ideal final result
DESCRIPTION
The presentation is a TRIZ excerise of generate ideas using the Ideal Final Result premise.TRANSCRIPT
TRIZFrom December 13th to 20th , 2008
New Can Platform (NCP)Functionality WS
Definition of the system
What do we sell?
Instead of instrumentation
NCP sells information display for decision making
If Procter and Gamble instead of laundry powder P&G sells clean cloths then
Ideal Final Result Attribute IFR
Final customer
IFR
Customers
Plants
IFR
Manufacturer
What is important to the customer:
Have a product that fit their design:
Hermetic
Cosmetic
Communication Protocol
Simple product:
Easy to connect
Easy to assemble (mounting)
Communication protocol
Self- Configurable
Self Diagnostics
Hermetic:
No condensation or dust inside, always have the functionality, no interference.
Cosmetic:
Customer can decide the styling od the dial and pointer
Communication:
Not relevant
Connection: not relevant
Mounting: Not relevant
Communication: not relevant
Configuration. Can change the order of the module if he wants
Diagnostic: can have a fast diagnostic at the workshop of which part is failing (the measurment system of the part)
Hermetic
Within requirements (IP69, IP66, etc)
Cosmetic:
Cosmetics can be different depending the assembly. No scratches during assembly
Communication:
Standard
Connection not needed, no cables
Mounting: fast and easy
Comm: 100% compatible
Configuration: Assemble and later decide the configuration
Diagnostic: can have a fast diagnostic at the workshop of which part is failing (the measurment system of the part)
Hermetic
Easy to close at the manufacturing line: no scrap and fast
Cosmetics
Less part numbers , materials that aren't delicate
Communication:
Standard
Connection not relevant
Mounting: Not relevant
Comm: 100% compatible
One variant of a product
Not relevant
Attribute IFR
Final customer
IFR
Customers
Plants
IFR
Manufacturer
Customized customer have the functions that he needs
Friendly to the environment: Current consumption
Availability of information
Information is available at any time
Can Add modules if he wants to
Battery is available for other applications
Knows the status of the variables through other devices such as internet, PDA, SMS, etc
The module has the functions that each customer requires yet is a platform
?
Competitive advantage over competitors
Less part numbers, less stock
One core product
Less components to manage energy
Competitive advantage over competitors
Ideal Final Result
Ideal Final ResultWe manufacture one product but customer obtains
several products: platform
Final Customer:
•Those products are "Plug & Play" by the final customer (or workshop) meaning That can be re-arranged by the user at the panel layout•The information is always available (status of variables)
Manufacture:
At the application plants: •Easy to mount one movement to clamp
At our facility: As few part numbers as possible•As few efforts as possible
Functions to improve (team consensus)
Functions while
module is Off
Mounting Method
Functions while
module is On
Manufacture
Configurable
Ideas:
Configurable
•Use displays to configure the look of the gauge (Eliminates pointers)One variant – check display type color gauge preferred
•Use a display (front) and a pointer (back) to have a different look
• Use a display with a hole in the middle so we can configure the dial but the pointer still mechanical or with light.
•Use dials that have a cut so we can change• them without taking out the pointer
Ideas
Mounting method
*
Use a turn & lock system using a modification in the housing
Use a bottle vacuum lock to fix the module (a)
Use an elastomeric cone wrapping the module and press it into the mask
Assemble the module in the back and the ring – bezel should be attached to the mask or panel
Hook that slides and holds the module
(a)
Ideas
Functions while
module is Off
* Add an alarm function to the main gauge: For door lock open , Diesel level Door open, Wake-up alarm (trend: Security and paranoia)
Turn the module in an uniform surface (if it is a display)Turn the module in to a mirror
Use the pointers as a found sensitive device and Make the pointers move as an equalizer
ideas
Functions while
module is On
Use more senses to advice the user (tact, smell, sound): all display is a button
If we connect an other module , master recognize it
Master can rearrange slaves in order without take them out (if module has a display)
Information can be send to PDA, internet or other sources: ¿How much gas do I have?
Module concept• The customer decides which functions he wants
But for us is just connecting modules to a main core module. (pass a station or not)
• If it's a display module the module would be thinner • If it's a display we are producing just one variant with
no dial obsolesce
Bez
el -
no
bez
el
Her
met
icC
om
mu
nic
atio
n a
dd
s
Bas
ic c
om
mu
nic
atio
n
Mas
ter
Mo
du
le
Gra
ph
ic c
on
tro
ller
Plu
g a
nd
pla
y s
oft
wa
re
Oth
ers
Contradictions: • Styling is good & bad
• Good mounting support at the truck but the cycle time at assembly plant is too long.
• The closing of the bezel is not good at production but achieves the requirement.
• We can update the software but user is not able to do so
Styling: • Mount from the back of the mask so it can stay flat at the cockpit + the bezel, if
needed is part of the cockpit mask
• Some of the features can be decided by the user, e.g. Illumination can change colors (LED)
Architecture: • Have a master "combo" to built the PCB meaning it´s a general PCB design and if
needed the components and software will be placed
• All others are slaves and can be digital or analog
• No restriction in quantity of modules linked to eachother
• Master recognize automatically the slaves
Market trends: succesful products have at least one of these
• Individualism against Tribalism • Ubiquitous Computing• Environmental awareness• Security and paranoia• Third places between home and work• Simplicity• Sedentary life style• Obesity • Guilt• Being alive• Travel & Vacation• Life long Learning• Virtual• Future Tense• More litigation• Little luxuries• Women in to market
Ideas by trend
• Individualism against Tribalism: Individualism:
--Load images while the unit is off such as advertising, visual aids, remainders.
Change colors of bezels or backlights
---If a display is chosen, the dial can be modify for each application (B&W, limited colors, full color)
Tribalism:
-- Do not change pointers, even when we have displays, the information should be
Graphical and not alphanumerical (meaning pointer that moves, instead showing a value)
Ubiquitous Computing: (hmi)• Data interaction with electronic devices: Send status or history to an aplication.
(module can be present or not)
• Have a local storage and download if needed
• Add functions not related to the application such as thermometer of weather.
Simplicity- virtual:• Change the display information. User does not need all information all the time, so
display information can change and have less devices installed (maybe can turn bigger)
Environmental awareness• Use recycled material for non Cosmetics parts
• Equipotenciallity: Since the truck vibrates , use the energy to have the module always charged