i'mhome.uchicago.edu/rjr6/articles/schleicher haeckel darwin... · 2011. 10. 12. · .1',,. !a:...
TRANSCRIPT
-
i'm.rx{Eo0I:.F360,6 I
5'o
FJ
F'F
\-
\\'G
> (r)ZFI
F
FHtsf4zq,OHdzf)
zH
-
iFfl1?Ei rlFF$s'xalir}ilAl1 $ fI$i}iiiiq+iii:laiiiEi;air!€ * lFl ;iE1*i9li*{1ti{{iliFEEltga
-
Etl
iilliilsgllgil1ggga€*islli1li111*a; 1: Fltl1aFliEilii
. iisas iEl 11?;i*rilill;ili
-
E* illlg lilgltlul1gl ttlEggteilIigE[?li
{
;i aiF11gil1E?EEl1l* EgiEEltliaEEstasE I i
:1 Egiiili1iitlll} lliillgi?lE;tl$ilgFIi
iiillgllliiilil galiilagliilg?i ?lr.j,*+:."e;ql:*.*rri+ra".*.:*.u+rr.*l€ilr*:txi**ir:+*i:*g.#*ia!il'ixitt . i{.-td1'1'.*tq?dF i' '
iIFi[1F
-
i iaali-i11[[1i;+sara Z il$gi}lfia+i1, :
El'l''Eiiilaii'lilgl t'*iir1lll*l1* i
i++laa*****tllilla-ritggl111g;lg
lilggggi[F[iili$$ilEgilllllrrlig
-
lir'rliig?1i; ' E
'[[$[llg[$[$1 ffi[ ii11lEaaElg l l1lilil*r llgF+
?;lliliiaa+s1[1[E}ig;{isliii'iat!l'..+:!a:iF_i+::.::tljt:r1$n4tni€1;i.1!ta:e:i.:rlii!n: ii.il'ri'.t:ri1'*.'*:q4erarr:iti';::::i{
i iF$gf iFf1[$
I i liiBFl t[ F$l1 li 1 rl$i?ig
i1glIi l1l11$|*s*;ii+lilgliiig'g5li1i*rs** lliiiS$FiIIiililiiil'*u ui', = +
iliilig 6gg'iFg1gglgFi-si9il1;i liiai I+lg*tl iti{a?ellatril FlliIlg1 1FiIl i
-
.1',,. !a: ._.:Frlti'-_i ----i qliiI i I m_; r +-'u
rli "pt :+i'
-, -.-, --.i---xa!: ;=' -v
!!-jr' ,- -,- *------ u': -
e''' '- -+:-*-w,utlc'
.rl:,,,r;i,'i It nti,t jtr.
n,
I
ABC EF GHD
mS@
FIGURE z.r Darwin's diagram of possi descent relations of species. From the Origin of Speries (London:
John Murray, r859).
*vryu*
*, 1 "..: : ,-,- . :.' . i .; .. ; +Xaa'**p;Xg*$Xlg+$st**.;4*; ;*.r ''. .
mffi.WlffiN,'.!Jq'6,-ts&dr*t.)edrldffitehffi
dMelkffiffilWM.tM(W1frae)
ob*l&w)o lb&w
lllffikxbt#ilttst lr&r/s,
an&,clffitlottrMtllutffieMM(WIMfteraMUffinlt*r'irm.fo&*t*Wfuta,'[email protected]*e&recd*hektffi;ryntNt MiaotlrptMt llur&t*,NTMMWsltuturu
dh&&.hffidorffitI*aAnU
WlraU3X,let#)
FIGURE 2.2 Schleicher'sdiagramofthedescentrelationsof thelndo-Germaniclanguages.FromhisDartuinsche Theorie und die S,rachwissenschaft (Wermar: Bohlau. r86r ).
-
o
F-.1str
oo
?
+(D
^o]E
DA.D'
;-N-
a- x'
o
-
-oo-
on'lo-on
3E?gB#+Hi*F2:U:: FT5 i\i =; o -.E sLa*1** g O rJ 6F6 5 X 6 o\) 6 F 5c\t.o-p:
Eq a'8: E* e ri $E-n!lAngj'6*B3ict i -rq s E9 H !.r id L= s3 F 3:ltx=-oP E d,; Y,2E +,E } * Eid oJ? Y n
=?2aY
-
r{?l ; l gg
ii tgEa ls lgi l[g ll a tll s s i lr i l "
:
iliilgs gllgglgllgiggE$[i$ggla ig+giI I€ il+'i'
lig$lllil1ggilrris1lai
-ra'la
iltelia i+rssFlagiiiigigagslll ilgiilr,i].i.,:'.h..::.:qri:i.l-+1jj.d.;.id.}'ijj'1'',;.':f;i"-r:-.'''i..'.'...."-;a.#.';:-";*;l.rli*6i..q]i:]airf.iiii.:'F.i..,iiil]j]ii*F$#4*5d
iFiFilgiiglFg[u --$
FtB1Ei[Fg]g[[Fil
-
itIlii?g$ilEiFgiiiiFFiitlli?ElEFiga i i
i+ili[ig1giEgr$llglgrlgiilllai?litg i *
riliii ai?Elli?iaiigi*El[ii?l?lliii I
Hs.
t*.
F.
n
\
?a
A.
n
t
a
E tH ! r65f f gCE i* $3iAf Ig x s * s E * r s;s tE rf i *; i i 5 I t ? € t { T $ n*ii?iss*lgtgin; isru1;i nNxEiiiaI[3 giil++: i$$t: jiifi i *3 AilnrEiE*re r;ils. if igf :;i: *8 eleij ilit "atiigat+lrei iilr i +s+;tEFtrts lai5 ifi"at r,t tliiit;t tiifiFF;ilsgqlFl +g+E F i H s-:;€ ? E F r S vl% rtE{a i:6 g f r slTE 3E +; i € fr I ; 3 1 s a4A4ia+l
-
t= AV!€aeg?E ei$:7==
aiTaa:E:iza?lzzz*Ez; ; A : i a? =, ei71?:_E e Vz'? a;E:,ii"=$ez 7 ZE
=:Zgi e?A#? i:? a= 7E:e E'
7'z ,zi;sa*a Z{z;e= 1=4. s:-lsg=7?= L===e=e VEZ ?',,2€=zZE:' iirlE*+ t,7,i E:;siii=az iTT,Zil ==zJ =-7i="Eq:i :' i?;iA7u: ti;lag&i' Ee',:l='2Z E7=r'ri 7 7"2 1 ;E'= =t Ez
rtls
p
4
-
T-'l
@-
oc
Fo
qF)
(D
o3
g)
g)t
(!
o
ilrla v i T*i*i+itilt[e$$ *?=i#i-I i|iii '"
rlll+ i 1 lllAirlalFalllilit?*lt11;11 tlguii il liia?EaFiiaEr*qi'?i ll??li{ Iii*t1'l g111Al?g111;?aii*ii 11lt1la ir l +; Y ii;i;r i si iaEtllallE1affia?1 lll1?*ilit;$ [iie;ia;*;ir[[e??.Fr ;*:ii5=lFltt =1??iF3?fr+iFi*EFtE? iatr?ileilie ?r;+rllA*f;nFasc?F E{*+;ia
! (} P ' e
- r 'i '-':: :!'''-r'*;'"l*+*;':l '1+i Jiii"*1t: "' i
i{git? Itgi IgEqq atlg Ala allll ltlIIII?gl
la?Eq[I
-
3
@
dtns- br\- o\
oo
_lJ:i. o
*r.€6."o
n.D-
.h.D-.
Oni-; -<
podP--r
qq-)<
OrDo
6-€ Rfr.D.DP-.D
d$^
-r;'^
-
f1lr : l.r5':,:'' -:'';,;"-
-
!SG
t-
not
B-; pi'l')3 " t;,e ; \
-.i\j5 i \-F^lAq :-NU+6^a=.6oalq Rtr9VG"'nOiLo
n^s*+r-:s
J.a (! ts:t{GYA6N
*,2' ss;+dA* ? cE\
^jP
H 6 Eo-.' o*@;_;j #3
*F 31ri o- i;,9,lH<"- [" ng.D (D O\d< .) Ycrfti(-'hEoD2q"8if-^v)Hin F 'i'
\vHI
R!
!io^+rX)FriL:. - lo:^v.Dl-:- o: own@ I id
h F.:
$lDa0Qos)hPri
i *f@6',lrsr'A- 8.,;3 i1 qoqSe
- -oq
-fD[.li-Ub"(}€!.o-^-5-
'*-tr ?-
-)r'-.D^\ H i'
-q
HA-
:--diPl
;x;.i";-1-t$3a"jo=^PDo;C-A).)
6tr=-^i; i =-o i;+-r!?O-cDO T J-rP*;O0).F3 N X o-;'=45-.n :vA(n.;X-p.1,' o --' Ji *l" f 9
-
3 3 F iai H.*E H(/ ts o 6 oao-'-iaXY-@;a)ui n C-.:';lEOaVtr!.,S66-l_$ :s.NE$F<$; E o-e;XX\^c a @--A'n^j X 6-o p)
JP^FP;E;
-
AF SE.F $ *e \ Fr e-rIFg F I ir$',*[il4;TE?FiF*$ 8 F ilESlFlbe*rTg}
-
i i + i i€ i- i* i * isi i*[? i*$ir I z:iFtiiFa;e i IoqsA*rt3$L E si?;:i;€F- t t[1ifriF?g: i I€*:E"?;+g* s3i$ge:;5 t esa$$ggigS 'rI I & o p 9 o * .' fi9x--cH-:"e3Y= i\-''o o s =a >B #x-+1iFr;.sfF i i=3-: -t+/ e S s.*;iiii; i 1:gAf;'xj $ ?Fr.?HF;3 $ €ss;a*as $ ;
lt;iFilllitllirilggi gg{l u|| -
1li:?l:?l*illl''E*ll***' E*lqirEqi{?l11}1tI?iBttlE?
11?i'[51il}l1};l*$iigl:lr: sir+ 3 i?'!6li t?isi tB ffiia; L tF iiF$ iliii sE g.E
-
ll+lllatgE1ig[ligl?tl*Etgqtilgll gtlg[$i ae+
isaai;'; l-' i*+i *
Illg liit iglggtlggi laii ii lilil$gEB $iEFFffiggl$l$i'$$iB'i,$lEgilEilgE
**i{ r'iliii'glii,a iltg
i illgiigiiiili{
l$glEi:i'ii'$iiEiiiElIE$iig$ii?g1l
-
iiigi+ attaltilal igffi ltllgqiitillt' llggg:i
lt, ffil,llEAllal? rli liEiliEEa}i}sr FFIElil
i? q?E
li ii F? i;* * lts
?E$?iiEE?{i 1 g1
liiEqii $l1 I
iil1+l?llt, tsilll1 ii, Eu ;ll?*E alt : li
l1?18*lai=rllg*ligilaiEll*fi?lF,;r
-
xiuEE.lu[i+F*i:il. t 'na€$']&'n';' list?'lier*F: illliigF*' tilal+?E" r
$lgIl $*$3g;ei{il5igaa Ei i}iii isF
i
iFErg * illl a$ii$F$" i,}iiii}li i
li:ilgil$atirailgiil$iiir*aur$uss*r*lFu$illltiiiE$YE*iii$$*e+r F EgrF$F
7ro\o\
Q ot
9 rrp0)H
*i Ea\:] slD a "'ivl
!@=-
;Fq\agbr ..o\lo- .r.FYo
F-t
"o
FT{
o7l
z
l-ns-\]
s.
o
o
r:al 7co-:!3'-)'6e50- --v
H J
:ql