

c\"3$Y:&:>+E( UbUk" _6CA" Wi" G0(" S,1X&" @,5;.043FA" !aa!bA" ^c^mchA"^aZ)" O,1" 71/$/Y50A" +00"LF"-:&$E( %='(-%=<A" !R!mRRA" 3-4" !hWmhZA" -)" W)"=#0" +3L0" /4/,L" /+" 5+04" 7,-701-/-2" $#0" +3-7$531F" /-" >0E" R!&RW" 3-4"7,-701-/-2"$#0"%1/0+$#,,4"/-"RR&a"_7H)"R!&cbA";,$#",H"(#/7#"310"+3-7$/JH/04)""

c^""#$%&$'()*+%,A"^A"^hm^c"H,1"0<3L%.0)"ch"M-" K<,4" !a&^" 3+" 3"@" +5%%.0L0-$A" +00A" 0)2)A"B31$/-"G,$#A".(

5:E&6#N(6C(?$=&%&$+>8%,(/#%':&:6=E" _$13-+)"C)"P)"6-401+,-i"I#/7,A"I3./H))&":7#,.31+"Q10++A"!ac!bA"W!A"-)"!!R)":00"3.+,"P/../3L"9)"I)"Q1,%%A"(#,"31250+"/-"7,-$13+$"$,"L0"$#3$"@05$"!Z&RmR!"/+"3"7,LL0-$31F",-"K<,4"!a&\m^"_)[6'+E(URbdW"d6CA"R3i"G0("S,1X&"@,5;.043FA"R``^eA"!\cb)"

Page 38: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

Wc"

C01L3-" 37X-,(.0420+" $#3$" (,L0-" 3-4" H,10/2-01+" 310"%51%,+0.F" -,$" /-" #/+" %51E/0(" /-" $#/+" +$54FA" 3-4" *5+$/H/0+" $#0/1"0<7.5+/,-"H1,L"7,-+/4013$/,-";F"+5220+$/-2"/L%./7/$.F"$#3$"$#0F"310"-,$"/-7.5404"/-"$#0"U7,10"D+130./$0"7/$/g0-1F",H"H100"%01+,-+AV"$#0"21,5%",H"/-$010+$"$,"#/L)cc"D-"LF"E/0(A"$#0FA"3+"(0.."3+"%01J+,-+"(/$#"4/+3;/./$/0+"_3"73$02,1F"/2-,104";F"C01L3-bA",52#$"$,"#3E0";00-"/-7.5404)"G,$";0735+0",H"$#0"0</20-7/0+",H"%,./$/73."7,1107$-0++A" 3-4" -,$" ;0735+0" ,H" $#0" /-7103+/-2" /-$010+$" ,H" $#0"H/0.4"_3-4",51".31201"+,7/0$/0+b"/-"/++50+",H"20-401A"4/+3;/./$FA"3-4"$#0" 7,-+$157$/,-" ,H" $#0" 3./0-" ,$#01A" ;5$" ;0735+0" 3" -5L;01" ,H"Q0-$3$057#3." $0<$+" ,H" 2103$" /-$010+$" $," C01L3-j/-" %31$/75.31A"$#0";,,X",H"@05$01,-,LFj/-7.540"(,L0-"3-4"10+/40-$"3./0-+":=( &8$( >6Y$=%=&( >6FF+=:&N" 0<%./7/$.FA" 3-4" 34410++" $#0" %.370" ,H" 3$".03+$"+,L0"%01+,-+"(/$#"4/+3;/./$/0+"/-"$#3$"7,LL5-/$F)"DH"C01JL3-]+"H,75+"/+"U3"7,10"D+130./$0"7/$/g0-1F",H"H100"%01+,-+V"3+"#0"+$3$0+A"3-4"(,L0-A"10+/40-$"3./0-+"3-4"%01+,-+"(/$#"4/+3;/./$/0+"310" %31$" ,H" $#3$" U7,10" 7/$/g0-1FV" /-" $#3$" $#0F" 310" %31$" ,H" $#0"7,E0-3-$" 7,LL5-/$F" 377,14/-2" $," 3$" .03+$" +,L0" $0<$+A" $#0/1"$103$L0-$"+#,5.4";0"7,-+/40104"/-"3";,,X"$#3$"+00X+"$,"7,-$13+$"$#0"+,7/,J%,./$/73."E/+/,-",H"$#0"Q0-$3$057#"(/$#"$#3$",H"D+130.]+"-0/2#;,1+"(/$#"10+%07$"$,"$#0"U7,10"7/$/g0-1F)V"

D"(/.." ;02/-"(/$#" %01+,-+"(/$#" 4/+3;/./$/0+)"@05$" RW&R" 0<J7.540+" L0-" (/$#" $(," $F%0+" ,H" 20-/$3." 43L320" H1,L" 0E01"0-$01/-2" $#0" U6++0L;.F" ,H"S#(#AV" 3-" ,%3Y50" 0<%10++/,-" 5-J401+$,,4";F" $#0"031./0+$" /-$01%10$01+",H"@05$"RW&RJaA" $#0" .31201"$0<$",H"(#/7#"RW&R"H,1L+"3"%31$A"$,"10H01"$,"$#0"8015+3.0L"$0LJ%.0" _0)2)A" >3L" !&!`b)ca" :,A" H,1" $#0" +3X0" ,H" 3125L0-$A" .0$" 5+"3++5L0" $#3$" 0-$01/-2" $#0" 3++0L;.F" ,H" S#(#" L03-+" +0751/-2"3770++" $," $#0" +3-7$531F" 377,14/-2" $," @05$" RW&R)" Q01L3-0-$"0<7.5+/,-" H1,L" S#(#]+" $0L%.0" 0HH07$/E0.F" +$/2L3$/g0+" $#,+0"D+130./$0"L3.0+"(#,"310"+,"%1,+71/;04A"73+$/-2"$#0L"3+"5-(,1J$#F",H"%10+0-$/-2"$#0L+0.E0+";0H,10"S#(#A"3"10Y5/10L0-$"$#100"$/L0+"%01"F031"H,1"3.."L3.0+"377,14/-2"$,"@05$"!^&!^A"3+"C01L3-"#/L+0.H" #3+" 0L%#3+/g04)" D$" 3.+," 0HH07$/E0.F"L312/-3./g0+" $#0L)"=#3$"$#0"S#(#",H"@05$01,-,LF"/+"3.+,"-,$"%31$/75.31.F"H,-4",H"$#0"+371/H/7/3."3-/L3."(/$#"3"%#F+/73."40H07$"_ b"+57#"3+"20-/$3."43L320"/+"-,$"(/$#,5$"+/2-/H/73-70)":57#"3-"3-/L3."/+"0<7.5404"H1,L"+371/H/70"3-4"10H01104"$,"3+"3-"U3;,L/-3$/,-",H"S#(#V"/-"@05$" !h&!A" +$1,-2A"#/2#.F" +$/2L3$/g/-2" 1#0$,1/7)" D$"(,5.4" +00L"$#3$"@05$"!h&!"+5220+$+" /-4/107$.F" $#3$"S#(#]+"3$$/$540" $,(314"$#0" L3-" (/$#" 20-/$3." 43L320" L/2#$" (0.." ;0" $#0" +3L0)" :57#"0-E/+/,-04" +,7/3."L312/-3./g3$/,-"3-4" +$/2L3$/g3$/,-",H"701$3/-"H100" D+130./$0"L3.0+" +5220+$+" 3" E/+/,-" ,H" +,7/3." :=$*+%,:&N" /-" $#0";,,X" ,H"@05$01,-,LF" $#3$" 2,0+"(0.." ;0F,-4"(#3$0E01" %1/E/J.020+" $#0" @05$01,-,L/7" %1/0+$#,,4" L/2#$" %,++0++" E/+JnJE/+",$#01" D+130./$0+)" =#5+A" /H" 4/+3;/./$F" /+" /-$1,45704" 3+" 3-" 3</+" ,H"3-3.F+/+A"2/E/-2"5+"3";1,3401"%01+%07$/E0",-",51"0E/40-70A"@05J$01,-,LF]+"+,7/3."E/+/,-"3%%031+".0++"023./$31/3-"3-4"$#0"+,7/0$F"0-E/+/,-04".0++"#,L,20-0,5+"$#3-"C01L3-"+5220+$+)"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""cc""#$%&$'()*+%,A"!Wm!Z)"ca" >3$01"L3$01/3.+" 0E/40-70" $#0" /-$01L311/320" /-$01%10$3$/,-A" 0)2)A"

G0#"!W&!mW)"

Page 39: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Wa"

DH"(0" $51-" $,"9]+"%1/0+$.F" .3(+" /-">0E"R!&!hJRWA"4/+3;/./$F"0L0120+" 3+" 3" %#0-,L0-,-" %1,457/-2" +$3$5+" 4/HH010-$/3$/,-"7:&8:=" $#0"13-X+",H" $#0"%1/0+$#,,4A" H,1" $#0"%1/0+$"(/$#"3"40H07$"_ b" /+" 0<7.5404" H1,L" 3.$31" +01E/70" 3-4" #3+" $#0" %,$0-$/3." $,"%1,H3-0" $#0" +3-7$531F" +#,5.4" #0" 3$$0L%$" $," ,HH01" +371/H/70+" 3$"$#0"3.$31)"=#,52#"$#0"%1/0+$"(/$#"3"40H07$"+$/.."#3+"3770++"$,"$#0"+3-7$531F"+%#010"3-4"73-"03$"#,.F"H,,4+A"$#0"10+$1/7$/,-+"%.3704",-"#/+"1/$53."37$/E/$F"3-4"#/+"%,$0-$/3."$,"%1,H3-0"$#0"+3-7$531F"0HH07$/E0.F"+$/2L3$/g0+"#/LA"73+$/-2"#/L"3+"3"+07,-4J7.3++"L0LJ;01" ,H" #/+" 0./$0" ./-0320)" >/X0" 7,LL,-" D+130./$0"L3.0+A" #0"L3F"-,$" ,HH01" +371/H/70+" 3$" $#0" 3.$31i" ./X0" #/+" H0..,(" %1/0+$+A" 3-4" /-"7,-$13+$" $," 7,LL,-" D+130./$0" L3.0+A" #0" L3F" -,-0$#0.0++" 03$"#,.F" H,,4+)" Q1/0+$.F" %1/E/.020" /$+0.H" /+" $#010H,10" -,$" 0Y53..F"+#3104"377,14/-2" $,">0E"R!&!hJRWi" 13$#01A"3"#/01317#F",H"%1/E/J.020" /+"+5220+$04";F"$#0"+$/2L3$/g/-2"10+$1/7$/,-+"%.3704",-"$#0"%1/0+$"(/$#" 3" 40H07$A" 10+$1/7$/,-+"(#/7#" 10-401" #/L" -,$" 5-./X0"$#0" -,-J%1/0+$.F" %,%5.3$/,-" /-" 701$3/-" 10+%07$+)" =#5+A" $#010" /+"/-0Y53./$F"0E0-"(/$#/-"$#0"13-X+",H"$#0"%1/0+$#,,4"377,14/-2"$,">0E"R!&!hJRWA"+5220+$/-2",-70"323/-" $#3$"C01L3-]+"E/+/,-",H"3"%1/E/.0204A"Q0-$3$057#3."%1/0+$.F"0./$0"10Y5/10+"2103$01"-53-70)"D"L/2#$" 3.+," 344" $#3$" 4/+$/-25/+#/-2" +,5170+" /-" $#0" Q0-$3$057#"3..,(+"5+" $,"7,L%310"3-4"7,-$13+$" $#0" $103$L0-$",H"L0-"(/$#"20-/$3."43L320"/-"@05$"RW&R"3-4"%1/0+$+"(/$#"20-/$3."43L320"/-">0E"R!&!a&"P#/.0"@05$"RW&R"34E,73$0+"3"20-013.A"#/2#.F"+$/2L3J$/g/-2" 0<7.5+/,-" ,H" D+130./$0" L3.0+" (/$#" 20-/$3." 43L320A" ./X0.F"H1,L"$#0"+3-7$531FA">0E"R!&!hJRW"4,0+"-,$";3-"$#0"%1/0+$"(/$#"20-/$3." 43L320" H1,L" $#0" $0L%.0" +%#010A" 3+" D" #3E0" 4/+75++04)"=#5+A" 4/+$/-25/+#/-2" +,5170+" ,-70" 323/-" 3..,(+" 5+" 3770++" $," 3"E31/0$F" ,H" E/0(%,/-$+"(/$#/-" $#0" Q0-$3$057#" $#3$" #3E0" /L%,1J$3-$"/L%./73$/,-+"H,1"3-F"+$54F",H"0Y53./$F"3-4"/-0Y53./$F)"

:,L0"Q0-$3$057#3."$0<$+"+00L"$,"0<7.540"(,L0-"3-4"10+J/40-$"3./0-+"H1,L"$#0"%0,%.0",H"D+130."(#,"0-$01"$#0"7,E0-3-$)"6-",H$"-,$04"0<3L%.0" /+"K<,4"!a&!\A"(#/7#" +%03X+",H" 3-",;JE/,5+.F" 3..JL3.0" A" $#0" L0L;01+" ,H" (#/7#" +#,5.4" -,$" #3E0"+0<53."7,-$37$"(/$#"(,L0-"3+"$#0F"%10%310"H,1"$#0/1"0-7,5-$01"(/$#" S#(#)" D-" 7,-$13+$A" $#0" " ,H" @05$" W!&!!J!R" 0<%./7/$.F":=>,+'$E" (,L0-" 3-4" 3.+," 10+/40-$" 3./0-+A" (#," 310" ,;./23$04" $,"#031A" .031-" 3-4" %01H,1L" S#(#]+" 7,LL3-4L0-$+&" U6++0L;.0"$#0" %0,%.0A" $#0"L0-A" $#0" (,L0-A" 3-4" $#0" 7#/.410-A" 3-4" F,51"10+/40-$" 3./0-"(#," /+" /-" F,51" $,(-+A" /-" ,1401" $#3$" $#0F"L/2#$"#031" 3-4" /-" ,1401" $#3$" $#0F"L/2#$" .031-" 3-4" 10E010-70" S#(#"F,51"2,4A"3-4";0"7310H5."$,"4,"3.."$#0"(,14+",H"$#/+"$037#/-2)V"@05$" Ra&aJ!R" /+" +/L/.31)" 9010A" (/E0+A" 7#/.410-A" 10+/40-$" 3./0-+"3-4" 0E0-" +.3E0+A" (#," 310" %10+5L3;.F" ,H" H,10/2-" ,1/2/-A" 0-$01"S#(#]+" 7,E0-3-$" 3.,-2"(/$#" H100"L3.0" D+130./$0+A" 310" 7,5-$04"3L,-2" $#,+0" (#," ;07,L0" #/+" U%0,%.0V" 3+" 3" 10+5.$A" 3-4" 310"+5;*07$" $," 7,E0-3-$" 751+0+)a`" [/E0-" $#0" /-7.5+/,-" ,H" (,L0-A"10+/40-$"3./0-+"3-4A"/-"$#0"73+0",H"@05$"Ra&!`A"0E0-"+.3E0+"%10J+5L3;.F" ,H" H,10/2-" ,1/2/-A" /-" $#0" 7,E0-3-$" 7,LL5-/$F"377,14/-2"$,"3"$0<$"+57#"3+"@05$01,-,LFA"/$"/+"+$1/X/-2"$,"-,$0"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""a`"=#0"%3/104"0<%10++/,-+"U#0(01",H"(,,4V"3-4"U413(01",H"(3$01V"

,7751"0.+0(#010"(/$#"10H010-70"$,"H,10/2-"+.3E0+"_8,+#"a&R!A"RWA"Rhb)"

Page 40: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

Z`"

$#0"402100",H"/-$137,LL5-3."/-0Y53./$F"0-E/+/,-04";F"$#3$"$0<$)"B3-Fj$#,52#"-,$" 3..j",H" $#0" .3(+",H"@05$01,-,LF"310" 34J410++04"$,"3"L3+75./-0"+/-25.31"UF,5AV"(#/7#"C01L3-"/-$01%10$+"3$"$/L0+"3+"10H011/-2"$,"$#0"7,LL5-/$F"3+"3"(#,.0A"3-4"3$"$/L0+"3+" 10H011/-2" $," $#0" /-4/E/453." 7,LL,-" D+130./$0"L3.0)a!" C5$" /$"73-" ;0" +#,(-" H3/1.F" 7,-E/-7/-2.F" $#3$" $#/+" L3+75./-0" +/-25.31"UF,5V"/+",H$0-A"/H"-,$"3.(3F+A"$#0"#034",H"#,5+0#,.4A",1"0.401A"3+"/-"@05$" !^&!!A" !Z&" US,5" +#3.." 10*,/70" ;0H,10"S#(#" F,51" 2,4A"F,5A" F,51" +,-A" F,51" 4352#$01A" F,51" L3.0" +.3E0A" F,51" H0L3.0"+.3E0A" 3-4" $#0" >0E/$0" (#," /+" /-" F,51" $,(-+A" 3-4" $#0" 10+/40-$"3./0-A" $#0" H3$#01.0++" %01+,-A" 3-4" $#0" (/4,(" (#," 310" /-" F,51"L/4+$pV"=#/+"UF,5V" /+"%1/E/.0204";F";0/-2"34410++04"4/107$.FA"(#010",$#01+"310"+%,X0-",H"/-"$#0"$#/14"%01+,-)"=#/+"UF,5V"3.+,"#3+"1/$53."%1/E/.020+)"D-"@05$"R^&!RJ!ZA" /$" /+"#0"(#,"4/+$1/;5$0+"$#0" $/$#0" $," $#0" >0E/$0A" 10+/40-$" 3./0-A" H3$#01.0++" %01+,-" 3-4"(/4,(A" 3-4" 7,-H0++0+" #/+" 7,-H,1L/$F" $," S#(#]+" 7,LL3-4JL0-$+" ;0H,10"S#(#)" D$" /+" $#1,52#" +57#" 1/$53." 320-7F" $#3$" $#0"0.401]+"%1/E/.0204" +$3$5+" /+" 7103$04"3-4"%01%0$53$04A" *5+$" 3+" $#0"%1/0+$]+" +$3$5+" E/+JnJE/+" ,$#01+" /+" 0+$3;./+#04" 3-4" 7,-H/1L04"$#1,52#"#/+"%1/E/.0204" 1/$53." 37$+)aR"=#0" 0.401"4,0+" $#0" $3.X/-2"H,1"$#0"#,5+0#,.4" /-"@05$"R^&!RJ!Zi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b)"M$#01"L3.0+" ,H" $#0" #,5+0J#,.4A";,$#"/LL3$510"3-4"L3$510A"310"3.+,".37X/-2"$#0"%1/E/.0204"+$3$5+",H"$#0"0.401)"=#5+A"/$"L/2#$";0";0+$"$,"+%03X",H"3"10.3$/E0"023./$31/3-/+L" 0-E/+/,-04" 3L,-2"#034+" ,H" #,5+0#,.4"(#," 310"H100" ,H" 20-/$3." 43L320" 13$#01" $#3-" $," +%03X" ,H" 3" E/+/,-" ,H" U3"+/-2.0A"5-/H,1L.F"0L%,(0104A"#,L,20-0,5+"7.3++AV"3+"C01L3-"4,0+)"

=#010"/+"L57#"L,10"$,"+3F"3;,5$"0Y53./$F"3-4"/-0Y53./$F"3+"0-E/+/,-04";F"$#0"+,5170+",H"$#0"Q0-$3$057#A"3-4"3;,5$"4/HH01J0-70+"/-"$#0"+,7/,J%,./$/73."E/+/,-+",H"Q0-$3$057#3."$0<$+",-"$#0",-0"#3-4A"3-4"-,-JD+130./$0"L3$01/3.+",-" $#0",$#01)" D"#3E0"H,J75+04"LF"7,LL0-$+",-"$#0"H,1L01A"3-4"3.+,"0L%#3+/g04"/++50+",H" 20-401" 3-4" 4/+3;/./$F)" D-" 7,-7.5+/,-A" #,(0E01A" D]4" ./X0" $,"L0-$/,-"/-"%3++/-2"3"H0("(0.."X-,(-"0<3L%.0+",H"-,-JD+130./$0"20-401J;3+04" +,7/3." %137$/70+" $#3$" +5220+$" 3" 2103$01" 402100" ,H"0Y53./$F";0$(00-"$#0"+0<0+"$#3-",-0"H/-4+"/-"$#0"+,7/,J%,./$/73."E/+/,-+",H"Q0-$3$057#3."$0<$+&"4/E,170"/-"K2F%$"3-4",773+/,-3..F"/-"P0+$"6+/3A"(#/7#"73-";0"/-/$/3$04";F"(,L0-"3+"(0.."3+"L0-i"3"%1/0+$#,,4"$#3$" /-7.540+"(,L0-A"3+" /-"Q#,0-/7/3-"3-4",$#01"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

a!"O,1"$#0"L3+75./-0"+/-25.31"UF,5V"3+"3"10H010-70"$,"$#0"7,LL5J-/$F" 3+" 3" (#,.0A" +00" "#$%&$'( )*+%,A" ^`i" H,1" UF,5V" 3+" $#0" /-4/E/453."7,LL,-"D+130./$0"L3.0A"+00"/;/4)A"c`A";F"/L%./73$/,-)"

aR"M-" 1/$0+" 7103$/-2" 3-4"%01%0$53$/-2" +,7/3." +$3$5+0+A" +00"LF"4/+J75++/,-" /-" 9:;,:>%,( P6+#=:=A4( -:&+%,( %='( D6>:%,( 0:F$=E:6=E" _M<H,14&"M<H,14"N-/E)"Q10++A"R``ZbA"Z"-)"h)"

Page 41: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Z!"

B04/$0113-03-"3-4"P0+$"6+/3-"75.$+i"3-4"7,LL,-%.370"H0L3.0",(-01+#/%",H" 3-4" $1340" /-" .3-404"%1,%01$FA" 0)2)A" 3$"G5g/)aW" D-"+#,1$A" (#0-" 20-401" /+" ;1,52#$" /-$," H5.." 7,-+/4013$/,-A" $#0" E/J+/,-+",H"0Y53./$F" /-"Q0-$3$057#3." $0<$+"4,"-,$"3%%031" $,";0"+,"5-/Y50.F"%1,210++/E0"3H$01"3..)" "

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""aW"O,1"(,L0-"/-/$/3$/-2"4/E,170" /-"K2F%$A"+00A"0)2)A"=011F"[)"P/.J

H,-2A" UB311/320" 3-4" @/E,170AV" /-" @)" ?04H,14" _04)b" /8$( \[C6#'()=>N>,6G$':%(6C(.=>:$=&()ANG&O()@-$C$#$=>$()':&:6=(_M<H,14&"M<H,14"N-/E)"Q10++A" R``!A" R``\b)" C1,(-"N-/E)"@07)" cA" R``a)" #$$%&''(((),<H,14J3-7/0-$02F%$)7,L'0-$1Fo0-$1Fw$!h^)0`ZW`)"M-"(,L0-" 3+" %1/0+$0++0+"3-4",$#01"75.$/7"H5-7$/,-31/0+"/-"B0+,%,$3L/3"3-4":F1/3A"+00A"0)2)A"9)"8)"B31+L3-A"Z6F$=(:=(2A%#:&(%='(ME#%$,4(/8$:#(D6>:%,(%='(-$,:A:6+E(?6E:&:6=(:=(&8$("6=&$[&(6C(&8$(.=>:$=&(X$%#()%E&"_>0/40-&"C1/..A"R``WbA"ZcamaW)"O,1"(,L0-"3-4" $#0/1" 10.3$/,-+#/%" $," .3-404"%1,%01$F" 3$"G5g/A" +00"B)"Q)"B3/4L3-A"U=#0":$3$5+",H"O100"P,L0-"3$"G5g/AV"/-"".X)"R&aZZmZ\)"

Page 42: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

ZR"

?$@;0M7F0;Q$!-@;;$M7AF!0$7L$:;!-7G787RE$

8M:9N6"6)"CK?B6G"C6?JD>6G"NGDTK?:D=S"

BF" H/1+$" 3-4" L,+$" /L%,1$3-$" 10+%,-+0" $," :5+3-" 67X01L3-A"G,1L3-" [,$$(3.4A" 3-4" :35." M.F3-A" /+" 3" 400%.F" H0.$" 40;$" ,H"$#3-X+"H,1"/-E0+$/-2"+,"L57#"$/L0"3-4"0-012F"/-"$#0/1"10E/0(",H"LF"(,1XA" 3-4" H,1" 344/-2" +,"L3-F" +$/L5.3$/-2"71/$/Y50+" $," $#0"4/+75++/,-)" D" (/+#" 3.+," $," $#3-X" C01-314" >0E/-+,-A" (#,+0"7,LL0-$+"H1,L"$#0":C>"%3-0."310"3%%031/-2"3+"%31$",H"3".31201"10E/0(" 0++3FA" /-" $#0" B6+#=%,( 6C( /8$6,6A:>%,( D&+':$E" ^!&R" _M7$,;01"R`!`b)"Q1,H)">0E/-+,-"#3+"2137/,5+.F"0-7,513204"L0"$,"5+0"$#/+"H,15L"$,"10+%,-4"$,"#/+"71/$/Y50)"P#/.0"L3-F"/-$010+$/-2"%,/-$+"#3E0" ;00-" 13/+04" /-" $#0+0" 7,LL0-$+" D]4" ./X0" $," 404/73$0" LF"10+%,-+0"$,"$#100"/++50+A"(#010".31201"Y50+$/,-+",H"L0$#,4,.,J2F"310"3$"+$3X0)"

G?!AFR$!-;$!;K!0$7L$!-;$M;F!?!;9B-Q$B7FL@7F!AFR$!-;$B7:M8;KA!E$

C01-314" >0E/-+,-" 3+$5$0.F" /40-$/H/0+" 3" 4,5;.0J+$3-4314" /-" LF"(,1X&" (#0-" D" ;1/-2" /-$," $#0" 4/+75++/,-" 3-" 0%/213%#/7" +,5170"H1,L"$#0"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$A"D"4/+75++"(#010"$#0"$0<$"(3+"H,5-4"3-4"2/E0"3-",E01E/0(",H"$#0"+7#,.31+#/%"7,-701-/-2"/$+"#/+$,1/J73."+0$$/-2)"S0$A"(#0-"D"(,1X"(/$#"3"$0<$"H1,L"$#0"Q0-$3$057#A"$#3$" 4/+75++/,-" /+" ,L/$$04)" D" L5+$" 34L/$" $#3$" D" 3L" 25/.$F" 3+"7#31204)"=#0"4/7#,$,LF"D" 0L%.,FA" #,(0E01A" /+" 41/E0-";F"L0J$#,4,.,2/73." 7,-701-+)" D" 34410++" $#/+" /++50" H/1+$A" ;0735+0" D";0./0E0"$#3$"$#0"7,L%.0</$/0+",H"43$/-2"$0<$+j3-4",51"H3/.510"$,"H13-X.F"34L/$"$#,+0"4/HH/75.$/0+j310",-0",H"$#0"(03X0+$"3+%07$+",H",51"4/+7/%./-0"3+"/$"/+"%137$/704"$,43F)"

P0" 310" 7,LL/$$04" $," $(,"L0$#,4,.,2/73." 73../-2+)"6+" /+"$#0" 73+0" H,1" +7#,.31+" /-" 3-F" H/0.4A" (0" 310" 73..04" $," %5$" H,1$#"3125L0-$+" ,-.F" $," $#0" 402100" $#3$" $#0F" 310" +5%%,1$04" ;F" $#0"0E/40-70)" P0" L3F" ,HH01" 7,-*07$510" ,1" +%075.3$/,-" (#010" $#0"0E/40-70"/+"(03XA";5$"(#0-"(0"4,"+,A"$#3$"0E/40-$/31F"(03X-0++"L5+$";0"H,1$#1/2#$.F"37X-,(.04204)"6$"$#0"+3L0"$/L0A"3+";/;./7J/+$+A"(0" 310" 73..04" $," 0<3L/-0" $#0" $0<$+"(0"(,1X"(/$#" /-" $#0/1"#/+$,1/73."3-4"+,7/3."+0$$/-2)"D$"/+"71/$/73."$#3$"(0"107,2-/g0"$#3$"$#0+0"$(,"73../-2+"L5+$";0"%51+504"/-"3"%1/,1/$/g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

Page 43: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

ZW"

+0$$/-2"(0"$,,",H$0-"7,L%1,L/+0",-"$#0"H/1+$"73../-2&"$,",HH01"3"+%07/H/7"43$0"H,1"3"$0<$",-.F"(#0-"$#0"0E/40-70"H,1" /$" /+"+$1,-2"3-4"5-3L;/25,5+)"

D-",HH01/-2"$#/+"71/$/Y50",H"LF"(,1XA"Q1,H)">0E/-+,-"$3X0+"3+"3"%31340"0<3L%.0"$#0"+$,1F",H"$#0"10+750",H"B,+0+"/-"K<,4"R&!J!`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hRRJh`\"C)I)K)b)"

D]4"./X0"$,"H,..,(">0E/-+,-]+".034A"3-4"4,"$#0"H5.."L3$#A"3+"/$" (010A" ,H" $#0" 7,-+/4013$/,-+" $#3$" -004" $," ;0" $3X0-" /-$," 37J7,5-$" $," +07510.F"43$0" $#0"K<,45+" $0<$" /-" ./2#$",H" $#0":312,-"377,5-$)"@,/-2"+,A" D";0./0E0A"(/.."(0.." /..5+$13$0" *5+$"#,("4/HH/J75.$" /$" /+"H,1"5+"$,"43$0"$#0"$0<$+"(0"(,1X"(/$#A"0E0-"(#0-"(0"#3E0" /-"#3-4"3"%.35+/;.0"%1,%,+/$/,-A"3+" /+" $#0",-0"$#3$">0E/-J+,-"%1,%,+0+)"

=,"0-2320"/-"$#/+"0<3L/-3$/,-A"D"3L"2,/-2"$,"0L%.,F"3"40J2100" ,H" 31$/H/70)" P0" X-,(" H1,L" #/2#" +7#,,." L3$#A" $#3$"%1,;3;/./$/0+" 310" 7,L%,5-404)"=#3$" /+A" /H" $#0" ./X0./#,,4",H" 3-"0E0-$"40%0-4+",-A"+3FA"H/E0A"H37$,1+A"$#0-"(0"L5+$"7,L%5$0"$#0"./X0./#,,4",H"037#"H37$,1A"3-4"L5.$/%.F" $#0LA" H,1"3" H/-3."40$01JL/-3$/,-" ,H" %1,;3;/./$F)" P31-/-2&" ;/;./7/+$+" 5-$13/-04" /-"+$3$/+$/7+" _+57#" 3+" $#0" %10+0-$" (1/$01yb" +#,5.4" +$3F" 3(3F" H1,L"-5L;01+A"3-4"7,L%5$/-2" $#0" ./X0./#,,4",H"3-F$#/-2" /-";/;./73."+$54/0+"(/$#"Y53-$/$3$/E0"3775137F" /+" +510.F" 3-" /L%,++/;.0" $3+X)"G,-0$#0.0++A"D"3+X"$#0"103401]+"/-45.20-70)"KE0-"/H"D"3L"(/.4.F"L/+$3X0-" /-"LF"H/2510+A" $#0"0<017/+0A" D"#,%0"(/.."%1,E0"3-" /LJ%,1$3-$"%,/-$"-,-0$#0.0++)"

O,1" $#0"+3X0",H"3125L0-$A"3$" $#0",5$+0$A"D"3L"3++/2-/-2"3"!``z" 701$3/-$F" $," $#0" 7.3/L" $#3$" $#0" K<,45+" 377,5-$" /+" ;,1J1,(04"H1,L"$#0"B0+,%,$3L/3-"377,5-$A"3-4"(3+"7,L%,+04"/-"$#0" .3$0" 0/2#$#" 70-$51F)" O1,L" #010A" (0"L,E0" $," 7,-+/401" $#0"L/$/23$/-2"H37$,1+)"

>0$" 5+" ;02/-" ;F" +715$/-/g/-2" $#0" +0751/$F" (/$#" (#/7#" (0"L3F"3++/2-"$#0":312,-"377,5-$"$,"$#0" .3$0"0/2#$#"70-$51F)":31J2,-",H"6XX34"_7)"RW``"C)I)K)b"(3+"$#0"H/1+$"2103$"7,-Y501,1",H"B0+,%,$3L/3"3-4"0+$3;./+#04"3"E3+$"0L%/10)""=#0"+$,1/0+",H"#/+"0+73%340+"7,-$/-504"$,";0"$,.4"H,1"$(,"$#,5+3-4"F031+"3H$01"#/+"40L/+0A"-,$",-.F"/-"B0+,%,$3L/3";5$"/-"6-3$,./3"3-4"/-"K2F%$"3+"(0..)"9/+"-3L0"/+"L0-$/,-04"/-"/-+71/%$/,-+A",L0-+A"#/+$,1/J73." $0<$+A" /-" :5L01/3-A" 6XX34/3-A" 9/$$/$0" 3-4" %01#3%+" 3.+," /-"9511/3-)aZ"P/$#"$#0"%,++/;.0"0<70%$/,-",H"[/.23L0+#A"#/+"%,+/J$/,-" /+"5-1/E3.04"(/$#/-" $#0" ./$0131F" $134/$/,-",H"B0+,%,$3L/3-"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""aZ"C1/3-">0(/+A"/8$(D%#A6=(3$A$='4(.(D&+'N(6C(&8$(.<<%':%=(/$[&(%='(

&8$( /%,$( 6C( &8$( 5$#6( Z86( Z%E( )[G6E$'( %&( 9:#&8" _I3L;1/420A" B3++)&"6:M?A"!ac`bA"!R\)"

Page 44: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

ZZ"

#/+$,1/,213%#F)a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a`z)"

C5$"%01#3%+"3".3$01"43$0"H,1"$#0":312,-"$0<$"+#,5.4";0"34J45704)"P0"#3E0" /-",51"%,++0++/,-" $#100" H132L0-$+",H"$#0" $0<$"H1,L"6+#51;3-/%3.]+"./;131F)"6"H,51$#"H132L0-$A"#,(0E01A"43$0+"H1,L"$#0"G0,JC3;F.,-/3-"%01/,4)a^"=,"+5220+$"0/2#$#J",1"031.F"+0E0-$#J70-$51F" /-H.50-70A" (,5.4" 10Y5/10" 5+" $," %,+/$" $#3$" $#0"10.3$/E0.F" +L3.."-5L;01",H"+71/;0+",H" 8543#"(010" H3L/./31"(/$#"$#0" ./$0131F" 7,1%5+" ,H" 6+#51;3-/%3.]+" ./;131F)" " 610" (0" 701$3/-"$#3$" +57#" 3770++" (3+" 0E0-" %,++/;.0o" S0$A" 451/-2" $#0" G0,JC3;F.,-/3-"%01/,4A"(/$#"L,+$",H"8543#"/-"0</.0A"L3-F"%3$#+",H"/-H.50-70"7,5.4"#3E0"40E0.,%04)"C5$".0$"5+"+3F"$#3$"$#/+"+70-3J1/,A"$,,A"/+"5-./X0.F)">0$"5+"+3F"$#3$"(0"7,-+/401"/$"H,51"$/L0+"3+"./X0.F" $#3$" 8543#]+" 0<%,+510" $," $#0" :312,-" .020-4" (3+" /-" $#0"0/2#$#"70-$51F)"=#/+"L03-+"$#3$"(0"3++/2-"/$"3-"c`z"%1,;3;/./$F)"I,L%,5-404A",51",1/2/-3."#F%,$#0+/+"-,(";031+"3"hRz"%1,;3J;/./$F)"

G,(" .0$" 5+" 0-$01" $#0" K<,45+" -3113$/E0" /-$," $#0" %/7$510)"=#0" 377,5-$" 10E03.+" +0E013." 4/+$/-7$.F" K2F%$/3-" 3+%07$+)" =#0"(,14+" " _K<,4" R&WA" \b" 3-4" " _R&Wb" 310" K2F%$/3-" .,3-"(,14+A" 3-4" $#0" -3L0"B,+0+" /+" 3.+," ,H" K2F%$/3-" 401/E3$/,-)ah"B,10,E01A"H1,L"$#0"$/L0",H"?3L+0+"uD"_!!$#"7)b"7,L0+"3"107,14",H" 3-"K2F%$/3-"(,L3-"(#,"34,%$04" $#0"7#/.410-",H" 3" H0L3.0"+.3E0"3-4"0L3-7/%3$04"$#0L"$,"L3X0"$#0L"#01"#0/1+)ac"Q01#3%+"3".3$0J+07,-4"L/..0--/5L"K2F%$/3-"/-H.50-70"+#,5.4";0"3445704"H,1",51" $0<$)"C5$" .0$" 5+" +3F" $#3$" $#/+" +70-31/,A" $,,A" /+" 5-./X0.FA"3-4"$#3$"(0"323/-"7,-+/401"/$"H,51"$/L0+"3+"./X0.F"_3-4"#0-70"3-"c`z"%1,;3;/./$Fb"$#3$"$#0"B,+0+"377,5-$"(3+"7,L%,+04"5-401"8543#]+" 0<%,+510" $," $#0" :312,-" .020-4" /-" $#0" 0/2#$#" 70-$51FA"3-4"-,$"/-"K2F%$"H,51"70-$51/0+"031./01)"I,L%,5-404A",51",1/2J/-3."#F%,$#0+/+"-,(";031+"3"\hz"%1,;3;/./$F)"

=#0" B,+0+" 377,5-$" 3.+," ;031+" +$1/X/-2" 10+,-3-70" (/$#".3(+"H,5-4"/-"$#0"%=%(:&&:E8+"$0<$+A";/./-253.":5L01/3-"3-4"6XX3J4/3-"$0<$+"H1,L"$#0"M.4"C3;F.,-/3-"%01/,4"/-"(#/7#"3"7#/.4" /+"H,5-4A"107,2-/g04"3+"3"H,5-4./-2A"40./E0104"$,"3"(0$"-51+0"H,1"3"+0$"(320A"(03-04A" 10$51-04" $,"#/+",(-01A" 3-4" H/-3..F" 34,%$04)"=#0+0" $0<$+" +5220+$" $#3$" H,..,(/-2" $#0" 34,%$/,-A" 3" -0(" +,-"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""a\"D;/4)A"!`a)"a^"D;/4)A"\)"ah"P/../3L"9)"I)"Q1,%%A")[6'+E(UbUc"_6CA"Ri"G0("S,1X&"@,5;.0J

43FA"!aacbA"!Za)"ac"6.3-"9)"[314/-01A"U64,%$/,-"K<$13,14/-31FAV"B6+#=%,(6C()ANG&:%=(

.#>8%$6,6AN"R^"_!aZ`b"RWmRc)"

Page 45: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Z\"

(,5.4";0"2/E0-"3"-3L0)aa"B,10,E01A" $#100",$#01"3-7/0-$"G031"K3+$01-".020-4+",H"+%07/3."7#/.410-";0/-2"+3E04"H1,L"(3$01+"/-"/-H3-7F"#3E0";00-" /40-$/H/04" /-"344/$/,-" $," $#0":312,-" .020-4A"/-7.54/-2" $(," H1,L" $#0" >3$0" C1,-g0"9/$$/$0" KL%/10A!``" 3.." ,H"(#/7#"L/2#$"+5220+$"3"+07,-4"L/..0--/5L"%1,E0-3-70"H,1",51"+$,1F)" C5$" .0$" 5+" +3F" $#3$" $#0" /-H.50-70" ,H" 3-F" ,H" $#0+0A" $,,A"5%,-" $#0"B,+0+" -3113$/E0" /+" 5-./X0.FA" 3-4" $#3$"(0" 7,-+/401" /$"-/-0" $/L0+" 3+" ./X0.F" _3-4" #0-70" 3" a`z" %1,;3;/./$Fb" $#3$" $#0"B,+0+" 377,5-$"(3+" 7,L%,+04" 5-401" 8543#]+" 0<%,+510" $," $#0":312,-".020-4"/-"$#0"0/2#$#"70-$51F)"I,L%,5-404A",51",1/2/-3."#F%,$#0+/+"-,(";031+"3"\!z"%1,;3;/./$F)"

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jL3F;0"$0-+",H"$#,5+3-4+j,H"D+130./$0+"(010"0</.04"03+$"(/$#"$#0"H3..",H":3L31/3A"$#3$"$#0F"$,,X"(/$#"$#0L"$#0/1".020-4+"3+"(0..o"C5$".0$"5+"+3F"$#3$"/$"(3+"H,51"$/L0+"3+"./X0.F"_3-4"#0-70"3-"c`z"%1,;3;/./$Fb"$#3$"85403-"+71/;0+"#34"L3+$01F",H"6+#51J;3-/%3.]+" ./;131FA" 3-4" $#3$" $#0" B,+0+" 377,5-$" (3+" 7,L%,+04"5-401"8543#]+"0<%,+510"$,"$#0":312,-".020-4"/-"$#0"0/2#$#"70-J$51F)" I,L%,5-404A" ,51" ,1/2/-3." #F%,$#0+/+" -,(" ;031+" 3" Z!z"%1,;3;/./$F)"

O/-3..FA".0$"5+"3.+,"7,-+/401"$#0"%,++/;/./$F"$#3$",51"$0<$"(3+"-,$"(1/$$0-"/-",-0"H0.."+(,,%A";5$"5-401(0-$"0<$0-+/E0"04/$/-2A"(/$#" 37710$/,-+" 34404",-" 3$" E31/,5+" +$320+" /-" $#0" D1,-"620j3-4"(#,"4310+"%5$"3"%1,;3;/./$F"%0170-$320",-"$#3$o"

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

>0$"L0" 0L%#3$/73..F" +$3$0" $#3$" D" ;0./0E0" $#3$" /$" /+" 71/$/73."$#3$"(0" .,73$0" ,51" $0<$+"(/$#/-" 3" #/+$,1/73." 3-4" +,7/3." +0$$/-2)"=#0"402100",H"10+,.5$/,-"$#3$"(0"73-"37#/0E0A"#,(0E01A"/+",H$0-",-.F" 3" H5-7$/,-A" ,H" (#3$" /+" #/2#.F" 7,-H./7$/-2" 3-4" 3L;/25,5+"0E/40-70)"6+"D"$1/04"$,"+#,("/-"$#0";,,XA"3..",H"$#0"+,5170+"$#3$"D"#3E0"4/+75++04"#010"310"E3.53;.0"10+,5170+"H,1"5-401+$3-4/-2"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""aa" [0,120" P)" I,3$+A" )[6'+E( UbUc" _[13-4" ?3%/4+&" K014L3-+A"

!aaabA"Rh)"!``" P/../3L" P)" 93..,A" /8$( 966<( 6C( &8$( ?$6G,$" _C8:A" RR\i" 6$.3-$3&"

:7#,.31+"Q10++A"!aa!bA"!W`m!WR)"

Page 46: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

Z^"

$#0"377,5-$",H"$#0"10+750",H"B,+0+)"D-4004A"/$"/+";F"$3X/-2"/-$,"377,5-$" 3.." ,H" $#0" 7,-H./7$/-2" 0E/40-70" $#3$"(0" 20$" $#0" H5..0+$"%/7$510)"P0"#3E0"2,,4"$,,.+"3$",51"4/+%,+3.A"3-4"73-"37#/0E0"3"402100",H"10+,.5$/,-"3;,5$"$#0"3-7/0-$"(,1.4"$#3$"7103$04"$#0+0"$0<$+A" $#3$"(3+"5-/L32/-3;.0" !\`" F031+" 32,)"C5$"(0"L5+$" 3.+,"%1,7004"$,"$#0"$3+X",H"43$/-2"$#0+0"$0<$+"(/$#"$#0"+,;01"107,2-/J$/,-" $#3$"(0" E/0(" $#0L" $#1,52#" 3" $0.0+7,%0" ,H" $#0" #3-4J#0.4"E31/0$FA"-,$"3"95;;.0)"

M$?FG$!-;$-78AF;00$7L$A0@?;8Q$!-;$B7:M8;KA!A;0$7L$H7@WAFR$HA!-$079@B;$B@A!ABA0:$

:35."M.F3-" /+" 701$3/-.F" 7,1107$" /-"-,$/-2" $#3$"(#0-"(0" 10H137$"$#0" $0<$+",H" $#0"Q0-$3$057#" $#1,52#" $#0"%1/+L",H" +,5170"71/$/J7/+LA" -53-70" 3-4" 3" E31/0$F",H" E/0(%,/-$+" 0L0120)"6-4" D" H5..F"3770%$" #/+" $10-7#3-$" ,;+01E3$/,-" $#3$" /-" @05$01,-,LFA" $#0"40H/-/$/,-",H"$#0"7,10"7/$/g0-1F"/+"0<%3-404"$,"/-7.540"10+/40-$"3./0-+" 3-4" +,L0" /-4/E/453.+" (/$#" 4/+3;/./$/0+)" D-4004A" M.F3-]+",(-"(,1X"#3+";1,52#$",5$"L3-F",H" $#0" $0-+/,-+" $#3$" 0</+$" /-"$#0"E31/,5+"Q0-$3$057#3."7,40+"7,-701-/-2"$#0"/-J,5$"+$3$5+",H"E31/,5+"/-4/E/453.+"/-"$#0"D+130./$0"%,./$F)"

BF" /-$0-$/,-A" #,(0E01A"(3+" $," 7,L%310" $#0" $0<$+" ,H" $#0"Q0-$3$057#" $3X0-" $,20$#01j3+" 3" H,10+$" (/$#" L3-F" E31F/-2"$100+j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

D",H$0-"H/-4"(,1X/-2"(/$#"$#0"4,75L0-$31F"#F%,$#0+/+"5-J+3$/+HF/-2",-"$(,"377,5-$+A";,$#",H"(#/7#"310"0<#/;/$04" /-"$#0"+,5170" 71/$/73." 3%%1,37#" $," $#0"{,13#" 10;0../,-" /-"G5L"!^&!J!h&\)" =#0" H/1+$" /+" $#3$" (0..J40E0.,%04" .3F01+" ,H" L03-/-2" $#3$"0L0120"H1,L"1034/-2"3" $0<$"(/$#/-" $#0"-3113$/E0"7,-$/-55L",H"3-"37$53.A"0</+$/-2"$0<$A"$#0"B=A"310"10*07$04"/-"H3E,1",H"3.$01-3J$/E0"L03-/-2+"H,5-4",-.F"/-"$#0"#F%,$#0+/g04"+,5170"$0<$)"M-0",H" $#0" 2103$" 3%%03.+" ,H" +,5170" 71/$/7/+LA" ,H" 7,51+0A" /+" $#3$" /$"3..,(+"5+"$,"L3X0"+0-+0",H"$#0"L3-F" /-7,-+/+$0-7/0+" H,5-4" /-"$#0"Q0-$3$057#";F"+00/-2"$#0L"3+"$#1034+" /-"3"+01/0+",H" .31201A"7,L%0$/-2A"/40,.,2/73."$3%0+$1/0+)"S0$A"+,L0$/L0+A"$,"LF"L/-4A"+,5170" 71/$/7/+L" /L%,+0+" /-$01%10$3$/,-+" $#3$" $#0" $0<$+" 4," -,$"H5..F";031"+,"$#3$"$#,+0"$0<$+"(/.." H/$" $#0" /40,.,2F",H"$#0"#F%,J$#0$/73."+,5170"$,"(#/7#"$#0F"#3E0";00-"3++/2-04)"

>0$"5+"7,-+/401"$#0"73+0"3$"#3-4A"$#0"377,5-$",H"$#0"{,13#"10;0../,-)"O,1"+,5170"71/$/7+A"$#0"-3113$/E0"/+"H/1+$"3-4"H,10L,+$"3"%,.0L/7"7,-701-/-2"$#0"Y50+$/,-",H"#,./-0++&"(#,"/+"#,.Fj$#0"631,-/4"%1/0+$+A",1"$#0"%0,%.0",H"D+130."3+"3"(#,.0o"S0$A"(#0-"1034"(/$#/-" $#0" -3113$/E0" ,H"G5L;01+A" $#0" +$,1F" /+" ,-0" ,H" 3-"3$$0L%$04"%5$+7#"3-4"/$+"5-L3+X/-2)"D-"$#0"%10704/-2"-3113$/E0"

Page 47: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Zh"

+07$/,-"B,+0+"3-4"631,-"40L,-+$13$0"$#0L+0.E0+"/-73%3;.0",H"L3X/-2"2,,4",-"$#0/1"%1,L/+0"$,";1/-2"$#0"%0,%.0"$,"$#0".3-4",H"D+130.A"3-4"/-+$034"H,1073+$A"$#3$"$#0"D+130./$0+"(/.."3.."%01/+#A"(3-401/-2"/-"$#0"40+01$"_G5L"!WJ!\bA"3"%,/-$"L340"0<%./7/$" /-"$#0"{,13#"-3113$/E0"_!^&!Wb)"{,13#"+0/g0+"$#0",%%,1$5-/$F"3+"3"L,10" +0-/,1" L0L;01" ,H" $#0" $1/;0" ,H" >0E/" $,"L3X0" 3" ;/4" H,1".03401+#/%)"B,+0+]"10+%,-+0"+00X+"$,"0<%,+0"{,13#]+"3L;/$/,-A"3-4"4,0+"-,$"34410++"$#0"/++50",H"$#0"+$3$5+",H"$#0"%0,%.0"3+"3"#,.F"%0,%.0"_!^&cJ!!b&"

B,+0+"+3/4"$,"f,13#A"q9031"-,(A"F,5">0E/$0+y"aD+"/$"$,,"./$J$.0"H,1"F,5"$#3$"$#0"[,4",H"D+130."#3+"+0%313$04"F,5"H1,L"$#0"7,-21023$/,-",H"D+130.A"$,"3..,("F,5"$,"3%%1,37#"#/L"/-",1401"$,"%01H,1L"$#0"45$/0+",H"$#0">M?@]+"$3;01-37.0A"3-4"$,"+$3-4";0H,10"$#0"7,-21023$/,-"3-4"+01E0"$#0Lo"!`90"#3+"3..,(04"F,5"$,"3%%1,37#"#/LA"3-4"3.."F,51";1,$#01">0E/$0+"(/$#"F,5i"F0$"F,5"+00X"$#0"%1/0+$#,,4"3+"(0..y"!!=#010H,10"F,5"3-4"3.." F,51"7,L%3-F"#3E0"23$#0104" $,20$#01" 323/-+$"$#0">M?@)"P#3$"/+"631,-"$#3$"F,5"13/."323/-+$"#/Lo]"

D$"/+"$150"$#3$"B,+0+"5-401+7,10+"631,-]+"#,./-0++"_!^&\A"hb)"C5$"/$"/+"-,$"$,"#/2#./2#$"3"g01,J+5L"23L0A"$,"(/$A"$#3$"631,-"/+"#,.F"(#/.0"D+130."/+"-,$)"=#1,52#,5$"$#0"Q0-$3$057#A"%1/0+$.F"#,./-0++"/+"13/+04"/-"3"+/-2.0"7,-$0<$&"%1/0+$.F"#,./-0++"0-$3/.+"$#0"1/2#$"$,"+01E0"3+"%1/0+$+" /-"$#0"+3-7$531FA"3+"+00-"/-"$#0"H10Y50-$" *5<$3J%,+/$/,-"$,"L3X0"631,-"U#,.FV" #" "+,"$#3$"#0"L3F"U+01E0V"_ bA" _0)2)"K<,4"Rc&WA"Ra&ZZA"W`&W`A"Z`&!Wb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{,13#" 3%%03.04" $,"(#3$"(3+" 3-" 5-4/+%5$04" 3-4" 377513$0" 5-J401+$3-4/-2j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`!""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

!`!"D$"/+"$150"$#3$"@05$01,-,LF"-0E01"10H01+"$,"$#0"%1/0+$+"0L%.,FJ/-2"$#0"1,,$" $$ )"S0$"/$"/+"0Y53..F"7.031"$#3$"%1/0+$+"/-"@05$01,-,LF"310" 7#,+0-" 3-4" ;031" +%07/3." %1/E/.020" _!c&Wm\i" R!&\i" R^&Zb)" D$" /+" 3.+,"$150" $#3$" @05$01,-,LF" -0E01" 10H01+" $," $#0" 70-$13." +#1/-0" 3+" #,.FA"0/$#01)"I,5.4"/$";0"$#3$"@05$01,-,LF"3++5L0+"40+/2-3$/,-+"0<%./7/$.F"

Page 48: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

8MN?G6>"MO"9KC?KP":I?DQ=N?K:"

"

Zc"

?@;$H7:;F$M?@!$7L$!-;$F?!A7FXQ$;K7G$<CQ<Y$AF$A!0$HAG;@$B7F!;K!$

D40,.,2/73."71/$/7/+L"L5+$"3.(3F+";0"(31F",H"$#0"7#3120"$#3$" /$"H3E,1+" 320-43" ,E01" 0E/40-70)" O0L/-/+$" /-$01%10$3$/,-"L5+$" ;0"(31F" ,H" +57#"L/++$0%+" 3+"(0..A" .0+$" /$+" E/$3." E,/70" ;0" 7,L%1,JL/+04)!`R" :5+3-" 67X01L3-" 7/$0+" +0E013." 4/+75++/,-+" ,H" K<,4"!a&!\"(/$#/-"H0L/-/+$"/-$01%10$3$/,-A"3-4"/$+"/L%./73$/,-+"H,1"$#0"+$3$5+"3-4"+$3-4/-2",H"(,L0-"(/$#/-"$#0"7,E0-3-$3."7,LL5-/J$F)"":,L0"5-401+$3-4"$#0"E01+0"$,"0<7.540"(,L0-"3+"34410++00+"(#0-"B,+0+"+%03X+"$,"U$#0"%0,%.0AV" i",$#01+A"+57#"3+"Q#F.J./+" C/14A" +5220+$" $#3$" $#/+" E01+0" /L%./0+" $#3$" (,L0-" 310" -,$"%31$F"$,"$#0"7,E0-3-$"3.$,20$#01)"

6"$#,1,52#"10E/0(",H"$#0"0E/40-70"/-"K<,4"!aA"#,(0E01A"10E03.+"3"%/7$510"L,10"7,L%.0<"$#3-"$#0",-0"13/+04"/-"$#/+"./$0J13$510)" =#010" 701$3/-.F" /+" L01/$" /-" $#0" 7.3/L" $#3$" $#0! +07,-4J%01+,-"L3+75./-0"%.513."H,1L"U4,"-,$"3%%1,37#V"_ b" /-"!a&!\" +%07/H/73..F" 34410++0+" 3-" 3.."L3.0" 354/0-70)" S0$A" 7,-+/+J$0-$.F"L/++/-2"H1,L"$#0+0"4/+75++/,-+"/+"3-"3(310-0++"$#3$",$#01"E01+0+" /-" $#0" 7#3%$01" 7,L%./73$0" $#3$" 7,-7.5+/,-)" =3X0A" H,1"0<3L%.0A" K<,4" !a&!R&" US,5" +#3.." +0$" ;,5-4+" H,1" $#0" %0,%.0"_ b" 1,5-4"3;,5$A" +3F/-2A" qC0(310",H"2,/-2"5%" $#0"L,5-$3/-",1" $,57#/-2" $#0" ;,1401" ,H" /$)"P#,0E01" $,57#0+" $#0"L,5-$3/-"+#3.." ;0" %5$" $," 403$#)]V" =#0" H,..,(/-2" E01+0A" E" !WA" 0<%./7/$.F"+$3$0+"$#3$"3-F"./E/-2";0/-2j#5L3-",1";03+$j$#3$"$,57#0+"$#0"L,5-$3/-"+#3..";0"%5$"$,"403$#)"I.031.FA"(,L0-"310"/-7.5404"/-"$#0" %1,#/;/$/,-)" =#0" %1,#/;/$/,-" 323/-+$" $#0" %0,%.0" _ bj7.031.F" /-7.54/-2" $#0" (,L0-j3+70-4/-2" $#0" L,5-$3/-A" /+"07#,04"3-,$#01"$#100"$/L0+"/-"$#/+"7#3%$01"_EE"R!A"RWA"3-4"RZb)"

9,(A"$#0-A"+#3.."(0"107,-7/.0"$#0"/L%./73$/,-",H"E01+0"!\A"$#3$",-.F"L0-"310"$#0"34410++00+",H"$#0"73.."$,"$#0" A"(/$#"$#0"/L%./73$/,-+",H"$#0",$#01"H/E0"E01+0+"$#3$"(,L0-A"$,,A"310"%1,J#/;/$04" H1,L"3+70-4/-2" $#0"L,5-$o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

S0$A" 0Y53..F" %.35+/;.0" 310" $(,",$#01" 0<%.3-3$/,-+)"M-0" /+"$," %,+/$" $#3$" $#0" E01F" Y50+$/,-" ,H"(#0$#01" U$#0" -3$/,-V" 7,LJ%1/+0+"L3.0+",-.FA",1"(,L0-"3+"(0..A"10H.07$+"3"4/7#,$,LF"$#3$"/+"3-37#1,-/+$/7i"$#3$"/40-$/$F"/-"$#0";/;./73."7,-$0<$"/+"H/1+$"3-4"H,10L,+$"7,1%,13$0" 3-4"7,..07$/E0)"=#0" /40-$/$F",H" $#0"34410+J+00+" ,H" $#0" %1,-,5-70L0-$+" $," $#0" -3$/,-A" /-" $51-A" /+" 3" H.5/4A"7#3-2/-2"354/0-70A"40%0-4/-2",-"$#0"7,-$0<$",H"$#0"73..)"P#0-"$#0" >,14" +%03X+" $," $#0" -3$/,-" 7,-701-/-2" $#0" %1,#/;/$/,-" ,H"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""L340"/-",$#01"$0<$+o"

!`R"O,1"3-"3++0++L0-$",H"$#0"7#3137$01",H"K+$#01"$#3$"413(+"(/40.F"H1,L" $#0" (1/$/-2+" ,H" :/L,-0" 40" C035E,/1A" +00" LF" U9343++3#" ;3$"6;/#3/.&"=#0"KE,.5$/,-"O1,L"M;*07$" $," :5;*07$" /-" $#0"I#3137$01" ,H"K+$#01AV"B93"!R`"_R``!bA"^Zhm^a)"

Page 49: In Conversation With Joshua A. Berman, Created Equal - Journal of

DG"IMGTK?:6=DMG"PD=9"8)"6)"CK?B6GA""-)./)0()12.3"""

"

Za"

3+70-4/-2" $#0"B,5-$A" $#0" 34410++00+" 310" 3.." +0-$/0-$";0/-2+j(,L0-"3+"(0.."3+"L0-)" "D-"E"!\A"(#010"$#0"+5;*07$",H"$#0"34J410++"/+"L3.0"1/$53."40H/.0L0-$A"/$"L3F"(0..";0"$#3$"$#3$",-.F"L0-"310"34410++04)"

6"H/-3."3%%1,37#"$,"$#0"Y50+$/,-",H"$#0"34410++00+"/-"K<J,4"!a"/+"$,"7.3/L"$#3$"3$"3.."$/L0+"$#0"34410++00+"/-7.540"3.."L0-"3-4"(,L0-)"T01+0" !\A" 377,14/-2" $," $#/+" 1034/-2A" 4,0+"-,$A" /-"H37$A"34410++" $#0"L0-"3.,-0)" "?3$#01A"E"!\"%1,#/;/$+"+0<53." /-J$017,51+0" H,1" 3.." D+130./$0+)" O,1" $#0" 90;10(" C/;.0A" #,(0E01A"+0<53." 10.3$/,-+" 310" /-#010-$.F" 3" L3.0J/-/$/3$04" 37$/E/$FA" 3-4"#0-70" 10H010-70+" $," +57#" 10.3$/,-+" 310" 3.(3F+" 0<%10++04" 3+" 3-"37$/,-" $#3$" 3" L3-" 4,0+" $," 3" (,L3-" _ $$$! %$$! %$$$ A!

$$$ b)"=,";0" +510A" $#/+" /+" /$+0.H" 3" 10H.07$/,-",H" $#0"C/;.0]+" 3-J41,70-$1/7" -3$510A" ;5$" +/-70" $#010" /+" -," ,$#01" (3F" $," $0.." $#0"D+130./$0+"U4,"-,$"#3E0"10.3$/,-+AV"(0"73--,$"7,-7.540"$#3$",-.F"L0-"310"$#0"34410++00+"/-"$#0"73.."$,"$#0"-3$/,-"/-"E"!\)"

D"3..,("$#3$"$#0"H/1+$",%$/,-"D"%10+0-$04A"(#3$"D"$01L04"$#0"H0L/-/+$" /-$01%10$3$/,-A"L3F" ;0" $#0" 7,1107$" ,-0)" =#0" H0L/-/+$"71/$/Y50" /+" 7,L%1,L/+04A" #,(0E01A" ;F" -,$" H5..F" 34L/$$/-2" $#0"402100",H"7,L%./73$/,-"$#0+0"E01+0+"4/+%.3F)!`W!

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!`W" O,1" $#0" 107,14A" D" 3L" /-" H5.." 32100L0-$" (/$#" 67X01L3-" $#3$"

(,L0-" 310" -,$" /-7.5404" /-" $#0" 73.." $," %/.21/L320" /-" @05$01,-,LF)"=#3$"$#/+"/+"+,"/+"0E/40-$"H1,L"$#0"7/$3$/,-"$#3$"+#0"#01+0.H"10H010-70+"H1,L"LF"(,1X"_"#$%&$'()*+%,A"^`b&"

O1,L"3"./$0131F"+$3-4%,/-$A"@05$01,-,LF"/+"+$157$5104"3+"3"+01/0+",H"34410++0+" $," D+130." 3+" 3" 7,..07$/E0" UF,5V&" U"`6+( +#3.." .,E0" $#0" >,14"F,51"[,4"(/$#"3.."F,51"#031$V" _^&\bi"U"N6+(+#3.." H03+$" d/-" $#0" $0L%.0e";0H,10"$#0">,14"F,51"[,4A"#3%%F"/-"3.."$#0"5-401$3X/-2+"/-"(#/7#"$#0">,14"F,51"[,4"#3+";.0++04"N6+(U"_!R&hbp"6.."L0-"310"0Y53.";0H,10"$#0">,14A";0735+0"3.."+#310"$#0"+$3$5+",H"$#0"+5;,14/-3$0"X/-2",H"$#0"+5g013/-$F"$103$F)V"