i.legacycontent.halifax.ca/archives/halifaxcity... · city council meeting friday november 12, 1954...
TRANSCRIPT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING
FRIDAY November 12, 1954
A G'ENDA
Prayer. Minutes. Public Hearing re Building Lots Gorsebrook.
9 0 Building Line Cunard & Windsor Sts. Motion Alderman Ahern re Fairview Underpass. Accounts over $500.00.
5, Claim Fort Massey Church $139.00. 11 Mrs. E. F. Boudreau $179.45.
7. Progress Payment to J. M. Cleminehaw & Co. 3, Undersized Lot 35 Beaufort Ave. 9, " 88 Morris Street. 3. Housing Authority of Halifax.
Sewer Extension Oxford & Maxwell Sts. 12. City Manager's Vacation. 3, Land Sale Account. . Superannuation.
Provincial Grant - School Buildings. Report T. B. Hospitalization Across Canada.
17. Bedford Row Fire Station - Roof. 1. Fairview Cemetery Ordinance and Changes. 19, Resolution City of Windsor, Ontario re Food Commodities. '0, Ross Hall Retirement. 21. Group Life Insurance. 22. Boxing Day December 27. 23. Tenders for Land. 24. Tenders for Groceries, Fish etc. ',C. Tenders for License Plates. • _• Tenders for Supplies.
Appropriation under Section 316 C for payment of Coupon Interest. December Pay.
29. Halifax City Charter. Legislation re Retiring Allowances. Financial Statements. Downtown Parking Lot 1955 Lease.
33. Reservation International Trade Fair. • Appointment of Coal Weigher.
Heating System City Field. Incinerator Dates. Additional Court Reporter. Street Names. •,. Resubdivision of Lands of S. Walker - Liverpool St. ,0. City Owned Lands Liverpool St.
i. Building Line Hollis St. '2. Land required from St. Patrick's Home for Romans Ave. • Television Antennae Licenses.
George H. German Retirement. Grants for Pensioners. Final Payment to Bedford Construction Co. $2,508.00. Proposed Sewer Extension Clinton Ave. & Dutch Village Road. Blasting Permits. Overhanging Signs. Closing Portion of Bowers Road for Sale. Sale of Land Connaught Ave. (near Chebucto Road).
• • Street Lighting Bayern Road and Elliott St. • Normandy Drive between Rosemead Ave. and Robie St. '• Application for Amendment to Zoning Bungay Windsor St.
• • cuestions.
November 12,1954.
DEFERRED ITEMS.
City Field Union 40—hour week. Motion Alderman Ahern re Memorial Drive.
FOR INFORMATION ONLY
City Manager's Administrative Report. Tree List. Solicitor's Report on Convention. Tax Collections. Statistical Report Prefab Houses. Approvals by Minister of Municipal Affairs.
ENING SESSION
Council Chamber, City Hall, Halifax, N.S., November 12, 1954, 8:00 P.M.
A meeting of the City Council was held on the above date.
After the meeting was called to order by the Chairman and be—
fore considering the regular order of business, the members of
Council attending, led by the City Clerk, joined in repeating the
Lord's Prayer.
There were; present His Worship the Mayor Chairman; Aldermen
DeWolf, Moriarty: Dunlop, Macdonald, Lloyd, Kitz, O'Malley, Ahern,
Allen, Vaughan and Hatfield.
Also present were Messrs. A.A. DeBard, Jr.: W.P. Publicover,
R.H. Stoddard, C.P. Bethune, Q.C., A.J. Yeadon, L.M. Romkey, G.F.
West, W.A.G. Snook, J.L. Leitch, V.W. Mitchell and Dr. A.R. Morton.
The meeting was called to proceed with business standing over
and ne transaction of other business.
The following named papers were submitted.
MINUTES
Moved Alderman Hatfield seconded by Alderman Lloyd that the
minutes of the previous meetings be approved. Motion passed.
PUBLIC HEARING RE: BUILDING LOTS GORSEBROOK
A Public Hear:::f1,7 for the purpose of considering the matter of
developing 18 building lots for single family dwellings on a proposed
street tIlrough a portion of the Gorsebrook grounds was held at this
time.
His Worship the Mayor: "There has been another public hearing
on this matter sponsored by the Community Planning Association of
which 4 Home and School Associations were invited and at least 6.
members of Council and I appeared at that meeting and listened to
the discussion that took place. I hope there need be no necessity
for extended remarks at this meeting tonight. We might have the
City Manager's report read".
--859-
November 12, 1954.
Alderman Vaughan: "It has been sent to the Aldermen".
cr vcil-ship the Mayor: "Ottawr bus said it is no longer
r:ttei in the acquisition of this land. I would like to go on
1 ..t if Ottawa has changed. its point of view neither the City
ri,J2 I have been advised to that effect. W.C. Godson has
said so far as the R.O.A.F. here is concerned, no such word has
Teen for-:;hcoming."
Alderman Lane arrives 8:10 P.M.
Reports were submitted from the City Manager dated October 7
and November 8, 1954 respectively concerning this subject. Copies
of the same were furnished the members of Council for their inform-
ation.
Mr. Gordon Black appeared in opposition to the land being sub-
divided and submitted a resolution duly passed at a public meeting
held et St. Francis School Auditorium on Wednesday, November 3,
1954 as follows:
COPY OF A RESOLUTION PASSED AT A PUBLIC MEETING HELD AT ST. FRANCIS SCHOOL AUDITORIUM ON WEDNESDAY THE 3RD DAY OF NOVEMBER A.D. 1954 RELATING TO THE PUBLIC HEARING TO BE HELD
AT CITY HALL ON FRIDAY THE 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER A.D. 1954 FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONSIDERING THE MATTER OF DEVELOPING 18 BUILDING LOTS FOR SINGLE FA!.1ILY DWELLINGS ON A PROPOSED STREET THROUGH A PORTION OF THE GORSEBROOK GROUNDS COMPRISING ABOUT
4 ACRES.
On Motion duly made and seconded, it was
resolved that this meeting is of opinion that the Gorsebrook area
be laintained as land zoned for park and institutional purposes.
It is further resolved that this meeting is
opposed to any further encroachment by the City, the Royal Canadian
Air. Force or any other person or body corporate on the Gorsebrook
property.
It is further resolved that the reasons for
opposing the said development attached to this Resolution and form-
ing part of it be forwarded to City Council ancl that they are hereby
approved as read.
- 860 -
November 12, 195k.
Alderman Dunlop: "At that meeting the discussion was mostly
on tyre question of recreation mostly to do with the
,';on 717.. area. There are 2 lots on Inglis Street which I
are in an entirely different position than the 16 lots. Are
those people opposed to the sale of the 2 lots fronting on Inglis
:;greet? I thinl they could be disposed of. Has Mr. Black any in-
formation cn those 2 lots?"
Mr. Black: "The 2 lots '.re part of the 18. As to the desire-
ability of selling those 2 lots; in the first place Mr. Donovan
Recreation Director, in his present plan, with respect to certain
playground materials, would be to put them just where those 2 lots
are. I don't know whether St. Francis School will be expanded in
that direction or not. Is the School so close so as to constitute
n hazard if you put houses there? That particular question was
not discussed at that meeting but I can point out that the meeting
was opposed to any further development of any part of t'e Gorsebrook
prperty. I think there are several good reasons for not selling
those particular lots. I must oppose even those 2 lots being sub-
divided nr.,1 sold. I am repr-senting those people and they strongly
feel %hat Gorsebrook rerlain in its present state".
Alderman Dunlop: "As far as I am ()were no report has come
o this Council nor the Recreation Commission from Mr. Donovan on
this. I tirIX before any City Official, et any City meeting should
express views on City property, the proper thing for him to do is
o . :?lce representations to us".
His WorWIlp the Mayor: "The City Manager's memo shows that at
last part of AuL-;,Ist y sny the reed a portion of that land".'
Aldernn DeWolf: "In 1949 the Council advertised those lots
th.,:ire were tenders on them rnd they were pbout to be
the .ion from thn area was so great the City
Colncil v and unnnimoualy that the land would.
hf0A for rerxention purposes".
- 861-
November 19, 1954.
1:15 Wor.ship the Mayor then asked if anyone were in favor of
,v.::Lvisi.on to which there was no reply.
Alaexnan Kitz, seconded by Alderman Ahern that the
for rezoning be rejected and the land remain zoned as
Park and Institutional and that the Recreation Commission produ
ce
some plans for the 'future development of the area.
kiderman Lloyd asked that the School Board inspect the back
yardof the Gorsebrook School.
The motion was put and passed.
PUBLIC HEARING Re: BUILDING LINE CUNARD AND WINDSOR STREETS
A Public Hearing into the matter of relocating the Building
Line at N:tlleast corner of Cunard and Windsor Streets as
shown on Plan RR-2-12849 for the purpose of extending the b.
lilding r
I nown at the Olympic Gardens, was held at this time.
Nobody appeared either for or against.
The followi resolution was then submitted:
WHEREAS the Committee on Works at a Meeting held on th
e
14th 611y of October, A.D., 1954, did recommend that the buil
ding
line at *L he Northea3t corner of Cunard and Windsor Streets be
altered,
P,ND ,JHEREAS pursuant to the provisions of Section 543A of
the Olt:: Charter public notice of t intention to titer t
he
1 111.111,, 7 1:17 at Vie 7:_least corner of und Cuncr:'_
T , y avert]sement inserted It lcts once a wee::
L r.) -ot,);s in a newspaper published in the City, the
htIvi!ig been published at least three clear
weeks before the 12th day of November, A.D. 1954, that bein
g the
day appointed by the City Council to .consider the matter
;
AND WHEREAS the said notice stated the intention of the
Council to alter the said building line at the Northeast corner of
Cunard rad WAnd!;or Streets, and the date of the meeting
of the
Council appointed for the consideration of the matter, and that
86, —
November 12, 1954.
plaa Wi-IoIng such alterations may be inspected at the office
tc? (.7 vioiler of. Works at any time during office hours up to
ra&Y apnonted for consideration of the matter;
AND WHEREAS the Council has considered the said matter and
'e;els!:1!_ned to alter the said building line in the manner set
on said pl.F.n filed in the Office of the Commissioner of Works
as No. 17;11.-2-1n49;
BE IT THEREFORE RESOLVED that pursuant to the authority in
it ve5terl by Section 543A of the City Charter as aforesaid, the
building line at the Northeast corner of Cunard and Windsor Streets
for approximately a distance of seventy-five (75) feet along the
north side of Cunard Street be altered in the manner and form as
shown on Plan No. RRA12849, on file in the Office of the Commissioner
of Works.
Movca Alderman Dunlop, seconded by Alderman Lloyd that the
resoluzlon as submitted be approved. Motion passed.
MOTION ALDERMAN AHERN Re: FAIRVIEW UNDERPASS
Alderman Ahern: "This matter was before the Committee on
Works and a lilan was submitted. I will withdraw that motion
because it would complicate the plan as presented at the Committee
on Works".
Alderman Ahern then withdrew his motion.
ACCOUNTS OVER $500.00
To: His Worship, R.A. Donahoe, Q.C., and Membrs of City Council.
From: City Manager, A.A. DeBard, Jr.,
Date: Nc,v,:!mber 9, 1954.
Subjec%: Acc;nts over $500.00
In a,:7.o.cdt- ce I. :1h Section 119F of the City Charter, the 1011w:tint; acr.ouns rare submitted for Council's approval. Theue acc7)w,ts have been certified and audited.
DEPART 4E':T
Finance & AccotiA
VENDOR
PURPOSE AMOUNT
Celltral Mortgage & Ho.xing
25% share of E::pend-itur-s on Federal- Provincial Project for i ending September 30, 1954 $4,251.62
- 363 -
.4
Various Departments
Mlght Directories Atlantic Ltd.
November 12, 1954.
City Directories 1,045.00
Finance Concrete Sewer Stores L.E. Shaw, Limited Pipe 700.20
Works Municipal Spraying & Crushed Run Contracting Ltd. Gravel 2,066.30
Works M. Van Waveren & Sons Narcissus & N.V. Tulip Bulbs 625.25
Works Walker & Hall Ltd. Joining Private Walks with Main Sidewalk on Romans Ave. & Federal Ave. 541.2
$9,'29.6
A.A. DeBard, Jr., City Manager.
Moved by Alderman Lane, seconded by Alderman DeWoif that the
report be approved. Motion passed.
CLAIM FORT MASSEY CHURCH $139.00
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of City Council.
From: Comittee on Works.
Date: October 25th, 1954.
Subject: Claim Re Boiler Flooding — Fort Massey Church.
At a meeting of the Committee on Works held on October 21st,
1954, a claim from Fort Massey Church, amolnting to $139.00, for
damage caused by the flooding of their boiler room, was considered.
The committee recommended that this claim be paid.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK
Per..J.B. Sabean, Clerk of Works.
Moved by Alderman Lane, seconded by Alderman DeWoif thEt the
report be apl,roved. Motion passed.
CLAIM MRS. E.F. BOUDREAU $179.45
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
From: Con-dttee on Works.
Dpte: October 25th, 1954.
Subject: Clain Re; Basenent Flooding— Mrs. E.F. Boudreau, 82 Queen Street.
- 864 - *
November 12, 1954.
At a meeting of the Committee on Works held on October 21st,
1954, the attached report from the City Solicitor relative to a lain; from Mrs. E.F. Boudreau, amounting to $179.45, for damage
-atte:30. by the backing up of a sewer into her basement apartment ,Y; #82 Queen Street, was considered.
The committee recommended that thfJ; claim be paid.
Alderman Dunlop against.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Per..J.B. Sabean, Clerk of Works.
Alderman Dunlop: "I feel that claim should not be paid.
That claim was not inspected nor appraised and in my opinion there
was no adequate investigation taken. Water backed up during a heavy
rain. I don't believe that apartment was constructed in compliance
with the Charter. I don't think an occupancy permit was issued.
There was not even an affidavit supporting the claim".
City Solicitor: "I believe we are liable for damages. The
amount of the damages I have discussed with the person and I took
their word for it. I would be quite satisfied that an affidavit
be obtairLed. Before the money is paid I can require the claimant
to swear to it. The place was flooded and it took some time after
for the City to find out what caused the flood. There was some delay
until we could find out what caused it. I was satisfied that there
was a liability on the City. I accepted the word of the claimant".
Alderman Lloyd: "You are satisfied as to the reasonableness
of the claim?"
City Solicitor: "Yes but I did not examine the goods them-
selves".
Moved by Alderman Ahern, seco-ided by Alderman Hatfield thrt
'11.e report be approved.
Alderman Macdonald felt that in future the City Officials
should take steps to see that an accurate inventory of damages is
taken when claims arise.
-865..
November 12, 1954.
City Manager: "I will take the responsibility for not having
1:een down to examine the goods".
The motion was put and passed with Alderman Dunlop wishing to
recorded against.
PROGRESS PAYMENT J.M. CLEMINSHAW & CO
Halifax, N:S., November 8, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
The Finance and Executive Committee at a meeting held on the above date agreed to recommend for payment an account of the J.M. Cleminshaw Company amounting to $14,280.00 for services rendered in connection with re-assessment.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Moved by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderman Lane that the
report be approved. Motion passed.
UNDERSIZED LOT #35 BEAUFORT AVENUE
To: His Worship the Mayrr and Members of City Council.
From: Town Planning Board.
Date: October 25th, 1954.
Subject: Lot 35 - Beaufort Avenue - Application to Build on Undersize Lot.
At a meeting of the Town Planning Board held on October 21str 1954, the attached report from the Town Planning Engineer in regard to an application from Mr. B.B. Beaumont and F.J. Bruhm for per-mission to erect a single family dwelling on Lot 35 - Beaufort Avenue, was considered.
The Board recommended that the application be not granted.
Alderman Ahern against.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Per.. J.B. Sabean, Clerk of Works.
Moved. by Alderman Dunlop, seconded by Alderman Lloyd that
the report be approved. Motion passed.
- 866 -
November 12, 1954.
UNDERSIZED LOT 88 MORRIS STREET
o: His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
Town Planning Engineer.
November 8th. , 1954.
Subject: Request to build an Eight Apartment Unit on an Undersize Lot at 83 Morris Street.
The Town Planning Board, at a meeting held on November 4th., c -fIsidered the at Lacheci 3 ,,r:)ort fror. the Town Planning Engineer relativ to a request from R.W. Ferguson for permission to erect an eight bachelor apartment unit on an undersize lot at 88 Morris Street.
The Board recommended that the request be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Per..J.B. Sabean, Clerk of Works.
City Manager: "The Greek Church is objecting to the side
yard on their side being cut from 10 feet to 3 feet". Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Moriarty that
the matter be referred back to the Town Planning Board for further
consideration and report. Motion passed.
HOUSING AUTHORITY OF HALIFAX
City Manager: "We had a discussion of this subject about
raising the rental ceiling at the Finance and Executive Committee.
Mr. Haley saiCL there was nothing pressing on this. I think it
needs quite a bit of study."
His Worship the Mayor: "I thought we voted against increas—
ing the ceiling. The discussion arose in the Finance and Executive
Committee because previously there was no opportunity for the
Housing Authority to express its views. I considered it in the
nature of an information session.
Alderman Lloyd: "It was pointed out that there were some
meet ings being held by the Tenants' Association and repn,,;entations
could be made to Council by the Tenants."
-867-
November 12, 19540
Alderman Ahern "In the paper very serious charges were made
..tis that meeting. We should ask the Housing Authority to take note
those charges at that meeting".
Alderman Vaughan: "I attended the meeting in Westmount School
and I think that many of the matters arising out of that meeting
will be ironed out by the Authority. I think we might wait until
the Tenants' Association have had an opportunity to meet with the
Authority,"
His Worship the Mayor: "If we get representations from the
Tenants' Association channelled through the Authority there will
be a public hearing on it".
Alderman Kitz felt if there were a representative present from
the Tenants' Association, he could be heard.
Alderman Hatfield: "The Authority should be present here".
Alderman Lanes "We are only one governing body in this
episode. It should be emphasized that we are the smaller partner
in the deal. Why we are being held 100% responsible by the tenants
is what is puzzling me".
Mr. Earl Hamlin of the Bayers Road Project was present and was
asked by His Worship the MAyor if he were present at the request of
the Association to express any opinion to which he replied in the
negative.
His Worship the Mayor stated that if there were to be any
hearing and the Authority criticized for its conduct it should be
present when the hearing was held.
Mr. Hamlin said he felt the Association should meet with the
Authority.
His Worship the Mayor: "After you have discussed the matter
with the Authority and if there are representations you wish to
make, we will arrange an opportunity and at that meeting the other
partners can be present."
— 868 —
November 12, 1954.
Mr. Smith: "The Housing Authority is being run by one member
of the Board".
The suggestion of Rig Worship the Mayor was then approved.
SEWER EXTENSION OXFORD & MAXWELL STREETS
November 8, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
At a meeting of the Finance and Executive Committee held on the
above date, a report from the Committee on Works recommending sewer
extensions for Lot #6-8 Claremont Subdivision Oxford Street and Lot
#4 on Maxwell Street, at an estimated cost of $16,000.00.
A report was also submitted from the City Manager recommending
against this extension until there is an offer for substantial
assistance from those who benefit most.
It was decided to recommend that the extensions be made and an
opinion obtained from the Pliblic Servioe Commission, as to whether
they can co-operate with the City in extending the water.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Alderman Dunlop: "If the Public)* Service Commission are pre-
pared to put the water in the same time as the sewer, I will with
draw my objection".
Mr. West: "The Manager stated he did not think the
Commission would put water in there this year. We have no official
word on that"
City Manager: "The report was that they Would not put water
in this year. The street will have to be built up and after
settlement, because of the fill, the Public Service Commission will
be prepared to put the water in".
Mr. West: "It is not feasible from an engineering point of
view to put the water in. It has to be filled to a certain height.
It has to settle to a certain degree. The Public Service Commission
would not recommend it and neither would we. I don't think it
would be wise to put the sewer in without the water. The sewer
and water has to go hand in hand."
—869—
November 12, 1954.
Alderman Lloyd.: " Suppose we delay the sewer and, wait till
;text year, we will have the same problem all over. You have to
bers211 somewhere."
City Managers "Mr. Ma.cnab said. he would be against putting
the water in this year".
Alderman Ahern: "If Mr. Macnab is not going to co-operate
the City Solicitor should be instructed to appear before the Public
Utility Board and find out why".
Alderman Kitz: "They will.lay a line if it will pay its way.
I suggest the Manager apply formally to the Public Service Commission
to obtain a view for the next meeting".
Alderman Lloyd: "It should be explained to the Commission
we find ourselves in an awkward position and we should. proceed with
the sewer".
His Worship the Mayor: "The Commission has not had an
opportunity to meet on it as yet."
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Kitz that the
matter be referred back to the Committee on Works for investigation
and report back to Council. Motion passed.
CITY MANAGER08 VACATION
To: His Worship 2. R.A. Donahoe, Q.C. , and Members of City Council.
From: City Manager, A.A. DeBard, Jr.,
Date: October 25, 1954.
Subject: City Managergs Vacation.
Approximately one-half of my vacation was taken in May. With
Councils permission, I would like to take the rest of it from
December 6, 1954 -. December 15, 1954.
A.A. DeBard, Jr., City Manager
Moved by Alderman Lane, seconded by Alderman Lloyd that the
report be approved. Motion passed.
8?0 ti
November 12, 1934.
gIIKIDIsgq911MT,10
Kak'Aonaidg "I understand there has been an invitation
MilaagelL F,o attend a eonvention in St, Petersburg, Florida.
know whether the dates of his vacation coincide with the
.cnvc.tion but I think would be of great value to the City to
have him attend this convention%
City Manaift-:L° :-oing to go anyway. I would naturally
,y4.efer to go as delegate from the City rather than on my own.
Every City should co-operate in the work of an Association."
Moved by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderman Macdonald that
a sum not exceeding $400.00 be granted the City Manager for the
purpose of attending the City Manager's Convention in St. Petersburg,
Florida as a delegate of the City of Halifax.
Alderman Kitzg "I think we have to make a stand sometime on
conventions. I think we should have a policy whereby our senior
personnel do not go each year to conventions. I don't think in-
dustry generally, when they have a policy, permit annual conventions.
The Manager went to a convention one year ago. We paid for the
`tanager to go to Windsor. To pay for a trip to St. Petersburg a
few months later, I feel I cannot agree with. Let it not rebound
agaiest the policy that we have been trying to build up".
Alderman Dunlopg He wen to Windsor at the renuest of Council
and not on hi6 ow r&q‘lest. I think he would gain much more if he
attended his own body".
Alderman Lloyds 3In view of the fact that he is going to take
the time on his ho14 lays, I feel it is fair to make a contributioa
towards his expeneeEL'.
The City Mana&-x stpted that he had become acquainted with the
qlffcrent Mayors wh;.le at the Mayors' Convention but he speoifiaally
referred to some rc:/-son to help the delegates with resolutions. He
laid that poss1bly r,oxt year tne City Clerk of City Solicitor might
1,1.,?1, to Licrecri e rf,dolutiung to ascertain which ones would
L to C; t er
F;71
November 12, 1954„
Trit xction was put and passed with Alderman Kitz wishing to be
LArTs)._ ,-E.,„ficqoupT
1115 Worshtp R.A. Donahoe, Q.0. 0 and nembE:ra of City Council. City Manager. A.A. DeBard, Jr.,
October 1954.
Land 5a16 Ar;count.
At Cle May, 175L' Council meeting Alderman DeWoif raised certain
veatLons concerning responsibility fcr the Land Sale Account. An
analysis has been prepaeea and City Council at its September 16
meeting ai,proved of certain Journal entries segregating the various
elements of the proceeds.
The general responsibility as a matter of administration should
be in the hands of the City Manager. Only one receipt from the sale
of land has occurred since the last report. This is the proceeds of
the sale of 80 Market :;treet. I have prepared a schedule of the
various credits due accounts for this tax sale land. The balance of
the proceeds will be a credit to the land sale account. After the
pattern is set for a few transactions, I will expect the Finance
Department to handle these as a matter of routine.
The City Manager should also havea responsibility for use of
Land Sale Account proceeds. There has been a tendency to use the
Land Sale Account_ when r funds are not available. The fact that
a propose& expenditure is ZL capital one is not justification for use
of the Land Sale Account. I refer specifically to the $60000.00
ucIed to purchase library books and $2,0000.00 for lights for the
Wanderers' field,
Nothing goes into the Land Sale Account but the proceeds from
land sales and nothlng should come out unless it is being used to
acquire land, A.A. DeBard, Jr., City Manager.
The City Manager advised that this report was in answer to a
request from Alderman DeWolf respecting the responsibility of the
Ae,..!ount. He pointed out he would have a responsibility for making
recomnondations with regard to the use of the Account.
He felt that since nothing went into the Account except money
from the sale of land nothing should go out of it unless it were to
acquire land.
Moved by Alder:ran Lloyd seconded by Alderman Vaughan that
she report be approved. Motion passed.
November 129 1954.
'yAJaviEw CEMETERY LAND BETWEEN ST. ANDREWS SCHOOL
& BAYERS ROAD
Al6erman VauFkang 'Gould we discuss the land front
ing on
Grim2tery bctwoon St, Andrews School and Mayers Road
. The
'.1(- 031 Board was most anxious to have that developed.
Mr. Snook
prepared a plan and he sent a copy to me and filed
a copy with the
manager. The Board wants to put a wire fence aroun
d the burial
p1.c,t3. I expr6sba t't-16 hope that the Land Sale Account
would be
available for the improvements. I felt this would
be a good time
to Introduce the matter. The principle amount invo
lved is for the
fence around the burial plots".
Moved by Alderman Vaughan r seconded by Alderman Ahern that
the City Manager pro3eso this matter and secure an
estimate of the
cost from the Engineering Department and report ba
nk at the next
meeting of Council with the suggestion that the fu
nds be secured
from the Land Sale Account. Motion passed.
SUPERANNUATION
November 8n 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and
Members of the City Council.
The Finance and Executive Committee at a meeting h
eld on the
above date concurred in the attached report under
date of October
29, 1954 respecting Superannuation.
Respectfully submittedr
W.P..Publicover, CITY CLERK.
To: His Worship. R.A. Donahoe, Q.C., and
Members of City Council.
From: City Manager,. A.A. DeEard, Jr.,
Date: October 29r 1954.
Subject: Superannuation.
The cub—G=mit*Lee appointed to consider the matter
of a request
from Mrs. Ella Hoganson, Widow of the late G.P. Ho
ganson for an
annual nflowrnce met on the above date and. agreed t
o make the
following ree,ommandatins.
J. That ,inelc:r th authority of legislat
ion obtained at the
last neasion of she Legislature, Mrs. Hoganson be
paid at the
rate of $e4f%.50 annually being 50% of $1,699.00, th
e sum her
late huebroid wafi receiving from the Flremens Super
annuation
Fund at the tIme of his death.
37) .16
November 12, 1954.
That W. M. Mercer Ltd. be engaged to appraise the operation
of the, uperunru fund and confer with us on the matter of c-vriapping of benefits.
Alderman John E. Lloyd,
Alderman Charles A. Vaughan.
Alderman Vaughan: "They are the logical persons to examine
the plan now".
106 Worship the Mayor: "It was understood that when a 5 year
period had elapsed they were to make a re—appraisal of it".
Alderman Vaughan: "This is the proper time to do it and they
are the proper people to examine it".
Alderman Ahern: "At what cost?".
His Worship the Mayor: "If it is over $500.00 it will be
brought before this Council for approval."
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Vaughan that
the report be approved but before the firm of Wm. Mercer Ltd. is
engaged, the City Manager inquire from them their rates, terms and
conditions.- Motion passed.
PROVINCIAL GRANT—SCHOOL BUILDINGS
To: His Worship, R.A. Donahoe, QbOop and Members of City Council.
From: City Manager, A.A. DeBard, Jr.,
Date: October 29, 1954.
Subject: Provincial Grant — School Buildings.
When His Worship and a special Council committee waited upon
the Provincial Government they were informed the government
had in mind a special school grant to the cities of Halifax
and Sydney to reimburse them in part for considerable expend—
itures which happended to fall in a period when no funds were
available for assistance. The sum of $500,000 was mentioned
for Halifax.
At a subsequent meeting with Mr. Fielding, he indicated the
nature of the Information desired and the following will be
sent to him. It is presented to Council to see if they have
any ideas to be added.
Dear Mr. Minister:
Attached is a tabulation of the $7,4,5,342.44 spent by the City
of Halifax on ochools from April 14, 1949 to September 1. 1954
and a forecast of further expenditures beyond that date (Table
I).
874 —
November 12, 1954.
The amount of $4569,785.04 was further analyzed in Table II
[,pi,11%tln the amount for junior and senior high school
c,trootion.
there 12 any further information you require, we will be
-5.ppy- to furniah A.t;
Very truly yours,
A.A. DeBard, Jr., City Manager.
Moved by Alderman Lloyd„ seconded by Alderman Lane that the
report be approved. Motion passed.
REPORT TB. HOSPITALIZATION ACROSS CANADA
November 3, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
At a meeting of the Public Health and Welfare Committee held
on the above date it was agreed to recommend that copies of the
attached report respecting Tuberculosis Treatment be forwarded to
the Premier of Nova Scotia and the Minister of Health.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Moved by Alderman DeWolf r seconded by Alderman Kitz that the
report be approved Mot:on passed.
ROOF BEDFORD ROW FIRE STATION
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
From: Committee on Works.
Date: Novembe:' 8th. 1954.
Subject: Bedford Row Fire Station - Roof.
The Committee on Works at a meeting held on November 4thor
considered the attached report from the City Manager recommend-
ing acceptance of Nova Scotia Waterproofers bid of $2986.00
for repairing the roof of Bedford Row Fire Station.
The Committee app-r,ved same.
Respectfully submittedr
W.P. Publicoverr CITY CLERK.
Per..J.B. Babeanr Clerk of Works.
4
- 875 -
November 12, 1954.
I", MEAgep :,tated thp_t after the contract had been
oy te C.W1 or, Ig:5 Inothor contractor had approached
the ;v- r!,
than rGcc,mm-n1 t- Ci)uri3i1 tat the roof be not proceeded
with at this t1:- ;7, od 1112Lt the two conractors who had been interested
in this rAtter be reonted to give an estimate on what it would
to i.1 t, the uk.li;'!t: anl sloping roof over the stairway.
'nonttoned fig,..:{-6 of $200.00 from Jas. Donohue Ltd.
He r,3cc,:lm:,,ndea the temporary repairs for the winter and in the
spring compiet€ speoifieations for the roof would be drawn up.
Alderman DeWolf "Is it not true that some official ordered
tills work be done7
Mr. West 'The contrac;tur was told by someone other than
myaelf butt he was toir-1 before the materials were processed through
the surpliers I explained the situations to him and asked if he
would mind his orders".
14oved by Alderman Lloyd seconded by Alderman O'Malley that
the City Managers -feconaendation be approved.
Alderman Dunlop "I was assured the N.S. Waterprnofers were
a competent firm and able to complete the job. We were informed
at no tenders were received from anyone else. Something must be
wrong wi.sn at this stage the City says the specifications are not
r,.o%iplete. I don( t t1:111 it j.s fair to the man. We are now told
that a temporary job will last for the winter pending complete
specifications. I understood the specifications covered copper
roofing".
His Worship the Mayor! "what was wrong with our specifications?"
Aide' man Dunic.p' "I think this man who put his tender in was
the Lowebt of all Lenders received. If the Manager slipped LIT), I
t'Ank it is .!y fail* tr: have the tenders reopened rain".
876 --
November 12, 1954.
City Managorg "I was informed that when the bids were brought
me GhiLla on(1 ;:f the tenderers did not tender on the whole job.
ai:kri If the cempleta specifications of the successful bidder had
beer, submitted to the other firms. I find it was never sub-
mitted to them beoause the bidder could not submit that because his
price was on it.
The roof needs to be done. If this were July we would be
taking complete tenders to have the whole job done".
Alderman Dmiorg Wasnot it known that we were in the winter
months. At the Committee on Works you and your Department were
willing to proceed %.71t% the roof".
City Managerg "me other tenderer did not get a fair chance
to bid on this job. I wsnt our own engineers to draw up our
specifications and not specifications lifted from a particular
tenderer and made to apply to another tenderer".
Alderman Dunlop "I am confused about this matter more than
ever. I find now we have no specifications".
City Manager "One tenderer did not have the same specific-
ations as the other."
The motion was then put and passed.
FAIRVIEW CEMETERY ORDINANCE & CHARGES
November 8, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
A report from the City Manager respecting "Fairview Cemetery -
Ordinance & Charges" was considered by the Finance and Executive
Committee at a meeting held on the above date.
It was decided to recommend that a committee consisting of
Aldermen Lloyd. MacMillan and Dunlop be appointed to confer with
representatives of the Ministerial Association on this matter and
report to Counclio
Respectfully submitted,
W.P.1PUblicover, CITY CLERK.
- 877-
November 12, 1954.
14oved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Lane that the
"T) -'„ t)e approved. Motion passed.
TION CITY OF WINDSOR., ONTARIO Reo FOOD COMMODITIES
November 8, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
A resolution adopted by the City of Windsor, Ontario, respect-
ing the disposition of food commodities held in storage by the Federal Government, was read at a meeting of the Finance and Executive Committee held on the above date.
It was decided to recommend that the resolution be filed.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P..Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Moved by Alderman DeWolf, seconded by Alderman Vaughan that
the report be approved. Motion passed.
RETIREMENT MR. ROSS HALL
November 8, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
At a meeting of the Finance and Executive Committee held on
the above date, a report was submitted from the Retirement Committee
advising that Mr. John Ross Hall had been retired effective as from
December 31, 1954 at an annual allowance of $813.83.
It was decided to recommend that legislation be obtained at
the next session of the Legislature, enabling the City to pay Mr. John Ross Hall an annual allowance of $386.17 in addition to the
amount he is entitled to receive from the Superannuation Plan.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Lane that
report be approved. Motion passed.
TENDERS GROUP LIFE INSURANCE
November 8, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Co'incil.
The Finance and Executive above date, decided to forward Manager respecting "Group Life recommendation.
Committee at a meeting held on the the attached report from the City Insurance" to City Council without
- 878 -
the
November 12, 1954.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicovern CITY -CLERK.
His Worship, R.A. Donahoe, Q.C., and Members of City Council.
Fromt City Manager, A.A. DeBard, Jr.n
Dated November 8, 1954.
Subjects Group Life Insurance.
In order to further assist City Council with information and
to enable further study each company was requested to give the
figures for the volume for the City of Halifax policy
02,362,500), death loss of 65% of the annual premium for 10
years past, and 10 years in the future.
The purpose of these questions was to get the reverse side of
the retention figures given.
8 companies submitted figures for both periods, 3 other
companies submitted figures for the 10 years in the future,
and 1 for 5 years in the future. 2 companies were unable to
submit figures.
These companies have their figures analyzed below.
Standard Life Assurance Company of Edinburgh, Scotland operates
on a different basis than the other companies. The premiums
are considerably higher than other companies, but they are
guaranteed for five years regardless of the size of death
claims. They could not submit figures for the past ten years
because accounts are not separated into different classes of
business.
The Metropolitan Life Insurance did not furnish figures for
the lest ten years based on the 195 4divIlend formula. Great-West Life Assurance Company also submitted fig
ures for the
next ten years only.
The Prudential Insurance Company of America did not answer the
questions, but did give the experience of a company writing a
policy in 1943 in which the avers e amount was $2,4840180 and
the avera e death claim 64.2 . The average net annual premium
was s 32,090.00 which would not be the same kind of an average
as the other averages given in the table.
The Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada did not supply in-
formation requested, but did have information ln certain
years, but it would be impossible to compare it with the other
companies without making certain assumptions.
Conm1dering the eight companies who submitted figures for the
two ten-year periods, I have the following comments to make.
Confederation Life submitted an identical figure for all twenty
years and based this figure on death claims of 54% of the annual
premium. I feel this is an unrealistic figure and cannot
i_tnderstand how they would arrive at such a figure.
- 879
November 12, 1954.
His Worship, R.A. Donahoe Members of City Council. City Manager, A.A. DeBard From
Dates November 8, 1954.
Subjects Group Life Insurance.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY 'CLERK.
Q.C., and
„ Jr.,
In order to further assist City Council with information and
to enable further study each company was requested to give the
figures for the volume for the City of Halifax policy
($2s362,500)v death loss of 65% of the annual premium for 10
years past, and 10 years in the future.
The purpose of these questions was to get the reverse side of
the retention figures given.
8 companies submitted figures for both periods, 3 other
companies submitted figures for the 10 years in the future,
and 1 for 5 years in the future. 2 companies were unable to
submit figures.
Thew) companies have their figures analyzed below.
Standard Life Assurance Company of Edinburgh, Scotland operates
on a different basis than the other companies. The premiums
are considerably higher than other companies, but they are
guaranteed for five years regardless of the size of death
claims. They could not submit figures for the past ten years
because accounts are not separated into different classes of
business.
The Metropolitan Life Insurance did not furnish figures for
the lest ten years based on the 1954 dividend formula, Great-
West Life Assurance Company also submitted figures for the
next ten years only.
The Prudential Insurance Company of America did not answer the
questions, but did give the experience of a company writing a
policy in 1943 in which the average amount was $2,484,180 and
the avers e death claim 64.2%. The average net annual premium
WO8 ‘32,090.00 which would not be the same kind of an average
as the other averages given in the table.
The Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada did not supply in-
formation renuested, but did have information In certain
years, but it ::ould be impossible to compare it with the other
companies without making certain assumptions.
Cons!dering theeight companies who submitted figures for the
two ten-year periods, I have the following comments to make.
Confed€ration Life submitted an identical figure for all twenty
years and based this figure on death claims of 54% of the annual
premium. I feel this is an unrealistic figure and cannot
'ten' erstand how they would arrive at such a figure.
- 879 -
-.!.9540
.i A.6,...ccicall Company t:lo 'r. -1 :p 0..nnual
- 1 --. 1.n,!: l',-..:itl 3:3,0/00 .- !:, 1::, '. -,- ,” 000 16 19630
'•1,1 ,.' - 1:110 t:61.; y t'; 0. r;i: , • •- „. ‘,:-?'.:;.240 drops
. :'. -:.1.0? ;:--;(.1.,'ond. t•e!.. J. ei.,•:;: 6 .t3" i. dc, not
`1,..,,id Lv.-.r nremlum f!.1r 1953 -c•f: 40-760 tc,,-; the first
I.-% 'r..-: :'22,3'.6,00 f..-. 1' 1'..4 _ Lhe. (2,.2 ,:,nd gl'ollp when
1._2_ ,.: .,i hici.h aniC,a2., - ::at..fc,„:, a polle:y,,
N..... -i-.1..:,aa Lle. AssurAnf. Cf.. i-::..., til. a r,o/Aue,;. pattern for
fl.i, t .' 1:1 :: perlod, and the di,iNt."7 pi eatfor every one
c.4 *Ow ;t5.,: 10 yoare. In udditi6n, the 1933 premium is larger
ti-lrY-:: tri -, -:9.:A in anal premium ft r' the Eleoond ten years°
aocir-wnt. on TV:,
rema'a-ling premium,
fina no objeottkc
l'ender wlth a
.onaliitent for the r,hot.
By of elimination ht, navrws down to
Lni-lAor% i Canada Life ) Luso.. Imperial Life
nnd C.:f .42-: Life,
1.1 ;:r1panteil have given all ir ae.ked for
e*Yep:- that Manufacturers the pilt 10 yenrs.
1 :%all .ivhy C:: 1- ,ct i 114:,har average
kor t tc;n—yeer period thu firco,
are ultrR-cc:-.i/J1 -;,. 0
;If'e :w;%'L; for the
1))011 ,i have 11 ,A ic.mIt for the
p41.oe., and rank third for the
I would re„-,oifil,fi of t he tr tender°
adlitional fiL;nr:lo 0: 0,2.1,Tf ;It1E-3 1,:,tated
-1mittA- „:7:.culd .f,. tt::T fr ,-4e, for the
c.omparini; ti arJual
r t c . 'AiA. AA ,.
6.anmitted a fa )0:A: ii it , . t,:3ndero
,1) I. ak:. 12.y.
the retention for
ten-year period,
#:
-:: ;DT
1);: tr
R.A. rionahc C i ty Council
A DeD%IrrL
;..
• c2r,
',Icror" 1.1tAlt:f Aor,ur,,nce Co„ tt
:!1;tErA1.1 t%-c)ra the
i.1,1-44cently
c 01. North eome opinions Inauranoe
-
November 12, 1954.
is The North American Life figures I used for the period
1.954 - 1937 were intended to show the premiums for the 11th
to 20th years for a policy written in 1944. This information
eaa not asked for and would have been additional information
had the North American given the into-rmaticn in the form
asked. Because they did not, I misinterpreted what they did
give in their letter.
In their original proposal, the North American did not indi-
cate the volume of the policy. In their letter of October
5v 1954 they revealed for the first time they had used a
volume of- $2 v 555v000.00 for the insurance in force. In a
revision they sent me dated November 9, 1.954 they used a volume
of t2,362,500.00. The figures follow-
1944- $22v800.00 1954 $22,800.00
1945 229800.00 1955 22,800.00
.1946- 1956
1953 179168.00 each yr. 1963 17,168.00 each yr.
Avg. 18,294.40 Avg. 18, 294.40
By using the same figures for the two ten -year periods, the
North American Life Assurance Company are saying that returns
on investments and expenses are the same for both periods, and
I find that hard to believe.
2. Metntepqi.ten Ltfe Insurance Comeeev.
Mr. D.C.1, Buell wrote Mr. Maedonield, Manager of the Halifax
office saying, We were asked to assume that over this ten-
year period the same number of lives were insured as are
currently employed, that there was a leeel ethim rate and no
change in the benefits during thts period. We did not make
this calculation since we feel the assumptioas are unrealistic,
and furthermore sueh a calculation mightbe misleading".
Mr. Buell. a vice-president, points out t,:eir dividend formula
is changed twice a year and that war conditions affected the
last ten-year period Including war risk on employees continued
in groups while in service.
*Later on he says. "Past performance in its Group Division as
a whole and as shown in published statements we think is the
best indication as to what comptny may be expected to provide
Group Insurance at the lowest cost".
The Metropolitan Life Insurance Oompany, in a separate brief,
is pointing out that an assumption of 65% of annual premlum
works aeainst the company with high grose premiums. This is
a point I did not realize since I did hot think the variation
in gross premium would be so great. The high gross premium
results in such a company have the nee of the policyholderts
money fe); a time, and some measure of interest cost might be
asseused egainet that company.
3. 1 am under the impression that Amer erg end Canadian
ccmpanles de not uee the name experience teblee and this may
account fel• the higLer piemiume of tit- Prudential Insurance
Company of An and Metropolitan Life Insurance Company.
-563
November 12, 1954.
4. May 1 also explain that a company le "penalized" by not
questionG k{ d only .L nle !T.:nc% that a com-
OZIASOn between. the a.tual experiene of 1711,. past ten years
!ftnnof be thir forecast for ti next ien years.
A.A. DeBardr Jr,,, City Managet.
The C;'-Lty Manager briefly went over the stepe leading up to
the present; time and stated that the thing the Clt7 was primarily
interested In wao figGre. He [.,7t1:1 most ..:ompanies
could tell him what the past had been If they not, tell what
their future costs would be. By an examination of the figures he
would arrive at some kind of a pattern between the same companies
for the same period. He felt the past would be some indication
of the future.
Alderman Lloyd. By going back you had a basis for forecasting
the future. If we selet an insuranr:e company this year It is
most unwise for ue to :Mange another year and p.nother year because
the acquisition costs would run our net costs up to a very high
degree It is practical for us to say, t'A.ft. whoever is selected
will be continued for many years to come. The past 10 years was
an indication as to whether or not the first year s premium is
conservative. By the firet 10 years costs, you have some in-
dication of the future costEj.
Alderman Kitz. o "Did you arbitrarily tal a :55 year claim
rateV1
City Manager cr lr.L talkAng TO varlous ':orT:pnies they in-
dicated to me that the losses ran to C) or perent of the
premium. The c:ost is going to he appr'_,Iim!itely t,11 SPMfE: and no-
body can tell you what tre 16 Fcinir tr. t'e",
Alderman Lan e2 In (.1.-- mmlttee the ot),or :say I
made a state-
ment with whl3h you did ,:.0T au.ee and the City Manager was
not
inclined to be happy. do have an e.xpro:;ion of opinion regard-
ing certain elements 3f the queGtIonnfilre.
-
November 1.2 l9514
i-, Iderman Lane then read tw., paragraphs from a letter from the
Mhnager S40 L,.-ILL Assurance Company addressed to the
(7anyiii Manager here aa follows
In the first -ulace, whoever recommended the questionnaire and
set it up undoubtedly did sc, with the definite purpose in mind of
adding not only aci element of confusion bus: of ereating impressions
which are not only meanin4Ieos but far—fetc.hed to say the le-ast.
The purpose of the estimator is readily obvious and the results are
totally misleading to the uninitiated.
Our eempany never hae and I hope never will operate on the
retention basis, The inequities and iniquities of such a practise
have been clearly demonstrated even to the point where this system
is not countenanced in the States on account of the many inherent
abuses the t are involved. As a matter offast the practise of
operating on a retention basis proved so vieious that a movement
is on foot in the United States to legally abolish this type of
underwriting. Unfortunately some of the Ameriean companies operat—
ing in Canada have adopted similar tactiee and a few Canadian
companies are following suit so it may take a little time for the
Canadian authorities to oatch up with the situation and rectify
it.
Alderman Laee "Are you prepared to a:cept a motion or do
you want the recommendation of the City Manager put first?
Moved by Alderman Lane. seconded by Alderman Allen that the
Group Life Insurance policy for the employees of the City of Halifax
be split 4 ways between the Canada Lifer Sul: Life Metropolitan
Life and Maritime Life assoeiated with the London L1fe.
Alderman Lloyd auggested that any company whose representative
is here and who wlshee to critieize our procedure be now invited
to do so t,
City Mar:agr:; Whcever diEect question& had done so
to confuse, is net so. AL; a laywan I was approaching the problem
in the best manner I eolld.r
His Worship thr:- Mayor ne ma::r:ty of quJetiona asked were
arrived at after a ,J:11f€,r6r:(2c, In adl ccapanies here."
Alderma.c, Lar.e "No c: mpany is 6oln:; benefit. I feel
this has expresecd fee:Ung on retention. I agree with Alder—
man Lloyd we should hear wiiet comTan 1. feel about it."
Alderman Vaughan' "On a :.:atter like thie te a perf;on not
qualified to am ;(. :r Lo put myeelf completely in the
hands of the City •Manor i.:c,2pt hie eeeommendatien without
fear or CrILIlem, 1.1
November 12, 1954.
Alderman Dunlepg When the matter was referred to the
*tlanager he ee.td he was not an, insurance expert. Persons expert
in 1:h. is field should be engaged was the thought expressed at that
t:Loie He was asked to tabulate ce..-itain figures and to recommend".
Alderman DeWolf 8Have we any ol:ficial indication that 4
companies are willing to divide the business?"
Alderman Lane "I have no assurance of that. In my opinion
it is a fair amount of business divided 4 ways and I think they
would be quite content.4
Alderman DeWolft "I would like to give it to them all. We
do that with fire and automobile insurance. Why not divide it
amongst 14. I would like to find out if it is acceptable to have
it divided by 4 or 14."
It was then agreed to hear the representatives of the various
companies.
Mr. D.O. Robertson, Manager of the North American Life
Insurance Company., stated that in his Company's submission the
figure of $19,695.98 should have been $18,294.40 which was the
lowest of any Company. Also the figure 80 cents as the basic
rate per $1,000.00. "Had the City Manager that statement before
him at the last meeting of the Finance and Executive Committee,
he would have been in a position: to show that the North American
Life Company was first in all departments. Alderman Lane seems
to be more interested with the feelings of the Insurance Companies
than with the taxpayers. In our letter of October 5th. to the
Manager, we stated not only what the cost would be for the first
and second year but we also gave him the average of the first 10
years which worked out to be $18,294.40 and we went beyond that.
Because we gave additional information, we were criticized. North
American Life is capable of handling it themselves. If you want
to bring in another company we would not mind that but beyond that
we are not interested. If you want to put in another company, it
would be okay providing they accept our rates".
884
November 12, 1954.
Alderman Lloyd nThe Sun Life envisaged a contract nailing
1.0wn 3-.,%4,,es Does the Crown Life representative now say that 90%
of ;11(3 companies agree to that?
Mr. Barber "No. It you itsk them for a retention, none of
them can be guaranteed.4
Mr. Cavanagh, Metr politan Life "1 think Mr. DeBard will
agree that the figures recently prepared are very misleading not
as a direct result of anything Mr. DeBard intended. The same
claim rnte is going to apply no matter what Company gets this
business. I would say all these figures are entirely meaningless.
The net cost of this to the City is based on 3 things.
1. The amount of claims paid out.
2. What the Company is going to hold back for its expenses
3. What the Company is going to set aside for reserves."
Alderman Lloyd° Yost contend that the indication of what
is to be known in the future can best be determined from the
retention in the last 10 years?E
Mr. Cavanagh: "Yes".
Alderman Lane: "This motion was to bring it to a head. I
have been accused of having a particular interest in these 4
companies. That statement was made by a man on the floor of this
chamber".
Alderman Lloyd: "We should give some consideration to the
fact that the City Manager did try to get at the best cost of
insurance and how many comprnies should be in on it is a matter
for Council to decide. m
Mr. Maclntyre of Maritime and London Life: "I think Mr.
DeBard's questions were exsellent. I would suggest that the
average retention for all cnmprnies in the group life business
in the last 10 years is not the most important factor".
November 120 1954.
Alderman Lloyd: "Would your rate be the same with or with-
out the Maritime Life?"
Mr. Maclntyre: "The same. The rates are those of the London
LIfo. The rates in the submission from Maritime and London Life
are London Life rates. The risk will be divided equally. °B
Alderman Lloyd: "If any 3 companies were joined with Maritime
Life what effect would that have on the cost?"
Mr. Maclntyre: "I don't think that would have any real effect
on the cost. One would be chosen as the administering company and
their rates would be used."
Alderman Ahprn: "I would like to see Maritime Life get in
there some way. I want to support home industry."
Mr. Maclntyre: "As far as associating with Crown Life and
any other Company, London Life would have no objection in teaming
up with any one shown."
Alderman Lloyd: "It seems some further study of retention
rates for the past years seems to be the course we should follow.
Some committee could be appointed to consider the merits of these
matters and there is a local company involved."
Moved in amendment by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman
Ahern that the Finance and Executive Committee give further
consideration, in the light of this discussion p to the submissions
and recommendations of the City Manager and also give consideration
to the suggestion made by Alderman Lane and recommend to the City
Council at its next regular meeting what Company or group of
Companies should be entrusted with the group life insurance
underwritings for the City of Halifax. Amendment passed.
Alderman Kitz retires 10:40 P.M.
BOXING DAY DECEMBER 1954
The matter of deciding whether Monday December 27, 1954 would
be observed as Boxing Day and declared a public holiday was
considered.
- 886 -
November 12, 1954.
Moved by Alderman Ahern, seconded by Alderman Lane that
f.ay. December 26, 1954 falling on Sunday, Monday December
:7!„ be declared as a public holiday.
His Worship the Mayor stated that Council should decide to
either confine the holiday to City Hall or the general public.
Moved in amendment by Alderman Dunlop, seconded by Alderman
01 14,a1ley that the City Offices be closed on Monday, December 27,
1954.
Ald,3rman OcMalley: "I don't think we should rule for all
businesses and organizations in the Cl.ty."
Alderman Delfolf: "Has the Mayor ever declared a holiday in
the past? I understand it is not a public holiday unless he
declares it. It has to be declared."
Alderman Vaughan: "Is there a question of cost as far as
the amendment is concerned?"
City Manager: "If we had a snow storm. If we have the
holiday it will cost extra money for garbage.0
Alderman Lloyd "It only happens once in
what this Council does, every employer will be
from his staff and he is going to give in and say we 14111 work a
skeleton staff on Monday. If we take the lead on it that will
settle it. Many people like to take advantage of a holiday in
order to join their families in different parts of the Province."
In answer to a question from Alderman Dunlop the City
Solicitor read the law respecting holidays for the information
of the Council.
The amendment was put and passed 6 voting for the sane and
4 against it as follows:
7 years. No matter ,
faced with requests
FOR THE AMENDMENT
Alderman Macdonald O'Malley Vaughan DeWolf Moriarty Dunlop
C OPP
AGAINST IT
Alderman Lloyd Ahern Allen Lane
--867-
Alderman. Lloyd gives Notice of Reconsideration.
,TENDERS FOR LAND
Tog HIs Worship. R.A. Donahoe, Q.C., and Membera of City Council.
Fro;,o! City Manager, A.A. DeBard, Jr.,
Dateg November 9v 1954.
Subjectg Terd,3rs for Land .. Tabulation
Lora Claremont Street
4ChariG W. Macintosh $1,600.00
Lot B Forreoter Street
HubJey Sand & Gravel Co. Ltd. 1,700.00 *Ralph Gould 2,600.00
Lot C. Mumford Road;,,
#Mary Griffiths 500.00
Lot D., Lot #1 - Doug Smith Drive.
John dCEntremont 1,750.00 D.M. Tingley 1,501.00 Leon B. Baccardax 2,600.00
Lot En Loy.,12.=_Domg_gmith Drive,
Howard F. Blundell John d'Entremont D.M. Tingley *DOB. Nicholson
* Recommended bid.
# Recommend rejection
1,800.00 1,850.00 1,501.00 2,540.00
A.A. DeBard, Jr., City Manager.
Moved by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderman Macdonald
that the report be approved. Motion passed.
Alderman Dunlopg "With respect to the Mumford Road lot we
should re-advertise lt and put a minimum bid on it.*
City Manager, "I can bring it to Committee on Worko.'1
TENDERSJOR GROCERIES , FISH ETC.
CITY OF HALIFAX
NOVA SCOTIA
TABULATION OF GROCERY TENDERS FOR
HALIFAX TUBERCULOSIS HOSPITAL AND INFECTIOUS DISEASES
HOSPITAL CITY HOME AND CITY PRISON.
-888-
GROUPS SCOTIA FLOUR & FEED CO. LTD.
HOWARDeS LIMITED
5
X Indicate iowei:t group bid,
Howarde Llmited — Lowest in Groups 1, 2 4 and
PREVIOUS PRICE
MAC "13'; "CH ITEM BURNS FISH FISHERMAN , S BOUTILIER2S LOW
ERIES_LTD_ MARKET TENDER
Haddock Fillets
Fresh Codfish (Dressed) x .10 Lb.
Fresh Haddock (Dressed) x .15
r
3
Or; x trAl
Haddock Steak
Halibut Steak
Cod Steak
November 12, 1954.
Group 4
kc:2AR—Zs.,
Group It
Canned Dry Fruit1;0 Jams and Julc,e
Canned & Diy Vegetable,E,
Canned Bottled Sauce.Es Chow & Pickles Canned. Fish
$4752.06 X
$2657.59 X
$3679.32
No Bid
No Bid
$3638.11 x
Group 4. Cerc:.Wa,Coffee,Teao Flour, SgaT, Blouits, Cheese $3404.12 X $8409.48
Group_j. Soap, °leaning Material 654.66 X 664.72
asilp_§a All Other Supplies $2152.92 $2151.89 x
Scotia & Feed Co. Lowest in Groups 3 and 6.
A.A. DeBard p Jr., City Manager.
CITY O HALIFAX NOVA SCOTIA
TABULATION OF FISH TENDERS
HALIFAX TUBERCULOSIS HOSPITAL AND INFECTIOUS DISEASES HOSPITAL, CITY HOME AND CITY PRISON.
OmMilm•••••••M•04....•••••••,•••••
x .10 Lb0
.17
.11 Lb..
. 16 "
A & B
A
10¢
15¢
.29 x .27 " 28¢
x .18 " C 19¢
.23 E .18 " A 17¢
.43 .42 A 40¢
71,r v14 2 A 13¢
X o32 0 335/
Cod Fillets 019
Sole Fillets.1
November 12, 1954.
Smoked Ccd Fillets .19 Lit x .18 Lb .20 Lb. B 19¢
Smelt' Pressed x 4 37 .33 A 320
Srinrin,Frozen x ' B& 37¢
Fresh Herring (Hde. Off 7. .09 .10 ' .10 It A 090
Salt Herring -;.gi.b.;.. No. I 8.00 x 7.45 E 8.25 B $7.00
Dressed Mackeral Fresh Hde, on x .1L4 , .14 I .15 A & B 140
Kippers N n !! x .15 C 1.60
Finnan Hadftie x x „_.. Y .24 A 230
Cod,. Boneless .% A .27 .29 B 260
Codfish, Salt, one under 4 Lbs. 112ce , . 0 ", : 017 .18?1 B 150
Scallops ilik- ,...,s ... x 0 52 C 50
X — Re,:ommcrid, T.7r.
Individual ltcmi, c,f )ndic.ated in 4th. Column to right.
Two Bidders qu6te c):). Fresh Codfish and it is recommended
this item be spil: EI:rnt, Fisheries and Fisherman's Market on a monthly r:)tatIon t-_:si::.- Estimated supply of Codfish required
for next 6 monthe IC ,1 ,00C value of which 18 5700.00. The
same two Bidders qi:o1,.:,d prIzeF1 for Fresh Dressed Mackeral
and it is rez*om::.e:lued tno T.,:,rider be split on a monthly rotation
basis for thi3 !tem, Approx.Imately 600 Lbe. are reql,ired at a cost
of S8400.
A.A. DeBard. Jr., City Manager.
Marred by Aldormil% 1:7.:.(nlde(i by Alderman O'Malley that
the report be f3ppro, pastaed,
TE!1DERS FOR LICENSE PLATES
CITY GF HALIFAX
TENDES_TOR_ TA ;S liADGKS___PLATES;.ETC. FOR 1 55
FOR
r 'rt . g PV T'ARTMENT
ITEM
3335 only
4000
131.:11
ti • - • $ , .
1%-,4„;(1
• • ;1'40”
LciNT,(,% itUPBFR .11, POWER PRICES
:3 TAMP CO- LTD. LIMITED
95.77
14.04
115.3o
q5.77
14.04
31536
Item #3 Works November 4, 1954.
CITY OF HALIFAX
TABULATION OF TENDERS FOR SUPPLIES - 1955
APPLICATION OF ROAD OILS, TARS AND LIQUID ASPHALT
PRICE PRICE 1954 Per Gal. Per Gal.
ZiO 240
3i0
3(10 3a0
COMPANY ITEM
UNICIPAL SPRAYING & Application - Dust Layer
CCNTRACTING LIMITED.
Application - Rotar B, Etc.
Application Rotar R.T., Etc.
7n1y Tender Received.
a CITY MANAGER
CITY MANAGER
• • •
$ 1.00 .900 (At Warehouse)
.960 (At City Fie)f.
G
CITY MANAGER
Item #3 Works November 4, 1954.
CITY OF HALIFAX
TABULATION OF MNDERS FOR SUPPLIES - 195 5
SALT
100 Lb. Bags Salt 100 Lb. Bags Salt PHIS 1954
Delivered At Warehouse Delivered At City Field 100 Lb. Bags
1•.-Y!* 7 I COMPANY
A.M. SMITH & CO. LTD. .960
'17 Tender Received.
-7:1' - Sample of Salt available at Purchasing Cffice.
• • •
CITY P.ANAGM
TABULATION OF TENDERS FOR SUPPLIES - 1955
SPRAYING &
CON :TRACTING LIMIT
Item 43 Works November 4, 1954,
CITY OF HALIFAX
TABULATION OF TENDERS FOR SUPPLIES - 1955
FURNACE OIL, STOVE OIL, BUNKER "A" AND "C"
COMPANY FURNACE OIL Price Per Gal.
ST.TMLINE OILS LTD. 15.70
S. CUNARD & CO. LTD. 16.70
17:ION COAL CO, 16.70
n:RIAL OIL LTD. # 14.950
A:iCiATALD COAL & OIL LTD. 16.60
T7=C OIL CO. LTD. 16.70
STOVE OIL BUNTER "C" BUNIMR "A" Price Per Gal. Price Per Gal. Price Per Gal.
# 18.60
19.60
19.60
19.60
19.4
19.60
#
10.90
•••••••
10.240 #
11.111 •••• WED
9.200
OMNI, MD MOANS
8.950
1•411.1••••• 'UMW&
r Recsmmended Bid
.A 6 4-(22-16 CITY MANAGMI
Tender Prices - 1954.
Furnace Oil - 15.10 Per Gal. Bunker "C" - 9.400 Per Gal.
CITY MANAGER
Item #3 Works
CITY OF HALIFAX November 4, 1954,
TABULATION OF TENDERS FOR SUPPLIES - 1955
SPECIAL CASTINGS
Hillis & Sony Dartmouth Iron Prices Limited Foundry 1954
PRICE PER LB. PRICE PER LB. ITEM
(li,TCITIT - COVER .114 .100 .110
II - GRATING .130 .110 .140
TE BARS .140 .040 .1010
`:HOLE COVERS, SEW SQUARE .100 .040 .040
n li TRACK .140 .040 .040
n II COAL HOLE .100 .100 .110
rriOLE FRAMES, SEWER SQUARE .140 .040 .09ip
II It TRACK .100 .040 .040
It ti COAL HOLE .10i0 .100 .110
KrIT.On STrYS 4 1330 .11i0 .123-0
.31:::-:7-7 1'.011UMTT CASTING .110 .100 .1*
CV ER GRATES .1110 .110 .140
OTHER CASTINGS .140 .100 .120
7'‘1172TDED TM1DER - Dartmouth Iron Foundry.
CITY MANAGER
• • •
CITY MANAGER
It em #3 Works November 4, 1954.
CITY OF HALIFAX
ielivered at Siding 2.75 c.Y.
TABULATION OF TENDERS FOR SUPPLIES - 1955
SAND AND GRAVEL
HtTBLEYIS SAND NAUGLE SAND & GRAVEN, CO. & GRAM CO. ITEM
Price Paid 1954
$ 3.25 c.y. $ 3.40 c.y. $ 3.25 0.7.
3.25 c.y. 3.40 c.y. 3.25 c.y. 3.50 c.y. 3.40 c.y. 3.25 c.y.
3.25 ca. 3.50 c.y. 3.25 c.Y. 3.25 c.y. 3.50 c.y. 3.25 c.y. 3.50 c.y. 3.50 c.y. 3.25 c.y.
SOD livered at Wharf
elivered at Siding livered at City Field
?.J.S11 SAND telivered at Wharf relivered at Siding telivered at City Field
#1 - 3.00 c.y. #2 - 3.10 c.y. #3 - 3.30 c. y. #4 - 3.50 c.y. #5 - 4.25 c.y.
#1 - 3.00 ca. #2 - 3.10 ca. #3 - 3.30 ca. #4 - 3.50 c.y. #5 - 4.25 c.y.
#1 - 3.00 c. y. #2 •- 3.10 c.y. #3 - 3.30 c.y. #4 - 3.50 c.y. #5 - 4.25 ca.
telivered at City Field 3.25 c.y.
F.AVa elivered at Wharf 2.75 c.y.
SAND i:.livered at Wharf
telivered at Siding relivered at City Field
2.25 c.y. 2.25 c.y. 2.75 c•y•
2.50 ca. 2.25 c.y. 2.50 ca. 2.25 ca. 2.50 0.7. 2.75 0.7.
.:!mzended Tender - Rubley's Sand & Gravel Company.
CITY MANAGER
• • •
2.75 c.y.
2.75 c•y•
3.25 c.y.
• • •
ITEM
CITY OF HALIFAX
TABULATION OF TENDERS FOR SUPPLIES - 1955
ASPHALT. TAR. ROAD OILS AND COLD PATCH
TENDERER - IMPERIAL OIL LIMITED
PRICE
Item #3 Works November 4, 1954.
PRICE 1954
Sr01,2.3,4,5,6. Drums(Carload) 18.550 "
iALT
BC-1,2,3,4,5o Tank Car
-1,2,3,4,5. Tank Wagon 16.500
C-1 2 3,40. Drums (Carload) 21.850
MC:4,1,2,3,4,5. Tank Car
NC-0,1,2,314,5. Tank Wagon
N.,-0,1,2,3,40. Drums (Carload) 21.350
F.O.B. Refinery Imperoyal Delivered
Delivered
F.O.B. Refinery Imperoyal Delivered
Delivered
F.O.B. Refinery Imperoyal Delivered
17.300 (Tank Car Lots)
21.300 (Drums Carload Lots)
14.000 (Tank Wagon Lots)
II 11
11
16.850 16.000
L-0,1,2,3,4,5,6. Tank Car
SC-0,1,2,3,4,5,6. Tank Wagon
14.050 13.200
17.350 Per Gal. Delivered
kecial Primer (Tank Car)
Srecial Primer (Tank Wagon)
17.350
16.500
Delivered
F.O.B. Refinery Imperoyal
Orly Tender Received.
aq CITY MANAGER
Item #3 Works November 4, 1954.
IRVING OIL
#
TABULATION
CITY OF HALIFAX
- 1955
IMPERIAL OIL
OF TENDERS FOR SUFPLIES
CANADIAN OIL
GASOLINE AND
OILS. ETC.
MCCOLL-FRONTENAC SHELL OIL
CO. LTD. COS. LTD.
OIL CO. LTD. CO. LTD.
LTD.
37.400 Gal. 36.050 Gal.
36.250 Gal. 37.100 Gal.
41•1
11•••••••••••••....
26.700 37.050
"
••••••••••••=
•••••
22,100
# 26.400
••••••.•
••••••••••••
# 26.400
24.200 24.200 Gal.
.2370 Gal. 24.200
ft
17.800 17.800
"
# 16.800
,.890
46i0 Qt.
#
#
79.500 "
25.000 Qt.
.870 & .890 Gal.
.2650 Qt.
$1.12
$1.32
Gel,
Gal.
.880 11
.270 qt.
$1.10 Gal.
$1.15 Gal. $1.08
Gal. $1.32
$1.09 Gal.
OILS PRICE 1954
SUPERLINE LTD.
Gal. .370
37.60 Gal.
#
.220 n
22.90 "
26.400 "
24.40 Gal.
24.20 n
17.80 n
17.80
ITEM
GASOLINE
MARKED GAS
NAPHTHA GAS
KEROSENE
DIESEL Furs
MOTOR OIL (Drums)
MOTOR OIL (Quarts)
DIESEL ENGINE LUBRICANT #30
HOIST OIL
.890
.26i0 Qt.
$1.08 Gal.
.870
.260 Qt.
$1.04 Gal.
FLUSHING On
E.P. LUENICANT 90 tio 140
HYPOID LUBRICANT 80 t. 140
ALL PURPOSE GREASE
#
.510
n 51.400
"
.500 "
.350 "
.120 Lb.
.120 Lb.
.1. "
.150 "
#
21.250 "
.740 n
.350 n
51.750 "
43.750 "
.550 #
.520
It
.510
.440
.520
n
.500 "
.16 1 10 Lb. 14.000 Lb.
.1570 Lb. .1620 Lb.
$1.50 Gal.
.16E10 #
14.000 r.
.1370 & .1570 Lb. .1620
"
$1.50 "
.16a.0 11
22.500 .2730
Lb. .2620
if 21.250 Lb.
# RECOWINDED BIDS
It is recommended the tender of Irving Oil and Imperial Oil be accepted for
the supply of Naphtha Gas on a rotation basis.
It is recLmmended the tender of Shell liw and Suporline 'silo be nceoptod for
the supply cf Holut Oil r
rotaticsi ban's.
CITY MANAGER
•
• •
•
CITY OF HALIFAX
Item #3 Works November 4, 1954.
TYPE
ANTHRACITE
COKE
FORGE
BLOWER
Reduction Allowed Per Ton
NAAM
TABULATION OF
TENDERS FOR SUPPLIES — 1955
CUURD CCAL PRICES 1954
UNION COAL
ANTHRACITE COAL AND OTHERS
ARCHIBALD COAL MATHEWS
COAL
Per Ton Per Ton
Per Ton Per Ton
lTalsh 31.50
32.00 31.75
# 31.00
31.00 Per ToL
American 30.50
—
30.75 # 30.00
31.00 11
U
712e.n5on 25.65
26.00 25.72
# 25.60
25.60 R
Acadia 17.20
18.00 17.25
# 17.10
17.30 8
1
u'elih 25.50
if, 24.50
25.50 25.00
25.00 1
a
1.00 .800
1.00 .750
# RECOMMENDED BIDS a
. 4.90//3 (\le
CITY MANAGER
• ........ .
• •
-( t . .
"7.
t:4
November 12 k, 1954.
Only Mar.:.hine .•
3
20 ac
10
13.35
i94. 25
i.00)3
5.87
14.„55
141.46
12015
91.47
14.55
21.83
10.33
5087
14.55
130.99
12.15
21.47
14.55
21.83 150
16.84
Tr% PLate,-- 28.47
;t 888. '.--, 9 Fderal t t7 'Ai
Chimney p,14 Padgea
$673.25
$.740.57
12,21
$ 669.82 66_2_98
$ b6A-76
b
RECOMMENDED TENDE 'Per L 1m 1
A.A. D6Bard, Jr.. Ctty Managr.
Mov- ed ty Aiairact s,::':;onded by Alderman Lloyd that
the report be ar,-.,T;r. Mcr) paLiGi:dr
TENDER FOR SUPPLIES
To r.ne- Kayor and Meml7c r C tv Co unc.11.
Frcmt Work,?
4 Date No7emb , 19
Sub,lect:
The by T.he 1954.
Tenth:: f !,1)!77,.116"
Tracr, of toncir-s for 6upplieg was considered c a mef:ting held on November 4th v
t•Drys as submttted with the The C(..,mmt
from Ir_y ir,E....011_Co,,..L.tc3,. and
v
iarlended tha t the tender of Hillis Hn : 0: i
if recr: be f lied wl th City Council at
oti
; the tenders
wor,=! • •
12v 19540
CITY CLERK.
Sabean0 Clerk el Works.
A
1i Aldrmtvi Allen that the
report .tE7 gle item Spectal Castings"
and "E,...1':'„ 111'
b7 A]darman 0° Malley that •
S. fc:r Sptial Castings be
be :-;ald about industry in
lndu.,?,try in
—.em, t dc.n't think it is
I ha-.)e every: sympathy
!:flit? the motion.:c
nae 7-2ee-. cqzanized
t":. put the company
m,,-h. ar, Indirect way
my pra.:..t1ae in the
I tn:-cr: rnis a little
fc..;undry be better
.;t. that an Alder—
This C=pany701
Alderman la
the tendr
appra he
Nova Scc''.
our dut-j:
but or; the
'
recently 3::(i
• •
on n
of .tax ext,,;p
Aldt
paet tc
dIfferero' - 4 .
than f.1
M:, W•-
AA 4
man et
1191t1-.,:r
Lic-yd wishing to
, i.:acQuarrie of Na
to hear iii, ;n 1ft!
is that it
of what we do in 1.1 II,
(J(.-,varnments. We have been,:7,o;unli.x,,-;01..:,!d a:11
understand tiv: -
in a municipality, rhit,! !:
I:c salt had too mucli kt„ Wu %;%11)1...)./ 12.0
me,-?..ns quite a bit to the e;:orlour,, of• the area..!'
Worship the Mayor ~What: huc, beeri
,z:.,:,ther salt that is availa-Ae. to do the )(..)-r be tt
MacQuarrie; The NAM.,
r.J:n our competitor l Et t
Lloyd.;; '1 In the case --, -.r. C -, 0/ hal ft x::
to deliver., cuarEz..,:r They :,:Nplied
they thernselve;--i si:ty
lianaLer: "I
DeWoif that the fz,117 wi;f, nnt
saw that himself, ;
,it conforiAs f; r e • I t; the ,.
40 Oa certain Jobs it jui t ,
:•i!.use the.
1 .
Dunlop:; tICsn MmcQwtrrA: :. 1 ye:- L..
to ,:ipeclricf...itic,-,z?'
1 y
Llo C:1fl yd '
I, •
„
•
n
November 12 r 1954,
Alaryan Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Ahern that the
a. an6. Commissioner of Works be 1..Allurld to mE..t
e.ntatives of the6e companies aLk cad for taildel'8
Motion oassed.
-\.PPROPRIATION PIONEI:T QOUP01 TNTPE'iT
November o i 1954.
Mayo.!: and Oity Council.
meeting of the Finance and Executive Committee held on
a report was submitted from thi. Depaty C -cistlioher
..iuesting that an appropriation be provided for the of p.ying coupon interest on the 1954 Bond Issu.
It was agreed to recommend that a sum not exceediniz 83o.250.00
bs ::pr. priated under the authority of Section 3160 of the City
s: or this purpose.
Respeotfully s.tibmi'cted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
d by Alderman ',Dna, seconded by Alderman OrMallev that,
approved. 1.1ocion passea.
DECEMBER PAY
the Mayor and City Council.
nar ,:c.. and Executive Committee at a meetinc .i7reed to reconnend that the City Tresirer be e ,.ahr,rized
07:ficials and employees tLeir full atlary on or about the 15th of t1J, t mcinth.
RespectflAl]y submitt(d,
W.P. CITY CLEI1C.
,L1deran DeWolf, 6,2c,';;Ided A (nri.,.;11
i,:ppvoved. MG1:10:1
REVISIGN OITY CHARTER
i-,he Mayor wirA
;f City Counr.:11.
report from 1:1. City SoliG11...r rt, c1:t!
Chtirter was considerel. by the Finnt-7,e aryl Ex,
at meeting held on the above date.
— 894 —
V November l'z v 1954.
It, was 4;reed to 1.euommend that rhf City ;..lathorized tc undertaea cif te Cliy th;.,t the it!attoy of tne chare for his i t.L',G fur
undertakJa14 be considered by a special (tufilLee arA
that His Worship the Mayor confer wlth the City Boli.:Ator
:)n the preparation of a resolution to cary:y o>t this
.i..ecoomendati.on.
w.lbmi)Jed,
-!,
Alderman Dunlop ":I in not sure the Solieltor has
the spare time to revise the Charter. I have in
the other two assistants who are in need of extra pily
It would make for a quicker revision. The City Soil t,.cr
would be the head of the Committee. That would be the
way I prefer to see it done."
Alderman Lloyd: "I think the observatic.nH
Alderman could be considered by the Committeu”
Alderman Dunicp: The Solicitor should !:s.':e
Issistance."
Moved by Aiderm.an Lloyd seconded
that the report be approved..
City Solicitor: " I am not -Looking
lilproach this with tl great deal of concern. I know what
It entails. Personally I would prefer rlit to Liy:e tc
.f.c.; it at all under any circumstance. t
want it.8
The motion was pl:t and iu
wishing to be recorded against,
LEGISLATION RE RETIRING ALLU4ANCES
r,
November
— 895 —
November 12„ 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and. Members of the City Council.
The Finance and Executive Committee at a meeting
held on the above date recommended for approval thE,
attached legislation respecting retiring allowances.
Respectfully eubmit,ted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERKK,
The Charter is amended by inserting therein,
mediately following Section 309 thereof, the folowing
Section:
309A, (1) The City may pay 1- o i1tly elJp,1,:vee (,!
City9 upon his retirement from employment with the City,
an annual allowance of such sum as the Cou:. may
determine, not tc exceed the amount of ynt, _:Aou_7,and
dollars per annum; provided, however, that sir any
such employee is entitled to receive a retiring ailcwance
from any superannuation fund or plan to which contribut-
ions are being made by the City the allowance autIvirized
to be paid by this Section shall be such sum as will rlf)T
exceed the amount by which the said allowance whicn st::n
employee is entitled to receive in any one year an
y
such fund or plan is lees than one thousand dol:bre
(2) Any sums required to pay any such allowane6 In
any year may be included in the estimates for that year
and any sums paid in any year as such allowanes shall
be shown as an expenditure by the City in such year,
Moved by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderri
Lloyd that the report be approved. Motion peesd2/4
November 12., 1954.
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
A report was submitted from the City Manager under ilte of
Lember 30 v 1954 embodying a letter from H.R. Doane & Co. out-
Llning the procedure and problems encountered during the annual
Independent audit and same is attached to the original:copy of
these minutes.
TILED
DOWNTOWN PARKING LOT LEASE _FOR 12. 1
November 8, 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
The Finance and Executive Committee at a meeting held on the
above date considered a request from the Downtown Merchants
Association for a renewal of the lease on the Grbfton Street
Parking Lot.
It was agreed to recommend that the lease be renewed for the
year 1955 and the Mayor and City Clerk authorized to execute same
on behalf of the City.
Respectfully suhmltt.:-d.
W.P. Pubilover, CITY CLERX.
Moved by Alderman DeWolf, seconded by Aldermi.,r. Yeighan that
the report be approved. Motion passed.
RESERVATION INTERNATIONAL TRADE FAIR
Moved by Alderman O'Malley, seconded by Alderman Lane that
the action of the City Manager in reserving a double booth tor
the 1956 Fair be approved. Motion passed.
A report was submitted from Alderman Ahern c.ontitin several int;
recommendations respecting the Trade Fair.
It was agreed that hie report would be dieousi;ed w!tv!! the
1955 estimates are considered.
APPOINTMENT OF COAL WEIGHER
November 8.. 1954.
To His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
A request from Mathews Coal Company to have Mr, C.W. Dr,ublcday
896-
Novmber 12, .1.9
IJIJoonted. a Coal Weigher was considered by the Flnr.r!,e ;Inci Committee at a meetin 11L1 t -
arree'a reordmend that the l'queht
outAltt ,.
CITI CLERK.
Moved by Alderman. ValJghan, se,:.oded by lUcL,viLac, D..op that
report be approved, Mti '
HEATING SYSTEM CITY FXELD
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council,
From: Committee on Works.
Date: November 8th., 1954.
Subject: Heating System — City Field„
At a meeting of the Committee on Works. held on No7,-mber )4th the Commissioner of Works recommended the pu::'3'nase cif the number
of Unit Heaters required from the lowec,t bidder on eac;1-1 b e Unit u at a cost of $3000.00. Funds for spme are available in the Capital Borrowing.
The Committee approved and :'ec,ommended same tr) CAt Cowic1),
Pesi,eLf Ily
W.P. Publico‘e:. CITY CLERK
Per—J:13, Satean, Clerk of Work_.
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council°
rom: GoF. West Commissioner of Wors,
4te: October 2. 1954,
Subject: Heating S:Tstem - City Fieia
The original plans for the instaliaLion sjstem at City Field calla fGr
he placed throughout the
t,ht 'ice/ heatini4
Quotations on these wippliers, and the total
C1:: r. 1:ea havf OGt C 24 A'411,5
, A. luca ,00
Cranes Ltd. were low OP ail sl:-.e6 of
except ones. and Stairs Son L Morrow Ltd, were
one.
11,- */
-ro t!..a
encn It is recommended that athr)rity number of unit heaters ren'ilree,
f:.6m the lovic id der
unit.
Novmter 1954„
There is money available in the Capital Borrowing 7o cover is expenditure .
M. . West, Couuissioner of Wolit
Moved by Alderman Macdonald, sed by Alderman Dw.lop that
the report be approved. Moton pass:.d.
INCINERATOR DATES
To: His Worship, R.A. Donahoe, ° r
7::
arc; Members of City Counc-11
A From: City Manager, .A, D d eBar, Jr
Date: November 10, 1954.
Subject: Incinerator - Engineering.
Mr. West has written to several consulting engineers acid they
will visit Halifax for a preliminery survey without charge as
follows:-
November 18
November 22
To be arranged
500 P.M. Mr, Harrison 13„ Eddy of Metcalfe & Eddy, Boston,
8:00 P.M. Mr, Clarke of Greeiey & Hansen, Chlcago,
Proctor Redi'L!rn ToronL.
A,A, DeBard City
Moved by Alderman Ahern., seconded by Aldermq . that
the report be approved. Motion paLeed,
ADDITIONAL COURT REPORTER
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of the CiYy Council.
From: Carl P. Bethune: R.C. City
Date: November 10, 1954.
Subject: Re: Additional Court Reporter - City Cnu:T. and
Your Worship and Aldermen
As instructed by the City Council I havo conferred with the
Attorney General)s Department of the Pr::Ivince and AM EsdVlBtA
that
the Province is prepared to share half th.? cc,st (if an adfltional
Court Reporter for the Police Court, City Cot and County
Magistrategs Court, The salary ranf7e nrcposo:i wao S:23110,00 to
$2700.00.
This I think is the Infor the Cln.il and
if this is approved I would reco;i:Ixnd %IA;_i y t n
November 12, 1934 .
authorized to make an appointment to fill this position after
oonsultation with the Stipendiary Magletrate.
Yours very truly,
CARL P. BETHUNE, CITY SOLICITOR.
Moved by Alderman Dunlop, se:looded by Alderman DeWolf that
the report be approved. Motion
STREET NAMES
To: His Worship the Mayor
From: Committee on Works.
Date: October 25th, 1954.
Subject: Street Names.
passed.
and Members of City Council.
At a meeting of the Committee on Works held on October 21st
1954 the question of changing the name of Gebhart Street to avoid
confusion between it and Geldert Street was considered.
The Committee recommended that the name of GebbArt,
Street be changed to Belcher Street.
Respectfully submAtted.
W.P. Pubilcover, CITY CLERK.
Per..j.B. Sabean, Clerk of Work
His Worship the Mayor stated that the residents had indicated
their desire to have the named changed to either Pearson Drive or
Chelsea Drive.
Moved by Alderman Dunlop, seconded by Alderman Ahern that
Gebhart Street be renamed Pearson Drive. Motion passed.
RESUBDIVISION OF LANDS OF MR. S. WAIXER_LIyERP9OLJTREET
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of City Council.
From: Town Planning Board.
Date: November 8th.. 1954.
Subject: Resubdivision of lands of
Samuel Walker - Liverpool St.
At a meeting of the Town Planning Board, held on November
4th., the Town Planning Engineer recommended approval of a plan
of resubdivision of two lots of land of So,muel Welker, on Liverpool
Street, to correct an error in measurement made in the original
plan.
899
Ncy,.-mber 12, 19.540
Roard approved Eiame as 11.7) j.,, or. P1,3r
of 11:)rk6.
9a:.,D7ed by Aiderma:i Lloyd, Le:aonded Aidermari DuCiop that
be appmv.6d, Mc,;13(i p!Antit,
1-:EF:UBDIVISION OF CITY OWNED LANDS LDIEEPOOL STREET
41
Woreh)p the Mayor an.a Members of the City OolnctI.
Town Plannang Board,
November Eith„ :1954.
Resubdivis:or, of C.t r. y own-Ld larid
a meeting of tht.-, r;oard held Nc7;embeT 4th
Planning Eng:i.nse!: 3.'e;,:omme!ided ol n cbdivistor!
crf C't.t owned land o!.1. the norh sIde of LiverpJoi Sts er
. tc be
a :qtr tc, the bounding propertiEe.
Board approect same ar.?, Lih3wo Piac, :j-_ ., RE 2 J2890,
CilY cLEaK
c>f
by Alderma J'._ 1. by ikIrmb.:. that
:-:Drt be appro-.-ed, Mz,v1c -i;ad!;6d
BUILDING LINE ROLLIS ST.
His Wcrsh:p art.
Members of Crit-: Town P1anniT i -130;JI-Th
No,:ember i23,
Reg Building
a meeting Cl the1(t vi: At r ; 4o N.-,mtr th„
from the. Town PI:.-LnnIc!.g remm.:rd1n1-7 that, a
building Ilne be establish, 76 or the %j..t r side Hoill6
from Saolc.fille Strout southwarl.Ly Hotid. was
riTp:. .H:71 and recommended City Coun.111,
p 1 r
,A:Liffmon Al) en. asked tf by layAng this bulldrig .tine would
of Le C till chit, new 11'6 i•LA Lit; L
adibed Lhiit J r wouia
building.
i.ceved by Alderman Dt4Aloo, sticondE;d by ik.6erma:1 klitcA,,:,r:.ald that
REqpinED FROM ST. PAniC-C6 h.
His Worship :he Mayor and Members of the City Counell. Town Planning Board.,
November 8th., 19)4.
Sub,:,ie,',t; Land required by the City of Hailfax Cfoir, St, Petvi home for RoElanci AveLoe,
meeting of the Town Plannint_7 Boafd. heJcl attached repcx- 1.- from the City Enne2r 1%
C;.ity acquiring land from St. Patrick's H(:me was approved and reoommended to City Con:.:1
Nc)vember 4th., tc the
Ronia4:6 Avenue
R6spec;tfu11y
West, CoTiImissic)ner 01
Crtv ELE'
(I of halifa froal St
1(IL:7 tht,; City hniitax, ,A Corpc:ration were c.onsAdring
ho)Iset'i in rL!'a 57111d:
proposed erotio the adlillcnni
6, was In r!!: ar,:a f;r?an of
darc,h II. 194h tLe Gity , n proposed. Eitrt?et iu nr_,w Ro;;;iina AveLe,
r:nyers Road throln City of Hz!lifpx' .D. It3ner pr(,:)ert y thr:-, Lq-* T!ie
::;ford Road.
A•ff.,.rt -t-tf.:! , ' t. A
• :! 1")
tIA le .1 I
Motion passed, 1-:7sport be approved.
iV .velob
'eES at f rrt thr,1.4;7,:ht obta in an t,,PqP,ilt7tot 1- 11 -E-),:rrh the ,•• t; a r.",0
t r,crtion to ;1-11r,i
(Tha
s Hch16, ma.dt,-: with
1. may be se&n f nom th.ls that 1 r: r.1: ili. in ilomans Averru, the C ty ts.21:
me 01,:ltte in ord_6r r The CI ty r Ohl ould
Aved by Aldermar sa,i•ondd • (1) A 0
r
AMENDMENT TO ORDINANCE 4 TELE V IS
His Wor'ship .h;- Mavor Lind Members of Counil. Co-ronit tee
November ;".t1.,
Pie r Te.1.71J,ion Aritenr
t. a meet-Inc. of the (3,-:n-711 toe on Works Ci Ly
,ce No 46 ba amend t,, , • ied by the Cr%m:niss
o
Res •
W 0? CityV..
it tea .. .11 .
I d, r:nan
r t be an:
Mc„7:on
.1-A--J - - - -
Trp orrtr.-n
M,:iyi)r a nd
,• as followe:
. Sect ion 1 Inant-e •
,f S tr,lc tureFi Gor!-;) Teie.'1 .-•n An ..,„!,
,./t/6, tltd
(a ) Nc nern :
any r other 1-,t"-rni.or, 'Ifr cons trlc t int7. r,y ..onstrw t
,ree f)r. ri,
, •-e! unless tit' 1.
ti
Novembt,17 1L'o 1954.
ths authority of this Ord-inanoe Such lieense shall be signed and -.,.;maed by the Commissioner of Works Etna shill remazn. for,::e for -fie year from the date of its issue 1es6 reed. prix t to the eienl:cation thereof as hereinafter provided° The Commissioner of WrAs may revoke any such license at any time If in his opinion th person holding such license has failed to comply with any of the provisions of this Ordinance.
(b) Before any such license is issued tt any person such person shall provide a good And sufficient bond in the penal sum of Five Thousand Dollars (45,000.00), executed by a surety company licensed to do business in the Province of Nova Scotia and approved e form by the Cry Solicitor, which said bond shli be 3onditioned upon the faithful performance of ali lawe and of the ordinances of the City of Halifax, and shall indemnify and keep hariaess the City of Halifax fi-ota any and all damajes° judE;ements, costs or expenses which the said City may incur or suffer by reason of the granting of such license. The said bond shall also extend to the use and benefit of the City of Halifax as well as of any person who may suffer in3uriee or property damaa;e b•,r repsoa of the license granted hereunder. Such bond shall be maintained in effeet at all times during the currency of the said licen.ee.
Moved by Alderman Dunlop, seconded by Alderman Macdonald that
the amendment as set OUT above be read and passed a first T,lme and
referred to the Finance and Executive Committee Moon passed.
RETIREMENT OF MRS GEORGE H. GERMAN
No-:ember 8, 19.54.
His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council,
At a meeting of the Finanee and Exec',4tiv Co;rtee held on the above date, a report was submitted from the Retirement Comm-ittee advising that Mr, George H. Germen, a former Janior employed
by the Board of School Commissioners, had been reT.lred effective
as from October lr 195j at an annual allowance of a211„72,
It was decided to forward this information te
RespectfulL sul-mi/fed.
Puolle:over, CITY CLERK_
Moved by Aldermar, O'Malley , eeoondoc:i rm,-,r, Lloyd that
the report be approved, Motion passed.
GRANTS FOR PENSIONERS
No,-.o ,mter 8. 1954
• His Worship tie Mayor and !/,:r:bers of the City Council
Tht, attached statement respectlhg e i-oetints to pensioners, who are in receipt of ',mount& lesa than
1.100.00 per annum. %tat; onaldered by .he. 1,- rlar_cp.? Ex votive
tee tit n inee theld *,:w 17,ove tft.!
0
4
Gra :16
...r1 Cat
:.'t i) •-•
agreed. to rec,c,mmend that -,:11,± pbyment!,.. be wlae in .p1,161.-3 OUC if; t‘I;
Resoeful ocitm:ta.
14, Zi .1. a .•-•• — 1
v• r er
SUPPL4MEN1ARY 6U1*'ERAMMUAT'i
Pi;i:11: A
Den' • .
Ala:'(111
'. r. y f
ri 111x1
,
Dept, Emp, T,
vmp,,
ff •
Emp,
Emp. Llbinty Emp, Wc:,rk.s Dep!,
r
G,- I'
TOTAL
; •• 804.00
00 804.00
_,.00 804.00 804.00 804.00
:34000 804.00
1,044.00
Yi„CO 804.00
„)0 804.00
L 4
384.00
804.00
„ oil 804,00
804-.00
1,094,88
684,00
324.,00 644,00
i,.08j0 C-46
93_3.96
983095
804.00 R04,00
513.92
(:,84,00
88j.92
644.00
EdORMER PFNRITON P.AriENT OC,CUPATION C41 GRANT 1, 9 %, 4 •
ON
Miss t,;arsE.. Heal ?,n Depa.r7lmeni: Gran!'
0 Fre6
Water Dept. Grant Y2.C.00 Emp„ Grkl%r ;2,1)0
F. -irrrocrA GranA 72.).0n
Jamee r.L. 7d1 Me,z'har,La2 &upt„ Depart..mn.T. CrrarT.
Arthu! Stableman. Grant 726.06 Emp,, Work.
Dent, Gca,:tr r Work
r e p Wort“
P,.1:zhael.
I
Pens
Gr. fin r
908. 66 869.00
U r
ireman fed while on dt11:
• ?ranee Shanks F mark e
F :era.J;...;.-• ir r
Pep ., F
r-ep.-Lari 1' Iit
F P. C onn 1 3. y
or,) and F ; 11: Brushe t t F
F E.- ehan F r
F se,
•"- in F2 re Dep.-.,.r mtn:
P.:;n6:.
j- arntl',S 0 - Brien W1.17 t a I li Settle
11ann ,7ames Cc:,dy
L.' :hp. 1‘, en
e!:, .1. -leaden McKay
ell u_b
:1C - 4.. .44▪ 0 a 4
Kennedy -? Virtue T, Smi .
; vi ri Po-1 '1_ P
• 1.
L Q9 9 2
Pens 1.o.:1 Pene ~.cr. PeriE; Fen rs.
P S or
11.
Pen
-• I (
I. -,-. 19'
.A McDonald Emp. Works
Pq.alINNUAT ION
t I
_
GG I , ".? „ o , 9 6
4., 9
, c, 88 , 83
i 5: „ 88
4'2 „ li 'I i 9 C44 „ 00 849' „ 60
6 ,)0
8 9 8 95
683.92
Dib .68 929. 28 988,,68
„ 22
R A 1'
S SUPERAIT115As TON 17.-ri1',1•17:: SUPERAiir,iJAT 'V .,
P TPE I CiN
ied by Alci-:, rrro.f
-Art- tie paef;,,::i
-
Affttlx- s
No,xember ';=15
TO 13EDFORD_OONSTRUCTON_C(L. V.,50A00„
Worsnlp the Mayor and Members of the City iottric,., Committee Works.
November 8t'.h., 1954.
= Paymer0; Bedford Con -7 trutioD Co. — ,1;250b 00
a meeting of the Committee on Works, geld c.7:; Novembe:.: 4th. report from the . Commissioner of Works recommending that a
payment of $2508,00 he made to the Bark r Mc;r1reai account of the Bf,dford ConstructIon Co. , ror repoLntlhg Memorial Tower at Fleming Park, was approved and.
t-”c,ommended City Council.
Respectftlly
W.P.Pub1io.er, CITY CLERK.
Per, .J,B. Sanean, Clerk of WoriL*,
ed by Alderman Lloyd, seconded. Aldermar.. t
be approvpd, MotA on pasaed.
POSED SEWER EXTENSION CLINTON AVE. D ROAD
HJe Worship th.: Mayor a,d Members of the C:ty Co,,nClc Commvttee on Wcrke.
Noember 8th., 1954.
Proposed Sewer Extension — Clint, Avenue ' :tch vaila,=7 Rcad,
meeting of the Committee on Works, held on Nove-,7,ber 4tho the attached report from the C ty ErILT.lneer roc rend ni.7,-
a 24 .' sewer be laid on Cl in ton Avenu and ,,c norT nwa rd_
.4-i Dutch Village Road was c.onE. Ider
, Committee approved and recommeride.d s.&mti- - Lc) NC 1
Reapez t f ,.._i 1',.- L.3. !tr ' ;_ed,
WcP Publ CITY CLI;RX.
Pero,J.E Sabt:_ari, Clock
' est, CommieeIoner of Wrkb.
, C7ty Englner F
1954.
Lfewer Extension — Glinth A'Jonue (Ina 1)ut:f1 V111E1.7t road.
NO'Ye;Mts6:::
FINPL TO BEDFORD CONSTRUCTION CO .?508A00
E11s Worship the Mayor and Members of the C:1 try -Ciounc:.1„ Oonirn e rks
November 8:11,„ 1954.
Paymen ,-,t. Bedfoi'd Con -.7truLio!,, l s320b.00
t: a meeting of the Commitee on Works, tield c NoveMbe!,:, report from the Commissioner ox' Works recommending that a
payment of 82";08,00 be Tfitlkl tr:: the 13 .A: Monreal, • account of T:ne Bedford Constre,:Alon ier rupoLnting Memorial Tower at Fleming Park e was appro-,ted and ommended City Council.
RespectfCily submlf:tea,
W.P. CITY CLERK.
Per..J,B. Sanean, Clerk of WoriL6,
vad by Alderman Lloyd. seconded. Alder-marl D2:ir,p
I" be approvpd„ Mot.l.on passed.
-POSED SEWER EXTENSION CLINTON AVN , u rl,.V RnAD
Hle Worship t h nayer ar;d Members cf the Olty Committee on Wcrks.
No-:ember 6th,. 1954.
Proposed Sewer Extensicn -• Villa -"ad,
' a meeting of the Committee on Worke held on Noveber tl-leattahed report from ':he rocndlnii;
a 24 sewer ne laid or °Linton A-:enue and. , oc norTnward-
:21 Dutch V:IllaRe Road WB6 onsLd:::rcd.
Committee Ftpprwed F'. nil
eaneZ
CITY
Per—J.?. Sab,:.ari.
WeGt, CO:.M16e.1 0n 6 • of
.1.e City Engln
1954u
sewer Extenuion - c.:111,Lon A,.,enue a%a 1 11, c tiOD.04.
- 906
I
November 12, 19.54.
The problem of serving this area has been thorohly gene ,to9 c:heok levels have been taken, and it is oul- rec.ommendaioo,
proposed 24" sewer be laid on Clinton Avertue, anO, elso sewer be laid northwardly on Dateh Villag Road,
The sewer on Clinton Avenue would flow eaetwardly froct D-ate;h ee.ge Road to a pumphouse r and then discharge the existing
:.:v!dur along the Canadian National. Railway rlght-of-way.
The estimated cost for the above amounts to 424,400.009 but; t. Ie recommended that an additional length of 480' be lald on
1.)t -Th Village Road to clear up a very bad drainage problem whd -;91 ...an additional $5000.00. The total funds available
a.T.;!;7: $25,900.00. $9,000.00 of this total was appraved for 161P3r4: tliro water mains at first thought necessary were it, possible
Clinton Avenue directly into the sewer on Chebuoto Road.
It is requested that permission be granted to transfer the Rnt of $9,000.00 to this new scheme of serving this area by wsty ef pumping into the existing sewer on the Canadian National Railway right-of-way. An additional amount of $..3,500.00 would be reauired for the complete installation for which would include the additional 4809 of sewer on Dutch Village Road, and 1t is suggested tnat this amount be carried over for the 1955 Capital Borrowing.
A sketch is attached showing the proposed layout. It should be noted from the sketch that a sewer easement will be neeeesary over that, portion of the Canadian National Railway rightof-way for onne3ting the proposed pumphouse to the existing 2L sewer.
We estimate the yearly maintenance and operation of the pumps to amount to $275.00 per year.
A.0 Harris City Engineer,
Moyed by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Aldermar,. D..1:L)p that
the reboil; be approved. Motion passed.
FEE BLASTING PERMITS 1955 LEGISLATION
Te
Frome
November 8tho t 1954.
Subl=i,-,tg Blasting Permits.
At a meeting of the Committee on Works, held on November 4th., 1-) the attached report from the Commissioner of Works, recommend- Anc. an annual fee of $25.00 be charged fcr Blating Permits In ad, titic, n to Insurance requirements was appro.;ed pnd recommended to City Council.
Respectfully submitted_
WnPo Publi(..over, CITY CLERK
Per„.J.b. 8t.beark, Clerk of 11,)rkti,
6%-4101.ng nereto a report subPequently rec.e,lvt,ii from the Cltv
- 907 "
His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Counc,11. Committee on Works.
November 12, 1954.
Te His Worship the Mayor and Members of the Committee on Wok
ri.r1 P. Bethune, c1.0., Oty SolicAtor,
Novembsle 9
g Rdg 1,935 Legislation. ite Fee for blasting permits.
Wership and Aidermet
,i7, the meeting of the Committee on Works held NoveMber 4th., 1954„ it was decided to make an annual e.harge for blasting permits
Under the present legtelatlen there is no authority to :::harge ele,h a fee. and 1 attach heretc an amendment to Section 589A of the Charter, enabling the City te.-) provide a fee for blasting permits which will constitute an amendmenc t.e. the Ordinance when the legislative authority therefor is granted,
This should be reeommended to the City Council.
Yours very truly.
CARL P. BETHUNE, CITY SOLICITOR
'95
Item 19,
Alon 589A, as ha e:.acted Cy- Section 22 rThapter 56 of the Azi-ta c. 1.01 . is i- -.-lended by inserting thereiri. betwen the words 'perfriIY and "and' an the sixth line there.,-)f,
rand the fee payal.ie therefor.
note This amendmtft will enablt: the C)ty to -.7.11rge an annual fee for any blasting permits issued. The amount of the fee will be incaud an the Ordinanee,)
:t-Ivccl by 4derman DI;n1c.p seconded by Alderman Lloyd that
e ::pert and legislation as eubmitted be approved.
Motion passed.
OVERHANG-ING SIGNS
His Worship the Mayor and Members of the CiTy CelJnell,
Trom Committee on WozkE,
D a t P ;' November 8th. 19.54-
t% Overhanging Slues,
At a meeting cf the Coi:Jrattee Wcrks, held on November LIth,. 1:;f;4 e r3port from the Colf,mieeloner of Works recomeJinding that
-.eermisslon be granted to ere et feliowAng Overhaning Signs was
ey.erc-Jed and recommended to Cit7
NoveMber 12 1954.
`49 Sac:kville Street $3.00 Neon
Cran7ille Street ii.uddy Co. Ltd. 5.00
16
Brurolvik Street
5.00 Illuminated viper Service tatiorn
g15 Bedford Row Canadian Pittsburg Ind. Ltd. 5.00
432 Slree ries Ltd.
J,leeL
BerilsTLd,
.;orner Roble and. Cunard Street Irving 011 Co. Ltd.
#8034r Barrington Street. Neatha Ryder
#3) Morris ST:reet Mrs. Ada. McCallum
Dreiiden Row Mrs. R. MacFarlane
Oxtord Street Stores, Ltd.
5.00
500
5.00
7.00
.5.00
x
Neon.
1-3.1.wer Street MctorE
ttingen Stx.eet ty Tobaccc. 5.00
2..ricola Street Jacobson ..00
"1- 1:_ng Street. 14-j 011 .00
#2.62 3-cttingen Street Mens Shop
Moved by Alderman
Neon
Respectfully submitted..
W,P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Per.. J.B. Sabean Clerk of Works
secc:- ded by Alder7sn Ma:donald that
apj):•oved.. .
AG Plan #0A-1-11664A. rt- T e -11-.. idd and appro-:pd tyr
NoveMber 12, 1954.
C'03TNC PORTION OF BOWER ROAD AND SALE OF LAND
ad\iised that as a first step action should
T Y dcwn a portc,r, of the official street line.
sec,GncIed b r Aideila,an Lloyd that
h.',r.aday, December lb. 1954 at 8000 P.M. t i. the Council
Ohamber, Halifax, N.S. as the time and place for- a
into he natr ol laying down a portion of the
Steet Line on the West Side of Bower Road between Tower
-,,(7,;la and the CoN.R. right-of—way as shown on Sect:loa 20B of the
Official City Plan. Motion passed,
SALEAgLgONNA7pETAyFNtirE] (NEAR gHEBucTp_RpApl
To: His Worship the Mayor and. Membel's of the City Couni.t.
From: Committee on W::!rks,
nate: Noember 195LL
1Lnd — Conral,ght As:enue (Near OhetYuto Road)
At. meetng of the Ccmmitee or Works, held on November 4th., the atthed report from City Solicitor in regard to four feet ;) -f land remain).niz afer the r;3subd171.sio:ri was approved by Clty
i2th,, L):31t, was considered.
Cc.mmlf, recoi:nlended that the remaining feet be sold to J.P. '' .Tlry and Marga.ret StanbIlry ad,loining cwn,:rs for the
o0.00.
Respectfully submitted,
W.F. Publicover r CITY CLERK.
Per,, .B. Sabean, Clerk of Works.
DeBard, Jr. City Manager.
Ir► :r:iu C.P. Solicitor.
Date° 0::.tobc-,r 3_3(h. 1.9
SI! Co:lnaught Avenue (Near Chebucto
17th, tr:c Gity Coun311 sold lots on Connaught At thi,T Lt was suggsted that thr.! 6ub—
divi8iry7i 3hc,uld be r'i..;,lsed oy moving all boundaies 4 feet south
wardly. Tice ;d.,:a this t,o provide room for the A.loining
grope 'z nrorerty.
5tallation cost
..,reared maintenance a.nee of year
ereased ma.i.ntenance .1 year
Cost for
cost for
$250.00
13.32
80.00
A.?, „ Cltey E;.ectri,:ian
911 —
November 12, 1954.
Apparently the 4 feet remaining were not sold and the t owns rr, of the adjoiniAg property, JB. $tanbury and
rge. Suanbtery r 376 Connteugh'c Avenue, are anx.lous t3 acquire
Yours very truly,
CARL P. BETHUNE, CITY SOLICITOR.
Per.. T.C. Doyle
_ ,,tea. by Alderman Madonald, secondd by Alderman Ahern
eE,port be approved. Mot:ver, passed.
STREET LIGHTING BAYERS ROAD AND ELLIOTT STREET
His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
Fromg Committee on Works.
November 8th.. 1954.
Street Lighting — Bayers Road.
a meeting cf the Committee on Works, held on November 4th. t.. t! !:.ached report from the City Electrician, recommending that rwo isti-cury Street Lights be installed on Bayers Road, at an ensllatiae cost of N 250.00 was approved and recommended to
•
ReE..- peC,LfU117;
W.F. Publicc-Ter CITY CLERK.
Per..J.B. Sabeen, Clerk of Works.
that
A..P c Flynn City Electrician
A.A, DeBard., jr.r. 3ity Manager
Date October 29th, 719.54
Re Street lighting Bayers Road — New Dominion Store
eceeld reeommend that 2 mercury street, lichee be installed Bayers Road — one near the entrance and one near the exit the new Dominion Store where traffic officer& are on duty eing busy hours.
November 12, 1954.
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of City Council.
From: Committee on Works.
Da-roe: November 8th., 1954.
Subject: Street Lighting - Elliott Street
At a meeting of the Committee on Works, held on November 4th., the attached report from the City Electrician, in regard to Street Lighting on Elliott Street was approved and recommend-ed to City Council.
Respectfully submitted,
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
Per..J.B. Sabean, Clerk of Works.
Date October 29th„ 1954. From: A.P. Flynn, City Electrician
To Re Street Lighting on City Manager Elliott Street.
I have received a verbal request for street lighting on Elliott Street. I went over this street and as this is a new subdivision with no street lighting at the present time it will require 2-250 candle power lights.
A.A. DeBard, Jr.,
Trioreased maintenance cost for balance of year
This street is owned by the city but as such until it is properly graded.
Installation cost
Increased maintenance cost for mull year
will not be designated
$158.88
6'088
40.00
Installation cost to be changed to capital borrowing street lighting new subdivision.
A.P. Flynn, City Electrician.
Moved by Alderman Macdonald, seconded by Alderman Ahern
that the report be approved. Motion passed.
NOR:4ANDY DRIVE BETWEEN ROSEMEAD AVENUE AND ROBIE STREET
To: His Worship the Mayor and Members of the City Council.
From: Committee on Works.
Date: November 8th., 1954.
Subject: Normandy Drive - Between Rosemead Avenue and Roble Street
- 912 --
November 12 v 19540
At cL lrze; o t in, ^f tne Committee on. Works held on November 4th., a report frtort Commissioner of Works recommending that new side- walk ana iutter be installed on Normandy Drive, according tc th nev- J'c-r€,, t line, at an estimated cost of $1400p000 vas ai7,prr),rati and fc(lommended to Ctty Council.
Respecif.ally submitted,
W.P. Publioover, CITY CLERK.
Per..J. B. Sabean, Clerk of Works.
To: His Worship the Mayor End Memberr_7 of' the Committee on Works.
From: G.F. West, Commissioner of Works.
Date: November 4tho r 1954.
Subject: Normandy Drive - Between Rosemead Avenue and Robie Street.
The estimated cost of removing the existing sidewalk, curb and gutter and sodding on. Normandy Drive between Rosemead Avenue and Roble Street and installing new sidewalk and curb and gutter on this same street according to the new street line r is Pr000.;:lo.
It is retomended that authority be given to use this amount from the sidawa3k Canital Account in order that the work may be carried out tins year.
G.F. West, Commissioner of Works.
Moved by Alderman Macdonald, seconded by Alderman Ahern that
the report be approved. Motion passed.
APPLICATION FOR AMENDMENT _TO ZONING MRS. BUNGAY WI'a3OR ST.
Alderman Vaughan: "There are no other commercial establish-
ments in tha area but Mrs. Bunpm has been by bits and ?leces
encroaching n residential district. This was primarily a
residential secLionc r
Alderman DeWolf said there was a reservation VA the title that
a commt:.rcial establishment was not permitted.
Aldermen WTI:haw "It would seem wrong for this Coun,711 to
proceed to have a hearing for rezoning0 E
His Worship the Mayors "When it comes back to Council we can
decide whether tere shou13 or should not be a publie hearing.°
Moved by Alderman Vaueihna, seconded by Aldermnn Lloyd that
this applic:=1.r,a t not ranted.
t.
November 12 1954.
A1d.er itar.. DAWo1f 'All the residents of that, area slF;ned the
amo purchase tc agree that it was a residential
ar,:a nn3 wc:Ilid be kept as suoh.';
His 'iVn-ehip the Mayor 'There is a petition hare with L
signatures on it saying they have no objection to 1'0.
Moved in amendment by Alderman Dunlop, seconded by Ald6rman
L. ';hat appliaation be referred to the Town Ple_nning Board
for a report and that the petition be investigated.
Amendment Passed D
FENCE FOOT OF JUBILEE ROAD
Alderman 0r Malley "Alderman Kitz asked me tc ask this
question before he left. He would like tc know ar the City owns
that sectiot: cf the property at the foot of Jubilee Road and it
it will the Trilfflo Authority conslder a strong bc,ard renc,Lo G'
"ne matter was referred to the City Manager,
UNSIGHTLY PROPERTIES
Alderman VA tIghan "Would the Solicitor look into the matter
of Lnsightly properties both commercial and residential and report
Council what he deems necessary to control ii7
PRESENTATION TO TENNIS CHAMPIONS
Alderman Ahern asked when His Worship the Mayor would make
the y.resentations to Miss De is and Mr. Woodworth.
Worship the Mayor asked to be reminded of lt before next
regul;ir meeting ,
11/tr_v. _7 71 6, A_
STEPHENLS_SCINOL_AND_PAKINp,GORSEBROK_GROUNDS
report was s,.4t,4ti1ttd from, the Board of Schccl Cu7, niesiohers
requ,Aitini,; permleolo:-. to spend the unexper,ded appropriat:on of
InelJrane Lc ;ay for the erection of a stage
at L. t!., pave a eecticn of the Gorsebrook
S t.•
e r:(*IviaGd the proposed expe%ditures %ou.ld be
4 -. c) r tr.e at St., 5 tephet. a S:_n:)o-1. and.
Gorstbroo
114
•
.misom
mil"m
millW
11.0111nomom
omm
111.11
1.
, -1
*. • s, 1
4 ,
. 4
. •
k4
1,44 \ .
4,
4.4
I.
4 •••
-•
" 4 I I
• • •
•
•
•
1•1 4-00
‘k:
• 4
.4 ;
••
Ii
I •
11
II" 0
4
4 '4
r
• ) • 4
I' t ) .4
, .
w 4
• •
1 ;
•
) 1 • •
l.)
eI
Il
. 4 I
0 4
.1
t1)
'....i r4-4
4,' '
41 7_1
io
4)
4'4 4 N
(1 (..) tr)
• : .
!,.. $ C
.' 4 )
..: 1
.! '
1 '
4 . , 4
I •
4 :4
4 4
. •
4
; : .....4:
4 : ,
l) (4)
4 '
1 I.1
4:
t :
.. 1
1)
4:'
. •
4 4
(1
)
. .
4 r
• •
'I
t S
4r)
4 41
.4 •
i 4
•• I
,.- 4
4:4
1 4
4 ..
4:::4.)
II
L.
t,
4','.
tl' 4. 'I w
1
tai
i 1
U;
41
)
: 1.
, 4 :
• I
I *
I,
.IH r
1
,
'1 1
44
- • 4
4. ,
I 4.;
' '
4 ,
.4.
• • .4,
I .
. •
• $
t 4.
4.
4* 1
I.
,
4- I
.•
4 'T 4. , • • ! 4 I 4
'I 4
•
. . 1 ' 1
•: ' 4; '
9 1
1 I I 1
'1 $ •
4 •
.1
4 I 4 ,
1
r.
I • I
•
i:
• •
• •
1
4,4
••• •
4' . 54
• 0
•
4
•, ,'•
:, "
": j .1
'
,
•
1 •
tr •
E:ayfle10, sic„!.
:ti Thtro-!Nr
)Tooe r
D6ai y
13.71,Dd R..--Ayers Hcwaa Dv GorsclirooL Roty,..?rs Drive
Connur:lit Avenue
- 1254 Season to October 31, 1954
Lenif ft. Job Completed
July 261 1954 August 20,1954 October 191954 October 5 919!,4 October 7,1954 October 7,1954 October 7,1954 October 9,1954
Oct.31,1954 — 95% complete
'380 71
tt
50 20% complete
•
1.6 300 100
90
250 170 700 250 267
Ft b 0 Cur Gutterz: Comnicted this
To
month
Side Str,7!et From Work
Be levue Ave. I-al I s nrir,ht T.4-:eds Howe Ave. 13:Ayers Scot Rowe Federal Ave. Romans Atlantle ::r1dEes Howe Ave. Bayers
Oakland B:asinview Scot St. Howe Romans Tower Scot
West Both Both Both Both South East
S. & S. C. & G. S.& S.,C.&G.
do. do. do. do.
9. Cu'cb Cutter -. inconlete.
Dudley Ave. Ba:-.;illvic-;t1 Dr.
Dr.
House Ccalnolly Rol;io 1,c;c'do
Ar7nrrn
Both Both Both
South
C.& G.75% S.& S.98(11 C.& G.98% S.& S.,C.& G.
98% comp. C.e: G.98% ” C.E: G.98% "
comp.
• •
L_
Cor-:ol'atio71 ndvises us that in nr!sc . roperti es that
A r 1 :30, 1955. The r,..- ovz-A from ;hr lund.
. :-",ay r the ouestion was
0' Co:I -. 7.1 br rr.).,'
•, :icy.d
t o 1: 1. •
•
.1=ion As 71' te beCtI7C of the
C,ncreaco in fr(;e
1,•
THE 'A.:Y
1KA;'
KALTFAX N
0,:tober 18, 1954.
Hi Won :31'11D th€,. Nay: ;• AT1(1
of the City Y.Airv1:1 City Hall Halifax, N. S9
Your Worship and Ald,i.,717.
I
at ?1,,ITc :,?port on my rF:c.?nt attendance at the Annual rjonfr..enc,e of Me, 1.;ationl InEiitute of Municipal
Law Officers held during L'A:Tte, mtif,r Fr3r1cisco, California.
Your3 very truly,
SOLT,1`,11'OR
CPB,,EHJ Enc.1.
"r,r1,-A7
" 4 A "- lu • I_ 4.... • ,..k
r rt"
Cr3tober 4, 1954.
N.1.2
J:ity HE311 IYLdifaxs 3,
Yr,tar Worahin National
of Munieipal
following report
regarding :leititute of
Municipal 11,,1(1 ',Lan 7ranciseo,
year3. Aporoxily
vol7ing in ..:sale of general I1f.51-4-,,ior
7". And the Unitd,
pattern of previous pap And reports were read
ot olAnllpal matters in-applAtlon of law or matters ”,.A:litpal lawyers.
1.tc?-,nded from Quebec WT:_nipg, Vancouver
InJn1ip31 lawyers from
:)v:1- 2.to a :opy of the variety of subjects
7h=1,T-1% 1),:lpr,5 and reports
whi.7-.h may bt-
1 tb2t, a.1 on previous
ooca5io, fr.,2-mb of the Institute if?ti: nothing to be
;i1cii'Nyer3 to discuss
‘Inatinted. It is
pro, :.:+: ,,mribute some
r:or that, apart from
*;r1=, of the United th--7 resulting legal
problema
pub.Lic -- t
A , 1
lifoRr P'k
.•17 : •••.:
(.!:,;:-Y In 11-0. !.'cared States as well of 35,000 low
•,ontruction of these ...unl-clearance project.
1 r4.;,,If.01 if the building Ihen to a limited
: 7 rlumb,..-r of units which Y n `-ht number of
• • -I • __,laced as a result thFlt ‹-ommunity.
- 2 -
There are several houlr!z t737octs in addition
to low r.ent housing, namely Public Wax HouoIng, Veterans Re-use
HouLAAng an, Defence Housing (ia-1! the Korean War).
All of t*e.. ase to be in our of r, Anation and transfer to
boda for public uae -!xarket value.
e.hould be not: th::,1) fc.r admission of
tnant6 In limov rent public houing , i7erided to families who
are .:z;!Tlaed by such a proj os- by a 6,11earance or re-
deviopm6nt, project.
It is also of intere that fiy-A payments in lieu
of taxes are required by the iloaiing ,Akt 1954 where such projects
are tax exempt. Where such pzja.elt.!,.. are taxable the munici-
pality mu'A 2h are in the co .1,uLf.-4g in. cash the difference
bstwe:,..n full taxes and 10 perit rents but not
less than 20 proent of the Fr14,101
On the disposal of aTey ths proceeds are to
be divided _-tom en the FedrAl the municipality in
proportion 7c1 the aggregate c:ontribt; of each.
In New Orleans, :0:16.ian, Minimum Hcu,L,.ing Ordinances have "o4,n
I plan to copies of the action by t" se
Yemphis, Tennessee, _ dep :- urrig the past year.
:; a guide for similar
hedevelcpw2n.
attention l, . belnE ar
in(luden ,:learance and Urbn Rede,vc1,:vment Act of 195:J. e
t•rLe ad,Janct of funds to a ,.L.
gornment b:,:..a:ring interest at cut of mon,-:y-!- to be received f;:orr,
plc,71on the project or any otht,:
e;ubject, which 1)iightedn areas. The qatute, provides for ag-,,ny by the Federal "Th-LI loan is repaid ;:-tint on the com-a7allable.
steps together
vl err
Th paper on this matel- .,71; In detail the
to h- 7.akn in commencing and aI'ryi!, cu .A:h a project
with an ordinanc.e setting out ,.!;-1.+
A somewhat similar plan i.f :1Yai1ble in Canada.
5. Munieipal Revenue_ ft em. y-owned Property.
This problem is a ee“Ie in 7-cited States as in
Canada, although in this country arrived at a
mor.e flerIn17 clolution. The ;:vir;:lp. in both the
;Jnadic. Urkil:ed Statee t.t-it Federally-owed
rel propy should contribute of the munici-
7ei.! ,;-if the United pplity in it is locatEd Stm:es ha!5 Appointed a C;omm16z,.:oil :Ir;;.,::7:.nc
al Relations to
andy _:rid allied matt. J that the report bg: of considerable
will •c), avaiable March lt. intcrit 1 C :anadian
,lipz.oat:.h to the
GOV‘7.1.:7M
licport on Internal
encroachments
cc pow-crs of the protection of
municipal revenues. This le not strictly applicable in principle
to 1.7anada
A eeiei:er of interest however' le the fear that the
eede:ed goveeneent might en .roach upon the preneiple that con-
atituelonal eax it of state and munAcipal bonds must be
maintelned,
en the United States income from municipal and state
bonde ie exempt from Federal Income Tax and ae a result the
munielpalities are able to sell their bond: at a lower interest
rate and higher price than is the case in .,eanada where income from
such bonds 16 subject to tax. It might be a :.ears of securing
some relief to municipalities if this principle were in effect in
Canada. The difference in coupon rate between:UR bonds upon
which interest is taxable and those upon which it is non-taxable
15 estimated as between 1% and 11%.
An additional report by the Committee on Municipal Bonds
in a most interesting manner dealt with thla question of tax
exempt. bond.
An interesting matter is also dealt with in this report
namely the question of priority of Federal liens for income tax
or wetheolding tax as against municipal liens for taxes. The
Supreme Court of the United States held that all such liens were
equal but priority was established on the baala "a prior lien
gives a prior claim which is entitled to prior satisfaction out
of the subject it binds" - or in other words "first in time,
first in right".
Building codes and Fire Prevention Ordinances.
The paper submitted on this matter naturally fell into
two parts - (1) Building Codes, and t2) Fire Prevention Ordinances.
An to the former reference was made to a most com-
prehen2ive Government publication dealing with "Administrative
Proeeduree for Enforcement of Building Regulations". I am
arranging to secure this report as it may be of assistance to our
Building Inspeetion Department. This report deals with
(1) The application for and issuance of permits.
inspection of new construction.
131 Action against violators. fe) Oeeupational licensing as a means ef enforcement. (We
now have this in our Charter, as occupancy permits,
as a result of a suggestion 14hieh I made several
years ago following my attendanee at a Conference
of this Association.)
(5) Powers and Procedure for Ordering repair and Demolition
of Existing Buildings.
i(;) Adminietrative hearings and appeele.
(7) Legislative and Judicial Appeal e ane penalties.
A further publication deals with "Loeal Development and
Enforcer nT of Rousing Codse". I also propose to secure a copy
of this pamphlet.
fo, A matter of interest, I would lles to refer to a
glow1ne teneency in eeeeral cities to dier.oetinut the use of the
fl re telteraph box and aubetitute a eyetem of public
cn which can be ealled fire, pcelie and ambulance.
The:. or eeueee, feettai]s a ewetchboard deepetchIng operation manned
5 •
ty oee- e.re. The emrgerkey eevtreee:i of the fire departmerne poee department and ambulanee and dleater facilities are thus Tritwed.
It !:.9.S1C1 to reduce faire AlatIve, reduce the o . — peeett elled out to a fire and glee more particulars
to 30 that the police will inlmediately know 14titrr AMitional policemen for t:reffic And other duty and ii)ieeCeer ete., are needed.
It tt rete, a .o.ineldence that thle matter i5 fully dealt with Au. th 1,a5ue of Readers Digeet. It might clear loekinR inte,
6 1°_a titer
Tiere es.:e2lent reports and papers were presented pre-pared by reuelei:el 1.,i ,lyeee who have specialized la the field of
L111.1:0' prectiee and who have national reputations in the 7.nAt:e! crhe matters dealt with were? of particular nt. t le ete ar:e eete of a technical nature.
fiee paper, in a general manner, reviewed the ,zenerel ef rate applications - pointing out that i;enerally T. eppleetton le made some time aft the utility
c..eNpany !teessary to make the appileation and vice eeei.e In eosts. The e(.)lutien appears to lie
In . k.tention on the part of both the utility eornpany end !'re tx) the earning pleti-Jre o rb. utility
eo 7:het a F•. ^'E can be made.
w».11d entail on the part of the consumers
effeet !.he merlieipality) the necessity of having continuously
employed e per: in public utility law end practice who
%ould Q regeite. te .ee continuously in touch v;ith these developments.
A niember !!;111 :7z-al.ei- cities now have this type of officer on
the i.-11, -de Jo. this province such an official could be
aPPoant:.?d by the Frovineial Government and be OA the staff of the
leeartment of reil.e:1;.ell
Tne paper dealt exhaustliely '..Tit h decisions of
Uni•.ed St- ee 7'eert , or: the questions of Electric, rar, and Tele-
pho!;e Fcite *Ye:. rreiters contained are cef great value in pre-
p3ring fee 7.
oontained references to _Jeelded cases
involvIrg menilpI.I.:yrewned utilities but B1r-.. T-4 11fax does not
dlect:y ery putAic utility the immediet.e vaLue of these
ro re% apparent.
7 :.--; ::'1)r.:" ef ":eexation and Fe-venue.
-Th; 1. i - leAlelGoing subject and n:m an iicademic point
e.' elre.; !:„-,e •:; Iii.1 ;II r ,:, h A v •1- merit. Whe f
n, .n.o.., r, additional
1--- , 1 - :.-• ,.17., T. !.:(r, !J-J, eeme persone alrealy heavily taxed it
,i*, 7r r .k .I ;•., eereful fonsideratioo to .:'etermine just
wnerl. •ri:: 1;,e0 , e*. new texes will be felt.
L7tee e survey of nearly ,1-0:7; with
r - I • 7 *: ;Pr e !-e91 nerr thar. 500,000 to Uee;--e under. 50,000.
1 . -.0e; ",he trend toward nen-property taxes
leer , eIeT-1.,e1 pace - that the ,tie make
more use of such tazeee ae the sales tax, businese privilege tax,
income tax, cigarette Lax and admissions taxes in various com-
binations. The ema:lier cities are also increasing their use of non-preperty. tee,:ee
Many states _Levy non-property taxes for municipalities,
or which they share with municipalities.
Real and pereonal property taxes still continue to be
the main source of revenue for municipalitiee. Most cities
hove both of these taee. There were mcre eiteee reporting an
assessed-valuation of leas than 50% of actual value than cities
reporting an aseeeeed valuation of over 50%. The most popular
valuation is between 40% and 60%.
Many of the non-property taxes above referred to are
apparently being made more acceptable to the public by being ear-
marked at least to a portion for capital improvements. From
70% to 85% of the citiee reporting have some form of non-
property tax.
The Busineee rrivilege Tax is a tax unknown to us and
if any further information is desired I shall be pleased to
supply it. In effect et ie similar in some cities to our license
fees under Section 361 of our City Charter, but many variations
exist.
However, in our cave, we may find that insofar as cor-
porations are concerned we may be restricted by the Dominion-
Provincial Agreements.
8. Civil Libertiee.
This report dealt with various phases of the matter
not all of which have any application to Canada.
(1) pegre ation. Since the recent decinion of the Supreme
Court of the Un 7e etatee on this matter, many United States
cities have had to change their outlook and the problems created
are many and troubleaome. This problem extends to schools, public
housing, employment, public accommodation hotel and restaurants),
recreational facilities and even to cemeteries.
(2) Freedom of Religion. This involves religious education
in schools, the Ituerirgtion of water as offending the religious
views of those who de not believe in medicatlon, and other matters.
(3) Freedom of Aetivity, Speech and Association. This
involves the right f77Trectise professions and trail e without
prohibition, making epeches which might cause the overthrow of
the government by weenP o! force or violence or other unconstitutional
means, being a member of eubverslve oeganization, censorship of
movies and let-ter: e7r!y. pernennel.
(4) The use of eeri.:e to legal prceeedings when the
evidence has been al-legelly obtained - such as by the unauthorized
placing of microphonei7. In various parts of defendant , s house and
by confessions obtalnel t . fraud.
(5) immigratt Deportation and Naturalization.
- 6 -
9. Municipal Officer and Employee Problems.
This was an informative paper dealing in par
t with the
survey of municipal salaries made recently i
n the City of New York
and which includes the various salaries and
the annual increments.
The paper also contains the Order made by th
e City of
New York dealing with the Conduct of Relatio
ns between the City
of New York and its Employees. This Order
contains much that is
contained in our agreements with our unions.
10. Disposal and Preservation of Public ,Records.
This is a matter upon which I commented last
year. Dis-
posal of records is, in my opinion, highly t
echnical and I- think
the responsible head of each department should
be required to
take such time as it may require to intellig
ently arrange for the
disposal or destruction of old , useless rec
ords and the careful
preservation of useful records in a manner t
hat will enable them
to be readily available. I do not think th
is has been done in
Halifax. I believe the uncoordinated mass
of records at present
at the City Field should be gone over at onc
e by the staff
familiar with them while such staff is av'aila'ble .
I mean by
this - senior staff. Then proper facilitie
s should be provided
to arraTO—nr future preservation.
It might not be unreasonable to select a sen
ior member
of the staff to supervise and approve of thi
s effort so that
there will be someone responsible.
We should set up schedules as to how long to
preserve
records, what records are to be microfilmed
and destroyed and
what records are to be mircofilmed and retai
ned in a place of
safekeeping - preferably away from the local
site of government
in order that the same may be preserved in t
he event of destruction
of the local records by peacetime or war casua
lty.
I believe a guide has been prepared by the N
ational
Institute of Municipal Clerks.
Certain States have enacted statutes definin
g what
records should be destroyed and when and wha
t records kept.
11. Zoning and Planning.
An instructive technical paper was given o
n this subject
dealing with various decisions on the interp
retation of zoning
by-laws and other relevant matters, such
as non-conforming uses,
relaxation of provisions, etc.
In addition to the foregoing other reports a
nd papers were
presented dealing with -
Civil Defence Condemnation (Expropri
ation) of Real Property
Liability of Municipalities for Tort
Municipal Contracts Ordinances and Ordinan
ce Enforcement.
City-State Relations
School Legal Problems
Airports Federal-City Relations
.
- 7 -
Dissuzsions took place on all of the matters submitted
and many questions were asked and answered. Great interest was
shown and a remarkably full attendance was present at each con-fereme sessAr)n,
It will be noted from the programme that two prominent speakers Addressed the Conference - Mr. Lloyd Wright, President
of the American Bar Association, and Mr. Simon E. Sobeloff, Solicitor- General of the United States, formerly City Attorney
of the City of Paltimore, whom I first met in 1942.
I wish to take this opportunity of expressing my
appreciation to the City Council for the assistance given me to
enable me to attend this meeting. I enjoyed the association with other lawrers, engaged in the same work as I, and feel that
such a meeting cannot help but be of value.
trust the foregoing memorandum will be of interest
and if there are any particular points which require clarification
or elaboration I will do my best to provide this information.
Respectfully submitted,
CARL P. BETHUNE CITY SOLICITOR
CPB:EHJ
November 12, I954„
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Va t̀:.t;bari. that
tne pe-:AissAon. requested be granted. Motion. passed.
AO CITY MANAGERU3 ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT FOR OCTOUER
A report was submitted from the City Manager for the month
of October and same is attached to the original copy of these
minutes.
of the report were furnished the members of Ccsrl:..11
for their Anformation.
FILE2
TREE LIST #1 FOR 12_,Iy
The Ornamental Tree list #1 showing the number of trees
planted on various C:.ty streets was submitted,
FILED
CITY SOLICITOR 0 S REPORT Reg CONVENTION
A reporl: was trabmitted from the City Soliclor utlinIng the
various items that were dlscussed at the Municipal Law Officers
Convention held in San Francisco on September 1.4 24 end 1 1954
and same As attached to the original copy of these ?
Copies of the report were furnished the member :;f
for their information.
FILED
BUILDINGS_TOWER ROAD BRIDGES AND ATLANTIC_STRF.ETS,
A letter was submitted from G. M. & H. C. intrmir.c, tne
City that they were authorized to secure vacant poss sin of the
above buildings not later than April 30, 1955 try', r.6 nulid:ng
become vacant lt would be demolished or sold for reirl from
the land.
FILED.
-915
Prior Go 1952 (covered by reserves)
November
TAX COLS.ECTIONS MONTH OF OCTOBER 1954
12, 1954.
Balane P - i -7Pc, S?pt, 30/54
New Accounts & Adjustments
October 1954 0/6 Balance
Collections October 1954
. •..-t
.•) , , 159,96;609 Cr.
):9.,476.46 Or. 99(;.027.52 Dr.
365.11 1,941.62 15,588.34
1,488,493607 Dr. 13,281.61
i.
14,018.77 21,645.25
105,150.49
140 9 814.51 8,358.87
149,173.38
1,360,960.17
145,605.21 305,889.59 909,465.37
22,128.10 2,407.77 2,317.25 Dr. 549 721.28 Dr.
:'c.1.] Taxes other than listed above
r,)tal Collections in October 1954
Collections in October 1953
1.11,rer.t Taxes collected January 2nd
) 1i)(:tobt,:r 29/54
,:,t,,I,,punding Period 1955
rears collected January 2nd
October 29, 1954
_-:-fsponding Period 1953
Tax Collections January 2nd
r)etober 29, 1954
32.25 58.15
1.00 756.55
8,359.20
9,116.75 720.16
22,128.10 2,406.77 1,592.95 46,420.23
9,836.91
159,010.29 131.926.16
6,089,378.72
613,261.40
110,020.12
5,820,765.86
476,572.38
111,627.31
6,812,660.24 6,408,965.55
AMOUNT COLTRAITED Jan.2nd to Oct.29th.
6,089,378.72 86.54
5,820,765.86 85.54
613,261.40 54.83
476,572.38 49.75
6,702,640.12 95.26
6,297,338.24 92.55
•rresponding Period 1953
1,evy 1954 7,036,505.98
Levy 1953 6,804,375.60
Arrears January 2nd, 1954 1,118,470.92
Arrears January 2nd, 1953 957,954.00
►, Collections to October :11, 1954
Collections to October 1953
Respectfully submitted,
H. R. McDonald, CHIEF ACCOUNTANT.
November 12, 1954.
REPORT. PREFAB HOUSES FOR OCTOBER
THE MONTH OF OCTOBER 1954
Total advances made to date - $1 OUD,:,d;,,42.
No further advances will be made for If..,:ndations.
341_:ES 224 - Four purchasers borrowed from r
foundation purposes and two of the c.-.7t. r.owings
have been repaid.
CURRENT_ ACCOUNTS r.,00 of which 162 are 0 the rate of % ln'z.erest
BAUXVERDRAFT Balance as t September 30, 1954 - Cr, $
Balance as October 31 1954 -Dr 54,148,.45
(Overdraft in October due chiefly to repayment of
$100,000.00 to City - General Funds.)
TOTAL BORROWINGS
Sept. 30/54 Bank Balance Cr. 214:,10L4
Owing City - Genl. Funds Dr. 700,000.en Dr. $o28.608.=s6
Oot. 31/54 Bank Overdraft Dr. 148,'5 Owing City-Genl. Funds 600 000,Co- Dr..
6:54,146.35
'-' 111ENT PAYMENTS IN ARREARS TWO MONTHS OR MORE
Accounts totalling - $4 352.13
Tn previous month we reported 44 Accounts $L L503.89
L.G. Fraser, ACCOUNTANT.
FILED
APPROVALS BY MINISTER OF MUNICIPAL AFFAIRS
The following approvals were reported to Coup: ii
Rezoning C159 Gottingen Street,
2. rezoning Scutt. past corner Dutch Village and Bay ,:- Rr)ads
3.;--ale of Land Weetmount School Ground.
Mw:,. by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderman L 7:-ft:•
th16 rcee ng do now adjourn. Motion passed.
Mee -c,*.ng adjol....rneda 12
?
No/ember L?54„
LTt T OF HEADLINES
Minutes Heartnis B,J,I.Iding Lots Gorsebrook
Pub' . Hearin g Rt71 Building Line Cunard and Windsor Street
65q
i362
Motio. AidermAT! Ahern Re Fairview Underpass 663
Aeounts Over $500.00 863
Claim Fort Massey Ohur,:•.h $139.00 864. Claim Mrs. E.F. Boudreau $179.45
864
Progress Paymer :/ .M0 Cieminshaw & Co„ 866
Undersized. Lot #)5 Beaufort Avenue 866
Undersized Lot 88 Morris Street Housing Aut.11:)r.0'; t
86? 5,-.)
Sewer Extencriorl OA:ford & Maxwell Streets 86
City Manager 4 s Ifa,3ation 870
City Manageros Convention 8 -A.
Land Sale Account 812 Fairview Cemetery Land Between St. Andrews School & Byer
11:..:ad 873
Superannuat iml 7.3 Provincial. Grant—School Buildings 874
Report T.B. Hospitalization across Canada 87=7;
Roof Bedford. Row FAre Station 87!)
Fairview Cemetery Ordinance & Charges 8
;--s
Resolution Cit of Windsor. Ontario Re Food Commoditiee 78y Retirement Mr. Ross Hall 878
Tenders Group LIfe Insurance 0--':.
Boxing Day Decemoe 19t',4 :15...
Tenders for Lnnd 58
Tenders rot' GrD,':-er:Iii. Fleh Etc. 888 Tenders for Lloense Plates ,,;0
Tenders for Stippll ,_--./.
Special Castings c:.-
Salt ,39 --.3 Appropriation Payment coupon Interest -.
December Pay Revision City Ch5Tter
o7-, ,
89̀ 4
Legislation Rea Retaring Allowances F* _;)
Financial Statements P.9i.
Downtown Parking Lot Lease for 1955 596
Reservation International Trade Fair 896
Appointment of Coal Weigher i9E.
Heating System City Field 'i97
Incinerator Dates 3:.,J8
Additional Collrt Reporter r.Q.t -,,_
Street Names F,C)Q
Resubdivision of Lands of Mr. S. Walker Liverpcol Stret t.,,:i9 Resubdivision of City Owned Lands — Liverpool Street yclo
Building Line Hollis Street ';'00 Land Required fro St. Patriokts Home for Romans Averc: c01
Amendment to Ord:nanl:e 446 Television Antennae - 0','
Amendment '7,O4
Retirement of Mr., G.•orge H. German 9
Grants for Pertet!:; 7,c,.;
Final to Btedf Cot,-1.1ztion Co. $2.508.00 :, t7,1.-,
Proposed Sewt,r Fyzelon Clinton Ave. & D.V. Road r;:se
Fee Blasting Perto 113:) -5 Legislation
OverhprigIng Sis 9Ub
918
November 12, 1954.
Closing Portion of Bower Road and Sale of Land 5J.0 Sale of Land Connaught Avenue (Near Chebucto Road) Street Lighting Bayers Road and Elliott Street 911 Normandy Drive Between Rosemead Avenue and Robie Street 912 Application for Amendment to Zoning Mrs. Bungay Windsor St. 913 Fence Foot of Jubilee Road 914 Unsightly Properties 9l4 Presentation to Tennis Champions 914 Stage St. Stephen's School and Paving Gorsebrook Grounds 914 City Manager's Administrative Report for October 9L5 Tree List #1 for 1954 915 City Solicitor's Report Res Convention 9i Buildings Tower Road, Bridges and Atlantic Streets 915 Tax Collections Month of October 916 Report Prefab Houses for October 917 Approvals by Minister of Municipal Affairs 917
.A. Donahoe,- Q.C . p
MAYOR AND CHAIRMAN.
t' r • 1,-
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK°
,
- 919
AFTERNOON SESSION SPECIAL MEETING
Council Chamber, City Hall, Halifax, N.B., November 18, 1954, 5:00 P.M.
A meeting of the City Council was held on the above date.
After the meeting was called to order by the Chairman and
before considering the regular order of business, the members of
Council attending, led by the City Clerk, joined in repeating the
Lord's Prayer.
There were present His Worship the Mayor Chairman; Aldermen
DeWolf, Moriarty, Dunlop, Macdonald, Adams, Lloyd, Kitz, O'Malley,
Ahern, Allen, Vaughan, Hatfield and MacMillan.
Also present were Messrs. A.A. DeBard, Jr., W.P. Publicover,
R.H. Stoddard, A.J. Yeadon, G.F. West and Dr. A.R. Morton.
The meeting was called specially to consider the following
items:
1. Extension of 40 hour week City Field.
2. Incinerator Problem.
EXTENSION 40 HOUR WEEK CITY FIELD
The matter of extending the 40 hour week at City Field was
considered.
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Ahern that the
40 hour week at City Field be extended to December 31, 1954.
Motion passed.
The City Manager submitted a report respecting Overtime paid
to City Field employees as follows:
To: His Worship, R.A. Donahoe, Q.C., and Members of City Council.
From: City Manager, A.A. DeBard, Jr.,
Date: November 17, 1954.
Subject: City Field — 40 Hour Week . Overtime.
A tabulation has been made by our cost section of the Works
—920—
17,-,5partment October 13 .J.bout 90% opivLalons
November 18v 1954.
showing the total overtime paid from January la 1954- , 1954. In most cases no regular hours were put in and of the overtime was paid during the time of snow removal
F." •T NO. OF HOURS COST
1.59 2,232 $ 30548.88 1.71 574 981.54 1.75 484 847.00 1.84 327 601.68 1.90 19244 29363.70 2.35 2 4.70
4,862 8,147.40
Had straight time been paid for this work the cost to the City
would have been 02,782.46 less. It should be remembered if we
follow the present practice that these costs could rise with the
shorter work week and no Saturday work.
The decision, however, should not be made as a matter of cost
but as a matter of principle that overtime is paid only for hours
worked in excess of 8 per day or 40 per week.
By following such a policy we would be able to.spread the work
more at a lower cost and prevent any attempt to pay overtime to
men who have already worked a full day or week.
A.A. DeBard, Jr., City Manager.
Alderman Vaughan suggested that an employee should be paid a
10 cent differential for night work.
Moved by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderman Lloyd that
the City Manager bargain with the City Field Union on the various
points and that instead of the 10 cent differential being paid for
regular off-shift, that anyone who works after the regular shift
shall be paid the 10 cent differential until he has worked enough
hours to be paid at the overtime rate. Motion passed.
INCINERATOR PROBLEM
At this time Mr. Harrison Eddy of the firm of Metcalf and
Eddy Boston, Mass. was present to address the Council on the
matter of the Incinerator Problem.
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Vaughan that
Council adjourn and meet as a Committee of the Whole.
Motion passed.
- 921-
November 18, 1954.
5:20 P.M. Council adjourned.
62.5 P.M. Council reconvened the following members being
Gant His Worship the Mayor Chairman; Aldermen DeWolf, Moriarty,
1lAn1op, Macdonald, Adams, Lloyd, O'Malley, Ahern, Allen, Vaughan
and MacMillan.
Moved by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderman Allen that
this meeting do now adjourn. Motion passed.
Meeting adjourned. 6:25 P.M.
LIST OF HEADLINES
Extension 40 Hour Week City Field Incinerator Problem
920 921
R.A. Donahoe, Q.C. 9 MAYOR AND CHAIRMAN.
W.P. Publicover„ CITY CLERK.
.. 922 —
EVENING SESSION SPECIAL MEETING
Council Chadber, City Hall, Halifax, N. S., November 22, 1954, 8:00 P. M.
A meeting of the City Council was held on the above date.
After the meeting was called to order by the Chairman and
before considering the regular order of business, the members
of Council attending led by the Deputy City Clerk joined in
repeating the Lord's Prayer.
There were present His Worship the Mayor Chairman; Aldermen
DeWolf, Moriarty, Dunlop, Lane, Macdonald, Lloyd, Kitz, O'Malley,
Ahern, Allen, Vaughan and MacMillan.
Also present were Messrs. A. A. DeBard.. Jr., R. H. Stoddard,
A. J. Yeadon, L. M. Romkey and G. F. West.
The meeting was called specially to consider the Incinerator
Problem.
At this time Mr. Clarke of the Firm of Greeley and Hansen
from Chicago, Engineering Consultants, was present to address the
Council on the matter of the Incinerator Problem.
Moved by Alderman Vaughan, seconded by Alderman Lloyd that
the Council adjourn and meet as a Committee of the Whole. Motion
passed.
8:05 P. M. Council adjourned.
9:30 P. M. Council reconvened, the following members being
present Aldermen DeWolf, Moriarty, Dunlop? Lane, Macdonald, Lloyd,
Kitz, O'Malley, Ahern, Allen, Vaughan and MacMillan.
Moved by Alderman Dunlop, seconded by Alderman Moriarty that
this meeting do now adjourn. Motion passed.
Meeting adjourned 9:35 P. M.
R. A. Donahoe, Q. C.. MAYOR & CHAIRMAN. '
R. H. Stoddard, Deputy City Clerk. - 923 -
F T E 7.; I-3 0 N *,‘T
BEr. •-• ' -;•
Council Chamber, City Hall, Halifax, N.B. November 30, 1954. 4:05 P.M.
A meeting tt-- City Council was held on the above date.
After thv, - !1/1. tAiled to order by the Deputy Mayor
send before corticg the regular order of business, the members
of Council attoctIrt;:* led by the City. Clerk joined in repeating
the Lordee P7aye-,
There were prent Her Worship the Deputy Mayor Chairman;
Allermen DeWoiff livlary, Macdonald, Adams, Lloyd, Kitz O'Malley
Hatfield and Ma';44Alin
Also preserl Mes5re, A.A. DeBard, Jr., W.P. Publicover,
R.H. Stoddard, L,M. Romkey, C.P. Bethune, Q.C., and
G.F. West.
The meetth7; vau oalled specially to consider the following
items:
1. Motion Aldermp Lloyd to Reconsider the Observance of Boxing
Day.
2. Tenders for s‘t:
3. Incinerato Prc,blem.
MOTION ALDERYAn LL(JYD TO RECNSIDER THE OBSERVANCE OF BOXING DAY
As several -1..int,',ft3 of Council were not present it was agreed
to defer actin., 1 th7; end of the meeting when it was anticipated
that the absent MC:rfl 7 -."117.1e4 be present.
4:10 P,M. cmc:i Hatfield and Ahern arrive.
TY1:ERS 70R SALT
Tenders orr, --eived from two firms.
Movel. by A' ; n,q;,11 2econded by Alderman Moriarty that
the tenders b,-! Mr.! .!7n passed.
November 30 D 1954.
T1-.e were opended as follows:
Piel- teries Ltd.
Arri. Smrh
92 per 100 lb. bag at warehouse 941; City Field
It warehouse City Field
The Ciy Manager stated that a meeting was held with the
presentativel,. of the three salt companies and new specifications
were worked out that were nc i. as restricted at the former ones.
Alderman DeWolf "Isnct, Smith's tender the same as it was?"
City Monaer: uThat is right. They were the only tenderer
as they were the only ones who could meet the specifications."
Alderman DeWolf: "In this ,)articular case I don't think it
is fair to the man who tendered in the first case. Tenders are
sacred and should be. The contract might be divided. It might
be the fairest way to do it. The Manager might want to consider
it."
Moved by Alderman DeWelf, eeeended by Alderman O'Malley that
the tenders be divided equally.
Alderman O'Malley: "Who drafted the specifications in the
first place? Were they not the specifications from A.M. Smith?"
City Managef: 'That is true In part."
Aldeman OcMalley: "If that Is so there is no unfairness in
calling tenders again . T an :%,c;ainst this business of speoific—
ations being drawn by any firm tendering on City business. The
specifications sho,Ild be supp2.1ed within the City Hall."
The City Mara,:er stated Alderman was right to a degree.
He cited a cas;-: -e'_:ere a merchant in - %'[Ie City eald that mattresses
were purch,ea Trithout specf,,flations. The merchant helped to
draft specifications but ,he merchant never sold any to the City
since that tiTne.
With resT,ect to salt er)ereations the Manager sttted that
had the representatl vc from Be:-'ne Ltd. come to the City Officiate
an amendmert. cnuld Lave been te them but he made his objections
after the sit:
November 30, 1954.
0C Malley: qqinitil the City of Halifax we have
D,:oal-tments th&t are n.xt al!rdiable in other centres. I
M:=cwc!: and Work e7: Deparment should be able to gather
'r12atIon clraft own specifications.0
t,loved Ln aT.endmPnt by AlCrman Ahern, seconded by Alderman
t'r..-7 the *;enl.ers be referred to the Committee on Works for a
Amend;:len; passed.
Moved by Aldermen Ki'uz, seconded by Alderman Ahern that
C3unc1.l and meet as a CommAttee of the Whole.
Motion passed.
Met Ling adjourned. 4:20 P.M.
Council reconvened at .520 P.M. the following members being
present His Worship the Mayor Chairman; Aldermen DeWolf, Moriarty,
Litne, Macdonald, Adams, Lloyd, Kiuz, 01 Malley, Ahern, Hatfield and
MacMillan.
MOTION ALDERMAN LLOYD TO RFCONFITIFR THE OBSERVATICE OF BOXING DAY
Alderman Lloyd °Fo1lowinE4 ;he meeting of Council I took
it that the exrdres:;ion ..pf Council was subject to review. I made
some inclu..,ries and fcund :psons, Eatons and Woods are all
on De,:,::.!ber 27. I 'foald say that practically all retail
,,:osed. The perE:onE.; to whom it is a matter of
c:Jr1:,srn is the hnns. I have Ic:Aors from the banks in my own
Ward. ;.41T1 peaole live cu:ade the City will take advantage
the eitl,r day °
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, st:_cded by Alderman Ahern that the
cf the briervt.nee of DT.cer 27, 1954 as Boxing Day be
reeen2..dereci.
Alderman Ah.. stuted e received several communications
lc nr::11-4; _;1 a .)sernct on Monday, December 27th.
CtMr..1 1 ut •
" 7. was not the responr,ibility of
tbls CulfJ. decide the r (;ood many bLwinco.; orGani-
/ -Lt.tc 7 ;);•(-'. -.uarently the citizens feel we —,1011 peOp
-
NoveMber 30, 1954.
a murt, 1,)igf:er body that I '.ramed of. I find that the majorlty
17,GQ.-ple nre in favor of Monday being declared a holiday.6
Alderman Adams: "Are we n -rder to deal with this?"
Otty Sc)IAcitor: "The motion ths.r passed Council at the last
regular meeting was an affirmative one and that can be reconsidered.
don't think the Otty has any corporate power to declare a publAo
holidaY. n.
He then read the Bills of Exchange Act dealing with this
matter.
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Ahern that
Boxing Day this year, be observed as a Civic Holiday on Monday
December 27, 1954, within the meaning of the Bills of Exchange
Act. Motion passed
Moved by Alderman Lloyd, seconded by Alderman Hatfield that
this meeting do now adjourn. Motion passed
Meeting adjourned. 5:30 P.M.
LIST OF HEADLINES
Motion Alderman Lloyd to Reconsider the Observance of Boxing Day 924
Tenders for Salt 924
Motion Alderman Lloyd to Reconstder the Observance of Boxing Day 926
R.A. Donahoe, Q.C., MAYOR & CHAIRMAN.
W.P. Publicover, CITY CLERK.
- 9i'
COUNCIL MEETING
THURSDAY DECEMBER 16. 1954
AGENDA
Prayer. Minutes.
1, Presentation to Miss Pamela Dewis and Master David Woodw,,)rth. 2. Public Hearing Re: Official Street Lines Bower Road. 3, Amendment to Ordinance #46 Television Antennae (2nd. Readtr.O. u. Aocounts over $500.00.
Claim Mrs. Joy Keeler $69.00. c. Appropriation for repointing Halifax Memorial Librery $1,030.42, 7. Authority to pay damages Wood Motors (Nova Scotia) Ltd. vs City of
Halifax $6,636.75. 8. Tax Write Offs $912.07 q. Sale of Tax Certificates. 10. Sa ckville Street Widening. ,l. Port of Halifax Commission and St. Lawrence Seaway. 3?. Gorsebrook Development R.C.A.F. 13. F lemir.g Glen Subdivision. 14. Dump Additional Land.
Fluorescent Lighting Quinpool Road and Gottingen Street.. 16. :valuation of Pension Retirement Fund. I?. National Harbours Board Grant.
Sick Leave M.L. Bellew and W.J. Clancey. ▪ Spec:ial Tax Halifax Chapter Hadassah.
20. Grant Halifax Community Chest. 21. Closing City Collector's Office for taking off Balances.
Retirement Mr. Henry Rising. 23. Retirement Mr. Wallace Ferguson
Retirement W.L. Bassett, D.A. Beaton and W. Williams. 25. Voters Lists.
Authority to extend Rental Control beyond December 31, ;roup Life Insurance. MeJtoal Care etc. School Board Employees. • International Trade Fair.
30. Nova Scotia College of Art. 31. Angus L. MacDonald Bridge - Land North Stref,t. 32. ).esolution Prefab Borrowing.
Water Pressure Mulgrave Park School Area. Water Pressure St. Stephenls School.
),. La:iclscaping Burial Grounds near St. Andrew's School. t.,=;a7e of Absence City Solicitor.
. Resubdivision of Lands Dominion Stores Ltd. - Bayers 1 Y:es'Ibdivision of G.D. Hogan Property Prescott Street.
:'esubdivision of Mrs. Ba.yne Hilchie Property Dutch Viii e :yesuhaivision Lots 59-62 Hartlen Subdivision Basinview 7)21.!. YE,,Tlest for rezoning 398 Windsor Street. A:,:lication to build or. undersJzed Lots C. Dickey, L.E. Weir tof:
J.B.
''1.-- 11cation to build on undersized lot D.M. TinEley. :'affL.: Circle Windsor Street and Fairview Underpass.
of Gorsebrook Avenue. of Market Lane. Forrester Street.
• .. -2;rd Street ext,:nsion. ters for Salt.
Proposed Sewer extension Connolly S:--!et.
-Jfficial Street Line Bower Road.
52. Butler Bros. Ltd. Property on Cedar Street. 53. Overhanging Signs. 514, Trachoma Hospital. 55. Settlement of Judgement City of Halifax vs Fisherman's Market Ltd. 56. Notice of Motion by Alderman Dunlop. 57, Appointments Board of School Commissioners. 58. Appointments Halifax Regional Library Board. 59. Unsightly Properties. 60. Questions. 61. Application to build on undersized lot #1.3 Uniacke Street.
DEFERRED ITEM
Motion by Alderman Ahern Re: Memorial Drive.
ITEMS FOR INFORMATION ONLY.
City Manager's Administrative Report. Tax Collections. Statistical Report Prefab Houses. Convention Expenses. Approvals Minister of Municipal Affairs. Acknowledgement of Grant C.N.I.B.