ihp news 488 : #almaata40 & modicare · ihp news 488 : #almaata40 & modicare (14 september...
TRANSCRIPT
1
IHPnews488:#AlmaAta40&Modicare(14September2018)
TheweeklyInternationalHealthPolicies(IHP)newsletterisaninitiativeoftheHealthPolicyunitattheInstituteofTropicalMedicineinAntwerp,Belgium.
DearColleagues,
Unsurprisingly,Septemberisshapingupasamonthchockfullofglobalhealthpolicy&HPSRrelatednewsandpublications,andOctoberwon’tbemuchdifferent.We’llkeepthisintroshortthen.Amongothers,thisissuewillzoominonthe40thanniversaryoftheAlmaAtadeclaration(ofcourse),thefinalweeksbeforeUNGA73inNewYork(includingthelastpreparationsforthehigh-levelmeetingsonTB&NCDs),globalhealthsecurityanalysisandnews(withamongotherstheGlobalPreparednessMonitoringBoardconveningforthefirsttimeinGeneva),WorldSuicidePreventionDay,theGlobalClimateActionSummitinSanFrancisco,GBDstudiesintheLancetonIndia(NCDs),andmuchmore.
SpeakingofIndia,inthisweek’sFeaturedArticleDeepikaSaluja(IHPresident&EV2016)sharessomeofherhopesandconcernsabout“Modicare”.
AndspeakingofEmergingVoices,inafewweeksfromnowthenewcohort’sF2FprogramstartsinLiverpool,abouttendaysbeforethe“big”HSRsymposiumkicksoff.Thefinalcountdownhasstarted!
TurnsoutI’mexpectedtotakeabloodyVirgintraintogettoLiverpool.FeelsaboutasannoyingassendingoutAmazonvoucherstowinnersoftheIHPevaluation,takinganUbercaborflyingwithRyanair.Inotherüber-capitalistnews,“Liverpool-ManchesterCity”on7Octoberstillhasafewseatsleft.Startingfrom£190,ahum.MaybeweneedsomeHPSRcrowdfunding“toleavenofootballfanbehind”:)
Enjoyyourreading.
KristofDecoster
2
FeaturedArticle
Myhopesandworriesfor“Modicare”
DeepikaSaluja(IHPresident&EV2016)
India’sjourneytowardsUniversalHealthCoverage(UHC)isgainingspecialattentionsincetheModiGovernmentannouncedthecountry’slargesthealthcareprogrammeever,named‘AyushmanBharat’on1st Feb,2018 - just a yearbefore thegeneralelections scheduled in2019.Bywayofexample,RichardHortondiscussesinthisweek’sLancetOfflineCommenthowhealthwilllikelybeakeyissuein India’s 2019 general elections, quoting Modi as the first PrimeMinister of India “to prioritizeUniversalHealthCoverageaspartofhispoliticalplatform”.
TheAyushmanBharat(AB)Programme(whichmeans“blessedIndia”inliteraltermsor“healthyIndia”inthecontextofhealth)restsonthetwinpillarsoftheNationalHealthProtectionMission(NHPM-thesecondary&tertiarycaresocialhealthinsuranceprogramme)andtheestablishmentof150,000additionalHealthandWellnessCentres(HWCs-anupdatedversionofprimaryhealthcentresthatwillinclude a focus on wellness as well). In his Independence Day speech, Modi called the healthprotection scheme“PradhanMantri JanAarogyaAbhiyaan” (PMJAA -meaning thePrimeMinisterPeople’s Health Mission). The programme has had quite a multi-monicker journey since its firstannouncementinFeb,2018.Itsnamehasbeenchangedseveraltimes,allinthequesttofindaHindiname that would be acceptable to its target beneficiaries: from Modicare to National HealthProtection Mission (NHPM) to Pradhan Mantri Rashtriya Swasthya Suraksha Mission (PMRSSM,meaningPrimeMinisterNationalHealthProtectionMission),andnowPradhanMantriJanAarogyaAbhiyaan(PMJAA).PMRSSMwasinterestinglydroppedforthepresenceoftheletters“RSS”(RashtriyaSwayasevakSangh-meaningNationalVolunteerOrganization)inthename,RSSbeingtheIndianright-wing,Hindu-nationalistvoluntaryorganization.Forthetimebeing,though,ModicareandNHPMarethenamesusedmostfrequently.
“Successor”ofRSBY&somelessonsfrommyPhD
Maybegoodtoknowforyou:IstudiedtheimplementationofRashtriyaSwasthyaBimaYojana(RSBY)inoneofthewesternstatesofIndiaformyPhDthesis.Usingatheorybasedevaluation,Iidentifiedthe accountability mechanisms available in the programme design of enrolment and tried tounderstandhowtheyfunctionedontheground.Basedonmy8-9monthsofextensivefieldexperienceinteractingwithmultiplestakeholdersfromalllevels(publicaswellasprivate;national,state,districtaswellaslocal),Ifoundthatmostofthesemechanismslargelyplayedasymbolicrole.Hence,IhavesomeseriousconcernsaboutthedesignandimplementationofthisnewlyannouncedAB-NHPM,asinmanywaysit’sthesuccessorofRSBY.Letmeexplainabitmoreindetailbelow,afterelaboratinghowNHPMdiffersfromRSBY.
TheNationalHealthProtectionMission(NHPM)aimstoprovidefreeaccesstosecondaryandtertiarycaretoover100millionhouseholdsforacoverageofuptoINR5lakhs(~7000USD)annually,withoutany limit in terms of family size and age of the householdmembers. RSBY, NHPM’s predecessorintroducedin2008,providedafinancialcoverageofINR30000(~500USD)forafamilyofupto5,to~36.33millionhouseholds(againstthetargetof60mnhouseholds).WhilethetargetpopulationforRSBYwasprimarilytheBelowPovertyLine(BPL)population(basedonthe2001Censusinamajorityof the implementing states) along with a handful of unorganized sector categories, NHPM has
3
improved upon this, by considering the Socio-Economic Caste Census, 2011 to identify its targetbeneficiaries.Still,alagof7yearswillresultintheexclusionofsomeeligiblebeneficiaries.
Enrolment (mandatory inRSBY)hasbeeneliminatedandreplacedbythebeneficiary identificationprocessforAB-NHPMatthepointofcontactforhealthcarei.e.healthcarefacilities.EliminationofthefirstpointofcontactwiththebeneficiariesviaenrolmentinNHPM,makestheroleofInformation,EducationandCommunication(IEC)activitiesevenmorecritical,asthebeneficiariesneedtoknowabouttheireligibilityfortheprogramme,programmefeaturesandbenefitsandwaystoaccessit.Donotassumethat thecurrentmassmediacoverageonModicarewill informthebeneficiariesofallthesedetails.
SimilartoRSBY,NHPMaimstoprovidecashless,paperlesstransactionstoitstargetbeneficiarieswithportabilityfeatures,i.e.beneficiariescangetthetreatmentthroughanyempaneledpublicorprivatehospital across the country. Evidence fromRSBY implementation pointed to difficulties in settlinginter-insurance claim settlements (in terms of delays and rejections). Also, like in RSBY, the newscheme will cover all pre-existing illnesses, pre-hospitalization, post-hospitalization andtransportationexpenses,thoughtheliteratureonRSBYreportsbeneficiarieswhoreceivedtreatmentunderRSBYincurredOOPexpendituresparticularlyonmedicinesanddiagnostics.TheNationalHealthAgency(NHA)andStateHealthAgencies(SHAs)–theagenciesestablishedatcentralandstatelevelsrespectivelytomanageandmonitortheimplementationoftheprogramme,willhavetoensurethattheimplementationofNHPMimprovesuponthemistakesidentifiedintheimplementationofRSBY,andmakeevidence-informeddecisions.
FindingsofmyPh.D.thesisalsohighlightedothercriticalissuesinthedesignandimplementationoftheRSBY,moreinparticulartheinvolvementofprivateactorsatmultiplelevels(Insurancecompanies,ThirdPartyAdministrators,SmartCardServiceProvidersandhospitals);theirvaryingpowerrelationswithdifferentlevelsofthegovernmentmachinery,lackofclarityonspecificrolesandresponsibilitiesofeachoftheseimplementingactors,oftenleadingtopoorcommunicationandweakco-ordinationamongst them while working on the ground, and all this coupled with weak accountabilitymechanisms.ItisclearthatmanyoftheseconcernswillneedtobeaddressedifimplementationofNHPMistobeeffectiveontheground.
Apprehensionsontheinvolvementoftheprivatesector,andregulatoryandmonitoringelementsinthedesignofNHPMmakethefindingsofmythesisevenmorepertinent.Intheabsenceofadequateaccountability mechanisms, challenges like overutilization of health care services through over-prescription of diagnostics and treatment, converting outpatient into inpatient care, selectivelychoosingprofitablecasesorhospitalschargingforcashlessproceduresarequiteforeseeable,havingbeenhighlightedseveraltimesintheimplementationliteratureofRSBY.
Nevertheless,‘Modicare’isseenasasignificantsteptowardsachievingthetwintargetsofSDG3.8ofreducingthefinancialburdenandincreasingpopulationcoverage.India’sHealthMinister,JPNaddaclaimsthat‘NHPMisgoingtobeoneoftheworld’slargestsocialhealthinsuranceprogrammesduetoitssheernumbersandthisschemeshallbeagamechangerfortheIndianHealthcare’.Alongwithitspreventivearmofestablishing150,000HWCsaiming toprovidecomprehensiveprimaryhealthcare,ABcanalsobeseenasimprovingonthethirdelement(theothertwobeingfinancialcoverageandpopulationcoverage)ofthe“UHCcube”, i.e. improvingaccesstoawiderrangeofhealthcareservices.AsNHPMgets thebulkof theattention, it is feared,however, that theHWCsmightnotreceivetheirdueresources.
Qualityconcerns
4
In addition, while the focus is largely on increasing service coverage to ~40% of the country’spopulation,anotherpotentialchallengetheschemewill face is thequalityofservicesdelivered.ALancetarticlepublishedcoincidingwiththelaunchofTheLancetGlobalHealthCommissiononHighQualityHealthSystemsintheSDGerareportedthat2.4mnpeopleinIndiayearlydieduetotreatableconditions,outofwhich1.6mn(~66%)dieduetopoorqualityofhealthcare,andtherestduetonon-utilizationofhealthcare.While ‘Modicare’wouldpotentially increasetheutilizationofhealthcareservicesinIndia,itshouldalsoatthesametimefocusonensuring(andimproving)thequalityofhealthcareservicesdeliveredthroughitsempaneledhospitalsandHWCs.
Around6000privatehospitalsareexpected to joinNHPM,butnotallwouldbeaccreditedby theNationalAccreditationBoardforHospitalsandHealthcareproviders(NABH),anaccreditationboardestablished by the Quality Council of India (QCI) to ensure quality standards in the delivery ofhealthcare.Only540hospitalsacrossthecountryhaveNABHaccreditationcurrentlyandnotallofthemmay joinNHPM.Given the incentive of 15%higher rates for approved treatments toNABHaccreditedhospitalsand10%higherratestoentry-levelNABHhospitals,arisecanbeexpected(notsufficient,though)intheaccreditationofhospitalsasNHPMimplementationtakesoff.Withrespectto theHWCs,other than the inaugurationnewsof thesecentres indifferentpartsof thecountry,there’s not much information on the availability and utilization of resources in terms of staff,medicines,medicalequipmentsetc.andmoreimportantlyonhowthequalityofservicesdeliveryinthesecentreswillbemonitored.Bytheway, focusingonqualitywouldalsoneed integrationwithothersocialdeterminantsofhealthlikecleandrinkingwater,hygienictoilets,nutritiousfoodetc.aswellasappropriatehandlingofbio-medicalwaste,especiallyinthehospitals,topreventanyhospital-acquiredinfections(butalsointheirhomes).
Currentpicture&hopeforagoodstartofModicare
With the soft launchofNHPMbyModi on IndependenceDay,wenowhave 30 states andunionterritoriesonboard(withTamilNadubeingthelatesttojoin).21outofthe30stateswhoagreedtobeapartofNHPMareoptingforthe“trustmodel”(wherethestateestablishesatrustandhandlestheentireimplementationoftheprogramme)asopposedtothe“Insurancemodel”(wherethestatecontractsouttheinsuranceservicestotheinsurancecompanies).Withchangesintheimplementationdesignmodel,itwon’tbeeasytoavoidstatecapacitydeficitsandotherissuesofalignmentofcentralandstate level schemeswith respect topopulationcoverage, financial coverageaswellas servicecoverage,thatmuchisclear.Itwouldalsobeimportantforthestatestohaveclearlydefinedrolesandresponsibilitiesforeachoftheimplementingactorstoavoidanyambiguitiesatthetimeofrollout.
Onamorepositivenote,pilotshavenowstartedinmorethanhalfoftheagreedstatesandthefirstclaimunderNHPMhasalreadybeenraisedfromapublichospitalinHaryanaforanewbornbabygirl.
IfModicareisimplementedeffectively,thelandscapeofIndianHealthcarewillindeedsubstantiallybetransformedinthecomingyears.Withtheofficiallaunchdateof25thSeptemberquitenear,theNHAandSHAswillhavetogearuptheirpreparationfortheimplementationofNHPM.Ashiccupscanbeexpectedandareonlynormalifsuchahugeschemeistoberolledout,hopefullytheseagencieswillturnouttobe‘learningsystems’,beingquickandresponsiveinaddressingtheseinitialhiccups.
Lastbutnotleast,IalsohopethatModicaredoesn’tgetcaughtinasimilardestructivepolarizationprocessasisthecaseintheUSforObamacare.IndiansneedUHC,morethanever.
5
Highlightsoftheweek
40thanniversaryof“AlmaAta”
Yes-entera“DesperateHousewives”voiceover-,thiswastheweekthat40yearsago,theAlmaAtaDeclarationsawthelight.Ifyoufirstwanttore-readtheoriginalAlmaAtadeclaration,seeAlmaAtaDeclaration-1978.
AnniversaryEvents
• OnWednesday(12September),the40thAnniversaryoftheAlmaAtaDeclarationwascelebratedattheJohnHopkinsBloombergSchoolofPublicHealthwithakeynotespeakersessionbyDr.RitaThapa,whowaspresentinthatroomatthetimeofsigningthedeclarationonSeptember12,1978.RepresentingNepalatAlma-Ata,sherecalls“thedeclarationasasingularmomentinherlifeandcareer”.Onthesameday,40yearslater,Dr.Thapasharedherjourneyandreflectionsonhowthingshavechangedoverthepast40years,andhowpromisingthefuturelooks(seeGHN:thelessonsfromAlmaAta).
• WealreadywanttoflaghereanotherupcomingAlmaAta40event,inAntwerpwhichwilltakeplacejustafewdaysbeforetheAstanaconferenceinOctober.
23rdOct,2018:InternationalSymposiumattheInstituteofTropicalMedicine,Antwerp,Belgium40yearsafterAlma-Ata:Primaryhealthcarein2018andbeyond,insouthandnorth.Formoredetails,seehere.FortheConceptNote:40YearsAfterAlma-AtaSymposium-Conceptnote
Somereads&analysis
OngoingblogseriesonAlmaAta40bytheHealthandHumanRightsJournal
Withamongothers:
Recommended:ALMA-ATAat40:CivilSocietyContinuestheCommitmenttoHealthforAll
Evenmorerecommended:ALMA-ATAat40:TimeforaCriticalHealthEconomics(bySaraDavis)
6
Excerpt:“…Humanrightsandhealtheconomicscouldbecomplementary.Globalrightsstandards,includingAlma-Ata,recognizeinequality,discrimination,andotherbarrierstoaccessinghealthservices,butarefranklyunrealisticaboutbudgetaryconstraintsanddatagaps.Healtheconomicstoolsmayberealisticaboutresourceconstraints,withoutaddressingthecomplexbarriersdiscriminationandinequalitycreatetoaccessinghealthforthosemostoftenleftbehind.Tomovebeyondthisimpasse,humanrightsscholarsandhealtheconomistsshouldcometogethertoforgeacriticalhealtheconomicsthatrecognizesthathealthistheproductofapoliticalcontext,onethatshapesdataandevenresearchagendas.Morebroadly,wealsoneedtoworktogethertochallengetheconceptofthelimitedbucketoffunds—theparadigmofscarcitythatisbecomingincreasinglynormalized,atamomentofstarklygrowingglobalinequality….”
CheckoutalsoALMA-ATAat40:RevisitingtheDeclaration.
JHanalysis
DavidBishaietal,inJHmagazine-PrimaryHealthCareForAll—Alma-AtaDeclaration's40thAnniversaryRecommended!!
Ifyoucan’tgetenoughofDavidBishai,readalsoFromAlmaAtatoAstana:ourforkintheroadtowardsachievinghealthforall
MedicalHistory-VisualisingPrimaryHealthCare:WorldHealthOrganizationRepresentationsofCommunityHealthWorkers,1970–89 AMedcalf&JNunes;https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/medical-history/article/visualising-primary-health-care-world-health-organization-representations-of-community-health-workers-197089/A65B47A10DE38F003CD72B7AF552A445
Fascinatingarticle&oneofthereadsoftheweek.
“FortheWorldHealthOrganization(WHO),the1978Alma-AtaDeclarationmarkedamoveawayfromthedisease-specificandtechnologically-focusedprogrammesofthe1950sand1960stowardsareimaginedstrategytoprovide‘HealthforAllbytheYear2000’.Thisnewapproachwascentredonprimaryhealthcare,avisionbasedonacceptablemethodsandappropriatetechnologies,devisedincollaborationwithcommunitiesanddependentontheirfullparticipation.Since1948,theWHOhadusedmasscommunicationsstrategiestopubliciseitsinitiativesandshapepublicattitudes,andthepolicyshiftinthe1970srequiredanewvisualstrategy.Inthiscontext,communityhealthworkers(CHWs)playedacentralroleaskeyvisualidentifiersofHealthforAll.ThisarticleexaminesaperiodofpicturingandpublicinformationworkonthepartoftheWHOregardingCHWs.ItsetsouttounderstandhowthevisualpoliticsoftheWHOchangedtoaccommodatePHCasanewpriorityprogrammefromthe1970sonwards.TheargumenttracksattemptstodefineCHWsandexaminesthetechniquesemployedbytheWHOduringthe1970sandearly1980stopromotetheconcepttodifferentaudiencesaroundtheworld.Itthenmovestoexplorehowtheprocesswasevaluated,aswellasthedifficultiesinprocuringfreshimagery.Finally,thearticletracestheserepresentations
7
throughthe1980s,whencommunityapproachescameundersustainedpressurefromexternalandinternalfactorsandimagerytookonthesupplementaryroleofdefendingtheconcept.”
Newsclick–WhyaccesstohealthcareisabiggerproblemthanqualityinIndia
https://www.newsclick.in/why-access-healthcare-bigger-problem-quality-india
Weare40yearslaternow.Thisarticlewas,amongothers,recommendedbyRob“UHC”Yates.AndoneofthefirstreactionstotheHQSSreportfromlastweek,focusingonIndia.
WiththelaunchofLancetCommissiononHighQualityHealthsystemsintheSDGera,thearticlepointstothegeneraltrendofdiscussionsbeingdriftedtowardsqualityofcareintheIndianHealthcaresystembutalsohighlightsthatwiththisshiftinthefocusonquality,thepersistentquestionofaccesstohealthcaredoesnotbecomeanylessimportant.
(ReadthefeaturedarticleofthiseditionforadetailedreviewofAyushmanBharat)
Finalpreparations/negotiationsforHLmeetingsonTB&NCDsatUNGA73
IP-Watch-Shhh…UNDeclarationOnTuberculosisDraftTextOutForApproval
http://www.ip-watch.org/2018/09/11/shh-un-declaration-tuberculosis-draft-text-approval/
“Negotiators’agreeddrafttextforaUnitedNationspoliticaldeclarationonendingtuberculosisworldwidehasbeenpostedforallmemberstatestosee,andnegotiatorshope,notcommenton.UnderaUNprocedure,thetexthasbeenplaced“undersilence”until10:00amNewYorktimeon14September.Ifnoonebreaksthesilence,thetextisconsideredagreedandwilladvancetotheHigh-LevelMeetingontuberculosison26SeptemberaspartoftheannualUNGeneralAssembly….”
Notsureeverybodyis“enjoyingthesilence”:)
Forthedraftpoliticaldeclaration,seehere.
“…ThecompromisewasreportedlynegotiatedbyrepresentativesfromtheUnitedStatesandSouthAfrica.SouthAfricabrokethesilenceinlateJulyafterthedraftfollowedaUSdemandandstrippedoutallreferenceintheoperativeparagraphstotheWorldTradeOrganizationAgreementonTrade-RelatedAspectsofIntellectualPropertyRights(TRIPS).The16-pagedraftdeclarationsetsoutprinciples–suchasthebasisthatTBispreventableandcurable,andaffectsallpopulationsbutinequitably–andaseriesoffairlybroadcommitments,suchastobuildcapacity,promoteandencourageresearch,andmobilizefunding.Thedeclarationcallsforaprogressreportin2020,andanextheadsofstate-levelHigh-LevelMeetingin2023.”
8
Andatweet:“Newtextmadepublicfor#UNHLMTBdeclaration.languageon#TRIPSpromotingpublichealthisbackinthetext.USwasresponsibleforitsremovalearlierwhileSouthAfricaplayedaverycriticalroleinbringingitbacktothetable.”(Cfrparagraph19)
EPHA-WhattoexpectfromtheUNHeadsofStatemeetingonNCDsinSeptember?EPHA;
Excellent&hard-hittinganalysisbyNinaRenshaw(Policy&AdvocacyDirectorNCDAlliance)Must-read!“….atthislatestageofthenegotiationsofthePoliticalDeclaration,thedrafttextthatHeadsofGovernmentandStatewillsigninSeptemberislackinginthestrength,clarityandambitionneededtoturnthetideonNCDsandtheirtollofpreventableprematuremortality.”
FormoreupliftingexpectationsontheNCDHLmeeting(scheduledfor27September),werefertothetweetsfromMennovanHilten(WHO).Forexample:
“HealthAttachéinGeneva:"Theoverarchingmessageat#HLM3#NCDswillbeoptimistic.Almost10MprematuredeathsfromNCDscanbeavoidedby2025ifPresidentsandPrime-Ministersdecidetoimplementthe16@WHObestbuysforNCDsendorsedbytheWorldHealthAssemblyin2017."
“DiplomatinGeneva:"Theworldisreachinganinflectionpoint.#HLM3isthetimeforPresidentsandPrime-Ministerstointensifytheireffortsduringthenext3-5yearstoputtheircountryontracktoattain#SDGstarget3.4on#NCDsby2030".”
Globalhealthsecurity
GlobalPreparednessMonitoringBoardconvenesforthefirsttimeinGeneva
http://www.who.int/news-room/detail/10-09-2018-global-preparedness-monitoring-board-convenes-for-the-first-time-in-geneva
Earlierthisweek,“WHOandtheWorldBankGroupconvenedthefirstmeetingoftheGlobalPreparednessMonitoringBoard(GPMB),anewbodysetuptomonitortheworld’sreadinesstorespondtooutbreaksandotherhealthemergencies.TheGPMBischairedbyDrGroHarlemBrundtland,formerPrimeMinisterofNorwayandformerWHODirector-GeneralandMrElhadjAsSy,SecretaryGeneraloftheInternationalFederationofRedCrossandRedCrescentSocieties,andincludessomeofthemostnotableleadersinglobalhealth….”
“TheGPMBhasbeenestablishedtomonitorprogress,identifygapsandadvocateforsustained,effectiveworktoensureglobalpreparedness.AtitsfirstmeetingatWHO’sheadquartersinGeneva,theGPMBtodaydiscussedkeyissuesinglobalpreparednessandagreeditstermsofreferenceandgovernancestructure.TheboardaimstopublishitsfirstreportontheglobalstateofpreparednessinSeptember2019.”
FortheshortspeechbydrTedrosattheoccasion,seehere.
9
CNN-ThedeclineinvirussamplesharingisnotjustaboutChina
TBollyky&DFidler;https://edition.cnn.com/2018/09/08/opinions/china-virus-sample-sharing-bollyky-fidler/index.html
“…USandglobalhealthofficialshavebeenconcernedaboutChina'ssporadicsharingofH7N9samplessince2013.ThelackofsharingoverthepastyearfitsthispatternanddoesnotappeartobearesponsetotheTrumpadministrationoritspoliciesontrade….”
…Itwouldbecomfortingtobelievethatthelackofsamplesharingwasthefaultofasinglebadactorandcouldberesolvedwithaneasingoftradetensions.Themoretroublingreality,however,isthattheglobalsystemforinfluenzasamplesharinggenerallymaybeweakening….”ThePandemicInfluenzaPreparedness(PIP)Framework,thatis.
Seeapoetictweet:"T.S.Eliotfamouslywrotethattheworldwouldendwithawhimperratherthanabang,butacoughmightbethelikelierscenario."@D_P_Fidler&Ion#Chinavirussharing”
TheConversation-Fluplane:arewereallyreadyforaglobalpandemic?
METurner;https://theconversation.com/flu-plane-are-we-really-ready-for-a-global-pandemic-102789?utm_medium=amptwitter&utm_source=twitter
No.Comingbackonlastweek’suproarontheEmiratesairlinerinNY,Turnerargues:“…Butiftheseeventsreallywerethestartofaflupandemic(aworldwidespreadofadisease),theworldisvastlyunpreparedforit.Thereispoorpublichealthsurveillanceinmanypartsoftheworld,therearen’tenoughvaccinestogoaroundandtheinternationallegalframeworkdesignedtoensurevaccinesgettothepoorestcountriesisnotfitforpurpose.”
Putdifferently:“…Ifthenextpandemicissevere,millionsofpeoplewilldie,largelyinpoorercountries,andlargelybecausetheyhavenoaccesstoavaccine–theonethingthatthePIPframeworkwasmeanttoresolve.”
ITMmagazine-Thisautumn...Africatakescharge!
Africatakeschargeofitshealthagenda.
Inthis7thissuethespotlightisonDrJohnNkengasong,ITMalumnusandnowatthehelmoftheAfricanCDC.Muchrecommendedinterview!
TheHill(Op-ed)-WecankeepsyntheticbiologymiraclescomingbyinvestinginUSresearchGGronvall;http://thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/405908-we-can-keep-synthetic-biology-miracles-coming-by-investing-in-us-research
“…TheU.S.iscurrentlythedominantforceinthesyntheticbiologyfield,boastingbiotechcompanieslikeSynlogicaswellasmajorresearchcenters.However,theU.S.can’taffordtobe
10
complacent.Othernationshaveevaluatedthepotentialforsyntheticbiologytoimprovetheireconomies,andhaveinvestedaccordingly,includingtheUK,France,Japan,Germany,andespeciallyChina.China’sscienceisgrowinginsignificance,buttheindicatorsforU.S.sciencearegoingtheotherway….”
Op-EdbyGigiGronvall,aseniorscholarattheJohnsHopkinsCenterforHealthSecurityandauthorofSyntheticBiology:Safety,SecurityandPromise.
EbolaoutbreakDRC–“Comingdayswillbecriticalfortrajectoryoutbreak”(WHO)
Cidrap–Ebolainfects5moreinDRC,liftingtotalto137
http://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2018/09/ebola-infects-5-more-drc-lifting-total-137
“TheDemocraticRepublicoftheCongo(DRC),inupdatesyesterdayandtoday,reportedfivemoreconfirmedEbolacases,includingtwofromtheurbanhubofButembo,oneofwhichinvolvesahealthworkerfromaclinicwherethecity'sfirstcasehadbeentreated.Inarelateddevelopment,theWorldHealthOrganization(WHO)saidinanupdateyesterdaythatalotofprogresshasbeenmadein6weeks,andcasesanddeathsinthepastweekdeclinedsignificantly.Itadded,however,thatcommunityresistance,weakinfectionpreventionandcontrolpracticesinhealthcenters,andriskofvirusspreadingtoinsecureareasarestillmajorthreats.Someareashavestabilized,buttheWHOsaidBeniisthenewhotspot,andresponseactivitiesarescalinguptoeasetheimpactofpotentialclustersinButemboandinMaserekahealthzone,thelatestnewareastoreportcases."Thecomingfewdayswillbecriticalindeterminingthetrajectoryoftheoutbreak,"theagencysaid….”
ThecurrentEbolaoutbreakis,tillnow,the8thlargestepidemicofthediseaseever.
SeealsosometweetsfromHelenBranswell(Stat)fromyesterday:
1."Thecomingfewdayswillbecriticalindeterminingthetrajectoryoftheoutbreak."Sosays@WHOinitslatest#Ebolasituationreport.There'sbeenadropinnewcases,butsignificantchallengesstillfacetheresponseoperation,includingsomecommunityresistance.
2.@WHOhasbeenreportingforawhilethatpeopleintheNdindineighborhoodofBeni,inparticular,haven'tbeencooperativewithcontainmentefforts.Asyet,though,Ihaven'tseen/heardafigureonpercentageofpeopleoffered#Ebolavaccinewhohaverefusedit.
3.Reportsays17healthworkershavebeeninfectedwith#Ebola,and3havedied.Believethisisnow18.Yesterdaythe@MinSanteRDCreport,whichisbasedonmorecurrentdata,revealedanotherHCworkerinfection.
4.@WHO#Ebolasitrepupdatesonthepatientswho'vereceivedexperimentalEbolatherapies.Basedondatato6Sept,29patientsweregiventherapies;9ofthemdied.Itnotes,though,thatallwhodiedwereinend-stagediseasewhenadmitted.Likelynothingworksthen.-30-
11
LancetComment–Addressingthefragmentationofglobalhealth:theLancetCommissiononsynergiesbetweenuniversalhealthcoverage,healthsecurity,andhealthpromotion
GorikOoms,IreneAgyepongetal;
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)32072-5/fulltext
“Globalhealthisfragmented.Manystakeholderspursuetheirownagendawhileneglectingotherimportantgoalsforglobalhealth.Someglobalhealthactors,forexample,focusonstrengtheninghealthsecuritywithoutattentiontouniversalhealthcoverage(UHC),primaryhealthcare(PHC),andpopulation-basedhealthpromotion.PreventionisakeypartofPHCandUHC,buteffortstoensurePHCormakeprogresstowardsUHCoftendonotincludepopulation-basedpreventionefforts…”
“TheLancetCommissiononsynergiesbetweenUHC,healthsecurity,andhealthpromotionaimstoovercomefragmentationandrealizethepotentialforcoherenceinglobalhealth.TheCommissionwillsystematicallyexamineintersectionsbetweentheseleadingagendasinglobalhealth..,identifyasetofkeypolicies,institutionalcapacities,decision-supportsystems,andinterventionsthateachcontributesacrossthethreeagendasandmakesprogressinoneareaamplifyprogressintheothers.Thefindingswillhelpthemanyanddiversestakeholdersinglobalhealthbetteraligntheirefforts,cooperatemoreefficiently,andsaveandimprovemorelives.
“ThesynergiesCommissionwillbeco-chairedbyIreneAkuaAgyepongandGorikOomsandhostedbytheLondonSchoolofHygiene&TropicalMedicine,theNorwegianInstituteofPublicHealth,andtheHeidelbergInstituteofGlobalHealth.”
“…ThesynergiesCommissionhasitsfirstmeetinginLondon,UK,onSept10–12,2018,andaimstopublishitsfinalreportin2020.”
TheLancetonDairyconsumption&cardiovasculardisease:“Dairyfoodinmoderationmightprotecttheheart”
Lancet-Associationofdairyintakewithcardiovasculardiseaseandmortalityin21countriesfromfivecontinents(PURE):aprospectivecohortstudy
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)31812-9/fulltext
“Acohortstudyanalysingdatafrom21countriesshowsthatdietswithahighdairyconsumptionareassociatedwithlowerratesofmortalityandcardiovasculardisease.”
FortheaccompanyingLancetComment:Noneedtochangedairyfooddietaryguidelinesyet.
12
Somekeymessagesviathepressrelease:
“TheLancet:Dairyconsumptionlinkedtolowerratesofcardiovasculardiseaseandmortality
Globalstudyfindsthatdietsthatincludewhole-fatdairywerelinkedtolowerratesofcardiovasculardisease,comparedtothosethatdidn’t.AuthorssaythatregionswithlowestintakesincludingsouthAsia,southeastAsiaandAfricamaybenefitfromincreasedconsumptionofdairy.
Dairyconsumptionofaroundthreeservingsperdayisassociatedwithlowerratesofcardiovasculardiseaseandmortality,comparedtolowerlevelsofconsumption,accordingtoaglobalobservationalstudyofover130,000peoplein21countries,publishedinTheLancet.Inaddition,thestudyfoundthatpeoplewhoconsumedthreeservingsofwholefatdairyperdayhadlowerratesofmortalityandcardiovasculardiseasecomparedtothosewhoconsumedlessthan0.5servingofwholefatdairyperday.Thefindingsareconsistentwithpreviousmeta-analysesofobservationalstudiesandrandomisedtrials,butstandincontrasttocurrentdietaryguidelineswhichrecommendconsuming2-4servingsoffat-freeorlow-fatdairyperday,andminimisingconsumptionofwhole-fatdairyproductsforcardiovasculardiseaseprevention.…
Guardiancoverage(SarahBoseley):Dairyfoodinmoderation'mayprotecttheheart'“Threesmallportionsofdairyadaymayactuallyprotectagainstheartdiseaseandstroke.”
WorldSuicidePreventionDay-800,000peoplecommitsuicideeveryyear:WHO
UNNews-Everyyear,closeto800,000peoplecommitsuicide,thesecondleadingcauseofdeathamongstpeopleaged15-29in2016.
WHOreleasedanewsuicidepreventiontoolkittomarkWorldSuicidePreventionDay.
GFF
SimonWright–AGlobalFinancingFacilityforlong-termchangeiswhatweneed
SavetheChildren;
Wright(SavetheChildren)givestheperspectivefromvariousactorsontheGFF(anditsperceivedadvantages).
13
Excerpt:“…FortheWorldBank–andforotherswhoseethat,inatimeofstagnatingresources,innovativesolutionsareneededifcountrieshaveanyhopeofmakingfastprogresstowardstheSustainableDevelopmentGoals–theGFFisimportantbecauseitisamechanismtogetcountriestomakebetteruseofWorldBankmoney.HealthandnutritionoftenmissoutonInternationalDevelopmentAssociation(IDA)andInternationalBankforDevelopmentandReconstruction(IDRB)grantsandconcessionalloansastheyaretraditionallyusedforeconomicinfrastructure.WorldBankPresidentJimKimispushingcountriestousethesefacilitiesforhealthandtheGFFmechanismisalreadyshowingresults.However,loanshavetoberepaidandaresuitableforinvestmentsbutnotfortheongoingrunningcostsofafunctioninghealthservice.Forme,theGFFismostexcitingasanopportunitytoencouragecountriestoincreasetheirowndomesticresourcesforhealthandnutrition.Theonlysubstantialandlong-termsolutionisforgovernmentstotaxfairlyandallocatesufficientresources.ThisisespeciallytrueascountriestransitionfromaidmechanismslikeGaviandtheGlobalFund….”
AsyouknowtheGFFreplenishmenttakesplaceon6November,inNorway.2billionisthetarget.
Aid&developmenttrends
Inthissection,we’llprovidesomenews,analysis&trendsonvarioustraditional&newdonors(whethertheyliketheterm‘donors’isanotherquestion).
JapanandChinatakefirststeptowardjointinfrastructureabroad
https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-Relations/Japan-and-China-take-first-step-toward-joint-infrastructure-abroad
“JapanandChinaaremovingaheadwiththeirplanstocooperateonoverseasinfrastructureprojects,withanewlyestablishedpublic-privatecommitteescheduledtoholditsfirstmeetinginlateSeptemberinBeijing.……JapanesePrimeMinisterShinzoAbeandChinesePremierLiKeqiangmetinTokyoinMayandagreedtocooperateoninfrastructureprojectsinthirdcountries.……JapanaimstoavoidexcessivecompetitionwithChinaoninfrastructureprojectsbycollaborating.ShowingsupportforBeijing'sBeltandRoadInitiativecouldalsoleadtobetterbilateralties.China,foritspart,seekstoavoidbeinglabeledoverseasasadisreputableinvestorbybringingJapanonboard….”
Ifyoucan’tbeatthem,join’em,Abeprobablythinks.
DukeCenterforPolicyImpactinGlobalHealth(Analysis)–TheForumonChina-Africacooperationsummit:whatisitandwhydoesitmattertoglobalhealth?
KKennedy;http://centerforpolicyimpact.org/2018/09/10/the-forum-on-china-africa-cooperation-summit-what-is-it-and-why-does-it-matter-to-global-health/
Must-readanalysisoftheFOCACmeeting(andpre-events)byKaciKennedy-fromaglobalhealthpolicyangle.Theconclusion:“TheFOCAC2018Summit—aswithmostofChina’shigh-levelforums—involvesadecentamountofpompandcircumstance.However,thesedeclarationsandhigh-level
14
forumsgiveusanopportunitytoseeChina’spriorities.FOCACreaffirmshealthasafocalpointofChina’sdiplomaticengagementwithAfrica,andcomesasdevelopmentassistanceforhealth(DAH)continuestostagnate.The2018FOCACsummitanditsrelevantsidemeetingsreaffirmthatChinaispositioningitselftoleadinthisarea.”
ForanoverviewofwhatwasdecidedatFOCAC(intermsofhealth),seealsoUNAIDSnews-LeadersfromChinaandAfricacometogethertobuildstrongerandhealthiercommunities
SomeotherquicklinkswithanalysisonFOCAC:
CGD(blog)(byScottMorris)-FearingMarxisminChineseFinancing
“TheTrumpadministrationisworriedabouttheroleofChinesefinanceinspreadingMarxismaroundthedevelopingworld.Butit’sChicoMarx,notKarl,thattheyshouldbefocusedon.GrouchoMarx’sbrotherfamouslyaskedinDuckSoup,“whoyougoingtobelieve,meoryourowneyes?”
Quartz-Africancountrieswantmore“win”fromthewin-win,butChinaisn’tquiteready.
Guardian–Russia'sscrambleforinfluenceinAfricacatcheswesternofficialsoff-guard
https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2018/sep/11/russias-scramble-for-influence-in-africa-catches-western-officials-off-guard
“RussiaisengagedinafranticnewscrambleforinfluenceinAfrica,whichisbeingspearheadedbyarashofmilitarycooperationandarmsdealssignedacrossthecontinentin2018….”
Apparently,thisistheonlynicheinwhichRussiais‘competitive’.
Devex-Macron'sdevelopmentvisiontakesshape
https://www.devex.com/news/macron-s-development-vision-takes-shape-93375
“It’sbeenaneventfulendtothesummerinFrenchdevelopment,asPresidentEmmanuelMacronbeginstopushhisvisionforaid.AddressingambassadorsinParisattheendoflastmonth,Macroncalledforanewlawtoencapsulatehisdevelopmentagenda,sayinghewantedtofoster“solidarityinvestment”[“investissementsolidaire”],includingmorepartnershipswithcivilsociety,youth,business,anddiasporas,andmoremoneyforambassadorstosupportlocalinitiatives.Thosepointswereamongtherecommendationsinagovernment-commissionedreportdeliveredthepreviousweekbyHervéBerville,amemberofparliamentfromMacron’sLaRépubliqueEnMarcheparty.
Then,lastMonday,theFrenchaidagency,AgenceFrançaisedeDéveloppement,issueditsstrategicplanfor2018-2022,asFrenchForeignMinisterJean-YvesLeDrianannouncedFrancewouldquadrupleitsgrantassistanceto€1.3billionin2019tobetterreach19prioritycountriesinAfrica….…Macronaimstohit0.55percentofgrossnationalincomespentonofficialdevelopment
15
assistancebytheendofhismandatein2022—upfrom0.38percentin2016,asteptowardthe0.7percentUnitedNations-setbenchmark.……ThestrategicplanoutlinesfiveoverarchingcommitmentsforAFD:Tobe100%“compatible”withtheParisClimateAgreement;toensureallprojectsreinforcesocialcohesionandwell-being,includingaccesstoeducationandgenderequality;toengageinfragilecontextsinclosecollaborationwithdefenseanddiplomaticefforts;toincreasefinancingfornon-stateactors;andtoworkwithnewpartnerstoboostknowledge-sharingandeffectiveness….”
PartnershipEU&AfricaMeanwhile,inhisannualStateoftheUnion,“TheEuropeanCommissionPresidentJean-ClaudeJunckersaidonWednesdaythecontinent’sregionalblocwillproposeanewalliancewithAfrica,thatwillcreateupto10millionjobs.“
‘‘Today,weareproposinganewAllianceforSustainableInvestmentandJobsbetweenEuropeandAfrica,thatwouldhelpcreateupto10millionjobsinAfricainthenext5yearsalone,’‘Junckersaid.
SomemoreevidencethattheEU,likemostothercountries,isshiftingfromanaid-centeredapproachtoapartnershipapproachwithAfrica.
SeealsoanalysisbyVinceChadwickinDevex-EUannouncesneweconomicpackageonAfrica.
Including:“….ForBrussels,theworst-casescenariowouldbealossofbothpoliticalandeconomiccloutinAfricatothelikesofChinaandBrazil,aseniorEUofficialtoldDevex.Inthatscenario,Africanleaders“couldn’tcarelessaboutmigrationtoEurope,sotheysay‘whoeverwantstoleavetoEurope,leavestoEurope.’”HencewhyEUleadersaremeetingnextweektoconsiderofferingmoreaidasanincentiveforAfricanstatestohelppreventillegalmigration.”
Someotherreads:
CSISbrief-TheWorldisComingtoSub-SaharanAfrica.WhereistheUnitedStates?
“Sub-SaharanAfrica’sforeigncounterpartsareforgingcloserpartnershipswiththeregionbecausetheyseenewopeningsfortradeandinvestment,aswellasgrowingthreatsfromterrorism,criminality,epidemics,andirregularmigration.JustlikeChina,thesecountriesbelievethatAfricaisincreasinglyimportanttoawiderangeofeconomic,security,andpoliticalgoals.ThisuptickinengagementrepresentsaseachangeinAfrica'sforeignrelations.Whilemanyofthesecountries—includingChinaandtheGulfStates—havebeeninvolvedintheregionfordecades,thesheernumberofcountriesandsignificantinfluxofresourceshavereshapedthelandscape.TheUnitedStatesparadoxicallyissteppingawayfromtheregionwhiletherestoftheworldisleaningin.…”
DevexonUKaid:
AidministerdoesnotneedsignoffonODAspending,saysUKgovernment
16
“TheUnitedKingdomgovernmenthasrejectedaproposaltogivethesecretaryofstateforinternationaldevelopmentultimateoversightandsignoffonaidspending,asever-moreofficialdevelopmentassistanceisspentoutsideherdepartment….”
UKwill'continuetoreassess'itsuseofODAdefinitionifreformscannotbemade
“TheUnitedKingdom’sDepartmentforInternationalDevelopmenthasreaffirmeditisnotafraidtobreaktheinternationalrulesgoverningaidspendingandhinteditcouldrunwithitsowndefinitionifitdoesnotachievethe“modernizationagenda”itisseeking.TheOrganisationforEconomicCo-operationandDevelopment’sDevelopmentAssistanceCommitteecurrentlysetstherulesforits30membercountries,coveringthemajorityofdevelopmentaidspentglobally.However,theU.K.hasbeenpushingforseveralyearstobroadenwhatcanbecountedasofficialdevelopmentassistanceunderthecommittee’srules….”
South-SouthCooperationDay
UNNews-South-SouthCooperationDayfocusesinonsustainabledevelopment,a‘newphaseofcooperation’https://news.un.org/en/story/2018/09/1019172
“Aspartofthe40thanniversaryoftheInternationalDayforSouth-SouthCooperation,theUnitedNationsdrewtogetheronWednesday,morethan100best-practicesdevelopedinthecountriesoftheGlobalSouth,whichembodythe17SustainableDevelopmentGoals(SDGs)and2030AgendaforSustainableDevelopment.”
PS:atweet-OntheoccasionoftheUN#SouthSouthCooperationDay#SSC,the#G77&ChinaGenevaChapterand@South_CentrejoinhandstoorganizeaveryfirstbrainstormingmeetinginpreparationoftheSecondHigh-LevelUnitedNationsConferenceon#SouthSouthCooperation#BAPA40!
It’sclearthatSouth-SouthCooperationissurgingintheSDGera.
GlobalPartnershiponEffectiveDevelopmentCooperationmeetinginParis-2018Monitoringround
“Thebiennial,voluntaryGlobalPartnershipmonitoringisledbycountrygovernmentsandbringstogetherbilateralandmultilateralorganisations,theprivatesector,civilsocietyandparliaments,amongothers,tostrengthentheeffectivenessandresultsoftheirpartnershipsatcountrylevel.”
17
JonathanGlennie–BalancingScopewithAccountability–AChallengeforDevelopmentEffectiveness
http://effectivecooperation.org/2018/09/balancing-scope-with-accountability-a-challenge-for-development-effectiveness/
Must-readanalysisbyGlennieaheadofthismeetinginParis,reflectingonwhathasbecomeofthe‘aideffectiveness’agendaand‘Paris’since2005.Heseessomestepsforward,andsomebackward.
Excerpts:
“…Fastforwardto2018(viamajormeetingsinAccra,Busan,MexicoCityandNairobi,andhundredsofsmallermeetingsbesides)andtwomainthingshavehappened.First,thefocusonbetteraidhasbecomehardwiredintotheinternationaldevelopmentcommunity.Perhapsthemosttellingdemonstrationofthisisthenumberofimpactevaluationsnowbeingcarriedout,manyofadetailed,oftenrandomised,nature.BeforeParisthesewerefewandfarbetween–todaytheyareparforthecourse.Andsecond,thelanguageofaideffectivenesshasevolvedintoafocuson‘effectivedevelopmentco-operation’or‘developmenteffectiveness’.Thisreflectsthebroadeningoutfromanobsessionwithaidtoanunderstandingthatwithallformsoffinance,resourcesneedtobeharnessedtofurtherglobalprogress,whetherpublic,privateorphilanthropic,bothdomesticandinternational.
“…Parisisdead’.Ithoughtatthetimehewasbeingabitmelodramatic,butIsoonbegantoseehispoint.Byexpandingthescopeoftheeffectivenessagenda,tocovermoresectors,morethemes,moregeographies,itsoonbecameimpossibletomaintainthatprocessofholdingthepowerful(donorsetal)toaccountfortheirspendingdecisions.……Butwhile‘impact’,‘effectiveness’and‘results’arenowattheheartofeverykeynotespeechonaidanddevelopment,‘ownership’and‘participation’arenolongerthebuzzwordstheyoncewerewheneveryonewasstillreadingRobertChambers….”
Oxfamhasanewboss
Devex-FreshstartforOxfamasnewCEOannounced
https://www.devex.com/news/fresh-start-for-oxfam-as-new-ceo-announced-93415
“AidinsiderssaiditwasthestartofafreshchapterforOxfamGBasitannounceditsnewchiefexecutiveonTuesday,followingatumultuoussixmonths.TheembattledcharitynamedDhananjayanSriskandarajah,currentlychiefexecutiveofficerofCIVICUS,aJohannesburg-basedglobalallianceofcivilsocietyorganizations,asitsnewhead.Describedbyinsidersasastrongadvocateofthe“globalsouth”andaprogressivethinkerondevelopment,heisduetotakeuptheroleattheendoftheyear.SriskandarajahtakesoverfromMarkGoldring,whohasoverseenthecharity’sresponsetoasexualmisconductscandalthatbeganearlierthisyear.Thathasincludedapackageofreforms,theresignationofitsdeputychiefexecutive,andanindependentreviewofitscultureandsafeguardingpractices….”
InotherOxfamrelatednews,checkout:
18
HowcanCivilSocietyrespondtogovernmentcrackdownsaroundtheworld?NewOxfampaper(andhellotoOxfamGB’snewboss)
https://oxfamblogs.org/fp2p/how-can-civil-society-respond-to-government-crackdowns-around-the-world-new-oxfam-paper/
ByDuncanGreen,onanewOxfampaper-Spacetobeheard:Mobilizingthepowerofpeopletoreshapecivicspace
Asia-Pacific:TwoInitiativesToEliminateMalariaOnceAndForAll
HPW-Asia-Pacific:TwoInitiativesToEliminateMalariaOnceAndForAll
“…theAsiaPacificLeadersMalariaAlliance(APLMA)announced–[today]attheWorldEconomicForumonASEAN–supportfortwonewinitiatives,BlendedFinanceforImpactandM2030.Asstatedinthepressrelease,externalgrantfundingtosupportmalariaeliminationisexpectedtodeclineintheregion….“Enterinnovativefinancing.
“BlendedFinanceforImpactisapartnershipoftheAsianDevelopmentBank(ADB),theGlobalFundtoFightAIDS,TuberculosisandMalaria,andAPLMAtoenableandincreaselong-termintegratedfinancingforhealth,includingmalaria.M2030aimstobringtogethersomeofthemostinfluentialbusinessesinAsiatoraisefunds,engageconsumersasagentsofchangeandsustainpoliticalsupportformalariaelimination.InlinewiththeobjectivesofBlendedFinanceforImpact,theADBtodayannouncedanewRegionalHealthFund….”
SeealsoDevex-Asia-Pacificturnstoinnovativefinancetostampoutmalaria
G20&globalhealth
TheG20thirdSherpameetingtookplaceinArgentina.Justatweet:
“Pleasedwithoutcomeofthediscussionsontheleaders’communiquéat#G20whichsupportsglobalhealth,sustainablefinanceandthesustainabledevelopmentagenda@SDG@g20org�@DrTedros�”
I’mnotexpectingmuch,tobehonest,givenArgentina’scurrentpredicament.
Related,aDevexop-ed(byADonnellyetal)-Opinion:G20leadershipontacklingdiseasewouldsavelivesandmoney
With3callstoactionforG20:“1.G-20membersshouldpooltheirnationalpublichealthandscientificexpertisetosupportglobaleffortstocombatAMR.2.AcommitmentfromG-20membersis
19
neededtosteadilyincreaseinvestmentsinhealthresearchanddevelopment,andofferinnovativefinancingoptions.3.TheG-20mustprovidepoliticalleadershiptoaddresstheinter-relatedissuesofAMR,pandemicpreparedness/responseandPovertyRelatedNeglectedDiseases(PRNDs).”
(Ohyeah,Ialsowantthemtotackleplanetaryhealth,atlast,anddealonceandforallwithglobalinequality:))
Sawsomeofthesegentlemen(yes,allgentlemen–Putin,Xi,Abe,…)atasummitinRussia,ontv,thisweek.I’dberathersurprisedifglobalhealthorevensustainabledevelopmentwasontopoftheirauthoritarian/nationalistminds.
NewStatisticsShowCancerBurdenRisingInTheWorld,LungCancerBiggestKiller
HPW-NewStatisticsShowCancerBurdenRisingInTheWorld,LungCancerBiggestKiller
“Cancerisrisingandisexpectedtobecometheleadingcauseofglobaldeathsinthe21stcentury,accordingtoexpertsfromaWorldHealthOrganizationresearchagencyoncancer.Lungcanceristhemostcommonandtheleadingcauseofcancerdeaths,theagencyfoundinitsnewlypublishedstudy,thefirstsince2012.However,politicalcommitmentlagsbehindwhenitcomestoprevention,speakerssaidatapressbriefingattheUNinGenevatoday.TheInternationalAgencyforResearchonCancer(IARC)[today]launcheditsGlobalCancerStatistics2018,estimatingincidenceandmortalityworldwidefor36cancersin185countries.……ThestudybuildsonananalysisoftheaccessibledatabaseGLOBOCAN2018,partoftheIARCGlobalCancerObservatory.TheIARCistheresearchagencyoncanceroftheWHO,andislocatedinLyon,France.“
“…Thereportestimatesthatsome18.1millionpeoplewillbediagnosedwithcancerin2018,and9.6millioncancerpatientswilldie.…”
SeealsoUNNews-Cancerisagrowingglobalthreatandpreventioniskey,UNstudyshows.
LancetGlobalHealth(Comment)-Livercirrhosisinsub-SaharanAfrica:neglected,yetimportant
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/langlo/article/PIIS2214-109X(18)30344-9/fulltext
“Clinicaleffortsandresearchonliverdiseaseshavebeenscarceinsub-SaharanAfrica.ThefirstConferenceonLiverDiseaseinAfrica(Nairobi,Sept13–15,2018),gatheringallstakeholdersfromthecontinent,isawelcomesteptowardsgreaterattentiontotheproblem,andtheimportantissueoflivercirrhosis….”
20
RichardSmith(blog)–WhoandWhataremedicaljournalsfor?
https://richardswsmith.wordpress.com/2018/09/06/what-and-who-are-medical-journals-for/
Withoutanydoubt,oneofthereadsoftheweek.Startingfrom‘PlanS’,SmithdwellsonthehistoryoftheLancetandBMJ,amongothers.Amongothersonthequestionwhethermedicaljournalsshouldbepolitical,entertaining,…&muchmore.
“…Thepossiblefunctionsofjournalsarethusinforming,reforming,disseminatingscience,educating,providingaforumforacommunitytodebatetheissuesoftheday,entertaining,andmakingmoney.Ibelievethatagoodjournalwilldoallofthesethings,tryingalwaystomaintainabalance….”
Heconcludes:“Medicaljournalshavemanyfunctionsanddiversecustomers.Theyseemtobegoodatstirringupdebatebutpoorataffectingchange.Traditionallytheyhavebeenmoreconcernedwithauthorsthanreaders,buttheirfuture—iftheyhaveafuture—liesinbeingmoreconcernedwithreaders.”
Lancet(Letter)-SupportforUNRWA'ssurvival
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)32264-5/fulltext
ByKarlBlanchet&150+othersignatories.
“…UNRWAisnowfightingforsurvival.OnAug31,2018,theTrumpAdministrationconfirmedthattheUSA,previouslyUNRWA'slargestdonor,willnolongerfundUNRWA.FundingcrisesarenotnewtoUNRWA.Thiscrisis,however,isunprecedented….…Ifactionisnottaken,governmentswillbegivingthegreenlighttoaruinousmultifacetedemergency,onetheregionsimplycannotbear.We,scientistsandscholars,urgeourgovernmentstosupportUNRWAnow,sustainingUNRWAservicesandtherebyavertingfurtherlossoflife,dignity,andhope.”
SeealsoaLancetWorldReport-FundscutforaidintheoccupiedPalestinianterritory
“InthewakeoftheUSA'scutstoPalestinianaid,healthintheoccupiedPalestinianterritorymightbejeopardisedbyafundingshortfall.SharmilaDevireports.”
Leftpopulism&globalhealth?
It’sincreasinglyclearthatglobalhealtheitherhastosidewiththeMacrons,Merkels&Trudeausofthisworld–who,foralltheirflaws,wanttomaintainamultilateralorder,thoughwith(somewhatmitigated)neoliberalcharacteristics,andtry(oratleastproclaimtotry)avoidingrunawayclimatechangeusing,however,capitalistapproaches–orinsteadbackleft-wingpopulismasadvocatedbyChantalMouffe.
21
Tworeadsrelatedtothislatteroption:
Guardian-Populistsareontherisebutthiscanbeamomentforprogressivestoo(ChantalMouffe)
“Neoliberalismhascreatedgenuinegrievances,exploitedbytheradicalright.Theleftmustfindanewwaytoarticulatethem.”
OpenDemocracy-Leftpopulismovertheyears(byCMouffe&RBechler)
(longread)“Aconversationabouttheriseoftheright-wingsincetheturnofthecentury,whatthistellsusaboutliberaldemocracy,andthedeepeningofdemocracyneededinresponse.”
Andonefromaslightlydifferentangle,onthefutureofinternationalleft:
BernieSandersintheGuardian-AnewauthoritarianaxisdemandsaninternationalprogressivefrontVaroufakis&manyothersseemtoagree.
“Inordertoeffectivelycombattheriseoftheinternationalauthoritarianaxis,weneedaninternationalprogressivemovementthatmobilizesbehindavisionofsharedprosperity,securityanddignityforallpeople,andthataddressesthemassiveglobalinequalitythatexists,notonlyinwealthbutinpoliticalpower.”
StartBacheletasUNHighCommissionerofHumanRights
UNNews-NewUNrightschiefpledgestopushbackon‘centuriesofprejudiceanddiscrimination’
https://news.un.org/en/story/2018/09/1018882
“TheUN’snewlyappointedHighCommissionerforHumanRights,MichelleBachelet,intendstopushback“centuriesofprejudiceanddiscrimination”againstvulnerablegroupsincludingwomenandthepeoplesoftheGlobalSouth,bypushingformoreconsensusbetweenMemberStates,shesaidonMonday.”Bacheletisclearlya“toughcookie”,andsoIhavehighhopesaboutherstintasUNHumanRightschief.
SeealsotheGuardian-UNhumanrightschiefsendsteamtoItalyafter‘alarming’anti-migrantviolence.
AndReuters-U.N.rightschiefBachelettakesonChina,otherpowersinfirstspeech.
UNNews-Alarminglevelofreprisalsagainstactivists,humanrightsdefenders,andvictims–newUNreporthttps://news.un.org/en/story/2018/09/1019082
22
Bacheletwillhaveherhandsfull.“Analarmingand“shameful”levelofharshreprisalsandintimidationagainstthosewhocooperatewiththeUnitedNationsinanefforttoupholdhumanrights,hasbeenrevealedbyanewUNreportlaunchedonWednesday.TheninthannualreportofSecretary-GeneralAntónioGuterresdetailsthelevelofretaliationagainsthumanrightsdefendersonacountry-by-countrybasis,includingallegationsofkilling,torture,arbitraryarrests,andpublicstigmatizationcampaigns,whichalsotargetvictimsofrightsabuse.”
PlanetaryHealth,conflict&globalhunger
UNNews-‘Directexistentialthreat’ofclimatechangenearspointofnoreturn,warnsUNchief
https://news.un.org/en/story/2018/09/1018852
“Theworldriskscrossingthepointofnoreturnonclimatechange,withdisastrousconsequencesforpeopleacrosstheplanetandthenaturalsystemsthatsustainthem,theUnitedNationsSecretary-GeneralAntónioGuterreswarnedonMonday,callingformoreleadershipandgreaterambitionforclimateaction,toreversecourse.”
Hecalledforrenewedcommitmentandannouncedahigh-levelU.N.summitonclimatechangein2019.
Meanwhile,inSanFrancisco,theGlobalClimateActionSummitistakingplace,withafocusonsubnational&privatesectoraction.“Thesummit,hostedbyCaliforniaGov.JerryBrown—andwithsupportfromothermajorplayers,includingphilanthropistMichaelBloomberg—willgiverisetoarangeofnewcommitments,someofwhichhavealreadybeguntotricklein….”
Formoreinfo,seethe‘PlanetaryHealth’sectionbelow.
Guardian-Globalhungerlevelsrisingduetoextremeweather,UNwarns
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/sep/11/global-hunger-levels-rising-due-to-extreme-weather-un-warns
“Globalhungerhasrevertedtolevelslastseenadecadeago,wipingoutprogressonimprovingpeople’saccesstofoodandleavingoneinninepeopleundernourishedlastyear,withextremeweatheraleadingcause,theUNhaswarned.Hungerafflicted821millionpeoplelastyear,thethirdannualrisesince2015,withmostregionsofAfricaandmuchofSouthAmericashowingworseningsignsoffoodshortagesandmalnutrition.Morethanhalfabillionoftheworld’shungryliveinAsia.Thereversalofprogressmadeinslowingmalnutritioninthefirsthalfofthisdecadehascausedseriousconcernamonginternationalagencies.Climateshocks,suchasdroughtsandfloods,wereidentifiedbytheUNas“amongthekeydrivers”fortherisein2017,alongwithconflictandeconomicslowdowns.Nearly100millionpeoplewereleftdependentonhumanitarianaidduringtheyear….”
ForthenewFAOreport,see2018:Thestateoffoodandsecurityintheworld
23
ForeignPolicy-WhyGrowthCan’tBeGreen
JasonHickel;https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/09/12/why-growth-cant-be-green/
“Newdataprovesyoucansupportcapitalismortheenvironment—butit’shardtodoboth.”
Guardian-Starvation:aweaponofwarthatcouldkill590,000childrenbytheendof2018
https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2018/sep/10/starvation-a-weapon-of-war-that-could-kill-590000-children-by-the-end-of-2018
“Starvationbeingusedasaweaponofwarhasbecomethenewnormal,accordingtoSavetheChildren.Itsanalysisshowsmorethanhalfamillioninfantsinconflictzonescoulddieofmalnutritionbytheendoftheyeariftheydonotreceivetreatment,theequivalentofoneeveryminute.ThecharitymakesitsownestimatesusingUNdata,andprojectsthat4.5millionunder-fiveswillneedtreatmentforlife-threateninghungerthisyearinthemostdangerousconflictzones–anincreaseof20%since2016.Atcurrentrates,onlyoneinthreewillreceivetreatment,and590,000coulddieasaresult.ThedataemergedaheadofTuesday’slaunchoftheUNannualreportonfoodsecurity….”
LancetWorldReport–CrisisintheChadBasinhttps://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)32250-5/fulltext
“Thoseintheregionarecontendingwithdisplacement,malnutrition,drought,andpooraccesstohealthcare,9yearsaftertheBokoHaraminsurgencybegan.SharmilaDevireports.”
LancetGBDseriesonNCDsinIndia
Lancet–https://www.thelancet.com/gbd?utm_campaign=gbdindia18&utm_source=carousel
“FiveGlobalBurdenofDiseasestudiesreportthefindingsonthehealthinIndia,focusingoncardiovasculardisease,cancers,chronicrespiratorydiseases,diabetes,andsuicidedeaths.”
Lancet–Offline:ThenewpoliticsofhealthinIndia
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)32211-6/fulltext
““Thereisafull-blowncrisisinIndia.”SosaidRahulGandhi,PresidentoftheIndianNationalCongressParty,duringavisittotheLondonSchoolofEconomicslastmonth.Hewastalkingabouta“jobscrisis”.Butthereisalsoahealthcrisis,asfivepaperspublishedacrossthreeLancetspecialtyjournals—LancetOncology,GlobalHealth,andPublicHealth—setoutthisweek.Nowistherightmomenttobedebatingthefuturehealthoftheworld'slargestdemocracy.InApril,2019,IndianvoterswillgotothepollsinthemostimportantgeneralelectionsinceIndiaachievedindependence
24
in1947.Thenewgovernmentwillnotonlysetafreshcourseforhealthpolicy.ItwillalsohavetheopportunitytoredefinetheideaofIndiaforanewgeneration….”
“HealthshouldbeanimportantissueinIndia'scominggeneralelection.ThefiveLancetpapersrevealadangerouslyrapidepidemiologicaltransition…”(intermsofNCDs)
MaybeI’moverinterpretinghere,butHortonsomewhathintsatfavoringModi(becauseof“Modicare”).“ModihasgraspedtheimportanceofhealthnotonlyasanaturalrightforIndia'scitizens,butalsoasapoliticalinstrumenttomeetthegrowingexpectationsofIndia'semergingmiddleclass.ModiisthefirstIndianPrimeMinistertoprioritiseuniversalhealthcoverageaspartofhispoliticalplatform….”
YoumightalsowanttoreadthisLancetComment-InformingNCDcontroleffortsinIndiaontheeveofAyushmanBharat(byBBhargavaetal).
TheysummarisethekeypolicyimplicationsofthefindingsoftheIndiaState-LevelDiseaseBurdenInitiative.
AndthissadGuardianreport-Nearly40%offemalesuicidesoccurinIndia.
SRHR
Devex-ForcedtochoosebetweenUSandSwedishfunding,sexualhealthNGOsspeakout
https://www.devex.com/news/forced-to-choose-between-us-and-swedish-funding-sexual-health-ngos-speak-out-93369
«SexualandreproductivehealthandrightsNGOsstrugglingtodeliverservicesinthewakeoftheUnitedStates“globalgagrule”havespentayearcaughtbetweendonors,aftertheSwedishaidagency,akeyfunderofsexualandreproductivehealthandrights,saiditcouldnotsupportorganizationsthatgoalongwiththerule.Thatdecision,activiststoldDevex,isunintentionallymakinglifeharderforthemontheground….”
“…InJuly2017,theSwedishInternationalDevelopmentCooperationAgencyannounceditwouldwithdrawfundingfromgroupscontractedtocarryoutSRHRprogramsiftheycompliedwiththeU.S.rule.Sidaarguesthatcompliancewiththegagrulewouldinterferewithacontractor’sabilitytocarryoutSwedish-fundedSRHRservices.Butadvocateshavedescribedthemoveasa“counter-condition”andsayitisforcingNGOstochoosebetweenU.S.andSwedishfunding.TheyalsosayithasledtosomeSidasubgranteeshavingtheircontractscancelled….”
25
AnnualReportGF:GlobalFundPartnershiphasSaved27MillionLives
https://www.theglobalfund.org/en/news/2018-09-12-global-fund-partnership-has-saved-27-million-lives/
“TheGlobalFundtoFightAIDS,TuberculosisandMalariareleasedareport[today]demonstratingthat27millionliveshavebeensavedbytheGlobalFundpartnership.Thereportshowstremendousprogressthathasbeenachievedbyeffortstoendtheepidemics,whilehighlightingnewthreats.TheResultsReport2018includeskeyannualresultsachievedincountrieswheretheGlobalFundinvests:17.5millionpeoplereceivedantiretroviraltherapyforHIV.5millionpeopletestedandtreatedforTB.197millionmosquitonetsdistributedtopreventmalaria….…Theprogresscomesagainstthebackdropofnewthreatstoglobalhealth.”
Jean-YvesleDrian,FrenchMinisterforEurope&ForeignAffairs,wasamongthehostsofthisreport.Theeventlaunchedpreparationsforthe6thReplenishmentConferenceoftheGlobalFund,scheduledforLyononOctober10,2019.(cfr.FranceDiplomatie)
WorldBankLaunchesFirstSustainableDevelopmentNotesLinkedtoNewGlobalSustainabilitySignatoriesIndex
https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2018/09/10/world-bank-launches-first-sustainable-development-notes-linked-to-new-global-sustainability-signatories-index
“TheWorldBank(InternationalBankforReconstructionandDevelopmentorIBRD),ratedAaa/AAA,willforthefirsttime,issueUSdollar-denominatedsustainabledevelopmentnotesthatprovideinvestorsreturnexposuretotheenvironmental,socialandgovernance(“ESG”)performanceofUNGlobalCompactsignatoriesthroughtheGlobalSustainabilitySignatoriesIndex7.5%VCER….”
Notquitesurewhatthismeans,butI’mguessingthisisimportantfromanSDGpointofview:)
Lancet(Perspective)–Rwanda:nottheofficialnarrative
LaurieGarrett;https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)32124-X/fulltext
LaurieGarrettreviewsJudithRever’sbook–“InPraiseofBlood:TheCrimesoftheRwandanPatrioticFront”.
Garrettwonders,“…WhatifKagame,likeMyanmar'sNobelPeacePrizerecipientAungSanSuuKyi,islessavictimthananethniccleansingconspirator?”
26
Someotherquotes:““…ThestoryofamorallydisciplinedRPFrescuingRwandafromthebrink,tosaveTutsisfromagenocide…Thisstorywaseasiertocomprehendthanwhatactuallyhappened.”
““…Thetruth,nomatterwhataiddonorsseemtobelieve,isthattheRPFhasneverstoppedtheviolence”,Reverwrites.“Kagamekilledbeforethegenocide.Hekilledduringthegenocide.Andhekilledafterthegenocide.TheWest'sunbridledsupportonlyfedtheregime'ssenseofimpunity.”
Somekeypublications
CriticalPublicHealth-TheCommissiononSocialDeterminantsofHealth:Tenyearson,ataleofasinkingstone,orofpromiseyetunrealised?
TedSchrecker;https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09581596.2018.1516034
“TenyearsaftertheAugust2008releaseofthereportoftheWHOCommissiononSocialDeterminantsofHealth,itisimportanttoreflectonthefateofitsrecommendationsforreducing‘healthinequity’.Thearticledescribessomekeydevelopmentsinthedecade,notablyinunderstandingtheetiologyofhealthinequalities,andthenjuxtaposesahopefulcomparisonwithofanearlier(1987)UNCommissiononEnvironmentandDevelopmentwithascepticalviewbasedontheexpandingsocialscienceliteratureonthepoliticsofeconomicinequality.”
BMJGlobalHealth–Institutionalisinganevidence-informedapproachtoguidelinedevelopment:progressandchallengesattheWorldHealthOrganization
UGopinathan&SHoffman;https://gh.bmj.com/content/3/5/e000716
“Thisstudyexploredexperiences,perceptionsandviewsamongWorldHealthOrganization(WHO)staffaboutthechanges,progressandchallengesbroughtbytheguidelinedevelopmentreformsinitiatedin2007…”Theylist5keythemes&tworemainingchallenges.
ORF-Securingthe21stCentury:MappingIndia-AfricaEngagement
https://www.orfonline.org/research/42593-securing-21st-century-mapping-india-africa-engagement/
Thisnewbookfeatures,amongothers,achapterbyKabirSheikh&AnnsIsaacson“StrengtheningHealthSystemsinIndiaandAfrica-AConvergingAgenda”.
Cfratweettogiveyouahunch:“By2050,Africawillbe56%urban,andIndia,50%.Theemergenceof“mixed”healthsystemsislinkedtorapidurbanisation.”
27
BMJGlobalHealth(Editorial)-Healthsystemsresearchonaccesstomedicines:unpackingchallengesinimplementingpoliciesinthefaceoftheepidemiologicaltransition
MaryamBigdeli,ZubinCShroff,AbdulGhaffaretal;https://gh.bmj.com/content/2/Suppl_3/e000941
Editorialintroducingaspecialcollection.Recommended!
MilibankQuarterly-SystemsThinkingasaFrameworkforAnalyzingCommercialDeterminantsofHealth
CKnaietal;https://www.milbank.org/quarterly/articles/systems-thinking-as-a-framework-for-analyzing-commercial-determinants-of-health/
“…ThisarticleshowshowacomplexsystemsperspectivemaybeusedtoanalyzethecommercialdeterminantsofNCDs,anditexplainshowthiscanhelpwith(1)conceptualizingtheproblemofNCDsand(2)developingeffectivepolicyinterventions.”
ODI(report)–FinancingtheendofextremepovertyMManueletal;https://www.odi.org/publications/11187-financing-end-extreme-poverty
“…Inthepast25years,theworldhasmanagedtohalvethenumberofpeoplelivinginextremepoverty(WorldBank,2015).Yetdespitethisprogress,atleast400millionpeoplewillstillbelivingonlessthan$1.90adayby2030.Overhalfofthesepeoplewillbeinlow-income,fragilecountries.Thisresearchreportpresentskeyfindingsandanalysisfromresearchonwhatneedstobedonesothatwecandelivertheglobaltargettoendextremepovertyby2030.Itfindsthatamongsomeofthepoorestcountriesthereiscurrentlyafundinggapof$125billioneachyearforhealth,educationandsocialprotection,whicharecrucialforreducingpoverty.Althoughincreasedtaxationcouldclosethisgapinmostmiddle-incomecountries,low-incomecountrieswillremainreliantonaidtofundthesesocialsectors.Thereportrecommendsthatdonors:(1)Focusaidonthosecountriesthatareleastabletofinancetheirownpublicspendingtoendextremepoverty,evenaftermaximisingtheirtaxrevenueswithOECDDACdonorsincreasingtheirshareofaidtoleastdevelopedcountriesfrom29%to50%;(2)Increasingfundinginthesecountriesforthecoresocialsectorsofhealth,educationandparticularlysocialprotection,and(3)IncreasingglobalaidfromOECDDACdonorsto0.7%ofGNI.
Somekeyblogs&articles
Bloomberg-JackMaTalksAboutHisPlansAfterRetiringFromAlibaba
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-09-08/jack-ma-talks-about-his-plans-after-retiring-from-alibaba
28
Apparently,Jackwantsto“goBill(Gates)”.He’llfocusmoreoneducation,though.
AsforJeffBezos,heannounceda$2billionphilanthropiceffortfocusingonhelpinghomelessfamiliesandstartingpreschoolsinlow-incomecommunities.IntheBezosDay1Fund.SeealsotheGuardian-JeffBezostofundschoolswhere'childwillbethecustomer'withnewcharity.
QuotefromaUSDemocrat,Khanna:““ThebiggeststatementMrBezoscouldmakeisbyraisingthepayofworkersinhisowncompany.Philanthropywillnotsolveincomeinequalityorstagnantwages.RaisingwageslikeHenryForddidin1914wouldmakeadent.””
LancetLetter–ImprovingtheavailabilityofhealthresearchinlanguagesotherthanEnglish
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/langlo/article/PIIS2214-109X(18)30384-X/fulltext
“…DiscussionsontheHIFAforumunderlinetheimportanceandurgencyofaddressinglanguageissuesasabarriertohealthinformationaccess.Specifically,wecallonthemedicaljournalpublishingindustrytotakeactiontoaddressthisanomaly.Thesimplestfirststepwouldbeforjournalstomakeatleasttheabstractavailableinthemainlanguageorlanguagesofthecountryinwhichtheresearchwasdone.“
Globalhealthevents
UniversalHealthCoveragePartnership–Secondmeetingofthemulti-donorcoordinationcommitteeforUHC(11Sept)
http://uhcpartnership.net/second-meeting-of-the-multi-donor-coordination-committee-for-uhc/
Thefirstmeetingofthemulti-donorcoordinationcommitteeforUHCsuccessfullytookplaceon9May2018.Totakeastepforward,WHOandpartnersheldtthesecondmeetingon11September)inGeneva,Switzerland.ThismeetingallowedtheUHCPartnership,fundedbytheEuropeanUnion(EU),GrandDuchyofLuxembourgandIrishAid,toharmonizewithotherfundingmechanismssuchastheEU’sACPHealthSystemStrengthening(HSS)grantandtheJapanesefundingforUHC.
WHO–InternationalPlatformonHealthWorkerMobility:Evidence,SolutionsandInstruments(Geneve,13-14September2018)
http://www.who.int/hrh/events/2018/int-platf-hwm/en/
29
“TheInternationalPlatformonHealthWorkerMobilityconvenedonthe13thand14thofSeptember2018inGeneva,Switzerland,withrepresentativesfromNationalGovernments,InternationalAgenciesandCivilSociety.“Checkoutthemeetingobjectives.
Andsomemeetings&eventswealreadywanttoflagfortheweeks&monthsahead:
Comingup–UNGA73(73rdsessionoftheUNGeneralAssembly)inNewYork(Sept18-Oct5)
https://www.devex.com/news/unga-2018-event-guide-93409
CheckoutDevex’seventguide.
Comingup-Firsteverinternationalconferenceonmedicinequality(23-28September,Oxford)
https://www.tropicalmedicine.ox.ac.uk/medicinequality2018/
“Howdoweensureaffordableandquality-assuredmedicineforall?JointhediscussionatOxfordUniversityfrom23-28September.“
Comingup:WHO2018symposiumonhealthfinancingforUHC(9October,Liverpool)
http://www.who.int/health_financing/events/symposium-2018/en/
“Whatdoesmakingprogressinhealthfinancing,insupportofUHCmean?Howdocountriesknowthey'reheadedintherightdirection?Whatpoliticalstrategiesfacilitateprogress?ToanswerthesequestionsWHO’sDepartmentofHealthSystemsGovernanceandFinancingishostingaone-daysymposiumonHealthFinancingforUHCaspartoftheGlobalSymposiumonHealthSystemsResearchinLiverpool.ItwilltakeplaceonTuesday,October9,2018from08:45–17:00inACCroom12.Thissessionwilladvancethethinkingandevidence-basearoundhowtoactuallydevelopandimplementhealthfinancingpoliciesthatfacilitateprogresstowardsUHC.Topacademics,policymakers,andpractitionerswillcometogethertodiscussanddebatenewlydevelopedframeworksthataddressbothtechnicalandpoliticalaspectsoftheimplementationofpoliciesthatfinancecoverageexpansion.ThesessionwillfocusonthefeasibleandusefulapplicationoftheseframeworksincountriestoadvanceprogresstowardsUHC….”SpeakersareamongothersJesseBump,AgnesSoucat,LucyGilson,JoeKutzin…
30
UHC2030attheFifthGlobalSymposiumonHealthSystemsResearch,Liverpool,UK
https://www.uhc2030.org/news-events/uhc2030-events/article/uhc2030-at-the-fifth-global-symposium-on-health-systems-research-liverpool-uk-501371/
IfyouwanttoknowwhatUHC2030isuptoinLiverpool–intermsofsessionsetc.
Comingup-ThePoliticalOriginsofHealthInequitiesandUniversalHealthCoverage(Nov1-2,Oslo)
https://www.uio.no/english/research/interfaculty-research-areas/globalgov/globalgov-for-health/news-and-events/events/2018/the-political-origins-of-health-inequities-and-uni/index.html
“TheIndependentPanelonGlobalGovernanceforHealthorganizesitsfirstannualinternationalconferenceinOslo.”Fascinatingline-up.
Globalgovernanceofhealth
Mo*paper–VanSimpeleMillenniumdoelennaarwarrigeDuurzameOntwikkelingsdoelen
JanVandemoortele;https://www.mo.be/sites/default/files/article/attachment/MOpaper117_MDGs_SDGs.pdf
It’snotoftenwerecommendapaperinDutch,butinthiscasewemakeanexception.Fortheonesamongyouwhodon’tread/speakDutch,werecommendGoogleTranslate!JanVandemoortele’stakeontheSDGs.
DuncanGreen(blog)-Sothreeyearsin,whatdoweknowabouttheimpactoftheSDGs?
https://oxfamblogs.org/fp2p/so-three-years-in-what-do-we-know-about-the-impact-of-the-sdgs/
DuncanGreen(Oxfam)hassomemajorreservationsatthestartoftheSDGs.Threeyearslaterheconcludes,atleastfornow,ontheirimpactsofar:
“…MaybeIwastooharsh–theSDGsareshowingsignsofhavingadripdripinfluencethatisdispersedandhardtopindown.Lotsofspinandlipservice,butsomeimpact,albeitsofter,more
31
pervasiveandhardertomeasurethan‘haveyouhalvedX?’TheSDGsseemtofitadiverse,multipolarworldwheredevelopmentprioritiesarequiterightlydecidedatalocallevel,notimposedfromoutside,andbeingbeingsubsumedintonationalpoliticsindifferentwaysindifferentplaces.Butthatstilldoesn’tanswerthequestionofwhyweshoulddevotesomuchtimeandattentiontotheSDGs,whenotherinternationalinstrumentsaremorebinding(ILOandUNConventions).IhavestillhaveseennothingthatcomparestheSDGsagainstalltheseotheragreementsintermsoftheirimpactondecisionmakers….”
DevelopmentPolicyReview-CriticaldiscourseanalysisofperspectivesonknowledgeandtheknowledgesocietywithintheSustainableDevelopmentGoals
SarahCummingsetal;https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/dpr.12296
“Criticaldiscourseanalysis(CDA)isemployedtoanalyzediscoursesofknowledgeandtheknowledgesocietyintheSustainableDevelopmentGoals(SDGs).Discourseanalysisisacollectivenameforanumberofscientificmethodologiesforanalyzingsemiosis,namelyhowmeaningiscreatedandcommunicatedthoughwritten,vocalorsignlanguage.Employingagenealogicalapproachwhichlocatesdiscoursesinthefieldofpriordiscourses,twopriordiscoursesoftheknowledgesocietyareidentifiedinthekeydocumentoftheSDGs.Theconceptsknowledgeandknowledgesocietyarefoundtohaveamarginalpositionwithinthemainpolicydocument“Transformingourworld,”adoptedbytheUnitedNationsinSeptember2015.Thetechno-scientific-economicdiscourseisfoundtobedominantatthelevelofimplementationandofgoals,whilethereissomeevidenceofthepluralist-participatorydiscourseatthelevelofvisionandstrategy.Analysisofsomeofthepolicyadviceprovidedbyinternationalorganizationsandcivilsocietyindicatesthatmorepluralist-participatorydiscoursesonknowledgewererepresentedwhentheSDGswerebeingformulated.Developedcountriesandthecorporatesectorwereveryinfluentialindeterminingthefinaltextandwereprobablyinstrumentalinexcludingmoretransformationaldiscoursesandmaintainingthestatusquo.”
MeToo&aid/globalhealth
Devex-Q&A:ILOexpertonnewworkplaceharassmentandviolencetreaty
https://www.devex.com/news/q-a-ilo-expert-on-new-workplace-harassment-and-violence-treaty-93370
“AstheUnitedNationsisconsideringadditionalmeasurestobeefupitsownsexualharassmentpolicies,oneagency—theInternationalLabourOrganization—islookingattryingtocreateaglobalsetofstandardsaroundharassmentandviolenceforworkers.ILOisconsideringalegallybindingtreatythatcouldprotectallworkersfromviolenceandharassmentintheworkplace,ifindividualcountriesadoptedandratifiedthemeasure.Theideahasbeenconsideredforthepastdecade,butconversationsaroundapotentialtreatyhavebeenongoingforthepastfouryears,precedingthe#MeToo,andaidanddevelopmentindustry-specific#AidToo,movements…”
32
RHM(Editorial)–TheAIDSconference2018:acriticalmoment
SofiaGruskinetal;https://tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09688080.2018.1510602?platform=hootsuite
Mainlyforthisparagraph:
«…Lookingforward,therearetwooverridingconsiderationsinanyreflectionforthefuture.First,concernsthequestionofMichelSidibe,thedirectorofUNAIDS,andtheprospectofUNAIDSmoregenerally.CorridordiscussionswerefilledwithwhatseemedtobefairlyunanimousagreementthatSidibe’stimehadcomeandthathemustresign,notsimplybecausehefailedtoadequatelyaddressthecasesofsexualharassmentbroughttohiminvolvingUNAIDSstaffmembers,butbecauseofhisapparentinabilitytotrulyhearandunderstandtheglobalcallforhimtoresignasnecessary,notsimplybecauseofhisactions(orlackthereof),butforthegoodofUNAIDSandtheAIDSresponsemoregenerally.……Thesecond,ironically,concernsthelocationofthenextinternationalAIDSconferencetwoyearsfromnow.”
InotherMeToorelatednews,TedrosflaggedWHO’sIntegrityHotlineonTwitter:“TheIntegrityhotlineprovidesasafeandindependentmechanismtoreportanyconcernsaboutissuesinvolvingWHO.ItismanagedbyaprofessionalcompanyselectedcompetitivelybyWHO….”
WHO-GovernmentofSwedenhostsPMNCHBoardretreatinStockholm
http://www.who.int/pmnch/media/news/2018/board-retreat-stockholm/en/
ShortreportofthePMNCHBoardretreatinSweden,endofAugust.ThefirstonechairedbyMBachelet.“…Theobjectiveoftheboardretreatwastofocusonthehigh-levelstrategicimplementationofPMNCH2018-2020BusinessPlan.ThenewBusinessPlanwillmoveawayfromtheStrategicObjectives(SOs)andtowardscenteringitsworkonthesixEveryWomanEveryChild(EWEC)Partners’Frameworkfocusareasandshareddeliverables….”
Surgery-WorldHealthOrganization:Leadingsurgicalcaretowardsustainabledevelopmentintheeraofglobalization
DLungman,RMartenetal;https://www.surgjournal.com/article/S0039-6060(18)30479-3/fulltext
“Intoday'sshrinkingworld,theroleoftheWorldHealthOrganizationastheleaderofglobalhealthisofincreasingimportance.Thisreviewaddresseshowtheorganizationisevolvingtomeetnewdemands,withafocusonitsrelevanceforsurgeryworldwide.”
33
IISD-ReportonFinancingtheUNDevelopmentSystemLaunched
IISD;
“In2016,theUNhadUS$49.3billioninrevenue,upapproximatelyUS$1billionfrom2015.ThereportindicatesthatrevenueoftheUNsystemissplit54%earmarked,28%assessedcontributions,10%voluntarycorecontributions,and8%fees,andthatthehighpercentageofear-markedfundsreducesflexibility.Thesecondpartofthereportconsistsofessaysthatprovideanoverviewofthecurrentstateandcomingtrendsinfinanceforsustainabledevelopment.”
Forthereport,“FinancingtheUNDevelopmentSystem:OpeningDoors”,seehere.
Atweet,perhaps:“.@DebapriyaBh@cpdbdon#SDGfinancinginLMIC-"aseriousmismatchbetweenglobaldiscourse...andrealitiesontheground,[andalackof]politicalenergy”
GlobeandMail–TrudeautopitchCanada’sworkondevelopmentfundinginbidforUNSecurityCouncilseat
GlobeandMail;
“PrimeMinisterJustinTrudeauwillpitchhisgovernment’seffortstounlockprivate-sectormoneyneededtohelpmeetasetofambitiousUnitedNationssustainable-developmentgoalsasakeypartofCanada’sbidforaUNSecurityCouncilseatinNewYorklaterthismonth.InaninterviewwithTheGlobeandMail,Canada’sambassadortotheUN,Marc-AndréBlanchard,saidthePrimeMinisterwilldeliverthekeynotespeechatahigh-leveleventhostedbySecretary-GeneralAntónioGuterresonSept.24,onedaybeforeworldleadersconveneinNewYorkfortheUNGeneralAssembly.Mr.BlanchardsaidMr.TrudeauwillusehisaddresstohighlighttheLiberalgovernment’scommitmenttohelpfinancetheUN’s17SustainableDevelopmentGoals(SDGs)focusedonendingpoverty,fightinginequalityandtacklingclimatechangeby2030–acornerstoneofCanada’scampaignforaSecurityCouncilseat….”
NYT-IsCashBetterforPoorPeopleThanConventionalForeignAid?
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/11/opinion/is-cash-better-for-poor-people-than-conventional-foreign-aid.html
“U.S.A.I.D.,theAmericanforeignaidagency,isconductingatrialthatmeasurestheimpactwhenpoorpeopleabroadaresimplygivenmoneywithwhichtodecidewhat’sbestforthemselves.”
34
#LancetWomen
https://www.thelancet.com/lancet-women
Withallthepapers&commentsfromthelastmonths.
Reuters-Ascountrieslookinward,developmentcashfallsshort-UNdeputychief
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-global-development-climatechange/as-countries-look-inward-development-cash-falls-short-un-deputy-chief-idUSKCN1LM2AJ
“Fundingforinternationaleffortstobuildresiliencetoclimatechangeandmeetotherdevelopmentgoalsisfaltering,warnsUnitedNationsDeputySecretary-GeneralAminaJ.Mohammed.“Itisatoughworldrightnowoutthere.Everyoneisbacksliding,”shesaidinaninterview.Insteadofthinkingaboutcommonaction,moreworldleadersaretakingtheapproachof“let’ssortthingsoutwithinourownborders”,sheadded….”
Devex–Opinion:CommunicationisessentialtoachievingWHO’snewstrategy
https://www.devex.com/news/opinion-communication-is-essential-to-achieving-who-s-new-strategy-93356
Noneedtoreadthis.Onlyifyou’re,likeme,ratherbaffledattheuseoftheterm‘healthconsumers’throughoutthepiece.
Excerpt:
“…Wecannotcontinuetosolelyprovidehealtheducationandawarenessandexpecttoovercomedeep-seatedculturalbeliefs.Effectivepublichealthcommunicationsmustbebasedonastrategythatisinformedbywell-formulatedqualitativeandquantitativemarketresearch.Thestrategymustsystematicallytakeintoaccountinsightsintothehealthconsumer;environmental,cultural,andsocietalfactorsthatinfluencethatconsumerdecision-making;themosteffectivechannelsofcommunications;othercompetitorproductsandservices;anunderstandingofwherethehealthinterventionsitswithinitsproductcategory;andperceptionsamongconsumersabouttheorganizationprovidingtheintervention….”
Finally,atweetfromGavinYamey
35
“Petpeeve.Intheglobalhealthcommunity,weusetheabbreviationLMICsforlow-andmiddle-incomecountries.Butinthewiderdevelopmentandglobaleconomicscommunity,LMICsarelowermiddle-incomecountries.Ourmeaningsaregettingcrossed&confused.”
UHC
HQSSCommission–countryprofiles
https://www.hqsscommission.org/countryprofiles/
Checkthemout.
BMJ(Analysis)-Healthsystemsshouldbepubliclyfundedandpubliclyprovided
NeenaModi,MartinMcKeeetal;https://www.bmj.com/content/362/bmj.k3580
“Amarketinhealthcareincreasesthelikelihoodofinequityandexploitation,withsuboptimalcareforbothrichandpoor,sayNeenaModiandcolleagues.”FocusontheNHSinthisarticle.
AllianceHPSR–EmbeddedimplementationresearchgrantstoachievetheSDGsannouncedintheAmericas
http://www.who.int/alliance-hpsr/news/2018/er-sdg-award-announcement/en/
“TheAllianceforHealthPolicyandSystemsResearch(AllianceHPSR)togetherwiththePanAmericanHealthOrganization(PAHO),andTDR,theSpecialProgrammeforResearchandTraininginTropicalDiseases,havejointlyawarded13grantstodecision-makersandresearchersin11countriestoexaminehowtoimprovehealthdecision-makingintheAmericas….”
36
Planetaryhealth
Devex-Bangkokclimatetalkleaves'heavylifting'toPolandCOP24
https://www.devex.com/news/bangkok-climate-talk-leaves-heavy-lifting-to-poland-cop24-93401
“TheBangkokclimatetalkculminatedina300-pagedraft,atomethathighlightshowmuchislefttodobeforetherulebookfortheParisAgreementonclimatechangecanbeadoptedinthePolishcityofKatowicelaterthisyear.Negotiatorsfrom178countriesgatheredintheThaicapitalforalastchanceaheadof24thConferenceofthePartiestotheUnitedNationsFrameworkConventiononClimateChangetountanglethesuiteofguidelinesthatwillsteertheParisAgreementtowardeffectiveimplementation.Withweeklongnegotiationsoftenprogressingwellintothenight,severalaspectsoftherulebookdidseeanimprovementinclarity,tirednegotiatorsandstakeholderstoldDevexonSunday.Butotheraspects,suchasthevitalissueofclimatefinanceanddetailsofnationallydeterminedcontributions,orNDCs,remainmurky.Developedcountries—ledbytheUnitedStates—tookanaggressivestanceonfinance,avoidingconversationsabouthowtheywouldcommunicatefuturepayoutstocountrieshithardbyrisingtemperatures.RichnationsskirtedtalksofthereplenishmentoftheGreenClimateFundandaprocesstoestablishanewlong-termfinancegoalinamovethatActionAid'sGlobalLeadonClimateChangeHarjeetSinghsaidthreatenstheaccordentirely.“TheParisAgreementisonthebrink,”SinghsaidonSunday.“Developedcountriesaregoingbackontheirwordandrefusingtoagreeclearrulesgoverningclimatefinance.Iftheyremainstuckintheirpositionsandfailtoloosentheirpurses,thistreatymaycollapse….”
SeealsotheGuardian-'Limited'progressatBangkokclimatetalksorUNNews-UnevenprogressonclimateactionatBangkokconference.
IISD-SDGKnowledgeWeekly:ClimateActionbyStateandNon-StateActors
IISD;
“AspreviewedbytheSDGKnowledgeHub’sMonthlyForecastforSeptember,climatechangefeaturesprominentlyontheglobalcommunity’sagendaforthemonth.Thisweek’s'KnowledgeWeekly'reviewseventsandpapersfromState-andnon-stateactors,highlightingthoselaunchedaroundthisweek'sGlobalClimateActionSummitandthejust-concludedBangkokClimateChangeConference.“
“…TheGlobalClimateActionSummit(GCAS)isbeingconvenedbyCaliforniaGovernorJerryBrownfrom12-14September,inSanFrancisco,California,US,onthetheme,‘TakeAmbitiontotheNextLevel.’TheSummitwillserveasaplatformfornon-stateactorssuchaslocalgovernments,businessesandcivilsocietytoshowcaseactiontowardsthegoalsoftheParisAgreementonclimatechange.Itfurtherseekstoinspirenationalgovernmentstoincreasetheambitionoftheir
37
NationallyDeterminedContributions(NDCs)aheadoftheUNClimateChangeConferenceinKatowice,Poland,thisDecember….”
AheadoftheSanFranciscosummit,theGuardianreported-JerryBrown:Trump's'grossignorance'mainobstacleinclimatechangefight“Californiagovernoristakingtheleadinconfrontingplanet’s‘existentialchallenge’andsignsbillforcarbon-freepowerby2045.”
ForanupdateonthisSanFranciscoSummit,seetheGuardian-USactivistslaunchclimatechangeinitiativesinabsenceoffederalleadership
“…America’sgovernors,mayorsandCEOsareforgingaheadwithclimatechangeinitiativesdespitetheTrumpadministration’swithdrawalfromtheParisAgreementandcommitmenttorevivingthecoalindustry.Butareportpublished[today]setsoutaroadmapthatcouldquickenthatpaceandcutcarbonemissionsto24%below2005levelsby2025intheabsenceoffederalleadership.”
Focusisthusonsubnational&privatesectoractioninSanFrancisco.
ProjectSyndicate-TheMassesAreMobilizingforClimateLeadership
ChristianaFigueres&MayBoeve;https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/mobilizing-public-for-climate-leadership-by-christiana-figueres-and-may-boeve-2018-09
“Afterayearofunprecedentedwildfires,droughts,floods,andothernaturaldisastersaroundtheworld,itisclearthattheclimatecrisisisalreadyuponus.Withoutmoreeffectivepoliticalleadershiptoreducegreenhouse-gasemissionsimmediately,theapocalypticconditionsofawarmingplanetwillbecomethenewnormal….”
Onthepositiveside,“…RiseforClimate,aglobalmobilizationof250,000peopletakingpartinover900eventsin95countriestookplaceonSeptember8.Ithassetthetoneforaseriesofupcomingpoliticaleventstoaddressclimatechange,includingthismonth’sGlobalClimateActionSummit,theOnePlanetSummit,andtheUNClimateChangeConferenceinPoland(COP24)thisDecember….”
ProjectSyndicate-TheTrialoftheCentury
PeterSinger;https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/climate-change-trial-of-the-century-juliana-v-united-states-by-peter-singer-2018-09
“Will21youngplaintiffsultimatelybeabletopersuadeaconservative-dominatedUSSupremeCourtthatthefederalgovernmentisviolatingtheirconstitutionalrighttoalivableplanet?ItdependsonwhethertheCourtiswillingtoheedthescientificevidence.”
38
Nature-Fivestepstoimproveair-qualityforecasts
RKumaretal;https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06150-5?utm_source=twt_nnc&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=naturenews&sf196938041=1
“Aworldwidemonitoringandmodellingnetworkwouldreducethedramatictollofairpollutiononhealthandfoodproduction,urgeRajeshKumarandcolleagues.”
“…WecallontheWMO,theWHO,theUnitedNationsEnvironmentProgramme(UNEP)andtheFoodandAgricultureOrganizationoftheUN(FAO)toleadthedevelopmentofaninternationalprogrammeforair-qualitymonitoringandprediction.FinancialinstitutionssuchastheWorldBankandnon-governmentalorganizationsshouldsupportair-qualityinitiatives….”
Meanwhile,ontheacceleratingclimatechangefront:
Atweet-“Manyscientistsarestunnedbythesimultaneousemergenceofmajorstorm/hurricanesystemsintheAtlantic&Pacific--possiblyunprecedentedinrecordedhistory.Thismapshowsastunningconformityinlatituderange,fromWestAfricatothewesternPacificIsl.”
Vox-Whyhurricanesareexpectedtodumpmoreraininawarmingworld
Infectiousdiseases&NTDs
Guardian-PoliooutbreakinPapuaNewGuineareachescapitalPortMoresby
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/sep/11/polio-outbreak-in-papua-new-guinea-reaches-capital-port-moresby
CfratweetbyLaurieGarrett:
“Keypoint:thisis#vaccine-derived#polio,not"wild"virus.Inmostcasesthesecasesarelimited,usuallyspawnedbyfailuresinkeepingvaxcoldbeforeuse.Scaryptofthisisapparentspread,nowurban.”
AlJazeerareportedPapuaNewGuineatolaunchnationwidepoliovaccinationcampaign
“PapuaNewGuinea(PNG)isgearingupforanationwidevaccinationcampaigntoprotectcitizensagainstpolio18yearsafterthediseasewaseradicatedfromthecountry.Theinitiative,whichisorganisedbythePNGgovernmentandtheWorldHealthOrganization(WHO),isaimedatstoppingthespreadofthediseaseafter10caseswereconfirmedinthecountry.Lastweek,thePNGMinistry
39
ofHealthconfirmedthetenthcaseinPortMoresby,thecapitaloftheimpoverishedsouthwestPacificcountry….”
Science–SteepdropinZikacasesunderminesvaccinetrial
JonCohen;http://science.sciencemag.org/content/361/6407/1055
“Controversialstrategyofintentionallyinfectingvolunteerstotestvaccinecandidatesisnowbackontheagenda.”
Aidsmap–Startingfromhere–whatPrEPprogrammescanlearnfromcircumcision
http://www.aidsmap.com/Starting-from-here-what-PrEP-programmes-can-learn-from-circumcision/page/3333820/
“Funders,healthprovidersandadvocatesshouldtakelessonsfromtherolloutofvoluntarymedicalmalecircumcision(VMMC)asanHIVpreventionmeasureinAfricaiftheywishtohastenaccesstoprogrammesprovidingpre-exposureprophylaxis(PrEP),researchersargueintheInternationalJournalofSTDandAIDS.”
UNAIDS-NewmodeldruglawlaunchedinwesternAfrica
http://www.unaids.org/en/resources/presscentre/featurestories/2018/september/new-model-drug-law-launched-in-western-africa
“UnjustlawscanpreventpeoplefromaccessingtheservicestheyneedtopreventortreatHIV,andpeoplewhousedrugsneedhelpandcare,notpunishment—thesearetwoofthemessagesfromthenewModelDrugLawforWestAfrica.Launchedon11SeptemberinDakar,Senegal,themodeldruglawaimstoguidepolicy-makersintheregiononhowtobetterframetheirdruglaws.”
Aidscaresupplement–HouseholdEconomicStrengtheningforHIVOutcomes.
https://www.tandfonline.com/toc/caic20/30/sup3?nav=tocList
ThissupplementwasfundedbytheUnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopmentandthePresident’sEmergencyFundforAIDSReliefanddevelopedbytheASPIRESprojectatFHI360.
Forsomemoreinfoonthebackgroundofthissupplement,seealsoThestateoftheevidenceforhouseholdeconomicstrengtheningapproachesforHIVoutcomes.
40
“…UndertheauspicesoftheAcceleratingStrategiesforPracticalInnovationandResearchinEconomicStrengthening(ASPIRES)project–fundedbyUSAID/PEPFARandimplementedbyFHI360–ourteamatFHI360developedanopenaccesssupplementalissueofAIDSCaretoprovideusefulinformationtoresearchersandpractitionersaboutwhatworksandwhatwestillneedtolearnaboutHouseholdEconomicStrengthening(HES)inthecontextoftheHIVepidemic…”
BMJGlobalHealth(Editorial)-ThesexgapinneonatalmortalityandtheAIDSepidemicinsub-SaharanAfrica
SYayaetal;https://gh.bmj.com/content/3/5/e000940
“Inthiseditorial,weanalysetrendsinthesexgapinneonataldeath—deathoccurringwithin1monthofbirth-duringtheeraoftheAIDSepidemic,andarguethattheyweresensitivetotheavailabilityofantiretroviralmedicines.ChildexposuretoHIV(duringpregnancy,deliveryandbreastfeeding)reducedthefemalesurvivaladvantage,butthissituationwasgraduallyreversedbytheavailabilityofantiretroviraltreatment.“
Scidev.net–Arabcountriescaughtinacycleofwaranddisease
Scidev.net;
“ConflicthasleftthedoorwideopenforepidemicsintheMiddleEast,lettingleishmaniasisintoSyria,poliobackintoIraqafter14years,and—aftertwoviolentwaves—choleratospreadacrossYemenonceagain….”“Sometimes,morepeoplediefromdiseasesassociatedwithwar,ortheaftermathofwar,thanfromtheconflictitself.Theeffectofepidemicslingersacrosstimeaswellasborders…”
UNNews-BackedbyUNagency,countriessettotakeondeadlylivestock-killingdisease
https://news.un.org/en/story/2018/09/1018751
“GatheredatamajorUnitedNationsagriculturalconference,over45countriestodaypledgedtoeradicateby2030ahighlycontagiousanddevastatingdiseaseresponsibleforthedeathofmillionsofsmallfarmanimals,atcostofmorethan$2billioneachyear.”
Relatedtothe«Pestedespetitsruminants(PPR)disease».
Andaquicklink:
Guardian-Zimbabwedeclaresstateofemergencyaftercholeraoutbreakclaims20lives
41
AMR
ScientificAmerican-GettingtheUpperHandonSuperbugs
ScientificAmerican;
“Weneedanentirelynewclassofantibiotic,whichscientistshavebeenunabletocreateformorethan50years.Untilnow,thatis.”Well,atleastaccordingtothisarticle:)
“…InastudyjustpublishedinNature,ourgroupdescribesanewclassofantibioticwedevelopedthatmayprovidefreshhopeagainstthedeadliestsuperbugs….”
FutureHealthSystems(blog)–TacklingAMRinpluralistichealthsystems
GBloometal;http://www.futurehealthsystems.org/blog/2018/9/7/tackling-antimicrobial-resistance-amr-in-pluralistic-health-systems
ByGerryBloometal.“Thereisgrowingscientificevidencethatinfectionsthatareresistanttoantibioticsareaseriousglobalhealthchallenge.ThishasstimulatedwideagreementonaGlobalActionPlanforAddressingAMRandmanycountrieshaveproducedNationalActionPlans.Itisimportantthattheseactionplanstakeintoaccountthelocalcontext.Thisisespeciallyimportantincountrieswithapluralistichealthsysteminwhichpeopleseekhealthcarefromawidevarietyofpublicandprivateprovidersofdrugsandmedicalcare.OnelessonfromtheworkoftheFutureHealthSystemsConsortiumistheneedtotakeasystemsapproachfortacklinghealthchallengesinthesecountries.Thisbloghighlightssomepriorityissuesthatthiskindofapproachneedstotakeintoaccount….”
Eurekalert-ScientistsdevelopnewdrugtreatmentforTB
UniversityofManchester;
“ScientistsatTheUniversityofManchesterhavedevelopedthefirstnon-antibioticdrugtosuccessfullytreattuberculosisinanimals.Theteamhopethecompound-developedafter10yearsofpainstakingresearchwillbetrialledonhumanswithinthreetofouryears.Thedrug-whichworksbytargetingMycobacteriumtuberculosis'defencesratherthanthebacteriaitself-canalsotakeoutitsincreasinglycommonlyantibioticresistantstrains….”
42
NCDs
GlobalPublicHealth-Timetotacklerheumaticheartdisease:Dataneededtodriveglobalpolicydialogues
MAbouzeletal;https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17441692.2018.1515970
“Rheumaticheartdisease(RHD)isanavoidablediseaseofpovertythatpersistspredominantlyinlowresourcesettingsandamongIndigenousandotherhigh-riskpopulationsinsomehigh-incomenations.FollowingaperiodofrelativeglobalpolicyinertiaonRHD,recentyearshaveseenaresurgenceofresearch,policyandcivilsocietyactivitytotackleRHD;thishasculminatedingrowingmomentumatthehighestlevelsofglobalhealthdiplomacytodefinitivelyaddressthisdiseaseofdisadvantage.RHDisinextricablyentangledwiththeglobaldevelopmentagenda,andeffectiveRHDactionrequiresconcertedeffortsbothwithinandbeyondthehealthpolicysphere.ThisreportprovidesanupdateonthecontemporaryglobalandregionalpolicylandscapesrelevanttoRHD,andhighlightsthefundamentalimportanceofgooddatatoinformthesepolicydialogues,monitorsystemsresponsesandensurethatnooneisleftbehind.”
LondonSchool-Johnson&Johnsonpartnershiptoboostmentalhealthcareinsub-SaharanAfrica
LSHTM;
NewsfromearlyAugust,butgoodtorecall.«TheLondonSchoolofHygiene&TropicalMedicine(LSHTM)hasteamedupwithJohnson&Johnsontodevelopanewgenerationofmentalhealthcareprofessionals,particularlyinsub-SaharanAfrica.»
FDAtakesnewstepstoaddressepidemicofyouthe-cigaretteuse,includingahistoricactionagainstmorethan1,300retailersand5majormanufacturersfortheirrolesperpetuatingyouthaccess
FDA;
TheFDAgoesaftere-cigarettemanufacturers&retailers,withaviewonkeepingthedevicesawayfromminors.
SeealsoBMJNews-Marketinge-cigarettestokidshascreatedan“epidemic”inUS,saysFDAchief.
43
Sexual&Reproductive/maternal,neonatal&childhealth
Unicefreport–Aneverydaylesson:#ENDviolenceinSchools
https://www.unicef.org/eap/reports/everyday-lesson-endviolence-schools
“AnEverydayLesson:#ENDviolenceinSchoolssaysthatpeerviolence–measuredasthenumberofchildrenwhoreporthavingbeenbulliedinthelastmonthorhavingbeeninvolvedinaphysicalfightinthelastyear–isapervasivepartofyoungpeople’seducationaroundtheworld.Itimpactsstudentlearningandwell-beinginrichandpoorcountriesalike.TheReportisreleasedaspartoftheUNICEF#ENDviolenceglobalcampaign…”
Forthepressrelease,seeHalfofworld’steensexperiencepeerviolenceinandaroundschool–UNICEF
“Physicalfightsandbullyingdisrupttheeducationof150million13-15-year-oldsworldwide.”
WB(blog)-MaternalDepressionandStuntedChildren:AnAvoidableReality
http://blogs.worldbank.org/health/maternal-depression-and-stunted-children-avoidable-reality
ByPatricioMarquezetal.«…acriticalbutoftenoverlookedfactinpolicydesignandprogramdevelopmentacrosstheworldistheassociationbetweenmaternaldepressionandchildhoodstunting--theimpairedgrowthanddevelopmentmeasuredbylowheight-for-age.”
BMCInternationalHealthandHumanRights-GlobalAbortionPoliciesDatabase:anewapproachtostrengtheningknowledgeonlaws,policies,andhumanrightsstandards
BRJohnsonetal;https://bmcinthealthhumrights.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12914-018-0174-2
“TheGlobalAbortionPoliciesDatabase(GAPD),launchedinJune2017,providesaverifiable,comprehensive,nuancedapproachtoinformationanddatasourcesonabortionlawandpolicy.Abortionlaws,policies,andguidelinesfromUnitedNations(UN)andWorldHealthOrganization(WHO)MemberStatesarejuxtaposedtoinformationandrecommendationsfromWHOsafeabortionguidance,nationalsexualandreproductivehealthindicators,andrelevantUNhumanrightsbodies’concludingobservationstocountries….”
44
GlobalHealthScienceandPractice–AssessmentofFamilyPlanningServiceAvailabilityandReadinessin10AfricanCountries
MAlietal;http://www.ghspjournal.org/content/early/2018/09/12/GHSP-D-18-00041
«Inthe10countriessurveyed,theavailabilityoforalcontraceptives,injectables,andcondomsvariedgreatly,andtheavailabilityofbasicitemsindicatingservicereadiness,suchasguidelines,trainedstaff,equipment,andcertaincommodities,waslow.”Thecountriessurveyed:Benin,BurkinaFaso,theDemocraticRepublicoftheCongo,Djibouti,Mauritania,Niger,SierraLeone,Tanzania,Togo,andUganda.
Finally,youprobablyheardaboutthatdumbheadinTanzania:
Tanzania'sJohnMagufuliadvisesagainstbirthcontrol(AlJazeera)
“PresidentJohnMagufulihasadvisedTanzaniancouplestostopusingcontraceptivemethods,sayingthatthecountryneedsmorepeople,accordingtolocalmediareports."Thosegoingforfamilyplanningarelazy...theyareafraidtheywillnotbeabletofeedtheirchildren….”Obviously,afiercebacklashfollowedhiscomments.
Accesstomedicines
HealthPolicyWatch-AfricanAcademyOfSciencesInitiativeAimsToBoostDrugDiscoveryForDiseasesInAfrica
https://www.healthpolicy-watch.org/african-academy-of-sciences-initiative-aims-to-boost-drug-discovery-for-diseases-in-africa/
“…Overadecadeago,Africangovernmentspledgedtoboostoverallresearchfundinginthe2006KhartoumDecisionoftheExecutiveCounciloftheAfricanUnion(AU)byallocatingatleastonepercenttheirgrossdomesticproduct(GDP)tostirresearchanddevelopment,butyearslaterithasremainedachosenbutless-troddenroute.ThescenariohaspromptedtheAfricanAcademyofSciences(AAS)toofferaremedy,targetingthehealthsector.TheacademyandpartnershaveinvestedinfundingtodevelopthecapacityofAfricanscientiststoengageindrugdiscovery.AASisapan-AfricanKenya-basedorganisationwithamandateofpursuingexcellencethroughrecognisingscholars,providingadvisory,shapingthecontinent’sstrategiesandpoliciesandimplementingscience,technologyandinnovationprogrammestotackledevelopmentalchallenges.ItsinitiativesareundertakenthroughtheAllianceforAcceleratingExcellenceinScienceinAfrica(AESA).Theacademy,incollaborationwithSouthAfrica’sUniversityofCapeTown(UCT)DrugDiscoveryand
45
DevelopmentCentre(H3D),MedicinesforMalariaVenture(MMV),andtheBill&MelindaGatesFoundation,havecommittedfundingforthediscoveryofnewdrugsfordiseasesendemictoAfricaoverthenexttwoyears….”
IP-Watch-ExtendedMonopoliesOnBiologicDrugs–AWarningToDevelopingCountries
http://www.ip-watch.org/2018/09/10/extended-monopolies-biologic-drugs-warning-developing-countries/
“ItwasrecentlyannouncedthattheUSgovernmentwouldbeseekingtotableatleast10yearsofmarketexclusivityforbiologicdrugsintherenegotiatedNAFTA.Thereareseveralreasonsforthis.Biologicdrugshavebecomeanimportanteconomiccommodity:nineofthetoptenbestsellingpharmaceuticalsarebiologic,includingdrugsforcancerandrheumatoidarthritis.Itisestimatedthattheglobalmarketpotentialofbiologicswillreach$250billiongloballyby2020.NAFTAwasnotthestartoftheUnitedStates’biologicsIPambitions.ItwasintheTPP,with12Pacificcountriesofdiversedevelopmentallevels,thattheysoughttoestablishthenormof12yearsofexclusivityforbiologicdrugs….”
Reuters–Indiabans328combinationdrugsinsetbackforpharmacompanies
https://in.reuters.com/article/india-health-drugs/india-bans-328-combination-drugs-in-setback-for-pharma-companies-idINKCN1LT15F?utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Twitter
“TheIndiangovernmenthasbanned328combinationdrugsinablowtobothdomesticandforeignpharmaceuticalfirms,butthebanhasbeencheeredbyhealthactivistsworriedaboutgrowingantibioticresistanceduetothemisuseofmedicines….”
FTHealth-Pharmachiefdefends400%drugpricehikeasa‘moralrequirement’
https://www.ft.com/content/48b0ce2c-b544-11e8-bbc3-ccd7de085ffe
Bethewillgostraighttoheavenafterhedies.
46
Vox-Hisfamilyhelpedcausetheopioidcrisis.Nowhemightprofitfromaddictiontreatment.
https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/9/7/17831710/richard-sackler-opioid-epidemic-buprenorphine
StoryonanotherPharma“gentleman”.“RichardSackler,formerpresidentofPurduePharma,may“benefitfinanciallyfromtheaddictioncrisisthathisfamily’scompanyisaccusedoffueling.”
Andafewquicklinks:
HPW-EPOUpholdsGileadPatentOnHepCMedicines,CivilSocietySays
“Accordingtocivilsocietygroups–whoexpresseddismay–theEuropeanPatentOffice(EPO)todayruledinfavourofpharmaceuticalcompanyGileadandmaintainedthecompany’spatentonhepatitisCdrugsofosbuvir.Thepatent,however,ismaintainedinanamendedform.”
HPW-NewR&DModelsAndIncentivesNecessaryToStepUpFightAgainstAMR,EUParliamentDeclares.
Humanresourcesforhealth
HumanResourcesforHealth-Communityboundaryspannersasanadditiontothehealthworkforcetoreachmarginalisedpeople:ascopingreviewoftheliterature
CWallaceetal;https://human-resources-health.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12960-018-0310-z
“Healthservicesinhigh-incomecountriesincreasinglyrecognisethechallengeofeffectivelyservingandengagingwithmarginalisedpeople.Effectiveengagementwithmarginalisedpeopleisessentialtoreducehealthdisparitiesthesepopulationsface.Onesolutionisbytappingintothephenomenonofboundary-spanningpeopleinthecommunity—thosewhofacilitatetheflowofideas,information,activitiesandrelationshipsacrossorganisationandsocio-culturalboundaries….”
47
Miscellaneous
Nature(News)–HealthdataoverlooksEurope’smostvulnerablecitizens
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06672-y?utm_source=twt_nnc&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=naturenews&sf197507033=1
“Europeisthebestintheworldatcollectinghealthdata,butitstrugglestoaccuratelycapturethehealthproblemsofpeopleinitslowestsocioeconomictiers,accordingtotheWorldHealthOrganization(WHO).TheEuropeanHealthReport,publishedbytheWHOon12September,foundthatresearchersmaketoolittleefforttoseekoutdatafrompeoplelivinginpoverty,whichcouldconfoundunderstandingofthecontinent’shealthburden….”
Callforpapers:specialHealthPolicy&PlanningsupplementonadvancinghealthsystemsforallintheSDGera
http://www.healthsystemsglobal.org/blog/309/Call-for-Papers-Special-Health-Policy-and-Planning-supplement-on-Advancing-Health-Systems-for-all-in-the-SDG-Era-.html
“ThiscallforpapersisjointlyorganisedbythejournalHealthPolicyandPlanning,andtheorganizeroftheFifthGlobalSymposiumonHealthSystemsResearch(HSR2018)–HealthSystemsGlobal.Thiscallisintendedforthosewhohavehadconferenceabstractsand/orpresentationsacceptedforHSR2018….”Deadline:20December2018.
WB(blog)-InvestinginPeopletoBuildHumanCapital
http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/immersive-story/2018/08/03/investing-in-people-to-build-human-capital?cid=ECR_TT_worldbank_EN_EXT
Meanwhile,theworldisgearingupfortheWB’sHumanCapitalProject,withanewHumanCapitalIndextobereleasedattheWB’sannualmeetingsinOctober:“…PresidentKimhasputthefullbackingoftheinstitutionbehindanewHumanCapitalProject.TheWorldBankGroupiscommittingtohelpcountriesprioritizehumancapitalinasustainedway,giventhedeepeningrecognitionthatjobsandskilledworkersarekeytonationalprogressincountriesatallincomelevels.……Therearethreemainobjectives:first,tobuilddemandformoreandbetterinvestmentsinpeople;second,tohelpcountriesstrengthentheirhumancapitalstrategiesandinvestmentsforrapidimprovementsinoutcomes;andthird,toimprovehowwemeasurehumancapital.……ThenewHumanCapitalIndex,tobereleasedattheWorldBank’sAnnualMeetingsinOctober,willsupportallthreeobjectivesandofferacrucialresourceforbothgovernmentsandcitizens.Itwillhelpmeasureproductivity-relatedhumancapitaloutcomessuchaschildsurvival,earlyhardwiringofchildrenforsuccess,studentlearning,andadulthealth…”
48
ODI(blog)-Africa10yearsaftertheglobalfinancialcrisis:whatwe’velearned
DirkWillemteVelde;https://www.odi.org/comment/10680-africa-10-years-after-global-financial-crisis-what-we-ve-learned
“Thisweekmarksthe10thanniversaryoftheglobalfinancialcrisis,whenLehmanBrotherscollapsed,developedcountrystockmarketsfoldedandtradecreditfroze.Severalthoughtpieces(Wolf,Tett,andTheEconomist)havearguedthatremarkablylittlehasbeenlearnedglobally.Thereismuchlessanalysis,however,ontheimpactonpoorercountries–particularlyinAfrica.Herearesevenlessonswe’velearnedorconclusionswehavedrawnatODI,andwhatitmeansforeconomictransformationandjobcreation.”
Foramoredirepicture,seeEurodad-10yearson:Globaldebtatall-timehigh.Developingcountrieshithardbyfallout“”TenyearsafterthecollapseofUSinvestmentbankLehmanBrotherson15September2008,theworldisindeeperdebtthanitwasattheheightofthefinancialcrisis.Thefalloutfromthefinancialcrisisisnowalsohittingdevelopingcountrieshard.ReadmoreinBodoEllmers'analysis.”
Alongthesame(dire)lines,thisODIAnalysis-Recorddebtlevelssuggestwemaybesleepwalkingintothenextglobaleconomiccrisis(byJGriffiths).
Devex-USAIDrelaunchesDevelopmentInnovationVenturesprogram
https://www.devex.com/news/usaid-relaunches-development-innovation-ventures-program-93402
“TheUnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopment’sDevelopmentInnovationVentures,aprogramthatprovidesgrantstotestandscaleinnovations,willonceagainacceptapplicationsafterbeingsuspendedformorethanayear….”
PlosMed(Perspective)ScienceWithoutPublicationPaywalls:cOAlitionSfortheRealisationofFullandImmediateOpenAccess
https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.1002663
Somemoredetailon“PlanS”oflastweek.“InthisPerspective,agroupofnationalfunders,joinedbytheEuropeanCommissionandtheEuropeanResearchCouncil,announceplanstomakeOpenAccesspublishingmandatoryforrecipientsoftheiragencies’researchfunding.”
ReadalsoGMonbiot’stakeintheGuardian-Scientificpublishingisarip-off.Wefundtheresearch–itshouldbefree.
49
Nature(News)-Peerreviewersunmasked:largestglobalsurveyrevealstrends
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06602-y?utm_source=twt_nnc&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=naturenews&sf197149141=1
“Thelargest-everpeer-reviewstudyrevealsthatthereisgrowing“reviewerfatigue”,witheditorshavingtoinvitemoreresearcherstogeteachreviewdone.Asurveyofmorethan11,000researchersalsofoundthatscientistsindevelopedcountrieswritenearly2peerreviewspersubmittedarticleoftheirown—nearly3timestherateofresearchersinemergingnations.”
LancetGlobalHealth(Comment)-Thankyoutoourdiverse(butnotdiverseenough)reviewers
ZoëMullan;https://www.thelancet.com/journals/langlo/article/PIIS2214-109X(18)30414-5/fulltext
“…Aspartofthisyear'sannualthanksandpublicrecognitionofallthosewhohavereviewedforusoverthepast12months,weattemptedtoanalysethegenderofall624reviewersbetweenAugust2017andAugust2018.Wesuccessfullyidentifiedthegenderofallbutthree,andfoundthat225(36%)werewomenand396(64%)men.Soourgenderbalanceisbetterthansome,butisitgoodenough?Wedon'tthinkso….…Takingtheself-punishmentalittlefurther,wealsoanalysedreviewerdiversitybycountry(figure).Theresultsshowthat,although64countrieswererepresented,nearlyathirdofreviewerscamefromtheUSAalone,with15%fromtheUK.ThenexthighestrepresentationswereCanada,Australia,Switzerland,India,SouthAfrica,France,Brazil,andItaly…”
ProjectSyndicate-ChinaisLosingtheNewColdWar
MinxinPei;https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/china-cold-war-us-competition-by-minxin-pei-2018-09
“IncontrasttotheSovietUnion,China'sleadersrecognizethatstrongeconomicperformanceisessentialtopoliticallegitimacy.LiketheSovietUnion,however,theyarepayingthroughthenoseforafewfriends,gainingonlylimitedbenefitswhilebecomingincreasinglyentrenchedinanunsustainablearmsracewiththeUS.”
Analysistobetakenwithagrainofsalt.ButthefirsttimeIsawtheBeltandRoadInitiativebeingdescribedas‘imperialoverreach’:)
MethinksthatthesecronycapitalistsfromtheUSwillgodownbeforethecronycapitalistsfromChina.
50
IDS-IsCRISPRthenextbigthingininternationaldevelopment?
PSchröder;http://www.ids.ac.uk/opinion/is-crispr-the-next-big-thing-in-international-development
“ThegeneeditingtechnologyCRISPR/cas9hasbeencreatingabuzzinthebiotechscienceworldoverthelastfewyears.Morerecently,ithasbecomeasignificantnewfieldinthecontextofthebioeconomyandcould,potentially,becomeagamechangerforinternationaldevelopment.Viewedbysomeasanewinnovationwithmassiveopportunities,othersaretakingamorecriticalpositiontowardsCRISPRandgeneediting.”
IISD(PolicyBrief)-September2018UpdateonUNReformProcesses
http://sdg.iisd.org/commentary/policy-briefs/september-2018-update-on-un-reform-processes/
“Numerousreformsareunderwayatonce,whichcanoverwhelmcalendarsandattractcriticismof“processproliferation”.Thispolicybriefprovidesasnapshotofrecentdevelopmentsintheparallelbutinter-relatedreformprocessesunderwaywithintheUNsystem….”
Nature(News)-SouthAfricapushessciencetoimprovedailylife
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06122-9
“Sweepingpolicychangesaimtorefocusresearcheffortsonpoverty,unemployment,droughtandothernationalproblems.”
BMJ-Defendingevidenceinformedpolicymakingfromideologicalattack
CBonell,MMcKeeetal;https://www.bmj.com/content/362/bmj.k3827
“Theworldfacesaneweraofgreaterhostilitytoexpertsandevidence,argueChrisBonellandcolleagues.Theantidote,theysay,istoremindthepublichowevidencebasedpolicymakingevolved—andofitsadvantagesandlimitations”.
Recommended.
51
WorldDevelopmentReport2018–LearningtorealizeEducation’spromise
http://www.worldbank.org/en/publication/wdr2018#
“TheWorldDevelopmentReport2018(WDR2018)—LEARNINGtoRealizeEducation’sPromise—isthefirsteverdevotedentirelytoeducation.……Thebestwaytoequipchildrenandyouthforthefutureistoplacetheirlearningatthecenter.The2018WDRexploresfourmainthemes:1)education’spromise;2)theneedtoshinealightonlearning;3)howtomakeschoolsworkforlearners;and4)howtomakesystemsworkforlearning.”
OpenDemocracy-Whypositivethinkingwon’tgetyououtofpoverty
FSialetal;https://www.opendemocracy.net/transformation/farwa-sial-and-carolina-alves/why-positive-thinking-won-t-get-you-out-of-poverty
“Tosaythatpoorpeopledon’thaveenoughhope,tenacityandaspirationistodenytheiragencyaswellasthesizeofthestructuraloddstheyface.InarecentarticleintheNewYorkTimes,thedevelopmenteconomistSeemaJayachandrandiscussesthreestudiesthatusedRandomisedControlledTrials(orRCTs)tounderstandthebenefitsofenhancingtheself-worthofpoorpeople.Despitewidedifferencesincontext,allthecasesexploretheviabilityof‘modestinterventions’to‘instillhope’inmarginalisedcommunities,concludingthat‘remarkableimprovements’inthequestforpovertyreductionarepossible….”
CGD(blog)–MoreResultsfortheMoney:CashBenchmarkingatUSAID
SarahRose&AmandaGlassman;https://www.cgdev.org/blog/more-results-money-cash-benchmarking-usaid
“Today,USAIDtookabigstepforwardonaneweffortthatcouldmakearealdifferencetotheagency’simpactandcost-effectiveness.”
AmericanAnthropologist–TeachingandCritiquingGlobalHealth:Or,“IThinkI’llGointoConsulting”
RMcKay;http://www.americananthropologist.org/teaching-and-critiquing-global-health-or-i-think-ill-go-into-consulting/
“Inmycontributiontothisseries,Iwanttoreflectontheambivalentpositionofbothteachingandcritiquingglobalhealth.Asanethnographer,myworkhasaskedhowanthropologicaltoolsnotonly
52
reflectbutalsoconstruct“globalhealth”conceptsandpractices.ThroughfieldworkIhaveconductedinMaputo,Mozambique,since2006,Ihaveaskedwhatitmeanstoconstructhealthprojectsasexplicitly“global”andaboutthemodesofmedicine,caregiving,andhealththatsuchdefinitionsexclude.Thesequestionsalsoanimatemyteaching.Likemanyanthropologistsofmedicine,Ioftenteachcoursesonthemesrelatedtoglobalhealth,humanitarianism,anddevelopmenttoundergraduatesinanthropologyandrelatedfields.Yetglobalhealthisahighlycontingentandpolysemicconcept.Itdescribesashiftingsetofpracticesandinstantiatesadiversearrayofsubjectpositionsandinequalitiesforhealthactorsandethnographersalike.Asaresult,theworkofteaching,writingabout,andevencritiquingglobalhealthcanbehardtodistinguishfromtheworkofconstitutingit….”
CfratweetbyFelixStein:“Onteaching#globalhealth,a"boundaryobject"betweenintervention,andcritique.”
Vox-Whyyourdeskjobissodamnexhausting
https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/9/5/17818170/work-fatigue-exhaustion-psychology
Ifyouwanttoknow,you’llhavetoreadthisarticle:)
Research
SS&M-Evidencesuggestsaneedtorethinksocialcapitalandsocialcapitalinterventions
AShieletal;https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S027795361830488X
Iincludedthisoneforoldtimes’sake:)20yearsago,IwasinvolvedinaPhDproject(totestPutnam’ssocialcapitaltheoryintheEU)thatwasabsolutelygoingnowhere.Abitlikethecurrentreality,youmightsay.
“Policyimplicationsrelatingtosocialcapitalandhealthareelusiveandcontradictory.Theywillremainsounlesswechangethewaywedesignandevaluatehealthinterventions.Suggestionsareofferedonhowtoaddressthischallenge.”
53
JournalofEmpiricalResearchonHumanResearchEthics-LinkingParticipatoryActionResearchonHealthSystemstoJusticeinGlobalHealth:ACaseStudyoftheMaternalandNeonatalImplementationforEquitableHealthSystemsProjectinRuralUganda.
BPratt&AHyder;https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29160115
“Anethicalframeworkcalled"researchforhealthjustice"providesinitialguidanceonhowtolinkhealthsystemsresearchinlow-andmiddle-incomecountriestohealthequity.Tofurtherdevelopthelargelyconceptualframework,wetesteditsguidanceagainsttheexperienceoftheMaternalandNeonatalImplementationforEquitableHealthSystems(Manifest)project,whichwasperformedinruralUgandabyresearchersfromMakerereUniversity.……Ouranalysisidentifieswherealignmentexistsbetweentheframework'sguidanceandtheManifestproject,providinginitiallessonsonhowthatwasachieved.Italsoidentifieswherenonalignmentoccurredandgapsintheframework'sguidance.Suggestionsarethenmadeforrevisingandexpanding"researchforhealthjustice."”
BMJGlobalHealth-Systematicdebriefingafterqualitativeencounters:anessentialanalysisstepinappliedqualitativeresearch
SMcMahonetal;https://gh.bmj.com/content/3/5/e000837
“Conversationsregardingqualitativeresearchandqualitativedataanalysisinglobalpublichealthprogrammingoftenemphasizetheproductofdatacollection(audiorecordings,transcripts,codebooksandcodes),whilepayingrelativelylessattentiontotheprocessofdatacollection.……Thispaperdefinesanddiscussesaprocessforsystematicdebriefings.Debriefingsentailthorough,goal-orienteddiscussionofdataimmediatelyafteritiscollected.Debriefingstakedifferentformsandfulfillslightlydifferentpurposesasdatacollectionprogresses.DrawingfromexamplesinourhealthsystemsresearchinTanzaniaandSierraLeone,weelucidatehowdebriefingshaveallowedusto:enhancetheskillsofdatacollectors;gainimmediateinsightsintothecontentofdata;correctcourseamidunforeseenchangesandchallengesinthelocalcontext;strengthenthequalityandtrustworthinessofdatainrealtime;andquicklyshareemergingdatawithstakeholdersinprogrammatic,policyandacademicspheres….”
BMJGlobalHealth(Editorial)-Towardsequityinglobalhealthpartnerships:adoptionoftheResearchFairnessInitiative(RFI)byPortuguese-speakingcountries
ACarvalhoetal;https://gh.bmj.com/content/3/5/e000978
54
Thetitlespeaksprettymuchforitself.FormoreinfoonRFI,seealsoarecentIHPFeatarticle-FromgoodintentionstoEquitableSolutionsinHealthResearchCollaborations–TheResearchFairnessInitiative(RFI).