iiml_consult casebook summers 2009 batch
TRANSCRIPT
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 1/34
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 2/34
! "# $%&
'
( )# * %# + *, ) $ - .# +& "+ # /( + % 0#( "( 1 0 ! .1 ++& ' 2 +
*
+& ,
"1 !-
3 # "(# 01
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 3/34
4301 5 1
/ / 6++# 4+
7# # 8#&
! "
91 4 # 4: ;# # 8 # %+ ;# # # #3#+
! # #!
/ 3 8 +# & # 8## + #1+ # # 8%8# % # # # % < 3;+ 8% < =< % #+ % # %# 8 # +% # #1 # 3 &# +% 466 4#1 >3< 33#1 ># #3# # & &#< &3 & 3#% 1 # #& 71< % # % %# ## % + < 8 & ++ + #3;# #
$ % &
8 3 &# %3# #3# # # 3 % 33# # 1# 8 # + &# 8 & # +# # /+ %% #
$ % &
8 3% # + # + # #+# 1< # & # % 8 & +##+ # 8# 1 ## # # 1 3
' # # (
8# # # + # +##+ # #3# +# / %< ##& # 1 # # &# 1 ++ # +# #< # # # #&
$ 4301 % 1
$ /1 .#
7# % 8#&
! "
# ;# #% # 1 = & %< # #1 # 1 3 & ## ? 3% # 1 %## # .4. .3#3 # 4301< &3 8 #%% # &
! # #!
/ 3 & # #3# < &3 & # # % # # ># 3< # # # #%1 3 # 8 % # .#@ 3 &< &3 & 1 % &# ? #+#&1 #% # ;# & 1 < % 8 ;31 3 &# # #31 & + + # # >3 #< 3% ## 3## 8 #+#% 1 33 1 + # &# & #+ % # ##% + # < % # #& & 1 1 # #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 4/34
$ % &
8 % ;# #+# # 3 %3 % #+#% 133 # %
$ % &
8 %@# # 1#+ &# &+ < # 1 & # # 8#& 8% %
' # # (
/+ % #+ 8 3# # + A # 4663 # 1 & &# /1 #+#+ #33 %&< 1
$ 4301 5 1
/ =# 3# .#
3% # 5 B1 8#&
! "
/ & 3 # #&< 1 3#3#
! # #! $ % & $ % & ' # # (
$
.4+
3%
! "
91 % # & 3% 1 # #&: 8 % # 1 2 91 # 33 :
91 3: # &3 8 %%@# &C
! # #!
8#&D # # ## # #3 +# 14D 8 % # % # +% # 8 & %% # 3#1 #;%## < # #3 % E#F # / 8 &% # #3 % E# 3#+ # ;< < # 3#+ &3 +#% %# # 3#1 ##+ &# # E# 8 &% #1 # ## # % ++ # # &# 3 3#+ %%+ # #1 D %#< 33 +&1 1< 8 &% #1 # ## # % ++ # # # 3 #3 3#+ $& 8 #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 5/34
+ % # +# % # %# $&< 8 3 33# #+ % #3#+ 3#+ $& 8 # %#< 8 3 # #3 %#1 %# # # 1 ##F < &# # #3 +# ;% ## 3#+ # %%+ # #3 %#1
8#& D )#@ 1 ## +% ;%# +# 3#% #& 9# &% # 3# # )1%:4D 8##1 < #1 &% 3< % #3 & # &1 # % # + # # 1 % & %3
8#& D 8 8 1 ## # & %3 % 8@ 33#< 3 (#1 ##:4D # #+ $ < 8 3#8#& D 8 # + # # %3 1 %< # #3 & # # # #< #1 %+ 33#1 #% ## #< # # & %34D 8 3#1 %%@# # 3#< 8 ##% #& % % ## 8 +## +3
$ % &
# # 3< 8# & 3# 3# 1 3 % + 8 & 3 ## # % 8 #% # 31 ## #+ # >#
$ %
$ &
% #+# &+ # 3% 3
' # # (
2@# #1 # ## 3# % 3#3
$
.#
7#
! "
9% 1 # #%3 1: 8#3# #% # 1 1< ## < + 7 71 #% ;#< 3%+ & 1 # # 3 3% ! 9#G?& &% 1 %3 " 2< # 43 7 3< # +# + # %3 #& # % :
! # #!
H 3#+ %3 # %3#D < % # %3# 3 " / . I " *< I " - % I "
/ 31 %3 # # # # %3# 8 % # #< # 6B # 31 ## # 31 %33## %3+ < & # 1 ## #1 % + %3# / 6B< % 1< 3 # 1 3## 1 #:
.# I $ # J .# #
.# # >%F 3 # # # #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 6/34
/ # ## 3# # # ;% # %3# 3 # %3# < % 8 # 3< # #& #% ## # # %3# < & # ' % /< ## & + 3% # %
B# # >% D
• / # +&# # # %3#
•
/ #> %% %3#< 3 # 1 3 #
3# • ## # + %3#
$ % &
9 # # # # # 3 6>% 1 # % % % 3# ?% 1 +% #3# #% # 1 1 % 1
$ % $ &
8 & # # #3# # 1 1 / & 1 3 8# # &1 ' 3% %% ##@ &1 8>% # # #> % 3 ### #3< # # # G ##< &3 &% ## 3
' # # (
&# < 1 < # # < #% # + #3 # #3 #+ &3 # #& &% #% 9 #1 < # #@ ## @ #1+ # % 1 + 1 % # 8 # # 3 &% # # #& &13< &3 # 3 &% 33#+ 3 %# # 3
$
.#
3%
!
"
?& & # # #&:
#+ #% # 1 # #& # #% # 1 1< ## < + 7! ?& 1 #1 # 884 )3&:
! # #!
) H / KLM +# 3#+ / 31 1 3#1< # 3# # 3#1 7 #< # %## # %3##+# # 3#1 % 3< 3 ### 3# / 3##< ##% 1 # &1 / +# # 313 # & ## # ### 3# # 3## 3%1 # # 8 % # % # # < #1 % 1 &
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 7/34
& 1 + # #:
/ ## ### 3# # 31 & %% # 3# / 3%D
• / %#3 #% #
• # 0 %#3
• $ # &3 & %% %+ # #3 33#1
#E#
3 # 3## & 3#% # < # %#3 #% # % # 3# # 0 &% # / +# # ## # 8# +# ## # KLM 31 +## 1 #E+ # 33#1 # #3 % 3< ;% # # ## # +# # 3## /<#1 % 33##+ # > #E# # 33#1
B# # ## 3 >% 3%D
• "# &# # ## %
•
9# 3## % # & # #3 ###
• / %## # 3##
* + ,
L # % 6.$/" 7 3+ # 8% % 1 #%%+ # # +# # ?& &% 1 + # %+ #:
/ ## 3 1 3% # 1 #3#+ # # 3
#& &1D• B # 3#D 2% # 3# 'N< ## #&
'N % + , N
• B # +D 2% # # +F ''N< '' 'N% ' 'N
7 3 # 3#1 % # %% # # # # + + $&< 3#< # + + ' H ' # 1 #  )# # N # 7 & % # + +< # # N
8 3 ## #&< # 3#+ '' + + 3 % # 'N % N % & # + +
9 + # 3 1 % ## %1  7 # / # ## 3 3% # # &1
$ % &
8 ## >+ # # + & # #3 %# &# % & 3% # # 3
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 8/34
#3#% # ## 3 & % 1E% # # 3#1 # +% #3# 1 1
$ % $ &
2%@# 3 #+# +%+ # # ##% # # 3 6>% # # +
/ ;# # # #1 # 884 )3& & #&% # % %8 8 %%@# & # ?% 3#
### # # # # + #
' # # (
+ % # + % # #3#+ &# + &# # 3 1 % 2 # #< 8 % 1 3# 3 # 1#& % 1 % 1 # #+ % & < 8 % #3# 3 # #& >3# 1 # % # %3 % & 3 1 31 # &% &# #& & +# # &1< #@ % # #
"# $%&
$
< 0.4< 6 5L
4#1< #1 & # # # 33%
/& % < % 3 #
!
"
/ & + ;# 91 3#+< 91 # 31<
#3B# ;# & 331 #% # 1 < 3%3 3+%< &>3 % ##
! # #!
L 3# &# # # 3# 3#1 ?& &% 13 % &# 3# &% 3# # 3# %3:
L 3# %% 1 #< + &3 3# 3% &## 3#3 ?&< # & 1 %1 < & # 3 # 1%1 + ## # 3# %3+ # # ++ / 3# 3% "3 % 2# &3 ## # ?& % #1 # % 3 # %3#:
6## # # 3% % 3 8%:!
4 3% 2=2 + # % 3 " ! 3 31< K # # # & 1 5 + 2=2 " ' ?& % #1 3# # ### 3#1 + %%:
' 6## # %% 33# # 8%*
6## # E # #># 8%#1: O8# & 33 ;# 8 + # #P
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 9/34
$ % &
8 % 3 % # # %# 3 1 &>3 8 % #%% & % 3 +%# % # % # 3% &% 3# &1E+ # % ++ #3# # 1 1
$ % $ &
8 3< 8 +# # # 3 # #& 8 %##1% #+ &3 & # 3## &# # &1 &#% #3 # 3 8 % #3#% &# # %#% >3# ;#
' # # (
2@# 31 3 +##+ # +# # / ++# # # 1 3 / 1 #+ #& ##% # 1#+ 38 # #3#%< 3 A%#%+ 1 %#1< 2#3# 1 3 & %++ # 3< L 3 <#3
( )#
$ 431
6++# 4+
7#
! "
9# %% 1 % 1 #: 8 % #?& & 1 % # : 9# # & 1 % &1:.EED L # 1 &# 3#+ ' " / &# &# & # 1 L # % +# +# 1%% # +# # 1 # &# 9# &% 1 %:
! # #!
6## # %% #% 8% L 3 ## # 1 #1 #% 3#+
$ % &
6##% # %% 33#1< #+#% # #< &% #33# 3 33# % # %%+ # #< #< # 3# 4% 8 3% %% # 3#<+1 % # 3# # 3 # #3 %% % #33 % %%
$ % $ &
7 % ## #3# & 33#+ # # 7 #3 # # # 3#1
'
# # ( ### #%% &1 # 3% % 1 33
( )#
$ 431
3# 4+
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 10/34
3%
! "
/ #+ # 1 & >391 %% 1 884 & 1 31#+ 1 &% #
! # #!
.6 &# # # ##1 2=2 # # 8% % #
/ 3#G3;# 3# 3%# 3% 31 %%13% / 3 1 #+ # 9# 3 #
$ % &
D )% # %< # 3 31<%% %< %< +#% # 3#< ##% % 3# /% ## # &% 3 # &# .6 %% ##D % # # #< # ##< &%3# < 3## #3 2%% # >% % 3# %%3#% ## 1 3# &% 3% 3#
$ % $ &
' # # (
3%#< # 1 #< % #1 # ++ # 33#1 ++ # & 8#& &# ##1 >3
( )#
$ 431
.#
/%
! "
?& # %1:1#+ 1 &% #
! # #!
8 ' 3 5 888 ' 4 / ##& #+ ' 3 % ' 3 "3#1 9# #
$ % &
8#1 33% &# # & 8 1 %#1+ 1 # %## # < 31 3 % 1
3 # #8%#% # &+ D
4#+ # 1 888 9% # 3 # / &# " ## +1!
)& #F %+3' # %1 #F . #3+1*
3 #&% # +, B# = %% 1 888
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 11/34
$ % $ & ' # # (
%# +
$
.(3# 4+
7#
! "
/ #+ # 1
! # #!
/ + 31 73 8% + 3 % #1 %# 8# &# # >% # # # ++1 / %#1< 3#< #< %% # # %3# +# %# 6## # # %% # %3# # & ++1% % &3 %3# +# # % #
$ % &
2% +# 33# 3 % & )1 3% 1 # +# 1< % %#1 % #16#% & # 3##< 3## # # %3#
$ % & / 1 + # # # < 3% # 33% % # # 33
'
# # (
3 33# %+ # # # #& 0 #
33
%# +
$
.#
3%
! "
/ 3#1 8 + #: 8 # # # # 8 #1+ &1 : 41# >3 3#1 )3& %1 3#3# 8##: 9#3+%31 3< #3# / #& % %&%+ #3# 3# < % # # 3+ #%% ;# 8 + 3#3# %#1 % > &# 8 /= % & 3#3# %#1 &% 3+ &# # + &+ &% # + %+< + >71 #3#
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 12/34
! # #!
H 3#+ %3 # %3#D < % # %3# 3 " / . I " *< I" - % I " / 31 %3 # # # # %3# 8 % # #< # 6B # 31 ## # 31 % 33## %3+ < & # 1 ## #1 % + %3# / 6B< % 1< 3 # 1 3##
1 #:.# I $ # J .# # .# # >%F 3 # # # # / # ## 3# # # ;% # %3# 3 # %3# < % 8 # 3< # #&#% ## # # %3# < & #' % /< # # & +3% # %
$ %
&
2% 3## 1 % % #+ 3# 33# 2@# &
&# # & +# 3 # $ % &
9# 3 %# 1 < +# # 3% ## %# # 1 % # 1E # 3 &
' # # (
9# &# %# + 1< % > &# # ;% # 3 #
%# +
$
/%
! "
6> # 1 (
! #
#!
3 3 31 + # + 3 ## &3 & 3 3 # %:23 # 3# ## % 3% + 3 ##
$ % &
6>% 33# 3 # %< #33 % 1 3 %% 3# ;31 3+ % +< 3;#< #3< 3 3+< 3# #3 % 3# &
$ % &
3 431 # ## # 3#+ #.1< # 3#% +#
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 13/34
' # # (
%# +
$ 431
42< 45 %1
7#
! "
% # (
! #
#!
/ & #+ & L # % # 3# 1 3# ?& & 1 % # #: ?& & 1 (#1 # 1 3# 3 1 %%+ # >3 " 3:
;# # $ % &
$ % &
' # # (
%# +
$ 431
.#
3%
! "
?& & # %1: 6#3
! # #!
74 31 &# # # # 3+% # (3 +# 8% 9# 3# % # # # 33#: = # # (3 &# # # ###: 91 %#3++< 3+ ##+1:
$ % &
1E% # & ##+ ;## % ;### 3# "(3#< 3# #3 ##< 72 +#
$ % &
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 14/34
' # # (
/1 # 3 1 3# / #& # % & %3# #&% # 3 +
%# +
$ ( .# 6;#1
23#< 3#
3% 7# % & # 3%
! "
) # 884 )3& #3 9# & >3 3< ##& % ;# + %# # # 1< # #3#@ < % & %
! # #!
# # +#3 31 8% / # 3 &3 # &% # + # %3 &# # # # #< .63#
$ % &
1E% # 3 & 3%+ +&# ## # %#1< +&### # 31< 1 3# %#+ # 33< 3#%< 3#< 3 #3 % + < 431 &# # 3# 27 # < "# #%#< % ## 3# ;#1 % # # ;# # .6
$ % &
' # # (
+ 1 3# 33%+ # # &3 # 1 # 3% # 7 >D .6 # +&# ## &# + #3# 3# # # ## 1 %#% #< % #3% #
$
$
4301 % 1
6++# 4+
7#
! "
23% 1 = # 41 # %+ % +%# 8% #% # /3< ## /% # 1 % &1 4: 91
3#+:
/ Q&1 3#@ ;# 1 #3% 3# 333+% # + # ## 1 % # 3 #+ # % &% # Q#@ # #& #+ 1 =
! # #!
/ 3 & # %3+ ##1 8# ## $& 2)% ##1 3 # 8 %% # 33# #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 15/34
% + # #%% 3# # % 1 #3# ?% # #3# & % % # 3# 8 3% # # 11 # #% (# # #
/ ## & # + % 3# & # 8 % # # # 3 # 8 # # # % %3%% # #3# &% +# & 7% + % ##% !.C .%3# + # % # # # %C % # 3 # # ? &#
# % % + ##1 + #1 3 % ##1 # # % #
8 % # %3# > % 3+% # # 1 & # %%3% / 3 #% # 3 & ?&< &%# &# ##+ ;# # &1 # 1 % 8 + #& +% ## & # % &# #% #C +# 3 % 3 #+? % # # # # # &# # & # ## 1 % &3 % # 8 # # 3#1 # % 3 &# # % ## 1 # & % #% # 3 #< 1
+ 3 # % ## # 3 3% 3 & #1 &#% # 3
%% # % + # & B # & +%3
$ % &
/ # 3 1 1 %1 61 # 8 & # %3# ## 8 3% 1 # # #+ #
$ % &
8 & #% & &# # 8 & # +##+ #+# % # # & # 1 ;#
'
# # (
.3#3 % 1 #+ # # 3 # #&% # #+ # & # #& 3%+
$
$
4301 % 1
3# .#
3%
! "
= # + Q&1 3#@ + & 8 + #1 & 33+ 3#31
! # #!
8## %3 &# #% %+# # # 3R3 ## # 3R3 ## 3 %
9 #% &1 #+ # 3
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 16/34
$ % &
B # + 4%% ## # #3# & + %
$ % &
/ %+ # 8 & #%
'
# # (
9 3% &# %1 #& 1 3 % # > # # % #
# 1 +% %& 3#1
$
$
4301 % 1
6++# 4+
7#
! "
+1 # Q3# @ C % 8 &#% # 31 1#+
! # #!
& # C + 8% 9#% # # # ## 33# % #3# %+ 8 %#% 33#1 # &# % # 1 # # + # 9 #% +##+ %#
$ % &
#3# )+3 #+ 41 # #
$ % &
$#+ 8 3 #
' # # (
$ .
.# +&
$
7#
! "
& 1 %+ 3+ # ! 1 (: 1 #% &# 1 %3 (+ 884 ): 9# 1 # # )1% # 81 % # 3+ 3# 3+ (# ! 1: / #+ # 1 81 # 3# 3#:
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 17/34
! # #!
/ #3# 3# ? % # 3 # 3#1# ## # # 3# # #: ? %+ # %3# # % +% % + #3# 9# # #
D / 3 &3 8 # & % # + # +# #3% # # # % ## & & 8 +# #3 / & #% # # # +##+ +#% # ## 3 # ;# + & #3# &3 # 31 & # 3
%3+ $ % &
$ % & $#+ &# +# 8 % # # 1 ++
' # # (
1 % % 3 1 8 #% # # + #+ %+ 1 # 3 % % # ++ # /1 # 3%% % # +31 % #3#1 ## # 1 3 1 3G% / # # 1 % # %@# %
"+ #
$
4301
7#
! "
4# +3# 3# 91 3#+
! # #!
8 ##% 1 31+ # 33 # % &# % # #& 13 8 & #% ## # 33 # & # 3 1 1 +3# # % # 3 & #% # 3 % # # 8 #% # & +# 3 # %+3 # %&#& % & % 3 # #1 ##< # #& % # # ### # 3# 3 # 3 + % 8# #141 3 1 ##% &# 3% # ## 8# ## > % #% 1 3 >3# 33 3 / 3 # # # % % # + +< 3+< +% #3 % % # %3# &3 & # ##&
$ % &
8 & +% # #+ # # &% 8# % %&#& 11
$ % &
# 8 % # # > ## 3 3 # ### %1 < 8 (% # # 3 % # 1%+ % % #3# / & # 1 # % # ## ! #% # +# 1 3 & 3 #+#
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 18/34
% # # + &#
' # # (
B %# #+ ## # #& &# # # & & &3+ 3 # # % % # # & 3 #1 + 1# # # # % 1 %@# #
"+ #
$
4301
3%
! "
B # ## 8 &% &# # # # 1 ++# ++# 1 = # = #% ;#
! # #!
/ #& 3% #+#&1 ## & + # ;3 % 133# ## 8 ##% + # #%# # %%+ # # # % # 3 % 8 & % # % # 1 1 % # 3 # &# # 33 % # & # +1 % # # 3# & #%+# # ? # 1 & # +1 % + #% 3 +1 # # # ##& # 33
1#3 ;#D
! 8 & 3% &# # ;# 3 8 #+# # & # % %#% ## & 3# % # & ? % # &1 8 & 1+ ##% #% ## # % 3# # # #7 8 # # # # # # # # %% %3# # / & 3 ## & # # # # # # # ## & &## ##
$ % &
8 % # +## ##1 33#1 3 # #& % # & 1 3 # # #1 + # # 3#
$ % &
/ 3% ;# & 3#1 #31 # ;# 8 % #+#1 8 &#% # # + # # #
' # # (
/ #+ &+ + % 3# # 1 & 3#% # # 3 B 3 %+ # # %%
/(
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 19/34
$
7#
! "
$ % # 3 #
! # #!
6## # % # # # ' 1 $#+ & +?&< # %# & + %% & 8 % #
$ % &
##% & 1 + # +# ;#
$ % & # #3 & #& % 3%@# % &
' # # (
/(
$
3%
!
"
# 1 >#33 3##
! # #!
31 &# # # # # 1+ % + % 36## # # ## # # ## % 3 8%
$ % &
$ % & %@# % # +# 3 # 3%
'
# # (
/(
$
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 20/34
/%
! "
# 1
! # #!
31 %3 %3# / 3# % # # # & +
%% %3# / 33## # %3 1 #%3# ## + # +# # # 6# # $ % &
.3%% &# # +# 3 % % # & # %
$ % & # #3 3 % # #& % # + #
' # # (
+ %
$ 2##
7#
! "
/ #+ # 1: 91 #+: # (3# 9 3# 3%% #33;# # #& % >3 ## %
! # #!
$ 3#1 # % # # 8%4# % # % &# # 3 # # 1 % N + # ++# %+ #
8 ##% 1 + # # 3 +# &3 # % / & % 3#+ & 3 # # 1 > / 8 ;% # # 1 3% % # 3 %%< # # & & 31 3 & # # / 8 ;% # >%# %#+ & 3 # # #3< # &3 # & & 1
8 ++#% ## 1 # & #3 # 3# # # #< # %#1 #3 &3 # 31 3% %## 1 1 3% 3%3#% # % # 1#+ #3 ## # #3 # # 31 3% # &# 24 % "3 // 8%3< & # # %% + &# # 33#
$ % &
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 21/34
$ % &
.1 & # & 3+ &# # # % %% # & 1 #3#% 3
' # # (
L % #+ &# 1 % #%1 # 3# #% # 1# (3# ##1 &
0#( "(
$ 43 01
7#
! "
• 91 3#+:
• / # 1
! # #!
/ 3 & # # ;#1 &3 % # # %3 # 1 & 31 8 1 # & &% 1 3%: / #& &#% # # 3 % & &+ # + %# ;% # %3
$ % &
8 & # #3# # 3 % & 33% 1 3
$ % & ' # # (
%1 # > 3 1 #.3#3 & 33# # ## & + 3
0#( "(
$ 43 01
7#
! "
• / #+ &3 # 1
• / # # (3# &3 1 #%1+
! # #!
? #% # 3# % # 3 & ## 8 #% &# ? # % ## # 31 3 &3 3# 7 # # 1 # # %3+ ++# &1 # #
$ % &
8 & # 3 # # # &1 # & + 8# & 3 # +# +%+ # # 3#3#1 & 3#1 &
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 22/34
$ % &
8 # 3%# # & # 3 8 3% 3 &# &#
' # # (
"> % %& #3# &3 %#% & 1 &+
1 0
$ 4301
$< .#
/%
! "
8# & 3# 3# + 0# % #
! # #!
/ # # #3# ( Q@ & 'N # 1 % ## ## 3## Q@ & N ?&< # 1 # # ## 1 N / #3# ( 33% # %#+ 'N &% # 1 9# 3 # 3 %#3 %3# # # :
$ % &
#3#% # 3 1
$ % & 4% # 3#3 # # # & # 3#3 ;31
' # #
(
2 1 1 31 #
.1 +&
$ 0.4
7#
! "
% # 3% %
! # #!
)- KLM 3 &# # #%3 # # 8# 3# 1 3#+ # ## &# # %3# & # % & ## 3 # %3#< + &# # #+ % # ##+
/ ## # #1 % ##1 # # 3 1E% #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 23/34
# &+ 3#D
• ###D #+ < #
• 3D # 3 3 & # ### 3# & 3%+ %3# 3
• ##D # 8 % ;# # # # # 31 % # %+ 3## # # % #1E% #
7 # #+ % # ##+ 8 ++#% # &+D• / 3 % 3## &# # ### # 3
3 #
•
"# 3%# 1 ## + %3# # #
• 8#%3 # %3# 3# # 3 1 3 #1 %@# # 1 # # %
*- 884) 3#1 # ' # # &%< &# 3#% # E% # + # + # # ' ###
/ 3# # % & D
•
%# # 3#1
• %
• .3#
• S3# #%#
• 8#3#
/ &% # 3# / 8 #% & 3 # &% ## 3# # # 3# # ## & 3 #3% %
$ % &
"+%+ # # 3 8 % (3# #+ 1 = #3 & + #% # ##< &3 8 % % 8 &# # +# 3 #3#% < &3 & # # # % & # 3 &# +% #
$ % &
' # # (
3 +# + #+ # %#1 (3# &3 1 1 =< 1 % 3 &%+ # ## # 3 #3#% < # #& % # & # # # % #+ L 3 + # 3 1 ##
2 $
7#
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 24/34
! "
/ #+ # 1
! # #!
!( " ( .(
" D 9# # 3# 3# 3 %##:
# $ # 3 % # 3 %
"# < #1 % # 3## L
"# 2 # % # # 3 %@ &# L< '* # # #
"# 9# 3#+ 3# +# 3 %##:# % N< # ##
"# 9# # :# /1 ## + # #
"# E% # %+ # & % ##% # ;### & % # > ! / # ! % % "
"# 8 &% # > # 3# ## &1 &% N +## # 2## L< &# 3 # :
"# 41 < #1 # +##+ # #1 # ##
3%# # L< # &1 ## 3 3 %# # ## %@# &# #
"# 3< # 3 %# # # # 3 %< #1 3 3++ # % + %& 1# / 3 # 3 %# %3+ # 1## B< % &# 3 # # &1 &3 # 3 %# # 3 %
"# / 3 %# 3 # 3# # 3 # % 3 % 1
& 3 + # 1 % # 3 %# & & # # B< &1 &%@# % ##:
"# 3 # ## # + # #3 %# 3 % # ## # 3#># + &3 % + # # D 7
"# 8 &% # E # 3 3
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 25/34
# L< %T1 # 3U
$ % &
9# 3 8 3% % % # # # 3
$ % &
' # # (
)#+ 1 ## 3# 3 #& )# #
3 & E+ # 3< % %# 3 #&3 #& # 3 #
# < & 1 # %# % 1 ## 1 1 # 1 3
E+ # # % 3 #& 1 ## & # ##
2 $
3%
! "
/ # 1 3% &+ # 1 31
! # #!
' ! !! !!0 (. ! # (
8 ##% &# #& ; # # 3 ## # ++ # 3 # 38 3 # & ## & % # % # &# 3 & # ## 3< &# # 3 ## & & #38 ++#% ## 8 & 3 #3 3#1 % # ## &# #%3 8#& & &# #
01 3# ## 3 # # 3D ## % 3 & % 1 &3 3% # ##
3# + 3#+ # - 3 ## 3 # % 3D
• "+ 3D ?+ < & #
• .%3 3 3D 4% < % #< + 3#
•
33%# 3D )& < + #8 % # % # #& 3 % + # # 3
7& # & %3% #% # ## 2< & 8 #%# 3+ 5 %+ ## #3 # 2 % & &
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 26/34
3E% 3 3 +#+ # #
$ % &
8 #% # # & % %%@# % 1 3
$ % & '
# # (
/ # % > # % % 1
## 3 #&
2 $
/%
! "
% # #% # 1 =
! # #!
3# %3 %3# < 5 ? 3#1 33## #< 3 + 1 ## % 33## /< #< # %< # # # %3 # < 5 #3 & +
$ %
&
/ & # %# % &# % & # +# 3 % # # # # # %#
$ % & ' # # (
2 # +# ++% %& 1 # 3 %# &# ## 1
2 $ 43 3 #& 1 431 #
! "
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 27/34
! # #!
' ! 1*1 ( 2!
/ 1 33#+ &# # 3# + # %D
• .#
• 4
• 3
T8# % ## 3## % & .# %< 3 4% 3 3 # # # 31< % # 1 # 3+ +3# 33#+ + # & #& 8 %3%% # 3 ##U
73+ .#D.# + 3#% 1 & 3#< 3 D
2#3 33# 7;31 33# $ 3# # 33# &#
# & ;#< & 3 # & ## # 31 % ## 3# %#3 3 %3% 1 %+ # 3 3#13 #+ # 3 #% 3 3#1 3 % 3 %#3% 31
$% 9 3 > # # # %+ # 3 # #< ## 33# &@# 1+ # 3 #< 3# # "
V N ## #< # # '"< ## # #& # & # " /< # ' #< 3 # 3 #& #
& # 3 % # #1 3#1 &# ## # # & (3#% 1 #& 33# ## %1 3# & &#
/ #& +% # # # ## 3# 3 &@# ## +3#
$ %
& $ % &
' # # (
8 %%@# 3 &# # ## # % ## 33# 1 &8 #+# # # # (3#% # #+ ## # 1 # 3 #3 # # # #& % # + %3# # # #. 0 23 # &# #& % + # # (3#+ >+ # # /1 &% # #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 28/34
%# 1 #+ < 1 Q# # >@ % 3 3#1 %+# #&
+&
$
2#
7#
! "
3#+ #& # # ##% &# # ;#D ' % # 3 # ### #3 # &# # 1 ☺
! # #!
31 ##% $# 8% 3 # & # # &## 8# 33% &# # + ## 3# # 3+ 3% ## 3##
$ % &
/ #& % 3# & % # 1 # & +#< &3 #% ;# 1 )#3% # % # & 1 #
$ % & $# 3
' # # (
)# # # #& 31 % #1 # #3 # # & # %# 33W% # # # 1&1
+&
$
2 #
3%
! "
! # #!
31 &# # # # # # 3% ?% 3 6## #
E # # % % # 31 # # %3 # # ##
$ % &
$# 3
$ % &
/ # %3 # 1 % # 3 & ##3#% &# %
' # # (
2@# # #3#%
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 29/34
"1
$ 34
7#
! "
/ #+ # 1 9# 1 %# # #%# 884 )3&
! # #!
6## # E # 33+ %#1 # 8% / &%3#1 #% # 1 & >3
$ % &
8 # 1 3
$ %
&
8 ##% # &+ &1 % & #
' # # (
/ # # # 1 ## 3+ # #
"1
$ 34
7#
! "
/ #+ # 1 91 % 1 &# 3 3#+
! # #!
31 &# # # # # + % 3 23 # ##1/ # # 3## % 3 1 &% %
$ % &
8 & 3%# % 3#1 33% # 3
$ % &
' # # (
/ 1 + # ;#
"1
$ 34
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 30/34
7#
! "
9# % 1 # &# +% G % # # #&:
! # #!
6## # E # # 8%
$ % &
0# + # +< % # ;31 9 1 # 3 &# ##
$ % &
' # # (
.3#3 ;3 33# )# +# % # # 33#
"1
$
5%
7# /& 3
! "
1 : 9# 1 >3## : 9# 1 >#33 3## 3:= % ;#
! # #!
D L # & ## L 3#3#% # # #& & 1%1 / & + 33 % +
# # #& # ?&< 1 # + 8#+#
D L 3#1 31 % % > ## # 3 L # #1 3 % # %3# &+ L # 3# 3% 3#1 8+ # 3# L # #& 3# #< # + % # # # 8#+# +## # %# #
$ % &
3% # 3< # &# # #
$ %
&& &# 33#
' # # (
0&%+ < 31 4$ 8< 1 ## 431 #1 %@# 1
3 #
$ 431 5
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 31/34
3# ##
7# # 8#&
! "
91 #+: L 7 1 = ?& & ## 1 #: /+ #& & # 8 #& &#% # ## 1 3:
! # #!
# 3# # # # # 8% ?& % 3%:
41 3D3 # #1 # # # % ##1B# 3# & /# 3##< /# % & 3# &3 & 3 1 3+
$ % &
41 # 3#3 + 3 % # #3#% 3 & & 3#% 1 # #&
$ %
&
41 # &%+ # # %#1 8 % # % #%
# #& # #< ;#% & 8 & # % 1 11 & X 8 % 3 # %#1Y
' # # (
## 1 # # # #& % %@# 1 &%+ # 3 /# 1 3 & 3+ % ##3#1 + %& # 3 # #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 32/34
3 #
$ 431 5
3# ##
7#
%
8#&! "
9# 1 # # ## #+# % &:)% # % 3%:
! # #!
## + # # + ?& # # :
3D .##1 < %& # " % #"D 73# #3# 3< % # #3 &3%%
#D # 3#< # #3 #3 & ## % &%3% & & # %3 # $ % &
+ #3#% 3
$ % &
8 ;31 3 # # #. 8#& # & # 33+
' # # (
# #& 3 1 %# 3 1 +# #3 &. & 1 3 & .8 #
"(# 01 $
4301 5 )#%
.( 3# / +1 & $L 3 % % (% 8% 3 (#
& & 3
7#
!
"
? ##% &# # #%3# # / # & ;# & 3 7# % # # #+ 1 8#% & # % # & 3;#+ % ##
$># % # 1 &> % &# 8 %% # ? %+ # %#= # % % %# %3 ;# & =% % + ;# &1 3#+ &1 43 #3 & # % / ;# #% % ' #
! # #!
8 ## .( & + # 3 1 / # & 3# % # %3# & < 5 &#! 3#N< 3#N % N3# # % #%3#
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 33/34
$ % &
8 % & %+ # # ;# ## % ## +# % #% 33# #& % .(2+ # 3 8 ++#% & # 3++ # %+ ##<+ 3# #3 &3 .( % 1 # # 1 #
$ %
&
8 # %++% # & & ;# %+ # # ##& 2+ # 3 8 % 1 # &+ ! ## #% ! ## ## # 3#%
' # # (
33%+ # < # # #& # # ## + # #3% % 8 3 1 3& 1 # #&< 33 + # #3% % 3 1 /1 # 33# &# # #& % %# 1 1 # +# 3 # 31 # % ##1 # 3& 1#+
"(# 01
$ 4301 5 )#%
=1 3# .#
7#
! "
=1 & 3% # ++ 8 & + 33# &3 # #& & 33##% ? % #& ;# / #+ ##+ # 1 ?& % 430 3 &# 1 &# # %
! # #!
/ 3 & 1 # ? #% ## 8 & 3## ?# &3 33% &# # & 3%3 # / %3#< 3#< % 3+ & / 1 & #%#1 # # # % 3## ## 3 % #% ## ##
$ % &
/ & # # ;# & ##1 +% % %% 1 ##
$ % &
+ %% 1 # # %+++ # ;#1 # 5 %3#+ 1% 1 # #
' # # (
/1 # + # 1#+ ## 3 3# #3 ##G3 /1 +# # # #+ + % 1 # #&< # # & #%# 1 &%+ #
8/11/2019 IIML_consult Casebook Summers 2009 Batch
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/iimlconsult-casebook-summers-2009-batch 34/34
"(# 01
$
4301 5 )#%
/ 3# .#
3%
! "
/ + & # % >3 # 4301 ?+ # 3 ## & + + # # % % 8 & # 32 # # 3 8 & & # 3 % #% / &1 #& ;# ## # & % # 3#12+ # #& % # # #&< / % 8 %3% ## % % 3 +&# ? #% # # ## # 4301 % &1 @# # # # &
! # #!
/ + %# 73 #& 3 % % #
%3 # # 1 #& #% % # % ## / % # 3 31 &3 8 &% # 8%#1 1% .6 # 8 & # #%#% # ++ & &++ # 3 # #& 3 # ! # # 31 #+ %##ZZ % # # # +# 3 # ## 3 / 1 3# & %#1+ # %3 # # % %#1 1 8 & # 31 ## # ? & 1 &# # 3 % #% ? % # # %#1+ #%3 # # 1 #& #% / 3% 3 & +3 EE &3 & % # 1 8 + %% # &%+ # EE % 3% # / EE &
## 8 % 1 % # # &# 8 % " # &# % 8 & # # # 1 %@ &# % # % # % # # &# 9 % > &% +# # # &# 9# > % % 8 :8 & # # EE &# ## ? 3#% #
$ % &
/ 33# &# # #& % # # # # +3 EE / 3% # # 3 % #% + # 1 3
$ % &
/ # 3 #+ %& 3 + 3# #&ZZ
' # # (
4# 1 3 / +# 3 & 1 % # % # 33# 0&%+ # 3 %#1