ikea ppt - final presented
TRANSCRIPT
INVADES AMERICAIKEA
ADITYA IYER | BRUNA FURLAN | DENIS SMIRNOV | MONICA CANCINO | RENATA SILVA
1985
Youngme Moon, Harvard Business School | Sep 2004
TABLE OF CONTENTS
3 | Company Overview4 | Case Synopsis 5 | History6 | Timeline8 | Furniture Market in the USA 9 | Competitors 10 | Ikea’s positioning 11 | Product Development 13 | Key Issues 14 | Ikea enters USA – expansion strategy 15 | Product & Service Management 16 | Action Plan 17 | Brand Positioning 19 | First Results 20 | SWOT Analysis 28 | PEST Analysis 29 | Porter’s 5 Forces Analysis 31 | Problem Statement 32 | Scenarios: Pros & Cons 37 | Recommendation 38 | 2015 Ikea USA 39 | Learnings
OVERVIEWIKEA AT A GLANCE
World’s leading home furnishing Co.
• Swedish Company • Owned by a Foundation• 328 Stores in 28 countries• Offers well-designed products at
low prices• Mission: home furnishing that
many can afford• € 31.9 Billion Revenue• € 1.6 Billion in Food• € 1 Billion in Online Sales• 9,500 Products• 155,000 Employees• 978 suppliers in 50 Countries • 51% Production in Europe
SYNOPSIS• In 1985 Ikea opens its first store in the USA
• Struggles with low sales and acceptance of its Scandinavian essence
• The successful European formula needed to be revised
• The POD didn’t seem to appeal for Americans
• Issues with product, lack of service and shopping experience
• USA furniture retailing market very fragmented
• Difficult for Ikea to disrupt standardized market habits
• Ikea changes its strategy to reinforce its reverse positioning
• Strengthen economy of scale to achieve the goal of 50 stores by 2013
HISTORYI K E AINGVAR KAMPRAD ELMTARYD AGUNNARYD
Ambitious, focusedand patient sinceyoung boy
Didn’t spend moneyon toys
Not a good student
Received moneyas reward
During school yearswas looking for ways to makemoney
Moved from hishouse at 17
Opened his own company with money borrowedfrom father
Name of the farmHe grew up in
Spent childhood in Parent’s farm
Name of the village he lived nearby
Where he first stablished TradeOf Essentials – pen selling business
Lessons of advertisingand necessity of free food
1960in Älmhult IKEA opens the first restaurant 1965
The largest store opens in Stockholm (self-service system)
1980 - 1984stores were opened in Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and China
1970Opens more than 20 stores in the world, from Europe to Australia
1948The business expands into furniture
TIMELINE
1943IKEA is founded as a pen business
1953Furniture showroom opens in Älmhult, Sweden
1958The first Ikea Store opens in Stockholm
1951First IKEA catalogue is published
1956Designing furniture for flat packaging and self-assembly
1985Ikea opens the first store in the USA
FRAGMENTED
·$67 Billion sales in 2002
·Highly disjointed market
COMPETITIVE·Modest competition for Home furnishing ·Big for General retail · Main retailersresponsible for just 14.2% of market share
GAP BETWEEN HIGH END & LOW END·Customer service· Payment options · Trained salespeople· Huge inventories ·Super Centres·Small Shops
HIGH COSTS· Marketing costs to reach people· Land and construction· Staff costs, social security & turnover· Manufacturing industry weak - import
FURNITURE MARKET IN THE USA
HIGH END
GAP
o Ethan Alleno Thomasvilleo Jordan’s Furniture multiple-brand retailersWith sales consultants and interior design services
o Wal-Mart #1 furniture retailero Office Depot o Costcoo Small shops targeted college students
LOW END
COMPETITORS
POD: LOW PRICE WITH MEANING #1
Unique combination of form, function, and affordability
Design & Aesthetic
Low Priced furniture
Right Quality – perceived as not long lasting
Mission: Create a better everyday life
Saving in all directions and partnering with customers IKEA’S
POSITIONING
Store Layout, Childcare center and Restaurant
Stablish target retail price based in a product Matrix
Find a manufacturer to produce it: 978 suppliers
IKEA’s engineers determine the materials to be used in the product: surface X interior
Design process- internal and external professionals
Flat transportation, product in flat-packaged boxes, not assembled.
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT 1
2345
MATRIX
SCANDINAVIAN MODERN COUNTRY YOUNG
HIGH
MEDIUM
LOWPRIC
E RA
NGE
STYLE
IKEA
IKEA
IKEA
IKEA
the company would set its own price point 30% to 50% lower that its rivals.
•Target Competition: finding gaps in the market•Intern gaps within their own portfolio•Identify gaps in the product lineup• Identify market opportunities by looking at the product
offering on the grid and looking of empty spaces
ETHAN ALLEN ETHAN ALLEN
WALMART
WALMARTTHOMASVILLE
THOMASVILLECOSTCO
COSTCO
EXPANSION STRATEGYThe USA invasion didn’t consider local
habits & cultureSpecific aspects of the market ignored
Copy & Paste of Ikea’s European Business Model
Lack of Market Research .
HGHHJKKJJL KJKJKJLL JNKLMLM NKNLM, KLMLML
Lack of appropriate assortment and level of service to match new consumer’s needs. Scandinavian design and DIY culture were unfamiliar for new target
BRAND POSITIONINGTrying to change customer behavior instead
of adapting its products and services to local demand
Target & Niche positioning that wouldn’t sustain the growth needed
KEY ISSUES
PRODUCT & SERVICE MGT
IKEA ENTERS USAEXPANSION STRATEGY
Market Test in Canada in 1976
Market strategy for medium-long term growth
Need of economy of scale
Strong Self Confidence from Europe Success
Ikea Struggled from beginning
1985 – 1990 Operating 5 stores
US Market Challenges
PRODUCT & SERVICE MGT
LIMITED STYLES
COMFORT
SELF SERVICE
DIMENSIONS
SIZE
DYI
LIFETIME FURNITURE PICK UP
PRODUCT
Align US range with overall Ikea
StrategyBedroom & Kitchen as engine of sales
growth
ACTION PLAN
PRICE
Align the price strategy with overall Ikea
StrategyAggressive sales price reduction
OPERATIONAL COSTS
Upgrade stores and open in better
locations
Reduce turnover of staff, stable working
environment and improve operations
GROW SALES
Add a substantial # of stores and
increase in existing ones – economy of
scale
SUPPLY CHAIN
Build local production
More stable profit to fight volatility of
exchange – margins fluctuating with dependency on
importing
MARKETING
Needed all this steps to make it possible to afford
investment in marketing
BRAND POSITIONING
• Campaign: New ad agency based in Miami – Budget $45 million (US)• Award Winning: Cannes | Direction of Spike Jonze (Being John Malcovich)• Target: Americans compulsion to keep outdated furniture• Key message: Commitment free approach to furniture• Furniture as fashion: Adoption of a disposable concept to meet lack of longevity• Results: Continued until 2005 and increased sales in 8% between 2002/2003
Unboring CampaignIkea Lamp, USA 2002 | first TV spot
FIRST RESULTS
19851 Store
$ 50 Million
1992
11 StoreBought a competitor
1999
12 Stores
16 in Market Share
1993 - 1998
No store opening
$ 600 Million
2002
14 Stores
14 in Market Share
2001
14 Stores$ 1.27 Billion
GOAL2013
50 Stores
STRENGTHS
SWOT
STRENGTHS
1. Global Brand Identity & Strong Brand Image
2. Strong and differentiated Area A as compared to competitors
3. Wide product range and styles
4. Hip, Swedish designs
5. Cheap and affordable products
6. Furniture easy to assemble and ship
7. One stop shop for home furniture
8. Friendly atmosphere/ store layout.
9. Facilities – Restaurant and day care center.
10.Strong global sourcing capabilities
WEAKNESSESSWOT
WEAKNESSES
1. Consumer perception of cost vs. quality
2. Locations not accessible or relatively few
3. Assembling furniture may be unappealing to certain groups of consumers
4. Store layout is a hassle if you want just one particular item
5. Swedish designs may not appeal to the North American consumers (USA)
6. Advertising and communications fail to attract the younger minds
7. Furniture are not built to last a lifetime
8. Shortage of inventories for the new market
9. Niche positioning not enough to bring revenues needed
10.Dependent on importing products - weak USA industry and no partnership
11. Currency and exchange rates: products coming from different places
THREATS
SWOT
THREATS
1. Economic slowdown, global economy crisis and recession have
decreased store traffic
2. Barriers to enter new profitable markets
3. Indirect threats from Walmart , Home depot etc.
OPPORTUNITIES
SWOT
OPPORTUNITIES
1. Shifting trend towards greener, sustainable products and lower priced
products
2. Increase ONLINE presence and sales and take advantage of the recent
boom in IT and internet (late 90’s)
3. Educate and attract younger consumers through better IMC tools.
4. Convert few, large stores to more, smaller stores
5. Minimalist trend - clean design, slim forms and plain surfaces - coming
from Europe to western cultures
OLITICAL
Constitutional System
Stability of Government
Business Freedom
Trade Freedom
Tax Policy
P CONOMICAL
Economic Growth
Exchange Rates
GDP Growth
Globalisation
Interest RatesInflation Rate (cost of capital)
Labour Costs
Unemployment Rate
Recession
E OCIAL
Population Growth RateAge
DistributionPerception of Safety & Quality
Educational Infrastructure
Employment Patterns
Cultural Taboos
Home Decor & life style trends
S ECHNOLOGICAL
Emerging Technologies
Impact of Internet
Reduced Communication Costs
IT Boom
Rate of Technological Change
R&D Activity (SEZs)
T
THREAT OF NEW ENTRANTS
BARGAINING POWER OF SUPPLIERS
THREAT OF SUBSTITUTE
RIVALRY AMONG EXISTING COMPETITORS
BARGAINING POWER OF BUYERS
PORTER 5 FORCES
NEW ENTRANTSMEDIUM
Competitive market but chances of new entrants in the cheap furniture business
is HIGH
POWER OF SUPPLIERSHIGH - EUA weak industry
LOW - EUROPE/ASIA too many alternatives
THREAT OF SUBSTITUTELOW
Furniture at home cannot be replaced by A substitute
COMPETITORSHIGH
Major players in discount furniture business
POWER OF BUYERSLOW
unique offer for a gap in the market (high x low end)
PORTER 5 FORCES
PROBLEM STATEMENT
“HOW CAN IKEA FIND THE BALANCE BETWEEN ITS SCANDINAVIAN ESSENCE AND THE LOCAL USA CULTURE IN ORDER TO EXPAND AND MEET ITS GROWTH GOALS BY APPEALING TO A BROADER PUBLIC WITHOUT LOSING ITS UNIQUENESS?”
SCENARIOS
1KEEP UP WITH THE CURRENT EUROPE’S BUSINESS MODEL, ENFORCING IT TO U.S PRICE CONSCIOUS CONSUMERS, BUT ALSO OPENING A PREMIUM BUSINESS IN ORDER TO ATTRACT A NICHE TARGET SEEKING FOR MORE CONVENIENCE.
CURRENT MODEL + PREMIUM STORES 2
INCREASE THE INVESTMENT IN ADVERTISING AND MARKETING IN ORDER TO REINFORCE IT’S REVERSE POSITIONING AND CHANGE CUSTOMER PERCEPTION WHILE POSITIONING STORES IN URBAN DOWNTOWN AREAS AND SUBURBS.
+ MARKETING& STORES TO REINFORCE POSITIONING 3
KEEP UP WITH CURRENT EUROPE’S BUSINESS MODELINTRODUCING EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE BY STRENGTHENING CUSTOMER RELATIONS AND PROVIDING MORE CONVENIENCE, ASSEMBLY AND DELIVERY OF PRODUCTS.
CURRENT MODEL + CHARGED SERVICES 4
INCREASE THE INVESTMENT IN ONLINE PRESENCE & CREATE SPECIAL COLLECTIONS IN PARTNERSHIP WITH LOCAL DESIGNERS AND LOCAL ENGINEERS FOR THAT PARTICULAR MARKET
INCREASE ONLINE + LOCAL COLLECTIONS
1KEEP UP WITH THE CURRENT EUROPE’S BUSINESS MODEL, ENFORCING IT TO U.S PRICE CONSCIOUS CONSUMERS, BUT ALSO OPENING A PREMIUM BUSINESS IN ORDER TO ATTRACT A NICHE TARGET SEEKING FOR MORE CONVENIENCE.
CURRENT MODEL + PREMIUM STORES
CONS
• High costs to implement • Lack of trust in quality• Big efforts to build brand positioning and awareness• Loss of cost efficiency & loss of mass production• Loss of core company values
PROS
• Positive brand association• New target and niche market, broadening the public
base• Test market• Trend social inclusion by premium purchase
CONS
• High cost for frequent advertising.• Consumers are not open to new products and
designs which are not local• Consumer perceptions of Ikea being a brand with
low quality products (difficult to change perception)• The real state prices in downtown areas are high -
increase fixed costs• Ikea’s theme park style is difficult to fit in downtown
area
PROS
• Reverse positioning increases product life cycle and help increase sales
• Improved brand identity, retention and awareness• Attract innovators and early adopters
promote Scandinavian design• Easy access to stores will increase store traffic
and may increase non-drivers visitors• Stimulate small item sales which is a big part of the
business
2INCREASE THE INVESTMENT IN ADVERTISING AND MARKETING IN ORDER TO REINFORCE IT’S REVERSE POSITIONING AND CHANGE CUSTOMER PERCEPTION WHILE POSITIONING STORES IN CRITICAL URBAN DOWNTOWN AREAS AND SUBURBS.
+ MARKETING& STORES TO REINFORCE POSITIONING
CONS
• Consumers won’t pay extra• Expensive to implement, train and manage the
operation · • Loss of cost efficiency and loss of profit margin
PROS
• Local acceptance – Customized for US• Faster results vs consumers changing their behavior• Attracting non-drivers and non-DIY consumers
3KEEP UP WITH CURRENT EUROPE’S BUSINESS MODELINTRODUCING EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE BY STRENGTHENING CUSTOMER RELATIONS AND PROVIDING MORE CONVENIENCE, ASSEMBLY AND DELIVERY OF PRODUCTS.
CURRENT MODEL + CHARGED SERVICES
CONS
• No assistance and specialized staff• People like to look and feel items• Expensive online shipping• Risks of delivery damage• Returns can be an issue• Products more expensive due to loss of mass
production & efficiency ·• Different styles might impact the whole operation• Loss of brand identity and Scandinavian style• Impact on their uniqueness & essence·
PROS
• Good supply chain to facilitate deliveries• More convenient for consumers• Worldwide presence with small investment• Bigger product portfolio• Reduction of staff costs• Direct appeal to local consumers• Customized offer & local strategy• Market test, can be expanded to other areas
4INCREASE THE INVESTMENT IN ONLINE PRESENCE & CREATE SPECIAL COLLECTIONS IN PARTNERSHIP WITH LOCAL DESIGNERS AND LOCAL ENGINEERS FOR THAT PARTICULAR MARKET
INCREASE ONLINE + LOCAL COLLECTIONS
RECOMMENDATION
+ MARKETING& STORES TO REINFORCE POSITIONING
CURRENT MODEL + CHARGED SERVICES2 3+
We strong believe in the potential of 4 alternatives presented, but being realistic, considering budget limitation Ikea would be facing after more than a decade struggling with low sales & profitability in the US operation we recommend the combination above.
• Ikea opened 15 new stores in 2015 – 2 in USA
• Total Ikea 2015 Revenue € 31 Billion – USA represents 14%
• USA is the 2nd top selling country after Germany
• America is the 2 biggest regional market, only after Europe
• 3% of total purchases are made in the USA
2015 | IKEA USA
USA 2015
LEARNINGS•Be consistent and true to the core values
•Put consumers in first place – pass cost savings instead of only improving profit margin•Think locally and adapt your offer instead of trying to change consumer behavior
•There’s no one size fits all in marketing and business strategy
• The control of the value chain can give more competitive advantage and consistency to everything the company does