imfi 3 ifi enm
TRANSCRIPT
imfi 3
ifienm<ufmi a
luniii^miQ^Hanii flmsismififla^iJuimSilih (cdppa model) ijsanfninii
(experimental research) -3Wl ll^'mvll4Pimj?19\ i'Ufn5^im'Umi?ntiaiaiJ ^U
1 ibsitnfmiatjnaiiehem-a
2. imuiiwu iwrnniifi
3. mia^fia^l lumii^o
4. fnimununw 'gjLjfi
6. ttciwvilflwmi'3tfins;'Hi)9ija
l. ilisjvini lvl'Mmfiaa
tlm^^ntn 2557 TmieivmB'ajBii'tf'UflihflQi "0114114 7 "HQ^iltiu ^iiiiwun^uu 210 fii4
cB^ i(f'ut1y'uui]Ufias;fTu?n}jfnnjJtnuiiC) tri-a ilTunai-a ujisjodu
nau^Qem-a^WitJfniifofif-afi iili4'unii iv4^i4ilis;tiu^n%nil 3 nifii1ai4^ 2
iJfm fiin 2557 Ii-aiiyunSfUBii tJ^ili ef 1 ^e-adoi4 9114114 30fii4 ^Ifluiipiejnug'uimu
fiqu (cluster random sampling) 1 jHl18-aiiai4lSl4'H141O< 0-3fnigii f 14fliitll4llPif1S1ie^Sw?1
nn^i fm1iiu(andijmimn3"nin1f ilou1 'fl1piii9 i tJi4UiJiJffisf(iiJj iJJiia^e4iTnnoi4
65
imimH-Mfmiffc
I'UfllSQ'OeJfn^mil'U fli 31 fTmiH VI pme>3 (experimental research) iflfli tllllJllWlJ
fniViemQ^UlJlJ one-group pretest-posttest design (ATU ffWUfl UftZmfiQll flMEItlff, 2538, 'H'UI
244-249) cB-a8ttU1JUN'Ufl"mi8EJ nW
emi-ayi 3.1 uwmimimiiw
T, tmu mitT9iiri0ii^!)sviifniviPia8^
T2 uvm nnittoimciwnfi&amsvhfmYiflfio-j
x tmt! mi Ani5i1mmiJuuu$iJih (CIPPA Model) ij^QnmfmjfjSifflityi
tf\ A \ \ m'3im
l. iiwuniifffm'nif tmflfwfiJuiJijSilih (ciPPAModei)ijimiminimjjiffyan
q> qi12 nwu uwufi^ l iilw nw 12 vilu^ enCS
itR'U'oVifi'mfa'uff] 2 tia^ tTuijiuQ^'KTg: "lit nil laws uni
uwu^imiiteiufvi 3 if a-3 tniiiimo^fOT : viz vmwm mzmv m
uHUflPifrmieiufvi 4 1I9-3 ilislti'K'unjg-j'ftT^ .- nszmv @u nmtim laws;
iiHWO(pifn?ifeivj|^ 5 iia-3 ilisIenfuue 'ftTq: oi^ Ijj n't imi
66
T,
neiae-j
X
arovHafr
uwu'Dian'nifoufii 7 iie-a ^^yiiiwofffliiJaouuiJa-a
uwu'DfifniiiH'UTn 8 ife-3 "fflfqiilatmuiJti-a
uwwfpifniiloi4|fl 10 ife-a fninJaaumJu-ai/e^TfTg 2
uwu^Vimiiiejui^ 11 iie@a ij'jslfiui4innfi8iiiilatiuuila^n)0^'?ct^
uwuwimititiul^ 12 iie>3 eupinasnnminJaoi4iiiln^'e^'jtfq
2. uiiiJviPitreii1Viwa 3Jt]inifniiit)'u|T e/iiJimii5iliJi (cippa Model) ijianminij
gfitfajcyTne-aaiJ iie-aifiieaijiiRuiwi^jj'tfuifnsjinifl ^mT^uwmijI ngsjfnisjfniiiEiuf
ivifJifntTRi uo^wmiauTuibsojj fi'y'iilYi 3TfloiilwuiJiiiififT0iJiliira ^ufliaenpieii 4
enmon hum 30 #0
3. imuTipifiniiwyoifl^Q^ufitiow 'uiJ^soumuiiJ^ 3 viSstaniiffan'm'f m^flaa
sihmiiiiJih (CiPPA Model) ij?Qnminun2iffyajTi0^'u iig ifiig-aflufluiwipj'K'uifnsinifl
sNHiVm'U'm/f ndiifmsn'm'fEjmiYifnffmfli SmitjaisJiilvjuuiJttoiicnw en u in em in u
ll^SJJIfUfli (rating scale) 5 SSfllJ I^llfi fniU<W-3n9l1o1u52JflU mf)Y\ Uifi lilUfiai^ 1488 lias
@u9ejfi?ra ^num i) Itutu 20 ^o
fnf^ff^ifiio^fio^lU'umiifEi nmiifn^fri'i-j^Cj
l. mstrfi-mwunii^nisiitmflflEniJuiiijSiJih (cippa Model) @yi an fmtru
ivifJifTiftfil'wil?sou fTHiiJ^ 3 flin'Htfagemmuflai-ini^n'yimj'Wuij'i'u 'w.ff. 2551 ims
1.2 ^ntnnon2;i9o 'U0-m9'Hi^iO 'uiintrfi4iiHum5fl fn5ilow| iniontn5
ilisfi0iimf tf9ii ngurfif smma'ujiYifJifnfrwifnisjvi 3 tmimsflruuflug-afm wu
1.3 fTH111f)aSl8Elftnj9-3tl49Vng5ifajfljTnO'3O'U lI94tfi1e-3'J'uiwtW1^3J1fl4
imsmifi fw3Vm<UYnji ^<osUiinfr9fiuii?n1'uuw'Ufnf9Vimfi1aw|ngjJtnfsm?ifoi4|
i a* @
67
1.4 mwiiflMihaniiiiemfvtasihflfitfyyiii8-3flV! tiQ-aifi1e-3ih 'uiH"i<pw
ffa^imifil'n'U 2 vsiiit) fie
1.4.1 wuiumnfitim if 8* ittmttmi
1.4.2 @Hiiiamitiom ile-a -TiPiQmjui-anisyii
1.5 ilejmiwiinisflflniiiimjfifleniluuuSiJih (cippaModel)inanm?nil
1.5.1 WHihei/1 oilo-a
1.5.2 irasfiufniiftruf
OS C& QS1.5.3 enin^
1.5.4 tnisthficy
1.5.5 tnisfrmieruf
1.5.6 iibsfnfifvnilmi!
1.5.7 mniW fms TU
1.5.8 frnQjpiNfiihsiS'UHa
1.5.9 nssUTUfm'SVlfrmf Tuf Illuuuilllh (CIPPA Model)
1.5.10mhmfi^aw
1.5.11 uuiimmfmfva?re'u
1.6 ihUHUfm'ifafmif BufYmfl-JIIU im40fl00'limeJ'@ilJin*mYienii'W'Uij
I'WQPii'j^tTQUfniugnwQ'jmi'UQ'Hi mi5fin nmjmiilo<u|uasfn%n^miiisffumjiJTiiiaii
uviilyu uaiwiuiilfuiJ|-3unlupnjj6u'0t?tu0<i)0-3H'i5a'3<Kify8fifif^
1.8 iIiiiw^m5flfim5ifEj'u|^il!'uiJ|-3im1iiuai!nfi^i5n^ia invifiiroti
disSviSfnn (try out) nuiTnBauvuitasawfrninilfi 3 Ifiyfivu^ow ^S
1.8.1 m^vnilisS'nsfn'wnguaeEJ 1fiaiiiuwwm59Vifn?ilai4|T a3iJiiiiiJ
Jlflifl flW3Vl
@yum/I naWiisniiBmif imnfrarm 1iJYia?)9-3Hmj1uni!oi4 'w'iJisiu^ninil^ 3 mfiiiemvi 2
68
ilmi^nin 25571?-3i?ownftQisiicw iliPi9i ^SHafnuiiouff-a iliumm trasdou gtinas l nu
sujihrnu 3 fiu imiiIiHfi\ nfn?viiiiiJii?ln/lu-aTuuasuuuyiPifT9uuiiif)nsHin
iJis^viifnv(D9^uRi4m5fD(pimiiit)'u| m9vn'#9'ijfi'Hi9<aTufli'UM0wi mm raiviK emgAinj
uHunnifoni^iiouf Ivmiiluuuiilih (CiPPAModel) ijifuim?nij(j2iffyyTn9-3O'u 110-3
ifiio^wiutHiw'K'uimstniPi ^vitViuutuji Sfii E^minu 79.00/81.11 Ipiyilis^YiifniNiJO^
itn'lD^oiinvjiQ^fioti'uiiilvniJisS'viBmyifidjjmnpieiiJ
1.8.2 fniMiibsfYYiifrmnauian 1*iio<i4iiiH'umi Vimiiiwii|^iJfijiJ|^inn
%> f afnnnili^^yiifnyindjjdgej iiJviPifio^lwiJiTfiiifiUTUil Kciu fTyii)^ 3 nifiBow^ 2 ilm^flntn
2557ls3i1oun^cu5stwflihei0i ^Swamiilaw tr-3 ^tutu 3 nu iJi"unai-a ^tutu 4fiw ims
o'qv! btutu 3 fiu nu^TUiiJ 10 fTU tmiilnwatnnfn^TimiJiilln/lu^TUUfisiiuijyififTODin
iifins;'HMiiJ?s; viimviD9^HN'Ufn?!oVimiilej\ | m9<HTU9iin'wi9^1w ii4m9'Hi fiTHi nai^
I^ fna9fif)Ufnifht'Q'unflni5jj?i'n n Iwiiwumiflfifniilovjl @sitifniviPiag^fif^S'wii'ii
iJis^vi5nTW^9^UMi4fniflpifnii1oi4npiE/iiluuij5i]iJi(ciPPA Model) \ ?fMiminiJfjSifQJtyi
<n9-ioi4!,i9-3mi9-3'Jwii4tHi^uctft!imsm1?i fowifwiu-ftm Sfii E^mnnu 82.80/84.67 snniru
hi folfliliuHU mi ffin ii iiejufjjiiJiii ill -aun 1^)^91) n'wig^figviiIiiil'H iili stTYiim vi
1.8.3 mirnilisSnSnTWfnfitTuiu Ifio<uiiiHi4fn?flVimii!o'u|^iJfuil|'3
"oinmi^nilis^viBfiTNngumn liJvi aQ-a1 'n'iJ\ nilei^iv%4iJ^si3j^ntJ-iiJ^ 3fnfii?oi4^ 2
ilmiflfitn 2557li-3ilf)\ nSfUTiiii! 'u^i]iPi95 1 @H9-3titi'u hniuumvu 30fii4 imi'uiHfisnnfn^
Tiiimijlln/1iJ^ii4imsiiiJiJvi tT9i)jjiitfiiisTiMiiJ?sBvi5fiir)iJ9^tiw<unn?flV)fiiii5ejv!| >3iu
f111<MPia8-3flf'-9B<NllQI1ll5S^YlSfn'W'U9-3llHl4m?f fnH?tJw|1flO^lJlllJlj5lJlll (CiPPAModel)
\ iQnmimjfj2 tytyTn9^ 'uii9 ifii0-3Jw <uiHi JJlwwifnsin??i if3Ti'3Vi'ui4Yiiji Sfii E^tvinmj
84.50/86.89 -ag^jiwrnfu in^is114 80/8 ^nivsw^iT
1.9 @U1UH\ fni'0'iim5iit)li|1plO|lJuillj5lJlJi (CiPPAModel) TJIfUiniifTlJ
fjfliiajfiJTMg^o'uiig^ifiie 'JijiuiHi^uwiimsmlpi io'^M/5'fiwi4<mJj1 ngjjtni^niiifo'uf
69
tfrwnian|rm (niSif) misfniif trufutisnfi'iiiEJVj
3/ @
.A.
JnTHWfl'H'uiamiiloiil^'osj'uifjSiffyQjTna^oiJ
t1o-am1e iluiwiHT U'Wi4ifnstmip)m1iltT8?iimifiiijifMimf
i? ommj n 11 ffa ft "ml ej"u f
i4iuHT4mi^am5t1ejv!|^iJfiJiJ|-3un1uuai!nnHtlejiifif\
@muHUfrn'sfafnii!
twm\ 3.1 uupiQ'Ufii?ii'!'i-3uwiimi^ipim5iiai4nfif)|iJii'iJ'u5ili]i (cippa Model) ijfonminii
nawenssniiiitmJiYifnffmeii
70
2. fnitri'i^miiivififr9ii'5Viwaarijq'nSfn?tlejt4|If)y5iluiiuiiJiJi (ciPPAModei)
^iiaQn otutu 30 #9 2<wae<ulumi?Ti''i3uuuY]em9iJ ^w
2.1 fffiynfmitT?i-3uinjviPi?T0inf)Ha?f3jqvitivn^fniiifiijQ6ifnvitnfntTPii
2.2 iifmsvi'wqeifii'iun'mia'ufTJQ^ Bloom fniiwamjqviiiYmfmismjTin
imimtim ?fau
flii'Uvi 3.2 liflSISTfwfjflfmiJfl'mseJuf 119-3 Bloom CwSfl qYlibiflJ, 2552, "H141 31-36)
pnuwa 3JC]<nBm5ilJi4|1f> i?iltmij5iliJn (cippa Model) @yftuim^fTiifjflilfycin
@**
71
~^^ --^^ nqwmijj
1.wftua^^
3.tfiHJ iis^TfTfl:en^vtaiOTfi
4.dsslmfmjg-mfl: nisfnwiu
5.ilisIaifuija-iftTq: ai^ Wwiuni
6.mimani'tf'KfgWmwisffij
7.^fiYhWftKjtiJfia'uuilfN
8.ffTfliilaaimiJa^
9.fninJaaiiitiJt Ka-3'3'Tg 1
10.fninJayuuiia^Da -fOT2
ll.'iJisla'wusnnmiiiJaawiiila'aua^'ftr
12.mmiasnfimiii)aa\ iiilfi @ua^iiTfl
s:
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
I-
-
-
-
-
-
-
?E
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
?a
-
-
-
-
E
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
E
-
-
-@
-
-
-
-
-
-
2.3 ?tfi-3Ullll'V1?ltt91JTVlWf1 Jjq'Vlifnit!fJwfl^)1llimij5<lJ'lJi (CIPPAModel)
fnniamivienfrmfli ^g^umimjTuitasoiJflntniJfi 3 pnunwumi^fniiiyuf^HitJ
mmfmg-a iilw^ufimQfiPiDU 4 <nmon shtnti 52 'uo
2.4 UlUlJlJYlflfTgilfAWafllJqYlSnnitiEJuflflEniluiJllSlllh (CIPPAModel)
\ 5fuiminug2iIfjjfyTn8^w ti9^tfii9-3ilwSutwwuuv!im ifi1fi ^htVcutjviijI fmri-wij m-us
pigaTfnio^ilin'yiQvienwvj'us mg^nBtTgiifniugn^'g^ fniiiiT9f;ioa8-35s;'H'ii^fiifnjju9-3
miuvifi?f9iinu 'iJis;iT^fimii7fJi4i m9 lf)n)9itTW9ims;uaTuiini)?i)'Ll|-3mmjJi^fr3Jinfiij'u
2.5 (niQ!)tT9ij^mni^^9^uiJi)vi^fr9ijQViwsd3jqviBnnii!t)y|Ipifj?iJuiJii5iJili
(cippa Model) ijifunfniniifjniInjfyTng45\ tig ifiig-j'JuiiJiwTww 'uifnsmifi ^vfTfiTJwviiii
naytmsniiiitJ'ufiYifnfrmfl! ipioTJiiiiiDYifitreuiiJl'Hmf otwiiu 5 fita @wimanfmu
ng ifi^^is'Hii-jfiifiijjnfg^uiiiJviPitfg'umjflfiilismnfnfiiei'uf mgiifu'df^uni'U'foun'mg^
UaSJflVimgn'fi'otfOlJ^S m index of item objective congruence (IOC) ffalipi 0.5 Dljill
2.6 t41UlllJ11^tt9ll^^1T9a91JUa^lJilJlJ|-3UfTi^tmi1'lJ'Vlflt19-3tTll'lTnoy'UW
iJi^ou^n'ynil^ 3 Ii-aiieiwnSfuiiii vi iJmgl ^@HiViwuYnjI ^isJHndn^igdi^ hum 30
fit! uaTuiiiuunspitT9iiinpii'3!o?T9UfiiPiQiiIfit/1i!'fisimv! l fistrutj ^THiiJ'ug^Pigufin imslti
2.7 iIiHamivififfguuiiifi^n^miej 'g T1^fi^fn^JJnfl-3^eJlmsf ^9^vnDfl^ll 4n
n/o-3imuvifitT9iJ uaiffomon'UfmSfhfmiimfi-na (p) ^ii i 0.20-0.80 imsfiidiviiflBiimn (r)
< ufi 0.20 njuld ilnngi'il injD'MPitrgiiTiawa^iiq'Kiinraiowl -314 so uq ^Sfiifmuain
^iej(p)8tbs;tm-3 0.37-0.73 tms;fii9oivn9Bm'un (r) g^jisviii^ 0.27-0.60
2.8 'uitiuij'n ?f9iifiRwa^wt]yiim?iifjijnpifjiiJuuii5iJili (ciPPAModei)
iiiajifniniifj2ifQjfyi'M9-3Q'u ii9-3mi8^^yiwiwT u %jifns;tn1fi ^Mifiii'uynji ndutnis
fhfmutf QiT'uteifji'tffleii KR-20 1104 Kuder-Richardson lhingi1UlllJVlAtfeijiV)WfimJC)V115
mill truf SfmuwtamaYhniJ 0.89
2.9 iIiiiu'uvifitrsu'f^Ha iiqviim^ilfJijnfifjiiJuuiiiiJiJi (ciPPAModel)
mmuuili'ntnmm? hum 30 4@ 1ilvifitiQ^Kmjnd}j(r30m'3Pi9li!
72
ia^mmti'iniiim'Sm- i\ %ii\ 1
^ntnTifnitrfi^imiJviPitTQiiinniefiinipii-i <n
Iiifms'H'wqSniiufniif truing Bloom
niJ*mmjqYiBYmniii!ej\ Y3Y)mfniYfll
TT
Tilnmiiyi?i?f9iJ^iJfiiil^fnjJ'U0tttwa(ii9-39i^n?OTil1ntn
b < O*qviotu'Wue inm'uoetefjjmninfy'inm'u 5 yitu
JJ>_ Q_
ihuuuiifitraimiJfiJib'au^Q iilwflaB-aKnungjjenadi^
fnvm 3.2 m!?i9'uniii<ffi^uiiii'yifitfoiJ'3Viwfi 'jjqv)5nnii1y'unfiq'iJuiJii5iliJi
(cippa Model) tjifuiminujnSiffyfijTiio-io'u ile^miQ^tfui'uiMTttimiifnstmei
tfanifimmi^ ndiJtmsmsBmm'1'itnffmei?
73
3. mutfi^ituuiVifmw'tt-a'Melfl'ue^wfiilfi'uw'iJisaD^fntJiil^ 3 <n2piofmioV)
milfauf iflEJSlJu'lJllilJ'lJl (CIPPAModel) IJIQiifninilfjfllffyCyTMO^Bw lia fliO'JlI'UAUim
if 3>
3.1 ^n iilmifrfi-3injiJ'5fifniJJ<w-i'W0l!) inmonfmuas4iir3iTayHncnij0$
foniiiiounflaiiluiJimJih (CIPPA Model) yiQnminufjOiffynji'no^oviiio iniQ iii'uiHi
3.3 fin iauuo^Qfmuu^as'uefmjjSvn^monod 5 vn-amon m fnuj^ngti)
f\ wuu @walmJiufifn^lii 3 fisimu via'ta'uaoi'H 2 fisawu urtsvolBiJoy^g^lM l fisuuu
1f)E)mni4fimfucviltufniiiilfif)Qi}j'HJJi)fis;iiv!V4 ^S (i tyifu friffsaia, 2545, vtwi 103)
4.51-5.00 vmiEjiva viai^infi^gfi
3.51-4.50 viuion-a "waifluin
2.51-3.50 'HU'mik <We1flllil4nc11-3
1.51-2.50 viina ^ vmiflijacj
1.00-1.50 MJJiao-a vioi 'ueej gpi
3.4 @unimiJTVin'nu'w^alfl^tTfi-Juw mwa'eai!)iifmiJin%jiivienuyiuB ims
3.5 UitmiiTflfnijjw 'WQlB^frii-sDti iiJYiflaosHnutfmioiJVuihsau^mn
il^ 3 I^ iifjiJfiSaiBii u^ilifia^ f-a'HTPiu'uynjf ^liiKnguwietin hum 30 nu
3.6 51S)ims;?'3Uf)SJUl4U^1^inm 01J<U0^Yjn'M0fl-31JJtll'UnsU14U^'3'pl
3.7 Uifis:imw^1 iniifinsM'Hifii0oiiJTDfliuwn uas'HifiifniJjifomjTpioK
* iffrpima-3 Cronbachilnngiimiij-fiafmjj'w-a'naiD^itfi-jnj'u SfiidiwiDfliimnoo^sM'ii-s 0.65-
0.92 im^fiifniuif ajTuminii 0.97
3.8tJiiiiJii%fi^iii^Tie1fl1illwi)na3j^Qam-3'H^ ifi1 !/'ijniif'ani?i1ej'u|
IpiajiiuuijiiJiJi (CIPPAModel) ijsonmsnDfjSiffy^TMa^o'u fie^ifiia-a^us-uiwi^yuv!
74
r& .c eS j; <l* *=9 a IfTntjn^mitm-aiiiJiJQfifniu'w-3'M8liosnni9ntn5?n-a'n
wot^emiilmnuiJii\ fuim5nim3Jikijf|n
IHi0-38n!n?ej' iJ1ni)iivin'uv)iiB'uimi4Q IaHWfjQstfia! 5 yitu
ilvificio^HmjiTfiiiyu^iiilwciwiQd
vnfis inimnsi'H'HifiieTyiDfliimn
ufisvnfhfirnjifml'U
Twiimuiflfmu'w-3'weifliinOTungwtned'u
inrm 3.3 w^euniittfi^uiiii'TfifiQiij 'Moi 'iiQ iIriiiei'u^ilisfiJjnfi'Hii] 3 Yiiim
miflVim?i1ow|l i|iluiJii5iiiJi (Cippa Model) tjiQnfnimjfjSifflJiyi'ne^S'u
75
rminimimwiraija
@jruibsou^mnflw 3 iilijwfto'u ifitii^it'uviniivifiae^imsmiiiQ'ijnjj^'oyfi^njJvupia'u m\
fn?l5fJVJnf)fi|llimuSlllJl (CEPPAModel) ljfOnfninilfjSlfQjaTV10>3O'U ti9-3im0-3il'U 'UlHl
3. 1iifi?HfT0%4'nimi<Mfia0>3fY0<ui?nuiiH'Ufn5ifl'pim?i1own?)O?iJiiuii5iliJi
(CIPPA Model) \ fuim5nunMcysii'm0-ai)"u ii0 im0-3^wiuiWT@uifiJifns;im?i ^MiVi'U'unij!
fnn1o<u|l a|iltiiiijSililn (ciPPAModel) @yifmmiinijfjfliffijqiTn'o^o'u ii0^ifi1o^iluiyiwi
fni^mit1f)tj|IfiEj|'iJuiiiiiiJili (ciPPAModel) ij 5 jut fin 5 nun 2 iftufyTno^S w 1I0-3
5. 911^1)nslmlJ1l^nn^^vl0tT0lJlnJlJ'!flHc1 'JJqYl5fl^5BfJm]fly1lJlllJlJ5llll (cippa
Model) ipanminufiijtffycinVitHcitJ iio ifiio^ilwiiaiHi^uuviifnsjmifi f-3'H'fpi'uiJviij! mnmi
mi'wnfisii'U'uiilijfi^tm'UfnivifitToii'Ha^iiyw im^iJiwafi^uwu^i^infniviPitTounoiJims;
@H iifju uaswtini;ui4i4?inuiJiif(afiiii)W'W0iflpi0ni5flVini5ilejijlIpifj?iJuiJii5iJiJi (cippa
Model) ij^onfniniJfjSifajQjTnQ^fl'u iiQ-aflie^ijimw'i^uTuifnsifnfl "ifa'H'SVm'UYii/!
76
rmiifms'H'uaija
l. HnibsBviimvjnjg^im^nii^niiiseAifTflejiiJuiJijSil'ih (CiPPAModel)
E/E22. Mifiitrofl'Niisiw<ii9^fisim%4^1 s)ifiiiiJii'nfifr8iJ'3ViHfinijqyilniii? i'unpitJ
iiJuuuiilih (ceppaModel) \ ianmimjfjC{fQj?yTno^Sw iiQ-3ifii0-3'J'ui(uiHiKuu'uifns;m1pi
3. n]ifJiii^fJUfis;tn4'uwfi^uqyiifnii,1ejij|l3fJ7iJitinj5iliJT (cippaModel)
tnmim?nufi5iffijfljTnQ^B'uii9-3ifii0^'JuiuiNi^D^wtms;m1fi ^mtViw'uviijI ngu^nss;
mill01411 VlOifflfTWI riotJimsVm-siiO'U IfloHttSSfil^ (t-test dependent sample)
4. 'H^fi^m^o^t1^;t1" ^4lfi)-3lll 4U^pl1|^ 4fn^iJ' - v ^1!)?i9m?fl/plfn^l1tJ l|I^t)
itluiJiiiiJdi (cippa Model) \ ifuinniniifj5i1fywi^9^Bi4ti94mi9 'Ji4iuiwi 3j i4mis;in1fi
fNTnemrnnii naijrifsmitiamiYimfrmeif
frB^tnift'uni'nifms'Hifemfi
l. tTotwm$iu
1.1 Vlifiilfjaa (mean) SHflffflS (mflflfl OJJ?fni4 flPI, 2555, nw 146)
Yxx = ~F~
i ci
n imu @oTimi'umleju
77
1.2 @vnfiitTTume)4m'UJJiPii|TU (sd) mnfleii (mrtm omiflUfthS, 2555, vcui
167)
sd . ." *'- *>'
@y n(n-i)
die SD tiYiu fhthmCjeum'uy'ieisip'u
V
n ami tfi'uiu'umimjyfavmspi
X UV1U f1Stl%4U1JO %TnilJ'Uli f1SflU
2. pfQ^I'wl'Ufn^^n^tTeijqaifnyiifiio^yB
2.1 vnil5j;Sv)5fn^U0^itRt4fn? ifnii1fj'y| flintreii (mimifm, 2545 01-30-3
1u qtnuwn M0-3A, 2552, vmi 53)
E, = _^L_xlOO
A
ZLE2 = -^L_xlOO
Bme e, imw ibs^YiBnima^msiiTUfi'mia'uf
E2 imw iJi^Sviifn'MUQ-aHafni'nfitTeiJNfi^jjqYii
~ Y tinw HanjJU9^f)siiiiu^1fl inuiJiJiifitfeu
b imt4 fis;iii4<ui D iniiuuvififr0iiwaarjJtiviB
78
Z^iV xlOO
2.2 @Hnfiiw<Ufi-3iiiiT0fifia9^is;viQi^^iafiiciiijmj^iJij;ft-3f(fnii!yi4| Bifmen
a* a"fffaflfili nu^f 'uffni. 2555. nm 329)
IOC = ^~
N
mn toc imu wfifmuftapifiaQ^i^vf^^^omcnufTij
2.3 Tiifiifiiiijejin^it)n)8^uiJiJVifltt8i)TViHa ijqviiniiiiej<unRej|iJimij5iJiJi
(CiPPAModei)ijiQnminufjSiffljftjTJiQ^o'u iiQ-aifiie iTunviim jj'ifuifnsinifl sN-HTWuu-m^!
iiifitrpii (Him ttiejopf uase fiwi mm?(, 2538, vcui 210)
R_
~N
ijj9 P imu fiifmuoin^na
N UY1U fl1Ull4fll4 <niaU0 'u 'H}J^
2.4 Mifii0iwnflfliuwn^o^imiJvi it0ii'3Viwci^ijq'viSnnii!ei\ |]piEJi'iJuiiijiililn
(CiPPAModel) ijituifn?nufi2iffijfyTn'o-3oiu ile tfiio ifufliuH'ipj'numsinifl fNWiVm'U'mjf
flinffPii (vlixi tnejejfT imsa fiui enejopf, 2538, vcut 210-211)
(cippaModel) i]ituifn?niif)2ifftjfiJTM'8-3O'u il8 tfiiQ^Ju uiHi u<wviimsini fNwiVm'U'mjf
R -R,n _ _u 1
2
79
am D imu fhoTUiwimn
R, imu flTUTU^m1f)V!^?i0iicjn1'undjJ9O'u
2.5 vnfhfmutfgmj (reliability) mo-auuuMflffQU'fAwa^uq'ninisilejVinfle)
iikuuSiJih (CEPPAModei)\ ianmimj()5iffyaj"m8<jflii ife^ifiie^ifw^uiHT^jjuiJimsiimw
f-3V(T(p)i4iiyiij! inng^i kr - 20 (atu mmn uazmfnn mum, 2538, wui 197-198)
am ru ivnu fmuwtailiwa'auiiimRtTeii
n uvm mnutfanjawiJiiYifmaiJ
q unu ar?ifr'3iJua-3w''M'nnHPi1'u '8'H'y'3 <n ma ^a
l-p
51,2 imu fisim'ypniuniliiJ^Tumo^ifiia^Sa'n^
2.6 'Hifl'iQi'uifl'oiuun'UQ-uiuu'fAfmy' 'WolD IflensfmiiflfuiTNfhfi
(t-distribution) 'Olflfffli (fllli mom Ut\ f>WW) JTifJOfT, 2538, VfUl 215-216)
If nH nL
XL imii fisim-umaoiiQ^ngjJwi
80
c2 uvm fjsimvifmuniliilnt4D0-3ndjjtT-3
2.7 @HifhfmJJlfojT'U (reliability) <U93UlluiVlfmU'iN-3'W0iT) ]flfj1^?l11J8^
Cronbach (aiu mwn tmso fi i mum, 2538, vmi 200)
na = @-
H-ls,
s2: wv\ fisnuiifmuuiJiil^iuiiluiiovo
<R1J1J
3. mimU^uniiY)fltfaijmjiJ%Tu
3.1 tiHoiimoijfisiiv!<uwfi^'3jqyiifnii!fj'unpifj5iJimii5'iJilT (CiPPAModei)
iJi9nfninunSiJfuajiiiQ^Swi1o-3ifii9-3J'uiv!iHi^uif<uifnj;imfi w?miiivii|i fidutms
mil1f)u|Q'nEJlffntffl1 neiiimsna-SlisEJ'U I?lo1 ttB f11^ (t-test dependent sample) @Olfltjm (3TU
mum ims^fiui tnueipf, 2538, m-ui 104)
V N-\
f = N-l
l5g t UVIV! fil^i^llJfni'W^niQiit-distribution
81
3.2 nii;iifiiTSiTiuiJij'5Vifi'3iij'w-3vi!)l!)pi9fni!B'fimi(,1t/i4|lfla?iluiJii5iJiii
(CEPPAModel) ijffunminijgSifqjtyi'nQ^o'u if g^ifiia^iJ'UA'uiHT^jJvuimsinifl vwimiumfi
vnfinmao (X) imzdiwvmi'mimm^in (SD) imimJiwa^nuinai'M^nTH'UPiiT^S djcyftu
ffitizm@, 2545, YtW 103)
ftzuumnm fimmwu
4.51-5.00 vialtiuin^gpi
3.51-4.50 viotuinn
2.51-3.50 yo1i)i)iwnfn-3
1.51 -2.50 V)9l!)^9fi
1.00-1.50 YifAmtitiYtTlfi
82